Thank you for this amazing explanation teacher , by watching your videos it gives confidence to me that no topic is impossible to understand once it is taught in the right way . Your simplified and twisted theory videos expands my imagination power which helps me see the world in a new way . I guess I'm a bit late but I wish you a very🎉 HAPPY BIRTHDAY DAY TEACHER 🎂🥳🎉🕊 (my mamma says that the person who gives you knowledge and helps you to grow in life is a teacher)
I honestly think I could listen to Toby explain pretty much anything. Why do I feel so relaxed after listening to someone on a video explaining something quite complex? She exudes an aura of confidence and understanding very few can achieve, yet in such a relaxed, none consuming way. What a wonderful woman.
You can make white holes in your sink. Turn on the faucet to maximum, and watch a ring of smooth water form around the bottom of the flowing water column. That is where water is in supercritical flow, flowing faster than waves can propagate through the water. Nothing that is free floating around in the water will ever be able to cross the outer ring, no matter how hard it tries. Similarly, the drain in a sink is like a black hole. Anything floating in the water that passes the neck of the whirlpool will never be able to leave.
@@mcusa77Only after it has spent some time in the curved space we know as a U-bend. The analogy with real black holes gets stretched a bit thin (as black holes are wont to do) where pipe wrenches come into play.
@@purefoldnz3070Allegory is about perspective and making hard to visualize concepts accessible, yes they are spherical, but that's irrelevant when you take an applicable descriptive slice. Given the video mentioned this more than once there was no reason for posters to do so.
all these years and I never realized the intended metaphor of the event HORIZON of a black hole as being like watching a ship sailing beyond the horizon of the observer on land. thanks Toby for making it clear!
Does that mean that the location of the event horizon of a black hole depends on the location of the observer? In case of horizon on Earth, it is moving along with the observer.
"We're just gonna get squished, & that's okay" Seriously tho, love your channel & I am thankful you bring knowledge to all. In a easy to understand, clear way.
"We're just gonna get squished, & that's okay" It could be true. We had to have the assumption of excluding all the physical impossiblity when we think/consider the black hole as incompressible fluid.
"I think there's an artist hidden at the heart of every one of us." I wholeheartedly agree. As an artist who failed to do well in math class at school - not for a lack of interest in the subject but because it wasn't taught well - I was always keenly aware that the only reason I felt unhappy when presented with math to solve was because I was frustrated that I couldn't understand it and that others would look down on me for that rather than take it as an opportunity to teach me properly. I wanted to like and understand math but no one was patient enough or had the time enough to teach it patiently in a way I could understand. As I got into the arts, I also became aware more and more that people seemed to underestimate the importance of the creative arts and how deeply they are linked to our existence as humans, as well as to other "more" analytical subjects. Imagine my joy at finding this channel then. Especially the video about Finding X, just immediately captured me. Thanks for all the education, for being a free, patient space online where I can learn about this subject that I have always wanted to, and for wholeheartedly believing in the importance of art as well as science. Thanks for being a welcoming space for both artists and scientists, as we each all have art and science within us.
Wow, I always thought white holes should be bright cause they would basicly throw out a lot of matter. Never thought of them of just time reversed black holes, but it seems so elegantly simple. Thank you Toby for explaining this so wonderfully!
Thank you so much for your relaxing videos about Astronomy, Math, Physics ^_^ I appreciate learning with the beautiful birds and calming vibes 😌 10/10! Btw, it's Bob Ross' Birthday today! 🕊🎂:) I wish for you to find and follow your dreams, just as Bob Ross inspired/taught us to :) 🍓
I have always avoided math. I was an English major in college and part of the reason for that was i didn't need to take any math classes... but i took a couple conceptual physics classes and got really interested in physics and now regret my lack of math understanding. And now, your videos are making me interested in math...
I loved Carlo Rovelli's The Order of Time. It blew me away! I'm looking forward to his new book and will be looking for his other books as well. Thanks, Toby. You are an amazing presence on TH-cam!
Your explanation of white holes was very interesting and educational as well. I enjoyed it very much. I was really impressed with the birds that were scattered about in the scenes. You surely do pick some beautiful places to film your recordings. Very lovable "Cat of the Day".
Thank you so much for your videos! They are so unique and wonderful! I love your creative, playful intelligent style, that makes the concepts of physics and maths fun, enjoyable and easy to understand! Much love! 🌈
I was fascinated by the concept of black holes since childhood. Shouldn’t White Holes and Hawking Radiation be linked if I understand correctly? 😮 I’m in no way proficient in physics. Just asking from what I have read from books and journals. Regardless of the answer, regards to Toby for putting in efforts and telling us things in her own unique way to make common folks understand these topics.❤
I have absolutely loved Rovelli's book The order of time. To me he's one of the best science communicators., often combining physics with references to literature and philosophy
Great video! Thanks. I have this quirky idea that all BHs start as a BH, but transition into a wave-like oscillation between BH and WH. QM forces repeated bounces to prevent a singularity from forming. So, behind the EH curtain, all BHs are really like a beating human heart. ❤
I didn't know this book by Carlo Rovelli, only the "order of time" and reality is not what it seems", and if the topic of black holes is very interesting, now I am reading Kip S Thorne's book "Black Holes and Curved Time ". Happy strokes Tibees Ross. Saludos desde México.
Ok, gotta admit you blew my mind in the last minute there about the Big Bang maybe being just a White Hole bounce back 🤯 you just dropped it so casually. Great vid
Tibees, thank you so kindly to be here with humanity and being so forward and passionate. Your awesome ultra long hair witnessed the journey of understanding and growing knowledge on thousands years of intelligent and daring human beings who brought our world of understanding to entire new level of comprehension through your engaging and resonating education you have shared with us. Bob Ross would be so proud of you, and he would truly understand this subject.
That said I'm still stumped by the fact that we would never see the sailboat move passed the event horizon, but the folks on the sailboat would see themselves continuing to move. Like I don't understand how there is a time outside of our eternal timeline where sailboat exists inside the event horizon. 🙃
Amazing explanation and I find it lucky to find your video. One of the best explanation which leads to very logical imagination of dimensions to grasp understanding on black hole & white hole
Doing math on top of a mountain! How Gauss of you! Kudos! In the latest Veritasium video - the one about hyperbolic space - I learned that Gauss climbed mountains in order to draw maps of Hannover. He and fellow surveyors climbed mountains and measured angles and triangles whose points were at the mountains' peaks (or something like that).
I wish I had time over the years to watch your channel like I used to. Like your last video, everything has been influenced and it would be nice to get back to normalcy
Wow, this is very impressive, thank you so much for providing us with this most interesting and informative video presentation which is very much appreciated by us. We are absolutely delighted that you have gone to the trouble of explaining such a complex subject in a way that is most helpful to us.
Omg thank you SO MUCH that during your breif description of a black hole you didnt say "nothing can escape NOT EVEN LIGHT" That statement drives me nuts bc ive heard it over and over since the first time i read about black holes in the 80s when i as around 6 yr old.
Describing any scientific stuff isn't a small thing and now I understood completely about the white and black holes after your explanation especially that mathematical analysis made me think 🤔 larger .. Keep doing..Love u 😊Sunny grace
Happy Birthday to Bob Ross (October 29th) 🕊🎨
Thank you for this amazing explanation teacher , by watching your videos it gives confidence to me that no topic is impossible to understand once it is taught in the right way . Your simplified and twisted theory videos expands my imagination power which helps me see the world in a new way . I guess I'm a bit late but I wish you a very🎉 HAPPY BIRTHDAY DAY TEACHER 🎂🥳🎉🕊 (my mamma says that the person who gives you knowledge and helps you to grow in life is a teacher)
The parrot was the cherry on top!
Happy Birthday to your Channel 😻
🕯
🧐🌀
“And we’re just gonna put a happy little collapsed star right there.”
Comedic genius, you are.
Pleasant surprise seeing you in the comments of this video cause I really loved watching your videos when I was younger:)
are stars really that happy after collapsing?
She's got a point, she's an icon, she's a legend and she is the moment.
Thankyou Toby for bringing back this beautiful scenery
I honestly think I could listen to Toby explain pretty much anything. Why do I feel so relaxed after listening to someone on a video explaining something quite complex? She exudes an aura of confidence and understanding very few can achieve, yet in such a relaxed, none consuming way.
What a wonderful woman.
She's a beautiful person. Such a gracious and calm demeanour.
Who is Toby?
@@Trev-rp8nd the creator of this video. Her name is Toby
This!
@@Amazing_Markshe is so wonderful...😊
You can make white holes in your sink. Turn on the faucet to maximum, and watch a ring of smooth water form around the bottom of the flowing water column. That is where water is in supercritical flow, flowing faster than waves can propagate through the water. Nothing that is free floating around in the water will ever be able to cross the outer ring, no matter how hard it tries.
Similarly, the drain in a sink is like a black hole. Anything floating in the water that passes the neck of the whirlpool will never be able to leave.
"Anything floating in the water that passes the neck of the whirlpool will never be able to leave." ??
@@mcusa77Only after it has spent some time in the curved space we know as a U-bend. The analogy with real black holes gets stretched a bit thin (as black holes are wont to do) where pipe wrenches come into play.
except black holes are spherical.
@@purefoldnz3070Allegory is about perspective and making hard to visualize concepts accessible, yes they are spherical, but that's irrelevant when you take an applicable descriptive slice. Given the video mentioned this more than once there was no reason for posters to do so.
@@orbatos not irrelevant at all.
all these years and I never realized the intended metaphor of the event HORIZON of a black hole as being like watching a ship sailing beyond the horizon of the observer on land.
thanks Toby for making it clear!
She makes me feel like I understand theoretical physics haha
Thanks Toby
Does that mean that the location of the event horizon of a black hole depends on the location of the observer?
In case of horizon on Earth, it is moving along with the observer.
"There are no mistakes, just happy, infinitely dense singularities."
"We're just gonna get squished, & that's okay"
Seriously tho, love your channel & I am thankful you bring knowledge to all. In a easy to understand, clear way.
"We're just gonna get squished, & that's okay" It could be true. We had to have the assumption of excluding all the physical impossiblity when we think/consider the black hole as incompressible fluid.
As an artist I have to say that your line work is excellent. Art and science do belong together! Great explanations Toby. Well done!
Toby is the purest and most wholesome woman on the Internet. ❤
Appearances can deceive
She is so intelligent, well spoken, sweet, like a really wonderful fairy ❤
Do you know something we don't?@@DarrylHebbes
She is a smart gal
@@sgtpepper1729 A white angel from a white star in the Milky Way Galaxy.
And she's ours!
"I think there's an artist hidden at the heart of every one of us." I wholeheartedly agree. As an artist who failed to do well in math class at school - not for a lack of interest in the subject but because it wasn't taught well - I was always keenly aware that the only reason I felt unhappy when presented with math to solve was because I was frustrated that I couldn't understand it and that others would look down on me for that rather than take it as an opportunity to teach me properly. I wanted to like and understand math but no one was patient enough or had the time enough to teach it patiently in a way I could understand. As I got into the arts, I also became aware more and more that people seemed to underestimate the importance of the creative arts and how deeply they are linked to our existence as humans, as well as to other "more" analytical subjects. Imagine my joy at finding this channel then. Especially the video about Finding X, just immediately captured me. Thanks for all the education, for being a free, patient space online where I can learn about this subject that I have always wanted to, and for wholeheartedly believing in the importance of art as well as science. Thanks for being a welcoming space for both artists and scientists, as we each all have art and science within us.
Wow, I always thought white holes should be bright cause they would basicly throw out a lot of matter. Never thought of them of just time reversed black holes, but it seems so elegantly simple. Thank you Toby for explaining this so wonderfully!
A white hole will look like a giant spherical mirror because it is reflecting the your light and everything else too.
Thank you so much for your relaxing videos about Astronomy, Math, Physics ^_^ I appreciate learning with the beautiful birds and calming vibes 😌 10/10!
Btw, it's Bob Ross' Birthday today! 🕊🎂:) I wish for you to find and follow your dreams, just as Bob Ross inspired/taught us to :) 🍓
I really like the way you present stuff.
Not only is it informative, but its bob-ross levels of relaxing lol
The inclusion of the King Parrot was sublime. 👍
I have always avoided math. I was an English major in college and part of the reason for that was i didn't need to take any math classes... but i took a couple conceptual physics classes and got really interested in physics and now regret my lack of math understanding. And now, your videos are making me interested in math...
Same here man, I like learning math on my own but in school I struggle
Thank you for another great video. I really enjoyed your Bob Ross style. You explained the subject matter so well, and your art is wonderful.
Hello 👋 how are you doing today??
Imagine an inverted universe thats mostly light with only black holes for stars.
Your soothing video cured my headache today. ❤
I loved Carlo Rovelli's The Order of Time. It blew me away! I'm looking forward to his new book and will be looking for his other books as well.
Thanks, Toby. You are an amazing presence on TH-cam!
Tell me about it?
Your explanation of white holes was very interesting and educational as well. I enjoyed it very much. I was really impressed with the birds that were scattered about in the scenes. You surely do pick some beautiful places to film your recordings. Very lovable "Cat of the Day".
Thank you so much for your videos! They are so unique and wonderful! I love your creative, playful intelligent style, that makes the concepts of physics and maths fun, enjoyable and easy to understand!
Much love! 🌈
Your content is incredibly relaxing. Thank you. Keep em coming!
And again this year... Happy birthday Bob Ross on 10/29!
Over the years I have watched your videos and loved them. Keep up the good work.
In 8:55, the little boat escaped both the black and white wholes, and sat on the left leg of the tripod, watching everything else traveling thru time.
I was fascinated by the concept of black holes since childhood. Shouldn’t White Holes and Hawking Radiation be linked if I understand correctly? 😮
I’m in no way proficient in physics. Just asking from what I have read from books and journals.
Regardless of the answer, regards to Toby for putting in efforts and telling us things in her own unique way to make common folks understand these topics.❤
Great video! I love the cuts to the wildlife too!
Perfect way to enjoy my morning coffee. I find myself having to rewind multiple times to try and conceptualize these ideas fully.
I have absolutely loved Rovelli's book The order of time. To me he's one of the best science communicators., often combining physics with references to literature and philosophy
I just finished that one myself, and, seconded!
Great video! Thanks. I have this quirky idea that all BHs start as a BH, but transition into a wave-like oscillation between BH and WH. QM forces repeated bounces to prevent a singularity from forming. So, behind the EH curtain, all BHs are really like a beating human heart. ❤
What a relaxing way to learn about white holes. Very interesting and thought provoking. Thank you Toby.
Your enthusiasm for science is contagious, igniting curiosity and wonder in those around you
I didn't know this book by Carlo Rovelli, only the "order of time" and reality is not what it seems", and if the topic of black holes is very interesting, now I am reading Kip S Thorne's book "Black Holes and Curved Time ". Happy strokes Tibees Ross. Saludos desde México.
I can't believe your videos have only just reached my feed!
"So what is it?"
(cookie to anyone getting the reference)
Very soothing and informative video!
I was going to be very disappointed if no one had posted this
Thank you for the upload Tibees. I will be on the lookout for any white holes.
"shower of light drops" is a wonderful little phrase
Im glad youtube recommended me this video as i have a speech tomorrow explaining the basics of relativity
Ok, gotta admit you blew my mind in the last minute there about the Big Bang maybe being just a White Hole bounce back 🤯 you just dropped it so casually. Great vid
You should do more videos like this!! I've already watched all of them
I was just watching the imaginary numbers video! These are so relaxing to watch while doing my chores, thank you so much ❤
After watching the full video I can finally say, "It's a really good asmr video" 👍
Tibees, thank you so kindly to be here with humanity and being so forward and passionate. Your awesome ultra long hair witnessed the journey of understanding and growing knowledge on thousands years of intelligent and daring human beings who brought our world of understanding to entire new level of comprehension through your engaging and resonating education you have shared with us. Bob Ross would be so proud of you, and he would truly understand this subject.
Clever and very creative alternative to explaining a complex subject.
Thanks so much for explaining! I will definitely be requesting this for purchase at my library!
This is absolutely my favorite kind of video you make! TY!
good grief. she's shilling for a bad book. i hope that's not what the little heart is for.
Oh how I've missed these videos of yours
That was truly delightful. Brilliant, and in that legendary peaceful style of Bob Ross. Thank you for this gift!!
That said I'm still stumped by the fact that we would never see the sailboat move passed the event horizon, but the folks on the sailboat would see themselves continuing to move. Like I don't understand how there is a time outside of our eternal timeline where sailboat exists inside the event horizon. 🙃
Amazing explanation and I find it lucky to find your video. One of the best explanation which leads to very logical imagination of dimensions to grasp understanding on black hole & white hole
Awesome!...the water droplets & sand grains part is pretty elegant...u r an awesome science communicator!!
It makes my day when Tibees uploads! 😃⚛
Doing math on top of a mountain!
How Gauss of you! Kudos!
In the latest Veritasium video - the one about hyperbolic space - I learned that Gauss climbed mountains in order to draw maps of Hannover. He and fellow surveyors climbed mountains and measured angles and triangles whose points were at the mountains' peaks (or something like that).
Great presentation. Many thanks to Tibees.
You already explain everything Bob Ross style, @tibees! You’re the science Aussie Bob Ross!
Greetings from an antipode, again. Good job, as always. That "|x|" at 10:50 made me smile. Thank you!
Amazing as always
Some times we need to revise what we already know, Tibees help in such revisions)
Now why can't all ads be like this
Thanks Toby. You rock!
You're voice is so sweet and calming it helps me pay attention to everything you're saying. Thank you
In a white hole, with black curtains...
Asmr has never worked for me until now
I wish I had time over the years to watch your channel like I used to. Like your last video, everything has been influenced and it would be nice to get back to normalcy
thank you for this!!! amazing explanation and absolutely impeccable vibes 🥺💕
Bob Ross would be screaming at the top of his lungs all the way from the cemetery. Keep up the good work.
Love your Bob Ross style math sessions. Thank you Toby
Falling more in love with spatial science by the week!
The drawings are incredible. Great video
This is a wonderful presentation, thank you!
Her voice is so soothing! ❤
This is the most calming way to engage with my existentialism in the most calmest, warmest way on a Sunday morning
Your videos are amazing toby. Rainbow was spectacular. ✌😍
Bob Ross style requires at least one 'happy accident'. ' .
I already know it’s going to be a great video
This is such an amazing and wonderfully informative channel.
That was awesome!
That blue and yellow space. I don't know why, I feel like it's a subtle statement of support for Ukraine?
this is where I find science fascinating...🙌🙌
Educational, Peaceful and even Relaxing ! This woman is genius ! Thank you for this amazing content!
I live for white holes. They are my favourite and I would do anything to see one in person.
If you were to draw the diagram with spheres you would end up with happy little caterpillar type thing which I'm sure Bob would have approved of.
The day Tibees does ASMR is the day I start my hibernation.
I love the interludes of nature in this video so we can take in the deep concepts
Thank you for showing me how stupid I am every time I watch one of your videos
“Every day is a good day when you are a Star”.
Wow, this is very impressive, thank you so much for providing us with this most interesting and informative video presentation which is very much appreciated by us. We are absolutely delighted that you have gone to the trouble of explaining such a complex subject in a way that is most helpful to us.
Fascinating..pretty colors...mind-blowing
After I found your channel, I really begun enjoying mathematic
Omg thank you SO MUCH that during your breif description of a black hole you didnt say "nothing can escape NOT EVEN LIGHT"
That statement drives me nuts bc ive heard it over and over since the first time i read about black holes in the 80s when i as around 6 yr old.
You are amazing Toby. Thank you.
Omg the topics appearing on the bottom 😂😂 dead
Thank you for your explanations about White Holes. It helps, in order to understand Physics and the world around us in a better way!
I love the explanation. Thank you for this!
I didn’t expect to be learning astrophysics from Repunzel but I’m not complaining.
Please do more book videos, this was great!
These are my favourite
Oh what a delightful way to explain science. Big sub.
This would be great longer as a sleep story 😌. Got a sub for your pleasant voice 😄
Describing any scientific stuff isn't a small thing and now I understood completely about the white and black holes after your explanation especially that mathematical analysis made me think 🤔 larger .. Keep doing..Love u 😊Sunny grace