Real vs Fake Arduino Test
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ม.ค. 2015
- Real vs Fake Arduino Test
It's possible - there are a lot of fakes out there. Maybe you bought a counterfeit Arduino. Was it priced lower that normal? Is it missing the small details that make it a genuine Arduino board? Watch the video to find out if your Arduino is real or fake. If you don't know where to buy a genuine Arduino, you can get one from the Arduino shop at www.arduino.cc/
Check out the Circuit Basics blog for articles and tutorials on the Raspberry Pi, Arduino and other DIY electronic projects! www.circuitbasics.com
Facebook: / circuitbasic
Twitter: / circuitbasics
Instagram: / circuitbasics - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[UNCUT]"เศรษฐา" โดนบีบให้ลาออก เผยดีลลับ "ทักษิณ" ต้องต่อโปร ไม่งั้นเจอจุดจบ! I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XlH3k81dxmE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Genshin Impact | กาชา Clorinde ไวฟุนั้น ควร C6 [เทสตัวละครต่อ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SOVaBvL7K20/mqdefault.jpg)
I saw "test" in the title and got excited that someone was actually going to test the counterfit vs the fake for once... Oh well, time to move on.
All those people, who are writing that the board on the left is not a fake but just an unofficial version, are wrong. The board on the left uses the same logo as the original, which is not allowed by Arduino's licence. If the fake board was called "SHITduino" or something else, then it would fine. But using Arduino's logo by other companies isn't allowed.
I would buy the shitduino.
It also says made in italy, which is not only fraud by itself but also proves undoubtedly that they want the customer to think that it's an original one made by arduino (as opposed to calling it arduino r3 just because it's a microcontroller using the same design as the original one that everyone knows, which would still be a crime (trademark and shit), just less severe)
The problem with these Chinese boards is that sometimes they will get away with it and make you think your buying an original
@@erimemrebaran1206 i would buy the shitduino mega
sooo where is the test ???
I would not call this "a test"!!!
You forgot to mention the main chip. Real ones appear to have the better quality ATMEGA32, that other one was not branded.
no actual testing... waste of time
I assume no-one cares as long as they're both working like they should.
That's what should have been tested (as the title of the video implies).
@Love made in Japan Mine is just like the one on the left. The fake one. It has the 16U2 on it. Works great. A lot of my other fakes have the CH340 on them. Great for Linux (Supported out of the box ). Needs a driver installed for windows. But the CH34X works fine. It's just another serial interface. They work fine. Have you had problems with the CH340?
Disappointing - I was expecting a test. All this was was an advertisement for Arduinos from Arduino.
In which part of this video do you carry out the test? Sorry but I cannot find it.
I have quite a few fake/counterfeit and clones and have had no issues with them so far.
Where was the test of them? Are there any performance issues with fakes or clones?
Hmm, was expecting a real test, not a sales promotion. #fail
where is the test ha where did it go we want an test with circuit
The Arduino you are comparing is an older style counterfeit. It looks just like my Genuine R3 from ~2012.
But they both work right?..i am new into this stuff..and i just bought a fake ..mine is the dotten uno.. will it work fine tho??
A ton of the fake arduino's or even legal open source replicas, are either completely missing the polyfuse, or have a wrong one.
it is much difficult to spot fake one
since it is open source hardware
but I suggest to buy it from its official website
question, do they both use the same atmega328p chip? or one is also remanufactured?
There exists no "fake" or "original" arduino boards.
Everyone is able the produce these boards as they are open platform.
You can even download the pcb designs and produce one arduino board yourself.
As long as there is no technical/compatibility problem there is no issue.
Until now I have bought some "original" boards and some "fake" boards and they all work 100% as it should be.
It does not matter if it is fake or not as long as it works perfectly well. You're just being genius.
Is it a different software for the unoficial then ??
Although fake ones have 16MHz clock. But it still cannot take input of delay of 10s of microseconds. But originals do a lot better.
THANK YOU for letting us know how to tell original from counterfeit. THANK YOU 🙏
When the design is published as open-source, even down to the PC board files, and people encouraged to make them, how can any of them be called "fake?"
Even the Arduino community was, until recently, divided into two camps, both claiming to be the legitimate provider.
I've bought genuine Arduino boards and supported the designers, and yeah, some of the cheapest clones are crap too, but there are very good quality ones available in the middle and there is no reason to not take advantage of them.
There is no fake or real arduino because it's an open hardware.
The hardware is open source, but the name 'Arduino' is not. Only an official Arduino may use that name, therefore the board in the video is counterfeit.
+unicyclematt mine is a perfect CHEAP Copy that does not use the name 'Arduino' - it is totally unbranded; May I now use it with a clear conscience?
So, I purchased a 4 dollar counterfeit board. ( knew this beforehand) So I could have a board that I wouldn't really mind frying or messing up. Does it work just fine, or is it gonna not work? It hasn't come in yet and I was just wondering.
It should be fine, I have few as well and they work just like the genuine Arduino
No, After 1 circuit it broke so NEVER GET COUNTERFIT urg
so what are the pro's and con's apart from components? One can get a PCB and solder the components themselves, but if it works out the same. One could play with the "copy/clone" and finalized on a the genuine article. I don't disagree with supporting Arduino at all, but it is open sourced.
The people that make the fake boards (not clones, clones are perfectly fine), are leeches, and are charging unknowing people into paying a premium for what at first appears to be real. But it's not. Real boards obviously are usually of the highest quality, and obviously, money made from them goes back to the company. But these fake boards cost more, and don't give that premium back to the organization. Everybody loses - you get a shoddily made, sub par product, Arduino doesn't get their cut when somebody intends to buy original brand. The people that manufacture the fakes are scum and exploit the open nature of the board for simple monetary gain, with no regard for where the designs come from.
... and it doesnt matter. I've been using cheap clones and there's nothing wrong with them.
It was just a mere visual comparison, not a test.
i got that exact clone one what to do its ide is not showing its port man plz help me ;"(
I have two Arduino I thought both were originals but there is one fake
When Radio Shack came out with the PC Clones, the fact that they were not genuine PCs didn't matter, because they where better than original IBM PCs. The same is to do a real test to see if the functionality is the same. If it is, I don't care, it does the job, and we save money. Who cares about esthetics?
okay so if they work the same then the "unofficial" works for me then. all i want to know if they work the same
Did he just say he spent $14 on a counterfeit ? Those things are worth $4 at best.
you mean genuine and not genuine, well tell you something, according to your video all my boards are not genuine. LOl..... from Iraq, I wanted to say thank you for this valuable tutorial. I liked and subscribed
This is no fake. There are other manufacturers that make Arduino pleasures. The microcontroller is important.
i ahve a mix of two
well sell open source board is ok but using another company logo without there permission is not ok. That basicly is the point of this video.
hey, what can you tell me about the "Infiduino"? is it fake? thanks in advance
they have a different name. they are not faking they just took the source from original which is an open source.they used at the end "duino" just to make them a family member from the original arduino
HeRoXLeGenD1 sweet
I suppose the correct distinction is "clone" as the board is as functional as the genuine Arduino. To say that it's fake the board has to be missing some essential functionality, the intrinsic value of the board (the raw materials and components) is no more or less than the clone version, so it's safe to say that if you want to buy just for the sake of functionality then the clone version is your inexpensive choice. But, of course since it's open-source the developers deserve some support to help them improve their existing products and create something new and unique.
True, I came by a counterfeit UNO that looks and performs exactly like a genuine one, with 40% of the price. all the components were in place and soldered very well.. no problems at all..
Arduino itself is a copy of the Wiring project. so there's no point of buying genuines in the first place.
Al-Moutasm Bellah Rajab Part of what you pay for the Arduino goes to the development which helps improve the support of various libraries meant for the Arduino environment, because it's open-source, they cannot license to anyone which is a source of income. In a way, by buying the genuine boards you are helping Arduino remain open-source and free to use for anyone. I use my genuine board for research and development, I buy clones for the purpose of permanently embedding them onto a specialized build, as I do not like to spend my time and energy building an actual prototype with the exemption of commercial purposes.
Well I think it is counterfeit because it ckaims to be a genuine Arduino board but it is not. It is only a Arduino compatible board. You can buy compatible board in the far east, where it is never writen Arduino or made in Italy, and on which the build quality is far better than the example of the video, almost as good as a genuine Arduino.
Only if it said f...duino I would happily but I will never buy a fake.
The original one has "Made in Italy" printed on it.
Well, I have a fake Arduino Mega 2560 (it isn't a clone but a fake) and it says "Made in Italy"
this fake ass Arduino Uno of mine can't even detect RFID Module, so I'm forced to use a simulation for my next project 🤦♂️
Your information is not original 😒😑
Comparing, not testing.
Does they work same
Most probably
Mine's fake sigh ...
same here :p
Comparing appearance? So you teach people circuits? For real? Comparing appearance?
What a complete waste of time !
Real vs fake it dosen't matter both works same. both have same microcontroller company atmel which don't have real or fake. But wise choice is if you buy fake one you will save some money
not always true... there are many boards of varying quality, some will die quickly due to inccorectly sized capacitor / poor component quality. There are some good 3rd party boards available but they all have their own names and branding... this particular board is made to be a counterfeit of a genuine board, these are usually ones to stay away from as they are made to maximise profit and don't care about customer.. many of the good 3rd party board makers are proud to put their own name on them, i.e ruggedino etc.
both are different versions of arduino
Arduino is open source.So how could this be countefit ?
Well cloning is fine, but they never say Arduino & Made in Italy tag. It would just say UNO, Mega 2560 etc. and not claim to be have Arduino labels or mimic the original labels. They fake ones try to say it's original and people might get confused at times. Well they work fine, but just make sure people don't get scammed into paying a higher price for a fake thinking they are getting a genuine one.
Yes Baby, I have the clone one ,Fortunetly it only cost Rp120.000 or $11 USD
ooo fellow indonesian.. i saw one for rp 105.000 and one for Rp 95 000
where did you find that ?
+Choco Bit bukalapak...
Tüpfelschisser am Werk.
Both of your boards are fake
Are you talking in your socks?
There is no fake. Fake does not exist in the world of open source. Only closed source does.
You should change the title to OFFICIAL vs UNOFFICIAL. The board on the right side is officially designed and distributed by ARDUINO itself. That doesn't mean anyone can't copy the design and sell it for profit. ARDUINO won't sue u. That's the beauty of Open Source Hardware (OSH).
"Build It, Hack It and Share It" - Massimo Banzi
+MOHD FADLY The hardware is open source of course, but not the name neither the logo which are trademark ( www.arduino.cc/en/Trademark/HomePage ). The fake Arduinos uses these without permission, and Arduino team fights counterfeits according to this page : www.arduino.cc/en/Products/Counterfeit
+MOHD FADLY please u r dumbing down the IQ of all the open source community.
+MOHD FADLY
Correct, but when you make one from the arduino source, you can't call it an Arduino, due to its registered trademarks.
Most replica builders does infact call them something else, and then it's ok..
The problem is the ones that use the same name, and claim to be officials.
+MOHD FADLY thank you, it's a good point you make, and whereas in this video the replica board does use the Trademark Name 'Arduino' (which so many here are making an issue of) mine in fact does not; And yes it is a jolly good copy and perfectly functioning CHEAP 'Unofficial' Board.
Wrong. They are using the trademarked name illegally.
Arduino is Open source. It cant possibly be a "fake"
Hi Addi, "Arduino" is a company/brand much like you might say Nike. The platform and it's IDE are opensource. You just can't put there logo on your board. Much like making sneakers is legal. You can have the same design and materials like "nike" you can't brand it as Nike.
when talking about "Arduino" I meant the UNO board, sorry for your apparent confusion
I think that Arduino UNO (and/or Arduino UNO R3) is trademarked
Golden 501k on both.... no fake in this video..... they are both genuine
who gives a crap, its the exact same hardware and performance. Why would you even buy an genuine uno for 30$ when you can get it from eBay for 4$ ?!
haha... we are the same although buying the original is better, for a starter buying the counterfeit is enough
less than 2 dollars now lol
Joe Blow they give nothing to the community of makers? Well what they do give us is a cheap board that allows people who can't afford an expensive board to become a maker. Sure buying an official arduino board is cool but the price is not. Last I check its 30 dollars. Which is a lot. And idk if they are a for-profit company but if they are they are definitely milking their board and design while they can. Most makers have multiple boards and most makers are younger individuals who make in order to save money or in order to learn. 30 something dollars is too much for a simple board. It costs less than 5 dollars to manufacture those boards. And software wise I'm sure they sell enough boards in a day to pay the salary of their developers.
hasso0n you support the creators so like that they can improve the hardware
@@mikeonthebox Yes, I totally agree with you.
😳. It almost look identical... 😳.. It will both run on the ide though... 😀... It's arduino China but on a license... 😁.wait, I checked, nope, China doesn't have a license, it's a cloned ripoff... 😄... It will still get the job done, the goal is to flash code on the atmega chip anyways... 😀
BSDK pehle nhi daal sakta tha!!! Teri wajah se meine fake khareed kar apne dosto se original ki cost le li and now I REGRET IT!!! :(
#failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok #failbutok