I was reading R.S Sharma's India's Ancient Past, somehow while reading the book something was bothering me. So I was searching for other Historians books, then I came across your video. Taking ur suggestion I browse through R.C Majumder's Ancient India from the online archive. After some reading, the historical manipulation u were talking about became undoubtedly evident. I placed an order for the book, going to read it throughly. In the future I would love to read 'The History and Culture of the Indian People' its all 11 volume. Though I am not a history student. But I belive its very crucial for everyone to understand its true roots. Thanks a lot sir.🙏🙏🙏
@@AjayKumarChaudhary-t1v It would be my humble suggestion to you sir, to Read R.C Majumders' Ancient India first, then just because u already have R.S Sharmas' book just compare the two just contents of various chapters (Atleast that's what I did).You'll understand how our history has been manipulated.
Proud of myself that i didn't pay any attention during history classes in school. Lol. Rc Majumdar Jadunath sarkar Har bilas sarda G c pande Meenakshi jain Sita ram goel - historic hindu resistance to Muslim invaders
We read Meenakshi Jain, was hunting for non fiction history of India so found your books as well, we know school books were always wrong.. Sanskrit is mother of all languages .. watch movies of freedom fightings of all types of freedom fighters, Indian freedom fighters and foreign freedom fighters, read non fiction on griefs pains suffered abroad and in India for Centuries, then you understand that how big is the hidden history which is to be found on own like told in this video..
Ancient history by RC Majumdar is also helpful for UPSC gs and mains prep. You can also refer ncert Makkhan Lal ancient Indian history far better then RS Sharma
Sir, when I searched for the correct Indian history in English, then I found your video, this is what I do in Hindi, then hundreds of thousands of competitive exams come.
For UPSC what I figured out is I can filter the History from RC Majumdar's book with respect to UPSC syllabus and then learn and present the answer in balanced way in Exam, I do not know if it is feasible but I have started the process. I am also in search of History books which does not has Marxist influence in it, to prepare for UPSC and I will do that by clubbing the imp contents from Nationalist Historian Books even if they are scattered
@@saurabhshrivastavCould you please provide some suggestions for Indian history books? I'm looking for books that offer accurate details about our past.
Very true till 1947 the Hindu high is too good and people were more United in those times alone but after the bloody Nehru Civilization entire a generation lost the Hindu hope. Even within Hindu there are snakes being anti hindu. It's high time we start educating our children what is true. Send them to iskon, temples, gurukulas rather than sending them to missionary schools. Nothing is achieved there at the end of day. You will not be lived by English all the life. You have to stand on Dharma Learn Hindu literature. If it's complicated listen to saints sages and those who propagate hindu Eg. Chaganti koteswara garu, garikapati Garu (telugu). Never Ever be afraid of being Hindu. Feel Proud that you have Hindu blood which is source of this existence right from Satya, thretha, dwapara Yuga to Kali yuga
Mughal history and British history of India is important for contemporary world as the social , political, economical condition today is very relevant to the situations and impact of those ..this is the reason this period of our indian history is prime part of syllabus and important to study primarily ... It is important to study why we became slave so that we don't repeat those mistakes .
We should know why we became slaves, but what has been written after that is rubbish. How Indians were portrayed as workers for the empire is what is taught to us, instead of how Indians struggled throughout that period and fought for freedom was either removed or just briefly ended with a line. When I read the struggle of freedom led by Nelson Mandela and other people, it inspired me. When I did that for our struggle all I found was, how amazing the Mughals were and they gave us such rich art. How the Brits gave us the blessings of English and made us civilized... Those same Brits now come to our country and look for our culture abandoning their own. So what good is our history book? Except helping qualify UPSC
I know of multi millionaires here that do not know a shit of history. Is ' his story' that important. History was written by the white supremacists with a glass of wine in one hand and a cigar in the other and some brown supremacists follow it.
We were not slaves dumbass ..first read ...we were oppressed by these invaders but later we fought and reclaimed it . We have to read neutral perspectives from both the side not some biased and paid historian books. That's what he is talking about
Are you planning to, or by any chance passed from JNU? You have to clear away the foggy cloud of secularism, liberalism from your mind. Roots of Ancient Indian civilization is spread till span of southern and norther American dating even before the time of Mayank and Olmec, we have (had) a knowledge base that educated the entire world and our universities were burned down by intruders. And you think Mughal histor and british histor is important. Bro read Gita and Ramayan. You anit-Indian sentiments may be due to 2 reasons, 1.) your mind is clouded with fad ideas or liberalism 2.) You are born of either British or Mughal father.
Very surprisingly you have only 5k vew when I am seeing this,may be our society is not ready for you,I request you to come to as many podcasts as you could and speak in Hindi, people of my country and specially State must hear you, God bless you,and good luck, with love and respect..
Hi J Sai, its hard to get the right history about bharat. Should we setup a seperate youtyube channel , that may will work better than trying to find and read the books.
J.Sai Deepak sir Plz read Chidanand Murthy who is a true historian n Karnataka. He has written book on " Tipu Sultan" n Kannada with proofs & facts. S.L.Bairappa another renowned writer challends tht nobody or no historian knows more abt Tipu Sultan. He has not written a book on Tipu Sultan He has lot of materials on Tipu If historians like Vikram Sampath or so on wish to write on Tipu thn they can contact S.L.Bairappa fr contents wth strong facts.
Today I had a thought.is India truly got independence? Bcz we are still a slave of western culture.i am not trying to preach anybody.but just think do we really respect our culture? Do we know about our history .India has some drawbacks like dowry,women oppression, untouchability etc.But the same India has principles, spirituality,yoga, meditation, humanity..Don't know where we are now heading to? But we are slowly becoming machines and running away from being a human.just a deep rant
Respected sir my daughter is in 10th class ,she is asking me always why we read about French revolution in our books ???? Where is our true history??? I have no answer .why books not teach us about our culture agricultural our dance our local artists our poet .If Im studying English literature there is no indin poet Why plz do some thing for this .
If you really like history , you have to study by yourself . The history taught in school is not wrong , history overall is supposed to teach a person to realise their mistakes and go ahead. As far as I know despite the RTI point that respect deepak sir makes , there is plenty research done at least according to sources tagged on Wikipedia , which suggests that the mughals did in fact build and preserve temples albeit this was done in order to please the Rajputs who were hindu communities. They were simultaneously also responsible for destroying multiple temples. Learning history is never wasted as they act as case studies. Apart from that there are plenty of indian poets in language based classes for regional as well as hindi lectures , most of the english lit work is derived from english classics at least back when I did my schooling , although I do remember the books did change to more simpler language while we had much tougher english. Most of the NCERT books only touch up on things at most mentioning one or two lines about something including history books, in fact they do actually summarise events like plassey or whole biographies in one paragraph , in every subject they are meant to provide you an introduction on everything , there were plenty of references to indian culture and dances etc. as far as I remember , and im pretty sure there used be a subsection of SST in lower grades where they did teach that. Hence they are also considered great material to study from .
I don't know about this RS Sharma book... I bought RS Sharma Medival India book then i saw all the references and content then i compared to INDIA THAT IS BHARAT Book..Then i knew how they hide all the independent times and Hindu tenures were hindu knowledgeable point has been not written over the book 🤷🤷
@@sahilyadavvvvv of course, anyone who loves our culture and embrace it is a "right wing" (Nationalist). Anyone who is hell bent on destroying the native culture and identity is left wing (Anti National)..
Problem with the books that he has mentioned is, they are extremely expensive! As much as I would want to read Dr.Jain, none of her books are below ₹800. Becomes quite difficult for a student to purchase them.
@@sannibabukandala6933libraries are not available in every nook and corner of the country and if they did they hardly have the books that he has mentioned. You are saying use library as if your father has provided libraries for the whole world😂😂😂
Basically I'm from medical field but I want to study my country history so anyone please suggest me some books which are in basic language, straight to the point.
The BJP wrote these books 🤣🤣 They were written by MMJ and a committee by Neeladri Bhatacharya a JNU Historian Source: NCERT through the ages by Outlook India
@@ramyaaaa Why?? Being a history department student from DELHI UNIVERSITY and JNU I know what j.sai deepak is saying. Marxist Historians has their own propoganda which is only economic centric and full of feudalistic approach. D.D koshambi imposed the direct european feudalism theory on Indian society which was inspired by the european marxist scholar known as Marc Bloch. Do you really think that comparing European society and Indian society from the perspective of a western marxist scholar is a good thing?? You can come and debate anyday. From satish chandra books to Romila thapar books Or from Karl max to lynn white jr...
@@KumarKumar-sp5mn then you must also know that old Marxist theories have been refuted and revised. I do not subscribe to the Marxist way of thinking but I would never say that historians belonging to this school of thought are idiots. Marxist frameworks are good for looking at things from a particular perspective. But they are not absolute - nothing is absolute, at the end of the day. I know what being context specific means and I also know that Marxist theories are best suited for the transition debate & 18th-19th century Europe. India was diverse, and still is, but his (Deepak’s) approach is not correct, in my opinion. This guy is also talking about Jadunath Sarkar. Why aren't you questioning the credibility of his claim, being a history student & all? even his theories have been debated upon by historians. I also think that this guy shouldn't be taken seriously because he said that Romila Thapar, Irfan Habib should be thrown out of this country. Is this not his own propaganda ? Whatever, their viewpoints are, he has no right to claim who should and shouldn't be a part of this country. He is a lawyer, not a historian so I don't expect him to have all the historical knowledge in this world either.
Sir , how do we demolish Aryans theory which west keep teaching . They say .. sythians gave India Sanskrit & religion ..and you were uncivilized . I still see many youtubers Germans & Dutch calling themselves pure Aryans ..I feel they didn't learned from holocaust
1. R.C.Majumdar History and Culture of Indian People (Volume 5 and 6) 2. R.C. Majumdar An advanced History of India 3. H.M. Elliot The History Of INDIA as told by Its own Historians : THE MUHAMMADAN PERIOD
Can someone explain me why he said ‘’They teach you Marxist school of nonsense. Whats the context? How indian historians while writing books on indian history can teach us about marxism??
The history which we read in our NCERT books is flawed and is written with bias against Hindus. For eg, the NCERT mentions how great Mughals were , how secular Akhbar was ( according to NCERT he was a secular who built temples which is utterly false), the disgusting part is glorification of Gandhi and Nehru, calling the real freedom fighters radical , Aryan invasion theory, the so called great mother Teresa, Raja rammohan Roy and his lies, etc. Not a single line about AZAAD HIND FAUJ and The real father of nation Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
@@parthgautam4605 Marxist historiography represents Indian history as a running theme of exploitation” and there is nothing in the textbooks about Indian achievements in maths and science. Left historians “attacked the sanctity of the cow and Brahmins” by claiming that beef was a staple in ancient India for which there is no evidence. He said marxist school of nonsense bcz our books do not tell us about real rulers. I am sure you must have also noticed that in the chapters about of the great rulers of india we are being taught about mughals , how come mughals = great indian rulers. They were invaders. Marxism do not allow any space of yogic studies. No spiritual studies as well. Their whole agenda is to make people of india ( particularly all hindus which includes sikhs, budhist, jains, etc) believe in Aryan Invasion Theory even though they do not have any evidence to prove it. This is all marxist nonsense. I suggest you to read more about this on google . swarajyamag.com/magazine/what-are-we-teaching-our-children news.careers360.com/ncert-book-textbook-syllabus-panel-history-social-science-school-amu-jamia-millia-sanjeev-sanyal-indian-knowledge-system 》Please do read these 2 articles bcz it covers every thing and you will have more clarity.
@@Gajanan-db4vy Definitely not But I am curious student of History who had completed masters & PGDM in History. History always relate with truth-evidence & only Centrist can justify it.😊
Again you asking to repeat the same mistake sir. Completely ingoring the Mughal history is not a healthy way. Sorry to say this it's reminding me of right wing vs left wing that I watched last night on TV news. Why both of these eliminated by Ctrl+alt+delete ? Somehow now we become mixed bag of all religions so our history books also should be touching all of the information (about Mughals as well as hindutva and others ) so it must not feels lopsided
Is bipin chandra books are leftist? And tell me which books i should read for nationalist movements and modern history after Independence and before independence.. Like medival history and about mughals, and revolts againts mughals and islamic invaders.. Tell me Authors with their book title, not just wrote Author names.. Because i am also a student from science side, so, i don't know, and does not have enough time to search each and every author to search about...
Bharat behaved as one? Do not Indian sub continent Kings fought with each other to occupy the thrones? Is there a nationality feeling prior to Moghal invasion to India? Sir please suggest and leave it to the understanding of people. Please don't say don't read let the readers judge. I can understand your intention with respect.
What he means by Bharat behaved as one he means it as a civilization,where all of the Indian from all parts of the nation saw each other as part of one culture,now you would say but there was no concept on India or Bharat but no there was a concept of Bharat before the British and Mughals ,India has been mentioned as Bharatvarsha in Vishnu Purana, Vayu Purana, Linga Purana, Brahmanda Purana, Agni Purana, Skanda Purana, Khanda and Markandaya Purana. Vishnu Purana clearly says in it उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् । वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।। This shloka means: “The country that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bharatam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata. And though the kings and Emperors of Bharat had fought with eachother but when we were attacked by outside forces we have seen that many times Kings put there differences aside to resist the invader ,like When the Indo Greek emperor Menander or Milinda as we Indians know him invaded the Shungas and reached the patliputra,we know that they suddenly retreated back there were many reasons for this like rebellious population of Patliputra, Pushyamitra Shunga threatened to cut their logistics,but one reason was that king Kalinga Kharvela of the Mahameghvan dynasty threatened to invade, when the Arabs were Invading Bharat they were resisted by Kashmir's Lalitaditya to the Chalukyan king Vikramaditya II in today's Karnataka, an arc of resistance kept the invaders at bay for centuries
@@kenkaneki4925 thanks for the reply. we too call a particular area as middle east but doesn’t a country right … in ancient texts they used to call a particular land by its boundaries that doesn’t mean it was a nation by that time. Even Porus stopped Alexander at his place that doesn’t mean he stopped Alexander entering India that was their individual battle. We shouldn’t rely on puranic names as we can’t date them. My intention is that all the battles were to protect their individual benefits rather than a nationality feeling and this is true for mughals also.
Some more suggestions from
# J Sai Deepak
th-cam.com/video/NULZHck68p4/w-d-xo.html
# Abhijit Chavda
th-cam.com/video/JzPuymCGqfM/w-d-xo.html
@qubedoo3289
"What you taught in you text book is rubbish it's garbage"
Voice of a true frustrated citizen who recently find his real history
I was reading R.S Sharma's India's Ancient Past, somehow while reading the book something was bothering me. So I was searching for other Historians books, then I came across your video. Taking ur suggestion I browse through R.C Majumder's Ancient India from the online archive. After some reading, the historical manipulation u were talking about became undoubtedly evident. I placed an order for the book, going to read it throughly. In the future I would love to read 'The History and Culture of the Indian People' its all 11 volume. Though I am not a history student. But I belive its very crucial for everyone to understand its true roots. Thanks a lot sir.🙏🙏🙏
I have RS Sharma's ancient history of India book . Should I read this book ? Pls 🙏 tell me
@@AjayKumarChaudhary-t1v It would be my humble suggestion to you sir, to Read R.C Majumders' Ancient India first, then just because u already have R.S Sharmas' book just compare the two just contents of various chapters (Atleast that's what I did).You'll understand how our history has been manipulated.
Bhai, Ancient India by RC Majumdar ji covers history till 1200 AD.
Can you recommend a book for later history ?
@@GauravPandey-we7rjHistory Of Modern India by R.C Majumdar
0:44 R c Majumdar, jadunath sarkar, Meenakshi jain, sita ram goel, har bilas sarda, g c pande
Started reading books by Dr. Meenakshi Jain. Thanks for your recommendation.
The best book currently for us is Snakes in the Ganga it tells you all the dangers which we will face in next 50 to 100 years
@@dontTalkBullshit bhai konse platform se download kr skte hai ye book jo aapne btayi
@@SahilSharma-cz1ox bhai kharidni padgei aisa koi platform mujhe nhi jaha ye book free me available ho
@@SahilSharma-cz1oxI can send u pdf
@@shiwanktiwari6395konsi website hai
Absolutely straight forward and pinpointed suggestions.
Thank you, Dipakji !
I think right in India is gaining scholars like him. Good to see an intellectual debate in the public, which are most often dominated by the left.
Proud of myself that i didn't pay any attention during history classes in school. Lol.
Rc Majumdar
Jadunath sarkar
Har bilas sarda
G c pande
Meenakshi jain
Sita ram goel - historic hindu resistance to Muslim invaders
Vikram sampath
We read Meenakshi Jain, was hunting for non fiction history of India so found your books as well, we know school books were always wrong.. Sanskrit is mother of all languages .. watch movies of freedom fightings of all types of freedom fighters, Indian freedom fighters and foreign freedom fighters, read non fiction on griefs pains suffered abroad and in India for Centuries, then you understand that how big is the hidden history which is to be found on own like told in this video..
RC Majumdar is a legend in terms of Indian history
Bro there are many books of his. Which one do you think is the best to start with?
प्राचीन भारत
Ancient history by RC Majumdar is also helpful for UPSC gs and mains prep.
You can also refer ncert Makkhan Lal ancient Indian history far better then RS Sharma
Sir, when I searched for the correct Indian history in English, then I found your video, this is what I do in Hindi, then hundreds of thousands of competitive exams come.
I gave up UPSC dream because i could not digest the ncert nonsense
For UPSC what I figured out is I can filter the History from RC Majumdar's book with respect to UPSC syllabus and then learn and present the answer in balanced way in Exam, I do not know if it is feasible but I have started the process. I am also in search of History books which does not has Marxist influence in it, to prepare for UPSC and I will do that by clubbing the imp contents from Nationalist Historian Books even if they are scattered
@@keshava470 same
@@keshava470Watch Sai's video for civil services aspirants
@@saurabhshrivastavCould you please provide some suggestions for Indian history books? I'm looking for books that offer accurate details about our past.
Started reading your book.Thank you. Flipkart deliverd me it yesterday.
Govt Should change farji NCERT History...
You are giving great details all the time! Thanks. Regards!!!
Whatever DI Deepak said is correct 💯.
Very true till 1947 the Hindu high is too good and people were more United in those times alone but after the bloody Nehru Civilization entire a generation lost the Hindu hope. Even within Hindu there are snakes being anti hindu.
It's high time we start educating our children what is true.
Send them to iskon, temples, gurukulas rather than sending them to missionary schools. Nothing is achieved there at the end of day. You will not be lived by English all the life. You have to stand on Dharma
Learn Hindu literature. If it's complicated listen to saints sages and those who propagate hindu
Eg. Chaganti koteswara garu, garikapati Garu (telugu).
Never Ever be afraid of being Hindu.
Feel Proud that you have Hindu blood which is source of this existence right from Satya, thretha, dwapara Yuga to Kali yuga
You are right Deepak. I am ordering your book today
thank u for giving us the correct list of real good books
J Sai Deepak -Modern Day Gem of Bharat
Should publish in all indian languages
Thank you sir.
Best advice for Indian
Learn it correctly before it is too late
Iam going to read it❤
Kindly bring your these books in Regional languages. You will get many readers waiting to get enlightened
Thank you Sir, I will .
Mughal history and British history of India is important for contemporary world as the social , political, economical condition today is very relevant to the situations and impact of those ..this is the reason this period of our indian history is prime part of syllabus and important to study primarily ... It is important to study why we became slave so that we don't repeat those mistakes .
We should know why we became slaves, but what has been written after that is rubbish. How Indians were portrayed as workers for the empire is what is taught to us, instead of how Indians struggled throughout that period and fought for freedom was either removed or just briefly ended with a line. When I read the struggle of freedom led by Nelson Mandela and other people, it inspired me. When I did that for our struggle all I found was, how amazing the Mughals were and they gave us such rich art. How the Brits gave us the blessings of English and made us civilized... Those same Brits now come to our country and look for our culture abandoning their own. So what good is our history book? Except helping qualify UPSC
Yes
I know of multi millionaires here that do not know a shit of history. Is ' his story' that important.
History was written by the white supremacists with a glass of wine in one hand and a cigar in the other and some brown supremacists follow it.
We were not slaves dumbass ..first read ...we were oppressed by these invaders but later we fought and reclaimed it . We have to read neutral perspectives from both the side not some biased and paid historian books. That's what he is talking about
Are you planning to, or by any chance passed from JNU? You have to clear away the foggy cloud of secularism, liberalism from your mind. Roots of Ancient Indian civilization is spread till span of southern and norther American dating even before the time of Mayank and Olmec, we have (had) a knowledge base that educated the entire world and our universities were burned down by intruders. And you think Mughal histor and british histor is important. Bro read Gita and Ramayan. You anit-Indian sentiments may be due to 2 reasons, 1.) your mind is clouded with fad ideas or liberalism 2.) You are born of either British or Mughal father.
We should find and read the real history of india first. Thank you sir for these books ❤
Excellent j sai Deepak sir
Very surprisingly you have only 5k vew when I am seeing this,may be our society is not ready for you,I request you to come to as many podcasts as you could and speak in Hindi, people of my country and specially State must hear you, God bless you,and good luck, with love and respect..
Hi J Sai, its hard to get the right history about bharat. Should we setup a seperate youtyube channel , that may will work better than trying to find and read the books.
Need to keep spreading the REAL HISTORY as many ways as possible
You are awesome, I love your English the way you speak 👍👍🙏🙏🙏
they still teach us aryan invasion theory even though it had been proved a myth by many...a long time ago
J.Sai Deepak sir
Plz read Chidanand Murthy who is a true historian n Karnataka.
He has written book on " Tipu Sultan"
n Kannada with proofs & facts.
S.L.Bairappa another renowned writer
challends tht nobody or no historian knows more abt Tipu Sultan. He has not written a book on Tipu Sultan
He has lot of materials on Tipu
If historians like Vikram Sampath
or so on wish to write on Tipu thn they can contact S.L.Bairappa fr contents wth strong facts.
Thank you...
Keep up your good work
What are we supposed to do if our textbooks are printed by this
Jay Hind sir...Salute u sir..thank you Dear
him>>>
Today I had a thought.is India truly got independence? Bcz we are still a slave of western culture.i am not trying to preach anybody.but just think do we really respect our culture? Do we know about our history .India has some drawbacks like dowry,women oppression, untouchability etc.But the same India has principles, spirituality,yoga, meditation, humanity..Don't know where we are now heading to? But we are slowly becoming machines and running away from being a human.just a deep rant
Thank you
Which book should i read to study about Ashoka Samrat?
Right sir
Thank you so much sir❤❤❤
Respected sir my daughter is in 10th class ,she is asking me always why we read about French revolution in our books ???? Where is our true history??? I have no answer .why books not teach us about our culture agricultural our dance our local artists our poet .If Im studying English literature there is no indin poet Why plz do some thing for this .
If you really like history , you have to study by yourself . The history taught in school is not wrong , history overall is supposed to teach a person to realise their mistakes and go ahead.
As far as I know despite the RTI point that respect deepak sir makes , there is plenty research done at least according to sources tagged on Wikipedia , which suggests that the mughals did in fact build and preserve temples albeit this was done in order to please the Rajputs who were hindu communities.
They were simultaneously also responsible for destroying multiple temples.
Learning history is never wasted as they act as case studies.
Apart from that there are plenty of indian poets in language based classes for regional as well as hindi lectures , most of the english lit work is derived from english classics at least back when I did my schooling , although I do remember the books did change to more simpler language while we had much tougher english.
Most of the NCERT books only touch up on things at most mentioning one or two lines about something including history books, in fact they do actually summarise events like plassey or whole biographies in one paragraph , in every subject they are meant to provide you an introduction on everything , there were plenty of references to indian culture and dances etc. as far as I remember , and im pretty sure there used be a subsection of SST in lower grades where they did teach that.
Hence they are also considered great material to study from .
Fantastic work…awakening
i have both of them, got to read them now
❤❤❤❤❤❤
I think one should read all type of literature and decide with his or her own wisdom that's who is saying in an unbiased way or who is biased
Thanq sir .
I don't know about this RS Sharma book... I bought RS Sharma Medival India book then i saw all the references and content then i compared to INDIA THAT IS BHARAT Book..Then i knew how they hide all the independent times and Hindu tenures were hindu knowledgeable point has been not written over the book 🤷🤷
But sir we need to read them as they are the part of our syllabus! Change our syllabus so that we can throw that garbage permanently
You are gonna be real sad when you realize Atal ji had these books written 🤣
Read those to pass the exams not to gain knowledge
You are right.
Yeah he’s right wing jingoistic
@@sahilyadavvvvv of course, anyone who loves our culture and embrace it is a "right wing" (Nationalist). Anyone who is hell bent on destroying the native culture and identity is left wing (Anti National)..
@@sahilyadavvvvvand u r a librandu
@@chintansolanki2852 yeah you’re a neo nazi 😂
Problem with the books that he has mentioned is, they are extremely expensive! As much as I would want to read Dr.Jain, none of her books are below ₹800. Becomes quite difficult for a student to purchase them.
Use library
@@sannibabukandala6933libraries are not available in every nook and corner of the country and if they did they hardly have the books that he has mentioned. You are saying use library as if your father has provided libraries for the whole world😂😂😂
Thanku
Today I Ordered "india that is bharat" book in flipkart
Very sorry state of affair..The govt needs to take urgent steps to make our children aware of the great civilisation we are part of.
thank you Sir
Basically I'm from medical field but I want to study my country history so anyone please suggest me some books which are in basic language, straight to the point.
Google needs to reinstate the history of India.
Agreed ,But what has Hindutva Led BJP party done to rewrite NCERT history texts. NOTHING .So why keep blaming Leftist's
Agree with u ,I am pretty much disappointed with the current government
Wonder if the new NEP-compliant books will change anything
Both have their flaws
It takes time
The BJP wrote these books 🤣🤣 They were written by MMJ and a committee by Neeladri Bhatacharya a JNU Historian
Source: NCERT through the ages by Outlook India
Great knowledge
Read book written by Jadunath Sarkar and RC Majumdar.
Yes
Based
I am with u
4:01 New more faces is yet to be added in the picture
3:58 to 4:00 is super hilarious 😂
This video is “rubbish”
@@ramyaaaa Why?? Being a history department student from DELHI UNIVERSITY and JNU I know what j.sai deepak is saying. Marxist Historians has their own propoganda which is only economic centric and full of feudalistic approach. D.D koshambi imposed the direct european feudalism theory on Indian society which was inspired by the european marxist scholar known as Marc Bloch. Do you really think that comparing European society and Indian society from the perspective of a western marxist scholar is a good thing??
You can come and debate anyday. From satish chandra books to Romila thapar books Or from Karl max to lynn white jr...
@@KumarKumar-sp5mn then you must also know that old Marxist theories have been refuted and revised. I do not subscribe to the Marxist way of thinking but I would never say that historians belonging to this school of thought are idiots. Marxist frameworks are good for looking at things from a particular perspective. But they are not absolute - nothing is absolute, at the end of the day. I know what being context specific means and I also know that Marxist theories are best suited for the transition debate & 18th-19th century Europe. India was diverse, and still is, but his (Deepak’s) approach is not correct, in my opinion. This guy is also talking about Jadunath Sarkar. Why aren't you questioning the credibility of his claim, being a history student & all? even his theories have been debated upon by historians. I also think that this guy shouldn't be taken seriously because he said that Romila Thapar, Irfan Habib should be thrown out of this country. Is this not his own propaganda ? Whatever, their viewpoints are, he has no right to claim who should and shouldn't be a part of this country. He is a lawyer, not a historian so I don't expect him to have all the historical knowledge in this world either.
Sir , how do we demolish Aryans theory which west keep teaching . They say .. sythians gave India Sanskrit & religion ..and you were uncivilized .
I still see many youtubers Germans & Dutch calling themselves pure Aryans ..I feel they didn't learned from holocaust
Jadunath sardar
GC Pandey
Dr Meenakshi jain
Seetaram goel
Harbilas sarda
Thank you btother
Had Netaji been the prime minister of Independent India we would have learnt true Indian history in schools!!
Desperation stinks…
Plz recommend books in hindi also
Agree sir
Whether upsc and other govt organisations also used the recommended books or old ncerts in their exams ??
ye system hee angrezo ka banaya hua h to tumhe loda marks milega authenti books ka tumhe whi likhnaa h jo madarchod muaslimo aur angrezo ne krwaya h
I have same question
Can anyone suggest a good book that covers history after 1200 AD
1. R.C.Majumdar History and Culture of Indian People (Volume 5 and 6)
2. R.C. Majumdar An advanced History of India
3. H.M. Elliot The History Of INDIA as told by Its own Historians : THE MUHAMMADAN PERIOD
@@bharatiyaindia2709 thank you very much 🙏🏻
RS Sharma is a bihari legend!
Love U sir❤️
🙏🏽👍🏽
Can someone explain me why he said ‘’They teach you Marxist school of nonsense. Whats the context? How indian historians while writing books on indian history can teach us about marxism??
The history which we read in our NCERT books is flawed and is written with bias against Hindus.
For eg, the NCERT mentions how great Mughals were , how secular Akhbar was ( according to NCERT he was a secular who built temples which is utterly false), the disgusting part is glorification of Gandhi and Nehru, calling the real freedom fighters radical , Aryan invasion theory, the so called great mother Teresa, Raja rammohan Roy and his lies, etc.
Not a single line about AZAAD HIND FAUJ and The real father of nation Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
@@vartika8176 okay. Got it. But Why he said they teach ''MARXIST'' school of nonsense? Why he said Marxist??????
@@parthgautam4605 Marxist historiography represents Indian history as a running theme of exploitation” and there is nothing in the textbooks about Indian achievements in maths and science. Left historians “attacked the sanctity of the cow and Brahmins” by claiming that beef was a staple in ancient India for which there is no evidence.
He said marxist school of nonsense bcz our books do not tell us about real rulers. I am sure you must have also noticed that in the chapters about of the great rulers of india we are being taught about mughals , how come mughals = great indian rulers. They were invaders. Marxism do not allow any space of yogic studies. No spiritual studies as well.
Their whole agenda is to make people of india ( particularly all hindus which includes sikhs, budhist, jains, etc) believe in Aryan Invasion Theory even though they do not have any evidence to prove it.
This is all marxist nonsense.
I suggest you to read more about this on google .
swarajyamag.com/magazine/what-are-we-teaching-our-children
news.careers360.com/ncert-book-textbook-syllabus-panel-history-social-science-school-amu-jamia-millia-sanjeev-sanyal-indian-knowledge-system
》Please do read these 2 articles bcz it covers every thing and you will have more clarity.
I will read ur book mate.
I am not agree with you because you should read atleast something
What is the Best book for british period history?
A best book doesn't exist
You are the great sir🙏🙏🙏
Can these books help me out even in UPSC???
Most of them are fiction.
@@siddheshchavan2642 I would agree with u if there is no reference to his content ...
@@siddheshchavan2642 your leftist
@@Gajanan-db4vy Definitely not
But I am curious student of History who had completed masters & PGDM in History.
History always relate with truth-evidence & only Centrist can justify it.😊
@@siddheshchavan2642 that's my point.
Need this in tamil
वो सब ठीक है सर जी लेकिन ये रवीश कुमार और बाकी लोगो का फोटो क्यों लगाया समझा नही
Again you asking to repeat the same mistake sir. Completely ingoring the Mughal history is not a healthy way. Sorry to say this it's reminding me of right wing vs left wing that I watched last night on TV news. Why both of these eliminated by Ctrl+alt+delete ? Somehow now we become mixed bag of all religions so our history books also should be touching all of the information (about Mughals as well as hindutva and others ) so it must not feels lopsided
O le le le le le
Could some one suggest good books on pre Mughal history especially focussed on Technology, science, Medicine systems
You can start with
India's glorious scientific tradition &
Ancient Hindu Science
🙏🏽👍🏽🙏🏽
Can Anyone Send Me The Full Video Link..
IWill Redding on that online or offline Jaya prakash Nagatihli
Amar Chitra Katha Says Great Mughals.
What about Bipan Chandra
Is bipin chandra books are leftist?
And tell me which books i should read for nationalist movements and modern history after Independence and before independence..
Like medival history and about mughals, and revolts againts mughals and islamic invaders..
Tell me Authors with their book title, not just wrote Author names..
Because i am also a student from science side, so, i don't know, and does not have enough time to search each and every author to search about...
Kya kah diyA ENGLISH ME KUCH SAMAJH NAHI AAYA
👍👍
Bharat behaved as one? Do not Indian sub continent Kings fought with each other to occupy the thrones? Is there a nationality feeling prior to Moghal invasion to India? Sir please suggest and leave it to the understanding of people. Please don't say don't read let the readers judge. I can understand your intention with respect.
Exactly.
You don't know about Chandragupta and Chanakya who stopped Alexander. Don't comment only after reading Mughal period.
What he means by Bharat behaved as one he means it as a civilization,where all of the Indian from all parts of the nation saw each other as part of one culture,now you would say but there was no concept on India or Bharat but no there was a concept of Bharat before the British and Mughals ,India has been mentioned as Bharatvarsha in Vishnu Purana, Vayu Purana, Linga Purana, Brahmanda Purana, Agni Purana, Skanda Purana, Khanda and Markandaya Purana. Vishnu Purana clearly says in it
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् । वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
This shloka means: “The country that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bharatam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata.
And though the kings and Emperors of Bharat had fought with eachother but when we were attacked by outside forces we have seen that many times Kings put there differences aside to resist the invader ,like When the Indo Greek emperor Menander or Milinda as we Indians know him invaded the Shungas and reached the patliputra,we know that they suddenly retreated back there were many reasons for this like rebellious population of Patliputra, Pushyamitra Shunga threatened to cut their logistics,but one reason was that king Kalinga Kharvela of the Mahameghvan dynasty threatened to invade, when the Arabs were Invading Bharat they were resisted by Kashmir's Lalitaditya to the Chalukyan king Vikramaditya II in today's Karnataka, an arc of resistance kept the invaders at bay for centuries
@@kenkaneki4925 thanks for the reply. we too call a particular area as middle east but doesn’t a country right … in ancient texts they used to call a particular land by its boundaries that doesn’t mean it was a nation by that time. Even Porus stopped Alexander at his place that doesn’t mean he stopped Alexander entering India that was their individual battle. We shouldn’t rely on puranic names as we can’t date them. My intention is that all the battles were to protect their individual benefits rather than a nationality feeling and this is true for mughals also.
@@LOHPURUSHA i think Porus stopped Alexander without any involvement of Chandra Gupta or Chanakya
What about bipin chandra, is he leftist?
Vetses of nature