@@A_Goan South East Asia have so many words derivated from Sanksrit. Thats why. Sadly Sanksrit is not widely spoken anymore by Indians, that is why it is always surpising you guys, as if it is something new. Meanwhile here we already know where it is coming from. :D
I am a Malay from Malaysia but on my father's side, we still have close family in Patani. So close, that my father had first and second cousins that would come and visit us in Pendang, Kedah. From what I gathered, they are not asking to be part of Malaysia. What they want is to be able to PRACTISE being a Malay (to speak Malay, to have a Malay name and to write in Jawi - a Malay script). Thailand is their country but being a Malay is what they are born with. Thai is probably their national identity but Malay is what in their heart is. In other places, you can be who you are, and still be part of the country. Similar to Chinese in Malaysia or Jamaican in the UK. But in Thailand, Malay identity was being suppressed through Siamisation (naming and preference for government jobs). We lost extended family members in the conflict and we do mourn them. If the Thai government stopped looking at these Malays as the "others" and started to look at them as "our Thai nationals", developed the area and embraced that multi-ethnicity and multi-cultural is something to be proud of I am sure, peace can slowly take place in these states. Let's be clear, these states are part of Thailand. But their heart is Malay and help them and make them proud to be part of Thailand. They just want to have some economic prosperity and to live in happiness. From us in Malaysia, we hope our extended families in Patani will always be strong.
Thanks and I would agree with you on this. Learning from Aceh for example, Indonesia (as a Muslim majority nation) conceded to give Aceh more autonomy regarding religion affairs. After failing to hold on to East Timor, a majority Catholic land with unique ethnicity. The southern Thai issue is somewhat similar to Papua issue in Indonesia. Ethnicity and religion they are closer to Papua New Guinea but ruled by majority Moslems in Jakarta.
They didn't want to be like the other Malay people of Southern Thailand such Satun (new generation), Songkhla, Krabi or even in Bangkok. Those Malay people can't speak Malay anymore and lose their Malay culture and now to be called Thai Muslim with Thai ethnicity. Not all Thai Muslim was Malay but most of them was Malay that being assimilation especially the peninsular people. Except for Yala, Narathiwat and Patani. Look the Malay people of Southern Myanmar, they still can speak Malay with Kedah Dialect and using Jawi script. Because Myanmar didn't force Malay Muslim to assimilate like Thailand.
Chinese in Thai kingdom experience Siamization processfrom the late of 19th century. This No difference for Malay people in Thai kingdom . Sad but it's the reality
As a Thai, I'm so sorry to all Thai Muslim and who lived in 3 Southern provinces people for everything that happened I wish peoples, friends, families, everyone deserves justice, but everything is too late. 😢🙏 (Sorry if my English is bad.)
Why apologies when you are know the Islamic history they want their domination in the country they are residing first creating chaos and then dominate the country when they have the chance ...please watch from youtube from muslim who have left and protecting the western ideas than the islamic totalitarian ideas who have never evolved since 1400 years where how they have divided former Yugoslavia to become two Islamic state Kosovo and Bosnia, In India they have divided to form Pakistan and Bangladesh, In Thailand they are fighting to form their own state in the South, In Myanmar they want to have their own state in Rohingya, In Philippine they are fighting to form their own state ...well can you see the pattern ...please watch on youtube Apostate Prophet, Ex muslim of America, Friendly muslim, Ex muslim of Norway and many more to understand their Islamic ideology...
Why do you want to apologize where they want to dominate Thai when given the time as how they have changed Indonesia and Malaysia from Hindus and Buddhist as what they have being doing their best ...
Sorry is a cheap word used in Thailand however the damage is those people in the south they won't need anything from Thailand they just want their autonomy, their land back, kingdom of Pattani was a country alone and has nothing to do with Thailand we don't forget that Thailand stole lands from Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar as well, in my opinion the international committee are hypocrite they have make sanctions, embargo against Thailand for those inhuman terrorist activities, Thailand unfortunately as many people don't know is a country that promote hate and violence against minorities and even against tourists who spend money and all foreigners this is a mental disease
why are you following the thai government's narrative ? they were protesting and murdered and now seeking reparations not because they are Muslim , but because they are Patani Malay. There are loads of other muslims in Thailand that don't have this issue because they are ethnically Tai.
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman this is not true. I can tell their ethnicity by just looking at them and ask a few Malay words - majority Muslims in around Bangkok and surroundings provinces are ethnic Malays. Almost none ethic Tai. There are some decendence from Java too. So it you don’t know the issue, it is not ethic or religion - just some jihadist stupid people stirring thing up.
because this is a singapuran news outlet and singapura doesnt support the idea of native people belong to their lands, looking at the country it's de facto a chinese country, but we all know that historically it's not, if native singapuran heard the difference of native people and native land it will start something. i mean look they support israhell as well, that speaks volume bro
@ and how do people treat the other people in their own land? Look at corruption in Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines … who suppress who, who steal from who? Get real bro. Singapore is the most successful nation to bring prosperity to its people of any ethnicity in this area.
@@Freedomnomad555you act and sound like as Singapore doesn't have their own oppression problems, also the only reason Singapore even get rich it's because of Britain so they also corrupted
@@Freedomnomad555 wow singapura is so perfect no supression no thief, you want me to get real? you get real, there is no perfect country. everyone can use google, and find all singapuran social and government problems singapura is chinese country is a fact, singapura is historically melayu land is a fact, singapura support israel is a fact. singapura has its own problem is a fact. get real bro , get real🤙
If I were Thai King , i would humbly visit this area more frequently to show sincerity and win my people's heart. But very unfortunate, this useless king rather spend time in europe than his people..
Thai government should learn from Malaysia using 3 R to strengthen the power of the Thai king and the government. Malaysia use 3R to oppress the NON Muslim the result is very encouraging
@@patrickp8315 ask uk about how they king Charles visit Australia last week. You know how people really fill about some king who conquer other. South Thailand pattani are malay land before British give it away without approval of malay king. Simple answer they malay not Thailand
Of course they wouldn't. They were literally conquered and never once got much of an autonomy after thailand centralization. They're not thai, they're malay.@@patrickp8315
@@azleadam9239He visited australia because it is 2nd england they wiped out real population basically all australian are english....did he go to africa or india or said sorry....saying sorry to muslim is hitting rock to your head they are not thankful and want to implement their rule has soon has their population increse..
The malay muslim in yala narathiwat songkla pattani krabi are seperated from their brothers in malaysia. I used to hired muslim malay lady from bangkok. She told me there are many malay muslim in bangkok. She spoke malay. Used malay name here. But spoke thai and used thai name in thailand
@@Freedomnomad555 We dont really have strong ties with sumatran malay. Our accent is hugely difference except kepri. Unlike the kelantanese who even until today have relatives across border in pattani and their accent is almost identical.
@@zaki-pq1ps Read your history. Even your first Agong post British rule was an Indonesian descent. People of Negeri Sembilan are Minang ethic from West Sumatera (even their food tastes the same like Padang). Lots of people are descendent of Bugis, Javanese, Banjar etc. Here for you to read: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysians_of_Indonesian_descent . Soekarno did Ganyang Malaysia against the British because he considered Malaysia as the British made up puppet country. But ok lah now we are a friendly neighbor, and you should treat Thailand with the same respect for their territorial integrity.
@@Freedomnomad555 That is only for the state of negeri sembilan with strong minang ties. We have rotation system for agong. Just because N9 is like that doesnt mean the whole malaysia is like that. Other state in malaysia barely have any ties with sumatra.
In this case, the separatists killed teachers, soldiers, and policemen. The Thai government compensated 7500,000 baht per person for the incident that happened. As a Muslim, there were no problems in other parts of the country. Thailand has never prohibited anyone from practicing their own religion. However, these rioters have caused a lot of violence. Many of the people who died in the violence were Muslims. These people like to use religion as an excuse even though Thailand gives full rights to practice their religion. I am a Thai Muslim. I do not support these extremists using religion as an excuse. It is disgusting.
Trust me whole world knows about them 😂they just turn blind eyes😂just now UK and Europe include USA headache by muslims they can't live in peace and they hate other religion can't assimilate with other cultures
I agree, other Muslim community in other province don’t have problems integrating with Thai government or Thai way of life in general, Thai government allow them to practice their religion, then they think Thais are too nice ,these couple provinces in the south have been wanting their own territory for so long, they don’t even want to be part of Malaysia either, they just want to have their own little country in the middle of between 2 country that they don’t like. They need to have more respect for Thailand .
they will never forget their historical region.. their land was given to thailand by the british without their consent.. they will think their land are still in colonial occupation..
Great idea now tell that to Palestinian to stop resisting If you have no idea what are you taking about perhaps just shut the f@ck up it's at least the less you speak the less you exposed your own idiocy and ignorant☺️
@@asifhassan4980I think he meant General Sonthi Boonyaratglin, a Muslim general that caused the insurgency to become worse in 2005, although Thaksin Shinawatra, (the prime minister before being couped by Sonthi) was the first reason the insurgency became full scaled which was started since 2004
Yes they should move to Malaysia then, leave Thailand at peace. The land belongs to Thailand, like it or not, based on all legal standing and international acceptance.
@@Freedomnomad555 you dont know the history, thai take the land with british blessing, because thai at time war with burma and malay state, what not give them independent end of stroy.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 and your source? Ah khayalan sahaja. Malaysia never even brought it to the international court, because they have no legal claim. Unlike Sepadan and Ligitan, for example. So please don't made up story.
The Thai people have origins in southern China, specifically from the Tai ethnic groups. They migrated southward over centuries, eventually settling in what is now Thailand and forming various kingdoms, including Sukhothai, Ayutthaya etc. This migration and cultural exchange played a significant role in the development of Thai identity. So It started very small as the Sukhothai Kingdom rebel against the Khmer Empire. In the 13th century, Sukhothai gained independence from Khmer control, asserting its sovereignty and expanding its territory. This period marked a significant shift in power in the region, as Sukhothai began to establish itself as a major kingdom in Southeast Asia and stole a lot of land from their neighbours like Malays, Khmers, Laotian, Burmese. Fact is fact!
They should have their own autonomy. Fullstop. It hard for the Thai government to control. Manage like Russia did to Dagestan. Easy Peace. Southern Thai is quite complex in term of demography and history
Could not agree more. However, southern Thai situation always being used by both sides to withstand their own interest. Like for thai officials that were posted to these provinces, they are known to receive certain special funds to thrive there. Easy money there. The political instability in these provinces also has caused social mishaps like drug smuggling for decades.
Malaysia and Thailand. I pray both sides will live forever in peace. I love both countries. Extremist groups and crazy people with crazy ideas are causing trouble for the people who just want to live life normally. My father is Malaysian and my mother is Singaporean. I spent a lot of my time in Thailand because I have a deep love of Muay Thai and have many friends there. I find so much similarities between all the people. It is absolutely sad to know about the conflicts like this. I've learned to be comfortable in this life enough to call Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand home. Countries I never feel out of place. We are all brothers and sisters.
There is no issue between the two countries, actually they have warm relationship. The issue is the separatist Thai people of Malay ethnicity, who are not Malaysian.
Where ever mu$|ims become majority in certain region they start separatist movements be it Thailand, Phillipines or Myanmar. Minorities exist in malaysia also and they more di$criminated by their government but they don't pick up guns and fight with the state .
@@HKim0072 Yes, it is separatism. Like Rohingya, Southern Thailand, Uyghur. It's just when the separatist is Muslim, they love to play religion card. In Indonesia, some extreme group do get funding from Middle East.
@@sitianiszakiah5134 nah these provinces already get too many privileges and yet they kill 7000+ innocent people in the name of Islam the religion of "peace"
The Honourable Thai King should comission planting of MRQ 76 malaysia rice breed, musang king durian and encouraged goat breeding in the three province so that pattani malay can eat biryani dish mutton kebab and durian ice cream everyday....
@@joemichael5150 hahahaha..when other minorities want to do the same but you ppl say no, oppress them...just look at ME, Bangla, Pak....when others can follow the same rule of law, they can too...arent u doing that to the minorities in Malaysia? practice what you preach bruh.
Thailand government should not be biased on Malay Muslims residing in Pattani,Yala and Narathiwat. It’s sad to see how they were treated with unfair treatment compared to the Thai Buddhist community.
But this is also the case in Indonesia and Malaysia with ethnic minorities. Not saying that Thailand is right. But it’s sad we cannot see fellow humans beyond skin color and religion.
Am not thai, but it's better to make peace with your neighbours writing hateful comments to each other. A nation must be a united person, especially WW3, which is around the corner.
Around 2015 I met a Thai Malay young man selling keropok at one of the Petronas petrol pumps near my house in Malaysia. We chatted about the conditions in the South i.e. his hometown. When I opined that maybe one day you guys over there would see peace, he said as if whispering to himself..."payoh doh" meaning, I dont think so.
@@muhdyusri7691 Rubbish Arabs are the worst colonisers. Bapa Sukarno liberated Indonesian from Dutch colonisers but failed to Liberate them from the Arab colonisers.
Religion has always been a 'scapegoat' excuse for those lazy minded people. The southern thais/ northern malays are Malays by ethnic, many are muslim by faith and some are buddhists. The problem here stems from you know who empire and the exclusion of the Malay sultans during the negotiations and half baked effort to form a 'Malay' nation state. And thai gov policy after the bangkok agreement helped fuel the fire. Yeah sure blame islam and the jihadists like usual because it fits the narative, when in fact the Malaysia- thai borders are infested with smugglers, syndicates, drug dealers and gangsters, intelligence agency false flag and whatnot that contributed to the violence... More so than the separatists operations.
@@mirrorocean3852Self - proclaimed 💁💁💁💁 those who know history well Thailand (i mean,Siam or Sukothai) only established after 1299 due rebellion prince towards then Khmer Empire.in other hand some of other Malay states like Old Kedah & Kelantan has existed way before formation of Sukothai itself
Exactly. In numbers they demand autonomy. That they will never get. Being neighbours with an extremist government across the border in Kelantan, Trengganu and Perlis is no help either.
Vietnam was also has this kind of problem in previous centuries. They had Muslim population of Champa, but in the end they whiped them out so there is no anymore problem about religious conflict in Vietnamese modern era.
The best example of embracing all ethnicities and religions in Southeast Asia is Singapore. Don't say Indonesia, I will laugh out loud, even in Indonesia fellow Muslims persecute each other.
Because Singapore is small hence its easy to control. Can you rule 17000 island with millions rural village? I don't think so, and I don't think it ever done before
@@Highwhyman19 No because Singapore's PAP under Lee Kuan Yew and S. Rajaratnam taught its people to respect each other and they learned from experience that the race riots of the 1960s only hurt their society.
@@user-jt3dw6vv4x I love LKY and I'm not trying to discredit his achievement in SG, but what I meant to said is indonesia is a big country compared to SG, you can teach people this and that. But due to vastness of our land there always a perpetrator somewhere hiding and spreading hatred.
Bad choice for a do be good icon peace. Singapore can goven how it think fit, but they must also have a mind to under the sensitivity of their neighbours, Malaysia and Indonesia Brunei ? Singapore did neither cuz they invited the Israeli head of state to visit Singapore. Singapore is the great bully here just cuz it has uncle sam looking after their backs. No country in the region can buy fighters jets more advance than Singapore from US. The few that US govt gave the green light were refused it's sauce code !! meaning none can engage a RSAF in anger cuz the missiles will not be active. The US let Israel be in the middle of the Arab world, similarly uncle sam let Singapore be in the middle of the "Malay Muslim" area. Another example was when the Thai govt want to build a new Kra Canal across its south for shipping but was protested by Singapore and America .... anything new ? CNA is nothing but a mouthpiece for the Sing govt to show their investigation into other countries affairs. Have CNA ever done any journalistic investigation of the coverup of anything in Singapore itself ?.... there u go, their independent out the windows.
You blame us for not following what you us to do. One thing, without tongkat you are nothing we have to face hardship the gov only care majority not minority.supremacy at it peak. @@kelapamudalaut
@@kelapamudalautusually they blame we held too much power in economy so politically we need to be nerf in term of position. For example, many minority in the education can’t get into matriculation or government aid. So minority parents usually saved up funds to send their kids to overseas. We also have a policy that major government post is not run by minorities etc. and when it comes to election, we are always mistreated or scapegoated, like we wanted more privileges and etc and want to denounce Islamic etc. May be the normal average citizen don’t care about this but as you can see in rural Malay areas like in Kelantan and Terregganu, anti minority rhetoric is heard
The reason they aren't being held accountable is because Thaksin was in power at the time and he's back in power now having let the offenders flee overseas until the statue of limitations expires.
The disturbing but familiar scenes of Muslim Uyghurs dragged into one of 380 Xinjiang camps in China 🇨🇳 for: - having a beard, - wearing a veil, - applying for a passport, - possessing a Quran, - praying, - downloading WhatsApp or - having too many children.
That's why I support muslim immigrating toward the west. It's, for them, freedom and the EU and the US can provide safety to them in return for their contribution toward the economy and works in fields of research such as hospital and achitecture.
As an outsider, why can't the Muslim majority areas be merged with Malaysia or created as a separate Muslim country? After all its a very small area , also its headache free for the Buddhist Thailand
How about each states of Semenanjung make a special zones for non Muslims to run their way of life as long abiding to the federal laws without interference of Jakim?
Agree. We really have different values. I as a religious zealot would like an ethnostate religious supremacy however I respect liberal values of others. We need special autonomous zones or much like red and blue states such as certain zones in Penang, Kl, Johor. We need new State Craft Model. Who knows maybe Singapore may join back the Federation.😉
Who is those non Muslim? Are they the one that were brought by British? are they the one who refused to go back to their mainland? Melaka Kingdom in peninsular already practjsed syariah law-like rules.
15:41 That, right there, is part of the problem: the military is at the front of a political process. In another country, it would be a central government >civilian< taking the lead.
A highly respected Ulama/ Islamic scholar who had been fighting for independence of the Malay regions in Thailand about 100 years ago said that it's ok if we lost this time because they will know that we will always be the pain in the arse for them.
I think this video is provocative. Thailand is the country where all religions are coexisting together without any problems. I have a lot of friends both Buddhists and Muslims. And they respect each other and stay together
In Bangkok Thailand have many cultures and live in peace but 3 province peoples do not recognized to be Thai people,should leave in peace.Thailand love peace but not corward.
These three MALAY MAJORITY regions can try to achieve independence from Thailand and become their very own country... or do that first, then apply to join the Malaysian Federation to further strengthen the Malay people.
Victimization as what they have done best and have succeeding since ancient from wars, to trading and creating chaos this present day to have their own independent state where ever country they are residing
@@areebachewa8318 That's Islamophobic at its best but too coward to spit it out. That's exactly their land! Not like Caucasian migration to Americas and so called white 'Jews' migrated to the middle east!
Not 20 years of conflict. 70+ years, bordering on 80. Ever since the Sultanate of Patani was split between the British and the Siamese, the remnants stuck on the Siamese side of the cordon faced attempts of cultural genocide that begun in earnest with Plaek Phibunsongkram's Thai-ification policies. If not for decades of cultural genocide, Wahhabi Jihadism would've never gained traction in 2000s.
Sekarang banyak negara asia tenggara dimasuki ajaran wahabi terorist,indonesia utuh sampai sekarang tidak terpecah pecah karena ajaran islam moderat, kini banyak orang asia tenggara beriman kepada ajaran islam radikal teroris, ciri cirinya wajib jilbab, tidak boleh berteman dengan kafir, bahkan mengucapkan salam untuk rasa persahabatan antar agama gak boleh dan banyak lagi, ajaran seperti itu hanya memicu konflik, apalagi sampai mrmisahkan diri, jadilah agama yg mau berdamai dengan agama manapun pupuk toleransi, beri jabat tangan bukan pukulan tangan.
I love regardless how the facts are, people like you will still be blinded and blame Islam and muslims for everything you do. Exactly your kind throw the first stone and expecting muslims to not retaliate.
Eh, pretty natural response when a country decided to annexed another territory and forced them to become what they're not. Even hong kong-er retaliated with violent protest when china want to exert more control on them 🤷♂️
@@syahmiqawiem yet Hongkonger never killing 7000+. Innocent people with guns bombs decapitated and burn you talk bullshit who force who to become who in this case in Thailand name any policy from Thai gov that suppress local culture nah you can't there ain't so stop your nonsense and just admit it's religion of peace problems.
@Pls_dont_eat_macat the hong kongers did stabbed and throw molotov directly at polices. I didn't remember when both actions were not with the intention to kill. I also didn't remember the ukrainian , irish, papuan, sardinian, vietnamese, korean and many other armed separatist movement are muslims
Thailand must give them special otonomy like Aceh province in Indonesia. Let them build their future without prejudice and discrimination. I believe them patani" people has blood relation with Indonesia clan (maybe Java and Melayu).
You throw gasoline on the fire. Each country has many ethnicities. Imagine if each ethnic claims to be autonomy then claims be independent. How subdivided the country will be. Just allow them do their religion practice is ok, treat them as fair as other ethnic. Should be learnt from Singapore.
Autonomy? Here, you are talking about the country that has never been colonized by the west and it has only one governing body. Thailand is different from Malaysia and Indonesia. It is not a federal state. Proposing autonomouse region is not different from seperating Thailand into two countries which may be not a big deal in Malaysia and Indonesia, but it is the redline in Thailand.
Not only has there been 20 years to take action but the lead suspect is ex-General cum Phue Thai MP Pisarn who was recently allowed to go overseas after he became suddenly "sick" (you know, like Thaksin did) and was allowed to travel overseas for "treatment" and will no doubt make a swift return as the statute of limitations expires. Sadly familiar two tier Thai "justice" system.
Simple answer, are the cause of the situation is by coloniser and is the ppl that claim that land are actually the native ppl itself and not a foreign ppl who just follow the book because of they religion. We support the native and they right in they own land.
They want justice in Thailand, Myanmar, India, Israel, Germany, Russia, Norway, Denmark, South Korea, Greece, Armenia, Sri Lanka but they don't want to give justice in Iraq, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Afghanistan, Turkey, Iran. 😅
Here you are talking as if you are any better. Let's not even talk about minorities of India, lower caste Hindus are oppressed for thousands of years by your own fellow Hinuds. You have the audacity to talk about the matter you have no idea. Sit down clown :D
@@cosmaputra879 Holy cow ..yes the world is soo in jealous of you ... the rest of us are trying soo hard to be like Afghanistan, Pakistan Seriously ? I don't think any nation on earth has a mental disorder to be another hellhole
I personally felt Bangkok didn't have any interest in Southern Thai where predominantly occupied by Muslims. Might as well give them independence and let them run their provinces independently. Those who ran away and didn't get prosecuted after the conflict 20 years ago should be brought to the court again. I can't fathom how the Thai government could close one eye for this inhumane act by the military and Thaksin during that time. What a shame !
Take your people back. If they don't want to live in Thailand But the country's territory cannot be taken away. If they don't want to stay, wouldn't it be easier to get rid of them?
Young Patani folks themselves up to this day still brought up the ethnonationalism point . That's why PULO and BRN are still active and present to this day. Many of them still viewed Bangkok as a colonizer and occupied their land. Imagine since year 1795, noted the downfall of Patani kingdom, they are still resilient to Thai authority until now. Malaysians are not the one sparking this ethnic nationalism thing, it is a value that Patani people uplifted by themselves. I don't really know if the majority of Patani people want to get independence or not. But i do sense that patani young folks mostly prefer for autonomy better than independence.
In india problem with hidus,Thailand problem with buddies, chiana problem with Chinese community,eruope problem with Christian...if Muslim become majority only God except Allah...
Deep problem for these 3 southern provinces and some part of Songkhala not related with Thai Muslim. Most Thai people and many people in Asean don't know cause a problem. I think many Thai muslim live happily and peace in another part of Thailand. This 3 provinces and some part of Songkhala mostly or majority races namely Malay Patani. They use different language and culture. Historically they have war with Siamese empire almost since 200 year ago. They feel betrayed by the 1909 anglo siamese treaty. After world war 2 they get betrayed again by British and Thai government. Many religious teacher and leaders of Patani get killed by Siamese force. Your know Haji Sulong? He demand justice Malay patani people. He not seek directly independence from Thailand for Patani. He just ask 7 demanded right for Malay Patani people. What happen to him?. Get killed by Thai government and very unjustice to him. Since 2004 Takbai masscre new erupted and anger of Malay patani to Thailand government until today. Actually Malay patani don't want any war and unjustice do it by Thailand government and military. Let go to the peace. Key point Thailand government know what they need to do. All the solutions and deal already on the table. Let Malay Patani self determination for their region or if Thailand very hard to give them independence let find another solution like give them autonomy reunited 3 regions as one region. Let approve 7 demand from late Haji Sulong. Peace no war.
Meanwhile, around 80,000 Malaysian Siamese ethnic group in Malaysia is considered as indigenious or bumiputra, just like the Malays.
Bumiputra... Interesting. You'll find this word in India too... Even in my State - Goa. I am kind off aware of the connection...
If you know the difference of Siamese & Thai, then you know why Siamese got bumi status.
@@A_Goan South East Asia have so many words derivated from Sanksrit. Thats why. Sadly Sanksrit is not widely spoken anymore by Indians, that is why it is always surpising you guys, as if it is something new. Meanwhile here we already know where it is coming from. :D
bumi = earth
putra = son
cmiiw @@A_Goan
@@A_Goanindia and malay have loong history.
I am a Malay from Malaysia but on my father's side, we still have close family in Patani. So close, that my father had first and second cousins that would come and visit us in Pendang, Kedah.
From what I gathered, they are not asking to be part of Malaysia. What they want is to be able to PRACTISE being a Malay (to speak Malay, to have a Malay name and to write in Jawi - a Malay script). Thailand is their country but being a Malay is what they are born with. Thai is probably their national identity but Malay is what in their heart is. In other places, you can be who you are, and still be part of the country. Similar to Chinese in Malaysia or Jamaican in the UK. But in Thailand, Malay identity was being suppressed through Siamisation (naming and preference for government jobs).
We lost extended family members in the conflict and we do mourn them.
If the Thai government stopped looking at these Malays as the "others" and started to look at them as "our Thai nationals", developed the area and embraced that multi-ethnicity and multi-cultural is something to be proud of I am sure, peace can slowly take place in these states.
Let's be clear, these states are part of Thailand. But their heart is Malay and help them and make them proud to be part of Thailand. They just want to have some economic prosperity and to live in happiness.
From us in Malaysia, we hope our extended families in Patani will always be strong.
Thanks and I would agree with you on this. Learning from Aceh for example, Indonesia (as a Muslim majority nation) conceded to give Aceh more autonomy regarding religion affairs. After failing to hold on to East Timor, a majority Catholic land with unique ethnicity. The southern Thai issue is somewhat similar to Papua issue in Indonesia. Ethnicity and religion they are closer to Papua New Guinea but ruled by majority Moslems in Jakarta.
They didn't want to be like the other Malay people of Southern Thailand such Satun (new generation), Songkhla, Krabi or even in Bangkok. Those Malay people can't speak Malay anymore and lose their Malay culture and now to be called Thai Muslim with Thai ethnicity. Not all Thai Muslim was Malay but most of them was Malay that being assimilation especially the peninsular people. Except for Yala, Narathiwat and Patani. Look the Malay people of Southern Myanmar, they still can speak Malay with Kedah Dialect and using Jawi script. Because Myanmar didn't force Malay Muslim to assimilate like Thailand.
Chinese in Thai kingdom experience Siamization processfrom the late of 19th century. This No difference for Malay people in Thai kingdom . Sad but it's the reality
I don't know why muslims always make ridiculous mistakes????😅 They really ❤ demontration😅
เข้าใจอะไรผิดหรือเปล่า ไทยไม่ได้ห้ามในความเป็นมลายู ทุกคนมีเสรีภาพในการแสดงอัตลักษณ์ของตัวเอง ทั้งศาสนา ภาษาและวัฒนธรรม เราไม่เคยแบ่งแยกพลเมืองชั้น1ชั้น2 ทุกคนมีสิทธิเท่าเทียมกันหมด ไม่มีการเลือกปฏิบัติ ทุกคนสามารถรับราชการได้ เพราะถือว่าเป็นคนไทย
As a Thai, I'm so sorry to all Thai Muslim and who lived in 3 Southern provinces people for everything that happened I wish peoples, friends, families, everyone deserves justice, but everything is too late. 😢🙏
(Sorry if my English is bad.)
Why apologies when you are know the Islamic history they want their domination in the country they are residing first creating chaos and then dominate the country when they have the chance ...please watch from youtube from muslim who have left and protecting the western ideas than the islamic totalitarian ideas who have never evolved since 1400 years where how they have divided former Yugoslavia to become two Islamic state Kosovo and Bosnia, In India they have divided to form Pakistan and Bangladesh, In Thailand they are fighting to form their own state in the South, In Myanmar they want to have their own state in Rohingya, In Philippine they are fighting to form their own state ...well can you see the pattern ...please watch on youtube Apostate Prophet, Ex muslim of America, Friendly muslim, Ex muslim of Norway and many more to understand their Islamic ideology...
Why do you want to apologize where they want to dominate Thai when given the time as how they have changed Indonesia and Malaysia from Hindus and Buddhist as what they have being doing their best ...
Sorry is a cheap word used in Thailand however the damage is those people in the south they won't need anything from Thailand they just want their autonomy, their land back, kingdom of Pattani was a country alone and has nothing to do with Thailand we don't forget that Thailand stole lands from Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar as well, in my opinion the international committee are hypocrite they have make sanctions, embargo against Thailand for those inhuman terrorist activities, Thailand unfortunately as many people don't know is a country that promote hate and violence against minorities and even against tourists who spend money and all foreigners this is a mental disease
your English isnt bad, but your thinking is worse.
@@Real99xx-eq8gt for me, just give 3 provinxes back to malaysia. Thailand needs to reconsider this
why are you following the thai government's narrative ? they were protesting and murdered and now seeking reparations not because they are Muslim , but because they are Patani Malay. There are loads of other muslims in Thailand that don't have this issue because they are ethnically Tai.
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman this is not true. I can tell their ethnicity by just looking at them and ask a few Malay words - majority Muslims in around Bangkok and surroundings provinces are ethnic Malays. Almost none ethic Tai. There are some decendence from Java too. So it you don’t know the issue, it is not ethic or religion - just some jihadist stupid people stirring thing up.
because this is a singapuran news outlet and singapura doesnt support the idea of native people belong to their lands, looking at the country it's de facto a chinese country, but we all know that historically it's not, if native singapuran heard the difference of native people and native land it will start something.
i mean look they support israhell as well, that speaks volume bro
@ and how do people treat the other people in their own land? Look at corruption in Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines … who suppress who, who steal from who? Get real bro. Singapore is the most successful nation to bring prosperity to its people of any ethnicity in this area.
@@Freedomnomad555you act and sound like as Singapore doesn't have their own oppression problems, also the only reason Singapore even get rich it's because of Britain so they also corrupted
@@Freedomnomad555 wow singapura is so perfect no supression no thief, you want me to get real? you get real, there is no perfect country. everyone can use google, and find all singapuran social and government problems
singapura is chinese country is a fact, singapura is historically melayu land is a fact, singapura support israel is a fact. singapura has its own problem is a fact. get real bro , get real🤙
If I were Thai King , i would humbly visit this area more frequently to show sincerity and win my people's heart.
But very unfortunate, this useless king rather spend time in europe than his people..
Useless king yes. The Muslim will never satisfied even if the king visited anyway.
Thai government should learn from Malaysia using 3 R to strengthen the power of the Thai king and the government. Malaysia use 3R to oppress the NON Muslim the result is very encouraging
@@patrickp8315 ask uk about how they king Charles visit Australia last week. You know how people really fill about some king who conquer other. South Thailand pattani are malay land before British give it away without approval of malay king. Simple answer they malay not Thailand
Of course they wouldn't. They were literally conquered and never once got much of an autonomy after thailand centralization. They're not thai, they're malay.@@patrickp8315
@@azleadam9239He visited australia because it is 2nd england they wiped out real population basically all australian are english....did he go to africa or india or said sorry....saying sorry to muslim is hitting rock to your head they are not thankful and want to implement their rule has soon has their population increse..
The malay muslim in yala narathiwat songkla pattani krabi are seperated from their brothers in malaysia. I used to hired muslim malay lady from bangkok. She told me there are many malay muslim in bangkok. She spoke malay. Used malay name here. But spoke thai and used thai name in thailand
With the same logic, the malays in Malaysia are separated from their brothers in Indonesia. They speak the same malay language from Riau in Indonesia.
Free Sabah
@@Freedomnomad555 We dont really have strong ties with sumatran malay. Our accent is hugely difference except kepri. Unlike the kelantanese who even until today have relatives across border in pattani and their accent is almost identical.
@@zaki-pq1ps Read your history. Even your first Agong post British rule was an Indonesian descent. People of Negeri Sembilan are Minang ethic from West Sumatera (even their food tastes the same like Padang). Lots of people are descendent of Bugis, Javanese, Banjar etc. Here for you to read: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysians_of_Indonesian_descent . Soekarno did Ganyang Malaysia against the British because he considered Malaysia as the British made up puppet country. But ok lah now we are a friendly neighbor, and you should treat Thailand with the same respect for their territorial integrity.
@@Freedomnomad555 That is only for the state of negeri sembilan with strong minang ties. We have rotation system for agong. Just because N9 is like that doesnt mean the whole malaysia is like that. Other state in malaysia barely have any ties with sumatra.
The case is now closed. Justice delayed, is justice denied. So much for the pathetic Thai judiciary...and so sad for the families of the victims😢
Then,that people interested in kaffir's judiciary?😁
In this case, the separatists killed teachers, soldiers, and policemen. The Thai government compensated 7500,000 baht per person for the incident that happened. As a Muslim, there were no problems in other parts of the country. Thailand has never prohibited anyone from practicing their own religion. However, these rioters have caused a lot of violence. Many of the people who died in the violence were Muslims. These people like to use religion as an excuse even though Thailand gives full rights to practice their religion. I am a Thai Muslim. I do not support these extremists using religion as an excuse. It is disgusting.
Trust me whole world knows about them 😂they just turn blind eyes😂just now UK and Europe include USA headache by muslims they can't live in peace and they hate other religion can't assimilate with other cultures
Thank you for stating the truth.
I agree, other Muslim community in other province don’t have problems integrating with Thai government or Thai way of life in general, Thai government allow them to practice their religion, then they think Thais are too nice ,these couple provinces in the south have been wanting their own territory for so long, they don’t even want to be part of Malaysia either, they just want to have their own little country in the middle of between 2 country that they don’t like. They need to have more respect for Thailand .
they will never forget their historical region.. their land was given to thailand by the british without their consent.. they will think their land are still in colonial occupation..
Just three regions causing trouble to Thai government for years? Let them joint Malaysia federation and no more headache to deal it.
Kapir Buddha perangai macam tu la. Dia tahu ekonomi region Islam kuat dari sektor pelacong. Tak akan dia serahkan pada Malaysia
From what I've heard, they want to be freed from both Malaysia and Thailand.
มึงจะบ้าหรือไง ใครจะยอมให้แบ่งแยกดินแดนว่ะ ไทยเราเสียดินแดนถึง14ครั้งแล้ว แล้วมันจะไม่มีครั้งที่15อย่างแน่นอน เราถอยไม่ได้แร้ว เรามาสุดปลายทางแผ่นดินแร้ว กูคนนึงที่จะไม่ยอมแน่ ถึงจะแลกด้วยชีวิตก้อตาม
Great idea now tell that to Palestinian to stop resisting
If you have no idea what are you taking about perhaps just shut the f@ck up it's at least the less you speak the less you exposed your own idiocy and ignorant☺️
Actually they want to be an independent sovereign country .
Ironically the one who launched the recent offensives 20 years ago against them was a Muslim general
Who was that ????
@@asifhassan4980I think he meant General Sonthi Boonyaratglin, a Muslim general that caused the insurgency to become worse in 2005, although Thaksin Shinawatra, (the prime minister before being couped by Sonthi) was the first reason the insurgency became full scaled which was started since 2004
The Anglo-Siamese Treaty of 1909 established the Malaysia-Thailand border.
they are not thai muslim, thay are malay people
Yes they should move to Malaysia then, leave Thailand at peace. The land belongs to Thailand, like it or not, based on all legal standing and international acceptance.
@@Freedomnomad555 you dont know the history, thai take the land with british blessing, because thai at time war with burma and malay state, what not give them independent end of stroy.
Please take that people out of Thailand. Thai people can't be muslims
@@safuwanfauzi5014 and your source? Ah khayalan sahaja. Malaysia never even brought it to the international court, because they have no legal claim. Unlike Sepadan and Ligitan, for example. So please don't made up story.
The Thai people have origins in southern China, specifically from the Tai ethnic groups. They migrated southward over centuries, eventually settling in what is now Thailand and forming various kingdoms, including Sukhothai, Ayutthaya etc. This migration and cultural exchange played a significant role in the development of Thai identity. So It started very small as the Sukhothai Kingdom rebel against the Khmer Empire. In the 13th century, Sukhothai gained independence from Khmer control, asserting its sovereignty and expanding its territory. This period marked a significant shift in power in the region, as Sukhothai began to establish itself as a major kingdom in Southeast Asia and stole a lot of land from their neighbours like Malays, Khmers, Laotian, Burmese. Fact is fact!
They should be allowed to join malaysia. Historically, they were part of Malaya before the british!
Then give back Palis Kedah Penang Kelantan and Terrenganu to Thailand because it belonged to Siam before the British!
@@Pls_dont_eat_macat Please read history properly. There even film made by Siamese about it. Look for it. Don't be lazy bum.
Kan. Sebahagian Kedah. Itula bengong yang pi buat perjanjian percaya sangat dengan British yang tamak lagi selfish.
@@Pls_dont_eat_macat those state was more older and didn't even belong to siam/Thailand in the first place
@@yuniainanajiha6923 should we reset every country's border to what they were at that time?
They should have their own autonomy. Fullstop. It hard for the Thai government to control. Manage like Russia did to Dagestan. Easy Peace. Southern Thai is quite complex in term of demography and history
Could not agree more. However, southern Thai situation always being used by both sides to withstand their own interest. Like for thai officials that were posted to these provinces, they are known to receive certain special funds to thrive there. Easy money there.
The political instability in these provinces also has caused social mishaps like drug smuggling for decades.
thai ruler ignorant ….
Muslims are difficult as neighbors.
Then leave the country, its theirs to begin with
@@shahrimanshahnaz7008 I am sorry, I am in the USA. Israel has always belonged to the Jews, for ALL of history. As far as Thailand,,,morally corrupt.
Go back to Europe then with all military and also take away the jews
Muslims are difficult everywhere. Even the Muslims in the same Muslim countries. The Suni and Shia are still killing each other til this day
said by ka fa ro
Malaysia and Thailand. I pray both sides will live forever in peace. I love both countries. Extremist groups and crazy people with crazy ideas are causing trouble for the people who just want to live life normally. My father is Malaysian and my mother is Singaporean. I spent a lot of my time in Thailand because I have a deep love of Muay Thai and have many friends there. I find so much similarities between all the people. It is absolutely sad to know about the conflicts like this. I've learned to be comfortable in this life enough to call Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand home. Countries I never feel out of place. We are all brothers and sisters.
There is no issue between the two countries, actually they have warm relationship. The issue is the separatist Thai people of Malay ethnicity, who are not Malaysian.
Where ever mu$|ims become majority in certain region they start separatist movements be it Thailand, Phillipines or Myanmar. Minorities exist in malaysia also and they more di$criminated by their government but they don't pick up guns and fight with the state .
So true so true
Completely agree
you ignorant dont know the history…..the pattani muslim is part of malay sultanate before british give them to siamese thai…..
You know that history so you racist terrorist
@@arelee7974British numbers one white terrorist country.
This is separatism problem. But as usual, they love to portray it as religious oppression.
Same thing in the Southern Philippines. I’m not a conspiracy theorist, but I’m sure they are getting funding from the Middle East.
@@HKim0072 Yes, it is separatism. Like Rohingya, Southern Thailand, Uyghur. It's just when the separatist is Muslim, they love to play religion card. In Indonesia, some extreme group do get funding from Middle East.
Patani provinces should at least get an autonomy !
I totally agree. They should have their own autonomy.
@@sitianiszakiah5134 nah these provinces already get too many privileges and yet they kill 7000+ innocent people in the name of Islam the religion of "peace"
Agree. Make it like Xinjiang Autonomous region in China
The Honourable Thai King should comission planting of MRQ 76 malaysia rice breed, musang king durian and encouraged goat breeding in the three province so that pattani malay can eat biryani dish mutton kebab and durian ice cream everyday....
If they get autonomy, they will become terrorists.
Mereka adalah Islam Melayu dan berhak mentadbir golongan mereka sendiri.
Move to Malaysia then
@@mirrorocean3852 kau tak tahu sejarah ke? Pergi Malaysia buat apa. Itu tanah air mereka. Mereka penduduk asal di kawasan itu.
@@joemichael5150 hahahaha..when other minorities want to do the same but you ppl say no, oppress them...just look at ME, Bangla, Pak....when others can follow the same rule of law, they can too...arent u doing that to the minorities in Malaysia? practice what you preach bruh.
Boleh pindah masuk rumah kau. 😂
@zulali4307 tak suka ? keluar lah !!! sound familiar
Thailand government should not be biased on Malay Muslims residing in Pattani,Yala and Narathiwat. It’s sad to see how they were treated with unfair treatment compared to the Thai Buddhist community.
@@muhammedridhwan5425 lol 😂 you know nothing about this 🤡
@@muhammedridhwan5425 Muslims in 3 provinces can practice Islam without restrictions. 🤡
@@muhammedridhwan5425 my @$$ Thai government did not discriminate anyone, Muslims still can practice freely🤡
But this is also the case in Indonesia and Malaysia with ethnic minorities. Not saying that Thailand is right. But it’s sad we cannot see fellow humans beyond skin color and religion.
@@Skiddo0284nah thais even worst.
This is one of the major reasons why Kra Canal would not happen.
Am not thai, but it's better to make peace with your neighbours writing hateful comments to each other. A nation must be a united person, especially WW3, which is around the corner.
I agreed. From Malaysia
Around 2015 I met a Thai Malay young man selling keropok at one of the Petronas petrol pumps near my house in Malaysia. We chatted about the conditions in the South i.e. his hometown. When I opined that maybe one day you guys over there would see peace, he said as if whispering to himself..."payoh doh" meaning, I dont think so.
Anyone ever heard about Non muslim minority seeking justice in
Egypt 🇪🇬
Syria 🇸🇾
Lebanon 🇱🇧
Iraq 🇮🇶
Yemen 🇾🇪
Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Malaysia 🇲🇾
Pakistan 🇵🇰
Afghanistan 🇦🇫
?
No💯
Never, because it's impossible.
Non muslim doing well in Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, Qatar, Kazakshtan, Kygrstan, Uzbekistan, UAE, Kuwait, Oman, etc
@@izaanzahari8001 😁 you mean kaffir workers?
So what is the case prinders? Look at yourself
Stop playing the victim card, it is a matter of theocracy vs secularism.
Its about coloniser vs the colonised.
@@muhdyusri7691 Rubbish Arabs are the worst colonisers. Bapa Sukarno liberated Indonesian from Dutch colonisers but failed to Liberate them from the Arab colonisers.
@@muhdyusri7691 th-cam.com/video/1tN0SvFk0xw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=HH1aZVjKLPyBjLmd
Religion has always been a 'scapegoat' excuse for those lazy minded people. The southern thais/ northern malays are Malays by ethnic, many are muslim by faith and some are buddhists.
The problem here stems from you know who empire and the exclusion of the Malay sultans during the negotiations and half baked effort to form a 'Malay' nation state.
And thai gov policy after the bangkok agreement helped fuel the fire. Yeah sure blame islam and the jihadists like usual because it fits the narative, when in fact the Malaysia- thai borders are infested with smugglers, syndicates, drug dealers and gangsters, intelligence agency false flag and whatnot that contributed to the violence... More so than the separatists operations.
Buddhists are secular now? What kind of drugs are you on?
They are Malay not Thai, give them autonomy status
Malaysian here,i have a relative in Yala.. Never forget tak bai tragedy. Thai gov is evil
@@nafiznastaim7491 Free Sabah Sarawak supporter here, lucky I have no orang meleyu relative
There won’t be peace without justice
Again and again that crime alliance played victims .
Again and again u are stupid not studying history of southern Thai region !
Malay land annexed by Siam
4 Northern states of your were also Thailand’s territory.
@@mirrorocean3852 colonized by siam with the aid of britain
@@mirrorocean3852 5 province
@@mirrorocean3852Self - proclaimed 💁💁💁💁 those who know history well Thailand (i mean,Siam or Sukothai) only established after 1299 due rebellion prince towards then Khmer Empire.in other hand some of other Malay states like Old Kedah & Kelantan has existed way before formation of Sukothai itself
@@94snapazzurri scambodia
We have muslim brothers and sisters living peacefully all over places in Thailand but why can't these people...
It is matter of integration everywhere
Exactly. In numbers they demand autonomy. That they will never get. Being neighbours with an extremist government across the border in Kelantan, Trengganu and Perlis is no help either.
because they are malay muslims not thai muslims
Because the Thai government treat these regions differently
@@JojoJogetNot true at all.
Vietnam was also has this kind of problem in previous centuries. They had Muslim population of Champa, but in the end they whiped them out so there is no anymore problem about religious conflict in Vietnamese modern era.
Wiped out😢. Wow that s ethnic cleansing. Tyranny
Yikes.
Muslim minority is always a pain in the arse
Wiped out? That's called a geno... You know it.
And using this as an excuse just shows your moral decadence
Those Champa people ran to Kelantan and Thai. Vietnam forced others to accept their problema.
The best example of embracing all ethnicities and religions in Southeast Asia is Singapore. Don't say Indonesia, I will laugh out loud, even in Indonesia fellow Muslims persecute each other.
Even fellow muslims in Indonesia are fighting each others over dogma.. or over small issue such as the practice of "horeg" speaker
Because Singapore is small hence its easy to control. Can you rule 17000 island with millions rural village? I don't think so, and I don't think it ever done before
@@Highwhyman19 No because Singapore's PAP under Lee Kuan Yew and S. Rajaratnam taught its people to respect each other and they learned from experience that the race riots of the 1960s only hurt their society.
@@user-jt3dw6vv4x I love LKY and I'm not trying to discredit his achievement in SG, but what I meant to said is indonesia is a big country compared to SG, you can teach people this and that. But due to vastness of our land there always a perpetrator somewhere hiding and spreading hatred.
Bad choice for a do be good icon peace. Singapore can goven how it think fit, but they must also have a mind to under the sensitivity of their neighbours, Malaysia and Indonesia Brunei ? Singapore did neither cuz they invited the Israeli head of state to visit Singapore. Singapore is the great bully here just cuz it has uncle sam looking after their backs. No country in the region can buy fighters jets more advance than Singapore from US. The few that US govt gave the green light were refused it's sauce code !! meaning none can engage a RSAF in anger cuz the missiles will not be active. The US let Israel be in the middle of the Arab world, similarly uncle sam let Singapore be in the middle of the "Malay Muslim" area. Another example was when the Thai govt want to build a new Kra Canal across its south for shipping but was protested by Singapore and America .... anything new ? CNA is nothing but a mouthpiece for the Sing govt to show their investigation into other countries affairs. Have CNA ever done any journalistic investigation of the coverup of anything in Singapore itself ?.... there u go, their independent out the windows.
While in Malaysia, Malay Muslim blames minority non-Muslim population 😅
Edit: Thank you guys for proving my points! 😄
Pls elaborate what's kind of blame you mentioned?
You blame us for not following what you us to do. One thing, without tongkat you are nothing we have to face hardship the gov only care majority not minority.supremacy at it peak. @@kelapamudalaut
@@bradleytv9813 " not following what you ask to do" such as? Tongkat? What do you mean by tongkat?
Then dont stay in Malaysia. Nobody ask you to live in Malaysia since your birth 😂
@@kelapamudalautusually they blame we held too much power in economy so politically we need to be nerf in term of position. For example, many minority in the education can’t get into matriculation or government aid. So minority parents usually saved up funds to send their kids to overseas. We also have a policy that major government post is not run by minorities etc. and when it comes to election, we are always mistreated or scapegoated, like we wanted more privileges and etc and want to denounce Islamic etc. May be the normal average citizen don’t care about this but as you can see in rural Malay areas like in Kelantan and Terregganu, anti minority rhetoric is heard
Thailand Bukan Hanya Bangkok Pattaya dan segala kegemerlapaanya
Support minoritas in south Thailand👍
Support Papua merdeka? Jangan ikut2an, kita sendiri punya PR yg belum selesai
Asal seagama support, pemikiran kera
Hadeh sesama negara Asean harusnya dukung negara yang menjadi tetangga dan memiliki otoritas yang jelas
@@JePkphn Thailand annex a Malay kingdom but suprise the people do not want to follow a them is a crazy concept to you or something?
@@STORYSEEKER1 We don't need history lesson, the Fact is that they belong to Thailand, case closed
The reason they aren't being held accountable is because Thaksin was in power at the time and he's back in power now having let the offenders flee overseas until the statue of limitations expires.
We want JUSTICE for what happened in Takbai. Bring those who are responsible to the court.
The disturbing but familiar scenes of Muslim Uyghurs dragged into one of 380 Xinjiang camps in China 🇨🇳 for:
- having a beard,
- wearing a veil,
- applying for a passport,
- possessing a Quran,
- praying,
- downloading WhatsApp or
- having too many children.
That's why I support muslim immigrating toward the west. It's, for them, freedom and the EU and the US can provide safety to them in return for their contribution toward the economy and works in fields of research such as hospital and achitecture.
Not you again?
not this US sponsored anti China bot
Bruh Transgender Xi Jin Ping on your pfp
@@FlyingFishXYZ eventually they want their own caliphate and syariah laws turning their adopted country into the country they left behind.
As an outsider, why can't the Muslim majority areas be merged with Malaysia or created as a separate Muslim country? After all its a very small area , also its headache free for the Buddhist Thailand
The British want those areas to be included in Malaya, but then the new power USA dont want that to happen...Now, USA is supporting Israel
Asked and answered. Land is valuable.
@@jeromefitzroyit's not about land it's about sovereignty.
They use that as their victimization and to be naive is your stupidity ...
Long ago the Siamese Kingdom invaded this part of Malay territory, this is why its an issue to this date.
A lot of comments in this comment section are making me LAUGH OUT LOUD 😂
Independence and self determination is the only solution for Southern Thailand conflict.
Nah we rather keep fighting thx for your ignorant useful idea.
Move to Malay
No muslim should leave that to place and go to muslim countries
@@VivekKamble-ir4xq the problem is no Muslim country welcomes Muslim migrant
@@mirrorocean3852for what? 😂
CNA production is always top notch and brave touching sensitive issues
How about each states of Semenanjung make a special zones for non Muslims to run their way of life as long abiding to the federal laws without interference of Jakim?
Agree. We really have different values. I as a religious zealot would like an ethnostate religious supremacy however I respect liberal values of others. We need special autonomous zones or much like red and blue states such as certain zones in Penang, Kl, Johor. We need new State Craft Model. Who knows maybe Singapore may join back the Federation.😉
What non-muslim way of life that is blocked by government?
Democracy means following what the majority wants and please also tell me what jakim had done to you??
Who is those non Muslim? Are they the one that were brought by British? are they the one who refused to go back to their mainland? Melaka Kingdom in peninsular already practjsed syariah law-like rules.
Since when JAKIM has power or in any way affected your life? As far as i concern, JAKIM task and responsibilities is not about non muslim
15:41 That, right there, is part of the problem: the military is at the front of a political process. In another country, it would be a central government >civilian< taking the lead.
A highly respected Ulama/ Islamic scholar who had been fighting for independence of the Malay regions in Thailand about 100 years ago said that it's ok if we lost this time because they will know that we will always be the pain in the arse for them.
I think this video is provocative. Thailand is the country where all religions are coexisting together without any problems. I have a lot of friends both Buddhists and Muslims. And they respect each other and stay together
In Bangkok Thailand have many cultures and live in peace but 3 province peoples do not recognized to be Thai people,should leave in peace.Thailand love peace but not corward.
Peace and Muslims aren't mixed. Don't you know this? :)
@@patrickp8315peace don't mix with christianity
As an outsider, I'm praying peace ✌️ for this beautiful ❤️ country. Try to settle
No islam - know peace
Know islam - no peace
Islam is peace . you don't know Islam so you will never know peace
@@Cptidris yea keep saying that. Pretty much all the terrorist organisations are Islamic
It's not about Islam, itd about Siamese colonisation of the Malay majority territory.
another dik head.With no knowledge.Rat
clearly didnt watch the full vid, dont ya?
Free Southern Thai 🤝
These three MALAY MAJORITY regions can try to achieve independence from Thailand and become their very own country... or do that first, then apply to join the Malaysian Federation to further strengthen the Malay people.
Victimization as what they have done best and have succeeding since ancient from wars, to trading and creating chaos this present day to have their own independent state where ever country they are residing
@@areebachewa8318 That's Islamophobic at its best but too coward to spit it out. That's exactly their land! Not like Caucasian migration to Americas and so called white 'Jews' migrated to the middle east!
@@abdmanafali2975 Free Sabah Free Sarawak, agree?
Bebaskan Sabah & Sarawak
@@lolsiahsahfWhat for? They declared independence within Malaysia on 31st August 1963.
Not 20 years of conflict. 70+ years, bordering on 80.
Ever since the Sultanate of Patani was split between the British and the Siamese, the remnants stuck on the Siamese side of the cordon faced attempts of cultural genocide that begun in earnest with Plaek Phibunsongkram's Thai-ification policies.
If not for decades of cultural genocide, Wahhabi Jihadism would've never gained traction in 2000s.
Its been since 1785
Semoga Patani/Yala/Narathiwat/ Aceh/Kalimantan jadi negara merdeka aja.
In your dream
Apa-apan kau bawa bawa nama Indonesia hahhh ?!!!!!!🎉
Sabah, Sarawak, Johor jadi negara merdeka juga
saudari saudaraku melayu patani..semoga saudari saudara sentiasa diberkati dan dirahmati ALLAH TAALA
Sekarang banyak negara asia tenggara dimasuki ajaran wahabi terorist,indonesia utuh sampai sekarang tidak terpecah pecah karena ajaran islam moderat, kini banyak orang asia tenggara beriman kepada ajaran islam radikal teroris, ciri cirinya wajib jilbab, tidak boleh berteman dengan kafir, bahkan mengucapkan salam untuk rasa persahabatan antar agama gak boleh dan banyak lagi, ajaran seperti itu hanya memicu konflik, apalagi sampai mrmisahkan diri, jadilah agama yg mau berdamai dengan agama manapun pupuk toleransi, beri jabat tangan bukan pukulan tangan.
That was soo good documentary. Thank you so much. It was an eye opener.
I love how anywhere Islam is, it causes these exact problems.
Religion of peace 😂
I love regardless how the facts are, people like you will still be blinded and blame Islam and muslims for everything you do. Exactly your kind throw the first stone and expecting muslims to not retaliate.
Eh, pretty natural response when a country decided to annexed another territory and forced them to become what they're not. Even hong kong-er retaliated with violent protest when china want to exert more control on them 🤷♂️
@@syahmiqawiem yet Hongkonger never killing 7000+. Innocent people with guns bombs decapitated and burn you talk bullshit who force who to become who in this case in Thailand name any policy from Thai gov that suppress local culture nah you can't there ain't so stop your nonsense and just admit it's religion of peace problems.
@Pls_dont_eat_macat the hong kongers did stabbed and throw molotov directly at polices. I didn't remember when both actions were not with the intention to kill. I also didn't remember the ukrainian , irish, papuan, sardinian, vietnamese, korean and many other armed separatist movement are muslims
Good on Thai people, learn from Sri Lanka and Myanmar 🙌🏻💯❤️
Learn about what?
Thailand must give them special otonomy like Aceh province in Indonesia. Let them build their future without prejudice and discrimination.
I believe them patani" people has blood relation with Indonesia clan (maybe Java and Melayu).
Did you ask all people there want it? What a clown 🤡
You throw gasoline on the fire. Each country has many ethnicities. Imagine if each ethnic claims to be autonomy then claims be independent. How subdivided the country will be. Just allow them do their religion practice is ok, treat them as fair as other ethnic. Should be learnt from Singapore.
Should be learnt from Singapore..😂😂😂😂
If you are not open for an ethical debate plz dont comment. Telling other a clown is not a value in disscusion.
Autonomy? Here, you are talking about the country that has never been colonized by the west and it has only one governing body. Thailand is different from Malaysia and Indonesia. It is not a federal state. Proposing autonomouse region is not different from seperating Thailand into two countries which may be not a big deal in Malaysia and Indonesia, but it is the redline in Thailand.
Not only has there been 20 years to take action but the lead suspect is ex-General cum Phue Thai MP Pisarn who was recently allowed to go overseas after he became suddenly "sick" (you know, like Thaksin did) and was allowed to travel overseas for "treatment" and will no doubt make a swift return as the statute of limitations expires.
Sadly familiar two tier Thai "justice" system.
Free the malay states from the Buddhist government.!!
Bodoh ko ni 😂😂😂
free muslim women from abusive muslim men
Free Sarawak from Malaysia❤
@@mattnoMatt-s2u free the world from backward ideology like Islam!!
@@zeik04😂😂😂
The narrator got some really accurate pronunciation.
Just a simple question. Will Malaysia support a land for the NON Muslim like their sympathy for these southern Thai Muslim.
Simple answer, are the cause of the situation is by coloniser and is the ppl that claim that land are actually the native ppl itself and not a foreign ppl who just follow the book because of they religion. We support the native and they right in they own land.
Yes,they already did
Yes. It’s called Singapore… 😂😂😊
😂simple answer,you were taken out of china,while northen malays never gone anywhere,there a different
Pulau Pinang
Just look at Malaysia's PAS party, you will find the"AUTHENTIC" answers.
Just look at DAP... Raising islamophobic in our country by making false statement...
Look at DAP, become China mainland.😂😂😂
Shut up PAS is native to this land meanwhile DAP is from China mainland people 😂😂
Look up DAP the communist party
What the injustice for the victim and the leader who killed by accident got away.
They want justice in Thailand, Myanmar, India, Israel, Germany, Russia, Norway, Denmark, South Korea, Greece, Armenia, Sri Lanka but they don't want to give justice in Iraq, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Afghanistan, Turkey, Iran. 😅
😜
Here you are talking as if you are any better. Let's not even talk about minorities of India, lower caste Hindus are oppressed for thousands of years by your own fellow Hinuds. You have the audacity to talk about the matter you have no idea. Sit down clown :D
Then look at yourself bloody prinders
HARMONY is the foundation of WEALTH 💞💞💞
Free Sarawak from Malaysia..
in your dream…
And join Brunei ? LOL
Goodluck with china
@@hassankhuzmawi2834 And yet Malaysia wants to join BRICS which benefits China. So, Free Sarawak from Malaysia.💪
Ok
There were sound of gun battles yesterday 26.10.24....reported by people across the border in Malaysia.
As a Muslim Iranian, I pray Patani having independence from Thailand.
Peaceful community spreading peace in Phillipines, India, myanmar and now Thailand
😂😂😂no peace in the Philippines, Muslim for war not for peace.😂😂😂😂
@@pangitko3142di*k slave spain
@@pangitko3142typical pinoy😂
The Thai government has been horrible to this people. Give them back their land!
Different regions diferent countries
But same religion and same mindset .. ofc problme is ixlam😊😊
Exactly. Moslem cannot live in harmony with any other religion because they are always thirsty of power to control with their obsession of shariah.
the problem is you people
the problem is, islam is beautiful religion, the land are beautiful and full of blessing, others are jelous about it and want annexation the land..
@@cosmaputra879 Holy cow ..yes the world is soo in jealous of you ... the rest of us are trying soo hard to be like Afghanistan, Pakistan
Seriously ? I don't think any nation on earth has a mental disorder to be another hellhole
Peoblem is paje*t
Saya dari indonesia.. tetap sabar untuk saudara muslimku di thailand❤
Then also pray for your brothers in Papua?
God bless Isreal
😂😂😂
Israel Wil be free from earth
Go to Israel
Selepas 2 tahun, thaksin disingkirkan dalam keadaan hina dan keji sebagai pemimpin zalim
I personally felt Bangkok didn't have any interest in Southern Thai where predominantly occupied by Muslims. Might as well give them independence and let them run their provinces independently. Those who ran away and didn't get prosecuted after the conflict 20 years ago should be brought to the court again. I can't fathom how the Thai government could close one eye for this inhumane act by the military and Thaksin during that time. What a shame !
I from Narathiwat Southern Thailand 🇹🇭
They deserve to be independant as thai occupied those area..
เราคนไทยทุกคนและทุกจังหวัดรักพี่น้องชาวสามจังหวัดชายแดนใต้ค่ะและเราอยู่ร่วมกันได้ ยกเว้นภาคอีสานคนพวกนี้อคติชอบดูหมิ่นอสลามและชอบสร้างความแตกแยกเรื่องศาสนาในสังคมไทย สู้ๆค่ะพี่น้อง 3 จังหวัดจากภาคกลาง ✌️🙏❤️
From Ayuthia to Nakhon Si Tammarat it was never southern thai, the locals were part of Cham with Malay lineage,
My suggestion,, give them autonomy in local politics, education, law etc. Beside that like army, foreign policy & most of taxes belong to Thai.
If thai government neglected them like this , we malaysia would gladly accepted those territories and people as our own.
เอาคนไป ดินแดนของสยาม
Songkhla people chill ( basically me )
And songkhla is southern Thailand but doesn’t have connections with Malaysia but mostly Chinese
Take your people back. If they don't want to live in Thailand But the country's territory cannot be taken away. If they don't want to stay, wouldn't it be easier to get rid of them?
The three south region should be a buffer zone! Autonomy and free from foreign influence.
The thai government and politicians should try and be more professional. These persecutions are NOT a solution to anything, but it will onlu end peace
They did not show the infamous video of thai army brutality on people who was captured in tak bai
Why don't they go to Malaysia?
why they go to another country when the land belong to theirs? wtf
One MFK just gets away with a smiley face because of the Statute of limitations and the corruption in our judiciary.
Young Patani folks themselves up to this day still brought up the ethnonationalism point . That's why PULO and BRN are still active and present to this day. Many of them still viewed Bangkok as a colonizer and occupied their land.
Imagine since year 1795, noted the downfall of Patani kingdom, they are still resilient to Thai authority until now. Malaysians are not the one sparking this ethnic nationalism thing, it is a value that Patani people uplifted by themselves.
I don't really know if the majority of Patani people want to get independence or not. But i do sense that patani young folks mostly prefer for autonomy better than independence.
Semoga Allah memelihara kita semua saudaraku... Keadilan akan tertegak jua InsyaAllah
In india problem with hidus,Thailand problem with buddies, chiana problem with Chinese community,eruope problem with Christian...if Muslim become majority only God except Allah...
The U.S never talks about human rights in Thailand haha
May malay states in Southern Thailand gain independence
The last attack was in 2018, so far no violence since then, and the govt have apologised
Deep problem for these 3 southern provinces and some part of Songkhala not related with Thai Muslim. Most Thai people and many people in Asean don't know cause a problem. I think many Thai muslim live happily and peace in another part of Thailand. This 3 provinces and some part of Songkhala mostly or majority races namely Malay Patani. They use different language and culture. Historically they have war with Siamese empire almost since 200 year ago. They feel betrayed by the 1909 anglo siamese treaty. After world war 2 they get betrayed again by British and Thai government. Many religious teacher and leaders of Patani get killed by Siamese force. Your know Haji Sulong? He demand justice Malay patani people. He not seek directly independence from Thailand for Patani. He just ask 7 demanded right for Malay Patani people. What happen to him?. Get killed by Thai government and very unjustice to him. Since 2004 Takbai masscre new erupted and anger of Malay patani to Thailand government until today. Actually Malay patani don't want any war and unjustice do it by Thailand government and military. Let go to the peace. Key point Thailand government know what they need to do. All the solutions and deal already on the table. Let Malay Patani self determination for their region or if Thailand very hard to give them independence let find another solution like give them autonomy reunited 3 regions as one region. Let approve 7 demand from late Haji Sulong. Peace no war.
Thigh land is full of talent…
Vote for independent
Right,win or lose is another story