z > r is not that weird. The reason why English has was - were is that the r in were was a z at one point. This sound change is also found in Latin. But one group of languages where z > r had a big influence is in North Germanic. This is why plurals in North Germanic end in -r rather than -s like in West Germanic. You also have the *-Vz nominative endings becoming -r in Old Norse and -ur in Modern Icelandic and Faroese. So gastiz > gestr > gestur. Chuvash is wildly fascinating. Hope to try it out sometime.
😊😊😊😊😊Салам, тавансем Чувашия, салам, родная Чувашия, я чистокровная чувашка, меня зовут Алиса Максимова, Ячувашка сама, а живу в Латвии, безмерно скучаю по родной Чувашии❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
Greetings from the chuvash) It was very interesting to watch the video, although I didn't understand anything. For the first time I see such a book, now I wonder what it says))) I am writing thanks to an online translator.
I don't feel a heavy Finnic influence in the Chuvash language. It definitely sounds like other Turkic languages, similar grammar, most words are of Turkic origin. Yes, in the Chuvash language some letters are pronounced completely differently (because it is an Ogur language), but then we can say that the Bashkir language was influenced by Spanish, because Bashkir has the same sounds as in Spanish, which are rare in other Turkic languages. Although in fact the Bashkir and Tatar languages (which do not have these sounds) are one language. For me, the most strangely pronounced Turkic language that I have heard on the Internet is the Salar language. It's as if a Chinese were trying to speak some Turkic language. And from the point of view of a person who understands the Kipchak, Karluk and Oguz languages quite well, the most difficult Turkic language to understand is the Yakut language.
Very true, no any heavy finnic influence. Chuvash is turk language. Just more antion then another groups of turk languages, that's why there is some difference between them. But many words are coming from same roots.
@@alexeyrumyantsev3524 give examples please. I know that the Udmurt language itself was influenced by the Tatar language. But I am sure that the Finno-Ugric languages also influenced the Turkic languages of the Volga region, not only Chuvash. After all, the Turkic and Finno-Ugric peoples of this region have long lived side by side.
As a native Turkish speaker, I can tell you that Chuvash is a bit difficult to understand, but when I pay a little attention I can understand how most of the words (in this video) come from the same root and how they have changed
@@sahteekrem Ogur Türkçesindeki hangi harflerin, yaygın Türkçedeki hangi harflerle değiştiğini (r-z ve p-b gibi) ve kelimelerdeki asıl noktanın sessiz harfler olduğunu sesli harflerin değişebileceğini biliyorsan anlıyorsun.
As a chuvash girl I don't understand Turkish at all😂 only a couple of words like Anne, çiçek, elma(ulma in chuvash), but overall they are too different. Although, weirdly somehow it still feels like I know this language.
As a proud Chuvash, if i remove Islam and the Arab appearance from the Turkish People, suddenly I begin to see Turkic in you. hope this helps to understand that mooslims from Anatolia are not the main characters💞
@@msitsoThat's your ignorance. Arab apperance? Lol you know nothing. Also you know nothing about Muslim Turks too. Turks reformed Islam with their own culture.. It is basically Turkic culture + Islamic rituals. Smart Turks don't divide Turks because of religions..There is no difference between Tengrist, Buddhist, Christian,Jewish, Muslim and non believer Turks
22:04 Old Turkic loanwords in Hungarian with rhotacism: iker [=Turkish ikiz], ökör [=Turkish öküz], tenger [=Turkish deniz, OT. tengiz], térd [=Turkish diz (knee)] , karó [=Turkish kazık] etc.
@@precursors Avars came from around Mongolia in the 600's, Hungarians have pretty much interacted with very late Avars in the late 800's. The R-Turkic influence on Hungarian is dated to the 400-500's.
@@barkasz6066 Avars came to Pannonian basin in lates 400s, not 600s. There was another Avar migration to Pannonia in early to mid 500s. Also, Gokturks originate from present-day Mongolia too. But neither Avars nor Gokturks were Mongolian.
Да, мой дорогой соплеменник-чуваш, я очень бы хотела пообщаться с вами, я😊😊😊😊😊сама чистокровная чувашка, меня зовут😊😊😊😊😊Алиса Максимова 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊!!!!!
Я чувашка, меня зовут😊😊😊😊😊Алиса Максимова, я уже очень сильно и давно хочу пообщаться с моими соотечественниками-чувашами, и я очень рада, что я узнала про вас, мой милый соотечественник❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
-рах is very common amongst other turkish language while ă and ĕ are like /ɤ̆/ and /ø/ when i pay attention to each and everyword i can see similaties a tip păr - is related to biz in proto turkic in present tense we added the pronominal suffix at thr end which is why chuvash has a păr while turkush as uz since both are from -bïŕ which became -uz and -păr respectively same for others also z --> r is actually wrong rather its ŕ which merged with r in oghur branch and z in common turkic so thats why we have z and r turkic similarly ş and l(some not all) are from ĺ where ĺ merged with l in oghur while shifted to a sibilent sound in common turkic the y to ş of chuvash can be explained by the analogy that y first shifted to something like spanish y like in playa then devoiced to ş
Iră kun pultăr! It's such a pleasure somebody is interested in exploring Chuvash language! Unfortunately as being part of ex-Russian, ex-Soviet, neomodern Russian empire Chuvash people can not choose alphabet by themselves, that causes some stupid situations like 37 letters in alphabet, lots of them are not needed in the alphabet - ya, ye, yo, yu - 4 Russian vowels and all voiced consonants, as we don't have any of them in Chuvash language (you mentioned that in the video). It's very pity that you couldn't have found Chuvash speaking person by the moment you finished work on the video. Unfortunately discussion on the future of the Chuvash language mainly being taken in Russian, but as we can see, Russia is not interested in any diversity even in culture or language. I can help you talk to native Chuvash speakers if you would like to, can help make professional studio voice records in Chuvash if you need any. Reply the message and I'll give you my contact. In Civilization 5 Atilla spoke Chuvash language but with accent that was worse than yours, why couldn't they contact any native speaker to make an affordable record..
variations also among Northern and Southern Turkic dialects .. y - j or g '' yıldız - jıldız/ jıltız - şıltız/şıltır.. some words without K .. ene - inek ''cow'' .. when we hear Chuvash speakers we feel that we are descendants of same ancestors went in different directions.. miraculously maintaned some common words,
I am a West Asian Turk. I love the Chuvash language because it is closest to ancient Turkish, which was spoken by the Huns, Khazars, and Gokturks, and it is the link between the Turkish language and other Eurasian languages.
you know I am from central anatolia when our women weave carpets or "klims" they always use this figure weaved on them ( the figure is on the flag) it can not be a coincidence it must be the Turkish culture heritance.
pretty cool video man, I'm learning Turkish right now and am interested in how different it is from Turkish compared to other Turkic languages just from hearing and reading.
Why am I watching this, I’m a Chuvash myself and I know everything. Great video anyway) P.S. There are 8 main cases in the Chuvash language And not šivrE but šivrA PoyezdRa for locative, poyezdPa for instrumental Also has a negation particle ан (AN), used for the imperative mood.Example ан кил (an kil') - do not come
You can hear an example of spoken Chuvash on the I Love Languages ! channel on TH-cam , complete with an English translation and transliteration from the Cyrillic .
It is amazing in Turkey it is Bahçe and in Chauvash they say Pahça, that is Arabic influence because in Arabic we don't have the letter P, so Pepsi is Bebsi, Problem is broblem 😅 upgrade is ubgrade.
You and the Japanese woman who played an Alevi poem on a bağlama are the only two Turkaboos that exist in the world and I don't know how to feel about it. Great video btw
Chuvash sounds or seems nothing similar to Turkic Languages actually. As a native Turkish speaker, when I hear or see something written in any Turkic languages, I can understand a certain percentage of it. If it is a geographically closer language the percentage is higher and if the contrary, my percentage of things I can catch is lower, which makes the whole language family a dialect continuum, I suppose. But in the Chuvash case, my percentage is very close to zero. Word roots, suffixes etc sound quite unfamiliar, but I feel like I am hearing some Hungarian or Finnic words. Are linguists really sure that Chuvash is a Turkic language? Chuvashia is relatively close to Turkiye, and the Chuvash language seems to break down Dialect Continuum situation among the Turkic languages. Thanks for the video
This song belongs to guests song genre. In fact, this is not a song but different songs with one melody. Chuvash folk rests on aphoristic poetry - one verse contains a completed idea and meaning. And, the melody is in E pentatonic scale.
Мы,чуваши, не тюрки и язык у нас не тюркский.Не надо нас сравнивать с тюрками и с тюркскими языками.Это тюркские языки произошли на основе чувашского языка(Марр Н.Я). А в тюркскую языковую группу ученые-лингвисты загнали чувашский язык как КОМПРОМИССНЫЙ ВАРИАНТ в споре о принадлежности чувашского языка к какой-либо языковой группе.
Чуваши и казанские татары никогда не были единым народом! Болгары - это чуваши! А казанские татары - это кыпчаки.Татары к болгарам никакого отношения не имеют.И не пытайтесь примазываться со своим золотоордынским исламом.Татары ислам приняли только в Золотой Орде! Татары только и уничтожили все болгарское и истребляли болгар(чувашей)@@SiimplyZ03YV
@@ВалерийСтоляров-ы7п интересная точка зрения. я понимаю Вас, как бы это грустно не звучало, но Вы считаете что Казанские татары и чуваши имеют разное происхождение. Допустим, все что мы знали и читали было просто байками. Но где и как можно больше узнать о правдивой истории чувашей? Если только Чуваши древние Булгары, тогда получается это именно вы кто принял Ислам так рано в истории народов- 10м веке. Я правильно понимаю?
Русский язык явно отупляет людей. "Чувашский язык не тюркский, но тюркские языки произошли от чувашского". Что ты несешь? Чувашский язык очевидно тюркский язык. Причем разница между чувашским и любым тюркским языком во много раз меньше чем, например, между многими индо-европейскими языками.
Чуваши если мы ходим понять кто такие Чуваш , Чуваш это прежде всего язык , ни какой язык даже близко не подходит к этому языку , потому что этот язык - живой язык которой имеет свою веру . Человек который владеет верой Чувашского языка никогда не скажет что он Тюрк , тюрк это низшая который подчиняется религию животного . Человек верующий веру Чувашского языка он Туранец истиный Турок , владеющий силой ТуРАна . Туранец это высшая раса - жизнь деревьев , которыми владели Хунну они владели Суварской верой развивались через три солнца . Мустафа Кемаль и Ленин они не подчинялись религию животного они понимали веру Туранцев , Веру которую сегодня наше осознанность не может распознать .
любой, кто возвышает себя или кого-то другого за счёт принижения других, особенно относительно нации или расы - достоин если не презрения и потешания, то вразумления Будьте человеком, долой невежество и человеконенавистничество
@@russianyoutube Гитлер жил как человек , а не как животное , не быть рабом . Виновен не тот кто делает , виновен тот кто позволяет делать . Спасибо за вашу противодействие и извините что унизил ваше осознанность.
z > r is not that weird. The reason why English has was - were is that the r in were was a z at one point. This sound change is also found in Latin. But one group of languages where z > r had a big influence is in North Germanic. This is why plurals in North Germanic end in -r rather than -s like in West Germanic. You also have the *-Vz nominative endings becoming -r in Old Norse and -ur in Modern Icelandic and Faroese. So gastiz > gestr > gestur.
Chuvash is wildly fascinating. Hope to try it out sometime.
Thanks for the video! Our people have really amazing culture, language, the fantasticful history;) with great last and no less great future!❤
I would like to learn more. Nice to meet you, I'm Jen from the USA
😊😊😊😊😊Салам, тавансем Чувашия, салам, родная Чувашия, я чистокровная чувашка, меня зовут Алиса Максимова, Ячувашка сама, а живу в Латвии, безмерно скучаю по родной Чувашии❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
Салам чӑваш тилине ан манӑр! Эпӗ Анатри Чӑваш, Чӑваш Республикирен!
Greetings from the chuvash) It was very interesting to watch the video, although I didn't understand anything. For the first time I see such a book, now I wonder what it says))) I am writing thanks to an online translator.
Selam Çuvaş halkına 🈴 Epe Çavaş ✅
I don't feel a heavy Finnic influence in the Chuvash language. It definitely sounds like other Turkic languages, similar grammar, most words are of Turkic origin.
Yes, in the Chuvash language some letters are pronounced completely differently (because it is an Ogur language), but then we can say that the Bashkir language was influenced by Spanish, because Bashkir has the same sounds as in Spanish, which are rare in other Turkic languages. Although in fact the Bashkir and Tatar languages (which do not have these sounds) are one language.
For me, the most strangely pronounced Turkic language that I have heard on the Internet is the Salar language. It's as if a Chinese were trying to speak some Turkic language. And from the point of view of a person who understands the Kipchak, Karluk and Oguz languages quite well, the most difficult Turkic language to understand is the Yakut language.
Very true, no any heavy finnic influence. Chuvash is turk language. Just more antion then another groups of turk languages, that's why there is some difference between them. But many words are coming from same roots.
Many words in certain fields are borrowings from Mari and udmurt. Dual counting system is from Udmurt. It is non existent in other Turkish languages
@@alexeyrumyantsev3524 give examples please. I know that the Udmurt language itself was influenced by the Tatar language. But I am sure that the Finno-Ugric languages also influenced the Turkic languages of the Volga region, not only Chuvash. After all, the Turkic and Finno-Ugric peoples of this region have long lived side by side.
As a native Turkish speaker, I can tell you that Chuvash is a bit difficult to understand, but when I pay a little attention I can understand how most of the words (in this video) come from the same root and how they have changed
Atıyorsun... 😂
@@sahteekrem Ogur Türkçesindeki hangi harflerin, yaygın Türkçedeki hangi harflerle değiştiğini (r-z ve p-b gibi) ve kelimelerdeki asıl noktanın sessiz harfler olduğunu sesli harflerin değişebileceğini biliyorsan anlıyorsun.
you're right@@b26s . It's definitely Turkic. Bosver onu.
@@sahteekrem atıyosun diyen yavşak, ben uzun bi yorum yazdım. bi bak yoruma. kim atıyo kim tutuyo görürsün
As a chuvash girl I don't understand Turkish at all😂 only a couple of words like Anne, çiçek, elma(ulma in chuvash), but overall they are too different. Although, weirdly somehow it still feels like I know this language.
As a Turkish person, when I replaced the r in Chuvash words with d, suddenly everything made sense 😂
As a proud Chuvash, if i remove Islam and the Arab appearance from the Turkish People, suddenly I begin to see Turkic in you. hope this helps to understand that mooslims from Anatolia are not the main characters💞
@@msitsoThat's your ignorance. Arab apperance? Lol you know nothing. Also you know nothing about Muslim Turks too. Turks reformed Islam with their own culture.. It is basically Turkic culture + Islamic rituals. Smart Turks don't divide Turks because of religions..There is no difference between Tengrist, Buddhist, Christian,Jewish, Muslim and non believer Turks
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤да, чувашский язык именно чисто ТЮРКСКИЙ, это именно так, и😊😊😊😊😊это очень необычно и загадочно❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
Selam Çuvaş 🈴
22:04 Old Turkic loanwords in Hungarian with rhotacism: iker [=Turkish ikiz], ökör [=Turkish öküz], tenger [=Turkish deniz, OT. tengiz], térd [=Turkish diz (knee)] , karó [=Turkish kazık] etc.
Good catch. Though I think it is because of Avar influence on Magyar language. Avars settled in Pannonia before Magyars did.
@@precursors Speakers of the Hungarian language had contact with speakers of the R-Turkic branch even before arriving in the Carpathian Basin.
@@precursors Avars came from around Mongolia in the 600's, Hungarians have pretty much interacted with very late Avars in the late 800's. The R-Turkic influence on Hungarian is dated to the 400-500's.
@@barkasz6066 Avars came to Pannonian basin in lates 400s, not 600s. There was another Avar migration to Pannonia in early to mid 500s. Also, Gokturks originate from present-day Mongolia too. But neither Avars nor Gokturks were Mongolian.
The suffix 'rax' is widely used in other Turkic languages. At the same time, the Chuvash language has the word 'daha'. This word is 'тата' ('tata')
Avan-i! I am the Chuvash speaker living in the US. Can you please reach out to me?
Salam Alexey! Eppe chavashla k@shtah pelep. I am living in the US as well . And I am chuvash too
Salam))! I m also Chuvash and living in the USA. I couldn't expect to meet any Chuvash from USA here:).
Да, мой дорогой соплеменник-чуваш, я очень бы хотела пообщаться с вами, я😊😊😊😊😊сама чистокровная чувашка, меня зовут😊😊😊😊😊Алиса Максимова 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊!!!!!
Я чувашка, меня зовут😊😊😊😊😊Алиса Максимова, я уже очень сильно и давно хочу пообщаться с моими соотечественниками-чувашами, и я очень рада, что я узнала про вас, мой милый соотечественник❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
Thnx a lot for this video! It's a language of my ancestors and it was a surprise for me to find such a gem:)
-рах is very common amongst other turkish language
while ă and ĕ are like /ɤ̆/ and /ø/
when i pay attention to each and everyword i can see similaties
a tip
păr - is related to biz
in proto turkic in present tense we added the pronominal suffix at thr end which is why chuvash has a păr while turkush as uz
since both are from -bïŕ which became -uz and -păr respectively same for others
also z --> r is actually wrong
rather its ŕ which merged with r in oghur branch and z in common turkic
so thats why we have z and r turkic
similarly ş and l(some not all) are from ĺ where ĺ merged with l in oghur while shifted to a sibilent sound in common turkic
the y to ş of chuvash can be explained by the analogy that y first shifted to something like spanish y like in playa
then devoiced to ş
Iră kun pultăr! It's such a pleasure somebody is interested in exploring Chuvash language!
Unfortunately as being part of ex-Russian, ex-Soviet, neomodern Russian empire Chuvash people can not choose alphabet by themselves, that causes some stupid situations like 37 letters in alphabet, lots of them are not needed in the alphabet - ya, ye, yo, yu - 4 Russian vowels and all voiced consonants, as we don't have any of them in Chuvash language (you mentioned that in the video).
It's very pity that you couldn't have found Chuvash speaking person by the moment you finished work on the video.
Unfortunately discussion on the future of the Chuvash language mainly being taken in Russian, but as we can see, Russia is not interested in any diversity even in culture or language.
I can help you talk to native Chuvash speakers if you would like to, can help make professional studio voice records in Chuvash if you need any. Reply the message and I'll give you my contact.
In Civilization 5 Atilla spoke Chuvash language but with accent that was worse than yours, why couldn't they contact any native speaker to make an affordable record..
variations also among Northern and Southern Turkic dialects .. y - j or g '' yıldız - jıldız/ jıltız - şıltız/şıltır.. some words without K .. ene - inek ''cow'' .. when we hear Chuvash speakers we feel that we are descendants of same ancestors went in different directions.. miraculously maintaned some common words,
Ячувашка, Алиса Максимова😊😊😊😊😊!!!!! Чаваш херараме Алиса Максимова, Ячувашка❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
I am a West Asian Turk. I love the Chuvash language because it is closest to ancient Turkish, which was spoken by the Huns, Khazars, and Gokturks, and it is the link between the Turkish language and other Eurasian languages.
Closest to Huns and Khazars, not Gokturks. Gokturks spoke from Shaz Turkic group.
we are so tired of attention from 🇹🇷🇧🇬🇭🇺. Our brothers are Mari and Volga Tatar People
Ура. Чуваши.
you know I am from central anatolia when our women weave carpets or "klims" they always use this figure weaved on them ( the figure is on the flag) it can not be a coincidence it must be the Turkish culture heritance.
Ofcourse that symbol is an ancient Turkic heritage from Bulgar ancestors of Chuvash!
@@Apistoleon Bolgar, not Bulgar
@@precursors it is the same thing. bulgars is used for the old peoples not present day bulgarians which are unrelated
pretty cool video man, I'm learning Turkish right now and am interested in how different it is from Turkish compared to other Turkic languages just from hearing and reading.
Thank you. I wish I had the chuvash manual. I am currently learning kazakh.
Why am I watching this, I’m a Chuvash myself and I know everything. Great video anyway)
P.S. There are 8 main cases in the Chuvash language
And not šivrE but šivrA
PoyezdRa for locative, poyezdPa for instrumental
Also has a negation particle ан (AN), used for the imperative mood.Example ан кил (an kil') - do not come
You can hear an example of spoken Chuvash on the I Love Languages ! channel on TH-cam , complete with an English translation and transliteration from the Cyrillic .
I just found out Daniil Orain of 1420 channel is from the Chuvash minority in Russia, and that sparked my curiosity.
I was wondering because he does some videos in Chuvashia
Very informative . Thank you for sharing.
Thanks a lot mate, subscribed. Great work. Sana ve uzaktaki kardeslerimize kucak dolusu selamlar.
in kazakh we actually say more similar to chuvash, we add -рақ (-raq), -рек (-rek), so we would say uzın + raq = uzınıraq
Lenin was chuvash
Ancestry*
It is amazing in Turkey it is Bahçe and in Chauvash they say Pahça, that is Arabic influence because in Arabic we don't have the letter P, so Pepsi is Bebsi, Problem is broblem 😅 upgrade is ubgrade.
What's the name of the song in the intro?
As a proud representative of Chuvashs I have to consent that your pronunciation is definitely Turkish, nor Chuvash :)
His pronunciation is definitely not Turkish either, more like an American trying to pronounce Turkish vowels
You and the Japanese woman who played an Alevi poem on a bağlama are the only two Turkaboos that exist in the world and I don't know how to feel about it. Great video btw
which japanese woman? Can you provide a link please
@@AsylumDaemon th-cam.com/video/Rcoe6K8fV1U/w-d-xo.htmlfeature=shared
Dude your hair is fabulous! Also are u American?
Chuvash sounds or seems nothing similar to Turkic Languages actually. As a native Turkish speaker, when I hear or see something written in any Turkic languages, I can understand a certain percentage of it. If it is a geographically closer language the percentage is higher and if the contrary, my percentage of things I can catch is lower, which makes the whole language family a dialect continuum, I suppose. But in the Chuvash case, my percentage is very close to zero. Word roots, suffixes etc sound quite unfamiliar, but I feel like I am hearing some Hungarian or Finnic words. Are linguists really sure that Chuvash is a Turkic language? Chuvashia is relatively close to Turkiye, and the Chuvash language seems to break down Dialect Continuum situation among the Turkic languages. Thanks for the video
Interesting to see someone so interested in a smaller language, but much less interesting to see so many mistakes in such a short timeframe
OMG WHAT'S THE NAME OF THE INTRO SONG????
th-cam.com/video/H2oK_5lPjPo/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/n9FBdUr2EgM/w-d-xo.html
Chuvash folk song - Piren Ajakpa Shyv Juhaty
Thanks a lot buddy
This song belongs to guests song genre.
In fact, this is not a song but different songs with one melody. Chuvash folk rests on aphoristic poetry - one verse contains a completed idea and meaning.
And, the melody is in E pentatonic scale.
Avan-ı!
Аван-ха! Халсем мӗнле?
Салам! Hi from Chuvashia
pronunciation is a bit off but nice video
Just FYI, Tuesday just has a regular old /tʃ/, no idea where you got the /tɕ/ thing from 😂
im also a turkaboo
2:30 ты чего-то попутал!
санан капща пур и?
Малтан хӑвӑнине пурсӑра кӑтарт-ха унтан хӑтланса пӑхӑпӑр 😅
@@Tarai так у меня нет капщи(
@@victoricus1шыраквн тупать тет! 😂
@@Tarai эсе хамар ял что ли?
@@victoricus1 пулмасӑр! Кам-кам тата кунта чӑвашла ҫыратех, э? Робот мар-ҫке :)
Wait... CHUVASH IS TURKIC!? I THOUGHT IT WAS N A T I V E A M E R I C A N LIKE N A V A J O
i got it confused too but apparently the native american group is chumash
Chuvash descendants of Attila's Huns
Promo'SM 🌟
Мы,чуваши, не тюрки и язык у нас не тюркский.Не надо нас сравнивать с тюрками и с тюркскими языками.Это тюркские языки произошли на основе чувашского языка(Марр Н.Я). А в тюркскую языковую группу ученые-лингвисты загнали чувашский язык как КОМПРОМИССНЫЙ ВАРИАНТ в споре о принадлежности чувашского языка к какой-либо языковой группе.
Почему вы не хотите считаться тюрками? Что же в этом плохого? Я считаю, чуваши и казанские татары были единым народом - древними Болгарами. Салям!
Чуваши и казанские татары никогда не были единым народом! Болгары - это чуваши! А казанские татары - это кыпчаки.Татары к болгарам никакого отношения не имеют.И не пытайтесь примазываться со своим золотоордынским исламом.Татары ислам приняли только в Золотой Орде! Татары только и уничтожили все болгарское и истребляли болгар(чувашей)@@SiimplyZ03YV
@@ВалерийСтоляров-ы7п интересная точка зрения. я понимаю Вас, как бы это грустно не звучало, но Вы считаете что Казанские татары и чуваши имеют разное происхождение. Допустим, все что мы знали и читали было просто байками. Но где и как можно больше узнать о правдивой истории чувашей? Если только Чуваши древние Булгары, тогда получается это именно вы кто принял Ислам так рано в истории народов- 10м веке. Я правильно понимаю?
Не надо изобретать велосипед. Давно уже всё доказано. Чувашский- тюркский язык булгарской ветви.
Русский язык явно отупляет людей. "Чувашский язык не тюркский, но тюркские языки произошли от чувашского". Что ты несешь?
Чувашский язык очевидно тюркский язык. Причем разница между чувашским и любым тюркским языком во много раз меньше чем, например, между многими индо-европейскими языками.
Чуваши если мы ходим понять кто такие Чуваш , Чуваш это прежде всего язык , ни какой язык даже близко не подходит к этому языку , потому что этот язык - живой язык которой имеет свою веру . Человек который владеет верой Чувашского языка никогда не скажет что он Тюрк , тюрк это низшая который подчиняется религию животного . Человек верующий веру Чувашского языка он Туранец истиный Турок , владеющий силой ТуРАна . Туранец это высшая раса - жизнь деревьев , которыми владели Хунну они владели Суварской верой развивались через три солнца . Мустафа Кемаль и Ленин они не подчинялись религию животного они понимали веру Туранцев , Веру которую сегодня наше осознанность не может распознать .
любой, кто возвышает себя или кого-то другого за счёт принижения других, особенно относительно нации или расы - достоин если не презрения и потешания, то вразумления
Будьте человеком, долой невежество и человеконенавистничество
Гитлер так же говорил
@@russianyoutube Гитлер жил как человек , а не как животное , не быть рабом . Виновен не тот кто делает , виновен тот кто позволяет делать . Спасибо за вашу противодействие и извините что унизил ваше осознанность.
A goddam mess of an "in-depth analysis". Impossible to follow. You really should redo it after a lot of -- this time in depth -- study.
To me it seemed quite well structured
@@LangXplorer I don't mean the parts with grammar rules and phonetics but the whole intro that lacks any structure