I had ancestors that were in that situation and I realized that the homesteaders weren't really liked by the Indian fighters. ... They came after all the bloodshed and just claimed blood soaked ground The Indian fighters were sick of it of the blood .. two different cultures
As others have said, this film is so underated. First time I saw it, I was transfixed and have watched it many times since. A truly epic film, with a gripping story and some fantastic acting.
Bale convincingly has the look of a worn out cavalry captain that's seen too many horrible things on the plains in his career. However he's a well-oiled machine in his environment when the bullets start flying that exhibits zero emotion except instincts that have kept him alive through many scraps.
One of the greatest films I've ever watched. It's crazy how underrated it is too, not many folk have seen it or would give it the time of day. Truly great film.
Meh. The director screwed it up. Bale's performance as a supposedly experienced cavalry officer is incompetent at best. My full comment above explains why. His job performance - as a military leader - was rife with 2nd Lieutenant mistakes that got 4 of his people killed needlessly.
I have never scene an actor with such control in just their expression and speaks directly to the audience without uttering a word or sound. I first saw Christian Bale in "Empire of the Sun" the scene that I loved the most was in the end when his mother finds him after the war and his 14 year old face has no expression, just sunken eyes that show all he has been through. He is one of the greatest actors of our time.
Wes Studi has always impressed me in the roles he played. the quality of his facial features are on another scale and his acting has always pleased me.
I'm just an old movie fan smiling at seeing some dudes I haven't seen in what feels like a good damn minute. I'm absolutely terrible with names but I'm tickled pink and thrilled to see old chief dude (That I know from last of the Mohicans) and the younger, dude. I haven't seen them in forever! Always enjoyed watching those two gentlemen work. Time sure is a trip.
This western is brilliant best of all time the acting was outstanding the story is about redemption Bale nailed it Wes Study my favourite indian actor.
Tears of utter futility at what we as humans have done to each other...Why does it take a movie to make us sit up..The movie is tragic, the acting immense, the story of killing just goes on. What a well told story, it moves me to tears each time I see it.
I'm sorry to say that the greed of white men knows no bounds. You might only want access to a few acres for your purposes, old whitey wants thousands of acres and doesn't want to anyone walking on 'his land' Walking never hurt the ground. People will shoot you just because they can. America is a disaster for killing people and, here's the history of it, in recreated drama. Whether or not the characters are real, there's plenty of documented evidence of killing innocent people in the name of the United States of America. Even when natives were given land, it didn't take long for evil people to turn up and abuse them and kill them. Are not the original inhabitants still on reservations. Have they ever been accepted as humans and Americans Will they ever be acknowledged How todays generations can still hold to the history claiming it was justified, is beyond reason
We do recognize the indigenous people. I see them every day in movies and television. HOWEVER, you are a conquered people. You lost the war and lost your lands. I don't agree with how it happened. I think it was a travesty, at best. But the fact remains....your ancestors lost. You should feel fortunate that the government allowed you to stay. Most conquering governments exterminated, expelled or enslaved their victims. Get over it. Get on with your life. Make a life for yourself. How your ancestors chose to handle the opportunities placed before them in is not my fault or yours. My ancestors are not from this country. You don't see me complaining to Scotland about how they were expelled from their lands in Europe. They made a life where they could. This land has inumerable opportunities for everyone. Nobody is going to give it to you though. You have to go get it for yourself... The fact is, the entirety of the USA was populated by native Americans at one time. Do you really think that the US Government will give it back? Do you really want LA or New York or Chicago now that whitey has ruined it? They are not going to give it back, any of it. You'll have to take it....if you can. Or....you can go out and buy a piece of it, like millions of us have done, and be a productive member of society. Not saying you aren't, I don't know your situation. My point is the same as I had to learn for myself and what I told my children: quit whining and get to work. Nobody cares. Nobody is thrilled about having to support you. Go build a life for yourself. Your life is your responsibility alone. 😊😊😊
Yeah and that 65 year old obese man at the end shrugs off .45 LC like its nothing. Takes two to the chest and then gets up and does the 100 yard dash! YEAH RIGHT!
It appears as though Bale fired 9 shots out of his six gun without reloading. Unfortunately Hollywood always seems to overlook these details which would only add more authenticity to an already excellent movie if they would portray the use of these guns properly.
Anyone who says this is the best Western of all time is forgetting Lonesome Dove ( albeit a miniseries) or The Unforgiven. This is obviously a great Western, but a little too slow and plodding to be considered the absolute best. Bale is undeniably a great actor when you consider some of the roles he had played. From Batman to Burt in Amsterdam to Irving in American Hustle to Dicky in The Fighter ( I believe his best ever role) to Patrick in American Psycho. I think he is this generations' most versatile actor, and he covers his British accent impeccably.
@@valarmorghulis2350I agree. I wanted to mention that movie also, I just thought the role was too similar to the one in Hostiles. I was just trying to show the range of his roles. I really liked 3:10 to Yuma.
@@olderthanyoucali8512 Yes, the ending was classic. When Shane rides off into the sunset wounded and his friend the little boy runs after him crying “Shane come back! Shane…”
Should have taken more defensive positions when riders were approaching. Why were standing in the wide open. And no one uses rifle to full advantage as a longer range weapon.
The reload might have ended up on the cutting room floor. It happens sometimes. Artistic license covers a myriad of sins. Don't watch any of the John Wick movies if you intend to count shots.
Freedom from tyranny is a human right. Unite! We were all born to freedom. It should never cost anything. AHs convinced most of us to die trying for something different. #freedomisfree
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D1 | Summer | แข่งที่ไทย ต้องใส่ให้สุด](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jkuf7nCS7jI/mqdefault.jpg)
Wes Studi is a master piece. Every role he plays is such a delight to watch.
Except for his role in Street Fighter
He plays a good and or bad Indian too.
I've never seen a mediocre performance from Bale. He is extremely versatile and brings all his characters to life.
BALE IS A TRUE PROFESSIONAL. ADMIRABLE TALENT ALWAYS.
I had ancestors that were in that situation and I realized that the homesteaders weren't really liked by the Indian fighters. ...
They came after all the bloodshed and just claimed blood soaked ground
The Indian fighters were sick of it of the blood .. two different cultures
Never ! Cadillac of the skies !!!!!
True, its such a shame he is a total douchebag in real life.
Mediocre is not bad.
As others have said, this film is so underated. First time I saw it, I was transfixed and have watched it many times since. A truly epic film, with a gripping story and some fantastic acting.
: My sentiments exactly.
75% on Rotten Tomatoes. Could you show us where this film is underrated?
@@brucemcbain3150you believe in rotten tomatoe reviews? Funny...
Bale convincingly has the look of a worn out cavalry captain that's seen too many horrible things on the plains in his career. However he's a well-oiled machine in his environment when the bullets start flying that exhibits zero emotion except instincts that have kept him alive through many scraps.
One of the greatest films I've ever watched. It's crazy how underrated it is too, not many folk have seen it or would give it the time of day. Truly great film.
Seen in 4 times. A classic and highly accurate portrayal of the time, the clothing, the firearms and the pattern of speech. Excellent.
davvero? allora non hai visto i film di Leone
Yes it's superb.
I will be looking for it today 2023, , 2017 its made, and I never heard of it.
Ive just seen clips and I'm already addicted. Have got to watch it now
CB’s finest role. Eerie and believable at the same time. It says so much with just a few words. Ms Pikes performance was superb as well. Bravo.
I don’t know. 3:10 to Yuma he was good too.
Meh. The director screwed it up. Bale's performance as a supposedly experienced cavalry officer is incompetent at best. My full comment above explains why. His job performance - as a military leader - was rife with 2nd Lieutenant mistakes that got 4 of his people killed needlessly.
Christian Bale is GOAT 👏 What an unmatched performance here, it makes me cry everytime, amazing movie 😭👏❤️🙏🏻
I have never scene an actor with such control in just their expression and speaks directly to the audience without uttering a word or sound. I first saw Christian Bale in "Empire of the Sun" the scene that I loved the most was in the end when his mother finds him after the war and his 14 year old face has no expression, just sunken eyes that show all he has been through. He is one of the greatest actors of our time.
@@Mike-hw6yx absolutely agree, great actor of our century 👏🙏🏻❤️
Wonderful performance by Wes Studi as always
Wes Studi
has always impressed me in the roles he played. the quality of his facial features are on another scale and his acting has always pleased me.
Agreed. Been a huge fan ever since Last of the Mohicans. He's a definite GoTo guy when it comes to portraying Nations.
Bale is a great actor and Rosamund is gorgeous and a fine actress in her own right.
Excellent performances!
This film grips like no other. Stunning!!
Qual o nome do filme por favor
I'm just an old movie fan smiling at seeing some dudes I haven't seen in what feels like a good damn minute.
I'm absolutely terrible with names but I'm tickled pink and thrilled to see old chief dude (That I know from last of the Mohicans) and the younger, dude. I haven't seen them in forever! Always enjoyed watching those two gentlemen work. Time sure is a trip.
This western is brilliant best of all time the acting was outstanding the story is about redemption Bale nailed it Wes Study my favourite indian actor.
Love the ending to this film
Best Western to come along in a very long time
Anyone that says CB is not a good actor needs to see this scene ... the conviction in his eyes is haunting ...
Tears of utter futility at what we as humans have done to each other...Why does it take a movie to make us sit up..The movie is tragic, the acting immense, the story of killing just goes on. What a well told story, it moves me to tears each time I see it.
Bale, one of the most legit actors of our time.
I agree. Have you watched Kenneth Branagh's "Henry V" ? Christian had a speaking role. Must have been all of 10 or 11.
Im going to have to get this on DVD and watch it !
Great film. Very dark. But master piece
Best film I've seen for a long ,long time.
Outstanding western. One of the best if not the best in modern time
Ie never seen it but will make it a point to in the next 2 weeks. Bale is one of my top 5 actors for sure.
This movie though! So amazing.
My all time favorite movie. And this clip is my most favorite scene.
Very underrated !!
One of the best most under rated movies of all time...every emotion ...every bit believable as if you saw it all yourself
This 10 minute scene from beginning to end has so much impact .... .....
Great acting,by all, glad he got on the train
Jejejejeje muy buena Dimitriiii, la crítica !!!! Muy divertida y con toda la razón.
I think one of Bale's best performances and very under rated
I get that sometimes you just have to make a stand. But it's a bitter victory if it comes at making the words of your enemy come true.
@drewby613 Which explains Bale's actions and look at the end of the scene. He knew it and hated it and made the arrogant landowner pay for it.
Sometimes their land is our land .I am part native American and wish this country would recognize those that were here first.
I'm sorry to say that the greed of white men knows no bounds.
You might only want access to a few acres for your purposes, old whitey wants thousands of acres and doesn't want to anyone walking on 'his land'
Walking never hurt the ground.
People will shoot you just because they can.
America is a disaster for killing people and, here's the history of it, in recreated drama.
Whether or not the characters are real, there's plenty of documented evidence of killing innocent people in the name of the United States of America.
Even when natives were given land, it didn't take long for evil people to turn up and abuse them and kill them.
Are not the original inhabitants still on reservations. Have they ever been accepted as humans and Americans
Will they ever be acknowledged
How todays generations can still hold to the history claiming it was justified, is beyond reason
The one half of you should give the other half of you that recognition then.
We do recognize the indigenous people. I see them every day in movies and television.
HOWEVER, you are a conquered people. You lost the war and lost your lands. I don't agree with how it happened. I think it was a travesty, at best. But the fact remains....your ancestors lost. You should feel fortunate that the government allowed you to stay. Most conquering governments exterminated, expelled or enslaved their victims. Get over it. Get on with your life. Make a life for yourself. How your ancestors chose to handle the opportunities placed before them in is not my fault or yours.
My ancestors are not from this country. You don't see me complaining to Scotland about how they were expelled from their lands in Europe. They made a life where they could.
This land has inumerable opportunities for everyone. Nobody is going to give it to you though. You have to go get it for yourself...
The fact is, the entirety of the USA was populated by native Americans at one time. Do you really think that the US Government will give it back? Do you really want LA or New York or Chicago now that whitey has ruined it? They are not going to give it back, any of it. You'll have to take it....if you can.
Or....you can go out and buy a piece of it, like millions of us have done, and be a productive member of society. Not saying you aren't, I don't know your situation.
My point is the same as I had to learn for myself and what I told my children: quit whining and get to work. Nobody cares. Nobody is thrilled about having to support you. Go build a life for yourself. Your life is your responsibility alone. 😊😊😊
There was always enough Land for everyone but there was just to many greedy people
@@nohillforahighstepperI care about his land being stolen. The difference is his land was stolen by hypocritical men of the highest order
Ostiles un grande Film di origine reali..
great film
It’s garbage.
sorely underrated movie.
Es un peliculón
So they shot three of them right off the jump yet somehow get completely surrounded and at least four NPCs get killed. Talk about a Pyrrhic victory...
Right? Only Bale's character and Pike's were smart enough to take cover. Just seemed unrealistic.
Bale had two Colt Cavalry Models in 45 caliber.
Yeah and that 65 year old obese man at the end shrugs off .45 LC like its nothing. Takes two to the chest and then gets up and does the 100 yard dash! YEAH RIGHT!
Fantastic. Incredible. Emotionally Nuclear , riveting
It appears as though Bale fired 9 shots out of his six gun without reloading. Unfortunately Hollywood always seems to overlook these details which would only add more authenticity to an already excellent movie if they would portray the use of these guns properly.
And smokeless powder cartridges before it was even invented.
He speed loads
Maybe had a LeMat.
Maybe he had two six shooters which is twelve shots?
Often reloading or pulling a second gun is cut by the director to speed a shot up.
No winners here!
grandissimo film. Christian Bale da oscar... punto.
Great film.
Wes has been on of my favorites for decades.
I’ve never even heard of this movie. I’ll have to check it out.
By the way, nice nine shooter.
Most people today have no clue what a good movie is anymore
Especially the fans of this one.
That was pretty mindless.
It would be. Its genocide tiktoktik. Ur next.
Well he kept his land alright! He's in it!
It would have been better for him just to do as that owner said. .. the final outcome was not worth the loss of lives.
the owner was a land grabber
I think the CPT character has finally seen the other side of the fight. He has sympathy for those he fought. It shows his human side.
Wes Studi is always good.
It's happened before, in Open Range, Kevin Costner's two six shooters carried twelve rounds each.
Anyone who says this is the best Western of all time is forgetting Lonesome Dove ( albeit a miniseries) or The Unforgiven. This is obviously a great Western, but a little too slow and plodding to be considered the absolute best.
Bale is undeniably a great actor when you consider some of the roles he had played. From Batman to Burt in Amsterdam to Irving in American Hustle to Dicky in The Fighter ( I believe his best ever role) to Patrick in American Psycho. I think he is this generations' most versatile actor, and he covers his British accent impeccably.
He was great in “3:10 To Yuma” with Russell Crowe…
@@valarmorghulis2350I agree. I wanted to mention that movie also, I just thought the role was too similar to the one in Hostiles. I was just trying to show the range of his roles. I really liked 3:10 to Yuma.
Unforgiven is number one
Loved lonesome dove as well.
Sorry kids! But the best and most imitated Western movie made from post WW2 till today is " Shane ". All the rest are lesser copies!
@@olderthanyoucali8512 Yes, the ending was classic. When Shane rides off into the sunset wounded and his friend the little boy runs after him crying “Shane come back! Shane…”
Very good movie.
Was the dialog recorded in a trailer?
Should have taken more defensive positions when riders were approaching. Why were standing in the wide open. And no one uses rifle to full advantage as a longer range weapon.
It's still just a movie
Ageed
Great movie.
I’m thinking a few well placed ‘No Trespassing’ signs would’ve been a safer option. 🤷🏼♂️
And just to prove we won't be intimidated, we're gonna bury FOUR more of us on your land!
5:21 This might be a dumb question but I’ve seen this plenty times and just now realizing, is that Herschel from TWD
that'll learn em
great movie... mr Bale and Ms pike do well in this movie along with the native actors....
wes is cool
Sometimes, greed, ignorance, stupidity and ego are inseparable. 😕
If the script called for more than 6 shots from Bale’s character, the director should have given him two pistols.
The reload might have ended up on the cutting room floor. It happens sometimes. Artistic license covers a myriad of sins. Don't watch any of the John Wick movies if you intend to count shots.
Never heard of this movie but rate C B highly. Looking forward to watching it
What is the name of this movie? I haven’t seen it.
I bet that you're the only one who was counting. Sometimes it's the big picture, not the derails......
Where did our freedom go
Such a sad scene. Even the women shot.
Wish Adam Beach had more screen time , great actor
Wait a minute, first shot Magwa next Uncas turns up. What film am I watching?
"I ain't telling you one more time".
"I ain't telling you one more time".
"I ain't telling you one more time".
It's Magua (Wes Studi) from Last of the Mohicans....
I forgot about this movie.
It’s really good.
Too cruel, too sad this film.
I tried watching it and it moved so slowly I had to resort to snippets on yt.
Wes studi. Brilliant in the last of the Mohicans
I saw it. Very good in my opinion.
There is no way that Hershell could be so evil....😄😄
If I'd been the rancher, I'd have let them have the plot, unharmed as long it was used strictly for burials
One of the 10 best movies ever made!…🔥🔥🔥
7:23 - There are but a few situations where “backshooting” could be considered acceptable…
Freedom from tyranny is a human right. Unite! We were all born to freedom. It should never cost anything. AHs convinced most of us to die trying for something different. #freedomisfree
Great Movie! But couldn’t hear a lot of the words when they where speaking.
It's neither his or his Sons' land now.
What makes it worse is they only put 5 in their guns, because there was no safety, the hammer would rest against an empty chamber.
That’s not true
The Son on the far left, is a relative of mine.
Scott Cooper knows how do a great western
Epic
If you ain't Cav! You ain't sh.t! Air Cav!
One of the best westerns ever.
He should've just maimed his legs so he couldn't walk, then leave him for the wolves to devour alive!
Back then it was easier to commit crimes and not get caught..finger prints didn't exist yet
Politically correct
I've never heard of "Hostiles". I have to watch it now.
Hershal continuously tries to get people off his farm. But they just don't leave b
He had two guns