Amir Khan was trying to do the nation some favors. Time he restarted his program. Now people are sufficiently upset and will be more open to his progressive views. That was not the right time for him apparently.
If Pakista took Kashmir issue in UN why Modi brought E.U leaders in the past and now many leaders fro Europe, Japan and other country leaders and made Kashmir as an international at the same time preventing Indian leaders visit to J k
To day a British MP was prevented to enter into India just because she criticized article 370 CAA NRC and NPR. And a person was arrested in UP. There is no point now realized after the every thing including judiciary states worsaning
True. That statement always reminds me of how Truth always triumphs. Today Modi is 2 time prime minister while Karan thappar is making youtube videos and fallen from being a prime time anchor to a 2nd grade youtuber.
Secular was an unknown word till the first day of Partition. The same people who got their butchered, raped and driven out Hindus, Sikhs Buddhists and Jains.
Karan is a leftist ideological thinking person. Also she did not get a good post during Modis tenure hence the problem. She always had a hold during Congress regime and enjoyed power
Journalism is simply a profession. They are not obsessed with any ideology, but obsessed with making some fast buck. Eve of elections is harvesting time for them and 'make hey while the sun shines'. I have seen professional speakers in Kerala who are well versed in contemporary political history and events. They are in good demand during election time and all parties hire them.
Veteran journalist and author Tavleen Singh, who often in the past took a pro-government position on several matters, was forced to come out in support of her son after the government labelled him a 'Pakistani'. Under attack from both Left and the Right-wing supporters, Tavleen took to Twitter on Friday and claimed that her son's citizenship was under question because he wrote an article that the "Home Minister did not like". Her tweet resulted in many comments from writers and other personalities. article in First post Nov 2019
Tavleen didn't saw him in Gujarat ? Then how could she like Modi as Prime minister ? She belongs to educated elite class !!!! Is she journalist and had no idea of RSS ?!!! Should we believe this ?
Arijoy Majumdar all lies and nothing else, she had the taste of her own medicine.... she had some differences with the Congress Party, but liking Modi?? huh.... who she’s fooling around?
youo had no idea of what rss is.foll you dont believe in supreme court then its your problem your mulla would have told you about modi.you people just sit in madarsa will never have true education .
Dhiraj Pal thanks a lot, Mr Dheeraj Pal, perhaps I don’t know what RSS, is , dont follow the dictats of Supreme Court???????, and I sat in Madrasas all through???????, but right now with your rejoinder, and some words I have come to know who you are... ... 😃😃
"Modi was silent. Everyone expected that the Prime Minister would say something to indicate that he did not approve of what had happened (i.e. the lynchings). Instead he said nothing. Not one word."
According to you my Liberandu friend, only muslims are Lynch ahhaa in this country. And others are just murdered wahhhh.... & Practically speaking country of 1.4b peoples and only muslim Lynch in past 7 yrs & give me an average please in numbers. That's it!
@@falhenchachal9817 where was Hindutva community when Muslims were killed by raja Hari Singh in jammu to change demography of Muslims from 63% to 36% in Jammu.
I think it is very brave on her part to acknowledge adn write about and interview about her change in judgement about the present government. She may face a lot of lashback but I would applaud a change of heart than trustless support to a leader. Thank you for bringing this interview to us, @The Wire and Karan Thapar.
Yeah that's a fair question. I think she didn't paint all RSS alumni with the same brush. Vajpy was also RSS but his role in Nellie massacre and babri masjid massacre were not investigated. It's fair to miss those points I guess. She might have seen modi would be as good as Vajpayee. Well at least she moved away when she noticed the wrong when most people are still in denial.
@@telepost2250 Just wait for the time when Muslim countries in the rich Middle East (Dubai, Abu Dhabi,) will expel all Hindus back to India... It is painfully shame what RSS and BJP doing to such a great country of ours, India. Just travel now to other countries and you will notice how fast Modi and Amit Shah are taking our country down the drain... shame!
@@1008apocalypse1008 Every Muslim? Really? That’s a terrible statement. Did you take a poll? If not, it’s gross exaggeration. You’re not qualified to make such an assumption. Sadly, this is one of the reasons people shouldn’t believe everything they read. I know many Muslims and Hindus who are very good friends.
She is a World class hypocrite without a heart. How can you call someone who was the CM of Gujarat during the worst riot in independent India as a "shining comet"? Hypocrite Shame
Correction, the worst riot in India was the Bhagalpur riots in Bihar with a death toll more than that of the Godhra ones. Then, don't forget Maliana and Hashimpura, for which no justice has been meted out. But since those happened during Congress rule or that of it's leftist or centre left allies, so those become SECULAR riots. Now this is hypocrisy. Do research on these SECULAR riots and pogroms too.
She protected herself so well! Its a pity Karan didnt corner her for her subtle islamophobia. She constantly treats muslims as some other race as to being just humans or Indians.
she's contradicting herself...she understands RSS to its core n knows RSS is Mr Modi's base, yet she supported him in 2014!! what r u trying to say Ma'am??
plaban Buragohain don’t know who she is fooling around... not only RSS , Modi himself has been such a vile and despicable person, ever since he came to be known after joining public life
Yes exactly, she said Modi has no formal general education except for the RSS, that is, she knew that Modi is the loyal product of a fascist organisation and yet she hoped that somehow he'd turn out to be different. She was so easily swayed away by his utterly false rhetoric like a complete fool.
@@ibbysvloggs1018 innocent people are dying everywhere in India, what's your point? Most deaths are happening through road accidents, where is the outrage? Gujarat have lower crime rate and no riots since 2002 all because of Modi.
I was a vehement anti Congress person, but even in 2014 I knew that Modi was not the answer. People just saw their benefit and Now when they haven't materialized they're trying to distance themselves and jump ship
Isn't that always the case? But I'd say it's even worse in this instance. The smart people know that they've been let down and are disavowing him. But all the others who voted for him are basically doubling down and supporting/pretending to support every one of his policies regardless of their atrocity because they don't have the maturity to accept that they made a mistake in voting for him.
Unless another party is able to arouse emotions of the whole country and is capable of challenging BJP, you have no choice but to vote Congress in the next election
On second thought, Modi actually love the Muslims by imposing strict regulations so that the Muslims save from covid and let the Hindus add the Covid statistic. Thank you Modi.
See, if you give your house keys to a bugler because he told you that he's changed and then end up getting your house ransacked, you'd definitely be called a FOOL.
It’s great to see Mr Thappar on The Wire channel. Karan means quality and making sense. I like The Wire already for it’s exemplary work but now I liked it more. Tavleen, I am glad that you got your awakening and you are the only one.
Yes ... My Majesty? where you have been, Massiah of the world. " Wolf In Sheep Disguise". Do your own Bussiness. He is a PM of the country. If you have so much of quality, try and fight election or be merely a spectator.
There is no const in muslim countries. They dont deserve one. Why is it that muslims are against police security forces only in non muslim countries. In Pak civilians are carpet bombed by fighter aircrafts. Yet muslim civilians dont hv problem with securty forces
I am a Marathi Brahmin, I have nothing to lose from this Modi Shah regime. But being a Marathi Brahmin, I fully understand RSS school of thoughts and both Modi n Shah admire Savarkar, Golwalkar. Make no mistake, they want to take revenge of past 1000 years and in the process, our country will get destroyed. Overthrow Modi n Shah.
Actually she is lying. She knew Modi when he was the CM of Gujrat. As CM he had committed hundreds of crimes. Because her son was ill treated by Modi she has turned hostile.
People like Tavleen also responsible for the present sorry state of affairs in the country. They supported and praised Modi despite knowing fully well what disastrous things he had done in Gujarat.
@Yogesh Sharma 2000+ Muslim were butchered right under his nose ..even rajiv Gandhi couldn't be accused of sikh riot but every one knows whether it was sikh riot or Gujarat riot both couldn't happen without complicity of state
I am a bit amused to know that a senior journalist like her had hopes from a man who questioned the authority of the CAG on the floor of the house as a CM when a scam of 6000 crs in allotment of land for industrial project was unearthed by the CAG. His style of functioning was absolutely authoritarian as a CM. It seems to me that Tavleen Singh has something personal against the Congress.
* It is also written in the RSS book Bunch of Thats that liquor shops should be opened near the houses of the Shudras so that they might get drunk and fight and die. Build temples in the neighborhood of the Shudras so that they get caught in the swamp of hypocrisy. So keeping these things in mind, do not quarrel with each other and all the Shudra OBC, SC, ST indigenous people should always maintain unity among themselves. "One Buns" "Right Bones" Jai Moolniwasi! Jai Bheem ! Jai Bharat ! !From an Indian pen »Praveen Togadia has children, ever seen him involved in any disturbance? »Yogi Adityanath's nephew seen somewhere? »Keshav Maurya's son seen anywhere? * Why do Smriti Irani's children not go to Shakha »Subramanian children's life set? »Sushil Kumar Modi's children do not appear in Bajrang Dal. »Ever heard that a child from Advani's house was caught waving the saffron flag in the court? »Vasundhara Raje is also never seen in temples. »How many people in Narendra Modi's house get into the Hinduist crowd on the street? बच्चे Raman Singh's children become MPs without any Hindu movement. . - Was Vinay Katiyar's son in a frenzied crowd? »Kalyan Singh's daughter-in-law, daughter-in-law, all the MPs became legislators who never took to the streets. »Why did Rajnath Singh's son not join Bajrang Dal? »Shivraj Singh Chauhan's child does not know Vande Mataram full song. »What do both daughters of Murali Manohar Joshi do? • Poonam Mahajan or Pankaja Munde. . Because of the father, there are MPs and MLAs. . »You all know Amit Shah's son. . . Before going mad, think who was from his family among the youth who were hoisting the saffron flag on the court premises of Rajasthan, climbing to the dome of Babri and dying, getting arrested, lathi-shot. . . The The The And you are letting your children use them and their ideology. . . ! ! Have a little mind, it's just use and throw politics, sir. . . Save your children from this poison. . . ! ! !
Is it really true? Coz I have heard from many that BJP keeps desi liquor available at low prices for dalits, so that they can dont stand up to ask questions..but I didn't believe it..
@@chrisgallagher7769 : Ajay Singh which I think must be pakistani "Wolf In sheep disguise" has now become your teacher. " Rab ne bana di jodi, Ek andha ek kodhi " Enjoy the music.
Brother RSS is following Talmud which is a man written "holy" book for the jews. Talmud portrays jews as god's chosen people. Manusmriti is exactly same with different title. It is not just muslims RSS is opposing, they are working to establish Brahman supremacy. Next, RSS agenda is to creat mass unemployment, sell all national treasures to selected few and allowing populatin to kill one another. The killing wont be about religious belief but for the food and survival. *The ground is being created.*
It's simply really: tell the news publications to grow a pair and report actual news. Bhakts have to get their news from somewhere just like the rest of the people; the only issue is that most of the prominent news publications are shackled by the balls by the government, so you'd have to be fairly discerning in order to call bullshit when you see it. Seeing as India's education system isn't going to turn into that of Singapore's or Finland's overnight, nor are the hundreds of millions of people who are already grown adults going to learn how to think critically overnight, fixing news dissemination is the most effective way to fix them.
What a lame person she is to find out modi and RSS is anti Muslim in 2019-20. That man was responsible for Gujrat riot. Intellectual honesty Gaya tel lene. She became a critic when atish tashir her son was attacked.
Dipesh Parida muslim ko gali deny sy pehly hindu aur sikh kali bheeron ko b daikh lo wo b usi thali m cheed krty hn jis m khaty hn Just one person is not enough to blame a community
Usman Muhammed please don’t say like this... we should never ever be judgemental, we don’t know what were her circumstances... what she went through and suffered ... and how can the children be illegitimate...
Difficult to understand, how an educated/ intellectual humanly person took so long to realise. Does not mean that she was blind. It only means she believed Modi, much more than he deserved.
I think it's more than just belief, it's hste for one turning to love for another and that bias actively helped her overlook the most horrible realities of be people she turned towards
@@footballforyou8856 I was once a lover of him bro. I voted for development. But with economy falling, I dont find a reason to support him. its just as simple as that.
@@shivkrishna7706 still the average growth is greater than upa tenure.Even the improvement is slight he should still be rewarded for improvement.Credit should also be given for decision which makes history.You also know nobody except modi would have guts to remove 370 and 35A.if you all consider caa as against constitution then you sould thant modi for removing 370 and 35 A which was way against contitution and it was looming from 50 years.
Excellent interview ; saw it on TV screen with my entire family ! We really enjoyed it. With this interview I had started loving Tavleen singh,'s candid Persona. Hattsoff to you karan....💖💕:-)
No person can be great when a person has hate inside him about another human being specially his fellow countryman and when u treat your fellow countryman as second class citizens
She is a serious lier. Until the issue related to his son, she was a vocal supporter of bharat jalao party and Modi. She was also many times guilty of spreading fake things....
@@SAFFRONINFERNO seriously I am biased against people who spread fake propaganda and people support them. I just can't tolerate liers. I Know it's a upbringing problem. But I can't help.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO liers can't stand against the truth. That's why to support liers, they try to spread fake propaganda against people who catch their lies.
This lady sees the past government as dark time and just because she hated socialism...the basis of the constitution of India is socialist state....and now when she was faced with intense discriminatory action she is critical of Modi...isi ko kehte Hain जाके पांव न फटे बिवाई, सो क्या जाने पीर पराई Typical Indian mentality...जब तक ख़ुद पर न पड़े तब तक पता नहीं चलता
@Amit Roshan RSS led BJP is creating mass unemployment,that is intentional so that people kill one another- not because you are either hindu or a muslim but for food and survival. Those 10&-20% people will be OK.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO This country can never become a developed state without adopting a successful socialistic model. Nehru was a genius to have thought of this very early but morons like you who are filled with anti communism hatred can never understand the socio economic fabric this country longs for. India was freaking poor when Nehru took over, by the time it gained some strength, Indira happened and institutionalized every bad that still plagues this country. Without a perfect welfare model, this country is bound to doom as the socio economic divide keep getting wider and wider, making poors stuck in a never ending loop of poverty.
@@fazlulkarim9123 every kind of knowledge is greater than illiterate things of madarsa.you people just go to madarsa day and be just a burden to your country not an asset.
@@footballforyou8856 BJP IT cell knowledge is above all. They know that Jawaharlal Nehru was a Muslim. There are lot of knowledge you will get from BJP IT cell. If you don't understand go to a pandit of nearby temple. Ok?
YEAH, FOR SURE MODI N SHAH WILL BRING DOWM INDIA AS HITLER DID IN GERMANY. THEY R LEADING INDIA ON. A. VERY DANGEROUS PATH. GIVING BRUTAL. ORDERS. TO THE COPS. TO LATHI CHARGE N SHOOT AT. SIGHT. SO MANY YOUNG STUDENTS,. WOMEN N KIDS R SERIOUSELY INJURED.. WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE BIG POLE SHOVED UP THE FAT ASSES OF BOTH MODI N SHAH... NOW IS 4HE RIGHT TIME TO BRING THEM DOWN N CRUSH THEM ONCE N FOR ALL. JAI HIND.
You said it! Very prophetic. Yes, Modi is finished. But Bharat will continue to be a Democracy of the people, by the people and for the people. Without realising it the RSS in cahoots with the BJP has woken up a Sleeping Giant who will destroy those who tried to destroy this Great Nation. We can look forward to the Nation raising good and honest and well educated and patriotic Political Leaders in the very near future. Thanks be to God.
@@asnashaikh6725 and this not the first time she had talked to RSS ppl and she came to know about their master plan still she blvd modi and herself says she is born child of rss how can he change... then how she was convinced that he had changed in 2013-14
@@nimeshkhatri1435 hahaha.. he himself killed his own ppl to rule the state.... u can expect atleast this from duo shah.. there is no concrete proff that Muslims fire the train in the official report, rest we know how corrupt Gujarat police is by seeing the present condition of delhi police.
I think he has no fear of his life..... Love u sir...Praising his determination to journalism.... May be the only journalist in india having sword in his hands..... The Wire_ Valiant journalism
Agree, once in public rally discribed his very NATURE,said,,Mai bhoolata nahee, Aur badalaa letaa hun, I feel he collected and preserved some prejudices, accordingly reacting
I really would like her to critically explain how her idea of ‘liberal democracy’ is not socialistic? Anyway, let’s applaud her enlightenment and her supreme honesty in finally speaking out.
Those were different times, when Modi used to talk/act about development ,no corruption and no discrimination, but now on his second term reality is out , now his blind followers are like terminal stage of cancer, no coming back for them
Tavleen Singh is behaving naive and it's understandable and also commendable to come out and express her disappointment and disillusionment. Anyone who claims to have covered RSS extensively and against the backdrop of 2002, hoping Modi would strengthen India positively, seems hard to believe. Lastly, the shining comet on a dark sky and the reason that PM in UPA government was controlled by Chairperson of Congress is pretty dumb thing to say in the context of Indian politics. Are we to believe Modi controls RSS and its not the other way around? Didn't we see Vajpayeeji spend his political capital in keeping a leash over RSS? Congress was running a coalition and the chairperson of the largest party in the coalition will be a key decision - maker on policy matters. Didn't Balasaheb Thackerey loved remote control. Isn't NDA and Modi run the administration via a remote control, euphemistically speaking?
Ananthiyer1973 yes, as a journalist she should have known all this and rather knew it, having Sonia Gandhi, chairperson of Congress party as a remote was much better than having remotes with criminal ideology and she should have also given a thought to the working of Mr Manmohan Singh, an able and conscientious person to the core...
I can't help but notice Karan's inability to control his devilish smile when someone bashes Modi just like how he's thinking in his head. 😆Nothing against him, just feels a bit dishonest.
True. Every time i watch karan thapar i am reminded of the statement always reminds me of how Truth always triumphs. Today Modi is 2 time prime minister, repealed 370, constructing ram mandir, implementing several anti poverty schemes like jandhan, ujwala, pradhan mantri was yojna, nal se jal, swach bharat, etc while Karan thappar is making youtube videos and fallen from being a prime time anchor to a 2nd grade youtuber.
I think she's just saying that to appear less of a fool than she already seems. Like the way a person buys a bad stock and doesn't want to sell it because they have to admit they made a mistake.
This interview have all the ingredients, the elegance, the decorum, the grace, articulation, interaction just superb. The interviewer and the guest both at classical best, both made India proud within and outside. It rekindles hope among muslims that all is not lost, there are statesman amidst them which not allow India to become an erstwhile Germany.
@@_kumu_ku How polite and cultured. Disrespecting one’s interlocutor has got to be the most efficient communication strategy, hasn’t it! Noice. As they say these days, "lit AF".
@@FarhanAmin1994 no matter how many strong English words ( "interlocutor") you use in your comments, you are still a Muslim and came here to support YOUR brother, isn't it ? If that is someone who is not a muslim who put the first comment, you won't be here to reply to KUBENDRA Mukkund (provided the main theme is not related to Islam and Muslims).
Respect the sense of honesty conveyed. And by the way, Karan and Tavleen, for twice a month we say "fortnightly" while once in two months is referred to as "bi-monthly".
Completely overlooked the genocide of Gujarat, lady -"that didn't worry you?" For starters? Or like said towards the end, when got bitten herself (the son was denied citizenship) is when it became clear
Why see only about Delhi alone what had happened in Gujarat after the Godhra tragedy, thousands of innocent muslims were burnt alive and killed and no one was arrested so far a d those arrested were released on bail by SC
You media people were responsible for state of affairs today.You were forefront in supported Modi knowing very well his background and Gujarat Model just because you donot like congress.Now regret and criticized when the things are goi g out of control
First of all Jinnah ain't alive. And secondly since you speak about 1946, then how about answering about those who sided with the British by taking a salary and siding with the British during the freedom struggle while all other communities laid down their lives for the freedom struggle
@@RKumar-tm1tz ... Brahmano ne OBC,ST ,SC ko shudraa,ATI shudraa ,acchhooot ko ghulaam es tarah Bana liya hai....parh likhkar punchar Bana Raha....samjhegaa q nahi. Bilkul sahi kaha
Love you thapar sir for your candid views...thanks a tonne portraying our feelings....if I Express my my feelings on social media I am trolled with lot of abuse and my phone gets hacked..this is Modi ji ka true India
She hate elites and she also hates socialism what a great contradiction. In the Rest of the interview Thapar continues to baby her and it Seems like they removed her from godi media's payroll.
Madam Tavleen welcome to the club...you are also a victim of Modi Propaganda like any other Indian. He talks Parivartan but he doesn't understand it. So you connect the dots. 🤣🤣🤣
Lay man do gross injustice when they say that Hitler Stalin or changeiz khan caused maximum bloodshed . Just one historic figure has wrecked havoc on mankind and continues to do so
I too read the Indian Express column. Not impressed at all by her answers. For a person who claims to have been a journalist all her life and to have covered the RSS and politics in the course of her work , I think naive is a kind word to use. I suspect she’s been pro Hindutva and now for personal reasons things have changed. Sorry Tavleen you didn’t convince me
Both of you r the best Journlist. I wrote 120 Letters to P. M in 2014_15 I suggest him lots of things but being a common senior citizen He did not reply but he passed my suggestion as bill. I want to send my Book to both of you please send me your address so I can post it. I don't want any kind of favour and don't want to become Famous. I m a retired teacher very happy. मै भी मोदी जी के भाषणो से भ्रमित हुई अब मै भी भ्रम से बाहर आ गयी हूँ तलवीन जी की तरह। नमस्कार।
Very insightful interview. Appreciate the fact that she had the independent mind and wisdom to question the wrong and distance herself from them upong noticing criminal intent. These intents are not always clear and she says that those were dark days. At least she had the wisdom and courage to speak out. Well done! Modi got lucky in so many ways!
I appreciate your views as well as your work ma'am (: . And i don't find your statements contradictory as you accepted the mistake you once made. I do agree with most of the points you made.
itna muslim hate wala humara pm nhi ho sakta,, wo khud bhul chuka h ke wo musalmano ka bhi pm he,, uske "kapde dekh kar pehchan" aur "hindu atankwadi nhi ho sakta" wale remarks se pata chalta hai k wo kitna khokhla aur prejudiced insan hei,, halanke wo insan banne k bhi qabil nhi,, pm to door ki baat,
Mana ki godi bura h but tum logo ne 15 min police hta lo wale ko support kyn kra nation anthem nhi gayenge Nation song Islam k khilaf h court ki nhi Islam ki chlegi hypocrisy
@@sk....3049 yeh RSS ka gobar gyan mat paliyo idhar, aur rahi baat vande mataram ki toh 99.9% BJP ko bhi nahi ata yakeen nahi toh Modi Shah se puchlo woh bhi nahi ga payenge, suna BJP ke It cell ke bhadwe
@@sk....3049 "15minute police hatalo" ko hum nhi support karte,, kaun kehta hai hum national anthem nhi gaate,, hum SC k khilaf hn? it's rss jo national flag me believe nhi karte,, you are right,, godi bahut bura h,,
@@user-hy7vj2jx3k shah bano case baangi h k kitna tum log supreme Court ka izzat krte ho ...tum logo ne triple talaq hlala ka court k baar baar khne PR sanmaan nhi kea kha k Muslims ka internal matters h jabki yh anti consitution tha 15 min wale k time pr godi nhi Congress thi mene deka than reaction Muslims ka molana barkati ka byaan b yaad h muje Azam Khan etc k b tum logo k videos h jha national song Nation anthem k khilaf ho ....AGR rss esa h toh tum Islamic log b vese e brainwash muglo ko support krte ho hinduo se converted ho k arif muhmad Khan rizwaan Ahmed ko sun Lena ek baar
Took too long to realize. When the fire reached home, she felt the heat.
Sanjeev Bhanot well said
@@SAFFRONINFERNO her son is not Pakistani citizen he is British born and British citizen .
Yessss
Everyone will feel the heat sooner or later cos the fire will spread !!
Sabka time ayega
Hahaha... Still recall the time she got pissed off at amir Khan's intolerant comment. She was furious at that time. Playing a different tune now.
These are opportunists these doesn't have any qualities
Amir Khan was trying to do the nation some favors. Time he restarted his program. Now people are sufficiently upset and will be more open to his progressive views. That was not the right time for him apparently.
Tavleen Singh too little too late.......
Yes
If Pakista took Kashmir issue in UN why Modi brought E.U leaders in the past and now many leaders fro Europe, Japan and other country leaders and made Kashmir as an international at the same time preventing Indian leaders visit to J k
To day a British MP was prevented to enter into India just because she criticized article 370 CAA NRC and NPR. And a person was arrested in UP. There is no point now realized after the every thing including judiciary states worsaning
@@sreenivasanpn3506 Nehru did worse to democracy than modi.
offo you are all writing my own thoughts--what am I going to add now 😠🤨
I liked the statement when Karan said " You are a mass murderer in a Secular India". This is journalism.
Is Karan not murderer of truth? Do not glorify journalists.
True. That statement always reminds me of how Truth always triumphs. Today Modi is 2 time prime minister while Karan thappar is making youtube videos and fallen from being a prime time anchor to a 2nd grade youtuber.
Secular was an unknown word till the first day of Partition. The same people who got their butchered, raped and driven out Hindus, Sikhs Buddhists and Jains.
Karan is a leftist ideological thinking person. Also she did not get a good post during Modis tenure hence the problem. She always had a hold during Congress regime and enjoyed power
Journalism is simply a profession. They are not obsessed with any ideology, but obsessed with making some fast buck. Eve of elections is harvesting time for them and 'make hey while the sun shines'. I have seen professional speakers in Kerala who are well versed in contemporary political history and events. They are in good demand during election time and all parties hire them.
I really appreciate and truthfulness involved in the interview.
Anti-Hindu prejudice is in DNA of every Muslim.
I couldn't stop chuckling! Finally Tavleen got disillusioned with Modi! Thanks Karan for this interview!
Veteran journalist and author Tavleen Singh, who often in the past took a pro-government position on several matters, was forced to come out in support of her son after the government labelled him a 'Pakistani'. Under attack from both Left and the Right-wing supporters, Tavleen took to Twitter on Friday and claimed that her son's citizenship was under question because he wrote an article that the "Home Minister did not like". Her tweet resulted in many comments from writers and other personalities. article in First post Nov 2019
@@margaretfernandes3041 Putra moh ne toh Gandhari ko andha Kar Diya tha! Iske saath Ulta hua he! Ye andh Bhakt se ek responsible journalist ban gayi😂
@@chainrupsharma7375 you nailed it
well said!
😮 I find it difficult to believe her.
Dosti bane rahe I will have water.
Tavleen didn't saw him in Gujarat ? Then how could she like Modi as Prime minister ? She belongs to educated elite class !!!! Is she journalist and had no idea of RSS ?!!! Should we believe this ?
Arijoy Majumdar all lies and nothing else, she had the taste of her own medicine.... she had some differences with the Congress Party, but liking Modi?? huh.... who she’s fooling around?
youo had no idea of what rss is.foll you dont believe in supreme court then its your problem your mulla would have told you about modi.you people just sit in madarsa will never have true education .
Dhiraj Pal thanks a lot, Mr Dheeraj Pal, perhaps I don’t know what RSS, is , dont follow the dictats of Supreme Court???????, and I sat in Madrasas all through???????, but right now with your rejoinder, and some words I have come to know who you are... ... 😃😃
@@mouseeqhee okay increase literacy rate of your community they are just 57percent literate compard to normal indian s literacy rate which is 76.
@@mouseeqhee knowing me wouold not help you .before critisizing anything know about it
Thank you Tavleen ji
Thanks for real and true analysis of the present government. Every word spoken has so much weight and truth.
Karan, this is one of those rare interviews that you didn’t play a devil’s advocate. Iam not convinced!!
Karan is now becoming intelligent.. Can no longer paly the cards!! Exposed!!
It took a ban on her son for her to realise this.
Absolutely right.
Oh ya
Every time i see karna thapar this comes to mind
'Bas dosti bni rhe'
😂😂
😎🤓😎
😁😁😁👍👍even me also. Dosti Bani rahe . Pani Pina hai😁😁😁👌👌👌
Even I think as you
😂😂
@Bubbly Srinath he shattered Obama too fyi
Madamji, you are also responsible for establishment of bjp government. You appreciated modi since long why?
Lr Bharti because she had some scores to settle with congress and Sonia Gandhi
newsjunkieish quite an apt analysis... she’s a hypocrite
because he is a guy who cares for kashmir who cares for persecuted people who cares for every indian not like you all who just cares for jihadis
@Maneesh Singh
Rightly said
We Hindus r there for Modi
Come whatever may come.
Now she will write another book called `DEVIL 'S MESSENGER MODI' & make more money from its sales!
"Modi was silent. Everyone expected that the Prime Minister would say something to indicate that he did not approve of what had happened (i.e. the lynchings). Instead he said nothing. Not one word."
Mr. Rahmat, what about ur country? R u from India??? If yes, please leave.. Disgusted!!!
According to you my Liberandu friend, only muslims are Lynch ahhaa in this country. And others are just murdered wahhhh.... & Practically speaking country of 1.4b peoples and only muslim Lynch in past 7 yrs & give me an average please in numbers. That's it!
Where was the muslims community when 5 million Kashmiri hindu were driven out of Kashmir ? Absolute hypocrisy.
@@falhenchachal9817 These people are disgusting. Save India from these Bigots.
@@falhenchachal9817 where was Hindutva community when Muslims were killed by raja Hari Singh in jammu to change demography of Muslims from 63% to 36% in Jammu.
I think it is very brave on her part to acknowledge adn write about and interview about her change in judgement about the present government. She may face a lot of lashback but I would applaud a change of heart than trustless support to a leader. Thank you for bringing this interview to us, @The Wire and Karan Thapar.
Thanks again Karan for another fabulous interview.
I fail to understand how a person who knows RSS so well can miss to understand what's in Modi's dna...she is fooling herself or us?
Yeah, its hard 2 digest, what ws she thinking all this time.
Yeah that's a fair question. I think she didn't paint all RSS alumni with the same brush. Vajpy was also RSS but his role in Nellie massacre and babri masjid massacre were not investigated. It's fair to miss those points I guess. She might have seen modi would be as good as Vajpayee. Well at least she moved away when she noticed the wrong when most people are still in denial.
The latter
@Bubbly Srinath PA got the Lutyon's virus from Khan market.
@@monalisahota Why go so deep. Why not investigate Rattan Lal death.
It is optimistic fools who miscalculate and thus misguide masses. Later they try to turn their mistakes into 'disappointments'
Apne chacha nana ka hi roj interview lete hai ye log.pure propoganda even worse then republic or republic of left.
@@footballforyou8856 Karan Thapar Modi ka intervew lene ko tayyar hai agar Modi "ji" me himmat hai.
I feel that RSS led BJP will NOT give up power at any cost. There are many hadden reasons behind it.
Why cannot people change their perceptions based on happenings?
@@telepost2250 Just wait for the time when Muslim countries in the rich Middle East (Dubai, Abu Dhabi,) will expel all Hindus back to India... It is painfully shame what RSS and BJP doing to such a great country of ours, India. Just travel now to other countries and you will notice how fast Modi and Amit Shah are taking our country down the drain... shame!
A sterling analysis and perspective of Modi’s fractured form of government. This woman is brilliant as is the interviewer.
Anti-Hindu prejudice is in DNA of every Muslim.
@@1008apocalypse1008 Every Muslim? Really? That’s a terrible statement. Did you take a poll? If not, it’s gross exaggeration. You’re not qualified to make such an assumption. Sadly, this is one of the reasons people shouldn’t believe everything they read. I know many Muslims and Hindus who are very good friends.
Tavleen u spoke my mind....time to remove the question mark!
She is a World class hypocrite without a heart.
How can you call someone who was the CM of Gujarat during the worst riot in independent India as a "shining comet"?
Hypocrite
Shame
Correction, the worst riot in India was the Bhagalpur riots in Bihar with a death toll more than that of the Godhra ones. Then, don't forget Maliana and Hashimpura, for which no justice has been meted out. But since those happened during Congress rule or that of it's leftist or centre left allies, so those become SECULAR riots. Now this is hypocrisy. Do research on these SECULAR riots and pogroms too.
Thanks ma'am
You said he is against Muslim
That a truth
Not only Muslims but also against those who criticise his policy .
@@sumitsingh7835 rss and modi too is enemy of majorities who dont agree with their hate and violence and minorities an low castes people
@mohd azam:: first you teach your co muslims respect and consider ahmedias and soofis are also Muslim!!. Then speak about other religion !!!
She is a fraud. She is Hindu Nationalist Lite. She has proven that over her career.
She reacted when she was personally affected.
Yes, the chickens have come home to roost.
true
Like most people.
Amazing Interview!
She protected herself so well! Its a pity Karan didnt corner her for her subtle islamophobia. She constantly treats muslims as some other race as to being just humans or Indians.
Its' not just this lady; the illusion regarding the PM is quickly getting written off for many of us.
Glad I never had the illusion.
Modi Modi Modi.
What happened?.
U bastard, only bcz of people like you, whole India is Suffering.
Sachin Vartak can not say, I think there still are too many out there
manipulation works faster .when you watch wire you are already manipulated.
she's contradicting herself...she understands RSS to its core n knows RSS is Mr Modi's base, yet she supported him in 2014!! what r u trying to say Ma'am??
plaban Buragohain don’t know who she is fooling around... not only RSS , Modi himself has been such a vile and despicable person, ever since he came to be known after joining public life
She specialize in self contradiction..
I think she was clear. She hoped and prayed Modi will be different. But he turned out as a faithful RSS stooge.
Yes exactly, she said Modi has no formal general education except for the RSS, that is, she knew that Modi is the loyal product of a fascist organisation and yet she hoped that somehow he'd turn out to be different. She was so easily swayed away by his utterly false rhetoric like a complete fool.
Perhaps she came to her sense?
I was switched off when I heard her saying "I hate socialism". A country like India doesn't need socialism. Wow!!
If you destroy the rich then whom are you going to plunder from.
We went through socialism from 1967-1985
It didn't work
Still saying, “he is a wise politician’... some people will never learn...and Tavleen is one of them...
Hat's off to you Mam, you have the voice, and a spine, keep up the good work
How could this lady forget everything that happened in Gujarat ?
Totally agree.
S Sahu does your memory begin with Godhra ?
Yes, Gujarat progressed during Modi time. People in general are happy in Gujarat.
BoxerBaboon_2 AND THE KILLINGS OF INNOCENT PPL???
@@ibbysvloggs1018 innocent people are dying everywhere in India, what's your point? Most deaths are happening through road accidents, where is the outrage?
Gujarat have lower crime rate and no riots since 2002 all because of Modi.
She was shamelessly defending modi all these years but when her son got suffered she changed her viewpoint
Wouldn't you had done the same if you were in her shoes?
@@sonusingh-zr6xw never
Its not about her son, she is sharing her observations , her experience, she has a spine to speak up
our opinions are what we know and what we know changes
@@liveexpressed554 go through her old interview..she has done the same with Rajiv Gandhi and Sonia Gandhi
I was a vehement anti Congress person, but even in 2014 I knew that Modi was not the answer. People just saw their benefit and Now when they haven't materialized they're trying to distance themselves and jump ship
Exactly.
AAP like parties should emerge in politics
Isn't that always the case? But I'd say it's even worse in this instance. The smart people know that they've been let down and are disavowing him. But all the others who voted for him are basically doubling down and supporting/pretending to support every one of his policies regardless of their atrocity because they don't have the maturity to accept that they made a mistake in voting for him.
Everybody voted for bjp in 2014 because Modi was considered to be a panacea of all Ill also to teach congress a lesson.
Unless another party is able to arouse emotions of the whole country and is capable of challenging BJP, you have no choice but to vote Congress in the next election
It is not prejudice, it is safety mechanism for survival.
On second thought, Modi actually love the Muslims by imposing strict regulations so that the Muslims save from covid and let the Hindus add the Covid statistic. Thank you Modi.
See, if you give your house keys to a bugler because he told you that he's changed and then end up getting your house ransacked, you'd definitely be called a FOOL.
It requires guts to admit I have been a fool, and ego suppression.
It’s great to see Mr Thappar on The Wire channel. Karan means quality and making sense. I like The Wire already for it’s exemplary work but now I liked it more. Tavleen, I am glad that you got your awakening and you are the only one.
You like it because they are a bunch of suave fluent English speaking trying to fool you with their bunch of lies
Sad madam , that you realised this very late.
Thanks for forthright interaction ,where you gave a clear insight of the man named Narendra Modi
Constitution to barbadi ki kagaar pr pahuch chuka h😷
Yes ... My Majesty? where you have been, Massiah of the world. " Wolf In Sheep Disguise". Do your own Bussiness. He is a PM of the country. If you have so much of quality, try and fight election or be merely a spectator.
Without a doubt constitution is gone now
Desh consitution see chlega hindutwa ya shria ki bkwas see nhi
There something toxic about this islamic faith that even a fakir like Modi gets drawn into this kinda discourse
There is no const in muslim countries. They dont deserve one. Why is it that muslims are against police security forces only in non muslim countries. In Pak civilians are carpet bombed by fighter aircrafts. Yet muslim civilians dont hv problem with securty forces
I am a Marathi Brahmin, I have nothing to lose from this Modi Shah regime. But being a Marathi Brahmin, I fully understand RSS school of thoughts and both Modi n Shah admire Savarkar, Golwalkar. Make no mistake, they want to take revenge of past 1000 years and in the process, our country will get destroyed. Overthrow Modi n Shah.
It takes real guts to say that about RSS! Revenge for some real, mostly false ..history!
Karma leaves no one. 1000 years of injustice and destruction will be paid back for next 1000 years.
Actually she is lying. She knew Modi when he was the CM of Gujrat. As CM he had committed hundreds of crimes. Because her son was ill treated by Modi she has turned hostile.
She is a hypocrite and is certainly lying
Yes....
People like Tavleen also responsible for the present sorry state of affairs in the country. They supported and praised Modi despite knowing fully well what disastrous things he had done in Gujarat.
I totally agree with you. She is opportunistic and hypocrite.
@Yogesh Sharma 2000+ Muslim were butchered right under his nose ..even rajiv Gandhi couldn't be accused of sikh riot but every one knows whether it was sikh riot or Gujarat riot both couldn't happen without complicity of state
Karan Thapar is salivating with joy hearing Tavleen Singh who doesn’t know who to support! Wait till next year she will change her opinion to suit her
I am a bit amused to know that a senior journalist like her had hopes from a man who questioned the authority of the CAG on the floor of the house as a CM when a scam of 6000 crs in allotment of land for industrial project was unearthed by the CAG. His style of functioning was absolutely authoritarian as a CM. It seems to me that Tavleen Singh has something personal against the Congress.
Dhairysheel Ghatge !Same feelings here...
Agreed... 👍
exactly
Right on bro.
Even after repeated requests lok pal was not introduced in Gujarat, clearly shows there was no transparency in the Gujarat model.
* It is also written in the RSS book Bunch of Thats that liquor shops should be opened near the houses of the Shudras so that they might get drunk and fight and die. Build temples in the neighborhood of the Shudras so that they get caught in the swamp of hypocrisy. So keeping these things in mind, do not quarrel with each other and all the Shudra OBC, SC, ST indigenous people should always maintain unity among themselves. "One Buns" "Right Bones" Jai Moolniwasi! Jai Bheem ! Jai Bharat ! !From an Indian pen
»Praveen Togadia has children, ever seen him involved in any disturbance?
»Yogi Adityanath's nephew seen somewhere?
»Keshav Maurya's son seen anywhere?
* Why do Smriti Irani's children not go to Shakha
»Subramanian children's life set?
»Sushil Kumar Modi's children do not appear in Bajrang Dal.
»Ever heard that a child from Advani's house was caught waving the saffron flag in the court?
»Vasundhara Raje is also never seen in temples. »How many people in Narendra Modi's house get into the Hinduist crowd on the street? बच्चे Raman Singh's children become MPs without any Hindu movement. . - Was Vinay Katiyar's son in a frenzied crowd?
»Kalyan Singh's daughter-in-law, daughter-in-law, all the MPs became legislators who never took to the streets.
»Why did Rajnath Singh's son not join Bajrang Dal?
»Shivraj Singh Chauhan's child does not know Vande Mataram full song.
»What do both daughters of Murali Manohar Joshi do? • Poonam Mahajan or Pankaja Munde. . Because of the father, there are MPs and MLAs. .
»You all know Amit Shah's son. . . Before going mad, think who was from his family among the youth who were hoisting the saffron flag on the court premises of Rajasthan, climbing to the dome of Babri and dying, getting arrested, lathi-shot. . . The The The And you are letting your children use them and their ideology. . . ! ! Have a little mind, it's just use and throw politics, sir. . . Save your children from this poison. . . ! ! !
Is it really true? Coz I have heard from many that BJP keeps desi liquor available at low prices for dalits, so that they can dont stand up to ask questions..but I didn't believe it..
@@chrisgallagher7769 : Ajay Singh which I think must be pakistani "Wolf In sheep disguise" has now become your teacher.
" Rab ne bana di jodi, Ek andha ek kodhi "
Enjoy the music.
@@SantoshJha20 oh not again pakistan obsession
You arr right you will find liqour shops near dalit houses it is very common
Brother RSS is following Talmud which is a man written "holy" book for the jews. Talmud portrays jews as god's chosen people. Manusmriti is exactly same with different title.
It is not just muslims RSS is opposing, they are working to establish Brahman supremacy.
Next, RSS agenda is to creat mass unemployment, sell all national treasures to selected few and allowing populatin to kill one another.
The killing wont be about religious belief but for the food and survival. *The ground is being created.*
Can you please make a video on how to turn a Bhakt into a Normal Person
Please please......
It's simply really: tell the news publications to grow a pair and report actual news. Bhakts have to get their news from somewhere just like the rest of the people; the only issue is that most of the prominent news publications are shackled by the balls by the government, so you'd have to be fairly discerning in order to call bullshit when you see it. Seeing as India's education system isn't going to turn into that of Singapore's or Finland's overnight, nor are the hundreds of millions of people who are already grown adults going to learn how to think critically overnight, fixing news dissemination is the most effective way to fix them.
thats tough. like making butter from ghee. . the mind has melted you see.
Uninstall their whatsApp & gift them some books
@Shashwat mishra haha you are in grave danger. Beware!
Also how to cure anti-modi zombies lol!!!
What a lame person she is to find out modi and RSS is anti Muslim in 2019-20. That man was responsible for Gujrat riot.
Intellectual honesty Gaya tel lene.
She became a critic when atish tashir her son was attacked.
Dipesh Parida muslim ko gali deny sy pehly hindu aur sikh kali bheeron ko b daikh lo wo b usi thali m cheed krty hn jis m khaty hn
Just one person is not enough to blame a community
deepjyoti bhattacharjee absolutely correct, please read my reply to someone else here
again modi hater firing the bullshit arrow in dark. cant able to digest his popularity
OHOO, THIS WAS THE WOMAN OR KEP OF TASHEER HADI, HAVING THE ILLIGMATE SON ATISH FROM TASHEER. IT IS QUITE CLEAR TO UNDERSTAND HER CHARACTER.
Usman Muhammed please don’t say like this... we should never ever be judgemental, we don’t know what were her circumstances... what she went through and suffered ... and how can the children be illegitimate...
Difficult to understand, how an educated/ intellectual humanly person took so long to realise. Does not mean that she was blind. It only means she believed Modi, much more than he deserved.
I think it's more than just belief, it's hste for one turning to love for another and that bias actively helped her overlook the most horrible realities of be people she turned towards
She only turned against Modi when her son Aatish Taseen was stripped of his citizenship.
SO TRUE
This interview perfectly encapsulates my personal journey with Modi regime.
modi haters i enjoy seeing your anxiety.
@@footballforyou8856 I was once a lover of him bro. I voted for development. But with economy falling, I dont find a reason to support him. its just as simple as that.
@@shivkrishna7706 still the average growth is greater than upa tenure.Even the improvement is slight he should still be rewarded for improvement.Credit should also be given for decision which makes history.You also know nobody except modi would have guts to remove 370 and 35A.if you all consider caa as against constitution then you sould thant modi for removing 370 and 35 A which was way against contitution and it was looming from 50 years.
For me he hasnt given me reason for hate.i would have hated him if he would have not removed 370
Excellent interview ; saw it on TV screen with my entire family ! We really enjoyed it.
With this interview
I had started loving Tavleen singh,'s candid Persona.
Hattsoff to you karan....💖💕:-)
Interesting family
No person can be great when a person has hate inside him about another human being specially his fellow countryman and when u treat your fellow countryman as second class citizens
Absolutely right.
I think you are talking about Pakistan and most Islamic countries.
@@satyajitverma2158 now you know my friend why we never become a developed country
@@johnsonmathew8565 Not really. Do you mean Pakistan and most Islamic countries?
I knew it..
She is a serious lier. Until the issue related to his son, she was a vocal supporter of bharat jalao party and Modi. She was also many times guilty of spreading fake things....
absolutely right!!
What kind of fake things??
@@shimab8898 you need to search her Twitter history know this. I don't have time provide that to you.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO seriously I am biased against people who spread fake propaganda and people support them. I just can't tolerate liers. I Know it's a upbringing problem. But I can't help.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO liers can't stand against the truth. That's why to support liers, they try to spread fake propaganda against people who catch their lies.
This lady sees the past government as dark time and just because she hated socialism...the basis of the constitution of India is socialist state....and now when she was faced with intense discriminatory action she is critical of Modi...isi ko kehte Hain जाके पांव न फटे बिवाई, सो क्या जाने पीर पराई
Typical Indian mentality...जब तक ख़ुद पर न पड़े तब तक पता नहीं चलता
Sonia Minz 👌🏻👌🏻
@Amit Roshan RSS led BJP is creating mass unemployment,that is intentional so that people kill one another- not because you are either hindu or a muslim but for food and survival. Those 10&-20% people will be OK.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO This country can never become a developed state without adopting a successful socialistic model. Nehru was a genius to have thought of this very early but morons like you who are filled with anti communism hatred can never understand the socio economic fabric this country longs for. India was freaking poor when Nehru took over, by the time it gained some strength, Indira happened and institutionalized every bad that still plagues this country. Without a perfect welfare model, this country is bound to doom as the socio economic divide keep getting wider and wider, making poors stuck in a never ending loop of poverty.
why she hate socialism?
@@beingakhiL She wants big highways for cheap, and you can only build them with cheap labor. Which can't work with socialism. 🤷🏻♂️
She didn't understand rhetoric of Modi? Great intellectual.
to understant rhetoric of modi you have to be educated but ofcourse people who just go to madrsa cant be educated
@@footballforyou8856 knowledge comes from BJP IT cell only. Keep it up.Ghanti bajao
@@fazlulkarim9123 every kind of knowledge is greater than illiterate things of madarsa.you people just go to madarsa day and be just a burden to your country not an asset.
@@footballforyou8856 BJP IT cell knowledge is above all. They know that Jawaharlal Nehru was a Muslim. There are lot of knowledge you will get from BJP IT cell. If you don't understand go to a pandit of nearby temple. Ok?
@@fazlulkarim9123 So, Nehru was a Pandit. How ? Please explain.
I'm here to improve and sharpen my vocabulary. Thanks Karan.
Quran padho na iski kya zarurat hai
There something toxic about this islamic faith that even a fakir like Modi gets drawn into this kinda discourse
listen to bbc to sharpen eng vocab. Karn the fake will ruin ya
@@ntrhopi itni insecurities laate kahan se ho?
@@sddevrj I wish you start making sense someday. For now you don't. Have a good day.
Karan is always great in bringing out the truth from the people he interviews. Good.
Really?
Most surprizing!! After seeing his tenure as CM of Gujarat and as PM of India for six years Tavlinsimh steel hopes against hope!! Really!!
I'm afraid of the day when Modi will know for sure he's going down.Will he take the country down with him as Hitler did ?
YEAH, FOR SURE MODI N SHAH WILL BRING DOWM INDIA AS HITLER DID IN GERMANY. THEY R LEADING INDIA ON. A. VERY DANGEROUS PATH. GIVING BRUTAL. ORDERS. TO THE COPS. TO LATHI CHARGE N SHOOT AT. SIGHT. SO MANY YOUNG STUDENTS,. WOMEN N KIDS R SERIOUSELY INJURED.. WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE BIG POLE SHOVED UP THE FAT ASSES OF BOTH MODI N SHAH... NOW IS 4HE RIGHT TIME TO BRING THEM DOWN N CRUSH THEM ONCE N FOR ALL. JAI HIND.
You said it! Very prophetic. Yes, Modi is finished. But Bharat will continue to be a Democracy of the people, by the people and for the people. Without realising it the RSS in cahoots with the BJP has woken up a Sleeping Giant who will destroy those who tried to destroy this Great Nation. We can look forward to the Nation raising good and honest and well educated and patriotic Political Leaders in the very near future. Thanks be to God.
IT IS ALREADY DOWN
Modi and the country will do just fine. Only your Modi hatred will take YOU down.
@@vicky1b ok then.u go UP soon along with Modi g.
Uh lady you're twenty years late. But ok.
I don't intend 2 make fun of her, but she turned out 2 b d actual tubelight.
Vijay Kumar haha!
🤣ohh tavleen finally here... but disappointed just when she felt a personal loss her dillusional chant broke......
Was she blind in 2002
@@asnashaikh6725 and this not the first time she had talked to RSS ppl and she came to know about their master plan still she blvd modi and herself says she is born child of rss how can he change... then how she was convinced that he had changed in 2013-14
@@asnashaikh6725 when you ask a question on 2002 don't forget to answer about Godhra.
Jab aapne pe padi ,tab dard ka ahasas hua.
@@nimeshkhatri1435 hahaha.. he himself killed his own ppl to rule the state.... u can expect atleast this from duo shah.. there is no concrete proff that Muslims fire the train in the official report, rest we know how corrupt Gujarat police is by seeing the present condition of delhi police.
*AS READER OF HER COLUMN FOR YEARS, I REALLY LOVED HER WHOLE TURNAROUND, AND THE BEST OF WHOLE VIDEO AS FAR LOGIC IS CONCERNED IS **21:30**!!*
MRIDUL KUMAR ?? I could not understand,what are you trying to say
I think he has no fear of his life..... Love u sir...Praising his determination to journalism.... May be the only journalist in india having sword in his hands..... The Wire_ Valiant journalism
Agree, once in public rally discribed his very NATURE,said,,Mai bhoolata nahee, Aur badalaa letaa hun, I feel he collected and preserved some prejudices, accordingly reacting
I really would like her to critically explain how her idea of ‘liberal democracy’ is not socialistic? Anyway, let’s applaud her enlightenment and her supreme honesty in finally speaking out.
Oh here comes the bengalli with economic illiteracy.
Every bhatk's eye will open eventually 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Opened but still won’t vote for Italian national congress
I never trust the wisdom of anyone who fell for Modi. She look like too naive and gullible.
Well said,
Touche'
Those were different times, when Modi used to talk/act about development ,no corruption and no discrimination, but now on his second term reality is out , now his blind followers are like terminal stage of cancer, no coming back for them
Sujith Kumar yes, I agree with you
then you should check your wisdom .you are bhakt
Glass of water is always ready, who knows what may happen to thapar's interviewee.
Even recently she was supporting Modi. 🤦♂️.. Now she says this... Does she need so many samples to understand the reality 😔
hhahhahahahha......they are intellectuals
He made feku drink water
This is an interview of magnanamus proportions coming from a past supporter...!! It shows times are changing.
@Alternative View let me DM you and I will post everything what I was posting here in that comment. It is still saved in my clipboard.
Tavleen Singh is behaving naive and it's understandable and also commendable to come out and express her disappointment and disillusionment.
Anyone who claims to have covered RSS extensively and against the backdrop of 2002, hoping Modi would strengthen India positively, seems hard to believe.
Lastly, the shining comet on a dark sky and the reason that PM in UPA government was controlled by Chairperson of Congress is pretty dumb thing to say in the context of Indian politics. Are we to believe Modi controls RSS and its not the other way around? Didn't we see Vajpayeeji spend his political capital in keeping a leash over RSS? Congress was running a coalition and the chairperson of the largest party in the coalition will be a key decision - maker on policy matters. Didn't Balasaheb Thackerey loved remote control. Isn't NDA and Modi run the administration via a remote control, euphemistically speaking?
Ananthiyer1973 yes, as a journalist she should have known all this and rather knew it, having Sonia Gandhi, chairperson of Congress party as a remote was much better than having remotes with criminal ideology and she should have also given a thought to the working of Mr Manmohan Singh, an able and conscientious person to the core...
SHE IS A LIAR
In the end she actually got emotional but it's a quite impressive interview
I can't help but notice Karan's inability to control his devilish smile when someone bashes Modi just like how he's thinking in his head. 😆Nothing against him, just feels a bit dishonest.
True. Every time i watch karan thapar i am reminded of the statement always reminds me of how Truth always triumphs. Today Modi is 2 time prime minister, repealed 370, constructing ram mandir, implementing several anti poverty schemes like jandhan, ujwala, pradhan mantri was yojna, nal se jal, swach bharat, etc while Karan thappar is making youtube videos and fallen from being a prime time anchor to a 2nd grade youtuber.
Epic observation 😂
After seeing whole interview she still hope on Modi.😆😆😆😆
I think she's just saying that to appear less of a fool than she already seems. Like the way a person buys a bad stock and doesn't want to sell it because they have to admit they made a mistake.
If one's humanity is rotten then his religion will never make him a good person.
Religion is just a camouflage for such ppl.
This interview have all the ingredients, the elegance, the decorum, the grace, articulation, interaction just superb. The interviewer and the guest both at classical best, both made India proud within and outside. It rekindles hope among muslims that all is not lost, there are statesman amidst them which not allow India to become an erstwhile Germany.
It has hatred, & fools like you appreciate
@@_kumu_ku How polite and cultured. Disrespecting one’s interlocutor has got to be the most efficient communication strategy, hasn’t it! Noice. As they say these days, "lit AF".
@@FarhanAmin1994 no matter how many strong English words ( "interlocutor") you use in your comments, you are still a Muslim and came here to support YOUR brother, isn't it ? If that is someone who is not a muslim who put the first comment, you won't be here to reply to KUBENDRA Mukkund (provided the main theme is not related to Islam and Muslims).
Or pak and banhladesh or saudi or Afghanistan?
@Harsh G Islamic Republic of kerala and west bengal are on the way
Respect the sense of honesty conveyed.
And by the way, Karan and Tavleen, for twice a month we say "fortnightly" while once in two months is referred to as "bi-monthly".
I was surprised when he said 'bi-monthly' for 'twice in a month'.
Both are surprisingly correct in English - Once in two months as well as twice in a month. Check it in any dictionary.
Completely overlooked the genocide of Gujarat, lady -"that didn't worry you?" For starters? Or like said towards the end, when got bitten herself (the son was denied citizenship) is when it became clear
Why see only about Delhi alone what had happened in Gujarat after the Godhra tragedy, thousands of innocent muslims were burnt alive and killed and no one was arrested so far a d those arrested were released on bail by SC
You media people were responsible for state of affairs today.You were forefront in supported Modi knowing very well his background and Gujarat Model just because you donot like congress.Now regret and criticized when the things are goi g out of control
Ayub Khan yes that’s surprising, rather shocking, she’s not young, 70 years old has seen and heard everything
@Eric sam its like osama bin laden saying, 9/11 happened after Afghanistan bombings 👎
First of all Jinnah ain't alive. And secondly since you speak about 1946, then how about answering about those who sided with the British by taking a salary and siding with the British during the freedom struggle while all other communities laid down their lives for the freedom struggle
Achha program Hindi me nhi hota hai
English me hota hai ...jo Bharat ki majority jnta Samajh hi na paye ...or Hindi wala chhapta nhi hai..
💥
So sorry dekho
Punchar lagane wale to samajh jare hai
@@RKumar-tm1tz ...
Brahmano ne OBC,ST ,SC ko shudraa,ATI shudraa ,acchhooot ko ghulaam es tarah Bana liya hai....parh likhkar punchar Bana Raha....samjhegaa q nahi. Bilkul sahi kaha
Amazing 🤔🤔... You told him a messiah... Now what happened... Have you awakened?
Karan Thapar is the best interviewer we have at the moment.
Love you thapar sir for your candid views...thanks a tonne portraying our feelings....if I Express my my feelings on social media I am trolled with lot of abuse and my phone gets hacked..this is Modi ji ka true India
Thapars father was a Bagodia...Beacuse of whom we lost the China war
She hate elites and she also hates socialism what a great contradiction. In the Rest of the interview Thapar continues to baby her and it Seems like they removed her from godi media's payroll.
Thank God,finally she spoke out and more of Modi Ji ,we come to know,that Modi Ji is dramabaas.
Figura Molen yes contradicting herself,she’s a liar... and Thapar has been extra kind to her, donno why??
@@mouseeqhee he is kind because, " Subah ka Bhola agar sham ko laut aaye ...
Madam Tavleen welcome to the club...you are also a victim of Modi Propaganda like any other Indian. He talks Parivartan but he doesn't understand it. So you connect the dots. 🤣🤣🤣
Madam forgot his background, from where he came, his actual & true ideology, his history in Gujarat, etc etc but lay man like us never believed him
He had an illustrious background already before 2013-14!
Lay man do gross injustice when they say that Hitler Stalin or changeiz khan caused maximum bloodshed . Just one historic figure has wrecked havoc on mankind and continues to do so
I too read the Indian Express column. Not impressed at all by her answers. For a person who claims to have been a journalist all her life and to have covered the RSS and politics in the course of her work , I think naive is a kind word to use. I suspect she’s been pro Hindutva and now for personal reasons things have changed. Sorry Tavleen you didn’t convince me
opportunist journalist turn Rani Harischandra... her naivete is not at all credible
In the morning I saw her interview in the @quint.
Very fabulous indeed
Watch that also guys. 💖:-)
It seems: she has been duped by MODI in an irreparable measure .
Talveen is right, when she says if somebody is the embodiment of megalomania and vanity can be very dangerous.
SHE IS A BORN LIAR AND HIPOCRATE
Graceful Lady with Graceful ideas and Graceful delivery. Good job done by KT.
Both of you r the best Journlist. I wrote 120 Letters to P. M in 2014_15 I suggest him lots of things but being a common senior citizen He did not reply but he passed my suggestion as bill. I want to send my Book to both of you please send me your address so I can post it. I don't want any kind of favour and don't want to become Famous. I m a retired teacher very happy. मै भी मोदी जी के भाषणो से भ्रमित हुई अब मै भी भ्रम से बाहर आ गयी हूँ तलवीन जी की तरह। नमस्कार।
Haan ji, Modi ji ko har chitthi ka jawab likhana chaiye. Unko chuna hi isi liye tha ki chitthi ka jawab regularly diya karen.
26:00 onwards
The conversation becomes dangerous .
If what she’s saying is true ,we are all heading for dark dark days.
Yes there are Dark days Ahead for Jihadis.
You seriously don't think India is already dark?
‘I hate socialism’; yet, you’re on WIRE! 😂
No matter . She baits modi now,. That will do for wire vardarajas of the land
Very insightful interview. Appreciate the fact that she had the independent mind and wisdom to question the wrong and distance herself from them upong noticing criminal intent. These intents are not always clear and she says that those were dark days. At least she had the wisdom and courage to speak out. Well done! Modi got lucky in so many ways!
😜
She is playing innocence all while.
Everyone knew what Modi stood for. Her current behaviour seems like a reaction to the Govt of India cancelling her son's OCI card.
I appreciate your views as well as your work ma'am (: . And i don't find your statements contradictory as you accepted the mistake you once made. I do agree with most of the points you made.
Sonia Gandhi called him "Mout Ka soudagar" (merchant of death) once was right.
What should Sonia Gandhi call Rajeev Gandhi for Sikh genocide in 1984?
What truckload of bs? Did she not know of Modi's credentials in 2013?
itna muslim hate wala humara pm nhi ho sakta,, wo khud bhul chuka h ke wo musalmano ka bhi pm he,, uske "kapde dekh kar pehchan" aur "hindu atankwadi nhi ho sakta" wale remarks se pata chalta hai k wo kitna khokhla aur prejudiced insan hei,, halanke wo insan banne k bhi qabil nhi,, pm to door ki baat,
Mana ki godi bura h but tum logo ne 15 min police hta lo wale ko support kyn kra nation anthem nhi gayenge Nation song Islam k khilaf h court ki nhi Islam ki chlegi hypocrisy
@@sk....3049 yeh RSS ka gobar gyan mat paliyo idhar, aur rahi baat vande mataram ki toh 99.9% BJP ko bhi nahi ata yakeen nahi toh Modi Shah se puchlo woh bhi nahi ga payenge, suna BJP ke It cell ke bhadwe
@@sk....3049 "15minute police hatalo" ko hum nhi support karte,, kaun kehta hai hum national anthem nhi gaate,, hum SC k khilaf hn? it's rss jo national flag me believe nhi karte,, you are right,, godi bahut bura h,,
@@user-hy7vj2jx3k shah bano case baangi h k kitna tum log supreme Court ka izzat krte ho ...tum logo ne triple talaq hlala ka court k baar baar khne PR sanmaan nhi kea kha k Muslims ka internal matters h jabki yh anti consitution tha 15 min wale k time pr godi nhi Congress thi mene deka than reaction Muslims ka molana barkati ka byaan b yaad h muje Azam Khan etc k b tum logo k videos h jha national song Nation anthem k khilaf ho ....AGR rss esa h toh tum Islamic log b vese e brainwash muglo ko support krte ho hinduo se converted ho k arif muhmad Khan rizwaan Ahmed ko sun Lena ek baar
After one year
@karanthaper @theWire
Do another interview as much water had flown into Rivers.. 🙏❤️