Beautiful cover! If you want my feedback/tips, continue reading :) The song is in 5/4, which is very uncommon. This makes it hard to play AND sing if you're not used to it, that's what also really stumps me when i play this song. You did great on the intro and parts of the verses, but on the chorus, you switched to 4/4. That's why it is more 'rushed'. I recommend going through the original version and trying to find the pattern in melody and chord switch. then you can start off by singing and playing the chords only once on the down beat, then trying every beat and eventually going to a rhythm you want to play. In general it's still a good cover tho! Hope to see you pop up on my recommended again soon :)
thanks for taking the time to write this! i appreciate the feedback. i honestly don't pay much attention to timing when i'm singing while playing but i guess i should really work on that. and even while just playing i've always kind of sucked at timing haha. but thank you so much. hope to see you back sometime :)
Was looking for this comment! Yt recommended this to me cause I also made a cover of this song and went through hell with 5/4. I love this so much though, your delivery on the chorus is so beautiful, timing is insignificant
I got chills!! mashallah your voice is magical. I was reading in a novel about how impactful songs covers are, the delivery just channels emotion in a way that is not necessarily better but just different, tolerate it is one of my fav songs on evermore but the way you sang it hit me in a way it has never before ❤🩹
oh my gosh. i think this is one of the most thoughtful comments i have ever received. this truly means everything to me. my favorite part of making and listening to covers is getting an new perspective on a song and i am so glad that this cover resonated with you. thank you so so much, this really made my day. i love you so much. 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
@@katy_ly it’s just really good. I’ve been playing piano for way too many years now, and I can’t play like that. I’ve never tried, but still. That’s just amazing
oh i’ve been playing since i was four and i still struggle. you should give it a try sometime, i’m genuinely sure you’re amazing!! you are so incredibly kind. thank you :)))
:) wish you the best on your channel. im growing mine as well and also play piano. but i dont sing well so i do other things haha check it out sometime if you'd like.@@katy_ly
heart touching heart warming performance have a angel voice hugs all my love your amazing talented singer piano player always come out with the best thats why i have so much love you make my day your going places your the best ever and ever
godddd you're voice is SO mesmerizing and your playing on the piano ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS. Btw, I think you'd sound amazing covering Dear Reader, I think it's perfect for your voice.❤❤
your voice is so clear and smooth, this has to be my favourite cover of this song
omg. thank you so much, you are so kind. this truly means a lot to me. i love you
This is so stunningly beautiful. I love your tone and your transition from chest to head and vice versa is incredible!
this is so thoughtful. thank you, it means everything to me. i love you. 🫶🏻
It took me so long to hear the time signature change during the chorus. Beautiful!
haha if knowing this makes it any better, i didn’t exactly mean to change the time signature so i didn’t realize either!! thank you so much ❤️❤️
Girll stop is this really human voice is like it's from angels in heaven ✨
omg. stop it that is so incredibly kind. thank you so much
you're so talented!! i wish i could play the piano like this. loved this so much, keep going :)
stop i’m gonna start crying. thank you so much, i really appreciate it. i love you!!
Your voice suits this song so much !!
thank you so much :’))
Beautiful cover! If you want my feedback/tips, continue reading :)
The song is in 5/4, which is very uncommon. This makes it hard to play AND sing if you're not used to it, that's what also really stumps me when i play this song. You did great on the intro and parts of the verses, but on the chorus, you switched to 4/4. That's why it is more 'rushed'. I recommend going through the original version and trying to find the pattern in melody and chord switch. then you can start off by singing and playing the chords only once on the down beat, then trying every beat and eventually going to a rhythm you want to play.
In general it's still a good cover tho! Hope to see you pop up on my recommended again soon :)
thanks for taking the time to write this! i appreciate the feedback. i honestly don't pay much attention to timing when i'm singing while playing but i guess i should really work on that. and even while just playing i've always kind of sucked at timing haha. but thank you so much. hope to see you back sometime :)
@@katy_ly the best of luck to you! I feel you have a lot of potential! :)
that means a lot to me. thank you!
Was looking for this comment! Yt recommended this to me cause I also made a cover of this song and went through hell with 5/4. I love this so much though, your delivery on the chorus is so beautiful, timing is insignificant
aw thank you so much it means a lot to me!! 5/4 is truly so tricky. i’ll check out your cover :))
OMG STAWWPPP I love this song, your voice, it really takes a new turn on the song❤❤❤
omg this is so sweet. thank you so much. it truly means a lot to me. i love you
OMG your voice is amazing! it flows so well with piano
thank you so much omg
This cover is beautiful! Well done♥
thank you so much!!! i really appreciate it
i was searching for tolerate it covers and i fond this., and thank god for it!!! your voice is sooo beauty and u play so good. congrats
that is very kind of you to say. thank you :)
I love how is so much like the original but with your spin on it. you really killed it!
that is such a thoughtful thing to say. thank you so much, it really means a lot to me
Your voice is very beautiful , and YOU ARE EXTREMELY TALENTED! This is probably one of the best covers of this song I’ve ever heard. Keep it up ❤️❤️❤️
that is such a kind compliment. thank you so so much
Wow 🫶🏼🥹 so soothing! Tay would be proud of you
stop. this is making me cry. that is so kind of you to say, thank you. taylor would be proud of you
I got chills!! mashallah your voice is magical.
I was reading in a novel about how impactful songs covers are, the delivery just channels emotion in a way that is not necessarily better but just different, tolerate it is one of my fav songs on evermore but the way you sang it hit me in a way it has never before ❤🩹
oh my gosh. i think this is one of the most thoughtful comments i have ever received. this truly means everything to me. my favorite part of making and listening to covers is getting an new perspective on a song and i am so glad that this cover resonated with you. thank you so so much, this really made my day. i love you so much. 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
@@katy_ly Awwww thank you, I wish you all the best!💌💌
thank you!! all my love to you
@@katy_ly 💗💗💗
i was searching for a cover of this song, i gotta say you're literally-
MYGOD BEST COVER I SAW KEEP IT UP GURL !!
shut uppp you are so so sweet. thank you so much!!! it means everything to me. i love you
this is so amazing!!! you have so much talent!
stop it thank you so so much!!!
This is so gooooood!!! I could never. Thank you
aw thank you so so much. i love you
@@katy_ly it’s just really good. I’ve been playing piano for way too many years now, and I can’t play like that. I’ve never tried, but still. That’s just amazing
oh i’ve been playing since i was four and i still struggle. you should give it a try sometime, i’m genuinely sure you’re amazing!! you are so incredibly kind. thank you :)))
you have such an angelic voice, im completely in love.❤
that is so incredibly kind. thank you love
THIS IS SO GOOD WHOA
you are so sweet. thank you :'))
hiiii I love your videos sm your covers are awesome! this is the best!
aw thank you so much!! this is so sweet. i love you
i love you too! youre welcome. also can you do dorothea by Taylor swift@@katy_ly
sure! i love dorothea. thank you :))
youre welcome and hanks it’s like my fav. song!! @@katy_ly
❤❤❤
💗💗💗
beautiful voice, love the piano melody as well, keep it up fellow piano player. sounding great!
thank you so much :)) really appreciate it.
:) wish you the best on your channel. im growing mine as well and also play piano. but i dont sing well so i do other things haha check it out sometime if you'd like.@@katy_ly
heart touching heart warming performance have a angel voice hugs all my love your amazing talented singer piano player always come out with the best thats why i have so much love you make my day your going places your the best ever and ever
you always make my day
your welcome so happy to hear that thankyou so much all the love hugs support your the best @@katy_ly
so good - well done!
thank you so much!!! means a lot to me :))
godddd you're voice is SO mesmerizing and your playing on the piano ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS. Btw, I think you'd sound amazing covering Dear Reader, I think it's perfect for your voice.❤❤
oh my god. thank you so much. this is so unbelievably kind of you to say. it truly means so much to me, i love you
th-cam.com/video/taxqw0yUgvA/w-d-xo.html
hope you like it :)))
loveeeeee thiss 🤍
i love you. thank you so much!!
u deserve my sub and MANY MORE. keep it upp
thank you so much :’)) it means a lot to me.
That's not an easy song but did it so good! Keep going!
thank you so much!! means a lot to me 🫶🏻
May I know your piano brand?
yamaha!! i’m not sure about the model but i’ll try to figure it out and get back to you :)
the model is a Yamaha Clavinova CLP-430!!
@@katy_ly oh my god, thankss!!
no problem 🫶🏻
wow subscribed :)
thank you so much :)) really appreciate it
Pretty 🍀
thank you!!
Who is sobbing? Obviously not me!
stop it thank you so much ☹️🫶🏻 i love you
new sub:)))
i appreciate that more than i can say :’)))
Good job! The timing in the chorus is a bit off, though.
thanks!! i appreciate when people point out things like that because i’ve also noticed my timing can be off sometimes haha. working on it :))
damn girl this is gold
stop it omg thank you so much
"promosm" 😪