The way Rattle cues the massive bass trombone and tuba decending line just after the 2 minute mark makes me indescribably happy. Also, fantastic job by the horn section.
It's an interesting and showy idea, but the horn parts aren't *that* virtuosic, thematically significantly (we've heard the theme many times already... at least a wild key change would be more ...proper) or dazzling. The effect falls flat for me.
@@VanessaHolguin no offense to the Berlin Phil horns- but this performance does fall a little short. In the best performances, the energy is much more full and captivating- even more so if you get to see it live. It’s also important to have it within context of the whole piece. Mahler knew what he was doing when he told the horns to stand.
@@VanessaHolguinMahler wanted the horns to stand up so they could sound more forte and epic to the audience and the music. Is that so hard to understand...?
The most exciting piece I ever performed as a horn player! Exhausting, to be called upon to perform the most heroic horn passagaf ever, at the end of this 1 hour long masterpiece!
Even with 8 horns standing, we could not hear them that strongly. Perhaps the audience members behind them sucked up the sound? More projection was needed. That's what Mahler wanted.
Nicely done- great horns and percussion- but Simon, im a little disappointed that you rushed through the final bars too quickly...This was the hero conquering all adversaries and his moment of glory and it needed to be a bit slower! But overall nice job.
I was always taught that I didn't have to inflate my cheeks while playing and I did so.But I think it is a bit unnatural, I really don't understand why.
ab cd I’m guessing you are talking about a brass or wind instrument. If so, inflating your cheeks basically doesn’t allow you to engage all the muscles you need in your mouth to play.
ab cd it kind of diverts the air, so the airflow is a little bit sporadic and when you tighten your cheeks, you can get a more consistent airflow. I am a f horn player as well
Валторны как один, Алексадер 103 как эталон звука инструмента валторна всё же впереди, не шмид и другие хойеры, тем более американские. Очень удачная модель с великим прошлым и надеюсь будущим.
I have a theory that Karajan left this symphony alone for the reason of the flamboyant instructions from Mahler for the Horns to stand, one thing Karajan was not is flamboyant!
FAAAAANTASTIC PERFORMANCE OF SS RATTLE... WHO IS THE BEAUTIFUL LADY WHO STANDS UP TO BLOW THE HORN???? I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW YOUR NAME.... FROM MEXICO APR252023
In the instant just before the horns stand up, about 1:29, see Sarah Willis glancing to her left to make sure she rises in sync with her colleagues.
The way Rattle cues the massive bass trombone and tuba decending line just after the 2 minute mark makes me indescribably happy. Also, fantastic job by the horn section.
Gustav Mahler ha composto la colonna sonora di Star Trek un secolo prima!!! Finale stellare!!! Il Titano che spezza le catene!!! Sovrumano!!!
Bellissimo commento 🙂
Absolutely beautiful. this joyful and powerful finale often moves my heart to tears. It's overwhelming.
He escuchado esta preciosa sinfonía muchas veces y siempre el final me hace llorar
満足！納得！ありがとう！日本から！感謝を込めてブラボー！
So many musicians, such a fat sound! Look at how many horns are playing! Love Mahler for his aspirations of creating huge orchestras with huge sound.
Yes, thank you Mahler for providing more jobs for musicians.
@@peterrollinson-lorimer Lol that is a consequence but yeah 😂
As big as a Titan
Meravigliosa esecuzione,Corni Mitici,grandiosi👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
When they all stand up at 1:29 -- so wonderful!
It's an interesting and showy idea, but the horn parts aren't *that* virtuosic, thematically significantly (we've heard the theme many times already... at least a wild key change would be more ...proper) or dazzling. The effect falls flat for me.
@@VanessaHolguin I think it’s because it’s the last time the theme is played. It’s closure
@@VanessaHolguin no offense to the Berlin Phil horns- but this performance does fall a little short. In the best performances, the energy is much more full and captivating- even more so if you get to see it live. It’s also important to have it within context of the whole piece. Mahler knew what he was doing when he told the horns to stand.
@@VanessaHolguin It's what Mahler wanted. But you know better, of course
@@VanessaHolguinMahler wanted the horns to stand up so they could sound more forte and epic to the audience and the music. Is that so hard to understand...?
Lovely close up shots of the amazing and gorgeous Sarah Willis on the French horn 😍
HORNS!!!!!!!!!!
Sarah!
My favorite Mahler moment!
MARAVILLOSA INTERPRETACION DE LA BERLINER CON ESOS GENIOS DE MUSICOS NO PODIA SER DE OTRA MANERA.-SALUDOS DESDE ARGENTINA.-
It's all about the 📯📯📯📯📯📯📯📯
The most exciting piece I ever performed as a horn player! Exhausting, to be called upon to perform the most heroic horn passagaf ever, at the end of this 1 hour long masterpiece!
The king stood. "And He shall reign forever and ever."
Tears to my eyes 😭 so good
MONUMENTAL OBRA MUSICAL EN ESTA VERSION SUPREMA!
Lenny essa música para sempre vai fazer parte de você.
Takt op destiny :)
A melhor Orquestra Filarmônica do mundo.
Just amazing performance of Gustav Mahler!
Mahler Titan Masterwork 🤩
¡ Que perfección!
Happy birthday Meister Gustav Mahler.
Sublime el genio de Mahler
my favorite finale
Absolutely glorious horns!!! 😢
ホルン…かっこいい…✨泣
MAHLER ES HERMOSO.!! IMPTESIONANTE!!! SIN DUDA EL.MAS GRANDE Y JUNTO A SUS GENIALES ANTECESORES..UNICO
Mahler es el más grande del post romanticismo alemán, y uno de los grandes de todos los tiempos
Very beautiful and sensitive music.
Imaginemos.uma.orquestra sem as trompas ... Fantásticas !!!
Insane!!!! Bravoooooo
Berlim a melhor Orquestra Filarmônica do Mundo.
A colocação dos baixos está à ewquerda do Maestro ?!
Magnífico
Musica bella e grandiosa
Beyond belief fabulous!!
Two timpanists... Omg
Right nice, right nice.....
Contrary to the explicit instruction in the score, the horns stand up 4 bars too early.
Bravo.
Merci de nous faire partager...
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Even with 8 horns standing, we could not hear them that strongly. Perhaps the audience members behind them sucked up the sound?
More projection was needed. That's what Mahler wanted.
Je joue de la clarinette, mais écouter Mahler me donne envie de jouer de la trompette
Mon Français n’est pas Bon, mais je joue la trompette, et c’est trés amusante. Je commence jouer le hautbois, et c’est trés dificile
Nicely done- great horns and percussion- but Simon, im a little disappointed that you rushed through the final bars too quickly...This was the hero conquering all adversaries and his moment of glory and it needed to be a bit slower! But overall nice job.
Bellezza assoluta.
¿Por qué apuró el final? Hubiera dado un dramatismo más expresivo y sentido a las notas, pero...
Cada director tiene su estilo, algunos rápidos o lentos como celibache o karajan en algunas ocasiones
❤❤❤❤❤
Der letzte war irgendwie etwas zu leise, oder? 🤔
Sir Simon = G.Mahler❤
The horns ringing always reminds me of christmas tunes.
👏👏👏👏👏
E M O C I O N A N T E ! ! !
At 1.28 quote of the Messiah of Handel “And he shall reign forever…” spiritual triumph of the hero??
I was always taught that I didn't have to inflate my cheeks while playing and I did so.But I think it is a bit unnatural, I really don't understand why.
ab cd I’m guessing you are talking about a brass or wind instrument. If so, inflating your cheeks basically doesn’t allow you to engage all the muscles you need in your mouth to play.
@@benjaminhr1331 yeah I meant french horn
ab cd it kind of diverts the air, so the airflow is a little bit sporadic and when you tighten your cheeks, you can get a more consistent airflow. I am a f horn player as well
First - you have to learn proper fundamentals. When you already a professional player, sometimes you do puff your cheeks ;) Trust me
Валторны как один, Алексадер 103 как эталон звука инструмента валторна всё же впереди, не шмид и другие хойеры, тем более американские. Очень удачная модель с великим прошлым и надеюсь будущим.
Takt Op Destiny fans where you at?
Horns at 1:01
I iz jealous of the people present in that hall that day 🥺
GOD EXISTS!
It's not god , it's Mahler.
I have a theory that Karajan left this symphony alone for the reason of the flamboyant instructions from Mahler for the Horns to stand, one thing Karajan was not is flamboyant!
Karajan was way over rated!
Who is this!!!
Sir Simon Rittle
MGI2023 - Opening Show / Highlight
말러 교향곡은 1,3,9번 3곡으로 충분하지 않을까
7👏
FAAAAANTASTIC PERFORMANCE OF SS RATTLE... WHO IS THE BEAUTIFUL LADY WHO STANDS UP TO BLOW THE HORN???? I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW YOUR NAME.... FROM MEXICO APR252023
It is Sarah Willis
Greetings from East Anglia in England
thank you@@uranrising
6:14
Wow , even Jean Martinon with a Japanese orchestra sounded more exciting than this . How can you have so many horns and make them sound so small ?
I always think the tradition of the horn section is vulgar!
la chica del corno qué distiguida from mexico
Es la principal de la sección, Sarah Willis, desde hace varios años. Hay videos instruccionales con ella aquí en YT. Saludos desde Guadalajara.
Il titolo titano non poteva non essere che azzeccato secondo me
CHAPEAU !!
Dennis Prager brought me here.
MMM
ちょいとためすぎな感じがする
The horns stand up 4 bars too soon!!
Abbado l'avrebbe diretta molto meglio.
Senza dubbio!
Sarah!