+Florian Himsl I'm pretty sure that was, apart from the Eternal D6 part, almost wholly a joke. At least judging from his reply to your comment, the fact that he pinned/'loved' it, and the little subtitle at the bottom.
Florian Himsl It's very cool, but I just had to poke fun at you. And yes I did see the new game! All I'll say is it looks incredible so far. I'm sold because mice are adorable.
PentaHybrid Yeah, But Its Something, Also Question, What's Your Favorite Antibirth Item Mine's Rock Bottom (Beat Boss Rush As Jacob And Esau) The Item Makes Soy Milk God Like As It Prevents Your Stats From Being Lowered, So Ultimate Synergy Polyphemus + Eve's Mascara + Soy Milk + Spectral Tears + Every Range Up + Rock Bottom = Infinite Death Death Ray
Dorian King Very true. Sometimes reaching for a good synergy is worth it. I can't answer that because I am working on the video now. You'll have to watch it when it comes out. Lol
Just for fun I decided to see how these items are in Repentance compared to their Antibirth equivalents. Book of Despair: didn't make the cut for Repentance so it shall forever be a relic of Antibirth and Community Remix Luna: Has the old effect, but also reveals one secret room on the map and gives all of the secret rooms a beam of light that grants a half soul heart and a stackable cap breaking tears up for the duration of the floor (first beam gives +1 tears up, the other three beams give +0.5 tears up). The Luna buff gives what was "Fragmented Moon on steroids the item" actual value for a run with the soul hearts and temporary tears buffs. The Eraser: Now can be used once per floor instead of once per run, and deals 15 damage to bosses while erasing the boss if the Eraser lands a fatal blow. The Repentance changes here really bring out more of the potential that Eraser was showing but couldn't utilize in Antibirth. Adding the ability to erase bosses as well is a neat bonus. Venus: Has the old effect but also gives an HP up when picked up. Repentance Venus has more value for a run long term with the red heart but plays the same otherwise. Meat Cleaver: Was buffed to a two room cooldown, and can now split enemies in a room multiple times (normal enemies can be split twice, champions and bosses can be split three times, and trying to split enemies that can't split anymore deals 25 damage to them instead). Being able to split things multiple times is a funny, albeit niche, addition but doesn't solve the main conundrum the item had in Antibirth. Consolation Prize: it's the same Eternal D6: Was buffed to a two room cooldown and was given to the Lost as a starting item but is otherwise the same as Antibirth. Stone Bombs/Rocket in a Jar: Stone Bombs didn't make it into Repentance, so I'll mainly be talking about Rocket in a Jar. Rocket in a Jar was changed to only fire a rocket if you press the bomb button while also pressing a firing input. This one change makes the item way more takable as the player now has more control over whether they want to fire a rocket or use a normal bomb. The Scooper: Using the Scooper gives 34% more damage for shots from Isaac's right eye for one room, and the Scooper creates one additional Peeper for each use after the first if used multiple times in the same room. The Scooper is still not great, but the damage boost makes it at least useable until you find a better active item. Lil Dumpy: He's still a random fart boi, but with four synergies now instead of three(Ghost Pepper and Bird's Eye make Isaac shoot a fire behind him when Lil Dumpy is hit). whooooooooo edit as of 7/20/22: Lil Dumpy is actually good now! He was reworked to follow Isaac and fart whenever Isaac is about to take a hit, protecting Isaac with the fart knockback. Lil Dumpy will zoom around the room for a bit before coming to a rest after a fart, and Isaac will have to retrieve him to have the protection again in the same active room. The fart also does 10 damage to any enemy that is pushed into a wall or obstacle by it. While Lil Dumpy isn't going to be a perfect one item get out of jail free card the way the Holy Mantle is due it providing no protection against beams, it is still a very solid defense item that will make general play in most of the game and bullet hell endgame bosses an easier time (just don't expect this thing to do you as much good against things like the Vis family, the holy eyes in Cathedral, or the brimstone grimaces in Sheol).
* make a run, get overpowered, wish to make the third and last puzzle to get the last knife piece on first try * * lil dummy farts * * destroy fires * * ragequit *
GreedyRadish I like the Consolation Prize idea, but the cool down on cleaver could just end up silly. Maybe just a solid one room charge. Could you imagine a chest room with 30 micro-Gurdy Jr's?
Similarly, I think the Scooper could be really good if it had a single-room cooldown. Then it would combo well with items like the Habit or the 9 Volt.
GreedyRadish I like an idea another commenter had. The suggested making the Scooper work like Potato Peeler and just create multiple Peeper eyes across rooms at an HP cost.
That would be cool. It could even add a slight damage boost to the eye that is removed (similar to the way Blood Clot and Chemical Peel work) since Potato Peeler gives a Range and Damage boost.
consolation prize is much better than like 50% of all boss drops, _because_ it only increases your lowest stat, and if you're anything like me, I'd rather get a tears up than another range or damage up when I've got enough of those. I feel the eternal d6 is supposed to be more of a joke. stone/rocket bombs are cool items that are hard to use. It's like bob's brain- mot a bad item, unless you're also bad. ....Don't be mean to lil dumpy!!!!!
RealityMasterRogue Consolation Prize more often than not gives me range or shot speed ups. I've never gotten a tears up from it. You are trying to argue with RNG, not a good idea. Lol Eternal D6 was a callback, yes. But still not something I like. As I said in the video,I dislike the bomb items because they are easy to forget I have. And it forces me to put my attention elsewhere. Still good though, just not for me. And hell with Lil' Dumpy, I'll be mean to him all I want. I'd rather have Holy Water. Haha
I completely agree with Lil' Dumpy. The lil' shit maker ruined a run I had when trying to get to the Corpse. I had the first two puzzles complete, amazing items, and Lil' Dumpy was working out for me... UNTIL I GOT TO THE LAST PUZZEL ROOM, THE ONE WITH THE FIRE. THAT LIL' SHIT FARTED ON THEM AND RUINED THE WHOLE PUZZLE. I WAS SO CLOSE.
Eternal D6 is still not useless, you wouldn't reroll an item you want, would you? If I find, say, mega bean in an item room, and I have the eternal D6, I'm gonna reroll it, because I don't care if it goes away, I don't want the item.
I know this video is super old, but I adore the new Repentance Lil Dumpy. That some of a gun saved me at least 15 times during Mom's Heart boss fight and yes I am new to the game. I had little damage as I got mostly hp and familiars instead of straight damage and him farting away enemies and projectiles if you're milliseconds from being hit is amazing. how do you recharge him? go touch him wherever he farted himself to even if its within a second. amazing follower now.
@@metalandmagic1424 are you dumb? It gives damage ups for every Stat down pill you take, and black hearts for all the other bad pills that don't affect your stats. It's insanely good.
Meat cleaver isn't that bad if you can flood the room with decently damaging tears, or a good effect. The best example of Meat cleaver's usefulness is with Soy milk, the parasite/cricket's body, and 20/20 or any multiple tear effect.
I came for a list of bad items, like items that can fuck your run up a la soymilk. If anything most of these were boring like you said, but most of them actually good.
Zen Deras Soy Milk is the best synergy item in the game. It synergizes well with just about every item, especially with the combo of Rubber Cement and Ipecac.
The creators of the mod messed up 'rocket in a jar' completly! Instead of replacing the player's placable bombs with rockets (which require you to shoot in the direction you wanna shoot the rocket), they should've made it so the player fires rocket tears (basically a potentially better version of ipecac, without the poison effect), which in my opinion would've made more sense. The only time I would pick this item up would be by curse of the blind, while having the D4 ready (and yes, I would use the D4 once I picked 'rocket in a jar' right away, because it just ruins the bombs, and makes it so the player cannot blow rocks up to fill gaps up in the middle of the room).
Stone bombs are OP when you get pyromaniac because every spike square(look closely at the spikes, they are squares) heals you. EVERY SINGLE SQUARE. So yeah, the other items, uhhh, hmmmm....
Jack Crack These take sometimes dozens of hours to make. And I had their permission to use it because I was on a tight schedule. Not my fault I have thousands of people pressuring me.
Luna isn't exactly that bad, since in Antibirth there is an item named Rock Bottom, which would normally bring all your stats back to the start, and only grant Stat upgrades for the rest of the run, but there is a bug that causes your stats to stay the same, it's really OP with items such as Mega Mushroom since the huge damage boost you get from it is permanent, but it's VERY rare, as it can only be found in Secret rooms or with a really small change from Tinted rocks
m8, this mod comes packed with missing hud, so alot of players would know what consolation prize boosted. not saying it's amazing, just that new payers would play with missing hud, and would know what stat increased. unless they dont know there is a missing hud in the mod
Pascl That wasn't the point though. The point is that it's a single plus one. And my point on the algorithm has nothing to do with Missing HUD, it has to do with how each stat scales differently.
The eraser I wish that thing can remove item so I can remove bob bloody brain from my perfect run well at least the enternal d6 can help me with that thing but with only 60%
If only Book of despair was in Afterbirth + Then if you get Bookworm, You could have a good amount of 20/20 (comple that with Perfection and you have a pretty decent item)
I agree with basically everything here except for the stone bombs/rocket in a jar tie. I actually think stone bombs is a really good item since it still gives you the placed bomb, and if you're paying attention you'll be able to see that your bomb is a rock and remember to get out of the way while the quake effect does its thing. ROCKET IN A JAR CAN GO FUCK ITSELF. Every time I pick it up I think "I can manage this, I'll remember I have it this time!" only to damage myself up to 10 times a run forgetting I have it and standing next to a wall, and let's not forget the occasions when you want to bomb something in the middle of the room but the rocket just flies right past it and hits a wall.
quite a good list, though i'd of put the missiles on their own. how do the tears move? in the direction you're facing and stop when they contact a wall. how do missiles move? move in the direction you're and explodes when they contact a wall. they're just explosive tears that use bombs.
the Planetary Items has it's names based on the Roman Deitys on which we named the planets, Quicksilver (Mercury), Venus (Aphrodite), Terra (Gea), Mars (Ares), Jupiter (Zeus), Saturn (Cronus), Uranus (this is Greek, you only had one job. William Herschel...), Neptune (Poseidon), and Pluto (Hades).
@@gustavogodoy9626 I know this video is old, but actually most of the names you listed are the names of the Greek deitys and have their Roman counterpart's name as the items.
Not objectively good. Brimstone can ruin great synergies, some people don't like charge items, etc. Cricket's Head is great, but some people don't like it. I know some of them, Lol (not me, it's my favorite item). And Magic Mush is an HP up with no tears increase. HP upgrades are able to ruin certain effects such as Polaroid, Whore of Babylon, and Negative.
if someone takes the bloat over something, either it's batshit horrible or they are completley insane and deserve to go to a asylum. i just can't decide which it is though...
The Eraser in Afterbirth+ however would be nicer since I'd happily pay 15 cents to get rid of the voids for the run (albeit you get the most use out of that you would want it fairly early on, when ideally you want stat ups)
I sometimes find an item said the tick and what it says it that it's not coming off and what it does is that I can't get a trinkit for the hole run. I hate that item
"i didn't like this item because i didn't get it when i wanted to get it" - his explanation for why he dislikes half the fricken things on this list. that or "its just meh" even though it sounds decent.
Matter of perspective. And you misunderstand then. It's not about getting it at the wrong time. It's about how rare it can be useful. "Getting it when I wanted it" is basically me saying "Yeah, it's only useful in a few circumstances. And those rarely happen". At the end of the day, it's my personal view/opinion on things. Whether I think something is "meh" is no concern to you, feel free to like what you want. I don't expect everyone to agree.
I feel the Eternal D6 needs a buff, because, Why would I prefer The E D6 over The D6? Half charge, but, If I doesn't want to wait that long, I can just get an item which generates bateries, like 48 Hours Energy pill, Fanny Pack, a Recharge Station, etc. I could find it more usefull, if it have 1 room charge, if it rerolls only to Special items or rerolls to Breakfast if failled to...
What if the consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize
I think a good way to buff Consolation Prize and make it less terrible would be to have it double your lowest stat, or at least raise it more significantly. Maybe take range out of the equation, too. Nobody really likes range upgrades.
See the thing with the item is that if it only offered something else. Anything else. I'd take a bomb and key drop with the stat boost over just a random stat up.
Book of Despair is Pretty good actually, Why? In the book room grab book of Despair, move the book to a different pedestal or the butter trinket, get the Book worm and take the book back, and D6 the trash books
Some items arent that bad, i know, the scooper is just silly, but for example rock blast and rocket in a jar are very good items ( im like you, i doesnt use bombs to attack enemys) and about the eternal d6, isnt bad, its balanced, half the charges but a %15 of deleting the item. In my opinion you should change the form you do tops, you should talk about the good things and bad things have X item, still, i like your videos Im not from USA
Still not sure how that makes me salty. The video is about what items I personally dislike the most. I touch on some of the good qualities they have, but I have no other reason to. This is about highlighting why I don't like them. I dislike something for bad reasons, no usually good reasons, lol. I appreciate the thoughts though, but differing opinions and all. I judge Eternal D6 too harshly, I admit this, but it is an opinion after all. Thanks for the support!
Other than the bomb items, for my own reasons and play style heavily working with items like Dr. Fetus whenever I can, I cant help but agree with this list. I haven't fully played through Antibirth due to some issues with uninstalling AB and AB+, but from what I DID play of it, this list seems very accurate for choices. Shame people give you so much slack over an opinion though. Eh, that's just TH-cam I guess. People don't realise content creators are actually people most of the time.
KuruCross_MK That's why I had to point out that the bomb items actually are super good. I just can't be trusted with them. Haha! And it is just the internet being the internet. Nothing we can fix.
Eternal D6 with huge luck is a 3 charge regular D6. at least that's how it works with perfection. not a single item lost. tho I usually lose my perfection unless I'm lost... still possibly my favourite trinket with luck based items
PentaHybrid I know that, and what I meant was if you bury it deep in your heart containers then you will have to lose a lot of health. but I do agree with it being a great item
this is IAMPIE Very true, but it's damage I return for the HP. Not every run is good for it, and I've died several times due to it. But when it works it is super good.
PentaHybrid yeah that is a reason why I can see it not being on this list but in my opinion I think it worked best in community remix because there was no health cap.
Wasnt the death with a zombie heart a bug thogh? If it fixed Blood Oath is one of the best items imo, if you can manage half red health and half spirit health
fuck you too you bitch! you can't handle the eternal Edition!
Florian Himsl I love ya, buddy. I do. Call it criticism out of love, Lol.
...but still, not a fan of the ED6. Lol
what's more risk vs reward than a d6 that has a chance to reroll to nothing.
btw did you see my new upcoming game poor mouse?
Florian Himsl u cant reroll pyro
+Florian Himsl
I'm pretty sure that was, apart from the Eternal D6 part, almost wholly a joke. At least judging from his reply to your comment, the fact that he pinned/'loved' it, and the little subtitle at the bottom.
Florian Himsl It's very cool, but I just had to poke fun at you. And yes I did see the new game! All I'll say is it looks incredible so far. I'm sold because mice are adorable.
"There is no objectively bad items"
*The Bean*
🦈
Gui Shark The Bean isn't "objectively" bad. Learn the difference between subjective and objective. It still had uses and benefits.
What's the benefit of carrying The Bean around? I genuinely think the only purpose of The Bean is for the Beans! Challenge.
Gui Shark Because if it's the only option, it's better to use it than be a stubborn ass and not use it.
At least in Antibirth The Butter Bean and Black Bean are pretty strong items when you have the Giant Bean trinket.
Actually, Consolation Prize + Soy Milk = DAMAGE (Sort Of) SAAAAAAAVED!
Dorian King That's reaching a little though. Lol
PentaHybrid Yeah, But Its Something, Also Question, What's Your Favorite Antibirth Item
Mine's Rock Bottom (Beat Boss Rush As Jacob And Esau) The Item Makes Soy Milk God Like As It Prevents Your Stats From Being Lowered, So Ultimate Synergy
Polyphemus + Eve's Mascara + Soy Milk + Spectral Tears + Every Range Up + Rock Bottom = Infinite Death Death Ray
Dorian King Very true. Sometimes reaching for a good synergy is worth it. I can't answer that because I am working on the video now. You'll have to watch it when it comes out. Lol
PentaHybrid Okay
libra + soy milk is better though
If the eraser was in Afterbirth+ i would throw it to the portal lol
HELL YES!!!!! XD
Most of the rooms would be empty. LAWL! ;P
i would on bonys
Peter Alves Throw it on a spider on any version of the game and you're set.
I think flies would be better than spiders personally, even if there are multiple variants so they won't all go..
Just for fun I decided to see how these items are in Repentance compared to their Antibirth equivalents.
Book of Despair: didn't make the cut for Repentance so it shall forever be a relic of Antibirth and Community Remix
Luna: Has the old effect, but also reveals one secret room on the map and gives all of the secret rooms a beam of light that grants a half soul heart and a stackable cap breaking tears up for the duration of the floor (first beam gives +1 tears up, the other three beams give +0.5 tears up). The Luna buff gives what was "Fragmented Moon on steroids the item" actual value for a run with the soul hearts and temporary tears buffs.
The Eraser: Now can be used once per floor instead of once per run, and deals 15 damage to bosses while erasing the boss if the Eraser lands a fatal blow. The Repentance changes here really bring out more of the potential that Eraser was showing but couldn't utilize in Antibirth. Adding the ability to erase bosses as well is a neat bonus.
Venus: Has the old effect but also gives an HP up when picked up. Repentance Venus has more value for a run long term with the red heart but plays the same otherwise.
Meat Cleaver: Was buffed to a two room cooldown, and can now split enemies in a room multiple times (normal enemies can be split twice, champions and bosses can be split three times, and trying to split enemies that can't split anymore deals 25 damage to them instead). Being able to split things multiple times is a funny, albeit niche, addition but doesn't solve the main conundrum the item had in Antibirth.
Consolation Prize: it's the same
Eternal D6: Was buffed to a two room cooldown and was given to the Lost as a starting item but is otherwise the same as Antibirth.
Stone Bombs/Rocket in a Jar: Stone Bombs didn't make it into Repentance, so I'll mainly be talking about Rocket in a Jar. Rocket in a Jar was changed to only fire a rocket if you press the bomb button while also pressing a firing input. This one change makes the item way more takable as the player now has more control over whether they want to fire a rocket or use a normal bomb.
The Scooper: Using the Scooper gives 34% more damage for shots from Isaac's right eye for one room, and the Scooper creates one additional Peeper for each use after the first if used multiple times in the same room. The Scooper is still not great, but the damage boost makes it at least useable until you find a better active item.
Lil Dumpy: He's still a random fart boi, but with four synergies now instead of three(Ghost Pepper and Bird's Eye make Isaac shoot a fire behind him when Lil Dumpy is hit). whooooooooo
edit as of 7/20/22: Lil Dumpy is actually good now! He was reworked to follow Isaac and fart whenever Isaac is about to take a hit, protecting Isaac with the fart knockback. Lil Dumpy will zoom around the room for a bit before coming to a rest after a fart, and Isaac will have to retrieve him to have the protection again in the same active room. The fart also does 10 damage to any enemy that is pushed into a wall or obstacle by it. While Lil Dumpy isn't going to be a perfect one item get out of jail free card the way the Holy Mantle is due it providing no protection against beams, it is still a very solid defense item that will make general play in most of the game and bullet hell endgame bosses an easier time (just don't expect this thing to do you as much good against things like the Vis family, the holy eyes in Cathedral, or the brimstone grimaces in Sheol).
* make a run, get overpowered, wish to make the third and last puzzle to get the last knife piece on first try *
* lil dummy farts *
* destroy fires *
* ragequit *
That thing ruined one of my runs of getting the last knife piece too. Have to redo the puzzle. Glad I don't have to do it over and over again.
i did all the puzzles first try luckily so i have not had to suffer that
i ran into a fire and i had theIT HURTS item with ipecac tears
lmao!!! I did them 1st try
Which is Lil Dumpy more: a useful item or something Strong Bad calls Strong Sad?
I think Consolation Prize should be a trinket and Cleaver should have a 15-20 sec. cooldown, similar to Candle and Boomerang.
GreedyRadish I like the Consolation Prize idea, but the cool down on cleaver could just end up silly. Maybe just a solid one room charge. Could you imagine a chest room with 30 micro-Gurdy Jr's?
Similarly, I think the Scooper could be really good if it had a single-room cooldown. Then it would combo well with items like the Habit or the 9 Volt.
GreedyRadish I like an idea another commenter had. The suggested making the Scooper work like Potato Peeler and just create multiple Peeper eyes across rooms at an HP cost.
That would be cool. It could even add a slight damage boost to the eye that is removed (similar to the way Blood Clot and Chemical Peel work) since Potato Peeler gives a Range and Damage boost.
GreedyRadish yeah consolation prize is to op with blank card othalu and battery pack.
I honestly don't know how and where the Scooper got it's right to exist.
Edplosion Game Devs being trolls, lol!
Edplosion Scooper is not too bad, better than other activez
Blake Blast While it has no real negatives, the item is a three room charge of another permanent passive. Kind of silly.
For example?
It's good if you don't already have an active item
consolation prize is much better than like 50% of all boss drops, _because_ it only increases your lowest stat, and if you're anything like me, I'd rather get a tears up than another range or damage up when I've got enough of those.
I feel the eternal d6 is supposed to be more of a joke.
stone/rocket bombs are cool items that are hard to use. It's like bob's brain- mot a bad item, unless you're also bad.
....Don't be mean to lil dumpy!!!!!
RealityMasterRogue Consolation Prize more often than not gives me range or shot speed ups. I've never gotten a tears up from it. You are trying to argue with RNG, not a good idea. Lol
Eternal D6 was a callback, yes. But still not something I like.
As I said in the video,I dislike the bomb items because they are easy to forget I have. And it forces me to put my attention elsewhere. Still good though, just not for me.
And hell with Lil' Dumpy, I'll be mean to him all I want. I'd rather have Holy Water. Haha
I completely agree with Lil' Dumpy.
The lil' shit maker ruined a run I had when trying to get to the Corpse. I had the first two puzzles complete, amazing items, and Lil' Dumpy was working out for me... UNTIL I GOT TO THE LAST PUZZEL ROOM, THE ONE WITH THE FIRE. THAT LIL' SHIT FARTED ON THEM AND RUINED THE WHOLE PUZZLE. I WAS SO CLOSE.
Eternal D6 is still not useless, you wouldn't reroll an item you want, would you?
If I find, say, mega bean in an item room, and I have the eternal D6, I'm gonna reroll it, because I don't care if it goes away, I don't want the item.
PentaHybrid three words to why this item blank card othalu
PentaHybrid Jesus Christ Holy Water give Dumpy just a slight bit of respect. Yeah he is as bad as the bean but Holy Water... Dear God It's so bad.
And yes! I am currently producing the follow up video for the Best Items in Antibaaaarth! Get hyped!
Obviously one of the Planetary items need to be on that list. Saturnus I suggest. And Rock Bottom!
Outertale Napstablook Well I'll put what I think are the best items on there, not suggestions. But thank you.
Hey, I saw you on that Terraria UT music video! Guess I found a fan of my two favorite Steam games I own.
I know this video is super old, but I adore the new Repentance Lil Dumpy. That some of a gun saved me at least 15 times during Mom's Heart boss fight and yes I am new to the game. I had little damage as I got mostly hp and familiars instead of straight damage and him farting away enemies and projectiles if you're milliseconds from being hit is amazing. how do you recharge him? go touch him wherever he farted himself to even if its within a second. amazing follower now.
Seeing Cricket's head turned down for an ice cream scoop makes me cringe
"there are no objectively bad items"
BUTTER BEAN
Wait, What?
Tiny planet
The False PHD coming in Repentance is literally objectively bad.
It has ZERO upsides
@@metalandmagic1424 are you dumb? It gives damage ups for every Stat down pill you take, and black hearts for all the other bad pills that don't affect your stats. It's insanely good.
"No objectively bad items"
Me:*laughs in whybirth bonesaw*
Now I don't want to be THAT guy buuut....
I never expected this many likes...
whybirth is
whybirth
Rocket in a jar + Dr. Fetus + sad bombs + brimstone
= lag
+ scatter bombs + rubber cement
=issac.exe was stoped working
If you use meat cleaver on the witness and you have high health, the fight is a lot easier.
Meat cleaver isn't that bad if you can flood the room with decently damaging tears, or a good effect. The best example of Meat cleaver's usefulness is with Soy milk, the parasite/cricket's body, and 20/20 or any multiple tear effect.
I like how all of these items are actually fun and I would never be disappointed in getting them in a run (except for the d6 one and lil dumpy).
I came for a list of bad items, like items that can fuck your run up a la soymilk.
If anything most of these were boring like you said, but most of them actually good.
Zen Deras I like Soy Milk. And it couldn't be on the list anyway as it's not an Antibirth original.
I like soy milk too, it synergizes with items that changes your tears
Zen Deras Soy Milk is the best synergy item in the game. It synergizes well with just about every item, especially with the combo of Rubber Cement and Ipecac.
The creators of the mod messed up 'rocket in a jar' completly! Instead of replacing the player's placable bombs with rockets (which require you to shoot in the direction you wanna shoot the rocket), they should've made it so the player fires rocket tears (basically a potentially better version of ipecac, without the poison effect), which in my opinion would've made more sense. The only time I would pick this item up would be by curse of the blind, while having the D4 ready (and yes, I would use the D4 once I picked 'rocket in a jar' right away, because it just ruins the bombs, and makes it so the player cannot blow rocks up to fill gaps up in the middle of the room).
"wait a minute..." VIDEO BUFFERS FOR A MINUTE
Stone bombs are OP when you get pyromaniac because every spike square(look closely at the spikes, they are squares) heals you. EVERY SINGLE SQUARE. So yeah, the other items, uhhh, hmmmm....
The best parts of the video is when he uses Syncer's footage because then it shows the item at its full potential.
Jack Crack These take sometimes dozens of hours to make. And I had their permission to use it because I was on a tight schedule. Not my fault I have thousands of people pressuring me.
Nothing I meant was in an ill way. Just letting you know that I wasn't hiding the usage of their footage. Lol
Luna isn't exactly that bad, since in Antibirth there is an item named Rock Bottom, which would normally bring all your stats back to the start, and only grant Stat upgrades for the rest of the run, but there is a bug that causes your stats to stay the same, it's really OP with items such as Mega Mushroom since the huge damage boost you get from it is permanent, but it's VERY rare, as it can only be found in Secret rooms or with a really small change from Tinted rocks
Eraser seems great imagine no spiders for a whole run
Lil' Dumpy saved me once as the Lost :P
I got cornered by a Monster and Lil' Dumpy saved me from it :P
Probably not a big deal, but it happened.
All i have to say, you have to have bad items to make a game fun, you shouldn't have to always get good items its about mixing skill and luck
m8, this mod comes packed with missing hud, so alot of players would know what consolation prize boosted.
not saying it's amazing, just that new payers would play with missing hud, and would know what stat increased. unless they dont know there is a missing hud in the mod
Pascl That wasn't the point though. The point is that it's a single plus one. And my point on the algorithm has nothing to do with Missing HUD, it has to do with how each stat scales differently.
I guess i'm really bad at listening
Pascl No, just interpreted it differently. No big deal. Lol
I really don't have a good awnser to awnser you so i'm just gonna say okay lol.
okay.
XD or something
most annoying enemies in the binding of isaac (rebirth/antibirth/afterbirth/afterbirth+
Ooooh, that's a tough one. I wouldn't count Antibirth because it isn't official, but it could be a separate selection.
Standard spiders. (Or are they more so for most op enemies?)
the Knight, and Cod Worm monsters
THE PORTALS!!!!!!!!! GOTTA HATE THEM GOD DAMNM PIECES OF SHIT PORTALS
Everyone thinks farts are useless until the enemy can use them
"Imagine experimental treatment, but really fucking bad." Soooo... experimental treatment?
The eraser I wish that thing can remove item so I can remove bob bloody brain from my perfect run well at least the enternal d6 can help me with that thing but with only 60%
So... the Eraser is a Scroll of Genocide from NetHack, with the serial numbers filed off? It can be used to genocide annoying enemies (e.g. Stoneys).
I know someone else has probably already said this, but
"Imagine Experimental Treatment, but bad!"
So, experimental treatment?
I think it says something about this mod that most of the items on this list are things that I still don't mind at all getting.
If only Book of despair was in Afterbirth + Then if you get Bookworm, You could have a good amount of 20/20 (comple that with Perfection and you have a pretty decent item)
XD the footages are from syncer right?
:u
myhiddenangels Some of the clips used were from their channel. Not all though.Only items I had no footage of.
That minute when he picks the scooper over crickets head
I agree with basically everything here except for the stone bombs/rocket in a jar tie. I actually think stone bombs is a really good item since it still gives you the placed bomb, and if you're paying attention you'll be able to see that your bomb is a rock and remember to get out of the way while the quake effect does its thing.
ROCKET IN A JAR CAN GO FUCK ITSELF. Every time I pick it up I think "I can manage this, I'll remember I have it this time!" only to damage myself up to 10 times a run forgetting I have it and standing next to a wall, and let's not forget the occasions when you want to bomb something in the middle of the room but the rocket just flies right past it and hits a wall.
Such a great video, keep it up :)
Snakey Thank you and I will try!
There are no objectively bad items:
The bean
Butter bean
Isaacs heart
AND FUCKING BREAKFAST
H u g o H e p w o r t h Look yo the word objective.
quite a good list, though i'd of put the missiles on their own.
how do the tears move? in the direction you're facing and stop when they contact a wall.
how do missiles move? move in the direction you're and explodes when they contact a wall.
they're just explosive tears that use bombs.
They buffed the eraser to recharge per floor
most of these got buffed
7:11 imagine talling about how bad an item is and picking it up instead of cricket's head
that moment he takes the scooper over crickets head
jacob snyder Crickets Head sucks.
Imagine playing greed mode with antibirth turned on after it gets its afterbirth+ compatibility update, so cool!
Lil'Dumpy - the best Altar Fodder for Devil/Angel rooms.
if you look at book of despair I feel as if it needed a character to start with it because it's just book of belial but altered
FUN FACT
Terra and Luna are Earth and Moon in italian
Edit 1:Wait...Oh my god
GREED BUTT CONFIRMED
Probably "latín" wich is simillar to italian and spanish
the Planetary Items has it's names based on the Roman Deitys on which we named the planets, Quicksilver (Mercury), Venus (Aphrodite), Terra (Gea), Mars (Ares), Jupiter (Zeus), Saturn (Cronus), Uranus (this is Greek, you only had one job. William Herschel...), Neptune (Poseidon), and Pluto (Hades).
@@gustavogodoy9626 I know this video is old, but actually most of the names you listed are the names of the Greek deitys and have their Roman counterpart's name as the items.
The meat cleaver is extremely good late game if you have any piercing shot. You can basically do double damage if you hit both of them.
7:11 that footage just hurt... May Cricket forgive you 😅
I like the concept of the Eraser, I see it borrowing the idea of the Scroll of Genocide from NetHack.
Well, this list should likely still hold up in the coming months.
'There are no good or bad anything in a game like Isaac.'
PentaHybrid
What about Magic Mushroom, Cricket's Head and Brimstone!
Not objectively good. Brimstone can ruin great synergies, some people don't like charge items, etc. Cricket's Head is great, but some people don't like it. I know some of them, Lol (not me, it's my favorite item). And Magic Mush is an HP up with no tears increase. HP upgrades are able to ruin certain effects such as Polaroid, Whore of Babylon, and Negative.
Book of Despair? More like book of Desperate to add one more item concept to the list.
if someone takes the bloat over something, either it's batshit horrible or they are completley insane and deserve to go to a asylum. i just can't decide which it is though...
What about triple charge? And black hearts?
In my opinion, Book of Despair is good, It just _double_ your dmg.
The Eraser in Afterbirth+ however would be nicer since I'd happily pay 15 cents to get rid of the voids for the run (albeit you get the most use out of that you would want it fairly early on, when ideally you want stat ups)
Nano Tenko Couldn't agree more. Someone mod this crossover.
I was half expecting Yuck Heart to be #1.
I sometimes find an item said the tick and what it says it that it's not coming off and what it does is that I can't get a trinkit for the hole run. I hate that item
"i didn't like this item because i didn't get it when i wanted to get it" - his explanation for why he dislikes half the fricken things on this list. that or "its just meh" even though it sounds decent.
Matter of perspective. And you misunderstand then. It's not about getting it at the wrong time. It's about how rare it can be useful. "Getting it when I wanted it" is basically me saying "Yeah, it's only useful in a few circumstances. And those rarely happen". At the end of the day, it's my personal view/opinion on things. Whether I think something is "meh" is no concern to you, feel free to like what you want. I don't expect everyone to agree.
>Top 10 worst items in Antibirth
>Gets to first place
>"Now is it the worst item in the game? No."
>Wat?
Naveication Considering there are over 340 other items not originally in Antibirth, it feels kind of self explanatory.
Well I think awful and even harmful items are an important part of binding of Isaac.
I completely agree. I love the balance and obvious "oh no" aspect of the bad or not fun items. But you still gotta rank them. Lol
PentaHybrid oh I know! I love the video! It's just a couple of times you said "I really wish they hadn't added this item"
The eraser only erases for the floor which makes it even worse
Rocket in a Jaw has some op synergies tbh
I wish anti birth would exist with afterbirth I mean I hate having to go back to a previous set of knowledge in order to enjoy this
The eraser can be used on walking hosts tho
antibirth is the BEST binding of isaac: afterbirth mod i have EVER seen!
It's a Rebirth mod
Doctor fetus and Rocket in a jar... SO FRICKEN OP
eraser must delete the enemy for a whole run
The eraser on either the stupid ghosts or the walking unbreakable skeletons!
I would love to have lildumpy and bumbo on my runs
I feel the Eternal D6 needs a buff, because, Why would I prefer The E D6 over The D6? Half charge, but, If I doesn't want to wait that long, I can just get an item which generates bateries, like 48 Hours Energy pill, Fanny Pack, a Recharge Station, etc.
I could find it more usefull, if it have 1 room charge, if it rerolls only to Special items or rerolls to Breakfast if failled to...
I just realized something
Binding
Of
Isaac
Boi
Consolation prize can be amazing in one situation that situation is blank card othalu and no other items except battery pack free every stats.
What if the consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize had a consolation prize
stone bombs + doctor/epic fetus is a pretty good synergy i think
If you don't use The Scooper item, you are a *NOSCOOPER* :D
spin around and then dont use the scooper = 360 NOSCOOPER
Book of despair junko would like that
Eternal D6 is shitty because he can to eat the item.(BUT THE DAMOCLES IS BEST!)Both items are saying:WHO DOESN'T RISKS THAT SUCKS!
I think a good way to buff Consolation Prize and make it less terrible would be to have it double your lowest stat, or at least raise it more significantly. Maybe take range out of the equation, too. Nobody really likes range upgrades.
See the thing with the item is that if it only offered something else. Anything else. I'd take a bomb and key drop with the stat boost over just a random stat up.
Miles Eggworth It can give you one. Not guaranteed though.
Book of Despair is Pretty good actually, Why? In the book room grab book of Despair, move the book to a different pedestal or the butter trinket, get the Book worm and take the book back, and D6 the trash books
Book Worm doesn't exist in Antibirth.
@@PentaHybrid Really!? That Sucks! The book worm transformation should be in Antibirth if it was in AB+
@@christianjames3797 There's also no butter trinket :P
@@prostyczowiek9782 yeah there is when you use your space bar the butter makes you drop the space bar
@@christianjames3797 bindingofisaacrebirth.gamepedia.com/Butter!
Rocket in a jar + dr fetus is best combo in the game
you won't be dissing little dumpy when you have giant bean...
Deftash49 Hahaha, so funny story...yes, yes I did still diss him with that. It's terrible.
The binding of isaac has had a ton items.....
SKELE-TON
gets eraser
sees walking host
Salty salt, arent ya, PentaHybrid?
Some items arent that bad, i know, the scooper is just silly, but for example rock blast and rocket in a jar are very good items ( im like you, i doesnt use bombs to attack enemys) and about the eternal d6, isnt bad, its balanced, half the charges but a %15 of deleting the item.
In my opinion you should change the form you do tops, you should talk about the good things and bad things have X item, still, i like your videos
Im not from USA
Still not sure how that makes me salty. The video is about what items I personally dislike the most. I touch on some of the good qualities they have, but I have no other reason to. This is about highlighting why I don't like them. I dislike something for bad reasons, no usually good reasons, lol. I appreciate the thoughts though, but differing opinions and all. I judge Eternal D6 too harshly, I admit this, but it is an opinion after all. Thanks for the support!
Keep doing your work, Penta!
stone bombs and rocket in a jar are very useful if you have a bunch of bombs
This isn't "top ten worst items in antibirth " it 's " top ten most usaless items in antibirth"
In my opinion, Eraser should be s 2 floor recharge. That way, it's more practical.
#3 is deadly with Dr. Fetus
Wait what would happen if you threw the eraser at the witness would he be insta-killed or would that phase be taken out
Other than the bomb items, for my own reasons and play style heavily working with items like Dr. Fetus whenever I can, I cant help but agree with this list. I haven't fully played through Antibirth due to some issues with uninstalling AB and AB+, but from what I DID play of it, this list seems very accurate for choices. Shame people give you so much slack over an opinion though. Eh, that's just TH-cam I guess. People don't realise content creators are actually people most of the time.
KuruCross_MK That's why I had to point out that the bomb items actually are super good. I just can't be trusted with them. Haha! And it is just the internet being the internet. Nothing we can fix.
The eraser is good! No more fucking walking hosts!
Then came repentance 😳
jaja true
but buffed
Eternal D6 with huge luck is a 3 charge regular D6. at least that's how it works with perfection. not a single item lost. tho I usually lose my perfection unless I'm lost... still possibly my favourite trinket with luck based items
domacules or however you spell it (the knife that hangs above you) i feel deserves a spot on this list. then again it's good/bad part is controversial
Aaron Stetts I love Damocles. Lol. Stay tuned for the Best list. But I understand that it rubs some people the wrong way.
Bro just think of the eraser as the chaos card. You could remove hush or delirium from a run! Or the bloat... oh god yes...
what about blood oath because if you have a zombie heart it will kill you
Blood Oath is a great item. You have to be more strategic than that. If it kills you, just restart and try again. Always another run.
PentaHybrid I know that, and what I meant was if you bury it deep in your heart containers then you will have to lose a lot of health. but I do agree with it being a great item
this is IAMPIE Very true, but it's damage I return for the HP. Not every run is good for it, and I've died several times due to it. But when it works it is super good.
PentaHybrid yeah that is a reason why I can see it not being on this list but in my opinion I think it worked best in community remix because there was no health cap.
Wasnt the death with a zombie heart a bug thogh? If it fixed Blood Oath is one of the best items imo, if you can manage half red health and half spirit health
Wait...he had to skip crickets head and take the scooper.... rip
RIP
when antiebirth came for afterbirth + eraser will be one of the best items in the game
Which enemy would you use it on?
mushrooms
i hate the host heads more than the mushrooms, you dont have to wait to kill the mushroom
Rade Despotovic Solid opinion here. Screw the shrooms, lol.