Why Blue Cards will RUIN Football…
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.พ. 2024
- Blue cards have been announced as part of future changes to football rules and The Kick Off lads have not reacted well to it.
📧 Business Email : info@truegeordie.com
🎙️ TG Channel : / @truegeordie
🥊 The Pain Game : / @paingamepodcast
⚽️ The Kick Off : / @thekickoff
🐦 Twitter : / truegeordietg
📸 Instagram : / truegeordieofficialll - กีฬา
Making it blue actually makes sense. A good chunk of ppl won't be able to tell the difference between yellow and orange on a TV screen, same for fans in upper tiers of big stadiums.
Indeed. Also, useful for color blind people
You have a brain, my friend, they have never had the brains to reason things out, only to criticise them. It's so tiring
Exactly what I was coming in to say. And some colour blind people struggle to distinguish between red and orange as well.
It's also not supposed to be an 'in between card'. It's more severe than yellow cards sometimes, and less severe when it would otherwise be a second yellow.
Exactly. The colour is the least ill-thought-out part of this doomed concept. Use red and yellow cards properly, please!
I totally agree with the point where if a player is "sin binned", the opposing team will become very defensive. However, what if there is a possibility where this further encourages the team with the advantage to have their players try to run at and take on players more often, instead of trying to do 300 passes to no avail. We may see multiple players get sin binned making for intriguing moments.
Works in Rugby, players wouldn't dare talk to the ref the way the football players do. They have no respect
Mate half the time the refs make a wrong decision they should be called out and challenged on the pitch … don’t ever protect theese refs
Fuck the refs lol
NBA dont need that because for stupid protest give you a technical fault.
they do this in Hockey and Bandy as well.. yet still players complain to the refs and still get sent off. i agree with Brian here! there is no reason to make the simple game of football more complicated. i get that it makes sense in other sports, but football aint the one. we have the yellow and red card for a reason.
Problem is the refs deserve no respect
If Blue cards are genuinely effective in stopping so many unnessessary breaks because a player is faking injury/acting like a twat then i'm actually all for it. What i DON'T want is a blue card handed out everytime there's any incident.
Agreed
So make football more robotic than it already is?😂😂😂
Stuff like that are part of the game, the dark arts should be praised
I as a colourblind would trouble to identify between yellow and orange or oragen and red. So I'm for the blue colour, but against the whole concept behind this new card.
Not even colourblind l, of your fat away, in the sun, or just ensures no confusion
I’m a rugby fan and don’t watch football much these days, one thing I’ll say whenever I do watch football even now compared to rugby the treatment refs get from players is disgusting (and I say that because rugby refs aren’t treated as well as they used to be) dissent should be punished far more, at the end of the day they’re doing a job, and they don’t deserve to be treated badly
No one cares about your rugby loving opinions, grown men can’t take few swear words, people like you are embarrassing
I watch both to, I agree that I hate when 3/4players rush up to the ref & stock their fingers in his face, it's childish af. Refs do need more respect, but the standard &way they treat players is also at a shocking level. In rugby the ref will always talk to a player, & is always available to the captain, if a decision is made they will explain why whether it's a try being awarded ir not, why it was a yellow not a red etc, if it's an issue with a player that doesn't warrant a card they will talk to them or tell the captain to, like a good parent, as its nothing serious but needs to be stopped as if not it will lead to something.l, like there's no way diego gets sent off in the Derby for swooning his arms (& I'm not man u fan), its petty af, he's frustrated. They talk with his upstairs to come to a decision together. Many of these soccer refs have far to big an ego, I barely ever see them move their mouths when players do surround them, they just stand there, maybe point a finger to go away. They do need to be treated better, but only after they pull their own fingers out of their as
One third of any match the ball is not in play. Another card will not do much to change the amount of time already wasted.
Automated offsides and either get rid of VAR or a challenge system. 1 challenge, lose it if you are wrong keep it if you’re right
How about stopping the clock every time the ball is out of play or when a player flops and writhes in fake agony instead of another card?? I think deliberate time-wasting is one of the most annoying things in football today!!
It's not time wasting VAR is already in every single football game ever.
Its just adding it correctly to the real game.
Yes, but you need to be punished for it, that's about keeping time, isn't going to stop players from vomiting a cynical foul of you just pause the click. It's also logistically impossible to stop the clock every time a single infraction is made & gameplay stops for 3 secs. Even in rugby they only pause the clock for a major stoppage
Honestly footballs going to end up like bloody nfl game at this rate. Might as well have a halftime show now and be done with it.
I thought the colour blue was the most logical part of it😂
It’s a strange thing to get annoyed about 2bf
So what happens once a keeper gets a blue card? Then you have to get a on field player must change shirts and gloves, this will slow down the game.
Same, that would happen if they had a red card.
Also it shouldn't slow down the game.
I play a card game with my friends, we added a rule and the games speed didn't change at all.
The management of th game itself sucks.
Even if blue card was a good idea(which is it), the refs being terrible and VAR being slow is an overall problem with the management of the game itself and not a problem with the game.
VAR is the perfect idea and should always be a thing, if they can't use it correct fire them.
Making the correct decide and fast should give them boost pay.
Being slow and wrong should decrease their pay or reduced any increased pay from good decides.
That'll rarely happen, because a gk isn't going to perform a cynical foul in the middle of the pitch. & yes, just like when a gk is sent off with no substitute left, an outfield player will take over, unless there's less than 10min & they do have a sub left
2:58 alright mate. You go have 90 minutes of little shits swearing and using intimidation against you when they have no right to. Dont mind arguments against blue cards based on not trusting the refs to use it correctly. But Jesus Christ saying “just deal with dissent” smacks of someone with very little thought beyond their own perspective
Old mate saying "4 guys in a fuckin Van somewhere 😅"
Well they can't seem to get it together, even the simple stuff like drawing lines
If Grealish had been playing 20 years ago he'd have been reviled by players and fans alike as a cheat who's primary skillet is diving or "Drawing Fouls" as it's known today.
Does the clock for 10 mins get stopped when the ball goes out of play. If I went a man down for a blue card, Id tell my players pre game to go down injured with cramp or something like that. Teams will just waste the 10 mins.
why is true geordies neck so red
There definitely have been fewer goals given. Think how many times there's an offside in play
Brian saying games are too slow as a newcastle fan is funny.
09:49 Spot on about handball and falling over
The handball rule is so clear. The problem is the penalty, not the handball.
VAR is ruining the premier league. Blue cards will be the final nail.
No, shirt bar is running the game, hey it to work correctly like in Germany or rugby, it'll be good
Blue cards, ffs. So players have to sit on the naughty step? VAR officials will waste 5 mins reviewing every incident to decide if a player should be sin-binned for 10 minutes, on top of all the other stoppages. Matches are going to drag on for 3 hours! If the powers that be are hellbent on introducing sinbins, the blue card should replace yellow cards entirely, with no VAR intervention.
I'd change the offside rule to benefit the attacker and the mark is the back foot vs the defender
What no recap of yesterday since United won? Figures.
VAR isn't a rule.
Its the way the rules are enforced.
The ref can't see everything.
If the ball didn't go In the net but was super close.
The ref wouldn't be able to tell what happened.
I wouldn’t get rid of VAR at this point I would just make them learn how to use it properly. There needs to be some kind of standard that every official has to maintain instead of all these areas left up to interpretation.
Whats next? Penalty Boxes like in hockey??
false comparison
Just make it a red card offence to backchat or shout at a referee. You would solve the dissent problem instantly.
Look at hockey, thats what they are proposing, im assuming
All I can think with the concept of Blue Cards is "Thank Fuck Mike Dean is Retired"
Old man shouts at clouds
It’s blue to cool down
Mental that in a 10 minute video about blue cards not one of you acknowledged the referee shortage, and the role dissent plays in causing that
I like the managers only have 2 choices because if they run out and there’s a situation they have to blame themselves and not the ref for burning their challenges
Until we all accept the fact that refs will always make mistakes like the players and no such realistic notion as perfection , all these rubbish VAR and blue cards will continue to infiltrate and ruin our game. The powers to be want 20 mins injury time to make it more “interesting “
If implicated well, this could be a great idea. It would mostly stop cynical fouls. Could speed the game up, but let's be honest, it'll slow it down. Most likely it won't be implicated well though, so I'd say no for now until the trials are done
What Geordie just said about Grealish is so true at Villa Grealish was so exciting and free flowing but at City he is forced into a boring system. I wish Grealish ended up at my club Man Utd as he would still be that player he was at Villa
I think its good as a Irish person its just like the Black card for synical fouls
So many players will be playing like 80minutes of the game by getting sin binned in the final minutes of the game 😢
nothing to do with a yellow its for decent and time wasting....got nothing to do with pep or klopp they have the most goals in a season in prem history
should be that the yellow leads to sin bin
Really bad performance against a really good team. We never expected to go there and win, but didn’t turn up. That said, anyone saying Howe out has clearly forgotten the last 10 years and needs their head shakin
Challenges had been brought up before, it'll never work in the game because it's not like tennis or cricket where you stop after every point played. & now imagine jose or someone slowing the game down etc, yeams will take advantage of it. & tell me how tf your going to determine who win the challenfe, you still need bar
Bad idea it works in rugby because there's like 30 players each teaming football thier be like 9 v 10 very easier to score with a player missing specially defenders I football and all players give out be blue cards everywhere yellow cards are already been thrown out
IFAB are responsible for the rules not the PGMOL. Two completely different entities.
VAR is not the problem, its the people who are using it
So we going to see park the bus football😂😂.
Need to have it for dissent IMO. In rugby there’s men filled with way more testosterone and they have to manage that and respect the referee, which takes pressure off the refs as they know they can’t be pushed around, which in turn makes them do their jobs better.
I guarantee a couple guys get sent off for 10 minutes for being a dick to the ref and players start having to work their bollocks off every week cos you’re down to 10 or 9 for 10 minutes constantly….the players will start keeping a lid on it and if not their teammates will make them.
Half the time taken is players complaining to refs about decisions in the first place🤣
its all for advertising the more stops the more advertising revenue football is now run by and for corporate interests not fans interests
Looking forward to this, it will speed the game up and stop the time wasting and cynical fouls
Josh - you’d be fuming if someone stops a goal scoring opportunity…
That’s a red card you mong
It’s not happening
I think the blue card is a good addition. I get so frustrated from all these movie star players being overly dramatic on the pitch.
If they give divers a blue card, it will make the game more fair. Players won't go to the ground as quick.
what were these lot wafflin about in the latter half? the good ol days? its not about talent anymore? some of these takes were wild
Guy who doesn't rate the refs top to bottom also loves 'the hand of God's & 'things like that's. Quality conversations as per usual.
I feel this will be horrible for teams who don’t dominate games lower in the table. It will enable teams like Man City to absolutely destroy teams.
Teams playing against City will be more likely to make these fouls due to chasing the ball all game, can’t see how this is a good idea for anyone but top clubs..
That's all it's for. All these stupid rules protect the cartel.
It's coming from IFAB. Who the hell is IFAB?
Lads, you talk on a legit subject then some idiot says it aint needed. Im not saying blue cards are needed. JUST BOOK PLAYER FOR BACKCHAT AND REGAIN RESPECT.
Rugby does it so easy
If it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Except it’s already broke from trying to fix what didn’t need fixing, now they’re just breaking it more trying to fix what they broke. Football is unrecognisable, not for the better imo
I’ll put hard cash on the blue card thing will never happen.
You mean ruin it more
Anyone else think they just moan about football in its entirety ?
IFAB decide the rules
Completely disagree, it's entertainment for the neutral, its results and competition for fans, I do not care how we get the win as long as we get it.
Spot on, modern football is destroying the game.
Is it true that most recent updates like goaline, VAR now this are due to sports betting and I higher need to get all calls perfect?
It's more likely just due to the massive amounts of investment in football, you can't have that much money floating around the sport and have inaccurate decisions, unfortunately it's destroying the game for spectators
Relax man…it won’t come in the PL
Blue cards are designed to stop professional fouls that DO slow the game down. This "slowing the game down" is a weird assumption
Haha exactly... with the threat of the sin bin, we will see more counter attacks which is probably the most exciting part of the game.
Gazza in the modern era is Saint-Maximim…
Ruined grealish but won the treble. Haha ok mate.
It's to prepare us for a big brother VAR society by getting us used to it through sport. Constant intervention from "authority" figures.
Alright Alex Jones.
It’s should be 2-3 minutes for first offense and increase it by a minute the second offense and so on. I don’t hate the idea but 10 minutes is ridiculous amount of time. 1/4 of a half and 1/3 of extra time.
Another terrible idea
You're actually defending the "Hand of God"? Please don't bring him back.
The blue card has been an eye opener to how much content is made for content’s sake as 90% of it has been created AFTER they’ve said it’s not coming in. Bore off, bunch of clueless idiots just getting angry for clicks.
Wait so they’re trying to make a penalty box like hockey? Are you gonna start calling it a power play when it’s 10v11 for 10 mins.? This is mad!
VAR has sucked out all the magic out of ⚽️
No, var is good
This is what happens with diversity hires who have blue hair...now we have blue cards and an even slower game
Interesting balance to the rule could be that the team with a player in sin bin can’t be offside, so they have a reason to not sit back for 10 minutes. Believe they do something like this is Ice Hockey?
Power Plays prevent Icing from being called so the defenders can clear the puck without worry, offsides is not influenced and still applies to both teams.
@@TheFunctioningInsomniac Ah right I see, cheers for clearing that up. Still think the idea might be interesting to keep the game flowing?
Why keep changing the game when everyone loved the game the way it was, every change they make the shitter , more painful and slower the game gets, simpletons running it and making the decisions. Blue card sounds shocking, Get rid of VAR aswell, and all that is needed is goal line technology
As a rugby man, I’m all for it
They just the in cynical fouls so people didn't focus on the descent. & I don't like players bombsrding a ref, 3/ getting right up to him with their fingers right in his face, yes like rugby they're needs to be more respect to them, but they also a) need to do a better job like rugby refs, who aren't perfect but hey far less wrong, & they work with bar to come to a decision that they all agree upon. & they talk to players & captains showing them respect as well, & b) only if the player steps out of line do they into "parent mode". & this os for a game with fat more aggression & pace. Far to many refs have way to big egos, I mean sending diego off in the derby, for swinging his arms, when that's mostly frustration, is embarrassing af. & then next game you see nothing
blue cards is fucking stupid. just enforce the rules correctly thats been there for over a hundred years
😮
These comments😂
VAR at least in theory makes sense and can possibly produce better decisions.
This is an incomprehensibly bad idea. In theory and in practice. It would ruin football.
What makes football so much better than rugby, NFL, boxing, cricket, golf and so on, is that it’s fast-paced. It’s not stop-start with constant breaks.
The changes that have already been made, and are still being proposed, are designed to kill the momentum of the sport.
When you look at the backpass rule, that was a rule designed to increase the intensity and entertainment of football, and it worked. We should be looking to make changes that will increase the intensity of football.
For example, if you want to stop timewasting, then add a stop-clock for when the ball is out of play. This immediately, overnight, eradicates timewasting from the sport. It would cease to exist, it’s that simple. Yet the FA wants to try and remove timewasting in the most convoluted, counter-productive ways possible.
These guys lost the plot. Just bc football is a game of emotions, doesn't give players the right to act like complete children and twats at times. If they wanted the game to become more fluid, they would want the blue card to stpo players from faking injuries etc.....
i like it
More rule changing nonsense! It’s getting worse than F1 with so many constant changes every season. Blue card / sin bin FFS! 🤦🏻♂️ These clowns are ruining the beautiful game.
Blue Cards will make the game way more exciting. Have 2 players in the bin and you'll have way more goals
No you won't as the other team would park the bus for 10 mins
Terrible opinion it's perfect just the way it is. Not necessary at all. Will ruin the game
Why not make it like basketball, make the goals 50 yards wide so every game will be 120-114 just like in the NBA
I don't want to be a Debbie downer . But it's already ruined. 1 club left that plays tiki taka in the whole world. All other clubs play kick n rush now. Good job English lads. You invented football and killed it too. You thinks speed is entertaining. FOOTBALL IS A PASSING GAMEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Goalpost Cosplay + longballs × Sprinting matches = Premier League🤢
How’s there only 1 team in the world that plays tiki taka left? 😂😂 you absolute clown
So you think Tiki taka was the original way of playing, that it's the only way to play? You don't think every generation there's a new style of play that dominates? Interesting
Mate are you seriously trying to say teams like Man City passing the ball around the opponent’s box for 20 minutes and scoring a tap in is more entertaining than high-speed rushing like Liverpool? Get a life lad.
Tiki taka isn't that interesting to watch, and man City don't play that style anyway. Bore off
@@nathaningram3382 Arsenal play the best football in the league
I’m not even trying to hate, watched this channel for a long time but these are by far some of the worst opinions in the state of the game I’ve ever heard 🤷♂️ really poor quality content guys, sorry
Ive loved the livesteams and content a d would love to start but ive got an achievement what i want to hit is 50 subs so i can start doing livestreams if anyone cpuld help out would be hugely appreciated