ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ธ.ค. 2021
- Indian-born CEOs are dominating the world. But, how does their success help India? Are they building brand India or do they represent lost Indian talent? On Gravitas Plus, Palki Sharma gets you the story of the Great Indian Brain Drain.
#BrainDrain #IndianCEOs #GravitasPlus
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
Everyone is talking about the 5 smart students from a graduating class that leave India, but no one is talking about the 50 smart students from that same batch who are still in India, but are unable to reach similar levels of "success".
I am sure guys like Sundar Pichai and Satya Nadella had classmates with even more potential than them, but who never left India and are now working in a 12-hr desk job where the toxic Indian work culture is stifling their creativity and intelligence.
We need to improve our home first and provide better opportunities to the smart folks still here instead of crying about those who have decided to leave.
Totally agree with you !
@deepGamingAI agree that, back in india we had unstabilised system bcos of those 1k years of continuous invasions. So now, for almost everyone in india or other looted nations, earning is success. But, we all need to think - we have enough food grains in godowns, almost 95% get food, now what it means is we came out of that hunger, also moat people can get clothes, agree shelter still problem for many, so now atleast we can say we got better, n i think some more time, we can rebuild our NATURE INCLUSIVE socio & political & Economical SYSTEM - and not like DEBT RIDDEN/HIGH ENERGY CONSUMERS / INSENSITIVE TO NATURE COUNTRIES 🙏
Agree
Agreed 👍
agreed brother
My sister worked hard ,topped her boards and got into the best govt college to do MBBS. We are general merit students. She came Rank 5 in MD entrance exams (now it's called NEET ) despite this she couldn't secure the speciality of her choice because of the quota system .I understand the quota system but in medical specialy that is about saving lives ,you need to treat everyone as equal after passing MBBS. She was so furious that that despite studying so hard someone who was half as efficient walked away with the seat .We didn't have enough money to get her a private college seat .She studied hard cracked USMLE. She got into the best US hospitals and today is leading oncologist at California 's top hospital . I'm following her footsteps now . We didn't choose this for ourselves, we are forced to flee . If you wonder why the best doctors are sitting in USA and UK, this s the reason.Medical Toppers without rich parents and without quota for my super speciality have no future in India. We are values everywhere else. It hurts to stay away from our family but we have NO CHOICE !
I feel u dude, have gone through the same pain but in the engineering field, planning to leave India for good.
Same here.. this reservation is such an issue 🙄
buddy, the government and the system in India are corrupted in all sectors. That's the only reason why talented people are thrown away.
Very unfortunate but true, but this no government can dare to touch, because it is vote Bank, initially set for 10 years, don't know how many times it would be renewed...
The Indian socialist society of 70 years of Democratic ruling gave India the gift of quotas and reservation system. It’s getting introduced in US too very soon.
I remember. Few decades back I was student of engineering in India. I was within top15% merit list . At the same time , another guy with 45% score was able to get admission in to same course as me. Why ? He happened to be born in specific caste. Job was reserved for him so when he eventually cleared BE after 6-7 years, he had government job. While other graduates, better than him, were still looking for job. I left India with 4 years of research experience and now working at organization that has engineering design center in India. Not everyone get lucky like me. If India wants to retain brains, 1) abolish reservations in education and jobs 2) reward merit 3) keep politics away from education 4) have national spirit among people of different states 5) encourage risk taking
How many times can I give a thumbs up for this comment? Finally.... I would like to add one thing, retain reservations for merit students who are from economically weaker sections, and Upgrade educational institutions and make them public not private. Padhega India tabhi badhega.
What is the reason for reservation ?
1. It is important for the specific caste to represent themselves in a society .
2. Specific caste might get the job but never get the equality in the social platform.
3. Specific caste should get reformed law by which they can come in upper cast and they must be accepted by society as well .. I bet you numbers are in millions.
4. Deep inside most of the people have discrimination elements ,it's a fact.
5. Lack of education was the only reason why they were kept doing small work(sweeper, Blacksmith,cleaner,cobbler,peasants etc) they have been exploited for a long time now they need education .
5. Fact : 100% of sweeper,cleaner and other dirty works come from specific cast ,you can check this fact by taking a small survey anytime anywhere in India .
6. Poverty is problem of government but discrimination is problem of society.
7. Specific caste have been a deprived group from education .. it's not a lottery ticket for getting job.
8. India is a very big country in which not only uppercast or privileged caste live .. but also others are there who have been exploited by upper cast who broke their backbone by keeping them to only small dirty works .. education was way too far from them .
9. Reservation is a secondary problem primary problem is discrimination.
10. Without reservation people may not be able to represent themselves in society and then like old time they will be limited to small work because you know everyone favour their community only and by this discrimination will increase.
11. No body is getting rich infact they just reach middle class or upper middle class.
12. Go and check work reports of specific caste employees in any sector they will be at their best with efficient contribution in their department and you will be surprised to see the data of corrupt employees taking bribe is rare most comes from upper caste .
Brother you should see the big picture .. I also want that country should develop but development should be for each and every group or community.
These decisions are guarded by supreme court and they know what will happen if they will take back reservation.
Maybe you don't discriminate but that doesn't means everyone is like you .. discrimination is curse for the country and reservation is just it's effect .
There are questions for you,if you will help me to know .
1. Why most of the specific caste are afraid of getting their caste revealed in public .. why don't they show off like thakur,gujjar,Brahmin .. where is their confidence ?
2. Still there are places if you want to rent a room or house then you must be a upper cast .. why is it so ?
3. In a society you are treated a little different than people belonging to your own community .. why ?
4. No body talks about discrimination but everyone is standing against reservation .. pehle discrimination Aya ya reservation ?
5. How many inter caste marriage happens in this modern scenario .. why youth also goes for their caste for getting married if there is no discrimination ?
6. There are places where people avoid having water or food in a specific caste house .. and they say that we will get "asudh" or polluted if they do so .. if they accidentally get touched by a specific caste they will immediately wash hands or will take bath .. is it right ?
7. Reservation is provided for social upliftment .. so why it is seen as economic empowerment ?
8. 22.8 % of upper caste have 41 % of money of India and 16.6 % of specific caste only have 7-8% money of India .. what's does this indicate ?
9. 50% of population of upper caste belong to rich class .. 10 % of population of specific caste belong to rich class .. how come it's only 10 % if they get jobs and admissions so easily ?
10. Why still there are incidents of inhuman behaviour with specific caste all around the India in today's world ?
Han par ek cheez jarur hai ab 10% tak vary karta hai merit jahan pehle 30-40% tha .. and i promise aage aur kamm ho jaega aur sayad fir reservation ki jarurat hi na pade jb equality aa jaegi sb community ke approach aur vision me .. jaldi Aisa hona chahiye .. you were right padhega india tbhi badhega india and uske liye sabka ek level pe ana jaruri hai jo(upper caste) pehle se knowledge le rahein hain they know the importance of studies bs sbko(others) samjh aa jaye 👍😊
Nevermind 😊
I am not Indian, but the excellent reporting skills of this lady made me watch the report right to the end. Respects Ma'am.
It’s horrible reporting, don’t check her dress , beauty and accent. Check her GUTS- she couldn’t call out #1 and only reason- caste based reservation. Lol. Caste system is adopted from British practices and specious thinking. We should unite as Hindus and leave behind a word ‘casta’ to Portuguese.
absolutely!
Doesn’t take much to impress you 🤣
@@blueeyes6192 It does.
@@wallsmash must be a low bar 🤣
Points missed by Palki.
1. Political Structure of India
2. Systemwide Corruption Rate in India.
3. Caste based Reservation System.
4. Law & Order Situation in India.
5. Air, Water & Food Quality in Metro Cities.
6. World looking at India & Indians as just a Market and NOT A NATION.
Each one of these individuals could be compared with Kohinoor diamonds
Bro u r absolutely rit! But with all those above mentioned negative points, we will have so many INDIAN companies i coming decades..so wait for just one decade. We will surprise the world, bt to achieve this goal INDIA should have a strong central govt..If milijhuli Sarkar comes then it will reverse..
@@mukherjee9262 and Guess what!! till then be unemployed and most importantly waste 10 years of your youth.
True
Unemployment
She's telling the truth. Most of my doctors and professors in University were Indian. Even my first employers were Indian brothers. I do notice that Indians in India praise monopolistic tendencies. Seems like India needs to create an environment for small businesses to thrive.
It's already happening we recently beat UK and took 3rd position after USA and china in number of unicorn companies and more are coming the main problem is because of overpopulation , caste based reservation system and ofcourse better salaries in west with every facility available on time and meeting with international community and doing lots of traveling .But now our government is trying to create as many industries in different fields as much as possible and reform our infrastructure.
@@Kalinga_yodha you can't conclude anything yet just because India was able to produce that many unicorns for one year. Sustaining the progress over the long term is needed more.
@Sangram Sarkar lol 🤣😂 just check the facts before saying anything we recently beat uk in unicorn if u can't believe a report which is not published in india then it's not my problem
@Sangram Sarkar hua hai jaa jake dekh le most unicorn likh ke dekh pata chal jayega WhatsApp par news padta hai kya jo itni important news ka pata nahi teko
Indian only want money
"Reservations at work place" and " Reservations in education" are not only catalysts but the very reason for brain drain. I wonder how did you missed it in your profound study.
Upper caste logo keh pass at least bahar desh jaa keh padhne keliye paisa hain. Jadatar Lower caste logo keh pass utna bhi nahi hain. Ager reservation nahi hoga toh woh aage padh hi nahi sakega. Ager sabko equal opportunity dena hain toh Sabko Equal facility bhi milna chahiye free of cost.
@@rubudollo6524 If so called Upper class had that much money and power with unity, either it would have been migrated totally or it would have been ruling the country.
Equiality does not mean tending towards other extremity it literally mean treating people equally irrespective of there caste, creed or religion, and not privileging a set of people at the cost of capacity of capable.
The capable is just a proved capable without any label of categories.
And by the way there is a famous saw " There is no free lunch." It fits in the law of karma too.
So many years after reservation started it should be have been made void either by understanding it is not really fruitfull or by concluding that it was successful attempt.
What is the reason for reservation ?
1. It is important for the specific caste to represent themselves in a society .
2. Specific caste might get the job but never get the equality in the social platform.
3. Specific caste should get reformed law by which they can come in upper cast and they must be accepted by society as well .. I bet you numbers are in millions.
4. Deep inside most of the people have discrimination elements ,it's a fact.
5. Lack of education was the only reason why they were kept doing small work(sweeper, Blacksmith,cleaner,cobbler,peasants etc) they have been exploited for a long time now they need education .
5. Fact : 100% of sweeper,cleaner and other dirty works come from specific cast ,you can check this fact by taking a small survey anytime anywhere in India .
6. Poverty is problem of government but discrimination is problem of society.
7. Specific caste have been a deprived group from education .. it's not a lottery ticket for getting job.
8. India is a very big country in which not only uppercast or privileged caste live .. but also others are there who have been exploited by upper cast who broke their backbone by keeping them to only small dirty works .. education was way too far from them .
9. Reservation is a secondary problem primary problem is discrimination.
10. Without reservation people may not be able to represent themselves in society and then like old time they will be limited to small work because you know everyone favour their community only and by this discrimination will increase.
11. No body is getting rich infact they just reach middle class or upper middle class.
12. Go and check work reports of specific caste employees in any sector they will be at their best with efficient contribution in their department and you will be surprised to see the data of corrupt employees taking bribe is rare most comes from upper caste .
Brother you should see the big picture .. I also want that country should develop but development should be for each and every group or community.
These decisions are guarded by supreme court and they know what will happen if they will take back reservation.
Maybe you don't discriminate but that doesn't means everyone is like you .. discrimination is curse for the country and reservation is just it's effect .
There are questions for you,if you will help me to know .
1. Why most of the specific caste are afraid of getting their caste revealed in public .. why don't they show off like thakur,gujjar,Brahmin .. where is their confidence ?
2. Still there are places if you want to rent a room or house then you must be a upper cast .. why is it so ?
3. In a society you are treated a little different than people belonging to your own community .. why ?
4. No body talks about discrimination but everyone is standing against reservation .. pehle discrimination Aya ya reservation ?
5. How many inter caste marriage happens in this modern scenario .. why youth also goes for their caste for getting married if there is no discrimination ?
6. There are places where people avoid having water or food in a specific caste house .. and they say that we will get "asudh" or polluted if they do so .. if they accidentally get touched by a specific caste they will immediately wash hands or will take bath .. is it right ?
7. Reservation is provided for social upliftment .. so why it is seen as economic empowerment ?
8. 22.8 % of upper caste have 41 % of money of India and 16.6 % of specific caste only have 7-8% money of India .. what's does this indicate ?
9. 50% of population of upper caste belong to rich class .. 10 % of population of specific caste belong to rich class .. how come it's only 10 % if they get jobs and admissions so easily ?
10. Why still there are incidents of inhuman behaviour with specific caste all around the India in today's world ?
Government do not give any kind of certificate course or diploma for cleaner and domestic workers .. brother brain drain se jyada apko manpower drain dikhega .. you know very well foreign countries me bht acha salary aur equal respect rehta hai har kaam ke liye .. humari country Aisa kaam bas lower caste hi milega .. manpower drain would be a 10 times more bigger problem .. desh chote kaam karne walon se hi Banta hai .. kyunki woh kaam har koi nahi kar sakta na jata hai .. dedo opportunity cleaners aur baki sbhi aise kaam walon ko .. then see .. jb baat kar rhe ho toh sb cheezon ki Karo 🙏😊
If a country cannot give equal opportunity to it's top talent, then it doesn't deserve to complain about brain drain.
As an American Prof of IT in the 90s and early 2000s, at least half of my graduate students were from India - highly motivated, determined to succeed. None of them wanted to remain in the US. They wanted to go back to India. After the year of practicum offered to them after they graduated, less than 10% did. When questioned, they listed what you have brought up. They talked about returning to India in the future once they had earned enough money, but none ever did.
That money earned will never be enough to return. Because India would have gotten equally expensive for their lifestyle.
Also they would have their family kids in US and since they came abroad for education they would think that their kids will come too right. So the cycle continues and hence they might have continued.
Report them to immigration.
@@AlAl-wn2cf lol
@@shwethap5775 give the anchor a job in NYT. she will also move abroad. lol :)
@@ayush.pratap.singh. WiON pays her Million Dollar salary idiot. Search about her. She even has stake in WiON.
Very well articulated and presented. This is Narendra Shukla from Sydney, Australia.
I love India, and after working in India for close to a decade, it wasn’t an easy decision to make a move to Australia. For me, a few of the reasons as listed below, were major factors.
-Equal opportunity
-Feel valued and respected
-Growth opportunities are not driven by who you know but what you can do and what you know - your real world capabilities.
-Red tape: Employers in India still demand 10th 12th mark sheets- even if you have 15+ years of experience. Not sure what they achieve by doing so. I personally find this practice quite rudimentary, boring and annoying.
-I’ve seen discriminatory job adverts. Such as candidates from IITs or IIMs only. Though, I’m not from any of these, I’ve led teams consisting of IITians. Developed countries offer opportunities based on merit/actual capabilities not based on where you come from.
-No reservation. At least my kids can have an environment free of cast based reservation.
I’m sure if not all, most of the immigrants consider at least some of these points before making a move.🙏
You love India but you work for Australia.
Clearly you love money more than India.
But don't worry bro we can build India without you
Best of luck for future!
@@bhagyasinghgurjar9923 You can't. You would've already if you could've but you are just good at talking after getting butt hurt.
Wanna know if a country is a failed banana republic state, look for brain drain problem 😂😂😂😂 India is right at the top of the list, the best case study of a failed 3rd world country with an ego bigger than its stomach 😂😂😂😂
dude no offence I agree on everything u commented just one I disagree and that is caste reservation....do u know how many SC and obc are below poverty line....guess u don't know...maybe u r yourself one of us...but u think we lower caste enjoy equal respect...no dude we don't...we are black...we are ugly and that's why we are sometimes and often treated with hate and disgust....and till now lower caste like mine is still below poverty line...so caste reservation is needed.........after all our ancestors and even current generation suffer discrimination from brahmj.s and upper caste...though not all are like that
This is very valid, 70% of my classmates in the UK are from India and none of the ones I have spoken to wants to return to work in India.
I wanted to do masters from an NIT or IIT.
being an average student who focuses more on practical learning than ratta learning, after studying for over 16 hours in a day, managed to secure 497 rank in NIT and 495 in IIT.
The admission list closed at 496 in NIT and 493 for IIT for general unreserved category, while list for reserved categories went on around 6000+ ranks.
Opted to take admission in a private college near my hometown, secured a honours degree for my masters.
Now I'm working in United Kingdom and have no regrets.
Wtf bhai log iit k liye koi bhi branch le lete h. M khud 2 saal drop m waste ke diye. I have 3 years left in my degree. Can I get a foreign placement? Few students in my cllg got foreign placement from Amazon, Google etc. through off campus placement.
@@bosongod2830 Gald that you left India. Atleast, your potential and talent didn't go down the drain.
Cast reservations exist because cast system exists and reservations exist because discrimination exists 😂😂 aur itna jhooth
Greetings from Everett Washington USA. Interesting topic, living here in the Seattle metro area. I've worked with many Indian Engineers, IT professionals, and Doctors etc. Indians are hard working people and they love India.
I've asked them why they decided to move to the USA instead of staying in India. The responses I've received is that their skills are more valued in the United States, hence they get job offers with more money. Since they have desirable skills, they can find better opportunities here in the USA. Some have said that the quality of life is better for them here.
Many Indian professionals have better access to other professionals who are educated and can network better something that I've heard said many times, that in India it's hard in some regions of the country for professionals to interact or not enough professionals to network etc.
Bs. Majority Indians on wion thinks India is a superpower and regard USA as a failed nation.
Precisely. Especially the part of better talent recognition. I too am trying for US. Good to know that you guys choose talent over some stupid caste.
India should thank the Brits for colonising them and teaching them English as these Indians would be nowhere if they didn't knew English to begin with.
Yes
@@molamola8305 okay bot bye
Finally a journalist who doesn't scream and speaks with reason. Kudos to the channel and the journalist for an amazing display to professionalism!
Its not only caste reservation. India also has gender reservations. Women are also getting reservations in many fields. Women have reservations even in buses and trains lol. Only general category men are suffering
Bengali detected Opinion Rejected
@@sushilsharma4202 what's wrong with you?
Ravish
@@sushilsharma4202 What's your issue ?
It's not the Students/Employees who want to leave India.
It's the country that forces us to go out. I left India back in 2019 and shifted to USA. I already refused many opportunities back in 2015, 2018 just because I want to be the part of the Indian economy.
In 2018, my daughter who was 7 year old was eve teased by the colonies uncles in Delhi where I used to live. She was visiting nearby shop to buy Chips and Bread.
Can you imagine? 7 year old girl eve teased by some bloody 40-50 year old uncles. Such a shame.
I confronted them but they were so many and I was all alone. They complained to my Landlord and he gave us eviction notice after saying that "beti ko shaam ko bahar bhejte hi kyu ho, Yeh toh hoga hi"
I complaint to Police. They came and they were drinking Chai with those uncles. Even I was taken to the police station because those uncle filed a false complaint against me that I eve teased their daughters. That i am mischievous and roam in balcony naked.
I immediately left the place and shifted to some other society.
Policeman took bribe of 15000 to dismiss my case. He also said to me "Ki ladte rehna case. Wife and beti ka bahar nikalna band karwa dunga".
I am 39 year old grown man and not some 17 year old teenager who take decision without thinking twice.
Me and my wife decided to leave India and I took that foreign opportunity and never regretted.
What a shame you had to go through such, sorry for what you had to go through I feel you brother
Dukh laga ye sun ka sir
I had been hearing about brain drain from India for the last fifty years. The media was complaining about it when unemployed College graduates of India were seeking to migrate to a country where they can get a job. The migration resulted in a stable and strong Indian community in US and Europe and they sent money back to India several times more than what the Govt. might have spent for their education in subsidies.
*This is a very important topic which unfortunately is being neglected with a pseudo feeling of pride, we as Indians feel proud that a large proportions of scientists in NASA are Indians but we fail to recognize that not many scientists in ISRO are foreigners. We proudly rhetorically say that India was a bird of Gold but we as Indians want Government jobs to just warm the chairs, so many examples like these that a book may be written... Sad truth!*
There are no Indians in NASA. Nasa only hires Americans. Foreign nationals are contractors and indians contractors are rare or none.
Dear we general category people don't even dream about government jobs we only want equal opportunities in educational institutions which sadly we don't get. When our country is not able to provide us opportunities why should we sacrifice ourself in the name of patriotism?? It should be both ways na!!
Its China Fault! Its the Wuhan virus! Indian intelligent and logic at its best ! Its always someone fault. If I was a real talented Indian , I will stay away from this country as far-as possible.
As per NASA data only 8% of its employees are Asian American or Pacific Islanders. Not sure where you got this information of large proportion of scientists in NASA are Indians.
@@pandeyom6877 I totally agree with you.
You must include Scientists and PhD holders in STEM subjects.
Having been established myself abroad, I went back to India in 2018 for a permanent settlement. This was just to spend time with my parents. I went on job hunting everywhere in India for two years. In June 2019 I got a job with 30k@month, and after the first two months, I was asked to work for 10k@month. I left the job and asked for a Bank loan to start a small business.
My 15-20 other NRI friends in India helped me with the capital after many banks refused.
With whatever capital I had, a large portion went on satisfying local political parties, and state bureaucrats.
I abandoned everything and came back with my parents in February 2020.
Now leading a happy and stable life abroad with my parents.
India does not value pure science. It values a Btech from IIT more than a PhD.
Sad reality of our country..!!
Sad reality of politics and economics
Your situation is questioning me now,if I should go for PhD abroad,as no matter what,even I,ll have to come back to India as my dad got properties here and I am the only child...
sad truth . But those who want to stay don't pay bribe , instead are now reporting to CBI to trap these crooks. And you can also report directly to PMO via email or twitter with your complaint. It does work.
As most folks are in hurry so they think they should bribe and so the corruption thrives.
But your decision is understandable
As an Indian born in America, I think it's just a matter of quality of life. I'll say that if India's quality of life was much better, many including myself would try and move there in a heartbeat. I truly wish the best for my homeland, but we have a long way to go.
even if I have to live in slum I will work for my country ;)
@@Nero6570 Analysis...“Did you really mean that ?”
@@kidnamedgrass yes :)
It's quality of life because of the medieval colonization and looting of Asia and Africa that's why quality life gain some knowledge instead talking about quality life.Native Americans and Blacks don't have a quality life over there
Nikal lodu 😂
i am watching this video as i enjoy my 6-figure salary in usa. glad I gave up on gate and moved here for masters. best decision of my life. life is so smooth here. a decision my future generation will applaud.
Sorry to put a pin in it but your future generation (and mine) will probably reject everything Dharmic about them and wont be able to tell their own gender. They will swallow every outdated lie their education system teaches about you and me. Sometimes, the costs aren't as plain in sight as the benefits.
Not to be a buzzkill, I'm in the same plight as you.
I am doing my Masters in a university in Germany and it's shocking to see out of 120 students 90 students are Indians. This is the level of migration happening from India. I know the reasons and completely agree with Ms. Palki. Indian Govt. has to do major reforms to stop young students from leaving the country.
Let’s come back pay to our motherland. We owe so much to our country and society.
@@brijeshthakkar3210 No we don't lmao
@@brijeshthakkar3210 we own to our country and society? What exactly do we owe?
All i know is the country is owing our chances of development
@@brijeshthakkar3210 What do we owe?? Could you explain?
Because Germany don't have reservations
Some of my Indian friends told me that they were frustrated with reservation in Indian universities, some said pollution would reduce their lives by 15 years, some believed that the west pays more money for similar skills, some were unhappy with traffic, but all my Indian friends miss their food and frequently go to Indian restaurants in America
Reservation of lower cast people is bullshit in today's world there's no real cast/racism in india
Reservation is real. When a general person, as we call it here, scores 85% they are denied admission in good colleges, not top colleges but average good colleges. At the same time some SC/ST/OBC person who scored 60 to 70 % will get admission in the same or better college without even paying the full fees just because they belong to a particular tribe/caste or they are minority. This is applicable everywhere in our country, in schools and colleges where general public has to pay extra fees + donations to get a seat which their child deserves rightfully. In government sectors, business, hospitals etc. And how can we forget NEPOTISM. People here do not respect the skills and talent. They care about money.
Why? They dont know how to cook?
@@calvinripley9093 There is in villages, but the reservation in higher education doesnt help those marginalized ones in any way at all. Only the already town and urban already educated and empowered of those 'so called lower castes' who already live in urbanised equal societies get reservations over and over. It doesnt help the actual poor and discriminated ones in godforsaken villages.
@@calvinripley9093 Really? You should be one of those privilegaged ones like the white people who say there is no racism or the uber rich who says there is no poverty, but people don't work hard enough.
Having been to both Canada and India I totally understand why Indians would move there and never move back.
Canada is phenomenally beautiful, has world class infrastructure and treats everyone equally.
Seriously, Canada is amazing
Except First Nations people.
@@shauncameron8390 Modern Day Canada has bent over backwards to rectify historical wrongs
Palki, your podcast on brain drain struck a chord with me. The Fiji Islands in the South Pacific had almost equal population of Indians and Indigenous people. After the military coup, staged primarily against Indians, 26,000 Indians of mainly the professional ilk left Fiji in the first year and the biggest beneficiaries were New Zealand, Australia, US and Canada. For a tiny island nation like Fiji, the loss of human capital was devastating to the economy, and took 30 years to recover. I was one of those , with 17 years of education including a University degree and 13 years of work experience , left Fiji reluctantly, and ended up with a better and well paying series of jobs in NZ. But the point is that if conditions at home are not safe or fair or promising then migration becomes an option.
Most of them are Tamilians
Simple reason: I got good marks in a govt exams, but not selected due to cast quota reason. Their cut was much lower.
So my brain also goes to drain because of caste based reservations.
I feel the caste system in India has become a divide.. Its the main reason I wonder how it's fair? A child is decided on where he can study not on marks.. But in the family he is born in... That is the wait fantastic British people.. Ensured.. We don't grow.. Even after they leave.. We will have divides continuesly... When it affects the children.. They leave India..
👍
Ok, don't return again ...
I belongs to gen category
But I like competition.
It's judges our brain capacity
Bcoz of article 13 in indian constitution that permits govt to create separate reservation on certain classes of people for employment as it thinks fit.
@@chatcricket1405 well see it this way, the country is over populated, more demand less options. There's no guarantee that you'd get a job even if reservations were there or not. If you can fight fight for it, else leave the country, earn more get a better living.
India will always stay like this for several centuries. Go out explore the world, have a better life.
As per an iit professor, less than 5 percent from his college goes out of the country every year, but the impact they are able to create in a merit based society is much greater. We completely ignore the 95% who stay back and go into oblivion in the country because they are stuck in traffic everyday,fighting potholes or dont have energy left to contribute after paying 30-40% taxes in their bracket with no future security or benefits for healthcare and children education.
Do we even notice the talent which is already there in the country, in your own office?
We are still talking about having more reservations in private sector and in promotions in govt jobs in Supreme court dealings regardless of how it impacts the economy and the country.
Why do we expect the talent to work hard for us, when in every election we see shameless freebies given in the form of loan waivers, free electricity and what not?
Truth is we are a socialist society with a crab mentality and we do not like anyone who is more successful than us,whether it is an nri or Tata, Adani or an Ambani.
Its a very frustrating place to decide your future, you cannot just pick up anything
you have to realize it will never get you any job or money.
everything is so risky and failure in society or family is simply not acceptable, you end up doing things you never wanted to do.
Its a depressing country to live in, so says the figure
Good point, I wanted this video to deal deeper into the issue but ended up sounding alarm only, "loss of opportunities" the sweeping term to put the entire problem into doesn't disuss why there are lesser opportunities, I still don't regard india a developing country yet when 50 percent of workforce is employed in agriculture and most of the service sector is full of call centers like work, there is no place for a skilled person in an underdeveloped country.
Well said brother 👏 👍
I think most of them won't go abroad straight out of the college. They will work for 1-2 years and then leave for MS. So actual percentage might be higher. Also for iitians, the salary in India itself is very high.
@@anujrbx Shaheen Bagh politics? Well FyI India secures 3rd rank after america and china in unicorn companies India defeated UK and secured 3rd position. You must appreciate the things done by present govt but you clearly have an agenda or you hate bjp coz you might be corrupt
Dear Palki, thanks for shedding light on this topic. As you can see in this comments section, we have lots of people complaining about caste reservation, that they lose out on opportunities because they cannot get into the college of their choice, corruption issues and fact that their talent is not respected but is instead neglected either due to caste or due to money matters. I too have faced similar issues but inspite of knowing this, I am planning to return back even though I am not an Indian passport holder anymore. After thinking a lot about this and I am sure that this is a question that every NRI/OCI thinks about, I can only think of the quote from 3 idiots, koi bhi desh perfect Nahi hota, use perfect banana padta hai.
Reservation system plays a major role in making talent migrate from India. I know several of my friends who left India as they can't get into IIM but still can get into universities like CMU or MIT
Growing up in India, I remember carrying a 50 rupee note every time I drove my bike because the local policeman always asked for a bribe even when I had a valid license and registration. I returned to India after living in the US for 10 years. Within 5 min after landing, a customs officer openly asked me for a bribe and harassed me until I gave up. Just last month, while my spouse was in the check in counter at the airport, the airline told us that all Indian visas were canceled and we need to reapply even though our visa was supposed to be active for 10 years. I gave up my Indian citizenship a few years ago and it was a bittersweet moment. I do want to contribute but I can't because India doesn't even allow for dual citizenship and screws me over every chance it gets. I'm not even allowed to apply for an OCI due to my job with the federal government. I hope and wish for a bright future for India but things have to change. Corruption is like cancer. It's killing India from the inside.
Well said, I hope things get better
@@rahulk2633 I don't think so, we hate corrupts ...but we would like a traffic police who would leave us with a little bribe ...for breaking law
I never faced bribery situation mentioned here. Government works get done in Telangana without bribe.
I agree with you brother. There is a lot of corruption here. People are insensitive to others problems. I'm kinda worried for my newborn daughter. I just wish she grows up well educated and moves to a better country where she is welcome.
@@skydoven people like you who promote and take bribe are the real curse of india
Reservation and lack of opportunities, recognition are the main reasons. I know a friend who didn’t got in ISRO because of open category cutoff but managed to get into NASA after a year.
Very sad but reality
Exactly so, I knew someone from ...she went to premier institute iit delhi, but wasn't able to secure a job in india, she moved to USA and now is working with avomeen. She settled there permanently. This is actually the story.
Quota reservations are there...and most importantly reservations through politics. I know people who failed classes in school now working in govt ranks...
Exactly 🔥
I know a whole bunch of people from open category in my college who scrapped through under grad, didn’t improve their communication skills, didn’t get placed in campus, but left for the US, Australia and UK thanks to their bank balance. All settled there now, so moving to usa and working there not necessarily translates to having good skills.
I believe the ones in India are equally skilled, look at the investments pouring into Indian start ups.
@@dudmatix has it ever occurred to you that it maybe because there is very few good jobs for the millions of us who are entering the job market every year and covid has just exacerbated that problem.
Palki, I graduated with B.E. in Mechanical and decided in late 1960 not to go abroad. I searched for a job in Gujarat, but I could not find a respectful job for a long time, eventually, I found a job 100 miles away from my home, but during my interview, a general manager offer me a job with only a salary of Rs. 60 per month. I refused that job because the living cost was Rs. 300 a month in the area. After a couple of months a got job in Western Railway of India, Lower Parel Factory in Bombay (Mumbai) for Rs. 300. With the hope, that I will advance there, I decided to survive for a few months in the Bombay economy by supplementing the cost of leaving with my own family money. But, in the very first week, a production manager who was not an engineering college graduate told all new recruits that he did not need us because he was running that factory since the British Raj and not needed any innovation or changes. He told new recruits that we get lost in the factory wherever we like to kill time our time and peacefully collect our salaries. Then and then I felt, that I need not struggle and I planned to go abroad to the USA for higher education. In the 1070s, I got M.E. in Mechanical and followed by MS in Computer Science. I am now U citizen and living in the USA as a retired engineer. I agree with you that Indian businesses and Government have to change a lot to retain India’s brain.
Wow!.... to the point and hits the core!!! Thanks Palki for bringing some important issue to the front.
American here, I used to work for an Indian company in the states and for a software company now with many Indians. Thank you for introducing me to your food, all have been good people glad to have them here.
Glad you enjoyed , their are lots of indian cooking channels ........ You can learn to cook Delicious , diet specific , health goods
Thank to ur government to providing opportunity for india immigrants worker also indian government dont know to priority valuable talented ppl inside their country that why india have high unemployment rate and collapsing economy
Pls oppose the caste system and birth based discrimination againsts so called user castes which wokes and liberals are bringing to Americas.
As an MBBS student, I can tell you this.... the Reservation system in medical sector, the quality of education and skills provided in all the medical colleges and the situation of resident doctors and their safety in India is enough to explain the brain drain. If you open any National news channel now, you'll see that there's 0 reporting about the current delay in NEET PG councelling, protests and harrassment of residents. Most public aren't even aware this is happening right now. Btw, this batch of residents are the "COVID warriors" that the govt. and media used for TRP.
And in the end, when something goes wrong people beat up the overworked doctors who are probably looking at 100s of patients at a given time
Harassment?? Sorry could you please explain a bit more. I'm appearing for neet next year so I wanted to know..
@@georgythomas8451 I literally hate that. Beating up doctors is literally such a cheap move. People need to get a life
Others ok excuse me reservation system? When u have money to pay for everything and have better education with all the support doin nathng but studies.. student like me who have to work and support family and study.. dont have anythng anyone to support us we only hav our education and scholarships.. reservations really gives chance for us to prove ourself either, its not simply served to us.. you think people who can buy seats are talented more talented than peoples like us who hard for studies? You are the kind of people who think mavali ka beta mavali hona chahiye.. sewage clean karne vale ke bete beti ko vahi kaam karna chahiye...? Because of your kind of mentality we are cornered many time saying what talent you have u are simply here because of your reservation? It does gave us chance to prove ourselves its simple as tht.. If you cant understand this simple thing.. society meh sabi keliye kuch acha karna chahthe ho ya particular group ke liye, like who is on the top let them on top? What govt is doin here they are cutting down all the opportunities we all have now.. Instead of focusing education good health developments they are simply doing what.. ? Aap log abi bhi reservation ko kosthe raho..
@@salups8284 bhai we genral candidates have no problem with the reservation for the EWS and the PWD but the problem starts when the SC/ST/OBC take up more than 50% seats out out of which 10-20% didnt have any problems with discrimination nor financial. Our simple point is why should we suffer for a thing which we didn't do. There are so many rich students who get seats easily just bcz they belong to some caste and then later on get monetary benefits too. U are just seeing ur situation. No one denies the fact that reservation should be financial based as the SCs who are poor will suffer discrimination and other hardships but what about the ones who are rich they dont live in places where they are discriminated they go to urban places where these things are almost dead. They study in the same coachings as the general candidates then how can u say they have any talent and calibre to share the same hostel room as the general who is paying much higher fees has lesser annual income work much much more harder than the other guy.
No one is saying that people with ur situation dont deserve reservation but they are against the ones i described. 50% in IITs 64% NEET PG for the reserved caste. AIR 3 and AIR 2 in NEET PG arent getting branches of choices now tell me who is more talented than them.
Wow palki u r extraordinary, the way u present, it s worth watching, informative, no drama involved, unlike other broadcasters, u r simple, yet appealing and simply superb
How nice to listen to the news presented without anger, self righteousness, drama, and wretched facial expressions that signifies the end of the world. Also nice to have the facts backed up with history and expert data. (US)
Really expert data (USA) that's the problem of you western people you think yourself superior and call your data expert really 😂
Actually, India will never lack in number of brains no matter how many of them leave for other countries, but these brains deserves and need better system and better opportunities.
Wanna know if a country is a failed banana republic state, look for brain drain problem. Philippines, Myanmar, Afghanistan all have the same problem, just to name a few 😂😂😂😂 India is right at the top of the list, the best case study of a failed 3rd world country with an ego bigger than its stomach 😂😂😂😂
The people who are leaving are the ones who already have jobs. They got all the opportunities in the form of education, long training, job experience. No country wants plain graduates.
True bro. India will.never lack talent. But if we continue exporting it , it doesn't matter even if are most talented in the world 😅😅
@@yangleezhao908 someone is hiring these people with high egos.
@@yangleezhao908 arey kurra puka nuv inka sachipooledaaa.. 🤣🤣
She’s right, Indian immigrants in the US are very successful, at least in my experience. I think as a country India should focus on smaller businesses. Small/medium size businesses are the backbones for a healthy society
6:09
No healthcare
No govt funding
Everywhere reservation
99% cut of in universities
Lot of corruption
And list goes on
India is way behind western nations
Small business is destroyed by GST
Meanwhile indian immigrants worker in saudi arabia,UAE are depressing,working like slavery but arab ppl disrespect,ungrateful to them
Right
Well said, Adding to that - Not only doctors but I would say this for every other people having aspirations in various fields.Some people getting NOTHING just because of quota system is very frustrating! More over the people from classes considered less privileged are far more wealthy now-a-days. A first step would be to establish a check based on the earnings of the people by the govt irrespective of the class and provide benefits to those who are really in need.I do not say this just for saying because I have actually experienced it seeing people who are wealthy from a different class getting scholarships,exam fee reductions etc while my parents had to work day and night to pay just because I do not belong to the class which gets benefits!
PS: This is only my personal view, yours might be different. Everyone in this country has the right to express their views and that's that!
DeepGamingAI, Fully Agreed..
Myself an Entrepreneur and become Pilot in US. - 25yrs in US (Florida)
Completely changed my life here.
US opportunities changed my life and soon I am planning to help many Indians too..
Well, If I had these same opportunities and happy life in India in 1995-1997..but not much change anyway in Indian lifestyle.
( My family still in Mumbai, but I can't visit right now due to COVID)
Well, my 1st visit UK in 1995 and then US biggest dream apportunity 1997..
Now become US citizen..Very happy, healthy, disciplined lifestyle..and financially god blessed too. (Businesses: Investors, developer, Funding, RE broker & mentor)
Well, make a best choice for yourself everyone, we have only one life.
same God bless to everyone and be safe.
I just graduated with a master's degree from a prominent university in the northeastern region of the United States.
Mrs. Palki is not lying India's best and brightest, going to school and settling abroad permanently in the U.S.
One-Third of my graduating class was of Asian-Indian descent; most of the students left with school honors.
in Germany, no one even knows what a master degree is. so backward
@@lunafringe10 Germans are more serious.
@@lunafringe10 Hey, JuJu! A master's degree is a post-bachelors degree. In some cases, there are 4 phases of degrees for Arts & Sciences fields in the USA. First, an Associate's degree is what most students attain in community college, which takes 2-3 years. Second, and most common, is Bachelor's degree which takes 4-6 years. Third, a Master's degree takes 2-3 years. Finally, the Doctorate degree, Ph.D. takes 5-7 years. Sadly, education is a BIG BUSINESS in the USA! Individual students debt amongst students is in the trillions of currency, and there is NO ESCAPE from payments with interests!
@@traceyscott909 Same in Canada, except is in billions.
@@earrth911 Earth, I do not doubt your statement.
I was denied IIT by a margin of 10 ranks and it propitiated me to pursue my education in Canada at a University of higher rankings. Surprise surprise, I received an offer with funding on my first attempt. As a result, I developed a strong disdain for the caste-based reservation system.
So you did not accept your failure & decided to blame it on someone else
Bro your testimonial is super encouraging. I want to apply for the same school too, please help with your guidance. Drop your email or contact so I can reach you directly. Thank you.
I keep seeing a lot of comments on "caste-based reservation system" what is that??
There is no caste-based reservation system in IIT
@@Skies133 very similar to affirmative action in south Africa .
After Listening this now I want to go abroad too ..fade up with reservations and post graduate bond here in medical field(I am a medical student)
Wonderful service you are providing this nation Mam. The issues you bring to the table are patriotic.
Mera Bharat magan. May god bless you.
As an African, I watched the video and read through a lot of the comments and I can see we have similar challenges in Africa. Somebody should create Indian Diaspora Development Institute, create offices around the world, assemble Indian talents around the world and use blockchain technology to raise bond to develop infrastructures and create many smart cities in India. The development of India is going to be accelerated by Indian diaspora!!! The quota system needs to be dismantled.
this is actually an amazing idea
This is a good idea
A person from altogether a different continent knows what has to be done but Not our government 😐....
Thank you so much fellow human
Indian government should take notes from you
The qota system is more like to equate india's population which has faced years of oppression and illiteracy thus can't perform. It's like reformed racism.
The people who leave the country are upper caste rich ones who've had rich parents and got personal tutors, therefore they are talented.
You need to understand india. Its much complex.
Brain drain can be solved and more equity can be brought without scrapping qota but government doesn't want to do this.
@@Aman-qr6wi Quota System is vote bank politics nothing else ! Poor ppl dont get benefitted from reservation anyways so what's the point? 🙄 we should help poor ppl irrespective of their social strata !
Brain drain was a topic when I was in school, in college, initial days of work and still it's being discussed 15 years after I started working. Except Govt everyone is bothered I guess
Spot-on!
Those clueless political morons, Some of them qualified professionals will have to given to peer pressure of their own clan
Removing reservation, and that much weight into an exam only would help.
Lots of the people who move out are really smart, middle class at least, didn't come in the top 0.1% of the exam. And it's easier to be accepted to a foreign University with a higher University rating than to get into a IIT/IISc.
@@hngroove3384 reservation won't change anything. Only the castes will change. But the core problem is going to be same corruption and ignorance.
@@bollywoodnews4797 Nope, reservation removal at higher education will help
Govt is bothered that's why GOI allocated loans to set up start ups and MSMEs in India dont just conclude acc to your perception !
More than a lot of great points are made in this video. This is my new favorite global news channel.
Palki, great presenter. Gravitas is in limelight with utmost respect and reality of facts and truth which is logic.
This is exactly what people need to hear. We applaud and pride ourselves when our people become ceos of foreign companies unware that they were able to do so because there is not enough opportunities in our country.
Are you saying these foreign ceos are the only Indian ceos ? And we are in shortage of skilled ceos in India ?
@@dudmatix yes I am. Why do all the talented and intelligent people decide to work abroad instead of staying in india and why do people go crazy when they hear some indian is the new ceo of a large multinational corporation ? . It's because there is very few opportunities for so many people in India.
@@joannejones363 i agree ..ofc there are less opportunities in india
If we had gone full communist this would not have happened, we could have become as great as the USSR, but sadly just like in the USSR, corrupt "democratically" "elected" officials will ruin everything and try to select systems like capitalism which increase and help corruption.
@@godfather7339 USSR was a living hell and communism is cancer on earth. It's the last thing we should be emulating.
There are multiple factors for "brain drain",
1st: Money (Salaries - India has very low per capita income)
2nd: Stability - job security & congenial work environment,
3rd: Political stability,
4th: General law & order,
5th: Environment & decent standard of living.
6th: Merit based recruitment, NOT reservations or cast allotment or quotas..
India has a long long way to go before people are given equal opportunity, not quota _(quotas are basically political appeasements for vote banks)_ based education or jobs etc...
Well said. My perspective is same
The main factor is reservation, no jobs and facilities for general category people.
🟡 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE PALKI SHARMA
Merit should be no.1 it's so difficult for the general caste nowadays
Solution is privatisation, more we move towards privatisation, this quota things will become redundant.
She discusses the most essential topics that requires our concern and attention.
Hot as fu.k 😭
This is a very good quality reporting, i am always impressed by the flow of the content, it is easy to understand, to the point and really worthwhile.
As a Filipino, we can relate to this Brain Drain Phenom.
hello 👋
Phillipines is a small nation where opportunities may be limited. I understand if Filipinos want to emigrate for better opportunities. But this shouldn't be happening in India.
Our failed govt policies regarding equality of status and opportunity has given rise to this trend.
@@sudeshnasarkar3538 Philippine population is Comparable to Japan, France, UK, Russia etc. So they are not small it's just that India is just too big in population.
The fact that india has a billion population and yet 17 million indians are abroad, Philippines only has 100m yet 12 million of them are not even in the country
But u can't relate to birth based reservations phenom
Since my family moved to Arusha, Tanzania, from Italy in 1949, I have come into close contact with persons of Indian origin. I have found them to be generally very fine persons, worthy of trust and employment. Later, when we moved to South Africa, my positive opinion of them never changed. They will outperform other nations in the future, and deservedly so.
Maybe the ones there left india because of hostilities in india.
@@adeeb8682 Yes there is still the problem of the cast system, but to a lesser extent.
One thing I have noticed with all human beings is that, if they are discriminated by "others", they tend to react in a positive way, by trying harder than the "well off", in order to achieve whatever they are capable of, and when moving to other countries, (often with only a small suitcase), dedicate all their energies available, in order to succeed and make their dreams come true.
The children of wealthy people rarely understand the value of "earning" what you get, and this is what is happening in rich countries, which start going downhill.
This is why I believe that India is in the up going stage. One has to be still a "dreamer" of better things, to put that extra effort to succeed
@@adeeb8682 hostility against whom? Sundar pichai, parag???
@@adeeb8682 Not in South Africa... Indians were dumped there by the British to be slaves with no way back to India. There was no hostilities against fellow Indians... It was a horrible thing done by the British that they don't acknowledge even today.
@@jn8922 Your knowledge of South Africa is limited or biased. The Indians were offered passages back to their country, but nearly all refused, because they were better off by remaining, and eventually created active communities like the town of Verulam in then Natal.
So many went into trading and shops, raising the standards of their family. They later went to university, though initially separated, by the "Afrikaner" governments when I was there.
Runga Naidoo was my accountant in the late '60s, and on weekends often used to visit us with his wife. A wonderful couple !
You should have met them "in" South Africa, before writing nonsense
I wanted to live in my home state after my engineering. But, I couldn't get a job after trying few exams as I was a general student. You need a connection or a quota for job, not merit. I had to leave my home for big cities, landed corporate job who sent me outside for work. My classmates from other casts are living the life I used to dream for.. however, I experienced life outside India only after I came here. I never thought I would leave India..
Being General category is a sin in India madam. We general category are the illigal child of India.
Cast reservations exist because cast system exists and reservations exist because discrimination exists 😂😂
When i passed out from IIT noone even bothered to ask me what I am planning to do , no Govt programs even showed any interest in hiring us .Even the professors who had taught us for so many years didn't even ask us what our future plans were. Money is the not problem .
This will not change until we give credit to capability rather than eligibility!
hope they remove caste totally
Chtye .Use your brain.
INDIANS arent moving to USA anymore .All these Twitter/google/microsoft Ceos moved to USA last decade ..INDIA produced most UNICORNS this year in the world .All these unicorns were created by youngsters in India
@@sanatandharma8837 Producing Unicorns and those Unicorns sustaining are two different things :) and Highest is relative to other countries because some countries don't even need to produce more Unicorns because the economic boost in each startup is more in western countries than in India. And producing more Unicorns has nothing to do with brain drain, according to statistics, India is still leaking lakhs of doctors, engineers and entrepreneurs to other countries and it wont stop until the economic gap is narrowed.
Also inferiority complex stricken Indians glorify NRIs more than Indian entrepreneurs.
@@sanatandharma8837 all the data given in the video was upto 2015. So the phenomenon is far from over.
Mad respect to India. I have worked with many great people from India. Brilliant men and women. They are stabilizing America.
America is the new British Raj, harnessing Indian brain power at no cost.
How about asian CEO in american they also contribute alot to economy,stabilized,providing so many job to ther immigrants worker
Thank you. Never mind the bxts'(of xing ping) replies.
@@CA213FAN not just india, countless other countries as well, we are after all living in the age of pax Americana and America is the world leader
@@CA213FAN shut up,it is not British Raj, indians are going on their own will to America.Educate yourself bro
Government officials need to see this. Simply giving big speeches in public is not required just develop simple issues at root level. Then no one in this world will be superior than Indians.
It's a blessing in disguise. Indians abroad never fail to promote Indianism. Moreover foreign nationals get to taste the brand of Indian diplomacy which they really appreciate and love. So all in all it's only Advantage Team India and the country that we Indians move into.
South Korea is a great example of a country full of patriots who came together for the love of their nation to help build it and to make it what it is today
I believe brain drain in India is GOOD for the individuals because
If a country can't serve it's talent and can't give them atleast basic appreciation or support
That country doesn't deserve that
Talent
And It has nothing to do with patriotism
Because When you work your Butt off
And still a guy from some other state gets the seat with having less numbers than you because of some god damn reservation system
That will be depressing
@@RishiHoonmai India definitely needs new leadership then. Out with the old, in with the new!
@@saveUyghurs every political party in India are dumb EVERY
Like even Congress or AAP or any other
They are just doing buisness
By spoiling the religions And dividing them
People call out Britishers for divide and rule/fool technique but the political parties are doing the same thing by dividing everywhere religion and person from each other
@@RishiHoonmai what you lack in your life is the understanding of socio economic development.
You must've thousand times repeated sare jaha se achha in your school time yet when time came to prove this point to World everyone of those who left India have failed here.
And stop using reservation as an excuse for covering your greed to look out for Western luxury lifestyle. Do you know what would have been the case of reservation wasn't there at all?..have you bothered about knowing the real demographic information of India?..do you realise the intensity of poverty which is in close nexus with social backwardness?....
@@sachinnn101 im sorry but do u realize most people leave India coz of frustration not for luxury lifestyle sure that plays an important role but thats not the reason i dont think that u have worked ur ass off for an exam and then i dont get a seat or a job just coz another person from a scheduled caste had reserved seats and they didnt deserve it didnt have good grades im all for getting them out of poverty but this doesnt help people in india exploit priviliges u should know that if u consider urself patriotic and actually have a social life
We still have more talented people in india. We need to provide them a environment
Pay them more. The idea of slavery is over
I found this comment the most interesting. You are very right in saying that. Wish someone would pay heeds to these words. Hope things would improve now. 🙏
@Space Dust My passport is still Indian and will always remain so irrespective of where I live.
How indi busy with silly mess.
How? By giving more reservation?
You are more of an educator than a journalist.. love this channel
I don't know why my earlier comment on brain drain as elaborated by Ms. Palki Sharma is not showing up. I recall that during my engineering college days a brilliant engineer from Canada took up Professorship. He was a great teacher and told me during my final year that if your brain is not drained it will be in the drain and asked me to migrate to gain recognition and due rewards. Like me, many in India did not heed such advice. Many did, some of them far less talented but almost all shone like shooting stars. They were obviously wiser and not foolish like so many nationalists like us who strongly believed of a great Indian dream coming true that only turned into a nightmare. We have a system geared to benefit the rulers and the persons who work for the rulers, to pillage and rob without remorse. This has been and continues to be in accordance with the system and culture established by the British, to serve their Kingdom. Calling our country as a democracy is a misnomer. It is truly a feudalistic democracy with a Government of the people, by some people for some people. The archaic and lackadaisical attitude of all arms of the Government is pathetic. So please don't blame intelligent people for running away. Laws to assist the downtrodden are misused by politicians, law enforcement agencies and administrators to serve their selfish ends, at the cost of talented and capable highly educated engineers, doctors and scientists. Of what use is there in lamenting brain drain and pushing more brains in Indian drains.
I’m not Indian and as glad as I am for the great Indian labor and intelligence we have in the USA, it is 100% a gain for us and a lose for India.
What's your yearly income that you are using the word labour.
Glad that you can see that it is a gain for the US to be able to grab the very best and the brightest from India. India educates these people at huge national expense. They take up opportunities that could have gone to other candidates who stayed behind in India. Nevertheless, the Indian population in the US loves both India and the US, and can act as a bridge between these two great nations.
Actually that was not my question bro
@@Lifeisenjoyyy I understand. But, in my humble opinion, you might have misunderstood David. Linguistically, the word "labor/labour" does not have the same connotations in the US as it does in India.
David was being quite fair and realistic. You must understand that even in the US, naturally, some people resent the fact that Indian immigrants are able to take up opportunities that they believe could have gone to people born in the US. These are very human issues. In my opinion, one should understand them, and not get into unnecessary blame game, particularly between two such beautiful and complementary societies as India and the US.
@Puneet Chauhan I think he just means workforce not like manual labor.
Two big reasons that were not mentioned:
1. Work culture in India is stifling due to a combination of hierarchical mindset, political influence and corruption.
2. Weather and pollution. I believe this is an understated and underappreciated reason. Each time I go to India, I am struck by how hot and smoky most Indian cities are.
Even the littering, poor city infrastructure and lack of cleanliness overall.
True, true and true. I worked in India briefly before immigrating. The “face time” requirement and recognition for seat warmers was stupid. Single guys had made the office their second home, having breakfast lunch snacks and also dinner at office! It didn’t matter if they were productive! Ridiculous office culture
And how cold western US, UK are! India is a hot country but it's not extreme like south africa as far as climate is concerned india is the best !
You can't study and work at the same time
Same people who don't give a damn to anything in India.. Suddenly go to abroad and start following everything 😂
Ma'am you are an inspiration. you are an incredible orator. I have been a journalism student and still I am learning so much from your videos. I wish I would work with you sometime.
Im an Indian after being tortured by parents and in school, and college and in jobs I have been , wounds after wounds mentally physically I can proudly say that I want to move to abroad .
Thanks to government and politics and labour makers .
Being an Indian is almost like being a labour which is slavery .
Edit :
Have a reality check
yes I want to go abroad too
India is a hellhole
@@theinformationbomber7102sameee
Indian nurses are the best. I’m a New Zealander and I always pray that God would send us Indian nurses to fill our job vacancies. They are smart, strong, reliable and awesome friends/colleagues. New Zealand is not a particularly wealthy western country, but our unions have fought hard for fair pay and conditions for our workers, which has made it a good place to live and raise a family. Now we are even attracting highly skilled American and British migrants because of our work conditions are a lot better than American ones, and because of our successful management of the pandemic. I hope that Indians can support their own workers unions to raise their society’s standards and expectations of workers pay and conditions, and make jobs more desirable for skilled workers to stay in.
@Voltar444 Starman445 that's the problem right there with Indians... They think being nurse is some kind of servant job... Maybe in India but in Western nations they are our heroes...
To be honest, I'd actually like to settle in the ANZ if I get the chance. Already decided though I'm only just starting college, and it's mainly because of many reasons others have already pointed out, some of which I'll mention:
The caste-based reservations made me hate the system. Affirmative action is one thing but compromising on quality is a consequence. I can understand to an extent in engineering but letting subpar doctors into the workforce isn't great. It's because of that that I barely missed out on an IIT seat. Thank God for BITS Pilani and its pure-merit system that let me in.
Apart from CSE and electrical branches, the other streams of engineering aren't appreciated as much. I love chemistry, so I chose Chemical Engineering, and job prospects are dim for us in the core branches. And I want to enter Academia, so I'd rather make it outside India than inside.
I could go on for a lot longer, but not a lot of people read a reply within a comment. But if you're ever more curious you're welcome to ask more about it! It's a common mentality among most of us youth, and unless the government adds some incentives for us general category students to stick around we'll all just go someplace we're appreciated better.
@Voltar444 Starman445 you know how many medicos are being detained r8 now? They can't even sue rather are being sued...
New Zealand not wealthy ?
@Voltar444 Starman445 how do you know that nurses are treated the same everywhere as they are in india? Stop embarassing yourself and concentrate on getting educated first. And what's with this white supremacy shit you are blabbering abt? What, did the indian society suddenly start giving the required respect to nurses? Stop watching porn and get off the internet for a while. You're humiliating our country.
brave woman, asking uncomfortable questions that needs to be asked. Kudos.
I totally 💯 agree she is Brave Woman, I love her profesionali to say the. News .
Wion is BJP mouth piece. Just a lip service for so called upper class due to UP election. Government is already doing other side in PG NEET counseling case to bury implementation of EWS
@I left my shoe laces in Virginia It is our ruling party in India
Fantastic. Much needed debate and Action! Wake up!!!!
One of the biggest reasons of brain drain is Competition in India. Life is a race in India. If you don’t perform as per the company, there is always someone ready to replace you. We keep competing throughout our academic career and then in the work life. There is no work-life balance. This is one of major reason for people to leave India to avoid rat race.
I live in Australia and my dr is Indian, she is really good. When I was young our family dr was also Indian, and I was born in 1966, so Indian drs in Australia have been very common for over 50 years. There are Indian drs everywhere here. They have it pretty good in Australia, the money is very good.
Wanna know if a country is a failed banana republic state, look for brain drain problem. Philippines, Myanmar, Afghanistan all have the same problem, just to name a few 😂😂😂😂 India is right at the top of the list, the best case study of a failed 3rd world country with an ego bigger than its stomach 😂😂😂😂
India has given best doctors to world
But what about racial attacks on indians?
@@deepika2117 It is not that India is the only country that produces the best doctors. India produces more doctors and do not give them proper opportunity and they immigrate to the rest of the world.
Hi Karen, glad to know. I would like to know your view about why the Indian doctor is really good in comparison to other doctors of different ethnicity.
@@deepika2117 I live in australia.. you cannot judge with 1-2 rotten apples in the basket..
India just needs business friendly culture and Indians won't even leave.
What these people want is freedom and America has it more for now.
What India needs is a better pay.
India needs a lot more than this & its never going to be possible not even in million years. This is coming from someone who has spent half his life here & half abroad .
Alot sikhs india american happy with their life,career and they never planning to going back india again,most of them working in logistics transportation company
And I think now The STARTUP Culture is Started Increasing in India But it takes Time ...
Reason:
1. No Minimum wage (Even for experience technology Professionals) i.e. Offering salaries less than a some one working at Wage Donalds US
2. No Work-life balance (Boss can may you work 14 hours a day without overtime and calls on weekends)
3. No Job security (Hire and fire culture with Social security)
Love India from Indonesia
Im from malaysia....and not an indian ...but i have to say ...gravitas reporting news...explanantion as well as facts and figures...is worth to watch...see and digest....pluss...and the presenter...i love the way how you present the facts...
Aah... Finally someone is asking right questions.
But I think Palki missed, maybe perhaps one of the biggest reason driving this brain drain, which is reservation in almost every field of study. Now "General" category is having minority seats.
Irony is on one side we are trying to be world superpower, yet on other side we are still stuck with this ancient concept of "Reservation". Why? Because politics come first than everything else.
Our politicians will never completely finish the issues like reservation, roads, infrastructure, quality of life, less pollution, because then what will they promise during next elections.
That's a fantastic true point... Reservations and not merit
Well said.
Truly said sir
This is the most common excuse given by most people but the fact is those who goes outside too have to compete in private sectors that are open for all just like the private sectors of India....'Generals' and 'Reserve' are only good in government sectors but when these competent people can compete in the private sectors of the West, why can't they do the same living in India....
Palki DID mention the way reservation is also responsible for India's brain drain, in the piece she did about reservation. She should have mentioned it here as well.
India ,A country where the reserved get facilities rather than the deserved.
Reservation is the core of all problems in India.
Sadly ,,, votes r important than brain drain problem for, be it any gov.
@@user-wb8ql4ky7j that's why if we can't change our nation better leave it on its own. My brother is an NRI and myself also aspire to leave india.
@@pandeyom6877 ek tarika hai privatisation par vo bhi thoda hi effective hai han tumhari baat sahi hai even though i am from obc
Caste system is the problem
Im an engineer, I have moved outside India as when I graduated and looked for a job. The salary is not even enough to make a living for one person. How will I survive as an Individual. And then there is position hike but no increments. And the way organisation deals with overtime without pay. Then the neglect and worst one is that we cannot express the ideas. Even if ideas are given, it will be taken up by someone else. Basically the organisation structure which is why MNCs target India now. Dnt think that they are giving benifit of giving us jobs they are profiting from cheap labour. Then the pay rate decided by employer no standard in job rate and also hectic contacts. Better understand you as an individual you can switch to what job you like not like after 3yrs or 5yrs. That is called restraint not freedom and independence.
How you moved outside of India??
Masters? Or got a job abroad?
Madam the way you speak is beyond appreciation. The subjects you choose are pertinent ones in respect of modern era . We acquire some fruitful information from your speeches. I request you from the recess of my heart to enrich us and make ourselves aware of the contemporary issues and things of paramount importance.
Thank you ma'am.
Excellent piece. As someone who was born, raised and worked in India and loves her motherland, I can list (in no
particular order) some of the reasons that motivated me as:
1) work life balance: working for 12 hours everyday is the expected thing to do in a lot of companies in India unlike lot of western countries where I may have to work more than 8-9 hours only occasionally. This leaves me more time with my loved ones and for myself
2) the corruption in India even at the grassroot level. Be it having to bribe the traffic cop even though my paper work is perfect or brining the government officials before building a new house even if the house plan meets all requirements. I can’t think of one place where I don’t have to grease palms despite of all the official requirements being met. This is nothing to do with any particular government
3) better infrastructure and facilities. Most of the taxes people pay in India goes directly to the pockets of politicians and common people don’t benefit much, be it hospitals, roads or other amenities
4) The Bollywood glam of NRI life did entice me a little before I moved abroad. They don’t show that people can live abroad and still be broke and not living in palatial buildings
5) some countries have excellent and accessible healthcare for free (govt funded)
6) The pay if definitely better especially when you convert into Indian currency
7) the reservation system in schools, colleges, workplaces, etc
Some of these points may seem like trivial issues but for a lot of people it does get to you eventually
Nobody really talks about reservation but I believe it is a major contributor in brain drain!
@@MrSaviour actually all 5 of big tech compaNies with indian CEOs belongs So called Brahmin caste
@@somethingnew7078 Yes and they left because they have no reservation so why stay if govt is supporting the reserved leeches at their expense?
@@a-woke5283 exactly the point even I feel disgusted by this
Why do i need to care for a country which doesn't even give me fair grounds to pursue my education.
I will obviously be tempted to leave country.
Everything is bearable here, but being treated as second grade citizens in other country is way better than being that in your own
@@demogorgon2424 but are you not responsible for this reservation thing? Had you learned to respect people instead of forcibly declaring them Dalits or low caste and deny them of basic human rights for 3000+ years, every day...then this reservation thing would not have happened. Instead of stopping and correcting your behavior, you Indians have forcefully tribalized an entire region, without explaining to the Asian clans that tribal means "low caste".
My friend always wanted to go to IIM for management but his 96 percentile didn't end him in IIM ABC whereas due to reservation a girl got there with 91(i mean the call). Now my friend gave GRE and went to UK. Crying over brain drain is not feasible as long as we don't develop our home system.
I agree brother
I have just passed my 12th board exams and I got 685 marks in NEET 2021.
I have applied for a few medical colleges in Canada, hopefully I'll get selected 🤞
My skills will be appreciated more in Canada.
Also, there is no scope for general category students in india.
Everything is for sc/st.
So no need to waste time here, I'll live a happy life in Canada 😊
@@bighit9508 You can. Get a Good Medical College in India
@@anshrastogi529 I guess that's not his real marks
@@anshrastogi529 yes, but not the one that i deserve.
An Sc will take my seat for low marks.
General category students have no value here.🙏🏻
This is what i have experienced and this is what I believe.
After seeing this I'm leaving India too. Their are many Indians abroad, I won't feel hone sick 👍
Thank you 🙏🇮🇳
This video is absolutely right and correct for any country, with "brain drain". I remember how much smart people left ex-Soviet countries after USSR fall. Process is the same everywhere and everytime...
Dont forget how many Stalin did murder, those time intelligent citizen, just because he was a paranox.
@@metsa12 I wonder how great the Brain Drain was for countries that effectively targeted individuals, like in Pol Pot's Kamphuchea. That is if they were successful in fleeing.
Best example is Sergey brin
One of my friend as a test engineer he used to get 15k per month in 2010's..he went uk and settled there ...now he is earning 350 pounds per day by doing same job..now he is able fulfill his and his family dreams ..proud of him
Might need to add currency exchange for better understanding cos that sounds like he’s making less a month.
15k a month to 350 a day sounds like a downgrade
@@olajong2315 Yeah. He should have said 15k INR
HE MEAN TO SAY THAT HE WAS EARNING 15K INR WHICH MEANS 150 POUNDS OF MONTH WHEREAS IN UK HE EARNS 350 POUNDS WHICH MEANS 35000 INR IN A SINGLE DAY.(THIS IS According To 2010 Now Pound Decreased To 85 INR COMPARE TO 100)
Indian youth became tremendously successful in foreign lands and became CEOs of big corporations. On the forefront, this seems like a matter of pride for the Indian citizen, but in reality, we must realise that their successes in foreign countries is the ultimate proof of the worrying condition of India’s education system, and India in general.
I did not get a master's in Surgery because I belonged to a caste which is stamped Forward by our constitution.
My sister did not get an MSc in statistics even though she was the university topper, just because she belonged to a caste which is stamped Forward by our constitution.
Who will stay here?
'Right to Equality' and 'Equality of Opportunity' should be removed from the constitution
Frankly speaking India will never fall short of great brains inspite of so many people leaving.
The problem lies in the system. There will be many brains like top Indian ceos. But they lack opportunities, failed incompetent and currupt systems add to the ruins.
India is nothing and hopeless country already. They don't give opportunity India Indian young talent. India needs old man folks country. Please don't compare US and India.
India first challenge China
🔴 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE PALKI SHARMA
@@eshwarashawn4493 why are you so deluded ?
@@darkansh2291 that's a copy paste bot. They got no life of their own.
@@AJ-rj3rj yeah man.
True. Apart from what they've mentioned major reasons of why cream crowd is leaving India -
1. Corruption
2. Reservation in education system and government jobs
3. Payoff is low
4. Work-life balance almost doesn't exist in India
Caste system is ok but not reservation due to caste?
@@notfunny3468 : isn't discrimination on caste system banned according to law. Then why use this system to promote discrimination in education system
@@notfunny3468 caste system is gone but reservation still exists. Funny thing now sometimes I think certain castes are really above other castes. Funny thing right
Even after high court giving verdict not to give promotions on the basis of reservations, karnataka govt. did not remove it, govt said they will not cancel reservation for promotions in govt. sector, as it will cause law and order problem. This is real sorry state we live in. Reservations are getting worse decade after decade.
Wow! Back in the late 1980s, I knew that there were SO MANY BRILLIANT AND TALENTED INDIANS. I had heard rumor about so many very smart Indians with advanced degrees in academic disciplines like chemistry, physics, and math but could not find jobs in India. They ended up working in jobs that did not fully make use of their potential talents.
The reason why I left back in 2004 to USA is still same for Indians today immigrating to other countries.... caste based Reservation quotas and corruption at every level which bugs our day to day conviniences. This brain drain will keep going well on to next 100 years but I would hope and be pleasantly surprised if it ever changes...
Agree with you bro..but I m sure it will never change
@Tall Grass I am too an victim of reservation but country matters for me this is not a solution you guys are selfish , giving reason If one have a love for a country then he try to do very possible contribution for it rather leaving it
That's what I was thinking. Screw reservation.
Also the entire system of India glorifies being an NRI more than being an Indian entrepreneur.
@@Adityapatil-up2wy be realistic.
This is so real..as a teen in india in my neighborhood mostly everyone's son and daughters are working abroad mostly in america.. this is really concerning for india but we can't really blame the people going out
Damn i can't imagine the pressure on u then
Yes due to Reservation system, all cream is leaving India, only system in the world were 40% marks can get you engineering or doctors seat and get govt. Job. Everyone knows their efficiency.
@@bmw1er85 yeah this is one of many reasons
@@bmw1er85 yes bro I have seen many good students who performed extremely well in their 10 and 12 boards are now fighting for a simple government job.
I think they had that much potential that they could have done better in their field.
@@bmw1er85 and as a student I got 95 percent in 10 and 93 in12 and now dropped to get in into some of the top engeenering colleges.
And my fear is that if I didn't get in to any top iit Or nit then most probably I will have to fights for government jobs (as my seniors did).
In that case I will choose Germany for engeenering because I want to make a career in stem
Thanks for Insights
There is a saying.. an Indian that does well is an Indian that is outside of India
It is just a simple chain to understand this process.
Population->lack of opportunities->reservation->political vote bank->excessive reservation->less opportunities to these talent.
And this is the point which change their mind.
There isn't much to it really. If you can find a proper job you like in India and are able to survive and pay off all your expenses then you should stay in India, and there's no reason for you to move. Else you should leave India. Nothing else.
And reservation quota hasn't stopped, finding ways to increase it
@@manjunathbs9790 absolutely
@Mehaboob khan Absolutely,
In India communities have moved far apart from vote bank.
THEY consider this as their right.
In Portugal we have the same problem : doctors , nurses , engineers and tech personnel leave the country to work abroad . The reason ? The disparity of wages in European Union between south and north countries .
I thought this wasn't an issue in a typical european country like Portugal
@@anthonyemede9689 Europe is a continent, with very different economic layouts across countries. Portugal is at the bottom of the pack.
Why cant portugal bring in people from Bangladesh and train them easy enough also india is overpopulated anyway so it's better if they leave less mouth to feed
@@cliffsofmoher4220 stay in Bangladesh
How ironic. I've known Indians who leave to work in Portugal due to lack of work force
It's a toxic cycle all the way I guess
Perfect presentation and voice
Thanks lots