This video was taken in madura, Indonesia. (I know from the language and dialect) I spend my childhood there. In dry season I always help my gandpa in farm. Honestly I laughed so hard after watched this video. There were no child labor there. I was confused why people make conclution without think further.
Niki Sayang It's a sin for the parents to forced the kids to work in a Dangerous Area. Don't you know that Tobacco is bad for your health when you work around it for long time? Also, hiring kids is Illegal in countries like the US or EU. Which these companies based on. And they promised to never hired underage kids.
Fuck with cultural reason, good parents just won't let their very young kids working on hard stuff while their time is supposed to be for study,looking up their talents, & play. Don't make if u can't rise.
nonton video tabayyun-nya dari Narasi Indonesia dulu, kak. Ga ada pemaksaan kerja untuk anak-anak disana. Kalo kakak pernah besar dan tumbuh di kampung sih pasti tau bagaimana asik dan menyenangkannya bermain di sawah/ladang hehe
ngeliat komentar yang ngebela prakter pekerja anak-anak, gue sadar, banyak orang yang nyaman ditindas di video ini udah dikasih tau bahaya nikotin, pestisida dalam jangka pendek bisa kerasa efeknya dan perusahaan yang menghasilkan trilyunan di indonesia gak mau peduli gak mau keluar duit buat petani seeing many comment judging and blaming the makers of this video, i realize many people feeling comfort to be forced in labor in this video we already see the danger of nicotine and perticide to our body, even just touching the tobacco plant can make you throw up and dizzy and the tobacco company who make trillions rupiah doesn't care about the farmers and the company doesn't want to pay them
It's not child labor dammit, it's cultural. They enjoy helping their parents and their parents never push them around. They receive decent money after harvest and they could do what they want with their money. They understand clearly that by doing so they indirectly paid their own education. Once again I stated: it's not child labor, it's cultural
YOU, the one made this documenter are the real exploiters !! You manipulated the real behind those video using innocent children! What a shame! This isnt the right way to stop other’s business!
Look at all these beautiful people. Kids who should be enjoying their youth playing in the fields instead of harvesting them. I'm sad this is happening in the land of my forefathers.
For fvk sake there is no child labor here though. It’s just kids playing while learning how to farm or follow thei familly step become a farmer. There is video which explain about this from the farmers itself that clarify all of these nonsense and misinformation and again misnaration. Go watch or type Narasi Indonesia, Tabayyun (following with this video tittle).
@@lagidirumah3861 Stop saying that its propaganda , as an indonesian we need to stop being overproud and just accept what weve done wrong , I mean just go outside into the streets youll see many child either being used as a bait so people will give them money or youll see many child labors
@@indonesianguy4026 indeed mate, but for fuck sake, when i was a kid too i also help on the field but that's really just helping not a child labour, (except on the street that's a whole different story)
Wherever it is, child Labor is injustice to human right, and adults, parents or community leaders, are entrusted and called to protect the young. Ignorance or avoidance is not an excuse, one is either called to respond with support or action when it comes to protecting the young, after all everyone has been a child once upon a time, in strength or weakness, by now, hopefully, understand what childhood is supposed to be.
I grew up working in tobacco, same as my father, his father, and his grandfather. I worked in the fields from the age of 9. It was hot, so is football practice. We had a water jug on the tailgate and shade trees nearby. We took breaks when we were hot. Wet tobacco can make you sick, we started later after it dried off. I paid for school clothes, backpacks, and Trapper Keepers with tobacco money. Later, I paid tuition at the University of Kentucky with my tobacco money. Hard work pays off! This video is a distortion of the facts. I am also certain that there is a wide range of conditions on tobacco farms. Those who mistreat their workers don't last. Come see us for the rest of the story. You'll find that we are kind, compassionate people who work hard and do right by all whom we deal with.
@@monkeyhn7104 You know nothing shits about our culture and how we educate our children. What is child labor? Do not they, the farmers' children, have their time to play or go to school? Who exploits them... their farmers parents-who got money from tobacco, therefore can pay the school education fee for their children........ or those who make this video?
How about disney or entertainment in US. How it could destroy someone's childhood and health? This is so hypocrite! If we want to stay against child laboring we all must do the same 🙏
sok tau nih, cuma mau menyudutkan petani tembakau. biasa aja kali orang indonesia bantu orang tua di sawah. kalian pikir masa kecil ug indah cuma habis di depan gadget? sok tau bgt.
biasa aja? bahkan mereka enggak tahu tujuan mereka bersusah payah itu untuk apa, mereka nggak tau betapa bahayanya pada usia segitu. emangnya mereka sekolah?
Haris Suhud sok tau gimana, video ini mau menghimbau bahwa sebaiknya anak anak tidak dipekerjakan Dan juga dampaknya terhadap anak itu sendiri. Bukan mau menyudutkan petani.
I agree with them working and being financially responsable for themselves but they need to go to school as well they can do both yes but school is a priority first and if there going to work I don’t care if there 5 18 or 40 they need safety gloves or something they can’t be working and getting sick the owner of the field needs to be more responsible and give them gloves and safety clothing for that kind of work this is bull shit 18 or 80 I don’t care.
Sathiya sadly playing don’t get them food on the table. They should play and teenagers should be teenagers but life is not just play play play play you don’t make a living out of playing only. Though there’s no excuses for why this kids aren’t in school.
So what do you want to happen? Finding a problem is very very easy but if you find a problem you need to come up with a solution. If you don't then your just complaining about how another people live. So tell me how are they going to make a living if they stop? If they had another way of making the same amount of money or more then they're making now,you don't think they would give up farming tobacco for it? People can't judge what another person action if they're not in the same country you're in. Different laws, different life,different people,different lands.
Nothing wrong with child labor as long as they are getting paid accordingly, i mowed lawns 10 hrs a day when i was 6 ,it taught me work ethic and i made money i saved up and got my own apt when i was 14
You can't compare you mowing the lawn to these kids that are working harder than you did these kids are getting affected by getting cancer illnesses that can kill them in other countries kids are working in mines getting crushed by the dirt some kids are working at age 5 respiratory problems before they can get old they can die before they can even own a apartment or placed a decent to live some places they can't even own apartment or a nice place to live they still can live outside getting paid $0.25 a day tell me how can you afford a house with that kind of money they can only afford little porridge food like rice
@@lucindamendiola8642 this video was set up, here's the actual conditions from the farmer. th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html Farmers said tobacco farming make a lot of work and takes years to master them, the children just play, go to school, and sometimes help their parents that look like help washing apples from the apple farm after harvesting them.
Its hoax video. Jadi sebenarnya anak2 itu tdk bekerja seperti yg di vedeo. Mereka hanya disuruh si pembuat video. Ada klarifikasi nya di video nya tabayun. Gak tau apa maksud dan tujuan organisasi ini membuat video propaganda ini.
kasihkumala No, I don't want to see it! Even if not what it appears to be, then a child being exploited for video viewing, so either way, it should give anyone just pause!
Harusnya netizen +62 itu comentarnya disini. Pasukan serbu julid nya pada kemana ini. Your money make my country stupid... (You are lier) production film stupid
Look, this film has been arranged in such a way that cigarette producers and tobacco farmers look bad, if you look closely, no one has ever watered the crops in the fields like that. smokers may be dangerous, but there are more dangerous than smokers, namely the anti-smoking, anti-tobacco
This video was taken in madura, Indonesia. (I know from the language and dialect) I spend my childhood there. In dry season I always help my gandpa in farm. Honestly I laughed so hard after watched this video. There were no child labor there. I was confused why people make conclution without think further.
Aljazeera also made same video. I am not sure too. I think they just want to make the industry colapse.
mbak bisa japri cerita ke saya?
In Developed countries. Children at your age shouldn't be working, they should at least go to school full time and graduate from high school.
I know that. but is it a sin if we help our parents and get money
Niki Sayang It's a sin for the parents to forced the kids to work in a Dangerous Area. Don't you know that Tobacco is bad for your health when you work around it for long time?
Also, hiring kids is Illegal in countries like the US or EU. Which these companies based on. And they promised to never hired underage kids.
indonesian children are so cute. give them gloves to use at least
Yes... they are so cute... too cute to be exploited in this video by the film maker.
try watch this, Sir... m.th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html
Fuck with cultural reason, good parents just won't let their very young kids working on hard stuff while their time is supposed to be for study,looking up their talents, & play. Don't make if u can't rise.
nonton video tabayyun-nya dari Narasi Indonesia dulu, kak. Ga ada pemaksaan kerja untuk anak-anak disana. Kalo kakak pernah besar dan tumbuh di kampung sih pasti tau bagaimana asik dan menyenangkannya bermain di sawah/ladang hehe
I thought we've already discussed about this in Jakarta.. Wish you are not forget on all points during our discussion..
my great grandfather used to own a tobacco farm oh and I'm from indonesia
these video were posed, my question is why you make this propaganda? for what? they're farmer, just trying to make a sustain life.
@Seb
give also to Palestinian children, they need it more...
Thank you for bringing this issue to light.
yang bisa saya katakan adalah " inilah indonesia, inilah duni. dimana romantisme hanya ada dalam sajak-sajak penghapus lelah"
BAGUS FERRY apaan sih lu, udah tabayyun belum lo? Fake documentary
ngeliat komentar yang ngebela prakter pekerja anak-anak, gue sadar, banyak orang yang nyaman ditindas
di video ini udah dikasih tau bahaya nikotin, pestisida dalam jangka pendek bisa kerasa efeknya
dan perusahaan yang menghasilkan trilyunan di indonesia gak mau peduli gak mau keluar duit buat petani
seeing many comment judging and blaming the makers of this video, i realize many people feeling comfort to be forced in labor
in this video we already see the danger of nicotine and perticide to our body, even just touching the tobacco plant can make you throw up and dizzy
and the tobacco company who make trillions rupiah doesn't care about the farmers and the company doesn't want to pay them
untuk sebuah dokumenter palsu, komentar anda panjang juga
Nikotin & jelas bahaya, tapi misleading video ini adalah pekerjaan anak, yg sesungguhnya tidak pernah ada di Industri tembakau, video ini propaganda.
It's not child labor dammit, it's cultural. They enjoy helping their parents and their parents never push them around. They receive decent money after harvest and they could do what they want with their money. They understand clearly that by doing so they indirectly paid their own education.
Once again I stated: it's not child labor, it's cultural
YOU, the one made this documenter are the real exploiters !! You manipulated the real behind those video using innocent children! What a shame! This isnt the right way to stop other’s business!
watch Tabayyun this video hoax
th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html
Look at all these beautiful people. Kids who should be enjoying their youth playing in the fields instead of harvesting them. I'm sad this is happening in the land of my forefathers.
This is propaganda
For fvk sake there is no child labor here though. It’s just kids playing while learning how to farm or follow thei familly step become a farmer. There is video which explain about this from the farmers itself that clarify all of these nonsense and misinformation and again misnaration. Go watch or type Narasi Indonesia, Tabayyun (following with this video tittle).
@@lagidirumah3861 Stop saying that its propaganda , as an indonesian we need to stop being overproud and just accept what weve done wrong , I mean just go outside into the streets youll see many child either being used as a bait so people will give them money or youll see many child labors
@@indonesianguy4026 indeed mate, but for fuck sake, when i was a kid too i also help on the field but that's really just helping not a child labour, (except on the street that's a whole different story)
Wherever it is, child Labor is injustice to human right, and adults, parents or community leaders, are entrusted and called to protect the young. Ignorance or avoidance is not an excuse, one is either called to respond with support or action when it comes to protecting the young, after all everyone has been a child once upon a time, in strength or weakness, by now, hopefully, understand what childhood is supposed to be.
m.th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html
I grew up working in tobacco, same as my father, his father, and his grandfather. I worked in the fields from the age of 9. It was hot, so is football practice. We had a water jug on the tailgate and shade trees nearby. We took breaks when we were hot. Wet tobacco can make you sick, we started later after it dried off. I paid for school clothes, backpacks, and Trapper Keepers with tobacco money. Later, I paid tuition at the University of Kentucky with my tobacco money. Hard work pays off! This video is a distortion of the facts. I am also certain that there is a wide range of conditions on tobacco farms. Those who mistreat their workers don't last. Come see us for the rest of the story. You'll find that we are kind, compassionate people who work hard and do right by all whom we deal with.
You grew fuck up as the rest of mentally slaves. That's no excuse to defend child exploitation.
@@monkeyhn7104 You know nothing shits about our culture and how we educate our children. What is child labor? Do not they, the farmers' children, have their time to play or go to school? Who exploits them... their farmers parents-who got money from tobacco, therefore can pay the school education fee for their children........ or those who make this video?
@@monkeyhn7104 they set them up.. the children are free to do whatever they want.
Fake documentary, look narasi Indonesia channel too see the right side
fail of their parents
I am Indonesian. the parents never ever forced their children to work...
How about disney or entertainment in US. How it could destroy someone's childhood and health? This is so hypocrite! If we want to stay against child laboring we all must do the same 🙏
Aren't you ashamed of yourself? Spreading lies. You're nothing more than a bully. This is not journalism.
sok tau nih, cuma mau menyudutkan petani tembakau. biasa aja kali orang indonesia bantu orang tua di sawah. kalian pikir masa kecil ug indah cuma habis di depan gadget? sok tau bgt.
biasa aja? bahkan mereka enggak tahu tujuan mereka bersusah payah itu untuk apa, mereka nggak tau betapa bahayanya pada usia segitu. emangnya mereka sekolah?
Haris Suhud sok tau gimana, video ini mau menghimbau bahwa sebaiknya anak anak tidak dipekerjakan Dan juga dampaknya terhadap anak itu sendiri. Bukan mau menyudutkan petani.
itu setingan !!! , silahkan cek link ini th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html agar tau kenyataannya seperti apa
I agree with them working and being financially responsable for themselves but they need to go to school as well they can do both yes but school is a priority first and if there going to work I don’t care if there 5 18 or 40 they need safety gloves or something they can’t be working and getting sick the owner of the field needs to be more responsible and give them gloves and safety clothing for that kind of work this is bull shit 18 or 80 I don’t care.
Stop child labor
Children deserve study and play
Sathiya sadly playing don’t get them food on the table. They should play and teenagers should be teenagers but life is not just play play play play you don’t make a living out of playing only. Though there’s no excuses for why this kids aren’t in school.
So what do you want to happen? Finding a problem is very very easy but if you find a problem you need to come up with a solution. If you don't then your just complaining about how another people live. So tell me how are they going to make a living if they stop? If they had another way of making the same amount of money or more then they're making now,you don't think they would give up farming tobacco for it? People can't judge what another person action if they're not in the same country you're in. Different laws, different life,different people,different lands.
Why aren't they wearing gloves?
Its all about making money
The big 1% SHAME SHAME ON YOU!!!
Government please help children
Fake documentary.....
Nothing wrong with child labor as long as they are getting paid accordingly, i mowed lawns 10 hrs a day when i was 6 ,it taught me work ethic and i made money i saved up and got my own apt when i was 14
You can't compare you mowing the lawn to these kids that are working harder than you did these kids are getting affected by getting cancer illnesses that can kill them in other countries kids are working in mines getting crushed by the dirt some kids are working at age 5 respiratory problems before they can get old they can die before they can even own a apartment or placed a decent to live some places they can't even own apartment or a nice place to live they still can live outside getting paid $0.25 a day tell me how can you afford a house with that kind of money they can only afford little porridge food like rice
@@lucindamendiola8642 this video was set up, here's the actual conditions from the farmer. th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html Farmers said tobacco farming make a lot of work and takes years to master them, the children just play, go to school, and sometimes help their parents that look like help washing apples from the apple farm after harvesting them.
This is not child labour
They look happy
Cause they don't know that happen in they future
@@rifqialdia6717 what future when you are dying hungry.
video propaganda dan settingan. untuk klarifikasi dan kebenarannya bisa cek disini th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html terima kasih
The indogs coping hard in the comments tho💀
Serak semua
ga ada komenan orang indo
Its hoax video. Jadi sebenarnya anak2 itu tdk bekerja seperti yg di vedeo. Mereka hanya disuruh si pembuat video. Ada klarifikasi nya di video nya tabayun. Gak tau apa maksud dan tujuan organisasi ini membuat video propaganda ini.
2:54 This is child?? 😂
he started when he was 12
I love poor Childern
not cool man
What nigga?💀
Plot twist : It's an hoax
بوزعيتر زيبام الأدوية التي آخذها من نقودي ليست لك
Sad!
I agree. this is sad.
not really. just come here to see it.
kasihkumala No, I don't want to see it! Even if not what it appears to be, then a child being exploited for video viewing, so either way, it should give anyone just pause!
+kasihkumala kak boleh dong diajak ke Madura :)
Sonia Nixon bj
Kalau gak kerja gak dapat uang makan gak bisa dari orang lain
And who are the merchants??? MUSLIMS....God dam them all!!!
Harusnya netizen +62 itu comentarnya disini. Pasukan serbu julid nya pada kemana ini.
Your money make my country stupid... (You are lier) production film stupid
Shameful
Find a better cast for hooman rights watch
A small price to pay so we can enjoy cheap but good quality tobacco in the west.
mugatu like this
Manipulated !!!
fake !!!!
Hoax
manipulating
Look, this film has been arranged in such a way that cigarette producers and tobacco farmers look bad, if you look closely, no one has ever watered the crops in the fields like that.
smokers may be dangerous, but there are more dangerous than smokers, namely the anti-smoking, anti-tobacco
This is fake
noobs
fake
Watch the answer video from farmers and this children's family. th-cam.com/video/4bnD6QPp1JU/w-d-xo.html
I think it’s great that they find things for the kids to do let’s them feel needed a part of something