2024 NFL Draft Quarterback Rankings | This Is A VERY Controversial Quarterback Class
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 มิ.ย. 2024
- Join Ultimate Autograph's today with code FIRST15 to get 15% off your first order here: ultimateautographs.com/pages/...
Grading The 2022 NFL Draft Two Years Later (Picks 1-16):
• Grading The 2022 NFL D...
TWITTER: / fballanalysisyt
DISCORD:
/ discord
TIKTOK: vm.tiktok.com/ZMe5NbVa7/
Welcome to the Football Analysis TH-cam channel! Subscribe for all NFL related content! Drop a like if you enjoyed the video as all support is very much appreciated! Thanks for watching!
#nfl #nflfootball #football #nfldraft - กีฬา
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.76[1/2] โจโฉเปิดป่าโหดรับโอ๊ต-ป๊อบ รอบนี้พี่เอาจริง!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pNg5O7Pf-a0/mqdefault.jpg)
Join Ultimate Autograph's today with code FIRST15 to get 15% off your first order here: ultimateautographs.com/pages/live-break?ref=footballanalysis
Can you please do a video of draft sleepers - like dudes that may fall to round 4 5 6 or even 7 that have big nfl potential?
There are NFL teams that have Jayden as the number 1 QB in the draft. Didn't want to mention that, did we?
Love the idea of Ultimate Autographs - thanks for the code to try it
As a video idea You should also Rank the Top CornerBacks in this class there’s so many exciting Corners that are good in there own unique way
This dude makes eating and watching youtube perfect
I try hahaha glad to hear
@@FootballAnalysis1 I always look forward to your videos man. Glad to see your account getting the attention it deserves
Fsfs
Fr haha the secret sauce
That’s exactly what I’m doing
0:00 intro
0:34 Bo Nix
3:41 Michael Penix
7:04 merch
8:13 JJ McCarthy
11:20 Jayden Daniels
14:52 Drake Maye
18:15 Caleb Williams
My favorite thing about your videos is even if i dont agree with a statement you make, you provide it in a way to challenge my thoughts. A lot of guys make baseless statements for clicks, ive never once watched a video and questioned whether or not you did your due diligence to form your opinion. I hope one day i create a space for fellow fans the way you have provided for us here. Even the other commenters are always in much more positive of a mindset when we talk about stuff in the comments, i always feel like we’re all listening to each other rather than take heads off cause we dont agree. Please dont sleep on what you are building here man, you are just as much “sports media” as the guys in suits on ESPN, keep doing you!
Dude I appreciate this more than you know truly
As a Raiders fan, i really don't want a 1st round QB, unless we massively trade down, which i wouldn't want. Our insiders are thinking a very small chance they take a 1st round QB. It's what the mainstream media wants them to do.
Minshew is your guy. It wouldn’t make sense for them to draft a QB
@@devinshearer7523Minshew is not our guy, he will start, but, trust me Raiders will be back with a top 15 pick
Nah we should trade down, swap 1st this year and 3rd this year, 1st next year, grab Newton at DT to simply add, go OT, CB (McKinstry if he’s there), and maybe Wr or LB
Minshew is a top 32 QB in the league. Is he in the 25-32 range? Yes, but still. @@user-hg4hz1lx2h
@@devinshearer7523like at all?
I trust the Washington receiving corps more than most for whichever qb they pick. They have scary terry, who leads the league in contested catches and has had 4 1000 yard receiving years in a row, even with poor qb play. They also have Jahan Dotson, who was tied for most rookie receiving touchdowns, just signed Zach Ertz, and can easily draft another WR with one of their second round picks. I trust that if Jaden or Drake wind up going there, they’re not walking into the same situation as Bryce young did. Both them and also the bears for that matter, are trying to give them the best situation possible.
Bears..
Chicago has much better weapons than Washington
@@ceezy585I mean is that wrong?😂
Bro really doesn’t want Maye to go to the Pats and is praying his Vikings get a shot 😂
lol pats are in a rebuild mode vikes just need a qb we have the best wr duo in the nfl patriots need everything 😂😂
@@joshuawilliams2447well you can’t have it all now can you 😂 you got the best wr core with no qb. NE will have the qb of the future with nothing else. You can have one but not both lol
@@Krispydounut dude 😂patriots have no good players on there squad and vikes got the 11th pick and 23rd so if we don’t trade with pats we still have the chargers and cardinals to trade with to get our qb 🤷🤷🤦♂️
Yeah I think that's true but his analysis that Maye would be better served in MN is very likely correct.
@@joshuawilliams2447 enjoy JJ McCarthy
Although Penix had a low downfield throw accuracy, he threw a significantly larger number of deep balls, which skews the stat.
thats what i always tell people
bro on the copuim
Ah yes, having an even larger sample size means we should ignore that he is pretty inaccurate downfield
Doesn’t really change the point? 💀
@@lordshaxx2024that’s not how accuracy percentage works and you know that. Don’t be slow
nice video man, this qb class can become the best or the worst
Cant get worse than 1999 2022
already basically guaranteed to be better than 2022's qb class
Reminds me a lot of 2018 QB class with Baker, Darnold, Rosen, Allen, and Lamar. I think the results will fare similar.
Thank you!
Love your truthful assessments but still keep it positive.
I’ve been a big proponent about how QBs use anticipating with reads and throwing on time or even before a cut and CJ Shroud has proven that worth for rookies. I’d be interested to hear about the anticipation abilities for the QBs in this class
I just can't compare any rookie prospects to CJ Stroud. He's an alien in terms of how separated he was from rookie quarterbacks and I think it could be decades before anyone comes in and plays at that level from day one. Not that there's nothing to learn from his draft profile, I just think there was so much more there that wasn't visible on tape.
I would like to see you and That Franchise Guy on a pod talkin pre draft ball. Marcus is one of a kind and your analysis is hearty and thorough.
Spencer rattler and Travis would be cool to breakdown as well they can be better than some other guys!
FA, you never let me down. I appreciate all the consistent, high quality content.
Thank you so much!
Great Work Gare 💯
Thank you gentlemen 🫡
This was 🔥 do WRs nxt
Didn’t he already do that?
you should do this for db your videos are great
W Video and keep up the great content
Thank you!
🔥 vid
I feel like penix definitely has touch especially on deep balls but that’s a correct assessment for jj
Yeah I disagree that he can't regulate his balls. He throws a lot of fastballs, yes, but that's because that is genuinely more advantageous, for your pass to arrive as quickly as possible. Only some seam shots, deep balls and corner/post routes can require touch, with most throws the quicker the ball gets there the better. And I saw a lot of good things by Penix on those routes.
Great breakdown Homie !!! Rookie QB’s could be successful only if the team they get drafted too has all the correct personnel in place. ( OL,WR,RB,TE and OC)
Thank you!
Minnesota has it all except iol but that can be fixed this draft too 😩
@@alvinkemboi5898 if McCarthy can be a viking he will be an absolute DAWG. mark my words.
Not true. If you can play you can play no matter what. If it was true you just need a supporting cast then every back up qb on a good team should be amazing.
I totally agree with your viewpoint. When a quarterback is the best guy he's likely to go to the worst situation that will either make him a hero or because of his own failings or just a bad organization a bust
I love this QB class, and i'm very excited to see where they go and how they play. However, i've gotten to the point where I don't feel confident about any NFL prospect until I see them play in the NFL. I think all of these guys are good, but I don't know how well any of them will transition.
Jj doesn’t have that much touch cuz if u look at his throws down field he drags his back leg
Are they any good rbs in this draft, need to know for my dynasty league 😂
Drake: “Positives far outweigh the bad”👀
Highlight him for playmaking and then blame his line for him not moving and throwing an INT. Middle of field high and behind tipped pass turned into a long TD and you give him accuracy credit. 🤣
Noti gang
❤️
Man even though I do not watch NFL beside playoffs, I watch almost every video on the chanel
Penix also compared to the other 5 qbs when he was pressured his accuracy was the worst compared to the other top qbs in this class
I like Penix a lot.
Great video, but i'm curious as to why having a loaded WR core and throwing to open guys are negatives for both Nix and Penix but not Jayden Daniels? IMO JD5 has benefited from his WR core the most. A lot of Nabers tape is him being wide open for TDs. and both of his WRs are projected 1st rounders, 1 being a top 10 pick.
Bo can't throw!
@@bigfootwalker5399you’re smoking crack jit
FR Malik Nabers might actually be better than Marv
The daniels hype is insane. Look for Thomas or Nabers they’re most likely open if not run. And his weak arm will be picked off.
Daniels is insanely overhyped. He padded his stats like crazy and threw to open WRs and all the sudden he's a can't miss prospect. He's going to get the coach and GM that drafts him fired in two years.
Penix has the best arm. He throws his WRs open
lmaoo you hit on all the draft predictions 😂
As a raiders fan we need to address the DBs room and Alabama Arnold is the way we need to go to address the gaping wholes in our secondary
Any insight into Nix’s (and others) attitude? i.e. we don’t need another Johnny Football…. Thanks for your videos! 👍
@@BludMunyeah because he left their garage school for a school none of those guys could get into😂😂
One of Nix's biggest upsides is apparently his personality. Apparently he's a great leader and such
Football content is good, but what's up with the background music? I've been meaning to ask for a while now, cause it always takes me out of the video and makes me think I'm listening to SMT-IV demon negotiations or something.
It’s pretty hilarious. I’ve been meaning to say something too.
?
@@FootballAnalysis1Whatever background music you having going on turns to like gothic cathedral/boss fight music. I for one, am not complaining :)
i feel like daniels has so much going against him but the idea of washington drafting him gets me so much more excited than drake maye
The days where a QB sits for a year learning seems to be long gone, but think it would be beneficial for several of these guys comin out
I know the word rn is Maye for Washington at #2, but I would LOVE it if they traded down and drafted Nix or Penix mid - late first. I feel like we could use a second this season to upgrade the O and D line 🤷🏽♂️ and Ik it’s probably a bad take but for some reason I just don’t like Jaden as a QB. Ik the LSU qb became a SUPERSTAR, but I think his size, arm strength, and his WRs make me doubt him.
Oregon ducks play screens alot to open up deep balls. Hes able to make those throws as well if you watched him enough. He doesnt have a absolute cannon but he can throw the ball as deep as you would ever want your QB to
Maye has a lot of upside but while he has rushing ability there’s times he’s very stiff in the pocket and he has pretty bad footwork which is important - also I feel like his processing ability isn’t amazing but that could be because unc sucks. If he goes to Minnesota he’ll succeed , if he goes anywhere else he’ll struggle if he doesn’t sit a year
If Jordan Travis is healthy and goes to a decent team he should do great
Size doesn't matter much bc I'm betting the NFL is going to put flags on QBs soon
Love how high quality this video was. Great work.
Thank you Joey!
Dude has a hard on for Drake Maye to the Vikings😅.
Unless the Vikings send a kings ransom to either the commies or the pats, there's no way he's going to the Vikings.
As a Patriots fan I will take either Williams, Maye or Daniel’s but nobody knows what will happen. If you are talented enough to be a top 3 pick then then you have immense potential so you just don’t know. But it’s fun to talk about 🤙🏈
Caleb is throwing off some manly execs.
we know what happened last time scouts doubted an oregon qb wearing the #10
Drake Maye is coming to to New England, The Mayeflower will set sail!
Interesting
What you said about Jayden or jj not going to bad situations is the exact situation that Mac Jones went into yet no one says anything about that!
Yeah but Mac is garbage
Yes I like NC AND MICHIGAN QB . I would wait till draft day before I trade up if I VIKINGS. There are three to 5 good qb they NC and MICHIGAN may be gone 1 and two then I would pick with the 11th a qb
1.caleb williams
2. Jayden Daniels
3. Drake maye
4. Bo nix
5. Michael penix
6. JJ McCarthy
Given that at best 50% will workout give me Williams maye and Penix.
@JJ-zr6fu if a player skips his Bowl Game, Combine and refuses certain workouts, then what does that say about his attitude? Red flag. The NFL is a meat grinder. If things get difficult these players will become disinterested
@@elscruffomcscruffy8371 You talking about Williams? He skipped the bowl game so his back up to secure the starting job next year and not have a QB competition. What workouts at the combine are going to tell me anything about williams I have the tape he can play QB. I don't care if he can jump a river or out run a rabbit.
JJ will be top 2-3 of qbs drafted...KOC will get the most out of him...like cousins..dobbs..mullens...plus none of those qbs will have the weapons the Vikings will...jj..addison..aaron Jones...prettygood oline with great LT and RT..hockenson...
Give Maye 2 more years in college and similar weapons to Danial’s and he would be the top prospect in this draft.
Jayden Danial’s was just another QB after his 1st 2 years
That’s dumb logic, you could say the thing for Trey Lance. Fact is they didn’t. Joe Burrow was a 5 year QB & is still elite.
@@donjohnson2758 I'm not saying the guys who played 3, 4 or 5 years are not elite obviously, I'm saying when you are projecting a QB prospect who is 21 and 2 years experience in college to someone who is 24 with 5 years experience in college you are going to project a different ceiling for them. if hooker and benson from last years draft were in their 1st or 2nd year as sophomores like Young and stroud with the stats they had as seniors they would have been top 10 picks but they didn't so 3rd 4th round in the draft. if we can't agree then that's dumb
Put maye at osu bama Washington and it’s not even close that he’s the second best.
Gang gang
Can’t wait to see Caleb in Chicago bro already a superstar
😂😂😂
As a Bears fan I’m excited too. But I’m not counting my chickens before they hatch. He needs to prove on the field that he’s the guy.
OVerRATed
Caleb is gonna be a bust!
You said a lot of things I saw watching these guys. Especially Nix, Penix, and McCarthy. The summation of Nix was on point. He has upside to be a good NFL starter and has more talent than people realize. I think you didn't cover a couple things Penix has to work on, and I generally disagree about him not throwing with touch unless we're talking intermediate throws. That's where I could see some of that criticism. This is definitely a thing with McCarthy, and I believe a lot the private workout with Minnesota is going to be about throwing routes different ways. Working on the timing of throws on specific routes as well. McCarthy's highlights are impressive though. Agreed. As I watched him play, and he progressed a ton from '22 to '23, I realized that all of the hype about him having a weak arm was mostly false. He drives the shit out of the ball. Problem is downfield timing and location. That's what made people think he has a weak arm, I think. You could make a 4 hour video breaking these guys down though, and there's a lot to talk about. I think you did a pretty good job providing a general synopsis.
Joe Milton to me has the chance to be best in this class with some time and coaching up.
Would Denver select either MPJ or Bo Nix in 1st round ? #NFL
There is no guarantee that any of the top 3 will trade down and there is little hope for the vikings of getting a top qb😢
Jj mcarthy going to the saints is the most ideal. Sit behind Derek carr cause of the contract for a year and then start.
Lets say Commanders take Marvin, I think Pats should trade down a couple spots for another team to take drake, we get the 5th pick lets say and 2 other firsts, we trade a first for like pick 15, we come out the draft with JD and Rome. I would love this but man I think the bears kinda screwed this type scenario, and yes I am a delusional Pats fan that also likes sum other teams, fight me.
I guess you don't think anything of Jordan Travis. He's always seemed like a good project
The question is will this Quarterback class be more like 2020 or 2021
rankings: 1. Caleb, 2. Jayden, 3. JJ, 4. Penix, 5. Drake May.
I worry about character issues with caleb
I really want Maye to be a Viking
so burrow relied on chase and jj.....stroud relied on olave, jaxon smith njigba and harrison.....but then how is it a knock it penix trusts he receivers and puts the ball consistently where his receivers can make a play????
every good qb has good weapons when it comes to college football
Bo Nix: Journeyman’s name.
Michael Penix Jr: Dude that’s on three teams in four years. Becomes a lifer as a 3rd stringer.
JJ: Some how Tom Brady II.
Daniels: Solid starter.
Drake Maye: Should be drafted as a backup for Miami in five years.
Caleb: Possibly a Leaf sized bus or football Jesus. No in-between.q
This post will age like milk
JJ “Zach Wilson” McCarthy
JJ “smart player” McCarthy
@@yes-it-is-ilol delusional
I'm so glad I'm not a fan of the team taking williams lol I just don't see the hype around him , he has great skill but something is missing , personally when I watch him I just do not see a franchise QB and on top of that I do not see a leader , I get taking him at 1 but I would be losing sleep knowing I'm tying my job to this player. He will make great plays and will help the bears to be better than they been but I also believe it will be a constant amount of BS and he will more or less be the new OBJ but OQBJ
Drake Maye is this years Zach Wilson. Book it.
Depends where he goes and if they sit him, Zach has possibly more talent than Maye, but he went to possibly the worst situation a qb could go to for his first 3 years.
Naw. He's better
Wtf, not even close to the same player, Drake Maye is 10x the athlete Zach is, bigger, and had more success against tougher competition, Mcarthy is the nezt Zach Wilson if anything
@@Kyle-bi7df I think JJ will have a better career. We can revisit this in a year if we remember.
Drake Maye is the next Daniel Jones, he made that comp and it's insanely accurate. I don't think he'll be quite as bad as Zach Wilson, he has a lot more tools, brings an element to the ground game which limits his floor, etc. But I think hell be, at best, an incredibly average or slightly below average quarterback.
Sam Hartman. Jewell for the future.
Besides age and injury history, there is no world that Penix is not better than McCarthy, you talk about the team around Penix but look at JJ, best Oline, and RB duo in the nation with solid WRs. Put Bo Nix on Michigan and they still win it all. I don’t get your points
Let’s revisit this to see who’s right…
1:20 WTF?! How was he not the Heisman. Those numbers are mind boggling. Videogame numbers!
Penix (i think) and jd3 had better numbers
@@Aburner960agreed
@@Aburner960plus JD3 did it in the SEC
Nix didn’t win the Heisman because he couldn’t beat Washington, I’m fairly certain if he did he would have made the playoffs, and effectively jumped Pennix and JD3. But he didn’t, and therefore didn’t deserve to win
If Jordan Travis had not broken his leg I wonder what people would be saying about him?!
JJ is only good when he has the entire defensive line chasing him.
Bo Nix later in the day to Chicago after the trade back okay
Why does no one talk about Austin Reed. Dude can seriously ball.
We see you, Mrs. Reed!
@@thevoxdeus have you seen his tape or are you just being contrarian. I’m not saying he’s a top 5 QB. But dude has the potential to be Kirk Cousins.
I’m not even kidding when I say this, WHO???😂😂😂
@@Kyle-bi7dfwestern kentucky QB, was one of the best FCS QBs at UWF
@@ligmaemperor7064😂😂
Nix and Penix are older than Trey Lance… Just a thought
“Soencer Rattler”
Not tryna hate and hope for the best for him but Michael penix is like Jamis winston
Penix threw a significantly more amount of balls downfield
This account is made to watch while taking a sht or eating lol
I should take that as a compliment right...? 🤣
Jalen hurts be good support for Drake may
Is his surname really Penix ?
Daniels has BUST written all over him. Take it to the bank. He benefits the most from two WR 1s and a good LSU line this year. Mark My Words
lol did u watch Penix at Indiana bro 🤡💀because da same thing he was doing in Washington he was doing in Indy with no receivers 🤦🏾♂️idk how u got that notion that he was heavily relying on those Washington WRs when he was doing da same in Indy with no WRs
Going to MN is not a good situation for JJ McCarthy, not if he needs time to develop. MN is going to have to trade a huge chunk of draft capitol and players to move up to get him and QBs like this are expected to play right away. Even if Sam Darnold starts, Sam Darnold is going to what Sam Darnold does, stink up the joint and the fans will be calling for McCarthy to start within 2-3 games. He's not getting time in MN.
Yep
lol u know nothing he will succeed with the best wr in jj and Jordan Addison plus he has a good rb duo in jones and chandler 😂😂stop yapping
Everyone sleeping on penix
minnesota ain’t getting drake maye 😹💀
Not impossible
Lol
They might trade up
It’s more possible than you think, they didn’t trade for the Texans first round pick just to settle there, I believe it’s more than just possible to believe they will use their two first round picks to potentially trade up with the patriots (which at this point they really just need more picks and the quality of them matters less)
@@Xcite343.-.Patriots need QB the most, they aren’t going to trade down no matter what you might think, nobody passes on their franchise QB, Vikings just want to jump the Giants for Mcarthy
Talk about joe milton.
"Penix is to reliant to throw to his WRs." The dumbest take Ive ever heard.😂😂
Williams is so hyped by the media if he doesn’t take win roty and take the Bears into the postseason it is going to be a failed season.
he’s hyped by the media just like every other star player? he doesn’t need to win roty to show he’s a good player
I hope Denver picks Bo.
please vikes draft jj
I'm calling Drake Maye & Jaden Daniel's being bust.
I'm not sure if I agree with your analysis of JJ mccarthy, it wasn't all bad but it wasn't entirely accurate as well so I don't know whose eyes you were filtering your statistics through which are not the only way to greet a quarterback, you have to understand the game of football and understand how it's played today instead of superimposing metrics from a different type of quarterback on to a new style of quarterback play that has been in college for over 10 years now therefore because it hasn't shown any sign of dissipating, must be the way the game is played today, alternatively...
I have to say I'm about 50/50 any analysis of JJ McCarthy
There's some stuff I flat-out agree with... And there's some stuff I flat out disagree with.
Bo Nix is a Patriot. Drake Maye is a NY Giant
Wish the bears draft Jayden