Prof Irfan Habib is a legend. In this interview, he is very articulate. It is always a great pleasure to listen to him. Prof Surender Bhutani in Warsaw (Poland)
He is no legend in India. He has a blot over him for misleading the Muslim community over Ayodhya. He and his students lied in the court of law about Ram Janmabhoomi. His knowledge is restricted to only Muslim community and Delhi centric Mughal history
Great conversation. Irfan Habib is a legendary icon in Indian History. You have asked very important questions and your way to ask is also very impressive.
Prof. Irfan Habib sahab se guftugu ho to wo kitni qeemti hogi iska andaza krna mushkil hai..Aise scholar ko sunna fakhr ki baat hai..Kyunki yahan jazbaat se nahin haqiqat se guftugu hoti hai...Tradition se zyada reason per focus kiya jata hai... Bahut ilmi session hai ye Prof Irfan Habib sahab k sath.. Bahut shukrya rekhta ka aur Irfan sahab ka..
Irfan Saheb is very frail and twilight of his life. More such conversations ahould be recorded off him to get the gist of his whole life studying history. The topics he touches in - no 9ne has even heard about it before. Esp fascinating was Akbar and Dara Shikoh thought dufferences. Amazing interview.. thanks
Sir, As an Indian muslim historian the fate of mughal sultanate is well known to all historians. Mr Jinnah had opened a door for all Indian Muslims. The tragedy is that Indian muslims overwhelmingly did not avail that opportunity and ended up in perennial confusion and pain.
The Interviewer has good voice and way of asking questions. Questions are also good. But he jumps from one topic to another too fast without exploriing anything in detail. Only touches them superficiously.
Recently came across an interview on Lallantop, where KK Mohd the archeologist (related to Ram Janmbhoomi) gave a scathing criticism of Irfan Habib. I am finding it hard to respect his opinions after watching that interview.
आदरणीय हबीब साहब:- आपने मानव गणेश के सिर पर हाथी का सिर लगाने पर कटाक्ष किया और हिन्दू ओ के कुछ धार्मिक विश्वास पर कटाक्षकिया लेकिन मुस्लिम्स के स्वर्ग और वहाँ मिलने वाली सुरा सुन्दरी पर चर्चा तक नही किया.पृथ्वी चपटी है इस पर भी कुछनही कुछ नही कहा. मैनै ईसाई धर्म मे भी बहुत से अन्ध विश्वास देखा हैऔर पढा है मेरा आशय यह है कि जहाँ धर्म हैवही पाखन्ड भी है और काल्पानिक कहानियाँ भी है. कोई भी धर्म इससे अछूता नही है.
इंटरव्यू बिल्कुल भी मूल्यवान नहीं है। इंटरव्यू लेने वाले ने इतिहास की जटिल और विवादित सिद्धांतों, निष्कर्षों पर बात नहीं की। इतिहास की विभिन्न पद्धतियों पर भी बात नहीं की। जिस मयार के इरफ़ान हबीब साहब हैं उस मयार के सवाल पूछने वाले नहीं हैं, बल्कि बात करने के दौरान वे हबीब साहब के सामने बहुत दबे-दबे से लगे
And they ( musalmsn) did defend India in 1979,in 1994,in 2001,in 2020 did you understand how I believe you did if not open the books and observe the recent past happenings specially from 1979 till 2020 and even now!! Yes the statement was foolish but ironically it got true when Pakistan buffered the whole geopolitics after 1947!!
Hindu sabda perian(farsi ) sabda hai arbi nahi .The Persians designated the land around the Indus River as Hindu, a mispronunciation of the Sanskrit sindhu(river) . Then this word commonly used by many Islamic rulers/invaders during their rule ,with The course of time this word is accepted by common mass .
Since it was Rekhta foundation which was interviewing,a few questions on Urdu was bound to be asked.The interviewer tried to ask all possible questions to Prof Irfan Habib in limited time slot. Nice and informative interview session.
Varanasi ki ASI report bhi padh Lena bevfoof.bad me bataye ga vaha Masjid tha.vaha dekhi to bahar se dikhai deta hi ki Mandir tod ke Masjid banai gai hai.
Lagta hai interviewer historian se nahin kiai poet se baat kar raha hai. Are bhai historian se tareekh ke swaal poocho , political sawal poocho. Magar wahi tendency jo kuch bhi hai urdu hai. Poor interviewer
Prof Irfan Habib is a legend. In this interview, he is very articulate. It is always a great pleasure to listen to him. Prof Surender Bhutani in Warsaw (Poland)
❤❤❤❤❤
Great
@@nuzhatparween3455k 16:5😮😅😅😅mk😢😅6 😅😅😅the only n😮😊that ko😮hmkky🎉jb😅 19:18 19:18 😅😮 21:07 hm😊
@@nuzhatparween3455 q l
He is no legend in India. He has a blot over him for misleading the Muslim community over Ayodhya. He and his students lied in the court of law about Ram Janmabhoomi. His knowledge is restricted to only Muslim community and Delhi centric Mughal history
Great conversation. Irfan Habib is a legendary icon in Indian History. You have asked very important questions and your way to ask is also very impressive.
Generations will agree or disagree..... but Prof Habib will remain a real academic hero 🎉
Prof. Irfan Habib sahab se guftugu ho to wo kitni qeemti hogi iska andaza krna mushkil hai..Aise scholar ko sunna fakhr ki baat hai..Kyunki yahan jazbaat se nahin haqiqat se guftugu hoti hai...Tradition se zyada reason per focus kiya jata hai...
Bahut ilmi session hai ye Prof Irfan Habib sahab k sath..
Bahut shukrya rekhta ka aur Irfan sahab ka..
Listening to prof. Irfan habib sir is always a great pleasure. Attended many lectures of sir in AMU.
A great source of knowledge in Indian history in the context of Urdu language, real pleasure.
th-cam.com/video/QBh_7mCtxmU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=fVAnuV0wr29qgPyX
Prof Irfan Habib has so many gems and experiencea
اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو صحت و سلامتی عطا فرمائے۔آمین
What an experience listening to Prof. Irfan Habib after so long. Thank you for the interview.
Prof Habib is blessing for academic and educated citizens
Hum khoosh naseeb hai ki prof. Irfaan Habib ko sun rahe hai.. unkeye daur mai jee rahe hain..very interested and intellectual discussion..
Hum Apne bujurg se pichle sadee ki kahani sun na ..tarikh ko ankhon se dekhne jaisa hai..thank you rekhta..
Irfan Saheb is very frail and twilight of his life. More such conversations ahould be recorded off him to get the gist of his whole life studying history. The topics he touches in - no 9ne has even heard about it before. Esp fascinating was Akbar and Dara Shikoh thought dufferences. Amazing interview.. thanks
Shukriya Irfaan saab..
He is a living Legend, ❤🎉
Thanks #Rekhta
Bahut hi achha laga .. shukriya rekhta foundation....
عمدہ گ 13:49 عمدہ گفتگو
True legend Irfan Sahebh ...✨🙏✨🙌✨
Melts my heart at 01:04:00
Yes at 1.04.34,
Bhoor behtarin guftagu
बहुत ही सराहनीय कार्यक्रम रेख्ता की टीम को बहुत बहुत बधाई प्रोफेसर साहब को सुनना हमारे लिए गर्व का पल है
Itsa great pleasure to listen Prof Irfan Habib Sir on history and historical evidences on a broad spectrum,
He is living legend
Hatss of you him
I always respect a learnt person.
Cool and nice conversation keep it up
Maza aa gaya..kya BAAT hai..irfaan sahab..
Irfan habeeb sahab ko mera salam
Such a sharp memory at 91😮
That's what I'm thinking of watching this interview.
th-cam.com/video/QBh_7mCtxmU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=fVAnuV0wr29qgPyX
First time i lessen his interview
I Red his name in my school ncert books
Did you learn to ‘red’ from NCERT books?
😂
Highly intellectual discussion...
A great interview
Sir, As an Indian muslim historian the fate of mughal sultanate is well known to all historians.
Mr Jinnah had opened a door for all Indian Muslims. The tragedy is that Indian muslims overwhelmingly did not avail that opportunity and ended up in perennial confusion and pain.
THEEK BAAT. THANX
La ilah il Allah Mohammad Rasul Allah
حسن کی تاثیر پر غالب نہ آسکتا تھا علم.
اتنی نادانی جہاں کے سارے داناؤں میں تھیں.
The Interviewer has good voice and way of asking questions. Questions are also good. But he jumps from one topic to another too fast without exploriing anything in detail. Only touches them superficiously.
Recently came across an interview on Lallantop, where KK Mohd the archeologist (related to Ram Janmbhoomi) gave a scathing criticism of Irfan Habib. I am finding it hard to respect his opinions after watching that interview.
Specific to this interview, you may be right. I too feel that Irfan Habib sahib is not the subject matter expert for most of questions asked anyway.
very nice... simple living
Amazing interview
The interviewer was our urdu teacher in AMU I remember him
The boy who take interview has great knowledge
Very nice..
A true historian not only in India but in the world
I met this legendary historian many times.
Jo history ham padhte hain wo ye dekh chuke hain apne ankhon Se
Respect and love
بہت خوب
Want to see Prof. Faizan Mustafa on rekhta rubaru
Taqreer de dngy Bhai wo
इरफान जी महान इतिहासकार हैं
Very nice 👍
Nice
I am pride to see Irfan Habib
आदरणीय हबीब साहब:- आपने मानव गणेश के सिर पर हाथी का सिर लगाने पर कटाक्ष किया और हिन्दू ओ के कुछ धार्मिक विश्वास पर कटाक्षकिया लेकिन मुस्लिम्स के स्वर्ग और वहाँ मिलने वाली सुरा सुन्दरी पर चर्चा तक नही किया.पृथ्वी चपटी है इस पर भी कुछनही कुछ नही कहा.
मैनै ईसाई धर्म मे भी बहुत से अन्ध विश्वास देखा हैऔर पढा है
मेरा आशय यह है कि जहाँ धर्म हैवही पाखन्ड भी है और काल्पानिक कहानियाँ भी है. कोई भी धर्म इससे अछूता नही है.
इंटरव्यू बिल्कुल भी मूल्यवान नहीं है। इंटरव्यू लेने वाले ने इतिहास की जटिल और विवादित सिद्धांतों, निष्कर्षों पर बात नहीं की। इतिहास की विभिन्न पद्धतियों पर भी बात नहीं की।
जिस मयार के इरफ़ान हबीब साहब हैं उस मयार के सवाल पूछने वाले नहीं हैं, बल्कि बात करने के दौरान वे हबीब साहब के सामने बहुत दबे-दबे से लगे
Exactly 💯
Very nice 💐
And they ( musalmsn) did defend India in 1979,in 1994,in 2001,in 2020 did you understand how I believe you did if not open the books and observe the recent past happenings specially from 1979 till 2020 and even now!! Yes the statement was foolish but ironically it got true when Pakistan buffered the whole geopolitics after 1947!!
Ye legend hn...lekin ye chahte t qaum k liye kuch kr sakte th...lekin nhi kiya..
Mai rekta e jasm nahi janta but janta hoon.
uff! yeh kursian, looks like plastic has replaced the old wooden beint threads...
Khan sahab?
Irfan shab not khan
Hindu sabda perian(farsi ) sabda hai arbi nahi .The Persians designated the land around the Indus River as Hindu, a mispronunciation of the Sanskrit sindhu(river) . Then this word commonly used by many Islamic rulers/invaders during their rule ,with The course of time this word is accepted by common mass .
..............🙏🙏
❤
💛
آپ شاعری میں جو بات کہہ سکتے ہیں وہ نثر میں نہیں ۔
امیر خسرو علائوالدین کے بارے میں کچھ کم لکھتے تو اچھا تھا ۔
معید صاحب زبان سے متعلق سوالات ایک مورخ سے غیر ضروری ہیں۔اس میں ان کا مطالعہ نہیں ہے۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
Janab Aab Bahut Zaheen hai kya India bharat ko ...tan kahna sahi aur Samvedhanik hai kya
P
बौद्धिक शैतान वो भी मीठा बोलनेवाले- को समझना आसान नहीं होता ।
Brainwashed baga baba’s pilla publication..😂😂
Some where i dont understand history professor se unnecessary poetry k sawaal…sawal aur ache ho skatey they
Since it was Rekhta foundation which was interviewing,a few questions on Urdu was bound to be asked.The interviewer tried to ask all possible questions to Prof Irfan Habib in limited time slot. Nice and informative interview session.
Syed sb ye aapka nazaraiya …mujko jo laga wo maine kaha ..
ghareeb. Ko. Roti. , Do. Waqt. Kee. Chahiye. , bane. "Muslim. Rashtara". Ya. "Hindu. Rashtara"!
हिंदुस्तान की जगह भारत कहें।
Punjabi ko bhi Hindvi ya hinko kaha jaata tha.
Ask thoo
Total anti sanatani person.
Varanasi ki ASI report bhi padh Lena bevfoof.bad me bataye ga vaha Masjid tha.vaha dekhi to bahar se dikhai deta hi ki Mandir tod ke Masjid banai gai hai.
SP k jamaane mai hua..
Only in India the bigots and anti nationals is celebrated as Hero. The ignorance of hindus and their lack of dharma is appalling.
Congressi supporter
Truely legend 🙏
Habib sahab ko khujli ho rakha hai..
Brahmmanwadi ko hota he 😅😂😂😂
Budhau ...😂
Lagta hai interviewer historian se nahin kiai poet se baat kar raha hai. Are bhai historian se tareekh ke swaal poocho , political sawal poocho. Magar wahi tendency jo kuch bhi hai urdu hai. Poor interviewer
Irfan sb adab se bhi poori jaankari rakhte hain
Very nice interview (Prof. Mufti Zahid, ex-Chairman, Sunni Teology, AMU, Aligarh.)
Hindu is Sanskrit word... Listen to Pujya Jagatguru Shri Rambhadracharya.... Irfan is leftist .
anyone who is well educated can see through the lies this guy is peddling.
A corrupt historian .
Ye log har mulk me gaddar hotey hain