A History of US Insurrections
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Given recent events, I think it's time to grasp a bit of history about US insurrections. Far from being exceptional, these events are almost commonplace in American history, the problem is, we all thought we were done with this kind of unrest.
------------------------------------------------------------
Connected videos:
0:05 - last week's episode: • Schindler’s List | Bas...
5:55 - 1920 vs. 2020: • [depreciated] 1920 vs ...
6:05 - race riots: • Race Riots in US History
6:05 - police: • How Police Brutality b...
8:55 - filibusters: • Evolution of filibuste...
8:55 - Walker: • Walker (1987) | Based ...
8:55 - vigilantism: • Vigilantism and Lynchi...
18.55 - Philippines: • The Philippine Insurre...
20:50 - filibusters: • Evolution of filibuste...
20:50 - stars on flags: • Stars on Flags and the...
23:15 - Philippines: • The Philippine Insurre...
24:25 - Lost Cause: • Understanding the Lost...
25:15 - Sectional Crisis: • Lincoln was a Conspira...
26:45 - police: • How Police Brutality b...
28:15 - bury my heart at wounded knee: • Bury my Heart at Wound...
29:10 - Lincoln County: • The Lincoln County War...
32:15 - Lost Cause: • Understanding the Lost...
38:10 - US veterans history: • The History of America...
------------------------------------------------------------
Lists of US insurrection-adjacent stuff:
Civil unrest: en.wikipedia.o...
Rebellions: en.wikipedia.o...
Racial upheavals: en.wikipedia.o...
Conflicts: docs.google.co...
Just a few books out of many that influenced this:
Hugh Davis Graham and Ted Robert Gurr eds., Violence in America: Historical and Comparative Perspectives; A Report to the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence, 2 vols. (Washington D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1969).
Richard Maxwell Brown, Strain of Violence: Historical Studies of American Violence and Vigilantism (New York: Oxford University Press, 1975). amzn.to/2KXI5Xb
Richard Maxwell Brown, No Duty to Retreat: Violence and Values in American History and Society (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991). amzn.to/2zldrFz
Daniel Richter, Facing East from Indian Country: A Native History of Early America (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2003). amzn.to/2MVhWJ4
Eric Foner, Reconstruction: America’s Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877, new ed. (1988; New York: Perennial Classics, 2002). amzn.to/34lFOhq
See pinned comment and its replies for further references, notes, responses, and errata
------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS:
www.youtube.com...
Support the channel through PATREON:
/ cynicalhistorian
or by purchasing MERCH: teespring.com/...
LET'S CONNECT:
Twitch: / cynicalhistorian
Facebook: / cynicalcypher88
Subreddit: / cynicalhistory
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / cynical_history
------------------------------------------------------------
Wiki: Rebellion, uprising, or insurrection is a refusal of obedience or order.[1] It refers to the open resistance against the orders of an established authority.
A rebellion originates from a sentiment of indignation and disapproval of a situation and then manifests itself by the refusal to submit or to obey the authority responsible for this situation. Rebellion can be individual or collective, peaceful (civil disobedience, civil resistance, and nonviolent resistance) or violent (terrorism, sabotage and guerrilla warfare.)
In political terms, rebellion and revolt are often distinguished by their different aims. If rebellion generally seeks to evade and/or gain concessions from an oppressive power, a revolt seeks to overthrow and destroy that power, as well as its accompanying laws. The goal of rebellion is resistance while a revolt seeks a revolution.[citation needed] As power shifts relative to the external adversary, or power shifts within a mixed coalition, or positions harden or soften on either side, an insurrection may seesaw between the two forms.
------------------------------------------------------------
Hashtags: #history #insurrection #US
*TH-cam has demonetized this,* so please consider buying some merch: teespring.com/stores/the-cynical-historian
Or donating to my Patreon: www.patreon.com/CynicalHistorian
See following comment for corrections and citations, but first, here are some related videos to check out:
5:55 - 1920 vs. 2020: th-cam.com/video/A-ulRXuxw3c/w-d-xo.html
6:05 - race riots: th-cam.com/video/tAbkCU5nBhM/w-d-xo.html
6:05 - police: th-cam.com/video/HehnDHNoItk/w-d-xo.html
8:55 - filibusters: th-cam.com/video/3oWFi8XLVhc/w-d-xo.html
8:55 - Walker: th-cam.com/video/DqOC2f4zee4/w-d-xo.html
8:55 - vigilantism: th-cam.com/video/RfceCvtEMJ4/w-d-xo.html
18.55 - Philippines: th-cam.com/video/mmYk0xxjDDA/w-d-xo.html
20:50 - filibusters: th-cam.com/video/3oWFi8XLVhc/w-d-xo.html
20:50 - stars on flags: th-cam.com/video/natx2c0kkXs/w-d-xo.html
23:15 - Philippines: th-cam.com/video/mmYk0xxjDDA/w-d-xo.html
24:25 - Lost Cause: th-cam.com/video/5EOhXF5lNgQ/w-d-xo.html
25:15 - Sectional Crisis: th-cam.com/video/Ff2AKILyi0o/w-d-xo.html
26:45 - police: th-cam.com/video/HehnDHNoItk/w-d-xo.html
28:15 - bury my heart at wounded knee: th-cam.com/video/4CwNgWCSA90/w-d-xo.html
29:10 - Lincoln County: th-cam.com/video/thDLWcWcFtc/w-d-xo.html
32:15 - Lost Cause: th-cam.com/video/5EOhXF5lNgQ/w-d-xo.html
38:10 - US veterans history: th-cam.com/video/ANUqaNykuRs/w-d-xo.html
*[reserved for errata]*
*References*
Civil unrest: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unrest_in_the_United_States
Rebellions: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rebellions_in_the_United_States
Racial upheavals: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_United_States
Conflicts: docs.google.com/document/d/1jlkz3eIQ0dH4SwzfezuZJw7ypUQ3QyReIliePi91Acg/edit?usp=sharing
Just a few books out of many that influenced this:
Hugh Davis Graham and Ted Robert Gurr eds., _Violence in America: Historical and Comparative Perspectives; A Report to the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence,_ 2 vols. (Washington D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1969).
Richard Maxwell Brown, _Strain of Violence: Historical Studies of American Violence and Vigilantism_ (New York: Oxford University Press, 1975). amzn.to/2KXI5Xb
Richard Maxwell Brown, _No Duty to Retreat: Violence and Values in American History and Society_ (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991). amzn.to/2zldrFz
Daniel Richter, _Facing East from Indian Country: A Native History of Early America_ (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2003). amzn.to/2MVhWJ4
Eric Foner, _Reconstruction: America’s Unfinished Revolution, 1863-1877,_ new ed. (1988; New York: Perennial Classics, 2002). amzn.to/34lFOhq
Looking at your TeeSpring store. Is there a meaning to the Zero-Lantern symbol?
honestly, it expected because it's a very recent topic but honestly, it was a very weird event
@@CynicalHistorian The Schindler’s List video up is age restricted. Just so you know.
As a Holocaust historian the fact that they are suppressing actual history about that atrocity and yet promoting antisemitic rhetoric is absolutely appalling. I mean, it doesn't completely surprise me but at the same time... what the hell?
TH-cam is pretty much pro atrocity denial which makes blood pressure spike
ha I thought I posted a comment here
Makes you wonder who's side this platform is on.
microbial2007 no one, they’ll punish either side if it means they keep their ads, TH-cam only cares about one thing money and will punish anyone who denies them that ability
Hosting content about such tragedies isn't good for business, TH-cam doesn't want to be associated with something so horrific, from its probably economically sensible to try and not have this on your platform, especially after past scandals
There are only three certainties in life: death, taxes, and Cypher ragging on Woodrow in each video.
All roads lead to Wilson
Wilson is the head of the Illuminati confirmed he founded the Patriots in Metal Gear.
ExtraHistory has something similar going on with British PM Robert Walpole (so there's four things).
And deservedly so.
Woody-boy has it coming. I knew he was pretty bad, but Cypher's video about him really highlighted that lot of issues that future generations had to deal with can be traced back directly to him.
I really hate that the best content and videos on this website get demonitized meanwhile we have peppa pig and blippi videos for days 🙄
I blame the algorithm..stop letting your kids watch youtube on your phone
@@redddollars5089 that's a lazy take. The answer is TH-cam as a corporation doesn't want accurate history or true left-wing influence. Because it will affect their bottom line
@@matthewarnold4557 No it has nothing to do with politics. They just do anything that makes them more money
@@benediktasilciukas2138 Pretty much, they're a business.
There is TH-cam kids
Calling this once in a generation is optimistic
World war 2 and the Great Depression were also once a generation
@@bingisbahn3374 wasnt ww2 the generation after TGD?
@@pennyforyourthots the WW2 generation grew up (and fought during) the depression.
@@pennyforyourthots same generation they were only like 10 years apart
A more accurate translation of "Viva la revolución, abajo los asesinos" is "long live the revolution, down with the murderers".
Im confused about the Obama years being normal. I think normal requires to go back before 9/11
Really it requires going back before Reagan. America hasn’t been normal ever since the blight of Neoliberalism took hold.
@@TrainmasterGT honestly perhaps Coolidge if we want to escape the scourge of statists
America has never been normal
@@TrainmasterGT
70s America was a mess
Go back before the Great Depression
King Henry VIII Tudor no, pre depression America was pretty screwed too. I think we’d probably want to go back sometime after Johnson entered office but before Watergate. Then, you miss the Chaos of the OPEC embargo and oil shortages, but you still have the Civil Rights legislation.
Shay's rebellion! I haven't heard that name since high school even my spouse hadn't heard about it. I guess that's what I get from being from a former colony of Massachusetts.
You should really know you made history
Best person for that is Atun Shei Films
@@theshenpartei His "Witch Hunter" character is really, really creepy! But the history is #1
As an archivist, I’m glad you are showing how conspiracies are not facts, and don’t hold up over time.
As a seattlite the CHAZ was a failure and fell to same flaws as the normal police. I wish you had mentiones the June 29/30 incident of 2 black teens being shot (14yr old and 16yr old) and one being murdered in an execution by the CHAZ guards. You can find footage even of them rummaging through thier car and hearing one saying in a smug tone, "Oh youre not dead?" Followed by a gunshot.
CHAZ was removed soon after. There are details I didnt mention because i strongly reccomend anyone reading this to do your own research.
Chop wasn’t as bad as folks think it was a hippy block party infiltrated by white supremacists who wanted to start a race war… the cops were the aggressors who broke it up.
HOW THE MF HELL do they demonetize your stuff but Tucker Carlson is on the news every night.
$$$
Because Tucker is awesome
stinky Tucker
Internal armed conflicts in American history are an obsession of mine as well. I've made a timeline comprising most of them and what I believe to be almost all of them.
Here's mine: docs.google.com/document/d/1jlkz3eIQ0dH4SwzfezuZJw7ypUQ3QyReIliePi91Acg/edit?usp=sharing
@@CynicalHistorianthanks. I can add some of those to my timeline.
~having a meltdown in the corner~
Wilmington! For the love of sticky little plants, please look into the Wilmington massacre in 1898.
It's criminal how few people know about that incident. While it wasn't quite as big as the Tulsa massacre, it was the end of any attempt at reconstruction in NC and paved the way for Jim Crow laws.
Eta- by "wasn't as big as Tulsa", I mean that the cost of the property damage wasn't as high. Because Wilmington is a much smaller city.
We'll never truly know how many Black people were killed in either
Noam Chomsky once stated:
"I think it only makes sense to seek out and identify structures of authority, hierarchy, and domination in every aspect of life, and to challenge them; unless a justification for them can be given, they are illegitimate, and should be dismantled, to increase the scope of human freedom"
@@anthonyvigil7567 what communist dictatorship r u talking about?
Subbed
Wouldn't dismantling those structures just add to more chaos in the world? The dismantling of traditional religious and political structures after WW1 is literally what led to the Nazis, Fascism, WW2, genocides, Communism, Nihilism, etc.
@@joelrebollar7055 it's also foolish to think anarchy benefits everyone. Flawed or not, there are some systems that can't function in anarchy. Case in point: healthcare, military and education. Where will the sickly go for medicines and checkups if there are no hospitals? What safety do the defenseless and elderly have without a strong standing military? How will the uneducated learn skills and trades? There are many more problems I could bring up, but these were the ones that came to mind for me.
@@anthonyvigil7567 There aren't any "Communist" dictatorships.
"History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes."
- Gary Johnson
-Mark Twain
Repost
Lol, y'all missing the joke that John Meacham and Gary Johnson look like long lost twins.
@@NotHPotter Oh, I thought the joke was Gary Johnson - just, generally.
@@fuzzydunlop7928 Fair assessment.
Great video as always! As a potential history major in my freshman year in college, I really enjoy your videos to really get a grasp of how to not only apply history to modern day, but also learn something!!!
YT completely delisting your excelent video on Schindlers List was the final straw for me, consider me a new patreon because this site is getting more bonkers by the day.
Not sure if that's a viable option, but maybe an idea for a video: The history of the term "race riots". What sort of event has been called by that name? Is it an illuminating term, or does it cover the actual character of the events? (It does fall within your History of US Violence purview, so you may be interested.)
@@nedludd7622 that's the sort of thing I'm interested in for Cypher to cover.
@@nedludd7622 Here in Tulsa we've pushed for the term to be Race Massacre nowadays
@@TheParadoxGamer1 I’ve heard pushback from some in the black community, because they don’t want to obscure that they fought back, it wasn’t one sided..
@@ripred42 A very fair point. I believe both terms aren't really perfect to describe what happened in Tulsa in 1921.
@@ripred42 Except it was one sided the whole town of green wood was bombarded by aerial fire. It was a massacre.
It may not be directly linked but now the line in Cabinet Battle #1 from Hamilton makes sense after this video and seeing the tax on Whisky
"Look, when Britain taxed our tea, we got frisky
Imagine what gon' happen when you try to tax our whisky"
My first thought, when the insurrection started was: hey these guys want to copy our defunct Partido Nacionalista.
Ayup
Ye they did a Mussolini
Or our Falange and Unión Patriótica
Febuary 6, 1934, France
There's your historic comparison
What happened?
@@theshenpartei anti-parliamentarist street demonstration in Paris organized by multiple far right leagues that culminated in a riot on the Place de la Concorde, near the seat of the French National Assembly.
Took from wikipedia cause too lazy **burp**
Doesn't wikipedia say it's not a verifiable source tho 😶
@@megancrager4397 Check the citations
I know this is really pedantic and doesn’t remotely matter but at roughly 24:00 you played the wrong version of Dixie, you played the unofficial ‘Union Dixie’ instead of the regular one just titled ‘Dixie’.
This is the type of criticism that I want when I seach by 'newest comment'
that was purposeful, lol
@@CynicalHistorian Well I can only apologise, it just seemed a little odd that in a video about insurrections you were playing the anthem of the government rather than the insurrectionists.
I refuse to say "Heil" to the algorithm! The only royalty that matters here is King Richard I!
He has the divine right
We should start a kistarter called the "TH-cam tithe" to retake the Algorithm in the name of God.
The Crusade is eternal brothers.
@@forickgrimaldus8301 Time for a digital crusade
@ϟCHUTZ Heresy
I KNEW I could count on Cipher to put recent events into an accurate historic perspective.
TH-cam when people spread myths: Wow neat Video! 😎
TH-cam when it sees this channel: How could this guy be so offensive 😦
Good information young man! IF I wasn't on a fixed income i would send monetary support.
I came across your site while researching specific information using the statement "the largest armed insurrection in US history", which I believe to be the United Mine Workers in west Virginia ending in 1920s.
I was glad to hear your inclusion of the defacto fascist state of that period with a picture of then President Wilson.
I applaud your efforts and have given a thumbs up as well as subscribed. Without the labor movement democracy would not exist as we know it today.
I intend to start writing about history again, inspired in part by your excellent work, TH-cam did not exist when I made my historical writing and community access tv productions about labor issues and history.
Keep up the good work and keep banning bigotry and include fascist.
In solidarity
Richard T.
History doesn’t repeat itself, human behavior constantly does, which is why despite the different circumstances these lunatics did what others did before
@@itsblitz4437 Next verse, same as the first. P.S., Archer, buddy, loved the latest season. Really pulling for you for season 12, hope things are going to get better for you.
Phrasing... are we not doing that anymore! Thank you Archer
Last week's episode was great and screw TH-cam trying to bury history to make shareholders and advertiser's happy history is nasty unclean and brutal and we need to see that
Great episode! My third time watching this episode and my first comment. This was not American insurrections first rodeo. Just the first time the President coached from the Presidential podium… Great explanations of history. Cynical but entertaining.
I got my BA from CSU Dominguez Hills, which owes its existence in part to insurrection. The school was originally supposed to be located on the Pales Verdes peninsula (and even held a few years of classes there), but after the 1965 Watts Rebellion, the CSU leadership decided to move the campus to its current location in Carson in order to make it more accessible to South Central LA. I actually got to handle some of the meeting and planning documents for the move while I was volunteering in the CSUDH archives.
I love the fact that TH-cam says they promote the teaching class f history but when somebody does they freak out that it doesn’t only portray the good and then demonitize, delete, and/or unlist the video
19:17 he talks about the year 1917
Returning to the “normal” of the last few decades will not fix the problem and hopefully now that this insurrection has occurred, maybe people will wake up.
Wishful thinking
@@c.w.johnsonjr6374 Don't forget that his VP is a prosecutor. And most of his Cabinet are Fraudulent and Corrupt.
The most amazing thing about this video:
Everything comes back to Wilson.
6 degrees of Woodrow Wilson it all comes full circle
GODAMMIT WILSON!!!
The MGS Zero of the real world is Wilson.
I'm sorry the algorithm hates nuance :(
It's ridiculous I hope my youtube premium account still gives you the extra money for my view.
Always enjoyed your videos for their historical depth and yes nuance!
Having take the civil service oath, and having had to consult my conscience before doing so, to be sure I was swearing to protect the Constitution not a president nor an administration, I joined the Peace Corps. and took the oath. I have nothing but the greatest contempt for a legislator or government official who breaks that oath. The treason of a sitting president, had it prevailed would have compelled me to go to the barricades with you young people. Those who tried to overthrow the Constitution and the government established thereby must be arrested and tried for treason and upon conviction face the same penalty the traitors of the 1860s faced, this time with no pardons. This includes the Confederacy's second president, DJ Trump. Thanks for another interesting if a somewhat disturbing video.
The way the eyes were so small yet so wide and did not blink ever unnerved me.
I think he does this intentionally. I think this is his way of removing emotion from his historical evaluation. If it is intentional, it's brilliant.
For your last video, I made a comment praising your video and the movie. It was almost instantly deleted. Presumably because I had to make several references to the event starting with "H" and the people starting with "J". So the stupid youtube bots also repress the comment section, but somehow, not the ones that deserve it.
TH-cam was deleting comments without permission. It was a problem across the entire collab
@@CynicalHistorian same thing happened to me, just using them to explain things then the comments are juat gone because oh no bad words.
When a veteran gets mad at you know you fricked up
Yeah what did I mean?
Well...
That Austrian Artist was a WWI veteran afterall, and used their anger to his advantage, though...
I honestly want to know what the Capitol Hill Insurrection will be called in the textbooks. The books will probably be written by Gen Z whose youngest members would have probably grown up and had kids by then. Of course the name of the event will be something memetic like the Beer Gut Putsch.
Twisted Insurrection.
Its also a name of a Tiberian Sun Mod where Nod an Ancient terror cult takes over a post apocalyptic world with what remains of the world Insurrecting under GDI a branch of the UN founded to combat Nod specifically.
In this real life insurrections case its Twisted not because a terror cult took over the world but a President openly endorsed it against a failed election.
Beer Gut Putsch lmao
th-cam.com/video/DZrGIIIBhNg/w-d-xo.html
Repalce Kane with Trump and you can kind of hear Far right extremists instead of future Apocalypse Cult worshiping Green rocks.
@@forickgrimaldus8301 that is a command and conquer reference
@@theshenpartei yes in the name of Kane!
My great grandfather was Washington state republican senator Earnest Leneart, who served from 1943-1968. The day of the insurrection I called family members who knew him and his political views best. All had the same answer: He would’ve been outraged beyond belief and vote for the removal of the president.
I should point out, he emigrated to the US from Sweden in 1910.
I still don't know if I would consider this a 9-11 or challenger moment. Those had the whole nation looking on with horror. This had a good majority looking on with horror but there are still plenty supportive of it. And that's just publicly. I fear what could happen next, what with people like Ted Cruz and Marjorie Taylor Greene in Washington.
Wanna bet something is gonna happen come September 11th this year, 20 years is a long time
For the sake of posterity, I decided today to write down where I was on January 6, 2021, because I was actually quite cut off from the internet that day.
“January 6th 2021 was a different day for me. The day before was my first day at my new job in Topeka, working as a Labor organizer for AFT-Kansas. That day I was begging the moving process into my new apartment in Topeka. I drove from my parents house in Kansas City, but was too early to start moving in, so I went to the office to drop some things off there and check my email. Then I went to finish my paperwork, arrived at my new apartment, and after that I was more or less isolated from the news. All I was concerned about was getting my stuff moved in, my new apartment cleaned and getting the power and water accounts set up, not to mention the ordeal of getting my Internet ordered. I spent most of that day waiting for the repair man to come and fix the lock on my door, because the key kept failing to work, meaning I couldn’t leave the apartment. And without wifi, I was more or less cut off from the world. But I was only a few miles away from the State Capitol. I could actually see the dome from my front door.
It wasn’t until my Mom called me that afternoon, concerned about where I was after hearing that there had been violence at the US Capitol, and allegedly violence in Topeka as well. I hadn’t heard anything, but I called my new boss at the office, which is down the street from the dome, just to make sure nothing had happened there. Thankfully it was mostly quiet apart from a protest in Topeka, but the MAGA Chuds had a permit to be both inside and outside the building.
After I got my lock fixed, my dishes unpacked and everything else I’d brought moved in, I went back to the office to pick up the stuff I’d dropped off there, and took a detour to drive by the Capitol. The crowd was thinning out by then, but I did see someone had erected gallows complete with a noose on the lawn of the building.
It wasn’t until I got to the office that I learned what had really happened in DC and saw the pictures, and over the next few days came to grips with what had happened. I couldn’t help but think of Mussolini’s March on Rome and it reminded me that in the coming years, the fight against reaction would not let up for us on the left.”
This video didn't show up in my notifications either. Love your content, great video!
Is it in you subscription feed? TH-cam removed the last episode from there, and I hope not this one too :-{
The comments section is going to a mess I have a bad feeling about this and I just know it
I hope the king Richard cheers everyone up in the video or at the end of it
We shall retake clarity Deus Vult, damn the Heretical deviants known as Bigots
I’m cheered every time I am notified of Cypher posting another piece of quality content 😊👍
@@nigeh5326 same here
Like the facts and myths of slavery he did.
@@tiredox3788 was that your first video of him you watched
"Heil, Algorithm!"
Joking, you said to do it D:
Always interesting your videos!
You're very special, King Richard
Another modern day example might be the Occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, Jan 2, 2016 - Feb 11, 2016
Late to the comment section here, but... does anyone not see the similarities between Trump's conspiracy theories and rhetoric and those of fascist dictators of the past?
Oh most definitely. I think trump supporters blaming antifa for the January 6th attack was, in a way, a direct homage to the nazis blaming communists for the burning of the reischtag. Luckily they failed this time.
One year later its a little more obvious but yeah it was pretty evident back then
I hope I'm wrong, and just missed the part about the only successful coup in US history. 😔
Wilmington, NC, 1898. Until very recently, most references called it a 'race riot', when in fact it was the overthrow of a legitimately elected government.
Skip to 6:22 if you wanna skip the "Trump man bad" rant, and watch the actual content.
Top comment
I'm surprised you didn't cover the battle of blair mountain, even if briefly
Any chance of a mug with his highnesses name underneath the artwork Cypher? If so I will definitely buy one 👍
I'm only licensed for the T-shirts
@@CynicalHistorian damn I would have bought two one for me one for my son. Thanks for the quick reply chin up my friend 👍
“I’ve been looking forward to this” - Count Dooku of Sorenno 19 BBY.
Been waiting to see what you were gonna say about le trumpet, and other examples. #monetisethisguyyoutube
????
@@itsblitz4437 “I’m just a simple man trying to make my way in the universe.” - Jango Fett, bounty Hunter, 21 BBY.
Thank you for using the plural of "Michigander."
Your analysis is a wee bit controversial, but spot on. You are an excellent historian. Keep up the good work.
I believe he was a bit too easy on the CHAZ event but overall a pretty good video.
Maybe we should elect King Richard as president....
President Richard all right I will bite
King Richard will win 538 electoral votes
Whats the difference between Nathan Bedford Forest and Q Shaman, branding
One got away scot free(the prick) and the other one is rotting in prison as he should?
Nathan Forrest probably didn't whine about not getting organic food in jail I bet. That's a difference other than branding lol.
@@jayjohnson8353 NBF might have been human garbage (spoiler: he was) but he wasn't a spoiled man-child either.
@@Shadowman4710 lol yes agreed!
Yes he mentioned the party switch🙂🙂 I’m glad someone said it
liked and shared bro best of luck with the algorithm
I love King Richard, may he rule forever.
On July 4, 1883, all three Grand County, Colorado, Commissioners died in a gun battle along with the sheriff and, presumably, the under-sheriff, the under-sheriff's brother along with a lawyer in the company of the two commissioners, who were the targets of the violence. Every person who participated in the shoot-out died. A toll of six dead seems rather significant. This happened on the shore of Grand Lake.
It's an interesting and fairly complex political tale, and, even though I am reasonably familiar with the story, would love to see another take. It was a brief but deadly, and politically devastating, county war.
My source is "Island in the Rockies" by Robert Black III.
Funny enough, that's actually one of the incidents i plan on covering in my dissertation
It's an incident that demonstrates the folly of getting into shoot-outs. Everyone dies, or disappears, never to be seen or heard from again. Easy to disappear in the 1883 Colorado wilderness.
I worked as a tour guide and rafting shuttle bus driver in Grand County and those were good stories to tell. I've actually visited the grave-sites of some of the participants.
Yeah honestly I'm just realizing I haven't seen your vids for months, fuck this BS system they runnin
What do you think of/classify the Battle of Athens, Tennessee in 1946?
I want to here your opinion of the creation of a 51st state by giving the District of Columbia statehood, which in turn would probably make people try to make U.S. territories like the Virgin Islands a state (Probably should have added this, which might be obvious, but from your usual historical viewpoint)
And thank you for sharing. And I actually mean it it's not a snarky comment I really appreciate having a place I can come to and get a succinct breakdown of the subject
History is my drug, TH-cam is my free clinic, Cypher's videos are my methadone, the comment section is the waiting room I hate being in, where the real crazy comes out.
Thank you for your efforts. i appreciate it. You have encouraged me to do more reading and research.
I am disabled. I live with family. This family fervently believes trump is 'good' and 'strong' instead of a bigoted thin skinned bully who will gladly throw every single one of his supporters under the bus for the slightest personal gain....
And what scares me is how many of the people I have personally heard speak of the mad mango.... Would count it a privilege.
if you stoped getting your trump news from the media who takes his speeches out of context
and in-sted went to one of his rallies you would understand why they think that
@@r.o.b8728 can you... Just not? I get 'trunp news' from his most recent fervent supporters who have said that Congress and pence were cowards, who believe wholeheartedly what trump says, and is willing to show the ugly trueth of how things are.
You are not particularly appreciated here as you PR reading comprehension needs some review. Reread what I said. I live with a pack of maga cultists. I get the trump point of view continually.
I have gotten it since the 'obama from kenya' Facebook bullshit spearheaded by Trump's then best friend Hillary. A cause he then gleefully took up to run smokescreen for her.
So sit down son and kindly shut your mouth.
Jesus Cypher, you went all in on this one. Way to air the truth and your grievances! Keep going man.
Was that recent event at the capital really an insurrection or a bunch of dumdums trolling and pooing on some desks?
Edit: finished video, didnt know it was that bad.
Maybe you should try makeup tutorials while you're cooking. That won't get demonetized. Excellent as always keep up the good work.
I have heard of the red shirts that untied Italy during the early 18th century
Super excited for your upcoming videos, keep up the good work!
What is your opinion on "good" revolution? When do you think an insurrection is justified? It's all weird because even though they are wrong, the people that stormed the capitol believe that they are doing the opposite of what we accuse them of. Namely trying to preserve "liberty", enact "justice" etc.
3:39 me when i saw the one video of a J6 Protester ripping an American flag off a stand and replacing it with Trump's. The irony of "patriotism" was on such full display, the only response I could muster was hysterical laughter thinking "Oh fuck, this is what we're dealing with"
Thanks for making this content.
Shout out to King Richard the First. Raise up your glass!
Reading history, current events, and watching this video, provides proof that insurrections are only allowed if the U.S. government supports it. Jan 6th was different because it did not have the support of the U.S. military though security was quite lax. I am honestly not sure if what took place at the Capitol was an insurrection. Yeah, they occupied the building for five hours but they did not have many weapons and did not attempt to take over the government (which has happened at every modern insurrection that I know about). There were some people in that group looking to kidnap Pence and other officials but most just seemed like ridiculous yahoos looking for attention with no plan.
Every other insurrection or take over of any other government that went against American 'interests' was supported by the American government. Jan 6th makes me wonder if this 'insurrection' was just allowed in order to further censor us and push out Patriot Act 2.0. It seems like our government can't function without some type of enemy. First it was Native Americans, then the Old Spanish Empire, then Communists, then Nazis, then Communists again, then Muslims....and now I guess any American citizen who is against neoliberalism.
0:28 yesssss!!!! I’ve been saying this to history channels for years now. Since youtube hates that symbol even for history videos, everyone should replace it with the TH-cam symbol.
This is going off a bit that you said during your intro but the thing that scares me most about the biden presidency and a return to the status quo is that it will lead to another trump like figure that the status quo just gave us 4 years ago. And the terrifying part to me is that this time, this figure might actually be competent
Ya mis-spelled Cheif in the Tecumseh slide :)
“I” before “e” except after “c” ^__^
@@teejayjones4964 with a few expectations
@@theshenpartei Yes well The commenter above also needed some help spelling a certain word & that is the general rule. :3
@@teejayjones4964 I know
Excellent video! The times, they are a changing. For better and worse.
I fully await the dumpster fire that this comments section will devolve into and only lament that I won't read any of them before they're deleted, hell even this one might be.
I read it.
@@SmOlEnSk6201 how long till the comments section gets turned off?
The censorship is fucked
You've got to know when to hold, know when to fold them. Know when to walk away, know when to run~BiBle
This one got recommended to me, and I've never seen your stuff before. Guess it survived the algorithm!
One of your best
I can tell the Trump cult members know how to hit the dislike button.
AFAIK 9-11, Challenger and JFK also had some impact outside the US (decreasing impact in that order due to TV availability). Covid and just being completely fed up with everything that happened with that election just made the news to be way undercovered in comparison, so mostly a US Gen-Z thing.
PS. I find quite ironic that a revolution started by not wanting to pay the lowest taxes in the empire resulted in very aggressive taxes and (hopefully) learning why taxes are important.
PS2. 20:19 more like "down with the murderers"; while the English language distinguishes between professional "assasins" and plain "murderers", the Spanish makes not such distinction, so, context.
Can’t believe the dislike ration is so small, you sir are impressive
I thought the Battle of Athens was in this video.
I am sad to hear that you have been demonetized. I thought that only happened to those on the right of the political spectrum.
Happens to anyone that covers anything advertiser unfriendly. Was happening heavily to LGBT+ creators for years before alt-right cry bullies
You live in a bubble
That is gonna backfire on them ... just wait... it will come at them like karma to a pie in the face
2:21& the people tired of gov bs...3:35 what process, that was gone years ago...4:20 I remember, Jackson the infamous crazy og prez that kept things interesting, like our modern contemporary...the rest I just enjoyed.
Props for including Natives in American history.
All Hail King Richard!
Long live the king
Long live the furriest king
What about the March on Washington by the "Bonus Army?"
I love your knowledge of history. I'll be honest, I hate politics.
Insurrection is great, but have you tried eXisTeNtiAl DrEAd??? Seriously though, if you haven't done so, look into putting your content on Nebula. Several of my favorite creators seem to do well in their more, shall we say, "educationally conducive" environment. Great video, I hope it stays up! I'll check my shekels and look at some merch :)
A fantastic video! I have downloaded it and saved it to watch at my leisure again and again. I am going to check out those Wikipedia articles on American Insurrections!
One slight note regarding the cops that took selfies: That was misinterpreted.
I will first say I am just taking the chance to, IMHO, clear up this and other misconceptions people may have (not that I am an expert. I am not in law enforcement on any level). That said:
The Rioter just leaned over and took it with the cop. The cop did lean in a little to help him get the picture but that does not mean he sympathized with the rioters. He likely just didn't want to make waves since he and the other rioters were leaving by that time in that area.
Here is a Politifact description of the possible misunderstanding
"In one video, a Capitol officer is seen posing for a selfie with one of the pro-Trump rioters inside. The man who shared it told PolitiFact that it happened after police managed to start herding the crowd out of the building."
tinyurl.com/yjxxxbyu
In the first few days a lot of accusations of Capitol Police "letting in" and cooperating with the Insurrectionist mostly due to misinterpreted video on Social Media (including the selfie and MAGA hat scandals), not understanding that the cops were initially wildly outnumbered and largely not having riot gear on and the general public not knowing procedure in a situation like that (you don't dive into a crowd like that outnumbered. You can get hurt, even killed and your gun taken), or yes were quick to draw a false equivalency between how the police acted during the George Floyd Protest and Riots and the Capitol Riot. All that led to a rush to judgment. Of course in the weeks since we have seen some horrific videotape of cops being beaten and almost shot with their own guns. We have learned that 150 cops were injured 15 of them hospitalized with one losing an eye, another three fingers, another with a badly injured back. And of course one dead; three if one counts the two suicides.
I am just saying the idea of the cops at the scene operating with the Rioters is very likely to be not true. I do not blame the cops on the ground. They were simply unprepared and undermanned. Why was that show I point the finger at the top brads who didn't take the Insurrection/terrorist chatter by extreme right-wing groups seriously, the Pentagon controlled by a Trump lackey and Trump himself.
Great Historical channel!!!😻 ❤😊