WOW, WOW, WOW!!!... THIS IS SOOOO BEAUTIFUL, her interpretation could NOT be any better and the whole scene with the guy picking up the stuff is just amazing, you guys are definitely genious!!!
As I said before, and as I will keep saying, this channel is for sure the most stunning and original on TH-cam. A true mine of talents and great performances, real music produced. Thanks guys.
I thought at the beginning of this video that the mics and drums were there because other musicians were going to come out for a full ensemble. I think I liked this better.
Every time I hear her sing, there’s always something that I look forward, something unexpected... she’s full of surprises and dang! That WHISTLE came out as beautiful as a song bird! 😍❤️
Scott, what an absolutely BRILLIANT job commemorating this chapter in your voyage. It has been a wonderful 52 videos ... I look forward to the next chapter. Thanks for choosing Shoshana for this one, her performances always touch my soul & hammer my heart, in the most beautiful way. You know ... you've made Thursdays my favorite day of the week! RP Rosen loves ya
This is by far my favorite Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox cover. The rawness of her voice mixed with the emotion of that scream gives me chills every time I listen. The only thing I would've changed is her pantsuit. This song calls for a floor length gown with a train.
Stone cold, stone cold You see me standing, but I'm dying on the floor Stone cold, stone cold Maybe if I don't cry, I won't feel anymore Stone cold, baby God knows I try to feel Happy for you Know that I am, even if I Can't understand, I'll take the pain Give me the truth, me and my heart We'll make it through If happy is her, I'm happy for you Stone cold, stone cold You're dancing with her, while I'm staring at my phone Stone cold, stone cold I was your amber, but now she's your shade of gold Stone cold, baby God knows I try to feel Happy for you Know that I am, even if I Can't understand, I'll take the pain Give me the truth, me and my heart We'll make it through If happy is her, I'm happy for you Don't wanna be stone cold, stone I wish I could mean this, but here's my goodbye Oh, I'm happy for you Know that I am, even if I Can't understand If happy is her If happy is her I'm happy for you
That guy moving around instruments is such a sharp reminder of what Christopher talked about in "Musicking"! - it is never only the scores, it's everyone and everything involved! The performer, the audience and everybody who put effort to the stage. Just love it!
Listening to this without video is emotionally powerful enough, but seeing her go through the expressions as she sings, especially that last line, made me shed tears multiple times watching this. Truly moving.
I have to say it. I think this is better than Demi's. Not gonna be everyone's opinion, and that's ok. I'm just saying that, to me, while Demi is a touch clearer on some of the notes, her performance emotion always comes off feeling "pop". Like it's designed to be played in a movie soundtrack over montaged relate-able teenage girls crying in their rooms. Shoshana feels like she's pouring her bleeding heart out in a song for real, on the spot spontaneously right there and then. It's raw, it isn't always pretty but it's honest and painful (in the right way, if you get what I mean). It's like the difference between artificial orange flavouring and an actual orange. People are gonna like one, the other, or even both and that's great. I'm just saying thanks to PMJ for giving us such a fabulous option to choose from!
francy1991a what!! have heard her sing , can sing way higher notes than Demi no hate to Demi but is a better singer more raw to her voice than that pop shit but still love me some Lovato
No one, not a single soul, can do this song better than Demi. The music video version, the in-studio version (my personal fav) or the version where she is on stage with country star Brad Paisley - all of them surpass this cover exponentially. This version is too "happy" even with some of the sad notes in there. And while I adore Shoshana's vocals in most cases, she can't bring across the same utter helplessness and hurt that Demi can. This is Demi's song and she owns it every time she sings it. Shoshana and anyone else covering it can't come close.
@@noahmoment I'm not gate keeping. It's my opinion which you just so kindly gave me permission to express, all powerful one, so I stand by it. And I'm happy, no need for your assumptions on that head either, all mighty opinion police ,sir/ma'am. 😁
Another profoundly outstanding performance Scott, made all the more poetic, sincere and poignantly engrossing by it's very simplicity as a duo, one voice and one instrument, the beautifully smooth yet emotionally raw, impassioned sound of Shoshana's voice set against your never wavering, never faltering intrinsic connection with the piano and the music you create from it. I also enjoyed the moving element to the video as well, the quietly persistent elimination of any excess or unnecessary items from the viewers vantage, one by one, it felt appropriate to the song's story, to the memorable nature of the occasion this song marks and to the sentiment within the tenor and tone of the moment. In short, it's fantastic and another example of why I eagerly await any and every new piece you offer, thank you thank you, you too Shoshana, gorgeous everything!
If this ain't perfection, then I don't know what is. At first, I thought it was an interesting conception and that something spectacular was going to happen in the end until I started reading the description and saw that you guys are moving out. Even though it is probably difficult for everyone to leave this place full of many great memories behind, I'm pretty certain that you will continue making magic everywhere you go. Good luck Scott and the entire PMJ crew + vocalists :)
wow ... seriously moved to tears ... everything about the song .. f*** I don't know what to think right now. I think I have witnessed perfection. Haley and Robyn can't be in every song folks not to say they ain't great but each deserves to do what she did. But they need to do their own song
This is touchingly amazing! I'm in awe of you :) Amazing in Lisbon and amazing here! Please make more songs with Shoshana, always pours heart and soul into the song and man... it shows! You keep making songs better than the original, damn!
WHAT!!! WHHHAAATTT!!! This is crazy!!! l LOVING the vocals! and the whole scene of moving stuff out.. Made me cry!! And the vocal .. I'm still in shock! That last unrealistic high note was mind blowing! thank you PMJ for always inspiring me
this is very emotional and also masterful too. the first time i heard it on spotify, i thought 2 ladies were having a duet. Inspiring! congratulations on everything!
Oh god, it has been a year since the beginning of this living room? Can't wait to see the new digs, but this place was the best. I can't believe it is done with now. Also, this was a great rendition of a song I never heard till now, but I am happy to hear first from you. Have fun in the new PMJ house!
d'un tout petit coin de france,je tenais à vous dire que peu de personnes ont une voix aussi expressive que vous et j'ai pourtant écouter beaucoup de chanteurs à mon âge .merci merci
I love this song. I'm actually glad you guys didn't change it up too much because I think it's really good the way it is. This is a great acoustic cover. Thank you. :)
When I was in my 20's I lived in Toledo Ohio and I listened to the Detroit radio station WJR. They had an afternoon DJ that played a wide range of music including Billie Holiday. He used to say that Ms. Holiday like to sing with big bands but he thought she was best with a small jazz band because the band could rap itself sound her vocals. It is my theory that Scott Beatles is similarly inclined with his great female vocalists. This video is a prime example of this. The highest compliment of Scott gives to his vocalists is to only have his piano and the volcalist. Other examples of this are Niche Braden signing PURPLE RAIN and Morgan James sing TAKE ME TO CHURCH. By the way, don't miss SAS Hanna Bean singing SHE USED TO BE MINE and MAKE IT RAIN. Two if the best songs on TH-cam. I also suggest you listen two an opera singer reacts to both if the above song. These performances are two If the d best performances I havebheard.
Omg! Her scream was the sound of a heart breaking. Unrequited love found a voice right here.
Yes! That part caught me off guard. And I had already read your comment, too.
WOW, WOW, WOW!!!... THIS IS SOOOO BEAUTIFUL, her interpretation could NOT be any better and the whole scene with the guy picking up the stuff is just amazing, you guys are definitely genious!!!
Thanks! You are welcome to subscribe to Scott's newsletter for new music and live shows! postmodernjukebox.com/
yup. totally agree. :-)
wow... this performance was so moving.
IS THAT A PUN
+Justice Green did you find it punny, tho?
As I said before, and as I will keep saying, this channel is for sure the most stunning and original on TH-cam. A true mine of talents and great performances, real music produced. Thanks guys.
Agree!
Agree
I think the clearing out of the room made me cry more than the song did....
They never stop performing it seems. Even after closing time
That's interesting
I criii
Please tell Shoshana that this was the best version of Stone Cold I've ever heard. And I listened to a lot of covers...
Songbird pls also checkout morissette amon's wishbus cover of the same song...
Natalie Weiss has the best cover
Jesus was a Buddhist & Amber Riley
That G#6 at 2:39 though!!!! Damn!!!! Slay us Shoshana, say ussssss!!!!
Slay us she did
I thought at the beginning of this video that the mics and drums were there because other musicians were going to come out for a full ensemble.
I think I liked this better.
Omg yeah i thought that too! Somehow they always pop out of weird places but i agree this is better.
Me too , I thought they were coming one by one .
Every time I hear her sing, there’s always something that I look forward, something unexpected... she’s full of surprises and dang! That WHISTLE came out as beautiful as a song bird! 😍❤️
How she makes every word and every note drip with Soul...WOW!!!!!! lol Nothing short of AMAZING!
Shoshana Bean is out of this world. The skill she has with her voice is masterful. I am a huge fan of her and PMJ. Thank you for making this art.
Scott, what an absolutely BRILLIANT job commemorating this chapter in your voyage. It has been a wonderful 52 videos ... I look forward to the next chapter. Thanks for choosing Shoshana for this one, her performances always touch my soul & hammer my heart, in the most beautiful way. You know ... you've made Thursdays my favorite day of the week! RP Rosen loves ya
+R.P. Rosen :)
This is by far my favorite Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox cover. The rawness of her voice mixed with the emotion of that scream gives me chills every time I listen. The only thing I would've changed is her pantsuit. This song calls for a floor length gown with a train.
Singing to good to notice but a dress would be nice she is brilliant.This channel blows my mind all stars .xxx❤❤❤
Now even I like this song. Shoshana
+MisterTrdlo Which show did you attend? Glad to hear you enjoyed the show !
The Munich show. Of course I loved it. I would gladly go again and again. Come back soon. :)PostmodernJukebox
I am amazed by Shoshana's voice, what a control!!! I really hope we see her in this channel soon!
Stone cold, stone cold
You see me standing, but I'm dying on the floor
Stone cold, stone cold
Maybe if I don't cry, I won't feel anymore
Stone cold, baby
God knows I try to feel
Happy for you
Know that I am, even if I
Can't understand, I'll take the pain
Give me the truth, me and my heart
We'll make it through
If happy is her, I'm happy for you
Stone cold, stone cold
You're dancing with her, while I'm staring at my phone
Stone cold, stone cold
I was your amber, but now she's your shade of gold
Stone cold, baby
God knows I try to feel
Happy for you
Know that I am, even if I
Can't understand, I'll take the pain
Give me the truth, me and my heart
We'll make it through
If happy is her, I'm happy for you
Don't wanna be stone cold, stone
I wish I could mean this, but here's my goodbye
Oh, I'm happy for you
Know that I am, even if I
Can't understand
If happy is her
If happy is her
I'm happy for you
Shoshana killed the vocals, but OMG that piano is stunning.
Good lord! CHILLS! An amazing singer putting in her BEST PMJ performance yet. Blown away.
Wow, this was stunning.
+Phil James Glad you like it :)
I have had tears listening to this song.. blows me away
I am consistently blowen away by the incredible talent you all share with us. Thank you so much!
Never ending chills throughout the song.
That guy moving around instruments is such a sharp reminder of what Christopher talked about in "Musicking"! - it is never only the scores, it's everyone and everything involved! The performer, the audience and everybody who put effort to the stage. Just love it!
this song is so beautiful... It's like there is a bunch of feelings inside of it...! I'm willing to see where you moved!!
Unbelievable voice. I can't stop listening.
Listening to this without video is emotionally powerful enough, but seeing her go through the expressions as she sings, especially that last line, made me shed tears multiple times watching this. Truly moving.
The MP3 is available here: smarturl.it/pmjvote
Hello. Just wondering when will the tickets for the Aus tour be on sale?
+FantasRos3 they already are
Mitchell Geddes Bought them the day they came out :D
The incomparable Shoshana Bean!
That's not a cover, that's a great performance 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
any one notice her lips when she said stone on 1:40? lol sorry i had to comment that. but damn that voice on 2:48 my god
LMAO
+Zainy x What the hell. Did the universe glitch out there
+johnie102 Hahahaha! It's like from The Mummy Returns!
+Zainy x ROFL
Haha
I have to say it. I think this is better than Demi's. Not gonna be everyone's opinion, and that's ok. I'm just saying that, to me, while Demi is a touch clearer on some of the notes, her performance emotion always comes off feeling "pop". Like it's designed to be played in a movie soundtrack over montaged relate-able teenage girls crying in their rooms. Shoshana feels like she's pouring her bleeding heart out in a song for real, on the spot spontaneously right there and then. It's raw, it isn't always pretty but it's honest and painful (in the right way, if you get what I mean). It's like the difference between artificial orange flavouring and an actual orange. People are gonna like one, the other, or even both and that's great. I'm just saying thanks to PMJ for giving us such a fabulous option to choose from!
francy1991a what!! have heard her sing , can sing way higher notes than Demi no hate to Demi but is a better singer more raw to her voice than that pop shit but still love me some Lovato
When the comment is that she cant do high notes, but you heard a whistle note over the song. Hahaha
@@francy1991a ..........................................gtfoh
No one, not a single soul, can do this song better than Demi. The music video version, the in-studio version (my personal fav) or the version where she is on stage with country star Brad Paisley - all of them surpass this cover exponentially. This version is too "happy" even with some of the sad notes in there. And while I adore Shoshana's vocals in most cases, she can't bring across the same utter helplessness and hurt that Demi can. This is Demi's song and she owns it every time she sings it. Shoshana and anyone else covering it can't come close.
@@noahmoment I'm not gate keeping. It's my opinion which you just so kindly gave me permission to express, all powerful one, so I stand by it.
And I'm happy, no need for your assumptions on that head either, all mighty opinion police ,sir/ma'am.
😁
that's a spectacular performance, what a voice!
SHOSHANA YOU GOTTA WARN SOMEBODY!! You can’t be doin all that at 2:39 without a warning. I almost choked on my food girl. 😂
A powerful performance and brilliantly sung. I'm sure that we will all miss that room.
Heartbreaking vocal performance. Really amazing
she should sing "who you are" by Jessie J
Or Nobody's Perfect 😱
+MrBooBig Or anything
or I Miss Her
Wow!! How come i had not seen this?!!
Wow this is incredibly beautiful and sad. Great job guys!
PMJB I can't stop liking your videos and adding them to my playlistsssssss! Shoshana your range is insane! Such emotion..Killing it!
My day just got so much better....I'm in love. It's sad to see the living room leave us though, can't wait to see the new space.
Another profoundly outstanding performance Scott, made all the more poetic, sincere and poignantly engrossing by it's very simplicity as a duo, one voice and one instrument, the beautifully smooth yet emotionally raw, impassioned sound of Shoshana's voice set against your never wavering, never faltering intrinsic connection with the piano and the music you create from it. I also enjoyed the moving element to the video as well, the quietly persistent elimination of any excess or unnecessary items from the viewers vantage, one by one, it felt appropriate to the song's story, to the memorable nature of the occasion this song marks and to the sentiment within the tenor and tone of the moment. In short, it's fantastic and another example of why I eagerly await any and every new piece you offer, thank you thank you, you too Shoshana, gorgeous everything!
Every single time I hear this song, I get goosebumps and I feel every word she sings. Just an incredibly musician, absolutely amazing.
If this ain't perfection, then I don't know what is. At first, I thought it was an interesting conception and that something spectacular was going to happen in the end until I started reading the description and saw that you guys are moving out. Even though it is probably difficult for everyone to leave this place full of many great memories behind, I'm pretty certain that you will continue making magic everywhere you go. Good luck Scott and the entire PMJ crew + vocalists :)
been listening to this on a loop. just love it!
wow ... seriously moved to tears ... everything about the song .. f*** I don't know what to think right now. I think I have witnessed perfection. Haley and Robyn can't be in every song folks not to say they ain't great but each deserves to do what she did. But they need to do their own song
This is the first time ive ever heard her.. Shock faced! Were so lucky to have so many great singers to listen too..
Then you need to listen to her sing make it rain if you haven’t yet.
thank you guys for this channel. please dont stop
This is touchingly amazing! I'm in awe of you :)
Amazing in Lisbon and amazing here! Please make more songs with Shoshana, always pours heart and soul into the song and man... it shows!
You keep making songs better than the original, damn!
I love the scenic ideas that encompasses the mood of the songs. SO creative. Also Shoshana Bean fucking rocks this! This made my eyes tear up.
Such a brilliant man and such a lady! Only you could make a farewell to a space this much poignant, dear Scott
what a voice ... brilliant...
Sad to see the living room go though. The end of the video kind of felt like the season finale of a show that you get emotionally invested in.
WHAT!!! WHHHAAATTT!!! This is crazy!!! l LOVING the vocals! and the whole scene of moving stuff out.. Made me cry!! And the vocal .. I'm still in shock! That last unrealistic high note was mind blowing! thank you PMJ for always inspiring me
The scream at 2:39
I can't tell if that was the high note of Shoshana or the sound I made when my wig was completely ripped off my head
So good. This gave me chills.
this is very emotional and also masterful too. the first time i heard it on spotify, i thought 2 ladies were having a duet. Inspiring! congratulations on everything!
her range is insane this was fantastic so glad I liked your page pmj
Your videos always have so many layers. I enjoy them a lot.
The guy dismantling the room, much as the relationship in the song was dismantled, was very well conceived.
Shobean is.... like.... i have no words to descride it.... a.... fricken.... like.... vocal god.... i just.... i bow down to her
i love shoshana! her vocal abilities are out of this world.
It made me laugh when the guy took even the microphone. Lol! Funny and a little different from your other videos. Great performance!
Thumbs up!
Oh god, it has been a year since the beginning of this living room? Can't wait to see the new digs, but this place was the best. I can't believe it is done with now. Also, this was a great rendition of a song I never heard till now, but I am happy to hear first from you. Have fun in the new PMJ house!
Oh my god, I'm crying, this version it's so beautiful!!!! I hope someday i'll sing like that!!!
Wow incredible performance by Shoshana... by far my favorite of her songs
beautiful, absolutely beautiful. every day i fall more in love with PMJ. Such talent wow.
What an outstanding set of vocal cords you have!
Oh my god!!! I was waiting for this song!!!!!!
I saw Shosanna Bean and I couldn't click fast enough. She is so great, I got some chills :)
Beautiful as always!
Shoshana is an actual magician. A sorceress of song
wow. when she did the little pause at the end my stomach was clenched and i was holding my breath. that’s how you know it’s good.
Absolutely the best version
So amazing. Wonderful vocal!
d'un tout petit coin de france,je tenais à vous dire que peu de personnes ont une voix aussi expressive que vous et j'ai pourtant écouter beaucoup de chanteurs à mon âge .merci merci
Shoshana is one of my favorites! Smooth cover!
Hope you can all come on a PMJ tour in Greece!
HERE FOR SHOSHANA BEAN AND ONLY SHOSHANA BEAN
Breathtaking voice! I can't stop listening to it. Gives me chills with her powerful voice. Can't wait for you guys to come back to Colorado!
There was absolutely nothing flat about that performance. Glorious on all counts.
I love this song. I'm actually glad you guys didn't change it up too much because I think it's really good the way it is. This is a great acoustic cover. Thank you. :)
Absolutely beautiful.
That was heartbreaking. Great arrangement.
I can't help but watch in awe as a singer loses themselves completely in the song they're singing.
This is so beautifully raw. Shoshana Bean yet again showing her incredible vocal control.
I put this on whenever I feel like I need to 'clean my eyes'. This is the ultimate trigger.
I listen to Demi's version almost daily on the way to work, and this version is on par. Good job!
This is awesome!!
This is perfect! I love the piano arrangement and Shoshana's interpretation is amazing.
Absolutely beautiful
Damn. I did not expect to hear what I did. Thankyou o so much for this!
this leaves me breathless
Great, Scott! Found this after seeing your live stream by coincidence on Facebook Live!
+Iskandar Bwefar Glad you found us! You can check our our website for new music and live shows: postmodernjukebox.com/events/
+Iskandar Bwefar You're in for a treat
SHO "NUFF AWESOME" SHANA! A million feels for this one!
oh men, you almost got me depressed but the music in the end breaks the melancholy aura.
Good luck with the new place! Can't wait for more videos.
When I was in my 20's I lived in Toledo Ohio and I listened to the Detroit radio station WJR. They had an afternoon DJ that played a wide range of music including Billie Holiday. He used to say that Ms. Holiday like to sing with big bands but he thought she was best with a small jazz band because the band could rap itself sound her vocals.
It is my theory that Scott Beatles is similarly inclined with his great female vocalists. This video is a prime example of this.
The highest compliment of Scott gives to his vocalists is to only have his piano and the volcalist. Other examples of this are Niche Braden signing PURPLE RAIN and Morgan James sing TAKE ME TO CHURCH.
By the way, don't miss SAS Hanna Bean singing SHE USED TO BE MINE and MAKE IT RAIN. Two if the best songs on TH-cam.
I also suggest you listen two an opera singer reacts to both if the above song.
These performances are two If the d best performances I havebheard.
PS: Also check out an Opera singer Shops an Bean singing Finishing the hat.
At the end of her review she asks how she can take lessons from Shoshanna.
Such an emotional Performance and voice!!!
This is the best combination of song and singer ever. Love her and love this song
how awesome she just sings those two words right from the beginning
nice Setup by the way
She has an amaaazing voice