Anand Ranganathan Fires At Modi Govt Time to Own History Instead of Blaming Historians, J Sai Deepak
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 มี.ค. 2024
- ❤️ kindly consider supporting us - rzp.io/l/Supportclearcutt
Your contributions help us Fund in Spreading the Word to More people ! 🙏
Video Credit 🔗 : PTC
🚀 Don't Want to miss any Video updates ? Join our community -
✅ Join WhatsApp Community - whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaJ3...
✅ Join Our Telegram Community - t.me/clearcuttalksdiscussion
In this compelling video, JNU Professor Anand Ranganathan delivers a scathing critique aimed at the Modi government's approach to history. With a focus on the contentious relationship between historical narratives and political agendas, Ranganathan delves into the pitfalls of blaming historians for the propagation of fake historical narratives. He argues passionately that it's time for the Modi government to take ownership of historical discourse rather than resorting to scapegoating.
Drawing attention to recent events and the discourse surrounding them, Ranganathan dissects the implications of virtue signaling within political spheres, particularly concerning historical interpretations. He highlights the dangers of allowing political narratives to overshadow scholarly rigor and calls for a reevaluation of the government's role in shaping historical discourse.
Furthermore, Ranganathan critiques the recent speech by renowned historian William Dalrymple, providing insightful commentary on the complexities of historical interpretation and its intersection with contemporary politics. Through his astute analysis, he sheds light on the responsibilities of both historians and policymakers in ensuring the integrity of historical narratives.
Whether you're a student of history, a political enthusiast, or simply interested in the intersection of academia and governance, this video offers thought-provoking insights that will stimulate meaningful discussions. Join the conversation as Anand Ranganathan challenges conventional wisdom and advocates for a more nuanced approach to understanding and shaping our collective past. Don't miss out on this enlightening discourse - watch now!
[Disclaimer] ⭐
This video has been reposted for educational and informational purposes . All credit for the creation of this content goes to its original owner . We do not claim ownership of any materials used in the making of this video . If you are the rightful owner of the content and wish for it to be removed or credited differently, please contact us immediately. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation .
Related Keywords - 📥
Myth Busted by J Sai Deepak Ganga Jamuni Tezheeb debates Mythology debunked Religious discussion Indian cultural heritage Secularism India Debunking religious misconceptions Unity diversity Historical myths clarified Outsider Hindu caste Hinduism system Intersectionality Social hierarchy Caste discrimination views Challenges Breaking Identity society speeches debate legal analysis Ayodhya verdict womens rights theories constitutional law savage moments thug life sabarimala lawyer interview caa arth Owaisi book speech sabarimala talk dharma sangam talks srijan rana sanga sanjay dixit kumari sanatan dharma balochistan bengal riots oceanography vikram sampath new historian release exclusive times now india today conclave author festival savarkar romila thapar gyanvapi masjid survey mosque gyanwapi controversy varanasi banaras shivling history ASI
💰 Support Us : pages.razorpay.com/supportclearcutt
Subscribe Our Backup Channel - youtube.com/@veer2024?si=VcvyIOrkI3QyC88Y
Your generous contributions help us expand our reach and spread the word to more people ! Thank you ! 🙏
🚀 Stay Updated : Don't want to miss any video updates?
💬 Join Our Community :
WhatsApp Channel : whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaJ3N2vBVJlAKI1Z2p3b
Telegram Community : t.me/clearcuttalksdiscussion
Hindus need not be patient, force politicians to free temples in the first place .
An eye opener for all hindus.. 🙏🙏
Brilliant discussion. AR hits the nail on the head everytime he speaks.
U nailed it Sir....Hindus really had high hopes n trust while voting #BJP to absolute majority but eventually it turned into #BharatiyaJimmyParty with their topmost leader became complete M apologiser n saviour
Amazing insights.
Its time we call spade a spade.
Very successive, development oriented, visionary PM Shri Narendra Modi Sir restlessly working for the well being of the people. Some quotes might have surprised and seemed to be quite opposite. In one decade he has done Tremendous works. Other works, Shri Anand Sir expecting, needs 400+ majority. Coming tenure these works also will be completed. Please be ready prepared new list of works Sir. Common man's voice is reaching to our Honourable Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi Sir. Your voice in the top of priority list Sir.
Anand Ranganathan is a black sheep. He is hard core leftist urban naxals type planted as a Hindu well-wisher
Anand Ranganathan is a leftist black sheep atheist posing as friends of Hindu. I appreciate time he will spread his fang
The speech that J Sai Deepak and especially Vivek Agnihotri ( Kashmir files director) gave during this session shook me to the core.
BJP members don't exactly know the exact history with proper facts and reasoning. But it's time to get educated. Everyone must get educated. We must ask questions. File PIL for the crimes all over India without considering any kind of boundaries
Focus on Temples is the Main Character of new Bharat 🙏🙏🕉️🔯🔱
We Sanatanis should unitedly pressurise government to make free our temples from clasp of the government.
Problem with Hindus is when we say we are sanatanis and we should be united ... Then the drama starts on caste and talk about all nonsense of higher caste and lower caste , Dalits and non Dalits or OBC ... The biggest divider of the country is OBC who are all included in the catagory of SC& ST by politicians for vote bank.. Take all benefit of quota ...but they get angry when you call them SC or ST ... They are the people who divide Hindus or Sanatanis ... not Brahmins or Dalits .
The duo, Lawer J Sai Deepak and Dr Anand Ranganathan. 🔥
The solutions are to be crafted out of the existing system.
Modernization of existing Temples is essential.
Savage Ranga Sir ❤❤❤❤
You are a blessed being by universe. Hoope you are grateful to up there. It's a very pleasant and delightful to hear you. You and Sai, great, salute to both of you. On the last point you said, even sai is incorrect, you are right.
Politicians are the root cause of all problems in India, it is high time people should determine what they want and do not allow these people to decide for us.
What about you?
Based on "Nature & Tacticts"
- Discovery cuIt is like Vampire
- Jehadi cuIt is like warewolf
*Both feeding on indigenous population of the world for more than 1,000 years...
- Comrad cuIt is like "Joker" of movie Batman - uses twisted phrases/ jargons to do the same thing...
BJP doesn't have good opposition, we need to have ppl like AR to critique current government.
Sahi pakde hai
Clearly said Dr.Anand, people to be made aware of facts at common man level.
Lot to happen Dr.Anand, politicians to do everything needed, after ensuring people are made aware of the facts, from making history books reflecting facts to resolution of status quo overall.
As a common man, an indian, a hindu, I say, we are awaiting..., but this has to be with a pragmatic timeline
Agree with your points totally.
Anand ,Sai, Upadhyay, kulshrestha n others will change the going .... We know ABT Akbar is din illahi ... What destruction he has done , no one wrote.
Patience is not a virtue. Fine. But moving certain elephants is not easy.
Social and political changes occur due to the broad support from the society only with astute leadership who know how much to speak bluntly and where to articulate with care to avoid giving chance to opponents to attack. They have to negotiate their path often in resisting social and political establishment to acquire the necessary power to implement their agenda.
Intellectuals will be dishonest if they behave like politicians and no politicians will be in power of they begin to behave like intellectuals.
Both have different roles to play for safety with reforms in society.
I agree with ranga sir about the quotes by our PM.
Anand & Sai Deepak respect & enjoy your talks but there are times you need to put yourself into PM’s boots & think what you can do. First issue had to be the economy so that people feel more confident of the govt & allow changes though being challenged at each & every step in Courts?? We need to know Modi better, have seen him as CM in Gujarat, to know that he works with his own time table. His planning is excellent. We gave congress 60yrs to mess up, to get the country out of it, Govt has to carefully but surely tread with NO scope of any future Govt rolling back or creating problems
Bharat never really got independence.The Brit dingleberries planned well. Their's wasn't a hasty exit from Bharat. They had their proxies well in place,much before 1947. Things seem to be improving in the past 10 years. It's a long road ahead. Jai Bharat !
❤fantastic ❤
First thing first people have to understand that any thing published by "an individual author inclined to an idealogy May NOT be true " and "any thing available in internet may also be NOT true always '
Let's hope things will be better after 2024 election
Politicians have compulssion not to hurt anybody and lust to please opposite bench. Modi's talk was formal and showing circumstantial etiqueetes.
You can never be formal and support evil at any circumstances.
First Chief o CVC ( Central Vigilance Commission ) said --- We can wake up people who are sleeping , we can not wake up people who are pretending to be sleeping .. Entire political class know whatever they are doing is not right YET they do it WHY ? Vote bank politics
A humble request to the owner or admin of this channel is that please if u can use a multi lingual subtitle option for this channel because in my study there are many people willing to listen to such debate and get ideas but not so much or at all comfortable on reading, writing or speaking English, even for their idealistic and their own ethical reason they refuse to participate in English language created content of this kind....this request is personal and fully judgemental on wider range of execution.
I am saying this for a conventional reason.
Where we all get benefits out of this.
Narendra Modiji wants to take Noble price now that's all
Modi and entire RSS need to be reschooled in history.
BRITISH had vested interest in dividing HINDUS in the lines of caste etc.. BUT I wonder why politicians do the same thing ?.. The Answer is VOTE BANK politics -- Today in Karnataka Lokasabha BJP seat ticket distribution is 200 % based on caste .. Which is very blatant and ugly .. Simple people like me are totally disappointed with the manner in which BJP handled the ticket distribution - MERIT is thrown out of the window -- SON / DAUGHTER / DAUGHET IN LAW / WIFE / SECOND SON / SON's Father in LAW etc.. are the virtues of ticket distribution -- Most of the people are talking BJP ticket as " Family Ticket " as if they inherited the political power . This is very very bad .. If so called THINKING POLITCIAL party BJP does these things so blatantly , perhaps GOD SAVE BHARAT .. Need of the hour is immediate revamp of Representation of people act - 1951 and bring in Merit in to it -- HOW ? Ask me -- I have beautiful Innovative Ideas on this subject
Yes it’s high time to make the changes. After after 10 years it’s no more a time to blame
Modi after taking maximum votes from Hindu just to become politically more correct he did maximum Muslim appeasement somehow more than Gandhi and Nehru.
Modi should haven't not been quoted by words against Maulana. Maulana and Nehru jointly damaged our history and culture.
Political compulsions drive say such words( which common man despise ) which PM says because of the position he holds.
BJP spent too much time on construction of 5 crores TOILETS . While that is an achievement by itself , this should not be at the cost of other structural changes to be brought in .. for example : Prevention of Corruption act is toothless act which perhaps passed to enhance corruption it appears.. Representation of people Act - 1951 is jaded to the core .. The officials of ECI is tired always conducting too many By elections and Assembly election all the time .. Need massive change in election system BJP government with 303 MPs could have done a lot to clean up election system BUT not done. Voters had high hopes on massive change on war footing .. That did not come through -- LAND AQUISITION ACT stalled , Farmers BILL stalled , CAA is slowly limping now ,
One by one you and Sai and Vishnu and Sampath and Sanniyal and .... are bringing down the falsehood created around Nehru and company on India. All the best to you all and for Bharat.
This guy do nothing other than coming into media and gather attention. How many books he had wrote to change history, just did a copy paste job to created 200 page document and call it a book. People like us also write 300 to 500 page contract letters in a week or two, then we can be more bigger complainant than him.
You are educated but you didn't understand Chanakya Niti or Sukra Niti. Neither you understand Narendra Modi.
Honestly, if in future any one other than BJP form government in lndia again, and finish the Hindus freedom, it is because of you people. Mark my words
Communist Party come manifasto convert hone ke liye taiyar ho jao
We don’t have access to the govt but u guys have contact with politicians like sudhanshu! Modi kitna bhi development kar le ! Miya vote nahi dega! Mark my words! Not even 1%!
then communal violence full is waiting for you
It is a historical message that call when Akbar was in power Grand Mansingh was thinking in the same way