Ok the case has been solved. Turns out the Themberchaud list going 3-0 was actually just a meme, and while it technically was submitted to an event, it never saw play and only received draws. The legend snowballed online, which is why I couldn’t actually find the results. Sorry for the misunderstanding. I will do better research next time before putting up a list like this. But glad we solved the case lol
Don’t worry about it! Video was super enjoyable and could easily be incorporated into a regular feature on decklists. This is content weeeeeee neeeeeed 🍿
I don't play cEDH and I legitimately can't tell whether the deck is making more and more sense as Rebel is making her way through it or if she's just resigning herself to the existence of this specific pile of cards
It's definitely the latter, This deck is legitimately sweet. It's a fun dragon theme that bombs people's stuff and can do WAY more damage from sticking a single brash taunter (or stuffy doll, ect. ect.) than you'd expect. But it's not a CEDH deck. Nothing about it really makes it a CEDH deck. It's just a mid-power commander deck with some fast mana/a couple CEDH staples in it, so it's probably a little overwhelming for a true casual table. Once again, not that there's anything WRONG with that, but if this deck DID pull off a 3-0 at a CEDH event it's just like... how? lol (which is also a thing that can happen from time to time, good matchups, bad draws, ect. Magic just has too many variables for the best deck to win all the time)
This decklist is magical. It looks like a casual deck. You _need_ to get that interview with Tim_Nook, because from the decklist alone we're definitely not getting the full picture.
It's really interesting to see such an "unedited" version of your thoughts and insights. I tend to like the "more edited" videos more, but it was fun watching you slowly try to figure out what this deck does!
Thank you Rebell! This video is Tier 0! Definitely going to rewatch for pure entertainment purposes but also editing skills. The confusion here is so honest and palpable, and the sassy Copium sprinkles really add to everything on multiple levels, hahaha! And the hair and makeup department really came through too! Super cute!
I have a casual deck built for this chonky boy. No crypt, or any high end gas. I use a lot of copy effects, and Flickr effects. I break parity with a little life gain or asymmetrical additional burn. I don’t think I have lost a game with him yet.
This was a blast to watch first thing in the morning here. Thanks a bunch, and I'm sorry it turned out to be a meme. Means this video was all you, then.
can't wait to know more about this deck, the reveal one by one is hilarious and the more you see the pieces of the puzzle the more you admire the craft ahahah
for a moment i thought that they would equip the infect equipment to the commander, but yeah, only on ETB as a cEDH noob it's very strange to see that this player didn't choose torbran and went in the "burn stax" direction, especially since there is some land destruction already
the more i learn about cedh and what deck win, the more i realize there is a bit of a circlejerk/echochamber problem with cedh analysis. there are plenty of decks that can 3-0. decks most people would under estimate for sure. because individual skill level matters a lot more than people are willing to fully introspect on. like i saw someone with literally all the fast mana in the world in a deck and many staples call teir deck a 7 recently. we forget many decks can punch above their weight class pretty easily if the pilot is smart and playing to win. this also looks so much like my Themberchaud deck i plan on building
This looks like a deck I'd build for a casual pod (except for the fast mana, blasts and wheel), how does it win cEDH games? It looks harmless in a world with thoracles and worldgorgers. I really would love a follow up where you can deep dive and find the strategy.
I think the deck is built assuming that everyone else will be working to stop the fast combo players, enabling the Themberchaud player to take advantage. "Stax loses to EDHRec.deck and this is EDHRec.deck." It's a complete meme deck, but when CEDH is so brutally inbred that players just don't plan for anything but the topmost decks, any deck that just doesn't bother playing on that axis has a natural advantage. It's like Slicer - "aggro isn't good in CEDH" means that no one is preparing to beat aggro in CEDH.
BTW@@RebellLily I was about to write woman ("The woman was too stunned to speak") but I given your pronouns I didn't know if calling you a woman was appropriate
i mean if toxrill can be a viable commander (i know better colors and toxrill can be a wincon) it not that far fetched that this can actually be tweaked to be viable to a certain extent.
There is very obvious cards I want to suggest like a jeweled lotus or dockside but it feels like if a single card is removed it will be like taking the toilet paper at the bottom of the wall display at Walmart.
@@RetroMTG I do not understand this deck whatsoever so I'm afraid that even seemingly objective upgrades are missing something because they feel so obvious.
@@RetroMTG Oh, it's a Superstore reference. There's those people who always think the products at the front of the display is damaged so they dig in back to find the "freshest" one. Combine that with a three-dimensional display and you get someone who removes a load-bearing pack at the bottom of a pyramid.
It turns out when you don't gatekeep which commanders are allowed and just let people try to make decks to optimize for winning you see decks that nobody thought of
you can see the visible distress that this is causing Rebel throughout the video. She's trying to hide it but I think she's experienced multiple heart palpitations/attacks. Props to Rebel for staying coherent and not devolving into a stream of profanities /ranting about bad deckbuilding lmao
Abbbbsolutely not 😭 this went 3-0 where lmao the type of lgs where azusa eldrazi is considered cedh? Wait a sec I have an idea that's too big to fail...
Well in yugioh the second place deck for its most beloved formst Edison, doom caliber gagets dosent work, doom caliber effecrs makes it a negats the gadgets destroying your own board. No one know how it made; fst dragon is the successer to this
Ok the case has been solved. Turns out the Themberchaud list going 3-0 was actually just a meme, and while it technically was submitted to an event, it never saw play and only received draws. The legend snowballed online, which is why I couldn’t actually find the results.
Sorry for the misunderstanding. I will do better research next time before putting up a list like this. But glad we solved the case lol
I wanted to believe :(
Don’t worry about it! Video was super enjoyable and could easily be incorporated into a regular feature on decklists. This is content weeeeeee neeeeeed 🍿
Thank God it was a meme..
I was so not excited to see that clunk pile of a deck ahhaha
Don't let your dreams be memes. Build some dumb shit and throw it into the cEDH grinder and see what happens!
We need to make this real
I don't play cEDH and I legitimately can't tell whether the deck is making more and more sense as Rebel is making her way through it or if she's just resigning herself to the existence of this specific pile of cards
rofl
It's definitely the latter, This deck is legitimately sweet. It's a fun dragon theme that bombs people's stuff and can do WAY more damage from sticking a single brash taunter (or stuffy doll, ect. ect.) than you'd expect. But it's not a CEDH deck. Nothing about it really makes it a CEDH deck. It's just a mid-power commander deck with some fast mana/a couple CEDH staples in it, so it's probably a little overwhelming for a true casual table.
Once again, not that there's anything WRONG with that, but if this deck DID pull off a 3-0 at a CEDH event it's just like... how? lol (which is also a thing that can happen from time to time, good matchups, bad draws, ect. Magic just has too many variables for the best deck to win all the time)
The moment I saw Birgi and the big dragon I went "oh dragonstorm!" and then was sad I was wrong :(
This decklist is magical. It looks like a casual deck. You _need_ to get that interview with Tim_Nook, because from the decklist alone we're definitely not getting the full picture.
yesss I want the interview so badly tooo ahah
It's really interesting to see such an "unedited" version of your thoughts and insights. I tend to like the "more edited" videos more, but it was fun watching you slowly try to figure out what this deck does!
As a frequent mono red player, bolt bend and ricochet trap would probably be really solid interaction in the list
Now we need to do an upgrade guide and get this up to actually playable.
That's the natural conclusion
Playable? This is elite already.
Lol it would be the deck of Theseus, leave it be
So Themberchaud + Stuffy Doll + Panharmonicon + a damage doubling card is a top tier CEDH combo indeed
The capital C stands for Cool.
Cedh is power level 10. 3-0. 10 - 3 = 7.
We must play power level 7 Themberchad.
Thank you Rebell! This video is Tier 0! Definitely going to rewatch for pure entertainment purposes but also editing skills. The confusion here is so honest and palpable, and the sassy Copium sprinkles really add to everything on multiple levels, hahaha! And the hair and makeup department really came through too! Super cute!
Id love a series of you reviewing your viewers memey/fun decks like this
Would love more read throughs like this, even if they didn’t actually end up winning anything 💀😂
They didn't lose anything either
@@RebellLily two things can be true…
Oh my god the faces you made while looking at the decklist are all amazing. This video is such a blast. One of the bests.
We need a follow up, we need to see the fat dragon in action!
This looks like a lot of fun to play in a non-tournament setting. And I enjoyed the video even if it was a meme in the end.
Happy to hear!
cackling madly as i watch this. thank you ms rebell
Now you have to refine the concept. Show us what an optimized Themberchaud cEDH deck looks like.
I think it's time we made memes our dreams
@@RebellLilycEDH Meme Tournament: everyone who signs up still plays, but the true winner is the one who gets the most votes: Boaty McBoatface-style
great video! That was one of the funniest things I have watch in a long time.
I have a casual deck built for this chonky boy. No crypt, or any high end gas. I use a lot of copy effects, and Flickr effects. I break parity with a little life gain or asymmetrical additional burn. I don’t think I have lost a game with him yet.
yo that sounds REALLY GOOD
@@RebellLilyThemberCHAD ftw!!
May I ask for the decklist? I cant decide what cards to include and which to cut
you can use the powerstones from visions of phyrexia to get your staff of nin out faster
LOL
This was a blast to watch first thing in the morning here. Thanks a bunch, and I'm sorry it turned out to be a meme. Means this video was all you, then.
We all wanted to believe
can't wait to know more about this deck, the reveal one by one is hilarious and the more you see the pieces of the puzzle the more you admire the craft ahahah
Girl, your makeup looks so good ❤💅
THANK YOU! I did very little for this one, just eyeliner and lip gloss
@@RebellLilywell it totally works! Looking great 😊
@@RebellLilySeconded 🔥🤳
This is unbelievably funny. I'm actually dying
I was dying too
for a moment i thought that they would equip the infect equipment to the commander, but yeah, only on ETB
as a cEDH noob it's very strange to see that this player didn't choose torbran and went in the "burn stax" direction, especially since there is some land destruction already
Now that we’ve gone through the whole deck, I think what happened is that “insert that m*fer is not real” meme here
idk fam this is clearly genius
Now i just want to use this as the start of a real Fat Dragon deck lol
SAME
When I watch this video you seem to start out fine and slowly start to cope more and more the further you get through the list. 😂
I’m a believer. Fat Dragons is my favorite cEDH archetype, and now I can also go 3-0 at my locals with this masterpiece.
I love Koth and love this deck
This deck is definitely "mountains and dragons go Brr"
"My commander is Valakut"
really enjoyed the deck view. would have loved if you tried playtesting it on camera as well!
I love ThemberChad
Funny deck might build it as a meme cedh deck. Would love to see it in action
If a deck runs Skred and Koth, in every format, I'm in.
My man said "I want to play Wildfire outside of cube". Absolute king shit right here. 👑
This has a direction I feel, the MLD stuff and the sheer amount of damage speaks to me like it’s mono red ponza. Our man here is a mad genius.
Huge miss on not naming this deck Alpha-Chaud
This makes my Timmy brain so happy!
CEDH or not this is amazing!😅😂😊
the more i learn about cedh and what deck win, the more i realize there is a bit of a circlejerk/echochamber problem with cedh analysis. there are plenty of decks that can 3-0. decks most people would under estimate for sure. because individual skill level matters a lot more than people are willing to fully introspect on. like i saw someone with literally all the fast mana in the world in a deck and many staples call teir deck a 7 recently. we forget many decks can punch above their weight class pretty easily if the pilot is smart and playing to win.
this also looks so much like my Themberchaud deck i plan on building
a deck to beat stax? the peoples deck has risen!
Sadly the 3-0 is just a meme lol. The deck doesn't perform
None can face the might of the tubby dragon
This was so fun joining in on your confusion
This is amazing and hilarious
Ah yes, Red, the ramp color.
"Dang this deck got hands" - Quote of 2023
I am so invested in this
Woot!
First!
+1 engagement ~♡
WOOT THANK YOU
This looks like a deck I'd build for a casual pod (except for the fast mana, blasts and wheel), how does it win cEDH games? It looks harmless in a world with thoracles and worldgorgers. I really would love a follow up where you can deep dive and find the strategy.
I think the deck is built assuming that everyone else will be working to stop the fast combo players, enabling the Themberchaud player to take advantage. "Stax loses to EDHRec.deck and this is EDHRec.deck." It's a complete meme deck, but when CEDH is so brutally inbred that players just don't plan for anything but the topmost decks, any deck that just doesn't bother playing on that axis has a natural advantage. It's like Slicer - "aggro isn't good in CEDH" means that no one is preparing to beat aggro in CEDH.
@@drpibisback7680 Rebell just updated with an explanation lol. It seems that it was all a meme
While the deck was not the 3-0 legend we thought it was it is still a trip to see fathom how this deck even works
nobody:
me at 2:37 AM: I need to call him (Themberchaud)
i am so confused but also so intrigued????!
Themberchaud ate the meta. And was still hungry
Too stunned to speak 😂
*reading Decree of Annihilation*
BTW@@RebellLily I was about to write woman ("The woman was too stunned to speak") but I given your pronouns I didn't know if calling you a woman was appropriate
Themberchaud? more liek ThemberCHAD.
Definitely reached chad status
I want to know where this cedh tournament is so I can play against this glorious tier 1 deck.
I’m sleeping with Tim Nook
Was looking for something like a Purphoros
How many times Rebell gets stunned/stumped? I like the deck.
Two days after I publish the longest CEDH primer of all time, this pops up. Whelp, fuck me I guess.
Of course, a red deck with no dockside~
Might as well play Daretti and cast turn 1 Trinisphere.
OF COURSE
Video Downloaded ✅ Decklist Ordered using Rebell Affiliate Link ✅ Boaty McBoatface sleeves otw ✅ I’m serious 🧐😂 #Winning!!
Getting serious Urza’s Destiny champion deck vibes from this.
i think a Repercussion would slap in this deck
Bless valakut tribal & koth tribal
i mean if toxrill can be a viable commander (i know better colors and toxrill can be a wincon) it not that far fetched that this can actually be tweaked to be viable to a certain extent.
this was wild what the hell
Love this
Disk and recruiter work well with stuffy doll and taunter
Ahahaha, awesome!
¡¡Git’em ‘chaud!!
Edit: Mass Mutiny got a speechless reaction, lol
There is very obvious cards I want to suggest like a jeweled lotus or dockside but it feels like if a single card is removed it will be like taking the toilet paper at the bottom of the wall display at Walmart.
Explain yourself! I need to understand this!!
@@RetroMTG I do not understand this deck whatsoever so I'm afraid that even seemingly objective upgrades are missing something because they feel so obvious.
@@MakeVarahHappen No, haha, that I understood. What I must know is the story behind the Walmart toilet paper reference! Please!!
@@RetroMTG Oh, it's a Superstore reference. There's those people who always think the products at the front of the display is damaged so they dig in back to find the "freshest" one. Combine that with a three-dimensional display and you get someone who removes a load-bearing pack at the bottom of a pyramid.
Magic really is a beautiful game
It was a pile of trash but I had genuinely thought with the midrange focus we got to the part of the timeline when Sligh was viable in CEDH
Braid of fire? Could help
Chonki Boi is best boi
I feel like a Godolike Themberchaud has to be possible somehow.
No mention of tournament structure or when/where it happened or against which opponents, L.
Damn girl, your gloss game be toight.
It turns out when you don't gatekeep which commanders are allowed and just let people try to make decks to optimize for winning you see decks that nobody thought of
i had the same reaction as the title
My poor Urza stax deck
i run Insurecction instead of mass munity
What. Is. Happening?
nah cos twinflame on themberchaud would actually be funny as hell.
you can see the visible distress that this is causing Rebel throughout the video. She's trying to hide it but I think she's experienced multiple heart palpitations/attacks. Props to Rebel for staying coherent and not devolving into a stream of profanities /ranting about bad deckbuilding lmao
Magnetic Theft?
Abbbbsolutely not 😭 this went 3-0 where lmao the type of lgs where azusa eldrazi is considered cedh? Wait a sec I have an idea that's too big to fail...
Please find the deck creator Please. I've been playing this chunky dragon. My combo is repercussion
Time to cope with alcohol I guess?
See? Dockside isn’t an auto-include for mono-red cEDH. It’s not THAT OP.
This is a casual deck with a Mana Crypt.
By cEDH, they meant casualEDH.
Ngl, your Hilda Deck looked better xD
ThemberCHAD
Kediss triggers at hitting every opponent, Kediss + Themberchaud trigger + 7 mountains = win.
@edit.
Ahhhhh, combat dmg, nevermind.
Well in yugioh the second place deck for its most beloved formst Edison, doom caliber gagets dosent work, doom caliber effecrs makes it a negats the gadgets destroying your own board. No one know how it made; fst dragon is the successer to this
You are funny af
Lmao this is gold
Dockside extortionist? Never heard of her.
Hahaha!
This is why I can't take cEDH seriously.
Fear the chonkiest of dragons!