Dear friends, if you like our content, click like and subscribe! And please consider making a financial contribution at quranspeaks.com We are building our Instagram presence and would love for you to follow us for shorter videos and behind the scenes photos of our work: instagram.com/quranspeaks.tv
Dr Shabir Ally can you explain how it is possible for Allah to enter his creation and only at one-third part of the latter.? (24)Chapter: Encouragement to supplicate and recite statements of remembrance at the end of the night, and the response to that. Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: Our Lord, the Blessed and the Exalted, descends every night to the lowest heaven when one-third of the latter part of the night is left, and says: Who supplicates Me so that I may answer him? Who asks Me so that I may give to him? Who asks Me forgiveness so that I may forgive him? Reference : Sahih Muslim 758 a In-book reference : Book 6, Hadith 201 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 4, Hadith 1656
Not to merge, difficult to put in english. It is what it is. Unexplainable. Different concepts denote it differently , so called scholars put that like Advaita, Dvaita, vishwadwaita but these concepts are intangible to limited intellect. Agnosticism and Skepticism (Ajnan) is the .......
@@QuranSpeaks I'm a dwaitin... which technically means two as opposed to the idea of adwaita which says what Dr shabir Ally said ...we believe that no matter what.. we can never become Brahman...in fact all Vedas except a few lines speak of Dwaita only ... remember that the lines the adwaitins use to say that we merge onto god have many meanings which is applicable to Dwaita also
@@whatever-tp2ek dr SA says that Hinduism accepts soul merges into God at moksha...dwaita says you don't merge with God but take your place according to your Jeeva yogyata in moksha
This is why Sanatan Dharm is beautiful, it doesn’t ask you to choose between one religion or another, it embraces all beliefs and accepts the commonalities of philosophy from all. Brahman, God, Allah! Whatever your preference it’s seems to me you are on the right path.
Sorry. Allah is based on monotheism which says there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air. But Brahman according to Vedas is conscious, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent. Does Islam accept that the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul = Allah? If not then how can Allah and Brahman mean the same? Above all Vedas say you (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (Brahman) because without the conscious and omnipresent soul nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation cycle of humans). If there is reincarnation then Karma or cause and effect comes into play as well. Does Islam accept karma and reincarnation? Of course not.
@@Dharmicaction Human being or any other creation of God is not God. Only God is God. This is true monotheism. With regards to existence then the real existence is that of God's. Our existence is dependent on His existence. We have our own distinct existence but we exist because God wants us to exist. He alone gives life and He alone causes us to die but death has no effect on Him because He is the Ever-Living the Self-Existing Being. The best definition of God is given in the Quran in chapter 112. God says: "Say: He is Allah (God), the One and Only. Allah (God), the Absolute and Eternal He does not beget, nor is He begotten. And there is like unto Him."
@Jay vaishnav dharma That's exactly why its beautiful. Vaishnavas explaining god with Vishnu's perspective and Shaivaits explaining god with Shiva's perspective. And still both are interconnected with various stories. If that's not beautiful than what is? If you go deep into the stories you will find out
Thanks for adding the captions As a muslim from India , I love this channel. Dr. Shabbir Ally is a great intellectual who gives rational and calm answers. May Allah bless and reward you guys for doing this great job
@@QuranSpeaks assalamualaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatahu , I had a question- What should be an islamic response to conspiracy theories? I know they sound weird but can muslims promote conspiracy theories which may be true? I think this topic is in dire need of response from an islamic scholar. Please reply
@@Afthab19 great question! Were currently editing a video on the COVID vaccine. We've also done a video on the COVID infodemic, which you can find using the search function on TH-cam. But we can always do more.
The goal of Hinduism is not to merge within Brahman but to realize You are Brahman (tat Vam asi) and once you realize it then everything becomes Brahman in your experience.
The story of moses &krishna r more or less same, the baby in basket, 2 mothers,dream to kill babies, there is snake in both stories ,spliting of water, meeting wife while grazing cattle..musa has harun...krishna has arjun Story of ram, sita, rawan, laxman...is mor or less story of, ibrahim, sara,firawun, lut.....evn the names....the time king was unable to touch sara, but may b ppl hav added in that story of ram...god knows best Story of nuh is mor or less like the story of manu....the flood ,father of human after adam...bcoz from the ppl in the ship,allah gav only nuh (as,) progeny maha(great in sanskrit)+nuh=manu Asslm alkm mns Allah's peace& In hindu om shanti means gods peace Allahu a'lam..god knws bst... Allah swt is wise, he said evry act is rewarded based on the intention
This guy clearly explained what I needed to know. I resonate with more with the "merging with God" rather than being separated and have to worship "him." There's an ancient Hindu myth that said: "human consciousness had begun as a ripple that decided to leave the ocean of consciousness the "timeless, spaceless and eternal". When it awakened to itself in this "disconnected" state, the myth said, it forgot that it was part of the infinite ocean and felt isolated and separated."
Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent athma (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul. Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer. So, the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma (Shiva) in combination with its energy (Shakhti) leads to duality cycles of nature. eg Birth/decay, wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment. freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious divine + energy. Microcosm = Macrocosm. Point is ATHMAN = BRAHMAN. 1. MAKUNDYA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 1 and verse 2 of ATHARVA VEDA "Ayam Atma Brahma" - "This Self (soul) is Brahman" - Does Islam accept that the soul has consciousness and it is Allah? 2. CHANDOGYA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 6 verse 8.7 of SAMA VEDA "Tat Tvam Asi" - meaning you (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul nothing can exist. 3. BRIHADARANYAKA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 1 and verse 4.10 of ATHARVA VEDA. "Aham Brahma Asmi" meaning "I am Brahman" (conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul = divine) 4. Aitareya Upanishad Chapter 3 and verse 3 of RIG VEDA "Prajnanam Brahma" means conscious soul = the divine or Brahman.
@@Dharmicaction yes Allah is consious,immanent and omnipresent,he breath soul into us so we are technically brahma(atman)means god present within us and doesnt mean he is in a form with us and actual brahman has a no frm,no modification in our perspective but in himself he has a form and modification,saguna and nirguna and he is infinite,i say this is allah too.
@@Dharmicaction one more microcosm is to understand by ourself abt brahman the supreme by 12 th manifestation brahman as atman,doesnt mean he is microcosm,i hope u know asat.
@@mrimperfect5214 but core beliefs of Islam go against what you are saying, allah is not omnipresent according to them but sitting on a throne, Actually Sufism of Islam was influenced by core of Hinduism and surface of Hinduism is influenced by core of islam
No it's not that way You see we basically worship the bigger picture instead of worshipping extremely small parts of him We also kinda think that if you consider brahman to be a separate being, you indirectly undermine their power of presence Which is equally important to potence
Yes bro and I am muslim and since I reside in India I got an opportunity to learn more about adwait vedant , dwait vedant , bhakti vedanta and and I am deep diving into these philosophies as well 😅🎉❤
@Joseph Christopher~ you're biological father He who protects and controls the worlds by His own powers, He-Rudra '_is indeed one only. There is no one beside Him who can make Him the second. O men, He is present inside the hearts of all beings. After projecting and maintaining all the worlds, He finally withdraws them into Himself. [NOTES-1. Rudra-This word is a synonym of S'iva in later Puräna literature, but no such sectarian meaning is intended here. The word is used in its literal sense. The root meaning of the word is' the destroyer of the sins and sorrows of devotees as well as the bestower of Jhana and bliss on them'. Rudra also means the punisher of those who break His laws, physical, moral and spiritual', The word seems to be used here to hint that God as the Indwelling Self watches the deeds of men, good as well as bad.] Just quoting from upanishads verses taken from Google ?? Go read upanishad in the guidance of a Guru.
@@raviqirvansyah1304 what? No. Paramatma has no shape whereas allah does. Everything is a part of paramatma whereas we or nothing is a part of Allah. Allah is pure as not is a part of him whereas paramatma's part is everyone so if anyone cheats and rapes is also a god's quality. And many more.
Consciousness is an attribute of the immortal, immutable, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman just like heat is an attribute and essential nature of the fire and the sun. Consciousness is pulled into the material realm from the athma (which is beyond space and time) by Prana (which is within the realm of Shakhti) for the duality cycles of nature to happen including birth/death, manifestation/concealment of the universe etc. Moreover, atman/brahman is not the same as Abrahamic religion word "god" which is based on monotheism. The monotheistic core of all the 3 Abrahamic religions simply says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe but still can create the universe and its "laws of nature" out of thin air and override them (whenever wanted) and control everything by just using a magic wand.
@@indianmilitary Actually the creation is the dream of a seperate self which does not exist except in imagination. When we take ourselves to be the contents of consciousness or mind, we take on bodies. It's fascinating what's happening, yet at the same time whatever happens happens but it all ends in joy. Such is our immutable nature as the cosmic being.
You take a glass of water from the ocean , and consider that glass of water to be different from the ocean ? They may appear different , but in essence , the h2o in the glass of water is the same as the h2o in the ocean. 2 different musical notes can be created from the same guitar string. They SOUND different , but in essence , they are the same air , just vibrating differently.
The computer that human made is alsow a part of human even the cake that your mother did cooking for you is a part of your mother hhhhh are you ok ? The CREATOR created you and brings to the existence but him is immortal! And he did give you attributes and gifts so ops! You believe to be him!!!!!!!!!!!
Really? Then why will Kalki come to fight against adharma, according to Hindus? If Brahman doesn't care about adharma, then why intervene in human history to stop it?
@@minskdhaka Do you even know meaning of Adharma? Adharma means Sin. Like Rap*,Murder,Alchohol,Gambling,Anima Saughlter etc. He will punish the sinner not the non believer if they don't did any sin.
There is no individual soul. There is only brahman alone in side every living entity. The living entity is called jiva, people refer jiva as individual soul, but its not the same as brahman. Brahman illumines the jiva just like sun illuminates the moon . Moon doesn’t have its own light, the moon light we see is reflection of sun alone. Similarly everything is brahman alone There is no individual soul(jiva) of its own.
@Ashwani Jha When Avidya is removed, the Atman (Soul, Self inside a person) is realized as identical with Brahman. Until then, it's not appropriate to call atman as brahman. You don't call a drop of water in an ocean as "the ocean" itself. It's just a drop until it merges with the ocean or identifies itself in the vastness of ocean. Moreover, "Enlightenment" is not moksha. Moksha is salvation or mukti which is complete freedom from this horrendous suffering and cycle of birth and death. Enlightenment is the self realization of " *अहं ब्रह्मास्मि* ". Enlightenment is not the final stage, it's a process.
@Ashwani Jha jiva is nothing but combination of body, mind, intellect, memory and ego. All of this is illuminated by Atman or brahman. That is why they say without god nothing moves. The reality is told in different levels according to level of each individual. When one indentify himself as an individual and god is seperate from him, then it is dvaitha(two) vedantha. When one identify himself to be a part of god, it is vishista advaitha vedanta. In this man experienced god within him. When one identify himself with atman or brahman, it is advaita(one) vedanta(ekam eva dwithiyam). When i say identify, its not about belief, its about being here and now, one looses individuality(ego) when he experience his real nature. Example is Bhagvan Ramana Maharshi. The man in the video claims sufi saints said i am the truth, its nothing but they reached the level of advaitha vedantha. All religions are true and say about same reality in different ways and language and different levels according to individual experience of an individual.
@@arnoldschafernaker512 may be you are saying at the level of vishistha advaitha. The drop and the ocean example is not for the highest level(advaitha). Because brahman is not physical in nature, how can one say Atman is divided? Avidya getting lost is nothing but ego(false identity that i am body,mind etc) getting lost. Lord Krishna said in bhagavad gita , “O conquerer of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread” Here thread represents the supreme brahman or Atman and the pearls represent the jivas(combination of body, mind, intellect,memory,ego) Ego is like a ghost , actually its not a reality like brahman. When i say real, its unchanging and eternal. Ego(false identity) is ever changing. example if one becomes rich, he identifies himself to be superior to lower status people than him. Like this so many branches of identities spring from the root identity which is ego(false identification of individual) . Bhagvan Ramana maharshi said, if the root of the tree is destroyed, entire tree falls, likewise the root ego(false identification as individual) is destroyed by realizing the true self as the supreme reality, eternal, infinite, the source of everything which nothing but brahman. When the individuality itself is lost , the tree of false identites cease to exist. And what remains is pure being which is brahman itself. Ego is in the mind and mind is nothing but collections of thoughts and ideas which are likely to change based on perceptions.
You can't equate Abrahamic religion's monotheistic understanding of so called "god" with the well validated Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu/dharmic tradition was built including yoga and tantra). Monotheism says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand.😊😊So, you can't replace the non translatable Sanskrit words like athman/brahman, karma, swarga and naraka with words like "god", sin, heaven/hell etc.
@Joseph Christopher~ you're biological father Shiva the name is made from 2 words Shi which means that and va which means which is not. So, in essence, Shiva means that which is not. Formless, ageless just like Brahman. So yes, you are right, Shiva is Brahman. It is said that Universe is in the form of an ellipsoid, Shiva linga is also an ellipsoid for that specific reason. It's funny how you learn something new every day! Thank for the quote from Yajurveda, I did not know about this :)
I believe that it’s all the same concept, but different end games. Brahman/God/Allah/YHWH/Waheguru ji, is the creator. Different names as these religions were all developed in different areas of the world but same thing. We can’t see God, we can’t physically touch God, but we all have an agreement that God is our creator and reason for life. And we all praise God. The goals may be different when it comes to afterlife and Heaven/Hell. But God is one. God may be perceived or worshipped different according to which religion you follow, but one God, by many names. That’s how I see it 😊 God is what unites the people!
@@polite.cat.has.playlists hence why I said “God may be perceived or worshipped different according to which religion you follow..” Also, in my opinion, if I say that God in Hinduism is a different God than in Christianity, I’m acknowledging that there is more than 1 divine, when there is only 1 divine, just worshipped differently by many people.
Fantastic ! As a Muslim I was reading Vedanta to teach my daughter for a theology class and surprise to see Monotheism in the very core of Hinduism . Veda being main book and Vedanta being most important part of Veda says God is One ! Allahu Akbar !
@@Soulreaper286but vedas and upanishads are rejects your concept. Yajurveda ch32v3 Creator doesn't have any similitude. He is one and alone No one saw him
@@ARRusulOneMessage 😂 Bruh hinduism isn't limited to vedas this is not islam in short God is with form and without form. I follow vendanta school which says God is without form and there is dvaita vendanta which says God have a form point is God can appear in any form do you think God is unable to take a form 😂
@@Soulreaper286 bro so many hindu claims except vedas and upanishads all are books are interpolated by people. Vedas and upanishads are shruti (heared) books most important book than smiriti which are lower than vedas. God has power on all things He knows all about his creatures so he doesn't need to take a human form. If God taking human forms to teach human what is good or bad why he not taking form of germs bacteria viruses animals birds reptiles these are also creatures of God Why God doesn't taking form of tiger to teach it to not to eat Innocent animals. These are blasphemous words to Almighty God he is power on all He is above all He is all knowing He knows what is in your hearts and in minds.
@@ARRusulOneMessagethe ultimate reality according to the Upanishads is non-dual, immaterial, efficient, formal and final cause of all that exists. It is the pervasive, infinite, eternal truth, consciousness and bliss which does not change, yet is the cause of all changes. Brahman as a metaphysical concept refers to the single binding unity behind diversity in all that exists in the universe while Islam is monotheism. Allah is the only creative intelligence and Quran advocates creator-creation duality. So you can't use Hindu scriptures to justify the existence of Allah because they are not the same.
🛑 Similarities Between *Kalki Avatar* and *Muhammad* : *[1] -* The name of the Kalki will be Narashangsha, which means praised human, the meaning of the name Muhammad is also praised man. *[2] -* Kalki will born on 12th day of Madhu month, the first month of the hindu lunar year and the first month of summer, Muhammad similarly born on the 12th day on Rabiul Awal, the third month of the Arabic lunar year but astrologically the time was summer season according to solar time. Kalki will born on Shambhala village or island, which means place/house of peace and a land beside water or sea, it also means Arab and Asia minor according to the world map division of Hindu religion, Makkah is Muhammad's birth place which is also beside sea and it is in Arab and Asia minor and its another name is Darul Aman, which means the place/house of peace. *[3] -* Kalki's father's and Mother's name will be Vishnuyash and Sumati, which means slave of God and peaceful lady. Muhammad's father's and mother's name are Abdullah and Amina, which also mean slave of God and peaceful lady. *[4] -* Kalki will be born of the family of the main priest of Shambhala, Muhammad was also born of the family of Abdul Muttalib, the main priest of then the Makkah. *[5] -* Kalki rides on miraculous flying white horse named Devadatta (meaning: given by God) given by Shiva to destroy the evil, Muhammad also rode a miraculous flying white horse named Buraq given by Allah and destroyed evil. *[6] -* Kalki will fight with Khaksha means sword, Muhammad also used to fight with sword. *[7] -* Kalki will go to hillside after birth and receive messages from a mount from Parshurama (spirit of Raam or God, verbally Raam means God of the World) and then will go to north and after that he will return, Muhammad also received messages from God through Jibrail in mount Jabal al-Nour, and another name of Jibrail is Ruhul-Amin which means spirit of God, and he also went to Madina situated in north of the Makkah and after that returned to Makkah again with victory. *[8] -* Gods will directly help Kalki in war, Muhammad was also helped by the angels in the battle of Badr. *[9] -* Kalki will defeat demon kali with the help of his four brothers, Muhammad also defeated Satan by the help of his major four closest companions, later known as Rashidun Caliph. *[10] -* Kalki will destroy the robbers as hidden as Kings, Muhammad also destroyed the oppressors who were kings and leaders at that time. *[11] -* Kalki will be impressively handsome (Anupama Kanti) and incomparably beautiful (Apratim Dyuti), Muhammad was also known to be handsome and impressive and had been described as the most beautiful man of contemporary Arabia. *[12] -* Fregrance will come out from Kalki's body, Muhammad's body odour was also renowned for charming fragrance. *[13] -* Kalki will be adviser of a very big society, Muhammad was also an adviser of a big society. *[14] -* Kalki will have eight divine virtues (Ashtaishwaryaguna): Wisedom, born of noble family, self-control, remembrance (heard from God), physically powerful, less speechful, charitable, advisor of Gods verses and gratefulness. Muhammad also had these eight virtues.
Mohammed is never kalki avatar of lord Vishnu. Moreover we don't have any prophets in Hinduism but god himself incarcerates in various avatars. Lord kalki is going to born in the indian subcontinent including Nepal and Tibet. Kalki is not going to learn teachings from various saints. He will have only two wives no slaves. Kalki is not going to theft any caravans for money. He is not against idol worshipping and many gods and goddesses. He never kills any women except the daughter of Ghatotgach. No slavery. Moreover when he comes there will be no Islam and all humans follow one religion I.e. "Sanathana Dharma (don't compare with Satan)". Try to search about "kaala gnaanam" by "Sri Pothuluri Veera Brahmendra Swamy" and his avatar "Veera Bhoga Vasantharaaya". Shambhala is not any desert place. Read Kalki Puranam. Kalki is not going to speak Arabic but Sanskrit or any Indian language. No way he is going to preach imaginary Allah nor evil Islam. Because he is the almighty himself.
Brahman, Allah, Elohim, Cosmic Consiousness, Universal Mind, Absolute Reality, Spirit Force, Necessary Being, Unconditioned Reality. These are just words that people use to refer to the same being which people cannot quantify. Monotheism, pantheism are just different ways of looking at the same thing, like men seeing only parts of the elephant. Polytheism is simply the division of attributes into different beings ie god of love, god of revenge, god of wealth. Thats all it is.
Concept of God in Indian religions (Hinduism, shikhism, jainsim) is different from abrahmic religions. Abrahmic religions focus more on materialism while Indic religions focus on spirituality.
The different is simple. Monotheism followed by all the Abrahamic religions say that there is just a transcendent "god" who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. It led to the assumption that the so called "god" can override laws of nature, needless prophets, middlemen, angels, messiah, son of god, non existent heaven/hell, fantasy stories (propagated as history) and half baked responsibilities towards nature and people due to lack of understanding of a well validated metaphysics (like Vedic metaphysics), law of karma, reincarnation (birth/death duality) and MOKSHA (microcosm to macrocosm)
Islam focuses on spirituality, material life in islam has been prohibited and spirituality is norm in quran and ahadiths, dont know about the other abrahamic faiths but they are very similar
@@taiyeebmuhtadi Sufism focuses on spirituality and mysticism. Orthodox Islam focuses on materialism and material actions to appease god and be in his good grace. It is indeed an inferior philosophy with no spiritual value.
On the authority of Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him), who said that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: Allah (mighty and sublime be He) said: Whosoever shows enmity to someone devoted to Me, I shall be at war with him. My servant draws not near to Me with anything more loved by Me than the religious duties I have enjoined upon him, and My servant continues to draw near to Me with supererogatory works so that I shall love him. When I love him I am his hearing with which he hears, his seeing with which he sees, his hand with which he strikes and his foot with which he walks. Were he to ask [something] of Me, I would surely give it to him, and were he to ask Me for refuge, I would surely grant him it. I do not hesitate about anything as much as I hesitate about [seizing] the soul of My faithful servant: he hates death and I hate hurting him. It was related by al-Bukhari.
Shabir did a good job bringing up Sufi to identify similarities with Brahman. He should have mentioned Ibn 'Arabi and his venture into Non-Dualism philosophy through Wahdat al-Wujud. Because the Brahmans have many philosophies, comparisons with the "Dvaita Vedanta" ideas may coincide with dualistic distinctions in Islam. However, Non-Dualism in western religions register as 'likeness' because Islam, Christianity and Judaism all consider some people worthy of vassalage. An elevated sense distinct from common people, coincidingly a place for God's presence. But here is a question: If what God has is God (glory, self awareness per se), You are offered this glory to be part of you, what does that make you? I think it is an ontological mess.
@Himanshu Khichar no we worship the creator not the creation. By the way what are you doing in the comment section of a Islamic video ? Here to find out the straight path ? You're welcomed.
@Himanshu Khichar to some points it's revelent.....but some are utterly dilusional....mysogany.... dogmatism....there's been too much adultration in Qur'an..........and on one point he explained god is different....is wrong according to us Hindus....coz if God is different from us...he don't own us he don't have control...over certain things....but in Hinduism......god is everything ...he is universe .....
Thank you for your enlightening videos Dr. Ally... but please allow me to point out one aspect that you've overlooked in this discussion. The fact that God says in the Quran that He has blown from His spirit into mankind. So, our spirits do have a part of God's spirit in them. And I contemplate that "al-salat" (connection with God) might be the equivalent of "merging" with God in Hinduism (on a spiritual level not literal). I know very little about Hinduism, though.. but I strongly believe that all monotheistic religions are one. Also, I wonder why you call us servants of God. I cannot recall any verse that implies so. What I understand is that we are worshippers (ebad) of God (Allah) as opposed to servants or slaves (abeed) of God. Both plurals (ebad and abeed) have the same singular term (abd) but different meanings.
@@TheKingofTheUniverse. But Deva is God/deity but Brahman is seen as Principle not as deity/God (Doesn't matters Formless God or not ) Brahman is seen as Principle not as Individualised God
1) People should stop comparing the Gods because "God is one with innumerable forms". 2) Gita is not for "Parayan", its for "Aacharan", so practice it. Dont just daily read it. Don't mug up the scriptures. Krishna told to adopt the teachings into our lives. 3) God is one and anybody can worship any form of God, or they can even worship formless God. But ultimate truth is God is one, so don't fight in the name of God. 4) If you worship Allah, you can see Ganesha,Krishna,Rama, etc. Similarly, if you worship Krishna, you get divine vision to see Allah,Ganesh,Budda etc. So, follow with one beloved God form, then you can see all of the God forms. 5) Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (saint) said he realized Allah, Jesus by worshipping Kaali. He says people believe when they truly experience/realize the fact themselves. 6) Krishna said every human being can become the God. First, a person should know the inner soul it's called self realization. Later, that person can realize the soul of God. Its called God realization or enlightenment. It's the ultimate aim of human life. 7) water from different sources dissolve into ocean and become one. Similarly, Soul (energy) of a person go and dissolve into supreme infinite soul (God). That's called God realization/enlightenment, thus becoming the God ourself by dissolving into God. 8) God realization can be achieved through many practices such as Sankhyayoga,Karma yoga, Bhaktiyoga, Jnanayoga. These practices are done by Hindus, Muslims, Christians etc in one or the other styles. 9) Gita explained the ultimate truth about God, God realization, becoming the God(qualitatively not quantitatively) ourselves. No other religious book explained this ultimate truth. Thus, Gita is the greatest book. It says u can take any path and practice yourself. 10) Knowledge of God realization is the base for all sciences. Its the supreme knowledge. Its called "Aadhyathma" in Sanskrit. Spiritualism in English.
As a Hindu, I appreciate you approaching this subject with respect and grace. I enjoyed this man's analogy about Brahman and also his explanation of Sufi Islam
Dear friends of the world. We are all one. Experience of Ultimate is only one. The question is what happens with the one who saw it after. If you know who you are and ego takes not over you it is ok and you are merged with Ultimate but to be sure it is better you keep reminding yourself as being separated to honour the Ultimate and thus subdue the Ego. Bot path are correct and talk about the same thing it is just a matter of training and emphasis so you do not go astray. Alah and Brahman are the same difference is in approach. We are all brothers and sisters under the same sky and under the same law of nature! Love and respect to you all!
Allah is based on monotheism which simply says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. But the understanding of conscious, self luminous, Immortal, immutable, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman and its intelligent energy are based on the Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu tradition) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience. Moreover, Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent athma (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul. Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious athma and it is NOT the doer ERWIN SCHRODINGER (ONE OF THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Hindu Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
Something cool to keep in mind is we belive most religions originate with a profit of Allah and then changed by humans. When thats kept in mind its cool to look at brahman, krishna, azurha mazda, see similarities and wonder are these echos of islam? Was zoraster was a profit? Etc
@@wavehixeno4915 No bro Islam existed even before prophet Muhammad p.b.u.h bcz prophet adam preaches Islam .so prophet adam is the first preacher of Islam and prophet Muhammad s.a.w is the last preacher of Islam . You should study Islam
@@QuranSpeaks my name is Sajjad hossain rifat i am Muslim i respect and love all the religion i love all prophet like prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) Jesus lord Krishna
Sorry not the same. Allah or so called god is only transcendent with a magic wand for all the 3 Abrahamic religions but Brahman is conscious, self luminous, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent. Brahman and its intelligent energy always exist together for the perpetual duality cycles to happen eg eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation of humans), wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment of the universe (NOT CREATION OR DESTRUCTION since energy can be neither created nor destroyed). freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious Brahman + energy (cosmic allegories Shiva + Shakthi or Vishnu + Lakshmi or Brahma + Saraswathi).. Microcosm = Macrocosm. Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent soul (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent soul there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul. Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent Brahman) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer. ERWIN SCHRODINGER (FATHER OF QUANTUM PHYSICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
@@Dharmicaction universe is one....so is all.... all is one, one is all..... same consciousness.... I don't type stones, Word Is GOD and we live in GOD of Gods ...... ........... ........behind me is 43 years of life experiences... was exploring and learning all my life, especially after 2003,....I speak 5 languages, have the internet from March 2003 and over 245.000 of all in 5 gmail, over 40.553 are the drafts, just in 1 gmail is over 151000 of all, over 1860 fb notes, read/& listen to over 3000 books-audio books, till 2017, hundreds of lectures, a lot of all .............
Brahman, ParamAtman and The Atman are one and the same. As the dreamer is all the components of the dream so is Brahman all Components of Reality. The Merging of the soul can be thought of that “he who thinks he knows, does not know and He that knows and think he does not know, knows.” This means that u can never know the infinite with a finite mind and intellect. The merging of the Soul/Atman is just the experiential comprehension of an infinitesimal part of the infinite called Brahman. Learning and knowing God will never end for it is infinite, so even after mergence you will still uncover greater truths found in infinity.
or we can put it this way. TAT TVAM ASI meaning you (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay, manifestation/concealment of the universe, wave/particle, energy/matter etc. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion due to the experience of 5 senses and it is not the doer. Conscious athma is like a silk thread through different pearls (animate and inanimate) if you want to look at it in the form of an analogy. The main purpose of expanded consciousness state or samadhi is either to remove past karma (Chitta shudddhi) or to gain knowledge (which is a different dimension). Not everyone with embodied experience can gain direct material knowledge
@@furqanirfan911 Brahman is attributeless, formless, impersonal, Absolute Truth.. It can’t be described in words.. It’s beyond mind.. Upanishads have tried to describe It as Sathyam (Absolute Truth), Gyaanam (Infinite Knowledge, Consciousness), Anantam (No beginning, no ending, timeless, spaceless, Infinity) and It is also described as Sat (Existence), Chit (Awareness), Ananda (Bliss).. It’s also described as Sathyam (Truth), Shivam (Auspiciousness), Sundaram (Infinite Beauty) It pervades the entire cosmos.. Cosmos is an appearance / illusion in Brahman which means whole creation is a manifestation or expression of its Divine Will yet it is transcendental and ever pure ever new untouched by creation!
What he said is incomplete. There are no strict laws and regulations like Islam or Christianity. There are many philosophies in Hinduism. Advaita vedana, vishishtata advaita and dvaita Vedanta. God and humans are separate and we should worship God, this is what dvaita Vedanta says. Hinduism is vast, you need 3 or 4 lives to complete reading all texts which are full of philosophical debates
@Gyanii purush I am not talk about Brahma the creator I talk about Brahman the supreme reality.hindu God Brahman Means invisible Formless concept of one God
It's really nice to know that all religions descended from the one entity Allah where He explained himself in similar fashion but with passage of time it all got contaminated with human interventions.. even dr zakir naik explained similar subject of tawheed mentioned in hindu Vedas.. Allah sent different messengers throughout history with unique signs in order to make people of that time hear same message of tawheed ... I always believed that hinduism never taught idol worship, these heroes were good people or some might had been prophets of Allaah but people started errecting their idols in order to remember them & their memorable acts and in doing so it all turned into worshiping them generation after generation..... Quran talks about idols and hindu bhagwans. The emphasis lies on jins fooling humans into believing that they are God.. since they can show themselves in different forms and take away the food kept for them hence proving that they are Gods.. Anyway I wish and hope any hindu who is reading this perhaps pay heed and accept that it's only one caretaker of this entire universe and all those nice people who came and did their best to help humanity never wished to be worshipped .. it's mentioned in quran that on day of judgement all the these people (so called gods) who were worshipped will deny any responsibility towards these worshippers ...even Jesus will tell that I never told my people to worship me and Allah knew that I wasn't the one doing that ....they ( worshippers and jinns ) all will be sent to hell fire .. After learning this from Quran we have no right to make them partner with the ONE who created everything neither none should think bhagwans are intercessors between humans and the ONE who controls everything ... Allaah can listen whatever is in the chests and whatever is uttered loudly ..hence no mediator is required between human and the ONE who created him .. Trust Him and rely on Him ..he will respond directly ..this is tawheed
Your comment really only reflects how unqualified you are in vedic philosophy. There is not a mass array of separated gods, all is one - the multitude of appearance does not contradict this. You've never lifted a page to study beyond the quran, have you?
Since you're so qualified in sanatanadharma, please explain archa-vigraha/ishta-devata, nirakara and Sakara, and how viveka and vairagya factor in around it all. This question relates precisely to "idol worship" so, I trust you can answer it quite simply.
Instead of writing these long paragraphs you should have just written that you believe Allah is the only God and followers of all other religions will burn in hell. People like you know nothing about what other religions teach and then pretend you know everything. Good luck living a life filled with ignorance and hatred!
Whats wrong in idol worship ... Vedas never say idol worship is wrong ... There is no concept of beleivers and non beleivers in vedic text as in abrahamic religions infact it encourages people to question the existence of god itself
I think merging with God makes it more of a way of living rather than a religion as to have the strength to overcome any obstacle in life because God is always with you. The concept of 1 submitting to God is more like a religion. I think both works depending on people's beliefs.
Very interesting question. I dont know much about Hinduism. What about the sikh religion? I've heard they believe in 1 God also. Is it the same God as Allah?
@@QuranSpeaks This concept is called Wahadat-ul-Wujood (unity of being) in Islamic tradition. In Hinduism it's called Advait, literally meaning there's no second (only one). This concept has been deliberately sidelined and demonized by Islamic rulers. Anyway, to answer your question, in reality there's only one existence, that's Allah or Brahman. Any other existence is an illusion, that came into being by Allah's Will. Because there's nothing but Allah, all other existence is simply the Will of Allah. But this can not be explained or understood and can only be experienced because Allah is the imperceptible to the senses (al-Ghayab). This realization is called "Moksha" in Hinduism. This is the "return" to Allah in Islam.
@@QuranSpeaks Thank you for your kind words. I did not feel you tried to put down Hinduism. I know you're very gracious and respectful. I'm a curios learner and seeker of religious philosophies and am a follower of Sai of Shirdi. He taught Islam and Hinduism are same. I think the difference is in Sharia which includes worship. That has caused the rift. None the less there are even Hindu philosophers whose teachings seem to be outwardly pointing to the duality "God" and "Creation" being separate. They're called "Dvaith" schools.
Hinduism also started as having a single God or single entity. One can compare it to multiple qualities or attributes given to a father namely -> The one who is procreator,A caretaker,An educator.......etc- ie.....a father can be all these and still be the same person father. Similar to how in islamic sense Allah has 99 names or 99 attributes. Hinduism existed with multiple naming of a single God but along the passage of time and courruption due to one varna/caste of Hinduism from 300BC to 200AD,most of the stuff was reformed and atlered and we ended up being a polytheistic culture and then a monothestic back to polytheistic.(Thats why in hinudism a person can be ploythiestic,his father be monotheistic and his son be atheist and all are not wrong but confused interpretations) Multiple random books emerged which started gaining relevance and so was most of the stuff manipulated and hidden from illiterate folks(as holy scripts were in not in common tongue) and well here we are now doing something different from what is written in original scriptures but following the texts of random saints. Edit:Some text is being striked out and am not aware of the reason.
This is the great theological debate about Theism, Panentheism, and Pantheism. Even Christian sects believe in different aspects of God, whether he's separate from his creation, present in all his creation, or distinct as well as present in all of his creation.
Same is what we call atma, which is immortal.. Once one realises the ultimate reality.. He is free from sorrow, happiness and all kinds of feelings and his atman merges with ultimate reality brahmam
So basically Islam copied concepts of God from Hinduism. One cannot deny this because Islam is way younger than Hinduism which is the oldest living religion in the world.
Partially true, Islam copied the Concept from Jews. All Prophet Prior to Mohamad was described and admitted in Koran. Adam and Eve, Abraham, Isac and many more. The Hallal also came from Jews Tradition. The tradition of circumcision also a Jews Tradition. Eating pig also forbidden in Jews. Some tradition are borrowed from Christian, Some from Jews and idol worship in the form of Kaba is from traditional ritual of the tribe of Mecca.
no, Islam is distinct and unique, Islam teaches la ilaha illa Allah, meaning there is no god except Allah. unlike hinduism, where you find so many gods created from each other, marry each other, overpower each other, and each of them has a limited role.
@@wavehixeno4915 i know, and thats what not right, bc these statues are man-made and carved by men, why should i worship some thing that i created, and which can't harm or benefit me? I worship Allah the one true God, without going to different statues, subhan Allah, la ilaha illa Allah
The two are absolutely NOT the same. Brahman is Satchitananda, Absolute consciousness, knowledge and bliss. Allah is an angry god who commands subservience only to him.
Advaitha (conscious and non dual shiva) and Dvaitha (duality capable Shakthi in combination with shiva) are INCOMPLETE without each other. In other words, Shiva and Shakthi always exist together for the perpetual duality cycles to happen. eg eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation of humans), wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment of the universe (NOT CREATION OR DESTRUCTION since energy can be neither created nor destroyed). freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious divine + energy or (cosmic allegories Shiva + Shakthi or Vishnu + Lakshmi or Brahma + Saraswathi).. Microcosm = Macrocosm. But the core of Abrahamic religions is monotheism which says that there is just a transcendent "god" who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. .It led to blind belief in a book, needless prophets/middlemen, angels, non existent heaven/hell, fantasy stories (propagated as history), proselytization, and half baked responsibilities towards nature and discrimination/violence against (non believers" due to lack of understanding of Karma or cause and effect (created due to violation of balance of natural law or dharma by human ego), reincarnation (birth/death duality cycle) and Moksha (microcosm to macrocosm) Consciousness is an attribute of the immanent and omnipresent athma or the divine just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun. It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul. Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer. ERWIN SCHRODINGER (FATHER OF QUANTUM PHYSICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
But there are some hadiths that say, on judgment day the people of God at the highest rank, are able to see him like we see the moon at night. And there is no bliss or pleasure more delightful ever experienced.
There is no judgement day in hinduism.. One can merge with that supreme reality in his life time... It's about realising that ultimate reality and after realising that ultimate reality one is free from sorrow, happiness and all such sensory things
@@islamaboyy588 god is in everything Just imagine it When there was nothing but god What did he use to build this world? He used himself We are all a part of him And will merge with him once again That's the glory of God/allah/vishnu/ahura mazda Whatever you call him
Regardless of difference in ideology and the bits of etymology that are often confused with equation; the creator is the creator but given different titles: The all being creator God became known as Anu in ancient sumeria, as Atum-Ra in what we call egypt, BrahmaN in india, Ahura Mazda in Persia, Ashurah-YaHWaH to caananites and jews, Al-lah to arabs and muslims, as Jehova to jehovas witnesses, and simply as ‘God’ with a capital G to Catholics
@@gauritutorials7665 Eastern traditions depict this “something” as the original source and something which is superior in intelligence and understanding. Can’t even call it “god”.
Salam! We’d love to have Dr. Shabir Ally review “Forty Rules of Love” by Elif Shafak. It talks about Qur’an and it’s 4 layers. A very interesting yet hard to grasp concept. It would be great if he can explain that concept. Ps: Love the show! 🌸💕
“Who has ascended to heaven and come down? Who has gathered the wind in his fists? Who has wrapped up the waters in a garment? Who has established all the ends of the earth? What is his name, and what is his son’s name? Surely you know!” Proverbs 30:4 ESV
This is a misconception that when you merge with God ..you become God. The truth is, by all accounts, that your ego dissappears and you see God in everyone else.
This was very interesting thank you both for this video. I was thinking Brahman could be the interpretation of Allah in hindu and the interpretation of day of judgment could have got interpreted as merging with Allah since Allah mentions that he will call us back to him. of course Allah knows best
Yes, this is also true, we should keep an open mind and perhaps "judgement day" is a symbolic meaning and not what we think. Subject to interpretation.
There is no judgement day in hinduism.. One can merge with that supreme reality in his life time... It's about realising that ultimate reality and after realising that ultimate reality one is free from sorrow, happiness and all such sensory things..
So there are 3 different realisations of God. 1) Those who realise Him as the Supreme Brahman attain sayujya mukti which is the lowest of the 5 types of muktis, which is uniting with the Brahman. This state is just the absence of material sufferings. 2) Those who realise Him as Paramatma, they attain a state called nirvan by the process of hath yog. They basically purify the soul within the heart from the 5 kinds of life air, thus realising the Paramatma feature of the Lord in their hearts. Nirvan is also just the absence of material sufferings like Brahman realisation. 3) Those who realise Him as Bhagvan, engage in devotional service or bhakti yog. Bhakti means engaging the senses in the service of the master of senses ( who in Sanskrit is known as Hrishikesh, ie Bhagvan). The highest stage of Bhakti is called Prem (pure unalloyed love for God). A bhakti yogi having attained the stage of Prema, attains the spiritual abode of God (Vaikuntha) after leaving this material body and does not take further birth in the material world. This state is not only the absence of material sufferings but also the presence of spiritual bliss as the jeev(soul) attains a spiritual body (sat-chit-ananda body) in Vaikuntha and serves the Lord there eternally. Hare Krishna 🙏
And being Seen as heretic is how atheïsts looked at prophets not as heretics but similar to their standpoint so its not a point to be made.. Rumi.. hallaj.. arabi.. ghazali.. Amir al kader. Etc etc brought more knowledge and clarity for those who's hearts are open to see.. Compared to what my first 30 years of my life was taught by Sunni school of thought and even many other sects.. Thanks to sufism I'm becoming free and finally understand my creator more.. And feel closer to Allah than ever
Assalamualaikum, Allah SWT keep us safe from inventions, Allah SWT set our feet firmly on the righteous path and help us to walk there upon, mashallah. Your friend, Muhammad Fauzan Karim
Inventions in the sense of additions to, subtractions from, and or modifications to what we know as the right actions stated in al Qur'an, the highly authenticated Haddith, and Sunnah of Nabi Muhammad SAW. That is what I meant. Hope this helps. Muhammad Fauzan Karim
How can something that is sitting on 7th Heaven can be pervaded everywhere? If Allah is sitting at 7th heaven then how can he be everywhere, and to sit, someone needs body, does Allah has a body? If Allah is everywhere then in which form he is everywhere ? And If Allah has no form than how is he sitting over his throne on 7th Heaven and where is that heaven .. ? Dear sir , please try to ans. Ans my question, thanks..
in the quran.. mentioned that Allah is in his arsy... sitting in his throne... scholars interpret this as governing the throne @ kingdom... Allah is ever present.. He is not like his creation.. mentioned in surah al ikhlas.. space & time are His creations.. they do no limit His presence... & He is not bound by time & space.. when mentioned Allah sees.. hears.. hand etc.. we muslim just accept this as just what was revealed without questioning if Allah sees.. so He has eyes.. how does his eyes look like.. how many eyes He has etc... as if God has eyes.. mouth.. body etc like His creations.. then He is not god.. not worthy to be praised & worship..
@Himanshu Khichar we don’t take sitting on the throne literally.. just take it as what was said as if u take it literally.. contradict with the nature of a creator.. creator doesn’t look like or having the same nature as his creations...
@Himanshu Khichar please .. if u want to insult our prophet muhammad s.a.w... u just shown how ill feelings u hv for muslims.. i hv no time for that.. i hope u hv a gd reflection of urself.. don’t look down on others.. we shd learn to respect one another..
I am glad you are asking questions. Please keep clarifying your doubts with love and open mind. The creator will guide you. What I believe is, no matter which religious belief we come from we are all created in exactly the same manner by exactly the same power. There's only one truth and we are all supposed to find it, this in Hinduism is called Moksha. Questioning is good because it opens our mind to find the truth. But the only way we'll be able to find that truth if we question our beliefs too the way we question the beliefs of others. I pray we all find the truth because deep down in our hearts we all know that we are all different parts of the same creation.
In Hinduism, we have different margs or paths. The paths are 1) Jnana Marg (the path of knowledge) 2) Bhakthi Marg (the path of devotion) 3) Karma Marg (the path of action) The merging with Brahman through knowledge is path 1. Islam belongs to the category (2) where one sees God as seperate and oneself as a servant or devotee of God. This is similar to the pathway that the Hare Krishna sect take. Note: When I say (1) or (2) i don't mean to impose a hierarchy to say 1 is better than 2. All paths are equal and some are suitable for different people.
All the Creation is just the manifestations of Brahman, yet Brahman is beyond the Creation. The individual souls go through innumerable lives and deaths in order to attain Moksha which is merging back into the ultimate reality that is Brahman. Shivoham Shivoham 🙏
There is absolutely no difference between athman and Brahman. It is the reason why Sri Krishna said the following verse in Bhagavad Gita Chapter 2 Verse 12 (ATHMAN = BRAHMAN) “na tv evāhaṁ jātu nāsaṁ na tvaṁ neme janādhipāḥ na caiva na bhaviṣyāmaḥ sarve vayam ataḥ param” “Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings, and from this time forward, none of us will ever cease to be” Here, Sri Krishna refers to the conscious, immortal, immutable, self luminous, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman as 'I", ''you ``,''us ``.
@@anmoltiwari5314 we don't go though a bunch of lives....we have this one then we die and will be brought back to life to go to paradise or hellfire...and that's it
Brahman is not God Brahman is Absolute Reality Saguna Brahman is qualified aspect of the Brahman main Hindu deities are pure form of Brahman like shiva, Vishnu Devi etc Other deities like Purandhar Indra, Brahma dev are presiding deities/positional deities
Can it be the case that both are actually the same and it's the zombified followers who have mistranslated and misinterpretated the meanings of the verses present in the Qur'an? You can't take everything at face value because a lot of the teachings in religion are meant to be understood allegorically, metaphorically and symbolically.
The drop of water on the surface of the ocean (which is also water ) analogy really means "we are that" - tat tvam asi - we humans are just polluted by material reality
Allah judges whether you believe in him or not.. eg during Moses.. Moses a.s led the people to believe in Allah.. who follows him consider believe in Allah.. who doesn’t consider not believe.. then Jesus a.s.. who do the same.. who believe follow him vice versa.. then the last prophet messenger Muhammad s.a.w.. who did the same as previous messengers did.. who follow him consider believe in Allah.. vice versa.. & mentioned in the quran.. only islam is accepted by Allah.. islam means total submission to Allah..
@@maxtyson9035 people who do bad things & at the same time submitting to Allah.. we call them munafiq.. even during the time of our prophet & before that the munafiq hv existed.. during the time of our prophet s.a.w.. the munafiq was praying 5 times a day at the mosque with our prophet & even goes to war with him.. our prophet s.a.w knew who were they.. this are mentioned in one of the hadith.. so it’s not a surprise or new thing to hv this kind of people.. human do make errors.. Allah did mention in the quran.. He will accept/pardon whoever repent & ask forgiveness from Him no matter how big ur sin is... as He is the most forgiving & merciful.. but remember.. sin towards fellow human being is much worse than to Allah as we human sometimes do not forgive or ask for forgiveness from fellow human beings.. there’s one sin that Allah will not forgive though.. the sin of shirk that there’s another god then Allah.. but if u repent before ur life expires (no one knows when).. u’ll b forgiven.. only Allah knows best..
@@maxtyson9035 it does matter in islam which god u worship.. only Allah.. of cos in the quran mentioned there’s no compulsion in religion.. believing in Him cannot b forced.. if u do find happiness in what u worshipping at.. go ahead.. the door to Allah is always open.. i hope one day ur heart will b guided insya allah my friend.. 🥰
In Hinduism you cannot merge with god during life , it is only after the soul leaves the body can you merge with the eternal ultimate reality , so this answer is incorrectly informed
Yes, they are the same. The speaker did not know that Bhagabat Geetaa by Bhagabaan Krishna says, “All the creations are situated in the Divine Brahmana field. The divine field pervades the universe.” And Brahma (The omnipotent God) is the source of the Brahmana field. (Like king and it’s kingdom, or sun and it’s rays). The Brahma (The God), and it’s divine Brahmana Field along with material creation are distinct. ( The English term God is not the correct translation of Allah or Brahmana). The Brahmana is of neutral property, yet He is the source of all properties. Like sun ray is neutral, though it become rainbow in certain condition. Man by spiritual exercises/meditation can become free of the body generated property of selfishness (man is born sinner). When one attains this neutral quality (“nirgoon” in Sanskrit), he becomes EQUAL to Brahma, not Brahama (God) Itself. They are of same magical quality (beyond known physics), but differ in property due to magnitude/volume. To be more clear, The Braahmin religion is based on Four Books of Beda of Indus Valley regions. And Bhagabat Geetaa is a universal scientific wisdom, that encompasses the common spirit of all the religions. In fact, by talks of Bhagabat Geetaa, Guru Krishna (Who says He came in human finite form of the infinite God by his magical power to save good people from the selfish people still carrying the magical power of the god, which was politely challenged by his disciple Arjun, when he transformed into Glaring light containing the different elements of the universe that present scientific discoveries points to be correct) walks away His disciple Arjuna, a faithful Beda practitioner, from Beda ritual practice/exercise to the universal knowledge of GENERIC God, instead of culture mixed spirituality, called religions, like pursuing drinkers of different brand of sodas like Coke, Pepsi, Vitamin water etc. to drink pure distilled water (Brahma. Not to confuse with Brahmaa of Trinity). sks030322.
That distinct mentioned is the philosophy of Imam As'Shaari. The Mu'tazilites disagree with him. The current mainstrean Sunni have gone astray with Imam As'Shaari 's philosophy. I hope the Muslims reform their understanding. To unite or be in Union with God means to manifest all of God's qualities, the essence of Being. The meaning of Being. That is the goal of life. When one unites with Brahman, he manifests all the names of God. For the ordinary ones, one who walks with Grace, who walks with Mercy, who walks with Love, who walks with Wisdom, one who walks with Forgiveness, etc. For the chosen ones Like Jesus Christ, Like Lord Krishna, Like Siddharta Gautama Buddha.
The story of moses &krishna r more or less same, the baby in basket, 2 mothers,dream to kill babies, there is snake in both stories ,spliting of water, meeting wife while grazing cattle..musa has harun...krishna has arjun Story of ram, sita, rawan, laxman...is mor or less story of, ibrahim, sara,firawun, lut.....evn the names....the time king was unable to touch sara, but may b ppl hav added in that story of ram...god knows best Story of nuh is mor or less like the story of manu....the flood ,father of human after adam...bcoz from the ppl in the ship,allah gav only nuh (as,) progeny maha(great in sanskrit)+nuh=manu Asslm alkm mns Allah's peace& In hindu om shanti means gods peace Allahu a'lam..god knws bst... Allah swt is wise, he said evry act is rewarded based on the intention
In hindu books, there is no judgement day...there is loop 🔁.... There is karma.... Karma is law of universe.... Simple words.. .. Do good, get good.. .. Do bad, get bad.... And also "rebirth "
Interesting question from a 13 years old. Brahma, Krishna and Siva are the Hindu 'Trimuti'. Whilst Buddhism comes from Hinduism and Lord Buddha gives guidance in a non-God environment, Judaism starts in Asia Minor thus we have Jehovah (God) and later we had his incarnation as Jesus. Jesus as a young teenager questions and argues in a Jewish temple with elders. His full story is in the Gospels. Prophet Mohammed comes about 500 years after Jesus to confirm the Bible (Jewish heritage) incl Gospels (Christian heritage). God bless our young teenager and guide him to learn everything properly.
Humility and oneness are not mutually exclusive. Humility in perceived divinity comes from the belief and doctrine that ALL are equal. There is no imposition here, of one soul above the rest.
What if i say God is distinctive and indistinctive from the creation at the same time. Its all about perspective nothing else. Becoming one with God or maintaining individuality while serving God entirely upto devotee. God doesn't force anyone. He only guides. God or Parabramha or Allah all are same. Because the creator does not have any names he only has titles based on his attributes. That ultimate divinity revealed itself in various ways based on language,culture,tradition of the region.
"God or Parabramha or Allah all are same" Sorry not true. Kindly understand the difference between monotheism (followed by all the 3 Abrahamic religions) and hindu/Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra). Monotheism says that there is just a transcendent god up there in the sky who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand.😊😊 But the well validated Sankhya Vedic metaphysics. So, what is Sankhya vedic metaphysics? It says that without the conscious, immortal, immutable, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent divine, nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay, wave/particle, energy/matter, creation/destruction, manifestation/concealment. freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc Sankhya Vedic metaphysics can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation) it also means TAT TVAM ASI meaning - You (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion due to the experience of 5 senses and it is not the doer. Conscious athma is like a silk thread through different pearls (animate and inanimate) if you want to look at it in the form of an analogy. Point is you can't equate the non translated Sanskrit words like Athman/Paramathman, karma, swarga and naraga with the heavily Christianized English words like god, sin, heaven/hell etc.
@@Dharmicaction i am impressed with your knowledge on vedic meta physics. Abrahamic religions are based loosely on bhaktiyoga and dualism to some extent. Even in hinduism there are people specially vaishnavas who refute non duality theory of creation. But after reading some books,articles and watching videos i come to conclusion that all of those theories are incomplete without each other. For example to merge with infinite consciousness of bliss what we call parabramhan we need faith and devotion towards parabramhan but parabramhan is incomprehensible for small minds like us so we focus on sagun paramatma Christians call it God, we call it paramatma or ishwar,muslims call it allah or jews call it yahweh. Somewhere i red that "our path should be dwaita and goal should be adwaita".
Vacuum bears all things . Vacuum is all things The vacuum in a pot and the vacuum outside the pot are the same. it seems as to be separate Brama (vacum ) Abrama (Matter) are same Abrama=Abraham
Brahman and Allah are not same. Brahman is not a being who can talk, be angry,laugh,have emotions,sending someone. Brahman is independent not like allah sending prophets. Brahman is within everybody, brahman is not be worshipped he is within every body. Even the Gods Like Shiva,Vishnu,Brahma are his forms. And forms take avaters to save his children(Humans) on earth. Allah symbols are more like Shiva and Sadashiv is also formless so Allah could be relate to Shiva but not Brahman.
Dear friends, if you like our content, click like and subscribe! And please consider making a financial contribution at quranspeaks.com
We are building our Instagram presence and would love for you to follow us for shorter videos and behind the scenes photos of our work: instagram.com/quranspeaks.tv
If we don't want to make Financial contribution you won't allow us to ask Question.
Muslims Are we?
God bless to this channel and Shabir ally. :)
Dr Shabir Ally can you explain how it is possible for Allah to enter his creation and only at one-third part of the latter.?
(24)Chapter: Encouragement to supplicate and recite statements of remembrance at the end of the night, and the response to that.
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:
Our Lord, the Blessed and the Exalted, descends every night to the lowest heaven when one-third of the latter part of the night is left, and says: Who supplicates Me so that I may answer him? Who asks Me so that I may give to him? Who asks Me forgiveness so that I may forgive him?
Reference : Sahih Muslim 758 a
In-book reference : Book 6, Hadith 201
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 4, Hadith 1656
@@muhammadibnkilab7026 abu huraira is weak narrator
Not to merge, difficult to put in english. It is what it is. Unexplainable. Different concepts denote it differently , so called scholars put that like Advaita, Dvaita, vishwadwaita but these concepts are intangible to limited intellect. Agnosticism and Skepticism (Ajnan) is the .......
There is a school of Hinduism that also believes that the Brahman is also separate from creation called Dvaita Vedanta
Wow, that's very interesting! Thank you for sharing. We appreciate this opportunity to learn from you.
@@QuranSpeaks I'm a dwaitin... which technically means two as opposed to the idea of adwaita which says what Dr shabir Ally said ...we believe that no matter what.. we can never become Brahman...in fact all Vedas except a few lines speak of Dwaita only ... remember that the lines the adwaitins use to say that we merge onto god have many meanings which is applicable to Dwaita also
@@ramprasadbhat570 can you explain to us..?
@@whatever-tp2ek dr SA says that Hinduism accepts soul merges into God at moksha...dwaita says you don't merge with God but take your place according to your Jeeva yogyata in moksha
@@ramprasadbhat570 hmm so in your opinion who is brahman to you ? is he the one true god ?
This is why Sanatan Dharm is beautiful, it doesn’t ask you to choose between one religion or another, it embraces all beliefs and accepts the commonalities of philosophy from all. Brahman, God, Allah! Whatever your preference it’s seems to me you are on the right path.
Sorry. Allah is based on monotheism which says there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air. But Brahman according to Vedas is conscious, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent. Does Islam accept that the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul = Allah? If not then how can Allah and Brahman mean the same? Above all Vedas say you (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (Brahman) because without the conscious and omnipresent soul nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation cycle of humans).
If there is reincarnation then Karma or cause and effect comes into play as well. Does Islam accept karma and reincarnation? Of course not.
@@Dharmicaction Human being or any other creation of God is not God. Only God is God. This is true monotheism. With regards to existence then the real existence is that of God's. Our existence is dependent on His existence. We have our own distinct existence but we exist because God wants us to exist. He alone gives life and He alone causes us to die but death has no effect on Him because He is the Ever-Living the Self-Existing Being. The best definition of God is given in the Quran in chapter 112. God says:
"Say: He is Allah (God), the One and Only.
Allah (God), the Absolute and Eternal
He does not beget, nor is He begotten.
And there is like unto Him."
@@maaziy_ghaziyIYI brother Brahman manifest lord vishnu From satvik gunna and lord shiva tamsik gunna .we have only one god who took many forms for us
@Jay vaishnav dharma its good to know u are a muslim.
@Jay vaishnav dharma That's exactly why its beautiful. Vaishnavas explaining god with Vishnu's perspective and Shaivaits explaining god with Shiva's perspective. And still both are interconnected with various stories. If that's not beautiful than what is? If you go deep into the stories you will find out
Thanks for adding the captions
As a muslim from India , I love this channel.
Dr. Shabbir Ally is a great intellectual who gives rational and calm answers.
May Allah bless and reward you guys for doing this great job
Thank you for your kind words! We appreciate your support ❤
@@QuranSpeaks assalamualaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatahu , I had a question-
What should be an islamic response to conspiracy theories?
I know they sound weird but can muslims promote conspiracy theories which may be true?
I think this topic is in dire need of response from an islamic scholar.
Please reply
@@Afthab19 great question! Were currently editing a video on the COVID vaccine. We've also done a video on the COVID infodemic, which you can find using the search function on TH-cam. But we can always do more.
The goal of Hinduism is not to merge within Brahman but to realize You are Brahman (tat Vam asi) and once you realize it then everything becomes Brahman in your experience.
Bruh. He is talking about moksh/mukti. And it's true.
@@prrithwirajbarman8389 yeah mukti and moksha is far better than jannat.
Brother it's just a part of hinduism not the whole. Only one school of philosophy believes in this that's Advaita vedanta.
@@someone-en1gg that's highest truth, kaivalya moksha. No suffering and full happiness
The story of moses &krishna r more or less same, the baby in basket, 2 mothers,dream to kill babies, there is snake in both stories ,spliting of water, meeting wife while grazing cattle..musa has harun...krishna has arjun
Story of ram, sita, rawan, laxman...is mor or less story of, ibrahim, sara,firawun, lut.....evn the names....the time king was unable to touch sara, but may b ppl hav added in that story of ram...god knows best
Story of nuh is mor or less like the story of manu....the flood ,father of human after adam...bcoz from the ppl in the ship,allah gav only nuh (as,) progeny maha(great in sanskrit)+nuh=manu
Asslm alkm mns Allah's peace&
In hindu om shanti means gods peace
Allahu a'lam..god knws bst... Allah swt is wise, he said evry act is rewarded based on the intention
This guy clearly explained what I needed to know. I resonate with more with the "merging with God" rather than being separated and have to worship "him."
There's an ancient Hindu myth that said: "human consciousness had begun as a ripple that decided to leave the ocean of consciousness the "timeless, spaceless and eternal". When it awakened to itself in this "disconnected" state, the myth said, it forgot that it was part of the infinite ocean and felt isolated and separated."
Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent athma (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul.
Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer.
So, the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma (Shiva) in combination with its energy (Shakhti) leads to duality cycles of nature. eg Birth/decay, wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment. freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious divine + energy. Microcosm = Macrocosm.
Point is ATHMAN = BRAHMAN.
1. MAKUNDYA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 1 and verse 2 of ATHARVA VEDA
"Ayam Atma Brahma" - "This Self (soul) is Brahman" - Does Islam accept that the soul has consciousness and it is Allah?
2. CHANDOGYA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 6 verse 8.7 of SAMA VEDA
"Tat Tvam Asi" - meaning you (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul nothing can exist.
3. BRIHADARANYAKA UPANISHAD - CHAPTER 1 and verse 4.10 of ATHARVA VEDA.
"Aham Brahma Asmi" meaning "I am Brahman" (conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul = divine)
4. Aitareya Upanishad Chapter 3 and verse 3 of RIG VEDA
"Prajnanam Brahma" means conscious soul = the divine or Brahman.
@@Dharmicaction yes Allah is consious,immanent and omnipresent,he breath soul into us so we are technically brahma(atman)means god present within us and doesnt mean he is in a form with us and actual brahman has a no frm,no modification in our perspective but in himself he has a form and modification,saguna and nirguna and he is infinite,i say this is allah too.
@@Dharmicaction one more microcosm is to understand by ourself abt brahman the supreme by 12 th manifestation brahman as atman,doesnt mean he is microcosm,i hope u know asat.
@@mrimperfect5214 but core beliefs of Islam go against what you are saying, allah is not omnipresent according to them but sitting on a throne,
Actually Sufism of Islam was influenced by core of Hinduism and surface of Hinduism is influenced by core of islam
@@Dharmicaction Does islam accept that soul has consciousness? Of course. Consciousness is part of the soul, which was created by allah.
In merging with God you see that everything and everyone is God, and in that you are humbled and worship God in every interaction.
No it's not that way
You see we basically worship the bigger picture instead of worshipping extremely small parts of him
We also kinda think that if you consider brahman to be a separate being, you indirectly undermine their power of presence
Which is equally important to potence
@@animangaweeb8501 Presence is what I am pointing to 💛
@@mahmoodabdulbaqi824I think it is similar to sufi saints
Iam a hindu, but this man is a gem
Right
Same
Yes bro and I am muslim and since I reside in India I got an opportunity to learn more about adwait vedant , dwait vedant , bhakti vedanta and and I am deep diving into these philosophies as well 😅🎉❤
Brahman is the one without a second everything is his part and manifestation 🌹🌹🌹
@Joseph Christopher~ you're biological father
He who protects and controls the worlds
by His own powers, He-Rudra
'_is indeed
one only. There is no one beside Him who
can make Him the second.
O men, He is
present inside the hearts of all beings.
After
projecting and maintaining all the worlds, He
finally withdraws them into Himself.
[NOTES-1. Rudra-This word is a synonym of S'iva
in later Puräna literature, but no such sectarian meaning
is intended here. The word is used in its literal sense.
The root meaning of the word is' the destroyer of the
sins and sorrows of devotees as well as the bestower of
Jhana and bliss on them'.
Rudra also means
the
punisher of those who break His laws, physical, moral
and spiritual',
The word seems to be used here to hint
that God as the Indwelling Self watches the deeds of
men, good as well as bad.]
Just quoting from upanishads verses taken from Google ?? Go read upanishad in the guidance of a Guru.
Allah is one without a second everything is his part
@@yousaf2003
Allah is Brahman...
I believe that...
Allah is Brahman...
I believe that...
@@raviqirvansyah1304 what? No. Paramatma has no shape whereas allah does. Everything is a part of paramatma whereas we or nothing is a part of Allah. Allah is pure as not is a part of him whereas paramatma's part is everyone so if anyone cheats and rapes is also a god's quality. And many more.
Words do not matter. God is consciousness, the feeling 'I AM'.
Consciousness is an attribute of the immortal, immutable, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman just like heat is an attribute and essential nature of the fire and the sun. Consciousness is pulled into the material realm from the athma (which is beyond space and time) by Prana (which is within the realm of Shakhti) for the duality cycles of nature to happen including birth/death, manifestation/concealment of the universe etc.
Moreover, atman/brahman is not the same as Abrahamic religion word "god" which is based on monotheism. The monotheistic core of all the 3 Abrahamic religions simply says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe but still can create the universe and its "laws of nature" out of thin air and override them (whenever wanted) and control everything by just using a magic wand.
@@indianmilitary Actually the creation is the dream of a seperate self which does not exist except in imagination. When we take ourselves to be the contents of consciousness or mind, we take on bodies. It's fascinating what's happening, yet at the same time whatever happens happens but it all ends in joy. Such is our immutable nature as the cosmic being.
@@dare-er7swI don't get it, do Muslims believe in Brahman or what
sounds like Neville Goddard
@@siamaminul6240no it's vedantic in nature, the individual soul is of the same quality as the supersoul God.
You take a glass of water from the ocean , and consider that glass of water to be different from the ocean ?
They may appear different , but in essence , the h2o in the glass of water is the same as the h2o in the ocean.
2 different musical notes can be created from the same guitar string. They SOUND different , but in essence , they are the same air , just vibrating differently.
The computer that human made is alsow a part of human even the cake that your mother did cooking for you is a part of your mother hhhhh are you ok ? The CREATOR created you and brings to the existence but him is immortal! And he did give you attributes and gifts so ops! You believe to be him!!!!!!!!!!!
@@khadijaelaoufi8030 no human "created" the computer or the cake. To create something is to bring it into existence from nothing.
Brahman doesn't get angry when someone doesn't worship him.
Allah also donot get angry lol It just people who get angry
@AnonymousAlien2099 lmao u shut him up for 7 months 💀
@@pranjal69696true 😂😂
Really? Then why will Kalki come to fight against adharma, according to Hindus? If Brahman doesn't care about adharma, then why intervene in human history to stop it?
@@minskdhaka Do you even know meaning of Adharma? Adharma means Sin. Like Rap*,Murder,Alchohol,Gambling,Anima Saughlter etc. He will punish the sinner not the non believer if they don't did any sin.
There is no individual soul. There is only brahman alone in side every living entity. The living entity is called jiva, people refer jiva as individual soul, but its not the same as brahman.
Brahman illumines the jiva just like sun illuminates the moon . Moon doesn’t have its own light, the moon light we see is reflection of sun alone.
Similarly everything is brahman alone
There is no individual soul(jiva) of its own.
Exactly. There is only one universal soul . It's everywhere in the universe.
@Ashwani Jha When Avidya is removed, the Atman (Soul, Self inside a person) is realized as identical with Brahman. Until then, it's not appropriate to call atman as brahman. You don't call a drop of water in an ocean as "the ocean" itself. It's just a drop until it merges with the ocean or identifies itself in the vastness of ocean. Moreover, "Enlightenment" is not moksha. Moksha is salvation or mukti which is complete freedom from this horrendous suffering and cycle of birth and death. Enlightenment is the self realization of " *अहं ब्रह्मास्मि* ". Enlightenment is not the final stage, it's a process.
@Ashwani Jha jiva is nothing but combination of body, mind, intellect, memory and ego. All of this is illuminated by Atman or brahman. That is why they say without god nothing moves. The reality is told in different levels according to level of each individual.
When one indentify himself as an individual and god is seperate from him, then it is dvaitha(two) vedantha.
When one identify himself to be a part of god, it is vishista advaitha vedanta. In this man experienced god within him.
When one identify himself with atman or brahman, it is advaita(one) vedanta(ekam eva dwithiyam). When i say identify, its not about belief, its about being here and now, one looses individuality(ego) when he experience his real nature. Example is Bhagvan Ramana Maharshi.
The man in the video claims sufi saints said i am the truth, its nothing but they reached the level of advaitha vedantha.
All religions are true and say about same reality in different ways and language and different levels according to individual experience of an individual.
@@arnoldschafernaker512 may be you are saying at the level of vishistha advaitha. The drop and the ocean example is not for the highest level(advaitha). Because brahman is not physical in nature, how can one say Atman is divided?
Avidya getting lost is nothing but ego(false identity that i am body,mind etc) getting lost.
Lord Krishna said in bhagavad gita , “O conquerer of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread”
Here thread represents the supreme brahman or Atman and the pearls represent the jivas(combination of body, mind, intellect,memory,ego)
Ego is like a ghost , actually its not a reality like brahman. When i say real, its unchanging and eternal. Ego(false identity) is ever changing.
example if one becomes rich, he identifies himself to be superior to lower status people than him. Like this so many branches of identities spring from the root identity which is ego(false identification of individual) .
Bhagvan Ramana maharshi said, if the root of the tree is destroyed, entire tree falls, likewise the root ego(false identification as individual) is destroyed by realizing the true self as the supreme reality, eternal, infinite, the source of everything which nothing but brahman.
When the individuality itself is lost , the tree of false identites cease to exist. And what remains is pure being which is brahman itself.
Ego is in the mind and mind is nothing but collections of thoughts and ideas which are likely to change based on perceptions.
No brahm jeevatma and prakriti are seperate district realities as mentioned in vedas
I was once telling brahman thing to my muslim friend.. His eyes got lit... He told me one of name of allah is ar rahman
You can't equate Abrahamic religion's monotheistic understanding of so called "god" with the well validated Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu/dharmic tradition was built including yoga and tantra). Monotheism says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand.😊😊So, you can't replace the non translatable Sanskrit words like athman/brahman, karma, swarga and naraka with words like "god", sin, heaven/hell etc.
@Joseph Christopher~ you're biological father Shiva the name is made from 2 words Shi which means that and va which means which is not. So, in essence, Shiva means that which is not. Formless, ageless just like Brahman. So yes, you are right, Shiva is Brahman. It is said that Universe is in the form of an ellipsoid, Shiva linga is also an ellipsoid for that specific reason. It's funny how you learn something new every day! Thank for the quote from Yajurveda, I did not know about this :)
@@ChillGoodVibe
Shiva is Form bro.he had wife and Children in Kailasa. You can't find it You Chant om Namah shivaya namaha 🕵️
@user-yd1je8pc7i what about Vaishnavism ? Vishnu is Brahman in Vaishnava tradition.
This person is very intelligent , peaceful and well respected by most of his listeners
I believe that it’s all the same concept, but different end games. Brahman/God/Allah/YHWH/Waheguru ji, is the creator. Different names as these religions were all developed in different areas of the world but same thing. We can’t see God, we can’t physically touch God, but we all have an agreement that God is our creator and reason for life. And we all praise God. The goals may be different when it comes to afterlife and Heaven/Hell. But God is one. God may be perceived or worshipped different according to which religion you follow, but one God, by many names. That’s how I see it 😊 God is what unites the people!
Yeah agree.but Allah says defferent way to worship,yhwh says defferent way to worship and brahman also say different way to worship.?
@@polite.cat.has.playlists hence why I said “God may be perceived or worshipped different according to which religion you follow..” Also, in my opinion, if I say that God in Hinduism is a different God than in Christianity, I’m acknowledging that there is more than 1 divine, when there is only 1 divine, just worshipped differently by many people.
There is nothing y h wh
I jus said that and 1000% agree with you
" Ekum sat vipra bahuda vadanti " - the ancient Rig Veda.
Which means - truth is one, the wise explain it differently.
Fantastic ! As a Muslim I was reading Vedanta to teach my daughter for a theology class and surprise to see Monotheism in the very core of Hinduism . Veda being main book and Vedanta being most important part of Veda says God is One ! Allahu Akbar !
Exactly all those shiva, durga and vishnu are just forms of God, in reality he is formless and we are his sons and daughters
@@Soulreaper286but vedas and upanishads are rejects your concept.
Yajurveda ch32v3
Creator doesn't have any similitude.
He is one and alone
No one saw him
@@ARRusulOneMessage 😂 Bruh hinduism isn't limited to vedas this is not islam in short God is with form and without form. I follow vendanta school which says God is without form and there is dvaita vendanta which says God have a form point is God can appear in any form do you think God is unable to take a form 😂
@@Soulreaper286 bro so many hindu claims except vedas and upanishads all are books are interpolated by people.
Vedas and upanishads are shruti (heared) books most important book than smiriti which are lower than vedas.
God has power on all things
He knows all about his creatures so he doesn't need to take a human form.
If God taking human forms to teach human what is good or bad why he not taking form of germs bacteria viruses animals birds reptiles these are also creatures of God
Why God doesn't taking form of tiger to teach it to not to eat Innocent animals.
These are blasphemous words to Almighty God he is power on all
He is above all
He is all knowing
He knows what is in your hearts and in minds.
@@ARRusulOneMessagethe ultimate reality according to the Upanishads is non-dual, immaterial, efficient, formal and final cause of all that exists. It is the pervasive, infinite, eternal truth, consciousness and bliss which does not change, yet is the cause of all changes. Brahman as a metaphysical concept refers to the single binding unity behind diversity in all that exists in the universe while Islam is monotheism. Allah is the only creative intelligence and Quran advocates creator-creation duality. So you can't use Hindu scriptures to justify the existence of Allah because they are not the same.
🛑 Similarities Between *Kalki Avatar* and *Muhammad* :
*[1] -* The name of the Kalki will be Narashangsha, which means praised human, the meaning of the name Muhammad is also praised man.
*[2] -* Kalki will born on 12th day of Madhu month, the first month of the hindu lunar year and the first month of summer, Muhammad similarly born on the 12th day on Rabiul Awal, the third month of the Arabic lunar year but astrologically the time was summer season according to solar time. Kalki will born on Shambhala village or island, which means place/house of peace and a land beside water or sea, it also means Arab and Asia minor according to the world map division of Hindu religion, Makkah is Muhammad's birth place which is also beside sea and it is in Arab and Asia minor and its another name is Darul Aman, which means the place/house of peace.
*[3] -* Kalki's father's and Mother's name will be Vishnuyash and Sumati, which means slave of God and peaceful lady. Muhammad's father's and mother's name are Abdullah and Amina, which also mean slave of God and peaceful lady.
*[4] -* Kalki will be born of the family of the main priest of Shambhala, Muhammad was also born of the family of Abdul Muttalib, the main priest of then the Makkah.
*[5] -* Kalki rides on miraculous flying white horse named Devadatta (meaning: given by God) given by Shiva to destroy the evil, Muhammad also rode a miraculous flying white horse named Buraq given by Allah and destroyed evil.
*[6] -* Kalki will fight with Khaksha means sword, Muhammad also used to fight with sword.
*[7] -* Kalki will go to hillside after birth and receive messages from a mount from Parshurama (spirit of Raam or God, verbally Raam means God of the World) and then will go to north and after that he will return, Muhammad also received messages from God through Jibrail in mount Jabal al-Nour, and another name of Jibrail is Ruhul-Amin which means spirit of God, and he also went to Madina situated in north of the Makkah and after that returned to Makkah again with victory.
*[8] -* Gods will directly help Kalki in war, Muhammad was also helped by the angels in the battle of Badr.
*[9] -* Kalki will defeat demon kali with the help of his four brothers, Muhammad also defeated Satan by the help of his major four closest companions, later known as Rashidun Caliph.
*[10] -* Kalki will destroy the robbers as hidden as Kings, Muhammad also destroyed the oppressors who were kings and leaders at that time.
*[11] -* Kalki will be impressively handsome (Anupama Kanti) and incomparably beautiful (Apratim Dyuti), Muhammad was also known to be handsome and impressive and had been described as the most beautiful man of contemporary Arabia.
*[12] -* Fregrance will come out from Kalki's body, Muhammad's body odour was also renowned for charming fragrance.
*[13] -* Kalki will be adviser of a very big society, Muhammad was also an adviser of a big society.
*[14] -* Kalki will have eight divine virtues (Ashtaishwaryaguna): Wisedom, born of noble family, self-control, remembrance (heard from God), physically powerful, less speechful, charitable, advisor of Gods verses and gratefulness. Muhammad also had these eight virtues.
This is so interesting, thank you for sharing! If you don’t mind could you tell me Who Kalki Avatar is in Hinduism? Peace and blessings
@@saimahussain7898 it is prophet Muhammad pbuh in Hinduism scripture
Mohammed is never kalki avatar of lord Vishnu. Moreover we don't have any prophets in Hinduism but god himself incarcerates in various avatars.
Lord kalki is going to born in the indian subcontinent including Nepal and Tibet.
Kalki is not going to learn teachings from various saints. He will have only two wives no slaves.
Kalki is not going to theft any caravans for money. He is not against idol worshipping and many gods and goddesses.
He never kills any women except the daughter of Ghatotgach. No slavery.
Moreover when he comes there will be no Islam and all humans follow one religion I.e. "Sanathana Dharma (don't compare with Satan)". Try to search about "kaala gnaanam" by "Sri Pothuluri Veera Brahmendra Swamy" and his avatar "Veera Bhoga Vasantharaaya".
Shambhala is not any desert place. Read Kalki Puranam.
Kalki is not going to speak Arabic but Sanskrit or any Indian language. No way he is going to preach imaginary Allah nor evil Islam. Because he is the almighty himself.
Go through *RAHUL SINGH's* answer on *QUORA* on the question: Was Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) the Kalki Avatar as predicted in Hindu Scriptures?
😂😂😂
Brahman, Allah, Elohim, Cosmic Consiousness, Universal Mind, Absolute Reality, Spirit Force, Necessary Being, Unconditioned Reality. These are just words that people use to refer to the same being which people cannot quantify. Monotheism, pantheism are just different ways of looking at the same thing, like men seeing only parts of the elephant. Polytheism is simply the division of attributes into different beings ie god of love, god of revenge, god of wealth. Thats all it is.
S it basically makes Krishna Allah !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@teamkrishnabhaktas9648 no man we say aham brahmasmi or an al haq that is the realization that you and creater are not seprate
No Brahman and Allah God are not same Brahman is different
Concept of God in Indian religions (Hinduism, shikhism, jainsim) is different from abrahmic religions. Abrahmic religions focus more on materialism while Indic religions focus on spirituality.
The different is simple. Monotheism followed by all the Abrahamic religions say that there is just a transcendent "god" who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. It led to the assumption that the so called "god" can override laws of nature, needless prophets, middlemen, angels, messiah, son of god, non existent heaven/hell, fantasy stories (propagated as history) and half baked responsibilities towards nature and people due to lack of understanding of a well validated metaphysics (like Vedic metaphysics), law of karma, reincarnation (birth/death duality) and MOKSHA (microcosm to macrocosm)
Islam focuses on spirituality, material life in islam has been prohibited and spirituality is norm in quran and ahadiths, dont know about the other abrahamic faiths but they are very similar
@@taiyeebmuhtadi no,, islamic philosophy inferior..
@@Chairman_LmaoZedong wow bro are u serious?
@@taiyeebmuhtadi Sufism focuses on spirituality and mysticism. Orthodox Islam focuses on materialism and material actions to appease god and be in his good grace. It is indeed an inferior philosophy with no spiritual value.
Hindu knowledge of GOD is attained by many many yogis/saints/prophets in different ways but with same answers.
Hindu knowledge of absolute reality not a individual Monotheistic deity
I love discourses like this!
On the authority of Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him), who said that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
Allah (mighty and sublime be He) said: Whosoever shows enmity to someone devoted to Me, I shall be at war with him. My servant draws not near to Me with anything more loved by Me than the religious duties I have enjoined upon him, and My servant continues to draw near to Me with supererogatory works so that I shall love him. When I love him I am his hearing with which he hears, his seeing with which he sees, his hand with which he strikes and his foot with which he walks. Were he to ask [something] of Me, I would surely give it to him, and were he to ask Me for refuge, I would surely grant him it. I do not hesitate about anything as much as I hesitate about [seizing] the soul of My faithful servant: he hates death and I hate hurting him. It was related by al-Bukhari.
Shabir did a good job bringing up Sufi to identify similarities with Brahman. He should have mentioned Ibn 'Arabi and his venture into Non-Dualism philosophy through Wahdat al-Wujud. Because the Brahmans have many philosophies, comparisons with the "Dvaita Vedanta" ideas may coincide with dualistic distinctions in Islam. However, Non-Dualism in western religions register as 'likeness' because Islam, Christianity and Judaism all consider some people worthy of vassalage. An elevated sense distinct from common people, coincidingly a place for God's presence. But here is a question: If what God has is God (glory, self awareness per se), You are offered this glory to be part of you, what does that make you? I think it is an ontological mess.
That's why Brahma which is a sanskrit word for Allah doesn't have an image even among hindus.
Tamil and Sanskrit are one of the oldest languages. Most probably spoken by Noah and his children.
@Himanshu Khichar no we worship the creator not the creation. By the way what are you doing in the comment section of a Islamic video ? Here to find out the straight path ? You're welcomed.
@Himanshu Khichar to some points it's revelent.....but some are utterly dilusional....mysogany.... dogmatism....there's been too much adultration in Qur'an..........and on one point he explained god is different....is wrong according to us Hindus....coz if God is different from us...he don't own us he don't have control...over certain things....but in Hinduism......god is everything ...he is universe .....
@S A bro stop being dilusional......ghalib Kamal ke sath live jao TH-cam p
Very true brother
Much respect to this Man for explaining with so much clarity and unbiased thoughts - Indian
If you ask same thing from Hindu he would insult or mich Islam .
@@mianmaaz5568 you can't generalise all Hindus like that it is same how some people generalise all muslims as terrorist
My apologies if this has already been covered, what are your thoughts regarding the NOI, and the Nation of Gods and Earths?
We will try to address your question in a future show, God willing!
Thank you for your enlightening videos Dr. Ally... but please allow me to point out one aspect that you've overlooked in this discussion. The fact that God says in the Quran that He has blown from His spirit into mankind. So, our spirits do have a part of God's spirit in them. And I contemplate that "al-salat" (connection with God) might be the equivalent of "merging" with God in Hinduism (on a spiritual level not literal). I know very little about Hinduism, though.. but I strongly believe that all monotheistic religions are one.
Also, I wonder why you call us servants of God. I cannot recall any verse that implies so. What I understand is that we are worshippers (ebad) of God (Allah) as opposed to servants or slaves (abeed) of God. Both plurals (ebad and abeed) have the same singular term (abd) but different meanings.
Thank you for sharing these interesting insights, @Noha Samir! We will pass on your comments to Dr. Shabir.
@@QuranSpeaks
Thank you for your timely reply.
@@nohasamir3134 Hinduism is not limited to monotheism
And Brahman is more than a God concept.
@@satyamindnectar7052 but Brahman is the only true ultimate reality. All your devas are manifestation of Brahman.
@@TheKingofTheUniverse. But Deva is God/deity but Brahman is seen as Principle not as deity/God (Doesn't matters Formless God or not )
Brahman is seen as Principle not as Individualised God
1) People should stop comparing the Gods because "God is one with innumerable forms".
2) Gita is not for "Parayan", its for "Aacharan", so practice it. Dont just daily read it. Don't mug up the scriptures. Krishna told to adopt the teachings into our lives.
3) God is one and anybody can worship any form of God, or they can even worship formless God. But ultimate truth is God is one, so don't fight in the name of God.
4) If you worship Allah, you can see Ganesha,Krishna,Rama, etc. Similarly, if you worship Krishna, you get divine vision to see Allah,Ganesh,Budda etc.
So, follow with one beloved God form, then you can see all of the God forms.
5) Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (saint) said he realized Allah, Jesus by worshipping Kaali. He says people believe when they truly experience/realize the fact themselves.
6) Krishna said every human being can become the God. First, a person should know the inner soul it's called self realization. Later, that person can realize the soul of God. Its called God realization or enlightenment. It's the ultimate aim of human life.
7) water from different sources dissolve into ocean and become one. Similarly, Soul (energy) of a person go and dissolve into supreme infinite soul (God). That's called God realization/enlightenment, thus becoming the God ourself by dissolving into God.
8) God realization can be achieved through many practices such as Sankhyayoga,Karma yoga, Bhaktiyoga, Jnanayoga. These practices are done by Hindus, Muslims, Christians etc in one or the other styles.
9) Gita explained the ultimate truth about God, God realization, becoming the God(qualitatively not quantitatively) ourselves. No other religious book explained this ultimate truth. Thus, Gita is the greatest book. It says u can take any path and practice yourself.
10) Knowledge of God realization is the base for all sciences. Its the supreme knowledge. Its called "Aadhyathma" in Sanskrit. Spiritualism in English.
As a Hindu, I appreciate you approaching this subject with respect and grace. I enjoyed this man's analogy about Brahman and also his explanation of Sufi Islam
Who told you he is sufi ?
@@satyamindnectar7052 I didn't say he was? I said I liked his explanation of Sufi Islam
Dear friends of the world.
We are all one. Experience of Ultimate is only one. The question is what happens with the one who saw it after. If you know who you are and ego takes not over you it is ok and you are merged with Ultimate but to be sure it is better you keep reminding yourself as being separated to honour the Ultimate and thus subdue the Ego.
Bot path are correct and talk about the same thing it is just a matter of training and emphasis so you do not go astray.
Alah and Brahman are the same difference is in approach.
We are all brothers and sisters under the same sky and under the same law of nature!
Love and respect to you all!
Allah is based on monotheism which simply says that there is just a transcendent god who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. But the understanding of conscious, self luminous, Immortal, immutable, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman and its intelligent energy are based on the Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu tradition) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience.
Moreover, Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent athma (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul.
Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious athma and it is NOT the doer
ERWIN SCHRODINGER (ONE OF THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Hindu Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
Thank you 🙏🏼❤
Elaborate please
Something cool to keep in mind is we belive most religions originate with a profit of Allah and then changed by humans.
When thats kept in mind its cool to look at brahman, krishna, azurha mazda, see similarities and wonder are these echos of islam? Was zoraster was a profit? Etc
Zurvan not ahuramazda
Bro Islam is just 1500 years old meanwhile Hinduism is most ancient religion on earth before Islam nobody worshipped allah
@@wavehixeno4915 No bro Islam existed even before prophet Muhammad p.b.u.h bcz prophet adam preaches Islam
.so prophet adam is the first preacher of Islam and prophet Muhammad s.a.w is the last preacher of Islam . You should study Islam
Both are same for experienced one . Truth is one wise speak of it differently. If you learn deep any religion you will come to this conclusion.
Knowledgeable and wise man. Respect 🙏🏼🤲🏼
This channel made me think rationally about this beautiful religion
May Allah bless you ❤️
Thank you! May Allah bless YOU!!!
Man I love how she ask him questions out of the blue...great video
This is actually a question we received from someone who watches our show in India.
@@QuranSpeaks my name is Sajjad hossain rifat i am Muslim i respect and love all the religion i love all prophet like prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.) Jesus lord Krishna
NOT JUST ALLAH, BRAHMAN BUT ALL AND US, WE ARE THAT LIGHT=GOD=ENERGY .. CREATOR is both, CREATOR and the Created!
Sorry not the same. Allah or so called god is only transcendent with a magic wand for all the 3 Abrahamic religions but Brahman is conscious, self luminous, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent. Brahman and its intelligent energy always exist together for the perpetual duality cycles to happen eg eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation of humans), wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment of the universe (NOT CREATION OR DESTRUCTION since energy can be neither created nor destroyed). freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra) which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious Brahman + energy (cosmic allegories Shiva + Shakthi or Vishnu + Lakshmi or Brahma + Saraswathi).. Microcosm = Macrocosm.
Hindu/Vedas say consciousness is an attribute of the immanent soul (just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun) which is also all pervading (omnipresent) just like a thread which passes through different pearls (animate and inanimate). It is because of the immanent and omnipresent soul there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul.
Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent Brahman) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer.
ERWIN SCHRODINGER (FATHER OF QUANTUM PHYSICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
Exactly
We are that
@@Dharmicaction universe is one....so is all.... all is one, one is all..... same consciousness.... I don't type stones, Word Is GOD and we live in GOD of Gods ......
...........
........behind me is 43 years of life experiences... was exploring and learning all my life, especially after 2003,....I speak 5 languages, have the internet from March 2003 and over 245.000 of all in 5 gmail, over 40.553 are the drafts, just in 1 gmail is over 151000 of all, over 1860 fb notes, read/& listen to over 3000 books-audio books, till 2017, hundreds of lectures, a lot of all .............
@selmir369 send me some of them, bruh, eye openers.❤
Brahman, ParamAtman and The Atman are one and the same. As the dreamer is all the components of the dream so is Brahman all Components of Reality. The Merging of the soul can be thought of that “he who thinks he knows, does not know and He that knows and think he does not know, knows.” This means that u can never know the infinite with a finite mind and intellect. The merging of the Soul/Atman is just the experiential comprehension of an infinitesimal part of the infinite called Brahman. Learning and knowing God will never end for it is infinite, so even after mergence you will still uncover greater truths found in infinity.
or we can put it this way. TAT TVAM ASI meaning you (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay, manifestation/concealment of the universe, wave/particle, energy/matter etc. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion due to the experience of 5 senses and it is not the doer. Conscious athma is like a silk thread through different pearls (animate and inanimate) if you want to look at it in the form of an analogy.
The main purpose of expanded consciousness state or samadhi is either to remove past karma (Chitta shudddhi) or to gain knowledge (which is a different dimension). Not everyone with embodied experience can gain direct material knowledge
Does Brahman have consciousness or personal being? i.e it has a distinct will?
@@furqanirfan911 Brahman is attributeless, formless, impersonal, Absolute Truth.. It can’t be described in words.. It’s beyond mind.. Upanishads have tried to describe It as Sathyam (Absolute Truth), Gyaanam (Infinite Knowledge, Consciousness), Anantam (No beginning, no ending, timeless, spaceless, Infinity) and It is also described as Sat (Existence), Chit (Awareness), Ananda (Bliss).. It’s also described as Sathyam (Truth), Shivam (Auspiciousness), Sundaram (Infinite Beauty)
It pervades the entire cosmos.. Cosmos is an appearance / illusion in Brahman which means whole creation is a manifestation or expression of its Divine Will yet it is transcendental and ever pure ever new untouched by creation!
@@Prashant-cw3ir wow mind boggling
Appreciate Dr.Shabir Ally's unbiased and balanced answer
Realisation of Brahman is not forced. Unlike Islam. So, don't compare. They're on two different leagues.
An interesting topic! This made me think of a song called "Brahman" sung by a band from the sixties called Quintessence on their Dive Deep album.
Thanks for this - very interesting. Thanks for humbly confessing you don’t know too much about Brahaman - making you a non ultracrepaderian 😀
What he said is incomplete. There are no strict laws and regulations like Islam or Christianity. There are many philosophies in Hinduism. Advaita vedana, vishishtata advaita and dvaita Vedanta. God and humans are separate and we should worship God, this is what dvaita Vedanta says. Hinduism is vast, you need 3 or 4 lives to complete reading all texts which are full of philosophical debates
But Hinduism believe one formless god called Brahman but hindus don't believe devil concept
Bro the devil is nothing but our ego. Dont take it literally
@Gyanii purush I am not talk about Brahma the creator I talk about Brahman the supreme reality.hindu God Brahman Means invisible Formless concept of one God
@Gyanii purush tereko galat femi he Bhai.Brahma Vishnu Mahesh ek Omkar Formless god ka Teen rup he Bhai.
@Gyanii purush dekh Bhai me nirakar ek khuda ko manta hu.baki Hindu ka pata nahi wo Kya manta he.wese tu mulle lagta he mujhe
Brahman is even unthinkable
It's really nice to know that all religions descended from the one entity Allah where He explained himself in similar fashion but with passage of time it all got contaminated with human interventions.. even dr zakir naik explained similar subject of tawheed mentioned in hindu Vedas.. Allah sent different messengers throughout history with unique signs in order to make people of that time hear same message of tawheed ...
I always believed that hinduism never taught idol worship, these heroes were good people or some might had been prophets of Allaah but people started errecting their idols in order to remember them & their memorable acts and in doing so it all turned into worshiping them generation after generation.....
Quran talks about idols and hindu bhagwans. The emphasis lies on jins fooling humans into believing that they are God.. since they can show themselves in different forms and take away the food kept for them hence proving that they are Gods..
Anyway I wish and hope any hindu who is reading this perhaps pay heed and accept that it's only one caretaker of this entire universe and all those nice people who came and did their best to help humanity never wished to be worshipped .. it's mentioned in quran that on day of judgement all the these people (so called gods) who were worshipped will deny any responsibility towards these worshippers ...even Jesus will tell that I never told my people to worship me and Allah knew that I wasn't the one doing that ....they ( worshippers and jinns ) all will be sent to hell fire ..
After learning this from Quran we have no right to make them partner with the ONE who created everything neither none should think bhagwans are intercessors between humans and the ONE who controls everything ...
Allaah can listen whatever is in the chests and whatever is uttered loudly ..hence no mediator is required between human and the ONE who created him ..
Trust Him and rely on Him ..he will respond directly ..this is tawheed
So Allah is invented only Just 1400 years ago, whereas Hindu Text is 10,000 year old and Jakir Nayak try to make the people full.
Your comment really only reflects how unqualified you are in vedic philosophy. There is not a mass array of separated gods, all is one - the multitude of appearance does not contradict this. You've never lifted a page to study beyond the quran, have you?
Since you're so qualified in sanatanadharma, please explain archa-vigraha/ishta-devata, nirakara and Sakara, and how viveka and vairagya factor in around it all. This question relates precisely to "idol worship" so, I trust you can answer it quite simply.
Instead of writing these long paragraphs you should have just written that you believe Allah is the only God and followers of all other religions will burn in hell. People like you know nothing about what other religions teach and then pretend you know everything. Good luck living a life filled with ignorance and hatred!
Whats wrong in idol worship ... Vedas never say idol worship is wrong ... There is no concept of beleivers and non beleivers in vedic text as in abrahamic religions infact it encourages people to question the existence of god itself
I think merging with God makes it more of a way of living rather than a religion as to have the strength to overcome any obstacle in life because God is always with you. The concept of 1 submitting to God is more like a religion. I think both works depending on people's beliefs.
Brahmn is also called formless rup of shiv that s called Sadashiv
The Only difference between western And eastern culture is the argument of omnipresence when it truly bubbles down
Very interesting question. I dont know much about Hinduism. What about the sikh religion? I've heard they believe in 1 God also. Is it the same God as Allah?
Great question!
@@QuranSpeaks This concept is called Wahadat-ul-Wujood (unity of being) in Islamic tradition. In Hinduism it's called Advait, literally meaning there's no second (only one). This concept has been deliberately sidelined and demonized by Islamic rulers. Anyway, to answer your question, in reality there's only one existence, that's Allah or Brahman. Any other existence is an illusion, that came into being by Allah's Will. Because there's nothing but Allah, all other existence is simply the Will of Allah. But this can not be explained or understood and can only be experienced because Allah is the imperceptible to the senses (al-Ghayab). This realization is called "Moksha" in Hinduism. This is the "return" to Allah in Islam.
@@RAMESHKOTIKALAPUDI thank you for sharing your perspective. We hope you feel welcome here...it is not our intention to put down Hinduism in any way.
@@QuranSpeaks Thank you for your kind words. I did not feel you tried to put down Hinduism. I know you're very gracious and respectful. I'm a curios learner and seeker of religious philosophies and am a follower of Sai of Shirdi. He taught Islam and Hinduism are same. I think the difference is in Sharia which includes worship. That has caused the rift. None the less there are even Hindu philosophers whose teachings seem to be outwardly pointing to the duality "God" and "Creation" being separate. They're called "Dvaith" schools.
Hinduism also started as having a single God or single entity.
One can compare it to multiple qualities or attributes given to a father namely -> The one who is procreator,A caretaker,An educator.......etc- ie.....a father can be all these and still be the same person father.
Similar to how in islamic sense Allah has 99 names or 99 attributes.
Hinduism existed with multiple naming of a single God but along the passage of time and courruption due to one varna/caste of Hinduism from 300BC to 200AD,most of the stuff was reformed and atlered and we ended up being a polytheistic culture and then a monothestic back to polytheistic.(Thats why in hinudism a person can be ploythiestic,his father be monotheistic and his son be atheist and all are not wrong but confused interpretations)
Multiple random books emerged which started gaining relevance and so was most of the stuff manipulated and hidden from illiterate folks(as holy scripts were in not in common tongue) and well here we are now doing something different from what is written in original scriptures but following the texts of random saints.
Edit:Some text is being striked out and am not aware of the reason.
This is the great theological debate about Theism, Panentheism, and Pantheism. Even Christian sects believe in different aspects of God, whether he's separate from his creation, present in all his creation, or distinct as well as present in all of his creation.
Thank you Sir, for explaining so beautifully
Thank you again for a level headed insight into your faith. Much respect
Ruh is from Allah and we all carry it.
But nobody can have the knowledge of true nature of ruhu.
Same is what we call atma, which is immortal.. Once one realises the ultimate reality.. He is free from sorrow, happiness and all kinds of feelings and his atman merges with ultimate reality brahmam
We all are allah
@@akshatpathak25 rooh and atma are different 😂
@@satyamindnectar7052 i'm not sure about ruh..i thought it's similar to aatma
Wow that was great. Thank You for this post I had the same question.
So basically Islam copied concepts of God from Hinduism. One cannot deny this because Islam is way younger than Hinduism which is the oldest living religion in the world.
Partially true, Islam copied the Concept from Jews. All Prophet Prior to Mohamad was described and admitted in Koran. Adam and Eve, Abraham, Isac and many more. The Hallal also came from Jews Tradition. The tradition of circumcision also a Jews Tradition. Eating pig also forbidden in Jews. Some tradition are borrowed from Christian, Some from Jews and idol worship in the form of Kaba is from traditional ritual of the tribe of Mecca.
no, Islam is distinct and unique, Islam teaches la ilaha illa Allah, meaning there is no god except Allah. unlike hinduism, where you find so many gods created from each other, marry each other, overpower each other, and each of them has a limited role.
@hzep_345 yes it doesn't but Islamic prophets were consisted of jews Many of themmm
@@WeWillAllReturnToAllahSoon in hinduism all god are manifestation of param Brahman
@@wavehixeno4915 i know, and thats what not right, bc these statues are man-made and carved by men, why should i worship some thing that i created, and which can't harm or benefit me?
I worship Allah the one true God, without going to different statues, subhan Allah, la ilaha illa Allah
The two are absolutely NOT the same. Brahman is Satchitananda, Absolute consciousness, knowledge and bliss. Allah is an angry god who commands subservience only to him.
Creator remain distinct from creation in transcendental reality is also in Hinduism in a different tradition called Vaishnavism
Good answer. They are fundamentally different concept. Islam more aligns with Dvaita Vedanta of Hinduism as opposed to the Advaita Vedanta.
Advaitha (conscious and non dual shiva) and Dvaitha (duality capable Shakthi in combination with shiva) are INCOMPLETE without each other. In other words, Shiva and Shakthi always exist together for the perpetual duality cycles to happen. eg eg Birth/decay (including reincarnation of humans), wave/particle, energy/matter, manifestation/concealment of the universe (NOT CREATION OR DESTRUCTION since energy can be neither created nor destroyed). freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc This is Sankhya Vedic metaphysics which can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation). In other words, there is nothing other than the conscious divine + energy or (cosmic allegories Shiva + Shakthi or Vishnu + Lakshmi or Brahma + Saraswathi).. Microcosm = Macrocosm.
But the core of Abrahamic religions is monotheism which says that there is just a transcendent "god" who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand. .It led to blind belief in a book, needless prophets/middlemen, angels, non existent heaven/hell, fantasy stories (propagated as history), proselytization, and half baked responsibilities towards nature and discrimination/violence against (non believers" due to lack of understanding of Karma or cause and effect (created due to violation of balance of natural law or dharma by human ego), reincarnation (birth/death duality cycle) and Moksha (microcosm to macrocosm)
Consciousness is an attribute of the immanent and omnipresent athma or the divine just like heat is an attribute of fire and the sun. It is because of the immanent and omnipresent athma there is consciousness in the psycho-physical body. But in Abrahamic religions there is no connection between consciousness and the soul.
Hindu/Vedas go further by saying TAT TVAM ASI meaning You (conscious and immanent soul) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent soul or divine nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion because the 5 senses are experienced by the conscious soul and it is NOT the doer.
ERWIN SCHRODINGER (FATHER OF QUANTUM PHYSICS) Schrodinger's biographer Moore, wrote -- “His system - or that of the Upanishads/Vedas - is delightful and consistent: the self and the world are one and they are all. He rejected traditional western religious beliefs (Jewish, Christian, and Islamic) not on the basis of any reasoned argument, nor even with an expression of emotional antipathy, for he loved to use religious expressions and metaphors, but simply by saying that they are naïve--and will NOT understand Quantum theory and consciousness.
I pray to ALLAH I I'll be like u and help my grandchildrens to help in knowing.
From Him we come, to Him we belong.
The soul within the flesh is our divine
The soul returns to God when we die while the body decays.
But there are some hadiths that say, on judgment day the people of God at the highest rank, are able to see him like we see the moon at night.
And there is no bliss or pleasure more delightful ever experienced.
NO
There is no judgement day in hinduism.. One can merge with that supreme reality in his life time... It's about realising that ultimate reality and after realising that ultimate reality one is free from sorrow, happiness and all such sensory things
@@akshatpathak25 there isnt a judgement day as such
but a last avatar of vishnu, called kalki which is similar to mahdi , in islam
Correct Islam does teach that ....but at the same time how can we see God when he's formless ??????
@@islamaboyy588 god is in everything
Just imagine it
When there was nothing but god
What did he use to build this world?
He used himself
We are all a part of him
And will merge with him once again
That's the glory of
God/allah/vishnu/ahura mazda
Whatever you call him
Regardless of difference in ideology and the bits of etymology that are often confused with equation; the creator is the creator but given different titles:
The all being creator God became known as Anu in ancient sumeria, as Atum-Ra in what we call egypt, BrahmaN in india, Ahura Mazda in Persia, Ashurah-YaHWaH to caananites and jews, Al-lah to arabs and muslims, as Jehova to jehovas witnesses, and simply as ‘God’ with a capital G to Catholics
Um No 😂
The abrahamic concept of “god” is VERY different to that of the eastern traditions.
Eastern tradition god is much better
@@gauritutorials7665 Eastern traditions depict this “something” as the original source and something which is superior in intelligence and understanding. Can’t even call it “god”.
@@kyliereed200
God is one = Eastern religions
There is only one god = Western religions
@@kyliereed200 true
What a good answer Dr. Shabir..
Barakallah..
Salam!
We’d love to have Dr. Shabir Ally review “Forty Rules of Love” by Elif Shafak.
It talks about Qur’an and it’s 4 layers. A very interesting yet hard to grasp concept. It would be great if he can explain that concept.
Ps: Love the show! 🌸💕
Interesting! We'll look into it! Thank you for sharing.
“Who has ascended to heaven and come down? Who has gathered the wind in his fists? Who has wrapped up the waters in a garment? Who has established all the ends of the earth? What is his name, and what is his son’s name? Surely you know!”
Proverbs 30:4 ESV
ELOHIM in hebrew
The name of Abram/Abraham could be a clue to this, "A Brahman." Perhaps he was a Priest of Brahman/Allah before Hinduism became idolatrous?
The letters h should not sound the same in Abraham and Brahman.
Good point in searching such relations but linguistics is not easy science.
I was the same..
But we really don't know the truth on that..
Lol, what nonsense....
If everything and everyone is Brahman, there is no question.
Everything in Universe is BRAHMAN alone sense of self is illusion and lack of awareness
No it is not pantheist concept
Brahman in Hinduism is
Monistic, qualified monistic, polymorphic henotheism
Earth Is flat 👌👌👌
Yup
@@islamaboyy588 🤣😂
@@Vishnujikasevak what , it is !!
@@islamaboyy588 you said yup 👍
@@Vishnujikasevak oh ok .....cool ...you really believe it's flat tho ?
This is a misconception that when you merge with God ..you become God. The truth is, by all accounts, that your ego dissappears and you see God in everyone else.
This was very interesting thank you both for this video. I was thinking Brahman could be the interpretation of Allah in hindu and the interpretation of day of judgment could have got interpreted as merging with Allah since Allah mentions that he will call us back to him. of course Allah knows best
Yes, this is also true, we should keep an open mind and perhaps "judgement day" is a symbolic meaning and not what we think. Subject to interpretation.
You cann,t merge with Allah the gentleman said. You are supposed to obey his rule forever.
@@bhabanikalita109 how do you know?
There is no judgement day in hinduism.. One can merge with that supreme reality in his life time... It's about realising that ultimate reality and after realising that ultimate reality one is free from sorrow, happiness and all such sensory things..
So there are 3 different realisations of God.
1) Those who realise Him as the Supreme Brahman attain sayujya mukti which is the lowest of the 5 types of muktis, which is uniting with the Brahman.
This state is just the absence of material sufferings.
2) Those who realise Him as Paramatma, they attain a state called nirvan by the process of hath yog.
They basically purify the soul within the heart from the 5 kinds of life air, thus realising the Paramatma feature of the Lord in their hearts.
Nirvan is also just the absence of material sufferings like Brahman realisation.
3) Those who realise Him as Bhagvan, engage in devotional service or bhakti yog. Bhakti means engaging the senses in the service of the master of senses ( who in Sanskrit is known as Hrishikesh, ie Bhagvan).
The highest stage of Bhakti is called Prem (pure unalloyed love for God).
A bhakti yogi having attained the stage of Prema, attains the spiritual abode of God (Vaikuntha) after leaving this material body and does not take further birth in the material world.
This state is not only the absence of material sufferings but also the presence of spiritual bliss as the jeev(soul) attains a spiritual body (sat-chit-ananda body) in Vaikuntha and serves the Lord there eternally.
Hare Krishna 🙏
And being Seen as heretic is how atheïsts looked at prophets not as heretics but similar to their standpoint so its not a point to be made..
Rumi.. hallaj.. arabi.. ghazali.. Amir al kader. Etc etc brought more knowledge and clarity for those who's hearts are open to see..
Compared to what my first 30 years of my life was taught by Sunni school of thought and even many other sects..
Thanks to sufism I'm becoming free and finally understand my creator more..
And feel closer to Allah than ever
Assalamualaikum,
Allah SWT keep us safe from inventions, Allah SWT set our feet firmly on the righteous path and help us to walk there upon, mashallah.
Your friend,
Muhammad Fauzan Karim
Inventions in the sense of additions to, subtractions from, and or modifications to what we know as the right actions stated in al Qur'an, the highly authenticated Haddith, and Sunnah of Nabi Muhammad SAW.
That is what I meant. Hope this helps.
Muhammad Fauzan Karim
@Himanshu Khichar yes he is not
@Himanshu Khichar how so ???
Muslim have transcendent view of God
@Himanshu Khichar no he is not formless , easy
@Himanshu Khichar lol what are you trying to prove ..
We are already brahman. We don't become it. We are already. Tat tvam asi🙏
How can something that is sitting on 7th Heaven can be pervaded everywhere? If Allah is sitting at 7th heaven then how can he be everywhere, and to sit, someone needs body, does Allah has a body? If Allah is everywhere then in which form he is everywhere ? And If Allah has no form than how is he sitting over his throne on 7th Heaven and where is that heaven .. ? Dear sir , please try to ans. Ans my question, thanks..
in the quran.. mentioned that Allah is in his arsy... sitting in his throne... scholars interpret this as governing the throne @ kingdom... Allah is ever present.. He is not like his creation.. mentioned in surah al ikhlas.. space & time are His creations.. they do no limit His presence... & He is not bound by time & space.. when mentioned Allah sees.. hears.. hand etc.. we muslim just accept this as just what was revealed without questioning if Allah sees.. so He has eyes.. how does his eyes look like.. how many eyes He has etc... as if God has eyes.. mouth.. body etc like His creations.. then He is not god.. not worthy to be praised & worship..
@Himanshu Khichar we don’t take sitting on the throne literally.. just take it as what was said as if u take it literally.. contradict with the nature of a creator.. creator doesn’t look like or having the same nature as his creations...
@Himanshu Khichar please .. if u want to insult our prophet muhammad s.a.w... u just shown how ill feelings u hv for muslims.. i hv no time for that.. i hope u hv a gd reflection of urself.. don’t look down on others.. we shd learn to respect one another..
@Himanshu Khichar no.. Allah has no body... he cannot hv the same thing as His creations... He’s the most high & supreme.. nothing like Him..
I am glad you are asking questions. Please keep clarifying your doubts with love and open mind. The creator will guide you.
What I believe is, no matter which religious belief we come from we are all created in exactly the same manner by exactly the same power. There's only one truth and we are all supposed to find it, this in Hinduism is called Moksha. Questioning is good because it opens our mind to find the truth. But the only way we'll be able to find that truth if we question our beliefs too the way we question the beliefs of others. I pray we all find the truth because deep down in our hearts we all know that we are all different parts of the same creation.
In Hinduism, we have different margs or paths. The paths are 1) Jnana Marg (the path of knowledge) 2) Bhakthi Marg (the path of devotion) 3) Karma Marg (the path of action)
The merging with Brahman through knowledge is path 1.
Islam belongs to the category (2) where one sees God as seperate and oneself as a servant or devotee of God. This is similar to the pathway that the Hare Krishna sect take.
Note: When I say (1) or (2) i don't mean to impose a hierarchy to say 1 is better than 2. All paths are equal and some are suitable for different people.
All the Creation is just the manifestations of Brahman, yet Brahman is beyond the Creation. The individual souls go through innumerable lives and deaths in order to attain Moksha which is merging back into the ultimate reality that is Brahman. Shivoham Shivoham 🙏
There is absolutely no difference between athman and Brahman. It is the reason why Sri Krishna said the following verse in Bhagavad Gita Chapter 2 Verse 12 (ATHMAN = BRAHMAN)
“na tv evāhaṁ jātu nāsaṁ na tvaṁ neme janādhipāḥ na caiva na bhaviṣyāmaḥ sarve vayam ataḥ param”
“Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings, and from this time forward, none of us will ever cease to be”
Here, Sri Krishna refers to the conscious, immortal, immutable, self luminous, immanent (athma), transcendent and omnipresent Brahman as 'I", ''you ``,''us ``.
Jiva means false identification with thoughts and body due to avidya (ignorance) and it has nothing to do with Athma which is beyond space and time.
That ain't true
@@islamaboyy588 it's our Truth which, of course, you have to deny.
@@anmoltiwari5314 we don't go though a bunch of lives....we have this one then we die and will be brought back to life to go to paradise or hellfire...and that's it
Brahman is not god either as god does something god creates the world but for brahman there is no world
Brahman is not God
Brahman is Absolute Reality
Saguna Brahman is qualified aspect of the Brahman
main Hindu deities are pure form of Brahman like shiva, Vishnu Devi etc
Other deities like Purandhar Indra, Brahma dev are presiding deities/positional deities
Mrs. Allah is a Hindu female God
Hehe
Can it be the case that both are actually the same and it's the zombified followers who have mistranslated and misinterpretated the meanings of the verses present in the Qur'an? You can't take everything at face value because a lot of the teachings in religion are meant to be understood allegorically, metaphorically and symbolically.
Waves in ocean :: individual soul universal soul
The drop of water on the surface of the ocean (which is also water ) analogy really means "we are that" - tat tvam asi - we humans are just polluted by material reality
As if God judges a man by his religion.
Allah judges whether you believe in him or not.. eg during Moses.. Moses a.s led the people to believe in Allah.. who follows him consider believe in Allah.. who doesn’t consider not believe.. then Jesus a.s.. who do the same.. who believe follow him vice versa.. then the last prophet messenger Muhammad s.a.w.. who did the same as previous messengers did.. who follow him consider believe in Allah.. vice versa.. & mentioned in the quran.. only islam is accepted by Allah.. islam means total submission to Allah..
@@SonOfCheepThrill yes and there are people who do bad things by submitting will to him.
@@SonOfCheepThrill it doesn't matter which god we worship. What matters to God is how much happiness we give to others.
@@maxtyson9035 people who do bad things & at the same time submitting to Allah.. we call them munafiq.. even during the time of our prophet & before that the munafiq hv existed.. during the time of our prophet s.a.w.. the munafiq was praying 5 times a day at the mosque with our prophet & even goes to war with him.. our prophet s.a.w knew who were they.. this are mentioned in one of the hadith.. so it’s not a surprise or new thing to hv this kind of people.. human do make errors.. Allah did mention in the quran.. He will accept/pardon whoever repent & ask forgiveness from Him no matter how big ur sin is... as He is the most forgiving & merciful.. but remember.. sin towards fellow human being is much worse than to Allah as we human sometimes do not forgive or ask for forgiveness from fellow human beings.. there’s one sin that Allah will not forgive though.. the sin of shirk that there’s another god then Allah.. but if u repent before ur life expires (no one knows when).. u’ll b forgiven.. only Allah knows best..
@@maxtyson9035 it does matter in islam which god u worship.. only Allah.. of cos in the quran mentioned there’s no compulsion in religion.. believing in Him cannot b forced.. if u do find happiness in what u worshipping at.. go ahead.. the door to Allah is always open.. i hope one day ur heart will b guided insya allah my friend.. 🥰
In Hinduism you cannot merge with god during life , it is only after the soul leaves the body can you merge with the eternal ultimate reality , so this answer is incorrectly informed
I am Hindu but i really respect this guy
Yes, they are the same. The speaker did not know that Bhagabat Geetaa by Bhagabaan Krishna says, “All the creations are situated in the Divine Brahmana field. The divine field pervades the universe.”
And Brahma (The omnipotent God) is the source of the Brahmana field. (Like king and it’s kingdom, or sun and it’s rays).
The Brahma (The God), and it’s divine Brahmana Field along with material creation are distinct.
( The English term God is not the correct translation of Allah or Brahmana).
The Brahmana is of neutral property, yet He is the source of all properties. Like sun ray is neutral, though it become rainbow in certain condition.
Man by spiritual exercises/meditation can become free of the body generated property of selfishness (man is born sinner). When one attains this neutral quality (“nirgoon” in Sanskrit), he becomes EQUAL to Brahma, not Brahama (God) Itself. They are of same magical quality (beyond known physics), but differ in property due to magnitude/volume.
To be more clear, The Braahmin religion is based on Four Books of Beda of Indus Valley regions.
And Bhagabat Geetaa is a universal scientific wisdom, that encompasses the common spirit of all the religions.
In fact, by talks of Bhagabat Geetaa, Guru Krishna
(Who says He came in human finite form of the infinite God by his magical power to save good people from the selfish people still carrying the magical power of the god, which was politely challenged by his disciple Arjun, when he transformed into Glaring light containing the different elements of the universe that present scientific discoveries points to be correct)
walks away His disciple Arjuna, a faithful Beda practitioner, from Beda ritual practice/exercise to the universal knowledge of GENERIC God, instead of culture mixed spirituality, called religions, like pursuing drinkers of different brand of sodas like Coke, Pepsi, Vitamin water etc. to drink pure distilled water (Brahma. Not to confuse with Brahmaa of Trinity).
sks030322.
Can you explain sir
JAI PARSHURAM
That distinct mentioned is the philosophy of Imam As'Shaari. The Mu'tazilites disagree with him. The current mainstrean Sunni have gone astray with Imam As'Shaari 's philosophy. I hope the Muslims reform their understanding. To unite or be in Union with God means to manifest all of God's qualities, the essence of Being. The meaning of Being. That is the goal of life. When one unites with Brahman, he manifests all the names of God. For the ordinary ones, one who walks with Grace, who walks with Mercy, who walks with Love, who walks with Wisdom, one who walks with Forgiveness, etc. For the chosen ones Like Jesus Christ, Like Lord Krishna, Like Siddharta Gautama Buddha.
The story of moses &krishna r more or less same, the baby in basket, 2 mothers,dream to kill babies, there is snake in both stories ,spliting of water, meeting wife while grazing cattle..musa has harun...krishna has arjun
Story of ram, sita, rawan, laxman...is mor or less story of, ibrahim, sara,firawun, lut.....evn the names....the time king was unable to touch sara, but may b ppl hav added in that story of ram...god knows best
Story of nuh is mor or less like the story of manu....the flood ,father of human after adam...bcoz from the ppl in the ship,allah gav only nuh (as,) progeny maha(great in sanskrit)+nuh=manu
Asslm alkm mns Allah's peace&
In hindu om shanti means gods peace
Allahu a'lam..god knws bst... Allah swt is wise, he said evry act is rewarded based on the intention
This man is a great wisdom 🙏
In hindu books, there is no judgement day...there is loop 🔁.... There is karma.... Karma is law of universe.... Simple words.. .. Do good, get good.. .. Do bad, get bad.... And also "rebirth "
books❌
Shastra✔️
Don't Compare Your Pimp Dallah
With My Mighty God Brahma
✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
Interesting question from a 13 years old. Brahma, Krishna and Siva are the Hindu 'Trimuti'. Whilst Buddhism comes from Hinduism and Lord Buddha gives guidance in a non-God environment, Judaism starts in Asia Minor thus we have Jehovah (God) and later we had his incarnation as Jesus. Jesus as a young teenager questions and argues in a Jewish temple with elders. His full story is in the Gospels. Prophet Mohammed comes about 500 years after Jesus to confirm the Bible (Jewish heritage) incl Gospels (Christian heritage). God bless our young teenager and guide him to learn everything properly.
Buddhism is not a religion it's just a philosophy which Buddha came up with!
Humility and oneness are not mutually exclusive. Humility in perceived divinity comes from the belief and doctrine that ALL are equal. There is no imposition here, of one soul above the rest.
In Hinduism soul will not merge to Brahman...that one Brahman is manifesting in the form of everything...
Dr Ally saw Cogito's video ahead of time. Good research.
What if i say God is distinctive and indistinctive from the creation at the same time. Its all about perspective nothing else. Becoming one with God or maintaining individuality while serving God entirely upto devotee. God doesn't force anyone. He only guides.
God or Parabramha or Allah all are same. Because the creator does not have any names he only has titles based on his attributes.
That ultimate divinity revealed itself in various ways based on language,culture,tradition of the region.
"God or Parabramha or Allah all are same" Sorry not true. Kindly understand the difference between monotheism (followed by all the 3 Abrahamic religions) and hindu/Vedic metaphysics Sankhya (around which the whole hindu tradition was built including yoga and tantra).
Monotheism says that there is just a transcendent god up there in the sky who is totally disconnected from the universe after creating it out of thin air using a magic wand.😊😊
But the well validated Sankhya Vedic metaphysics. So, what is Sankhya vedic metaphysics? It says that without the conscious, immortal, immutable, immanent (soul), transcendent and omnipresent divine, nothing can exist or nothing can be perceived in its current form or no duality cycles can happen eg Birth/decay, wave/particle, energy/matter, creation/destruction, manifestation/concealment. freezing/melting, man/woman, wake/sleep, summer/winter, day/night etc Sankhya Vedic metaphysics can be validated by logic, double slit quantum experiment and embodied experience (direct knowledge through focus + meditation)
it also means TAT TVAM ASI meaning - You (conscious and immanent athma) are (already) that (conscious, transcendent and omnipresent divine) regardless of whether you realize it or not because without the conscious, immanent and omnipresent athma nothing can exist. Identification with thoughts and body is just an illusion due to the experience of 5 senses and it is not the doer. Conscious athma is like a silk thread through different pearls (animate and inanimate) if you want to look at it in the form of an analogy.
Point is you can't equate the non translated Sanskrit words like Athman/Paramathman, karma, swarga and naraga with the heavily Christianized English words like god, sin, heaven/hell etc.
@@Dharmicaction i am impressed with your knowledge on vedic meta physics. Abrahamic religions are based loosely on bhaktiyoga and dualism to some extent. Even in hinduism there are people specially vaishnavas who refute non duality theory of creation. But after reading some books,articles and watching videos i come to conclusion that all of those theories are incomplete without each other. For example to merge with infinite consciousness of bliss what we call parabramhan we need faith and devotion towards parabramhan but parabramhan is incomprehensible for small minds like us so we focus on sagun paramatma Christians call it God, we call it paramatma or ishwar,muslims call it allah or jews call it yahweh. Somewhere i red that "our path should be dwaita and goal should be adwaita".
Have you heard of achintya beda-abheda siddhant or the "inconceivable simultaneous oneness and difference" philosophy?
Vacuum bears all things .
Vacuum is all things
The vacuum in a pot and the vacuum outside the pot are the same.
it seems as to be separate
Brama (vacum ) Abrama (Matter) are same
Abrama=Abraham
Brahman and Allah are not same. Brahman is not a being who can talk, be angry,laugh,have emotions,sending someone. Brahman is independent not like allah sending prophets. Brahman is within everybody, brahman is not be worshipped he is within every body. Even the Gods Like Shiva,Vishnu,Brahma are his forms. And forms take avaters to save his children(Humans) on earth. Allah symbols are more like Shiva and Sadashiv is also formless so Allah could be relate to Shiva but not Brahman.