This reminds me a story where the teacher could not solve a simple science problem and when the student solved the problem, the teacher got mad and called the student names. And so goes episodes of Indian Parliament.
There are several issues. 1. Today 25 years olds need jobs. They dont worry about other things. 2. Todays youth are facing AI as competing entity they dont know what skills to develop. 3. Todays military needs high level technical skills. Not foot soilders. 4. Todays elderly are worried about living healthy lives and economy. 5. The EMI payinh middle class is not Fakirs they need strong economy. 6. Today is social media world. Instant decisions perceptions made. No one cares about 1975. Most dont know or remember except retired people. But there is nothing discussed about vision for India by anyone. Why
He is well aware of tactics deployed by Gandhi's and their stooges who have otherwise very little to offer in terms of vision for country's development and growth.
@@Hehekk197 Really? Doubling of medical seats , expressways, electrification of railways, digital payments, metro rail, electricity production, all fake? 🤔
@@1008apocalypse1008 Have u seen the condition of railways in India or are u blind?? Electricity production.. ya'll talking abt basic needs smh. Doubling of medical seats but cant conduct a single exam properly😂
For a PM with experience it was a truly childish show. No maturity for anman who is 74years old and supposed to be a seasoned politician. His strength seems to be sarcasm, ridicule not at all becoming of a PM.
Why change the narrative and not try communicating with the millennials through the real history of independent India and tell them what the real 'emergency' looked like?? I understand the "past is the past" kind of thinking, but past should never be ignored completely as those who don't learn from the past are doomed to fall in the same pit again...
We are in 2024 and the histort of Emergency doesn't matter to people. We have outlived it . Its an expired part of history . Cam the Government answrers the burning issues of the people and the oppressed people ? Can the government reply on NEET, unemployed youth resorting to crimes due to no jobs? Can they respond to price rise, the vakue of Rupee? Can they respond to the facts about agnipath? Can they talk about of Manipur and Ladhak ? Can they talk about contractors responsible to the pathetic infrastructure which was flagged by PM ? Can the Government respond to Chinese intrusions ? Can they respond to the loss of MSME ?
@@1008apocalypse1008 no one wants to leave in the past . Its present which matters which will lay the foundation for the future . It's not the opposition that is responsible for the misery of common people in last 10 yrs . It's this very governments misplaced priorities over the social well being of citizens.
If Modiji gives respect to opposition he will get respect in return but PM of india has stooped so low by calling Rahulji names Actally PM is childish not Rahul Gandhi.
It is Kerala MP Hibi Eden who took the glass of water from PM and drank from it. The glass was first offered to Manickam Tagore which he politely refused. Both are Congress MPs.
Why should Modi be on the Blackfoot simply because he could not beat his own spectacular electoral performances of 2014 and 2019. He would have been on the Blackfoot had he scored a poor 99 like congress.
The crux of the matter is that they have the majority and that matters. Modi knows that people will never give the opposition enough vote to rule in their own right. So now and in the future he has the same power that he had in the parliament before. This is the reality of politics in India. It will take decades for Congress to come on its own and others will not side with them totally. There will always be CBN and Nitish to fil the gap for the BJP.. His warning of the opposition ecosystem being dealt with if they do not improve should never be taken lightly. It is possible half of them would be in jail sooner or later under the new laws. So his style in parliament did not come from thin air. He is 100% confident and understands politics like the back of his hand unlike any other politician.
Modi- Shah pair has an immense hatred for Gandhis . They are not just political rivals but personal enemies. So they were meted out a lot of disrespect and humiliation in last 10 years. Now the tables have been turned to some extent though not completely. Until this personal enmity remains, Modi regime cannot behave in a democratic way. That's the root problem
Prime Minister , the politician bitten by the bug of 'absolutism' for over 2 decades that culminated in an absurd statement of ,'Non- Biological human being' coincidentally not 'endorsed by the Mother Ganges ' having compounded his complex attitude beyond any retrieval / comeback !
BJP cannot believe where congress is now. They wanted congresa mukth bharat. The truth is PM and Amit shah hace their own agenda of their hadred to gandhi Nehru family honestly PM statemenrs looks like rhe story of sour grapes. He makes Bizarre statements
@@noneoftheabove666absolutely correct. The Damn beanbrain corrupt dynast Rahul Gandhi is spreading blatant lies and the fight needs to be taken right to him
Modi said, in 1993, the infamous kukis clashes against the Nagas of Manipur. There were no phones or Facebook, youtube, or any social media, still the communal conflict between the two tribes continue for 5 years. Today, it's 2024. And Modi is saying that conflict took 5 years m what does that mean. Boycott Modi and get out of India.
Amazing and shamelessly open bias. They carefully didn’t discuss the contents of Rahul’s speech or his conduct since he became LOP. If the opposition has some amazing ideas let’s see great debates, but they will always run away from it.
We have seen congress run two UPA governments with fewer number on board. Foisting Aruna Roy headed National Advisory Council on PM Manmohan Singh was the latest in series of proof that Modi could have cited to prove that congress does not give two hoots for the constitution. Congress does not have any feet to stand on. They are as dead as dodo. These shenanigans can’t affect the impact that Modi has made in the last decade.
As citizens can we have some light on who controls both houses in Parliament, it's very evident the Government has the remote. Does this constitutes a fair and just session, where the voice of India must be heard by it's elected representatives. Is there hope for a better India?
We are enjoying a stronger opposition. For a robust democracy you need a strong opposition. It’s was extremely worrying that new criminal bills were passed without any discussion
We are 140 cr population government can't give you all the jobs You start a start up and provide jobs Government role is to Provide easy access to setup businesses This government gave PLI product link incentives which is like if you want to open a manufacturing plant or a start up government will give benefits like tax exempt for few years and etc
Miss Barkha ...even if no one interupts they have their very own speaker to intervene. Have you seen the proceedings of the parliament or you want to believe the ministers of Jhumla party
Prime minister is a foolish man or what? How many people have been died while he was neglected? Anyone or any political party will politisize it if it continues for very long time.
It is sad and unfortunate to see the behaviour of elected members who kept heckling when a member is speaking. Shows the shallowness and lack of intellect of the hecklers
First time I see Modiji face such faded . However I should admit he shined last 20 years ( 10 years in Gujarat and 10 years in National ) which is ultimate milestone for any politician . Now his time to end and new leader should emerge .That is the world rule .
Miss. Barkha, how intelligently and cleverly Ragulji presented his speech in the parliament, without hurting any group. But bjp felt hurt beause they are wrong in every field.
The scene shifted post balkanization of the State of J&K in Aug 2019, handed over to Modi Ji by Singh Sahab that manifested in parting ways by Shiv Sena ; Akali Dal , the regional political parties , having struck the Chord in South with Jharkhand from North in the ring!
Modi has been forced to speak on Manipur. He did not speak spontaneously, though he spoke. He spoke, NOT bcos he is concerned about us. He could no longer bear d pressure now as his party is reduced to such a low number..... shame on Modi n BJP
According to Nilanjan, the PM has to bow down to a LOP who has only 99 seats and he can be belligerent but the PM has to tolerate his brashness. Mukherjee seems to think that he is very objective just because he has written a book on Modi.... The opposition shouted down Modi because , in my opinion, he is a far better speaker and the congress was scared that he would make an impression.. which he did despite the shouting. Did Mukherjee give any solutions as to how to handle any disruption?? No, his method was that the PM should pacify and not be strong..... He has forgotten 240 is more than 99. The junta has spoken. Please respect the mandate and Mukherjee, come to terms with the fact that this govt will serve its 5 yr term. The opposition also needs to be responsible because the junta is watching ....
1/Need total Transparency; 2/Leave Govt Institutions alone; ex; CBI/ED/IT/JUDICIARY/ RI/ POLICE ..Etc 3/Need one and all be Humble; Serve with all Humility. we do not need GAMMAND; AHANKARA. Over Confidence.. Serve to LIFT all poor indians out of poverty. to prosperity; Educate one and all Indians. Shelter to all living in SLUMS..Zompdapattis. Best Infra structure all to be handled by MILITARY..THE ARMY. since rest all are CORRUPT.. TOTALLY CORRUPT; SUB STANDARD.
Confused, Barkha said welcome back to the show, Nilanjan makes it clear it is his first time on her show. Anyways it is delightful to get back to having truthful commentators
Wow Nilanjan. While just touching upon the grave childish immature behaviour of his prince, immediately the narrative is diverted towards Modi. Wow Ecosystem lives 😮
first of all, heckling happened during last lok sabha too. I heard the speech by Modi few months ago where he was continuously heckled on Adani. Obviously the anchor, and the so called author either do NOT know or think it does not fit the narrative they are trying to build. leader of opposition came across as immature as they did NOT even let PM to make a speech. did NOT ruling party listen to opposition quietly ? it sounds like opposition is more frustrated that there is NO change, situation remains what it was for last 10 years for another 5 years.
In response to many queries put forward by opposition..Modi has nothing to utter more than just refers to the past instances occurred during 1975 & 1948'49,50
Why do modi always refer to Emergency period when criticism are being raised at his govt .. We the youth want jobs n an ease from inflation,,not to hear Namo lecturing always Emergency, Emergency, Emergency, Indira,Indira,Indira...
Rahul 's verbal diarrhea did not deserve to be dignified. Rahul should listen to Shrimati Sudhu Murthy' s maiden speech in the Rajia sabah to UNDERSTAND AND LEARN how to Address Parliament and how to contribute to THE DEVELOPMENT OF BHARAT
I appreciate Barkha Mam for this interview. It reveals the true reality of the ideologies the guests are hiding. Modi is not in denial mode but the Congress is acting delusional as if they are in majority. When you're biased(i am referring to the guest) towards a party, you'll downplay the other side. 240 is still a bigger mandate than what Congress got in the last two decades. 5:46: The loyalists start justifying as always. Stop sucking up to the Gandhis. Rahul Gandhi was ousted for a valid reason, just like Mahua Moitra for accepting gifts and Kejriwal for the Alcohol Scam. 8:30: Yes, saar, why let the parliament run? Hooliganism and shouting in parliament is very good,huh?? Taxpayer's money is for fun, from the Bofors scam to the 2G scam.
The gentlemen saying they dont care emergency, what we have to do with Mandir, Kasmir me peace se hme kya mila.. These are the people who would someday say, What our parents has done, we dont know and care. They will respect the parents who give them solid bank balance, but wont appreciate the sacrifices of their parents by simply saying, mujhe kya mila. I hate this type of new generation who claim to be educated.
We are clutching at straws where Modi seems to have taken up so much mindshare that making a passing remark is being touted as a speech on Manipur. There was no calling, no outreach of peace and no message to the people to withdraw arms. It was a defensive report of what the BJP has done to restore normalcy and a rebuke to the opposition. Sometimes we debate the perception and trivialities rather than the core issues on this channel. Why did he not speak about enforcing President rule after a year while the state continued to burn, while they were quite eager to do it in Kashmir? He rather spoke about how it was done in the Congress regime several times, because of their inability to run a small state, he seems like the stepson with a chip on his shoulder on the injustice of the stepmother (Congress). He didn't sound like a Prime Minister who has ruled the country for ten years with a clear strategy and vision. th-cam.com/video/zd3mb-PgNoA/w-d-xo.html
A insensitive , immature , inhuman emperor with zero accountability to the nation on matters which matter to people of India. Emperor only knows to taunt honest and true Rahul gandhi
His timline is of Sholay... Where Rahul Gandhi is dharamji, khadgey ji is Amitabh Bachchan... And Mausi is Mr Om Birla... The rest are in his tent.. who he is busy forcing to dance... And Ab Goli kha types... 😂... Someone please tell him about Gen X Mellinials, Gen z and the Balik boodhi Gen Alpha.. 1 of whom have a higher IQ then the whole BJP... I mean someone wake him up dudes😂😂😂😂
All of the M.Ps are wasting Time by calling names each other why not do their job by discussing paper leaks, "BABAS" , new Hitler Laws , Conditions of railway, Inflation etc .
Most of the press are bought by Modi. Where were they for the last 10 years. It is highly ridiculous to say that the treasury bench was quiet.😂😂😂😂 I don't know what for the PM didn't open anything on the common people's problems except implementing their agenda and making mockery of all Democratic forums. 😢😢😢
Sarcasm is a trait of a person with a Superiority complex who is clearly our PM. RG is truthful and humble which is the only way to challenge arrogance.
Nilanjan, though author of biography on Modi was very neutral. He spoke against Modis decisions and at the same time praised as well as criticised Rahul. I thought he would be biased.
Rahul Gandhi must pitch Lord Shiva against Modi, now. LOP Shri. Rahul Gandhi must expound on this point and travel thru-out India leading a "Shiv Yatra".. to fight and uproot Savarkar, head-on ! Do not care for Electoral Results. Do it in a spirit of National Duty. BALAK BUDDHI v/s. BAYL BUDDHI (tremendous potential v/s stagnation, a swamp). Child is The Father of The Man ! Ustadji (56"), is cracking up. Paanch-veen Fail., M. Phil (Oxford) ko munh chidaa rahaa hai. Chal'ni, Dongay ko Munh chidaa rahii hai ! Issues ko totally skip / avoid kar kay, cheeta-kashi aur bazaari baaton par utar aaya hai ! Chutkulay ISSUES kaa jawaab nahin ho saktay. "Balak Buddhi" waali baatein : [ NEET Fiasco, Inflation, 70 crore Indians Unemployed, Agniveer Contract Labour, MSP for Farmers, Collapse of Economy due to crony capitalism, Lynching Collapse of Law and order, and NOW, Infrastructure], naa karo. Ustad Ji (56") ko pasand nahin ! Adults : Desh kay assets / resources crony capitalists ko beych detey hain, Dangay (genocide of a certain community, identifiable by their attire) plan / execute kartay hain ! Yeh hai "Adult / Mature Mind" (BAYL BUDDHI) ki nishaani-yaan (as per Ustad Ji - 56").
Rahul spoke about ‘Daro mat’ and ‘Abhay mudra’. Thankfully not about ‘Mangal sutra’ , ‘Bhais’ - PM’s favourite song. About ‘Agni veer’ and bowing down of Speaker in front of leader of Treasury Wonder why there was no mention of the alleged corruption by Illegal Electoral Bond.
Modi has nothing to talk about except to talk about things dt happened 70 yrs ago. We r not at all bothered about what had happened 50-70 yrs bk. We need corruption free India, jobs, employment which is most important for us..... PM Modi is not in touch with an age of technology n science. Modi n d BJP do not have anything new to offer d youths of this country which wants to march forward with vibrance n strength
Modi never want to understand the burning issues of the country and the political history of our country. Instead of answering to Grahulji's question he runs away from it beause he never goes to the suffering situations. Will ever he understand anything.? In the hands of bjp our country is going down to the pit. So sad.
Humble background is a bagful of humbug. This is the beginning of the end. As a leader if you can’t present what plans there are for the people it only shows they don’t care and consider himself a god figure. 😅😅😅😅
I dont know what this guy is saying. Government still in majority so how increase in opposition change working other than some more MP from opposition can sought little louder. But technically majority gov can still do same thing unless their own allies does not support.
The ecosystem is gearing up! A simple point as a rebuttal to Mukhopadhyay's narrative - Modi spoke about what has been achieved and what will be done further in the 1st half of his LS speech. Yet Mukhopadhyay says that he has not spoken anything about giving any vision. If you are so biased that you only want to see what you want to see then your analysis is BS! The ecosystem's rant right now in essence is: The government should kowtow to the opposition's demand and narrative. This is bizarre. Matlab kuch bhi!
Well it was all lies and exaggeration. No substance whatsoever. Corruption has increased under BJP. He is the PM of India and therefore accountable to the people of this nation. What was the vision u speak about??
@@nanomunu Substantiate a lie and exaggeration that you mentioned. The vision is the vision of reforms, lowering governance, making governance efficient and tackling corruption. If you think corruption has increased under BJP them you are either an ostrich or a nincompoop. Neither are good. I am okay to say that the BJP has not tackled lower and mid level corruption in a lot of areas. However, they have removed it completely and substantially from a lot of areas. There is no high level corruption in BJP at the scale and scope of what was under Congress. Hope this answers.
In a way, as said here everything A to Z is available on social media, if so what is the meaning and relevance of "expunged" in today's world .... Emergency appears to be the only thuruppu gulan with BJP, they do not speak about what they have done to eradicate poverty, what they have done for the youth, to eradicate unemployment, what they have done to remove social injustice and so on...
Congress had been always against strengthening India and her armed forces, against building infrastructure near Chinese border and still is for whatever reasons. Same is the case now, hence opposition against Army recruiting. Congress has also been against Hindus, read the riot act Congress tried to bring in 2012...
People's talk, As per our logic, Those NTA organiser PRADEEP JOSHI belongs from where? he promote from where?.., this man already indulged on VYAPAM CORRUPTION in M.P, such a remarkable,how! govt nominated?..,As a controversial person they govt appointing in NTA at what basis?..,😅
To bring BJP down...The opposition needs to get Adani in Parliament direct in front of PM and his buddies..Like the US style... Issue Subpneius (spelling wrong)..get all the Adani group .Ambani.. Infosys group and big donors to face the House on live TV...we shall decide not Modi or Rahul...
RG is much more mature and equipped with facts, in context PM is worried,ill equipped,not in control of own speech, more or less bachpana in buddapa age is real issue.
@@bharatdave6288 err … right … its a great pity that i have no remembrance or consciousness of events that happened when i was 3 years old. Wonderful observation. 🙏👏👏
This reminds me a story where the teacher could not solve a simple science problem and when the student solved the problem, the teacher got mad and called the student names. And so goes episodes of Indian Parliament.
PM does not realise that the age group from 18 to 28 really don't care about emergency. It's 50 yrs and gone. They want jobs
Even the people who do care, Today they are much more likely to question the BJP than Congress
Exactly
I am 24 and i like pm modi and in my friend circle every one likes pm modi,but whom u are taking.?
@@PrathikKothariWhy do you like Modi is what I'm interested in....
@@maryannfernandes1291 i think he is better than rahul Gandhi he has vision for india ,he never does false promises like congress party
Modi is toooo late now on Manipur issue
Yes, I totally fail to see why he didn't talk about it particularly after the circulation of that woman's video! It was heartbreaking.
There are several issues.
1. Today 25 years olds need jobs. They dont worry about other things.
2. Todays youth are facing AI as competing entity they dont know what skills to develop.
3. Todays military needs high level technical skills. Not foot soilders.
4. Todays elderly are worried about living healthy lives and economy.
5. The EMI payinh middle class is not Fakirs they need strong economy.
6. Today is social media world. Instant decisions perceptions made. No one cares about 1975. Most dont know or remember except retired people.
But there is nothing discussed about vision for India by anyone. Why
Go for Pappu KHATA KHAT KHATA KHAT offer🤣
NM needs to be more moderate. He cannot go on as if he has all BJP support in Parliament. He's being deliberately blind to the reality.
He is well aware of tactics deployed by Gandhi's and their stooges who have otherwise very little to offer in terms of vision for country's development and growth.
Those who condone M8di's silence on grave issues are condoning violence in Manipur, Neet paper leaks, injustice to students, farmers etc.
@@1008apocalypse1008 bruh we've seen what Modi's "development" is. Total infrastructure collapse.
@@Hehekk197 Really? Doubling of medical seats , expressways, electrification of railways, digital payments, metro rail, electricity production, all fake? 🤔
@@1008apocalypse1008 Have u seen the condition of railways in India or are u blind?? Electricity production.. ya'll talking abt basic needs smh. Doubling of medical seats but cant conduct a single exam properly😂
The BJP were too stunned by RGs speech.
RG was doing false bravado,, 2july को सारा जाम निकाल दिया मोदी ने😄🔥
Pappu can’t even precent facts in Lok Sabha
Pappu can’t even precent facts in Lok Sabha
Pappu can’t even precent facts in Lok Sabha
Pappu can’t even precent facts in Lok Sabha
For a PM with experience it was a truly childish show. No maturity for anman who is 74years old and supposed to be a seasoned politician. His strength seems to be sarcasm, ridicule not at all becoming of a PM.
What is becoming of a PM ? Please do tell !
She perhaps seems to be of the view that an entitled dynast is a better option
@@prayagjoshi1179 look at Putin (strong leader.. 0 talk)
50% of India is born after Indira. PM is sounding like a old broken record. He needs a new narrative to connect with the millennials.
Reminding the brain dead what islamic congress had done in 1975.
Exactly sir
India is also tired of the Gandhi family and their corruption.
He must discard the Sabka Sath...narrative.
Why change the narrative and not try communicating with the millennials through the real history of independent India and tell them what the real 'emergency' looked like??
I understand the "past is the past" kind of thinking, but past should never be ignored completely as those who don't learn from the past are doomed to fall in the same pit again...
We are in 2024 and the histort of Emergency doesn't matter to people. We have outlived it . Its an expired part of history . Cam the Government answrers the burning issues of the people and the oppressed people ? Can the government reply on NEET, unemployed youth resorting to crimes due to no jobs? Can they respond to price rise, the vakue of Rupee? Can they respond to the facts about agnipath? Can they talk about of Manipur and Ladhak ? Can they talk about contractors responsible to the pathetic infrastructure which was flagged by PM ? Can the Government respond to Chinese intrusions ? Can they respond to the loss of MSME ?
But Rahul Gandhi can certainly condemn what happened fifty years ago but he won't because it was brought in by his grandmother.
Do we also have to forget our slavery period under Muslims and British?
@@1008apocalypse1008 no one wants to leave in the past . Its present which matters which will lay the foundation for the future . It's not the opposition that is responsible for the misery of common people in last 10 yrs . It's this very governments misplaced priorities over the social well being of citizens.
@@ravikuckian3685 And some how 60 years of Congress rule has nothing to do with the present situation we find ourselves in 😂
U are m
Modi is selling stale chapatis. No takers. Burnt out empty cartridge. Rahul has made a 56 inch hole in Modi's pyjama, exposing everything😂😂
😂😂😂 i like the 56 inch hole in the pajama..
LOL!!!
Fool's paradise! With 99 seats they are behaving as if they are having more than 3/4 th majority...
Modis face was like that a school bully who has been chastened by a new student
@davidkrupadanam1179 This is suchan imaginative statement. THE PM had to tolerate a stupid speech and that's the expression that I saw
If Modiji gives respect to opposition he will get respect in return but PM of india has stooped so low by calling Rahulji names Actally PM is childish not Rahul Gandhi.
It is Kerala MP Hibi Eden who took the glass of water from PM and drank from it. The glass was first offered to Manickam Tagore which he politely refused. Both are Congress MPs.
thank you for letting us know.
Why should Modi be on the Blackfoot simply because he could not beat his own spectacular electoral performances of 2014 and 2019. He would have been on the Blackfoot had he scored a poor 99 like congress.
In globe 🌎 first time only country have nonbiological PM
The crux of the matter is that they have the majority and that matters. Modi knows that people will never give the opposition enough vote to rule in their own right. So now and in the future he has the same power that he had in the parliament before. This is the reality of politics in India. It will take decades for Congress to come on its own and others will not side with them totally. There will always be CBN and Nitish to fil the gap for the BJP.. His warning of the opposition ecosystem being dealt with if they do not improve should never be taken lightly. It is possible half of them would be in jail sooner or later under the new laws. So his style in parliament did not come from thin air. He is 100% confident and understands politics like the back of his hand unlike any other politician.
Modi- Shah pair has an immense hatred for Gandhis . They are not just political rivals but personal enemies. So they were meted out a lot of disrespect and humiliation in last 10 years. Now the tables have been turned to some extent though not completely. Until this personal enmity remains, Modi regime cannot behave in a democratic way. That's the root problem
The Gandhis are too entitled too. See Modi as a brown naukar-chakar.
Prime Minister , the politician bitten by the bug of 'absolutism' for over 2 decades that culminated in an absurd statement of ,'Non- Biological human being' coincidentally not 'endorsed by the Mother Ganges ' having compounded his complex attitude beyond any retrieval / comeback !
Why on earth would anyone "spend a lifetime" studying Modi and RSS😅
Why not? People spend a lifetime studying fossils as well :P
@@pramodkrishnamurthy3707 and worse... studying the congress party
Shamelessly giving positive spin to dumb acts of opposition
BJP cannot believe where congress is now. They wanted congresa mukth bharat. The truth is PM and Amit shah hace their own agenda of their hadred to gandhi Nehru family honestly PM statemenrs looks like rhe story of sour grapes. He makes Bizarre statements
Very true hatred in politics towards the opposition is no good for democracy
Aur Kya puja kare Kya Gandhi pariwar ka?
The family looted and played the country for decades
@@noneoftheabove666absolutely correct. The Damn beanbrain corrupt dynast Rahul Gandhi is spreading blatant lies and the fight needs to be taken right to him
Modi said, in 1993, the infamous kukis clashes against the Nagas of Manipur. There were no phones or Facebook, youtube, or any social media, still the communal conflict between the two tribes continue for 5 years.
Today, it's 2024. And Modi is saying that conflict took 5 years m what does that mean.
Boycott Modi and get out of India.
Absolutely right, that's why we say he is feku.
Amazing and shamelessly open bias. They carefully didn’t discuss the contents of Rahul’s speech or his conduct since he became LOP. If the opposition has some amazing ideas let’s see great debates, but they will always run away from it.
We have seen congress run two UPA governments with fewer number on board. Foisting Aruna Roy headed National Advisory Council on PM Manmohan Singh was the latest in series of proof that Modi could have cited to prove that congress does not give two hoots for the constitution. Congress does not have any feet to stand on. They are as dead as dodo. These shenanigans can’t affect the impact that Modi has made in the last decade.
And there were so many bomb blasts happening at that time in our country and who could forget 26/11.i think some people's memory is short.
And we have no truth if our MP is a British or Indian. Voters need clarity of this confusion !
This is like teaching today's generation of what old gramophones used to operate.😂😂😂
As citizens can we have some light on who controls both houses in Parliament, it's very evident the Government has the remote. Does this constitutes a fair and just session, where the voice of India must be heard by it's elected representatives. Is there hope for a better India?
It's the Gandhis and their stooges who are shouting relentlessly and trying their best to silence the voice of the PM
I find all of you is enjoying depleted Modi….
We are enjoying a stronger opposition. For a robust democracy you need a strong opposition. It’s was extremely worrying that new criminal bills were passed without any discussion
The man has no right to life, when he does value others lives.
They talk about emergency. The current period is far worse than emergency if you really introspect...
Give us jobs, Mr. Prime Minister !
We are 140 cr population government can't give you all the jobs
You start a start up and provide jobs
Government role is to Provide easy access to setup businesses
This government gave PLI product link incentives which is like if you want to open a manufacturing plant or a start up government will give benefits like tax exempt for few years and etc
You id iot are you a gomuthra nagpur half knickers correct
U won't get job on TH-cam, so move ur butt and look for some work.
😂😂 what qualifications u have aunty…😂 job is ur responsibility not govt….i have job because I studied unlike u
How can pm give jobs? I am also jobless in bengal.
Very fair analysis of Mr. Nilanjan Mukhopadhaya.
The BJP does not have a think tank..it is Namo all the way...sadly!
Miss Barkha ...even if no one interupts they have their very own speaker to intervene. Have you seen the proceedings of the parliament or you want to believe the ministers of Jhumla party
Prime minister is a foolish man or what? How many people have been died while he was neglected? Anyone or any political party will politisize it if it continues for very long time.
Modi tried to twist what Rahul said but failed miserably. As during the election the public saw throughout the farse
The Modi boat appears won't sail smooth
Excellent conversation.many thanks.
Nilanjan gives very nuanced responses.lovely.
It is sad and unfortunate to see the behaviour of elected members who kept heckling when a member is speaking. Shows the shallowness and lack of intellect of the hecklers
It is scary what an unforgiving & spiteful man our leader has turned out to be. Rahul ,Sonia;Nehru & Rajiv we’re all elected to power ¬ nominated.
First time I see Modiji face such faded . However I should admit he shined last 20 years ( 10 years in Gujarat and 10 years in National ) which is ultimate milestone for any politician . Now his time to end and new leader should emerge .That is the world rule .
what was in Modi mouth all these months while manipur was burning....banana?
He appears to suffer from severe constipation after losing majority and suffering from withdrawal symptoms of power.😅
Miss. Barkha, how intelligently and cleverly Ragulji presented his speech in the parliament, without hurting any group. But bjp felt hurt beause they are wrong in every field.
The scene shifted post balkanization of the State of J&K in Aug 2019, handed over to Modi Ji by Singh Sahab that manifested in parting ways by Shiv Sena ; Akali Dal , the regional political parties , having struck the Chord in South with Jharkhand from North in the ring!
Modi is so childish and useless rhetoric. Drama drama more drama
And he called RG baal budhi..
And what Pappu is doing. Bloody buffoon. Has no sense of the responsibility as LOP.
says a rice bag who thinks rome still rules india
Modi has been forced to speak on Manipur. He did not speak spontaneously, though he spoke. He spoke, NOT bcos he is concerned about us. He could no longer bear d pressure now as his party is reduced to such a low number..... shame on Modi n BJP
Manipur has been under AFSPA since 1958. Why was it imposed? Did Manmohan or Rajiv ever speak on Manipur?
@@1008apocalypse1008Good question.
Nilanjan appears biased. The opposition is not allowing the parliament to function and he tries to put it deliberately differently
According to Nilanjan, the PM has to bow down to a LOP who has only 99 seats and he can be belligerent but the PM has to tolerate his brashness. Mukherjee seems to think that he is very objective just because he has written a book on Modi.... The opposition shouted down Modi because , in my opinion, he is a far better speaker and the congress was scared that he would make an impression.. which he did despite the shouting. Did Mukherjee give any solutions as to how to handle any disruption?? No, his method was that the PM should pacify and not be strong..... He has forgotten 240 is more than 99.
The junta has spoken. Please respect the mandate and Mukherjee, come to terms with the fact that this govt will serve its 5 yr term. The opposition also needs to be responsible because the junta is watching ....
1/Need total Transparency;
2/Leave Govt Institutions alone; ex; CBI/ED/IT/JUDICIARY/ RI/ POLICE ..Etc
3/Need one and all be Humble; Serve with all Humility.
we do not need GAMMAND; AHANKARA.
Over Confidence..
Serve to LIFT all poor indians out of poverty.
to prosperity;
Educate one and all Indians.
Shelter to all living in SLUMS..Zompdapattis.
Best Infra structure all to be handled by MILITARY..THE ARMY.
since rest all are CORRUPT.. TOTALLY CORRUPT;
SUB STANDARD.
Confused, Barkha said welcome back to the show, Nilanjan makes it clear it is his first time on her show. Anyways it is delightful to get back to having truthful commentators
One of the best interviews...enlightening and revealing...thank you Barkha
Who could gear it ?? Congress and other opposition members did not want anyone to hear it . They are not ready to hear facts😂
Wow Nilanjan. While just touching upon the grave childish immature behaviour of his prince, immediately the narrative is diverted towards Modi. Wow Ecosystem lives 😮
Thank you Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay for your frank opinion much to the discomfort of the barkha dutt !
first of all, heckling happened during last lok sabha too. I heard the speech by Modi few months ago where he was continuously heckled on Adani. Obviously the anchor, and the so called author either do NOT know or think it does not fit the narrative they are trying to build. leader of opposition came across as immature as they did NOT even let PM to make a speech. did NOT ruling party listen to opposition quietly ? it sounds like opposition is more frustrated that there is NO change, situation remains what it was for last 10 years for another 5 years.
Thought you would play the parts where Modi criticizes Sonia’s role as super PM and Rahul’s tearing of the ordinance bill?
In response to many queries put forward by opposition..Modi has nothing to utter more than just refers to the past instances occurred during 1975 & 1948'49,50
Why do modi always refer to Emergency period when criticism are being raised at his govt .. We the youth want jobs n an ease from inflation,,not to hear Namo lecturing always Emergency, Emergency, Emergency, Indira,Indira,Indira...
Perfectly valid points made. BRAVO!
Childish speech of PM
Waah beta 😂😂😂😂
Rahul 's verbal diarrhea did not deserve to be dignified. Rahul should listen to Shrimati Sudhu Murthy' s maiden speech in the Rajia sabah to UNDERSTAND AND LEARN how to Address Parliament and how to contribute to THE DEVELOPMENT OF BHARAT
Do you also notice that he accuses the opposition of the very thing he is guilty of .
I appreciate Barkha Mam for this interview. It reveals the true reality of the ideologies the guests are hiding.
Modi is not in denial mode but the Congress is acting delusional as if they are in majority.
When you're biased(i am referring to the guest) towards a party, you'll downplay the other side. 240 is still a bigger mandate than what Congress got in the last two decades.
5:46: The loyalists start justifying as always. Stop sucking up to the Gandhis. Rahul Gandhi was ousted for a valid reason, just like Mahua Moitra for accepting gifts and Kejriwal for the Alcohol Scam.
8:30: Yes, saar, why let the parliament run? Hooliganism and shouting in parliament is very good,huh??
Taxpayer's money is for fun, from the Bofors scam to the 2G scam.
Wish there were more biographers like him .
The gentlemen saying they dont care emergency, what we have to do with Mandir, Kasmir me peace se hme kya mila.. These are the people who would someday say, What our parents has done, we dont know and care.
They will respect the parents who give them solid bank balance, but wont appreciate the sacrifices of their parents by simply saying, mujhe kya mila.
I hate this type of new generation who claim to be educated.
The new story is not what the Congress did 50 years back. 😅
We are clutching at straws where Modi seems to have taken up so much mindshare that making a passing remark is being touted as a speech on Manipur. There was no calling, no outreach of peace and no message to the people to withdraw arms. It was a defensive report of what the BJP has done to restore normalcy and a rebuke to the opposition. Sometimes we debate the perception and trivialities rather than the core issues on this channel. Why did he not speak about enforcing President rule after a year while the state continued to burn, while they were quite eager to do it in Kashmir? He rather spoke about how it was done in the Congress regime several times, because of their inability to run a small state, he seems like the stepson with a chip on his shoulder on the injustice of the stepmother (Congress). He didn't sound like a Prime Minister who has ruled the country for ten years with a clear strategy and vision. th-cam.com/video/zd3mb-PgNoA/w-d-xo.html
A insensitive , immature , inhuman emperor with zero accountability to the nation on matters which matter to people of India. Emperor only knows to taunt honest and true Rahul gandhi
His timline is of Sholay... Where Rahul Gandhi is dharamji, khadgey ji is Amitabh Bachchan... And Mausi is Mr Om Birla... The rest are in his tent.. who he is busy forcing to dance... And Ab Goli kha types... 😂... Someone please tell him about Gen X Mellinials, Gen z and the Balik boodhi Gen Alpha.. 1 of whom have a higher IQ then the whole BJP... I mean someone wake him up dudes😂😂😂😂
All of the M.Ps are wasting Time by calling names each other why not do their job by discussing paper leaks,
"BABAS" , new Hitler Laws , Conditions of railway, Inflation etc .
Most of the press are bought by Modi. Where were they for the last 10 years. It is highly ridiculous to say that the treasury bench was quiet.😂😂😂😂
I don't know what for the PM didn't open anything on the common people's problems except implementing their agenda and making mockery of all Democratic forums.
😢😢😢
It is funny a party which did not care about parliament in last 10 years,suddenly started to talk propriety in parliament .White washed tombs
The ruling party got demoralized👏👍🙏
Sarcasm is a trait of a person with a Superiority complex who is clearly our PM. RG is truthful and humble which is the only way to challenge arrogance.
Talk of present pmji....do go back ....move forward....please in the name of PARAMATMA
Nilanjan is really good. Nice discussion.
Nilanjan, though author of biography on Modi was very neutral. He spoke against Modis decisions and at the same time praised as well as criticised Rahul. I thought he would be biased.
Modi forgot 2002 of Godra.
Rahul Gandhi must pitch Lord Shiva against Modi, now.
LOP Shri. Rahul Gandhi must expound on this point and travel thru-out India leading a "Shiv Yatra".. to fight and uproot Savarkar, head-on ! Do not care for Electoral Results. Do it in a spirit of National Duty.
BALAK BUDDHI v/s. BAYL BUDDHI (tremendous potential v/s stagnation, a swamp). Child is The Father of The Man !
Ustadji (56"), is cracking up.
Paanch-veen Fail., M. Phil (Oxford) ko munh chidaa rahaa hai. Chal'ni, Dongay ko Munh chidaa rahii hai !
Issues ko totally skip / avoid kar kay, cheeta-kashi aur bazaari baaton par utar aaya hai ! Chutkulay ISSUES kaa jawaab nahin ho saktay.
"Balak Buddhi" waali baatein : [ NEET Fiasco, Inflation, 70 crore Indians Unemployed, Agniveer Contract Labour, MSP for Farmers, Collapse of Economy due to crony capitalism, Lynching Collapse of Law and order, and NOW, Infrastructure], naa karo. Ustad Ji (56") ko pasand nahin !
Adults : Desh kay assets / resources crony capitalists ko beych detey hain, Dangay (genocide of a certain community, identifiable by their attire) plan / execute kartay hain ! Yeh hai "Adult / Mature Mind" (BAYL BUDDHI) ki nishaani-yaan (as per Ustad Ji - 56").
Don't worry Modi will get rid of Sharia inspired personal laws.
Rahul spoke about ‘Daro mat’ and ‘Abhay mudra’.
Thankfully not about ‘Mangal sutra’ , ‘Bhais’ - PM’s favourite song.
About ‘Agni veer’ and bowing down of Speaker in front of leader of Treasury
Wonder why there was no mention of the alleged corruption by Illegal Electoral Bond.
What exactly is the CORRUPTION in the Electoral Bond? You're being an id!0t
Bakha says Modi plays on front foot...!!
Enire India says Rahul won handsomely compare to Jumla Modi, in Parliament..
Modi has nothing to talk about except to talk about things dt happened 70 yrs ago.
We r not at all bothered about what had happened 50-70 yrs bk. We need corruption free India, jobs, employment which is most important for us.....
PM Modi is not in touch with an age of technology n science. Modi n d BJP do not have anything new to offer d youths of this country which wants to march forward with vibrance n strength
Modi never want to understand the burning issues of the country and the political history of our country. Instead of answering to Grahulji's question he runs away from it beause he never goes to the suffering situations. Will ever he understand anything.? In the hands of bjp our country is going down to the pit. So sad.
Humble background is a bagful of humbug. This is the beginning of the end. As a leader if you can’t present what plans there are for the people it only shows they don’t care and consider himself a god figure. 😅😅😅😅
But Nishikant Dube hit back in RS.
By the way 240 is farbetter than 99. I am not a BJP . Pl take note.
I dont know what this guy is saying. Government still in majority so how increase in opposition change working other than some more MP from opposition can sought little louder. But technically majority gov can still do same thing unless their own allies does not support.
CM did speak like a Statesman. He has to reply in language opposition understand!
Excellent Presentation 🌹
Nilanjan is making prejudicial assessment of modi. PM was calm and confident
Modi has his head on his shoulder..I don't agree abt denial, it's imp that he sends msg of continuity to d country and international community ..
The ecosystem is gearing up!
A simple point as a rebuttal to Mukhopadhyay's narrative - Modi spoke about what has been achieved and what will be done further in the 1st half of his LS speech. Yet Mukhopadhyay says that he has not spoken anything about giving any vision. If you are so biased that you only want to see what you want to see then your analysis is BS!
The ecosystem's rant right now in essence is: The government should kowtow to the opposition's demand and narrative. This is bizarre. Matlab kuch bhi!
Well it was all lies and exaggeration. No substance whatsoever. Corruption has increased under BJP. He is the PM of India and therefore accountable to the people of this nation. What was the vision u speak about??
@@nanomunu Substantiate a lie and exaggeration that you mentioned. The vision is the vision of reforms, lowering governance, making governance efficient and tackling corruption. If you think corruption has increased under BJP them you are either an ostrich or a nincompoop. Neither are good. I am okay to say that the BJP has not tackled lower and mid level corruption in a lot of areas. However, they have removed it completely and substantially from a lot of areas. There is no high level corruption in BJP at the scale and scope of what was under Congress.
Hope this answers.
that MP looks like Manickam Tagore of Congress from Tamilnadu
In a way, as said here everything A to Z is available on social media, if so what is the meaning and relevance of "expunged" in today's world ....
Emergency appears to be the only thuruppu gulan with BJP, they do not speak about what they have done to eradicate poverty, what they have done for the youth, to eradicate unemployment, what they have done to remove social injustice and so on...
Congress had been always against strengthening India and her armed forces, against building infrastructure near Chinese border and still is for whatever reasons. Same is the case now, hence opposition against Army recruiting. Congress has also been against Hindus, read the riot act Congress tried to bring in 2012...
The budget session will be unruly and likely to be a washout.
People's talk, As per our logic, Those NTA organiser PRADEEP JOSHI belongs from where? he promote from where?.., this man already indulged on VYAPAM CORRUPTION in M.P, such a remarkable,how! govt nominated?..,As a controversial person they govt appointing in NTA at what basis?..,😅
To bring BJP down...The opposition needs to get Adani in Parliament direct in front of PM and his buddies..Like the US style... Issue Subpneius (spelling wrong)..get all the Adani group .Ambani.. Infosys group and big donors to face the House on live TV...we shall decide not Modi or Rahul...
Nobody can accept PMs continuation of lies and that's the reason opposition needs keep boeing him,
RG is much more mature and equipped with facts, in context PM is worried,ill equipped,not in control of own speech, more or less bachpana in buddapa age is real issue.
I am 51 years old and I dont have any direct memory of the India is Indira thing. I have only read about it.
Pity for you not to remember atrocities of emergency.
You must be political illiterate
@@bharatdave6288 err … right … its a great pity that i have no remembrance or consciousness of events that happened when i was 3 years old. Wonderful observation. 🙏👏👏
Un educated u remember mogul but not vikryamdut
M
That MP is not from Manipur, be sure in identifying a person