the end of 2020 is getting closer , I just suddenly think of this song. I’m not a teenage fangirl anymore and I rarely follow their news in these few years. But during this Difficult time, I just start feeling nostalgic about their music and precious memories they brought to me when I was young. Tohoshiki is not just a idol group, their songs really touch my heart no matter what age I am now. Never regret to be their fan. Thank you Tohoshiki, you guys are one of my happiness in my teenage memory.
Im korean and fan of them tooㅠㅠmiss them a lot during this period...and always thx for my teenage memory full of happiness with their songs...and also want their happiness too even if they go different ways now...
@@어-w7p I feel the same as you guys. They filled my teenage years with happiness and I'll always love them for that. Wish I could find more people who felt the same way!
꼭 주기적으로 생각나서 들어오는 영상 나는 이 노래를 듣고 그 어리던 중학생 꼬맹이가 받았던 충격을 아직도 못잊어. 화성학이며 세션이며 어떤 이론적 지식과 스킬도 없는데, 다섯명의 목소리가 들릴때까지 듣고 또 듣고 또 들었어. 화음을 따서 따라부르고, 무슨 뜻인지 알고 싶어서 일본어도 배웠어. 악기를 배우고 싶다고 생각했고 그 이후로 신디사이저를 10년동안 치면서 취미지만 밴드를 했어. 라이브 공연이 주는 짜릿함을 못잊어서 이 공연장 저 공연장 돌아다니면서 공연을 해보고 싶다는 막연한 꿈도 가졌었어. 그렇게 더 좋아하고 잘 이해하고싶어서 닥치는대로 배웠던것들이 결국 지금의 나를 이뤘어. 어린시절 나의 부분일 수도 없고 나의 전부이기만 했던, 그 아름다운 기억을 이렇게 꺼내보는것도 언젠가부터는 미안한 마음도 들어. 모든게 변했는데 계속 붙잡고 있는 과거에 얽매여서 추억만 하고 있으니까 말이야. 이제는 영상 속 오빠들보다 훨씬 나이먹어 버렸지만, 이 나이가 되어서야 보이고 느낄 수 있는 것들이 있더라구. 그래서 자꾸 여기로 돌아오나봐. ㅠ 그치만 영원히 잊고 싶지 않아. 그때의 나, 그때의 카시오페아, 그때의 동방신기. 다시 오지 않기 때문에 더 그리운 옛날이 오늘따라 더 보고싶넹 잘있어
I love it that such vocal group as gospellers that has lasted this long, proving the voice and melody-not looks, trends, instruments, nor commerciality- to make an indispensable element in music.
They really matched each other, as gospellers & tohoshinki both compliment each other voices n very well harmonized! seniors n juniors best featuring!!! n gospellers were so nice by always clapping when it's toho's turn.. so encouraging!!
As far as i know. Gospellers is a famous acapella band of Japan :) They sang with THSK in this video... and Tohoshinki covered a lot of acapella songs of them and have a deep respect for them :)
I found myself smiling like an idiot not even halfway through the performance. The Gospellers are so humble and with TVXQ, the tweaks they made to this song made the performance even more awesome. They all looked so happy on stage and I wish I could see them do it live once more :\
I'm crying by seeing this,cos i remember it was one of the member's wish to sing with,which is junsu's,i'm right? and when that happen,he say he don't want to sing alone but with all members...watching them fullfilled one by one of their wishes and dreams make me stronger to believe in that we can achieve everything that we're dream of...Thank You Guys for never giving up..i'm waiting for the other member's turn to sing together with their favorite one...
I see that they all really love singing They sing this song with each other by hearts .... so beautiful Gospellers is a good senior and Tohoshinki always show their respect toward them ... Oh really sweet ^ ^
i still love this performance. all of their voices just melted together into something truly amazing. and you can tell that everyone on the stage was having a great time singing with one another. two of the best came together and gave a spectacular performance.
this gives me goosebumps, but makes me cry as well. i miss them ....TVXQ! this is just beautiful how 2 acapella groups harmonize together in this beautiful song.
I love how impressed The Gospellers are with the "boys" singing. Like when they get all clappy when Yunho and Changmin belt their notes. It makes me happy :)
they've always wanted to do a duet with the gospellers.... n they did it... im sooooooo proud....... and they sound amazing...... tohoshinkiiiiii fighting.... !!!:)
when i 1st listened to this, i didnt really like it much (thought there were too many people to let it work) but now i totally can't get enough of it! its amazing!!! just takes my breath away... must have listened to it over 100 times now! ^^
this really bring a whole new meaning to boyband..this shows that asian boybands are not just good looking they are extremely talented...the western boybands made alot of ppl think that all boybands are the same but this performance shows otherwise!the harmonizing is great! not a single person was out of tune and the pitching was accurate! truly a great performance by both band!
I keep coming back to this clip like a weekly dose for my ears. Forgive me, but this perf really dig in my heart. When 10 boys and men sing in the same time, you'd think the voices will be loud and scattering or just normal. These guys prove it wrong. Their voices are beautiful, soft yet powerful, and just like a unique harmony.
Wow this song is amazing...And i love the Gospellers now haha i never heard them before but they're so nice to the boys =D it was an awesome performance hehe
i really love the way Gospellers sort of step bk and let DBSK sing while they are in the bk noddin to very notes our bosy sang. its like they are fathers, watchin his son performin a old song that he used to sing bk in the days. i luv their interaction.
i'm so happy that they got to make their dreams come true it gives the rest of us hope ne? their harmony is perfect too, absolutely flawless. it's amazing how well the two groups melded together on this stage, i hope to see more DBSK/gospellers collaborations in the future.
such a perfect collaboration^-^ i noticed dat they totally compliment each other..even before dis i dun know whose gospellers,but they r great..supporting each other..thanks for sharing..something nice to see 10 guys in one stage like wat they did...
Seen this video so many times and it never fails to amaze me. I know it gets a bit messy at the end but dang...Jae's adlib from 5:01 is just absolutely stunning!
I wish other people who doesn't like asian music can see it like us fans do. Or people who appreciate the music. When you really try and listen to it, you can actually feel the song. Even if you don't understand a thing, it is beautiful, I don't understand how someone would not like DBSK. They sing live the best, their talented.
gosh...this is the first tym i watch this... also the first tym i heard this.. and i really felt goosebump... DBSK is really good... i dont know the gospellers but i feel that they are artists to remember and i feel proud of tvxq singing side by side with them...T_T i miss them so much...TT_TT
It was great that their dream collaborating with the Gospellers came true. I would also like to hear this song performed by DBSK alone since I want to hear more of their singing!
![[희귀] (MBC 아카이브) 뽀뽀뽀에 출연한 권지용(GD)!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1TE0c4rb-t0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[희귀] (MBC 아카이브) 뽀뽀뽀에 출연한 권지용(GD)!](/img/tr.png)
![[DBSK/TVXQ] Love in the Ice - Soul Power in Osaka](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kEvuioxf5sc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] ✨ Dust-Free Dream: ONEW's Morning Routine! 🔥 (ft. His Beloved Dust Remover aka. Doldori)](/img/n.gif)
back here again in 2024
2023 and suddenly i miss this song
same.. im here bcs i miss them singing this song~
2024
2022, still hearing and feeling so emotional
2023 here
the end of 2020 is getting closer , I just suddenly think of this song. I’m not a teenage fangirl anymore and I rarely follow their news in these few years. But during this Difficult time, I just start feeling nostalgic about their music and precious memories they brought to me when I was young. Tohoshiki is not just a idol group, their songs really touch my heart no matter what age I am now. Never regret to be their fan. Thank you Tohoshiki, you guys are one of my happiness in my teenage memory.
I miss them alot lately~~~ still the same. Long time has passed,right?~
Im korean and fan of them tooㅠㅠmiss them a lot during this period...and always thx for my teenage memory full of happiness with their songs...and also want their happiness too even if they go different ways now...
the memories we'll cherish forever, no matter what
@@어-w7p I feel the same as you guys. They filled my teenage years with happiness and I'll always love them for that. Wish I could find more people who felt the same way!
❤️ Good old days right..
2020 and I am still here..
2023 suddenly remembered this performance. One of the best harmonization ever, miss tvxq5 😢 aktf
2020, anyone?
2022
2022 here
2022
@@もとマム 고스페라스 노래 못불러. 진짜 못불러
love how gospellers are so supportive of tohoshinki. :) esp during that period of time when they're not that big in japan yet.
True, how gospellers gave them space during the chorus ❤️😭
I’m so glad I discovered them now even if I’m late😢 literally no one has as good as vocals as they did nowadays I miss them
4:35 The voice of lead vocal Jaejoong always stands out the most
東方神起の歌声はいつだって人を感動させる不思議な力がありますね。
ほんとうに最高のグループです！！！！
涙出てきそう。。。
Still watching in 2018, this performance still makes me want to cry a little even after all this time
Rainbow Vanishes ikr!! i was looking for this but forgot the title. Gotta save it in my playlist for sure
it's 2018 and jaejoong is still beautiful today and in this song
2019
Still here in 2020❤
Back again in 2020 :') still love this
Still watching in 2019. 😔
still watching here too April 13,2020
もし、タイムマシーンが有るならば、タイムスリップしてこの場に立ち会いたいです。
何度見ても素敵すぎてコーラスが胸に響き渡るわあー😭
I'm still here 2020-Sep and listening and waiting...
OMG I miss them singing together 😭
When first time I heard this song, I was just smiled, but then now I cry a lot 😭😭
I absolutely love yunho's voice here... It is very soft and beautiful. I think both groups sang so well and this unit sounds perfect;
꼭 주기적으로 생각나서 들어오는 영상
나는 이 노래를 듣고 그 어리던 중학생 꼬맹이가 받았던 충격을 아직도 못잊어. 화성학이며 세션이며 어떤 이론적 지식과 스킬도 없는데, 다섯명의 목소리가 들릴때까지 듣고 또 듣고 또 들었어. 화음을 따서 따라부르고, 무슨 뜻인지 알고 싶어서 일본어도 배웠어. 악기를 배우고 싶다고 생각했고 그 이후로 신디사이저를 10년동안 치면서 취미지만 밴드를 했어. 라이브 공연이 주는 짜릿함을 못잊어서 이 공연장 저 공연장 돌아다니면서 공연을 해보고 싶다는 막연한 꿈도 가졌었어. 그렇게 더 좋아하고 잘 이해하고싶어서 닥치는대로 배웠던것들이 결국 지금의 나를 이뤘어. 어린시절 나의 부분일 수도 없고 나의 전부이기만 했던, 그 아름다운 기억을 이렇게 꺼내보는것도 언젠가부터는 미안한 마음도 들어. 모든게 변했는데 계속 붙잡고 있는 과거에 얽매여서 추억만 하고 있으니까 말이야. 이제는 영상 속 오빠들보다 훨씬 나이먹어 버렸지만, 이 나이가 되어서야 보이고 느낄 수 있는 것들이 있더라구. 그래서 자꾸 여기로 돌아오나봐. ㅠ
그치만 영원히 잊고 싶지 않아. 그때의 나, 그때의 카시오페아, 그때의 동방신기. 다시 오지 않기 때문에 더 그리운 옛날이 오늘따라 더 보고싶넹 잘있어
I love it that such vocal group as gospellers that has lasted this long, proving the voice and melody-not looks, trends, instruments, nor commerciality- to make an indispensable element in music.
They really matched each other, as gospellers & tohoshinki both compliment each other voices n very well harmonized! seniors n juniors best featuring!!! n gospellers were so nice by always clapping when it's toho's turn.. so encouraging!!
During Changmin's part, Jaejoong looks so proud of Changmin 😊
Oh, that was so sweet. You're right.
soulfighter :_:
01:48 여기가 진짜 너무 좋아...ㅠㅠ 3:25... 아 멤버를 어떻게 생각하는지가 눈빛으로 너무 보여...우리 창민이ㅠ
Jae Joong voice in the chorus.. is really really great >.
Who are Gospellers? can u please explain me? thanks
As far as i know. Gospellers is a famous acapella band of Japan :) They sang with THSK in this video... and Tohoshinki covered a lot of acapella songs of them and have a deep respect for them :)
still slays in 2021
Love it...
I love the way they supported each other on stage. That's the way music should be! ^^ Love it
Still in love with this collab in 2023
I found myself smiling like an idiot not even halfway through the performance. The Gospellers are so humble and with TVXQ, the tweaks they made to this song made the performance even more awesome. They all looked so happy on stage and I wish I could see them do it live once more :\
鳥肌が・・・！！！
みんな楽しそう♪
This will never get old
It’s 2021 and i still miss them soo fckn much!
I'm crying by seeing this,cos i remember it was one of the member's wish to sing with,which is junsu's,i'm right? and when that happen,he say he don't want to sing alone but with all members...watching them fullfilled one by one of their wishes and dreams make me stronger to believe in that we can achieve everything that we're dream of...Thank You Guys for never giving up..i'm waiting for the other member's turn to sing together with their favorite one...
Suddenly i came to this lol missing their amazing voices
2023. im here again.
(i commented here every 2 years since 2019)
the gospellers and tohoshinki together. two of my favourite groups, with indubitable and fantastic vocal prowess. i love this!
I see that they all really love singing
They sing this song with each other by hearts .... so beautiful
Gospellers is a good senior
and Tohoshinki always show their respect toward them ... Oh really sweet ^ ^
GOSPELLERS ! The best acapellers ever. Such an effortless singing.
i still love this performance.
all of their voices just melted together into something truly amazing. and you can tell that everyone on the stage was having a great time singing with one another. two of the best came together and gave a spectacular performance.
I'll never tire of this performance
JYJ + HoMin=BEST group ever TVXQ their harmony is the BEST! Miss them so much :(
동방신기 버전 토와니 존버했었는데 ㅜㅜㅜ
DVD로 안풀려서 너무아숩
this gives me goosebumps, but makes me cry as well. i miss them ....TVXQ!
this is just beautiful how 2 acapella groups harmonize together in this beautiful song.
and 2024 too
I love how impressed The Gospellers are with the "boys" singing. Like when they get all clappy when Yunho and Changmin belt their notes. It makes me happy :)
this is so... this is simply amazing.. makes me tear up
two bands with great vocalists together..
와 진짜 감동이다❤ 이게 노래지!
2021 and I am still watching this video. I miss them so much...
they've always wanted to do a duet with the gospellers.... n they did it... im sooooooo proud....... and they sound amazing...... tohoshinkiiiiii fighting.... !!!:)
2022 here..
this is the reason that I still believe that DBSK is the best kpop group!!!!!!!!!
It was so nice how they gave more attention towards Tohoshinki~~such beautiful harmony!!
It is Towani. It is one of my favorite Gospellers songs. So beautiful!
when i 1st listened to this, i didnt really like it much (thought there were too many people to let it work) but now i totally can't get enough of it! its amazing!!! just takes my breath away...
must have listened to it over 100 times now! ^^
10 amazing, beautiful, distinguish and wonderful voice blended together in perfect harmony. This is what I call being in Heaven.
this really bring a whole new meaning to boyband..this shows that asian boybands are not just good looking they are extremely talented...the western boybands made alot of ppl think that all boybands are the same but this performance shows otherwise!the harmonizing is great! not a single person was out of tune and the pitching was accurate! truly a great performance by both band!
try to pay respect for those man, both Gospeller and DBSK are very great boyband, don't judge this real music by their appearance only :D
If compared to today's band, these guys are way beyond legends
2020 here!
2023 ❤
I keep coming back to this clip like a weekly dose for my ears. Forgive me, but this perf really dig in my heart. When 10 boys and men sing in the same time, you'd think the voices will be loud and scattering or just normal. These guys prove it wrong. Their voices are beautiful, soft yet powerful, and just like a unique harmony.
so proud of you.tohoshinki colab
Miss TV5XQ!
the most beautiful collaboration, seriously.
Have you ever heard any other 10 men sing so wonderfully together? :)
I'm so proud of TVXQ
woa...never failed to amaze me...
absolutely yes,our supports and loves would never end...right?
Wow this song is amazing...And i love the Gospellers now haha i never heard them before but they're so nice to the boys =D it was an awesome performance hehe
Such a great performance! I only found this today sadly... Changmin's part was heavenly
2024 ❤
2019, i'm back here...Jaejoong
Gospellers are amazing as always.
Tohoshinki's performance was superb as well.
these men are the reason why i love music
Gospellers like a big brother!!! They're so nice with our boys... Thank you!!!
I think it's because The Gospellers had a different harmony. But if you try to tune them out, DBSK was impressive :D
that leaves me speechless~
I don't know what to think or to feel... it's just amazing~~ ♥
I never knew my mouth was open watching this..
This is just... AMAZING
i really love the way Gospellers sort of step bk and let DBSK sing while they are in the bk noddin to very notes our bosy sang. its like they are fathers, watchin his son performin a old song that he used to sing bk in the days. i luv their interaction.
i'm so happy that they got to make their dreams come true it gives the rest of us hope ne? their harmony is perfect too, absolutely flawless. it's amazing how well the two groups melded together on this stage, i hope to see more DBSK/gospellers collaborations in the future.
such a perfect collaboration^-^
i noticed dat they totally compliment each other..even before dis i dun know whose gospellers,but they r great..supporting each other..thanks for sharing..something nice to see 10 guys in one stage like wat they did...
AMAZING!!!!!
2019 , Miss 5 .😭😭😭
Beautifully done!!!! Thanks so much!!! I'd like--love to see them all together soon....
2022 에도 들으러 옴 ㅠㅠ
Beautiful collab
Seen this video so many times and it never fails to amaze me. I know it gets a bit messy at the end but dang...Jae's adlib from 5:01 is just absolutely stunning!
I wish other people who doesn't like asian music can see it like us fans do.
Or people who appreciate the music.
When you really try and listen to it, you can actually feel the song.
Even if you don't understand a thing, it is beautiful, I don't understand
how someone would not like DBSK. They sing live the best, their talented.
Fallen in love with this song :D
i think changmin's part was totally the best!!! he sang so beautifully!!
Wow, tohoshinki the best of boy band with acapella group
T________T
this is beautiful.....
changmin waaaaa your voice is amazing...all sing fantastic
..Sigh..So Beautiful!
I love this song! And TVXQ just makes me love it better!
i have decided...that i will have this song at my wedding for sure...this exact version...
Every time I see this It brings tears to my eyes.. I'm so proud of them, and I'm proud to be a Cassie... I love them eternally.
their duet was just wonderful ;)
gosh...this is the first tym i watch this...
also the first tym i heard this..
and i really felt goosebump...
DBSK is really good...
i dont know the gospellers but i feel that they are artists to remember and i feel proud of tvxq singing side by side with them...T_T
i miss them so much...TT_TT
so touching!! -sniff-
i luv it!!! they were ALL GREAT!!!
and the gospellers r so nice 2 dbsk!!! ^^
2024 😢
It was great that their dream collaborating with the Gospellers came true. I would also like to hear this song performed by DBSK alone since I want to hear more of their singing!
2022...?
the two bands together are a perfect combination!!!