How Kambwala Showed He can be the Perfect CB for Man Utd vs Liverpool...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 เม.ย. 2024
- RETRO JERSEYS HERE: retrojerseyhub.com
SUB to the PATREON (7 day FREE TRIAL): patreon.com/AtlantisFootball572
How Kambwala Showed He can be the Perfect CB for Man Utd vs Liverpool...
Man Utd 4-3 Liverpool Extra Time Analysis (190k views): • How Ten Hag & Amad Won...
Recent Videos:
Kobbie Mainoo is a COMPLETE Midfielder: • Kobbie Mainoo is a COM...
Why Dalot is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED: • Why Dalot is CRIMINALL...
How Hojlund is Developing into the Complete Striker: • Hojlund is Evolving in...
How to Rebuild Man Utd's Midfield for £75M: • How to Rebuild Man Utd...
Email: atlantisfootball96@gmail.com
Instagram: @AtlantisFootball
Twitter: @atlantis861
I must state that in NO way, shape or form am I intending to infringe rights of the copyright holder. Content used is strictly for research/reviewing purposes and to help educate. All under the Fair Use law.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
If you ever wish for more information on visual or auditory terms, please click the link below:
is.gd/wvjoCp - กีฬา
![แฟนแนวใด๋ - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ SyncVersion ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fm8oDwos2uc/mqdefault.jpg)
This is the problem at times with TH-camrs, FIFA(FC24) and all these analysis apps and sites makes them think that they Fergusons, Klopps, Peps and the Cruyffs of this world. TH sees and coaches this kid in training everyday, you see few games and the result of TH's work and behold you have discovered talent. I agree with a lot of things you say with an exception on your view on ETH, I think that is B.S, De Jong, De Ligt, Ziyech and Van Der Beek (that we ruined) at Ajax are the proof it
Well obviously it’s not working considering we are conceding 30 shots a game which apparently according to everyone is because of the CB situation.
Ten Hag also seems to think Amad doesn’t deserve game time which he clearly does. Just because he sees him train doesn’t mean he is right
Ajax have a youth strategy that goes above the manager
@@Darkmountaindweller “maybe you should try managing Manchester United” yep that’s how it works 👍🏼 I’ll give it a go over summer mate.
Right so you’re basically saying that if Ten Hag decides to do something, he must be right. Mate stop watching fan channels. Ten Hag clearly should have given Amad time.
@@Darkmountaindweller mate you’re a crybaby. Can’t accept basic criticism. You can unsubscribe all you want if you want to live in an echo chamber and not here other opinions.
We are complete Shit and have been for months and you can’t take basic criticism of ten Hag. Are you his PR team or something?
@@AtlantisFootball that's not criticism you are trying to take away the man's credit to belittle what he is doing. How many youngsters have made it into the first team from the academy in the past 4 years the youth staffs haven't changed that much so why have there not been that many academic players breaking through to the first team in the past years
I realised he is actually better than I thought
I was praising him since he was 16
@@98godofwar i was never a fan of januzaj or wilson
I loved powell i still feel injuries ruined him
Is this an Video an analyzing Kambwallah of or Rant against ETH? Cuz the Tone changed Mid Video...😅
It’s not a rant video, it’s analysing the situation
@@AtlantisFootball love your videos dude - the analysis and stats but more importantly the ideas you have are quality. Just be careful with opinions on the manager as it will polarise the community ... it's very clear that the mainstream media want him out and will chuck negative looking stats down our throats to make everything look worse. Conceding a lot of shots because we played an open style to counter an oppositions style isn't a big deal when we end up roughly level on score or even on clear cut chances. I'd take 3 years of heartattack open football over the carcrash 6 months Southgate will get because he's sacked at christmas when we're 12th behind chelsea
💯facts. Love the channel as well but pushing the narrative that he hasn’t developed the younger players just to go against the manager is kinda tiresome within the fan base
worrd , 😅
Surely a rant 😂
This is why we should keep ETH….. I think we’ve found our Saliba with Kambwala.
It’s not tho. If anything it’s why we shouldn’t keep him because he only gives youth a chance when the likes of evans and Lindelof are injured. If we sign a new CB in the summer Kambwala might get fewer minutes
We need to sell 3 CB (lindelof, maguier, Evens)!! And get in 2 CB that have pace and can play ball! You have seen the injuries we get at CB and with Martinez we dont know if he will be injury pron.. so we may have only 4 at CB. And how do u want to give Youngsters a chanse?
We are both saying to play Kambwala mate
Yea but we need more CB is my point. He cant play 60 games a season and thats why we need 2 more like him that can play this way
@@AtlantisFootball you are just looking at the first team. When he arrived the first thing I remember he did was, get into the management of the youth teams. He standardized the way they played through tout the U16s to U21s. Ten Hag is looking this first team, he knows for sure 70% of them are not gonna be here. So he’s creating that pathway to the first team through youth football. He’s replicating what he did at Ajax at United. With his first team tactics, this is not the future. He knows exactly what he’s doing. Revolutions take time. And now that financial rules are tightening, the best way to build a quality team will be through the academy. John Mortough wasn’t stupid, they saw this ahead of time, hence their concentration on youth and a coach who could develop the system. This will pay off probably in 26/27 season. And I wouldn’t be shocked if we challenge for the title that year.
It's not like he didn't want to play him but he wanted to play him on the right time so that he don't destroy him l
Not really because he brought him on at full back a couple of times. If the CB’a are the issue for ten Hag, why isn’t he playing Kambwala?
Maybe cas he wasnt ready yet?? Maybe ETH was waiting for the best time to play him??
@@chillsounds1938 mate what are these excuses. He only played him becahse evans and Lindelof were injured. How is the best time to play him against Liverpool and not Luton or Everton?
Kambwala already played against westham in Dec. Started with Evans at the back.
Tbh, I think I’ve heard this somewhere...and it makes sense. Mainoo broke through at gala away, then went on to play Liverpool.
Yes it would have helped to bring him sooner, but I also think in environments like that (harsh) they develop faster. Mind set wise as well
Atlantis my guy, how do you know that kambwala was ready to play????{"HE WAS IN THE BENCH WHEN EVANS AND MAGUIRE WAS PLAYING"}, during the west ham game, he was steady but you could feel like he was overpromoted, he didn't seem calm on the ball... in the liverpool game, all that seem to be clear (he got wayyyy better). I'm not as good as an analyst has you, but i feel SO FAR when it comes to youth development, Ten hag hasn't put a foot wrong.
By the way, Oyedele can't even start on a league 2 relegation side (forrest green). Fair play to the youngster, but is this the type of player you want on the club??, A 19yr old benched on in league 2 to replace Casemiro right now.
Yes of course he’s ready 🤣 so you’re telling me he is not ready to start vs Luton and Everton but is vs Liverpool?
Ten Hag has most definitely put a foot wrong with youth development come on bro, look at the Fernandez and Amad situations.
Oyedele wasn’t starting because he had an argument, also they had Troy Deeney in charge which says it all. Casemiro has been absolutely horrific. There’s no way Oyedele could be worse
FAIR PLAY!, @@AtlantisFootball fernandez and amad may be profiles that ten hag doesn't want. But for Kambwala, I can still argue that he wasn't ready until the liverpool or probably truly not good enough to start yet until the latter game, probably he may not be consistent enough to start, we'll never know. like you said in the comments below, ten hags only picks youth players who are better than the starting squad. right now kobbie is benching mount, garna is benching antony/rashy/amad.. kambwala is no way near benching this season's maguire or varane. we wait and see how it goes from now
@@josiahrhobi8764 but my point is from a stylistic point of view, people will say that Ten Hag can’t play the way he wants with Maguire in the back line.
Yet then they’ll defend Ten Hag for not playing a quicker CB like Kambwala because he wasn’t ready. Do you see how making both arguments is a contradiction?
That’s a good point. Obviously you think Willy is good now, but before Liverpool, did you think he was? Lots of comments saying he was shaky and seemed unsettled before Liverpool...so you should have picked up on this
@@bear566 but how can we know if he doesn’t play. It’s not as if there were quality senior CB’s ahead of him it was evans and Lindelof
kabwala was injured almost the whole of last year, can we let him grow into the team. his an incredible talent
Todibo and Kambwala could be a french wall and the future united defensive partnership for many years to come.
I think they're keeping alvarro at benfica in the hopes of leveraging a deal for Joao Neves... it's a gamble that could pay off so hard to call it a bad decision yet. In terms of the speed that Willy has come through this season, there have been times where I've wanted to see him get more gametime but I think ETH has managed it relatively well given the balance of young to experienced players we've been forced into through injuries.. when ETH was playing survival full counter football just before christmas, it made more sense to use Evans and Maguire - it's positive to see his strategy moving away from safe, even if the pundits keep calling it 'chaos'
Nah they aren’t. They have no leverage coz there’s a release clause in the contract. Neves also has a release clause and Benfica ain’t selling for less so there’s no leverage to be gained in this deal
I think they should be bring Alvarez back
@@AtlantisFootball maybe not specifically contractual leverage - appreciate your knowledge of the details with the contracts. it just seemed like one of those 'goodwill' deals when we sent him there, like we were trying to do it as a persuasion tactic... perhaps I'm giving the recruitment strategy too much credit haha
dude they're not playing Alvaro. They're wasting him like other clubs do when they want to buy our players for cheap!!! All the last 5 matches its their other LB that played
I'd like to play Amad in a way where he and Bruno exchange between the right side of the pitch and the centre. Amad could drop to the midfield and carry the ball while Bruno is dangerous in the right or amad holds the right flank opening up space for Bruno
I think people don't realize that our youth academy has absolutely blown up ever since ten hag came because we know that Ten Hag has a lot of power in terms of the clubs structure
I'm not saying it's blowing up because of ten hag but he obviously had a major part to play
Mate it’s nothing to do with ten Hag come on. This dates back to 2016, with Nicky butt and Nick Cox. It just so happens that Ten Hag was manager.
We won the fa youth cup in 2022 which was before Ten Hag even came in
@@AtlantisFootball besides that I agree with a lot of stuff you have to say about ten hag
Because I'm ten hag in but I'm not completely in I have a lot critisms about him
My problem with you is that in the past 6 months I have never had you give Ten Hag credit for anything, I understand he's been rubbish this year but you act as if he's never done anything good and all this bad stuff happening is because of him for example the Fernandez situation: ten hag was told malacia and shaw would be back by January and many other players would be back from injury that's why Fernandez and others were loaned out
You've been very critical of ten hag and it's not really a problem but you've been down right unfair towards you even told me pep would finish top 4 with this current injury hit squad that's just delusional bro
Your videos in the past few weeks has been spot on. I really like the focus on youth. Please keep making more videos on youth its an area that hasn't really been tapped on youtube.
Thanks man 🙏🏼 any other videos you want to see?
Sadly I get the feeling ETH doesn’t feel him like he does garnacho. I think played Willy simply because he had to. If united are able to in the summer they’ll get new defenders and Kambalas performance against Liverpool will be forgotten much like amads is. When a manager doesn’t favour you there’s not
Much you can do.
Yep completely agree. Amad, Kambwala, Gore, Fernandez and Oyedele are perfect examples that Ten Hag doesn’t trust youth unless they are already better than first team players
@@AtlantisFootball my concern is that ETH isn’t even willing to see if they’re better or not. I don’t know if it’s a style of play thing or a personality thing but he favours some and not others. iMO amad is potentially uniteds best attacker- he’s ahead of garnacho technically and I think has a better football iq, considering how bad antony and Bruno have been this season he has been worth a run for a while. Gore? Is another who’s technically good like amad but is a bit on the slight side in terms of stature. So it appears ETH is favouring players on physicality? Which is surprising considering we thought he was more of a coach that favours tactical intelligence and technical ability. The guy confuses me. All I know if lvg would have used kambala a lot earlier than this.
@@AtlantisFootball but that is what ETH said when he came in, that he will only play them if they are better than what he has in the first team
@@kingt5528 so he genuinely thinks that antony and Bruno’s performances are still good enough to keep our young players? Joke manager
@@jga7887patience by the 31st game of the season? And we all know he keeps chosing Anthony over Amad. Anthony had to be piss poor to even get the bench when even his availability was a liability.
Like one of the commenters said, it's clearly a case of people he likes or doesn't
Nice work 💪
Love that you gave a shout out to Maxi Oyedele. Am surprised he hasn't at least been called up yet. His game is good. He is athletic, can tackle, and has really nice press resistance.
Would love to see him make the squad next season.
Keep up the work.
Thanks bro 🙏🏼 yep he should have been in the squad this season with the options we have. Exactly why I’m critical of Ten Hag. LVG played a lot more youth players
I think ETH should defo look at getting Scalvini (perfect for his system ) , Joao Neves, Olise and Toney
Forget neves he is value around 140m and United doesnt have money this season
If scalvini is attainable for a fee of no more than 50 mil, I'll go for it. Neves is a big no-no, because we have Mainoo, who is better and cheaper (0 VS 100 mil).
Olise had a severe injury.
Toney is not good enough to play for united and reputationwise I'd not take him, considering all other problems at united
@@user-mc4tm9lh6x where have you plucked that valuation out of... lol hes not valued at anywhere near that figure
His introduction has been very well managed and though he had to be thrown into the deep end during a rather injury ravaged period, he didn't sink... akin to when Rashford had to step up. He was never going to start ahead of a fit Varane, Martinez and in-form Maguire... he's grabbed his chance like Mainoo did, and he should push on now and grasp it.
Credit to ten Hag for continuing his impressive bringing in of youth and developing them plus having all levels play a similar way making it easier to come through. The Academy coaches are doing an incredible job.
Mainoo, Garnacho, Hojlund, Kambwala and many more gems to come by the looks of things. The future is looking bright. Great video!
Thanks man
I heard the possessive we and ours and realized your are a United fan. Love it!
Also Atlantis, forgot to say, great video! you never disappoint. as you already know, I'm in the TEN HAG IN bandwagon, you are in the TEN HAG OUT train. I watch the United Stand daily, from the pole you made, I can realize that i may be brainwashed by Mark🤧🤧. BUT after my own thorough thoughts i have generated my opinions on why ETH should stay
FIRST OF ALL, If some people are TEN HAG OUT then let's be real you absolutely also stand by
1)writing off last season's achievement
we saw prime rashford, garnacho rise, 2 cup finals, lisandro masterclass, dalot's rise, greenwood's saga ie the way he handled it, sancho saga ie the way he handled it, ronaldo saga etc. He took a team that was battered 4nil by watford which got relegated, the epl united team in history to finsh 3rd and win a cup with werghorst upfront and 10. We did not have style of play because we kicked it off to the dustbin the moment we lost to brentford because we didn't have players comfortable playing from the back.
2)disregarding this season's problem
these are facts, we probably have the highest cb combinations in the league, due to injuries, underperformance from all of our last season's best players ie rashford, Casemiro and eriksen. Onana's transition period is disregarded, ALSO INJURIES. Now people want to know ten hag's tactics,
=style of play
Do i say i know ETH's style of play?NO, because i watch football but not an expert in tactics. but i do see indications of what he wants to do.. 1)he wants to play from the back (he bought onana, wanted de jong, played eriksen deep), well this season casemiro, has been shite, lisandro and shaw are injured, Maguire varane and lindelof have been in and out. 2)he wants to press( indiscipline and lack of effort from some players), 3)he wants to play a highline(cbs aren't tight enough in the midfield and are slow and we can't risk slow cb's at the back coz we don't want silly thrashings like brighton). some of the in game tactics this season i would say have been inconsistent, but most of them have been down to the player's own individual errors (players switching off, not tracking their man, onana etc)
=expectactions
please don't compare united with brighton, spurs and aston villa, these teams can do what they are doing only because they don't have the same goals or the pressure as we are. they know they have a good enough squad to stay in the league and experiment. Any manager post fergie has tried their own system but all have fallen to the conservative, win focused, counter attacking style after 1-2 losing games. Same thing ten hag has done, but i'll say we've been more expansive has ever and won more games per games than any manager post fergie. SO MY QUESTION IS, if the likes of De Zerbi or Unai etc who take over after ETH, will you (fans) be patient enough to stand with their style of play even if we get thrashed 4nils in the first few games for the sake of tactics, even if it will cost us title contention? IF NO... then lets keep ten hag, let him battle this out, he has kept this season steady and we can agree that we assume last season doesn't exist(no major thrashings this season), lets get behind him until he gets the structure and recruitment he desires for his style of play. IF YES.....then still lets keep ten hag, because isn't style of play the reason why we bought him? the legendary Ajax coach who pisses on big clubs through entertaining football. lets get his players back from injury and get new signings that fit his system.
=Arsenal and liverpool
just to mention, arsenal style of play cost him top 4 for 3 seasons, liverpool for 2 seasons. clearly it was their plan all along, suffer now win later, fair play to us, we don't want to suffer at all, that's what ten hag did last season and it's what his doing now, only its not working especially because of the quality of players available this season. FAIR PLAY TO ETH coz he is trying to do both. So let's all agree that if we want to style of play NOW we should be ready to be midtable for 2-3 seasons before we start competing again.
i dont like that last part because not too long ago i had the same realisation😮💨😮💨. people are complaining saying "the players run too much" the intensity of the league is higher than its ever been, so we can't have players that dont want to run. the physical ceilings have to be pushed to a point whereby its better than the whole league. all that while having better technical players, better mentality, and consistently to deliver results. if you cant meet the standard physical requirements, you weeded out
@@bear566 spot on mate
He’s a fantastic addition going into a transfer window knowing we need two CBs. Although I still think that’s the case, we know Kambwala can definitely be a good back up.
you already getting rocked in the comments, so bro...can you do an analysis on ajax and this united team. there was a video trending on twitter where eth, guuilt and others were basically discussing tactics and principles. cause i think we experiencing the other side of the principle...pretty sure you'll find it
I’m not getting rocked in the comments at all mate. I’ve rebutted every comment criticising what I’ve said
Nice content ( informative )
Thanks 🙏🏼
He was solid throughout this game, and most of the other minutes he’s accumulated this season. Still young and I would be hesitant to play him full time next season. Either a loan, or as rotational player, then hopefully he can establish himself as the starter soon.
How does a loan with an option to buy work? If Benfica decide they want to buy Fernandez, do we have to sell?
He has passion for the game and the badge. He needs more playing time to cope like kobbie mainoo ❤❤❤. Much love for him by my side ❤❤🎉🎉.
A defensive combination of Kambwala Martinez Dalot and Malacia or Shaw will be elite
I don't agree with your point about Mainoo forcing ten Hag's hand because of his involvement with the first team last season, when Casemiro was still good, and the fact that he started all the pre-season games until his injury
I think you're coming off quite naive in this one i don't think a manager post fergie has been more involved in the whole structure of the club than ETH he aware of every player 16+ and has opinions on all of them it's clear fernandez lacks the strength or intensity to play premier league football at this point in time
Mate it’s not naive at all. Have you seen Fernandez? He doesn’t lack strength at all. He played in the championship for Preston and was very good. He is 100% ready to play in the premier league particularly this season.
Ten Hag hasn’t been as involved as people make out. United won the FA youth Cup in 2022 before ten Hag arrived. The real credit needs to go to Nick Cox, Jon Murtuagh and Nicky Butt
@AtlantisFootball for preston, he played as a lwb playing behind a natural lb. i watched him play in the europa against toulouse, and he struggled physically to win duels. If he was setting the world a light over there you would definitely have a case.
@@danielca3 not really he’s definitely physically ready for the PL, I defo have case coz we don’t even have a fit LB. He should 100% still be here
@@AtlantisFootballsounds so desperate to argue with no valid points to offer
@@bipindahal2712 all my points are valid, I don’t understand how you can’t understand them
Worth noting Garnacho, Alvares and Kambwala were all brought in at the same time, Good to see scouts are doing their jobs and looking forward to the future. But i agree these players should/would make it under any manager
True I remember that season like yesterday lol
We all saw how it took a good run of games for casimero to get going when he joined. That wasnt adjusting to a new league, new club. Hes comin off a few injuries. He'll be instrumental next season
Mate 100% won’t be. He’s done
AGREED, ENTIRELY!!
Any chance in seeing how you’d setup United on fm maybe? Would be cool to see
Don’t really play FM, haven’t for about 6 years now but I will do a video on how I’d set up United and use the terminology from football manager to describe the roles
No matter what happens, next season should be the decider for eth not this season.
I don't think eth develop the youth but he has an eye for the talented few and he brings them into first team training were he can then transition them into first team members members and he is fantastic at that. Maxi is good but watching him in the youth he strikes me as another attacking cm but hopefully he can make the grade.
I am sad about gore, loan spell didn’t go well as well. Ended up injured😪😪
I think him and mainoo are gonna interchange between 6 and 8
Starting young mids and wingers are easier.. defenders usually develop much more later.. they usually develop around 23-24 yrs old and peak at a later age.. not many can go straight to the team.. jonny evans was also played on off games during his early years.. even pique couldnt get enough play time.. even saliba was loaned by arsenal to get that extra experience.. who else started early as CB? Maybe Deligt in ajax and Upamecano.. but not as much as wingers/mids..
I agree . I am also disappointed with ETH on Alvaro and Pellestri. But hopefully he can course correct
Tbf I don’t think Pellistri was ever good enough but if so he should have been sold or loaned out well before
Ten Hag hasn’t played Kambwela cus he’s just come back from 2 years of injury, I think he’s managed kambwela perfectly as with kobbie and grancacho
Exciting times with these young players. It would be nice to see some get some first team minutes if United have nothing to play for. Oyedele still ineligible for 1st team to play this season as he is still technically on loan.
Oh is he I thought that only applied to PL teams and if he had been at 2 other clubs this season
@@AtlantisFootball yeah, I don't think his loan have officially been terminated. Would have been nice to see him get a chance end of season and see if he was good enough, especially with Casemiros struggles
Normally I agree with you in a lot of ways tbh ETH could've given Kambwala a shot much earlier but at the same time I think the squad is fragile mentally and you have to be careful how you integrate young talent because of that fragility now with Garnacho & Kobbie we have seen 2 young players who can handle the pressure whereas we've seen the more senior players crumble I would imagine ETH can see the fragile mindset in this squad and this state of mind has been here for a while now even before this current manager so I would guess to bring Kambwala along you need to make sure he can handle that same pressure now we need to see more then a couple games to make sure we are not just on a hype train even with Kobbie and Garnacho at this stage they are all young in a fragile team and thriving even tho the team are struggling there are defiantly things ETH HAS TO IMPROVE ON !!! but we also can't let these players get away with poor performances the players need to take accountability for these poor numbers as you said Casemiro was walking against Chelsea and he's the DM he could do more just like the other players are not giving everything and you can see that a lot of them need moving on asap it's like 10 or more that need moving on as a supporter I willing to give ETH another season with this new ownership in place and see what we can do
The Class of 22 🙌
Kambwala is one for the future, but during the next transfer window, united need to sign 2 centre backs, todibo and anselmino. Todibo is an experienced cb and should be paired with licha as our starting cbs next season while anselmino and kambwala will be the backup pairing since their both still young and inexperienced.
At left back, shaw is injury prone, so malacia should start with amass being backup and at right back, if wan bissaka is sold, sign geertruida, start him and dalot will be backup. That's my suggestion.
I don't think we can play Oyadele as he is on loan at forrest green (they don't want him now and he plays fo U21 so I wonder if he can be added to first team)
Apparently the loan hasn’t been officially ended which is why. Don’t understand the logic behind it. Just wasting him not being able to play. Typical United tho
Great video, Kambwalla is ready and this kinda reminds me of teden mengi who's doing good at Luton now. He played great everytime he put on a United shirt
I think the lad was already attributed himself in first game against West Ham but Eric took long to play him as analysed.
I feel amass should be our 3rd choice lb next season.
Your right the praise should lie at the door of the manager that is giving these young players a clear pathway to the first team....
He’s not giving them a clear pathway though. Evans and Lindelof were blocking it for Kambwala and Antony was blocking it for Amad
@@AtlantisFootball Sure you can say that and pick and choose. However, with that being said you could say that about Mainoo last season that he was "blocking" him with Erikson, loaning in Sabitzer. You can see that he has a clear plan with these players i.e. clearing the way for kobbie (selling garner, and sending out hannibal). What if he doesn't actually think Kambwala was ready and needed an extra year to be around the first team like he did with Mainoo last year. Im just saying taking all the credit away from him is a bit unfair. Big fan of the content just thought it was a bit unfair that's all.
I feel people are overplaying this whole eth is good with youth thing,like you said mainoo and garnacho would have played under any other manager due to underperformance in our squad, I feel the only reason kambwala started is because eth didn't have a choice players like maxi and fernandez would have likely been given playing time under someone like a jurgen klopp
Yep exactly my point. Look at the opportunities klopp is giving the Liverpool youngsters in a title challenging side
that Maxi guy is prolly the backup option if they couldnt gather much money to spend next season
i was just waiting to see de zerbi
Don’t agree with your take that Ten haag has nothing to do with their development he’s the one that integrating them into the first team and giving them a platform to perform no matter what’s the situation with injury. There are a lot of talented youngsters at other clubs but not being given the opportunity ten haag is giving these youngsters
I disagree. Selling Teden Mengi to make way for Kambwala was ETH's decision. It's easier for attacking players, but for midfielders and defenders, it's always a tough decision. Playing him against West Ham was the highlight of his career. If it is that easy - why is Pep, Klopp…going all out for CBs and ignoring academy players. Aside Smallings…mention any CB that came close. None
Even Messi did not make his debut until he was 17 ( and he was not a regular).
Willy already played against westham man and he had a solid game, even though we lost. Since then he's been coming on as a sub when needed and there's nothing wrong with that. This is not the season to throw a young cb in at the deep end.
No this is the exact season to throw young players in. They aren’t going to get game time when we are performing well with senior players. They need to play in seasons like this
@@AtlantisFootball this is the type of season that finished Tyler Blackett and borthwick-jackson. You can't afford to do that to your up and coming defenders.
Good analysis video as always... and I know that we've had a tough season so I'll forgive the silly whining... One can never question ten Hag on youth development... it's what he's done throughout his career and still doing. Calm down.
Thanks 🙏🏼 but he’s been playing evans and Lindelof over Kambwala. For months people have been telling me that the defensive issues are just because ten Hag didn’t have a quick CB. now people want to tell me he was right to start evans and Lindelof over Kambwala. Can’t have it both ways
Man Utd senior team should have a monthly game with the junior side. Those who excelled should be utilized to patched up with the seniors. The senior team will then have to showcase their capabilities or be replaced by these youngsters.
We've reached a point where its time to risk it and play the youngters, Hannibal wasnt that good but he had the athleticism Casemiro lacks, Amad is better in possession than Rashford, Alvaro couldve been a great alternative at Lb even if Shaw was rumoured to be returning we should've kept him as a plan B. Amass was on the bench in the last game, maybe its time to through him in as a wingback first, then gradually play him at Lb.
Yep completely agree
I guess you've got to give the manager some credit for bringing through these youngsters🤷♂️
😂🤡
He hasn’t brought through the youngsters. Garnacho and Mainoo are better than the first team players.
Fernandez, amad, gore and Kambwala all prove my point
@@AtlantisFootball No they don't.. Under other managers they wouldn't even have played.
They don't prove your point. You mis-use their case to try to make a point.
BIG difference
Yes they absolutely would have played considering the options we have. They absolutely prove my point. People want to bring through youth players until it actually comes to playing them
I bit you never knew about kambwalla before his debut againeast westham you talking about giving gernatcho chance whenever the coach he was and forgot that he wasnt the only guy whose get the chance omari forson dani gore majbre all they got chances to impress
Well I did considering I do videos analysing the youth players almost every year.
Gore and Amad have not gotten a chance 🤣
Yes because Garnacho and Mainoo are already better than the first team players he has. That’s not what we mean when we say giving youth a chance. How is this a hard concept to understand?
Lad had an absolute stinker today. I'm hoping with a settled system and a long term defensive partner he can kick on massively. Long road ahead.
Dalot didn't help him either with the second, being his senior and all.
Kluivert showed him
I feel, just to give EtH the benefit of the doubt, that he's not played Kambwala a lot this season because he's unsure how he'll perform in real matches. Whatever the reason. If EtH then goes back to Evans or Lindelof when they're fit again and not pick Kambwala, I'd be baffled especially after that Liverpool game. Kambwala should at least be 2nd behind Varane for the RCB role.
Also important to say- margin of success for academic players is always very low. Only 1% play pro football. We now have 3 - with 2 starting regularly for manutd. A lot more playing in other teams …
I hope this is a golden generation, if not we’re gonna be in the abyss for another decade.
We said the same about Tuanzebe against mbape
Yeah but they two different players
Gave a like cos, I've been a long-time subscriber and i genuinely think you'rea good person ....but some of the things you've been saying lately is honestly crazy and not in a good way. It feels like a hate campaign rather than objective criticism.
You're analysis are usually good and even if i dont agree with some i can at least appreciate the reasoning behind it. But lately its seems its more hate than actually analysis and objectivity.
I'll continue to support as always, just felt i just throw in my 2 cents
Mate it’s not crazy nor a hate campaign at all. You are trying to defend ten Hag wherever possible instead of being objective.
you say I am usually objective but suddenly when you disagree with me I’m not objective anymore. All my points are extremely objective and valid.
I literally praised ten Hag during the Liverpool 4-3 game. Just because you don’t agree with it doesn’t mean it’s crazy or not objective
@@AtlantisFootballi I'm a ten hag outer ..... soo I'm not saying don't sack him, all I'm saying is it lately juat feels like a pile on, that's all ......not saying you hate the man or anything.
All In all keep up the extent work and content 👌
People forget his debut was away at West Ham where he started and was really good. I can´t understand why people like Evans, Lindelof and Maguire have been starting ahead of him in the last couple of months.
Yep exactly my point. People will give credit to Ten Hag for playing him vs Liverpool but it’s only because he had no other options. He should have been in the team months ago.
People have been telling me that he doesn’t have the CB’s but now what to say that Ten Hag was right to play Lindelof and Evans over him. It can’t be both
@@AtlantisFootball mate you have people like Goldbridge gaslighting fans into thinking that if we sack Ten Hag we´re getting Southgate.
Yep that’s their main argument against sacking Ten Hag which says it all 🤣. Even if Southgate did come in, we are already terrible. But that’s not a reason to not sack a manager lol, the expectations of this club from the fan base are in the mud
@@AtlantisFootball i would replace him with Inzaghi in the Summer, i know you favour De Zerbi but since Lazio Inzaghi has been imprressive and the way he managed to step up at Inter has been amazing.
Alvaro fernandez is being pushed away to make space for Harry Amass just like iqbal made way for kobie
I don’t think he was. Amass is not ready for the first team for at least another 12-18 months realistically. Ten Hag just didn’t want to use Fernandez
Fernandez is worse defending... that's why Ten Hag didn't want to use him. He's worse
No he’s not 🤣🤣 you’ve not even watched him play. He was playing Lindelof at LB. this is what I am talking about in regards to fan channel delusion. You are just creating your own fantasies to justify ten hag’s bad decisions
Ten Hag has succeeded with promoting youths and only technically gifted players have gotten the node, he had to sell Zidane Iqbal coz that would pave way for Kobbie... you just don't have to be go but the best to play for United.
@@kingprosper5541 what about playing Antony over amad, Lindelof over Fernandez and Evans over Kambwala?
Glad you think you know more than ETH and the coaches that have seen these youngsters day in and day out... There are lots of factors that go into team selection. How do you know Kambwala was 100% ready to start? You got that wrong about Mainoo. ETH wanted to play him from the beginning of the season, but he got injured. I respected your analysis a lot, but starting to doubt it. Dont let a few subscribers get you into thinking you know more than professionals that have been doing it for longer than you seem to have been alive. Stop saying people are deluded for not sharing the same opinion as you, or calling you out on yours.
What a nonsense opinion. If ten Hag new so much he wouldn’t have signed Antony because he worked with him at Ajax. What sort of logic is that. Use your brain.
By your own logic I could say I obviously know more than you considering I do this professionally so therefore you should just listen to my opinion. You see how that’s ridiculous?
Evaluate the actual opinion, your way of thinking is exactly what is wrong with most of the fanbase
Good video in the first half, a bit too many assumptions/opinions or correlational infrences presented as fact in the second half of the vid
Zispoms, a tiktok creator, says that in upcoming decade united can easily become one of the best and biggest clubs in europe (by trophies, not legacy), winning UCLs and premierships.
When do you think Man United will start winning either one of those?
Can’t really say, depends on the manager, transfer window etc
@@AtlantisFootball maybe a worst case - realistic - optimistic scenarios?
Thank you Anthony Martial for bringing this gem to training one day 🙏🏾
With no left back ... Harry Amass Needs to gets some minutes
Promoting kids is good but needs to be managed as they develop physically... now with INEOS, they're is already a decent "club network" path for developing talent
Yep completely agree
I'm convinced Kambwala is our second best second best Centre back. Ten hag knows this but he's washed so yea
Kwambala isn’t ready. Pau Cubarsi and Antonio Silva is what an impressive youngster looks like. Maybe he develops faster, but from all the games I’ve watched of him recently, still not good.
Kambwala isn’t ready because he hasn’t been given enough game time
@@AtlantisFootball might be too early of me to criticize him, but even with game time, from what I see he’s not gonna be world class
He’s played 2 games 🤣
@@AtlantisFootball that’s why I said it might be too early to judge, so I won’t be overly critical. Maybe he’s young and not used to the pressure yet, but I think he’ll be a bench player for United at best
kwambwala has already played a couple games? Ten hag gave him chances even tho he didn’t look as good as he did against liverpool
Yes that’s my point. He gave him a chance when Evans and Lindelof were injured
He could have played more games over the last few months considering apparently we can’t play how Ten Hag wants because we haven’t got quick CB’a
@@AtlantisFootball yeah but you gotta put in to perspective he didn’t have the best of performances in the previous games
@@AtlantisFootball i’m pretty sure he started him over one of them two i might be wrong tho
Hope he doesn't end up like tuanzebe, he was good but poor management led to his downfall
He is actually good but remember is best you should not rush young players to the first team
Our first objective is to improve the side. If Kambwala improves the side he has to play. Playing him prior to this would have done no harm to him at all
I still think Case isn’t fully fit and recovered from his muscle injury that’s what I think tho
Nah it’s not. He is just unfit because he hasn’t kept himself in shape
And is analysis video about kambwala not ETH
ETH is the manager mate
u forgot amad his future star🌠
Didn’t include him as he wasn’t an academy graduate
United has to be smart this window and not buy players the block the development of these young players while still competing for a top spot.
But they also have to sign players that can actually allow them to compete for the title. Can’t focus solely on young players because you end up like chelsea
@AtlantisFootball agreed. Hopefully, Uniteds new back room can balance those two things
Mourinho should have sold garnacho and mainoo like he did to KDB
He wouldn’t have sold them because he wouldn’t have the set of senior players that he had at Chelsea like Hazard, Oscar and Willian
Atlantis always like your content but and I usually agree with your content and enjoy watching it but I believe your view about Erik ten Hag is wrong. I think the reason he hasn’t played Amad is because he is trying to find a consistent frontline which seems to be Rashford, Højlund and Garnacho. I don’t like the fact he hasn’t played Amad because I rate him but Garnacho is certainly at the moment better than him and Rashford has a place because of what he did last season. I also think with Kambwala in a way the way ten Hag has played him has been alright but also not alright. But with youngsters you usually don’t want to make their heads too big by giving them too many games. You have to make them realise how precious that spot in the team is. But maybe he should have been playing earlier on. Like I said like your content mate and this isn’t a major dig just something I disagree with you on. 👌
Mate I think you’re trying to rationalise his bad decisions. He has been playing Antony for months and barely given Amad game time. I don’t think it’s to do with a consistent front line I think he’d rather develop the player he brought in rather than someone who has more potential for United
Thanks bro 🙏🏼
Agree with you on the Antony thing it makes him look bad and I like Diallo over Antony but perhaps he is just trying to rely on who he thinks is better? Idk
@AtlantisFootball anthony has actually played well since the turn of the year all things considered
@@danielca3 only in the last few games particularly against Chelsea. And only because he was diabolical previously
He wasn’t starting cause he wasn’t ready. Against West Ham he wasn’t great but he learnt from that and was great against pool but had he been thrown in before he’s ready and had stinkers it would have destroyed his confidence and delayed development. The coaches and a managers see them everyday in training and know which player is ready or not.
He was ready. We had Evans and Lindelof starting ahead. I’ve been told that the reason our defence is a shambles is because we don’t have quick CB’s to play a high line. If that’s the case Kambwala should have played.
This is also the manager that trained everyday with Antony for 2 years and thought he was good enough for Man Utd. So obviously seeing them day in and day out doesn’t mean he knows more than everyone else and is always right
@@AtlantisFootball just because he’s quick doesn’t mean the other areas of his game are there yet. Cb is a position that needs experience to thrive. He needed to gain that experience in training first and then show it in matches. You’re talking like he’s the finished first team ready article in one match. He had a great game but there’s a long way to go for him
@@AtlantisFootball besides uniteds issues aren’t just slow cb specific. Casemiro has lost his legs, we don’t have another 6 and the lack of a stable back 4 cause of injures makes it harder. Sticking Willy in there isn’t gonna magically fix everything. He’s a good prospect but in the long term bedding him into the team slowly is far more beneficial to both him and united rather than throwing him into the deep end before he’s ready and ruin his confidence
@@12mightylion yes but he is clearly a better option than evans and Lindelof and that is the basis for everyone’s argument as to why we’ve been so horrific defensively
@@12mightylion the issues are mainly tactical. But my point is, people are making one argument to defend ten Hag and then making a contradiction to defend him in another scenario
Be careful with your youngsters
Look at barcelona
Gavi pedri fati
Don't go down that path
EtH is not a developer of young players? now your videos are just irritating to me now so am out
He’s just not tho is he. You’re looking through rose tinted glasses. If he was he wouldn’t have sent Fernandez out on loan to use Lindelof at LB, played evans over Kambwala and sent Gore and Oyedele out on loan to continue use a declining Casemiro who has been horrific. Also has barely given Amad game time since he’s return.
You’re continuing denial of blatant facts is irritating. You need to remember you’re a Man Utd fan not a ten Hag fan. Ten Hag is just not a great developer of youth at United anyway. Garnacho and Mainoo are already better than the current first team options. That’s not developing youth is it
Do you think Gore and Oyedele are quality enough to oust an aging Casemiro? You want Players to be rushed into playing? You have to get the timing right. Not every youth player will make it at United.
Not them alone. But considering we barely have any CM’s at the level we need, with Eriksen and Casemiro unable to run.
Alongside the amad, Fernandez and Kambwala situation
@@AtlantisFootball
Just because we think some kids have potential doesn't mean they're ever going to make it. Obviously, we didn't know Luke Shaw and Malacia were going to be injured for this long, hence why Fernandez was loaned out. and that's also the reason why we didn't keep Reguilón for the whole season. He sent out Gore on loan because we got Amarabat, Mount, McTominay, Eriksen, Casimero, Kobbie, and Fernandez, who will start before him, and this was at the start of the season before we got injuries. Yeah, let's just play every single kid that has potential immediately and see what that does to them when we get battered. Ten Hag has brought in Rasmus, started Garnacho, Kobbie, Forson, and now Kambwala in just one season, Amass might also potentially start this season, and you're still complaining he's not a youth team developer? What top 6 club in the Premiership has done that recently except for maybe Liverpool? The others will come at the right time if they show it in training. So please get your facts straight. Also did anyone think Casimiros legs was going to go this season when he played so well last season.
Fernandez will come back to United from Benfica though
Not if they trigger the option to buy
No guarantee he stays though
I rarely disagree with the views you raise but I disagree with so many things you say it's almost comical
Average United stand viewer
Off topic should united acc sign Olise
Injury issues tho. Big risk
I get it that there is a dissatisfaction in the fanbase and a big divide regarding ETH, and you as all other fans have the right to an opinion. However, the reason why I and many others follow you is for tactical analysis, and not for a constant rant regarding why ETH should be sacked. I agree that there have been a lot of misstakes this season, but I do believe there are also a lot of positives, i.e. The handling of Garnacho and other youngsters. For me there are mitigating circumstances this season and I simply want to give ETH another season to showcase some of the positives we saw last season. I propose that instead of fighting with your subscribers you simply respect that they have an opinion that differs from yours.
It’s not a constant rant at all. It’s objective analysis regarding Kambwala’s situation. People just don’t like ten Hag being criticised for some reason even though we are diabolical
I’m not fighting with them I’m back up my opinion. They are putting their views in the comments section criticising mine in the video and I am simply pointing out the faults in the comments.
If you agreed with my points when I was arguing with people you’d accept it. It’s only because we have a differing opinion
@@AtlantisFootball fair enough. I don’t agree with everything but you have the right to your view of the situation. Cheers.
You can't be serious. You're really not going to give ETH any credit for how he's handled the youth?
To hate manager is one thing but to discredit some of the good work he's done?!
I'm disappointed in you man
Mate I’m disappointed in you that you are viewing this with rose tinted glasses. He only played Kambwala once evans and Lindelof were injured.
For months everyone’s been telling me that it’s not ten hags fault that the defence is a joke, he just doesn’t have a quick CB to play alongside Varane to play a high line, meanwhile he had Kambwala he just played evans and Lindelof instead.
Also him playing Antony over amad for months and not even given Fernandez and gore a chance despite us needing players in those positions proves my point.
You need to be objective here
Great against Liverpool, crap against Bournemouth.
Casemiro collect shots for no reason 😂
Not for no reason, the guy was literally walking after 20 mins vs Chelsea as someone was running past him the ball
Mentions how Case gets left exposed in the defensive setup.. then wants to throw a youth player in there to solve a tactical issue. Smart.
Yes it is smart use your head. Casemiro can’t run. So using a youth player who can run would be much better. Use your head mate.
@@AtlantisFootball would it not be better where the tactical issue is resolved by EtH and his coaches?? That way you don't throw a youth product to the wolves??
You mentioned in a previous video how some youth players have been mismanaged, would this not fall into that category??
One thing we've seen with EtH is if a youth player does not perform as expected of a youth player you're axed. Iqbal case and point.
Yes but ten Hag isn’t resolving those issues. And even if he did, Casemiro’s inability to run would still be an issue
@@AtlantisFootball true. The benefit from that would be there's a gap for the youth to be introduced. Same way Kambwala was forced into the team with the injuries we've had. Hopefully he features for 70% if not 100% of the remaining games. Alongside Varane when fit obviously
Bro, come on about his inability to develop young players. He coached Balon D’or standard out of several Ajax players. He's struggling in England but give credit where it's due
We are talking about Ajax tho. We are talking about Kambwala, amad, Alvaro Fernandez, Dan Gore and Maxi Oyedele
@@AtlantisFootball He made those Ajax players Ballon D’or class.
@@kofimensah4225 we are talking about Man Utd not Ajax tho
You lost me at Bruno Fernandes...I thought this was a technical analysis🤷🏿♂️ on Willy...and playing better
At least put Mount in, he keep the ball better injured than Bruno all season!
Bruno Fernandes is one of the best creators in Europe mate. I don’t know why people pretend he’s Scott McTominay level
Bruno is better than Mount
@@AtlantisFootball I disagree. Mount can turn on the spin. Mount can drive forward. M&M can keep the ball better (exactly what we lack with Bruno 🎾...Not aided by Casemeiro) Mount can pass just as well- minus being erratic. M&M can play in thight space + the quick 1,2. Mount has better defensive actions. Mount has better positioning. Mount has been injured all season (so you cannot say Bruno is better- just yet. But for sake of argument- M&M has a champions league medal, that he played a big part in (and Chelsea were crap that season)
Love your videos- awesome analyst!
U saying EtH not develop players 🤣🤣🤣 what are u on?
Mate use your head. Mainoo and Garnacho are better than first team players already. He chose to play Antony over amad, Evans over Kambwala and sent Fernandez out on loan despite us not even having a fit LB. Its pretty simple to understand as to what I’m on about
@@AtlantisFootball u should. Mate it is EtH who deserve the credit of Mainoo, Garnacho, Kambwala.
Diallo is not he’s signing, and playing Antony i understand (because he is his signing and he knowing him and believe in him).
I love diallo, but i trust that the manager knowing more what he is doing than all of us fans.
He gave diallo a oportunity in fa cup against Liverpool and diallo tokes it! But not forget that diallo have Been injured for a lot this season.
And about Fernandez out on loan.
I Said in the moment “why on Earth are we doing that, he is good?”
But what we dont know was that EtH and the whole youth team, Saw that Amass was so good and want to make a space for him in the Squad.
So yeah i am 100% backing EtH, because all the noise around him and the club is too easy to say its the manager fault.
The whole setup in this club have Been fuckt for 11 years.
Now a new owner have coming in and taking over the sport setup, and with that i mean EtH should get 1 more season, and im sure Sir Jim think the same.
GGMU
Ten Hag should not be given credit for amad and Kambwala are you serious. He was playing Antony and evans over them.
Ten Hag is tactical inept and prefers to play declining players rather than promising youngsters
@@AtlantisFootball I took time to listen to your argument and rant. To be honest I rated your opinion before now but looking at your comments I am disappointed. Let's address kambwala, his first start was a loss to westham and no body even said after that match he should play again. He stood up fine against Liverpool let's not forget we could have actually conceded due to his error. The boy is similar to the Liverpool CB that made the error. He is still learning the trade and isn't great yet you can't justify that he should have started since there is no rationale. You just waited for one game to attack ten Haag who is to say he won't flop the next game.
Now Amad. Is Amad good, yes he probably is but you can't tell me he should play ahead of Garnacho. Rashford may be having a bad season but I would argue that ten Haag knowing what he can do is enough to keep his spot this season. Now Anthony let's not forget he hasn't started games since December. Apart from the odd game. When Amad could have played against Newport he was injured. How can you tell ten Haag to play a player who hasn't proved anything to him over those that have proved it to him
Now Alvaro Fernandez. Ten Haag was told that Shaw and Malacia will be back in January fit. I wonder if you watch his press conferences. He couldn't have known that the both of them will get injured immediately. And he ten Haag admitted he didn't want to have 3 left backs and the other will be disappointed. Gore isn't probably going to play much this season if he stayed. So why keep him.
How could he have brought him in when he was injured months ago he wasn't available
He wasn’t injured for that whole period was he tho
@AtlantisFootball he actually was do some more looking into where he was
He just wasn’t tho. Why don’t you do some research literally look at his injuries on transfermarkt instead of making Shit up
@AtlantisFootball I don't need to make anything up im not the one with a channel pumping out opinions and not total facts mate im not subscribed either so I dont give 2 shits if you don't care for my opinion as you would say
Well you’re wrong. He wasn’t injured. Check transfermarkt
Can't believe this comment section. I agree with atlantis on this. It's been clear since our pre season. In most of the games our under 23s were the one's who actually won us games. This generation of players coming out of our academy are insane and should be developed right
Yep people want us to bring throw youth but will then defend ten Hag when he plays evans and Lindelof over one of our most promising youth prospects
Ok bro I don't like eth either
But give the man a break its not that easy
He has started Antony over amad and evans and Lindelof over Kambwala for months now. You don’t think that’s an issue?
@@AtlantisFootball it's obviously an issue but
Almost everyone is playing poorly
The fans want his head
Older players want more playing time
He has a lot on his plate
He’s Man Utd manager and doing terribly this season. If he can’t handle a lot on his plate he shouldn’t be Man Utd manager. We are going backwards
@@AtlantisFootball like said it's not that easy
His bald head should just win the FA cup and go