I love it, IU song and voice made my heart cry and the MV was sooo good, the meaning is so pretty, and love the chemistry of IU and V, I want to see my V in another kdrama or movie
"I forgot about the box" "aahhhh key change!"- Anna, truer words have not been spoken, and i know for a fact no one remembered that silly box The MV is so beautiful and IU's vocals are heavenly
When she put her hand over V's good eye so he couldn't see, that to me was a pure expression of her love for him. He had protected her by trying to stop the inevitable from happening. Their love for each other is self-sacrificing. This MV is amazing and beautiful. IU's voice is beautiful and V, well that young man is so talented! V is amazing in everything he does!
Actually V is one of the most sought after Actor since he made a drama debut in Hwarang. Film outfits and producers are willing to pay with a blank cheque just for V to star in their movie or series. I think V would like to try acting again in one but duty (military enlistment) comes first and of course BTS’ comeback in 2025. It would be phenomenal to put V and IU together in a series and then they would be the one to sing the OST. Such a dream project! 💜💜💜 P.S. I cried! They’re acting, IU’s vocals, the song and the MV makes everything perfect! I want more! Also, I realized again how much I’m missing V and how much I worry about BTS in the military.
The boxes represent all the prejudices and judgements of the society. And when you don't fit in those boxes society will tear you down. Handicap (IU is deaf or mute and Tae and his blue eye), age gap (woman is older than him that represented by her most of the time dragging him). It's not about the end of the world. But it's them against the whole world. They were happy with their love of each other but people where mocking them, judging them. Their happy times at the restaurant and the wedding party. The anonymous face pointing there fingers.
For me the "box" represents what society, the media, the standard that people in general want to transform you into... and by the pile of clothes how many were lost in this process. Today, if IU and V decided to start dating (for example), thousands of "boxes" would appear to try to fit them into their own molds and would go to extremes for this, when for some people love is simply two people who are enough for each other. other.😢😢😢
This mv drained my tears dry. I watched it multiple times and still cried everytime, the scenes are tragic, hitting hard again and again throughout the mv. Along with IU's emotional voice, this is a killer. Masterpiece. IU surpass herself again, this is the best.
The concept I believe was the cube was hunting those with disabilities. Going deep, I believe the cube also represents the criticism and hate people send others. The Magic Camera allowing them to be normal. The world around them is a mess like today in reality, fight all you can to the end, her beautiful voice makes this so sad, LOVE, LOVE, LOVE. Your Analogy was great.
What a lovely reaction. I really loved your attention to detail and your thought process. The song was intricately and exquisitely beautiful… IU’s Vocals gave me goosebumps. And I couldn’t agree more about your comments on the acting and the visuals by both. Tae in all his sweetness, softness and gentleness was the honestly the definition of beauty. There was something so pretty and beautifully vulnerable and delicate about him, that touches the heart. In terms of the meaning… In the Korean press releases of this song used in all the articles earlier today and media… IU said that ‘I want to respect and support everyone who loves and lives in various ways with love rather than hate’ this and the statement before Love Wins was released which talked about people who face prejudices and obstacles in love… Personally make me think that it’s showing that many people in love face stigma’s and obstacles for whatever reason in life for things that they are born with and have no control over. Personally I think when they look through the camera they see the perfect world in which everyone can live without the lense of hate where people don’t see you or judge you for your stigma’s or labels but they see the whole you. Another thing that I find beautiful with the sign language involved is that both IU and Tae have a history of sign language. Tae has communicated in official sign language many times (his birthday is even celebrated by some of deaf community in S.K). I feel the box was representing the hate that tears people down and stripe them of their humanity. Personally I feel there was a wider message in this MV and feel that Tae very specifically chose to appear in this MV because of the message. I’ve lost count of times over the years where he has said he would like to side with the marginalised or the minority in life. From the creation of his drawn characters in numerous content, to his BT21 character, to his fairytale character he chose in the 7th Army Zip content that was killed for being different. This MV for me was very much Art. Fantastic job IU and Tae. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Im not remembering right now but what was Taes fairytale character in the 7th army zip?? Im drawing a blank right now even though i know i have seen it all hahaa
@@g100-w6j Tae chose a character from the Korean fairytale Agijangsu Uteri (the might baby) that he felt represented him or that he identifies with. It’s born different with wings on its back…his parents are afraid people will find out that he is different and they will be stigmatised so they choose to kill him instead (very gruesomely ). In the illustrations of the fairytale as part of the zip content, it’s illustrated with a rainbow too at the beginning of the fairytale. 💜
One of theories is that IU and Tae are an old couple who want to live together forever and the box represents death which inevitable and so they are running away from what is the inevitable 😢at the end death catches up to them but at least they are together when it happens
MV already has 4M views in 5 hours. I love the music and lyrics, the concept of a post apocalyptic world is cool but sad. I think the message is love wins all even after we leave this world, but with IU you never know, this could be the fist part of a larger story, like in You and I and Above time. We need to remember our Fairy doesn't just sings like an angel but, she's also a creative genius. Anyway Love her and thank you guys for all the work and dedication.
I’m cried the first time I watched it.. It's really one of the best MVs I've seen for so long! This song is so beautiful! IU always makes me feel all the emotions through her voice, I love the lyrics and this MV is like a movie. it made me so sad 😭And we have actor Kim Taehyung!! Both did it amazing 🙌🏻 And not gonna lie, the pile of clothing in the MV actually made me think of BTS' Spring Day, the symbolism of the clothing pile in both MVs are not far off from each other. The tragedy, what is happening in the MV and also made me think about IU losing so many love ones in her life 🥺 I really cried Here IU can't hear and Taehyung's one eye can't see. That square seems to extinguish those marginalized people, and that camcorder shows them in a world where they are not discriminated against. 😭 That's just a theory but It's so sad DAMN CUBE YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS. They looked so happy and so cute together 😭💜
in the last scenes, when IU squeezed her hand 3 times. it is means "I Love you". and peoples with black mask is not cheering for them, but pointing ther finger/hands to them, but still love wins all 🎉 there is much detail to breakdown
I can’t go thru this MV without crying 😭 the music, the story, the acting, ugh all soo soooo good! Her voice is like a comforting lullaby while going thru a struggle, like when she covered his good eye, she keeps taking care of everyone 🥺 also yes we need the wedding fit at the concert, heck yes 👏
iu also playing a role about the stigmas, fears, and hopes that come with deafness also made me tear up as it reminded me of her own ear condition-especially the scenes within the camcorder where she can freely sing in an ideal world 🥲 all the details in this mv were so well thought out, both their acting was so good, and the storytelling was very digestible to viewers where it can still leave room for interpretation...wow ♡
I enjoyed your reaction the most out of all. IU has the nicest fans. Your love and appreciation for her touched my heart and the fact that you appreciated Taehyung for how we see him and appreciate him made me 🥰💜. Thank you. You pointed out many things others didn’t catch. IU and Taehyung portrayed these characters so well. You could feel their love and care and innocence. The 5+ min of MV went by in a flash. Their chemistry and care for each other was tops. I could not picture anyone else starting in this with her. Good luck getting concert tickets. 💜Borahae.
Anna I love what you said about each partner taking the lead at different times in this! In the end it was IU protecting Taehyung when she covered his good eye so he wouldn't have to see it when they go. :,(
I was waiting for this! Thank you for uploading so quickly. One theory on the MV, that I've read a lot is that this is set in a dystopia which hunts down disabled people. IU is deaf an V is (part) blind. The box hunts them to eliminate all the diabled people. The world they see through the cameras is how it could have been in this world if they weren't disabled or if they weren't born in such a dystopia. I hope that made sense as english isn't my first language. I just wanted to mention the theory because it makes the MV even more heartbreaking to me. Thank you for helping me with korean (my fourth language)! :)
Good thought, I'll just add, since this is symbolic, it could mean special or different people, Would not be the first time IU refers to why people seem as different get a harsh treatment like Sulli, Gohara we all know the story.
The box is a stop button, and the story that the two people who are hard to hear and hard to see are an elderly couple who are close to death seems to be the best match. I liked the scene of reminiscing about good moments the most..
I'm just copy pasting an explaination I saw under another video: The Cube represents society, it is chasing every individual who doesn't fit the standards of society. Here V is half blind, IU is deaf and mute. So they are running from oppression of society. The world is controled by these standards of perfection to the point that people in South Korea put masks on when they don't have make-up or when they feel unsecure or they wear hats when their hair is messy. The MV is a dystopian view of our society. While they are trying to hide in this abondonned place filled with the clothes of people who died because of this oppression, they find a camera that allows them to have an illusion of what their lives could be if they were "normal" by society's standards, it starts with their looks, they could see how they would have looked like, then what they would eat, then they start to feel the illusion a bit too much to the point they beautifully imagine that IU could sing and V could sing as well and she could listen to his voice, they could marry each other and just have fun and eat whatever they want because they wouldn't have to care about society or any other kind of oppression. However, as soon as they feel a little bit of confort and try to live their life, the Cube (society) finds them again and push them to retreat and flee again, but the Cube managed to find them again, they try to survive against it and try to fight it as hard as they can, but they cannot beat a stronger system, they just give up but at least they stayed together until the end. Even if they died at the end, they loved each other deeply, it shows that even if society is oppressive, people can love each other and they can find their soulmate even if they are not "normal or perfect" to the eyes of some many others. The pile of clothes is like from Spring Day, these people died because of injustice, but they deserved love, so the pile of clothes can look very gloomy and sad, but as in Spring Day MV if you don't forget them you can seem them happy and free where they are right now...
My heart is so full! To be honest, I've been thinking about why I love watching you guys so much and now I know why. The thing is that nobody around me listens to Kpop, not a single person who sees the beauty of it, even if I share I have never been able to talk to people who see the beauty in IU/BTS/Seventeen. Even if I share with my friends and family, they only listen to be considerate. It is so hard to be able to communicate my thoughts on this with anyone. I absolutely love IU, I genuinely think she has changed my life ever since I discovered her. She has inspired me to be better during my slump, given me support when I felt alone and helpless living in a new country. I would always watch reaction videos to find people who lilked the same things as I did. But sadly, most of the reaction channels out there are only making reactions on Kpop to get the views and the subscribers, it is clear that they don't enjoy the music or the performances very much. But then I found you guys, people who were much bigger fans of the artists I loved. People who saw how beautiful their creations were and took the time to appreciate and point out all their effort, even the tinniest details. I want to thank you because your videos make me feel like I am able to talk about my feelings, share the love and join the positive and mature fandom. If ever times are tough for you guys, I hope you don't feel the pressure to create. I know what that feels like, and it sucks. How much ever you are able to give, I'm happy to know that there are others who see what I see, love what I love and that is enough. Ofcourse, I would love if you make more videos, but only if you are not stressing about it. Thank you both! Love from India
I love these "movie-MVs". This with IU voice and acting with V, we got cherrys on top of the cake... and I cried and cry... world is full of "perfect people" whom want to put "different than them" into boxes...
Beautiful story, it was not a just a beautiful song. IU and V are imperfect people according to the world. But through another lens, they see each other as perfect. In the real world, they may not have much, but they love each other and commit to each other by getting married. But the world intrudes on them and gets rid of their love, because their love should not be. It gets rid of them. We see that the world has done that before to others love that was deemed not worthy. Their stories is like other love that has come before theirs, disintegrated because they were perceived as imperfect by the world. The real world is broken.
It reminds me Celebrity.She is willing to chasing different genre of art even it may not be the popular majority in K-pop stream. However it end up the leading creative force of this industry. She is legend.
I really love all the theories that arised for this MV. It was all so interesting to read and they all make sense. I am an avid listener of IU and this is one of her songs that really gave me goosebumps especially that I’m watching the MV. I also love your reaction! I think we did the same reaction when I watched this 1 AM today lol. I was feeling sleepy but my soul WOKE UP after.
I'm amazed that people can basically make an artistic short film for a music video. Fitting all that in just a few minutes is very hard. And I love her voice! They're both brilliant actors :) 9:19 the Spanish: "eterno" = eternal / "junta" = ? doesn't really make sense, joint? / "muerte" = death
This is my first time coming across your channel I really like your reaction you were so into it, I had to subscribe 😂💗 Yes I get you they had all of us SPEECHLESS
Thanks for the great reaction. You are one of the few people that made a lot of sense to me with your interpretation. But I think you that besides the spectacular vocals, music, mv and actors the story so so well done you can find thousands of meanings that fit your view. Amazing times. Hope to get a ticket for the Berlin concert. finger crossed ;-)
The clothes as soon as it popped up, I thought of Spring Day and I knew something bad was going to happen and was happening. Makes me wonder what VHS movies they were throwing against the wall? Love who you love, not just what society, your religion, culture or anyone says!
I hope you guys wanna chat more about this on tomorrow’s livestream! The ARMY in me immediately saw the pile of clothes and the way it was colored as undeniably reminiscent of Spring Day. And the themes aren’t so different between the two videos it seems, though this speaks much more to romantic love compared to BTS’ fraternal love. With Taehyung’s feature, maybe they’re saying the two forms of love really aren’t so different-and that as they’ve now moved on from their youth, it simply manifests in a different way.
In the beginning iu being deaf and v being blind in one eye and running away from the box means they’re trying to escape the box ( society expectations/ criticism/ hate) by turning a blind eye and not listening to the noise. With their love they’re trying to have courage and fight to live on but in the end they disappear with despair but with each other. Just the metaphors and other ppl opinions and representations make this cinematic mv a masterpiece.
“IU can't hear and V’s one eye can't see” “That square seems to extinguish those marginalized people, and that camcorder shows them in a world where they are not discriminated against.”
@@nibhakumari7801 may be but i doubt about it........ I think she was perfectly fine bcz she was the one leading him everywhere and protecting him .... being blind by one eye doesn't create much difference so in my opinion he is both blind by one eye and deaf💜
Personal theory: The camcorder seems to show the characters in happy, healthy states. So my personal theory is that the camcorder represents the afterlife. After the cube destroyed IU and V for being different, their souls were trapped in the camcorder to relive happy memories of the wedding party.
영화 감독,엄태화 감독의 뮤비 해석 가이드 1)추격하는 네모의 존재는 주인공들을 향한 차별이다.우리 일상에서 만연한 각종 차별과 억압을 뜻한다. 2)켐코더의 의미는 렌즈는 곧 사랑의 필터를 뜻하며 세상의 아름다운 것들을 바라볼수 있는 장치로 볼수 있다. 3)아이유는 말하지 못하는 이다. 아이유의 입술 피어싱은 세상과 온전히 소통하기에 어려움이 있다는 의미이다. 4)태형은 윈쪽 눈으로만 세상을 보는이. 디스토피아 세계관 생존기로 보여지는 이 뮤비에는 여러 상징이 존재한다. 두사람이 세상의 난관들을 헤쳐가기에 많은 어려움이 있을것으로.그려지며 그럼에도 이들은 서로를 의지하며 각자 상처를 입고 지친 상황에서도 끝까지 이겨내라고 한다. 5)웨딩드레스 턱시도의 의미는 사랑의 결실을 상징한다. 뮤비에서는 웨딩드레스와 턱시도를 입고서 사진을 찍고 노래를 하며 즐겁게 노는등 일상에서 하기 어려웠던 일들을 함께 하며 잠시나마 행복을 누린다. 6)마지막 켐코더 화면에서 이들은 공중으로 떠오르는 것으로 암시되는데,이는 온갖 억압과 입막음으로 부터 벗어나 자유롭게 날아갈수 있음을 뜻한다. 7)하늘에서 떨어지는 웨딩 드레스와 턱시도는 현실에서, 의미있고 중요하다고 여겨지는 형식들이 과연 참다운 본질을 보여주는가에 대해 질문을 던진다는 의미를 내포한다. 아이유는 원곡 제목인 Love Wins 를 성소수자 인권 증진을 위해 사용해온 문구를 사용했다,라는 논란이 터지자 곡 제목을 바꿨다.Love Wins All 누구도 상처되지 않고 곡의 의미가 전달 되기를 바란다며 뜻을 전했다.팬들에게는 사랑하기를 방해하는 세상에서 끝까지 사랑하려 애쓰는 이들의 이야기를 담았다.라며 손편지로 앨범의 관한 메시지도 전했다.
Yours are the only reaction videos I choose to watch. I appreciate the low key way you express yourselves, love the bits of information and explanations you provide. Love how you explained what you loved about it. Thanks for the video!
The beauty of this music video is just awesome... And the layers to it Like It can represent anything, A Couple with disbility and how they are being targeted by the box which can represent the society that is trying to eliminate them A celeb couple who are doing their best to be together and be in love, live in love but the media, the people keep on tranishing their dreams until they give up.. Or maybe just a couple who want to live along life together but death is inevitable and they therefore lose on it Or Maybe that they are so in love, that The hurt and pain they are going throigh doesnt measure with the happiness they felt together! Its just crazy!
Uaenas can we email Edam to hire Seana TV to be their translator!? I just thought that they were here the only ones who could give IU's lyrics justice in English 😭😭 please 🙏
11:40 it's not like those people are not significant, they (IU and V) just can't remember their faces anymore, I think. 13:30 THANK YOU for this! Without this channel, I don't think I would ever understand that meaning. I mean, I get the basics of the message, but with this info, it's way more clear now.
Love your reaction videos. Specially the on the photobooth scene. Can you make a reaction to the behind the scene / making of Love Wins All, IU got one and Taehyung have one on BangtanTV. Really looking forward for your reaction.
i watched it first thing in the morning, (glad i don't have classes on a wednesday) otherwise i'd be going to uni with very swollen eyes, THE WAY I BAWLED UNDER THE BLANKET AT 6 AM!?,@(!?!? 😭
I love Sean's interpretation!!! I've been wondering what the box represented and it makes sense now! It ties well with what IU wrote on her note too 😢 9:36 And yes, I believe they're doing official KSL. They put someone in the credits for it ☺
Anna got emotional: eventho the world is ending I am glad I was with you then cut to Anna clinging to Sean.. lol that just made my day.. Jieun and Taehyung acting was so expressive and amazing. In 5 min video we can get the plot and see the emotions potrayed so well it made me cry. The composer of this song is the same composer with Start Up Ost - Day and night by Jung seunghwan which in my opinion is the most heartbreaking ost in my life. The moment I listen to the song instantly I need to know who wrote this. And IU as lyricist is just as poetic as it could be. This song and mv is just perfect. My personal greed would be IU-Woozi-Wonwoo to sit together writing the most peotic lyrics human ever made. But that just me as lyrics enthusiast dream. A person can dream right.. Thank you for the reaction, I missed out the Tae half blind part until you guys point out which makes more sense why IU only convering only one eye at the last scene. Have a great day!!
the way you talk about the box either is a representation of "destiny" and is something that they can try hiding from or run away...but in they end they certainly can't.... you know what came to my mind is the actual situation of celebrities... the amount of eyes looming and watching over them .. i can't put my thoughts into words this is my trying XD
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
Idk if you guys noticed but the way she covers his „functioning“ eye so that he doesn’t have to face their destiny MAKES ME BAWL
THAT was the part that broke me
Taehyung is definitely the prettiest 🥹💜 also i'm still can't get over from IU's voice 🤌 ✨️
Please vote for Tae best idol at shining awards. He deserves that
I love it, IU song and voice made my heart cry and the MV was sooo good, the meaning is so pretty, and love the chemistry of IU and V, I want to see my V in another kdrama or movie
"I forgot about the box" "aahhhh key change!"- Anna, truer words have not been spoken, and i know for a fact no one remembered that silly box
The MV is so beautiful and IU's vocals are heavenly
Its the "did it tho?!" For me
You were the ones who had the truest reaction. You guys really felt the MV and were mesmerized. Congratulations
I love this MV , IU and Tae was amazing with perfect chemistry. The song and IU’s voice is very beautiful 💜💜
When she put her hand over V's good eye so he couldn't see, that to me was a pure expression of her love for him. He had protected her by trying to stop the inevitable from happening. Their love for each other is self-sacrificing. This MV is amazing and beautiful. IU's voice is beautiful and V, well that young man is so talented! V is amazing in everything he does!
태형이 너무 좋아요 모든것이 완벽한 연기였습니다. 태형이의 연기를 볼 수 있어서 너무 행복합니다💚🫡💜
I will dress up as box ..to complete the cosplay please take me to concert 🤣🤣🤣🤣💜🫶🫣😂
HAHAHA OMFG THAT IS SUCH A GOOD IDEA
Actually V is one of the most sought after Actor since he made a drama debut in Hwarang. Film outfits and producers are willing to pay with a blank cheque just for V to star in their movie or series. I think V would like to try acting again in one but duty (military enlistment) comes first and of course BTS’ comeback in 2025. It would be phenomenal to put V and IU together in a series and then they would be the one to sing the OST. Such a dream project! 💜💜💜
P.S.
I cried! They’re acting, IU’s vocals, the song and the MV makes everything perfect! I want more! Also, I realized again how much I’m missing V and how much I worry about BTS in the military.
Best reaction to this mv I’ve seen. New fan of yours! Love this song and mv. And their acting!!!
The boxes represent all the prejudices and judgements of the society. And when you don't fit in those boxes society will tear you down. Handicap (IU is deaf or mute and Tae and his blue eye), age gap (woman is older than him that represented by her most of the time dragging him). It's not about the end of the world. But it's them against the whole world. They were happy with their love of each other but people where mocking them, judging them. Their happy times at the restaurant and the wedding party. The anonymous face pointing there fingers.
So proud of both of them 😭😭😭
For me the "box" represents what society, the media, the standard that people in general want to transform you into... and by the pile of clothes how many were lost in this process. Today, if IU and V decided to start dating (for example), thousands of "boxes" would appear to try to fit them into their own molds and would go to extremes for this, when for some people love is simply two people who are enough for each other. other.😢😢😢
This mv drained my tears dry. I watched it multiple times and still cried everytime, the scenes are tragic, hitting hard again and again throughout the mv. Along with IU's emotional voice, this is a killer. Masterpiece. IU surpass herself again, this is the best.
I loved your explanation of “destiny” that one cannot escape and so they accept it and face it together. Loved your reaction!
The concept I believe was the cube was hunting those with disabilities. Going deep, I believe the cube also represents the criticism and hate people send others. The Magic Camera allowing them to be normal. The world around them is a mess like today in reality, fight all you can to the end, her beautiful voice makes this so sad, LOVE, LOVE, LOVE.
Your Analogy was great.
What a lovely reaction. I really loved your attention to detail and your thought process. The song was intricately and exquisitely beautiful… IU’s Vocals gave me goosebumps. And I couldn’t agree more about your comments on the acting and the visuals by both. Tae in all his sweetness, softness and gentleness was the honestly the definition of beauty. There was something so pretty and beautifully vulnerable and delicate about him, that touches the heart.
In terms of the meaning… In the Korean press releases of this song used in all the articles earlier today and media… IU said that ‘I want to respect and support everyone who loves and lives in various ways with love rather than hate’ this and the statement before Love Wins was released which talked about people who face prejudices and obstacles in love… Personally make me think that it’s showing that many people in love face stigma’s and obstacles for whatever reason in life for things that they are born with and have no control over. Personally I think when they look through the camera they see the perfect world in which everyone can live without the lense of hate where people don’t see you or judge you for your stigma’s or labels but they see the whole you. Another thing that I find beautiful with the sign language involved is that both IU and Tae have a history of sign language. Tae has communicated in official sign language many times (his birthday is even celebrated by some of deaf community in S.K). I feel the box was representing the hate that tears people down and stripe them of their humanity. Personally I feel there was a wider message in this MV and feel that Tae very specifically chose to appear in this MV because of the message. I’ve lost count of times over the years where he has said he would like to side with the marginalised or the minority in life. From the creation of his drawn characters in numerous content, to his BT21 character, to his fairytale character he chose in the 7th Army Zip content that was killed for being different.
This MV for me was very much Art. Fantastic job IU and Tae. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Im not remembering right now but what was Taes fairytale character in the 7th army zip?? Im drawing a blank right now even though i know i have seen it all hahaa
@@g100-w6j Tae chose a character from the Korean fairytale Agijangsu Uteri (the might baby) that he felt represented him or that he identifies with. It’s born different with wings on its back…his parents are afraid people will find out that he is different and they will be stigmatised so they choose to kill him instead (very gruesomely ). In the illustrations of the fairytale as part of the zip content, it’s illustrated with a rainbow too at the beginning of the fairytale. 💜
One of theories is that IU and Tae are an old couple who want to live together forever and the box represents death which inevitable and so they are running away from what is the inevitable 😢at the end death catches up to them but at least they are together when it happens
MV already has 4M views in 5 hours. I love the music and lyrics, the concept of a post apocalyptic world is cool but sad. I think the message is love wins all even after we leave this world, but with IU you never know, this could be the fist part of a larger story, like in You and I and Above time. We need to remember our Fairy doesn't just sings like an angel but, she's also a creative genius. Anyway Love her and thank you guys for all the work and dedication.
I’m cried the first time I watched it.. It's really one of the best MVs I've seen for so long!
This song is so beautiful! IU always makes me feel all the emotions through her voice, I love the lyrics and this MV is like a movie. it made me so sad 😭And we have actor Kim Taehyung!! Both did it amazing 🙌🏻
And not gonna lie, the pile of clothing in the MV actually made me think of BTS' Spring Day, the symbolism of the clothing pile in both MVs are not far off from each other. The tragedy, what is happening in the MV and also made me think about IU losing so many love ones in her life 🥺 I really cried
Here IU can't hear and Taehyung's one eye can't see. That square seems to extinguish those marginalized people, and that camcorder shows them in a world where they are not discriminated against. 😭 That's just a theory but It's so sad
DAMN CUBE YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS. They looked so happy and so cute together 😭💜
I thought exactly the same about Spring Day. 😢
in the last scenes, when IU squeezed her hand 3 times. it is means "I Love you". and peoples with black mask is not cheering for them, but pointing ther finger/hands to them, but still love wins all 🎉 there is much detail to breakdown
Is that how you say I love you in sign language? Cause the ones I saw on the internet are different
@@checkmattee222 it is not sign language, is it just symbolic things
I can’t go thru this MV without crying 😭 the music, the story, the acting, ugh all soo soooo good! Her voice is like a comforting lullaby while going thru a struggle, like when she covered his good eye, she keeps taking care of everyone 🥺 also yes we need the wedding fit at the concert, heck yes 👏
So much crying, that is what True Love looks like!!! 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙💙🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
iu also playing a role about the stigmas, fears, and hopes that come with deafness also made me tear up as it reminded me of her own ear condition-especially the scenes within the camcorder where she can freely sing in an ideal world 🥲
all the details in this mv were so well thought out, both their acting was so good, and the storytelling was very digestible to viewers where it can still leave room for interpretation...wow ♡
I enjoyed your reaction the most out of all. IU has the nicest fans. Your love and appreciation for her touched my heart and the fact that you appreciated Taehyung for how we see him and appreciate him made me 🥰💜. Thank you. You pointed out many things others didn’t catch. IU and Taehyung portrayed these characters so well. You could feel their love and care and innocence. The 5+ min of MV went by in a flash. Their chemistry and care for each other was tops. I could not picture anyone else starting in this with her. Good luck getting concert tickets. 💜Borahae.
Anna I love what you said about each partner taking the lead at different times in this! In the end it was IU protecting Taehyung when she covered his good eye so he wouldn't have to see it when they go. :,(
I was waiting for this! Thank you for uploading so quickly.
One theory on the MV, that I've read a lot is that this is set in a dystopia which hunts down disabled people. IU is deaf an V is (part) blind. The box hunts them to eliminate all the diabled people. The world they see through the cameras is how it could have been in this world if they weren't disabled or if they weren't born in such a dystopia.
I hope that made sense as english isn't my first language. I just wanted to mention the theory because it makes the MV even more heartbreaking to me. Thank you for helping me with korean (my fourth language)! :)
Hi...wow you explained it so well...I'm new to the whole concept and didn't understand the whole box thing... thank you for the explanation ❤
Good thought, I'll just add, since this is symbolic, it could mean special or different people, Would not be the first time IU refers to why people seem as different get a harsh treatment like Sulli, Gohara we all know the story.
deaf*
The box is a stop button, and the story that the two people who are hard to hear and hard to see are an elderly couple who are close to death seems to be the best match. I liked the scene of reminiscing about good moments the most..
I'm just copy pasting an explaination I saw under another video:
The Cube represents society, it is chasing every individual who doesn't fit the standards of society. Here V is half blind, IU is deaf and mute. So they are running from oppression of society. The world is controled by these standards of perfection to the point that people in South Korea put masks on when they don't have make-up or when they feel unsecure or they wear hats when their hair is messy. The MV is a dystopian view of our society. While they are trying to hide in this abondonned place filled with the clothes of people who died because of this oppression, they find a camera that allows them to have an illusion of what their lives could be if they were "normal" by society's standards, it starts with their looks, they could see how they would have looked like, then what they would eat, then they start to feel the illusion a bit too much to the point they beautifully imagine that IU could sing and V could sing as well and she could listen to his voice, they could marry each other and just have fun and eat whatever they want because they wouldn't have to care about society or any other kind of oppression. However, as soon as they feel a little bit of confort and try to live their life, the Cube (society) finds them again and push them to retreat and flee again, but the Cube managed to find them again, they try to survive against it and try to fight it as hard as they can, but they cannot beat a stronger system, they just give up but at least they stayed together until the end. Even if they died at the end, they loved each other deeply, it shows that even if society is oppressive, people can love each other and they can find their soulmate even if they are not "normal or perfect" to the eyes of some many others. The pile of clothes is like from Spring Day, these people died because of injustice, but they deserved love, so the pile of clothes can look very gloomy and sad, but as in Spring Day MV if you don't forget them you can seem them happy and free where they are right now...
My heart is so full! To be honest, I've been thinking about why I love watching you guys so much and now I know why. The thing is that nobody around me listens to Kpop, not a single person who sees the beauty of it, even if I share I have never been able to talk to people who see the beauty in IU/BTS/Seventeen. Even if I share with my friends and family, they only listen to be considerate. It is so hard to be able to communicate my thoughts on this with anyone. I absolutely love IU, I genuinely think she has changed my life ever since I discovered her. She has inspired me to be better during my slump, given me support when I felt alone and helpless living in a new country. I would always watch reaction videos to find people who lilked the same things as I did. But sadly, most of the reaction channels out there are only making reactions on Kpop to get the views and the subscribers, it is clear that they don't enjoy the music or the performances very much. But then I found you guys, people who were much bigger fans of the artists I loved. People who saw how beautiful their creations were and took the time to appreciate and point out all their effort, even the tinniest details. I want to thank you because your videos make me feel like I am able to talk about my feelings, share the love and join the positive and mature fandom.
If ever times are tough for you guys, I hope you don't feel the pressure to create. I know what that feels like, and it sucks. How much ever you are able to give, I'm happy to know that there are others who see what I see, love what I love and that is enough. Ofcourse, I would love if you make more videos, but only if you are not stressing about it. Thank you both! Love from India
Me sinto tão sortuda de conhecer IU, ela uma artista e pessoa incrível, taehyung também atuou muito bem
I love these "movie-MVs". This with IU voice and acting with V, we got cherrys on top of the cake... and I cried and cry... world is full of "perfect people" whom want to put "different than them" into boxes...
Ahh the acting and the IU's vocals 🤌✨♥️😭😭😭😭
Yes thank you taehyung everything the best 👍🏽😘✌🏽💜💕
V is the most in demand actor since hwarang, but he is rejecting all the offers to focus on music for now
But soon we will see actor Tae comeback
Now i understand why IU kept leading V the whole time.. because he's blind one-eyed! I just know after reading the comments wahhh
Beautiful story, it was not a just a beautiful song. IU and V are imperfect people according to the world. But through another lens, they see each other as perfect. In the real world, they may not have much, but they love each other and commit to each other by getting married. But the world intrudes on them and gets rid of their love, because their love should not be. It gets rid of them. We see that the world has done that before to others love that was deemed not worthy. Their stories is like other love that has come before theirs, disintegrated because they were perceived as imperfect by the world. The real world is broken.
I love ur reaction, that"s they are so cute, it"s they are filming a kdrama...
Wow v and iu
I also screamed so much when the wedding scene appeared! lol
The pile of clothes is a reference to Spring Day and an art piece about victims... 💜💜💜
Alwayssss love your reaction to IU music 🥹
lU . V = 유애나로 보니까 더 눈물나는 뮤비🥹 ONLY 팬송은 아니지만, 포함 된다고 얘기 했어서 이 해석이 제일 좋더라구요ෆ
What a phenomenal MV !! 🤯🤯🤯
It reminds me Celebrity.She is willing to chasing different genre of art even it may not be the popular majority in K-pop stream. However it end up the leading creative force of this industry. She is legend.
I really love all the theories that arised for this MV. It was all so interesting to read and they all make sense. I am an avid listener of IU and this is one of her songs that really gave me goosebumps especially that I’m watching the MV.
I also love your reaction! I think we did the same reaction when I watched this 1 AM today lol. I was feeling sleepy but my soul WOKE UP after.
What a wonderful work of art, so emotional.
I'm amazed that people can basically make an artistic short film for a music video. Fitting all that in just a few minutes is very hard. And I love her voice! They're both brilliant actors :)
9:19 the Spanish: "eterno" = eternal / "junta" = ? doesn't really make sense, joint? / "muerte" = death
thank you for the review and the translation to some of the lyrics ❤❤❤
This is my first time coming across your channel I really like your reaction you were so into it, I had to subscribe 😂💗 Yes I get you they had all of us SPEECHLESS
Thanks for the great reaction.
You are one of the few people that made a lot of sense to me with your interpretation.
But I think you that besides the spectacular vocals, music, mv and actors the story so so well done you can find thousands of meanings that fit your view. Amazing times. Hope to get a ticket for the Berlin concert. finger crossed ;-)
This MV is top-tier !!
SEANNA TV thank you for reaction IU and V
여러분 팬을 위한 노래임을 잊지마세요. 아이유와 팬(뷔) 입장으로 해석해보면 또 흥미로운 해석이 나와요 ㅎㅎ
I want them in a drama together also love your reaction
The clothes as soon as it popped up, I thought of Spring Day and I knew something bad was going to happen and was happening. Makes me wonder what VHS movies they were throwing against the wall? Love who you love, not just what society, your religion, culture or anyone says!
I hope you guys wanna chat more about this on tomorrow’s livestream! The ARMY in me immediately saw the pile of clothes and the way it was colored as undeniably reminiscent of Spring Day. And the themes aren’t so different between the two videos it seems, though this speaks much more to romantic love compared to BTS’ fraternal love. With Taehyung’s feature, maybe they’re saying the two forms of love really aren’t so different-and that as they’ve now moved on from their youth, it simply manifests in a different way.
In the beginning iu being deaf and v being blind in one eye and running away from the box means they’re trying to escape the box ( society expectations/ criticism/ hate) by turning a blind eye and not listening to the noise. With their love they’re trying to have courage and fight to live on but in the end they disappear with despair but with each other. Just the metaphors and other ppl opinions and representations make this cinematic mv a masterpiece.
I’m know IU knows some Korean sign language from My Mister. She used it on Hyori’s B&B when they had a deaf guest.
watch again cry again😢
Perfect couple❤❤
“IU can't hear and V’s one eye can't see”
“That square seems to extinguish those marginalized people, and that camcorder shows them in a world where they are not discriminated against.”
I think V is the one who can't hear bcz she talks to him in sign language..... and protects him
@@kanwalabbasi8953IU in this character is mute and deaf
@@nibhakumari7801 may be but i doubt about it........ I think she was perfectly fine bcz she was the one leading him everywhere and protecting him .... being blind by one eye doesn't create much difference so in my opinion he is both blind by one eye and deaf💜
Personal theory: The camcorder seems to show the characters in happy, healthy states. So my personal theory is that the camcorder represents the afterlife. After the cube destroyed IU and V for being different, their souls were trapped in the camcorder to relive happy memories of the wedding party.
@@kanwalabbasi8953 yup ...I have been addicted to this mv and after watching it for so many times I think that too ...
영화 감독,엄태화 감독의 뮤비 해석 가이드
1)추격하는 네모의 존재는 주인공들을 향한 차별이다.우리 일상에서 만연한 각종 차별과 억압을 뜻한다.
2)켐코더의 의미는 렌즈는 곧 사랑의 필터를 뜻하며 세상의 아름다운 것들을 바라볼수 있는 장치로 볼수 있다.
3)아이유는 말하지 못하는 이다. 아이유의 입술 피어싱은 세상과 온전히 소통하기에 어려움이 있다는 의미이다.
4)태형은 윈쪽 눈으로만 세상을 보는이.
디스토피아 세계관 생존기로 보여지는 이 뮤비에는 여러 상징이 존재한다. 두사람이 세상의 난관들을 헤쳐가기에 많은 어려움이 있을것으로.그려지며 그럼에도 이들은 서로를 의지하며 각자 상처를 입고 지친 상황에서도 끝까지 이겨내라고 한다.
5)웨딩드레스 턱시도의 의미는 사랑의 결실을 상징한다. 뮤비에서는 웨딩드레스와 턱시도를 입고서 사진을 찍고 노래를 하며 즐겁게 노는등 일상에서 하기 어려웠던 일들을 함께 하며 잠시나마 행복을 누린다.
6)마지막 켐코더 화면에서 이들은 공중으로 떠오르는 것으로 암시되는데,이는 온갖 억압과 입막음으로 부터 벗어나 자유롭게 날아갈수 있음을 뜻한다.
7)하늘에서 떨어지는 웨딩 드레스와 턱시도는 현실에서, 의미있고 중요하다고 여겨지는 형식들이 과연 참다운 본질을 보여주는가에 대해 질문을 던진다는 의미를 내포한다.
아이유는 원곡 제목인 Love Wins 를 성소수자 인권 증진을 위해 사용해온 문구를 사용했다,라는 논란이 터지자 곡 제목을 바꿨다.Love Wins All 누구도 상처되지 않고 곡의 의미가 전달 되기를 바란다며 뜻을 전했다.팬들에게는 사랑하기를 방해하는 세상에서 끝까지 사랑하려 애쓰는 이들의 이야기를 담았다.라며 손편지로 앨범의 관한 메시지도 전했다.
Heartbreaking😭💜
Que tiene de gracia es un drama , con una cancion que es una belleza
Everything about this MV is perfect 😭😭
I like your comments a lot! I also think V is portraying a deafmute character
Yours are the only reaction videos I choose to watch. I appreciate the low key way you express yourselves, love the bits of information and explanations you provide. Love how you explained what you loved about it. Thanks for the video!
Just the facts of their 'happy memories' is their only imagination makes me bawling my eyes out goddamnn
to be honest, I'm crying a lot bc this music video. start crying at the morning is not joking 😭😭
İzlediğim en güzel mv dinlediğim en güzel şarkı ❤❤
Someone said the box is Lee Jong suk 😂😂😂😂
IU Queen is back😍😍
I loved your reactions both, very true.❤
"This is gonna be a boring reaction cus we're just amazed and in love-- aaaahhhh" 😂 i know righttt
i just know that this song will gonna sound amazing live. Both tae and iu did amazing job with their acting!! im crying ㅠㅠ
They are so cute, I wish it's a real movie for them.❤❤❤❤
The way both of our reactions are just the same!! yall so real, man I cried during the mv
The beauty of this music video is just awesome...
And the layers to it
Like It can represent anything,
A Couple with disbility and how they are being targeted by the box which can represent the society that is trying to eliminate them
A celeb couple who are doing their best to be together and be in love, live in love but the media, the people keep on tranishing their dreams until they give up..
Or maybe just a couple who want to live along life together but death is inevitable and they therefore lose on it
Or Maybe that they are so in love, that The hurt and pain they are going throigh doesnt measure with the happiness they felt together!
Its just crazy!
IU & V 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Cinema!!! THIS IS Cinema to me!!! I WANT THEIR WHOLE Movie!! IU's Vocals made me bawl in the middle of night and Tae's ACTING!!! I'M WeepiNG UGLY😭💜🧡
taehyung is rlly iu's babygirl in this mv i love it
I was about to say that so cute
Sameee, specially the way iu took the lead and he followed, he smiled prettily and iu covering his eyes😭
@@armoaeongene5163i think always iu took the lead because tae's blind
@@nwjn_l Tae is blind in one eye only
@@armoaeongene5163 lk but he can't see properly
This was too sad I’m still crying
IU is so pretty its so upsetting
Uaenas can we email Edam to hire Seana TV to be their translator!? I just thought that they were here the only ones who could give IU's lyrics justice in English 😭😭 please 🙏
Heyyyy tae's acting and iu voice ❤ made this MV more gracious 🥹🤌
레스토랑씬 검은옷입은 사람들은 세상의 잣대들 정도로 해석하면 될까?
great reaction^^! thank you
11:40 it's not like those people are not significant, they (IU and V) just can't remember their faces anymore, I think. 13:30 THANK YOU for this! Without this channel, I don't think I would ever understand that meaning. I mean, I get the basics of the message, but with this info, it's way more clear now.
Beautiful 💕
love u guysss
Love your reaction videos. Specially the on the photobooth scene. Can you make a reaction to the behind the scene / making of Love Wins All, IU got one and Taehyung have one on BangtanTV. Really looking forward for your reaction.
They are so cute together 🤏
love your sweater anna!!
Crying
i watched it first thing in the morning, (glad i don't have classes on a wednesday) otherwise i'd be going to uni with very swollen eyes, THE WAY I BAWLED UNDER THE BLANKET AT 6 AM!?,@(!?!? 😭
I love Sean's interpretation!!! I've been wondering what the box represented and it makes sense now! It ties well with what IU wrote on her note too 😢
9:36 And yes, I believe they're doing official KSL. They put someone in the credits for it ☺
Anna got emotional: eventho the world is ending I am glad I was with you then cut to Anna clinging to Sean.. lol that just made my day..
Jieun and Taehyung acting was so expressive and amazing. In 5 min video we can get the plot and see the emotions potrayed so well it made me cry.
The composer of this song is the same composer with Start Up Ost - Day and night by Jung seunghwan which in my opinion is the most heartbreaking ost in my life. The moment I listen to the song instantly I need to know who wrote this. And IU as lyricist is just as poetic as it could be. This song and mv is just perfect.
My personal greed would be IU-Woozi-Wonwoo to sit together writing the most peotic lyrics human ever made. But that just me as lyrics enthusiast dream. A person can dream right..
Thank you for the reaction, I missed out the Tae half blind part until you guys point out which makes more sense why IU only convering only one eye at the last scene.
Have a great day!!
Gracias por apoyar a mi IU 🙏
It's so sad. Thank you Anna, Did it though??????? I had the same reaction, they needed to survive despite it all
the way you talk about the box either is a representation of "destiny" and is something that they can try hiding from or run away...but in they end they certainly can't.... you know what came to my mind is the actual situation of celebrities... the amount of eyes looming and watching over them .. i can't put my thoughts into words this is my trying XD