Def 4 and 1. Funny thing is my younger brother never bothered with 1 for the longest time and finally played it with that PS plus collection thing. Now he says it's the best one 😂
For me, there's never really been an online gaming experience to match the atmosphere of BF1. It always felt like a legitimately massive battle between two sides on gorgeous maps in one of the most interesting conflicts in history. So good.
Yeah. I felt like I was in a crazy war whenever I played bf1. Never felt like the match had stale moments. It was chaos from the whistles to the explosions. And The brutality of CQC!
Personally BF1 is my favorite fps ever, maybe even one of my favorite games of all time. The attention to detail, the atmosphere, the design. I mean, they added sound to raindrops hitting empty artillery casings! You can only hear it if crouching when it rains. That's insane. It is, a masterpiece
EA really fucked up by releasing Titanfall 2 like a week after Battlefield 1, because it was an addictingly fantastic FPS as well. Not as good as Battlefield 1 in my opinion, but good in a class of it's own.
@@all_out_tripp7220 I like BF4 more as a whole but the atmosphere of BF1 cant be matched. The foggy maps, the smoke, all the screaming and explosions happening during the huge battles or battles inside the trenches or bunkers. BF4 doesnt have that epic feel, in BF1 every match feels like a movie
@@all_out_tripp7220 Gameplay wise, BF4 is superior to BF1. But the atmosphere is definetely not it's strong suit. BF1 reigns supreme over all the other Battlefield titles in this department.
@Diet Double Dew Political? What the actual hell? Do you even know a little bit of history? You should read more about the French Foreign Legion, The Harlem Hellfighters (Most condecorated military unit of the United States outside of the US.) German African Askaris etc... AND the helmets you see being used in BF1 are history accurate. So before you start dissing things, you should educate yourself a little bit because at this point you are not insulting the game. You are insulting those who died during the second bloodiest conflict this world has seen.
The last point on Verdun Heights in the Devil’s Anvil operation, when the smog comes in. The Germans all pour into the meat grinder, everything has an orange reddish tint from all the fire on the map. The screaming, explosions and gunfire combined with that perfect end of the round theme of pure desperation. The atmosphere for a ww1 game is perfect, battlefield 1 is a great example of how a large budget can be used to make a one of a kind game experience. The music of bf1 is also top notch.
You’ve never experienced hell in a video game till you are the Germans on the last sector of Verdun Heights. Jesus, that charge uphill is so hard yet so immersive. At that point I don’t even care if I lose the match the immersion is just so breathtaking
@@sleeper5905 my friend followed a similar path, all he does is play the latest trending shooter and just plays to be better than everyone. When I asked him why he plays he said "to pass time". Like bro you play all day why are you playing to kill time?
@@CommandoFrost the comment aged well... it was levelcaps desire for battlefield to chase trends that didnt age well.... but in all honesty im not surprised... u ever notice how levelcap always distinguishes himself from "casual players"? ive always found he wants things for battlefield that most casual players don't care about. but because hes a streamer that gets invited to EA events, they'll listen to a guy that doesn't represent the majority of the fan base in many ways... so level cap actually requested for bf to chase trends... and here we are.. #thankslevelcap
Same here, I remember when I first got the game, it was like nothing I ever played before. Of course I sucked in the beginning, but soon enough I was having a blast cutting through enemies with my Selbstlader 1916.
@@zacharyscott8083 yeah this game was around the same time when I got into history and now I love 20th Century history like the cold war Vietnam ww1 ww2 Korean War i love that stuff
2042's marketing is doing great, literally 1% of the playerbase that was nolifing reddit waiting for an unannounced game even knows soon june boom happened smh
The trailer for this game might have been the most EPIC trailer I’ve ever seen for a game, probably the reason it got so many sales because people were thinking if the game is anything like the trailer it’s gonna be a hell of a good game which it was.
I honestly think it was due to random bullet deviation. That threw so many people off at launch. Because everyone felt it but maybe didn’t understand it. At least I needed a good long time to get used to it.
Yes and Levelcap was one of them, saying he doesn't want to even play because of the grenade spam and other issues. Now he is riding the recent trend of saying BF1 was good (which it wasn't, he was right and honest the first time, this is just pure click baiting and trend riding)
Its almost like people can hold a variety of opinions, or, better yet, those opinions change over time.... huh... Also consider how every second of gameplay in this vid isnt on a close range map lol, the spam really is cancer-inducing. Fort de vaux, argonne, verdun heights, are constant explosions
@@elchucabagra he was also the person who was heavily critisizing the random spread on weapons, calling it something catering to casuals. I don't understand how have I never heard him say much great about this game while going on tirades about bf3 and bf4, and suddenly in 2021 comes out a video named "was battlefield 1 the best". Also for reference, I've been watching Charlie for 10 years, literally lol
Sniping in this game was super satisfying. I don't think the sweet spot was not as cheap as people seem to think. It added great variety to the scout class.
I loved this game by the end of its DLC track, it had so many great maps and guns even if they really pushed it with “experimental” guns. I’m fine with it; it was for the sake of making the time period more fun gun-wise It’s also an amazing time period, I’m a huge history nerd and I remember how hyped I was for this game, I still get on now and again with the bois to play on Gallipoli
I completely agree with this and the way they rolled out the dlc chronologically as the war waged on is the icing on the cake for me and personally think they should continue to do that.
Trying to make WW1 a "fun" environment is still kind of weird. But dice did a good job making it a "what if" scenario cuz honestly it doesn't look like WW1 at all
The maps were so much fun. Felt like all of them had a nice flow to the combat. Amiens has gotta be the best urban map I’ve ever played in a battlefield.
I adore this game. This was the first battlefield where I actually felt immersed in a historical battle. It also made me more interested in history and I learned more about WW1
The spread, the sponge class pickups, bayonet and melees, suppression, tank snipers, planes, horse mechanics, grenade spam. There was SO much wrong with BF1. Can’t forget sliding either. Holy shit.
@@gebrelius7442 I respect your wrong opinion. Just kidding, it may not be the best, but I really enjoyed the game. So I consider it the best. Mostly because you could switch to team chat and talk to everyone on the team sonce each te had 12 people.
@@FlaminKanami I feel like bf3 was the best balance. I felt like bf4 added too much verticality and too many hiding spots in cluttered maps. Bf3 was a lot flatter and it was easier predict player movement and area to clear before moving.
Sadly I couldn't join the Bf community earlier than 2019, but back then I started with Bf 1. And guess what: It absolutely amazed me! I love the WW I setting and the atmosphere. Later I got Bf V and that was no real fun at all... So yeah, I'm still playing Bf 1 daily up to this day! So if anyone searches for someone to game with - just react to this comment :)
I am very glad there was no shitty Battle Royale in BF1. Feels like the last real battlefield at the moment. It hit a rarely seen historical period, introduced the well-received Operations game mode, and doesn't need to follow the trends of the Fortnite and Apex bullshit. Battlefield is about the BATTLEFIELD.
@@edgarift Not sad really. BF 2, 3 and 4 are harder to pick up from and has missing (while minimal) gameplay aspects that make it much more frustrating experience. My first battlefield was BF1 and since a lot of my friends had BF4 I decided to give it a try. The movement is clunky, no vaulting over things that would make sense you could jump and the community is much more of a try hard. I agree with LevelCap here when he said you need a good squad to have a good time in the other BF titles. Overall, for a new BF player to go from 1 to 4 is a really bad advise.
One of the best, minus getting stuck with the vault animations, spotting enemies thru smoke, op SMG 08 and the damn Heavy Bomber strafes, cinematic masterpiece.
@@maddog063 the random bullet deviation is only there to prevent automatic weapons from being effective at all ranges, so that the classes can be a but more balanced.
@@carrion-fairy and I respect that. But I still feel like the classes were to cookie-cutter: that the roles they had were all they could effectively do.
The BF series has so many iconic and unforgettable moments Rolling into Karkand for the first time in BF2 Base jumping off Damavand Peak in BF3 Witnessing Shanghai's C-point crumble in BF4 That time the developers said "if you don't like it, don't buy it" in BFV
@@enjoi9970 It may be but I just couldn’t get past the bad visibility. Here’s exactly what I’m talking about. I just hope 2042 is good. 👍🏽✌🏽 th-cam.com/video/sj5mPuShilg/w-d-xo.html
I agree. BF3 to BF4 was bad IMO because the maps in BF3 were more on the "linear" side. BF4 was just a big map where anyone can go "anywhere" so to speak. It felt like I was playing in a sandbox and there was no progression throughout the match unless it was a map like locker/metro. BF1 comes out and most if not all base maps were linear just like BF3 and I enjoyed it more.
@@Cert1f1edM1dget Totally agree. Coming from Xbox 360 playing BF3 we didn't have the player count PC had. So I played majority rush. Op Metro, Seine Crossing, Grand Bazaar. Great close combat maps. BF4 every map is sandbox which to me was just too aimless. BF1 has sandbox but is directed.
Looking back the gameplay of Battlefield 1 was great. Apart from a very few balancing issues (Mortar Truck and the Ilya Muromets) I never got the feeling I died undeserved in this game, I'm alway like "ah yeah, that was a stupid idea of mine and it immediatly backfired on me" instead of BF2042, where it's just like "what in the world should I have done to prevent dying there?" I also loved how distinguished the classes are in bf1 and how you really feel like you're changing your playstyle when switching class, how ranged engagements change the mindset depending on which class and gun you're using. The often critizised random bullet deviation/ spread of the guns I also enjoyed. That is mainly due to the fact that I think it is important in order to balance the weapons. In other Battlefield games you can outsnipe a sniper with a machine pistol... in Battlefield 1 you have to be a little smarter than that. The map design was also amazing. Most of the maps always have enough cover to use to get to your prefered distance of combat. All weapons are useful on almost all maps (alright, maybe a shotgun isn't the best idea to use on Giant's Shadow or Galicia). And tbh Battlefield 2042 made me appreciate how Dice handled wide open maps in BF1, as even maps like Galicia have cover in most places, that can be used even though the map is a giant open mudfield. I don't wanna focus on it much, as basically the whole world agrees on it, but of course Battlefield 1s atmosphere is the most amazing thing a shooter game ever pulled of in my opinion. From the sounddesign to the voice acting to the musical score, it all comes together perfectly! Another great point is the vehicle combat (apart from the afore mentioned mortar truck and ilya) as it rewards a more aggressive yet team oriented way of playing. A tank can be easily destroyed by a few assaults and is no invincible powermachine, however if you advance with a few teammates, you can let hell loose on the enemy, as the tanks excell at close quarters combat and if you have a competent tank crew, a tank driver is a key player that can really make an impact on the game as a whole. In BFV tanks seem to be designed for long range, because of their high bullet velocity, high explosive damage and not much bullet drop, but suck at close quarters, since they lack machine gunners all around to cover their sides, resulting in them camping on hills most of the time. In BF2042 the sheer mass of vehicles with no effective way to combat them, make them a nighmare to go up against.
Hmmm, it would work in any of the older conflicts, but war has changed, there is no taking potshots from trench to trench or en-masse assaults on enemy lines. Very often a soldier can do 2 turns in Afghanistan and never even be in danger. Nonetheless i TOTALLY agree that they should include this gamemode into the next BF, whether it be 2048 or it's successor.
i'm a true gamer, a gamer to the core. And i quite frankly have to admit that battlefield 1 was really a chapter of its own. No game could do it like they did, its one of those games that had a lot of potential that wasn't all carried out while the game was live but still carried heavy. They made the game so enjoyable and i appreciate that for them.
Sound and visuals are just addictive. When I launch the game after a while I just like to stare at the ocean or the devastated lands. When you just fire a rifle and you hear the echo of the shot for seconds, it's just amazing.
I love this game. It's one of the few battlefield games that I can say when I play I can feel the love, time, and effort that went into making this game fun and satisfying. It may not have the most maps, weapons or content but it has quality and that's what matters and why I think you can keep coming back to this game and it will feel timeless.
I think BF4 is the best for me, aside from BC2 and Modern Combat. I know those are dated, but still. However! I will say this game definitely feels meaty and good, so I can definitely see why you dig it so much! I think this game's soundtrack is basically unmatched though!
I swear every minute feels like its own action movie. It's truly a new experience every match (except when you are a jet pilot then I feel sorry for you for not experiencing the real game)
BF3 was the best for me hands down. If they want this next BF to succeed as the past ones did with the dedicated servers its going to have to have the same feature. Otherwise its going to suffer the same fate being populated with hackers on a mass scale. Give us the option to rent out a server and actively police them.
I’ve been playing battlefield games since 1942 off and on but BF1 was the game I sank hundreds of hours and completed nearly everything in the game. So much fun
@@KenzieNakamura dude you really going around in every comment thread huh. It’s almost as if people can have a different opinion than yours, shocking I know.
What I remember about BF1 was that when I unlocked the Martini Henry it became my gun with the most kills by a lot. Even today 8 years later this game is a blast.
I really love it. One of my favourite things in battlefield 1, is the way vehicular combat felt compared to other titles. It all felt punchy. Battlefield V pissed on that with the worst and most inconsistent of all. Guns felt really well. All except for the automatico - which was the smoothbrain gamer guy's go-to. Overall, best feeling gunplay only rivalled by battlefield V's launch TTK. Battlefield 3, 4 and Hardline all play well. But the hit reg & overall feel of guns are way outdated. And I still play the hell out of 4. Hitting a headshot & hearing that ping is really nice.
This had so much to chase back in the day of dlc, I’m glad I got to sink my teeth into this game let’s hope for a full battlefield game this winter season
Hoping they never make it part of the BF franchise. Wanna play a WW1 shooter? Cool. Don't waste BF devs on it though, open a new sub-studio and have it produced by a new team. Leave DiceLA to what they do best, modern shooters.
Battlefield 1 is my favorite game of the franchise. Started playing it again this week and it’s been really fun. Unlocked the Peacekeeper, too. It’s good to be back.
The trailer had me in fucking tears it was so good, I still watch it too this day, and maybe it is the best idk I started on BF3, also I still play Bf1 faithfully
The game was amazing and will always be held dear to my heart. The game may not have been totally accurate to the WW1 era however it did extremely well to immerse yourself into the game and how little you can feel in such a large conflict. Comparing it to battlefield 5 goes to show how a game based on a world war was done right instead of by still making it feel like you were fighting in that war at that time. Was it the best? I would say no but honestly, it's hard to say which battlefield was the best since several were so memorable and great to play. Für Kaiser und Vaterland!
Dude a Battlefield WW1 battle royale set in a massive "no mans land" would have been absolutely amazing. Everyone jumps out of a burning behemoth and parachutes into a wasteland riddled with mud blood gas weapons and bodies
I loved the thematic of this game it felt gritty and that your actually in that time period with the objective names and the announcer. Loved the bits of historical insight on the break through was it can't remember the game mode name
In terms of atmosphere, feeling like you were in an actual war and fun factor, definitely. But I will say it is interesting to see many TH-camrs now considering this to be the best BF when it was criticized by them heavily for its lack of progression and gunplay.
BF1 is an excellent casual solo game. Not so fun with friends, I feel like every just goes off doing their own thing and don't work together that much. BF3 was so good with team play.
4:43 Be careful what you wish for I guess. DICE has now decided to become EA’s favourite child and implement so many shitty cashgrab mechanics into the newest Battlefield that it now feels more like a Warzone clone with absolutely no passion for what the game once used to be. I’m so glad they didn’t listen to you and didn’t implement shitty battle Royale into this game. Hopefully they recollect their brains for the next release
@@enjoi9970 I quit the game a couple months in so I really wouldn’t no. I don’t get the hype around it, gunplay really is utterly terrible with RNG spread or whatever you want to call it. I just grinded until I got that OP assault class AR then quit after that got boring. I even find BF5 (in the state it’s in now more fun) TBH.
@@Person-el3sf Movement, gunplay, attrition, reinforcements, fortifications, squad play, manual healing, no more 3D spotting button, no more random recoil spread, more more grenade spam, no more cheese gadgets, no more vehicle spam, etc.
Absolutely amazing soundtrack. Great sound design. Hearing the whistle and "going over the top" to the next objective was a great feeling. I felt incredibly in the moment every time.
![[DRIP] ‘Woke Up In Tokyo (RUKA & ASA)’ PREVIEW](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QN44lcR_VkI/mqdefault.jpg)
What's your favorite Battlefield game?
Battlefield 2142
Bad company 2 and bf1
BF4 followed by BF3 as a close second.
4
Def 4 and 1. Funny thing is my younger brother never bothered with 1 for the longest time and finally played it with that PS plus collection thing. Now he says it's the best one 😂
For me, there's never really been an online gaming experience to match the atmosphere of BF1. It always felt like a legitimately massive battle between two sides on gorgeous maps in one of the most interesting conflicts in history. So good.
Yeah. I felt like I was in a crazy war whenever I played bf1. Never felt like the match had stale moments. It was chaos from the whistles to the explosions. And The brutality of CQC!
I will buy an xbox again just to play this game... Do you know if there are any players left?
@@johnk3772 There are. Still enough that it is easy to find a game, if not always on the specific DLC map you'd want.
@@johnk3772 tons, I play everyday and am always full servers, conquest or domination are the main 2 but I see some tdm servers sometimes
That's why I keep playing this every single day. This game is becoming even more of a staple for the franchise just like CS 1.6 once did for CS
Bf1 was the only battlefield where i enjoyed all the classes equally, easily my no.1
Bro me too but, Im never picking a sniper hm
It’s so weird to think this game came out almost 5 years ago
its funny how it actually looks better than literally every game out there
@@shiner_music except rdr2
@Basically I'm Schlorping lmao
@@shiner_music Yeah, looks and runs better than most if not all new releases.
No good console games have come out in the last 5 yesrsexcept The ghost of Tsushima
Personally BF1 is my favorite fps ever, maybe even one of my favorite games of all time. The attention to detail, the atmosphere, the design.
I mean, they added sound to raindrops hitting empty artillery casings! You can only hear it if crouching when it rains. That's insane.
It is, a masterpiece
Absolutely agree
bruh its like when i go in the mud prone it has mud and grime
EA really fucked up by releasing Titanfall 2 like a week after Battlefield 1, because it was an addictingly fantastic FPS as well. Not as good as Battlefield 1 in my opinion, but good in a class of it's own.
Agree I love this game so much
BF1 has the best atmosphere out of all the battlefields
Bf4 has a much better atmosphere
@@all_out_tripp7220 I like BF4 more as a whole but the atmosphere of BF1 cant be matched. The foggy maps, the smoke, all the screaming and explosions happening during the huge battles or battles inside the trenches or bunkers. BF4 doesnt have that epic feel, in BF1 every match feels like a movie
@@all_out_tripp7220 Gameplay wise, BF4 is superior to BF1. But the atmosphere is definetely not it's strong suit. BF1 reigns supreme over all the other Battlefield titles in this department.
Hands down. The best atmosphere
@Diet Double Dew Political? What the actual hell? Do you even know a little bit of history?
You should read more about the French Foreign Legion, The Harlem Hellfighters (Most condecorated military unit of the United States outside of the US.) German African Askaris etc... AND the helmets you see being used in BF1 are history accurate.
So before you start dissing things, you should educate yourself a little bit because at this point you are not insulting the game. You are insulting those who died during the second bloodiest conflict this world has seen.
The last point on Verdun Heights in the Devil’s Anvil operation, when the smog comes in. The Germans all pour into the meat grinder, everything has an orange reddish tint from all the fire on the map. The screaming, explosions and gunfire combined with that perfect end of the round theme of pure desperation. The atmosphere for a ww1 game is perfect, battlefield 1 is a great example of how a large budget can be used to make a one of a kind game experience. The music of bf1 is also top notch.
You’ve never experienced hell in a video game till you are the Germans on the last sector of Verdun Heights. Jesus, that charge uphill is so hard yet so immersive. At that point I don’t even care if I lose the match the immersion is just so breathtaking
I love how every engagement in this game felt like a full team battle not just a squad capturing an objective
Yeah no I was called the unstoppable shotgun I can carry my team so hard it’s not fun
@@RealistRatRace go away, just....go
@@RealistRatRace u didn't carry any one lmao
@@RealistRatRace “I was called the unstoppable shotgun”
I think I puked in my mouth
@@chobai9996 u all just mad that i will 1 tap u and ur going to cry to ur mommies. Hahahahabaa
Not every game needs a battle royale….
but my friends think that every shooting game should be battle royale....
I agree, Tetris and Scrabble don't need battle royale mode :D
@@sleeper5905 your friend need to quit fortnite
@@rycanlase3639 ikr, he is saying that its the best game, he got so addicted i stopped chatting with him
@@sleeper5905 my friend followed a similar path, all he does is play the latest trending shooter and just plays to be better than everyone. When I asked him why he plays he said "to pass time". Like bro you play all day why are you playing to kill time?
Going back to BF1 after suffering through V was shocking. Maps and atmosphere are just so superior.
Atmosphere yes but it doesn’t have anything to do with the gameplay and I prefer BFV maps even though I don’t think BF1 has bad maps either
The only thing battlefield V has on 1 is gunplay in my opinion!
But the gunplay is just bad.
@@stephenurso9267 It's because BF5 of course is set in World War II only 20 years after WW1 so it's a successor.
@@stephenurso9267 Yup but i also really like squad revives, better movements and ping instead a marker over enemies head.
"Battlefield sucks at chasing trends and live service models"
Good, those things are what suck about "AAA" gaming these days
Amen to that
this comment didnt age well
@@CommandoFrost the comment aged well... it was levelcaps desire for battlefield to chase trends that didnt age well.... but in all honesty im not surprised... u ever notice how levelcap always distinguishes himself from "casual players"? ive always found he wants things for battlefield that most casual players don't care about. but because hes a streamer that gets invited to EA events, they'll listen to a guy that doesn't represent the majority of the fan base in many ways... so level cap actually requested for bf to chase trends... and here we are.. #thankslevelcap
The most satisfying sound in the world is getting a headshot with a martini henry
**THUNK**
**Pa-dink-twinkle**
**Orgasmic Reload**
Ah i see a man with taste:)
I literally bought an 1885 Martini Henry because of this game. Best 1k spent ever.
@@citizenoftheninthdivision is it the .303 version or the .55(I think?) Version?
@@citizenoftheninthdivision does the gun live up to the hype
Battlefield 1 was my first entry into the battlefield series so it had a big impact on me and it also got me interested in history which now I love
Same here, I remember when I first got the game, it was like nothing I ever played before. Of course I sucked in the beginning, but soon enough I was having a blast cutting through enemies with my Selbstlader 1916.
I was into WW2 history before BF1 came out, but when I saw the trailer for it, I was instantly like “oh god yes”
@@benhood5492 I never got good still am not I still play to this day
@@zacharyscott8083 yeah this game was around the same time when I got into history and now I love 20th Century history like the cold war Vietnam ww1 ww2 Korean War i love that stuff
I was never really a FPS kind of person, I mainly chilled on indie adventure games. Until I saw BF1 on gamepass almost a year ago.
Marketing for this game was phenomenal. Unlike the “soon june boom”
Catchy. Have a like.
2042's marketing is doing great, literally 1% of the playerbase that was nolifing reddit waiting for an unannounced game even knows soon june boom happened smh
@@biznichin13 really looking forward to killing bots in 2042! much skill such wow!
@@shaneguin12 you realize that’s only when the games aren’t full, right?
@@shaneguin12 man 125 players and 3 bots is totally going to ruin the experience
The trailer for this game might have been the most EPIC trailer I’ve ever seen for a game, probably the reason it got so many sales because people were thinking if the game is anything like the trailer it’s gonna be a hell of a good game which it was.
It came out when I was in middle school and it was literally all we could talk about for weeks
@@personalaccount8914 haha jeez, I was halfway done with University when this game came out...
I remember youtubers heavily criticizing BF1 at the time and declaring it dead quite early on in its lifecycle.
There's a crowd that declares every game "dead" if it doesn't cater solely to their every whim.
I honestly think it was due to random bullet deviation. That threw so many people off at launch. Because everyone felt it but maybe didn’t understand it. At least I needed a good long time to get used to it.
The community hates every new game and doesn’t appreciate it until the next one comes out.
Yes and Levelcap was one of them, saying he doesn't want to even play because of the grenade spam and other issues. Now he is riding the recent trend of saying BF1 was good (which it wasn't, he was right and honest the first time, this is just pure click baiting and trend riding)
I was just about to say this. I noticed this always happen with Battlefield and COD. Current game sux and last game everyone hated is now great.
Operations were actually good in this game as well
Operations was godlike, it was all I played for 3 years
until you get to play with a bad team and couldn't defend or attack the objective well
Rush was far superior
Absolute favorite, ambiance, music, sound, gameplay, some of the maps.
This game did everything i wanted a bf game to do
I just started playing the game again, and I just remembered how good it was. I’m gonna be playing it a lot more from now on.
the atmosphere of bf1 is unrivaled
Imagine if BF V was the quality of 1 but WWII... thats what we all had hoped for but lmao not what we got
Passchendale was one of my favorite maps for sheer gritty WWI atmosphere. Really felt like a map that captured the feeling of a "war to end all wars"
@@faceripper77 I take BFV’s better gameplay rather than BF1’s better atmosphere any day of the week.
@@enjoi9970 ya know what your opinion is wrong and you should feel very very bad
@@faceripper77 hes right tho i rather play bf5 than bf1 any day
Aren't you the one whose last video on BF1 during it's time was you talking about how the grenade spam makes the game legitimately unplayable?
Exactly. It is all about clickbait.
I remember this too.
The grenade spam was really bad.
Its almost like people can hold a variety of opinions, or, better yet, those opinions change over time.... huh...
Also consider how every second of gameplay in this vid isnt on a close range map lol, the spam really is cancer-inducing. Fort de vaux, argonne, verdun heights, are constant explosions
@@elchucabagra he was also the person who was heavily critisizing the random spread on weapons, calling it something catering to casuals. I don't understand how have I never heard him say much great about this game while going on tirades about bf3 and bf4, and suddenly in 2021 comes out a video named "was battlefield 1 the best". Also for reference, I've been watching Charlie for 10 years, literally lol
Just ended a really good round on monte grappe, closed the game, clicked on the bell, sees this video, *happy*
Sniping in this game was super satisfying. I don't think the sweet spot was not as cheap as people seem to think. It added great variety to the scout class.
I loved this game by the end of its DLC track, it had so many great maps and guns even if they really pushed it with “experimental” guns. I’m fine with it; it was for the sake of making the time period more fun gun-wise
It’s also an amazing time period, I’m a huge history nerd and I remember how hyped I was for this game, I still get on now and again with the bois to play on Gallipoli
I completely agree with this and the way they rolled out the dlc chronologically as the war waged on is the icing on the cake for me and personally think they should continue to do that.
I played on ps4 through its live time and never bought a dlc and absolutely loved the game and still do sadly it’s dead most of the time I play
I listened to the whole hardcore history season on ww1 in prep for this game
Trying to make WW1 a "fun" environment is still kind of weird. But dice did a good job making it a "what if" scenario cuz honestly it doesn't look like WW1 at all
2023 - and I am still playing BF1. Without a doubt, definitely one of my favorite games ever made.
Advancing/ retreating to the soundtrack during Operations absolutely did it for me.
The maps were so much fun. Felt like all of them had a nice flow to the combat. Amiens has gotta be the best urban map I’ve ever played in a battlefield.
Amiens is probably one of the most perfect maps ever made
I adore this game. This was the first battlefield where I actually felt immersed in a historical battle. It also made me more interested in history and I learned more about WW1
Unmatched immersion and atmosphere. Its not perfect but this game is just a joy to experience.
Bf1 is by far my favorite, every battle just felt bigger than what it was, especially when the music kicked it.
it felt like a real war all the time
Watching this brings back memories of playing BF1. Can't wait for offical BF2042 gameplay to be shown.
Hello from Ireland 🇮🇪☺
Thursday can’t get here soon enough and Hello from Illinois
The spread, the sponge class pickups, bayonet and melees, suppression, tank snipers, planes, horse mechanics, grenade spam. There was SO much wrong with BF1.
Can’t forget sliding either. Holy shit.
Well actually no, for me it was BF3. But that's just me.
BF1 is solid but BF3 is goat no cap
bf3 aint that good tbh
Battlefield 3 was the perfect sweet spot.
Battlefield 4 Felt Like A Massive "Team Deathmatch."
While Battlefield 1 got boring fast for me.
@@gebrelius7442 I respect your wrong opinion.
Just kidding, it may not be the best, but I really enjoyed the game. So I consider it the best. Mostly because you could switch to team chat and talk to everyone on the team sonce each te had 12 people.
@@FlaminKanami I feel like bf3 was the best balance. I felt like bf4 added too much verticality and too many hiding spots in cluttered maps. Bf3 was a lot flatter and it was easier predict player movement and area to clear before moving.
Battlefield 2042 has been out a few weeks now. Went back to Battlefield 1 and oh boy is it awesome!
It wasnt a perfect game but god damn it was fun
Sadly I couldn't join the Bf community earlier than 2019, but back then I started with Bf 1. And guess what: It absolutely amazed me! I love the WW I setting and the atmosphere. Later I got Bf V and that was no real fun at all... So yeah, I'm still playing Bf 1 daily up to this day! So if anyone searches for someone to game with - just react to this comment :)
I hope we see another bf1 in the future, remastered or something because this was seriously amazing
I am very glad there was no shitty Battle Royale in BF1. Feels like the last real battlefield at the moment. It hit a rarely seen historical period, introduced the well-received Operations game mode, and doesn't need to follow the trends of the Fortnite and Apex bullshit. Battlefield is about the BATTLEFIELD.
This was my first game and was the best I even obligated some of my friends to try it
it will always have a special place in my heart
Same!
was my first battlefield game as well.
You guys are missing out on bad company 2 battlefield 3 and 4 … so sad
@@edgarift Not sad really. BF 2, 3 and 4 are harder to pick up from and has missing (while minimal) gameplay aspects that make it much more frustrating experience.
My first battlefield was BF1 and since a lot of my friends had BF4 I decided to give it a try. The movement is clunky, no vaulting over things that would make sense you could jump and the community is much more of a try hard. I agree with LevelCap here when he said you need a good squad to have a good time in the other BF titles.
Overall, for a new BF player to go from 1 to 4 is a really bad advise.
@@edgarift I’m playing bf4 too
It was the best looking game for sure, hated the weapon physics though.
One of the best, minus getting stuck with the vault animations, spotting enemies thru smoke, op SMG 08 and the damn Heavy Bomber strafes, cinematic masterpiece.
You forgot about the mortar truck, but the game is still amazing despite these
my only problems were getting stuck on random shit, random bullet deviation, grenade spam, and some op weapons.
The planes, the fucking planes
This was the first battlefield campaign that made me cry and the soundtrack gives goosebumps ❤️
Seven Nation Army❤️🔥
I loved the music and graphics, but I couldn’t stand how the weapons worked.
Same
Agreed. So much of what seemed like random bullet deviation.
I liked it
@@maddog063 the random bullet deviation is only there to prevent automatic weapons from being effective at all ranges, so that the classes can be a but more balanced.
@@carrion-fairy and I respect that. But I still feel like the classes were to cookie-cutter: that the roles they had were all they could effectively do.
The BF series has so many iconic and unforgettable moments
Rolling into Karkand for the first time in BF2
Base jumping off Damavand Peak in BF3
Witnessing Shanghai's C-point crumble in BF4
That time the developers said "if you don't like it, don't buy it" in BFV
I didn’t realize how good BF1 was until I played BFV but my favorite is BF3 then 4. I can’t wait for 2042. 👍🏽✌🏽
Ehh I’d say BFV gameplay is superior than BF1
@@enjoi9970 no way. maps and modes are a mess in BFV with very little flow to them. gunplay may be a bit nicer but that's it.
@@bobby_c07 BFV gameplay has the most flow out of any battlefield lol
@@enjoi9970 It may be but I just couldn’t get past the bad visibility. Here’s exactly what I’m talking about. I just hope 2042 is good. 👍🏽✌🏽 th-cam.com/video/sj5mPuShilg/w-d-xo.html
@@Red_AIert I never really had a problem with the visibility. I think it’s much worse in BF4 since the lightning in that game is so dark and bad.
From someone who’s been playing since Battlefield 1943, this is By far my favorite battlefield game
Probably a lot of bf1 players haven't tried bf4/3, so they haven't still felt the real battlefield experience
Bf1 felt like it was made for newcomers
BF1 had the best rag doll effects I’ve ever seen.
BF4 will always remain the best for me but yeah BF1 is good and fun
*"And here i am still, who decides such things?"*
Battlefield 4 was much better imo, but BF1 was still a lot of fun.
it was not better it's just your opinion
@@awesomebrawel4050 it was better thats just your opinion
@@awesomebrawel4050 lol triggered
Bad company 2 was my fav
I think bf4 was a better overall , but I think of way more iconic, memorable and immersive moments in bf1
Nothing gives me goosebumps like this game the second the match starts, the music crescendos, and squad leaders blow their whistles.
BF3 and BF1 are my favorite I miss damavand peak so much
Rush on Grand Bazarr. Love that game.
I agree. BF3 to BF4 was bad IMO because the maps in BF3 were more on the "linear" side. BF4 was just a big map where anyone can go "anywhere" so to speak. It felt like I was playing in a sandbox and there was no progression throughout the match unless it was a map like locker/metro. BF1 comes out and most if not all base maps were linear just like BF3 and I enjoyed it more.
@@Cert1f1edM1dget Totally agree. Coming from Xbox 360 playing BF3 we didn't have the player count PC had. So I played majority rush. Op Metro, Seine Crossing, Grand Bazaar. Great close combat maps. BF4 every map is sandbox which to me was just too aimless. BF1 has sandbox but is directed.
Looking back the gameplay of Battlefield 1 was great. Apart from a very few balancing issues (Mortar Truck and the Ilya Muromets) I never got the feeling I died undeserved in this game, I'm alway like "ah yeah, that was a stupid idea of mine and it immediatly backfired on me" instead of BF2042, where it's just like "what in the world should I have done to prevent dying there?"
I also loved how distinguished the classes are in bf1 and how you really feel like you're changing your playstyle when switching class, how ranged engagements change the mindset depending on which class and gun you're using. The often critizised random bullet deviation/ spread of the guns I also enjoyed. That is mainly due to the fact that I think it is important in order to balance the weapons. In other Battlefield games you can outsnipe a sniper with a machine pistol... in Battlefield 1 you have to be a little smarter than that.
The map design was also amazing. Most of the maps always have enough cover to use to get to your prefered distance of combat. All weapons are useful on almost all maps (alright, maybe a shotgun isn't the best idea to use on Giant's Shadow or Galicia). And tbh Battlefield 2042 made me appreciate how Dice handled wide open maps in BF1, as even maps like Galicia have cover in most places, that can be used even though the map is a giant open mudfield.
I don't wanna focus on it much, as basically the whole world agrees on it, but of course Battlefield 1s atmosphere is the most amazing thing a shooter game ever pulled of in my opinion. From the sounddesign to the voice acting to the musical score, it all comes together perfectly!
Another great point is the vehicle combat (apart from the afore mentioned mortar truck and ilya) as it rewards a more aggressive yet team oriented way of playing. A tank can be easily destroyed by a few assaults and is no invincible powermachine, however if you advance with a few teammates, you can let hell loose on the enemy, as the tanks excell at close quarters combat and if you have a competent tank crew, a tank driver is a key player that can really make an impact on the game as a whole. In BFV tanks seem to be designed for long range, because of their high bullet velocity, high explosive damage and not much bullet drop, but suck at close quarters, since they lack machine gunners all around to cover their sides, resulting in them camping on hills most of the time. In BF2042 the sheer mass of vehicles with no effective way to combat them, make them a nighmare to go up against.
BF1 is my favorite BF by far, such a fun and immersive game. I’d love to see a modern version of Operations in the next BF.
Hmmm, it would work in any of the older conflicts, but war has changed, there is no taking potshots from trench to trench or en-masse assaults on enemy lines.
Very often a soldier can do 2 turns in Afghanistan and never even be in danger.
Nonetheless i TOTALLY agree that they should include this gamemode into the next BF, whether it be 2048 or it's successor.
i'm a true gamer, a gamer to the core. And i quite frankly have to admit that battlefield 1 was really a chapter of its own. No game could do it like they did, its one of those games that had a lot of potential that wasn't all carried out while the game was live but still carried heavy. They made the game so enjoyable and i appreciate that for them.
This was by far my favorite battlefield game. Just an absolute masterpiece.
Sound and visuals are just addictive. When I launch the game after a while I just like to stare at the ocean or the devastated lands. When you just fire a rifle and you hear the echo of the shot for seconds, it's just amazing.
I still play BF1 and it's my favorite BF game.
I love this game. It's one of the few battlefield games that I can say when I play I can feel the love, time, and effort that went into making this game fun and satisfying. It may not have the most maps, weapons or content but it has quality and that's what matters and why I think you can keep coming back to this game and it will feel timeless.
More than 5 years later i still sometimes out of nowhere begin to DUDUM DUM DUDUM DUM DUDUM DUM DUDUM DUM
Yes hahaha
BF1 is easily my favorite fps. The atmosphere and immersion is just unmatched. It's the only fps that actually feels like you're in a war.
I think BF4 is the best for me, aside from BC2 and Modern Combat. I know those are dated, but still. However! I will say this game definitely feels meaty and good, so I can definitely see why you dig it so much! I think this game's soundtrack is basically unmatched though!
I will consider this game Reborn if BF1 assets get featured in Battlefield Portal!
Yes, yes it was. It's the only Battlefield still installed.
Same here, the rest was shit! 👍👍
I swear every minute feels like its own action movie. It's truly a new experience every match
(except when you are a jet pilot then I feel sorry for you for not experiencing the real game)
BF3 was the best for me hands down. If they want this next BF to succeed as the past ones did with the dedicated servers its going to have to have the same feature. Otherwise its going to suffer the same fate being populated with hackers on a mass scale. Give us the option to rent out a server and actively police them.
who else is in love with the war story: The Runner.
Not the best, but definitely fun and chaotic as all hell 😎
What would you say is the best?
@@tetris_cube3397 it's an opinion like everyone can't think ""ooh this game is the best""
I’ve been playing battlefield games since 1942 off and on but BF1 was the game I sank hundreds of hours and completed nearly everything in the game. So much fun
BF1 was hands down one of the best games we’ve got in the last 10 yrs
So you haven't played any other game during those 10 years..hmm.
@@KenzieNakamura dude you really going around in every comment thread huh. It’s almost as if people can have a different opinion than yours, shocking I know.
What I remember about BF1 was that when I unlocked the Martini Henry it became my gun with the most kills by a lot. Even today 8 years later this game is a blast.
I really love it. One of my favourite things in battlefield 1, is the way vehicular combat felt compared to other titles. It all felt punchy. Battlefield V pissed on that with the worst and most inconsistent of all. Guns felt really well. All except for the automatico - which was the smoothbrain gamer guy's go-to. Overall, best feeling gunplay only rivalled by battlefield V's launch TTK. Battlefield 3, 4 and Hardline all play well. But the hit reg & overall feel of guns are way outdated. And I still play the hell out of 4. Hitting a headshot & hearing that ping is really nice.
Hands down the most history-based immersive Battlefield game of all time!
I love Battlefield 1, it's so good
This had so much to chase back in the day of dlc, I’m glad I got to sink my teeth into this game let’s hope for a full battlefield game this winter season
Wishing they will make another ww1 game in the future
No chance considering how many people complain about immersion and realism these days. We won’t see them for probably another 10 years.
@Cy Benevento Do you really think they give a damn about a fictional video game that is designed for entertainment
@Cy Benevento What? Lmao I legit don’t even care what you are saying right now you sound boring to talk to so no thanks
Hoping they never make it part of the BF franchise. Wanna play a WW1 shooter? Cool. Don't waste BF devs on it though, open a new sub-studio and have it produced by a new team. Leave DiceLA to what they do best, modern shooters.
@@enjoi9970 Dude's pissed about historically based games and... black people?
Battlefield 1 is my favorite game of the franchise. Started playing it again this week and it’s been really fun. Unlocked the Peacekeeper, too. It’s good to be back.
The trailer had me in fucking tears it was so good, I still watch it too this day, and maybe it is the best idk I started on BF3, also I still play Bf1 faithfully
I was sleeping on battlefield 1 i bought it on steam sale last week for 9.99 i love it best one of the series
The game was amazing and will always be held dear to my heart. The game may not have been totally accurate to the WW1 era however it did extremely well to immerse yourself into the game and how little you can feel in such a large conflict. Comparing it to battlefield 5 goes to show how a game based on a world war was done right instead of by still making it feel like you were fighting in that war at that time. Was it the best? I would say no but honestly, it's hard to say which battlefield was the best since several were so memorable and great to play. Für Kaiser und Vaterland!
Dude a Battlefield WW1 battle royale set in a massive "no mans land" would have been absolutely amazing. Everyone jumps out of a burning behemoth and parachutes into a wasteland riddled with mud blood gas weapons and bodies
Yes absolutely, BF1 is my number 1
I loved the thematic of this game it felt gritty and that your actually in that time period with the objective names and the announcer. Loved the bits of historical insight on the break through was it can't remember the game mode name
BF1 made me quit battlefield. It was just to slow and boring for me.
1 I think is peak of what a true battlefield is all about. The immersion is just perfect and it looks so stunning. The maps are also really nice.
In terms of atmosphere, feeling like you were in an actual war and fun factor, definitely. But I will say it is interesting to see many TH-camrs now considering this to be the best BF when it was criticized by them heavily for its lack of progression and gunplay.
The only game i will never uninstall from my PC.
id say bf1 was most definitely the best
I upgraded GPU and monitor and when I loaded up BF1 I was blown away just how visually pleasing this game is. It really is a work of art.
BF1 is an excellent casual solo game. Not so fun with friends, I feel like every just goes off doing their own thing and don't work together that much. BF3 was so good with team play.
Headshots with the Martini Henry is one of the most satisfying things I’ve ever done in gaming!
Of course with stock iron sights.
4:43 Be careful what you wish for I guess. DICE has now decided to become EA’s favourite child and implement so many shitty cashgrab mechanics into the newest Battlefield that it now feels more like a Warzone clone with absolutely no passion for what the game once used to be. I’m so glad they didn’t listen to you and didn’t implement shitty battle Royale into this game. Hopefully they recollect their brains for the next release
Agreed. not every game needs a shitty BR mode.
The music and overall atmosphere in BF1 is second to none.
lol he thought battlefield 2042 was gonna be good
Short answer yes. Long answer FUCK YES!
Gunplay at launch was absolutely abysmal in my opinion, I only played for a couple months because of this.
At launch? It’s still the same today
@@enjoi9970 I quit the game a couple months in so I really wouldn’t no. I don’t get the hype around it, gunplay really is utterly terrible with RNG spread or whatever you want to call it. I just grinded until I got that OP assault class AR then quit after that got boring. I even find BF5 (in the state it’s in now more fun) TBH.
@@user-fn5xg7qt7u Well, BF5 I consider one of the best battlefields anyways so many great core mechanics in that game
@@enjoi9970 core mechanics such as?
@@Person-el3sf Movement, gunplay, attrition, reinforcements, fortifications, squad play, manual healing, no more 3D spotting button, no more random recoil spread, more more grenade spam, no more cheese gadgets, no more vehicle spam, etc.
Thats song....you know which one... it hits you hard when she sings that beautiful melody... then you realize the sacrifice these men made...
It’s a fact that battlefield 1 is a masterpiece
Absolutely amazing soundtrack. Great sound design. Hearing the whistle and "going over the top" to the next objective was a great feeling. I felt incredibly in the moment every time.