Hosie is a bloody disgrace - he consistently appears in front of Andrew Neil without having done a scrap of research. Taking money under false pretences.
No. Unlike his guest, he has worked hard doing his research, has planned the interview and what is going to be discussed. The guest could have done exactly the same if he wasn't so stupid or lazy. I am not blind, and I don't think you are thinking clearly.
Benters the reason he’s flustered is he’s grappling with the enormity of Andrew Neil’s bias. The SNP has done more for the people of Scotland in a decade than half a century of direct Westminster rule ever did. If the union was so good to Scotland why were we allowed to live like a third world country for so long? How could a massively asset rich country like ours have so many funding problems? The common denominator is the toxic union and thieving Westminster. The colonial mentality is still alive and kicking in the lying Tory party and their attitude to Scotland only proves that. Brexit even more so. No democracy in Britain for Scotland.. time to go.
"I'm not sure why you're doing this" Stewart Hosie embarrasses himself here by attempting to field questions from Andrew Neil without having any facts or figures at hand to defend himself or his party - a feat Angus Robertson would match two days later when he went before Andrew Neil without having done his homework and having no facts or figures to defend himself.
Typical BBC bullshit. Westminster cuts our budget then asks us why we haven't got enough money to fund our public services. That just about sums Britain up.
@@karmabomb3768 i think the point was that scotland had just as much in percentage as the rest of the uk but HAD,NT spent it where it had been allowed for in the budget ie extra health provision---i dont why the snp were making such a fuss ,,,,their perfectly within there rights to spend it wherever they deemed most needed it
We want total fiscal control, not the convoluted Barnet formula. Finance is only one part of it. We want to run our own affairs and do it with people we choose..not some shyster Westminster cabal who we not only don't vote for but truly hate. Britain is undemocratic and gerrymandered and anti Scottish, why would we support that? To answer your point about finances we know we're being ripped off. That's not even up for debate any more. We are the only oil rich, poor country in the world. To add insult to injury we have to put up with Tory scum telling us they won't ALLOW this or that. A foreign government that we did not vote for is not legitimate in our eyes. We have a paliament in Holyrood, that's who we want to run our country not some parliament in another country telling us what we can and can't do. That's completely unacceptable to us.
@@karmabomb3768 wow rant alert---what happened at the last referendum then if you ALL wanted out? ,,oil rich has been and gone ,it will need to come from taxation simple as that ,,,,if you want it bad enough it will be worth it,,,ps the westminster cabal has 60 scottish mps or did,nt you notice ,,,maybe they should,nt take the stinking english £85k a year on principle or maybe give it to the SNP coffers,,,ummm no did,nt think so
You're easily impressed. Have you not spotted the laptop and 2 inches of paper Neil needs to do his job, while expecting his guests to have memorised and guessed what questions Neil is going to ask. Neil got called out on it and guess what.......he has left 99% of the job.
@@casperwallace9685 i,m not even sure its personal,,,politicians are normally prepared to the eyeballs with their prescripted responses,,,we just love to see the smarmy gits sqirming for a change -----if your policy has no gaping holes in it most can limp through even the most ardent journos questions---oil revenue is,nt reliable enough to set such a large percentage to a potential budget ala venuezuela. the problem is in a prospective own rule government,,,the numbers HAVE to add up, ,, they have to be honest with voters expecting the same levels of service from less money with their currency controlled by another country,,,,,,this will come down to good economic governance above everything else ,,,dont be surprised to see your own version of austerity politics.
Lol got to love the woman who says lets have one every year, till they get the result they want. she was told to put into sooner box and put it in later 16:52
You mean: SNP "It's England's fault" Every English Person:😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
He's an absolute joke, and so is the rest of the SNP. This interview is proof that Scotland made the right decision by remaining in the UK and not turning their back on our family of nations.
17:08 That's right. Just keep having a referendum until you get the result you want. What does that remind me of? The Scottish people HAVE decided, and they have decided to remain in the UK and not betray their United Kingdom.
I am not from the UK. But certainly what I do hear from SNP figures, everything gone wrong or bad in Scottish politics the blame is thrown onto England. I do think the SNP is campaigning on untruths, the Scottish people will wake up from a very bad dream if the EU would become the new master of an "independent" Scotland.
Thats not what they said though Andrew... was it. SNPs forecast was less than the Tories. But that's not important. Oil revenues go out with Scotland(currently)...but that's not important is it? The Tories own advisors just released a report that Scotland would do better not being in the uk... but thats important either. Scotlands success with 34% of the UKs natural resources and only 8.3% of population is a no brainer!
samantha-jane hood We would have been bankrupt right now if we had gone independent with their shambolic economic “plans” aka economy based on oil at over $110 a barrel for 15 years - complete fantasy economics.
If all nhs hospitals get rid of managers and the subsident staff they need. That would help the NHS.Let the hospital staff them like they used to with a Matron in charge.
@@bam-skater Great, then why bother to elect officials to govern? In ancient Athens they used to have the vote on everything, including executions. When they decided to try Socrates for corrupting the youth, the jury consisted of 500 people. In the end they convicted him and he had to take hemlock as a poison. That's why we have representative democracy as opposed to the people taking every major decision. If you leave it all to the people they vote stupidly - take Brexit, it should never have happened. What did the average English person understand about the EU? Nothing. Years of anti-European propaganda. The average person didn't even understand the difference between the European Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights.
Andrew Neil twisting the figures and the truth. A simple fact the SNP have been voted into power for 13 years because the people of Scotland trust them and they want Independence.
*Hold on a minute this was in 2015 :Today End 2019 The price of oil is set to top $300 a barrel, and Scotland will be awash with so much money - hang on just checked September 20, 2019 is $58.09 per barrel which is = to £44.83 !*
*The only good to come from this is the fact that in real terms Scotch in real terms is much cheaper today, however the USA has recently imposed a 25% Import Tariff on single Malt, so nipping down to Adsa tomorrow for a couple of bottles of Glenlivet.*
Did u know the then Brexit party would never be for chlorinated chicken etc, they looked more sensible than the Tories but attracted some of the public who voted labour in 2017
Q: When should there be another referendum? Ans: “I wunt it now and who says we cannie have one the year after that” - That’s the sort of logic that prevails in the SNP. Browbeat the entire country towards independence.
Once its dun its dun for ever an who says we cannot just keep having referendums to get what WE WANT well that will be the democratic people who vote No ya muppets
Is he having a laugh. Saying the NHS is not in crisis. Tell that to all the patients who are having operations cancelled or delayed. The patients lying on trolleys in corridors for hours on end. Get real.
This is a turning point for Britain it won't be called the United Kingdom anymore as Scotland will soon be Independent, N Ireland will soon join Ireland so Wales and England will have to be called rUK (rest of the UK) or little Britain.
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA Finals D3 | Fall | รู้ผลทีมแชมป์ พร้อมตั๋วสู่ PMGC](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7NxsN0Ch6vk/mqdefault.jpg)
Hosie is a bloody disgrace - he consistently appears in front of Andrew Neil without having done a scrap of research. Taking money under false pretences.
Oh dear, Tory Neil sits there with a laptop and 2 inches of paper because he can't remember, but expects his guests to do what he cant. Are you bline.
"Blind"
No. Unlike his guest, he has worked hard doing his research, has planned the interview and what is going to be discussed. The guest could have done exactly the same if he wasn't so stupid or lazy. I am not blind, and I don't think you are thinking clearly.
To be fair, he sounds like any other politician under pressure. Full of lies, bullsh!t and bluster when confronted with the facts.
Benters the reason he’s flustered is he’s grappling with the enormity of Andrew Neil’s bias. The SNP has done more for the people of Scotland in a decade than half a century of direct Westminster rule ever did. If the union was so good to Scotland why were we allowed to live like a third world country for so long? How could a massively asset rich country like ours have so many funding problems? The common denominator is the toxic union and thieving Westminster. The colonial mentality is still alive and kicking in the lying Tory party and their attitude to Scotland only proves that. Brexit even more so. No democracy in Britain for Scotland.. time to go.
“When the time is right”... aka “When we can tell enough lies to the Scottish people”
SNP: Why are you refighting the referendum.
Also SNP: Let's have another referendum.
Any referendum on “ independence “ for Scotland should be a UK-wide vote. We’ll all be affected by the result🏴🏴🏴 and Ulster....
This guy always gets his arse spanked by Andrew Neil. His figures are always incorrect and Andrew Neil constantly exposes this fact.
"How dare you ask me about my lies in hindsight"
"I'm not sure why you're doing this"
Stewart Hosie embarrasses himself here by attempting to field questions from Andrew Neil without having any facts or figures at hand to defend himself or his party - a feat Angus Robertson would match two days later when he went before Andrew Neil without having done his homework and having no facts or figures to defend himself.
You can't have facts to made up lies which Neil does constantly.
Typical BBC bullshit. Westminster cuts our budget then asks us why we haven't got enough money to fund our public services. That just about sums Britain up.
@@karmabomb3768 i think the point was that scotland had just as much in percentage as the rest of the uk but HAD,NT spent it where it had been allowed for in the budget ie extra health provision---i dont why the snp were making such a fuss ,,,,their perfectly within there rights to spend it wherever they deemed most needed it
We want total fiscal control, not the convoluted Barnet formula. Finance is only one part of it. We want to run our own affairs and do it with people we choose..not some shyster Westminster cabal who we not only don't vote for but truly hate. Britain is undemocratic and gerrymandered and anti Scottish, why would we support that? To answer your point about finances we know we're being ripped off. That's not even up for debate any more. We are the only oil rich, poor country in the world. To add insult to injury we have to put up with Tory scum telling us they won't ALLOW this or that. A foreign government that we did not vote for is not legitimate in our eyes. We have a paliament in Holyrood, that's who we want to run our country not some parliament in another country telling us what we can and can't do. That's completely unacceptable to us.
@@karmabomb3768 wow rant alert---what happened at the last referendum then if you ALL wanted out? ,,oil rich has been and gone ,it will need to come from taxation simple as that ,,,,if you want it bad enough it will be worth it,,,ps the westminster cabal has 60 scottish mps or did,nt you notice ,,,maybe they should,nt take the stinking english £85k a year on principle or maybe give it to the SNP coffers,,,ummm no did,nt think so
Politicians are just so slippery, why can they not just answer a simple question?
Andrew Neil is a scumbag and so if everyone on his programmes. A lying bastard with a stupid wig. Who takes this clown seriously?
Don’t know why he goes on this show... gets hammered every time🤣
This is how you talk to a Scottish nationalist.
Up- date : between 2014 and 2018 the oil revenue was £30 billion LESS than the SNP predicted in the referendum prospectus.
wow thats lots of moolah
If this man was taking an exam he would fail,but I feel the Scotish people should watch these .
If the SNP high command are a pack of vampires, then Andrew Neil is Blade.
You're easily impressed. Have you not spotted the laptop and 2 inches of paper Neil needs to do his job, while expecting his guests to have memorised and guessed what questions Neil is going to ask. Neil got called out on it and guess what.......he has left 99% of the job.
Typical SNP,crap !!
@@casperwallace9685 i,m not even sure its personal,,,politicians are normally prepared to the eyeballs with their prescripted responses,,,we just love to see the smarmy gits sqirming for a change -----if your policy has no gaping holes in it most can limp through even the most ardent journos questions---oil revenue is,nt reliable enough to set such a large percentage to a potential budget ala venuezuela.
the problem is in a prospective own rule government,,,the numbers HAVE to add up,
,,
they have to be honest with voters expecting the same levels of service from less money with their currency controlled by another country,,,,,,this will come down to good economic governance above everything else ,,,dont be surprised to see your own version of austerity politics.
@@casperwallace9685 His guests are mostly asswipes who talk bullshit and speak lies.
According to Hosie if you disagree with my lies you are trying to fight me 😂😂😂😂😂😂
That's what you call getting your back sided kicked.😅- Andrew Neil is a legend.
Andrew Neil fantastic.... never grow tired of watching him interview these goons!
Agree😂😂😂
Don't mess with Mr Neil. Lol..he'll rip you to shreds. Especially SNP mps.
Lol got to love the woman who says lets have one every year, till they get the result they want. she was told to put into sooner box and put it in later 16:52
"Should be sooner" - puts ball in later box. Lol.
Whenever I want to watch a blood sport, l look for Andrew Neil interviewing SNP politicians 😂
SNP "it's someone else's fault"
You mean:
SNP "It's England's fault"
Every English Person:😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
Good grief. These people actually represent me
100% of $48 barrel oil is a LOT more than 8% or $100 barrel oil !
He's an absolute joke, and so is the rest of the SNP. This interview is proof that Scotland made the right decision by remaining in the UK and not turning their back on our family of nations.
Stewart Hosie is a disgrace. He's lied several times, blatantly, in that interview.
They never take responsibility for their failures - it’s always someone else’s fault (usually the UK government). Pathetic.
@13:33 .....the Andrew Neil ‘mic drop’ moment right there 😳🤣
Head in the sand as akways by the snp !
Andrew Neill believes he is always correct in his views, someday someone will batter him.
A crank
Hosie is utterley useless
So long as Andrew Neil stands on the bridge ,guarding the way.
Our union is safe.
Hosie needs to put a gum shield in ,
gets hamered every time 🤣
🇬🇧💪
That says it all she was so keen to have the vote sooner she put it in the later box. That shows the thinking of leaving.
They used to call it selling snake oil
Don’t buy a car from that man😱
15:52 That child's vote is invalid and should've been treated as such. She is barely old enough to walk, let alone vote.
17:08 That's right. Just keep having a referendum until you get the result you want. What does that remind me of? The Scottish people HAVE decided, and they have decided to remain in the UK and not betray their United Kingdom.
Man who made billions out of oil... says we should cut down... ian wood you absolute yohgurt
Lee Gilray aye and I’m still owed for being on a retainer for BP Schehallion £14000.....which Wood Group refused to pay....
Andrew Neil's face is hilarious
Somebody explain ‘targets’ to Hosie please!!!
I am not from the UK.
But certainly what I do hear from SNP figures, everything gone wrong or bad in Scottish politics the blame is thrown onto England.
I do think the SNP is campaigning on untruths, the Scottish people will wake up from a very bad dream if the EU would become the new master of an "independent" Scotland.
Wow what a bunch of muppets need to stop watching braveheart!
Thats not what they said though Andrew... was it. SNPs forecast was less than the Tories. But that's not important. Oil revenues go out with Scotland(currently)...but that's not important is it? The Tories own advisors just released a report that Scotland would do better not being in the uk... but thats important either. Scotlands success with 34% of the UKs natural resources and only 8.3% of population is a no brainer!
I'm not sure all his ducks are in a row. Wants independence, but moaning about getting less money from England.
And here we are in July 2020 and the price of crude oil is less than US$40 and has not been near $100 in God knows how long.
I like the way that lady said have a referendum sooner rather than later and then put her ball in the later section, typical SNP supporter maybe ?.
This is scary can you imagine these lot running Scotland independent from the UK ....it would go bust
England would go bust. but you’re cute
samantha-jane hood We would have been bankrupt right now if we had gone independent with their shambolic economic “plans” aka economy based on oil at over $110 a barrel for 15 years - complete fantasy economics.
samantha-jane hood nope little Scotland would go to dust.
If all nhs hospitals get rid of managers and the subsident staff they need. That would help the NHS.Let the hospital staff them like they used to with a Matron in charge.
Superb interview " we're doomed Private Fraser used to say
Never ask a question you don't already know the answer to.
dodging it every time. had the SNP raised enough money it would be a different story.
Love the Andrew Neil show
In 2008, the SNP created 23 new quangos.
Yeah, that's right have a referendum until you get the right answer. You've learned well from the EU!
No, have a referendum every time the people of Scotland say they want one, that's how democracy works
@@bam-skater Great, then why bother to elect officials to govern? In ancient Athens they used to have the vote on everything, including executions. When they decided to try Socrates for corrupting the youth, the jury consisted of 500 people. In the end they convicted him and he had to take hemlock as a poison. That's why we have representative democracy as opposed to the people taking every major decision. If you leave it all to the people they vote stupidly - take Brexit, it should never have happened. What did the average English person understand about the EU? Nothing. Years of anti-European propaganda. The average person didn't even understand the difference between the European Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights.
I won't answer the question that you asked me however I will address the question that you should have asked me.
A target is not better just because you increase it. You have to achieve it. Wake up, man.
Mad daft Haggis
Cheats on his wife that Hosie
Andrew Neil twisting the figures and the truth. A simple fact the SNP have been voted into power for 13 years because the people of Scotland trust them and they want Independence.
Whats he twisting ? THE SNP ARE LOSERS FACT.
' some ' of the people John, some of them. A minority
Come the 2024 election and see how accurate your statement is.
*Hold on a minute this was in 2015 :Today End 2019 The price of oil is set to top $300 a barrel, and Scotland will be awash with so much money - hang on just checked September 20, 2019 is $58.09 per barrel which is = to £44.83 !*
And it went even lower after you wrote that
2020 it's not now you,d be poor again
*The only good to come from this is the fact that in real terms Scotch in real terms is much cheaper today, however the USA has recently imposed a 25% Import Tariff on single Malt, so nipping down to Adsa tomorrow for a couple of bottles of Glenlivet.*
£100 pb or £48 pb. What is higher? 8% of £100 or 90% of £48? Go on Nigel's try to work that out. Because the majority of Scots certainly can.
This did not age well for stuart hosie
Did u know the then Brexit party would never be for chlorinated chicken etc, they looked more sensible than the Tories but attracted some of the public who voted labour in 2017
*Oil the root of so much trouble in the 20th Century !*
no it provides the foundation of human society
Jan 2021 - oil still $55 a barrel and has been hovering at $45 for the past 6 years.
Q: When should there be another referendum? Ans: “I wunt it now and who says we cannie have one the year after that” - That’s the sort of logic that prevails in the SNP. Browbeat the entire country towards independence.
Lying, cheating so-and-so.
Love Getting away with it... Tune....
Once its dun its dun for ever an who says we cannot just keep having referendums to get what WE WANT
well that will be the democratic people who vote No ya muppets
Is he having a laugh. Saying the NHS is not in crisis. Tell that to all the patients who are having operations cancelled or delayed. The patients lying on trolleys in corridors for hours on end. Get real.
Grins every time he is stumped
Support industry? No, industry must support itself. Keep government out of business.
Should see the price of oil today $39.6 Brent crude spot price
Stewart hosie another no hoper
10:10 GP *are* doctors.
Hosie cheated on his wife
This time next year macrodney
12:09 zombie walks past the camera
It's a shame that TH-cam is allowing rape to be shown here, absolutely disgrace.
Lies!
Just get us out of the UK even if we loose!
Lose.
You can get yourself out by leaving...
Scotland needs to get out of this union before it goes down the tubes.
5
This is a turning point for Britain it won't be called the United Kingdom anymore as Scotland will soon be Independent, N Ireland will soon join Ireland so Wales and England will have to be called rUK (rest of the UK) or little Britain.
With oil money or not money scotland will be independent .
Okay - so what’s the plan? No one in the Yes camp can get give a solid answer so perhaps you can?
@@ABC-dw7pe freedom
and then join the EU 😅😅😅
Freedom? How is wanting to join the EU “freedom”? you’re delusional pal, educate yourself.
Aschloch
Andrew Neil = 🔔🔚💯%
A crank