ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Carl Wilson - "God Only Knows" (intimate setting)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 เม.ย. 2012
- Carl is singing at an event of a close family friend where he was a guest. It is June of 1992. The position of the band stand that was determined by management and the band that worked the event, was awkward with no other options due to the lack of space.
![[ไฮไลต์] รอบชิงชนะเลิศ "เทนนิส พาณิภัค" ไทย vs จีน Guo Qing เทควันโดหญิง 49kg | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xgvTIdE8j3U/mqdefault.jpg)
Carl was always proud that he was chosen to sing this song by Brian.
Actually it was at the suggestion of Brian, Dennis and Carl's mother that he was asked to sing lead on this by Brian! Good call Mrs Wilson!
In the end when he was so sick but still performing, he would stand up to sing 'God Only Knows'.
Brian said Carl could put the right amount of emotion in this song.
Dude I'm f'ing proud for him. Carl and Dennis had such shitty early endings so their wins make me happy.
I met Carl when I was in H.S. In the ‘90’s. He took time to talk to me backstage at Jones Beach. He couldn’t have been nicer. Just the loveliest, nicest, most down to earth guy taking time to talk to a 17 year old. I will never forget those few minutes w Carl for the rest of my life. What a talent. What a heart. What a loss.
Jones Beach was the last time I saw Carl too. He sang even though he already was battling the cancer. He succumbed shortly after. He and Dennis left us way too soon.
Beautifully put. You were lucky.
Thanks for sharing, nice!
Beautiful !
😍
R.I.P Carl Wilson I wish he was still alive
The contrast between Carl Wilson singing this absolute masterpiece while a kitchen staff goes about their business in the background is really something.
A rare video indeed...
I worked near a venue in Austin TX and got to do random peasant tasks while Beyonce did sound checks
agreed
Although from the looks of it, they largely just stopped and stared. Can't say I blame them.
Unreal, loving the Wilson Brothers since 1963, going to the Beach Boys with my friends at the first show (that I am aware of) where Brian was a no show. Has been joy and pain. Knowing now how special they are,they can't be judged against others.. thank God for them way more joy than the sadness.
It’s weird…It almost made it more special…It shows what a brilliant song it is and what a great talent he was, that even in such informal surroundings, it’s still incredibly poignant
Carl could have sung this in an airport cafeteria and I would still tear up at the sheer talent and commitment to excellence. Of all the Beach Boys, his voice was the purest.
And the SONG is one of the most gorgeous ever written.
AGREED
Looks like this WAS in an airport cafeteria...
@@SamJ_1980, I think it was at a
country club's restaurant. Doesn't
matter, it was Carl! We have this
clip. And, I'm VERY thankful.
steve
Note that the chefs were working away, heard Carl, and then stopped working to take it in. Amazing song...
yes, i noticed that, they knew what's what!
the world's a sadder place without carl. i miss that voice
Me too...Carl was just great.
Carl was the greatest Beach Boy. Al Jardine a distant second.
x2 :¨(
Dan Nunya what a great beautiful nice talented man
@@tombstone1111 Brian Wilson has left the chat
one of the most underrated singers in rock. Brian may be the genius of the Beach Boys, but Carl was the soul
beautiful comment.
And Mike was the anus.
3 of them were the mind, heart, and soul.
Brian has stated time and time again, that Carl had the best voice in the band. Dennis' was the most gut wrenching to me, though. Such a sensitive yet tortured soul.
Carl seemed so kind
Thank you for all the comments. The performance took place at a private function and I would like to keep it that way. This was the only song Carl performed. I feel blessed to have been there and I can't say enough about what a nice person he was.
But I think it is great that you shared this gorgeous footage of a gorgeous human being.
Thank you!
This is my favorite version of this song and I wish I could have been there to hear it and to thank Carl personally for singing it.
Thank you so much for sharing this with us♥️
Nice .. great ? ..but what an awful sound and video ..
Carl was gentle, kind and humble. He made me feel at ease when I spoke to him. He signed my Pet Sounds CD and overall seemed like a person with down to earth priorities.
Yes he absolutly was, what a lucky sum-bitch you are meeting Carl. Greetings from the Netherlands 🙏❤️
If only the chefs in the kitchen could understand this was a part of history that will never be repeated.
You can see one guy completely stop and listen for a bit then gets scolded but another chef
To be fair, one of them obviously stopped working and was just staring in the background listening. I don't blame him.
It’s crazy how much his voice held up through the years considering how fast his brother’s voices went while even being a chain smoker for almost his whole life. Still sounded like an angel.
That surprised me too. I quit smoking to try and improve my singing and it helped immediately. On the other hand, I've read that smoking has helped other vocalists. Whatever it may be, Carl had a great voice and is gone too soon.
He could sing in a bathroom stall and make it sound great.
He could sing taking a shit and it would still sound good. 4th best band ever!!!!!
mrsnoopyaaaaa what are the other 3 bands?
The Beatles the stones the who
Benjamin Rupp The Beach Boys
+mrsnoopyaaaaa The Beach Boys are better than the Stones and The Who. Sorry. You are right about The Beatles though.
Back when couples had "their song," this was my wife's and my song. She died in a car accident in 1986.
So sorry for your loss 😢 this song will forever keep you close at heart
I'm so sorry. God bless.
Carl wilson is up there in the top 5 vocalist of all time.
quote Brian Wilson
For sure. I'd put him in the same league as people like Roy Orbison, Elvis(I know he was cheesy, but he had a fantastic voice), Bono, and all the ones we think of when we think about chill-inducing singers.
This and Caroline No are songs that wouldn't sound more beautiful if real Ang els came down and joined Carl. The man had one in a million vocal chops. So many have described his kindness. He held that band together when others were ready to give up. Billy Hinsche always talked about how Carl taught him professionalism and leading by example. Carl was the whole package.
I agree. Other men would be Johnny Maestro, Cory Wells, Robin Zander, and Mickey Thomas.
Carl wilson had the voice of an angel rip
God wanted people to hear His singing voice.. So He gave it to Carl Wilson.
***** AMEN TO THAT!
***** Then he gave him lung cancer! That silly god!
+Joe Price the Lord's ways are not our ways. Not our will but His be done.
+Larry L Well said.
+Larry L Thank you for saying that from one believer to another. God bless you.
Such an angelic voice. Pure gold! RIP, Carl.
Lucky Angels have Carl's voice.
Carl is the major reason I HATE
tobacco. He'd still be here.
steve
Lov carl wilson
This just made my heart hurt. God he was great.
adsvx yes was wonderful
😪😢😥
Chef in back stopped what he was doing as he should. Respect an American icon singing one of the best songs by one of the best songwriters we've ever known.
You bet!
Louis G I mean he can't burn his shit tho
but I sort of agree
Does it get any better than Carl singing one of Brian's best songs? I'm thinking no.
The food prep can wait. A legend is singing.
When my 49 year old husband passed away in 2003. I had God Only Knows played at his funeral. Our twins were 10 years old and our singleton was 9 years old. This song has been played by my children on my deceased husbands anniversary of his death for the last 18 years. GOD ONLY KNOW WHAT I AM WITHOUT HIM. Thank you Beach Boys.
Carl Wilson 's smile completely transformed his face. Adorable, and the best voice out of the Beach Boys imo.
I met him at a party I was catering in Brentwood during the '80's
I didn't know who he was . He introduced himself and asked me if I was a musician. I said " yes. Are you a musician also?" "Yes". "Are you with a group?" "Yes, The Beach Boys". He was the most kind and unassuming person I had ever met in the music business.
❤😊😢❤😊🎉❤😊❤
Icon, that reminds me of a story I heard about Paul McCartney, which involved him talking (post-Beatles) to a little kid who was over to visit. The little guy proudly said, "MY dad's in a band!" And Paul replied, "I used to be in band once me-self..."
the guy is standing in front of a kitchen like a lounge singer and sounds absolutely amazing. one of the best songs ever written by one of the best vocalists of all time. stunning! thank you for sharing.
His brother Brian wrote and produced it.
@@colwilliamnoydb4134 Yeah, everybody knows it.
absolutely amazing, yes
@@DeeckyRizzo not everybody
@@Monkforilla Nope. I asked everybody... They know.
Even in his later years he had one of the purest voices I've ever heard.
Chills and tears. I didn't know Carl, but I felt like I knew him. His voice pierces my heart and soul every time I hear it. Ugh. Voice of an angel 😇
Make up your mind!
Mike Albanese What do you mean?
I was a New Jersey "greaser" kid in '67 listening to soul & motown music. When I heard Carl's voice on, "Darlin' ", I became a Beach Boys fan.
Probably the prettiest voice ever
The Wilson's are truly a gift to the world. Rip Carl
He had a beautiful spirit. Left us way too soon.
A consummate professional with a golden throat if ever I heard
one. Love Carl RIP.
No one... No one has Carls magnificent voice!! He is missed !
AGREED !
Brian Wilson's voice is more Unique!
He is sorely missed!
Imagine having to carry this whole song on your own. Great job, Carl. Love you RIP
find me one bad thing about this man. never seen a negative comment about him, and even for the best there always is, but not Carl. Never. Too kind of a soul
Absolutely correct. Brian has said he was the glue that kept them together. Always looked cool. Awesome musician. And as for his voice? Wow. I can't throw enough superlatives at him to be honest. My son loves him.
Fuck you cancer!
GoodGamer3000 I’ve seen too many interviews of Brian saying good things about Carl to believe some stranger on the internet. Unless you have reciepts.
@@Olivia.Sheree, if by receipts you mean links to the article, then here:
www.uncut.co.uk/blog/beach-boys-trying-destroy-77465/6
Remember, this is coming from a guy who can't remember that he was on Full House. I love Brian, but he still has mental health problems and memory loss.
Mike Love can’t even think of a bad thing to say about Carl.
GoodGamer3000 holy crap I thought you were trolling at first it sounded like a joke
Voice of an angel! God only knows how much he is missed!
Carl could really, really sing
I read right here, The Craig8754 comments 6 months ago, that Carl Wilson sang at the restaurant opening of his NEPHEW who is in the restaurant business. Years ago I read that Mike Wilson, Dennis Wilson's oldest son was a chef who bought his own restaurant. Carl was being CARL. A beautiful singer with a beautiful soul supporting his family. I wish Craig 8754 comments were at the TOP.
Carl was pure class in real life as well, the most gracious guy in the group. Shout out to Gina!
Carl was my favorite Beach Boy. I miss him still.
One of the greatest songs ever
God only knows. Sir Paul's favorite song.
Brian, THANK YOU, for letting Carl sing it.
steve
I loved every second of this. Thank you. RIP Carl, I named my boy after you.
Me too, fantastic wasn’t it. Greeting to you and your Carl from the UK.
Greatest TH-cam comment.
Cool😊 I named my daughter after Carly Simon, but call her Carl most of the time....lol
What a gentle spiritual voice and song
This is a God given talent
God given talent is pure and genuine and no one could make a better copy of it!
Such a beautiful song god bless you Carl Wilson
It was so nice seeing Billy Hinsche at the end, I knew he would be there! Now they are performing this track together in heaven!
Such a beautyfull song, rare footage, great performance, R.I.P Mr. Carl Wilson
this might probably be one of the best clips on youtube. an archive of such clips should be curated
I've added this to our little group here in Illinois called "the Music Emporium."
Imagine having Carl as a performer at your wedding, WOW!!!!
R.I.P
Wow! love this version. Carl Wilson, sadly missed.🙏🏻
This is SUPER special, whoever got to see this is super super lucky. This song almost can't not nearly bring tears to my eyes whenever I hear it. It's otherworldly eternal and divine.
Carl was the most underrated Beach Boy (Wilson brother) IMO, he was the glue over the years.
RIP Carl Wilson (1946-1998)
What a beautiful voice. Taken far too soon. Thanks for posting this.
Bob A You're welcome
Carl Wilson really had the voice of an angel. Other than (late) brother Dennis, Carl was the only other Beach Boy who took time out for his fans and never turned an autograph down.
I keeo coming back to this. If there was only one video I could watch, it would be this one of Carl. Just a perfect performance. He will ALWAYS be missed. Thank you Carl for all the joy, and for sharing your extraordinary talent with us!
It's so amazing that he is 46 here and can sing those verses with the innocence and hope of when he was 20.
There was no better or purer voice in rock music than Carl Wilson. He is so sorely missed it is beyond description. Taken way too soon!
Loved this . Thanks Bob
Dennis McKnight Brian was as good in his prime.Same with AL Jardine
@@davidrubenhold6677 correct, that's why their harmonies are so wonderfull, almost divine.
I've been a BB fan since my teens (the 60's)...Carl always tugged at my heart strings... I've seen the group dozens and dozens of times thru the years...met them in '68 with the Maharishi ..but listening to this masterpiece, Carl singing like the angel he was...over & over & over ..just brings me to tears.. these beautiful men...the Beach Boys...RIP Carl & Dennis... you will always be LOVED!! And oh, so missed!!!!! 💗💗💗💗
That's beautiful, wow ❤️🙏 lucky you seen them live.....
This is the best song of ALLLLLL time !!!!!
RIP Carl...you'll never be forgotten.
The Keyboarder Billy Hinsche is a old friend and the brother of his first wife of Carl Wilson.
Correct.
Dino, Desi & Billy
My Heart remains broken over the loss of Carl and, Dennis Wilson. They both sound like Angel's and now, they truly are Angels. Can you imagine what Heavens chior is gonna sound like ?
This song has been my all-time favorite since its released in 1966. I've recognized the beautiful allegory (for who Carl was) in this precious footage. Carl played for sold-out crowds and is still deeply loved by millions of people worldwide; yet, we see him dressed to the nines and ready to entertain this small gathering with all the grace and professionalism he did before packed stadiums. What a talented, humble, generous, and loving soul! And so deeply missed by so very many!
My heart goes out for this man, Carl Wilson. He was taken from us way too early. I saw him live in 1977, wonderful man with a voice like an angel. Rest in peace my good man...
Rob Julian, go to the Facebook called Carl Wilson the heart and voice of an angel. You will see great photos of Carl seldom seen and read comments of many people who feel just like YOU.
r
Totally agree...he was the glue to the entire group after Brian left...never be another voice like him...just doesn't seem fair, does it???
Yup. He looks terrible here. Waste.
@@lestergreen1190 remember at the end he was very sick... Still even here Carl has that unique thing.... Soul ! Hé is authentic, pure....real.
This was a family celebration - Carl gifted this - God only knows what we would be without Carl Wilson
Gifted to who? When? How do you know that?
@@tpowell453 to his nephew Dennis Wilson's oldest son was a chef that bought this particular restaurant where Carl Wilson is singing in this video.. this was a family event..
This was a stunning rendition of a stunning song sung by one of the great singers in music.
To me, this is one of the most beautiful performances of God Only Knows. Carl seemed like such a sweet, caring man. And because of his contribution to the world of music, he will live on forever. Thank you, Carl.
Incredible! Only a few musicians can sound this good all by themselves without all the background singers, pitch adjusters, multiple instruments, etc. Carl Wilson is one of only a few true standalone musicians. Thanks for sharing. Keith.
Watching this in June 2024 amd it made me cry. Rip Beautiful Carl
Oh God how much do I love this song and miss that man! Voice of my childhood.
Ok This is why YT is so wonderful
Here is Carl Wilson playing one of the most beautiful songs ever written at what looks like a wedding or a small restaurant. Carl Wilson had a beautiful beautiful voice and I was sad when he died (way to young). This is so special. Thank you for posting
I always loved the way Carl would flash those quick little smiles. Miss him bunches.
I've watched this many times.
I'll confess that not only the first time I watched and heard Carl here, but everytime, I get choked up as soon as he begins to sing. RIP Mr. Carl Wilson.
The thing about Carl is he easily hits all the notes dead on, but sings so delicately it sounds like he can’t. The years of touring and smoking did nothing to his voice. What a ridiculous talent. I keep coming back to this video, what a gem.
Voice of an angel.... Carl was such an intricate part of the boys...took over for his big brother when he wasnt well....helped free Brian from Landy... We love & miss you Carl.
I only wish I could have heard this man perform in person , Angelic voice, Harmonizing… Gifted!
The guy was a treasure, beautiful voice in a primitive setting, singing at a country club for a friend, incredible, the band, who ever they were did a admirable job backing Carl up, loved it, Carl and the band
Whoa... just watched a bunch of covers of God Only Knows, which were all great, but then... THIS. Stripped back, no big professional audio setup, and he still just stopped me in my tracks. Let alone Carl's magnificent voice, his sense of rhythm on that guitar is so tight. Brian made so many creative decisions as a producer when it came to which instruments to include and who would play them (Hal Blaine, Carol Kaye etc.), but his most brilliant decision was to have Carl sing this masterpiece. So very moving...
I can't remember the last time I saw a video that made me cry. Incredible
We lost Carl Wilson 16 years ago today. Thanks for the music Carl!
Always in my TOP 10 Greatest Songs Of All Time. Carl's voice is so beautiful. the vocal phrasing over the middle eight was heavenly.
How's this been on the internet for 8 years but I'm only now seeing it?
I'm disappointed in my recc algo, youtube.😂
This brings me to tears every time i hear Carl sing this song.. this one version m ore than anything,as he died a few years later. What a wonderful voice and person...
I can't believe he was singing this song in a setting as pedestrian as this. That's like the Pope giving a sermon in someone's backyard.
This was a private event of dear friends of Carl. He was a guest.
harvey20c The Pope's message is equally important regardless of venue.
harvey20c I Am Beach Boys Fan Forever Amanda Johnston / I Love Listening Beautiful Carl Singing God Only knows My Favorite Beach Boys Songs Ever 😆
harvey20C- don't need no Pope,we have the written word of God
You do? How do you know?
His voice is so clean, and sweet and accurate! Wow....
"Singers" today can't touch this talent. Just can't compare!
Bands back in the 50's through the 70's really had to prove they were worthy of the media's attention. I wish the music Industry still cared about what they put out for the public
What about Michael Buble, he's neck and neck with the beachboys! Also Justin Bieber. Who else 🤔
El Pistolero .... Bieber....? Seriously ?
bierber ist kign
Not even close to his talented singing voice!!!!!
I agree, it may seem strange to some to become a fan of somebody who died years ago, as I have recently of Carl but though we die, great music lives on. As a Brit I've just discovered that most of my favorite BB songs are the ones Carl sings and also that he was a great songwriter. Thank God for today's technology, which allows us to discover great talent, past and present.
what a beautiful voice Carl had, absolutely amazing.
The people in the restaurant have won the biggest lottery of all time
Done in this simple way makes it more personal to me. And that beautiful evocative melody shines through.
he fucking nailed it
He always did.
He is amazing sad he gone
This is 110% better than the BBC star studded version. Sadly I became a Beach Boys fan later in life. Didn't appreciate them as a teenager listening mainly to Zep, Floyd, and Sabbath (which I still love). Watching Carl in this intimate setting is bittersweet. I can only imagine the guest that were there. They must have left with huge smiles at the end of the night.
Wow, I could have written your post. Ditto to the tenth power.
Carl whould been proud of his brother if he sees in on the BBC!
Checho Kiko That is the way it was.
Checho Kiko True, I used to think Gun's N' Roses and Rolling Stones were the shit(obviously overrated and the magazine is biased towards rock) and I think Pop was shit (Pop is better than rock, I always considered Beach Boys a pop band and not a rock band because of their complicated structure of music). I also thought that today's generation sucked during my grade school days(which was not true) now that I'm in College, I appreciated music from every generation. Especially the Beach Boys, where I put Brian Wilson at a high regard and in this generation we can agree that great music never died since the likes of Mac Demarco and Tame Impala are in my generation.
Checho Kiko yes
I was born in the same year Carl died. It's so strange... his journey was over while mine was just starting.
Rest easy, beautiful soul. You are remembered and loved by many.
+fernanda mq It's not strange. It happens every day.
I was born over a year after. I feel it’s an absolute travesty that I was born into a world without Carl Wilson.
It's not as strange as you might think:
During the year he died and you were born, there were approximately 3,941,553 recorded births in just that year (and even that is a rough estimate!)
:-)
I saw Love and Mercy last night. Extremely well done.
+Arnie Michael I really like the film too, I wish they had more Carl and Dennis though.. even tough Brian really was the brains of Beach Boys, Carl and Dennis lives were still succesful and both ended in tragedy.. I wish they would have shown more on how that affected Brian!
+Anthony Baruch Well Carl's death happens afters the events of Love & Mercy of course.
+Anthony Baruch And Dennis' death is mentioned at the start of the movie.
Parched Pinemarten It is. And that's not even mentioned just for the audience to be updated at Brian's life at that point, but he honestly said that to Melinda when they met.
+Nicole Foster Huh, did not know that. That film really stayed true to the events.
This is my all-time favorite video on TH-cam. The gorgeous and classic song being sung by a musical legend combined with the absurd Spinal Tap-esque joke of the kitchen operating in the background makes it amazing on both a sincere and an ironic level.
Carl was one of the nicest, kindest man I have ever met and I'm so blessed to say he was a dear friend of mine. I miss his smile and quirkey laugh, and of course, his angelic voice! This video shows what a talented man Carl was, there was no need for any back up, "God Only Knows" was Carl's song and no other musician will ever be able to sing it as beautifully as Carl did. He will always be missed and will never be forgotten. RIP sweet angel.
God only knows why this makes me cry when I least expect it.....
One of the best voices ever
Got to see Brian sing this at a music industry event, where the Beatles were given a video award, then I was given a special journalism award, then Brian came out and did God Only Knows, solo, with just a keyboard. It was one of the great moments for me. Brian left the whole place in tears.
This performance is inspiring for every reason - the greatness of the song, the uniqueness of Carl's and the Beach Boys' vocal sound and the sincerity and passion of the singing in such an ordinary and nondescript venue. You don't see this sort of humility every day. Thank you, Carl and band.
he could sing in a fucking sewer for all i care, the man is beautiful.
I got to see this man sing this song over 400 times in 4 years. It still gives me chills.
That it does.
I got to see him sing it 650 times in 4 years. I'm better 😁
@@Martin-iv6lq those are 250 gigs as a keyboard roadie for the Beach boys I never setup gear at. For the last two years I got play the last six songs on guitar including the Barbara Ann guitar solo: th-cam.com/video/x_6Ixthvjno/w-d-xo.html
best song ever writtenn
So beautiful!