ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- Comparing With samples, voice-overs and ambient tests. cristal clear quality sound recorders, wind muff test, dead cat
UK Zoom H1n recorder amzn.to/3D4Utii
USA Zoom H1n recorder amzn.to/3E7ppzD
UK Tascam DR-05X amzn.to/3DayOFy
USA Tascam DR-05X amzn.to/3lhBD1j
UK Microphone Isolation Shield amzn.to/3I2Xqn9
USA Microphone Isolation Shield amzn.to/3rjOhAw
UK Microphone Stand amzn.to/3o2n1of
USA Microphone Stand amzn.to/3CYShIV
Some of my other kit (affiliate links)
UK Sony SELP1650 E Mount - APS-C 16-50mm amzn.to/31XYSTu
USA Sony SELP1650 E Mount - APS-C 16-50mm amzn.to/31SPzEp
UK Sony E PZ 18-105 mm f/4.0 G amzn.to/3kN7yF6
USA Sony E PZ 18-105 mm f/4.0 G amzn.to/3g3e5rs
UK 35mm F1.6 APS-C Television TV Lens amzn.to/2DdEUvR
USA 35mm F1.6 APS-C Television TV Lens amzn.to/3b8OfS9
UK Zecti 144leds Camera Video Light amzn.to/31Xj1cm
USA Neewer Dimmable 176 LED amzn.to/3g0EuGj
UK Neewer Dimmable 176 LED amzn.to/3kOknis
UK RGB LED Video Camera Light, 3200K to 5600K amzn.to/3kPTIll
USA RGB LED Video Camera Light amzn.to/31UdWBI
USA Weeylite RB08P 20 effects amzn.to/2DWWKmX
UK Weeylite RB08P 20 effects amzn.to/2PVQvCq
UK Smooth Q Gimbal amzn.to/2Y3tDFq
USA Smooth Q Gimbal amzn.to/3kPtJu0
UK Sony 55mm - 210 amzn.to/2Y2dT5H
USA Sony 55mm - 210 amzn.to/3kLiYZO
UK Camera & both lenses amzn.to/31Yf86W
USA Camera & both lenses amzn.to/340KQ6d
UK Sony A6100 amzn.to/2COeAb0
USA Sony A6100 amzn.to/30yjlxF
UK Zhiyun Weebill S amzn.to/2CvQ8eH
USA Zhiyun Weebill S amzn.to/3eMAdpl
UK Tascam Dr-05x amzn.to/30z6GKZ
USA Tascam Dr-05x amzn.to/2CRY0aa
UK Camera Bag amzn.to/2DbtdVP
USA Camera Bag amzn.to/2EgVWsV
UK Movo SMM5-R Universal Shock Mount amzn.to/3jmDLSM
USA Movo SMM5-R Universal Shock Mount amzn.to/2CzbWGn
UK Boya Universal Cardoid Microphone amzn.to/2Czd10T
USA Boya Universal Cardoid Microphone amzn.to/3eLuobK
UK Red shock mount amzn.to/2CP2IWn
USA Red shock mount amzn.to/39iS06r
UK Recorder wind muff amzn.to/30u0x2C
USA Recorder wind muff amzn.to/30uh9Hs
THIS IS HOW REVIEWS should be!
Directly to the point. No intros, talking a lot and such.
This is awesome. Thank you for making this! Why aren't all audio recording products doing this kind of comparison, it's way more valuable than hearing someone talk for 15 minutes about pros and cons through their own computer mic and not the actual products themselves! And with matching saucy eyebrow raises, haha. You're a freaking genius. :)
Well Thank you Lisa
Hahaha you nailed it and even mentioned the eyebrow raises :P
The noise level (the hissing) is higher for Zoom, I would say. Tascam is more quite in terms of noise. Thank you for this review.
I do love the tascam
I prefer Tascam DR-05X because:
1. Better sound quality.
2. More features.
3. AA battery instead of AAA, much more endurance.
4. Bigger screen.
5. Sturdier plastic body compared to Zoom H1N.
Trade off:
1. A little more expensive.
2. Bigger and less nice looking compared to Zoom H1N.
But if it is true that Tascam DR-05X has radio interference, then it ruins everything and I better go with Zoom H1N.
Does it have 2 inputs?
@@PerfectNormal Yes, it does
I think both have interference.
Just put your phone on airplane mode when recording.
No, Zoom has more realistic details and more natural sound
Awesome vídeo, TASCAM has more rich sound and less noise all the way.
Agreed
Tascam sounds pretty smooth and less noisy. Good job for a company that's been around since they cornered the market for four-track cassette tape recorders in the 70's (and 60s). Also, to be honest, the design of the Tascam looks more sleek. The Zoom looks a little hoakey! The Zoom is a neat, compact unit, but in the end, you were going to record guitar, or some quick emergency vocals, i'd want to be recording on the Tascam!
I'm so glad this video found me. Thank you for making this.
Just to mention it, I believe the Tascam has omnidirectional mics (a/b, or kinda pseudo a/b think?) and the Zoom has cartioids set up x/y. This may contribute to the timber and stereo image differences. Omnis are less susceptible to proximity effect, cartioids tend to be better for stereo imaging.
I have the dr-05x and I can't fault it. I actually bought the Zoom before and felt that it was quite cheap feeling and the handling noise was an issue for me. The dr-05x is a decent bit of kit for the price point. Definitely worth the investment. I use it for capturing organic samples mostly, but it's own interface means you can use it as a mic when you're travelling.
Do you have a problem with interference?
The Tascam has a much more noticeable timber in the vocals. Way deeper and smoother bass. I feel like the Tascam gives of a more natural and less sharp.
I have never owned a modern digital recorder. I have no brand loyalty/bias. I could definitely hear more detail/clarity in the Zoom recordings you played. But you thought the opposite? I may buy one just for fun.
The midrange and base of the Tascam is just slightly fuller sounding than the Zoom H1n. Superb comparison - thank you so much!
Thanks for the test!
The ZOOM sounds a bit better to me.
Замечательный обзор! Разнообразные образцы примеров записи. Большое спасибо))
Most interesting recorder review I have ever seen!
Thank you!
The zoom is a bit of a brighter recording than the Tascam. That's what I am hearing.
100%. Much more details.
I got the Tascam because of sound quality and extra functionality, like punch-in overdubbing and the chance to use it as an interface.
Yes it is great
Can't the Zoom be used as an interface as well?
@@goole7445 both can 😁
Incroyable ces interférences sur le tascam, c'est rédhibitoire pour moi et c'est dommage car le son y est globalement meilleur.
Merci pour ce test !!!
Well done! That is the way to do it. I do this myself :)... I hear the Zoom has far more noise, hissing per haps 4 times as much. But presents a better stereo effect ( judging the passing cars). I don't know about your gain levels but the Tascam seems outstanding sound quality...
All the stuff I needed to hear, nice suite of tests - thank you!
The Tascam interference is the showstopper - the unpredictability dooms an otherwise decent kit piece. Solid review - thx!
I will try to duplicate the interference the tascam was closer to my mobile and silly me it was only about 8 inches away
Unbelievable. This is amazing. Thank you for this 🙂. I hope I will be getting the Zoom h1 for recs. Great video comparison!
Subscribed. That double mount was clearly a brilliant idea, guaranteed a valid comparison. I had seen pictures of your voice-over device but never saw a demo. Works great and was certainly a necessity when doing the comparison. Alas, I’m old and wear an in-ear hearing aid in both ears. Can’t say I heard much of a difference with either, unfortunately. Does that mean, in your opinion, their performance is about equal? I was surprised at how well they performed outdoors recording ambient. Another reviewer leaned strongly towards a Sony device, but it costs about 4x the Zoom 4 model here near Toronto. And, those dead-cat wind suppressors really made a difference. I hope you can tell that I greatly appreciated this video.
Thank you Edward , I think it's pretty much equal , with a few cons and pros on each , both great at a great price
Excellent clear review with a pinch of humour. Love it- thank you.
These are great for band rehearsals and shows. You sound good, itll sound good.
I really like the stereo field of the zoom recorder. Seems or left right like ears. :) Thanks
agree, especially on that test with the cars approaching and honking
Superb comparison, thanks! Really helped to make decision! Tascam have more resolution to my ears, i am definitely hear more "space and details"
Super! Thank you so much!
Thank you for the comparison video. I appreciate how you would quickly go from one device to the other. I've seen other comparisons done with long sound samples, and this does not work well.
I like the sound that the Zoom produces. Its more like stereo sound for both left and right direction. The Tascam sounds like mono, and the left direction is weaker in volume ( or maybe its because my hearing has deteriorated ). With the wind muff on, the Tascam is great to be shielded from wind noise. With the wind muff on the Zoom, you can hear the wind a little, but not obnoxiously irritating.
I have tested both in a car journey at the same time , Video about interference to follow.
I posted a comment asking about interference on th H1n before I read the other comments, here. Looking forward to seeing your test. I didn't find it on your page, so could you please give us an idea when it will appear.
Thanks.
Thanks for awesome review. Real great compare
Love the accent. Its what makes us, Us.
Thanks for doing this
Thanks! Nice video!
The next time that I need to record a chef chopping vegetables, or a bartender pouring drinks, I'll be sure to get one of these recorders.
It will do the job well 😜
Awesome test. It made it easy for me to buy an audio recorder. Thank you.
You are very welcome, which one did you get ?
@@CineChi I get Zoom H1n. On my Yamaha MSP5 in your test Zoom sounded clearer. More detail of the sounds could be heard. The Tascam sounds more calm, subdued. In my music productions, when I creating samples for sampler I need sharper, closer sounds.
thanks for video! I love your voice
Tascam has got a more natural sound, the zoom h1n, which I've got for recording my singing lesson, adds a resonance which is very annoying. You can clearly hear that at 1:50.
Acoustic and rock band practice....this is a major use and you omitted it.
Oh , I'm sorry
In my opinion, Tascam sounds better with VO, but Zoom definitely wins for atmos recordings, it has a wider stereo field and more detail.
That mean to keep sound of nature it should be zoom right?
I'm new to microphone tech but my impression is that the Tascam sounds more directional, if that makes sense.
J'adore le début 😄😄😄
thks for posting!
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
You are welcome, welcome welcome
Tascam is the clear winner here imo. The Zoom is just way sharper which isn't nice to listen to
Zoom is little more crisp....Ir Tascam a tad muffled...
It would be good to show/layout settings beforehand....
Also, nowadays the Zoom is half the price of the Tascam....
Nice comparison 👍
Exactly after 10 years I am going to change Tascam DR-05 (not X version) for Zoom H1n. For years Tascam served OK, I did a lot of concert recordings (am a concert reviewer) and interviews with jazz musicians. However, this years a problem appeared, Tascam just sometimes is not able to save my recording which a a fatal failure. Why have I decided for Zoom now? I agree that Tascam may have a bit better sound quality. However, Zoom H1n looks OK in reviews, is smaller than Tascam and also cheaper. Very important matter - Zoom is interference resistant compared to Tascam. It has happened many times that my Tascam picked up the interference form a mobile phone. That really annoyed me. So, let's see how my new Zoom will work, I am going to pick it up today.
The tascam picks up more details than the room.
Great comparison!! Did you have the Limiter turned on the h1n? Because doing that brings up the noise floor on it.
Wonderful video thank you! I think this is moving me over to the Tascam camp as far as these two go - lower noise floor, and with the right headphones it sounds like the H1n has some kind of EQ that's cutting a bit of the higher end fidelity a bit. On the other hand, I wonder if the audio processing of the H1n with the effect mentioned is actually preferable with amateur videography? The audiophile in my chooses Tascam, the amateur film maker is still on the fence. .
Fantastc review. Have you tried either of these with an acoustic guitar?
I gotta say the Zoom sounds more natural and clear (not so muffled sounding) - I know others talk about noise, well yeah but I hear it as just room around and air. I just like the quality of the zoom sound better :) I guess it's about tone as much as anything. Nice video, thanks :) both are lovely amazing machines!
I also like Zoom more. Have to check samples because Tascam sounds “better“ without postprocessing, but I think this is some software trick.
Very nice video. I use a Zoom H1N recorder and I am more than satisfied with it BUT I would like to use the Tascam also...you know why...🙂
Thank you very much for your time and effort.
Thank you 😊
Hello.. You have done a detailed test, thank you.. My impression is that there is almost no bottom sound in Tascam.. Stereo separation is weak compared to Zoom, microphone sensitivity is less than Zoom.. Still, Tascam seemed to me to be of better quality, am I wrong?
I like the TASCAM DR-5X a bit more than the ZOOM H1n.
The lower tones are better recorded by the TASCAM.
The are more sensitive,. but the record-level can be turned very low.
The microfones can handel sound up to 125 dB, without deforming the sound !
I like the bigger size of the TASCAM, becouse i think the parts inside will be a bit bigger and stronger. I think that will give a bettrer sound, and make the device longer lasting.
You can record a lot more on the 128 Gb SD-card then on a 32 Gb SD-card !
You can also use the TASCAM as an interface between an analoge audio-set, and your Digital computer, without needing a 'Driver-program' !
(AD/DA-Converter, with a max sample-rate of 96 kHz - 24 bit)
I hope the microfones are as good as the mic's on the 'ROLAND R-07',
witch i had before, but i sadly lost it.
(I was realy surprised by the detailed, and very 'Realistic-Surround-Sound'' picked up by those 2 mic's !)
But a new ROLAND R-07 costs +/- 249,- euro's, and the TASCAM DR-05X is now available for 105,- euro's !
The ZOOM H1n is cheaper but i think the TASCAM sounds better, and is a bit more professional.
Edwin.
Yes but does tascam have interference problems?
I prefer the tascam one
i really like the tescam microphones but the interferance is a deal breaker
When the cars are passing i hear at high volume a more tunnel sound like if the mic is at the end of a pipe with the zoom. The tascam have a more authentik sound.
Do you mean 6:50 ? I have no idea, what is a problem here, but the Zoom sounds strange in these recordings, just like an acoustic feedback was nearly occurring for some reason. My H1n produces excellent recordings, clear and very naturally sounding, with excellent stereo reproduction. One can have some reservations as far as the build quality is concerned, there are issues with the limiter etc., but otherwise the sound quality is really great.
Which mic has less noise? And Which preamp has less noise?
excellent! thank you!
For those who ride a motorbike and don't want to feel the wind but the engine of their motorbike, what is better between the two?
Thank you, this is an outstanding review. I've been looking at these two for recording my in-house bass practice. I've read issues regarding the build quality of the Zoom H1n. With your tests I preferred the sound quality of the Tascam.
Can anyone confirm the build issues of the Zoom?
Again, thank you for a great review!
What do you exactly mean as "build quality"? :) Well yes, the H1n has problems with rattling buttons on the body sides - headphones volume rocker in my case.
I was also choosing between the R-05X and the H1n and I eventually acquired the Zoom, because of its better stereo reproduction (clearly audible in this video; plus I already had a recorder with A/B configuration, so I was tempter by X/Y ;) ), then I was also unable to find, how serious the RFI problem with the Tascam is. The buttons can be easily silenced with an adhesive tape when needed, the RFI is incurable.
which is better for recording college lectures?
How long H1n can record using aaa Ni-MH from full to zero? How about Tascam? Is H1n good recording audio from room where are many people around (like family birthday) or is it too direction oriented? I have been trying to find audio recorder using aa/aaa batteries, very long recording time and could record many people at the same time. There are so many products to compare pros and cons. I have eyes on my H1n it sounds and feels better but dont know what to buy. Searching and comparing week now these haha. Sony has some models but I dont like battery that cannot be replaced. Great review btw thanks!
AB and XY are not the same if you record then closely .... it cannot be compared together
Cual es mejor de las dos, cual me recomiendas.
which one would you go for?
The zoom is very sensitive microphone
Are both set at the same levels? Wav and sample rates
Thank you for this side-by-side comparison. I found the Zoom to have clearer, crisper sound. That, however may be due to hearing problems. After reading some comments and reviews, my biggest concern is that the H1n has a tendency to pick up interference from electronic devices such as PC's. Have you or your viewers had any issues with that?
I think, Tascam recorders are known of the radio interference problem. :)
And from this very film I think, the Zoom H1n offers much more pronounced and natural stereo effect reproduction than the Tascam.
@@Chemnitzer Thanks. I just bought a Zoom but haven't used it yet. Time will tell if there are anny issues.
@@BLAKHARTFILM I was choosing between the Tascam DR-05X and Zoom H1n for quite a long time - and I eventually bought the Zoom. Mostly because I think its stereo effect is more natural, then I already own a recorder with A/B mic configuration, so I decided to buy an X/Y one. :) I was also unable to find out, how serious the RFI problem of the Tascam is, i.e. what is the probability, the interference occurs in real life.
Eventually, I'm a little bit disappointed with the H1n. Yes, it records really great sound, it is pretty convenient to use, but it also has numerous issues like rattling buttons (headphones volume rocker in my case), it's very prone to handling noise due to very lightweight body, limiter is useless (increasing noise floor by 12 dB when turned on with the recording level set above approx. 5.5) and the useful recording level range is limited to the 5.5-10 (noise floor increases by 12 dB too when the level is set under 5.5). Fortunately, I usually use the level around 8, so with some care it works fine for me. And a foam wind shield or a deadcat is just obligatory, often even indoors. :)
@@Chemnitzer Thanks for the reply and the info. Mine did not come with a deadcat. Guess I should have ordered one with it.
@@BLAKHARTFILM There's an accessories set, Zoom SPH-1n, with a foam windshield, a very nice dedicated hard case for the recorder and an AC adaptor (there was also an earlier APH-1n, which also additionally included a small table tripod and a mic stand adaptor). The Zoom WSU-1 deadcat - also listed as a compatible accessory - is, in turn, very big for the H1n and I think something smaller would be more convenient.
Hello, The audio comparison is processed?
Thank you for so many specific tests with good controls! I liked the fact they were recorded side by side simultaneously. Is there any way to fix the interference on Tascom? Also, Zoom seems to catch more bass, which sounds better than Tascom?
I believe it was cus of my phone , it was in my pocket only about 10 inches away from tascam (14) from zoom. I am in the process of doing an interference test video around the house, car, and mobile, we will see how they compare. I have had interference on both units 🤔.
@@CineChi all tascams has the same issue and that's so bad, i hope they can fix it, tascam is great only in indoors but thinking of recording nature, it'll be a bad idea
Did you find the tascam picks up external RF/electrical noise? I purchased a dr-07x recently but returned it the same day after noise in hotel room from WiFi routers and electrical switching crashed all across the recordings made. Apparently the tascam DR series are unshielded so needs care in urban settings...
Didn't you improve the audio samples (voice). I mean, are these files raw?
Raw no editing
@@CineChi thank you! Nice review. I bought DR-05X based on your review, mostly.
Ótimo vídeo! Parabéns pelo trabalho.
#brasileira
you cannot get results by having the mics into different directions. one is focused the other one set on wide. bad compared. sorry.
Does your DR-05X have any white noise when recording silence? Any white noise on the line out when the unit is on and has earbuds plugged in? My unit has these issues and was wondering if others have it too, maybe it's normal, idk.
I regret buying the Zoom. Too noisy. I wish I had seen this video before I bought it.
The o5x sounds cheap
I think Tascam DR-05X is bether than Zoom
Zoom gave you and American accent. 😆
Damn the Tascam sounds a bit nicer but I really like close XY configuration of the Zoom. Spaced out XY sounds weird.
Very useful comparison, Glad you made this !
Thank you , glad you watched it 😁
Great content man thank you so much for this!
Tascam is the One i would go after hearing this superb comparison. Too bad for the interferance sensitive.
It was really helpful. Thank you!
I own a Zoom H1n, in your tests, I Thought Zoom was more Brilliant. And some times didn't captured all sounds Tascam got.
Amazing review. Thank you so much, I was ready to buy the Zoom because of the price and also because I know Zoom better but I never used the H1 but I am not anymore sure that I will ever use one now… I have to rethink my budget and many try to get a proper Zoom.
to me Tascam sounds muffled, Zoom sound is more rich with a deeper bass and better stereo, great test by the way, thanks for doing it !
Fantastic comparison video, thanks so much!
The thing I have trouble with is that the Tascam in every review I watch has an audio interference that I can’t figure where it comes from.
I feel like I got lucky with the Zoom. It’s not perfect but it is more resistant to the interference.
Actually, on sets, everyone turns their phones to airplane mode. No mic or recorder is perfect against interference, no matter if it is made out of aluminium (case), cables etc.
@@WEHAVETHISDREAM correct, it’ll never be perfect. Some devices are better shielded or don’t have internals that are unintentionally conductive. Airplane mode isn’t enough when we film. If it’s not part of the set, it’s shut down fully.
The Tascam recorders I watched in many reviews recorded side by side with other units. They always seemed to be effected when the other recorder didn’t. Could be simply both recorders just too close I guess. 🤷♀️ I don’t have the time to do my own testing.