Ok hear me out 2ne1 was also under yg..this proves that it’s not about the company it’s about the artist…everyone uses the word mismanagement too much….they are not getting mistreated or mismanaged…otherwise they would have never been the biggest gg for no reason
Can someone help YG realize that Jisoo and rosè are two different people so stop giving them the same lines. They need their own time to shine because they are also talented like Lisa and Jennie
Yh exactly they just shove jisoo and rose there just for being there's sake. They're only paying attention to the one's making them the most money and getting the most attention Jennie and Lisa. If they actually focused on Jisoo and Rose as individuals, it would show so well.
And someone needs to tell Y.G that Jisoo and Rosé could be extremely better vocalists if they had the right technique, especially for their higher notes, since we know they already rock the lower ones.
girl there duo is different from every one ya they have the same lines in all songs but they are the vocalist they have to do so and why are you acting like as if other group members dont sing the same lines
I don't know many Kpop groups...But Ateez which debuted in 2018, has over 20 songs! Some even in Japanese! Latest album took me some 40-50 plus mins to listen to all their songs! And they are rookies! So BP with 11 songs is a joke!
I kind of forgot black pink was still in the kpop industry- Like idk how their fans are hyping them up as if black pink is still trending when they’re actually only famous for YG’s scandals. It’s just sad.
Imagine training so hard at a very popular company that debuts you, gives you stylists that put you on the newest trendiest styles in the industry, gets you deals with the top designers, has the best marketing for your group, gives you collabs with the biggest artists in the industry, BUT- at the end of the day all you can really "do" is not gain weight, not date anyone, not even release your own songs that you've written and just be pretty the way that these people want you to be, all because you're under contract. at the end of the day you're not even an artist, just a performer- a puppet even
@@notwerkinginthishouse8634 if others idols have freedom, why can't the girls? why do they have to be someone else just so theyre more "relatable" or "marketable". we'd still support them :(
Ikr. I sometimes wonder if the girls are disappointed in all this. I really hope things change from now on. Coz apparently Jennie and Jisoo had written some lyrics for the lovesick girls song. We are also apparently getting Rosé's solo around the start of this year so. Also Lisa's solo in this year. Maybe things will change for the girls.
The problem with BlackPink is YG entirely. At this point they’re more models than idol singers, literally doing everything else but put out music. Now I stan BlackPink I love those girls but it’s really hard for me to continue to be invested in a group who as of now have 7 title tracks and 6 b-sides compared to other big 3 groups who have almost double that in title tracks and a lot more bsides. They’re literally the only female act under YG right now actively promoting and they haven’t had a full album yet, it’s a shame. Edit: so they’ve come back with How You Like That and idk about everyone else but it’s literally the same thing that we’ve already seen from them. Maybe cause it’s a pre-release and we’re getting something better with the full Korean album but so far I’m not impressed
I think that they could do a little more as well (I say this from a place of liking BP but no longer stanning due to boredom because of the reasons in this video) they have their own IGs they could do a few more covers or show something other than pretty pictures etc. Lisa has her yt now which is a bit better but I'm sure winner get comebacks by pushing for them or writing them
Vivi x yeah I feel like once they get into the creative process of writing their music, then maybe it’ll be better but more than that, start to get other producers with a variety of sound cause Teddy is starting to get stagnant
Andre Drew I think they aren’t allowed to write their own music. I remember in a video where it states that Jennie had a whole notebook of songs she wrote, but when she put it on some table it was gone. The same thing happens when Jennie put a pencil there it was gone.
은이지 Everybody knows he made gashina because it sounds almost the same as „solo“ 🤣And tbh if he doesn‘t have enough time to write more songs there is a really simple solution: Hire someone else to do it. It‘s not like blackpinks songs are artistic masterpieces- they could probably find someone else to write a one line chorus.
@@은이지-m6c Bruh, Gashina has the same exact boring formula. Yall are just too blind on the primary phase and the electronic notes. He's lacking the artistry cuz people perceived him to be so artistic, that he isn't experimenting with music anymore.
i hate when people do something they are not competent at and yet getting a bunch of money for that. i mean dear teddy, if you can't produce songs the way you are supposed to produce them, nothing wrong but then just simply don't do it. there are people who can and will do it. it's really unfair. no wonder why blackpink always look bored when performing, teddy is literally recycling boombayah for 3 years.
@@appletart7262 Yeah. I assume you didn't care for Pink Venom, then? I like the instrumental but it just sounds like another basic Blackpink song to me. I wasn't even impressed or interested in the vocals
blackpink debuted at a time when Bg stans were tearing apart twice n groups similar for having a cute concept and mourning disbandment of groups like 4minute and 2ne1 and they latched onto blackpink like a starving vampire to a bloody neck.
@@calliespltn Don't confuse the very vocal minority with the majority. People notice the malcontents because they are the screechiest part of the fandom. Meanwhile, the bulk of the fans are genuine, supportive of the girls (as a group) and are just as angry at the people attacking certain members as you are, only they do it with a lot less screeching. Have you ever heard "The squeaky wheel gets the grease". That's the case here with certain fandoms (or any large group for that matter). It's the people screeching the loudest that get the most attention. Have you ever been in a department store and there's a baby a few aisles over (or even at the other end of the store) crying his lungs out? You obviously notice the baby because, being so loud, he draws your attention. Meanwhile you hardly notice the dozens of other shoppers because they are quietly going about their business. It's the same way with fandoms. We have the screaming babies, which get most of the attention, versus the bulk of the fandom which is just quietly enjoying the music and supporting their groups. So, to answer your obviously baiting question, no, Geetha Ranjani was not referring to "the same “fans” that only care about certain members". She was referring to the fans who are genuinely supportive of the group, as a whole, not the fanwarriors who "only care about certain members'.
Kill this love music structure: - Jennie opens the song - Lisa second verse - Rosé and Jisoo sing the pre-chorus - Chorus primary phrase: let's kill this love - Onomatopeia: rupumpum - Trompets, electro notes - bridge Rosé I want something new for this comeback like for real (if ther is any).
Things we want - No Jennie starting - Jennie rapping - Vocals that suits jisoo - Jisoo saying "BP IN UR AREA" she never said it - Full written chorus (for real STOP. no a word/phrase and drop) - lisa dance break - no bridge rosé - the ending being nice - some cool chaesoo interaction (vocal) - and so much more oof
As was touched on in the video, that makes sense in a way. Having them model and do commercials means very little money spent by YG. Creating songs and, MV's is expensive. It's all money that has to be invested before there's a payoff. Modeling and commercials require very little investment from the agency. It's almost all gravy, as far as YG is concerned. Having them focus on modeling and commercials may suck for the music fans, but it makes a LOT of sense from a business standpoint.
Blackpink reminds me of how I played some strategy games, when I found a single good strategy, I would try to keep using it until the npc's or the game noticed something was wrong kahslwjsdohaosnmc
I dont hate blackpink but blinks are unbearable for acting like they're being hatecrimed every time someone points out blackpink has like 2 songs and they all sound the same. now they're saying liking BP is an unpopular opinion when they're literally the most popular girl group.
@@andinho2204 yes but we would prefer if you guys used the term blinks because saying blinks as a whole makes it seem like almost the whole fandom is bad.
It hurts my heart to know that all the girls wanted was to become idols and they worked hard for it just to come into some trash entertainment company and be managed by a misogynistic asshole that keeps them under his fingers, turning them into something they didn't want to be and turning their own fandom against them, and if not that then they become "toxic" to other fandoms that say our girls are underrated and don't deserve their fame. The girls of Blackpink don't deserve this hate or treatment and for all these people saying these horrible things doesn't make it any better
Blackpink song’s really don’t make Teddy seem like the genius he is made out to be... if he’s such a genius he should be able to produce versatile music no?
My thoughts: YG is really smart , he manipulates Blackpinks popularity. He knows that the song is going to get popular whether the music is good or not. The formula is getting boring , How you like that also has the same formula. YG GIVE US GOOD MUSIC.
He also manipulates the fans very well, trying to convince them that bp's lack of songs are because he prefers "quality over quantity" when it's obviously not true.
He somehow manipulated the whole world into thinking that bp is huge. They’re not. They have never won a daesang because their music isn’t good. That’s just the tea
@@namename9372 Not really. A lot of people agreed with Signal being bad but Signal won SOTY. You know that BLACKPINK barely join to the award shows. They don't have much songs. If their songs were bad, "The Album" wouldn't sell more than 1.260.000 units. Same for HYLT, they sold 302.000 just for a freaking single album. No daesang =/= bad songs Daesang =/= good songs
the empty choruses is something that's always annoyed me about blackpink songs despite them being my ult girl group. i think there's a reason why aiiyl is very popular amongst korean listeners and that's because of the very full chorus compared to the rest of their songs. i'm really hoping that when they do comeback soon they have a different formula and the chorus is rich with actual words instead of a single phrase and instrumental in the back
I personally think As If It's Your Last is one of their best title track along with Stay. The Blackpink title tracks that I can only stand are Stay, AIIYL, and PWF. The rest are just so-so. But they are catchy so I understand why many like it.
@@luluangelina2923 its such a good song because the rapping from jenlisa is probably one of their best, the vocals from all of them are insane and the bridge with rosie's vocals are literally everything, on top of that the music video is beautiful but the chorus... my god the chorus as catchy as it is, is so bloody annoying because its so... empty yknow?
1. Primary (English) Phrase 2. Onomatopoeia or Secondary Phrase 3. Cycling Pattern of Electronic Notes How you like that: 1. How you like that? 2. You gon like that that that/Look at you now look at me 3. [electronic sounds]
A couple additions: 1.) Rose's voice in Blackpink isn't her real voice. YG made her change it for the group. 2.) The choreography often repeats itself too with the same formula, just like the songs do. 3.) Most of Blackpink's songs are not even theirs - they were originally written for 2NE1 and put into the vault.
In the 3rd one your wrong not most of the songs were written for 2ne1 which they gave to blackpink.... only as if its your last was 2ne1’s song and they gave it to bp because 2ne1 disbanded before they could give it to them .. so they gave it to bp
I Know What They Don't Know I need proof... just because it is a badass song doesn’t mean its 2ne1’s song ok?? As I’ve heard only as if its your last was gonna be a 2ne1 song ... but you have no rights to tell its a 2ne1 because the song was the company’s... 2ne1 didn’t write the lyrics or produce it sooo....
@@itsariayt3163 The idea is not farfetched at all. Teddy is the producer for both groups and 2ne1 had A LOT of unreleased material, like the album they had ready when YG announced their disbandment by surprise. This is obviously not BP's fault at all and I don't get why Blinks get so sensitive about it.
You have to use your brains and realize that YG is using its groups just to launder its dirty money from drug trafficking, pimping and various other illegal trafficking. This is why YG does not seek to recruit teams of competent and diversified producers for its groups; I guess they must keep to themselves "experienced traffickers". All those who are at Yg are perfectly aware of everything that is happening but as it is their source of income they prefer to keep quiet and act as if nothing had happened.
*Is no one gonna talk about: "Yg, when you lock your consumers in the dungeon and not give them food, they start to eat eachother." Like if that isn't true idk what is*
2018: twice had 12 comebacks. in these 12 comebacks, they had a total of 29 songs. added up, you could spend 89 minutes and 10 seconds binging those songs. red velvet had 4 comebacks. in these 4 comebacks, they had a total of 25 songs. added up, you could spend 84 minutes and 3 seconds binging those songs. mamamoo? 3 comebacks. 21 songs. 61 minutes, 33 seconds. gfriend? 2 comebacks. 13 songs, 43 minutes, 31 seconds. clc? 1 comeback. 5 songs. 16 minutes, 38 seconds. blackpink had 1 comeback, 4 songs, 14 minutes, 3 seconds.
Brilliant analysis. Seriously. However, the explanation why Blackpink doesn't have any more music as of right now is Teddy. It is known that he and he alone decides and I think (co-)writes the stuff for blackpink. I remember an interview in which he said, he's not going to approve anything for Blackpink unless he feels it's a 100% fit for them. Now taking the formular into consideration, I don't get it anymore. There are tons of amazing music producers out there coming up with fresh and unique sounds and structures every day. Aquiring them shouldn't be as hard, especially for YG.
whats worse is DJ Snake admitted they were in talks of collaborating and even started the song but it got thrown away. Steve Aoki has requested collabs and YG ignored him AND ariana grandes producer even flew to SK last summer and yet we've not heard a peep out of whatever they worked on (probably cause teddy had no input and god forbid that happens)
@@ellielouise9625 That sucks. Ariana Grande and Diplo would have blown them up in the Western market. Can YG not see the opportunity there? Now there are rumors Ari's about to collab with BTS. YG threw away a great collab opportunity and possibly handed it to their biggest competitor in the Western market. Wth
@@goldyd144 i'd love ari x bts and ari x bp but YG are literal fools. their Dua Lipa collab got them so many casual listeners who could have turned into fans. I had locals who were streaming it not knowing who BP were!! And dua said she'd love to work again but guarantee if she offered them a song for her new album YG rejected it!! The fact there's been 2 artists alone in 2019 who admitted YG rejected them/called it off and then Tommy Brown literally flying to Seoul to meet with them and NOTHING has happened since then its such a joke. It's a lie that they've been working since the international tour ended cause all of the girls have been jetting off across the world. We all know its gonna be recycled songs that were recorded/written in 2016 for the third cb in a row, even Lisa said they do nothing once concerts are over so YG saying that is such a joke. First the cb was meant to be November 2019, then January 2020 and then it was in the first quarter and now March-April...wedged in between Big Bangs big return to the industry and IKONs comeback.......the jokes write themselves.
It's almost like YG is purposefully setting them up to fail. I can't imagine why. BP is a big source of revenue for the company and could be even bigger if they could actually DO something.
Keith Craig it’s the same reasons as RV being one of SMs best and most I demand world wide. They hate the fact that their ggs are doingbetter than their bgs. RV are more in demand in the U.K. than superm or NCT but they won’t promote or send them here. They won’t book RV on US tv shows but send other groups on them. BLACKPINK until their disbandment will just get 1 cb a year and shipped off onto world tours, esp now BB is back
@@onthescene7897 BTS doesn't really have a formula though. Big Hit gives them complete artistic freedom so their music is usually based off of personal experience or what they've read/watched/ listened to that made an impact with them. And for their non musical content is sort of becoming a formula as TXT now has their own version. It's less of a formula thing than it is that the amount of mockery/being ignored that happened to BTS when they were rookies Big Hit eventually decided that it wasn't worth it and stopped booking them as many places and doubled their company activities. And now the same thing is happening with TXT because honestly it's a lot more comfortable for the artist to not have to sensor themselves. So it's not so much as a formula as it is a freedom, kindness, experience, the company looking out for their artist personal wellbeing, and creating innovative solutions to problems. I'm not sure if the more corporate companies could or would be willing to change how their company's run enough to be like BTS'S Company so that they could possibly get the same results.
The fact that everything she said about the song formula came back with KTL and DKWTD 😭 Edit: call me crazy because the replies disagree, but I don't think How You Like That has the same structure 👀
@@placebo_effect it would certainly make them a very polarizing group with a one-dimensional sound. I dare say that their sound and image are already polarized. They won't be able to release other concepts like retro, dark, bright or anything else because they blinks will think "they abandoned their badass concept". Case in point is how their song Stay remains the most underrated in their discography
@@Faith-vg9ox Yes, so true. It's already happened with Twice, which is kind of a "scientifically proven" kind of thing. Which sucks, because they won't have their own freedom to say "we want to be different, unique and something special". They'll be pushed into that corner without any defense :(
@@placebo_effect Twice has had at least the chance to work with different producers so their sound...... While it has remained primarily bright and cute..... their songs still manage to sound different. Compare TT to Feel Special. Or Signal to Fancy. We can safely say that Twice has at least tried to switch up a bit with retro concept (What is Love) , bright (heart shaker, Like ooh ahh) , cute (most of their songs) and slightly sexy (fancy). What blackpink needs is to work with different producers. Just do that their songs can become more dynamic and unpredictable
FINALLY one person who is actually talking about real things and not just straight up hating on the girls. The only reason I unstanned was because I got tired of the repetitive sound and I have nothing against the girls, the music just stopped sounding authentic to me
same here..I liked them when they first debuted but it just got boring after square up, that was also the time I found out about (g)i-dle's debut so I gradually started losing interest in Blackpink's songs
@@grod338 same except i like lovesick girls and whistle. AIIYL just got pretty boring as i was obsessed with it for months. i just dont want to even want to look at the as if its your last MV's thumbnail at all. i just like solo and on the ground now. waiting for lisa's solo!!
@@jessnalulila5552 but I feel it's okay for itzy to have 14 songs, they just debuted last year. But for blackpink, HELL NO. 4 year girl group but having less than 20 songs is so messed up.
@@sabrinathereindeer6075 This video has nothing to do with the members of blackpink,Mera is talking about their discography,which is YG and Teddy's job.
@@lovely-fc2wv no. They don't. Not when I compare them to other ggs that are literally changing the concepts, sound, mvs, everything! Composing, directing, writing, etc. Other ggs are way up there in all of this but bp is just hovering at ground level. This new song of their's should have been released in their rookie days. I swear I have never seen a group regress this hard in musicality. Their first 5 songs were great and now it's just trash, I drew the line at dudu. That song wasn't it. And they went on to release two more versions of dudu? I had to laugh
... we just got the same formula a 10th time and the fans are about to give YG their money anyway and prove that starving them works. This will keep happening as long as we let YG get away with it.
Isn't it?! lol. I too came back to this video after seeing their new comeback only to be underwhelmed by the the same formula again. It's getting worse. I guess we won't see any improvement in the near future because blind stans will just keep excuzing yg's mediocre production and call anyone who gives feedback a hater so they'll keep making easy money.
@@timesup2812 yeah their newest song ice cream is one of their worst songs (it had to be said honestly) because i Of not only the line distribution but the lyrics snd I saw some blknks complaining saying all the blinks commenting on the ice cream saying that we're just blonks and its like I can't have a opinion and thus yg plans works
If they raise their voice against it then fans will obliviously support them but what to do ?? They aint compalining ! Seems to be satisfied for they are famous but not gonna improve
The song arrangement in MY opinion also makes first-time listeners gravitate more to Jennie and Lisa because the songs kinda set up for Jisoo and Rose to share pre-chrous’s which aren’t the peak of the song, and when Lisa’s rap or jennie’s rap makes more of an impact new fans gravitate to those two first
@Fluffy Fluff and yet lisa doesnt get a dance break, and jennie doesnt rap as much as her position as main rapper should. If they are already this popular then giving them this would break the internet. About jisoo and rose. U cant even say that this can be done so they shine more. There are so many things that ignorant yg just misses out on these balls of talent.
For real, and I noticed they had a lot of similar dance moves like the end to kill this love and how you like that are very similar, a huge group comes in, walking forward dramatically and then I saw the do those clap things in another song dance
Go watch the video titled 'All blackpink dances are the same' , even their choreographies are all same (not blackpink's fault tho...it's yg's fault for giving them the same choreography).
Came back after lovesick girls, and to no shock they used the same formula: Jennie starts Slice of Lisa Jisoo and rose on the pre chorus Primary phrase in English :”we are the lovesick girls” Secondary:” we were born to be alone” Nothing has changed :/
It's not only the line distribution... it's also the same sounds (Lovesick girls changes a bit fromt this formula, but Pretty Savage is basically another song "pure-Teddy-Blackpink")
It’s sad because this formula he makes, even though it’s the same and as long as BlackPink fans buy their songs he’s making a lot of money out of it so can’t really see him caring much if they sound the same or not.
Nah, it ain't Teddy's fault. It's YG and also BP's fault. I remember BP saying in an interview they felt most comfortable working with Teddy. They had plenty of chances to work with other producers but turned them down. No one else is to blame but the company and the artist. Producers produce music, but the company and the artists have a say in whether they like it or not.
Blue Moon why would bp members turn down producers and collabs they like just because they felt comfortable with teddy? sis you tried it, but this is completely a YGE problem 💅🏼
Damn. This is an excellently written essay that deserves so many more views. Very well done. Ps im not trying to sound condescending, I just wanted to say that I really enjoyed the video.
I had to come back to this vid immediately after I just listened to "How you like that"! 😂 It's literally the same procedure as every year. I don't even know what to say anymore about their songs, at this point I just feel sorry for everyone getting bullshitted by their producers.
@@nojam6212 i hate to agree but this is so true. i think that's really the intention. starve the blinks until they beg for a comeback and release a remix version of the previous songs with same old choreography but expensive mv sets and clothes, and put the mv under "people & blogs" to get views :) at this point, it's so obvious they want bp to break it into the western market to get on charts like billboard to compete with bts. kinda sad tbh :(
I found them through HYLT and I love the song a lot but I think it’s similar to their other songs. Even the phrase how you like that is in another song
Damn this video was released before KTL, but coming back from How You Like That, the music structure to bp songs still applies. The "missing chorus syndrome", onomatopoeia with "How you like that that that that", catchy/repetitive phrase "Look at you now look at me".... it's been 1 year and 2 months since KTL and we're still getting the same thing. Disappointed but not surprised sigh.
I started listening to Janny, who made blackpink fan made songs just to feed myself. I need music from these girls and I'm honestly frustrated that they have so much potential but YG wastes it all. Sis, you spoke the truth.
Ikr right I also listened to Janny's "Full Blackpink Album" lol with Rosé's like 3 "solos" and the others 2 I think haha we are seriously starving for music
"If you're sticking to one formula and just swapping out your phrases and techno-melodies, then writing 10 songs should take a week" YES THATS EXACTLY MY POINT!! YG makes absolutely no sense, why would it take an entire year to come out with a mini album with only four songs, if all of those songs share the exact same formula.
EXACTLY, bro they are not like the old composers who wrote 40 minute symphony which can take months but this song formula can only produce less than 20 songs? Make it make sense.
I would lie if I said I don't love the girls, especially Jennie, and I also won't deny I actually enjoy Blackpinks songs. However, as you mentioned, their heavily on EDM and Dance Tracks relying Discography makes their music at the same time stable and incredibly unstable. As someone who enjoys experimental, new music (I am a big fan of Red Velvets, EXOs and Taeyeons Discography- because especially SM likes to experiment with various genres. Probably because they buy extremely many songs and take their time putting together a perfect album. Then again, this is another discussion.) Blackpinks Discography is only bearable because I can switch to other artists to spice my listening experience a bit. But the same "strong" sound made them extremely popular, and as you also already mentioned, it is a little hard to find a difference between blackpinks choruses and the choruses of other artists, be it western Artists or Koreans. The amount of talent and potential those 4 girls have, and that is thrown away is ridiculous. I feel like their newest (lol) release had only one song that broke out of that formula, kinda like Really, and it was Kick it. But if you take a look at those two songs, that are also following the same formula. I consider myself a blink since Blackpinks debut, and I honestly hope YG keep their promise and releases the goddamn full album in January, and I hope they will feature a track like sure thing on it. My hopes are up- this time their worked with various producers.
Alice 2076 SAME, I just want them to get credited for their work too..., like teddy did NOT write stay, it was jennie and jisoo, and lisa wrote the rap in as if its your last, but they didn’t credit her work..
You really have not listened to all bp songs , huh They have been making new genre like rock with ep , edm with trap , reggae , future ballad ect. I am a taeyeon stan and I didn't knew my fellow listeners will be so ignorant
@@lianakeirasky3877 tf. Did you even read my comment. I enjoy BP Music, actually I enjoy it a lot, but the genrea you mentioned are not the ones in BPs music. For your information, I stan them since their debut, so of course I've listened to all of their songs. But if you can't see how similar they are, what a similar Vibe they have you are clearly "ignorant", as you just told me to be. They have two ballads, then they have Kick it and Teally which sound similar but different from the rest. Then you have Playing with fire, Don't know what to do and Forever Young, which qll have a beat drop (EDM, but rather soft) as a chorus. D4 and KTL have the exact same structure, I don't agree that they sound the same, and I actually think KTL was better than D4. Boombayah, See U later and whistle also have the same structure. The only song that stands out because it's upbeat and not that "I'm a bad bitch, oh I'm hurt, now I'm a bad bitch again" kinda song is Aiiyl, which remains their beat. Reggae is nowhere to be heard in their songs, you can have Reggae kind of beat and yes, they have a version of really with Reggea in it but that's it. They don't have any song with rock in it? You don't even seem to know what a certain Genre of music sounds like. I think it's perfectly finde to criticize a Groups Discography, because it comes down to personal taste. For me, it's just not diverse enough because, as I mentioned, I like genre blending Discographys like Taeyeons that have pop, Pop-Ballads, Jazz, EDM, even elements of hip hop, RnB and so much more. Blackpink mainly does EDM, with the focus on hip hop/dance, which is fine. But it gets boring after one listen of their Discography. And I'm happy you listen to Taeyeon. Quality music.
Blackpink are great, they have swag, style and great potential. But YG is the problem, not giving them any songs or letting them show their potential, no high notes for Rosé or original voice, no dance break for Lisa, no good rap part for Jennie and no good visual roles for Jisoo. Edit: For Jisoo, imma say smth else bcuz she gets decent visual roles. They should give some of Jennie's vocal parts to Jisoo and give a rap to Jennie or smth in those parts, e.g PWF and AIIYL bcuz she was full vocals on that.
You did Jisoo so dirty. She deserves much more that just visual exposure 🙄 don't limit her solely to her role as the 'visual'. She is also the lead vocal. Does she get lines accordingly? Jennie gets more vocal lines than her smh
@@user-hw7dz7mg5n exactly! And she's so damn good at rapping. Why tf would they make her sing and cut out even more vocal line parts that Chae and Jisoo should get anyways?
Anyone watching this AGAIN, after realizing that after now recieveing "How you like that"? Because... that song has the exact same formula as all these other songs. What's sad, is blackpink has so much talent, but YG doesnt want to spend the time on them because again, they dont have to. Their songs no longer interest me when they get a comeback. Reason being the same, no true chorus, and exact formula.
i love how you like that and the rest of their songs but i agree it has the same formula and i just wish the pinks could write their own songs because they have amazing voices but they cant because of yg
Prakriti Priyam well but sour candy is gaga song, so she is supposed to be here. But yeah sour candy was good, i didn’t like it but i can’t deny it’s good. HYLT is a mess
@@jimilismoldchannel5427 yes you are right it's a gaga song but there voices didn't mesh well together. It had atleast some substance but in comparison to it HYLT used most of the formula that teddy uses. I hope we get something good in the upcoming album. And if yg again played his cards, I will literally give up and boycott him. No streaming, no time and money investment to fill his pockets.
Prakriti Priyam yup same! if the album is trash, gonna unstan blackpink. I’m tired of putting my time and money in this group, even tho i love the girls. But i just can’t anymore. I think gaga has just made a collaboration with blackpink because she knows the problem with blinks. you just have to watch the views. They streamed it. Because they don’t have content.
Just because they have a huge social media following doesn't mean you have to shame them for it. Look at Ari and Selena they're artists with huge followers and sns is one of the many platforms they can use to update fans. If Bts had individual accounts you wouldn't say shit like this. Ya'll just hate women and BLACKPINK lol get a life
@@chaiantoinnette1667 lol then why do we love other girl groups??? Ari and selena have huge followers but that doesn't mean they don't continue to make music and spend the whole day on sns. And don't bring bts here. They have nothing to do with it cz they just don't sit around waste time. They use that platform to do something good unlike bp.
BP has an obsessive fandom. And YG knows that and purposely gives them less content so those fans replay the videos. They're not popular as in everyone loves them. Theyre popular as in everyone knows them. You'll find more people who aren't interested than actual fans.
I listened to them once since they're so hyped up and was surprised. I thought they were gonna be really good and unique to be so popular so it was disappointing. Guess I'll stick to DC and Loona and RV.
GoopyPegasus ;-; Jennie, Jisoo, Lisa, Rosé and five other girls were supposed to debut as a girl group called PinkPunk in 2014, but YG postponed it to 2016, but the five other girls left, and Lisa was gonna to be lead vocal and Jisoo was gonna to be lead rapper.
Honestly their fans are really bad a judging what’s good music and what’s bad but because yg starves the fandom to death. That fandom doesn’t care for shit what they release as long as they get to see the girls.
Most people don't notice the specifics. What generally happens is basically what happened with me. Discover a BP song, think it's cool and fun, listen to it for a while and then it falls off the radar. Rinse and repeat for each song. For me, BP's music is very much 'pop' music, or 'bubble gum' music. There's very little longevity to it. The initial excitement fades pretty quickly, comparatively speaking. Don't get me wrong. I think the members are all very talented. I still listen to most of their songs on occasion, but they don't have a permanent, or even semi-permanent spot on my playlist. Unlike other groups (I won't mention any names) who put out more complex and interesting songs, change up their style regularly (but still maintain their core 'feel') and, in general, keep my attention a lot longer.
Keith Craig please don’t take this wrong, but I feel this way about bts music. I think they’re a talented group but their music doesn’t do it for me. I think the popularity has gotten fans to settle for mediocre songs that are meh at best. There are other better GG and BG of Kpop that have better music but unfortunately they are overshadowed by BP and BTS.
Intelligently written, narrated with a lot of heart and...no swearing. This was a really satisfying video and actually made me feel like I should be paying for such high quality content. Thank you. Subscribed ✅
yikes, hylt used the same song sturcture. again. most of the fans don't even care though! most of them are just like: "well its blackpink, just appreciate the music!". we shouldn't praise no effort on yg's end, we should call them out on it. dear blinks: stop silencing the people who speak out about low quality music, thanks edit: notice how i said *yg* , not blackpink? did yall notice? it was probably for a reason that was explained in the video!
Lol, the part i love in hylt is just the pretty singing part in the beginning and the chorus "How you like that-dadadada" but that's it. I'm getting tired with Teddy's formula.
@@jasminewadsworth1983 they're dumb, pre-release supposed to make fans hyped up with their REAL release. I said it again, "If the pre-release one doesn't even makes impact for me, then what should i expect for the REAL one"
and I'm so conflicted because, I'm sure the girls are elated that they've been breaking records and charting with this music. Plus they are FINALLY performing again. but We're literally witnessing YG get away with this bullshit and I doubt they'll change if the results get better and better
as someone who was introduced to kpop through blackpink, the sole reason why i didn't explore other groups sooner was because my first impression of kpop was that the music was generic and repetitive, made to currently please and be forgotten in a few years. i did enjoy their songs, however it felt something was missing. the fact that blackpink is assumed to be one of the main 'representatives' of kpop by the general public and is probably the first thing that comes to their minds when kpop is mentioned makes me a little sad. so many people are driven away from kpop like i was because their first impression of it doesn't always make a positive impact on them.
So true, most of the people I know, don't Like kpop because of blackpink. They think kpop is repetitive and the same, it has nothing new and cringe lyrics.
As a music producer I agree with most of what was said because it IS TRUE. I unstanned bp (music wise) because of the reasons tackled in the video. Honestly I feel like Teddy is an "ok" producer based on how creative the industry is now and I feel like YG is afraid of getting another producer because he thinks he wont sell that well which is ridiculous because he HAD producers like B.I that made fresh music and he just threw him out. Tbh at this point I hope YG sinks but it's frustrating because i dont want the groups currently in YG to suffer from the companies inability to keep up with new monster rookie producers
Can we also talk about their theme for a minute. The concept of their songs and the meaning behind it have never changed, and knowing YG, it probably never will. They keep on talking about the same shit: love. Love songs, break up songs, post break-up songs, most of the times their title tracks are either about “turning badass after breaking up or getting heart broken” or something like that. Like, it’s getting tiring. Can’t YG write some songs about things other than that? Because it’s really boring and generic. There’s not really any story behind their lyrics, you can’t think about a story with the lyrics. How you like that made zero sense to me, it’s as if they cut out words from a diary, mixed things up, drew lots and sticked the words together to make a sentence. There isn’t much Blackpink mv/theories out there because there isn’t any theory to make. They don’t go in deep. Just some Easter eggs here and there but other than that, there’s nothing to look into. Another thing: the fans Blinks keep on whining about YG being a shitass company, and yes, they’re right. But they aren’t doing anything because at the end of the day, BP releases something, it blows up, Blinks break records, YG gets money. At the end of the day, YG wins. Blinks don’t stop blaming them and asking for more content, they rip each other’s throat and anyone who dares say something bad about Blackpink, while YG is watching the show. They’re smart, really, because of their strategy, they’re making money. Starve someone and they DEVOUR whatever you give them, no matter the quality. I might have sparred YG’s throat if BP’s long awaited comebacks weren’t so disappointing, yet here we are...
YG will never change the content of Blackpink's songs because Blackpink are MEGA popular in Mainland China, their comeback this year was talked about more than any other K-Pop comeback by Chinese teens, and very few topics other than love make it passed the censors there. If they branched out into more mature topics then they'd have a large portion of their market blocked off to them.
@@MrKikip1992 really?? not even BTS?? are blackpink really more popular than BTS in China? if it's true, then I'm really worried for the youth's future Also, BTS try and talk about a LOT of mature stuff, societal issues, criticise society, so does that mean BTS dont pass the censor board there???
"Bitch, I'm a star, but not Patrick" Girl, Patrick Star is one of the most memorable icon of this generation. PS. This is a joke, if any of you will get offended
I died at the comparison of all the repetition structures in all their songs. 😂😂😂 Case in point: 1. Compare Dreamcatcher's Chase Me (debut song which is hard core rock) and Deja Vu (latest song which is soft ballad + rock vibe) 2. Compare Everglow's Bon Bon chocolate (debut song) to Adios (latest song). 3. Compare Gidle's Latata (debut song) and Lion (latest song) . And all these groups are YOUNGER than blackpink. And different members start the songs, different members also sing different parts every damn time. You get a change every comeback and its always refreshing and exciting to look forward to. But the same can't be said for blackpink after almost 4 years of being active
How about Dreamcatcher's SCREAM and the other hits on their new album. All diff a bit yet most came from the same composers? :) As far as BP, liked all their songs, but agree, the group and the stans deserve way better than a gambling corrupt ceo who treat, and use them as cash cows. And really hope "that's all" he did.. www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/disgraced-k-pop-executive-star-hit-travel-bans-1233508
A fantastic analysis of BP's discography. It never really occurred to me that all of BP's title tracks ever released, they are singing about literally nothing in their choruses ahaha, and I've gotten so used to it that I've never questioned it. Thanks Mera for shining a light on this. I've always wondered why I couldn't subscribe to BP's music even though I really like the members and they are obviously very talented, but these single phrase chorus songs are really killing their music career. People will eventually get bored of these songs, I know I have. Thank goodness for Red Velvet's discography!!! Even though they also have these type of songs, it is few and far between relative to their extensive discography. Most recent example that comes to mind is Zimzalabim (2019), and from what I can recall (title track wise) they only put out one of these songs every TWO years. SM definitely has a better understanding of how to sprinkle these songs over an artist's career.
before I'd listen to BTS, I though all kpop songs were like black pink's, had the same structure. when I started listening bts I was like "oh, wow, they are different"
@@LM-ix7pk one of the reasons I love sm discographies is that all of their artists have such a diverse profile of songs. even before nct started with all their starkly different concepts, we'd get new content from shinee, exo, red velvet, etc each comeback
Pink venom was released today, and I saw formula. Jennie starts, Rosie & Jisoo shared a pre chorus, Lisa/Jennie rapped on second verse and the chorus has somewhat/ish formula use. Don’t get me wrong it’s rly good for a pre release and the girls looked killer asf (especially Jisoo) I’m just anxious and a little nervous for what the album brings in store.
Well ... I think for Bron Pink .... this video has still points. Mhh I know can understand why they have so many lazy alligations.... I mean if I had to perform 10 songs that only have different lyrics I would also get them mixed up.
Came here after HYLT release and I’m very disappointed with blackpinks music it hasn’t improved at all. I’m tired of waiting for the same content every year and I’m even more tired of seeing blinks hype them up for mediocre songs I’m just gonna wait till their album releases
Yh like when it came out it was so hyped that I couldn't see past that and see the flaws, it sounded the same, nothing new really. Not that it was bad but we're tired of them leaving for so long and coming back with nothing new, same old same old.
@@rosestea5896 Lovesick girls was pretty different, a full chorus, lisa coming in at 1st and 2nd verse. plus when looking into the bsides many songs didnt follow this formula. looking at songs like bet you wanna, you never know, love to hate me and ice cream. Now we are getting Rose solo and no doubt its not gonna follow the regular formula as it will be about rose not bp.
It also kills an industry. If 1 is so above others with less and unworthy songs. K POP will die if a More Hard Working and Great Music production is underrated and I meant there are a lot out there. Thanks to BTS and Twice getting the right treatment (sometimes) and attention they deserved because they do represent those and I'm sad for Mamamoo, GFriends and Red Velvet that supposed to be given the attention, the hype and fame that Blinkpink has. Producers will get tired and does K Pop as a whole will collapse, putting the wrong representative can hurt not just 1 but all.
@Kaaviya Sri yes!! Their discography is amazing!! I don't stan any other group than bts but I love twice,red velvet,mamamoo cz they're amazing and deserve better!!
Here after pink venom and holy shit it sounds exactly like every other song they have…AND THE BLINKS ARE ACTING LIKE ITS THE SECOND COMING OF CHRIST WHEN ITS NOT. I really hoped for something different…
Mamamoo is coming for Blackpink’s top 3 spot if they don’t step it up. Also it’s so funny how this video could be remade now and KtL would still fit the mold exactly. Side note: Solo sounds like a Sunmi song that wasn’t deemed good enough for the album. EDIT: Idk what happened to this thread but I’m tired of getting the notifications from it. 😂
So HYLT just dropped and lo and behold... same formula. Granted it's a pre-release, but after a year I hoped for some sort of evolution. Edit: and what irks me is that I bet a bunch of these k-pop reaction channels will all be like "omg FIRE" but no it was not fire, it was disappointing.
Hylt was actually the first ever kpop song I’ve ever listened to and it’s basically the reason why I’m into it now. I really thought it was a BOP and I still do tbh. But the remixes I heard are better than the actual song ngl
You literally deserve so much more subscribers! You’re so smart and mature about everything. You make great points and incredible videos! I love watching every single one of them!!
Back after HYLT and it’s amazing to see how your points about song structure are still extremely relevant a whole year later. They literally haven’t developed at all. Disappointed once again🤩
@@ranjana585 it wasn't different. Jennie starts,rosie and jisoo sing the pre-chorus, then an English phrase as the main chorus and strong electronic instruments noises,Lisa raps the 2nd verse,at the end a dance break,sudden ending of the song. They do have a proper chorus this time but do use the structure again and it got boring to me after my 3rd listen. And 1 song being a little different with having a chorus doesn't mean their whole discography is improving. The rest of the songs on the album don't have a proper chorus, the same empty one and the only song with a proper chorus is the ballad you never know.
@@oyshirahman897 it was different there wasn't a beat drop. There was a full chorus. Most of their songs are bad*ss But this one was a soft one. Most of their songs are shot in sets. This was shot outside there wasn't any set. Most of their songs rose just sings the line before chorus in this she didn't she had many lines and most of the songs jennie don't rap in this she did. What are you saying there were no strong electronic noises. There was no dance break at the end.
"Blackpink is the REVOLUTION" XDdd That's the funniest part. Revolution is something new, something that has not yet been, but I apologize for repeating the same thing is not something new, something like this cannot be called a revolution
And I know you said you would talk about the members but I NEED to make a point. Blackpink themselves are bored. Not invested in their own music. They probably don’t even train anymore ! When they debuted, it was okay for Rose to be sometimes shaky while dancing and messing up her parts sometimes. It was okay for Jennie to not really know how to hype up a crowd and just shout in her microphone. It was okay for Lisa tonne mostly a dancer and not nailing her vocal/rap performances every time. Now after almost 4 years ? It’s not okay. With the time they have on their hands, they should have DRASTICALLY improved. But I feel like they’re regressing. Why ? Because I think they don’t even care anymore. The only one who improved is Jisoo and she auditioned to be an actress damn it !
That's actually not true neither accurate, I can understand in the problem in YG and their music but every educated blink knows that what you said it's simply not true
Damn its rare to heard a person being so kind and open-minded about blackpinks discographie fan. We need more of thoses people. But yeah their discographie is not big
I'm a blink, I love the girls, but you're right. The thing is, blinks SHOULD also do their part and not just blindly praise and compliment their music when it clearly, in general, is mediocre, generic and leans more on the Western pop side, compared to their contemporaries. Enjoying generic music isn't bad. Enjoying a Western pop sound isn't bad too. Like, I enjoy D4, I enjoy How You Like That, I enjoy DKWTD, etc. I enjoy many Western pop songs. BUT, that's the thing. Their songs are just that: generic, mediocre and really Western pop-sounding. We may enjoy it, there's nothing wrong w/ that, BUT, that doesn't excuse them of being just that, mediocre and generic.
At this point it's not even YG's fault, we as consumers are just being dumb and that's it. I better wait for my bts and seventeen japanese releases and enjoy monster stages then spending my time and effort on yg because now I have just given up.
Yeah!! Fans are hyping mediocore songs like they're the best and when people call them out they say people are toxic. And yeah!! Stan BTS kings and seventeen kings!! They're so talented!! I've never seen any artists more versatile than bts!! Of course there's other versatile artists but to me bts is the most versatile! !!
True. This is gonna sound really horrible, but I always have my ult group (BTS) and a secondary group which is typically a girl group. It was Blackpink for a while, but I think I kinda took a step back and asked myself why I was continuing to stan when I was honestly bored. I lost interest, but ig I was just so used to calling myself an ARMYBlink so it was hard to let go of that. Since then, I lowkey wanted to explore/look into different groups, where I decided to focus on Red Velvet and eventually Mamamoo (my second favorite group right now). Now that I’ve been focusing on BTS, Mamamoo, and a few boy groups here and there, I’ve started to realize how versatile their concepts and music are compared to Blackpink whom I’ve been stanning for so long. Ngl, The Album was an upgrade from their previous EPs and I applaud them for that, but it just wasn’t for me. I wish the girls the best, though, and I think I’m still going to support them, just not as much as before.
@@namename9372 I mean, I do stan for music, but I also stan for their personalities, their affection towards their fans, their chemistry, and a lot more. I wouldn’t say that I just stan for the music, but music is also a part of why I stan certain groups.
omg yes I have always thought that about the arrangement of the songs. Jennie starts, then lisa goes then rose and jisoo then chorus then jennie again then rose and jisoo switch singing parts then the beat drop while they're all singing together and then that's it.
Im not a blink But I enjoy their songs and I noticed usually: Jennie starts the song Then Jisoo or Rose Sing The Chorus Then Lisa Then Jisoo or Rose again Then chorus again Then dance break Then end
"YG, when you lock your consumers in the dungeon and don't give them any food, they start to eat each other." 💀💀💀
That quote alone haunts me
Mixer!!
the platform
Cannibalisim at it's finest
This line basically explains what's going on with blackpink and there comebacks
Someone finally said it Jisoo and Rosé always gets a short bridge that they share before the chorus it's not ok
@@TheMPTV what do you mean?
@@rosemarysilvergate2569 He shaded Jisoo.
@@yayayuki8542 well his English is not on point just saying haha. But thanks for the translation haha
you mean prechorus ?
@@yayayuki8542 no he didn't
“The girls are irrelevant to this situation”
*ive never thought I’d hear someone call them irrelevant and be excited at the same time*
Jennie herself told once '' I would sing 10 more songs if I had any'' like seriously.... she speaks the truth...
That is why the poor women receives so much hate
@@malu_boomshivaborae8087 ikr
Lmao Queen of shade. YG listen or else im throwing hands
@@malu_boomshivaborae8087 that’s not exactly why-
Ok hear me out 2ne1 was also under yg..this proves that it’s not about the company it’s about the artist…everyone uses the word mismanagement too much….they are not getting mistreated or mismanaged…otherwise they would have never been the biggest gg for no reason
Can someone help YG realize that Jisoo and rosè are two different people so stop giving them the same lines. They need their own time to shine because they are also talented like Lisa and Jennie
Yh exactly they just shove jisoo and rose there just for being there's sake. They're only paying attention to the one's making them the most money and getting the most attention Jennie and Lisa. If they actually focused on Jisoo and Rose as individuals, it would show so well.
And someone needs to tell Y.G that Jisoo and Rosé could be extremely better vocalists if they had the right technique, especially for their higher notes, since we know they already rock the lower ones.
So things have changed a bit huh lmao
girl there duo is different from every one ya they have the same lines in all songs but they are the vocalist they have to do so and why are you acting like as if other group members dont sing the same lines
Yeah
I still can't believe that YG threw Jennies book away, where she wrote her OWN damn songs.
Wait what when
@@emmamcandrew3564 th-cam.com/video/9g7pdmRw_Tk/w-d-xo.html
wait i thought they just kept it away from her not throw it away :(
That man is such a freak!!!
They dont want them to go off and break up the group
Even now, they still only have 14 songs. 14 songs for a group that’s been in the industry for almost 4 years...
ikr? they have good songs but still not enough compared to the new groups that has more songs than them
I don't know many Kpop groups...But Ateez which debuted in 2018, has over 20 songs! Some even in Japanese! Latest album took me some 40-50 plus mins to listen to all their songs! And they are rookies! So BP with 11 songs is a joke!
I kind of forgot black pink was still in the kpop industry- Like idk how their fans are hyping them up as if black pink is still trending when they’re actually only famous for YG’s scandals. It’s just sad.
i thought they had 13 songs but I know it doesnt make a difference as it is still lower than a lot of other groyps
@@kellysmy it's because they are
Imagine training so hard at a very popular company that debuts you, gives you stylists that put you on the newest trendiest styles in the industry, gets you deals with the top designers, has the best marketing for your group, gives you collabs with the biggest artists in the industry, BUT- at the end of the day all you can really "do" is not gain weight, not date anyone, not even release your own songs that you've written and just be pretty the way that these people want you to be, all because you're under contract. at the end of the day you're not even an artist, just a performer- a puppet even
I have to ask this
aren't we all the puppets? And the others are our masters?
@@notwerkinginthishouse8634 if others idols have freedom, why can't the girls? why do they have to be someone else just so theyre more "relatable" or "marketable". we'd still support them :(
Ikr. I sometimes wonder if the girls are disappointed in all this. I really hope things change from now on. Coz apparently Jennie and Jisoo had written some lyrics for the lovesick girls song. We are also apparently getting Rosé's solo around the start of this year so. Also Lisa's solo in this year. Maybe things will change for the girls.
@@ananyabhat3366 hopefully! If they do get solos i hope they make the music they want and not just what YG wants to market them as
@@paimonspie8913 yeah. I can't help but keep my hopes high for their solo's tho 😂😂
The problem with BlackPink is YG entirely. At this point they’re more models than idol singers, literally doing everything else but put out music. Now I stan BlackPink I love those girls but it’s really hard for me to continue to be invested in a group who as of now have 7 title tracks and 6 b-sides compared to other big 3 groups who have almost double that in title tracks and a lot more bsides. They’re literally the only female act under YG right now actively promoting and they haven’t had a full album yet, it’s a shame.
Edit: so they’ve come back with How You Like That and idk about everyone else but it’s literally the same thing that we’ve already seen from them. Maybe cause it’s a pre-release and we’re getting something better with the full Korean album but so far I’m not impressed
I think that they could do a little more as well (I say this from a place of liking BP but no longer stanning due to boredom because of the reasons in this video) they have their own IGs they could do a few more covers or show something other than pretty pictures etc. Lisa has her yt now which is a bit better but I'm sure winner get comebacks by pushing for them or writing them
Vivi x yeah I feel like once they get into the creative process of writing their music, then maybe it’ll be better but more than that, start to get other producers with a variety of sound cause Teddy is starting to get stagnant
They’re not giving them a comeback so they have to be in a ton of commercials
Lisa! It’s a lot easier to do that than make music I guess
Andre Drew I think they aren’t allowed to write their own music. I remember in a video where it states that Jennie had a whole notebook of songs she wrote, but when she put it on some table it was gone. The same thing happens when Jennie put a pencil there it was gone.
it makes me LAUGH MY AS$ OFF thinking about teddy in the studio making the same songs for black pink once a year and getting his wallet full of coin
Deadass teddy really out here living a life,,,, I should be a producer in yg 😩😩🤚
은이지 Everybody knows he made gashina because it sounds almost the same as „solo“ 🤣And tbh if he doesn‘t have enough time to write more songs there is a really simple solution: Hire someone else to do it. It‘s not like blackpinks songs are artistic masterpieces- they could probably find someone else to write a one line chorus.
@@은이지-m6c Bruh, Gashina has the same exact boring formula. Yall are just too blind on the primary phase and the electronic notes. He's lacking the artistry cuz people perceived him to be so artistic, that he isn't experimenting with music anymore.
i hate when people do something they are not competent at and yet getting a bunch of money for that. i mean dear teddy, if you can't produce songs the way you are supposed to produce them, nothing wrong but then just simply don't do it. there are people who can and will do it. it's really unfair. no wonder why blackpink always look bored when performing, teddy is literally recycling boombayah for 3 years.
I feel like yg themselves don’t want any other formula. I’m pretty sure they’re making him use the same formula?
You forgot their comeback song
*AWESOME SCREEN AWESOME CAMERA LONG LASTING BATTERY LIFE*
ouch true tho
😂😂😂
Bruh how could you have forgotten such an iconic comeback
So awkward 😂🙄😂
I did not lmaoooo i swear 🤣
This aged incredibly well. Nothing has changed.
9 months later, it still holds up
@@appletart7262 Yeah. I assume you didn't care for Pink Venom, then? I like the instrumental but it just sounds like another basic Blackpink song to me. I wasn't even impressed or interested in the vocals
And today it's more actual than ever.
@@annaianniello1997 It's a real shame. YG is seriously wasting their talent
@@boop99 and some of the fandom are realizing that but still they keep streaming and buying to achieve some record, it's unbelievable.
NCT has more members than BLACKPINK has songs. Let that sink in
Both groups debuted in the same year but it's like NCT is way older when we look at the number of songs
@@jessnalulila5552 well thats yg not sm
im curious, how many members are in NCT?
@@us3r_fj0rd98 21 members!
@@heartsungs5120 ahh ok thank youu
blackpink debuted at a time when Bg stans were tearing apart twice n groups similar for having a cute concept and mourning disbandment of groups like 4minute and 2ne1 and they latched onto blackpink like a starving vampire to a bloody neck.
LMFAO! If that ain't the truth then I don't know what is
honestly. the girls deserve genuine supporters.
Geetha Ranjani they have those
@@calliespltn
Don't confuse the very vocal minority with the majority. People notice the malcontents because they are the screechiest part of the fandom. Meanwhile, the bulk of the fans are genuine, supportive of the girls (as a group) and are just as angry at the people attacking certain members as you are, only they do it with a lot less screeching.
Have you ever heard "The squeaky wheel gets the grease". That's the case here with certain fandoms (or any large group for that matter). It's the people screeching the loudest that get the most attention.
Have you ever been in a department store and there's a baby a few aisles over (or even at the other end of the store) crying his lungs out? You obviously notice the baby because, being so loud, he draws your attention. Meanwhile you hardly notice the dozens of other shoppers because they are quietly going about their business. It's the same way with fandoms. We have the screaming babies, which get most of the attention, versus the bulk of the fandom which is just quietly enjoying the music and supporting their groups.
So, to answer your obviously baiting question, no, Geetha Ranjani was not referring to "the same “fans” that only care about certain members". She was referring to the fans who are genuinely supportive of the group, as a whole, not the fanwarriors who "only care about certain members'.
Keith Craig ok
I’m glad someone is talking about how the “ formula “ of the songs are basically al the same
the fact that this entire vid still applies until today is just-- 💀
I was just gonna comment this
It's honestly very sad
naw cus they're flopping 😭
Yup
@@cupokopi2034 u clearly don't know what flopping mean
Kill this love music structure:
- Jennie opens the song
- Lisa second verse
- Rosé and Jisoo sing the pre-chorus
- Chorus primary phrase: let's kill this love
- Onomatopeia: rupumpum
- Trompets, electro notes
- bridge Rosé
I want something new for this comeback like for real (if ther is any).
Don’t forget about Lisa and Jennie duo rap
Jamir Alday I totally forgot about that!
Things we want
- No Jennie starting
- Jennie rapping
- Vocals that suits jisoo
- Jisoo saying "BP IN UR AREA" she never said it
- Full written chorus (for real STOP. no a word/phrase and drop)
- lisa dance break
- no bridge rosé
- the ending being nice
- some cool chaesoo interaction (vocal)
- and so much more oof
@@San-cb9mj I Agree with all of that, I would add vocals that suit Rosè's voice too and Lisa singing.
@@froggyf1les But Lisa is just sub vocalist. She doesn't need to sing that much but she need to rap more than everything
You know what really annoys me, Blackpink are more models then idols
Truth
Facts
Huu
I agree.
As was touched on in the video, that makes sense in a way. Having them model and do commercials means very little money spent by YG. Creating songs and, MV's is expensive. It's all money that has to be invested before there's a payoff. Modeling and commercials require very little investment from the agency. It's almost all gravy, as far as YG is concerned. Having them focus on modeling and commercials may suck for the music fans, but it makes a LOT of sense from a business standpoint.
Blackpink reminds me of how I played some strategy games, when I found a single good strategy, I would try to keep using it until the npc's or the game noticed something was wrong kahslwjsdohaosnmc
LMAO
Relateable 😂
yeah but the game already become boring at that point
same
@@adroitws1367 And the npc's are noticing It.
I dont hate blackpink but blinks are unbearable for acting like they're being hatecrimed every time someone points out blackpink has like 2 songs and they all sound the same. now they're saying liking BP is an unpopular opinion when they're literally the most popular girl group.
we only say this as joke because of how much hate bp were getting .
there's a difference between blinks and blonks.
@@ushamula5757 Stop using the term 'blonks' as a scapegoat, blonks are also a part of the blink fandom.
@@andinho2204 yes but we would prefer if you guys used the term blinks because saying blinks as a whole makes it seem like almost the whole fandom is bad.
@@ushamula5757 But saying "he isn't a blink, he is a blonk" everytime someone criticises the blinks fandom isn't right either.
It hurts my heart to know that all the girls wanted was to become idols and they worked hard for it just to come into some trash entertainment company and be managed by a misogynistic asshole that keeps them under his fingers, turning them into something they didn't want to be and turning their own fandom against them, and if not that then they become "toxic" to other fandoms that say our girls are underrated and don't deserve their fame. The girls of Blackpink don't deserve this hate or treatment and for all these people saying these horrible things doesn't make it any better
Do you mean to say overrated? If people were saying they were underrated and don’t deserve fame that’s contradictory
Facts sis just facts
Bp supposed to be most powerful gg at the moment. They are YG's money tree so, who has the power, why don't the girls re-negotiate their contracts?
well its true. they dont deserve it. anyone who likes this crap is contributing to the problem.
@@bingybingy2592 they can't really just leave. Sometimes contracts last years and can have consequences if they tried to leave
Blackpink song’s really don’t make Teddy seem like the genius he is made out to be... if he’s such a genius he should be able to produce versatile music no?
And also yg found out jennie had written 17 songs and threw the book and rosé, Lisa and jisoo also write songs but don't let them and throws them
To be fair, he's being told to stick to a formula that works and it clearly does, why would he change anything?
@@sarahmonametsi564 that's honestly so sad. i genuinely feel so bad for the girls. imagine training for 4 years, only for you to be a puppet. :(
Vimala M it's 😔
I noticed that in Jisoo and Rośe being forced to share a melody that Rośe is always singing before Jisoo
My thoughts:
YG is really smart , he manipulates Blackpinks popularity. He knows that the song is going to get popular whether the music is good or not.
The formula is getting boring , How you like that also has the same formula. YG GIVE US GOOD MUSIC.
He also manipulates the fans very well, trying to convince them that bp's lack of songs are because he prefers "quality over quantity" when it's obviously not true.
He somehow manipulated the whole world into thinking that bp is huge. They’re not. They have never won a daesang because their music isn’t good. That’s just the tea
@@namename9372 Not really. A lot of people agreed with Signal being bad but Signal won SOTY. You know that BLACKPINK barely join to the award shows. They don't have much songs. If their songs were bad, "The Album" wouldn't sell more than 1.260.000 units. Same for HYLT, they sold 302.000 just for a freaking single album. No daesang =/= bad songs
Daesang =/= good songs
@@mchiii9169 lmao
@@namename9372 isn’t that because of- well, award shows being rigged?
the empty choruses is something that's always annoyed me about blackpink songs despite them being my ult girl group. i think there's a reason why aiiyl is very popular amongst korean listeners and that's because of the very full chorus compared to the rest of their songs. i'm really hoping that when they do comeback soon they have a different formula and the chorus is rich with actual words instead of a single phrase and instrumental in the back
I agree, with you that's why I hate whistle with a passion it's just a whole bunch of sounds for the chorus. "We param" "hwieoo"
As if it's your last is my favourite blackpink songs.Not a big fan lisa rap in AIIYL but it's okey.😊🖤💗
@@Aitiqaxxx I like as if it's your last too even though I hate cute songs.
I personally think As If It's Your Last is one of their best title track along with Stay.
The Blackpink title tracks that I can only stand are Stay, AIIYL, and PWF. The rest are just so-so. But they are catchy so I understand why many like it.
@@luluangelina2923 its such a good song because the rapping from jenlisa is probably one of their best, the vocals from all of them are insane and the bridge with rosie's vocals are literally everything, on top of that the music video is beautiful but the chorus... my god the chorus as catchy as it is, is so bloody annoying because its so... empty yknow?
1. Primary (English) Phrase
2. Onomatopoeia or Secondary Phrase
3. Cycling Pattern of Electronic Notes
How you like that:
1. How you like that?
2. You gon like that that that/Look at you now look at me
3. [electronic sounds]
It's the same:(((
That electronic sound bothering while first half song is fun thought
I think the onomatopoeia is barabimbarabumbumbum
At least it’s a two part chorus this time... giving us the just above the bare minimum so people can claim it’s “getting better”
its basically the same formula once every year...
A couple additions:
1.) Rose's voice in Blackpink isn't her real voice. YG made her change it for the group.
2.) The choreography often repeats itself too with the same formula, just like the songs do.
3.) Most of Blackpink's songs are not even theirs - they were originally written for 2NE1 and put into the vault.
Yeah, Rose has to do the goddamn cursive singing thing, and her natural voice is so fucking nice? I dunno.
In the 3rd one your wrong not most of the songs were written for 2ne1 which they gave to blackpink.... only as if its your last was 2ne1’s song and they gave it to bp because 2ne1 disbanded before they could give it to them .. so they gave it to bp
@@itsariayt3163 Bombayah was definitely for 2NE1 before
I Know What They Don't Know I need proof... just because it is a badass song doesn’t mean its 2ne1’s song ok?? As I’ve heard only as if its your last was gonna be a 2ne1 song ... but you have no rights to tell its a 2ne1 because the song was the company’s... 2ne1 didn’t write the lyrics or produce it sooo....
@@itsariayt3163 The idea is not farfetched at all. Teddy is the producer for both groups and 2ne1 had A LOT of unreleased material, like the album they had ready when YG announced their disbandment by surprise. This is obviously not BP's fault at all and I don't get why Blinks get so sensitive about it.
i literally watch this video after every comeback and it’s always still true 😭
I literally comeback today just to comment how this video was so right, they really be doing the same song over and over again 😭
Ikr! Pink venom is the same boring thing
You have to use your brains and realize that YG is using its groups just to launder its dirty money from drug trafficking, pimping and various other illegal trafficking. This is why YG does not seek to recruit teams of competent and diversified producers for its groups; I guess they must keep to themselves "experienced traffickers". All those who are at Yg are perfectly aware of everything that is happening but as it is their source of income they prefer to keep quiet and act as if nothing had happened.
*Is no one gonna talk about: "Yg, when you lock your consumers in the dungeon and not give them food, they start to eat eachother." Like if that isn't true idk what is*
Facts
2018:
twice had 12 comebacks. in these 12 comebacks, they had a total of 29 songs. added up, you could spend 89 minutes and 10 seconds binging those songs.
red velvet had 4 comebacks. in these 4 comebacks, they had a total of 25 songs.
added up, you could spend 84 minutes and 3 seconds binging those songs.
mamamoo? 3 comebacks. 21 songs.
61 minutes, 33 seconds.
gfriend? 2 comebacks. 13 songs, 43 minutes, 31 seconds.
clc? 1 comeback. 5 songs. 16 minutes, 38 seconds.
blackpink had 1 comeback, 4 songs, 14 minutes, 3 seconds.
ᗝᗝF
@keep living That's kinda the reason I don't stan them. But I do like them.
that’s not including b sides, which still won’t help bp either :(
I hate this situation man
Rokhel Palmer i’m not talking about how many of all time, i’m talking about 2018.
Brilliant analysis. Seriously.
However, the explanation why Blackpink doesn't have any more music as of right now is Teddy. It is known that he and he alone decides and I think (co-)writes the stuff for blackpink. I remember an interview in which he said, he's not going to approve anything for Blackpink unless he feels it's a 100% fit for them. Now taking the formular into consideration, I don't get it anymore. There are tons of amazing music producers out there coming up with fresh and unique sounds and structures every day. Aquiring them shouldn't be as hard, especially for YG.
whats worse is DJ Snake admitted they were in talks of collaborating and even started the song but it got thrown away. Steve Aoki has requested collabs and YG ignored him AND ariana grandes producer even flew to SK last summer and yet we've not heard a peep out of whatever they worked on (probably cause teddy had no input and god forbid that happens)
@@ellielouise9625 That sucks. Ariana Grande and Diplo would have blown them up in the Western market. Can YG not see the opportunity there? Now there are rumors Ari's about to collab with BTS. YG threw away a great collab opportunity and possibly handed it to their biggest competitor in the Western market. Wth
@@goldyd144 i'd love ari x bts and ari x bp but YG are literal fools. their Dua Lipa collab got them so many casual listeners who could have turned into fans. I had locals who were streaming it not knowing who BP were!! And dua said she'd love to work again but guarantee if she offered them a song for her new album YG rejected it!!
The fact there's been 2 artists alone in 2019 who admitted YG rejected them/called it off and then Tommy Brown literally flying to Seoul to meet with them and NOTHING has happened since then its such a joke. It's a lie that they've been working since the international tour ended cause all of the girls have been jetting off across the world. We all know its gonna be recycled songs that were recorded/written in 2016 for the third cb in a row, even Lisa said they do nothing once concerts are over so YG saying that is such a joke. First the cb was meant to be November 2019, then January 2020 and then it was in the first quarter and now March-April...wedged in between Big Bangs big return to the industry and IKONs comeback.......the jokes write themselves.
It's almost like YG is purposefully setting them up to fail. I can't imagine why. BP is a big source of revenue for the company and could be even bigger if they could actually DO something.
Keith Craig it’s the same reasons as RV being one of SMs best and most I demand world wide. They hate the fact that their ggs are doingbetter than their bgs. RV are more in demand in the U.K. than superm or NCT but they won’t promote or send them here. They won’t book RV on US tv shows but send other groups on them.
BLACKPINK until their disbandment will just get 1 cb a year and shipped off onto world tours, esp now BB is back
Alternate title: *blackpink deserves better.*
lol
True
Hahahha omh
@@sosupportingblackpinkmeans1964 I know, I didn’t say the title should be changed. I’m just saying that’s what the video is basically about.
@@sosupportingblackpinkmeans1964 Oh okay! I didn’t realize you weren’t talking to me for a minute lol. :D
A fragile foundation wont create a long lasting empire.
Yup
This hits so much to every group who just falls hard ground after being at the top for years. Companies really need to follow the BTS formula.
@@onthescene7897 BTS doesn't really have a formula though. Big Hit gives them complete artistic freedom so their music is usually based off of personal experience or what they've read/watched/ listened to that made an impact with them. And for their non musical content is sort of becoming a formula as TXT now has their own version. It's less of a formula thing than it is that the amount of mockery/being ignored that happened to BTS when they were rookies Big Hit eventually decided that it wasn't worth it and stopped booking them as many places and doubled their company activities. And now the same thing is happening with TXT because honestly it's a lot more comfortable for the artist to not have to sensor themselves. So it's not so much as a formula as it is a freedom, kindness, experience, the company looking out for their artist personal wellbeing, and creating innovative solutions to problems. I'm not sure if the more corporate companies could or would be willing to change how their company's run enough to be like BTS'S Company so that they could possibly get the same results.
Micah Wulfensmith PERIOD
@@micahwulfensmith1354 bighit is decent
*"YG, when you lock your consumers in a dungeon, and you dont give them any food, they start to eat eachother."* SHE WENT OFF HOLY SHIT I LOVE THIS
The fact that everything she said about the song formula came back with KTL and DKWTD 😭
Edit: call me crazy because the replies disagree, but I don't think How You Like That has the same structure 👀
Imagine if their 2020 comeback is exactly like dududu and KTL.💀💀💀💀
@@Faith-vg9ox ugh devastating 💔
@@placebo_effect it would certainly make them a very polarizing group with a one-dimensional sound. I dare say that their sound and image are already polarized. They won't be able to release other concepts like retro, dark, bright or anything else because they blinks will think "they abandoned their badass concept". Case in point is how their song Stay remains the most underrated in their discography
@@Faith-vg9ox Yes, so true. It's already happened with Twice, which is kind of a "scientifically proven" kind of thing. Which sucks, because they won't have their own freedom to say "we want to be different, unique and something special". They'll be pushed into that corner without any defense :(
@@placebo_effect Twice has had at least the chance to work with different producers so their sound...... While it has remained primarily bright and cute..... their songs still manage to sound different. Compare TT to Feel Special. Or Signal to Fancy. We can safely say that Twice has at least tried to switch up a bit with retro concept (What is Love) , bright (heart shaker, Like ooh ahh) , cute (most of their songs) and slightly sexy (fancy).
What blackpink needs is to work with different producers. Just do that their songs can become more dynamic and unpredictable
FINALLY one person who is actually talking about real things and not just straight up hating on the girls. The only reason I unstanned was because I got tired of the repetitive sound and I have nothing against the girls, the music just stopped sounding authentic to me
I just to like them a lot but as time passed. I just got bored. Like they been in the industry for 5 years and I barely see any clips of them.
same here..I liked them when they first debuted but it just got boring after square up, that was also the time I found out about (g)i-dle's debut so I gradually started losing interest in Blackpink's songs
Same with me❤
The only songs i genuinely like are as if it's your last and lovesick girls( they tried something new)
@@grod338 same except i like lovesick girls and whistle. AIIYL just got pretty boring as i was obsessed with it for months. i just dont want to even want to look at the as if its your last MV's thumbnail at all. i just like solo and on the ground now. waiting for lisa's solo!!
Even rookies like itzy HAS MORE SONGS THEN A 4 YEAR OLD GROUP
ITZY has 14 songs, a little less than BlackPink
@@jessnalulila5552 but I feel it's okay for itzy to have 14 songs, they just debuted last year. But for blackpink, HELL NO. 4 year girl group but having less than 20 songs is so messed up.
Did y'all forget ateez ok it's a boy grp but still they have good Discography and have 2 times more songs than blackpink in just 1 and half year
@@nehaharish9741 😐😐😐
Neha Harish I’m thinking of stanning tbh
sis putting out some truth
And the shade, which is very well deserved to the people who deserved it, not the members
This comment needs more likes
Blackpink does better she just can't see it
@@sabrinathereindeer6075
This video has nothing to do with the members of blackpink,Mera is talking about their discography,which is YG and Teddy's job.
@@selmabesic9849 Ikr did she even watch the video
i came back after listening how you like that, yeah it can be added to this list, its the same formula, not surprised but still disapointing
Rafaela De Bonadona the thing is the songs get boring after a while I mean I only listened to it for a day and still didn’t like it
This group should not renew. Otherwise they will be stuck in the box for the rest of their musical careers
Chi Mei do they even have a music career at this point
@@lovely-fc2wv no. They don't. Not when I compare them to other ggs that are literally changing the concepts, sound, mvs, everything! Composing, directing, writing, etc. Other ggs are way up there in all of this but bp is just hovering at ground level. This new song of their's should have been released in their rookie days. I swear I have never seen a group regress this hard in musicality. Their first 5 songs were great and now it's just trash, I drew the line at dudu. That song wasn't it. And they went on to release two more versions of dudu? I had to laugh
Chi Mei yeah their songs feel old to me like i feel like they should’ve been released in 2016/2017 and they get so boring after a couple of days
Constructive criticism is valued, guys. This video actually makes the most sense as opposed to someone just hating. She knows her shit
Her opinion on "Kiss and Makeup," was mean ngl but everything else is spot on.
@@bribri6300 It wasn't mean, it was fact.
@@evita.v Nah "Kiss and Makeup" is so good, however "Ice-cream" was trash.
@@evita.v trash like ur life
@@freshmusic308 mad cause its bad
... we just got the same formula a 10th time and the fans are about to give YG their money anyway and prove that starving them works. This will keep happening as long as we let YG get away with it.
Isn't it?! lol. I too came back to this video after seeing their new comeback only to be underwhelmed by the the same formula again. It's getting worse. I guess we won't see any improvement in the near future because blind stans will just keep excuzing yg's mediocre production and call anyone who gives feedback a hater so they'll keep making easy money.
@@timesup2812 yeah their newest song ice cream is one of their worst songs (it had to be said honestly) because i
Of not only the line distribution but the lyrics snd I saw some blknks complaining saying all the blinks commenting on the ice cream saying that we're just blonks and its like I can't have a opinion and thus yg plans works
If they raise their voice against it then fans will obliviously support them but what to do ?? They aint compalining ! Seems to be satisfied for they are famous but not gonna improve
And "The Album" is coming up and I think they're going to use the same formula
Alexia Ralar Javier yes and that album contains some of their old songs
The song arrangement in MY opinion also makes first-time listeners gravitate more to Jennie and Lisa because the songs kinda set up for Jisoo and Rose to share pre-chrous’s which aren’t the peak of the song, and when Lisa’s rap or jennie’s rap makes more of an impact new fans gravitate to those two first
brandon roberts no the entire group is
fuck off brandon
@Fluffy Fluff and yet lisa doesnt get a dance break, and jennie doesnt rap as much as her position as main rapper should.
If they are already this popular then giving them this would break the internet.
About jisoo and rose. U cant even say that this can be done so they shine more. There are so many things that ignorant yg just misses out on these balls of talent.
omg U just made me realise this!
Rose & Jisoo deserve better
Who's here after HYLT? How easily it slides into this structure..
For real, and I noticed they had a lot of similar dance moves like the end to kill this love and how you like that are very similar, a huge group comes in, walking forward dramatically and then I saw the do those clap things in another song dance
@@taylorharris268 Let's hope the album is very different!
Elva yes hopefully!
Go watch the video titled 'All blackpink dances are the same' , even their choreographies are all same (not blackpink's fault tho...it's yg's fault for giving them the same choreography).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Came back after lovesick girls, and to no shock they used the same formula:
Jennie starts
Slice of Lisa
Jisoo and rose on the pre chorus
Primary phrase in English :”we are the lovesick girls”
Secondary:” we were born to be alone”
Nothing has changed :/
That’s just Teddy in action :/ even the songs he didn’t write sound similar
Atleast the lovesick girls they are singing in the chorus not just a same repeated praise
It's not only the line distribution... it's also the same sounds (Lovesick girls changes a bit fromt this formula, but Pretty Savage is basically another song "pure-Teddy-Blackpink")
lovesick girls had a real chorus and bridge though as well as an excellent outro
@@crm1301 Oh, yes, I don't denied that (I'll edit my comment to make it clearer, sorry!).
Teddy is literally screwing them over. I wish someone would call him out in his face.
Yes! Teddy is the problem. Not even YG. Just Teddy and his lazy ass.
It’s sad because this formula he makes, even though it’s the same and as long as BlackPink fans buy their songs he’s making a lot of money out of it so can’t really see him caring much if they sound the same or not.
Nah, it ain't Teddy's fault. It's YG and also BP's fault. I remember BP saying in an interview they felt most comfortable working with Teddy. They had plenty of chances to work with other producers but turned them down. No one else is to blame but the company and the artist. Producers produce music, but the company and the artists have a say in whether they like it or not.
@@bluemoon8856 you really think this is BP's fault lmao
Blue Moon
why would bp members turn down producers and collabs they like just because they felt comfortable with teddy? sis you tried it, but this is completely a YGE problem 💅🏼
damn, why is nobody talking about this video?? they made some hella good points. I hope to see more from your channel, just subbed :-)
At least TH-cam's algorithm finally came into its senses and recommended me this video.
@sadeee ikr
Yes
@sadeee Yes, the robot voice though. 😂😂😂
@sadeee I actually like the robot voice 🙈
Damn. This is an excellently written essay that deserves so many more views. Very well done.
Ps im not trying to sound condescending, I just wanted to say that I really enjoyed the video.
who’s here after Pink Venom dropped and Teddy’s still using the formula religiously
even after shut down!!
I had to come back to this vid immediately after I just listened to "How you like that"! 😂 It's literally the same procedure as every year. I don't even know what to say anymore about their songs, at this point I just feel sorry for everyone getting bullshitted by their producers.
oh yess i feel that i was so frustrated i had 2 rewatch this
I had to come back too
Funny how they still manage to get millions hyped up for them and gain the most views. Formula is repetitive yet somehow always works.
@@nojam6212 i hate to agree but this is so true. i think that's really the intention. starve the blinks until they beg for a comeback and release a remix version of the previous songs with same old choreography but expensive mv sets and clothes, and put the mv under "people & blogs" to get views :) at this point, it's so obvious they want bp to break it into the western market to get on charts like billboard to compete with bts. kinda sad tbh :(
I found them through HYLT and I love the song a lot but I think it’s similar to their other songs. Even the phrase how you like that is in another song
Damn this video was released before KTL, but coming back from How You Like That, the music structure to bp songs still applies. The "missing chorus syndrome", onomatopoeia with "How you like that that that that", catchy/repetitive phrase "Look at you now look at me".... it's been 1 year and 2 months since KTL and we're still getting the same thing. Disappointed but not surprised sigh.
200th like
“How you like that” is not an onomatopoeia- its clearly a bunch of words ._.
I started listening to Janny, who made blackpink fan made songs just to feed myself.
I need music from these girls and I'm honestly frustrated that they have so much potential but YG wastes it all.
Sis, you spoke the truth.
Ikr right I also listened to Janny's "Full Blackpink Album" lol with Rosé's like 3 "solos" and the others 2 I think haha we are seriously starving for music
Honestly shes promoting Balckpini better than Yg
"If you're sticking to one formula and just swapping out your phrases and techno-melodies, then writing 10 songs should take a week"
YES THATS EXACTLY MY POINT!! YG makes absolutely no sense, why would it take an entire year to come out with a mini album with only four songs, if all of those songs share the exact same formula.
EXACTLY, bro they are not like the old composers who wrote 40 minute symphony which can take months but this song formula can only produce less than 20 songs? Make it make sense.
I would lie if I said I don't love the girls, especially Jennie, and I also won't deny I actually enjoy Blackpinks songs.
However, as you mentioned, their heavily on EDM and Dance Tracks relying Discography makes their music at the same time stable and incredibly unstable. As someone who enjoys experimental, new music (I am a big fan of Red Velvets, EXOs and Taeyeons Discography- because especially SM likes to experiment with various genres. Probably because they buy extremely many songs and take their time putting together a perfect album. Then again, this is another discussion.) Blackpinks Discography is only bearable because I can switch to other artists to spice my listening experience a bit. But the same "strong" sound made them extremely popular, and as you also already mentioned, it is a little hard to find a difference between blackpinks choruses and the choruses of other artists, be it western Artists or Koreans.
The amount of talent and potential those 4 girls have, and that is thrown away is ridiculous. I feel like their newest (lol) release had only one song that broke out of that formula, kinda like Really, and it was Kick it. But if you take a look at those two songs, that are also following the same formula.
I consider myself a blink since Blackpinks debut, and I honestly hope YG keep their promise and releases the goddamn full album in January, and I hope they will feature a track like sure thing on it. My hopes are up- this time their worked with various producers.
Alice 2076 SAME, I just want them to get credited for their work too..., like teddy did NOT write stay, it was jennie and jisoo, and lisa wrote the rap in as if its your last, but they didn’t credit her work..
Don’t you just say anything about my nini jennie
@@mahi1114 nobody did say anything against her?
You really have not listened to all bp songs , huh
They have been making new genre like rock with ep , edm with trap , reggae , future ballad ect.
I am a taeyeon stan and I didn't knew my fellow listeners will be so ignorant
@@lianakeirasky3877 tf. Did you even read my comment. I enjoy BP Music, actually I enjoy it a lot, but the genrea you mentioned are not the ones in BPs music. For your information, I stan them since their debut, so of course I've listened to all of their songs. But if you can't see how similar they are, what a similar Vibe they have you are clearly "ignorant", as you just told me to be. They have two ballads, then they have Kick it and Teally which sound similar but different from the rest. Then you have Playing with fire, Don't know what to do and Forever Young, which qll have a beat drop (EDM, but rather soft) as a chorus. D4 and KTL have the exact same structure, I don't agree that they sound the same, and I actually think KTL was better than D4. Boombayah, See U later and whistle also have the same structure.
The only song that stands out because it's upbeat and not that "I'm a bad bitch, oh I'm hurt, now I'm a bad bitch again" kinda song is Aiiyl, which remains their beat. Reggae is nowhere to be heard in their songs, you can have Reggae kind of beat and yes, they have a version of really with Reggea in it but that's it. They don't have any song with rock in it? You don't even seem to know what a certain Genre of music sounds like. I think it's perfectly finde to criticize a Groups Discography, because it comes down to personal taste. For me, it's just not diverse enough because, as I mentioned, I like genre blending Discographys like Taeyeons that have pop, Pop-Ballads, Jazz, EDM, even elements of hip hop, RnB and so much more. Blackpink mainly does EDM, with the focus on hip hop/dance, which is fine. But it gets boring after one listen of their Discography. And I'm happy you listen to Taeyeon. Quality music.
Blackpink are great, they have swag, style and great potential. But YG is the problem, not giving them any songs or letting them show their potential, no high notes for Rosé or original voice, no dance break for Lisa, no good rap part for Jennie and no good visual roles for Jisoo.
Edit: For Jisoo, imma say smth else bcuz she gets decent visual roles. They should give some of Jennie's vocal parts to Jisoo and give a rap to Jennie or smth in those parts, e.g PWF and AIIYL bcuz she was full vocals on that.
Excatly yg haven't even let them make their own lyrics I hate the company it's trash
Visual?? That position is shit you train for debuting bc of your face?!??
You did Jisoo so dirty. She deserves much more that just visual exposure 🙄 don't limit her solely to her role as the 'visual'. She is also the lead vocal. Does she get lines accordingly? Jennie gets more vocal lines than her smh
@@khushi6846 Ikr and Jennie hardly raps although she's the main rapper
@@user-hw7dz7mg5n exactly! And she's so damn good at rapping. Why tf would they make her sing and cut out even more vocal line parts that Chae and Jisoo should get anyways?
Why is nobody talking about how Jennie's SOLO is just some recycled version of Sunmi's Gashina?
Guys, please...
Holy sh....
aren't those from the same producer tho? still lazy af, but you know, excuses.
I didn't even know that, i-
Point now when you said it i see the similarity
Omg I just realized!
4 years later and the situation with Blackpink is still pretty much the same lmao
NOT ANY MORE MY GIRLS ARE FREEEEEEE
Anyone watching this AGAIN, after realizing that after now recieveing "How you like that"? Because... that song has the exact same formula as all these other songs. What's sad, is blackpink has so much talent, but YG doesnt want to spend the time on them because again, they dont have to. Their songs no longer interest me when they get a comeback. Reason being the same, no true chorus, and exact formula.
i love how you like that and the rest of their songs but i agree it has the same formula and i just wish the pinks could write their own songs because they have amazing voices but they cant because of yg
sour candy made me realise how much better they are without teddy
Strongly agree 👍
Absolutely I loved it (if gaga wasn't there) way more than how you like that.
Prakriti Priyam well but sour candy is gaga song, so she is supposed to be here. But yeah sour candy was good, i didn’t like it but i can’t deny it’s good. HYLT is a mess
@@jimilismoldchannel5427 yes you are right it's a gaga song but there voices didn't mesh well together. It had atleast some substance but in comparison to it HYLT used most of the formula that teddy uses. I hope we get something good in the upcoming album. And if yg again played his cards, I will literally give up and boycott him. No streaming, no time and money investment to fill his pockets.
Prakriti Priyam yup same! if the album is trash, gonna unstan blackpink. I’m tired of putting my time and money in this group, even tho i love the girls. But i just can’t anymore.
I think gaga has just made a collaboration with blackpink because she knows the problem with blinks. you just have to watch the views. They streamed it. Because they don’t have content.
tbh, blackpink look/act more like social media influencers than K-POP Idols
Yep. You hate to see it.
True. Theyre more models than idols and although they had passion they constantly fail to show it
Fax
Just because they have a huge social media following doesn't mean you have to shame them for it. Look at Ari and Selena they're artists with huge followers and sns is one of the many platforms they can use to update fans. If Bts had individual accounts you wouldn't say shit like this. Ya'll just hate women and BLACKPINK lol get a life
@@chaiantoinnette1667 lol then why do we love other girl groups??? Ari and selena have huge followers but that doesn't mean they don't continue to make music and spend the whole day on sns. And don't bring bts here. They have nothing to do with it cz they just don't sit around waste time. They use that platform to do something good unlike bp.
YG focuses on their visual appearances rather than lyrics
I mean Blackpink is known mostly for their image/persona, much less their music.
Absolutely
@Xiaojun mi casita 🏡 Lmao I thought it was just me who got annoyed by that
BP has an obsessive fandom.
And YG knows that and purposely gives them less content so those fans replay the videos.
They're not popular as in everyone loves them. Theyre popular as in everyone knows them. You'll find more people who aren't interested than actual fans.
Wow so true.
The part about everybody knows them but not everyone loves them literally summed up everything. 👏🏻👏🏻
Thats really true. Agree 100%
Yes I agree with your opinion
This comment deserves more attention!!!
I listened to them once since they're so hyped up and was surprised. I thought they were gonna be really good and unique to be so popular so it was disappointing. Guess I'll stick to DC and Loona and RV.
Y’all forget that Lisa was gonna be lead vocal in the other group
Ella Becerra the other group?
GoopyPegasus ;-; Jennie, Jisoo, Lisa, Rosé and five other girls were supposed to debut as a girl group called PinkPunk in 2014, but YG postponed it to 2016, but the five other girls left, and Lisa was gonna to be lead vocal and Jisoo was gonna to be lead rapper.
@@rubyjane2648 JISOO rapper?
@@lausolanom.3846 yes
@@rubyjane2648
Woah
That's why Lisa can sing so well and that's why rapper Jichu can spit bars 😂
This is so underrated smh 👀
Honestly their fans are really bad a judging what’s good music and what’s bad but because yg starves the fandom to death. That fandom doesn’t care for shit what they release as long as they get to see the girls.
Literally
Yes
THIS
i can confirm this 😓
Be honest...how many of us didn’t realize a lot of these things wrong with their songs...
Most people don't notice the specifics. What generally happens is basically what happened with me. Discover a BP song, think it's cool and fun, listen to it for a while and then it falls off the radar. Rinse and repeat for each song. For me, BP's music is very much 'pop' music, or 'bubble gum' music. There's very little longevity to it. The initial excitement fades pretty quickly, comparatively speaking.
Don't get me wrong. I think the members are all very talented. I still listen to most of their songs on occasion, but they don't have a permanent, or even semi-permanent spot on my playlist. Unlike other groups (I won't mention any names) who put out more complex and interesting songs, change up their style regularly (but still maintain their core 'feel') and, in general, keep my attention a lot longer.
I just jam into them and now... I don't know if I'll unsee it XD
At first yes, then I heard 'Kill this love' and realized it sounds really similar to 'Du du du du'...
I did realise but I thought i was just dumb
Keith Craig please don’t take this wrong, but I feel this way about bts music. I think they’re a talented group but their music doesn’t do it for me. I think the popularity has gotten fans to settle for mediocre songs that are meh at best. There are other better GG and BG of Kpop that have better music but unfortunately they are overshadowed by BP and BTS.
Intelligently written, narrated with a lot of heart and...no swearing. This was a really satisfying video and actually made me feel like I should be paying for such high quality content. Thank you. Subscribed ✅
yikes, hylt used the same song sturcture. again. most of the fans don't even care though! most of them are just like: "well its blackpink, just appreciate the music!". we shouldn't praise no effort on yg's end, we should call them out on it. dear blinks: stop silencing the people who speak out about low quality music, thanks
edit: notice how i said *yg* , not blackpink? did yall notice? it was probably for a reason that was explained in the video!
Lol, the part i love in hylt is just the pretty singing part in the beginning and the chorus "How you like that-dadadada" but that's it. I'm getting tired with Teddy's formula.
yg starves their fans so they’ll eat up anything, even if it’s low quality
Don’t forget: “it’s just the pre-release, it doesn’t need to be good.”
@@jasminewadsworth1983 they're dumb, pre-release supposed to make fans hyped up with their REAL release. I said it again, "If the pre-release one doesn't even makes impact for me, then what should i expect for the REAL one"
and I'm so conflicted because, I'm sure the girls are elated that they've been breaking records and charting with this music. Plus they are FINALLY performing again. but We're literally witnessing YG get away with this bullshit and I doubt they'll change if the results get better and better
as someone who was introduced to kpop through blackpink, the sole reason why i didn't explore other groups sooner was because my first impression of kpop was that the music was generic and repetitive, made to currently please and be forgotten in a few years. i did enjoy their songs, however it felt something was missing. the fact that blackpink is assumed to be one of the main 'representatives' of kpop by the general public and is probably the first thing that comes to their minds when kpop is mentioned makes me a little sad. so many people are driven away from kpop like i was because their first impression of it doesn't always make a positive impact on them.
So true, most of the people I know, don't Like kpop because of blackpink. They think kpop is repetitive and the same, it has nothing new and cringe lyrics.
As a music producer I agree with most of what was said because it IS TRUE. I unstanned bp (music wise) because of the reasons tackled in the video. Honestly I feel like Teddy is an "ok" producer based on how creative the industry is now and I feel like YG is afraid of getting another producer because he thinks he wont sell that well which is ridiculous because he HAD producers like B.I that made fresh music and he just threw him out. Tbh at this point I hope YG sinks but it's frustrating because i dont want the groups currently in YG to suffer from the companies inability to keep up with new monster rookie producers
Legit every member of BTS is a more creative producer than Teddy 🙄 The girls deserve better
Emi the Ghost YUPPPPPPPP
@@javamikii pls don't bring BTS here
@@javamikii true
Big hit will take YG place soon if they keep messing up over and over again
i will literally cry myself to sleep if *how you like that* actually follows the same formula... .
Read my mind 😂
This aged horrible
this aged like a banana
This aged like spoiled milk
welp....
How you like that fits PERFECTLY in the structure you mentioned lol
Can we also talk about their theme for a minute.
The concept of their songs and the meaning behind it have never changed, and knowing YG, it probably never will. They keep on talking about the same shit: love. Love songs, break up songs, post break-up songs, most of the times their title tracks are either about “turning badass after breaking up or getting heart broken” or something like that. Like, it’s getting tiring. Can’t YG write some songs about things other than that? Because it’s really boring and generic. There’s not really any story behind their lyrics, you can’t think about a story with the lyrics. How you like that made zero sense to me, it’s as if they cut out words from a diary, mixed things up, drew lots and sticked the words together to make a sentence.
There isn’t much Blackpink mv/theories out there because there isn’t any theory to make. They don’t go in deep. Just some Easter eggs here and there but other than that, there’s nothing to look into.
Another thing: the fans
Blinks keep on whining about YG being a shitass company, and yes, they’re right. But they aren’t doing anything because at the end of the day, BP releases something, it blows up, Blinks break records, YG gets money. At the end of the day, YG wins. Blinks don’t stop blaming them and asking for more content, they rip each other’s throat and anyone who dares say something bad about Blackpink, while YG is watching the show. They’re smart, really, because of their strategy, they’re making money. Starve someone and they DEVOUR whatever you give them, no matter the quality. I might have sparred YG’s throat if BP’s long awaited comebacks weren’t so disappointing, yet here we are...
YG will never change the content of Blackpink's songs because Blackpink are MEGA popular in Mainland China, their comeback this year was talked about more than any other K-Pop comeback by Chinese teens, and very few topics other than love make it passed the censors there. If they branched out into more mature topics then they'd have a large portion of their market blocked off to them.
omg the last para🤣🤣🤣 i laughed so hard.... its true😂😂 lmao....
Your right everyone says that lovesick girl is bout suicide and that theory is fake
@@MrKikip1992 really?? not even BTS?? are blackpink really more popular than BTS in China?
if it's true, then I'm really worried for the youth's future
Also, BTS try and talk about a LOT of mature stuff, societal issues, criticise society, so does that mean BTS dont pass the censor board there???
btw, I LOVE your comment, so I'm copying and keeping it with myself hehe
"Bitch, I'm a star, but not Patrick"
Girl, Patrick Star is one of the most memorable icon of this generation.
PS. This is a joke, if any of you will get offended
like fr what are those lyrics? just give a pen to lisa and jennie, i bet they can write something less dumb.
@@Toxoplasmosis006 True dat
Totally blackpink's songs have no meaning behind them
This needs more attention
This is literally true but 𝘴𝘰𝘮𝘦 blinks don't wanna accept that it's true and just go through the same bull crap over and over
yeontan rises we literally do accept it...
Leah not all blinks accept it...
M A a majority do tho...
True they see any critism as hate
hani's tears if that isn’t facts. Look at this recent comeback. They can’t take any tape of criticism
So this video still holds TRUE for Pink Venom
I died at the comparison of all the repetition structures in all their songs. 😂😂😂
Case in point:
1. Compare Dreamcatcher's Chase Me (debut song which is hard core rock) and Deja Vu (latest song which is soft ballad + rock vibe)
2. Compare Everglow's Bon Bon chocolate (debut song) to Adios (latest song).
3. Compare Gidle's Latata (debut song) and Lion (latest song) .
And all these groups are YOUNGER than blackpink. And different members start the songs, different members also sing different parts every damn time. You get a change every comeback and its always refreshing and exciting to look forward to. But the same can't be said for blackpink after almost 4 years of being active
And then theres mamamoo changing concepts every song😆
But then they dont get the respect they deserve as seniors of other groups. (MAMA)
Red Velvet. Two words. They are Queens.
How about Dreamcatcher's SCREAM and the other hits on their new album. All diff a bit yet most came from the same composers? :)
As far as BP, liked all their songs, but agree, the group and the stans deserve way better than a gambling corrupt ceo who treat, and use them as cash cows. And really hope "that's all" he did.. www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/disgraced-k-pop-executive-star-hit-travel-bans-1233508
@@nye1915 I swear you're everywhere ×2
@@namjoonsoldjiminsjamsfor5d309 Hahahahha
A fantastic analysis of BP's discography. It never really occurred to me that all of BP's title tracks ever released, they are singing about literally nothing in their choruses ahaha, and I've gotten so used to it that I've never questioned it. Thanks Mera for shining a light on this. I've always wondered why I couldn't subscribe to BP's music even though I really like the members and they are obviously very talented, but these single phrase chorus songs are really killing their music career. People will eventually get bored of these songs, I know I have.
Thank goodness for Red Velvet's discography!!! Even though they also have these type of songs, it is few and far between relative to their extensive discography. Most recent example that comes to mind is Zimzalabim (2019), and from what I can recall (title track wise) they only put out one of these songs every TWO years. SM definitely has a better understanding of how to sprinkle these songs over an artist's career.
before I'd listen to BTS, I though all kpop songs were like black pink's, had the same structure. when I started listening bts I was like "oh, wow, they are different"
Listen to Red Velvet. Their discography and musical diversity is insane.
@@LM-ix7pk one of the reasons I love sm discographies is that all of their artists have such a diverse profile of songs. even before nct started with all their starkly different concepts, we'd get new content from shinee, exo, red velvet, etc each comeback
listen to mamamoo they’re amazing
Listen groups like gfriend, dreamcatcher and loona, they're amazing
There is verstality in k-pop
Pink venom was released today, and I saw formula. Jennie starts, Rosie & Jisoo shared a pre chorus, Lisa/Jennie rapped on second verse and the chorus has somewhat/ish formula use. Don’t get me wrong it’s rly good for a pre release and the girls looked killer asf (especially Jisoo) I’m just anxious and a little nervous for what the album brings in store.
Well ... I think for Bron Pink .... this video has still points. Mhh I know can understand why they have so many lazy alligations.... I mean if I had to perform 10 songs that only have different lyrics I would also get them mixed up.
Came here after HYLT release and I’m very disappointed with blackpinks music it hasn’t improved at all. I’m tired of waiting for the same content every year and I’m even more tired of seeing blinks hype them up for mediocre songs I’m just gonna wait till their album releases
when she pointed out the formula, i laugh-cried bc hylt followed the same formula and the fans are screwed over once again by yg
@@cheemsebol69 I agree with you. I am disappointed too
@@cheemsebol69 agree
yeah, In my opinion I like other songs of BP but HYLT is like the same with their previous songs. Now I'm confused if I'm still a blink.
Neslette I’m waiting till their album drops to decide to see if I want to leave or not
Chilee...this video is even more relevant now that How You Like That? is out.💀
fr
Yh like when it came out it was so hyped that I couldn't see past that and see the flaws, it sounded the same, nothing new really. Not that it was bad but we're tired of them leaving for so long and coming back with nothing new, same old same old.
and with lovesick girls and pretty savage and a few more on the album.
@@rosestea5896 Lovesick girls was pretty different, a full chorus, lisa coming in at 1st and 2nd verse. plus when looking into the bsides many songs didnt follow this formula. looking at songs like bet you wanna, you never know, love to hate me and ice cream. Now we are getting Rose solo and no doubt its not gonna follow the regular formula as it will be about rose not bp.
I’m not gonna lie I often confuse how you like that for dudududu but imo I prefer how you like that over dudududu
It also kills an industry. If 1 is so above others with less and unworthy songs. K POP will die if a More Hard Working and Great Music production is underrated and I meant there are a lot out there. Thanks to BTS and Twice getting the right treatment (sometimes) and attention they deserved because they do represent those and I'm sad for Mamamoo, GFriends and Red Velvet that supposed to be given the attention, the hype and fame that Blinkpink has. Producers will get tired and does K Pop as a whole will collapse, putting the wrong representative can hurt not just 1 but all.
I feel the same way. There's a lot of great groups especially GG's with worthy discographies yet people put blackpink on such high pedestal
@@lizfernandez7782 It literally disgusts me just to think about...
Yeah, like FUCKING PROVE IT. You’re called the “best girl group in kpop/world” so PROVE TO THE WORLD that you deserve the goddamn title.
U are right bts get what they deserves but girlgroup like gfriend , mamamlo and red velevet are underrated
@Kaaviya Sri yes!! Their discography is amazing!! I don't stan any other group than bts but I love twice,red velvet,mamamoo cz they're amazing and deserve better!!
Here after pink venom and holy shit it sounds exactly like every other song they have…AND THE BLINKS ARE ACTING LIKE ITS THE SECOND COMING OF CHRIST WHEN ITS NOT. I really hoped for something different…
thats what im saying. I cannot get behind the delusion that their music is good. like are we listening to the same thing?
Mamamoo is coming for Blackpink’s top 3 spot if they don’t step it up.
Also it’s so funny how this video could be remade now and KtL would still fit the mold exactly.
Side note: Solo sounds like a Sunmi song that wasn’t deemed good enough for the album.
EDIT: Idk what happened to this thread but I’m tired of getting the notifications from it. 😂
Yeah it sounds a lot like Sunmi gashina...
Finally some truth
Us radishes are waiting for that day
@@nye1915 Damn girl, you're everywhere 😶
@@namjoonsoldjiminsjamsfor5d309 i have severe mamamoo addiction
So HYLT just dropped and lo and behold... same formula.
Granted it's a pre-release, but after a year I hoped for some sort of evolution.
Edit: and what irks me is that I bet a bunch of these k-pop reaction channels will all be like "omg FIRE" but no it was not fire, it was disappointing.
Yes
They sometimes actually say it's good eventhough it's not that great
cause if they don't say it's lit , they might get bashed by blinks
Hylt was actually the first ever kpop song I’ve ever listened to and it’s basically the reason why I’m into it now. I really thought it was a BOP and I still do tbh. But the remixes I heard are better than the actual song ngl
Agreed! It wasn’t good, it was just catchy
i liked it tbh
but yh
Ktl only proves it
she seems like the girl in class that is shy then she gives a presentation on something she really cares about and shocks everyone
You literally deserve so much more subscribers! You’re so smart and mature about everything. You make great points and incredible videos! I love watching every single one of them!!
Are you busy? If not *please* take YG's position!
Back after HYLT and it’s amazing to see how your points about song structure are still extremely relevant a whole year later. They literally haven’t developed at all. Disappointed once again🤩
Go and watch lovesick girls
@@ranjana585 still the same but this time they have a chorus though it really got boring after my 3rd listen.
@@oyshirahman897 ok so you want them to try something different but when they try something different you get bored
@@ranjana585 it wasn't different. Jennie starts,rosie and jisoo sing the pre-chorus, then an English phrase as the main chorus and strong electronic instruments noises,Lisa raps the 2nd verse,at the end a dance break,sudden ending of the song. They do have a proper chorus this time but do use the structure again and it got boring to me after my 3rd listen. And 1 song being a little different with having a chorus doesn't mean their whole discography is improving. The rest of the songs on the album don't have a proper chorus, the same empty one and the only song with a proper chorus is the ballad you never know.
@@oyshirahman897 it was different there wasn't a beat drop. There was a full chorus. Most of their songs are bad*ss
But this one was a soft one. Most of their songs are shot in sets. This was shot outside there wasn't any set. Most of their songs rose just sings the line before chorus in this she didn't she had many lines and most of the songs jennie don't rap in this she did. What are you saying there were no strong electronic noises. There was no dance break at the end.
"Blackpink is the REVOLUTION"
XDdd
That's the funniest part. Revolution is something new, something that has not yet been, but I apologize for repeating the same thing is not something new, something like this cannot be called a revolution
I agree with you
Sneha K.N i think they are talking about the revolution of earth kind of thing
@@hypeace14__44 Lol
Sneha K.N 🤣
Ooo snap
“Bitch I’m a star but no Patrick” - 😭😭
Tehe
I love that line 😂😂
Bwahh😂
I found that line pretty iconic, I like it 😂
What timeline?
And I know you said you would talk about the members but I NEED to make a point. Blackpink themselves are bored. Not invested in their own music. They probably don’t even train anymore ! When they debuted, it was okay for Rose to be sometimes shaky while dancing and messing up her parts sometimes. It was okay for Jennie to not really know how to hype up a crowd and just shout in her microphone. It was okay for Lisa tonne mostly a dancer and not nailing her vocal/rap performances every time. Now after almost 4 years ? It’s not okay. With the time they have on their hands, they should have DRASTICALLY improved. But I feel like they’re regressing. Why ? Because I think they don’t even care anymore. The only one who improved is Jisoo and she auditioned to be an actress damn it !
FYI
Jennie is the one who hypes up the crowd out of all blackpink members
Glittergirl 2424 I think she meant at the beginning
Lisa is more stable but Yeah i agree
That's actually not true neither accurate, I can understand in the problem in YG and their music but every educated blink knows that what you said it's simply not true
Moonlight ENTM I would believe you If I saw them actually improve. But I don’t see it at all
Damn its rare to heard a person being so kind and open-minded about blackpinks discographie fan. We need more of thoses people. But yeah their discographie is not big
I'm a blink, I love the girls, but you're right. The thing is, blinks SHOULD also do their part and not just blindly praise and compliment their music when it clearly, in general, is mediocre, generic and leans more on the Western pop side, compared to their contemporaries. Enjoying generic music isn't bad. Enjoying a Western pop sound isn't bad too. Like, I enjoy D4, I enjoy How You Like That, I enjoy DKWTD, etc. I enjoy many Western pop songs. BUT, that's the thing. Their songs are just that: generic, mediocre and really Western pop-sounding. We may enjoy it, there's nothing wrong w/ that, BUT, that doesn't excuse them of being just that, mediocre and generic.
THIS
FINALLY FINALLY FINALLY IN A MILLION YEARS, a mature blink!
but thats just your opinion though
@@surge1993 but thats just your opinion though :)
@@abcabckabc but thats just your opinion too Syafiqah
At this point it's not even YG's fault, we as consumers are just being dumb and that's it. I better wait for my bts and seventeen japanese releases and enjoy monster stages then spending my time and effort on yg because now I have just given up.
Yeah!! Fans are hyping mediocore songs like they're the best and when people call them out they say people are toxic. And yeah!! Stan BTS kings and seventeen kings!! They're so talented!! I've never seen any artists more versatile than bts!! Of course there's other versatile artists but to me bts is the most versatile! !!
True. This is gonna sound really horrible, but I always have my ult group (BTS) and a secondary group which is typically a girl group. It was Blackpink for a while, but I think I kinda took a step back and asked myself why I was continuing to stan when I was honestly bored. I lost interest, but ig I was just so used to calling myself an ARMYBlink so it was hard to let go of that.
Since then, I lowkey wanted to explore/look into different groups, where I decided to focus on Red Velvet and eventually Mamamoo (my second favorite group right now). Now that I’ve been focusing on BTS, Mamamoo, and a few boy groups here and there, I’ve started to realize how versatile their concepts and music are compared to Blackpink whom I’ve been stanning for so long. Ngl, The Album was an upgrade from their previous EPs and I applaud them for that, but it just wasn’t for me. I wish the girls the best, though, and I think I’m still going to support them, just not as much as before.
@@tiramiisu0 I literally have the same story. I Stan for the music and not the people, and BTS and MAMAMOO do that for me
@@namename9372 I mean, I do stan for music, but I also stan for their personalities, their affection towards their fans, their chemistry, and a lot more. I wouldn’t say that I just stan for the music, but music is also a part of why I stan certain groups.
Check you never know by blackpink promise u won't waste ur time
You should become a kpop music producer
For real
*plot twist*
SHE IS😱
omg yes I have always thought that about the arrangement of the songs. Jennie starts, then lisa goes then rose and jisoo then chorus then jennie again then rose and jisoo switch singing parts then the beat drop while they're all singing together and then that's it.
Im not a blink But I enjoy their songs and I noticed usually:
Jennie starts the song
Then Jisoo or Rose Sing
The Chorus
Then Lisa
Then Jisoo or Rose again
Then chorus again
Then dance break
Then end