The importance of NSA Ajit Doval's elevation to cabinet & India's security architecture | ep 183
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2019
- In this episode of Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta explains the history of NSA in Indian govt.
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ This includes the link for subscription from overseas too
Damn man what happened to you? This is superb journalism fair and in-depth. Don't ever go back to being Congi boot locker.
That’s called “good survival instincts “
He learned from his hypocrite friend BARKHA DUTT
bhakhts always feel good when their line of thought is matched.
if you had bothered to pay attention to the video, you would realise that Doval came up during Congress regime.
@Nipam Chakma there's no such thing as "chamchas". We ourselves voted INC out via democratic process because of their corruption and complacency. Also, there was never a blind following of one single person/party like there is now. So your comparison is wrong.
@Nipam Chakma previous governments were heavy coalition governments. And yes, I still and by my comment. This kind of toxic blind following and blind hatred by a party's supporters was never there in India. If you want to debate this, then you're living in a parallel universe. And exactly whose boot is being licked? The ones who were thrown out of power by vote? . Opposing a fascist, party doesn't mean people automatically become supporters of INC or any other party. And if BJP bhakhts were so enlightened, why didn't BJP win from 2004 to 2014? Because they too voted for UPA.
@Nipam Chakma I myself told you that Congress was voted out for corruption so why are you trying to repackage that and selling it back to me? And yes it was voted out by Congress supporters themselves. Pata nahi tu kha bol rha hai. Seems like you're Baba Ramdev part-2 and you can see into the future what will happen in 2024. Beta, don't be so sure. Fascists and dictators don't last forever. And the followers and supporters of fascist regimes are not forgotten either. Remember the Nuremberg Trials?
What we are hearing from you these days is actual journalism that old Shekhar Gupta style.
Right
true
Exactly ... He should not get into congress propoganda and do nutral journalism
Exactly
@Ark
Yes , now Shekhar narrates very minutely and in unbiased manner.This change in his explanation is very positive, which is good for our country. Even Modi govt. also listen him carefully.
Now this is called journalism and a positive narration by an experienced talent. Finally subscribing this channel. Stay unbiased.
Exactly same thoughts.....
Yes, nobody should stop him from commenting against gvt, dis is really important in a democracy esp when gvt is in full majority. But criticism should be based on facts, unbiased analysis... Ppl of india r thirsty to c a constructive crticism without prejudice agnst gvt n even opposition..
D success of jandhan, ujjwala, toikets were everywhere seen in my town n villages. But he took a long time to acknowledge this but at least did it.
just one wrong thing...black thunder was not done by NSG
Same thoughts
Thanks for divorcing Barka Dutt journalism
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂👌👌👌👌🤣🤣🤣🤣
saikrishna chiluveru oof
😂😂😂😂
Shekhar
You seem to have resigned from khan market gang and secular Luten's delhi gang. I find some traces of your impartial writings in indian express days. keep it up.
You are right sir but i doubt he is habitual luyten/khan market, habits font die hard. E.g. here he says sikh terrorist. Never he said muslimnterrorist
Sir, it was pseudo secular gang. They only saw the sins of Hindus but not of Muslims or others.
Indians welcome the Reformed .....he is an intelligent & articulate journalist....Welcome him Embrace him but keep him under watch
Better late than never.
Hope it lasts.
else he will go to jail for corruption
Amazing, Ajit Dovaljee definitely does not look like he is 75 years old, great health and superb NSA chief. Jai Hind 🇮🇳💪🏽
He has pahari/nepali genes. That keeps him younger.
@@CoronaVirus-fu3zl he belongs to Uttarakhand, not Nepal. He is of the Indo Aryan race, not Mongoloid.
@@PradeepKumar-fq6kd i know. I have many pahari friends from both nepal and UK and fyi majority of nepali are pahari like Manisha koirala.
@@CoronaVirus-fu3zl are u blind chinese
....
...
We talk about india
U talk about china and nepal
Suddenly i start liking you😬😬
Hope to see more India Driven news 😊😊
kala Kumar hahaha looks like I am writing same reply to multiple people, yes me too. I suddenly started liking this guy 😀
HEY HE IS JUST PLAYING THE GAME.
HE WILL FIRST TELL YOU BEAUTIFUL THINGS OF MODI GOV AND THEN SLOWLY START CRITICIZING HIM , THEN HATING HIM AND TURN YOU INTO MODI HATER.HE IS GETTING READY FOR 2024.BE AWARE.
@@meetshah4921 You got it right man. One cud get clue of this in one of his video clearly telling that he will not accept Modi's greatness. This shows that he is preparing for a assualt on Modi government. He is just like wounded fox. All khan market gang have different strategies now
@@meetshah4921 dont wory i m in no ones influence.
Those who wil work for our country i appreciate them.
Whoever it may be.😊😊😊
And try to be same
@@prabathkumarr let them make strategy sir.
If we indian will unite no one could brake us.
Good to have u sir 😊😊
🙏🙏
Modiji did well in giving Cabinet rank to NSA-Ajith Dhovalji- a hero trusted by the entire Country, Jai Bharat !
Indian ajith 007
Such a drastic change sir. Good to know you are capable of stuff like this.
Papi pet ki sawal hey Saab!!
@Pavan Gupta No need to get to excited.
He is just freaked out that BJP is back to power and Amit Shah may come and end the reign of his crime.
It's for saving skin, sir
If he seeks redemption shouldn't we support it?
@@nustagamin For his false propaganda he should go to jail. TH-cam redemption is not enough.
Suddenly Vajpayee has become like a pm who brought reforms like no other person and yet lost to a family that brought darkness to the democracy! Even worse than Rajiv Gandhi!
Shivam Pandey what do you expect the life expectancy of a BJP leader is avg 70. But Congressis live 90
@@abhaykshirsagar1166 true that!
If only pappu was bajpai's opponent, he would have it easy 🙄.....if vajpeyi would be alive today he would be jealous of Modi ....😂
@@ritushukla9284 no i think he would be proud because he himself gave a speech on Congress future!
@@ShivamPandey-dg1vj :👍
Keeping your anti BJP bais aside to do some real jounalism . Thank you .
The slap of democracy is the best treatment for biased news reporters LOL
So basically, according to you only praising BJP allied persons is "real journalism". Thank you for clarifying
@@subhalaxmisen3463 He didn't say that, bcoz doval sir is not bjp man,
He was IB chief during upa only.
@@subhalaxmisen3463 To understand these things someone like you must have brain.. Unfortunately which you don't have
@@003somnath Seems like u dont have one
I just noticed that after 23rd may he has started to talk Pro BJP. Anyone else noticed
Not pro bjp but he has starting to state facts...This is better kind of journalism.
Now he is doing journalism and not propoganda 👈
Me too 😉
Wait till the 2024 elections for him to change his colors again
@@abhaykshirsagar1166 No bro the augusta Westland case came into light because of him and 2 other members of Indianexpress and that made Westland people tryna send Thier people to bribe Shekhar Gupta to bury the story but Shekhar gupta didn't Budge. So you should thank this guy otherwise you wouldn't have known the case.
There was never a Sikh militant
They were khalistanis and some unemployed youth mislead on the name of religion and to avenge 1984
Correct yourself
@Krishnan Raman no he wasn't a dharmic guru, he was a power hunger puppet who's foolishness led Punjab to it's darkest chapter
Yes, we are with u and brother 1984 , not hindu killed u , they are bloody congressi
satnam singh bindrawale never picked up a weapon . He was a guru
Satnam Singh.....good bro nice thinking well said....ajit doval ...himself wanted less human casualities and he said there were many young Sikh youth who were willing to work to eliminate bhinderwalla...watch operation thunderbolt from epic channel..
@Krishnan Raman Yeah please go ahead and read about him from a neutral perspective you'll understand..
He was a politician with a religious book and a gun in his hand. That's his reality.
Would love to see more non-congress videos
Hi Sir you given resignation from Pappu's party, Khan gang, tukre gang etc....👍
Because he knows that the next 5 years nothing will happen so just makeshift.
What amaze me is how people talk differently on TH-cam, twitter, TV and press conference. 🤔🧐
Modi effect, sir.
I started watching Cut the Clutter since the election 2019 results came out.....it is growing on me and every day I wait for these episodes...informative, analytical, holistic, unbiased and as the title suggests, the main headline/s of the day....Continue this good work.....would be more interesting if there are pictures and infographics in the background just like Vox is doing....However, Shekar Gupta should remain the focal point...
Same here
Same
कुत्ते को पता हो गया है कि अब 10 जनपथ पर हड्डी नहीं मिलने वाली अगले 15-20 साल तक..
यह चेंज बस नयी जगह खोजने के लिए है..
Me too...just beginning to understand and get interested in Indian politics since Modiji took over. I now start my day with these short episodes that really helps a layman like me understand the nittigritties of these political developments. Really an interesting time for Indian politics. Appreciate what you are doing.
Shekhar sir, what about your involvement in Augustawestland commission corruption
It was Shekar Gupta who brought out this Augusta Westland scam out
@@lavanyasunil5862 BS.
Why do you think Shekhar is suddenly pro BJP.
He is perhaps out that BJP is back to power and the govt. may come and end the reign of his crime.
yes indeed this bastard is involved in Augusta westland kaand.
@@MrManoj881 agreed
well true neutral because I hate both pro and anti govt in power propaganda if govt do good show that too if do bad also show it.
Same here. He is doing a nice job.
True
Now I understood, Amit Shah will just be a face of strong India but Doval will drive it.
I looks
Ajit we are proud of you please put a system to strength our internal security system.
Tell us suddenly what happened to you Mr Shekar? How you can be so balanced
Satya Vachan. Shree Ajit Dovalji can Save us and He's a Real Son of Maa Bharati. Question to me also is- what happened with Shekharji? sudden change! I hope he'll follow the Statement from Shree Vivekandandji that "Open Your Eyes and See the Light".......!! Light is Infront of Him, He only need to Open His Eyes...same advice to other people.
You compared elevation of Ajit Doval to cabinet level with Tsar.
That was quite interesting. I mean it kind of declutters your outlook on the event
It seems pulwama was not security failure
What u said I searched
I find true this time “only”
- well done
I actually like current version of this journalist
sir CDS is imperative, u can not mix internal, external security.
another issue lies with coordination of three wings of, armed forces, probably CDS will fill the gap.
So good to see Shekhar Gupta talking facts. Classic Shekhar Gupta. We dont want biased journalism. We can see and understand things too.
Keep it up
This is called modi effect.. I can't believe my own ears.. but shud be very careful of these chaemelions.. now they don't hv an option can switch back to their true colors anytime 😉
Perfectly said. It is indeed surprising that some of these luytens media/khan market journalists are actually changing their style of journalism and keeping a distance from their normal irritating promotion of agenda.
👌
Yes and print also two face chameleon 😠
Absolutely chaitra
True may change with slightest opportunity
I would love Maroof Raza as Doval's assistant. He is very knowledgeable and intelligent.
How u know tht he is already not working under Doval? 😂
Excellent presentation Sir!!! I'm a huge enthusiast on foreign policy matters... huge fan of the way you present the updates..
Love your detailed insight and analysis. Highly informative and definitely cuts the clutter. Keep 'em coming.
#ajitvadakayil blogspot, read out
Sudhish Menon talk something real. Oh yes am not a hindu fanatic. So I expect you to be real.
Sir, I really appreciate you taking the time to explain these things so clearly. I really felt good after seeing some really good journalism after years of bearing with Arnab and Barkha etc. I will keep on tuning everyday to hear you Sir!! Thank you again for your time!
Ajit Doval have been a mistery to me until now. Sir, you clearly explained. Thank you.
Today’s dose GK in Indian politics without any bias...we don’t want you to take sides, which is exactly what you are doing....good going sir
*wow Unbiased opinions by you...something unbelievable*
Vintage shekhar gupta back from frustration between May2014 to May2019, when he was imagining that he can change govt by fake narrative
True!!
Good content. This is the kind of journalism we would like to see.
Sir, news to the point with no bias is extremely pleasing to watch. I wish every media house follows this.
Regards
Girish
Thank you.
It's good for him 😂. Kidding. Absolutely love your videos.
Shekar Gupta is an intelligent and very unbiased journalist. He puts his facts black and white, it is up to readers to take it or leave it . He is very clear in his thoughts .
Thanks for removing the glasses of pseudo liberalism !
Bharat welcomes you with caution Shekhar ! We hope the change is real 😊
Perfect, no nonsense videos. Really cutting the clutter👍👍
I caught a point where you hinted at some past mistakes made by Doval, because of his operational background.
Please share your critical analysis of such instances.
In Pakistan where he was attacked by Sikh militia during the Khalistan insurgency I think that’s what he was referring to
Sir, you have gained more fans in the last 30 days than you have in the last 10 years.. What people nowadays expect is not biased one-sided news, but a more holistic and impartial view.. And you are doing exactly that.. Thanks
No questions sir,
But just a suggestion, Sir you've been articulating all these episodes on this channel on various significant topics extremely well, please sir continue with your great work because it's of enormous importance to a student like me to benefit from your expertise in not only journalism but also in life.
Thank you :)
U are turning into a good journalism rather than just spreading yr propoganda 👈👍
Absolutely brother..
Nope, he's still the snake in the grass..he wants to avoid jail time now..
@@varunpandey5762 atleast he's talking sense .😂
@Secularism Scam hai hahaha🤣🤣
Exactly, bilkul ye hi baat hai..
@Secularism Scam hai ek no bhai 🤣🤣😂😂
Finally for last few days I am feeling respect for SHEKHAR GUPTA.......... He is becoming MAN OF SUBSTANCE......it all started with his analysis with why Modi won......gr8 Sir keep it up....... SALUTATIONS...... please have a session about TECHNOLOGICAL SINGULARITY 2045 as well
One of the best Cut the Clutter episodes from Mr. Shekar! I must say, he has really started cutting the clutter in his own view points and it is definitely a throwback to the good old days!
we want this Shekhar , Neutral Shekhar. Ask relevant questions from the govt. but show both sides
Great informative video. Please continue to keep us well informed.
Refreshing factual journalistic narration without becoming a slave of prejudice that has been a hallmark of Indian media and so called intellectuals. Feel thst India is truly building it own narrative with dignity and not driven by so called highly regarded mouthpieces of the other countries worshipped by the colonial mindset.
Dear Shekhar jee , Explanation on Indian security has been best from your side . Let india have faith on Mr Ajit doval , nation shall not have any external and internal threat under his rich experience at border . We at Shakdher family pray for your good health and safety. We believe in his leadership constitutional position to make india to prosper . Regards sunil Shakdher
Clear & crisp. I feel this way probably because I suddenly started liking you lately 😀
Love your episodes. It reminds me of a wise grandfather speaking to the future generation about the history of India.
very well presented . very informative. thanks
If I am not wrong , he seems to be among the top librandu before May23.
Still now but he has to be careful
He's testing the waters.
This channel is real and unbiased in mid of all the other dramatic media. Kudos to the team! Please keep true journalism alive and providing us proper information! Thank you!
Excellent presentation comprehensive by Sekhar Gupta. It’s lovely that Ajit Doval has been elevated to Cabinet Minister rank as he deserves it. He did a very effective tenure in the first term. With a strong Home Minister in the form of Shah in the stable unless elevated Doval’s effectiveness would be lost . This man is full of action with clarity of purpose though not very good in expressing he is full of beans which is the job requirement & has a fantastic track record of tasks performed over & beyond. Good luck to him in his new post. India is on lines with the American structure of Administration. Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia.
Wonderful journalism, this is what we expect from you. When you were in Ind Exp under Arun Shourie and later as Editor, i had seen some fantastic journalism from you. And after a long time, you are back to it.
Congratulations for leaving Khan Market brigade ! 👍
Satya Hai
I must say I used to think shekhar Gupta as some other left oriented journalist but he is doing some good journalism. Talking about NSA is very important.
I'm loving this Cut the Clutter series by The Print. Keep up the good work.
Very nice informative episode.Thank you.
Now you talking Mr. Gupta. You just got a new subscriber. Neither bjp nor Congress only India should be the point of discussion. Keep up the good work👍
Shekhar Gupta Ji Has changed a Laaat....now he is doing actuall journalism ....
Enviably Skilled Journalist
Bravo..Good one.after long time. Learn many things
Sorry Shekar Sir I am reccorrecting you...... You Must say NSA as National Security Architect instead of Architecture...Because who plans very precisely and securely is known as Architect and Architecture is just built uping ....And other part that “Aap jaise Journalist Ki bahot Garaj hai hum jaise youngsters ke liye” thank you keep us updated 🤗🖤lots of wishes for further informative video about Security.... 🙏🏻
Shekherji, Admire your wonderful insight into present National Security architecture till Modi 2.0 beginning.Looks to be very good attempt to have effective input for GOI in present internal environment for quick actions & decision -making.
Finally u agree Ajit doval is James bond
No,he's ajit doval,not James bond, bond is fictional,doval isn't.
TATAI百 doval is real
I am subscribing . But please stay unbiased and away from khan Market pseudo-intellectuals .
Jai hind
# Sekhar sir you are sounding like ancient sage....wise and analytical. Respect.
Your new type of analysis pulls me to youtube like magnet ... glad you left NGO style of journalism and doing center (not left right) type of journalism ... keep it up
Very informative and balanced.
My father was a great fan of yours since many many years but I was never. Thanks for showing your real talent. We would like to know more on diff topics
Thanks for taking me back in time to the news I grew up reading.
Very informative. Thanks for sharing
Shekhar Sir - please continue to make these videos - I like the no nonsense- approach with which you cover key topics . kudos to you for cutting the clutter
Shekhar, in all honesty I must say that this episode of Cut the Clutter is only the one where you have not allowed a single thought of hatred arise in me while listening to you unlike all the previous ones... so kudos to you for this one and hoping that you would not clutter your ' Cut the Clutter' with prejudice....
Barring his bias towards Congress and hate towards NaMo, I do think Mr Gupta is an ace stalwart amongst his shrinking fraternity. I knew him before and fond of his Saturday 'National Interest' Column in Indian Express to which I eagerly waited. But I came face to face with him at EXIMS in 2011 where he interacted with me, amongst others there, with far more interest after he came to know that I am from Guwahati, Assam. He covered famous Assam Agitation from India Today and as he said to me and I still vividly remember as being more native than 'Native Assamese' ! He is a gem of a person only if he sheds his self-harming 'biasness' ! The best part is how he become so 'wise' after Mandate Modi 2.0 in 2019 !? Hope, in 'The Print' he will do himself a makeover being 'SG 2,0' !!! I wish him great health and energy to enlighten us about rarely known events etc being an 'Eye-witness' to most of them unfolding, having been there on the spot with so much enviable experience !!! Best of Luck...Shekhar Ji !
Thanks for creating such content. There’s so little exposure to such topics for the current generation and less avenues to obtain it
It's exactly as the name says - Cut the Clutter. This series is a very good case of story-telling journalism. Much better than the 'Tamasha' of the news channels.
Great analysis and very through .I love to listen from people like you who really have done some research and analysis rather hearing from immature people.
Such a lucid and thread-bare elaboration! Your acumen is remarkable.
Change is all around... Welcome Mr Shekhar...
Excellent clarity of expression, making it easy for the layman to understand the subtle intricacies of national security apart from the on the field hardware of Armed Forces, BSF, etc.
As always SG at his best.
Always enjoyed and munched on ur articles in Indian Express.
Deep insights and new angles to issues which most journalist lack these days.
#Respect
that's some kind of education !!! thanks Mr Gupta
Extremely insightful, Mr. Shekhar Gupta
Don't say Sikh terrorist they were khalistani not Sikh
Now you are meeting expectations, doing journalism as it should be done.... respect you Sir
चढते सूरज को सब सलाम करते हैं :- श्री शेखर गुप्ता
I wait daily for cut the clutter. This is awesome work. TY Shekhar Ji
Sir.... your explaination of issues is one of the best.....
This is the journalism we need in india.
India also needs a cyber security expert with a hardcore tech background as an adjunct NSA
Nsa does have a robust cyber security team but it is filles by IITianswho are network scurity graduates. But nsa needs a robust team of white hats who are not from fancy colleges but with real world network security exp.
True. I support your Statement Prem Bhai. We should have NSA-Cyber Security on the basis of Real Time Situation Worldwide. I hope it will be there in 2024 or soon. Jai Hind Jai Maa Bharati __/\__
@@abhishekrampalli6401 True! I Agreee.
@@abhishekrampalli6401 oh, you mean real world experts of the "Wolf Gupta" fame !!
One can't be bad just because he or she is an IIT graduate. Of late IITs have been getting s lot of bad press about the quality of practical training imparted to them. May be true, but that's true of our education system in general. IIT grads have been doing well and they are founding great companies even in high end areas like quantum technologies, cryptography, 3d printing, drones etc. So why pick some gypsies on the street instead of an IITian ?? Not that other grads should not be picked up , but the fact is IIT grads excelled in every field in every country. Dismissing that would be throwing the baby out with the bath water. Recruitment strategies are not inspired by Bollywood movies !
u explained it very nicely...thank u
You are a journalist with one eye opens
Kerala cadre always brilliant❤️
Mr. Vinayak Phadke is spot-on. Mr. Shekhar Gupta is getting more impartial. He was previously very anti-Modi once upon a time. Slowly but steadily, things have changed. And after 23rd May 2019, its been a welcome change and as Kala Kumar puts it --- I am also beginning to like you.