She could have been smart and moved this argument in the direction of “if Frank isn’t born then I won’t marry him and if I don’t marry him I won’t be there to go through the stones in Scotland and meet YOU”
That was the most dynamic scene of Season2! Sam Heughan was outstanding in this scene. 👏Even though Claire only asked for a delay, Jamie had no idea if he would ever get another chance to take his revenge on BJR. I thought it was selfish of her to ask him to give up this opportunity. Worked out in the end though at the Battle of Culloden.🙌
Claire was right about it being her fault after miscarriage…saying that she put Frank ahead of her husband, baby and her marriage…Randall wasn’t even his biological father…Alex was
She didn't know that and also logic stands that if Drank never existed then a large portion Claire's own timeline would change as well. Which makes sense. Clear was only in Scotland because she was on her second honeymoon with Frank. Also why wipe out the rest of the whole Randall bloodline because of one evil man? Jamie's own paternal grandfather was a terrible man as well.
I can't stand when someone puts 5th blame on the mother. It is not her fault that she lost the baby. It's no one's fault! Like others said with Randall gone roo early that will mess with her timeline and could change her from going to Scotland and meeting Jaime. No one is at fault but Randall for causing all that evil.
Frank hatte schon Alexander auf dem Radar. Nur war dieser ein Priester oder Pfarrer in armen Verhältnissen. Der ältere Bruder ging zur Armee, und das Black Jack. Also interessierte Frank sich nicht für den jüngeren Bruder. Erst Claire erzählte es ihm, als sie zurück kehrte. Es gibt einen Brief, den Brianna mit Roger fand, in dem steht, daß der Reverent Wakefield nicht mehr nach Randall suchen soll, weil er nicht das ist, was Frank angenommen hat.
Superb acting by both even though I thought Claire was being quite selfish and shallow, throwing in Jaime's face, how many times she has saved his life ! How many times has he saved her life ? His own wife not taking into consideration how Jaime must be feeling, short of castration, Claire is his wife and soon to bare his child, If I were him, I would have questioned her love, marriage ? He has such an allegiance to Claire during good times and bad, and she him. If I were Jaime, I would have to question Claire about using saving his life in the past as leverage ? Shame on her, even though she was trying to protect Frank's family legacy 😪 My heart is with Jaime on this one 💯
She could have been smart and moved this argument in the direction of “if Frank isn’t born then I won’t marry him and if I don’t marry him I won’t be there to go through the stones in Scotland and meet YOU”
That’s exactly what I have always thought!
Absolute Acting Perfection, Two Scene Stealers perfoming on the same Stage at the same time!!👌👍👍
Great acting from both of them, but Sam is outstanding. Cait seems to get more acclaim in this series but for me Sam is superb.
I don't think there is a better actor than Sam.
In essence Claire assisted in the death of Faith by allowing JR to roam around...Adore Jamie when he tells Claire ;"do not touch me"
It’s one of the best scenes in Dragonfly in Amber (the book), too. Sam doesn’t get enough credit, too. He’s also awesome.
Brilliant acting by both
Stunning scene.superb acting..I am in awe
That was the most dynamic scene of Season2! Sam Heughan was outstanding in this scene. 👏Even though Claire only asked for a delay, Jamie had no idea if he would ever get another chance to take his revenge on BJR. I thought it was selfish of her to ask him to give up this opportunity. Worked out in the end though at the Battle of Culloden.🙌
This is one of Sam's best acted scenes
Me encanta la serie!!!❤❤❤❤
For Christ sake how much did Jamie have to endure for his love
He hurt Claire too, don't worry
Claire was right about it being her fault after miscarriage…saying that she put Frank ahead of her husband, baby and her marriage…Randall wasn’t even his biological father…Alex was
Ah but she didn’t know that then.
She didn't know that and also logic stands that if Drank never existed then a large portion Claire's own timeline would change as well. Which makes sense. Clear was only in Scotland because she was on her second honeymoon with Frank. Also why wipe out the rest of the whole Randall bloodline because of one evil man? Jamie's own paternal grandfather was a terrible man as well.
I can't stand when someone puts 5th blame on the mother. It is not her fault that she lost the baby. It's no one's fault! Like others said with Randall gone roo early that will mess with her timeline and could change her from going to Scotland and meeting Jaime. No one is at fault but Randall for causing all that evil.
Ich frage mihh bis heute warum Frank als sehr guter Historiker nicht heraus gefunden hat das Alex und nicht Black Jack sein Vorfahre war.
Frank hatte schon Alexander auf dem Radar. Nur war dieser ein Priester oder Pfarrer in armen Verhältnissen. Der ältere Bruder ging zur Armee, und das Black Jack.
Also interessierte Frank sich nicht für den jüngeren Bruder.
Erst Claire erzählte es ihm, als sie zurück kehrte.
Es gibt einen Brief, den Brianna mit Roger fand, in dem steht, daß der Reverent Wakefield nicht mehr nach Randall suchen soll, weil er nicht das ist, was Frank angenommen hat.
Je trouve Jamie grandiose Claire lui demande l'impossible il est frustré mais pour elle il cede une année c'est tout pour Franck 👍♥️
😢😢😢❤❤❤
Didn't like her actions here
Superb acting by both even though I thought Claire was being quite selfish and shallow, throwing in Jaime's face, how many times she has saved his life ! How many times has he saved her life ? His own wife not taking into consideration how Jaime must be feeling, short of castration, Claire is his wife and soon to bare his child, If I were him, I would have questioned her love, marriage ? He has such an allegiance to Claire during good times and bad, and she him. If I were Jaime, I would have to question Claire about using saving his life in the past as leverage ? Shame on her, even though she was trying to protect Frank's family legacy 😪 My heart is with Jaime on this one 💯
Nah, I'm burnt out on ti. It's nothing like how the books were in my mind.