He was out-competed by Peregrin Took, because Gandalf needed a chaotic random generator that could confuse the plans of Lord Evil, by doing exactly the wrong thing at the wrong moment.
This is the main problem when authors/directors etc make a character too powerful; it either takes all the suspense out of the story, or it requires an arms race escalation of power to ad absurdum. The latter is what makes the whole Marvel universe so stupid; once you create a character or Macguffin along the lines of the Infinity Gauntlet, stupid writing and Deus Ex Machina becomes required to resolve the story. Tolkein saw that problem and deftly avoided it by just not having Superman-Elf along for the quest.
@@cameronlamb1869 i guess so, but Galadriel, easily one of the most powerful characters in the universe at the time, was able to resist within the space of just a conversation. Gandalf wasn't even tempted, nor Elrond, Aragorn, nor even lowly Faramir. Only Boromir the Jacka$$ was tempted. Glorfindel might have been though, we'll never know.
@@bobf5360 Boromir wasn't a jackass. He was a noble, valiant man that had a moment of weakness. He desperately wanted to protect his family and people from annihilation and the ring used that great desire of his to tempt him. He lived a valiant hero and died a valiant hero.
I love the fanarts of Glorfindel being rejected or refusing to join the Fellowship on the grounds that "He's good for killing Balrogs and what are the chances they'll run into one of those?" and then they find Durin's Bane and Gandalf makes an "aw shit!" face.
Down in the mines, the Troll and the Orcs all attack as normal, but when the Balrog comes out, it starts to roar and crack its whip, only to spot Glorfindel's aura, and go very still and quiet. It slowly drops its weapons, slowly raises its hands, and carefully begins to walk backward into the shadows. As the Orcs and goblins catch up, the Balrog tells the horde to, "Fly, you fools!" before disappearing from view.
I think I remember hearing somewhere that one of the video games has Glorfindel instead heading north during the War of the Ring to help the elves up that way. Which honestly makes sense --- Glorfindel can use his talents and status as a legendary hero to not only help defend his people, but also give Sauron another big shiny threat to focus on far away from the Fellowship.
That's very in line with what we see in the books. At every point, part of the goal was to draw attention away from the Ring's actual location. Gandalf being really flashy at and around Weathertop, him trying to _avoid_ being flashy atop Caradras, taking Pippin to Minas Tirith, and that frontal assault on the Black Gate come to mind.
This was my thought too for what he did after the Fellowship left. There were several other battles at the time that Frodo was getting to Mount Doom, and it makes sense that Glorfindel would have a role in the north.
I love that game. It managed to made up it's own campain without changing the lore unlike many games. It was really good, it made sense and it could exist in parallel with the original lore without problem.
Right!? Lmao, also, Gandalf, Glorfindel, Elrond and Aragorn alone would present a pretty damn powerful combo to stop, considering the ringwraiths want nothing to do with Glorfindel on his own, and Gandalf 1 v 5 'ed them at weathertop. Those 4 alone (not saying there wouldn't be others) would be a hell of a force to reckon with.
@@user-ci4gh7td7n The Wraiths are not Sauron only servants, just his most "thrustworthy" ones. Fighting the Nazguls far away from their master is one thing. Attacking them in the seat of power of Sauron would be another deal entirely.
This is the main problem when authors/directors etc make a character too powerful; it either takes all the suspense out of the story, or it requires an arms race escalation of power to ad absurdum. The latter is what makes the whole Marvel universe so stupid; once you create a character or Macguffin along the lines of the Infinity Gauntlet, stupid writing and Deus Ex Machina becomes required to resolve the story. Tolkein saw that problem and deftly avoided it by just not having Superman-Elf along for the quest.
@@bobf5360 But there is no superman elf. Neither Glorfindel or Fingolfin would have been able to storm Barad Dur and bring down Sauron. Yes, Fingolfin defied and wounded Morgoth but he still lost in the end.
@@laureate90Well, I mean. Glorfindel doesn't exactly eat the things for breakfast. On his own the result was roughly the same as Gandalf vs. the Balrog was: mutual destruction. If they took one on together, though, they'd likely come out definitively victorious.
I always thought Glorfindel was kept back as some sort of last reserve. Not to defeat Sauron, but to hold him/his forces back until the last of the elves could leave Middle Earth.
He was sent back to Middle Earth by the Valar to aid in the fight against Sauron. There were no real guidelines on what exactly that fight looked like. But his absence from the fellowship was because it was a stealth mission. But hard to remain hidden when you're being followed around by a being of literal angelic might 😂
Yeah. The Lord of the Rings is essentially a secret mission in the middle of a massive war - you wouldn't expect all the powerful warriors to be joining it. You'd expect a few powerful and knowledgable members to guide and protect the mission, and a few weaker ones to draw less attention.
That's a good and valid point. Even without the whole "this is a stealth mission" it's still a solid strategy, could've very well have been in the story. Like "If the mission fails we're fucked, better have SuperElf here as a backup plan".
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Sauron senses the ring. The Witch King: "Should we go retrieve it master?" Sauron: "Screw that ring, freaking Glorf is coming, get back into the gate. There's a higher chance we die from SuperElf here than someone wanting to destroy my ring."
Actually he would have only borked Gandalf xp, since we all know Gandalf stole everyone XP when he insisted on battling a balrog alone, and some time later he returns with a lot of loot and new spells, pretty sneaky guy this Gandalf but he doesn't fool me for a second.
@zeustechbr Gandalf i such a loot goblin. He even took Palantir for himself. I bet Gandalf would have taken the one ring too, if he was going for shadow build instead of light build.
It has also been suggested that Elrond intended the Fellowship as ambassadors of their races and messengers to the divided peoples of Middle Earth. This did indeed happen in the story. And that in particular the young Legolas and Gimli were chosen as the brightest and clearest representatives of their races. Glorfindel could not have developed a deep friendship with Gimli or some other, greater Dwarf Lord. He was about the past, not the future.
@@aldeayeah But Legolas and Gimli were more or less equals, peers, and could learn to respect each other on the same level. A Gimli-Glorfindel "bromance" would be like the Gimli-Galadriel "romance": extremely asymmetrical.
@@aldeayeah Legolas was primarily chosen because he is hastier and more impatient than other Elves, so he was able to communicate and relate better with the short lived races.
In this we also see the reason why Legolas was not likewise a liability and could indeed be the representative of the elves on the Fellowship, because he had never himself left Middle-earth in any sense. He would not have been "visible" in the way that Glorfindel was.
On a less lore-related note and more of a writing-process note, it's funny to think "Why wasn't Glorfindel part of the Fellowship when he was so powerful?" when you consider that, had Tolkien gone with the idea of including him in the Fellowship, then Glorfindel's power and significance likely wouldn't have become so great in the first place. In that event, the Glorfindel who fought the Balrog would likely have been his namesake at best. That Tolkien consciously chose to elevate Glorfindel's lore-significance after minimizing his plot-significance is an interesting point of discussion on its own.
Interesting point you have there. Asides from the obvious reason of semantics and feel of the overall structure of the story across all three books. I wonder what Tolkien’s personal reasons were. After all, feeling, being an important aspect of creativity.
He was always the character I was most disappointed in not being in the movie. Idk how it well if would have worked as it’s hard to argue with what we got. But I still missed him
Hot take, I think Tom bombadil should have been in the movie. Like I know his character didn't quite fit the theme of the movies but I think the movies would have been better if they made like a 4th and 5th movie so it could be more accurate to the books. I think peter Jackson made a masterpiece but I think it would have benefitted to have more time and less constraints. There's too many characters that deserved screen time that had to be dropped and that's sad to me because the books were awesome. Not flawless but I think they are an industry standard for fantasy and world building. I don't typically enjoy fantasy bc I always compare to LOTR, but I think the elder scrolls comes close to just how interesting fantasy can be
@@dimitrilitovsk2372That's not a hot take, as Bombadil is one of, if not the most named character people wanted to see in the films that was left out. Elijah Wood, on Marc Maron's WTF podcast, said it was by far the character that most people told him they wished was in the films. I love Tom Bombadil as a character, and it would've been great to see him in the movies. He wasn't really essential to the story/plot though, so I get why they chose to leave him out. I haven't heard Peter Jackson say anything about it, but since he was such a huge fan of LotR, I have to believe he would have loved to include him, if he was a more essential character.
@@dimitrilitovsk2372Elder Scrolls is great but it gets me every time i’m playing Skyrim or Oblivion and meet a friendly Orc. I just instantly want to fight them from all my years of loving LOTR. 😂
@@daytwaqua i only think Tom's character wouldn't work in the movies because he was a lot more whimsical, compared to the seriousness of the films in general, but you're right, many Tolkien fans wanted Tom. Idk, I feel like his character would be better in a TV series rather than a movie because they could have the tom bombadil episode and then people who don't like toms character wouldn't be stuck with him. Like I personally hate musicals but I imagine Tom would be singing half of the time he's on screen
On the screen, I really wish that someone will give Glorfindel some love! The race to the Fjord in the FOTR is one of my favorite scenes in the trilogy (a close second to Gandalf facing off the Balrog).
It wouldn't work well in the movies. In a book you're not really limited by screentime and can put in characters that are callbacks to other books, and it won't impact the story negatively too much. In a movie you have to be really efficient with your time. Putting in a super powerful character that only appears once for a moment and then disappears for the rest of the story would feel really out of place - a new plot thread (of which LotR has already an overwhelming abundance) that leads to no resolution in the end. While I love Glorfindel I have to admit using Arwen in his place makes much more sense in the movie narrative.
Basically, it was bad enough having Gandalf along. Add in Glorfindel and it would have been like a giant beacon to all of the baddies "Looky here!", especially to Sauron and Saruman. The Ring Wraiths certainly would have noticed and followed them everywhere (at a distance) until Sauron could surround them with an army. And as happened in the books, pretty much the only way Frodo could have gotten the ring to into Mordor and to Mt Doom was without any of the more powerful, and thus more noticeable members of the fellowship. Two hobbits and a wretch could (barely) pass notice, but even someone like Legolas would have got them caught.
This seems to have been considered from the start, too, since none of the Fellowship were charged with completing the journey alongside Frodo. Even before the Fellowship was forced apart, there were plans for, say, Aragorn and Boromir to split off from the group and go to Minas Tirith. It seems the group originally intended to wing it somewhat as far as who could actually cross Mordor's borders and who would break away to serve another purpose.
@@OneTrueNobody Didn't Boromir essentially say "I will accompany the Fellowship until the Falls, but after that I must return home"? I can't remember if that was pre-Moria or as they were sailing down the Anduin.
@@OneTrueNobody Boromir only joined, because they were more or less going the same way anyway, and it's a long and perilous road. (He also secretly wanted the ring for Gondor). But he had the obligation to go back to Minas Tirith and report to his Father. Aragorn had promised he's go to Minas Tirith with Boromir, thinking Gandalf would stay with Frodo. Gimli and Legolas asked to join, as it would be their first real adventure/quest or worth for them.(Both are considered very young for their race). Gimli was denied the quest of Erebor, so this was his chance. And it also ended up fitting that the ring be went to destruction, with represented of every free folk race of Middle Earth.(even if that was by, seemingly pure coincidence.) The idea that no oath was taken, was so that, no one must feel obligated to keep going, having no idea what else might happened on the way. (which did happen, when they split, the Trio had to choose between the Ringbearer and the quest, or Merry and Pippin. Had they taken an oath, they would have felt obligated to chase the Ring bearer, and leave Merry and Pip to their fate.
All of these decisions happened early enough during the writing process that Tolkien could have left out the fact that Glorfindel acted like a beacon. Probably the reason why Tolkien made the decision to leave him off the fellowship and instead use him as a device to get him to rivendell was because he would have made the whole journey that much easier. take out Legolas and add in Glorfindel... The Watcher in the Water can possibly be defeated, thus eliminating the necessity to only choose the mines of moria as a pathway. If they go through the mines Gandalf and Glorfindel together can probably either ward off or even defeat the balrog. Gandolf and Glorfindel probably would see the necessity to break the fellowship, with one of them accompanying frodo and sam, and the other off to fight the great wars of rohan and gondor. Or even if sam and frodo break off alone, the following conflicts probably aren't as dramatic. Saruman probably can't stand against the two of them, and maybe even denathor is excised much like Theoden. By writing in the idea that Glorfindel is essentially a giant torch that is visible to all evil doers you make the journey of frodo/fellowship more challenging and interesting. Otherwise having him around Glorfindel can essentially Dues ex machina any problem they come across.
I think there's another aspect as well, that Glorfindel in being so powerful was also proud of his power, and we all know how the One Ring responds to pride. Beings greater than him like Galadriel and Gandalf expressed desire for the ring, Galadriel referring to refusing it as a "trial," suggesting a real possibility of failure. In this sense, Glorfindel's power could well have been ruinous, because if he took the ring, not even Gandalf was likely to be able to reclaim it.
No. Glorfindel was completely impervious to the lure of the Ring. He was probably the most saintly creature in all of Middle-Earth. He had proven himself beyond all corruption, it is why he of all elves was sent back.
@@AllAhabNoMoby Is that totally confirmed? Given that Gandalf himself was not immune I wouldn't imagine it. If there's a direct source I'd be very interested.
I think it's worth mentioning that being impervious to the "lure" is not the same as being immune to the Ring itself. Many members of the Fellowship showed no inclination to seek the Ring (the notion that it would eventually corrupt them all is, as far as I remember, a movie-only invention). And a whole bunch of dwarves and elves had the Ring sitting in front of them for a while in Rivendell, and knew full well it would remain in Frodo's keeping there for a time afterward. So it's not exceptionally difficult to simply not lust after the Ring, to not be lured by it, when you know the danger of the thing and have not yet been directly touched by its magic. Glorfindel likely would have been impervious to that lure, just as Legolas and Gimli apparently were. The fact that he was powerful and proud of his power, even in a good-hearted sense, would have been dangerous if he, say, laid his hand on the Ring. But that applies to most of the Fellowship.
Tldr: Our boy is so powerful he literally emits a spiritual light that, while unseen to mortals, is a literal beacon to the enemy. That he cant turn off. "Oh wow, this super powerful elf is heading straight for us, i wonder what he is doing" He would simply give away Frodo's position.
A bigger question for me is why didn't he join the Gray Company when they went off to help Aragorn. Can you imagine how terrified Sauron would have been with the Heir of Elendil, Olorin, and Glorfindel riding around the black gates?
The elves kind of didn't care. Remember, they can all just leave. There's the risk of death if they stay and fight, and literally no consequence to most of them if they leave. Elrond is literally one of the few elves that even remotely gives a crap about middle earth. And even then, he was content to have the forming of the fellowship be his final contribution before he left. He wasn't intending to help further then that, except his daughter was in love with Aragorn, and so he reluctantly sent his gifts to Aragorn, but he didn't mobilise an army. He did just enough to help out, but entirely in a way that didn't risk any of his people's lives or take too much effort. The only elves that went with the Grey Company were Aragorn's old ranger buddies, Aragorn's good friends for decades. Obviously, they care about defending middle earth, they've spent years with Aragorn fighting off dangers that threaten the peaceful regions such as the Shire. But there's only 31 members, and not all of them are elves. Simply put, Glorfindel just doesn't care. He has no attachment to any men or dwarves. If the realm of Lotholorien was truly threatened by Saruman, then I'm sure he'd have ridden south to help the Elves escape. But he was content to just defend the elf realms and then return West. He certainly was never going to agree to go on a suicide mission that was based purely on the hope that Frodo might succeed at the 12th hour, with zero information on how close he was to achieving his goal. There is just no way Glorfindel would have ever been at the black gates. Yes, Glorfindel was sent back to help fight Sauron. But there's no rules or guidelines. Glorfindel can absolutely take that to mean "act as a last line of defence and help all the elves leave middle earth". By the time Lord of the Rings occurs, the elves have completely committed to sailing over the sea and leaving men to their fate. Elrond is considered kind of weird for caring about this conflict. When Glorfindel fought the first time around, it was for the survival of the elves and the entire world. But by the third age, the world is seperated and the elves can just bail. And they are completely happy for the most part to do so. So why didn't Glorfindel help more? Because he doesn't care. It's not his business and he doesn't care. His suggestions for the ring are give it to Tom Bombadil, some dude he basically knows nothing about, but figures why the hell not, or throw it in the ocean. Glorfindel doesn't care what happens to the ring, his options are give it some weirdo or throw it away. Why would he be eager to go on a mission to destroy it? If Glorfindel was asked by Frodo or Elrond, he probably would have agreed, but probably would have turned back by the time they reached Moria. The deal was only ever to go as far as any member personally wished, and I can't see him wanting to go into the mines, which he'd know as well as Gandalf were likely Goblin and Orc infested, with likelyhood of trolls and maybe worse. I imagine he'd think helping the fellowship reach Moria was service enough, and probably not want to risk a dangerous trek. Gandalf only wants to go through Moria because he knows they'll never be able to sneak through the gap of rohan now Sauruman is watching. Glorfindel or no, the fellowship could never fight an army of orcs by themselves. Gandalf and Glorfindel both know it's unlikely there's any dwarves left in Moria, and they both know there's been whispers of something more powerful then ordinary goblins and trolls. Gandalf takes the path as a last resort, the last option to save the mission, hoping his power combined with stealth and speed will let them scrape by. Glorfindel probably isn't going to be super excited to go into the death mines.
@@CharlesFreck You are right about a lot of things, but some things are inaccurate. Maybe the Elves did not care what happens to middle earth, because they all will eventually leave, but they had no need to raise armies and go fight Sauron. Sauron had enough power to assault them the whole time the fellowship was doing its thing. Lothlorien was assaulted 3 times and defeated, Rivendell was attacked, the Lonely Mountain was under siege, etc. The Grey Company that came to Aragorn's aid was all the Rangers (basically Aragorn's distant family) that could be gathered hastily, as well as only 2 elves, the sons of Elrond (Elladan and Elrohir), who desired to go to the great battle of the age. I assume not all the Rangers came because many were probably still out fighting and guarding the shire, bree, and other areas from Sauron's and Saruman's influence. As for why Glorfindel didn't go on the fellowship, it is true that he is very powerful. An easy thing for the Nazgul, the eye of sauron, saruman, and other great powers to track and find easily, since he cannot hide his spiritual power. People say he is a super elf, but he can still be killed. Maybe the Nazgul are afraid of him, but to orcs, trolls, evil humans, etc, he is just another elf warrior. Maybe Glorfindel can fight off the Nazgul, multiple lesser opponents, etc. But overwhelming numbers of basic troops that have no idea who he is can still eventually get in a lucky shot and he can still be killed. Being very powerful doesn't mean invulnerable, and he could still be killed by a rock, an arrow, a sword, etc. Very likely, he was used defensively and as a distraction, just like the attack on the black gate was meant to distract Sauron from the ring-bearer reaching mount doom.
Let's also remember one key great moment from Glorfindel: he's one of the responsible for saving the north (former Kingdom of Arnor) from destruction from the hands of the Witch-King of Angmar during the Third Age, so he basically saved The Shire, Bree, all these regions from felling to the dark side even before the events of LOTR
He didn't actually save Arthedain from being destroyed but he along with an army from Gondor made sure Angmar was wiped out so at least those areas that produced our Hobbit heroes would survive to do so.
As you say, Glofindal’s spirt was far too bright for the mission. Sauron expected Glorindal. I believe the orcs of Cirith Ungol thought Sam might be Glofindal because he was able to get past the watchers.
Here's another issue (or two) I can think of if Glorfindel had joined. Who would he have replaced? Most likely either Merry or Pippin as we already know there's no way Sam was going to leave Frodo's side. And then that would mean with two Humans, two Elves the Dwarves would demand two of their people to join, which might have seen Gloin go off on the mission. So we'd have 1 Wizard, Two Men, Two Elves, Two Dwarves, Two Hobbits in the fellowship, and probably Merry and Pippin sneaking off after them. That would certainly make the Balrog attack far more interesting. Could he and Gandalf take it down together? Would Gandalf still have fallen or would Glorfindel died a second time? And having Gimli and Gloin as a father son duo would make the scenes in Moria even more intense when they came upon certain graves. Could Gloin have gone crazy with grief and gone off at the Orcs and Goblins and Balrog himself before anyone could stop him? With all that said, given how Glorfindel would show up to the enemy due to his own great power, I do wonder if he was maybe used as a distraction to confuse Sauron by having him approach other strongholds while the Fellowship walked into Mordor.
Rob bud so pleased to see your channel explode!! every view is well deserved. long ago when you only had around 3k subs i did state audible needs to grab your talent for narrating, stil stand by it. keep on rocking bro, i got introduced to this world 26 years ago, and am still discovering decades later thanks to people like you.
Always a pleasure to watch Your videos and moreover to hear Your voice. I'm not a native English-speaker and in many other cases have some problems to understand every detail. So not in Yours. Your speak is so clear and well, that I really get everthing. Thanks a lot for that.
Early on, you describe Glorfindel's return to Middle-Earth in the Second Age. Right after that is a recap of his role at the Battle of Fornost, and a mention that the northern kingdom of Arnor falls as part of the outcome. This was confusing to me at first. I was associating "second age" and "battle" and trying to fit Glorfindel into the war in Eriador or the Last Alliance of Elves and Men, but that didn't compute. And with reason! The Battle of Fornost was in the Third Age (T.A. 1975) The confusion here was my own doing; happily, I got to browse more Middle-Earth history straightening myself out. Thanks for another wonderful video! :)
IIRC Tolkien contemplated having Glorfindel arrive before the Fall of Numenor, and he would have a large heroice role in the Last Alliance. Like so many things, it never got past the stage of vague notes.
It's not even just that Glorfindel was essentially, the brightest walking lighthouse, that would have been the main problem, it's also the obviousness of him being in such a group. Gandalf was bad enough, add in the military leader of Gondor, a prince of Mirkwood (or not since he wouldn't be needed), and a dwarf from under the mountain shortly after threatening them, and then Glorfindel, one of the most famous elves, who fought and killed 1 of Morgoths most powerful assets and then was given life again cuz he was so great of an elf? No that is wayyyy too much importance and suspicious diversity of enemies to not send a regiment to capture or destroy, when you already know that your ring is in Rivendell and Glorfindel and Gandalf are both there as well. Better to send Glorfindel to cause trouble for the enemy elsewhere and draw some of the heat.
Always felt that if the fellowship did have Glorfindel on their side. It would of been much more noticed by Sauron and his forces and he’d be much more of a liability than a asset. Since stealth was the better option then trying to force their way through Mordor. They just did not have the numbers and the costs and risks would be to great but most importantly they just didn’t have the time needed to muster a grand army since much of Gondor had already been infiltrated. Where glorfindel would of been an asset was marshaling the elven forces and assisting the Dúnedain and reaffirming alliances and providing a faint and distraction. Making himself look to be the most dangerous while giving the fellowship a way to remain unnoticed.
A major theme of the LOTR is that good benefits most when the least powerful among good people stand against the most powerful evil. Also, conversely, that using great power to do good is turned to ironic consequences by evil. Glorfindel + Gandalf might have been like bringing a nuke to a knife fight. The Powers figured out not to do that in the First Age, when their overzealous protection of the Elves came to be misinterpreted as contempt by Feanor's jealousy.
Well done, one of your best videos. And I would say the Weathertop scene was a highlight of the films. Bloody terrifying first time through on the big screen.
I think a case can also be made that Gandalf sensed the fate of the Fellowship depended on them all being tested and showing their own valour, he himself could not make the task easier for them by using more of his power than was absolutely necessary, so he would not have wanted to involve another being of great power as well.
No one in the book ever explicitly says that one of the main reasons Merry and Pippin were included in the Fellowship is because they act as decoy halflings distracting enemy forces.
@@knightrider585Maybe, but it was not the reason for their presence. Friendship, and the positive energy it can bring was a bigger reason. But I don't think they predicted they would have this much effect. At best they might have figured the 4 of them, could have snuck in Mordor, and pass the ring if one was to fall.(Hobbits are renown for their stealth). And if you want to bring in fate in, you could say they really wanted to go, because they were meant to shake the council of man in the south(Rohan and Gondor), and kind of wake them all up to fight against Sauron. (As well as wake up the forest, and disturb Saruman.) Everyone in the fellowship volunteered, and wanted to go, in the end. If Glorfindel went, he would have been the only one "appointed".
If they had such dark thoughts, they would not be so foolish to articulate them. But just to be sure, Gandalf blinked heavily when he brought up all the friendship talk to Elrond who had not caught up yet
There an even more disturbing necessity. Being that if Frodo had been killed - then they'd have a spare ring-bearers. A duty that Sam performed, after their encounter with Shelob.
I had never liked this explanation, but the way you explained it makes more sense. Before, I had only ever heard that "he would stand out because he's powerful". It makes a lot more sense when you explain that he stands out because he literally shines to those who can see the spirit world. However, I will still only accept this explanation if Gandalf is able to cover up his own shining light (because surely he would shine as well), while Glorfindel is unable to hide himself. On a lighter note, I've always thought it would be funny if Glorfindel went with them and fought the Balrog instead of Gandalf. As the Balrog falls, it grabs Glorfindel's hair and pulls him down with him, and Glorfindel yells, "Not agaaaaaaiiiinnnnn......"
It's established Maia can completely disguise themselves. Saruman and Sauron are both noted to do it, both spiritually and physically. Gandalf even remarks that Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli may have seen Saruman in the forest, and even Gandalf before he became the White probably could not have detected Saruman if he chose to be disguised. I think the best explanation though is that Glorfindel just doesn't care. When presented with what to do with the ring, his answers are either to give it to the weird dude who lives on the river that I've kind of heard about and Frodo says isn't effected by the ring, sounds legit to me, or throw it in the ocean and be done with it, whatever, who cares. If your options are give it to the first random dude that gets brought up or go and throw it away, then you probably aren't going to be super into the idea of a super dangerous mission to go and destroy it, when you've already shown you don't care about it. Glorfindel can just leave middle earth as can all the elves, and go over the sea, and Sauron will literally never be able to touch them. The elves have zero real consequences to leaving. Elrond only cares because he loves Rivendell and is probably the most sympathetic elf to men. And he's explicitly seen as a little weird for caring so much by the other elves, and all he does is organise travelling companions for Frodo and send Aragorn a couple gifts. And that's considered weirdly invested for an elf. Glorfindel absolutely just gives zero shits about the quest to destroy the ring.
It's not just Peter Jackson's LotR's where Glorfindel gets snubbed (just so that Liv Tyler gets more screen time from what I heard), but also in Ralph Bakshi's animated 1978 version too. In that one its Legolas who saves Frodo from the Black Riders.
*shrug* That's because in any medium that doesn't have a way to really benefit from the wider legendarium, Glorfindel would just seem like a there-and-gone minor side character. He only even manages to earn his significance in the novel by way of the written medium's luxurious ability to take its time dwelling on details of lore: even before The Silmarillion was actually published, The Lord of the Rings still had the benefit of being able to reference the lore Tolkien had worked out behind the scenes, and the time and page-space to make such references stick. Just the concept of elves in a general sense had already had a hundred times more build-up by the time Glorfindel arrived in the book, than it had in the film by the time Arwen or Legolas appeared in the Jackson or Bakshi adaptations. Arwen in the Peter Jackson film was literally the first introduction to elves in the theatrical release and practically still was in the extended edition, where all that appeared before her was a distant view of some passing migrants to the Grey Havens and a vague reference to them leaving Middle-earth. If The Lord of the Rings were re-imagined as a long-form streaming series, on the other hand, it might be more feasible to get Glorfindel in there for a nice two- or three-episode appearance.
Glorfindel showing up to help the siege of Minas Tirith along with Rohan would have been good. It would have made the march on the Black Gates even more of a diversion bc Sauron would have been all over seeing him marching. Also, it would have shown him doing something.
The real question is why they didn't send him south separately, he could have helped at many of the battles in the later books, especially Minus Tirith
You have a great point about how Glorfindel shined in the spectral real and would therefore attract attention. But can’t the same be said of Gandalf? The obvious answer is that a Mair had more power over how they take on physical form and was able to better conceal their true nature. But it does indicate that it is possible for a spiritual being to conceal their spiritual nature.
I remember hearing Tolkien actually stated he had originally thought of putting Glorifendel in the fellowship but realized he was too strong and could handle most anything that got thrown at the group so he decided not to.
Have you ever done a video about the dead marshes? Specifically in relation to the film version, that's the section I feel like I understand the least. I understand that it's a moment for Smeagol to help Frodo and prove he's trustworthy, but I don't understand why Frodo was compelled to fall into the water. Any deeper insight to that would be good.
I think he has but I’m not sure. However, Nerd of the Rings has a pretty in depth video on the subject (probably more than one) and he’s as thorough as In Deep Geek, so that might be helpful
0:05 Party would of been too OP, Elrond nerfed the group. (Genuinely though I love how utterly impressive and powerful Glorfindel is, RAW. No ainur lineage, no ring of power, just a really friggin solid warrior. He's like the one punch man of middle earth)
While Sam is trying to get into the Tower of Cirith Ungol, he overhears the orcs talking amongst each other, saying that they think that some great elvish warrior has penetrated their defenses, noting that the war isn't going well, and that even the Witch King was killed. To these orcs, a hobbit skulking around with elvish weapons (such as Sting and the Phial of Galadriel), was enough to set the whole garrison into a panic.
I think it was primarily because he did not volunteer in the book. Maybe Tolkien thought he was too OP. But even still, glorfindel saved frodo at the bridge
He did not shine until he returned as the White. He was very good at remaining secretive, People knew he came and went, but nobody knew all he did. As for Saruman, that's a movie only thing. In the book, it's the mountain itself beating the fellowship. (Or possibly a Maiar of the mountain, like the ones in the sea causing havoc on ships.)
Error at 7:44 "when Frodo put the ring on he was visible to the enemy, shining like a beacon." Your other video said this was true only when he was sitting on that magic seeing char.
The ring preys off weakness, whispering lies and promises of power. I don't think he would succumb too it , he'd probably be less tempted than Gladriel
@@lomiification Yes. Firstborn in this case refers to the Elves as they were the firstborn of the Children of Iluvatar. Galadriel was not of the very 1st generation of Elves; she was the daughter of Finarfin and Eärwen, a Teleri princess.
Makes me wonder how Gandalf is viewed in the spiritual world, cause although he is reduced his presence or appearance he would still be very powerful and different from most others as a Maia and I believe fairly noticeable. Or did the Valar give him a spiritual disguise along with a physical one?
I always got the impression that Gandalf limited himself internalizing his power, perhaps earning the designation "The Gray" as he was likely unnoticed compared to the others of his order in the spirit realm. This attitude that turned out to be a wise council for the Fellowship, was actually Gandalf's MO in all things: Go unnoticed, move behind the scenes. When he became "The White" it was "weapons hot" and nothing about his attitude resembled his former furtiveness but speed and action in all things. MHO
Hee hee like the fan-fic/HISHE version in which Gandalf saying "Fly you fools" was meant literally, as in "Take the eagles over Mt. Doom and just drop it in!'
3:02 Indeed we do: with Merry striking the killing blow from an enchanted Elvish blade, and Eowyn stabbing him with would ever harm the Witch King, yet getting all the credit.
Tolkien clearly enjoyed writing epic figures like Glorfindel, but at the end of the day, the stories that were most important to him weren't about them. They were about the goodness and resilience of ordinary people, about battles that might be won through decency, but never through strength of arms. It's part of what makes him so important, as an author.
I like the story progression aspect of this, it fits in very well into the world and the themes of the story. i think that it was smart to replace Glorfindel in the movies because the amount of nunace and explanation his character requires wouldn't have clicked for a large part of the audience and much like the eagles question, we'd have the glorfindel questions running around about it being a supposed plothole
In the Middle Earth Strategy Battle Game, there's rules for having a Fantasy Fellowship - with a few caveat rules. I really considered doing a "The Elves do it themselves" Fellowship. Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin as normal. Aragorn is replaced with Glorfindel Gandalf is replaced by Elrond Legolas and Gimli become Elladan and Elrohir And Boromir is swapped for Erestor
@@slMagnvox Because of how the rules work "Gandalf" has to be a Spellcaster, so that means Elrond has to be in it, Glorfindel just fits as Aragorn's replacement. Now, "Boromir" will always die at Amon Hen. So with Legolas, Elladan and Elrohir, you are always going to lose Legolas, or one of the Twins. Just feels better to keep it as an all Rivendell elf force.
I have a question. What if smaug got the one ring? Like its stated that the ring changes sizes when it comes to a new weilder, so would it grow to fit his finger/talon? Or i prefer this one, would it grow to be a perfect bracelet on the dragon? Then would smaug be on saurons team? Idk RIP Tolkien, i wish i was alive when he was so i could send him a letter. Yes his family is still around but i feel like they didn't understand his story as well as they think. They do understand his story more intimately then the layman but i dont think his family can accurately understand tolkiens work to its full potential
I think Tolkien knew what would happen if the dragons were not eliminated. At the end of Return of the King - Quote - 'Yet things might have gone far otherwise and far worse. When you think of the great Battle of the Pelennor, do not forget the battles in Dale and the valour of Durin's Folk. Think of what might have been. Dragon-fire and savage swords in Eriador, night in Rivendell. There might be no Queen in Gondor. We might now hope to return from the victory here only to ruin and ash. But that has been averted - because I met Thorin Oakenshield one evening on the edge of spring in Bree. A chance-meeting, as we say in Middle-earth.'
Given the nature of dragons, I think Smaug would have simply added the Ring to his horde, even if he recognised it for what it was. It would be more important to him to possess it than to wield it. We know certain beings are more resistant to the Ring's powers of domination and I have to believe dragons would be at the top of that list. Smaug, was immensely powerful, proud and evil but wasn't at all ambitious the way Sauron was. Gollum, at the other end of that spectrum, while dominated by the Ring, actually only wanted it for the same reasons though; just to have it, not use it. So that's kind of interesting.
@@jetsilveravenger i honestly love that analysis, and it's probably what Tolkien would have said. Smaug did have ambition but it was mainly more gold, and a spiteful nature towards the dwarves
@@jetsilveravenger Smaug having it might've even been a bad thing for Sauron. Smaug would've taken it for the sake of having it and might've even placed it alongside the Arkenstone in his hoard. Considering how he reacted when a mere goblet was taken, I shudder to think how he'd have reacted if _anyone_ had tried to take something so Precious from him, even by trade.
As usual, this is a great video with excellent analysis in depth about LOTR :). I agree, I think Glorfindel was powerful but was too prominent to be unnoticed by Sauron.
I was there at Rivendell. He stared at the Fellowship and went right down the list "Loser, shorter loser, crappy sword, spider-bait, uruk-bait...". He paused a bit on Gimli. "Alright, you're cool.". Then he looked at Gandalf. "Mithrandir, you better get your sh!+ together, because this elf has personal experience with the sandwich you're about to eat". Then he sat down.
Outstanding video. There are times when I wish Tolkien's writings were more modern, more tightly outlined. A minor subplot with Glorfindel being used as a decoy would be fascinating. Similar to how Patton was stationed at Calais prior to the Normandy invasion.
@Customerbuilder no trouble. I just had so much conversation with Lane i almost feel I was there. He was always clear and almost ashamed he didn't get there for the "real" fighting.
Really excellent lecture. As the local Middle Earth nerd, people who know of Glorfindel as one who can smite a balrog ask why he wasn't included. First I tell them what Gandalf said at the choosing of the fellowship. Then I, too point out the aspect of the separation of the Spirit World and the Physical world. For mere mortals, he is beautiful and radiates wisdom and confidence. But those that can see the Spirit would would see him shining brightly and not be able to veil it. But I do play around in my head with the thoughts of, what if it were Glorfindel for the Elves and Faramir instead of Boromir for the Men. It would be a very different story, though. Gandalf and Glorfindel could face the Balrog of Moria and very likely both survive and walk away. I feel that if Faramir was at the Council of Elrond, he would already have deep respect for Gandalf. Elrond was one of the wisest beings and Faramir had positive feelings toward the Elves. And he would have even more respect for Aragorn. For Faramir, unlike his father, would see the King that could return and that Hope - Estel - was right in front of him. His nature is calm, thoughtful and protective. He would befriend the hobbits and look out for them. I think he would lead them into Mordor safely. I quite believe that even with long time exposure to the Ring, he could resist it. He was wiser, more thoughtful, he would see that the Ring was a peril to stay away from. Boromir had many weaknesses that Faramir did not. Boromir was losing Hope. He was beginning to feel more of his fears of Mordor. The Lure of the Ring was pulling too hard on him. Finally, his nature too much wanted Glory and to be the one that brought it, and did so through force of arms. But then all else goes awry. There is no friendly elf equal to and kidding with Gimli, a lone dwarf with no special friendship forming. The fellowship would not have split up and Pippin & Merry would never affect the Ents nor Rohan. The Ents would likely not rallied in time. Théoden would still be under Grima's enchantment and Saruman would bring devastating war on Rohan. Faramir and Aragorn would also be stuck with a very difficult choice: Take the Hobbits to Mordor or take everyone to Minas Tirith. So, making the Fellowship more powerful, would have likely led to the loss of the West. Gandalf never becomes The White. After destroying much of Fanghorn forest, Saruman would also raze Rowan and come on Gondor from the West. Where would the Ring Go? Would it matter anymore?
I would expect Gandalf to be more powerful than an elf. Why wasn't he too powerful? I know he got separated after the Balrog, but that wasn't the plan.
Gandalf had no permanent home and was known for wandering all over the place. His leaving Rivendell would not be all that remarkable. Plus the disguise he had to take as one of the Istari made him less conspicuous. Glorfindel on the other hand had been first in Lindon and later in Rivendell for a very long time. His leaving to go south would have been noticed.
With just one super strong guy, sauron could guess he'd taken control over the ring With two, they'd have to be fighting each other for the ring It's a very important plot point that sauron thinks gandalf has fallen and is using aragorn as a puppet, the same as what happened to saruman
Good vid. The Fellowship was a stealth mission and Glorfindel was one of the two loudest dudes on ME along with Sauron. Same reason why Elrond and Galadriel didn't join.
Probably, but that wasn't the version of Gandalf that had planned to go to Mordor with Frodo and Sam, that was the old Gandalf the Grey. Olorin the Maiar was not noted for being super-powerful in a physical sense, other than being a Maia to begin with.
I think Tolkien himself realised the inherent plot weakness of not including Glorfindel in the Fellowship and put in Gandalf's somewhat contrived justification to pre-empt his critics. After the scattering of the Nazgul at the ford the Fellowship hoped to get to Caradhras in relative secrecy then down the Dimrill Stair and into Lothlorien. Galadriel's power here would cloak Glorfindel from evil eyes so he could get as far as the river Anduin without being spotted. At this point he could have accompanied Boromir and Aragorn to Minas Tirith creating a huge distraction away from Frodo and Sam.
Hmmm. With him there, they would have beaten the Balrog more easily, without losing Gandalf. (And hopefully Glorfindel would've survived this time, and not had to be respawned there). Then once they got to the River, Gandalf would've gone with Frodo and Sam.... Interesting new turn.
Great video and analysis as always. It would have still been pretty cool to see Glorfindel in the films, but I can understand why Jackson went with Arwen.
What makes your channel great Robert is your appreciation of the softer themes of the story. That it is not a fascist tale of conquering heroes but of little people becoming great. Tolkien rejected allegory but having Aaragorn, the uberman of ubermen kneel to Frodo and Sam has to be a comment on the Nazi worldview.
It is true that Glorfindel's power wasn't needed, but having the wisdom of a 1st Age Elf in the fellowship may have been important, and certainly having a Balrog killer would have come in very handy in Moria, so despite what Tolkien might have said, there are reasons why Glorfiendel would have been a good choice. What I think is much more likely is that Tolkien already had the character of Gandalf the White in mind which means Gandalf had to fight the Balrog, and that he wanted Aragorn to be the leader of the Fellowship in the first book which when placed together, really doesn't leave a lot of room for Glorfidenel.
People have a lot of trouble with the powerful yet 'inactive' characters in Middle Earth. Glorfindel, Tom Bombadil, the Eagles, the absent wizards etc. We see they are largely left out of the movies or replaced. But part of Tolkien's worlds is that there are many layers of importance, or fate and duty, unseen and unknown deep purposes and powers. Elrond recognises that this journey of the ring is in large part Gandalf's ultimate act, it is his story (in the mythic sense). A massive part of the power of elves (magic) is to understand these grand, deep, hidden narratives. The power of 'magic' is chiefly the power of story, and understanding the story of the world. Understanding God's song.
Also, the temptation of the Ring was ever present. As Gandalf said, the more powerful you are, the greater the temptation. By putting the Ring in close proximity to Glorfindel for a significant period of time would increase the risk of temptation. One of the reasons why the Ring was never a temptation to most of the Fellowship was their relatively less powerful nature. Admittedly, Gandalf and Aragorn were powerful spiritually, but the rest were less so. At best, Legolas, being an elf, had some spiritual power, but as a Sindar Elf who never made it to the Blessed Lands and was possibly born in the 2nd or 3rd Age, his spiritual power would have been much lower than ones like Glorfindel or Galadriel. Even then, the constant threat of temptation was high. Boromir, who was part Numenorean and, possibly, part-Elven through his mother, who was a Princess of Dol Amroth, fell to the temptation. Bluntly, who could have stopped Glorfindel if he decided to take the Ring for himself?
Given all this it seems that Glorfindel would have come in most handy when Aragorn marched on the Black Gate. Granted, everything worked out as is, but imagine how scary would it have been if not only could he assume Aragorn had taken up the ring, but that Glorfindel had taken it up and was marching towards him with an army.
That is exactly what I "guessed" when I saw your video title here. You say they could sense him from a mile away -- I would bet that Sauron could sense Glorfindel's presence from further away than that at least in many circumstances. Kind of like traveling with a sign that flashes "here we are" in neon in the unseen world.
Just picture Glorfindel and Gandalf riding on giant eagles with Frodo carrying the ring to mount doom ^^ I mean Saurons airforce are mostly the Nazgul and they wouldnt fare too well against those two.
Lol no. If Glofindel is that powerful to easily beat everything Sauron throws at him and easily finish the mission, why the fuck do you think Sauron is still a huge enemy that everyone is afraid of ?? Because Glofindel is nowhere near strong enough to contest against Sauron, and the strongest member of the Fellowship is always Gandalf no matter if Glofindel is in it or not, but him being in it only makes it worse
Having Glorfindel in The Fellowship would be akin to having a powerful beam of light stretching up towards the sky screaming "Hey everyone! We're RIGHT HERE!!" ever step of the way. Sure the enemies would've been very wary of Glorfindel's powerful aura, but likewise, he's basically a walking magnet pointing everyone good or bad right where he is. Sure he'd be a huge asset in a fight, but then he'd mop the floor of basically everything leaving none of the other members of The Fellowship a reason to be in it, and from a storytelling point, it'd wouldn't be very interesting to read, as well as leaving everyone with nothing to do, no chance for developing those characters. His best usage might've been as a misdirection decoy to draw the majority of the enemies AWAY from The Fellowship so they'd have a higher chance of success, much like near the end when Aragorn decided to pull a last ditch assault at The Black Gates to draw the armies of Mordor away to a single point in hopes that the missing Hobbits might slip through elsewhere.
I loved how in the Movie Mars with MattDamon that Project Elrond had the head of NASA say I want to be Glorfindel :)) He couldn't go..the creatures of Sauron would have seen his fea blazing like a sun at his coming.
He was out-competed by Peregrin Took, because Gandalf needed a chaotic random generator that could confuse the plans of Lord Evil, by doing exactly the wrong thing at the wrong moment.
This is the main problem when authors/directors etc make a character too powerful; it either takes all the suspense out of the story, or it requires an arms race escalation of power to ad absurdum. The latter is what makes the whole Marvel universe so stupid; once you create a character or Macguffin along the lines of the Infinity Gauntlet, stupid writing and Deus Ex Machina becomes required to resolve the story. Tolkein saw that problem and deftly avoided it by just not having Superman-Elf along for the quest.
@@bobf5360and the reason for him not going actually making sense and being perfectly reasonable.
The more powerful the character the more likely to fall to the ring. This makes balancing the universe easy
@@cameronlamb1869 i guess so, but Galadriel, easily one of the most powerful characters in the universe at the time, was able to resist within the space of just a conversation. Gandalf wasn't even tempted, nor Elrond, Aragorn, nor even lowly Faramir. Only Boromir the Jacka$$ was tempted. Glorfindel might have been though, we'll never know.
@@bobf5360 Boromir wasn't a jackass. He was a noble, valiant man that had a moment of weakness. He desperately wanted to protect his family and people from annihilation and the ring used that great desire of his to tempt him. He lived a valiant hero and died a valiant hero.
I love the fanarts of Glorfindel being rejected or refusing to join the Fellowship on the grounds that "He's good for killing Balrogs and what are the chances they'll run into one of those?" and then they find Durin's Bane and Gandalf makes an "aw shit!" face.
Do you happen to have a link to one?
it's better to have a Glorfindel and not need him, than need one and not have him.
@@lliamreusser4534yes please 😅
Lets be real, having a high level NPC in your party just takes away all the xp you could get :p @@exploreseafaring
lmaoooo, love that
Down in the mines, the Troll and the Orcs all attack as normal, but when the Balrog comes out, it starts to roar and crack its whip, only to spot Glorfindel's aura, and go very still and quiet. It slowly drops its weapons, slowly raises its hands, and carefully begins to walk backward into the shadows. As the Orcs and goblins catch up, the Balrog tells the horde to, "Fly, you fools!" before disappearing from view.
In broad New Zealand accent "aw jeez not this cant again"
lmaoo
I think I remember hearing somewhere that one of the video games has Glorfindel instead heading north during the War of the Ring to help the elves up that way. Which honestly makes sense --- Glorfindel can use his talents and status as a legendary hero to not only help defend his people, but also give Sauron another big shiny threat to focus on far away from the Fellowship.
Battle for Middle Earth II had that.
That's very in line with what we see in the books. At every point, part of the goal was to draw attention away from the Ring's actual location. Gandalf being really flashy at and around Weathertop, him trying to _avoid_ being flashy atop Caradras, taking Pippin to Minas Tirith, and that frontal assault on the Black Gate come to mind.
This was my thought too for what he did after the Fellowship left. There were several other battles at the time that Frodo was getting to Mount Doom, and it makes sense that Glorfindel would have a role in the north.
I love that game. It managed to made up it's own campain without changing the lore unlike many games. It was really good, it made sense and it could exist in parallel with the original lore without problem.
@efaristi9737 It's also Bonkers to me that the expansion is somehow to most faithful adaptation of the Fall of Arnor ever published.
"He could not single handedly fight his way to Mt Doom."
Fingolfin - "Hold my beer."
Right!? Lmao, also, Gandalf, Glorfindel, Elrond and Aragorn alone would present a pretty damn powerful combo to stop, considering the ringwraiths want nothing to do with Glorfindel on his own, and Gandalf 1 v 5 'ed them at weathertop. Those 4 alone (not saying there wouldn't be others) would be a hell of a force to reckon with.
And thus Fingolfin died.
@@user-ci4gh7td7n The Wraiths are not Sauron only servants, just his most "thrustworthy" ones. Fighting the Nazguls far away from their master is one thing. Attacking them in the seat of power of Sauron would be another deal entirely.
This is the main problem when authors/directors etc make a character too powerful; it either takes all the suspense out of the story, or it requires an arms race escalation of power to ad absurdum. The latter is what makes the whole Marvel universe so stupid; once you create a character or Macguffin along the lines of the Infinity Gauntlet, stupid writing and Deus Ex Machina becomes required to resolve the story. Tolkein saw that problem and deftly avoided it by just not having Superman-Elf along for the quest.
@@bobf5360 But there is no superman elf. Neither Glorfindel or Fingolfin would have been able to storm Barad Dur and bring down Sauron.
Yes, Fingolfin defied and wounded Morgoth but he still lost in the end.
I love how Nazgûl always flee just by the presence of Glorfindel.
That tag team match between Glorfindel and Gandalf against the Balrog would have been hype though.
Glorf would've been like, b**** please, I been killing Balrogs since you were a twinkle in Iluvatar's eye.
@@laureate90Well, I mean. Glorfindel doesn't exactly eat the things for breakfast. On his own the result was roughly the same as Gandalf vs. the Balrog was: mutual destruction. If they took one on together, though, they'd likely come out definitively victorious.
@@OneTrueNobodyGandalf would cast *haste* on Glorfindel, who would smite Durin's Bane back into the abyss!
Glorfindel at least wouldn't have wailed like a Hobbit lass and wet himself like SOME elves I could mention.
@@TJDious And some dwarves we could mention, if we're being totally fair there.
I always thought Glorfindel was kept back as some sort of last reserve. Not to defeat Sauron, but to hold him/his forces back until the last of the elves could leave Middle Earth.
He was sent back to Middle Earth by the Valar to aid in the fight against Sauron. There were no real guidelines on what exactly that fight looked like.
But his absence from the fellowship was because it was a stealth mission. But hard to remain hidden when you're being followed around by a being of literal angelic might 😂
@@BM-wf9ufBut Glorfindel could not hide his powerful presence, unlike Gandalf.
It was something that radiated from him as described in the books.
Yeah. The Lord of the Rings is essentially a secret mission in the middle of a massive war - you wouldn't expect all the powerful warriors to be joining it. You'd expect a few powerful and knowledgable members to guide and protect the mission, and a few weaker ones to draw less attention.
@@BM-wf9uf It would've been awesome if Glorfindel travelled south with Elrond's sons and the Grey Company to fight in the Battle at Pelennor Fields
That's a good and valid point. Even without the whole "this is a stealth mission" it's still a solid strategy, could've very well have been in the story. Like "If the mission fails we're fucked, better have SuperElf here as a backup plan".
I wonder if the council had ever thought of letting Glorfindel run in the opposite direction to confuse Sauron.
I think there are hints that he kinda did that, fighting in some of the battles that happened during the war of the ring.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Sauron senses the ring. The Witch King: "Should we go retrieve it master?" Sauron: "Screw that ring, freaking Glorf is coming, get back into the gate. There's a higher chance we die from SuperElf here than someone wanting to destroy my ring."
Moria had a level cap of 20. Glorifindel would have borked everybody’s xp.
basically like taking a level 80 into BRD
I hate that this makes perfect sense to me.
Actually he would have only borked Gandalf xp, since we all know Gandalf stole everyone XP when he insisted on battling a balrog alone, and some time later he returns with a lot of loot and new spells, pretty sneaky guy this Gandalf but he doesn't fool me for a second.
@zeustechbr
Gandalf i such a loot goblin. He even took Palantir for himself. I bet Gandalf would have taken the one ring too, if he was going for shadow build instead of light build.
@@sunnuntaiselori1927 also lets remember that gandalf threw a fit when Pippin stole his Palantir. Loot goblin indeed
It has also been suggested that Elrond intended the Fellowship as ambassadors of their races and messengers to the divided peoples of Middle Earth. This did indeed happen in the story. And that in particular the young Legolas and Gimli were chosen as the brightest and clearest representatives of their races. Glorfindel could not have developed a deep friendship with Gimli or some other, greater Dwarf Lord. He was about the past, not the future.
Glorfindel also would NOT have become fast friends with Gimli. that point also should not be overlooked.
As someone descending from the Doriath Sindar, Legolas would be more prejudiced against dwarves than a Gondolin Noldor such as Glorfindel.
@@aldeayeah But Legolas and Gimli were more or less equals, peers, and could learn to respect each other on the same level. A Gimli-Glorfindel "bromance" would be like the Gimli-Galadriel "romance": extremely asymmetrical.
@@aldeayeah Legolas was primarily chosen because he is hastier and more impatient than other Elves, so he was able to communicate and relate better with the short lived races.
@@gregoryl.levitre9759 Ah, the ol' Spock problem. The humans see him as uptight and stiff. The Vulcans see him as an emotional madman.
In this we also see the reason why Legolas was not likewise a liability and could indeed be the representative of the elves on the Fellowship, because he had never himself left Middle-earth in any sense. He would not have been "visible" in the way that Glorfindel was.
On a less lore-related note and more of a writing-process note, it's funny to think "Why wasn't Glorfindel part of the Fellowship when he was so powerful?" when you consider that, had Tolkien gone with the idea of including him in the Fellowship, then Glorfindel's power and significance likely wouldn't have become so great in the first place. In that event, the Glorfindel who fought the Balrog would likely have been his namesake at best. That Tolkien consciously chose to elevate Glorfindel's lore-significance after minimizing his plot-significance is an interesting point of discussion on its own.
Interesting point you have there. Asides from the obvious reason of semantics and feel of the overall structure of the story across all three books. I wonder what Tolkien’s personal reasons were. After all, feeling, being an important aspect of creativity.
He was always the character I was most disappointed in not being in the movie. Idk how it well if would have worked as it’s hard to argue with what we got. But I still missed him
Hot take, I think Tom bombadil should have been in the movie. Like I know his character didn't quite fit the theme of the movies but I think the movies would have been better if they made like a 4th and 5th movie so it could be more accurate to the books. I think peter Jackson made a masterpiece but I think it would have benefitted to have more time and less constraints. There's too many characters that deserved screen time that had to be dropped and that's sad to me because the books were awesome. Not flawless but I think they are an industry standard for fantasy and world building. I don't typically enjoy fantasy bc I always compare to LOTR, but I think the elder scrolls comes close to just how interesting fantasy can be
@@dimitrilitovsk2372That's not a hot take, as Bombadil is one of, if not the most named character people wanted to see in the films that was left out. Elijah Wood, on Marc Maron's WTF podcast, said it was by far the character that most people told him they wished was in the films. I love Tom Bombadil as a character, and it would've been great to see him in the movies. He wasn't really essential to the story/plot though, so I get why they chose to leave him out. I haven't heard Peter Jackson say anything about it, but since he was such a huge fan of LotR, I have to believe he would have loved to include him, if he was a more essential character.
@@dimitrilitovsk2372Elder Scrolls is great but it gets me every time i’m playing Skyrim or Oblivion and meet a friendly Orc. I just instantly want to fight them from all my years of loving LOTR. 😂
I missed him a lot also Tom Bombadil
@@daytwaqua i only think Tom's character wouldn't work in the movies because he was a lot more whimsical, compared to the seriousness of the films in general, but you're right, many Tolkien fans wanted Tom. Idk, I feel like his character would be better in a TV series rather than a movie because they could have the tom bombadil episode and then people who don't like toms character wouldn't be stuck with him. Like I personally hate musicals but I imagine Tom would be singing half of the time he's on screen
Because one does not simply Glorf into Mordor.
I've always wondered what that sign by the Black Gate meant. 'No Glorfing'
@@malcolmt7883 😂
@@malcolmt7883 The Glorf zone is only or glorfin' and unglorfin'!
I love his famous catchphrase "It's Glorfin' time!"
@@RyPolecatand then he Glorfed all over the place?
On the screen, I really wish that someone will give Glorfindel some love! The race to the Fjord in the FOTR is one of my favorite scenes in the trilogy (a close second to Gandalf facing off the Balrog).
It wouldn't work well in the movies. In a book you're not really limited by screentime and can put in characters that are callbacks to other books, and it won't impact the story negatively too much. In a movie you have to be really efficient with your time. Putting in a super powerful character that only appears once for a moment and then disappears for the rest of the story would feel really out of place - a new plot thread (of which LotR has already an overwhelming abundance) that leads to no resolution in the end. While I love Glorfindel I have to admit using Arwen in his place makes much more sense in the movie narrative.
I was so sad to lose that moment in the movie.
I can never learn too much about Glorfindel. Many thanks for digging deeper into his character!
Basically, it was bad enough having Gandalf along. Add in Glorfindel and it would have been like a giant beacon to all of the baddies "Looky here!", especially to Sauron and Saruman. The Ring Wraiths certainly would have noticed and followed them everywhere (at a distance) until Sauron could surround them with an army. And as happened in the books, pretty much the only way Frodo could have gotten the ring to into Mordor and to Mt Doom was without any of the more powerful, and thus more noticeable members of the fellowship. Two hobbits and a wretch could (barely) pass notice, but even someone like Legolas would have got them caught.
This seems to have been considered from the start, too, since none of the Fellowship were charged with completing the journey alongside Frodo. Even before the Fellowship was forced apart, there were plans for, say, Aragorn and Boromir to split off from the group and go to Minas Tirith. It seems the group originally intended to wing it somewhat as far as who could actually cross Mordor's borders and who would break away to serve another purpose.
@@OneTrueNobody Didn't Boromir essentially say "I will accompany the Fellowship until the Falls, but after that I must return home"? I can't remember if that was pre-Moria or as they were sailing down the Anduin.
Yes, and I have the impression that Gandalf's original plan was for only him (or maybe with Gimli) to actually go all the way to Mordor.
@@OneTrueNobody Boromir only joined, because they were more or less going the same way anyway, and it's a long and perilous road. (He also secretly wanted the ring for Gondor). But he had the obligation to go back to Minas Tirith and report to his Father.
Aragorn had promised he's go to Minas Tirith with Boromir, thinking Gandalf would stay with Frodo.
Gimli and Legolas asked to join, as it would be their first real adventure/quest or worth for them.(Both are considered very young for their race). Gimli was denied the quest of Erebor, so this was his chance. And it also ended up fitting that the ring be went to destruction, with represented of every free folk race of Middle Earth.(even if that was by, seemingly pure coincidence.)
The idea that no oath was taken, was so that, no one must feel obligated to keep going, having no idea what else might happened on the way. (which did happen, when they split, the Trio had to choose between the Ringbearer and the quest, or Merry and Pippin. Had they taken an oath, they would have felt obligated to chase the Ring bearer, and leave Merry and Pip to their fate.
All of these decisions happened early enough during the writing process that Tolkien could have left out the fact that Glorfindel acted like a beacon. Probably the reason why Tolkien made the decision to leave him off the fellowship and instead use him as a device to get him to rivendell was because he would have made the whole journey that much easier.
take out Legolas and add in Glorfindel... The Watcher in the Water can possibly be defeated, thus eliminating the necessity to only choose the mines of moria as a pathway. If they go through the mines Gandalf and Glorfindel together can probably either ward off or even defeat the balrog. Gandolf and Glorfindel probably would see the necessity to break the fellowship, with one of them accompanying frodo and sam, and the other off to fight the great wars of rohan and gondor. Or even if sam and frodo break off alone, the following conflicts probably aren't as dramatic. Saruman probably can't stand against the two of them, and maybe even denathor is excised much like Theoden.
By writing in the idea that Glorfindel is essentially a giant torch that is visible to all evil doers you make the journey of frodo/fellowship more challenging and interesting. Otherwise having him around Glorfindel can essentially Dues ex machina any problem they come across.
I think there's another aspect as well, that Glorfindel in being so powerful was also proud of his power, and we all know how the One Ring responds to pride. Beings greater than him like Galadriel and Gandalf expressed desire for the ring, Galadriel referring to refusing it as a "trial," suggesting a real possibility of failure. In this sense, Glorfindel's power could well have been ruinous, because if he took the ring, not even Gandalf was likely to be able to reclaim it.
No. Glorfindel was completely impervious to the lure of the Ring. He was probably the most saintly creature in all of Middle-Earth. He had proven himself beyond all corruption, it is why he of all elves was sent back.
@@AllAhabNoMoby Is that totally confirmed? Given that Gandalf himself was not immune I wouldn't imagine it. If there's a direct source I'd be very interested.
@@ItsmeInternetStranger The fact that he's the only one ever sent back settles it for me.
I think it's worth mentioning that being impervious to the "lure" is not the same as being immune to the Ring itself. Many members of the Fellowship showed no inclination to seek the Ring (the notion that it would eventually corrupt them all is, as far as I remember, a movie-only invention). And a whole bunch of dwarves and elves had the Ring sitting in front of them for a while in Rivendell, and knew full well it would remain in Frodo's keeping there for a time afterward.
So it's not exceptionally difficult to simply not lust after the Ring, to not be lured by it, when you know the danger of the thing and have not yet been directly touched by its magic. Glorfindel likely would have been impervious to that lure, just as Legolas and Gimli apparently were.
The fact that he was powerful and proud of his power, even in a good-hearted sense, would have been dangerous if he, say, laid his hand on the Ring. But that applies to most of the Fellowship.
@@OneTrueNobody I don't remember Glorfindel ever showing pride. I know OP said he did but he neglected to say where or when.
This was a wonderful explanation and the most satisfying I've heard for why the mighty Glorfindel did not join the Fellowship. Thank you.
Tldr:
Our boy is so powerful he literally emits a spiritual light that, while unseen to mortals, is a literal beacon to the enemy. That he cant turn off.
"Oh wow, this super powerful elf is heading straight for us, i wonder what he is doing"
He would simply give away Frodo's position.
His light was only revealed in wrath, her was a normal Elf until then as viewed by the Nazgul.
I’ve wondered this very question, since I first read LotR, back when I was a kid. Thank you for answering it.
A bigger question for me is why didn't he join the Gray Company when they went off to help Aragorn. Can you imagine how terrified Sauron would have been with the Heir of Elendil, Olorin, and Glorfindel riding around the black gates?
We are not told but I imagine he was heavily involved in the fighting in the north.
There were a bunch of battles being fought around Middle Earth at the same time and I betcha Glorfindel was kicking ass in some of them.
Would have been hype ASF tho
The elves kind of didn't care. Remember, they can all just leave. There's the risk of death if they stay and fight, and literally no consequence to most of them if they leave. Elrond is literally one of the few elves that even remotely gives a crap about middle earth. And even then, he was content to have the forming of the fellowship be his final contribution before he left. He wasn't intending to help further then that, except his daughter was in love with Aragorn, and so he reluctantly sent his gifts to Aragorn, but he didn't mobilise an army. He did just enough to help out, but entirely in a way that didn't risk any of his people's lives or take too much effort. The only elves that went with the Grey Company were Aragorn's old ranger buddies, Aragorn's good friends for decades. Obviously, they care about defending middle earth, they've spent years with Aragorn fighting off dangers that threaten the peaceful regions such as the Shire. But there's only 31 members, and not all of them are elves. Simply put, Glorfindel just doesn't care. He has no attachment to any men or dwarves. If the realm of Lotholorien was truly threatened by Saruman, then I'm sure he'd have ridden south to help the Elves escape. But he was content to just defend the elf realms and then return West. He certainly was never going to agree to go on a suicide mission that was based purely on the hope that Frodo might succeed at the 12th hour, with zero information on how close he was to achieving his goal. There is just no way Glorfindel would have ever been at the black gates.
Yes, Glorfindel was sent back to help fight Sauron. But there's no rules or guidelines. Glorfindel can absolutely take that to mean "act as a last line of defence and help all the elves leave middle earth". By the time Lord of the Rings occurs, the elves have completely committed to sailing over the sea and leaving men to their fate. Elrond is considered kind of weird for caring about this conflict. When Glorfindel fought the first time around, it was for the survival of the elves and the entire world. But by the third age, the world is seperated and the elves can just bail. And they are completely happy for the most part to do so.
So why didn't Glorfindel help more? Because he doesn't care. It's not his business and he doesn't care. His suggestions for the ring are give it to Tom Bombadil, some dude he basically knows nothing about, but figures why the hell not, or throw it in the ocean. Glorfindel doesn't care what happens to the ring, his options are give it some weirdo or throw it away. Why would he be eager to go on a mission to destroy it?
If Glorfindel was asked by Frodo or Elrond, he probably would have agreed, but probably would have turned back by the time they reached Moria. The deal was only ever to go as far as any member personally wished, and I can't see him wanting to go into the mines, which he'd know as well as Gandalf were likely Goblin and Orc infested, with likelyhood of trolls and maybe worse. I imagine he'd think helping the fellowship reach Moria was service enough, and probably not want to risk a dangerous trek. Gandalf only wants to go through Moria because he knows they'll never be able to sneak through the gap of rohan now Sauruman is watching. Glorfindel or no, the fellowship could never fight an army of orcs by themselves. Gandalf and Glorfindel both know it's unlikely there's any dwarves left in Moria, and they both know there's been whispers of something more powerful then ordinary goblins and trolls. Gandalf takes the path as a last resort, the last option to save the mission, hoping his power combined with stealth and speed will let them scrape by. Glorfindel probably isn't going to be super excited to go into the death mines.
@@CharlesFreck You are right about a lot of things, but some things are inaccurate. Maybe the Elves did not care what happens to middle earth, because they all will eventually leave, but they had no need to raise armies and go fight Sauron. Sauron had enough power to assault them the whole time the fellowship was doing its thing. Lothlorien was assaulted 3 times and defeated, Rivendell was attacked, the Lonely Mountain was under siege, etc. The Grey Company that came to Aragorn's aid was all the Rangers (basically Aragorn's distant family) that could be gathered hastily, as well as only 2 elves, the sons of Elrond (Elladan and Elrohir), who desired to go to the great battle of the age. I assume not all the Rangers came because many were probably still out fighting and guarding the shire, bree, and other areas from Sauron's and Saruman's influence.
As for why Glorfindel didn't go on the fellowship, it is true that he is very powerful. An easy thing for the Nazgul, the eye of sauron, saruman, and other great powers to track and find easily, since he cannot hide his spiritual power. People say he is a super elf, but he can still be killed. Maybe the Nazgul are afraid of him, but to orcs, trolls, evil humans, etc, he is just another elf warrior. Maybe Glorfindel can fight off the Nazgul, multiple lesser opponents, etc. But overwhelming numbers of basic troops that have no idea who he is can still eventually get in a lucky shot and he can still be killed. Being very powerful doesn't mean invulnerable, and he could still be killed by a rock, an arrow, a sword, etc.
Very likely, he was used defensively and as a distraction, just like the attack on the black gate was meant to distract Sauron from the ring-bearer reaching mount doom.
Let's also remember one key great moment from Glorfindel: he's one of the responsible for saving the north (former Kingdom of Arnor) from destruction from the hands of the Witch-King of Angmar during the Third Age, so he basically saved The Shire, Bree, all these regions from felling to the dark side even before the events of LOTR
He didn't actually save Arthedain from being destroyed but he along with an army from Gondor made sure Angmar was wiped out so at least those areas that produced our Hobbit heroes would survive to do so.
As you say, Glofindal’s spirt was far too bright for the mission. Sauron expected Glorindal. I believe the orcs of Cirith Ungol thought Sam might be Glofindal because he was able to get past the watchers.
At least pick a wrong spelling lol
Yeah the orcs were certain a powerful elven warrior was amongst them but just Sam with the ring of power 😂.
@@EpicMathTime lmao
@@EpicMathTimethe best comment I’ve read in weeks
Orcs actually do have a strong cultural memory, since they recognized Gandalf's and Thorin's swords.
Well said! I hadn't considered how easily visible Glorfindel would have been to the enemy. Another great video!
Here's another issue (or two) I can think of if Glorfindel had joined. Who would he have replaced? Most likely either Merry or Pippin as we already know there's no way Sam was going to leave Frodo's side. And then that would mean with two Humans, two Elves the Dwarves would demand two of their people to join, which might have seen Gloin go off on the mission. So we'd have 1 Wizard, Two Men, Two Elves, Two Dwarves, Two Hobbits in the fellowship, and probably Merry and Pippin sneaking off after them.
That would certainly make the Balrog attack far more interesting. Could he and Gandalf take it down together? Would Gandalf still have fallen or would Glorfindel died a second time? And having Gimli and Gloin as a father son duo would make the scenes in Moria even more intense when they came upon certain graves. Could Gloin have gone crazy with grief and gone off at the Orcs and Goblins and Balrog himself before anyone could stop him?
With all that said, given how Glorfindel would show up to the enemy due to his own great power, I do wonder if he was maybe used as a distraction to confuse Sauron by having him approach other strongholds while the Fellowship walked into Mordor.
Rob bud so pleased to see your channel explode!!
every view is well deserved.
long ago when you only had around 3k subs i did state audible needs to grab your talent for narrating, stil stand by it.
keep on rocking bro,
i got introduced to this world 26 years ago, and am still discovering decades later thanks to people like you.
I absolutely love the In Deep Geek title screen. Wonderful storytelling too. Subscribed!
Always a pleasure to watch Your videos and moreover to hear Your voice. I'm not a native English-speaker and in many other cases have some problems to understand every detail. So not in Yours. Your speak is so clear and well, that I really get everthing. Thanks a lot for that.
Early on, you describe Glorfindel's return to Middle-Earth in the Second Age. Right after that is a recap of his role at the Battle of Fornost, and a mention that the northern kingdom of Arnor falls as part of the outcome. This was confusing to me at first. I was associating "second age" and "battle" and trying to fit Glorfindel into the war in Eriador or the Last Alliance of Elves and Men, but that didn't compute. And with reason! The Battle of Fornost was in the Third Age (T.A. 1975) The confusion here was my own doing; happily, I got to browse more Middle-Earth history straightening myself out.
Thanks for another wonderful video! :)
IIRC Tolkien contemplated having Glorfindel arrive before the Fall of Numenor, and he would have a large heroice role in the Last Alliance. Like so many things, it never got past the stage of vague notes.
Love your content Robert and Co!
It's not even just that Glorfindel was essentially, the brightest walking lighthouse, that would have been the main problem, it's also the obviousness of him being in such a group. Gandalf was bad enough, add in the military leader of Gondor, a prince of Mirkwood (or not since he wouldn't be needed), and a dwarf from under the mountain shortly after threatening them, and then Glorfindel, one of the most famous elves, who fought and killed 1 of Morgoths most powerful assets and then was given life again cuz he was so great of an elf? No that is wayyyy too much importance and suspicious diversity of enemies to not send a regiment to capture or destroy, when you already know that your ring is in Rivendell and Glorfindel and Gandalf are both there as well. Better to send Glorfindel to cause trouble for the enemy elsewhere and draw some of the heat.
Always felt that if the fellowship did have Glorfindel on their side. It would of been much more noticed by Sauron and his forces and he’d be much more of a liability than a asset. Since stealth was the better option then trying to force their way through Mordor. They just did not have the numbers and the costs and risks would be to great but most importantly they just didn’t have the time needed to muster a grand army since much of Gondor had already been infiltrated. Where glorfindel would of been an asset was marshaling the elven forces and assisting the Dúnedain and reaffirming alliances and providing a faint and distraction. Making himself look to be the most dangerous while giving the fellowship a way to remain unnoticed.
A major theme of the LOTR is that good benefits most when the least powerful among good people stand against the most powerful evil. Also, conversely, that using great power to do good is turned to ironic consequences by evil. Glorfindel + Gandalf might have been like bringing a nuke to a knife fight. The Powers figured out not to do that in the First Age, when their overzealous protection of the Elves came to be misinterpreted as contempt by Feanor's jealousy.
Well done, one of your best videos. And I would say the Weathertop scene was a highlight of the films. Bloody terrifying first time through on the big screen.
I was wondering if you could do a video from the ring's point of view like you did for other characters.
I think a case can also be made that Gandalf sensed the fate of the Fellowship depended on them all being tested and showing their own valour, he himself could not make the task easier for them by using more of his power than was absolutely necessary, so he would not have wanted to involve another being of great power as well.
No one in the book ever explicitly says that one of the main reasons Merry and Pippin were included in the Fellowship is because they act as decoy halflings distracting enemy forces.
It just ended up being what happened. As they were mistaken for Frodo and his servant by Saruman's Uruk-Hai.
@@jawstrock2215 You don't think Gandalf and Elrond could have predicted extra halflings would help confuse Sauron and Saruman?
@@knightrider585Maybe, but it was not the reason for their presence. Friendship, and the positive energy it can bring was a bigger reason.
But I don't think they predicted they would have this much effect. At best they might have figured the 4 of them, could have snuck in Mordor, and pass the ring if one was to fall.(Hobbits are renown for their stealth).
And if you want to bring in fate in, you could say they really wanted to go, because they were meant to shake the council of man in the south(Rohan and Gondor), and kind of wake them all up to fight against Sauron. (As well as wake up the forest, and disturb Saruman.)
Everyone in the fellowship volunteered, and wanted to go, in the end.
If Glorfindel went, he would have been the only one "appointed".
If they had such dark thoughts, they would not be so foolish to articulate them. But just to be sure, Gandalf blinked heavily when he brought up all the friendship talk to Elrond who had not caught up yet
There an even more disturbing necessity. Being that if Frodo had been killed - then they'd have a spare ring-bearers. A duty that Sam performed, after their encounter with Shelob.
Spot on.
Glorfindel would literally be too much of a good thing for the mission.
I hadn't ever thought about that before, but it makes perfect sense.
I had never liked this explanation, but the way you explained it makes more sense. Before, I had only ever heard that "he would stand out because he's powerful". It makes a lot more sense when you explain that he stands out because he literally shines to those who can see the spirit world. However, I will still only accept this explanation if Gandalf is able to cover up his own shining light (because surely he would shine as well), while Glorfindel is unable to hide himself.
On a lighter note, I've always thought it would be funny if Glorfindel went with them and fought the Balrog instead of Gandalf. As the Balrog falls, it grabs Glorfindel's hair and pulls him down with him, and Glorfindel yells, "Not agaaaaaaiiiinnnnn......"
It's established Maia can completely disguise themselves. Saruman and Sauron are both noted to do it, both spiritually and physically. Gandalf even remarks that Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli may have seen Saruman in the forest, and even Gandalf before he became the White probably could not have detected Saruman if he chose to be disguised.
I think the best explanation though is that Glorfindel just doesn't care. When presented with what to do with the ring, his answers are either to give it to the weird dude who lives on the river that I've kind of heard about and Frodo says isn't effected by the ring, sounds legit to me, or throw it in the ocean and be done with it, whatever, who cares. If your options are give it to the first random dude that gets brought up or go and throw it away, then you probably aren't going to be super into the idea of a super dangerous mission to go and destroy it, when you've already shown you don't care about it. Glorfindel can just leave middle earth as can all the elves, and go over the sea, and Sauron will literally never be able to touch them. The elves have zero real consequences to leaving. Elrond only cares because he loves Rivendell and is probably the most sympathetic elf to men. And he's explicitly seen as a little weird for caring so much by the other elves, and all he does is organise travelling companions for Frodo and send Aragorn a couple gifts. And that's considered weirdly invested for an elf. Glorfindel absolutely just gives zero shits about the quest to destroy the ring.
My favorite part of Glorfindel's story is when he told the balrog "It's glorfin time" and glorfed all over him
"You have not seen what i have seen" type beat
It's not just Peter Jackson's LotR's where Glorfindel gets snubbed (just so that Liv Tyler gets more screen time from what I heard), but also in Ralph Bakshi's animated 1978 version too. In that one its Legolas who saves Frodo from the Black Riders.
*shrug* That's because in any medium that doesn't have a way to really benefit from the wider legendarium, Glorfindel would just seem like a there-and-gone minor side character. He only even manages to earn his significance in the novel by way of the written medium's luxurious ability to take its time dwelling on details of lore: even before The Silmarillion was actually published, The Lord of the Rings still had the benefit of being able to reference the lore Tolkien had worked out behind the scenes, and the time and page-space to make such references stick.
Just the concept of elves in a general sense had already had a hundred times more build-up by the time Glorfindel arrived in the book, than it had in the film by the time Arwen or Legolas appeared in the Jackson or Bakshi adaptations. Arwen in the Peter Jackson film was literally the first introduction to elves in the theatrical release and practically still was in the extended edition, where all that appeared before her was a distant view of some passing migrants to the Grey Havens and a vague reference to them leaving Middle-earth.
If The Lord of the Rings were re-imagined as a long-form streaming series, on the other hand, it might be more feasible to get Glorfindel in there for a nice two- or three-episode appearance.
Glorfindel showing up to help the siege of Minas Tirith along with Rohan would have been good. It would have made the march on the Black Gates even more of a diversion bc Sauron would have been all over seeing him marching. Also, it would have shown him doing something.
The real question is why they didn't send him south separately, he could have helped at many of the battles in the later books, especially Minus Tirith
You have a great point about how Glorfindel shined in the spectral real and would therefore attract attention. But can’t the same be said of Gandalf? The obvious answer is that a Mair had more power over how they take on physical form and was able to better conceal their true nature. But it does indicate that it is possible for a spiritual being to conceal their spiritual nature.
I remember hearing Tolkien actually stated he had originally thought of putting Glorifendel in the fellowship but realized he was too strong and could handle most anything that got thrown at the group so he decided not to.
A dm pc, in other words.
Great information. Thank you.
I always love learning new things about Tolkens legends.
Have you ever done a video about the dead marshes? Specifically in relation to the film version, that's the section I feel like I understand the least. I understand that it's a moment for Smeagol to help Frodo and prove he's trustworthy, but I don't understand why Frodo was compelled to fall into the water. Any deeper insight to that would be good.
I think he has but I’m not sure. However, Nerd of the Rings has a pretty in depth video on the subject (probably more than one) and he’s as thorough as In Deep Geek, so that might be helpful
0:05 Party would of been too OP, Elrond nerfed the group.
(Genuinely though I love how utterly impressive and powerful Glorfindel is, RAW. No ainur lineage, no ring of power, just a really friggin solid warrior. He's like the one punch man of middle earth)
While Sam is trying to get into the Tower of Cirith Ungol, he overhears the orcs talking amongst each other, saying that they think that some great elvish warrior has penetrated their defenses, noting that the war isn't going well, and that even the Witch King was killed. To these orcs, a hobbit skulking around with elvish weapons (such as Sting and the Phial of Galadriel), was enough to set the whole garrison into a panic.
And if they knew (or had soem inkling) that the likes of Glorfindel was still around, and would certainly be moving against their master...
This was so good! Now I have to find someone to impress with this new knowledge.
I think it was primarily because he did not volunteer in the book. Maybe Tolkien thought he was too OP. But even still, glorfindel saved frodo at the bridge
What an excellent video, this is a great explanation for the issue of glorfindel and the fellowship. Cheers.
You'd think Gandalf would shine just as much, but he seems to have a cloaking device.
The 5 Istari were prohibited from using their full power In mortal lands and thus would not appear as they would in the Blessed Immortal Lands.
To be honest, he kind of did; Saruman at least knew exactly where he was early on, when they were trying to cross the mountain.
I wouldnt even be surprised to learn, that it was Gandalfs presence that drew the attention of the Balrog in the first place. @@jermainerace4156
I believe you're thinking of Peter Jackson's Saruman. @@jermainerace4156
He did not shine until he returned as the White.
He was very good at remaining secretive, People knew he came and went, but nobody knew all he did.
As for Saruman, that's a movie only thing. In the book, it's the mountain itself beating the fellowship. (Or possibly a Maiar of the mountain, like the ones in the sea causing havoc on ships.)
Error at 7:44 "when Frodo put the ring on he was visible to the enemy, shining like a beacon." Your other video said this was true only when he was sitting on that magic seeing char.
I wonder if someone as powerful as Glorfindel was would be worried about being tempted by the ring?
The ring preys off weakness, whispering lies and promises of power. I don't think he would succumb too it , he'd probably be less tempted than Gladriel
Of course. Its temptation was greatest to the very powerful. Remember Gandalf's reaction when Frodo offered him the Ring at Bag End.
Since he and Galadriel were of the firstborn I think the temptation would've been similar.
@@barbiedahldoesn't galadriel have parents?
@@lomiification Yes. Firstborn in this case refers to the Elves as they were the firstborn of the Children of Iluvatar. Galadriel was not of the very 1st generation of Elves; she was the daughter of Finarfin and Eärwen, a Teleri princess.
Really excellent background and observations. Thanks.
Makes me wonder how Gandalf is viewed in the spiritual world, cause although he is reduced his presence or appearance he would still be very powerful and different from most others as a Maia and I believe fairly noticeable. Or did the Valar give him a spiritual disguise along with a physical one?
I always got the impression that Gandalf limited himself internalizing his power, perhaps earning the designation "The Gray" as he was likely unnoticed compared to the others of his order in the spirit realm. This attitude that turned out to be a wise council for the Fellowship, was actually Gandalf's MO in all things: Go unnoticed, move behind the scenes.
When he became "The White" it was "weapons hot" and nothing about his attitude resembled his former furtiveness but speed and action in all things. MHO
Very good! Thanks for sharing your insights around this.
Glorfindel could have just flown the ring to Mount Doom on eagleback by himself!
Hee hee like the fan-fic/HISHE version in which Gandalf saying "Fly you fools" was meant literally, as in "Take the eagles over Mt. Doom and just drop it in!'
3:02 Indeed we do: with Merry striking the killing blow from an enchanted Elvish blade, and Eowyn stabbing him with would ever harm the Witch King, yet getting all the credit.
Tolkien clearly enjoyed writing epic figures like Glorfindel, but at the end of the day, the stories that were most important to him weren't about them. They were about the goodness and resilience of ordinary people, about battles that might be won through decency, but never through strength of arms. It's part of what makes him so important, as an author.
I like the story progression aspect of this, it fits in very well into the world and the themes of the story. i think that it was smart to replace Glorfindel in the movies because the amount of nunace and explanation his character requires wouldn't have clicked for a large part of the audience and much like the eagles question, we'd have the glorfindel questions running around about it being a supposed plothole
In the Middle Earth Strategy Battle Game, there's rules for having a Fantasy Fellowship - with a few caveat rules.
I really considered doing a "The Elves do it themselves" Fellowship.
Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin as normal.
Aragorn is replaced with Glorfindel
Gandalf is replaced by Elrond
Legolas and Gimli become Elladan and Elrohir
And Boromir is swapped for Erestor
XD
ok but why swap out Legolas? ;P
Legolas isn't one of the Noldor elves that are heavily invested in the Morgoth / Sauron thing...
@@slMagnvox Because of how the rules work
"Gandalf" has to be a Spellcaster, so that means Elrond has to be in it, Glorfindel just fits as Aragorn's replacement.
Now, "Boromir" will always die at Amon Hen.
So with Legolas, Elladan and Elrohir, you are always going to lose Legolas, or one of the Twins.
Just feels better to keep it as an all Rivendell elf force.
This seems to illustrate the very meaning and theme of TLOTR. It is the smallest things, good things, simple things that can defeat huge evil.
I have a question. What if smaug got the one ring? Like its stated that the ring changes sizes when it comes to a new weilder, so would it grow to fit his finger/talon? Or i prefer this one, would it grow to be a perfect bracelet on the dragon? Then would smaug be on saurons team? Idk RIP Tolkien, i wish i was alive when he was so i could send him a letter. Yes his family is still around but i feel like they didn't understand his story as well as they think. They do understand his story more intimately then the layman but i dont think his family can accurately understand tolkiens work to its full potential
I think Tolkien knew what would happen if the dragons were not eliminated. At the end of Return of the King - Quote - 'Yet things might have gone far otherwise and far worse. When you think of the great Battle of the Pelennor, do not forget the battles in Dale and the valour of Durin's Folk. Think of what might have been. Dragon-fire and savage swords in Eriador, night in Rivendell. There might be no Queen in Gondor. We might now hope to return from the victory here only to ruin and ash. But that has been averted - because I met Thorin Oakenshield one evening on the edge of spring in Bree. A chance-meeting, as we say in Middle-earth.'
Given the nature of dragons, I think Smaug would have simply added the Ring to his horde, even if he recognised it for what it was. It would be more important to him to possess it than to wield it. We know certain beings are more resistant to the Ring's powers of domination and I have to believe dragons would be at the top of that list. Smaug, was immensely powerful, proud and evil but wasn't at all ambitious the way Sauron was. Gollum, at the other end of that spectrum, while dominated by the Ring, actually only wanted it for the same reasons though; just to have it, not use it. So that's kind of interesting.
@@jetsilveravenger i honestly love that analysis, and it's probably what Tolkien would have said. Smaug did have ambition but it was mainly more gold, and a spiteful nature towards the dwarves
@@jetsilveravenger Smaug having it might've even been a bad thing for Sauron. Smaug would've taken it for the sake of having it and might've even placed it alongside the Arkenstone in his hoard. Considering how he reacted when a mere goblet was taken, I shudder to think how he'd have reacted if _anyone_ had tried to take something so Precious from him, even by trade.
@@bluesbest1Sauron WITHOUT the One ring was still much more powerful than Smaug. Sauron was one of the most powerful Maiar in Arda
Been binge watching all your videos recently ❤
It's like bringing superman to fight batman villains
As usual, this is a great video with excellent analysis in depth about LOTR :). I agree, I think Glorfindel was powerful but was too prominent to be unnoticed by Sauron.
I was there at Rivendell. He stared at the Fellowship and went right down the list "Loser, shorter loser, crappy sword, spider-bait, uruk-bait...". He paused a bit on Gimli. "Alright, you're cool.". Then he looked at Gandalf. "Mithrandir, you better get your sh!+ together, because this elf has personal experience with the sandwich you're about to eat". Then he sat down.
Elrond: "No, that's too OP, plz nerf".
Outstanding video. There are times when I wish Tolkien's writings were more modern, more tightly outlined. A minor subplot with Glorfindel being used as a decoy would be fascinating. Similar to how Patton was stationed at Calais prior to the Normandy invasion.
More or less as Aragorn and Gandalf eventually did in the end.
My cousin was with Patton and did not arrive on Normandy Beach until the 3rd day from England. They were not in France.
@@LadyAlaina42-c3e you're right. I goofed.
@Customerbuilder no trouble. I just had so much conversation with Lane i almost feel I was there. He was always clear and almost ashamed he didn't get there for the "real" fighting.
Really excellent lecture. As the local Middle Earth nerd, people who know of Glorfindel as one who can smite a balrog ask why he wasn't included. First I tell them what Gandalf said at the choosing of the fellowship. Then I, too point out the aspect of the separation of the Spirit World and the Physical world. For mere mortals, he is beautiful and radiates wisdom and confidence. But those that can see the Spirit would would see him shining brightly and not be able to veil it.
But I do play around in my head with the thoughts of, what if it were Glorfindel for the Elves and Faramir instead of Boromir for the Men. It would be a very different story, though. Gandalf and Glorfindel could face the Balrog of Moria and very likely both survive and walk away.
I feel that if Faramir was at the Council of Elrond, he would already have deep respect for Gandalf. Elrond was one of the wisest beings and Faramir had positive feelings toward the Elves. And he would have even more respect for Aragorn. For Faramir, unlike his father, would see the King that could return and that Hope - Estel - was right in front of him. His nature is calm, thoughtful and protective. He would befriend the hobbits and look out for them. I think he would lead them into Mordor safely. I quite believe that even with long time exposure to the Ring, he could resist it. He was wiser, more thoughtful, he would see that the Ring was a peril to stay away from.
Boromir had many weaknesses that Faramir did not. Boromir was losing Hope. He was beginning to feel more of his fears of Mordor. The Lure of the Ring was pulling too hard on him. Finally, his nature too much wanted Glory and to be the one that brought it, and did so through force of arms.
But then all else goes awry. There is no friendly elf equal to and kidding with Gimli, a lone dwarf with no special friendship forming. The fellowship would not have split up and Pippin & Merry would never affect the Ents nor Rohan. The Ents would likely not rallied in time. Théoden would still be under Grima's enchantment and Saruman would bring devastating war on Rohan.
Faramir and Aragorn would also be stuck with a very difficult choice: Take the Hobbits to Mordor or take everyone to Minas Tirith.
So, making the Fellowship more powerful, would have likely led to the loss of the West. Gandalf never becomes The White. After destroying much of Fanghorn forest, Saruman would also raze Rowan and come on Gondor from the West. Where would the Ring Go? Would it matter anymore?
I would expect Gandalf to be more powerful than an elf. Why wasn't he too powerful? I know he got separated after the Balrog, but that wasn't the plan.
Gandalf had no permanent home and was known for wandering all over the place. His leaving Rivendell would not be all that remarkable. Plus the disguise he had to take as one of the Istari made him less conspicuous. Glorfindel on the other hand had been first in Lindon and later in Rivendell for a very long time. His leaving to go south would have been noticed.
Meeting the balrog wasn't in Gandalf's plan, but it was in Eru's plan.
There have been Elves more powerful than maiar in LoTR, like Feanor.
With just one super strong guy, sauron could guess he'd taken control over the ring
With two, they'd have to be fighting each other for the ring
It's a very important plot point that sauron thinks gandalf has fallen and is using aragorn as a puppet, the same as what happened to saruman
Good vid. The Fellowship was a stealth mission and Glorfindel was one of the two loudest dudes on ME along with Sauron. Same reason why Elrond and Galadriel didn't join.
There’s also the flatulence factor. Not a favorite to have in tight groups.
Whats this, there is some joke about Glorfindel being farty?
@@dan1e1473 Let’s just say you wouldn’t want him leading you through the Mines of Moria.
Glorfindel being present would be like having a tank leading a commando mission
So when Gandalf returns, is he shining like a giant Chinese weather balloon on the old spiritual radar too?
Probably, but that wasn't the version of Gandalf that had planned to go to Mordor with Frodo and Sam, that was the old Gandalf the Grey. Olorin the Maiar was not noted for being super-powerful in a physical sense, other than being a Maia to begin with.
Absolutely he is. Neither Gandalf nor even Aragorn could have made it into Mordor, I would think.
And it was them that Glorfindel buttered his famous insight: "It's Glorfin time."
I think Tolkien himself realised the inherent plot weakness of not including Glorfindel in the Fellowship and put in Gandalf's somewhat contrived justification to pre-empt his critics. After the scattering of the Nazgul at the ford the Fellowship hoped to get to Caradhras in relative secrecy then down the Dimrill Stair and into Lothlorien. Galadriel's power here would cloak Glorfindel from evil eyes so he could get as far as the river Anduin without being spotted. At this point he could have accompanied Boromir and Aragorn to Minas Tirith creating a huge distraction away from Frodo and Sam.
Hmmm. With him there, they would have beaten the Balrog more easily, without losing Gandalf. (And hopefully Glorfindel would've survived this time, and not had to be respawned there). Then once they got to the River, Gandalf would've gone with Frodo and Sam.... Interesting new turn.
Great video and analysis as always. It would have still been pretty cool to see Glorfindel in the films, but I can understand why Jackson went with Arwen.
All you've done is convince me that they should've split up the Hobbits and had Glorfindel lead a decoy fellowship.
Smartest comment here!
What makes your channel great Robert is your appreciation of the softer themes of the story. That it is not a fascist tale of conquering heroes but of little people becoming great. Tolkien rejected allegory but having Aaragorn, the uberman of ubermen kneel to Frodo and Sam has to be a comment on the Nazi worldview.
It is true that Glorfindel's power wasn't needed, but having the wisdom of a 1st Age Elf in the fellowship may have been important, and certainly having a Balrog killer would have come in very handy in Moria, so despite what Tolkien might have said, there are reasons why Glorfiendel would have been a good choice. What I think is much more likely is that Tolkien already had the character of Gandalf the White in mind which means Gandalf had to fight the Balrog, and that he wanted Aragorn to be the leader of the Fellowship in the first book which when placed together, really doesn't leave a lot of room for Glorfidenel.
Well done!
People have a lot of trouble with the powerful yet 'inactive' characters in Middle Earth. Glorfindel, Tom Bombadil, the Eagles, the absent wizards etc. We see they are largely left out of the movies or replaced. But part of Tolkien's worlds is that there are many layers of importance, or fate and duty, unseen and unknown deep purposes and powers. Elrond recognises that this journey of the ring is in large part Gandalf's ultimate act, it is his story (in the mythic sense). A massive part of the power of elves (magic) is to understand these grand, deep, hidden narratives. The power of 'magic' is chiefly the power of story, and understanding the story of the world. Understanding God's song.
Also, the temptation of the Ring was ever present. As Gandalf said, the more powerful you are, the greater the temptation. By putting the Ring in close proximity to Glorfindel for a significant period of time would increase the risk of temptation.
One of the reasons why the Ring was never a temptation to most of the Fellowship was their relatively less powerful nature. Admittedly, Gandalf and Aragorn were powerful spiritually, but the rest were less so. At best, Legolas, being an elf, had some spiritual power, but as a Sindar Elf who never made it to the Blessed Lands and was possibly born in the 2nd or 3rd Age, his spiritual power would have been much lower than ones like Glorfindel or Galadriel.
Even then, the constant threat of temptation was high. Boromir, who was part Numenorean and, possibly, part-Elven through his mother, who was a Princess of Dol Amroth, fell to the temptation. Bluntly, who could have stopped Glorfindel if he decided to take the Ring for himself?
Given all this it seems that Glorfindel would have come in most handy when Aragorn marched on the Black Gate. Granted, everything worked out as is, but imagine how scary would it have been if not only could he assume Aragorn had taken up the ring, but that Glorfindel had taken it up and was marching towards him with an army.
That is exactly what I "guessed" when I saw your video title here. You say they could sense him from a mile away -- I would bet that Sauron could sense Glorfindel's presence from further away than that at least in many circumstances. Kind of like traveling with a sign that flashes "here we are" in neon in the unseen world.
The real reason is that Glorfindel was so powerful that LOTR would have happily finished in 30 pages. It wouldn't have provided a literary challenge.
Just picture Glorfindel and Gandalf riding on giant eagles with Frodo carrying the ring to mount doom ^^
I mean Saurons airforce are mostly the Nazgul and they wouldnt fare too well against those two.
Lol no. If Glofindel is that powerful to easily beat everything Sauron throws at him and easily finish the mission, why the fuck do you think Sauron is still a huge enemy that everyone is afraid of ??
Because Glofindel is nowhere near strong enough to contest against Sauron, and the strongest member of the Fellowship is always Gandalf no matter if Glofindel is in it or not, but him being in it only makes it worse
Having Glorfindel in The Fellowship would be akin to having a powerful beam of light stretching up towards the sky screaming "Hey everyone! We're RIGHT HERE!!" ever step of the way. Sure the enemies would've been very wary of Glorfindel's powerful aura, but likewise, he's basically a walking magnet pointing everyone good or bad right where he is. Sure he'd be a huge asset in a fight, but then he'd mop the floor of basically everything leaving none of the other members of The Fellowship a reason to be in it, and from a storytelling point, it'd wouldn't be very interesting to read, as well as leaving everyone with nothing to do, no chance for developing those characters.
His best usage might've been as a misdirection decoy to draw the majority of the enemies AWAY from The Fellowship so they'd have a higher chance of success, much like near the end when Aragorn decided to pull a last ditch assault at The Black Gates to draw the armies of Mordor away to a single point in hopes that the missing Hobbits might slip through elsewhere.
Because he's too powerful for the story. There, I summarized for you
Excellent analysis. true!
4:50 They wanted stealth and included Gimli
I loved how in the Movie Mars with MattDamon that Project Elrond had the head of NASA say I want to be Glorfindel :)) He couldn't go..the creatures of Sauron would have seen his fea blazing like a sun at his coming.
3:52 - We needed Arnold Glorfindel in FotR!
Glorfindel to Gandalf when the Balrog appeared. " Bro... I got this"
He's so powerful that the Nazgul preferred to fight a magical tsunami than to face him, 9 to 1!
Wonderful! Now I like Glorfindel even more.