Learn more with me on how to become better at homebrewing: solo.to/drhansbrewery Gear I Use and recommend over at Amazon: bit.ly/drhanssf Visit my website for my free ebook: bit.ly/DrHans
Another interesting experiment! For me, the results point to the efficiency of pressure fermenting when it comes to keeping oxygen out of the equation, rather than the effectiveness of flushing a bottle with CO2 (or not). (And, also, the effectiveness of your bottling technique!) You are transferring beer to the bottle that is already carbonated and saturated with CO2, and, added to this, you are also squeezing the bottle so that beer reaches the opening and pushes any O2 out before capping. Once capped, the dissolved CO2 present in the beer release to fill the headspace. Which brings me to the final point, which is the headspace in a bottle is already very small, so by doing this you are effectively eliminating pretty much all O2, regardless of whether the bottles were preflushed with CO2. I believe that if the beer hadn't been squeezed to the top of the bottle before capping, and the headspace was larger, then the results may well have been different. The great news is that it IS possible to bottle NEIPA without suffering oxidation - at least for a week or so, anyway. Keep up the great work!
Great video :) I recently opened two bottles that were bottled with the Boel itap 6 months ago. The beer was wonderfull, which surpriced me actually. The Itap is awesome
Awesome video man! Would love a video where you bottle straight from the fermzilla and let it sit for a month or two. I think a lot of people (including me) don’t have the money or space for a keezer, so i think it would be very interesting to see the effect on the beer if it stays bottled for longer.
I'm in the 'a week isn't long enough to oxidise' camp. Shame you didnt just leave it another few weeks doc! most of my bottled from bucket beers didn't really oxidise much until week 3
Don't be dissapointed. Another great video. What we do know is that if theres a difference, it does not show in a week. That is good to know. This also shows your fermentation and transfer is clean. An ecouragement to maintain clean process. Therefore proof two things, excellent. Maybe a 'bad' control would have been a half fill bottle 'unflushed' and shake it. I'm sure the oxygen would have ruined the beer, right? But what if we don't shake it. Will C02 push oxy to the top and keep the beer good. Maybe an experiment. Cheer doc.
Try this again with these conditions: 1 bottle no purge no foam cap, 1 bottle itap purge no foam cap, 1 bottle itap purge foam cap, 1 bottle soda flush + itap purge cap on foam. Let them all sit for 6 weeks. See if any make a difference. Suspect the itap side filling action prevents most of the o2 contact and its pushed out with the foam cap.
I really appreciate this video and research! I've been lead to believe crown caps can let air in. That might make a difference. Good to know PET bottles are reliable and we don't need to be too serious about purging the headspace.
Vitamin C is getting a space in my heart, I use it to guarantee no Chlorine in my initial water. I over do-it but maybe I can split a tablet between beginning and end of brew-day.
Thanks for doing this video. As I commented on the previous video - my bottles oxidised before being sold to a shop using the itap. Mine were fine the 1st week. The 2 week mark, all oxidised. However, I still have around 30 bottles in the fridge 2-3 months on, and they aren’t any further oxidised to how they were at the 2 week point. Also still taste reasonable but just not as fresh as when dispensed from the keg
Transparent bottles, nevermind the vacuum bags and have a control bottle intentionally treated badly - perhaps poured from a pitcher* or straight from a regular tap with into the bottle. *although you might have to force carbonate that bottle as well then, to account for any loss of co2?
Also I think you can cut down on the amount of iTap samples and add another using a 'ghetto blaster' - it would be interesting to see if there's any difference.
Looking at it wrong way round buddy! Experiment doesn't suck... experiment shows the iTap does a great job and you don't need to faff about. Success I'd say
@@mtrout3394 yes, now we know that you should be able to ship sensitive beer mails in one week without issues. Now I can take it further. It's an awesome base to stand on.
If you squeeze the bottle removing all Oxygen carrying air before capping there will be no Oxygen to oxygenate. This would mean flushing is a waste of gas and time. But one flush probably best to be super sure. Why ascorbic acid? What does that do other than adjust PH? I’ve seen you add a citric acid to the mash for PH.
Hi! Squeezing the bottle after its filled does not ilminate oxygenation during the filling. It does a great job removing the head space as you mention. Which is great. Ascorbic acid is an antioxidant. I can't remember using citric acid (but it will work to adjust PH). I've used lemon 🍋 juice though for PH adjustment together with lactic acid in one brew.
@@DrHansBrewery Yes it was Lactic acid you used not citric. You put 2 caps in a 23L batch. Thanks for information and for your work on the vids. I watch them all.
Great stuff, I would love to see it done over a longer period. How would it be after a month maybe, your process is obviously dialed in. Also was thinking adding Ascorbic Acid into the mix, at bottling vs boil might be fun for a split boil batch test too!
it might be interesting to show a more extreme difference in oxidation potential. ie filling a bottle directly from a party tap with no purging vs use of the boel itap. I appreciate what you were trying here, but given the results, which are still valid and useful, didn't show any perceptible difference, this might be the next step
Shouldn't vacuum sealed the bottles to allow the natural pressure difference to effect it and also you should have waited 8-12 weeks I bottle condition my beers and I don't ferment under pressure and my neipas with 500-600 grams of hops for 19 litre batch dont get the oxidation until it been in bottles for over 4 weeks and that is without flushing the bottles with co2 when bottling
From what I've learned a strait pour from a keg is good for 24hrs. With flushing, 1 week. Closed loop transferring and flushing, up to one month. Even commercial hazies start going bad by 2mo.
@@DrHansBrewery I have used the picnic tap to tap the beer from plastic cap but it didn't fizzy as i pour it out but by hand(like pouring the soda bottle). The fizzy dramatically differrent but i try to buy some pressure filler to fill it to the bottle but I 'm not sure, Is it gonna work well ?
Learn more with me on how to become better at homebrewing: solo.to/drhansbrewery
Gear I Use and recommend over at Amazon: bit.ly/drhanssf
Visit my website for my free ebook: bit.ly/DrHans
Your channel is great, I never miss a episode
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
That's a really good experience. I am glad that I found your channel, very good content! Thanks for making this happen.
Thanks mate, glad you found it useful
Another interesting experiment! For me, the results point to the efficiency of pressure fermenting when it comes to keeping oxygen out of the equation, rather than the effectiveness of flushing a bottle with CO2 (or not). (And, also, the effectiveness of your bottling technique!) You are transferring beer to the bottle that is already carbonated and saturated with CO2, and, added to this, you are also squeezing the bottle so that beer reaches the opening and pushes any O2 out before capping. Once capped, the dissolved CO2 present in the beer release to fill the headspace. Which brings me to the final point, which is the headspace in a bottle is already very small, so by doing this you are effectively eliminating pretty much all O2, regardless of whether the bottles were preflushed with CO2. I believe that if the beer hadn't been squeezed to the top of the bottle before capping, and the headspace was larger, then the results may well have been different. The great news is that it IS possible to bottle NEIPA without suffering oxidation - at least for a week or so, anyway. Keep up the great work!
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Very interesting, thanks for taking the time and making the effort, always a good watch :)
Thanks Neo, much appreciated. Cheers 🍻
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
@@DrHansBrewery Excellent, always enjoy your new videos.......:)
Itap delivers everytime👍
Great video :) I recently opened two bottles that were bottled with the Boel itap 6 months ago. The beer was wonderfull, which surpriced me actually. The Itap is awesome
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Awesome video man!
Would love a video where you bottle straight from the fermzilla and let it sit for a month or two. I think a lot of people (including me) don’t have the money or space for a keezer, so i think it would be very interesting to see the effect on the beer if it stays bottled for longer.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
I'm in the 'a week isn't long enough to oxidise' camp. Shame you didnt just leave it another few weeks doc! most of my bottled from bucket beers didn't really oxidise much until week 3
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
I like your "sighs" you do 😂 its like your frustrated at having to teach us stuff 😂 do it more!
Hahaha, is it that obvious 🤣
Don't be dissapointed. Another great video. What we do know is that if theres a difference, it does not show in a week. That is good to know. This also shows your fermentation and transfer is clean. An ecouragement to maintain clean process. Therefore proof two things, excellent. Maybe a 'bad' control would have been a half fill bottle 'unflushed' and shake it. I'm sure the oxygen would have ruined the beer, right? But what if we don't shake it. Will C02 push oxy to the top and keep the beer good. Maybe an experiment. Cheer doc.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Try this again with these conditions: 1 bottle no purge no foam cap, 1 bottle itap purge no foam cap, 1 bottle itap purge foam cap, 1 bottle soda flush + itap purge cap on foam. Let them all sit for 6 weeks. See if any make a difference. Suspect the itap side filling action prevents most of the o2 contact and its pushed out with the foam cap.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
I really appreciate this video and research! I've been lead to believe crown caps can let air in. That might make a difference. Good to know PET bottles are reliable and we don't need to be too serious about purging the headspace.
He squeezed the bottle to remove all the headspace before capping. It would be interesting to see what happens if you leave headspace with air.
@@helimed01 Why don't we just squeeze out the headspace on a PET bottle like the Dr did, if we know it works from this?
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Vitamin C is getting a space in my heart, I use it to guarantee no Chlorine in my initial water.
I over do-it but maybe I can split a tablet between beginning and end of brew-day.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Thanks for doing this video. As I commented on the previous video - my bottles oxidised before being sold to a shop using the itap. Mine were fine the 1st week. The 2 week mark, all oxidised. However, I still have around 30 bottles in the fridge 2-3 months on, and they aren’t any further oxidised to how they were at the 2 week point. Also still taste reasonable but just not as fresh as when dispensed from the keg
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
@@DrHansBrewery that’s great. Can’t wait to watch it. Will look out for the notification
"No, this video sucks" haha I love it. Good video man, no result is a result my man.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Great vid! I recommend using a pressure washer to bottle the beer and you should see some interesting results! Cheers!
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
tack för ett fett test! , min egen erfarenhet är att mina öl blivit ok oavsett hur jag kört med Itap.:)
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Hey Dr Hans, one week is not long enough for effects of oxidation to activate. You should wait 2-3 months then sample..
2-3 months is the lifespan of a hazy. Even commercial hazies will be going bad by then. For a homebrew hazy you're lucky if it's fresh after a month.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Transparent bottles, nevermind the vacuum bags and have a control bottle intentionally treated badly - perhaps poured from a pitcher* or straight from a regular tap with into the bottle.
*although you might have to force carbonate that bottle as well then, to account for any loss of co2?
Also I think you can cut down on the amount of iTap samples and add another using a 'ghetto blaster' - it would be interesting to see if there's any difference.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Idea? Doc' could you use a flame thrower to burn the oxygen from the empty bottle?
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Looking at it wrong way round buddy! Experiment doesn't suck... experiment shows the iTap does a great job and you don't need to faff about.
Success I'd say
Yes you're right, it was a success. A lot of great data here to learn from.
@@DrHansBrewery maybe another one but leave for a month instead of a week...that should magnify any difference
@@mtrout3394 yes, now we know that you should be able to ship sensitive beer mails in one week without issues. Now I can take it further. It's an awesome base to stand on.
@@DrHansBrewery great work Dr!!
@@mtrout3394 Thanks
Hey Doctor, maybe in next experiment try using transparent bottles and just leave them at room temp (recording?) to watch the color changing. Cheers!
Sounds like a good time-laps experiment. Thanks for the suggestion
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
@@DrHansBrewery Hey Doc, awesome, really looking for the results! Cheers!
If you squeeze the bottle removing all Oxygen carrying air before capping there will be no Oxygen to oxygenate. This would mean flushing is a waste of gas and time. But one flush probably best to be super sure. Why ascorbic acid? What does that do other than adjust PH? I’ve seen you add a citric acid to the mash for PH.
Hi! Squeezing the bottle after its filled does not ilminate oxygenation during the filling. It does a great job removing the head space as you mention. Which is great. Ascorbic acid is an antioxidant. I can't remember using citric acid (but it will work to adjust PH). I've used lemon 🍋 juice though for PH adjustment together with lactic acid in one brew.
@@DrHansBrewery Yes it was Lactic acid you used not citric. You put 2 caps in a 23L batch. Thanks for information and for your work on the vids. I watch them all.
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Great stuff, I would love to see it done over a longer period. How would it be after a month maybe, your process is obviously dialed in. Also was thinking adding Ascorbic Acid into the mix, at bottling vs boil might be fun for a split boil batch test too!
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
You rock DrHans!!
@@96FiRE96 Thanks
it might be interesting to show a more extreme difference in oxidation potential. ie filling a bottle directly from a party tap with no purging vs use of the boel itap. I appreciate what you were trying here, but given the results, which are still valid and useful, didn't show any perceptible difference, this might be the next step
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Shouldn't vacuum sealed the bottles to allow the natural pressure difference to effect it and also you should have waited 8-12 weeks I bottle condition my beers and I don't ferment under pressure and my neipas with 500-600 grams of hops for 19 litre batch dont get the oxidation until it been in bottles for over 4 weeks and that is without flushing the bottles with co2 when bottling
Your video sucks and your channel sucks!! KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK!
Seriously tho the Yankees suck and you should be wearing a Milwaukee hat.
@@Lumpy50 Send one and I will wear it for you in a video :D
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
@@DrHansBrewery When I get one I'll have to get you one. I was a Cleveland Indian fan; but we're not allowed to say that anymore.
By airbourne it will not extend.
You reach 500 likes on the video, so you have to do another, like you promised in the video ;)
😱 never thought that would actually happen. What did I actually promise?
Why did you use pet?
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
492 👍 keep them coming Dr.
Love the content
Thanks
I think you meant to say "if none of the beers are bad then this video is gonna suck." Cause we expect and want some of the beers to be bad.
Yes that's exactly what I meant!
@@DrHansBrewery helping with your English.
:)
Perhaps a week was not long enough. Maybe a month or more is what was needed?
I have had Neipas that has been shipped to me that has gone bad in under a week from bottling from the keg.
From what I've learned a strait pour from a keg is good for 24hrs. With flushing, 1 week. Closed loop transferring and flushing, up to one month. Even commercial hazies start going bad by 2mo.
Is it fizzy ?
What is fizzy?
@@DrHansBrewery I have used the picnic tap to tap the beer from plastic cap but it didn't fizzy as i pour it out but by hand(like pouring the soda bottle). The fizzy dramatically differrent but i try to buy some pressure filler to fill it to the bottle but I 'm not sure, Is it gonna work well ?
@@goozavar got it, yes the beer keeps it carbonation well after being bottled with a counter pressure filler.
@@DrHansBrewery Thank you, Useful comment. :)
@@goozavar no worries
Well ill be damned!
Sounds like a brulosophy experiment lol tasters could tell any discernable difference.
Yup maybe a longer test period is needed...
Hahaha yes, I know exactly what you mean 😅
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
Thank you good doctor. Maybe your bitch proof method worked too well and protected the beer too well .
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!
I guess in 3 weeks you can see the difference
Maybe, this time it was the beer mail approach and I will always drink the hoppy beers asap. 🍻
I'm working on a special episode commenting on your comments on this video!