This is a terrific 'live' performance! I Maestro Janowski does some interesting things with the score, which you can hear when compared with other performances. This video deserves to be placed among the top recommendations for this symphony on TH-cam. Thanks for posting!
Absolutely fantastic recording in this world class AMAZING performance!!! Only 34k views of this ludicrous gem??? Should be 3 million! Others are missing big time on this!
MAGNÍFICA interpretación por esta célebre orquesta alemana con sede en Colonia de la Sinfonía Nº 8 apodada "La Grande" del compositor vienés Franz Schubert de inicios del Romanticismo. BRAVO !!!. Saludos desde España.
00:32 excelente enunciação do tema pelas trompas. Bom andamento. Boa articulação.03:21 destaque para a clareza das cordas.04:49 excelente articulação nas madeiras. Da mesma forma 07:45. 36:56 Trio do Scherzo. Destaque para edição de vídeo. 43:00 finale eletrizante!!! Excelente andamento!!! Espetacular cordas!!! Pela riqueza de detalhes, eloquência do discurso musical e conjunto imagem e som uma das melhores interpretações já gravadas no século XXI!!!! BRAVO!!!!
*Wspaniała wersja symf.nr.9, D major, powyżej (ABOVE) , jeśli zaliczymy jego `UNFINISHED` jako symf.nr.8! Brawo Maestro Janowski!* 👍👍🎶 ❤❤. *Many thanks for posting!*
Janowski navigates the lanscape of Schubert 8 with an inimitable sense for its temporal, spacial and spiritual cohesion and utmost clarity. What does a good conductor do ? Attend a performance under MJ and you will know the answer.
26:37 The best part of this mvt when this interlude returns in A major, here led a bit too fast for my liking, The cameraman, if he knew the score, would have focused on the violas which are the real stars of this part.
Hi, gabriel! According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
No soy muy conocedor de la obra de Shubert, pero esta sinfonia identifico que es la 9 "The Great", y la 8 es conocida también como inconclusa ¿Hay algún motivo o corrección que desconozco?
Hola Raúl, According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. 😊
According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
Am wondering if this is labeled Sym #8 because someone doesn't count the "Unfinished (#8) as a symphony. That would make this one the eighth. Seems unlikely, but perhaps that's the explanation. No classical music fan would mistake the 9th for the 8th, and this may be a simple error by the person who posted this. Anyway--the performance is superb, the music divine.
According to the Deutsch catalogue / Schubert: Thematic Catalogue of all his Works in Chronological Order, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. Interestingly, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new idea ;)
Hi, maxp129! According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
This is a terrific 'live' performance! I Maestro Janowski does some interesting things with the score, which you can hear when compared with other performances. This video deserves to be placed among the top recommendations for this symphony on TH-cam. Thanks for posting!
Sehr sehr schönes Hornsolo zu Beginn👍👍🎶🎶🎯🎯
Phantastic Version of this symphony!
Absolutely fantastic recording in this world class AMAZING performance!!! Only 34k views of this ludicrous gem??? Should be 3 million! Others are missing big time on this!
Thank you very much!
We're happy that you like our performance! 🥰
MAGNÍFICA interpretación por esta célebre orquesta alemana con sede en Colonia de la Sinfonía Nº 8 apodada "La Grande" del compositor vienés Franz Schubert de inicios del Romanticismo. BRAVO !!!. Saludos desde España.
00:32 excelente enunciação do tema pelas trompas. Bom andamento. Boa articulação.03:21 destaque para a clareza das cordas.04:49 excelente articulação nas madeiras. Da mesma forma 07:45. 36:56 Trio do Scherzo. Destaque para edição de vídeo. 43:00 finale eletrizante!!! Excelente andamento!!! Espetacular cordas!!! Pela riqueza de detalhes, eloquência do discurso musical e conjunto imagem e som uma das melhores interpretações já gravadas no século XXI!!!! BRAVO!!!!
27:06 look, Schubert himself playing the cello!
Magnifique !
참으로 멋지고 훌륭한 연주, 그리고 아름다운 영상입니다!!
Thank you! We are glad that you like it 🥰
Bellísimo!! Muchas gracias!!
*Wspaniała wersja symf.nr.9, D major, powyżej (ABOVE) , jeśli zaliczymy jego `UNFINISHED` jako symf.nr.8! Brawo Maestro Janowski!* 👍👍🎶 ❤❤. *Many thanks for posting!*
Our pleasure!
We're happy that you like it 🤗
دي السيمفونية رقم ٩ المعروفة باسم السيمفونية العظيمة
Janowski navigates the lanscape of Schubert 8 with an inimitable sense for its temporal, spacial and spiritual cohesion and utmost clarity. What does a good conductor do ? Attend a performance under MJ and you will know the answer.
Agreed! 🙂
What are you even talking about? They're not playing Schubert 8.
これほど素晴らしい「グレート」が今まであっただろうか
The Great!!!!!
26:37 The best part of this mvt when this interlude returns in A major, here led a bit too fast for my liking, The cameraman, if he knew the score, would have focused on the violas which are the real stars of this part.
壮大かつリズミカル！このグレートは歴史に遺したいです!
At 48.08 Schubert himself play cello
would've been the best recording of the symphony I've heard. if not for those merciless fits of coughing (((
Está no es la Octava (inconclusa) sino la Gran "Do" o 9a. Sinfonía de Schubert
Hi, gabriel! According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
@@WDRKlassik I appreciate your answer and be sure that I Will spread ir to My circle of family and Friends. Vielen Dank
@@WDRKlassik ah ok. I was gonna say there are two extra moments 😂!
No soy muy conocedor de la obra de Shubert, pero esta sinfonia identifico que es la 9 "The Great", y la 8 es conocida también como inconclusa ¿Hay algún motivo o corrección que desconozco?
Hola Raúl,
According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. 😊
I hate to be nitpicking, but, this is not Symphony No.8 by Schubert, but No.9 - " die Grosse ". This should be corrected !
According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
@@WDRKlassik Thanks for the clarification. For a long time I have been confused. Even since I was a kid, for me the 8th was the Unfinished Symphony.
Oups! This is not the 1080p in video quality! Could be a 720p.
Who is the wonderful leader of the first violins ?
Hi, sorry for replying so late. Her name is Elena Graf, she is a German violinist and played this concert with the WDR Symphony Orchestra 😄
Am wondering if this is labeled Sym #8 because someone doesn't count the "Unfinished (#8) as a symphony. That would make this one the eighth. Seems unlikely, but perhaps that's the explanation. No classical music fan would mistake the 9th for the 8th, and this may be a simple error by the person who posted this. Anyway--the performance is superb, the music divine.
According to the Deutsch catalogue / Schubert: Thematic Catalogue of all his Works in Chronological Order, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. Interestingly, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new idea ;)
@@WDRKlassik Thank you for this update. I was unaware of this, as I suppose were many others.
이 교향곡은 8번이 아니고 9번 아닌가요 ?
D 944 는 9번 거인이잖아요. 8번은 미완성 교향곡....
What ? This is not the 9th ?
Hi, maxp129! According to the Deutsch catalogue, Schuberts' "die Grosse" is actually symphony No. 8. But there has been - and still is - some controversy about it. Brahms originally counted it as No. 7 and other publishers later counted it as No. 9. But this has been revised since 1978. Also, Breitkopf & Härtel, publisher of the symphony, considers it be No. 8. But surprisingly or not, the other counting is still often used, even on CDs or in concert programmes. As we all know, the world of classical music tends to adapt slowly to new ideas. 😉
@@WDRKlassik Thank you so much for your response with further details !
1234
Ток это 9, а 8 это неоконченная
「偉大なる」？ 最近はこう訳すのか？ なんかなぁ‥‥。カタカナを避けるのなら「大交響曲」と直球で訳した方がいいんじゃなかろうか。