来新加坡打工赚三倍真的不错吗？！｜ 马劳的心声
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2024
- 0:00 - 本集序幕
1:28 - 为什么来新加坡？BT's 的故事
4:53 - Kelvin's 的故事
6:47 - 移居新加坡的担忧
10:50 - Eric 对马劳的看法
12:53 - 没有国民服役还享受公民福利?
16:53 - 外汇的权重!
17:34 - 如果所有人都移民，谁会留下来发展马来西亚!？
25:41 - 马来西亚创业容易吗？
29:50 - 使用马来语学习科学科目对马来西亚华人有害吗?
32:15 - 打算在马来西亚退休吗？
[Sponsor]: Webull (Free Stock): www.webull.com.sg/i/BagholderPod
Co-host: @KelvinLearnsInvesting @TayChiKeng @BoonTee @learninvestearnsave
Moomoo (Free Stock): j.moomoo.com/00vq0m
Webull (Free Stock): www.webull.com.sg/i/BagholderPod - บันเทิง
个人认为，生活在那个国家都有好有坏。无论你从事那个行业，只要你有专长，生活在那里都不是问题。乡村人有乡村人的生活方式，他们也有为国家作出供献，用他们勤奋的双手种了许多各种各类鲜美蔬菜供城市人享用！虽然他们大部份人都不会讲英语，但是生话也蛮开心的！追求高物質享受当然没错，我们也要非常感谢农村人付出汗水为都市人带来新鲜又美味的农作物，感恩！
是的，鄉民羨慕城市的繁華，城市人響往鄉下的恬𧂮，各有所長，各取所好
I enjoyed your discussion.😊 You guys did an excellent job, particularly on such a topic in mandarin!👍.
这集的内容还不错，各位主持人都发表很好的建议与论点。加油！
Thanks Chris!
加油！
Welcome my Malaysian friends, most are hardworking n talented ❤❤❤
Kudos to the four of you! Please have more of these!
hm, not sure if ppl can tahan listening to our broken chinese all the time though....😅
你们太谦虚了，中文水平和表达能力一点都不弱. Bravo!
Smooth, very innovative guys, I enjoy this video .👏
Thank you kimmy for your encouragement!
哇～意外发现啊 ！赞啦！👍🏻
你们以中文交流也蛮流利的 。继续加油！
🙏
说不定你们“四人帮“会成为“阿嫂杀手”！😂😂😂
@@makwoon3635 😅
It is good to see these younger generations of guy are trying to practise their mandarin in this video. Keep it up . Looking forward to see these four guy to speak mandarin
Refreshing idea to use mandarin on the pod cast! As a employer myself, we also work with Malaysian employees and they really earn much more doing the similar job back in Malaysia. That is why most of them choose to come Singapore to work. 😊
What type of employment is common for Malaysians living in Singapore?
Great idea and refreshing podcasting in Chinese. The topic is very interesting too.
Thank you for your encouragement!
😂🎉 omg! Great effort in podcast in Chinese. Looking forward to 2nd episode
Glad you like it 😊
can use dialect? 😆@@bagholderpod
@@silvervoice haha, you ask boon tee
I’m impressed with all your spoken Chinese 👍
这一集用中文来交谈还蛮有趣的，加油😊
你们的视频讲得非常好！ 加油！
I like this episode!
Very refreshing and entertaining video. Eric's chinese is the best among the four gentlemen.
Wow, thanks
💯
😂@@BoonTee
Eric view is quite on the point. Good counterpoint on the NS part. Let’s us be appreciative of our brothers from Malaysia and neighbours countries.
Thank you ☺
在这里我看到马来西亚，中国，印度，斯里兰卡，菲律宾，缅甸，泰国，印度尼西亚等等为了生活都在这里奋斗。坦白说，我都希望你们自己的国家昌盛繁荣，在自己祖国安定生活，有哪一个人希望离乡别井的到他国工作？那种思乡的情愁，日子的辛酸，只有和自己遭遇相同的朋友才能深深体会。。我是新加坡人。。
这當然, 如果能在自已国家工作發展是最好不过, 能多和家人互动, 相聚是件幸福的事, 这难于用金钱来衡量, 畢竟人生很無常！🙏
沒辦法，這世界上的third world countries 主要還是貪污腐敗、亂搞的國家居多
Plse dun treat yourself as 马劳。But thanks for coming to Singapore n work. Contributing to the growth of this country. greeting from a Singaporean.
说的很好我认为要当新加坡公民要当兵这个建议不错。👍
Take the advantage of the PR status, enjoy the benefits of both side. Can work on both side easily and also buy HDB. You do not have to die die buy the condominium which is very expensive now. Now $1 is approximately 3.4 ringgit.
來新加坡工作，千万别赌博，工作不易，要花也要储蓄，更要照顾自己，别為了钱钱犧牲健康，最重要的是：別稱自己馬勞，別自貶身份
要怎麼稱呼？大馬勞？
新加坡总理在疫情期中发表言论的時候称呼外来的工作人员叫做（客工），李总理毕竟是受中文教育的，言语当中透露着对人的尊重👍
勞工二字中有哪一個字比較不尊重嗎？
lol, I always thought Kelvin is Singaporean. Good job guys. A mandarin channel.
One episode only, not considered a mandarin channel
很特别的一集，给人耳目一新的感觉。4位的华语都很不错。可贵的是， Chi Kang 的华语挺好的，因该是双语人才吧! 我所看到的一般年轻人根本无法这样侃侃而谈。继续加油喔！
😎
Agree that Chi Keng's mandarin is pretty impressive, I would say better than the average Singaporeans. 有前途！感谢四位主持人勇敢的尝试！
如果在家也是說英文，華語還能這麼好不簡單
从小学到大学，都要精通不同语言，实在厉害。所以多数马劳都是精英。
😂😂😂 留守马来西亚就不是精英了。因为没世界观的格局😂😂😂新加坡现在好比盛唐的长安，万国来朝😊😊😊
对咯！能说英语、华语、马来语，甚至是广东话和福建话！😮😮
虽然是精英，马劳普遍说话比较小声，因为马来西亚比较落后。
我本人是很尊敬马劳的。欢迎，欢迎。
@@whyh Same. Respect turned to love for my wife 😆
@@whyh小孩子的见解😂
😂😂😂一言难尽…very funny episode…都是半桶哪里有一桶😂😂😂
Amen 😂
I think Msia new goverment's direction is not on service industry，the industry focus approach emphasise investments in new development areas like electric vehicles, smart factories using 5G technology, supply chain ecosystems and green technology, example like Geely ev car, Amazon, Infineon, Alibaba etc.
Story aside, I think Ipoh is the biggest 马劳 supply to Spore after Johor like Kevin.
新加坡和马耒西亜,薪水是差别很大,记得要感恩新加坡,有些一面賺钱,一面罵新加坡
哉培人才被骂抢人才，马来西亚大学固打制，进不了，来新加坡被哉培，还骂新加坡抢人才。大马华人白眼狼不是没道理。
谈话内容组织性还要加强，处处保留结果也留下很多空间没有涉及，结论不够給力，希望多安排更多话题把讨论的深度加深一点，给你赞👍
Asking my parents to listen to your channel from today onwards
Thank you for your support ❤
到了45歲或以上55歲。。還停留在新加坡工作的可能回家也不是那麼經常有時間安排
那就等於和最親的家人見一次面。。。少一次面了。。。。
但是說到最後人總要學習獨立因為每個人是獨生。。獨來。。。
Many higher educated Malaysian choose to go to different parts of the world to get a better job prospect or even business opportunities. The unstable Malaysia economic status and also the pay scale of grads cannot compare to the other developed countries.
If only there's someone like LKY to lay the foundations.....such a pity
马来西亚称马劳，中国人称华劳？😂
哇！用华语开讲！我喜欢！可不可以常常用华语开讲呢？谈谈生活费、柴米油盐等课题，相信这样可以吸引更多的观众！👍👍
Imo, Malaysians in Sg, I see them as locals. Be it friends, neighbours, colleagues, I feel they have the same culture, language, food preferences, etc that locals can relate and connect to easily. It’s easy to work with them also bcuz they are very real, down to earth and hardworking ppl. As for the earning 3x exchange rate, I agree with Boon Tee, u earn and spend here, if u are going to retire here as well, really no difference. But the only difference I see is parental and home support. Because supporting parents back in Malaysia will be much less costly. I rem my Malaysian frens who travel back for CNY, the red packet they give to parents can really be quite a lump sum kind. But to be fair, being away from family is the sacrifice in return. As for NS, many Singaporeans treat as wasting time, held back from career progression. But I see it as a process of maturing, and acquiring the skills to self defend Sg when needed. Why would u want the Malaysians to go thru motion when the 意义 is not there? In return, Malaysians who came to sg to work, all of them are a source of rental income for locals. In terms of paying rents for many years compared to serving NS for 1+ years, monetary disadvantage wise, I wouldn’t say they are better off.
Very pragmatic views 👍🏻
ya honest take as Singaporean, I believe most Singaporeans don't really see Malaysians as foreigners. the cultures are just so similar it's really more like long lost siblings.
新加坡与马来西亚本是一家，更是唇齿相依，是无耐的政治历史給分割了，但我们的先辈很多是早年过来一步一个脚印和新加坡人一起打拚的，很多最终成为新加坡公民，那年代是很普遍的，所以很多人两边都有亲人，两边都是根，我道地的新加坡人，已年过七十，和国家一起走过动荡的岁月，也领取过很低的工资，年轻过的是捉衿见勒的日子，我们国家能走到今天，是靠人民与国家一起努力，这一切不是平白无故从天上掉下个来的，我们欢迎世界各地的人来这里工作，读书，居住，，我们的宿命决定了我们生在那个国家，就像我们无从选择父母一样，父母再不好也是我们的父母，要尊敬孝顺他们，做为儿女我不喜欢外人对我父母不敬，我的国家就等同我父母，我们尊敬别人的父母同样的也希望别人尊重我们的父母😊
Malaysians Chinese said Singapore steals their talents. Without their talents, Singapore will be doomed. What do u think?
@@panda63725 I think talent poaching is very real. All countries tries to attract top talents. If they could, they would also try to poach top talents from SG too. Works both ways.
Those who say currency exchange is not important if one is working and spending at the same country, then it is nonsense.
A person working in sg earning $5k and someone in Malaysia earning $5k rm let’s see who can buy the latest and iPhone and gadgets.
1 Iphone wipe out 3 months of hard-earned salary in Malaysia
But Malaysia has good education and medical system.
Government university and hospital is very cheap.
Depends.
With RM5k one can already afford a landed and a car.
Try that in Singapore with SGD5k.
@@cwk18 I dk how your opinion was formed. Msia education system is like outright bad. Teachers are not up to mark and syllabus not up to standard.
Healthcare wise, yes they are way cheaper than sg but quality wise sg is way above them.
@@whatnameshouldichoose854 that’s because Singapore has limited land so landed house and cars are pretty much unaffordable.
Compare other stuff which are not heavily taxed by the government.
Daily necessities, food, entertainment , dollar for dollar sg wins Malaysia.
Sg ppl can go holiday at Japan Korea, Europe but can the $5k rm do that?
And before you say I’m like some stuck up Singaporean, I’m from Malaysia and am working in KL.
My fresh graduate pay in a bank is $2.8k rm. my peers who moved to sg upon graduation drew $3.2k sgd. it took them maybe just 6 years to double their income in a bank.
So it’s bullshit to say working in msia is as well off as working in sg.
Try living in malaysia with $5k rm then say. Now my chicken rice already 10rm. Milo ais at 3.5rm. How to survive?
You walk on the streets of sg u see most ppl using iPhone or Samsung, wearing branded sneakers and drink bbt.
You think living in malaysia earning rm can afford this?
@@Whatexactlyispeace i say good, I didn’t say excellent like Singapore NTU. Fresh graduate from Malaysia University can get job easily jn Singapore. At the end of the day, its the degree and skill that matter to employer. The university facility and syllabus wont give you higher chance to get a job.
非常有智慧
Actually not a bad ep. However your subs have quite abit of 錯字。。😂 加油呀。。要不然看了你的字幕會暈倒😂
Are u guys planning the next subscriber meet ups?
Yup
imo sg's edge is the currency. no sane person will want to take the trouble to move overseas to work for a company that pays less and reward you with longer working hours. sg with talents? yes there are, but probably less than a 1mil. a tiny fraction compared to bigger countries.
Refreshing to all speaking Mandarin🎉❤
We, singaporeans are fortunate
💯
赞！😂
请问你有没有点赞呢？ 🙂
哇，boon tee 的华语很流利， chi keng 的中文也不错。 老实说， 关于有没有人留在大马为国家付出，我们也不可以怪马劳为什么会来新加坡发展，syed sadiq 就是其中一个从新加坡去马来西亚做政治人员，可是政府怎样对待贪污的官员，最近的事件我们都看得见
所以马来西亚应该加入新加坡。
@@HawkishMerlion1965别加入新加坡，我们不需要。😂😂😂
@@Sunny-yh3vf 迟早会被我们新加坡占领。反抗者杀无赦！
加油！Not bad mandarin.
谢谢分享。其实在视频里面的每一位嘉宾中文都不会太差 (除了Kelvin看起来可能会比其他三位嘉宾弱一点以外)。我也觉得新加坡的两位年轻人其实中文都不赖，也能表达得蛮通顺和自然，这倒是令我觉得惊讶也蛮惊喜的。相信这和大家平时是否有在说中文很有关系，特别是在家里和父母或孩子之间的沟通语言，若全都是用英文的话，在外面和同事，上司下属也全都是用英文的话，那么相信中文水平方面自然就会比较差，因为这和完全没有机会去操练的关系。相反的，若是在家里或在外面都比较常有机会说或使用中文，以及让自己主动去学习多接触和找机会和花时间让自己去多看一点中文的视频而不止是英文视频，多听或看一些中文的新闻，时事报道，娱乐资讯，多听或唱些自己所喜欢的中文歌，在传whatsapp简讯或写什么讯息时也学习使用一下中文。另外，就跟学习英文一样，刚开始操练时多多少少都会觉得比较累，吃力和富有挑战性及困难，而且可能还需要时不时去翻查一下字典来帮助自己等等。不过，过了一段日子后，就会慢慢觉得会越来越得心应手，收放自如。假以时日，必定突飞猛进，更上一层楼或几层楼。虽然可能不一定或还是无法像那些使用单一语言也就是以中文为主的国家和地区如：中国大陆，台湾，香港，澳门那样可以如鱼得水般用得那么自然。但是，在一般的会话和沟通上来说，相信应该不成问题。有句话说：Practice does not make you perfect, it only makes you better. 盼望身为华人的我们会好好欣赏和珍惜我们的语言和文化，同时也学会尊重其他人和我们不同的语言和文化。大家彼此鼓励，一起加油。愿上帝继续赐福马来西亚，也赐福新加坡。😊🙏
谢谢老师！☺️
中國如果能改善自己在國際上的形象，願意使用華語的人自然會增加
要算当兵， 离乡背景我觉得更辛苦
Suggest to provide english subtitles instead :)
Our birth rights is a privilege NOT an entitlement. If one stays frivolous and spends precious time in their early career wasted, then they need to recognise they brought this upon themselves. When you falter later in life, remember you had a privileged start but there will always be a point in life when the doors to competition will open inevitably.
Excatly. But the younger genZ are increasing delusional thinking its their god given right to make a good living without sacrifice. They wanted good paying job yet refuse to put in the time or effort to build a career so most resort to gig economy like Grab because the money is better from the start with freedom only to realise 5-10 years has passed, they are in their mud 30s in a dead end job with the same pay, no cpf and no benefits while their peers have risen through the career ladder, have high paying jobs with perks. Then these people feel jelous blames the government, blames foreigners, blames everyone but themselves
为什么離开马来西亚,翻譯成(马鞋)笑死人!
华語譯成(花纹),马来文譯成(蚂蚁),看不下去了!抄了翻譯那位仁兄吧！
Kampong lorong buangong is in e east Hougang not ine west
Kelvin 和 Boon Tee 父母有沒有想過過來新加坡住？
中文版加油！
有没有想找出两组数据比较一下：多少马来西亚人申请新加坡PR与公民，多少新加坡人申请马来西亚的PR与公民
马来西亚没有移民的概念，0 移民。
不是啦，你们不是马劳我们新加坡人都把你们看成兄弟，多过于马劳，因此，所以你们和我们一样肩拼肩的兄弟。
对对对其实我们老-辈的人不会把马耒西亜人当外人我们是把他们当做是自己人，現在的年轻人我就不知道？
Kampong Lorong Buangkok 新加坡最后一个甘榜.
Lorong Buangkok at Yio Chu Kang. Not in the west.
spot on!
Talk big, no different to work in Malaysia or Singapore. Why come over and leave your family if no impact on exchange rate. Starting says exchange rate is 100% in consideration. I am confused.
Very small towns, really have no malls.
那里有？
hahah bros, love the chinese episode because I'm trying to improve my chinese too. but realised the subtitles need spell-check lah. next time make sure to vet.
Sorry, I got tired after a watching and vetting for the 3rd time 😢
hahah no big deal la. just pointing out in case u guys didn't notice. I assume the subtitling was outsourced? next time just find another one lo. basically now u know that this one isn't great.@@learninvestearnsave
@@alui5362 nope, i was the one doing the subtitles for this one 🥲
alamak....@@learninvestearnsave
@@alui5362 sorry boss 🥲
If you think you hava a lot of problems to work in Singapore for 3.5 times salary, then please go back to work in Malaysia.
新加坡傳媒用“大马游子”，反而本地傳媒却用“马劳”,哪一个比较有尊重含义？
其是我们老一辈的人都把马耒西亜人当做是自己人，现在的年轻人我就不知道？
The subtitle are hilarious
haha if you see the original you will ROFL. Confirm.
BagHolder Pod 应该叫做 宁可输但不肯卖 俱乐部
Will keep this in mind 😂
我喜欢这个名字！
潮州人有句话讲，那里凉那里坐，没有什么对错
Wow! Nice
to my surprise Eric's mandarin is good
Why are you surprised? 🤔
The Chinese caption of this video is so funny lol
希望你们四位大神以后用华语好吗? 我英文不好m每次你们讲” 太深 “的英文. 我需要 check dictionary leh..很麻烦. 😨
其实在马的华人生活并不是别人说得那么糟啦！生活也沒很大的压力. 年轻人不想待在小地方都往大地方或去国外看看,体验体验也是很正常的事. 其实他们家乡父母很多都有土地的, 有些更是放在家里的车还要多过家里的人口呢！只是看你自己想要过怎样的生活罢了！
但還是二等公民，馬來人伊斯蘭國教統治下
@@robin0941 你嘴里的二等公民竟然是掌握马国的经济一族哟！🤣
@@jia03 一開始掌握經濟時還不是二等公民
@@robin0941一个没钱的一等公民活着还不如二等公民, 只能酸啰！
@@jia03 沒錢的一等公民透過政策性的歧視，剝奪其他族群高等教育的受教權並掌握政治權利，二等公民也只能大量往海外去（就學/打工/移民）了，再加上一等公民連買房的價格都遠低於二等公民，長久下來錢當然自然流向一等公民那裡去了，無法出國留學在國內也沒受教權的二等公民很可能不只政治、連經濟上也成為弱勢，而且因這種政策性的歧視，之後世世代代都無法翻身
馬來西亞華人人口占比下降很多是不爭的事實（但有人還在溫水煮青蛙而選擇性忽視），連在新加坡拿PR受的待遇都比馬國自己公民身份好的多吧
我們叫客工，不叫 馬勞。
客工与馬劳都差不多一样
Any countries still depend to yrshelf can provide, if u not work harder n mindset😊
Eric ..以后回娘家 pls drop by all the KL shopping complexes..与新加坡相比 有过之而无不及
Eric: her hometown east Malaysia 🇲🇾
客观反映：谢谢 BagHolder Pod 的视频分享。我是以 “马劳” 这个观点来给予大家一些建议。要是您到新加坡工作的身价只不过是 “马劳”，而不是富豪，那么您就一定要预备回乡退休的计划。请别忘了，新加坡那些土生土长的国民，除了华人以外，还有其他的少数民族。要是您不是富豪，而只不过是以白手起家在新加坡这片土地幸运地活过来的话，那么这些 “少数民族” 是不会那么容易放过一切可以 “磨炼” 您们的机会。意识是说，他/她们曾经在新加坡里所吃过的任何苦难，都要您们 “新移民” 一样一样地 “尝试” 一下。要是当这一系列的 “人造磨炼” 降临的时候，而您又没有足够的资源来支撑的话，那么就预备自己和家人 “死得很难看” 成为牺牲品。在这种情况之下，国家政府是 “插不了手”，因为关系到种族 “公平” 的问题。我的分享没有恶意，更不会故意编造故事来吓人，而是以自己多年亲身观察得来的结论。目的就是希望能够帮助到更多的 “外劳”，尤其是马来西亚单纯的马劳，去看到您们还没有看到的角度而已 blind spot。其实，有许多 “他国” 的新永久居民（如：菲律宾；等等），都纷纷预备好回乡退休的一日。就连新加坡国民，也已经开始在往外跑了（不信的话，可以观察近年来 JB 房地产的市场）。求神怜悯帮助我们地球人。神是爱！佩（贝）玲笔。 🙏🏻💕🌻🇲🇾🌎💕🌈
认了吧！去新加坡工作的理由关键在于钱比较多。别一谈钱就不敢直説，觉得俗气，矮人一截的。其实也没什么。两国货币兑换下，许多马国人的确自觉占尽了便宜。把新币换回马国消费，那是一笔极可观的数目。他们有这般想法也不足为奇了。
马劳不只是在新加坡，其他国家也是有马劳
Anwar 不是在国大，而是马大畢业！
Those still want to vote for WP are voting to become 新劳. our future generations will have to go to MY to work daily 😂😂😂
Very true . They cannot “see” and “think” , only follow a minority group to create trouble for our self or our future generation
马来西亚隐形消费太多。。生活比新加坡辛苦
请问隐形消费是指?
持仓亏损者群体
😂
到美国35年、远不远？
有二点
1.如果你想一辈子打工做馬劳, 是可以呆在新加坡工作没问题
2.如果想要找出路創业,不想一輩子做馬劳, 就应该当机立断快快回馬, 在大馬找商机, 机會也多也較容易, 趁年青做个决定, 别只想到匯率问题, 更应该为未来前景做思维才是上策！
觉得华语要大大改进，不怎么流利，用字有的也不恰当。例如做工，做工通常是做粗工，如泥工，野外工作。如果在办公室上班，应该是＂工作＂不是做工。
又如我们来去吃饭。其实不用来又去，去吃饭就好了。客家话是来去，最普遍，但在传统的中文，不用来了又去。
Rmb4k federation
Kelvin 说 : "享受我们的女人"， 把女人当成物质品吗? 用词不当 !
你為什麼這麼認真，人家只是當笑話。有可能是新加坡人跟他說的呢
@@Steven-qs7zp 一点都不好笑。
@@hengjessica5930 不好笑你可以不看
@@Steven-qs7zp 是啊， 看了才知道这节目是那么讽刺女人，真的不该看 !
Podcast 播客
字幕让我喷饭😆
受访者说“马国换新政府”
下面字幕出来 : 马国换“性政府” 🤣🤣
马来西亚是首相不是总理
原来Kelvin是来自怡保。你中学是读三德吗？
sorry but no english sub 👎
Sorry about it 😅 will try to find a translation software!
马来西亚高中生的英文水平并不想你们记得那么差,你们自己差而已,
👏👏👏
一般是比较差， 当然还是有些特出的。
Good..three pet
马语 可以 translate 成 “ 蚂蚁🐜 “…够力哦 👍👍👍
No English subs for the bananas 🙈
🍌🍌🍌
持袋四人帮🤔😜
Msia life is better
How many years have you lived in both countries?
我曾经在星加坡工作十多年最后放弃永久居留回大马,如今很多大马人才在中国就业星加坡人不要太有优越感,
希望大家不论去到哪都能心想事成！😊
确实是如此。我曾经在山东青岛与吉隆坡和这些年轻人交谈过。
2 位新加坡的朋友应该多多用华语交谈。这集的表现有点卡， 有点生硬。
不会啊，我觉得他们的华文不比另外两个马来西亚人差。他们用的词汇还不错，比kelvin好一点，哈哈。
@@kaiserlow652 😉
马劳？为什么是“劳” 。难道管理层，专业人士，白领......等都是劳力阶级？