Heck, I'd like to see an extended episode that's dedicated to a bunch of one-off characters like Boulder, Thumper, Derek, S.C. Ruffey, and the Brake Van.
It always confused me in the classic series how most Diesels we’re described as rude and disrespectful when only Diesel, Arry and Bert were the only ones who never changed.
I think it's largely an artifact of Awdry's early portrayal of diesels since he was against the dieselfication of the BR, and in the early periods there were quite a few reasonable complaints, which can largely be summed up as "if it ain't broke, don't fix it", thus he initially portrayed them all in a more negative light.
When I was little watching the diesels seemed a lil scary or they kinda appeared intimidating especially the really big ones like class 40 and diesel 10
@@AdmiralBlackstar Also most of the diesels Awdry conceived of just didn't appear in the TV series, most of the negative depictions of diesels from the railway series didn't appear in the show, although oddly enough Bear never appeared either despite him being one of the nice diesels in the original books.
3:32 how they had an entire episode where rusty goes to a place filled with train corpses and an echoing voice and never used the horrified face surprises me.
Fun fact: in an episode of season 12 rusty's large model appeared with the smaller face, I think it's a second model because the bigger model has the bigger face,
Love the content, TTTE was my childhood and seeing the back story of it is awesome. Maybe if you get bored or run out of engines maybe do the Troublesome Trucks or other vehicles like Bertie. If there is anything about them that is. Keep it up!
Finally I always thought that Midlander was two different engines because I’ve never seen it talked about that the engine received a new radiator and I must admit I do agree that I prefer the older one.
The last part "the Small scale model of Rusty's last appearance was in Calling all engine in Thomas's dream sequence" was added by me on the Wikia because that bit of Info was missing.
I’d like to see what’s the background information about Fergus, his model was so unique to me when I was a kid. Fergus also has some of the most interesting episodes as well
What's great about both Rusty and Duncan, is they play off each other really well, and it's great to put them in the same episode, like Duncan gets spooked.
Enby TVS Rusty confirmed!!!! I always got that vibe from them, even before I properly understood what nonbinary was, but I thought it was only ever headcannon. Britt, my respect for you just increased a decent chunk. The only thing that I don't love about the RWS cannon is the very mid 20th century lack of gender representation, and it's nice to see that Britt at least tried.
I've been building a 16mm scale Midlander (going to be a different engine though), but good lord - finding close up shots of the details was a real pain in the backside. Still, my hand sculpting skills for making it proper controls from scratch is on point.
At 6:09, I thought you said ‘…horror model railway museum…’ and I believed you were talking about Drayton Manor lol Good to know Rusty isn’t, in fact, trapped there.
Can I just say that Train Boy admitting that Put Upon Percy is one of his All Time Favourite Episodes makes me very happy. I’ve always had a soft spot for that episode and to see such a big name recognise this underrated episode as a Personal Favourite just makes my Day. Also, what happened to the Large Scale Model’s Buffer Beam in the Thumbnail?
I sort of wish this was brought up (or if we know, was Rusty the most reliable of the O-Scale models? I ask because Rusty has no coupling rods. Since most of these videos give me the impression that it was those that caused the most problems.
Greg Tiernan left before Duncan was animated! 2012 was his last year with Thomas and friends so using Duncan (reintroduced in 2014) as an example is not fair.
Ah fair point; in that case I wish his ideology was kept from that point forward. Seeing that Duncan was a major blow to my respect for the CGI series.
I just stumbled across your channel, and boy, do I love your videos! Especially this one. As a kid, I _always_ saw Rusty as feminine-of-center (even despite the male pronouns), and it was kind of amazing to get actual confirmation that this wasn't just in my head!
Many years ago, I remember being on the old Microsoft Train Simulator official forums, when the discussion came up about Rusty, and the other narrow gauge trains. One of the forum members was a friend of the Awdry family, and wrote a letter (yes, with pen and paper) to Christopher Awdry asking questions about the trains. Christopher, at the time, helping in the construction of the various trains. In one of the letters, Christopher referred to Rusty as "She". This started a long argument back and forth, with the forum member writing yet another letter, and encouraging Christopher to chime in on things himself if he could. Christopher stated that his father, Rev Awdry, always described Rusty to him as being a female character, and noted that the name "Rusty" was unisex enough to work both for male, or female. Christopher noted that the first time Rusty was called male, was actually with the Britt Allcroft series, which Awdry was greatly annoyed by. Reportedly, Awdry himself brought this problem up with Allcroft, who told the Reverend that the show was being marketed more toward young boys, and not girls, and thus having a locomotive that was a girl wouldn't work. Besides, there were already two female locomotives (Daisy and Mavis), and correcting the error was just going to push production back, as they'd already recorded the voice-overs where Rusty was called "He". Interestingly, Allcroft did seem to acquiesce to Awdry's thoughts on the character, to some degree, by having Starr (the first narrator), affect a slightly feminine voice when voicing Rusty. In the end, though, the whole thing became moot, as by the time that any changes may have been made, viewers were accustomed to seeing Rusty as male, regardless of what the original creator thought. Note: The letters back and forth were scanned and uploaded to the forums. This all took place around 2001, shortly after MSTS released.
Ever since I heard that Rusty was supposed to be non gender specific, it feels weird hearing "he/him" pronouns for it. Those pronouns just don't sound right for Rusty in my opinion.
I just always thought Rusty was a guy when I was a kid even though Rusty was never even referred to as male in the show. Pretty sure his wooden railway card uses she/her. I always thought Skarloey, Rheneas, Stepney, Culdee and Rickety were female as a kid too. I still sometimes forget that Rickety is supposed to be a male character.
Voted Slate Trucks, but not disappointed, and actually very satisfied. Edit: if you look at Rusty’s cab and wonder why it’s only open on one side, all of the Talyllyn stations are on the right side of the track so you only needed one door and much of the Coaches are locked shut on one side because only one side needed to be able to open. I haven’t visited the Talyllyn yet, and I’ve only heard about this a while back.
He is painted orange because of his name - in a story in the 1997 Thomas The Tank Engine and Friends annual, Rusty told James that he was named after his paint which is rusty orange.
This is the third time I'm asking for Sir Topham Hatt's Car and it's models. I also saw Cranky on the last poll so Cranky would also be a good one too.
Could you do a story video about how come Japan and the Hara model railway who have a large collection of items from the tv series. How did they get them and why
I always joked about how Rusty is the first engine to get plastic surgery on his face because of the much bigger the large scale models face was in season 5 onwards XD
When I was a kid I was unsure if Rusty was a boy or a girl. For the longest time I thought I was just dumb as a child for not realizing he was male, but now i know Rusty's ambiguous gender was intentional. Learn something new everyday.
It was an attempt to make him gender neutral but the show eventually passed on it and let him stay male. And personally I think we shouldn't change a character like that and instead make a new one. Thats like making a white character black and claiming you solved Racism.
Not to be pedantic, but CNC stands for Computer Numeric Control. So the machine that was used to make the chassis was computer controlled. Still definitely custom machined, but thats not what CNC means. I have enjoyed your videos a lot, keep up the hard work.
CNC also refers to a type of motor that’s custom machined, you’re very right but it has another meaning too I suppose in another area haha. Thank you man! www.heidenhain.us/resources-and-news/servo-motors-for-cnc-machines/
So, I think we are talking about the same thing, kind of, CNC machine tools (such as a mill) use those motors controlled by a computer to move the work piece, the machine head, or both. There are commercial industrial applications for CNC machining because of their reliability and repeatability with little opportunity for operator error, as well as in smaller shops for prototyping and custom work because one can go from a computer modeled design to the physical end result with ease.
Can I get a Dennis history video? It would probably be shorter than Murdoch, but I don't care. Maybe do a double feature? Take two small characters that appeared only once each and smoosh them together. I can only hope...
I remember when I first watched "Tuneful Toots" on TV, I was like "Rusty's a girl!" For that point for a while, I passed off Rusty as being a girl. It was around that time that I had noticed that Rusty was never referred to as any gender pronouns in the show prior to that point, which was something I never even noticed until after watching Tuneful Toots. When Rusty was referred to as a male in Season 10, I was like "So now he's a boy? Make up your mind." Eventually, I adjusted to Rusty being male again from that point onward. I had no idea that Rusty was intentionally never referred to by gender-specific pronouns in the classic series.
Its a Pity we never got a Rusty Centered Story in CGI. I kinda like rusty a lot but I don't understand the whole Gender Neutral thing or why his Season 5 onwards model had a freakishly huge Face.
Rusty is an interesting character for sure. While I don't really like the larger scale Narrow Gauge models for having faces completely different from their smaller scale counterparts, Rusty is an outlier for having a gargantuan face on top of the different expressions. Still, the large engines are pretty good shape wise at least. Also I always liked that Rusty was gender neutral and kinda wish that stayed. Rather nice representation for those who are Non-Binary.
Rusty is one of the kindest engines on the Island. I love Rusty as a character, he's very kind, and the way Duncan behaved towards Rusty in the early episodes was disgusting. Apart from Edward, Rusty is up there as being the most kindest, and caring for passengers, and he always works hard.
I know this may seem silly...but how about a history of "boulder" from Rusty and the Boulder, would be fun to know that story.
That would be pretty cool. Always wondered why the boulders face looked like gordans
Heck, I'd like to see an extended episode that's dedicated to a bunch of one-off characters like Boulder, Thumper, Derek, S.C. Ruffey, and the Brake Van.
@@jamesytsigros4086 cuz it is gordon
@@sandradjordjevic231 so you’re saying that Gordon can shapeshift?
@@FishHarbor he always dose that
I, also, take it that rusty's small scale model was the best running of the SKR locomotives
I mean without the side rods the others could run fine
yeah
@@OfficialTrainzGod I knew it
It always confused me in the classic series how most Diesels we’re described as rude and disrespectful when only Diesel, Arry and Bert were the only ones who never changed.
Yeah. For nice diesels, we had Daisy, boco, mavis, rusty, and derek. They far outnumber the bad diesels.
I think it's largely an artifact of Awdry's early portrayal of diesels since he was against the dieselfication of the BR, and in the early periods there were quite a few reasonable complaints, which can largely be summed up as "if it ain't broke, don't fix it", thus he initially portrayed them all in a more negative light.
@@TheGoombaFromNowhere And in CGI we got even more nice diesels.
When I was little watching the diesels seemed a lil scary or they kinda appeared intimidating especially the really big ones like class 40 and diesel 10
@@AdmiralBlackstar Also most of the diesels Awdry conceived of just didn't appear in the TV series, most of the negative depictions of diesels from the railway series didn't appear in the show, although oddly enough Bear never appeared either despite him being one of the nice diesels in the original books.
Nitrogen Studios: "Every detail was carefully reproduced in CGI."
Also Nitrogen Studios: 7:53
To be fair to Nitrogen, Duncan wasn’t rendered in cgi by them; instead, he was built from scratch by Arc Productions
@@lknmjh good point
And Douglas was under overhaul at the time.
Douglas was under overhaul and thus they had to forgo Duncan, and Arc had to model him from scratch
Boy did we pay the price for it
That was Arc productions my dude. Nitrogen didn’t provide the animation for the brenner era nor the newer assets 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
3:32 how they had an entire episode where rusty goes to a place filled with train corpses and an echoing voice and never used the horrified face surprises me.
Fun fact: in an episode of season 12 rusty's large model appeared with the smaller face, I think it's a second model because the bigger model has the bigger face,
0:37 " Send Rusty packing! Send Rusty packing!
-Best line of Duncan
I honestly like the narrow gauge trains. It's neat to see the scale variance.
They are called Engines trains are what they pull.
Love the content, TTTE was my childhood and seeing the back story of it is awesome. Maybe if you get bored or run out of engines maybe do the Troublesome Trucks or other vehicles like Bertie. If there is anything about them that is. Keep it up!
Finally I always thought that Midlander was two different engines because I’ve never seen it talked about that the engine received a new radiator and I must admit I do agree that I prefer the older one.
IIRC the current radiator came from Indian Runner. No idea why they swapped shapes honestly.
Fun Fact that’s not very fun: S12 actually fixed Rusty’s oversized face issue, only for CGI to go RIGHT back to it.
THEY CAN’T MAKE UP THEIR MINDS!
The last part "the Small scale model of Rusty's last appearance was in Calling all engine in Thomas's dream sequence" was added by me on the Wikia because that bit of Info was missing.
Very cool!
8:15 fun fact, they did actually take some design choices from the rebuilt Midlander. Like Rusty chassis design, and he has vents on the side.
That’s very interesting at 2:03. When I was a kid I didn’t know if rusty was a boy or a girl.
I’d like to see what’s the background information about Fergus, his model was so unique to me when I was a kid. Fergus also has some of the most interesting episodes as well
What's great about both Rusty and Duncan, is they play off each other really well, and it's great to put them in the same episode, like Duncan gets spooked.
Rusty certainly helps to humble Duncan, that’s for sure.
Rusty is one of my favorite diesel engines!! Rusty is for sure a gem, especially since he saved Stepney from scrap!!
I'm a simple man, I see a TrainBoy video, I press like.
Enby TVS Rusty confirmed!!!!
I always got that vibe from them, even before I properly understood what nonbinary was, but I thought it was only ever headcannon. Britt, my respect for you just increased a decent chunk. The only thing that I don't love about the RWS cannon is the very mid 20th century lack of gender representation, and it's nice to see that Britt at least tried.
Love your videos man! Legit love learning more about the narrow gauge engines!
By the way Sir Handel Is my favorite :)
My favorite narrow guage engine! About time you did Rusty!
Rusty is one of my favorite engines of all time, and I am glad you finally covered him.
Train boy: * uploads *
Me: *"FINALLY SOME DELICIOUS FUCKING CONTENT!"*
Love coming home to a trainboy video
I've been building a 16mm scale Midlander (going to be a different engine though), but good lord - finding close up shots of the details was a real pain in the backside. Still, my hand sculpting skills for making it proper controls from scratch is on point.
At 6:09, I thought you said ‘…horror model railway museum…’ and I believed you were talking about Drayton Manor lol
Good to know Rusty isn’t, in fact, trapped there.
Can I just say that Train Boy admitting that Put Upon Percy is one of his All Time Favourite Episodes makes me very happy. I’ve always had a soft spot for that episode and to see such a big name recognise this underrated episode as a Personal Favourite just makes my Day.
Also, what happened to the Large Scale Model’s Buffer Beam in the Thumbnail?
I sort of wish this was brought up (or if we know, was Rusty the most reliable of the O-Scale models? I ask because Rusty has no coupling rods. Since most of these videos give me the impression that it was those that caused the most problems.
Nice upload today.Thank's for sharing.
Rusty and the boulder
Is a fantastic episode
I have been waiting for this vid
YES
Greg Tiernan left before Duncan was animated! 2012 was his last year with Thomas and friends so using Duncan (reintroduced in 2014) as an example is not fair.
Ah fair point; in that case I wish his ideology was kept from that point forward. Seeing that Duncan was a major blow to my respect for the CGI series.
@@ItsTrainBoy That makes sense. Duncan is one the best characters!
I just stumbled across your channel, and boy, do I love your videos! Especially this one. As a kid, I _always_ saw Rusty as feminine-of-center (even despite the male pronouns), and it was kind of amazing to get actual confirmation that this wasn't just in my head!
Yes. My boy. He has come
Rusty is my childhood favorite.🧡
7:53, Duncan was made when Arc Productions took over the show.
NOT Nitrogen Studios.
4:42, the big-face Rusty always scared me for some reason
Rusty's horrorfide face was used is season 5 rusty and the bolder
You know, that horrorified face would've been perfect for Rusty and the Boulder
Many years ago, I remember being on the old Microsoft Train Simulator official forums, when the discussion came up about Rusty, and the other narrow gauge trains. One of the forum members was a friend of the Awdry family, and wrote a letter (yes, with pen and paper) to Christopher Awdry asking questions about the trains. Christopher, at the time, helping in the construction of the various trains. In one of the letters, Christopher referred to Rusty as "She". This started a long argument back and forth, with the forum member writing yet another letter, and encouraging Christopher to chime in on things himself if he could. Christopher stated that his father, Rev Awdry, always described Rusty to him as being a female character, and noted that the name "Rusty" was unisex enough to work both for male, or female. Christopher noted that the first time Rusty was called male, was actually with the Britt Allcroft series, which Awdry was greatly annoyed by. Reportedly, Awdry himself brought this problem up with Allcroft, who told the Reverend that the show was being marketed more toward young boys, and not girls, and thus having a locomotive that was a girl wouldn't work. Besides, there were already two female locomotives (Daisy and Mavis), and correcting the error was just going to push production back, as they'd already recorded the voice-overs where Rusty was called "He". Interestingly, Allcroft did seem to acquiesce to Awdry's thoughts on the character, to some degree, by having Starr (the first narrator), affect a slightly feminine voice when voicing Rusty.
In the end, though, the whole thing became moot, as by the time that any changes may have been made, viewers were accustomed to seeing Rusty as male, regardless of what the original creator thought.
Note: The letters back and forth were scanned and uploaded to the forums. This all took place around 2001, shortly after MSTS released.
The history of Bertie the bus & his models could be next also it would be a nice transition into road vehicles.
The episode rusty and the boulder was also adapted to be a creepypasta by a youtuber named narrow gauge for the series horrors of the rails.
Ever since I heard that Rusty was supposed to be non gender specific, it feels weird hearing "he/him" pronouns for it. Those pronouns just don't sound right for Rusty in my opinion.
I just always thought Rusty was a guy when I was a kid even though Rusty was never even referred to as male in the show. Pretty sure his wooden railway card uses she/her. I always thought Skarloey, Rheneas, Stepney, Culdee and Rickety were female as a kid too. I still sometimes forget that Rickety is supposed to be a male character.
Voted Slate Trucks, but not disappointed, and actually very satisfied.
Edit: if you look at Rusty’s cab and wonder why it’s only open on one side, all of the Talyllyn stations are on the right side of the track so you only needed one door and much of the Coaches are locked shut on one side because only one side needed to be able to open. I haven’t visited the Talyllyn yet, and I’ve only heard about this a while back.
I voted rusty a fair few times so thanks for doing him!
rust boi is here
I love the small face for rusty it’s just really adorable
6:56 actually thats the front, the door is on the right side like how it’s supposed to be
I remember when I first saw Rusty. He was the first narrow gage engine in the series as I recall.
When I heard the model was preserved at Hara Model Railway Museum,that's is a relieving moment.
Great video. Loving the narrow gauge engine videos. Can we have the rolling stock they pull please
Trainboy: talking about Rusty
Me: are we not gonna talk about the gold running board?
Rusty has quite a history with the changes to how "The little diesel" was referred to and how "the little diesel's" face changed.
History of Henrietta.
Let’s see Derek in the poll
1:53 not only that but in the TV series if you pay close attention Rusty does have a bit of rust on him to
nice job & plus rusty is my favorite narrow gauge engine kind helpful & careing to all hehe even to gumpy Duncan
He is painted orange because of his name - in a story in the 1997 Thomas The Tank Engine and Friends annual, Rusty told James that he was named after his paint which is rusty orange.
I’d love to see you do videos where you rate episodes you either love or hate and why
Any of the road vehicles I want to know how they work
Hey train boy, you should do a video ranking your favorite episodes from each era of Thomas and friends
This is the third time I'm asking for Sir Topham Hatt's Car and it's models. I also saw Cranky on the last poll so Cranky would also be a good one too.
I like Rusty, he’s one of my favorite narrow gauge engines.
Could you do a story video about how come Japan and the Hara model railway who have a large collection of items from the tv series. How did they get them and why
My favorite narrow gauge diesel👍🏽👍🏽
Mines as well!
I always joked about how Rusty is the first engine to get plastic surgery on his face because of the much bigger the large scale models face was in season 5 onwards XD
Amazing video
When I was a kid I was unsure if Rusty was a boy or a girl. For the longest time I thought I was just dumb as a child for not realizing he was male, but now i know Rusty's ambiguous gender was intentional. Learn something new everyday.
I mean it's more weird when you consider that up to that point, more diesel characters were female.
It was an attempt to make him gender neutral but the show eventually passed on it and let him stay male. And personally I think we shouldn't change a character like that and instead make a new one. Thats like making a white character black and claiming you solved Racism.
Shame Rusty was the only narrow gauge diesel in the show. There should have been more.
Can you please do the troublesome trucks next. I really want to hear about their history.
Hey Trainboy, what about an episode on Nevil?
I agree Rusty's one of my favorite characters and Thomas and Friends
Not to be pedantic, but CNC stands for Computer Numeric Control. So the machine that was used to make the chassis was computer controlled. Still definitely custom machined, but thats not what CNC means. I have enjoyed your videos a lot, keep up the hard work.
CNC also refers to a type of motor that’s custom machined, you’re very right but it has another meaning too I suppose in another area haha. Thank you man!
www.heidenhain.us/resources-and-news/servo-motors-for-cnc-machines/
So, I think we are talking about the same thing, kind of, CNC machine tools (such as a mill) use those motors controlled by a computer to move the work piece, the machine head, or both.
There are commercial industrial applications for CNC machining because of their reliability and repeatability with little opportunity for operator error, as well as in smaller shops for prototyping and custom work because one can go from a computer modeled design to the physical end result with ease.
History of Daisy
Can I get a Dennis history video? It would probably be shorter than Murdoch, but I don't care. Maybe do a double feature? Take two small characters that appeared only once each and smoosh them together. I can only hope...
Could the next TTTE be on the Troublesome Trucks
I remember when I first watched "Tuneful Toots" on TV, I was like "Rusty's a girl!" For that point for a while, I passed off Rusty as being a girl. It was around that time that I had noticed that Rusty was never referred to as any gender pronouns in the show prior to that point, which was something I never even noticed until after watching Tuneful Toots. When Rusty was referred to as a male in Season 10, I was like "So now he's a boy? Make up your mind." Eventually, I adjusted to Rusty being male again from that point onward.
I had no idea that Rusty was intentionally never referred to by gender-specific pronouns in the classic series.
Don't know why britt made that decision, considering he(yes he will always be a boy) was always potrayed male by the Reverend.
Nobody: thomas and friends with narrow guage engines: tallylyn railway, take it or leave it
"Its a girl! What are you gonna name her?"
*"Rusty"*
"..."
Best lesson ever.
Its a Pity we never got a Rusty Centered Story in CGI.
I kinda like rusty a lot but I don't understand the whole Gender Neutral thing or why his Season 5 onwards model had a freakishly huge Face.
I suppose it is weird that the different models of Rusty were used in "Rusty and the Boulder"
My 5th favorite narrow gauge character
Did small scale Rusty have better running chsrictaristics than the other small scale narro gauge engines?
Rusty sure does have a neat history
Rusty got possessed in the thumbnail.
Wooo! Top 2 favourite train
Could you do the Scottish twins next!?
He already did Donald and Douglas.
Rusty is an interesting character for sure. While I don't really like the larger scale Narrow Gauge models for having faces completely different from their smaller scale counterparts, Rusty is an outlier for having a gargantuan face on top of the different expressions. Still, the large engines are pretty good shape wise at least.
Also I always liked that Rusty was gender neutral and kinda wish that stayed. Rather nice representation for those who are Non-Binary.
Rusty is one of the kindest engines on the Island. I love Rusty as a character, he's very kind, and the way Duncan behaved towards Rusty in the early episodes was disgusting. Apart from Edward, Rusty is up there as being the most kindest, and caring for passengers, and he always works hard.
I only wish that Rusty's large-scale model had the small face. Were that the case, he'd be spot-on.
Finally
Thomastankmerch is truly a savior.
Devious diesel would be great to examine
History of Lady next Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeéeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease😍😍😍😍😍😍
So it turns out TomsProps also owns Duncan, but wasn’t revealed until a few days ago.
I want troublesome trucks next
Thank you I’m a tad rusty on my history of this little engine..
Goddamn it, Barb!
did Alcroft do that because some people had complained about the the lack of Female engine characters in either the RWS or the tv series?
I honestly prefer the face on the large scale Rusty, I know it's oversized but it's just a much better sculpt.
Duncan Looks like that in the cgi era because arc made him look more realistic