He mentioned the story of Sheikh Hamza Yusuf with the bedouins. I thought they are colleagues in Zaytuna. But I am amused by knowing Sheikh Hamza Yusuf is his teacher. May Allah bless you both. 🤲
Sh. Hamza is more inclined towards Sufism while Dr. Ali Ataie does not associate himself with any sort of mysticism but Islam just as myself.. Nonetheless I have great respect for both great Scholars. It’s like me liking Allama Ibn Ajrum for his contribution to Arabic language while he was known for great Sufi mystic nothing more.
Hinduism make it make sense 🤷♀️ Are you still struggling to figure it out after the lecture? You are not alone. Pick up Quran and read it instead...it will change your life.
please explain how you reconcile concept of qada and qadr with free will. or perhaps fiqh ruling differences in different madhabs. all religons have their complexities. islam is not as simple as you like to preach.
@@treehigh5156 everything is already written. Example: someone tells you that everything is written so you decided to do something unpredictable like intentionally skipping a breath, it was your free win and decision, but it’s already been written that you will do that because God is all knowing.
@@ringgame if allah is all knowing and has created everything nothing i do is unpredictable from his point of view nor is it unknown to him. he knows what i will choose before i am born unless he does not know the future. so if i choose to kill someone, it was his will because he knew i would make that choice before i make it.
I thought the gunas were representative of energetic states of matter. Rajas = action/energy. Tamas = rest/lack of energy. Sattva = balance between the other two. That we all have these gunas within us.
Late to the party, do you think Hinduism is somewhat similar to Christianity in their concept of God's divinity incarnated into human(s) though Hindus do not say Vishu, Krishna were humans?
Vast because it includes 4 era (yug) 1. Eternal (always exist) Supreme God and his demigods (bev-devi). 2.Rama era (stya-treta yug) ramayana. 3.Krishna (Dwapar yug). Mahbharat/gita. 4. From 3200 b.c.Kali yug which includes Buddha too. That's why its vast. Its difficult to study whole 4 yuga all scriptures.
Not Brahmin but brahman,and universe is called brahmand, and Brahmin is just those who can reach a phase were his goal is just one not diverted, for example a later part of ur life where u reach a pos u need not think of lot of thing just focus on one thing, so u become brahmin
Panentheism and sometimes pantheism , creator is same as created . The mystic experience is merely a training , it blurs the boundaries between self and non-self. An illusion based on parietal lobe state. Sufism etc are such religions. Distinct from Prophetic revelation and real knowledge of reality .
Sufism is conform to orthodox sunni islam, it is merely a branch of knowledge of sunni islam that focuses on good behaviour and good intentions. It has nothing to do with pantheism, hinduism, buddhism or anything else besides strict sunni islam. The fact that they are marginal pseudo-sufi groups with unorthodox beliefs or practices does not change that fact. Only ignorance condemns sufism as non-islamic.
Hinduism or Vedanta philosophy is materialistic philosophy that worships five elements of nature and believes in the transmigration of souls within the realm of this material world and sometimes to the celestial abodes of the anthromorphic dieties and to different planets
Tell a single lie he said.........Also the teaching of Abrahamic people can be reflected from everything they have given this world....... Surely we don't understand philosophy of piss drinking, pedophilia, step relations, dowry, casteism, Gods lusting on women, warlord Gods etc.
@@robertsmith8629 He is probably a bakht, they are just always irritated with everybody. Their time is coming, they are going to stir stuff, and what will follow is going to be repeat of history.
@@rizwanmuhammad6468 its wider in the sense that it has more complex set of philosophies. Remember that hinduism directly bases in pluralism, which has allowed tje coexistence of islam judausm n christianity in history.
The pronunciation of Sanskrit terms in this lecture is off (long and short vowels confused; aspirated consonants not aspirated; dental letters pronounced like palatal ones). It makes it hard to listen to (if you speak any South Asian language).
You said Aldous Huxley believed in HCF, as all religions have including Abrahmical. It is wrong. When Vedanta developed, there was no Christianity or ISLAM. Sanatan believes those who believe in Brahmana as the supreme entity have HCF. Islam is Islam Sanatan is Sanatan, we are not interested in creating Din-e-Elahi that a common for the whole world. Either one is a follower of Sanatan dharma or NOT.
Huh? Have you read your own Scriptures, like the Bhagavad-Gita? It clearly talks about Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva. Are they not considered Gods in your texts?
The only cruelty human can experience in this world is from another human! So, humanity is the cruelty! The fact that you're saying the other religion is cruel, is a proof that you're human who is cruel to himself / herself! Why are you kind and the other is cruel, other than the baseless lies you're propagating? It's clear that you couldn't question yourself, only others! So, who do you question as a Hindu? Or what do you aim to self-realise, self-hatred!
@ÒγÓ REGIMÈ yes there are wars in Hinduism, but it was war between hindus n not between hindus n non hinduism. Mahabharatha war is a war with the intent of establishinh dharma, or righteousness. Its a war between who is the rightful owner of the land.
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 shaiva vaishnava wars, brutal supression and demonisation of lower castes,and persecution of Buddhists in south india etc the list goes on it was bloody
اَللهُمَّ صَلِّ عَلَى سَيِّدِنَا مُحَمَّد وَعَلَى آلِ سَيِّدِنَا مُحَمَّد۞
صل الله عليه و سلم و علی اله و صحبه و سلم تسليما
Concise and scholarly presentation. Thanks Dr. Ataie
He mentioned the story of Sheikh Hamza Yusuf with the bedouins. I thought they are colleagues in Zaytuna. But I am amused by knowing Sheikh Hamza Yusuf is his teacher. May Allah bless you both. 🤲
Sh. Hamza is more inclined towards Sufism while Dr. Ali Ataie does not associate himself with any sort of mysticism but Islam just as myself.. Nonetheless I have great respect for both great Scholars. It’s like me liking Allama Ibn Ajrum for his contribution to Arabic language while he was known for great Sufi mystic nothing more.
Hinduism make it make sense 🤷♀️ Are you still struggling to figure it out after the lecture? You are not alone. Pick up Quran and read it instead...it will change your life.
please explain how you reconcile concept of qada and qadr with free will. or perhaps fiqh ruling differences in different madhabs. all religons have their complexities. islam is not as simple as you like to preach.
it is and it is very simple, easy and practical too unless you want to confuse yourself by mixing some foreign ideas and tangle in it.
@@treehigh5156 everything is already written. Example: someone tells you that everything is written so you decided to do something unpredictable like intentionally skipping a breath, it was your free win and decision, but it’s already been written that you will do that because God is all knowing.
Hinduism is just a bad joke.
@@ringgame if allah is all knowing and has created everything nothing i do is unpredictable from his point of view nor is it unknown to him. he knows what i will choose before i am born unless he does not know the future. so if i choose to kill someone, it was his will because he knew i would make that choice before i make it.
Good to know. Thank uou
Bailey showed up to the Race with a 'Militant' Mean Streak.Losing was never an option for him
I thought the gunas were representative of energetic states of matter. Rajas = action/energy. Tamas = rest/lack of energy. Sattva = balance between the other two. That we all have these gunas within us.
Great...
This is a such a complex and confusing theology to grabs
Great lecture dr.Ali
Late to the party, do you think Hinduism is somewhat similar to Christianity in their concept of God's divinity incarnated into human(s) though Hindus do not say Vishu, Krishna were humans?
Vast because it includes 4 era (yug)
1. Eternal (always exist) Supreme God and his demigods (bev-devi).
2.Rama era (stya-treta yug) ramayana.
3.Krishna (Dwapar yug). Mahbharat/gita.
4. From 3200 b.c.Kali yug which includes Buddha too. That's why its vast. Its difficult to study whole 4 yuga all scriptures.
I think
Aatmaa=soul
Sach= reality
Not Brahmin but brahman,and universe is called brahmand, and Brahmin is just those who can reach a phase were his goal is just one not diverted, for example a later part of ur life where u reach a pos u need not think of lot of thing just focus on one thing, so u become brahmin
i think u should debate with christian missioneries live on social media ....
Why
The main difference is mukti, moskha, which is the ultimate goal unlike heaven in Abrahimic religion.
It is quite different from all other religions.
Sanatana can mean ancient as well
sanatan means eternal . which always exist.
@@ishaanrohmetra3447say a hindu who have 0% Knowledge about vedas and upadesh
Panentheism and sometimes pantheism , creator is same as created . The mystic experience is merely a training , it blurs the boundaries between self and non-self. An illusion based on parietal lobe state. Sufism etc are such religions. Distinct from Prophetic revelation and real knowledge of reality .
Sufism is conform to orthodox sunni islam, it is merely a branch of knowledge of sunni islam that focuses on good behaviour and good intentions. It has nothing to do with pantheism, hinduism, buddhism or anything else besides strict sunni islam. The fact that they are marginal pseudo-sufi groups with unorthodox beliefs or practices does not change that fact. Only ignorance condemns sufism as non-islamic.
@@karimb972precisely
This a confusing religion.
Not precisely. It is diverse, but it all connects logically.
Not only confusing but also overly theoritical on higher levels and zero by reaching to the ground.
Hinduism is just a bad joke.
It's better than pagananity that's for sure. At least Hinduism doesn't try to make s bunch of God's into 1. Christianity is cognitive dissonance
@@aft7837this is what we expect from Muslims 😂
Sanatan means truth
@@khokhonbabu5780 says quiet a lot about your character.
@@hamdimohammedtaha haha
Hinduism or Vedanta
philosophy is
materialistic philosophy
that worships five
elements of nature
and believes in the
transmigration of souls
within the realm of this
material world and
sometimes to the
celestial abodes of the
anthromorphic dieties
and to different planets
Hinduism is so difficult to understand.
Which is not a good thing
Highly misrepresenting, Abrahmic people don't have such level of intellect to understand philosphy of Dharmic Religions.
Please explain it for us.
Tell a single lie he said.........Also the teaching of Abrahamic people can be reflected from everything they have given this world....... Surely we don't understand philosophy of piss drinking, pedophilia, step relations, dowry, casteism, Gods lusting on women, warlord Gods etc.
He's always trying to find similarities with Abrahamic religions and then says they aren't the same. Hinduism is quite wider than Abrahamic religions.
Wider in what ?
It quest fir truth. Not wider. And wider in what sense. Seems quite limited in fact.
@@robertsmith8629 He is probably a bakht, they are just always irritated with everybody. Their time is coming, they are going to stir stuff, and what will follow is going to be repeat of history.
Too diverse to fathom
@@rizwanmuhammad6468 its wider in the sense that it has more complex set of philosophies. Remember that hinduism directly bases in pluralism, which has allowed tje coexistence of islam judausm n christianity in history.
The pronunciation of Sanskrit terms in this lecture is off (long and short vowels confused; aspirated consonants not aspirated; dental letters pronounced like palatal ones). It makes it hard to listen to (if you speak any South Asian language).
Well he isnt a sanskrit or hindi speaker but he did well for someone who is not used to it.
You said Aldous Huxley believed in HCF, as all religions have including Abrahmical. It is wrong. When Vedanta developed, there was no Christianity or ISLAM. Sanatan believes those who believe in Brahmana as the supreme entity have HCF. Islam is Islam Sanatan is Sanatan, we are not interested in creating Din-e-Elahi that a common for the whole world. Either one is a follower of Sanatan dharma or NOT.
In nutshell u said all wrong, we have no concept of God, we have philosophy of advait Vedanta like Buddhism
So why you worship god in temple ? 🤔
Huh? Have you read your own Scriptures, like the Bhagavad-Gita? It clearly talks about Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva. Are they not considered Gods in your texts?
Bro what
😂😂
Their goal is not god,only and anly goal is self realisation,ibrahamic believers history is cruel they says my way or no way,
Not exactly, all abrahamic traditions preach kindness and acceptance. But within laws
The only cruelty human can experience in this world is from another human! So, humanity is the cruelty!
The fact that you're saying the other religion is cruel, is a proof that you're human who is cruel to himself / herself!
Why are you kind and the other is cruel, other than the baseless lies you're propagating?
It's clear that you couldn't question yourself, only others! So, who do you question as a Hindu? Or what do you aim to self-realise, self-hatred!
@ÒγÓ REGIMÈ yes there are wars in Hinduism, but it was war between hindus n not between hindus n non hinduism. Mahabharatha war is a war with the intent of establishinh dharma, or righteousness. Its a war between who is the rightful owner of the land.
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 shaiva vaishnava wars, brutal supression and demonisation of lower castes,and persecution of Buddhists in south india etc the list goes on it was bloody
Huh? Have you read the Bhagavad-Gita? It is a pretty Bloody Poem that describes the Gods in your Religion.