16:46 Love how sweet Damien was to Chance when he got the spider at the end. Not just the offering of eating a bit, but reassuring that he can yeet it the second it goes in his mouth. You can just tell how caring he is in that moment.
"You know the smell of a pet store? That's what it tastes like." Spider Cookies Taste Test Ft. Shayne Topp: "This tastes like how Petco smells." Okay, two for two, I guess this really is the definitive way to describe eating a spider.
olivia has always been a badass on this show. never forget her thousand yard stare with the wasabi-chili oil-twinkie and refusing the yeet bucket like a goddamn god
you know what? I'd love an episode that was nothing but the "grave mouths" the ones who can either eat almost anything like Damian and Olivia or have "grave mouth" like Shane with malic acid. IDK who the others would be though
Chanse is so damn fun. I love his whole vibe. He seems like he'd be the absolute best friend to watch scary movies with at 1am because half the fun would be seeing him react to the movie in real time.
Olivia gasping and saying "Sandwich!" at 6:40 is right up there with her saying "Noodles!" in the donut EIOYI. She is ridiculously cute. Like a SUPER weird puppy. Also it's a shame there isn't at least one Damien and Olivia compilation because he's always so sweet and encouraging to her and I feel like their insane (in different ways) energies mesh so well together.
@@dsly4425 oh yeah, her first bite was from the vegan episode. spider is worse as a first bite, but jackie has definitely had one of the worst bites ever
@@misswilwarin8829 oh I absolutely think her bite was one of if not the absolute worst bite in the history of the show to date. Her “just dessert” revenge dish may have been worse for anyone if it hadn’t been Garrett. But the flip side is he knew what hell awaited him and that might be worse come to think of it.
Omg I love Patrick. Both Patrick and Jeremy actually, they have been the mvps of recent videos and I hope they continue to show up in front of the camera. Not only are they hilarious but they’re so full of energy and laughter and they just make every video they’re in great.
The fact that his idea of a “normal lunch” was doughnut holes supports your hypothesis. Also, a previous video where he said his pantry had gushers and/or fruit by the foot? Haha.
Chanse says everything I'm thinking. I wasn't sure I was gonna like him before but this boy is wayyyy over his head 🤣🤣🤣🤣 can't wait to see him get closer with the others
If I had a nickel for every time Garrett fed someone a bug their first time on EIOYI, I'd have 2 nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice
@@antoniacosta6221 oooh! I get you now. I've been mistaken. Thanks for clarifying that. Altho I will say now that you clarified that, Jackie didn't get the bug pie on her first appearance. Her first episode was the 1st vegan episode
Something I think would be interesting would be a mode where everyone has to collectively decide on a grouping of five foods, whether or not they would take it or use a 'skip' on it, only having two 'skips' with five meals total.
That's honestly a great idea. Maybe it can be buffet style so Garrett can flex his skills at hiding the "bad" foods more. The two skips thing really adds a fun game mechanic to the whole concept. I want to see an episode of EOYI that is similar to the Weird Ramen episode but with pizza. Different doughs, different sauces, different cheeses, different veggies, different proteins, and different powders (more than parmesan and red pepper flakes) to pour on top. That would be a killer episode, especially if the Mythical kitchen was involved.
props to Chance for eating the tarantula but yeah. Welcome to Smosh indeed! This Eat it or Yeet It was weirdly... nice? Like not as ruthless in flavour profiles as the usual (bbbugs aside). Maybe a redemption arc for Garrett?
Idea: Trader or Traitor Garrett’s Items from TJ that may have been altered by Garrett Swap Meet - each contestant has a card for a drink and a bite. One is good the other is bad. They can swap cards with others before the items are presented. They can end up with one of each or two drinks/bites.
The card idea sounds really fun. It also kinda sounds like the lazy Susan gimmick from Good Mythical Morning, which one of those games done with Smosh would be the as well.
One day I want Garret to just replace chocolate with laxative..."hmm seems like just an ordinary chocolateshake from McDonald's"..."congratulations, that was a McLax shake!"
Chanse is great. You should have a Fan Guest show. LOVE to see an Eat It or Yeet It with 1 cast and 4 fans. I'd def join if asked, and if i had a way to get to Cali from the East Coast. lol
Im surprised they havent brought one of those people who can make a cake that looks like friggin anything just to make 1 dish. Oh.. it looks like an actual log of doo doo... oh wait! Its cake!
Courtney: "Olivia what are you dipping into?"
Olivia: "Flatbread"
Everyone collectively: *facepalm*
i cackled until someone had to ask me if i was okay XD
when the right answer is mayonnaise, but you skip right past that and answer WRONG for pizza
Chanse: *trying his best not to cry*
Keith: Welcome to Smosh 😄
I CANT WITH THESE PEOPLE
Eat It or Yeet It is basically hazing for Smosh
@@misswilwarin8829 that’s what I said lol 😂
Ah yes, bugs. A top staple next to malic acid. Garrett really likes to torture everyone on this show. 😂
He shoulda moistened the spider with some malic acid 😂
Bugs with malic acid next
I was kind of hoping those grape fruit snacks would be full of malic acid
let jackie fight for chance
Olivia forgetting to describe what she’s tasting and continuing to just chow down is exactly what I needed to see today
1k likes and no comments
@@imjaricclown
@@Susancreamwood shut the hell up
@@Susancreamwood ya mother
@@imjaricnot the russian sleep experiment pfp 😭😭😭😭
16:46 Love how sweet Damien was to Chance when he got the spider at the end. Not just the offering of eating a bit, but reassuring that he can yeet it the second it goes in his mouth. You can just tell how caring he is in that moment.
"You know the smell of a pet store? That's what it tastes like."
Spider Cookies Taste Test Ft. Shayne Topp: "This tastes like how Petco smells."
Okay, two for two, I guess this really is the definitive way to describe eating a spider.
That’s exactly what I was thinking of!
Damien is such a sweetheart, being fully willing to eat part of a goddamn spider to make Chanse feel better 🥺 this is why we love him
110%
I think he just likes those legs lol
All of the above is facts.
Olivia and Patrick have such a cute chemistry, they get along and make each other laugh so well (same with Jeremy)
Omg I was thinking the same thing. They pair really well together on screen
Garrett just wanted to flex his sneaky re-sealing skills today
Olivia has become somewhat immune to the effects of this show.
As long as it's not a liquid she's fine
olivia has always been a badass on this show. never forget her thousand yard stare with the wasabi-chili oil-twinkie and refusing the yeet bucket like a goddamn god
@@ChicagoRatHole Well i think we need more Noah on this show.(His dishes were always Gross Man).
She did straight up ate wasabi on the first episodes, maybe her taste buds never recovered
you know what? I'd love an episode that was nothing but the "grave mouths" the ones who can either eat almost anything like Damian and Olivia or have "grave mouth" like Shane with malic acid. IDK who the others would be though
Chanse is so damn fun. I love his whole vibe. He seems like he'd be the absolute best friend to watch scary movies with at 1am because half the fun would be seeing him react to the movie in real time.
True, he'd have the funniest scared reaction face 😂
Who is Chanse? Do you mean Gay Zonday?
@@mug281 don't be rude
@@111_23 so the word “Gay” is rude? Stfu.
Damien immediately offering to eat a leg with Chance out of solidarity.....We stan a true friend
He just wanted to eat the leg let’s be honest
@@arthurboton4146Damien is literally laios from delicious in dungeon to a tee (he voices him)
The bibs really do match everyone very well. Keith looks good in purple and red is a great color for Chanse.
This is such a sweet comment 🥺
The green really suits Patrick, too
Garrett had a “have I created a hostile work environment for the new guy?” Moment when chance was preparing to eat
Chanse is hilarious. I need him and Jackie to be together for a Smosh Pit video lol
have you seen the acronym board af? 😭
@@jasmineae omg no! I rarely watch the board af videos but this gives me something to watch! thank you!
I definitely see a similarity in vibe!
I like the mystery style, so they can't even see what the food is when the cloche is lifted, do more of those!!
Keith: "Can i get a drink?"
Patrick: "Theres some sauce leftover"
Keith: "No, Fuck you"😂
Olivia gasping and saying "Sandwich!" at 6:40 is right up there with her saying "Noodles!" in the donut EIOYI. She is ridiculously cute. Like a SUPER weird puppy.
Also it's a shame there isn't at least one Damien and Olivia compilation because he's always so sweet and encouraging to her and I feel like their insane (in different ways) energies mesh so well together.
I think she's just leaning into the weird at this point. And frankly, I'm here for it.
here is one but its them being an awkward duo and i love it lol
Having only seen Damien's lunch, I am %100 certain the rest of this will be a catastrophe of epic proportions!
Damien got the lunch I always wanted as a kid
@@FaeMasquerade you always wanted to be tricked and confused by your lunch?
Chanse is such a good sport, that's a worse first bite than Jackie's 🥲
I don't think anything will ever beat a clay pie with huge beetles. Chanse just ate a bite of spider.
@@misswilwarin8829 yeah I agree Jackie’s was still worse 😅
@@misswilwarin8829 pretty sure Jackie’s bug pie was t the first bite she had though. But that was probably the worst bite to date.
@@dsly4425 oh yeah, her first bite was from the vegan episode. spider is worse as a first bite, but jackie has definitely had one of the worst bites ever
@@misswilwarin8829 oh I absolutely think her bite was one of if not the absolute worst bite in the history of the show to date. Her “just dessert” revenge dish may have been worse for anyone if it hadn’t been Garrett. But the flip side is he knew what hell awaited him and that might be worse come to think of it.
The instant cut after Keith says "Shout out to Digimon"
“it’s got the flavor profiles of an attic.” is such a funny line from olivia 😭😭😭
Couldn't have been a better timing to watch Beef Beef have his food after a really long delivery
Wonder where Hooey went
I just finished watching that one when I saw this.
@@charlottec4157 same
Hooey went back to the pond with Jennifer-Deborah
but didn't Hooey say something like "I'm gonna wack off my truck"? he's probably still busy doing that
Unfortunately HooEEEEEE is back in prison after going on what the police are calling "the most prolific hit-and-run crime spree of all time".
keith's whole color palette plus the matching bib is EVERYTHING
Love having Chance and Patrick on Eat It Or Yeet It. Also Keith:"I love Dragon Ball Z" to a Yu Gi Oh lunchbox 😂
And his “Shoutout to Digimon” at the end 😂
"It has flavor profiles of an attic" 🤣 olivia
Chanse and Patrick are awesome! Chanse's reactions were amazing!
Courtney’s subtle “fahaha” will haunt me in my dreams lol 😂
Keith and Chanse’s dynamic is so fun to watch. More of that please!
Chanse's 1st EIOYI was everything I thought it was gonna be! 😂😂😂
Garrett maniacally laughing to Chanse’s reaction to the spider was such a mood.
Omg I love Patrick. Both Patrick and Jeremy actually, they have been the mvps of recent videos and I hope they continue to show up in front of the camera. Not only are they hilarious but they’re so full of energy and laughter and they just make every video they’re in great.
I say this with the utmost respect and affection: Patrick LOOKS like a man who would buy Zebra Cakes by the case.
And I say that because I also would.
Don’t they normally come in boxes of 9,000? 🤣
They’re so good!
I'm obsessed with zebra cakes!
The fact that his idea of a “normal lunch” was doughnut holes supports your hypothesis. Also, a previous video where he said his pantry had gushers and/or fruit by the foot? Haha.
Zebra cakes and Jelly filled cream pies. 👀
Liv enjoying her food so much "Oh I forgot to talk" hahaha ❤️❤️ so cute when you said Banana!
damien: rich kid having a weird day
olivia: weird kid having a rich day
I just wanna say that Patrick is absolutely hilarious and we usually get to see it through his sketches. The jokes land just as well in person.
I read this as "in prison"
Chanse says everything I'm thinking. I wasn't sure I was gonna like him before but this boy is wayyyy over his head 🤣🤣🤣🤣 can't wait to see him get closer with the others
If I had a nickel for every time Garrett fed someone a bug their first time on EIOYI, I'd have 2 nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice
Actually 3 if I'm not mistaken
@@dlmbs I know Jackie and Chanse got it, but who else?
@@antoniacosta6221 i mean, if you count Shayne with the Ant-Man cookie. Also it would be 4 cause Keith got bug nachos one time
@@dlmbs Were those their first times on the show? I feel like those were after their initial appearances.
@@antoniacosta6221 oooh! I get you now. I've been mistaken. Thanks for clarifying that. Altho I will say now that you clarified that, Jackie didn't get the bug pie on her first appearance. Her first episode was the 1st vegan episode
Damien saying he was going to eat the bug with him. Always so sweet
I love it whenever Patrick is in a video, he’s so adorable (and hilarious ofc) 😭😭
I LOVE THIS! It's nice they are choosing mystery lunch boxes, and don't know what they are getting until they open it. They should do this more! 😊
Courtney: So what is it that you're dipping into?
Olivia: Flatbread?
Oh olivia. I lost it there lol
wtf everyone else just casually ingesting the dried up spider 💀💀🤣🤣 this is why smosh is smosh lmao
it was a cute solidarity moment
@@ChrisSeaASMR cute and totally unexpected lmao
The maniacal laughter with the, "no, no, no!!" was so funny! 😆
this by far has to be the funniest eat it or yeet it episode yet. olivia forgetting to talk because the donut was THAT good had me crying.
Something I think would be interesting would be a mode where everyone has to collectively decide on a grouping of five foods, whether or not they would take it or use a 'skip' on it, only having two 'skips' with five meals total.
That's honestly a great idea. Maybe it can be buffet style so Garrett can flex his skills at hiding the "bad" foods more. The two skips thing really adds a fun game mechanic to the whole concept.
I want to see an episode of EOYI that is similar to the Weird Ramen episode but with pizza. Different doughs, different sauces, different cheeses, different veggies, different proteins, and different powders (more than parmesan and red pepper flakes) to pour on top. That would be a killer episode, especially if the Mythical kitchen was involved.
Chanse's energy is so contagious, real charismatic, hope he is in more videos
he's so soft though, smosh doesnt need more soft people
@@livingportside soft people would yeet and simply retch upon seeing tarantula drenched with cotton candy.
Patrick is a funny guy! He needs to be in more videos.
Chanse's face when he sees the bug😂 Yes Chanse, we WILL watch this
Omg! I just love Patrick. He's so wholesome and also a cutie. ❤️
My favorite part of this episode is Damien and Patrick casually eating spider legs
i love the addition of Chanse. he is fantastic🖤
I'ma be honest, I had forgotten good food was an option on this show.
stop rn. i fell in love with chanses energy. seriously so cute. we need way more of him
Chanse has finally had his Smosh initiation. We love to see it
This is the petition for rhett and link to be on eat it or yeet it , they have eaten some weird things
Chanse: *having a meltdown*
Keith: "Welcome to Smosh 😁"
Loving this lunchbox special because it really gives no way to judge how good or bad it's gonna be beforehand. More of this please!!
This was a hilarious vid, everyone was firing off on all cylinders!!!
I love how well Olivia and Jeremy (Patrick too) seem to get along really well on screen. It’s sweet and hilarious in equal parts
Garret cam is my FAVORITE!! he’s just so swag
" it has the flavor profile of an attic" had me rolling
I just finished my lunch break at work and this is hilarious 😂
Chanse absolutely killed that 🎉
props to Chance for eating the tarantula but yeah. Welcome to Smosh indeed! This Eat it or Yeet It was weirdly... nice? Like not as ruthless in flavour profiles as the usual (bbbugs aside). Maybe a redemption arc for Garrett?
Idea: Trader or Traitor Garrett’s
Items from TJ that may have been altered by Garrett
Swap Meet - each contestant has a card for a drink and a bite. One is good the other is bad. They can swap cards with others before the items are presented. They can end up with one of each or two drinks/bites.
The card idea sounds really fun. It also kinda sounds like the lazy Susan gimmick from Good Mythical Morning, which one of those games done with Smosh would be the as well.
One day I want Garret to just replace chocolate with laxative..."hmm seems like just an ordinary chocolateshake from McDonald's"..."congratulations, that was a McLax shake!"
Loved Patrick and Chanse in this video!! Way to crush your first eat or yeet lol
olivia looks like she's just having a regular weird wednesday
Damien just gently cromching a bug leg in the background 🤣
Welp, I can see Chanse’s revenge against Garrett coming in the future. Poor Chanse 🥺
1:31
Chanse immediately establishes himself as the Gen Zer of Smosh
Feel like Chanse is giving strong youngest sibling energy here
Chanse is great. You should have a Fan Guest show. LOVE to see an Eat It or Yeet It with 1 cast and 4 fans. I'd def join if asked, and if i had a way to get to Cali from the East Coast. lol
New talent at Smosh can go one of two ways… and I really like Chanse!!
Patrick's laugh was EPIC! I'm still tearing up from laughter!
Im surprised they havent brought one of those people who can make a cake that looks like friggin anything just to make 1 dish. Oh.. it looks like an actual log of doo doo... oh wait! Its cake!
I love Chanse so much, he fits the smosh vibes
Damien: "the legs taste like sunflower seeds... Here take a leg"
It took him long enough.
Chanse is a true Smosh member now. Proud of him. Love his energy! 😌🖤🖤
Chanse and Jackie should start a support group 😆
something incredible about the chemistry between olivia and patrick, both this and the tntl
Ah yes, Obelisk the Tormenter, Slifer the Executive Producer, and Mega-Ultra Chicken. Damian got the best one.
lmaooo Chance is hilarious! This episode was so fun!
YAAAY!! More Chanse!
I like this new chance guy. I can't quite put my finger on it but something about him really resonates with me.
Keith sounds like the adults in Peanuts when he speeks about his dish 😂
baby chance shaking 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 he don’t know he gonna eat coagulated blood with bugs one day
I have an idea! What if Garrett makes mini cakes that are whole so you can't see what's inside them??? 👀
Courtney slaying the Trader Joe shirt yass queen!!
Not Damien being a supportive boy by wanting to eat a bug leg with Chanse ❤️
"Can i just remind everyone, keith spit out a meatball?" Holy shit, damien 😂
We need an ALL bento box game
Hands on the table rule is the best rule. Keith always has his hand over the buzzer before they even start the countdown.
You should’ve have them all pick immediately and then just have a lunch table. Like trading or getting angry at their moms
Chanse is a national treasure. Proteccccccc.
"It looks like my tumor" Dang, Keith, that's some gallows humor there man...
The way Chanse went from a young man to an old lady over time is my favorite.
So are we just gonna ignore the fact that Olivia dipped Bananas AND A DONUT in MAYONNAISE
Wait i didnt even notice she did that 😅
I think this is the best laugh I've heard come put of Garret for the big bite 🤣 plus Chance's reaction? *Priceless*