Qasr and Combining Prayers | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi | Q&A #23
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.พ. 2020
- East Plano Islamic Center Masjid
Please Donate at www.epicmasjid.org/donate/
www.epicmasjid.org
/ epic.masjid
/ epicmasjid
------------------------------------------------------------------------
EPIC is a multi-ethnic, multi-racial, multi-lingual, non-sectarian, diverse, and open community committed to full and equal participation and involvement of men and women who are community members of EPIC and subscribe to accept its rules, regulations, and procedures. EPIC is committed to civic and civil engagement with communities of other faiths and society at large.
All of its activities are in accordance with the teachings of the Quran and following the teachings and traditions of Prophet Mohammed ﷺ (Peace Be upon Him).
Combining Prayer - 27:18
Many of us benefit from these detailed, exhaustive answers which you have meticulously researched so please do not shorten these Q&A videos. Jazakallah
Yes totally agree, the detailed analysis gives me the understanding; excellent way of doing it.
But it's not like his research is complete, when he talked about the Hanafi position of 15 days, he missed a crucial evidence; a narration in the Kitab ul Athar of Imam Abu Hanifah in which he narrates with his chain from Ibn Umar (RA) that said that if you are a musafir, and plan on staying 15 days then complete your salah (don't do qasr). He made Hanafis sound like idiots.
The longer the video EPIC and Shk YQ give us, the happier I am. Keep talking, keep posting insha’Allah.
true
I'm a truck driver and this helped me so much elhumdullah
Never a scholar has made Islamic matters as clearly as you do, as rigorously as you do and as sensibly as you do that I can find anywhere in the planet. Thanks and regards
I agree with you absolutely!
Ya allah! Much love shaykh yasir qadhi. My mind was a blank canvas regarding this topic and the shaykh painted a vibrant, vivid, colorful 3D picture that brought this fiqh to life
We should appreciate the shaykh for taking 45 minutes of his time to explain to us a ruling of our Shariah. He could easily give us the short answer, but he wants us to understand. I'm actually enjoying these lectures very much.
Jazakhallah Khairan
Thank you for posting this every week and giving in depth explanation sheyk.
Ok
Excellent and logical analysis , guided by teachings of our religion. Totally support you yq; it’s a shame if people are criticising your truthful and educational approach. May Allah soften their hearts and open their hearts to a deep understanding of our beautiful religion; and may Allah sw forgive and guide us if we are in the wrong. Tolerating other people’s opinion in a polite and dignified way is the key. Exactly how our beloved sheikh yasir qadhi does. May Allah give him jaza for the excellent work that he is doing.
I travel a lot , several times a year often for less than 3 days. This has been very helpful for me. Thank you for helping us follow our deen properly.
Yasir Qadhi failed to mention a narration in kitab Al Athar of Abu Hanifah that Ibn Umar (RA) said that if you are a musafir but plan on staying for 15 days than complete the salah (don't do qasr).
Jazakallah Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadi. I love you for your openness about opinions of all Madhabs / Shaykhs; state what you lean towards or follow and leave it on an individual to follow whatever he/she prefers. Alhamdulillah, I am following you from past 9 yrs, I couldn't ever felt you mocked any shaykh/'s. It is not unIslamic to call spade a spade and truth is beyond & above anyone. May Allah reward you immensely for every misunderstood comment of yours. On a lighter note, Shk YQ, do you still love your Mocha?? 😊
Allah Bless you brother .. Masha Allah!!
You too
Exactly what am looking for!!!
Thank you.❤💚💙
I did not know lot of things before watching this video. Jazhakallahu Khairan
Thank you for the knowledge sharing
Jazakallahu khairan shaikh.. as always amazing work. I know that behind the hour and a half you spent talking, there were many more hours spent doing the required research and preparing. May Allah reward you Shaikh for the work, and further increase your ability.. ameen
Masha Allah, I love your lecture Dr.YQ.you go into so much detail and explain in an excellent manner
Excellent explanation
Allah u akbar
Sheikh your tangents are legendary
Jazakallah ya Syekh
jazakAllah khayr shaykh
Very informative and detailed lecture. Regarding combing prayers during the state of Hazr (35:36) there are AHadeeth in Sahih Muslim (1633, 1634, 1635, 1636 and 1637) in addition to the reference from Tirmidhi you mentioned in this session.
JazakaAllahu
Amazing
👍JazakAllahukhairan
jazakAllah shaykh i always admire your effort to connect us with our islamic heritage and different interpretations.may Allah reward you and us all jannah.
One of the Best Voices i want to Hear.....
I like ur Voice Sheikh...
May Allah bless you and accept ur Hardwork....
Top talk Alhamdulillah I’m travelling across borders a lot 🎉 and living out of a suitcase
I believe he said he will do about islamic home buying. I emailed him once on it. I’m eagerly awaiting. Jazakallah
👍👍
السلآم عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Qasr is mustahab, its in sunnah, its the default (rewarded for praying 2). Done when travelling.
Qasr begins when you travel outside of the walls of the city, you've left the premise of your city.
If musafar is praying behind iman, you must follow the iman. If musafar is leading (i.e the iman), you need to pray the four (extra 2 rakat). But to not confuse the congregation, sometimes it's best the iman prays 4.
How long do you do qasr for?
- A) if you are residing in some place and each day presents possibly of you leaving that day (e.g. In case of war for the sahabat, awaiting when flight will be booked by airline), you can do qasr for as long as needed
- B) what about if you know how long you are staying (e.g. 5 days). There are lots of opinions on this (over 20)
As Salam alikum, could you also please give an explanation about Halal Meat i.e. machine cut v/s hand cut. Jazak Allah
Yes I like the waz and wazer Dr MD Yasir Qadir He is the best wazer in the Quran and muslin world. Please discusses me sura ayth number.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته.
Can you give hadith number for all this specially for jama'a (that illness)
جزأك الله الخير.
Salam
For Hanafis, residency is 15 days or more. Not 16 days or more. And Allah knows best.
Can we do jamaa after we travel by plane?
Which group YQ meant when he said that they allowed "free for all" around 80s (around 44 min)?
saniahsan The Shaykh is talking about Salafism in the 80s, which harshly criticized Madahib, leading to, in the Shaykhs words “A free for all”.
There are many places in India where specially for a woman it's difficult to find a place to pray as you know 99% people are hanafis and they don't allow women inside the mosque nor there is any provision like having small prayer rooms in the shopping malls like in other countries then isn't it better to pray zuhr and asr together? Isn't it better to combine than to leave the prayer altogether? There are many instances where we have to leave home and we get stuck or we know we won't get back home sooner and surely we will miss the salah. Why can't we use this hadees once in a while in these scenarios? Don't you realise the situation is different in non Muslim majority countries?
Absolutely love and respect shaikh yq, but I humbly disagree with the statement that prayers should only be combined if there is an obvious reason. He said that he doesn’t want to open this door. Well, the door was opened by prophet sw himself in the saheeh Hadith he mentioned. I agree that the message should be that the preferred way is not to combine prayers but if someone wants to do it for no apparent reason then he does have the example of prophet sw himself. Of course prophet sw did not combine prayers generally and we should follow that but we can use the ease that prophet sw gave us if we want, otherwise what was the point of prophet sw combining the prayers without a reason.
Asalamoalaikum, one more question Sheikh Yasir, what if you are staying at your son, daughter, brothers or your parents house. A person can do Qasar then too..?
I understand qasr for travelling for work but what about when we travel for recreational purposes... what is the ruling of qasr
Why do some muslims hate Dr. Yasir Qadhi? I dont understand. Can someone tell me?
Because he actually makes sense and uses facts
Im soooo confused! I just want to know what I have to pray if I've left my country and travel every 4 days from one city to another.
You combine dhuhr and asr and maghrib you can pray with isha fajr is not combined you pray it alone this shortening of prayers is for travellers and you go to a place your mind your not settled your not very comfortable i hope this helps
@@zenanassor7186 Zena Nassor Thank you Zena. Just to confirm. I combine Dhuhr+Asr+Magrib? Isha & Fajr are prayed separate?
No you combine dhuhr and asr you can pray dhuhr and asr at the time of dhuhr that is one way or you can pray asr with dhuhr at the time of asr prayer either way as for maghrib you can pray maghrib with isha or pray isha and maghrib at the time of isha whatever works for you as for Fajr you are not suppose to combine it with any prayer it is prayed alone
Basically you can combine dhuhr and asr and combine maghrib and isha as for fajr pray it alone hope you have undesrstand?
FAJR PRAY ALONE
DHUHR WITH ASR
MAGHRIB WITH ISHA
Please Dr answer my question that I missed many of my Farz namaz during my school and college days Can I offer my previous Farz namaz after offering my daily present Farz namaz as Qiza namaz
What about Sunnah prayers sheikh , can we pray them with kasr or you can’t pray them while travelling? Jazaka Allah khayran
inshAllah would like to ask this , one learned Mufti from Pakistan , is claiming that there are no solid evidence for men and women Sal ah to be the same, and there are differences, can Sh Ya sir Qadi clarify this issue please ? JazakAllahukhair
Sheikh avoided the position that is also prevelant that qasr is wajib, for some reason
I travel to my work place every week on sunday night, stay there for four days and back to home on thursday night, Im I allowed to both combine and short prayers ? or i am allowed to Qasr only ?
In first video he addresses this case, someone who regularly and consistently travels for work. I believe he said you're not allowed to do jama'a qasr. Though I recommend you watch it yourself. He addresses it in the later half of the video.
I am a train driver working in one city but sometimes I am driving for 3-4hrs straight, is it permissible to combine prayers if I cannot pray during the prescribed time as I am physically on the train and cannot stop?
Exact same here, also working as train driver in one city. i do combine the prayers like some of my other colleagues. I do this as per hadith.
@@dannish2000 what hadith bro?
@@EsoTarek i will get back to you with hadith my brother InshaAllah! It's a hadith by Abu Hurayra (ra)
If you speak Urdu language, you should listen to Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza on TH-cam, highly recommended, he only speaks with guidance of Quran and Sunnah.
May Allah make it easier for you my brother! ♥️
@@dannish2000 ameen, you too my brother. Unfortunately I don't understand Urdu. What city are you in by the way?
Assalamu Alaykom wa'rahmatullahi wa'barakatuho ! What we called it is Qasar or JAMA? What's the intention for this Sallah? Jazakamullahu Khayr !
Aslamualeikum Warahmatullahi Wabrakatuhu. What's the condition of Qadar Namaj. Did the Nabi Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam prayed Qasar namaj in every journey. Which sura in Quran says about Qasar Namaj and it's conditions. Meanwhile in Umrah and Haj why we don't pray Qasar. Pl clarify
What about going for an internship out of state, for two months? Would that be Qasr.
4 days is the majority opinion. If you introspect you sincerely you will inshallah know what to do. my advise would be no to qasr if you're gone that long.
Can sick ummah do qasr for obligatory prayers.Two qasr for zohor and two qasr asar combine to zohor. Is this allowable?
No, qasr is for travel, not sickness
How does one contact him?
can one pray qasr without jama'
eg one has done zuhr before beginning safar/travel. but begins it before asar.
can one now do asar as qasr by itself?
jzkllh
What about three weeks stay?
I’m truck drivers
Can I Qesr my prayers ?
what if your muslims boss doesn't allow you to pray ? strictly no pray between dhur - asr ? every single day.
Hi
Hi
Hi
Please don’t read online critics, people are hiding behind their screens and openly criticizing from their ignorance.
It’s not even worth to read them.
Take care 👍
He must b crazy out of he’s mind
People don't have 45 minutes to listen to a video regarding fiqh? This is one of the problems in our community. You can't take out 45 minutes out of your precious time to listen to what the Shaykh has meticulously researched. That is SAD. Do it on the way to work or on your way to pick up the kids, it's not that hard.
Unfortunately, people are so used to getting info right away without realizing that Islamic issues are not that easy without giving a preface and historical context
Wallahi this is crazy, ppl can watch 10hours netflix but not a 45min about Islam. As for me I'm eagerly waiting for the q&a videos every week Alhamdulillah
Or even break it up throughout the day. You don't need to listen to it all at once.
I live in Canada ,sometimes I am waiting for yasir Qadhi video until midnight. may Allah grant him paradise
@@aminpop6674 ameen
nice video and information☺,but☺,dont say "namaz",it is supposed to be said to be "salaah" in every language as my knowledge😁.for my knowledge,you cant say that😊.but still research it a LOT😊.let me know if i am wrong☺
Brother, if its allowed to combine prayers without any excuse, then please site an evidence for an excuse to combine, otherwise don't insert your own speculation. If it has been made easy, don't try to make it difficult. You have no right to open or close a door, when it has already been opened in Islam. to combine prayers without an excuse..
No! Read Al Quran (2:101-103) again! Qasr (shortening) prayer is only when you are in fear of an enemy attack. Not when you feel secure; then you should perform regular prayer. In the context of shortening prayer, the definition of Safar has nothing to do with number of days or distance traveled. It simply is when you are in fear of an attack from an enemy; then you shorten prayer while carrying arms, on high alert! Read the Quran!
But there is soo many holes in the narrative and 27 different qurans
Sheikh when you talked about the Hanafi position of 15 days, you missed a crucial evidence; a narration in the Kitab ul Athar of Imam Abu Hanifah in which he narrates with his chain from Ibn Umar (RA) that said that if you are a musafir, and plan on staying 15 days then complete your salah (don't do qasr). You made Hanafis sound like idiots.
There is no qazr where there is no danger to you. You can pray one salah & after the other following prayer. Pray dohr 4 rak'a then followed by azar 4 rak'a. Follow the Quran & not the hadith of men. Hadith is a blasphemy by one making the statement or narrations other than the Quran & an idolatry to one who believes in that hadith not in the Quran. Qasr is clear only in time of danger in time of Prophet Muhammad pbuh an his companions in a state of war. When you are not in a state of danger or battle to pray 4 rak'a & 4 rak'a. Why follow those people when their opinion is not in the Quran. Do not mislead people of your learning not in the Quran. Why follow those Hanbali,Maliki, et al.? Where in the Quran Allah swt says of Hadiths to believe in other than the Quran? Read Quran 69:44-47 & 7:3. Astagfirullah! Subhanallah! Allahu'akbar!
to your quieston, koran tells us "atti ullah wa atti ur rasool. most important is to pray for wisdom which from your enthusiastic text seems to be missing, these people have spent years of there youth to study the rules and regulations in-depth of our religion, do not be so flippant and with a cavalier attitude towards the message of the educators.
may ALLAH give us hikma
May allah guide you
Do you know the meaning of Hadith? Hadith is not invented by the sahabas or men like you claimed. Hadith is an act what is said and done by Prophet Muhammad (saw) , if you are denying the hadith then you are denying Allah’s messenger and his message. Thus leads to disbelief. Beware of what you spout