I would like to address to anyone finding this video: I DID NOT MAKE THIS PIECE OF MUSIC. Multiple people seem to be mistaken in the comments here, and I would like to clear up that I am not the original author of this music. I simply added lyrics to the video. The original creator of the music is Chonny Jash, and he has made much like this. www.youtube.com/@ChonnyJash This is his account. If you liked this video, please refer to his channel. I am sure he will appreciate the comments you are all posting much more than I would.
wasnt he using words heart called him in the first half tho? idk thats how i understand it (and yeah ik half of the words he used probably werent used anywhere else in the album tho)
It's a callback to Heart concluding the same verse with "And any other adjective" , as well as Heart giving WAAAAAAY more descriptors then is necessary.
i kinda noticed that in the heart’s segment,he uses numbers and math,something youd think mind would do. but he dosent. i think this is supposed to show that heart is much more actually logical,trying to understand mind to no avail. mind just hates and hates,no matter what. and possibly,the weak emotions mind talks about is really just heart caring about him.
That could explain why hes getting sent to die via electric chair. The Mind acted reckless, causing him to do whatever made get in trouble. The original song could be the hearts perspective, from all what happened
Yeah, good observation! There’s a popular (iirc) comment on the original video pointing out that both Heart and Mind are really hypocritical; Heart’s pretty calm and logically dissing Mind, while Mind spends the entire time raging over Heart. As the song says, neither is wrong or right, but both are hypocritical.
@@mebin3059While it's the same melody as the OTHER The Mind Electric, the story of Hawaii Part II is entirely separate from the story Chonny is telling.
I actually thought the opposite when first hearing this, it seemed like to me that the heart and mind are trying to use each others native tounge to get the other to understand their point and thoughts, however they still are to focused on their demands to actually get the hint
"I won't hesitate to kill my heart and mind. I'll take you down in tandem, when this rope is tied." Death kills the physical brain and heart, but the soul will always remain. The soul seeks freedom, even if the cost is life.
I don't think Soul is actually what we'd consider a 'soul', I think he's just the psyche's self-image and sense of identity (similarly, Heart is the emotional side of the psyche rather than the physical organ), but I love this reading of that line. It's so interesting to consider whether Soul thinks he'll survive the death of the body. He's clearly very detached from Heart and Mind, it wouldn't surprise me if he hasn't fully processed that his existence would end with theirs.
I like to imagine this takes place before the real mind electric, and that it's the internal conflict that he experiences on his way to the courtroom. Eventually, soul gains control of both his heart and his mind, so he pleads insanity to satiate both of them, and it ended up being the worst possible decision he could have made.
I love how it sounds there are three characters, The Heart, The Brain and The Soul, Brain and Heart try and convince Soul to listen to one of them until they finally snap and gain control over the both of them as a result
Just a Little correction to help you understand the lyrics a bit better the Brain is to refer to both the Heart and Mind at once, as they are the hemispheres and the soul is the consciousness they make up
@@trashpanda3290 no, theyre right. the brain is in reference to the two halves as a whole. not an individual part. We know this because the heart says "See how the mind tricks the soul", and The Soul Eclectic is about the soul telling both halves that they are both at fault, and references them as one body "See how the brain plays around", and the person themself, or the "brain" is splitting "what was once whole down into three".
I haven't seen this mentioned, but Heart uses a more human voice, while Mind uses a more robotic voice (kinda electronic, like the mind) meanwhile, the Soul uses both
@galemannenman it's part of Chonny's covers album. It's an album of the conflict between the three, and how it affects Chonny. This and The Bidding are the peak of the proverbial conflict.
@galemannenman Basically, Heart and Mind, the first two characters, are fighting over who will influence the body and rule the brain. Soul, the third singer, is in charge and wants the two to either synchronize and merge, so they can be whole again, or all die, so they can be at peace.
9:23 I like to think of the "serfs" as the rest of the physical body. Its like he's showing the heart and the mind what servants should be like. Giving it they got for the kingdom instead of arguing for power like they do. Especially since organs and bidy parts dont think or hesitate they just fulfill their function. I also like how heart and say "fall" in the background seeing that role as more negative while soul sees it as noble.
Some funny things ive noticed on rewatch- -] The transition to the Soul Electic Act uses a sample from the original Mind Electric Maybe because during the original Mind Electric, The Soul is in complete control, So his actions and what he will do eventually is referenced here, which is cool. -] The 2 backup singers in Souls Act, At first i thought it was the Devil and Angel you can find sitting on both shoulders. But now with more thought, I think its actually The Heart and Mind. Fully controlled by the Soul. -] Heart is blind, Mind only speaks, Soul is whole. Heart is blind because the Heart acts solely on emotions alone. Mind only speaks because thats what the Mind does, speak to itself through thoughts. Soul is whole because it represents ones being. Its essence perchance.
Hey, so it seems like your new to chonny jash, maybe not. Anyways, I just want to tell you that the angel and devil on souls shoulder thing seems like a crazy theory and I think you might me onto something. There are four main charecters (Heart, Mind, Soul, Whole) but others are shown sometimes throughout the album. Maybe the angel and devil are responsible for some more voices throughout... Btw soul and whole aren't the same charecter, soul is a shell of what whole used to be.
@@KingCrafter999 oh fr? and yeah youre right about me being new to chonny jash I watched this because I liked Hawaii Pt.2 didnt realise there was a whole separate lore for chonny jash songs
The Soul is really just the creation. The true existence of one's being. The Heart and Brain playing as essential "Supports". But like a King with a Very Manipulative Courtier, they try to get the upperhand and be on top. They try to get the side of the SOUL on their side. The Heart using Empathy while the Brain uses Logicality The Soul finally had enough and question upon both of them. The heart who uses emotions as an answer yet is blinded by such while the Brain who uses Logic as the answer yet his pride shows stupidity underneath all that "absolute logic".
I think it's more like a emperor and two other kings/queens. The line "tridential regicide" refers to the act of killing a king/queen or a emperor as well as the "tridential" part which sugests that unlike heart and mind he see's it as three rulers, two who try to get him to defy/attack the other and the third who has the most power being sick of the two who see eachother as enemies when they are both partners who need eachother and also because he has more power but is useless without the other two and needs them to stay stable.
@@brodyratliff7441mind's supposed to be their thoughts/the logical side, the brain is the organ that the mind is in but the brain also controls emotions through hormones and stuff.
Don’t mind me, just leaving this here for myself 5:53 see how the heart plays profound 2:31 see how it hurts when the sound 11:17 Tridential regicide 6:11 see how his feet miss the ground My fav parts
So from what I can understand, this song is about someone's heart and mind fighting for control, or just to be heard. And it goes on and on until the person (soul i think) snaps and most likely takes their own life, to make the fighting stop. At least that's what I got from that last line about tying the rope.
there is a whole album revolving around this story. "Chonnys Charming Chaos Compendium". basically something happened so Chonnies (a fourth individual, the body) brain split in three (my guess is that Chonny tried suicide, but failed). the heart and mind need to become one, so that chonny doesnt get more suicidal. both heart and mind think that the other side isnt important and should be ignored. sould controls the body and mind and heart fight over who should control soul. at the end of this song the soul threatens final suicide to make heart and mind finally work together, which works as in the next song, the bidding, both finally match their rhymes for the first time and soul gets confidant and lets the suicide idea go. in a later song, the whole world and you, mind says that all of this was a test for heart to push the whole to be what they truly can be
the heart, is an emotional part, begging and bargaining, a "weak" yet rightful part, the mind, the unforgiving and has no sympathy, no emotion, a dictator of destruction, the soul, has both the parts of heart and mind, the most powerful, more sane than the mind yet is still insane to the heart.
Something I noticed several replays through: *(The Heart Acoustic)* - Heart has a human voice, well, more human than the others, and expresses more emotion, as they are the "emotional side" - Heart also seems to be very agitated, twitching and itching their shoulder before the final lines where they "stare" blindly into the camera before glitching and swapping to Mind. I think this is Soul trying to take them over and control them, as seen in The Soul Eclectic when both Mind and Heart become "backup singers" for Soul. Additionally, we can also see a second, fainter figure over Heart through the entirety of the song. Similarly, he's "begging for it to stop", indicating they're in pain both mentally and physically, referring to "rotting" and "death" quite a few times. - Heart's signature colour is a magenta pink/purple, representing the love and heartbreak Heart experiences due to Mind and Soul's combined abuse, as they're both absolutely more powerful than Heart and can easily batter him down into giving up (as seen in the final lines of The Heart Acoustic) - The backup singing lines Heart has with Mind in The Soul Eclectic, they both criticize Soul, and I think this could be taken one of two ways: → Soul is puppeteering both Mind and Heart to criticize Soul and push them both deeper into punishment → Mind and Heart are trying to break free of Soul's strings, Mind being more successful as his voice is quieter and fainter than Heart's, indicating he's breaking free of Soul's control. - Heart uses a lot of mathematics in The Heart Acoustic, which you would expect Mind to do, but I think it's symbolic that Heart may be the most logical and feeling of the trio, as their voice in the beginning is quiet and breaking, indicating they may have been crying behind their blind eyes, before becoming more agitated and angry. *(The Mind Electric)* - Mind has a deep, robotic voice, the complete opposite of Heart, symbolic of his "logical" nature, and how their "logic is absolute", showing how they're a cold, calculating machine, insulting Heart any chance they get. They even describe (through Heart's perception, no less) that Heart sees them as a "cynical machine", and similarly, Heart describes them as an "automaton freak" before The Mind Electric begins. - In The Mind Electric, when Mind is describing how Heart "plays profound", we can hear Soul in the background saying "see how he lies", perhaps indicating that Soul is making Mind say all these horrible things about Heart, as typically, a soul and a mind are more connected than a heart would be. - Both Mind and Heart refer to light in the beginning of their respective songs, referring to "glares", perhaps insinuating that Soul is watching and judging their every move, glaring at them. - Mind's signature colour is a medium, sea blue, which is typically the colour associated with mathematics in education, again referring to Mind's "logical" nature. - Mind refers to Heart as being scared, referring to how "fear still resounds" within them perhaps trying to break free from Soul's puppeteering. - Mind never moves during their song, maybe Soul has complete control, or maybe Soul has no control over them *(The Soul Eclectic)* - Soul is clearly insane, as described by Heart (Soul himself puppeteering) calling him a "madman" and even Soul themself saying that they doesn't mind what people call them, maybe even "insane", and they couldn't care if people use their real name (which is never stated), later even saying "I AM ME" to cement it. - Later, when they're talking to the "doctor", Soul says they cant tell if they're not themself, contradicting their earlier statement. - When Mind and Heart are backup singers, Soul forces them to work together, which is their biggest pet peeve. - At the end of The Mind Eclectic, Soul's guitar is blue, indicating they may have full control over Mind, but we don't see any indication of Heart's magenta. This has two connotations: → Something sinister, insinuating Soul absorbed Heart finally. → Something much less horrifying, that Heart finally broke free of Soul's strings. - Soul's voice is a blend of human and robot, indicating that they are a logical, feeling creature that's neither Mind nor Heart respectively. - Soul says that "one has split into three", indicating Heart and Mind are no longer part of them, as Soul is the ultimate being.
this sounds like Three people in a Honda pull up to a McDonald's. Heart is absolutely bawling about not getting a shake. Mind is just going wild on Heart thinking it'll help Heart settle down. Soul is so fed up of the arguing he says he'll cancel the order while trying to explain to the cashier.
I feel that the lyric "once humour me" sounds more like "resemble me". Like, "if Heart started to act like Mind, he'd see that the way he himself acts, isn't the best way to live life", that's just me-
@@ewelinanajgebauer8862 I do agree with you actually, I don't quite get how humoring him makes him see life 'logically'. I stuck to the official lyrics multiple times where they plain didn't fit. In the heart acoustic, i believe he said "spiralling down entropically" whereas in the lyrics it says "*so* spiralling down entropically". I added the word "so" in anyway even though he clearly doesn't say it 2:13
@@ewelinanajgebauer8862 In all honesty yeah? But then again when it means to Humor Someone or Something (like a thought or a decision) you do in fact step back to hear them out and think like them or think over an idea they have. So if Heart were to 'humor' Mind's way of living it would still kinda make sense. Yk?
I (indirectly) spoke to him about making this video public, and he said that he thought lyrics distracted from the video itself, which I can understand. He did say that this was a good alternative for anyone who wanted the lyrics, though
Soul: “WE’RE NOT GOING TO MCDONALDS IF YOU GUYS KEEP FIGHTING!” Mind: “HEART CALLED ME THE B WORD THOUGH!” Heart: “MOTHERF//KER DOESN’T START WITH A B-“
Gonna just sneak this in since this is half a year old and I don't think anyone except MAYBE the artist could read this. I always felt so sad for the anguish here, taking me back into a place I left a looong time ago with my family abuse. But now I feel.. so much closer to this. In the past month, I've gotten a triple-hernia in my neck along with early-age rheumatoid arthritis that's eating my spine, my mother who is the only reason I'm alive and got me out of that abusive place discovered two cancer-like tumors that are metastasizing at an insane rate, and yet everyone around us are draining every dollar they can before we both die what will assuredly be a painful death. My heart begs to give up and for mercy and love and peace and warmth, my mind screams for strength and logic and to shut it all out just to survive long enough to march through, and my soul just doesn't see the point of it all, walking the razor's edge between living and dead and begging to just stop thinking OR feeling, to just numb the pain and lobotomize myself. I won't do anything, if the artist does read this and worry, I'm no idiot and know I must carry on and will one day feel right again. I just wanted to say... I feel seen, is all. Thank you for giving me strength in these trying times.
i'd like to tell you I am not the artist, and the real artist, who has made much more like this is called Chonny Jash. Please, if you haven't, check him out.
this is literally perfect. the lyrics fit the song so well and all the effects work perfectly, the parts with multiple voices and multiple lyrics were amazing as well
This is the type of song I wish never ends (thank God I saved it) but I love how the soul is just the parent that is forced to put his fighting children on a leash while also trying to keep the body from killing itself. This is now my favorite song.
Left a comment not too long ago on the original post but just felt like reiterating that damn, this song makes me feel so understood, like a weight being lifted off my shoulders trying to conceptualize my thoughts and feelings and this cover just lays it out so perfectly for me, and the cherry on top being I find this cover on my birthday lol.
These lyrics are added in PERFECTLY DUDE. Absolutely wonderful, you not only found the font they use I think, it's animated in a really fun way they aren't just boring lyrics Legit the only "bad thing" is that there's lyrics that just aren't readable cause of too much glitchy effects, even though they ARE audible quite easily in actual audio -w-' Well done overall, amazing :>
@@portalmaster1018 hi! ive received that critique a lot, and I agree. I made the video like 2 years ago now maybe (whenever the song came out) and I would do a far better job now and I have considered redoing it, but this is kinda like my definitive version of this and a new one wouldnt get the same recognition. But I love your appreciation for it! Thank you
This is so well done!!! I love how you even went to the effort of adding special effects to the text to match the video's effects. If I didn't already know this was fanmade, I would 100% believe that Chonny himself had made this.
“I’m not nearly kind enough to leave you parasites fumbling slowly down this path in hopes the other stuck by lightning” This line is so unnecessary funny to me and I don’t know why😭 Everyone is just fed up with everyone else 💀
my favorite part is when both heart and mind fight in soul's song because even when not seeing the lyrics if you focus enough you can distinguish both sides
"So spiraling down entropically, I beg of thee have mercy on me, I am just a boy you see I plead of thee have sympathy for me-". It all sounds like a spiral both with the voice and the music behind it, I both do choir and play an instrument and I very appreciate it since it sounds nice :3"
Man this has a lot of love put into it! I love how it’s the same font that Chonny uses but with some unique editing of it. It fits the vibe really well!
anyone else get really intense plurality feels from this (and chonny's stuff in general) this deadass sounds like arguments my alters have had but like, way more intelligently worded and artful instead of just some brain gremlins hollering at each other
As someone who has no idea how they got here (but loves The Mind Electric a ton), I'd like to thank you for introducing me to this masterpiece! It was truly a blessing by the algorithm to find this video.:)
So basically… heart and mind are siblings that hate each other and soul is just “if you two don’t shut the fuck up I will crash this car and kill us all”
Damn, only just found this song and struggled to understand the lyrics. NGL, this song is probably a new favourite for having such a unique story and feelings.
"See how they fight all day. The other half wont hear whats has to say. Its just a game they play here in this labrynth maze" I relate to this harder than any of you realize. Explanation at 1k likes Edit: I'm joking even if I do get 1k likes I ain't saying sh*t
I am actually so obsessed with this trilogy of songs that i have made several ocs for it and have also squeezed all my favorite characters into situatiins where this song can represent them Edit: i also like the little detail that you can't see the eyes of Heart and Mind, because the eyes are the window to the Soul.
I like to think that these are the personalities or other people in the body like DIDs and the two others hate heart due to him being so emotional and caring while mind thinks he should be in charge due to being the smartest and soul is the main one in charge who tries to keep things together but hates the others and it’s a constant cycle between the three. A dysfunctional family
I'm just leaving this here to find my favorite parts, don't mind me. 2:32 - (this entire chorus) 5:54 - (again, this entire chorus) 9:14 - "I. AM. ME." 9:22 - (again, AGAIN, this entire chorus) 10:40 - "IT'S. JUST. A. GAME. They, play here in this la-byrinth, maze."
I like how in their end they turn to their other half, realising hat good they may do, but the lingering malice is still there, ending up in pure neutrality seeing their flaws, the order is also shown in the order that the organ shut down with the brain shutting down roughly 5 minutes after the heart stops beating, and with the cold calculations of the mind shut, the soul shows its true colours choosing the eliminates it's lesser thirds to end the torment of the conflict
This song feels like parents (Heart and Mind) arguing and their child (Soul) retreating to a world in their imagination where they’re in control. Idk, I think I’m just not over my parents being divorced
Theory The Vessel is experiencing depression and is about to crack (or as we like to call it "suicide") The Heart is trying to save the Vessel by controlling the Soul through emotion however he's not just trying to save the Vessel but also the Mind however emotion simply isn't strong enough but that's the only thing that they can do (talk through emotion) because they are blinded by their emotions unable to see other ways to fix the Vessel. The Mind is also trying to do the same but this time through logic as they view emotion as "weak" and they think that emotion is the reason why the Vessel is depressed so they trick the Soul into denying all emotion which causes the Vessel to become cold which causes it to "rot" and "fester" (become more depressed). both Mind and Heart are trying to control the Soul to save the Vessel however are not wise enough to work together The Soul who has complete control of the Vessel does not want to be controlled by the other two because they are them however they are unable to understand themselves due to Mind and Hearts constant fighting the Soul is unable to be heard and the Soul seeks freedom to be freed from their problems and to be freed from their festering Vessel (which is why the other two see him as a madman and insane) so they "tie the rope" (which is what the mind and heart were trying to prevent from doing so) Dang bro new OMORI DLC is wild
Something i like that i haven't seen someone point out is each versions instrumental How they fit the Singer The hearts instrumental is very Theatrical and Dramatic, fitting with hearts emotion driven argument The Minds instrumental is very oppressive and constructed, even intimidating, almost sounding like the musical version of an argument or verbal onslaught While the Souls instrumental feels chaotic and all over the place, fitting wuth him being over of mind and hearts bullshit, with the OG TME in the background too adds to the Chaos
I would like to address to anyone finding this video:
I DID NOT MAKE THIS PIECE OF MUSIC.
Multiple people seem to be mistaken in the comments here, and I would like to clear up that I am not the original author of this music. I simply added lyrics to the video.
The original creator of the music is Chonny Jash, and he has made much like this.
www.youtube.com/@ChonnyJash This is his account. If you liked this video, please refer to his channel.
I am sure he will appreciate the comments you are all posting much more than I would.
At least you addressed it
how did i get this comment section on a siivagunner rip
i mean id watched the video its from before but wtf
*Insulting Heart* "But let's leave it there" *proceeds to do anything but leave it there*
no because literally
wasnt he using words heart called him in the first half tho? idk thats how i understand it (and yeah ik half of the words he used probably werent used anywhere else in the album tho)
It's a callback to Heart concluding the same verse with "And any other adjective" , as well as Heart giving WAAAAAAY more descriptors then is necessary.
He did NOT leave it there😭
the vessel(if it's even concious): if i punch myself and it hurts, am i weak or strong?
heart: strong!
mind: weak.
soul: a dumb@ss
I refer to the Vessel as "The Whole" it rhymes with The Soul and fits real nice
@@The_Distortionist_Waits
The Heart Acoustic
The Mind Electric
The Soul Eclectic
The Whole Neglected
@@Asmokedetector OH MY WORD, YOU DID IT
@@AsmokedetectorPerfection
I think we can call the original mind electric The Whole Neglected, if you want lol
i kinda noticed that in the heart’s segment,he uses numbers and math,something youd think mind would do. but he dosent. i think this is supposed to show that heart is much more actually logical,trying to understand mind to no avail. mind just hates and hates,no matter what. and possibly,the weak emotions mind talks about is really just heart caring about him.
That could explain why hes getting sent to die via electric chair.
The Mind acted reckless, causing him to do whatever made get in trouble.
The original song could be the hearts perspective, from all what happened
Yeah, good observation! There’s a popular (iirc) comment on the original video pointing out that both Heart and Mind are really hypocritical; Heart’s pretty calm and logically dissing Mind, while Mind spends the entire time raging over Heart. As the song says, neither is wrong or right, but both are hypocritical.
@@mebin3059While it's the same melody as the OTHER The Mind Electric, the story of Hawaii Part II is entirely separate from the story Chonny is telling.
@mebin3059 this song is a completely different story from hawaii part 2 btw. This song is connected to chonnys own album
I actually thought the opposite when first hearing this, it seemed like to me that the heart and mind are trying to use each others native tounge to get the other to understand their point and thoughts, however they still are to focused on their demands to actually get the hint
The delivery on that "I AM ME" is incredible
RIGHT?? NOT ENOUGH PEOPLE TALK ABOUT IT AND GRRR THE ENTIRE SONG IS SO GOOD
Those words are the words of Simon trying to convince himself he’s not mad
*I AM ME* 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣
Timestamp?
*ITS ME*
"I won't hesitate to kill my heart and mind. I'll take you down in tandem, when this rope is tied."
Death kills the physical brain and heart, but the soul will always remain. The soul seeks freedom, even if the cost is life.
But the Heart and Mind refuse to die (Hence, the Bidding and We're Gonna win)
Im 90% sure its referencing suicide with how it mentions tridential regicide cluing us in on all 3 dying
@@Nos1maji had a stroke reading this and died
I don't think Soul is actually what we'd consider a 'soul', I think he's just the psyche's self-image and sense of identity (similarly, Heart is the emotional side of the psyche rather than the physical organ), but I love this reading of that line. It's so interesting to consider whether Soul thinks he'll survive the death of the body. He's clearly very detached from Heart and Mind, it wouldn't surprise me if he hasn't fully processed that his existence would end with theirs.
@@Nos1majyou mean triple regicide?
I like to imagine this takes place before the real mind electric, and that it's the internal conflict that he experiences on his way to the courtroom. Eventually, soul gains control of both his heart and his mind, so he pleads insanity to satiate both of them, and it ended up being the worst possible decision he could have made.
Soul: Alright if the two of you shut up for 5 minutes I have an idea to get us out of this mess. Trust me, nothing can _possibly_ go wrong.
^clueless
@@zekeram129 *5 hours later
Soul: guys I fucked up
Heart and mind: YOU THINK!?
@@BlueBerry20071 Soul like 2 seconds b4 the Nuns Commence Incanting: Guyyyys I didn't think this through :( We might be in trouble
misread courtroom as bathroom. he takes a shit and explodes
HOW MANY MIND ELECTRICS ARE THERE
The Kind of Irony
You'd read in *Bi-ble Stor-ies*
Idk why... But that line was absolutely beautiful
I swear, it’s just so _perfect_ and powerful in an almost indescribable way, like it just makes me *feel* things
timestamp?
6:11
@@redspikes07 6:21
Because it's true
I love how it sounds there are three characters, The Heart, The Brain and The Soul, Brain and Heart try and convince Soul to listen to one of them until they finally snap and gain control over the both of them as a result
Chonny is a galldamn master
Just a Little correction to help you understand the lyrics a bit better the Brain is to refer to both the Heart and Mind at once, as they are the hemispheres and the soul is the consciousness they make up
who's gonna tell em
Bro, they are different, the “brain” is the mind, and if you payed attention then you would’ve noticed
@@trashpanda3290 no, theyre right. the brain is in reference to the two halves as a whole. not an individual part. We know this because the heart says "See how the mind tricks the soul", and The Soul Eclectic is about the soul telling both halves that they are both at fault, and references them as one body "See how the brain plays around", and the person themself, or the "brain" is splitting "what was once whole down into three".
I haven't seen this mentioned, but Heart uses a more human voice, while Mind uses a more robotic voice (kinda electronic, like the mind) meanwhile, the Soul uses both
well it has been mentioned before
That is really interesting, genuine question: What is this song exactly about?
@galemannenman it's part of Chonny's covers album. It's an album of the conflict between the three, and how it affects Chonny. This and The Bidding are the peak of the proverbial conflict.
@galemannenman Basically, Heart and Mind, the first two characters, are fighting over who will influence the body and rule the brain.
Soul, the third singer, is in charge and wants the two to either synchronize and merge, so they can be whole again, or all die, so they can be at peace.
Soul is basically just autotuned Heart, Heart and Mind just sing in TSE
9:23 I like to think of the "serfs" as the rest of the physical body. Its like he's showing the heart and the mind what servants should be like. Giving it they got for the kingdom instead of arguing for power like they do. Especially since organs and bidy parts dont think or hesitate they just fulfill their function.
I also like how heart and say "fall" in the background seeing that role as more negative while soul sees it as noble.
body*
Some funny things ive noticed on rewatch-
-] The transition to the Soul Electic Act uses a sample from the original Mind Electric
Maybe because during the original Mind Electric, The Soul is in complete control, So his actions and what he will do eventually is referenced here, which is cool.
-] The 2 backup singers in Souls Act,
At first i thought it was the Devil and Angel you can find sitting on both shoulders.
But now with more thought, I think its actually The Heart and Mind. Fully controlled by the Soul.
-] Heart is blind, Mind only speaks, Soul is whole.
Heart is blind because the Heart acts solely on emotions alone.
Mind only speaks because thats what the Mind does, speak to itself through thoughts.
Soul is whole because it represents ones being. Its essence perchance.
Hey, so it seems like your new to chonny jash, maybe not.
Anyways, I just want to tell you that the angel and devil on souls shoulder thing seems like a crazy theory and I think you might me onto something.
There are four main charecters (Heart, Mind, Soul, Whole) but others are shown sometimes throughout the album. Maybe the angel and devil are responsible for some more voices throughout...
Btw soul and whole aren't the same charecter, soul is a shell of what whole used to be.
@@KingCrafter999 oh fr?
and yeah youre right about me being new to chonny jash
I watched this because I liked Hawaii Pt.2
didnt realise there was a whole separate lore for chonny jash songs
@@mebin3059 yep! Chonny jash has his own complete lore seperate from the rest of the Tally Hall/Miracle Musical songs.
It really does just narrow down to
“I’m angy because I lost my girl so I divide myself into 3 halves and then got stabbed.”
@@lolchipperson11person12 the story has nothing to do with original time
The emo version of bo Burnham's right brain* and left brain* act
Bo burnham is also emo 😭
@@whiteboytommy1411who told u bo was emo bro 😭
True tbh lol
@@ry0kugyu have you listened to any sing of his?
@@whiteboytommy1411 all of inside, all of www, and all of what
The Soul is really just the creation. The true existence of one's being.
The Heart and Brain playing as essential "Supports". But like a King with a Very Manipulative Courtier, they try to get the upperhand and be on top. They try to get the side of the SOUL on their side.
The Heart using Empathy while the Brain uses Logicality
The Soul finally had enough and question upon both of them. The heart who uses emotions as an answer yet is blinded by such while the Brain who uses Logic as the answer yet his pride shows stupidity underneath all that "absolute logic".
stop saying brain people
@@NyaberryOwOwhat's the difference
I think it's more like a emperor and two other kings/queens. The line "tridential regicide" refers to the act of killing a king/queen or a emperor as well as the "tridential" part which sugests that unlike heart and mind he see's it as three rulers, two who try to get him to defy/attack the other and the third who has the most power being sick of the two who see eachother as enemies when they are both partners who need eachother and also because he has more power but is useless without the other two and needs them to stay stable.
@@brodyratliff7441mind's supposed to be their thoughts/the logical side, the brain is the organ that the mind is in but the brain also controls emotions through hormones and stuff.
@@yigitkurtulmush4690 oh ok
Don’t mind me, just leaving this here for myself
5:53 see how the heart plays profound
2:31 see how it hurts when the sound
11:17 Tridential regicide
6:11 see how his feet miss the ground
My fav parts
So from what I can understand, this song is about someone's heart and mind fighting for control, or just to be heard. And it goes on and on until the person (soul i think) snaps and most likely takes their own life, to make the fighting stop. At least that's what I got from that last line about tying the rope.
Pretty much. As far as I can tell, the heart and mind are going back and forth and it ruins the person as a whole
there is a whole album revolving around this story. "Chonnys Charming Chaos Compendium". basically something happened so Chonnies (a fourth individual, the body) brain split in three (my guess is that Chonny tried suicide, but failed). the heart and mind need to become one, so that chonny doesnt get more suicidal. both heart and mind think that the other side isnt important and should be ignored. sould controls the body and mind and heart fight over who should control soul. at the end of this song the soul threatens final suicide to make heart and mind finally work together, which works as in the next song, the bidding, both finally match their rhymes for the first time and soul gets confidant and lets the suicide idea go. in a later song, the whole world and you, mind says that all of this was a test for heart to push the whole to be what they truly can be
the heart, is an emotional part, begging and bargaining, a "weak" yet rightful part, the mind, the unforgiving and has no sympathy, no emotion, a dictator of destruction, the soul, has both the parts of heart and mind, the most powerful, more sane than the mind yet is still insane to the heart.
Something I noticed several replays through:
*(The Heart Acoustic)*
- Heart has a human voice, well, more human than the others, and expresses more emotion, as they are the "emotional side"
- Heart also seems to be very agitated, twitching and itching their shoulder before the final lines where they "stare" blindly into the camera before glitching and swapping to Mind. I think this is Soul trying to take them over and control them, as seen in The Soul Eclectic when both Mind and Heart become "backup singers" for Soul. Additionally, we can also see a second, fainter figure over Heart through the entirety of the song. Similarly, he's "begging for it to stop", indicating they're in pain both mentally and physically, referring to "rotting" and "death" quite a few times.
- Heart's signature colour is a magenta pink/purple, representing the love and heartbreak Heart experiences due to Mind and Soul's combined abuse, as they're both absolutely more powerful than Heart and can easily batter him down into giving up (as seen in the final lines of The Heart Acoustic)
- The backup singing lines Heart has with Mind in The Soul Eclectic, they both criticize Soul, and I think this could be taken one of two ways:
→ Soul is puppeteering both Mind and Heart to criticize Soul and push them both deeper into punishment
→ Mind and Heart are trying to break free of Soul's strings, Mind being more successful as his voice is quieter and fainter than Heart's, indicating he's breaking free of Soul's control.
- Heart uses a lot of mathematics in The Heart Acoustic, which you would expect Mind to do, but I think it's symbolic that Heart may be the most logical and feeling of the trio, as their voice in the beginning is quiet and breaking, indicating they may have been crying behind their blind eyes, before becoming more agitated and angry.
*(The Mind Electric)*
- Mind has a deep, robotic voice, the complete opposite of Heart, symbolic of his "logical" nature, and how their "logic is absolute", showing how they're a cold, calculating machine, insulting Heart any chance they get. They even describe (through Heart's perception, no less) that Heart sees them as a "cynical machine", and similarly, Heart describes them as an "automaton freak" before The Mind Electric begins.
- In The Mind Electric, when Mind is describing how Heart "plays profound", we can hear Soul in the background saying "see how he lies", perhaps indicating that Soul is making Mind say all these horrible things about Heart, as typically, a soul and a mind are more connected than a heart would be.
- Both Mind and Heart refer to light in the beginning of their respective songs, referring to "glares", perhaps insinuating that Soul is watching and judging their every move, glaring at them.
- Mind's signature colour is a medium, sea blue, which is typically the colour associated with mathematics in education, again referring to Mind's "logical" nature.
- Mind refers to Heart as being scared, referring to how "fear still resounds" within them perhaps trying to break free from Soul's puppeteering.
- Mind never moves during their song, maybe Soul has complete control, or maybe Soul has no control over them
*(The Soul Eclectic)*
- Soul is clearly insane, as described by Heart (Soul himself puppeteering) calling him a "madman" and even Soul themself saying that they doesn't mind what people call them, maybe even "insane", and they couldn't care if people use their real name (which is never stated), later even saying "I AM ME" to cement it.
- Later, when they're talking to the "doctor", Soul says they cant tell if they're not themself, contradicting their earlier statement.
- When Mind and Heart are backup singers, Soul forces them to work together, which is their biggest pet peeve.
- At the end of The Mind Eclectic, Soul's guitar is blue, indicating they may have full control over Mind, but we don't see any indication of Heart's magenta. This has two connotations:
→ Something sinister, insinuating Soul absorbed Heart finally.
→ Something much less horrifying, that Heart finally broke free of Soul's strings.
- Soul's voice is a blend of human and robot, indicating that they are a logical, feeling creature that's neither Mind nor Heart respectively.
- Soul says that "one has split into three", indicating Heart and Mind are no longer part of them, as Soul is the ultimate being.
Thank you for this information it actually helped me understand the song better
Thank you for explaining this. I am a dumbass and needed this to understand the song
yall should listen to the whole album, theres so much more than this
Heart apologist
@@definitelynotaperson1598im a heart apologist because he is literally me /j
Yo does anyone notice that near the end of the hearts verse, the soul can be heard very faintly? Well until the heart hands off to the mind
Which part?
@@BradleyBiggle near the end, at "see how the sound..."
You can also see his visual effect and red color through the bit.
and you can see soul in the background during the "see how the serfs/someone help me" part
this sounds like
Three people in a Honda pull up to a McDonald's.
Heart is absolutely bawling about not getting a shake.
Mind is just going wild on Heart thinking it'll help Heart settle down.
Soul is so fed up of the arguing he says he'll cancel the order while trying to explain to the cashier.
I feel that the lyric "once humour me" sounds more like "resemble me". Like, "if Heart started to act like Mind, he'd see that the way he himself acts, isn't the best way to live life", that's just me-
I got these from the official lyrics
@@fayeknd Huh. Oke, i still feel like it kinds sounds better as "if he'd just resemble me, he'd see we need to live life logically"-
@@ewelinanajgebauer8862 I do agree with you actually, I don't quite get how humoring him makes him see life 'logically'. I stuck to the official lyrics multiple times where they plain didn't fit. In the heart acoustic, i believe he said "spiralling down entropically" whereas in the lyrics it says "*so* spiralling down entropically". I added the word "so" in anyway even though he clearly doesn't say it
2:13
@@fayeknd he didn't quite finish the word, but he DOES say it.
It sounds more like "s- spiraling down entropically"
@@ewelinanajgebauer8862 In all honesty yeah? But then again when it means to Humor Someone or Something (like a thought or a decision) you do in fact step back to hear them out and think like them or think over an idea they have. So if Heart were to 'humor' Mind's way of living it would still kinda make sense. Yk?
Everytime I listen to this I notice something different how one of the background beats in Heart's bit fo the song is literally a heartbeat
every time i listen to this i notice more and more how chonny jash is an incredible artist and his music is some of the best i have ever heard
7:20 THE WAY HE SAYS YO 💗💖💖💗
Yo🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😼😼😼😼😼😼😼😼🫁🫁🫁
KEL PFP
i think personally the mind and heart are divorced/j
in a custody battle for soul
@@ITZ_HIPPSHI I cannot handle this reply /pos
wdym /j that's literally what happened
I personally think they should get UNdivorced and then kiss /j
This happens in light@@The_lamb_sauce
I love their cover but I wish they were able to put lyrics so thank you for putting them on the video.
I (indirectly) spoke to him about making this video public, and he said that he thought lyrics distracted from the video itself, which I can understand. He did say that this was a good alternative for anyone who wanted the lyrics, though
@@fayeknd That is good! I get that too just its hard to catch all the lyrics.
Soul: “WE’RE NOT GOING TO MCDONALDS IF YOU GUYS KEEP FIGHTING!”
Mind: “HEART CALLED ME THE B WORD THOUGH!”
Heart: “MOTHERF//KER DOESN’T START WITH A B-“
i like you i think youre cool
@@fayeknd :0 omg thank you!
IM WHEEZING OMG
*correction
Heart: MIND CALLED ME THE B WORD
Mind: MOTHERFUCKER DOESN'T START WITH A B
Soul: DO NOT MAKE ME TURN THIS CAR THE F∆CK AROUND!
Gonna just sneak this in since this is half a year old and I don't think anyone except MAYBE the artist could read this.
I always felt so sad for the anguish here, taking me back into a place I left a looong time ago with my family abuse. But now I feel.. so much closer to this. In the past month, I've gotten a triple-hernia in my neck along with early-age rheumatoid arthritis that's eating my spine, my mother who is the only reason I'm alive and got me out of that abusive place discovered two cancer-like tumors that are metastasizing at an insane rate, and yet everyone around us are draining every dollar they can before we both die what will assuredly be a painful death.
My heart begs to give up and for mercy and love and peace and warmth, my mind screams for strength and logic and to shut it all out just to survive long enough to march through, and my soul just doesn't see the point of it all, walking the razor's edge between living and dead and begging to just stop thinking OR feeling, to just numb the pain and lobotomize myself.
I won't do anything, if the artist does read this and worry, I'm no idiot and know I must carry on and will one day feel right again. I just wanted to say... I feel seen, is all. Thank you for giving me strength in these trying times.
i'd like to tell you I am not the artist, and the real artist, who has made much more like this is called Chonny Jash. Please, if you haven't, check him out.
this is literally perfect. the lyrics fit the song so well and all the effects work perfectly, the parts with multiple voices and multiple lyrics were amazing as well
thank ou :))
This isn’t just a song, it’s a true work of art. The depth is truly amazing
Dam even chonny 's fans are dedicated! This lyrics video looks official:D
The heart acoustic already makes me feel feral
I might leave the rest for later
Came back, already a few seconds into the second part ARFARFARFARF
The soul already slaps after a few seconds as well
never seen a song inadvertently express the juxtaposing dichotomy of the philosophies of red and blue from mtg so well
I love Heart’s constant little self-soothing habits
This is the type of song I wish never ends (thank God I saved it) but I love how the soul is just the parent that is forced to put his fighting children on a leash while also trying to keep the body from killing itself. This is now my favorite song.
man i can't believe chonny jash invented epilepsy guys :3
Left a comment not too long ago on the original post but just felt like reiterating that damn, this song makes me feel so understood, like a weight being lifted off my shoulders trying to conceptualize my thoughts and feelings and this cover just lays it out so perfectly for me, and the cherry on top being I find this cover on my birthday lol.
6:12 - 6:40 is my favorite part.
Im saving this part to use In a pmv later!
2:03 heart teaches you how to math
These lyrics are added in PERFECTLY DUDE.
Absolutely wonderful, you not only found the font they use I think, it's animated in a really fun way they aren't just boring lyrics
Legit the only "bad thing" is that there's lyrics that just aren't readable cause of too much glitchy effects, even though they ARE audible quite easily in actual audio -w-'
Well done overall, amazing :>
@@portalmaster1018 hi! ive received that critique a lot, and I agree. I made the video like 2 years ago now maybe (whenever the song came out) and I would do a far better job now and I have considered redoing it, but this is kinda like my definitive version of this and a new one wouldnt get the same recognition. But I love your appreciation for it! Thank you
alternate take where Heart, blindfolded, is not facing the camera.
i think he doesnt know theres a camera but just accidentally stares at it
@@fayeknd makes sense
This is so well done!!! I love how you even went to the effort of adding special effects to the text to match the video's effects. If I didn't already know this was fanmade, I would 100% believe that Chonny himself had made this.
Thank you! this is exactly what I was going for, to make it as close as possible to his style. It means a lot to know this has worked!
Heart and Mind give vibes of siblings in an argument while soul is their arrogant, annoyed parent.
Mind keeps going on about “logic” but you can visibly *see* how mad mind is while talking about heart
2:31 see how it hurts when the sound
5:53 see how the heart plays profound
11:17 tridential regicide
This is basically a disrap between him, himself and they
This is a combination between a Mashup, cover, long versión and fanmade version, I love it
“I’m not nearly kind enough to leave you parasites fumbling slowly down this path in hopes the other stuck by lightning”
This line is so unnecessary funny to me and I don’t know why😭
Everyone is just fed up with everyone else 💀
This line is actually ironic, since in the actual Mind Electric they both get electrocuted, basically struck by lightning
@@Mx.muffinWAIT STOP I JUST REALIZED THAT😭
This would kill easily a victorian grown man in just 2 minutes
my favorite part is when both heart and mind fight in soul's song because even when not seeing the lyrics if you focus enough you can distinguish both sides
"So spiraling down entropically, I beg of thee have mercy on me, I am just a boy you see I plead of thee have sympathy for me-". It all sounds like a spiral both with the voice and the music behind it, I both do choir and play an instrument and I very appreciate it since it sounds nice :3"
Man this has a lot of love put into it! I love how it’s the same font that Chonny uses but with some unique editing of it. It fits the vibe really well!
8:26 ohh I saw that
you are the first person to mention seeing that ever (congratulations!!!)
@@fayekndbro everyone got that æ
See what?
@@Demo-cj5fdthe a in pray flickering to the e in prey
@@Demo-cj5fdsee ur mom
I like how you can hear a heartbeat during the first part. Once that rises and lowers in bpm based on the tempo of the song
anyone else get really intense plurality feels from this (and chonny's stuff in general)
this deadass sounds like arguments my alters have had but like, way more intelligently worded and artful instead of just some brain gremlins hollering at each other
Brain gremlins??!
YES OH MY GOD!!! My alters go ape shit for this song. Like..feral children with any form of sugar.
call me your HOST or call me insane
the soul is the host
As someone who has no idea how they got here (but loves The Mind Electric a ton), I'd like to thank you for introducing me to this masterpiece! It was truly a blessing by the algorithm to find this video.:)
average friend group
i like your comment thank you
So basically… heart and mind are siblings that hate each other and soul is just “if you two don’t shut the fuck up I will crash this car and kill us all”
yea
I love how the mind and heart get their own song/part but the souls part has both the mind and heart bickering in it.
this genuinely looks like its official. amazing fucking job mate, good on you
10:07 HOLY SHIT THIS IS THE BEST PART HONESTLY
I AGREE- but 5:50 - 6:40
These complex words are too complicated for my feeble mind to comprehend
u. ur feeble. ur feeble what,.?
@@heelturn2and frail??
@@Im_justhereCould this perhaps...be a Chonny Jash reference?
@@finleyforevermore perhaps…
I’ve never felt more badass making *pasta* before
5:50 HOLY FUCK THIS PART GOES HARD
2:24 Heart
5:51 Mind
9:14 Soul
For anyone who wants it:
Watch how his feet miss the ground verse for mind
5:45
Oh my god. This blew me away. This is now a canon prequel to Mind Electric for me
IM SO SILYL AND WHIMSICAL I LOVE CHONNY JASH YAYYY!!!
this is a top 5 comment....
Damn, only just found this song and struggled to understand the lyrics. NGL, this song is probably a new favourite for having such a unique story and feelings.
if chonny does a cover album of self ish I'll spontaneously combust
OH MY GOD I'D DIE /POS
1:30 i like to call these types of melodys round-a-bouts, and they're amazing
"See how they fight all day.
The other half wont hear whats has to say.
Its just a game they play here in this labrynth maze"
I relate to this harder than any of you realize.
Explanation at 1k likes
Edit: I'm joking even if I do get 1k likes I ain't saying sh*t
bro you aint getting 1k likes
@@fayeknd I know that's the point
@@TheDemonicChaoticFair enough lol
CMONNNN LETS GET THIS TO 1K LIKES!!!
@kelxey ain't no way u gonna try bruh
the end of mind's part is the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard
the way you added the effects to the lyricsss its all perfecttt
It was storming the whole time I was watching this but it started pouring rain and flashing like crazy when it got to the soul eclectic.
Rain world Five Pebbles reference no way
This is the most underrated cover I have ever seen
The heart is like pathos and the mind is logos, both trying to appeal to the side of the soul which is/has ethos
You know you can't see if you're blindfolded right
Really!?? 🤯
heart was blinded, they cant see anything anyway
6:11 this part tickles my brain
If only I knew how to animate...
Me too buddy. . . . Me too. . . .
MIND'S SCATTERING SPARKS PART SOUNDS LIKE SPACE STATION LEVEL 7
I am actually so obsessed with this trilogy of songs that i have made several ocs for it and have also squeezed all my favorite characters into situatiins where this song can represent them
Edit: i also like the little detail that you can't see the eyes of Heart and Mind, because the eyes are the window to the Soul.
I like to think that these are the personalities or other people in the body like DIDs and the two others hate heart due to him being so emotional and caring while mind thinks he should be in charge due to being the smartest and soul is the main one in charge who tries to keep things together but hates the others and it’s a constant cycle between the three. A dysfunctional family
If you are listening to this without headphones, listen to it with headphones NOW.
i am listening to this with headphones
@@fayeknd good
Kinda realizing, chonny is very androgynous.
Im gonna be honest,hes the only reason im more androgynous in my presentation (someone thought i was a guy onece lmao)
1:14 JEKYLL AND HYDE!!!!!!!!!1!!!
It's a great novella right?
If you wonder what the font is, it's called 'The Unseen'.
The mind and heart being an old married couple fighting over custody of their bratty kid the soul
The fact that he was able to mix The mind electric demo 4 and Labyrinth was Awesome.
10:08 sounds pretty cool with headphones
Mind keeps going on about “logic” but you can visibly *see* how mad heart is while talking about heart
6:11 the part i love.
i agree
I'm just leaving this here to find my favorite parts, don't mind me.
2:32 - (this entire chorus)
5:54 - (again, this entire chorus)
9:14 - "I. AM. ME."
9:22 - (again, AGAIN, this entire chorus)
10:40 - "IT'S. JUST. A. GAME. They, play here in this la-byrinth, maze."
The blood in my heart, the chemicals in my brain, and whatever in my soul very much likey likey
I Never Even noticed this wasn’t Chonny jash
I like how in their end they turn to their other half, realising hat good they may do, but the lingering malice is still there, ending up in pure neutrality seeing their flaws, the order is also shown in the order that the organ shut down with the brain shutting down roughly 5 minutes after the heart stops beating, and with the cold calculations of the mind shut, the soul shows its true colours choosing the eliminates it's lesser thirds to end the torment of the conflict
This song feels like parents (Heart and Mind) arguing and their child (Soul) retreating to a world in their imagination where they’re in control. Idk, I think I’m just not over my parents being divorced
3:01 - Heart
6:11 - Mind
9:18 - Soul
thank you for making this! it makes the song even more entertaining to listen to. amazing lyric video
Theory
The Vessel is experiencing depression and is about to crack (or as we like to call it "suicide")
The Heart is trying to save the Vessel by controlling the Soul through emotion however he's not just trying to save the Vessel but also the Mind however emotion simply isn't strong enough but that's the only thing that they can do (talk through emotion) because they are blinded by their emotions unable to see other ways to fix the Vessel.
The Mind is also trying to do the same but this time through logic as they view emotion as "weak" and they think that emotion is the reason why the Vessel is depressed so they trick the Soul into denying all emotion which causes the Vessel to become cold which causes it to "rot" and "fester" (become more depressed).
both Mind and Heart are trying to control the Soul to save the Vessel however are not wise enough to work together
The Soul who has complete control of the Vessel does not want to be controlled by the other two because they are them however they are unable to understand themselves due to Mind and Hearts constant fighting the Soul is unable to be heard and the Soul seeks freedom to be freed from their problems and to be freed from their festering Vessel (which is why the other two see him as a madman and insane) so they "tie the rope" (which is what the mind and heart were trying to prevent from doing so)
Dang bro new OMORI DLC is wild
Something i like that i haven't seen someone point out is each versions instrumental
How they fit the Singer
The hearts instrumental is very Theatrical and Dramatic, fitting with hearts emotion driven argument
The Minds instrumental is very oppressive and constructed, even intimidating, almost sounding like the musical version of an argument or verbal onslaught
While the Souls instrumental feels chaotic and all over the place, fitting wuth him being over of mind and hearts bullshit, with the OG TME in the background too adds to the Chaos