Apparently, I was the FIRST person to ever tell Trent he was the greatest singer/songwriter of the 20th Century... I met him backstage in 1994 at one of his secret shows that doubled as the "warm-up" leg to the Self Destruct Tour. He said "Wow, no one's ever said that to me that before. Thank you." He was really cool and down to earth. So I said "Really?? What do they usually say?" He took a deep breath... "Hi, I love your hair. How much money do you have? Can I suck your dick?" True story. I wonder today if he still remembers that cuz he was sober as a nun...
RW175 I’m a full time musician. I write my own songs. I even have a classic rock and roll past of drugs, politics and hate. I play three instruments to a very high standard...especially drums in which I play left handed (open handed) and am a master of the half time shuffle and have invented two drum rudiments...double kick pedal speed using one foot and that half time Purdie/Porcaro/Bonham shuffle groove with said open hi hat played with the hi hat pedal. No one does this. It’s super difficult to learn. And when you have no one to learn something new from it’s also a place where there are no places to turn to for help. BUT I CAN’T UNDERSTAND HOW SOME PEOPLE WRITE BRILLIANT SONGS LIKE OTHERS EAT BREAKFAST. Is it nature or nurture? Is there a God? It comes down to that in the end. And the answer, in my silly little world is “There must be for this type of genius to be unlearnable”. Or maybe I’m very stoned and this is jus mental?
Trent truly is one of the greatest and purest artist of our time. He makes what he wants with no censors or middlemen to fuck with him. I see him being a major contributor to future sounds and he definitely is an influence to the sounds of today. Praise Trent and his power to makes us all closer to God.
"Contrast" is the word I think you mean, "contradiction" carries a negative connotation. But I totally agree. I'm also a fan of Dave Matthews, been with Trent and Dave from right when they started to hit in the early '90s. ANYWAY, at one point, Dave brought on back up singers for a tour and live album (titled: Listener Supported). At first I was like, WTF? But I set aside bias and let it sink in and wow, just like these lovely ladies, they really add a killer new dimension. Hard to imagine since Trent's music is always layered with so much texture. Cheers!!
cavemancolton the entire Hesitation Marks album does tbh. it seems like less of a studio album and more of a "collection of great ass live songs, but in the studio"
+nofleshspared Aaron North's Big Come Down from the With Teeth tour is the gnarliest thing ever. It's too bad he's having so many issues now and doesn't play music anymore because he was a truly original guitar player.
I'm 18, born in 2004, and have been graced with my mom's old Walkman and Discman. I've been obsessed with "Closer" and seeing her old NIN album had me hype to hear more of their stuff. Hesitation Marks is not available to me on Spotify, and I am SO grateful I can listen to this album, to "All Time Low" when I'm out through sheer before-spotify will. This song is so incredible, I'm simply in love, and the artistry that is NIN is absolutely worshipped in me.
That’s five songs blended into one masterpiece then augmented with warmth coupled layered voices that just guide you to the conclusion your inside aural genius.
Wish I had enough spare time to have caught a piece of this particular tour. There's no real substitute for actually being there, but these videos are pretty well done.
All the kids in families who watch “Pixar’s Soul” won’t even know who made the soundtrack. I’ve heard of Bird Box and Social Network, but didn’t realize he and Atticus made the scores. He isn’t as known to many younger people like me now days, but his influence bleeds into music and pop culture.
i bet Trent said :"hey let's make a deep funk - dark -fundamental basic groove .....Yeah let's get Pino Palladino on bass and do an epic one" !!!!!....fucking legend!!!!fucking great great great track!!!
NvikIngsN that's fine with me. Closer has been ruined in live performances ever since with teeth era. I hate the way they play it now just playing half tge song then mixing in the only time which replaces the most awesome part of closer, the whole rest of the song after the final chorus with all the synth leads and keys. They completely take that part out. I love closer and the only time but id rather have them play each song separately in their entirety. Mixing them together just takes out the best parts of each song which is a waste of a couple minutes that could have been used for any other one of their songs.
Welcome to NIN Where the live performances are just as badass as the studio versions... no, we actually mean it this time. It's LITERALLY just as badass
God damned right! He brings the funk in a way that absolutely takes NIN to a new level. While Trent is 95% of the group, the session and touring musicians he chooses are every bit as important. That baseline is fucking incredible.
One of the best shows out there on TH-cam. Always a great piece to come back to when you just want to chill and enjoy something out of the ordinary. Absolutely love this show.
I saw NIN and Janes Addiction a few years back and if you have never seen NIN live (or JA for that matter) you really need to make it a goal in your life.
Just coming up to the end of the two hardest years of my life. Hard to say for sure but I really don't know if I'd have had the strength if it wasn't for great music like this to remind me of the beauty in even the darkest of moments
Helped me out too friend. I went thro a hellish divorce, lost my mum in amongst other crappy stuff. If it wasn't for listening to this magnificent man and group I'd be a sorry state. 😢 Hope ur doin good now ,I am..😁
its crazy how gooood the guitars here are. the guitar dude panned to the right audio sounds sick. pino, always mind blowing. but what do i know, im just a little stoned right now
They said from the early days this guy will influence pop music with his style and he has done....pretty every much every successful mainstream "pop" band has somewhere a line or a riff that sounds like it could have come from NIN.....I listen to Radio 1 frequently and I can't help but think often....you got that from NIN
Paul Snell really? I mean, when I first heard their music, it definitely sounded ahead of its time, but I can't really imagine anything mainstream that sounds like them :/
Go I've heard all I need to know Your voice in fucking echo stereo This particular scenario Looks like another all time low Why did you go and let them in See this is where the fun begins You barely even pierced the skin Just wait 'til you see what has come in Get down on the floor Shut the god damn door We'll do this all before They're coming back for more So give me just a little, baby Just something to get by It's gonna last forever, baby We'll get the other side And we will live forever, baby And stretch across the sky I'll follow right behind you, baby We're never gonna die Hey Everything is not okay We lost too much along the way The passengers are out today It looks as though they're here to stay This paranoia turns to fear This too is whispering in your ear Pretending but I know you hear That's how we fucking end up here So give me just a little, baby Just something to get by It's gonna last forever, baby We'll get the other side And we will live forever, baby And stretch across the sky I'll follow right behind you, baby We're never gonna die We're never gonna die How did we get so high Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky Stretch across the sky
😍..."Something to get by" NIN me over here, S.FL- come on! It's Time ...for Time. Bring it back! -Suffering from live NIN withdrawals. Rez🔥you hunky piece of work, come play!
agreed. if you dislike NIN live, then you shouldn't be going to any concert nor listen to any kind of music. i've seen NIN live four times and have tickets for another show coming at the fox theatre at the ATL and they never disappoint.
As soon as this song started at the live show, SEXY grooves permeated the hall. Immediately I felt a connection with 'Closer' so it was no surprise that Trent added the lyrics at the end.
![NIN: Echoplex live at rehearsals, July 2008 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0hfxwd3zpYo/mqdefault.jpg)
I seriously don't know how he makes songs this fucking good so consistently.
PariSitic Pictures He is a sober now.
Santa
Their music still gives me goose bumps. Can never get enough no matter how old I get!
Apparently, I was the FIRST person to ever tell Trent he was the greatest singer/songwriter of the 20th Century...
I met him backstage in 1994 at one of his secret shows that doubled as the "warm-up" leg to the Self Destruct Tour.
He said "Wow, no one's ever said that to me that before. Thank you."
He was really cool and down to earth.
So I said "Really?? What do they usually say?"
He took a deep breath... "Hi, I love your hair. How much money do you have? Can I suck your dick?"
True story.
I wonder today if he still remembers that cuz he was sober as a nun...
RW175 I’m a full time musician. I write my own songs. I even have a classic rock and roll past of drugs, politics and hate. I play three instruments to a very high standard...especially drums in which I play left handed (open handed) and am a master of the half time shuffle and have invented two drum rudiments...double kick pedal speed using one foot and that half time Purdie/Porcaro/Bonham shuffle groove with said open hi hat played with the hi hat pedal. No one does this. It’s super difficult to learn. And when you have no one to learn something new from it’s also a place where there are no places to turn to for help. BUT I CAN’T UNDERSTAND HOW SOME PEOPLE WRITE BRILLIANT SONGS LIKE OTHERS EAT BREAKFAST. Is it nature or nurture? Is there a God? It comes down to that in the end. And the answer, in my silly little world is “There must be for this type of genius to be unlearnable”.
Or maybe I’m very stoned and this is jus mental?
I actually can’t get enough of this song
Same
Samesies
Trent truly is one of the greatest and purest artist of our time. He makes what he wants with no censors or middlemen to fuck with him. I see him being a major contributor to future sounds and he definitely is an influence to the sounds of today. Praise Trent and his power to makes us all closer to God.
+Kevin Medina Interesting . Head like a hole . Closer to God .
+scott helft god money
Just a cheap copy of Nivek Orge.
💘💘💘
Also Brilliant lighting😍
Those girls NAIL it down! They're the beautiful contradiction that NIN needed.
LISA FISCHER!
"Contrast" is the word I think you mean, "contradiction" carries a negative connotation. But I totally agree. I'm also a fan of Dave Matthews, been with Trent and Dave from right when they started to hit in the early '90s. ANYWAY, at one point, Dave brought on back up singers for a tour and live album (titled: Listener Supported). At first I was like, WTF? But I set aside bias and let it sink in and wow, just like these lovely ladies, they really add a killer new dimension. Hard to imagine since Trent's music is always layered with so much texture.
Cheers!!
Contradiction?
Balance
@@boy_savage110 : She played with Steely Dan as well. She has range.
Check out how they performed Sanctified in this tour, this is amazing
this is by far one of the sexiest songs I have ever heard. What would I ever do without Mr. Reznor!
Those back up singers are everything :)
Yeah, it's definitely better than the studio version, IMO. Great performance by everyone.
The curly-haired one is Lisa Fischer - she's a legend! Look her up.
Mikenactor back up singers sound and look like the back up singers from pinks latest album
How Can I Ease The Pain is still my jam :)
OMG MIKE. ❤❤
This is better than the album version.
cavemancolton Almost EVERYTHING Trent does Live, sounds BETTER!
Richard Michael closer, only, sanctified, big come down,.....i can keep going on and on haha
Echoing Truth YOU OBVIOUSLY DIDNT HEAR THE AARON NORTH BIG COME DOWN!
cavemancolton the entire Hesitation Marks album does tbh. it seems like less of a studio album and more of a "collection of great ass live songs, but in the studio"
+nofleshspared Aaron North's Big Come Down from the With Teeth tour is the gnarliest thing ever. It's too bad he's having so many issues now and doesn't play music anymore because he was a truly original guitar player.
I'm 18, born in 2004, and have been graced with my mom's old Walkman and Discman. I've been obsessed with "Closer" and seeing her old NIN album had me hype to hear more of their stuff.
Hesitation Marks is not available to me on Spotify, and I am SO grateful I can listen to this album, to "All Time Low" when I'm out through sheer before-spotify will. This song is so incredible, I'm simply in love, and the artistry that is NIN is absolutely worshipped in me.
That’s five songs blended into one masterpiece then augmented with warmth coupled layered voices that just guide you to the conclusion your inside aural genius.
After all these years, this is as good as anything he has ever done. A true genius.
This is still the best concert I've ever been too. Before or since.
Sharlotte Gibson and Lisa Fischer are absolute gems.
"trent is the greatest musician of my generation" - dave grohl
They are both Dave and Trent, the greatest two loves of my life.
NIN is way better live than anything recorded in a studio.
One of the best songs of the Album IMO
One of his best songs period IMO
These live versions are phenomenal!
Wish I had enough spare time to have caught a piece of this particular tour. There's no real substitute for actually being there, but these videos are pretty well done.
I agree with everyone else here, those background singers are pure gold!
And the instrumentation is perfect!
I like this live arrangement of the song...it's got power and a hint of menace...and a groove too.
Damn those backing vocals are amazing
Yep. That's Lisa Fischer from the rolling Stones.
They've been around since the late 80's and Trent is still amazeballs!! I love them so much!!!
No words about Brilliant lighting? Common friends...
FINK .... Plays some of the most BAD ASS ... little riffs on this one! AMAZING!
He should be official member
Probably almost everyone in the world has heard something Trent Reznor has composed and not realised it....He is everywhere :D
He's the Stephen King of Rock
All the kids in families who watch “Pixar’s Soul” won’t even know who made the soundtrack. I’ve heard of Bird Box and Social Network, but didn’t realize he and Atticus made the scores. He isn’t as known to many younger people like me now days, but his influence bleeds into music and pop culture.
@@TheMark1999 he's becoming very well known now, especially due to the halsey album
Trent fucking Reznor for President!
***** Well it's settled then.
1:53 that guitar part, haunt me in the most beautiful way.
Most creative musician of our time:Mr.Trent Reznor.
I love the studio version of this song, but this great in a whole other way!
i bet Trent said :"hey let's make a deep funk - dark -fundamental basic groove .....Yeah let's get Pino Palladino on bass and do an epic one" !!!!!....fucking legend!!!!fucking great great great track!!!
This show was amazing. Trent ' s choice of band line up was spot on. Pino Palladium is funkadelic.
That would be Pino Palladino ;) and yes, he is damn good!
Seeing this show in Edmonton was amazing. The way Trent was moving to this song... just too sexy.
A NIN masterpiece. Trent loved this
One of my favorite tracks. This is amazing.
AND ME. LIKE THIS!
I went to his most recent concert in Kansas City...best show I've ever been to. NIN still rocks hard!
I can relate to this song so much right now, just like Find My Way and Various Methods of Escape ..
Frisbee Thomson - Me too. But... The Way Out is Through!
@@dominicm5657 into the void!
Hesitation Marks made for a great Live show, Wish I could've seen them
i need to see him againnnnn
trent is a goddd
best track on Hesitation Marks track 5, these backup singers made it even better
I loved the Closer lyrics at the ending
I love love love this song, and this might be the best version of it yet.
Closer (part 2) Confirmed!!!
I remember after the concert people were upset closer was never played, because they failed to hear it referenced in this song...
NvikIngsN that's fine with me. Closer has been ruined in live performances ever since with teeth era. I hate the way they play it now just playing half tge song then mixing in the only time which replaces the most awesome part of closer, the whole rest of the song after the final chorus with all the synth leads and keys. They completely take that part out. I love closer and the only time but id rather have them play each song separately in their entirety. Mixing them together just takes out the best parts of each song which is a waste of a couple minutes that could have been used for any other one of their songs.
Well, it is sung from the perspective of someone who's "been down this road before". Though nowadays, he's more experienced with handling his issues.
This version is an absolute masterpiece. JFC.
Welcome to NIN
Where the live performances are just as badass as the studio versions... no, we actually mean it this time. It's LITERALLY just as badass
Even better imho
Not often that something is so much better live but this is a billion times better than the album version imo
God Damned Pino Palladino for the win!
Roxie Marquez I would have loved to have seen Adrian Belew on stage with Pino!
Is that who's on bass?
@@ChinChest Yep, Pino Palladino, an awesome session bass player
A Pino fan! Nnnnnoice!!
God damned right! He brings the funk in a way that absolutely takes NIN to a new level.
While Trent is 95% of the group, the session and touring musicians he chooses are every bit as important.
That baseline is fucking incredible.
One of the best shows out there on TH-cam. Always a great piece to come back to when you just want to chill and enjoy something out of the ordinary. Absolutely love this show.
I thought he did a good job on this song . Love how he incorporated "Closer" in with it and I love the background singers.
I watched this video about 3 times in a row, This is so so good !
Yes! ... Same !
This song gets better every time i hear it... hoping it's played when you come to London next month!
"we're never gonna die"
I saw NIN and Janes Addiction a few years back and if you have never seen NIN live (or JA for that matter) you really need to make it a goal in your life.
Nine Inch Nails represents the most raw, unfiltered version of myself.
Edgy...
uh
considering who trent reznor is i don't think that's something to take pride in
Just coming up to the end of the two hardest years of my life. Hard to say for sure but I really don't know if I'd have had the strength if it wasn't for great music like this to remind me of the beauty in even the darkest of moments
Helped me out too friend. I went thro a hellish divorce, lost my mum in amongst other crappy stuff. If it wasn't for listening to this magnificent man and group I'd be a sorry state. 😢 Hope ur doin good now ,I am..😁
Love this! Love NIN
Sensuaidad al mil es lo que me hace experimentar este roloooooooon,me hace sentir sucio
Was at this tour and still 1 of the best concert experiences to date. 😎 🎶
Remember to stretch across the sky everyone!
Already doing that now. I did it when this album came out too. Forever trailing across the sky.
Tried that, got a crick in my back :(
its crazy how gooood the guitars here are. the guitar dude panned to the right audio sounds sick. pino, always mind blowing. but what do i know, im just a little stoned right now
He needs to get this band back together and give them free reign to play for a full album the way he did for this set.
This is so beautiful
this is one of the funkiest damn bass rifts I've ever heard, with the heavy the drumming, and the guitars.... what a fucking song
Pino Paladino plays bass :-)
Fantastic....don't think there's anything he's made I don't like,just so bloody fabulous ❤️💋
He is fascinating!!! I so wish I could climb in his head. He is fabulous!! Yum!
This song is just GREAT!!....how can you not love this song...
that song blow my mind
They played 2 nights in Vegas this tour.
Completely different sets. Amazing!
I wanna see him live again hell I wanna meet him
They said from the early days this guy will influence pop music with his style and he has done....pretty every much every successful mainstream "pop" band has somewhere a line or a riff that sounds like it could have come from NIN.....I listen to Radio 1 frequently and I can't help but think often....you got that from NIN
Paul Snell really? I mean, when I first heard their music, it definitely sounded ahead of its time, but I can't really imagine anything mainstream that sounds like them :/
Easily the best version of this track. Fuckin' incredible.
Nearly 40 years NIN has been at it. They're almost the same age as me😃
Go
I've heard all I need to know
Your voice in fucking echo stereo
This particular scenario
Looks like another all time low
Why did you go and let them in
See this is where the fun begins
You barely even pierced the skin
Just wait 'til you see what has come in
Get down on the floor
Shut the god damn door
We'll do this all before
They're coming back for more
So give me just a little, baby
Just something to get by
It's gonna last forever, baby
We'll get the other side
And we will live forever, baby
And stretch across the sky
I'll follow right behind you, baby
We're never gonna die
Hey
Everything is not okay
We lost too much along the way
The passengers are out today
It looks as though they're here to stay
This paranoia turns to fear
This too is whispering in your ear
Pretending but I know you hear
That's how we fucking end up here
So give me just a little, baby
Just something to get by
It's gonna last forever, baby
We'll get the other side
And we will live forever, baby
And stretch across the sky
I'll follow right behind you, baby
We're never gonna die
We're never gonna die
How did we get so high
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Stretch across the sky
Love the funk!
0:57 lady getting jiggy really encapsulates the groove here
somehow trent writes these amazing songs and then makes them even more amazing in concert
This makes me wish Trent brought two R&B singers out with him on tour EVERY time -- sounds so fucking good!
I've seen them five times and this was a special treat. Still the best.
Still kicking myself that I missed this tour.
I’m sorry but..please no.
This caught me off guard in a good way
SUPERB!!!!!
😍..."Something to get by"
NIN me over here, S.FL- come on!
It's Time ...for Time.
Bring it back! -Suffering from live NIN withdrawals.
Rez🔥you hunky piece of work, come play!
Just don't know what David Bowie saw in Trent Reznor.....😄 Their duo on "Hurt" is one of the most moving songs I've ever heard.
Those Pino bass lines are thick!!!!
increible en vivo. genios!!
This footage is and not to mention some of the best ever of Nine Inch Nails! Thanks for posting it!
i actually think that if i sawbthis live, i would spontaneously combust
It gets me closer to god
Dat is so ne spacyge musik
@ɮօʊռċɛ օʄʄ and yet I hear the lyrics to closer.
last 2 minutes are pure magic
How come 7 people dislked this tune...its fucking amazing!!???
Love how this lighting aesthetic harkens back to pretty hate machine’s cover. 3:04
Most Inbelievable Venue ❤❤❤
Pino!!! Would love to see them perform at the Sphere in Vegas.
Best stage efx of all hi slive shows on the Tube. great recording.
when he moved his shoulders like that i audibly said "YEEEESSS" 3:21
I can't stand the word but this is pure rizz
I wonder if this song has some deep hidden meaning. It definitely sounds like it.
Give me just a little baby...just something to get by...
Does seem to be from the perspective of someone quite familiar with depression.
It was a kinda ‘remake’ of 10 Miles High.
Obviously about using drugs and addiction.
you get me... you get me closer... you get me closer...
Goes down as the best concert I've ever seen in my life! a sweet Montreal show.
Thank you Mr. Reznor for All Time Low. It really speaks to me!
HEY HEY HEY HEYYYY!!! EVERY THING IS NOT OKAYYYYY KAYYYY KAAYYYY KAYYYY!!! Yesssssssss i feel that
Final Fantasy tribute at the end! Love NIN! Hot backup singers.
Where?
@@al112v4 around 5:01 the Crystal Theme ;) th-cam.com/video/sgg79-jxKao/w-d-xo.html
Definitely far from hot…
TH-cam should remove the unlike button for every video that involves NIN on a live setting.
I dislike one. The Last just can't feel that one. do you have any Nins you don't like?
agreed. if you dislike NIN live, then you shouldn't be going to any concert nor listen to any kind of music. i've seen NIN live four times and have tickets for another show coming at the fox theatre at the ATL and they never disappoint.
The unlike button just shows who sucks and doesn't appreciate good music but I agree
Hey bro guess what
@@TM__1566 Lmao
wow, did not expect this to be a funk rendition. amazing!
As soon as this song started at the live show, SEXY grooves permeated the hall. Immediately I felt a connection with 'Closer' so it was no surprise that Trent added the lyrics at the end.
wow perfect drug mixed in, this song takes on a new meaning to me now
closer i heard, not perfect drug.
wolfpyrospictures true it is closer lyrics
iconocast i wish it was perfect drug he has never done it live for personal reasons
zergoverlord666
personal reasons? its too fucking hard to reproduce live is why
nfsbp untrue, TPD is his least favorite because it was rushed and pressured for the lost highway