'The ABCs of Book Banning' underscores school children being affected by book banning efforts
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.พ. 2024
- Even Hollywood is paying attention to book banning efforts. A new Academy Award-nominated documentary short film, “The ABCs of Book Banning,” masterfully pays tribute to the important books that have faced calls for ban across the nation. The documentary makes clear just how important those books are to readers, just how absurd the nature of book bans are, and why access to those titles is so crucial. Perhaps most importantly, “The ABCs of Book Banning” emotionally underscores exactly who's most affected by the book bans: school children. There's another voice featured prominently in “The ABCs of Book Banning” - one that members of the 'Velshi Banned Book Club' might recognize: Grace Linn. “I don’t call about the ‘Moms for Liberty’,” says Linn, “I call myself a mother of liberty.” We first learned about the 101-year-old when she gave a salient warning at a Martin County School Board meeting in Florida with a hand-made quilt featuring the covers of popular banned books. Grace Linn knows what these children don't yet understand - that limiting access to literature doesn't just cheat them of knowledge, squash their creativity, and stifle their growth. It threatens the future of their country - our country.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#BannedBooks #Books #Education
Censors are traitors to humanity.
what you simpletons don't seem to get is that when society has no limits and standards with basic morals and values that everyone respects, society will start to break down with no public limits of check and balances, if parents want their kids to read this trash, then do it at home, at your own personal sanctuary that you can do what ever you want just like it always been! there was never swearing on tv even, movies were rated even to protect children, most people do not know this but age 1 to 7 is the most influential age of them all, kids are set to absorb everything, so we need to be really careful what we expose kids to, or you create what your seeing today in public, sad, confused, mislead, children, kids hate school these days and i wonder why?! back when i was kid, school was fun, everyone strived to be better and were generally happy!, that right there should tell you something, the way things are being run is wrong and not working! ruining more kids then creating young healthy adults that will benefit society, not sit on you tube all day making videos for a half a cent a click, really beneficial to society too, lol
children need these books , children should be free to pick there own gender , Ban the Parents , support the Government , Vote Blue
Agreed. Why do college students always try to prevent conservatives from speaking on campus? Hmmm
@@copyprint-fz2hb😂 Ban the parents... that's funny
So do you think children should have access to playboy mags?
I love Grace! Mother of Liberty! Thank you, Grace!!!
"MOL" ALL DAY!!
2:07 Grace Linn's words brought tears to my eyes! She's such a wonderful and wise person. "Fear is not freedom; fear is not liberty; fear is control."
Truth.
Same 😢
I prefer the advice of Joy Reid
"Sometimes you have to scare because you care"
Fear is a good motivator to not vote for Trump💙
Your right! Fear is free , but freedom is not free.
Freedom costs a $1.05.
GOD BLESS AMERICA, THE MCRIB IS BACK!!!
The greatest strength of the democratic party is ignorance and they use that to control you.
Have you actually been in a library? All the books in the children's section are age appropriate. No book should be restricted. Just because you don't want your child reading a particular book doesn't mean another parent doesn't want their child to read it. Go to the library and help your child pick books you are okay with and leave the rest alone.
Unless things changed since I was a kid, there is nothing preventing a kid from checking out adult level books.
Librarians don't care what a kid reads as much as that they do read (that's their job).
Furthermore, some of the teen stuff is marketed towards teens (rather than age sensitive) , and the Libraries only lightly check for age appropriate content.
Many kids are in the library unsupervised, which I'm cool with, but this allows kids to expose themselves to concepts they may not be mature enough to properly process.
I'm not stating that censorship is the answer, just that library sections aren't going to prevent a child from circumventing reasonable family norms.
Do you even know why the books were banned, or you're just yapping for something you don't understand.
A banned book usually has better sales because the ban invites curiosity and the urge to gain knowledge
I remember years and years and years ago, LOL, when I was in high school the book Catcher in the Rye was banned. I guarantee just about every student in that school read it anyway. That's not to say I approve banning books. But if older students want to read something, they will read it. The younger ones, it may be harder.
The “knowledge” in question is false and subversive
Streisand effect.
Tis nothing new really. Those who seek to prevent something, only end up inviting more of it. The fact that those idyats have as yet, failed to comprehend such, tis just more proof, they sure didn't do much 'reading' of their own.
@@rhondah1587the book wasn't banned, it just wasn't allowed in school. There is a big difference.
Leave the kids alone.
Simple request aint it????
@@seanmccartney5177 Not for the depraved.
@@salvi1111 what choice?
People used to know what 'inappropriate for children' meant.
Ya joe! No sniffing
Thank you for Grace 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
We are all a work of art and we are meant to be here. We all have something to give to our world..
I would love to know Grace’s favorite book. A century of reading, what a joy for her!
Her favorite book is "Two Girls, One Cup: A Novelization of the Acclaimed Motion Picture"
@@stoopidpursun8140 Thank you! I so appreciate the time you took to tell me Mrs. Lynn’s favorite book.
@@MontanaBlue-sbw That's a troll, don't listen to them.
What are the democratic people in the USA doing and how is it possible the most creative and inventive nation on earth can allow books to be banned??
Democrats unfortunately need the Republican support to get bills past.
Liberals / progressive are fighting this but propagating and doubling down on ignorance, fear-mongering, hate-mongering, and many other forces spearheaded by reactionaries are way too pervasive thanks to many factors, very unfortunately. Our culture & values have been devolving for a long time; the fascists are absurdly powerful.]
What a beautiful champion for freedom. I want to be her when I grow up
E-books aren't having any of this book banning nonsense - you can check them out with an e-library card available everywhere regardless of where you live and whether they're 'banned' in your town or not. You can't keep an inquisitive mind down.
Thank you Mr. Velshi.
This lady is everything that’s right with America. Thank you ma’am, and thank your husband for the ultimate sacrifice he made so I could grow up reading books in freedom.
Right. My kids wanted to read Playboy mags, Mein Kampf, and the Anarchist Cookbook last year in the 2nd grade and some radical parents were trying to say they were "inappropriate". What a bunch of fascist racist homophobes.
They had Mein Kampf and The Anarchist Cookbook in your school library when you were a kid? I could have sworn those books were considered age inappropriate and not allowed in schools when we were kids growing up in the 80s. What school did you go to that allowed such books with highly inappropriate content?
Thank you, Ms Linn. You are blessing.
This documentary is brilliant! I am beyond impressed by the wisdom, maturity and insight of these 7 to 10 year olds … their eagerness to learn … the empathy they display … their desire to understand history … their inclusiveness in wanting every child to see themselves in the books they read. Therein lies my hope for the future.
Really she has no clue she is brain washed by Democrats who teach ungodly things like women's rights and other wong though. 😊
Instead of trying to get this important documentary out in the public for everyone to see, Paramount pictures has blocked it from being shown on youtube just to make money.
Anyway, I lived in Martin County, and worked as a teacher there. I am so happy I am no longer there.
Yep, let’s silence those who talk about freedom. Let’s make sure we hear what we want to hear. Blind folds are a best friend to the true fascist.
Getting their way by fabricating stories to invoke fear is how these zealots operate.
White washing history is a favourite, as well.
Books that can be boughten in stores are not banned if you want your children reading them go out and get them for them
We pay taxes into the same fund you do thus that money should be spent in our interest as well. Including public library funds. You have the right to choose to NOT read said books.
Books about banners and bands should also be banned.
i made a contribution to the ACLU and they sent me a cap with banned books club logo on it. I wear the cap almost everyday.
I be the Bible the Holy Word of the Living God was one. The only book that should be read in the public Schools. 😊
Lesson “Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups”. It’s all about dumbing people down and creating dependency.
In Ireland there was a time when the banned books made up the reading list...
There is literally not one book banned here in the US.
@@afridgetoofar1818lol, where are you from?
There are hundreds.
@@ShawnHartmann-ul2qk Name one.
@@afridgetoofar1818 Several were listed in the video you’re commenting on.
If that’s not enough, use a search engine. If time is an issue, just search for the top fifty.
@@afridgetoofar1818 “Tango Makes Three” was listed in the video.
What is wrong with maps targeting children?- msdnc
Bot
🎯 💯
This network should just come out and say it: they want the age ofConsent lowered by eight years
pedocrats 👎
@winstonsmith6607 Oh that makes sense now why it's all the red states that have laws that allow for child marriage by and large, because of the DNC, yup that tracks.
If you can purchase a book and read it in any public place, is it really banned?
Not all families can afford to buy books.
No
@@WabiSabiLady so? some people can't afford to buy a gun, but it doesn't mean guns are banned or they don't have the right to own one. just because something isn't supplied by the government doesn't mean it's banned, commie
Of course it is not being banned from being published. Censorship can involve other things.
As usual, it's disadvantaging those without a budget for buying their own books
The ABC of perversions banned . Protect our children
As a public school teacher my biggest concern for Florida’s students is that they will be painfully less knowledgeable than their college peers. Florida is setting up their next generation to fall far behind the general knowledge of students from other states. How? Well, if you have no point of view of these classic books, that are almost ALL banned, you will sit through college classes with zero prior knowledge . Florida is robbing this from students who will feel foolish and ill prepared for college dialogue, research, and perspective. It is a huge deal, it cannot be downplayed. Why are these books classics? Because they teach immeasurable concepts, situations, outcomes. They ask a student to be free thinkers, to interpret these books for themselves. R.I.P. college bound sunshine state kids.
Florida is not banning books. They are restricting access to minors for certain book content. You'll find in California that there are actual book bans of content that would expose the leftists attempts to rewrite history.
It's the dumbing down of America. If our kids are not allowed to learn critical thinking how are we as a country expected to compete with other countries academically. It's complete madness that this is happening!!
@@WabiSabiLadyDumbing down of America? The thumbnail on this video has a black male in a pink shirt with a "flower pot" on his head. 🙄
@@WabiSabiLadyDumbing down? Take a look at the thumbnail of this video of an African American male sporting a pink shirt and a "flower pot" on his head. 🙄
I hope we are not conflating "book banning" with age restricting books in school libraries and children's sections in libraries (as a parent I don't want mature content in the children's section, as I would have to "pre-read" all material for my children.)
That is exactly what is happening. And watch how many people are here to tell you that a child should be able to read any book they want to.
No it is not. Don’t listen to the trolls.
@@Arulane Yes it is. I'd go into detail, but the subjects are too sensitive for YT.
@@Arulanemap
The net effect is Christian thugs like Moms for Liberty telling me what my child is not allowed to read. That's a book ban.
Thank you for this video
They were banned for a reason. They talk about strappings, doing it to yourself, children being abused, etc. To little children.
Informed people are able to live in the world, 😊
😂😂😂"...they don't turn into werewolves or anything..."😂😂😂😂 I LOVE him!!! 💙💙💙
Brillant. Thank you.
I have recently had the signal honor of having my book - the first volume of a 4-book YA fantasy series which reviewers have called an American incarnation of "Harry Potter" even while describing it as wholly original and a grea HP "antidote - banned in Florida as part of a grand sweep that included five *dictionaries*. The series is Worldweavers - the banned book is "Gift of the Unmage" - I submit it for your "Banned Book Club"...
Should help with sales!
Those books aren't banned. You can buy and order them anywhere in Florida.
@@stoopidpursun8140 What can I tell you except that they appear on a long list of banned books in one Florida jurisdiction at least...
@@almaalexander5874 No they aren't. They have been disallowed in PUBLIC SCHOOLS. That isn't "banned" you complete clown.
@@stoopidpursun8140 Apparently, you're wrong. But don't apologize.
Thank you, Ali Velshi, for what you do for literacy and learning❤
I am impressed by this woman Grace.
As a trans black man I'm glad black history month is the shortest month of the year and will be voting for president Trump 🎉🎉🎉🎉F J B
Might I ask why?
As a conservative, this comment is cancer
How many Republicans would see these kids talking, and think that they're being told what to say.
Kids KNOW that books and reading are important, and banning books is 100% WRONG!!
Bring back Reading Rainbow with all banned books!
At your house...............With consent forms or parental supervision
Banning books you don't like is no different than banning statues/monuments you don't like.
This is manipulating the truth. In WWII they were banning all books from all the public. These books are not appropriate for elementary schools! The parents have every right to let their own children read these books at home. I'm sickened by this.
Bruh, when the draft hits, your coming with us men. Period. You will uphold your role as a man in this society, end of story. Like the men did before you, for you.
There's no draft.
@@wtfisthishandlebullshitwhen there is, he’s coming with!
@@johnbrown4949 There never will be. What is wrong with you.
@@wtfisthishandlebullshityour right, we just register for selective service for our health
@@johnbrown4949 That's outdated and needs removed, but there will never be another draft.
I would love to be able to rent this.
Give it the Oscar
Instead of banning books, you need to ban trump and maga.
This is the sort of guy who thinks the government should offer The Anarchist Cookbook to students in middle school
Sybil!!!😂
@@TaytesHuugeCaulk Oh look somebody who thinks the government needs to provide students access to, Hit Man: A Technical Manual for Independent Contractors
No, that's what the dark web is for.
If middle school students really want to read something like that, they will find a way. Banning only makes it more desirable to get and read.
@@rhondah1587 Right, so let's start having government purchase and provide Mein Kampf, The Communist Manifesto and First Person
The only book that we should make every child read is The Holy Word of God the Bible. As a Born-again Christian man being a Christian is the only truth worth it. Other books not so much they are a problem. Christ is King Proverbs 1:7 KJVS
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge: but fools despise wisdom and instruction.
Why do you advocate to have pornographic material in schools?
@rukiddingmeNJ there aren't any books in schools that are pornographic
I honestly don't know. Everyone who looks into it realizes that many of these books are completely inappropriate for children. They're trying to gaslight people into thinking that the dems are in favor of free speech, but almost every single one of these 'banned' book are friggin' children's books with sexualContent. It's messed up
These laws are generally universally enacted to protect children from pornographic or sexually explicit materials. These youngsters will have plenty of time to be exposed to this type of sexually explicit material as they get older, however, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, as well as parents want this type of material restricted from children.
It's so important to stay informed about issues like book banning, especially when it involves school children. Understanding how these efforts can impact education and access to diverse perspectives is crucial. It's great to see discussions that bring awareness to such a significant topic, encouraging everyone to think critically about the value of literature and free access to information. Let's keep advocating for a world where every voice can be heard and every story can be shared! 📚✨
Okay I know that the issue of age appropriate material for kids is the focus here but that was hilarious 😆🤣😂
@@BringBackFreeSpeechToYT
Where are these books? In what school?
@@WabiSabiLady They are in a lot of school libraries, and have been removed from a lot as well. The first place that popped up is CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa.
@@BringBackFreeSpeechToYT And at what school?
Very well put ❤
There are no banned books. You can buy any book in any state in any city in the US.
They're banned
Provided you can afford to buy your own.
Not all families can afford to buy books.
@@WabiSabiLady Go to the public library, not the public school library.
They are banning books in public libraries, too. So adults can't read them, either. Not all towns have bookstores and Walmart carries a limited number of titles.
Yep. The country of freedom. Except when it's not.
This is histrionics. None of these books are banned. If they were, then you couldn't buy them. The problem is that you can't force parents to pay for material that is counter to community standards. That is the way local schools function and it shouldn't come as a sudden surprise to anyone. You can complain that not everyone meets your superior standards, but those people you're belittling think the same thing about you.
Every schoolchild should have access to The Satanic Verses by Salman Rushdie.
Agreed but will they even consider reading it .........and what age
I oppose book banning in any form, but I do wonder how many of these parents complaining about it read with their children on a regular basis? One way to overcome a ban is to purchase the banned book for your kids. Not an optimal solution but one that can work before the eventual day when Moms for Liberty self-implodes.
The second you tell a normal curious child what she is not allowed to read, she'll immediately hop on the internet to read all about it.
They've taken away access to free books. Not every parent can afford to buy books.
@@WabiSabiLady "Not an optimal solution" is what I believe I said.
@@tommyudo3195 Yes, you did. I apologize. I grew up reading and love books. This topic has my blood boiling!!
@tommyudo3195 I challenge you to find and read one of the real books that is banned and the ban was upheld by an appeal process. I guarantee you don't want children reading that book.
@@tflg3257 Right, as a PARENT, I would not allow my child to read such a book. On the other hand, I don't want a gang of Christian hysterics deciding what my child should read.
Why is it that right-wingers don't trust the state to do anything properly except tell us what books we're allowed to read?
If a school cuts their archery program, does that mean that archery is banned? or is it simply not available at that particular institution?
Derp
@@TaytesHuugeCaulk derp
Aren't you a clever troll.
@@WabiSabiLady what's the matter? Don't have an answer?
@@WabiSabiLady what's the matter? Don't have an answer?
What's the liberal outrage of the week? 'Book bans', White supremacy, Patriarchy, GOP, climate, Israel?
I've kinda lost track.
Do you think any of those are GOOD things?
Dems are mad because a journalist had the gall to interview a world leader.
Quite Simple...............Don't tell 'em
Is Forestry Ever A Verb ?
Only A Firm Problem ?
👌🏻👏🏻✊🏻💙, these signs tells you how I feel!
I read your book, sir. Most of it is straight up p*rn & should only be available to purchase in an adult book store.
L you don't read books
The people who tried to ban you from life..for not wearing a mask..are mad that their books are being banned 😅
And she's 20 years older than Biden!!!😂😂😂😂
My kids all loved reading!!!@
children need these books , children should be free to pick there own gender , Ban the Parents , support the Government , Vote Blue
@@copyprint-fz2hb You don't pick your gender. Try reading a biology book sometime.
Omg children , let them be the future of the world because after all theyu are our future!!
Velshi reminds me of a Mime with all his hand gestures. He gets excited. 🤷
He gets too excited when he's talking about his support of warping the minds of our youth in the hopes that he can hook up with them.
Zem zer definitely needs the makeup 🤡🤡
Thank you Veshi for doing this.
children need these books , children should be free to pick there own gender , Ban the Parents , support the Government , Vote Blue
Heck yeah! Subscriptions to Hustler for all elementary school students paid for by taxes!
Great report. 👍
Thanks to the Republicans for protecting America's children
🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤮🤮🤮
Those books have killed so many children, not the guns though. You never hear about children being killed with guns in this country. Ban the books, protect the guns. And protect the criminals too! It's criminal what they're doing to Donnie. He's special, god sent him!
That's a joke? Right?
100%
Republicans vote against expanding the child tax credit, veto in their states free school lunches. A hungry child cannot learn, especially when they are denied access to books to learn.
Sh..... I've never heard of this old lady. MSNBC's definition of "viral" is hilarious.😂😂😂😂
Thank you governor DeSantis for banning CRT and drag queen shows in schools 🎉🎉
There's still some hope for you to escape the cult. You just need to wake up.
@@Char99 Quote, Trump loves the poorly educated.
you do not even understand CRT so shove it.
VElshi, I love your show and thank you for your precious work. We need it desperatly!
BUT: This time you were too fast. The old Lady had to say much more and you went on with YOUR speed and cut her off. A petty, as she really knew what she was talking about. Don't forget: Old people are slow but not stupid or not awake. But with all their experiences they could give us such an immense lot of precious knowledge, we only must go down with our speed and LISTEN to them and benefit. Sorry to say this, but the idiotic discussion about the age of Biden make people oversee the treasure that goes lost. Must human race for some more 5'000 years repeat the same faults again and again and again?! NO!! Listen to the old people!!
MSNBS PROPAGANDA NETWORK 😭👹
@adiliareis3631 claiming a site is propaganda only proves you don't like hearing the facts/truth
@@psycobleach46 YOU ARE NOT GOING TO GET THE FACTS OR TRUTH ON THIS PROPAGANDA CLOWN NETWORK !
MsLSD practicing president banning and complaining about book banning.🤪
Trump 2024!
jail 2024
This made me cry. I just can't believe book bans are happening. It makes me sick to my stomach.
They aren't. No books are being banned. Stop crying.
Hey TH-cam! Are you going to delete this comment as well?
So you guys want to allow pornographic books under the guise of LGBTQ classification? A child read this in front of a school council and ask why this kind of books are in their libraries. If this would make them more mature too early, be my guest.
How will children receive a valid education without learning ftom many viewpoints ? I cannot image giving a good defense as an attorney or trying to treat as a doctor or without understanding many lives. Even to pack and stock groceries you need to know the world.
An attorney has a base system that is grounded not a ton of different concepts. That’s how a good attorney wins, by knowing what is actually base and what isn’t.
That's not a concern GOP has
@@angelikalindenau943 nice baseless argument
Should we have Playboy and Hustler available in school libraries?
Just stop
@@rensinclair4218So you believe in book bans. Thanks.
I didn’t know The Onion Network News had an opinion on this subject matter 😆🤣😳 I find it hysterical that these wannabe news jokes look so serious 🤣😆
Hi Winston!! 👋
Why are you watching if that's how you feel? Troll.
You'll get more real news out of the Onion and SNL, than you'll get out of all the far right tabloid rags like fox, et al, combined.
I don't know why fox has a WH press pass, they are not the press and they make the press room look like a joke.
Liberals: Why can't my 6 year old checkout 50 shades of grey from their school library?
Sane People: 🤦♂
Obviously fake TH-cam trolling account created solely to sow division, mistrust, lies, fear and hate.
@@nigeltufnel9525You like the little kiddos Nigel?
Teachers: Where are all the books?
Sane People: Who voted for this?
Show me an example of where that's happening? What school? Shame on you!!
@@DarthSailorMoo The Books are there. Just not the ones that should be age restricted.
Since we all came from Adam and Eve that makes us all cousins. Hi cousins.
We came from Adam and Steve according to this guy
What a fabulous lady. Banning books is shocking, I don’t understand their mentality. I have been an ardent book reader all my life. I have read any book I ever wanted to read. I am horrified that some people feel they have the power to ban books. Take the power back in your own hands and read what you want.
I wonder why (george) is writing books for children 🤢🤢🤢
Bot
@@TaytesHuugeCaulkfar from it SYBIL
I never understood the whole argument of over this book banning. I am a school teacher by trade and ran into another individual that built homes for a living and was obviously very more wealthy than me. But we did share of common trust with both of us being parents and we couldn't understand why anybody would support pyrography as good reading for out children. I get it I'm older but I feel like the people supporting this just have an infatuation that most people cannot understand.
What Hamas supporting Velshi doesn't tell you is that these books can be bought at your bookstore or AMZ
they should put playboy in school libraries
Hustler
I’m pretty certain the books are not banned. Just out of reach of young kids in school libraries 😂
I gots mah gold Trump sneakaaz.✊🏿
When Trump business is forced out of NY how many jobs leave the state with him?
Hundreds? Thousands ?
Troll, that's not the topic of discussion.
@louistully3831 These are the same people who destroyed small businesses through Covid mandates. And the same people who have decriminalized shoplifting, and forced retail stores to close and leave the area.
😂❤❤❤❤❤
None of these books are banned. They can be purchased online or at your local bookstore.
@Sturmavk t hey are banned from schools and some public libraries. that is what they are talking about.
Banned
@@psycobleach46 thanks for proving the books aren’t actually banned. Books or content deemed “age inappropriate” or “not suitable for younger viewers” are just what they say they are. Not banned.
@@Sturmavk nope, what i stated is that books are BANNED from schools and libraries. you can look that and you find that I am correct. The books were age appropriate, the only problem those people and you have are that they deal with other genders. they are banned.
During the 2021-2022 school year, more than 1,600 books were banned from school libraries. The bans affected 138 school districts in 32 states, according to a report from PEN America, an organization dedicated to protecting free expression in literature.
The privilege of comments like "parents can just buy the book" - it reads like folks who have never worked in schools & don't understand the importance of free access to information of all kinds
No books have been "banned." You can still buy them.
Not the point.
@@jockyoung4491 The point should include, "accuracy"
@@jockyoung4491 How's the stalking going today, racist?
@kahanakahuna1470 they have been banned from schools.
@@psycobleach46 Yeah, Hustler Magazine and Playboy Magazine were banned from schools, 60 years ago, too You have a problem with that?
There's been a lot of blowback in Black America from Joyless's nasty interview with Mom's for Liberty where she defended books about r4pe, inc3st, and strapp-ons being available for children. Hopefully a petition will get started to force MSDNC to fire Joyless and Velshi
The irony of such a hateful, miserable wretch of a human being being named “Joy” 😂
I've got a book for ya..."Revenge Of The Tiger" by Claude Bahls 🤣
So incredibly childish
ALL of these books are available at the public library. They aren’t banned.
Removing books is banning books.
@@mytruecrimelibrary No it’s not. I REMOVED some old books from my bookshelf and donated them. That doesn’t mean they are now banned.
@@roejogan7770 if you take away books from a library then they are banned. Stop trying to justify your bigotry with nonsense.
@@mytruecrimelibrary If they are available in other libraries then they aren’t banned.
@@mytruecrimelibrary Hustler isn’t available in the library yet hustler isn’t banned.
Don't ban books. Instead, ban "Moms For Liberty" .
joe biden has finally got a new job as a Walmart greeter. his first phrase was 'welcome to Target!'