Following the outbreak of the war in Gaza, TH-cam updated its community guidelines, and as a result, the previous version of this video was age-restricted. We decided to edit and upload a less graphic version in the hopes that an unrestricted video will be viewed and shared by the widest possible audience. Please continue to share your comments and thanks for your support!
So much of what's in this video is accurate and depicts a tragic truth about life in Gaza. However, framing tge testimonies into the narrative that Hamas, not Israel, is the root cause of Palestinian suffering is ridiculous. Yes, we did protest Hamas for years after their violent takeover of Gaza. But it was always Israel that blockaded Gaza and created the need for smuggling tunnels in the first place! Yes, children worked in the tunnels, but no forced labor was in effect. I've had friends and neighbors boast to me about how much money they used to make building tunnels throughout their teen years for the benefit of not only militant groups, but also for rich oligarchs who wanted in on the smuggling business that was profitable due to the currency difference between Egypt and Gaza and significantly cheaper goods imported and sold for less than a reasonable price in Gaza for a brief time. Since elsisi regime took over in Egypt, all of that ceased to exist and if any weapons were delivered to Hamas after the 2014 assault against Gaza it would've been with the full approval of the Israeli government and the Israel-friendly Egyptian regime. Which makes even more sense when you couple that with millions of dollars in cash delivered to Hamas in suitcases through the Beit Hanoun checkpoint (eretz). Despite all the humiliation, restrictions, and blockade Gazans had to endure outside Hamas jurisdiction in Egypt and in the occupied territories, Hamas was still able to advance and build up an enormous military arsenal of rockets, antitank and anti personnel explosives as we're seeing in Gaza. How can anyone justify or advocate for the stifling and suffocation of Palestinians in Gaza by Israel and Egypt then blame it all on a rogue military group of victims to Israel's genocidal trek that started waaaay before Hamas was ever conceived!
The history of Gaza began long before that. In about 1590, the city of Gaza was founded by Rabbi Israel Najara. Gaza was a Jewish city from then until 1929. What happened in 1929? The Arab Revolt. Hundreds of Jews were murdered and the city of Gaza was occupied. The Jews were expelled from it. Women and girls were kidnapped and Islamized and until 1967 Jews did not return to the area.
I worked on a kibbutz north of israel in agriculture some of the workers were israeli arab (muslims) whenever there was a jewish wedding the arabs would come with their families their wives wearing hijabs and children, and we went to their kfar on events, i couldnl not see the apartheid anywhere yet much of the west who havent stepped foot in israel claim they know better, wish one day arabs will build up a huge trust with israelis and never again will we see war Amen.
@@ErikaMatthieu-my4of He has had 2,000 years, and it hasn't worked yet. In fact, a surprisingly large number of people who claim to follow Jesus murdered others "in his name."
As an Iranian who had been living under the Islamic Republic regime in Tehran. I can understand the innocent people who just need a normal life😢 These autocratic regimes are literally barbarism
innocent who? They had rose their children to destoy israel for generation! Thosand flood in the Gaza stretts praising 7th october massacre! They could build a garden in Gaza, they built an help of killers and tunnels. Innocent are only kids , for some Years, than rhey will become terrorist as their father egraand fathers and mothers and gran mothers. No innocent there
If only Ali Khamenei would learn from Cyrus the Great. True freedom is the right of everyone to choose who to worship and to be free from all forms of enslavement. Barbarism is a curse upon the simple.
Israeli here, standing behind every word. I hope that one day we can live in peace, none of us deserve this war. I see your pain. We are still traumatised as a nation. As you are too. We want peace. We cherish life. We believe we can have a better future, with you- peace seekers- among us. We have nothing against Palestinians. Only against those who want to harm us. I'm Jewish, but not religious. Yet I pray with all my heart to find our way for peace. ❤
Very touching words ❤️ I am a Christian in Germany. I have been to Israel two weeks ago, because I wanted to be with my jewish sisters and brothers in these dark and sad times. I will always pray with all my heart for Israel and for all the people loving this wonderful land 🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️
@doraross5810 Israel vored in a far right government. So all Israeli Jews will be responsible for what happened and is happening. 67% of all Israeli Jews voted in this government. So what is Israel now? A horrible nation.
Please, answer these questions about Gaza Arabs: 1/ Jordan once gave citizenship to all Palestinians. Why they later kicked them out of the country? 2/ Why Egypt built a strong double wall on Gaza border and insist not to take 1 child or woman or wounded Gazan to Egypt? 3/ Why Lebanon, once beautiful half Christians country, was TOTALLY DESTROYED when Jordan kicked out Palestinians and they moved to Lebanon? 4/ Why Kuwait kicked out 400 000 Palestinians in only one week? 5/ Why none of many Arabic Muslim countries would not accept Gazans?
1. All the Palestinians that Jordan accepted after the 6 day war try to overthrow the Jordanian monarch. They even assassinated the prime minster. 2. Egypt has had peace with Israel for a very long time. They refuse to jeopardize it to help Palestinian refugees. 3. The Palestinian refugees that enter Lebanon sided with the radical Islam groups to over throw the government. 4. All the Palestinian refugees supported the invasion of Kuwait by Iraq. 5. History has shown time and time again that any country who has accepted Palestinian refugees has lead to chaos within their country.
1) because the palestinians tried to overthrow the jordanian goverment with a violent uprise. 2) Same in egypt. 3 and 4) they saw what happended to countries who trust palestinians.....
1. Their violence both directed at and launched from Jordan. 2. Arab rejection of Palestinians whom they regard as inferior and whose brains they filled with fantasies of reversing 48, coupled with mutual violence. 3. Palestinian narcissism and meddling in Lebanon. 4. The Palestinians backed Saddam , hoping that his conquest would lead to a joint uprising against israel. 5. Arabs don’t like Palestinians, they just exploit them. The Abraham accords put a fine point on this betrayal - Palestinians know that nobody in the neighborhood cares about them. This leads to the nihilism you see today.
@@Thenoobestgirlthankfully we no longer live there , yet the horrors we endured live in our memories. I’d like to remember all the wonderful people we lived alongside and there is many. Unfortunately radical Islam is what destroyed the people and Gaza
As an Israeli, although the last year was rough (to say the least) I hope one day we live side by side in peace, no terror proxies, no terrorist attacks, just two countries side by side. That is my true dream.
Not going to happen, Islamism is a group of ideologies that say that the Muslim world should be run by sharia (Islamic laws). Generally, it is the idea that Islam should guide both society and politics, as well as people's personal lives.
@@savxiredThose videos are from a documentary series called Whispered in Gaza. The speakers’ identities and proper translations were confirmed. News outlets like Al Arabia and Al Monitor authenticated the series. There are 25 vignettes to watch. Pull up a chair and get started.
I don't understand why it is Israel's and sometimes Egypt's responsibility to give Gaza food, water, fuel and electricity. They have their own government and practically state since 2005... Why can't they do anything themselves?
They spent all the aid money on tunnels and weapons. So sad. As you said they have had a country since 2005 and they chose to fight one more time. By the way, Palestine is receiving the biggest amount of international aid. There is no other example of a 75-year refugee statute in the world. The world's most privileged refugees they are... They are indoctrinated and this is the reason why they still choose to fight against "Jews". The key word is Jew. It is not about free Palestine.
Arab Israelis are sitting in Goverment and have the right to vote. They also have the option of joining the Israeli army, which is not compulsory for them. So life in general for Israeli Arabs (muslims) is good.
Your right that 'technically' they're equal, but there's still lots of racism that even reaches the political scene. Still, much better than what goes on in gaza.
@@uataweye6264 It's easier for an Arab to go to medical school here than Jews. I personally have friends whose children had to go to Italy to study medicine, while the admission requirements for Arabs and Druze are lower. Many Arabs, both men and women, are pharmacists. In Ariel University, (I know because I'm on the staff) Arabs can get dispensations because Eng is their third language, even if they have good grades, etc.
@@naattxxnaattxx7055No more racism exists in Israel than in the US, Australia and Eastern Europe. Why is it that Israel must be beyond reproach just because they’re Jews.
many more facts and information is available people don't want to see it , they are either to biased to Israel or Hate H a m as to much to understand the other side
My grandma still talks about how much she loved going to the Gazan market, both as a little kid, and as a young adult, and says that often you couldnt find better goods (spices, fish and etc.) for cheaper, with a better experience.
Thank you ❤I am a German Jew , came to Israel 30 years ago and just wanted peace for everyone. After Oktober 7. I am afraid that too many extremists are in powerful positions on both sides 😢
@@pavila195417I personally know people from Gaza who are suffering and afraid because of Hamas. So no bs here. And in Israel are extreme people too who make others suffer.
You right , but don't forget , most palestinians are for Hamas sick us it is , like the ones that was part of the 7th palestinians from young to old ,raided the kubuts the men raping jewish women it was not just Hamas
Ya'll should be the last one talking about countries not letting people in. How many countries were the chosen people expelled from and continue to be expelled from? Even from Guatemala.
@@blueizumi Jews were expelled and hunted down by basically every nation and empire ever since the religion was formed. Pretty much every European country has hunted and expelled us, and now the Middle East won't even let us create a nation after the Ottomans sold land to Jewish people after the Ottomans lost WW1.
Any person with a functioning brain understands knows that the people who were invented in the last hundred years were created for a clear purpose. Islamic unity.Look at the discussions about the design of their flag; it proves it.
walt, thats cause islamist nations working hard to enable more their kind to succeed and jewish to fail,they keep fighting israel when they home is arabia
If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
Hey man, just wanted to say thank you for posting this, it's refreshing to see someone being humane and compassionate to others first and foremost. I've been referring to the Whispered in Gaza series as well as talking about the protests in Gaza since the war started, but those who choose to be blind will remain so. Much love from an Israeli Arab.
I am not surprised that many Gazan's want to be done with Hamas. Their rule has been oppressive and devastating... and perhaps SOME of the Gazans elected this new government on right pretenses but as we see, were really duped by their lies. BUT, one thing that SIMPLY CAN'T BE IGNORED -- because it would be ignoring reality, and therefore could end up being very dangerous -- is that there were literally thousands of Gazans celebrating in the streets after October 7th. Thousands. Please address this in another video. What about those celebrating Gazans?
I am Arab and I approve of this message. I have lived in Cairo, Khartoum, Tangier, Amman, Baghdad and Beirut. I have also spent time in Israel and the Palestinian Territories. I know from first hand observations that Palestinian leadership has rejected peace time after time to keep the money rolling in to support their lavish lifestyle OUTSIDE OF PALESTINE. Anyone who sides with Hamas is a fool. You can blindly believe their propaganda or do what I did and go to Palestine and see for yourself how they (Palestinian leadership) exploit the Palestinian people for their own vanity. Life is better for Israeli Arabs of any religion or sexual orientation than in anywhere else in the Middle East. You might know that if you at least read and even better, go to the Middle East to see for yourself.
wish more people like you existed! and really put the words out because the ones that do and when I share those videos always get me a message Israeli propaganda and so on. People can be so blind in life. Shalom Aleichem Salaam Alaikum my brother.
@@robertgorlee2552If you look into it, its supposed to be an acronym, but its even scarier if you translate it to english. It means violence. Even if you don't beleive in the supernatural, its prophesised that violence will be destroyed completly by God himself. Not just the terror organization that coincidentaly named themselves basically violence. Just look into the history. Who invaded first? Thats right. The Islamic Forces. Islam beleives to kill all non beleivers. Look in the Quran. It says that.
@@robertgorlee2552 Freedom fighters that kills and abuse their own people, while using them as human shields. Hope you had when the Hamas leader said that 75% some those living in Gaza are refugees, and they don't care about them. Your problem is the virus called Islam, you don't even care about the Gaza people, if you do you should have moved there.
This report needs to go to Every university in the United States and all over Europe because it tells the truth of the plight of the Gazans and how they have been shorted, tortured, killed, and restricted by Hamas. Israel did nothing but help them until they attacked Israel. Israel would never attack them unprovoked.
@@micahjohnsonboxing6409in 1947 four Arab countries tried to erase Jews from Israel, and somehow they lost the war…. The Arabs who wanted to stay and live in Israel still live there and still own their homes from 100 years ago… so p,ease stop the bs
I am israelí, I wish Gazan`s to have a good life and I wish more people in the world see this video and begin to understand what is really happening in Gaza. May peace come as soon as possible and forever! Thank you for this video
The Arabs have rejected a state at least 6 times. Consider the following: One: At the recommendation of the Peel Commission, the British, who controlled Palestine at the time, agreed to create a two-state solution, offering the Palestinian Arabs 80 per cent of the disputed territory. The Palestinian Jews said yes, the Arabs said no. Two: On Nov. 7, 1947, the United Nations voted to create two states. The Palestinian Jews (who changed their name to Israelis) said yes, the Palestinian Arabs said no. Three: After the Six Day War In 1967, Israel wanted to return the captured lands to Egypt and Jordan or to the Palestinian Arabs. The Arab league met in Sudan and said: “No peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel.” In other words, the Arabs said no. Four: In 2000, then-Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak offered all of Gaza and 94 per cent of the West Bank with East Jerusalem as its capital to Yasser Arafat. Arafat said no. Five: In 2008, the prime minister of Israel, Ehud Olmert, added additional land to the previous offer of 2000. Mahmoud Abbas said no. History shows that each time Israel has agreed to offering land for peace, the Palestinian Arabs have rejected the offers. Six: The one time, in 2005, when Israel unilaterally left Gaza to the Palestinian Arabs. The terrorists took control and turned it into a base from which thousands of rockets have been fired into Israel up to, and including, the present day. Trading land for peace didn’t work. The Arabs want the eradication of Jews more than they want a state If the Palestinians truly care about their children and, here are some tips for them: 1. Do not elect a terrorist organization to rule over you. 2. Do not educate your children from the age of zero to hate Jews and to aspire to murder them as the sole purpose of their lives. Invest in your children's education instead, maybe in a few decades their lives could improve as a result. 3. Cherish life instead of death and martyrdom. 4. Hold your leaders accountable and protest when they operate against your wellbeing, use you or manipulate you. Revolt against them if they treat you badly. 5. Admit the historical fact that the Arabs lost the war they started in 1948. Deal with it. Own your loss, there is no shame in it. Hold yourself accountable and leverage it as a growth opportunity instead of calling it “Nakhba” and blaming others for the consequences of your leaders' actions. 6. Recognize Israel’s right to exist and accept the fact that Israel is a sovereign state and legitimate under international law. Understand that the Jews are here to stay and will never again leave this region, no matter how hard you try. 7. Focus on rebuilding yourself as a nation instead of spending your time and energy trying to annihilate your neighbors. Focus on the land that you do have and on how to self develop and thrive. 8. Stop trying to constantly frame Israel and blame it for false crimes using Qatar funded media outlets and other means of propaganda. 9. Stop institutionalizing and legislating salary payments of hundreds of millions of dollars annually to imprisoned terrorists and the families of terrorists who died while carrying out terror attacks against Israel. 10. Stop accepting military aid, training, weapons and financial aid from Iran, the world's worst state sponsor of terrorism. They do not truly care about you and only use you as pawns. 11. Release the hostages kidnapped by Hamas on October 7, including a one-year old infant and his mother who have been held hostages to this very day. 12. Lay down your arms and stop choosing violence as the only solution for your problems. Look where it got you to in the last 75 years. 13. Understand that actions speak a whole lot louder than meaningless and empty words. The entire world is watching you. 14. Take a hard look at yourself and your actions before blaming Israel for yet another injustice. 15. Now take a hard look at Israel and see how, just by following these tips, it became the most thriving and successful democracy in the region. 16. Embrace peace.
@@MuhammadIdris-jb6jvofficially, it was more than 50% which translate that the UN gave the arabs more land than the Jews. Now, losing wars resulted to losing land.
Congratulations on the best, most honest video I've seen in 9 months. I hope everyone and every country sees this and all the nonsense disappears. Thank you💗☮️💗☮️💗☮️
🤣If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
We must not say or even think such things if we want peace. Research how many moderate vs how many extremist muslims there are worldwide, the majority is non-violent, only in war-torn, conflict-ridden, poverty-stricken areas do radical extremists thrive. We cannot be either racists or islamophobes, we cannot spread such rhetoric. They use vile anti-Jewish 1930s slander Tropes, antisemitic conspiracy theories which WW2 Germany used to fuel the Holocaust, we must rise taller, be morally upright and not mirror the vile slander.
THAT was Beautiful! ❤ I will save your video to share. I am praying for the Gazan people and I know that God wants them to have life and have it abundantly ❤
Given that this is a plainly pro-Israel channel, I was impressed with how fair and frank this video was. As well as comprehensive and well researched. Good job!
@@Lukxvsp That doesn't matter for the current ongoing conflict getting obsessed over past aggressions isn't fixing helping Palestinians, who have also, committed acts of genocide against the Jews. You sound like a Hamas and oct 7 apologist bro
@@starcapture3040 Your also leaving out a bunch of context, but also what about the Jews and Christians that were ethnically cleansed from every arab country?? There is factually no diversity among the Muslim majority countries.
I hope everyone knows that when Israel uprooted the lives of all Gazan Jews in 2005’s disengagement, they left the infrastructure to support the population- Hamas destroyed it all as it was “Jewish and dirty”
wow this brought tears in my eyes fr. we need more of this content and mentality instead of the warmongering biased crap that permeates on both sides.. תודה לך על זה אחי < 3
As an Israeli I want to believe them but I can't, they are talking like Hamas is something that came from the sky. Hamas is within them, every year they get new recruits, from where?
Agreed, we've watched this happen time and time again. I saw the news in the 2nd intifada and the targeting of civilians, this time I'm not staying silent. It's the same playbook as before. Somehow we're supposed to forget they do the same thing over and over and over. We can't be lulled into complacency again. Israel is always expected to be the good guy and leave their sworn enemy to attack another day. It's sickening.
UN is as much to blame as Hamas. With All the money given to Gaza there’s absolutely nothing to show. Gaza should have had several water plants, electrical plants,and water treatment plants to show that money was being used for the people. Investigation should be done to see which UN leaders received kick backs. Gazans are to blame as they kept quite. 16:15
I love these videos. As someone from the US who really doesn't understand any of this.. or why?? But these videos give me a better understanding of what's going on over there and why? Thanks for the education. 😊👍
@@UNPACKED well it seems hella biased to me, which is why i went to the comments. but really all these are here are a shitshow. not an ounce of help. i'll go back to watching the Grayzone and Norman Finklestein. hey, i gave it a shot.
Brilliant and informative feature. Such a shame mainstream Western Media appears to be incapable of reporting these dimensions of this tragic narrative.
Mainstream media promotes antisemitic tropes, for some reason their reporting would make a person even less informed about events if all they did was listen to the news. Frustrating to say the least.
What a wonderful, powerful video. So informative and broad in its testimonies that it really gave me a wider perspective on the situation and people’s experiences.
Just want to say that your video is the most unbiased, factually correct depiction of the Israel/Hamas war going on at the moment. It is refreshing not to have to sift through slanted narratives to understand the situation. Your dedication to presenting the facts without taking sides is highly appreciated. Thank you for your commitment to truthful reporting. RG from South Africa
the problem i have with this is that i have seen personally the vedios of Gazan people celebrate in the streets all across gaza. thousands of social media post from gaza about the joy the felt on october 7th. so to see them crying about how bad hamas is now is hipocritical becouse we all know now very clearly what their view on freedom is, what their view on peace is, and what their view on israel is.
The greco-roman Palestine has never been a state in all of history and was just a colonialist province!!!Tis so-called palestinians have just never existed!!!By the way the letter "P" does not exist in arabic alphabet!!!They are in majority jordanians and more than 50% of the gazouites are egyptians!!!
Dude most of palestine are actually jews who intermarriage with arabs this have been confirmed by dna they are arab jews u are basically at war with your people
Very true Thomas. L'chaim. My Hebrew name Jacova is the female form of Jacob. I was born March 11th in Bethlehem 51 years ago. In Aramaic Khubba means love. Khubba to you and yours.
Twice now I written you a response that was erased by youtube. L'chaim. In Aramaic Khubba means love. Khubba to you and yours. I was born March 11th in Bethlehem 51 years ago.
If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
250,000 work permits were issued from January 2023 till October 6th 2023. How many Gazan's spied while working in Israel? Also how many civilians attacked Israel on October 7th?
And a catastrophic economic situation by now for the West bank since all job with Israel stoped. According to The times of Israel, 150 000 palestiniens from West bank enter every day to work in Israel and some 18 000 were crossing Gaza border every day (it was part of a sort of "pacification" policy toward Gaza, better busyness meaning more peace from the population). Of course hamas could not care less about that, the population is just there to be human shield and victimisation propaganda against Israel. At the present 10 000 of palestinien are authorized again.
I remember the 2019 protest, social media and international news made it look like it was Israel 🇮🇱 not HAMAS!! Now, I know the truth.... AM YISRAEL CHAI 🇮🇱 My people live
If Gazans are fed up with Hamas, why did the survey show that 70 or 80 % support Hamas? I may be mistaken, but I think the survey covered BOTH the West Bank and Gaza.
You have 2 things here. First Hamas has little to none existent state in the West bank since it's a PLO rule (And btw the Palestinians there live way better - Note that there are terror cells starting to pop up which may will cause their lives to be a lot harder for no reason...) additionally you have the fact that people can not say anything bad on Hamas even if they thinks it's anonymous survey they know they may be killed.
trusting polls that come out of gaza is like trusting polls north koreans give. they're not free to say what they truly believe so the polls just aren't very trustworthy. unfortunately they're all we have aside from what we've all seen.
I start to think they supported them at start due to false promises as often in Dictatorships and when they realised that it's gotten worse they can't really officially speak out against it anymore due to being prosecuted for it. I can imagine that lots still fall for the blame game towards Israel though and children are heavily indoctrinated for the jihad but I am sure many want out of Hamas Regime. I wished western societies would support the ones who try to get out rather than the fairy tale narrative of the terrorists.
Thanks! I hope with all my heart that I will see a much better future for Israel and Gaza during my lifetime. We are all exhausted . The blood shed has to stop! We want peace and quite!
Thanks for reaveling the truth and for making us to fully understand what's really happening in Gaza.Please kindly share this video to the ICJ,ICC,UN and the US Universities.This is really a great video.
They wont, they're completely lost in their anti-Israel narrative. Algorithm showed me a video once, I didn't know them. It was right after Oct 7th, like days later only. This was one of the most disgusting things I've watched in all these months. I think it was Amy Adams who 'contextualized' things there.
@@Parpl22 Inform Amy Goodman, I danced ballet across the Iron Curtain thru Romania. Whilst she was. Wishing she danced ballet with The Philadelphia Orchestra, Eugene Ormondy, Conductor.
I believed that there are many Palestinians in Gaza that hate Hamas but then there was also some polls that showed most of them support Hamas and support the 7th of October attack. Do they support Hamas just because their life would be threatened if they don't?
This is the same situation for Germany under Nazi. They claimed they did not support Nazi, they were not with the Nazi. But no one said a thing when they are swimming in the wealth and benefits that Nazi gave them.
A lot of it has to do with Hamas’s education system turning innocent children into warriors before they’re even 10. I imagine if there wasn’t such indoctrination taking place they would think differently.
I roughly knew about Gaza's story since 2005. Initially, Hamas was democratically elected. But so was Hitler, and the rest is history! Mossab, and many others have no idea ( or not officially) how Gaza will be administered "after". Am Yisrael Chai, Druze, Jews and Bedouins are together defending the only country they have!
So here's the BIG QUESTION.....Are there enough Palestininans prepared to live side by side in peace with Israel? If yes, are they prepared to get behind a leader who supports that same vision and push back against the rejectionists who want a one state solution?
I feel bad for them , for the children especially, however it is terrifying tot hink about the future of these children that they might get revenge without learning the history of their war.. they have to know between good muslim and extremists muslim. GOD GIVE THEM PEACE
stfu! have you seen the released hostages who look like they have been staying in a hotel vs the ones released from israeli prisons who can barely walk and have lost 80 lbs and been tortured? gimmie a f'n break
I grew up hearing stories of playing SheshBesh and smoking shisha with locals on the beaches of Gaza, and Sinai... every israeli I grew up with has a rich and diverse background that somehow makes them even more intriguing... even the "boring" white kids all had a old polish song or Russian tradition that makes them special. I hope one day people can see Israel for its true beauty - the ability to accept all beliefs and cultures and blend history with innovation and aspiration. We will free Gaza from Hamas then it's up to us to make that beach town great again ;) Together.
לפי התגובות אני יכולה להבין שהרבה אנשים בעולם נוקטים עמדה כבר שנים , מבלי לדעת מה קורה פה , ומבלי לבוא לישראל ולהבין את השורש של הסכסוך. אני מציעה לא לנקוט עמדה מבלי לדעת את כל הפרטים. וגם בסירטון הזה חסרים המון פרטים. בתור ישראלית אני יכולה לספר לכם שאין ישראלי אחד שגדל פה מבלי לחוות מלחמות , טילים , פיגועים. לכל אחד בישראל יש חברים או משפחה שנהרגו או נרצחו . אני שירתתי בצבא הייתי בעזה . חברים אם אתם לא יודעים- עדיף לא לנקוט עמדה . מי שנוקט עמדה שילמד טוב טוב את ההיסטוריה. בעזה כמו בכל המקומות מסביב לישראל מלמדים ילדים מגיל אפס לרצוח ולשנוא יהודים. זה מה שהם לומדים בבתי הספר שלהם! אז איך אפשר לצפות לשלום?
Number of questions-1. Why did Gazan citizens participate in the massacre on 7.10? They murdered, raped and stole... 2. Why were tunnel shafts, antisemitic books found in houses in Gaza? 3. Why until now have Gazan citizens not cooperated with the Israeli army and not found out where the abductees are? 4. Why did families from Gaza keep hostages in their home? The innocent citizens of Gaza are not believed!! All of Hamas!!!
Not all citizens participated. Books can easily be planted so that is not a solid reason. When you are ordered and controlled by an authority that can easily eliminate you or your family what choice do you have not to hold hostages handed to you to secure while they do other things
Unfortunately, these people are not the majority in Gaza. Hamas has a very high approval rating there. In fact, most Gazan civilians approve of October 7th.
How do we know if they can't speak out and Hamas opressed them and only leaks the propaganda they want to further their cause. No child "wants" to be in this awful situation, they are indoctrinated and forced into it.
Again if you are asked by a pollster if you support Hamas, most sensible people will say yes. If Hamas was so wonderful they would allow elections but of course they won't. Election 2006, nothing since then.
Porq no midieron las consecuencias antes de la masacre y despues sus festejos....ahora lloran busquen a sus lideres escondidos como ratas y platiquenlo..... Bring the hostages back now!!!
What I don’t get is, the tunnels cost up to 1.5 billion money. How can a country with its own administration, have so much money without contributing to the world anything the world would like?
Gaza should look like and act Dubai. Our tax dollars fund UNRw4, PLO, Martyrs Fund 🤮 and more. Watched a video of two Ham4s t’s sipping tea under a tree each holding stacks of US Currency 💵 in their hands. The following countries temporarily suspended and then resumed funding to UNRW4, in addition to providing annual contributions: - USA: $343.9 Million - Canada: $23.7 Million - Germany: $202.1 Million - European Union: $114.1 Million - Sweden: $61 Million - Japan: $30.2 Million - France: $28.9 Million - Switzerland: $25.5 Million - The Netherlands: $21.2 Million - Australia: $13.8 Million - Italy: $18 Million - Austria: $8.1 Million - Finland: $7.8 Million - New Zealand: $560.8 K - Iceland: $558.7 K - Romania: $210.7 K - Estonia: $90 K
It’s way more than 1.5 billion 200 miles of concrete fortified underground tunnels built over 17 years is at least billions in the double digits and it’s not in the hundreds because they use free child labor , the Hamas leaders themselves stole over ten billion dollars for their own personal pocket money this is a global money laundering scam
If you live on a piece of land, only your own people live there, schools only teach in your language, 32 hospitals are there for the 2 million people, you have your own flag, rules and your own government. Isn't this then an independent country? Not a refugee nation. Praying for the people who suffer under the rule of Hamas.
Following the outbreak of the war in Gaza, TH-cam updated its community guidelines, and as a result, the previous version of this video was age-restricted. We decided to edit and upload a less graphic version in the hopes that an unrestricted video will be viewed and shared by the widest possible audience. Please continue to share your comments and thanks for your support!
thank you you can edit your infos about that.
those who speak in Arabic expect the women speak in Egyptian and emirati accents
@@starcapture3040 I don't understand a word , اتكلم عربي علشان نفهم
So much of what's in this video is accurate and depicts a tragic truth about life in Gaza. However, framing tge testimonies into the narrative that Hamas, not Israel, is the root cause of Palestinian suffering is ridiculous. Yes, we did protest Hamas for years after their violent takeover of Gaza. But it was always Israel that blockaded Gaza and created the need for smuggling tunnels in the first place! Yes, children worked in the tunnels, but no forced labor was in effect. I've had friends and neighbors boast to me about how much money they used to make building tunnels throughout their teen years for the benefit of not only militant groups, but also for rich oligarchs who wanted in on the smuggling business that was profitable due to the currency difference between Egypt and Gaza and significantly cheaper goods imported and sold for less than a reasonable price in Gaza for a brief time. Since elsisi regime took over in Egypt, all of that ceased to exist and if any weapons were delivered to Hamas after the 2014 assault against Gaza it would've been with the full approval of the Israeli government and the Israel-friendly Egyptian regime. Which makes even more sense when you couple that with millions of dollars in cash delivered to Hamas in suitcases through the Beit Hanoun checkpoint (eretz).
Despite all the humiliation, restrictions, and blockade Gazans had to endure outside Hamas jurisdiction in Egypt and in the occupied territories, Hamas was still able to advance and build up an enormous military arsenal of rockets, antitank and anti personnel explosives as we're seeing in Gaza. How can anyone justify or advocate for the stifling and suffocation of Palestinians in Gaza by Israel and Egypt then blame it all on a rogue military group of victims to Israel's genocidal trek that started waaaay before Hamas was ever conceived!
The history of Gaza began long before that. In about 1590, the city of Gaza was founded by Rabbi Israel Najara. Gaza was a Jewish city from then until 1929. What happened in 1929? The Arab Revolt. Hundreds of Jews were murdered and the city of Gaza was occupied. The Jews were expelled from it. Women and girls were kidnapped and Islamized and until 1967 Jews did not return to the area.
I worked on a kibbutz north of israel in agriculture some of the workers were israeli arab (muslims) whenever there was a jewish wedding the arabs would come with their families their wives wearing hijabs and children, and we went to their kfar on events, i couldnl not see the apartheid anywhere yet much of the west who havent stepped foot in israel claim they know better, wish one day arabs will build up a huge trust with israelis and never again will we see war Amen.
It's happening for Muslim Israeli citizens. They aren't drafted & as time goes on more & more volunteer for the IDF.
Only Jesus has the power to bring peace. ❤
It reminds me of the Thanksgiving feast between native Americans and white settlers. What happened?
@@ErikaMatthieu-my4ofjesus through Spain and Portugal brought peace to the indigenous population of the Americas
@@ErikaMatthieu-my4of He has had 2,000 years, and it hasn't worked yet. In fact, a surprisingly large number of people who claim to follow Jesus murdered others "in his name."
As an Iranian who had been living under the Islamic Republic regime in Tehran. I can understand the innocent people who just need a normal life😢
These autocratic regimes are literally barbarism
What happended to over million Jewish people who used to live in Iran, Eraq and arab countries as well as Gaza?
innocent who? They had rose their children to destoy israel for generation! Thosand flood in the Gaza stretts praising 7th october massacre! They could build a garden in Gaza, they built an help of killers and tunnels. Innocent are only kids , for some Years, than rhey will become terrorist as their father egraand fathers and mothers and gran mothers. No innocent there
If only Ali Khamenei would learn from Cyrus the Great.
True freedom is the right of everyone to choose who to worship and to be free from all forms of enslavement.
Barbarism is a curse upon the simple.
@@tolstoryWell, it's TOOOO late for him or ANYONE in the regime to learn... hate to say this, but their times up
A normal human Should entitle to chose the ways of life style , Basic humanity .
Israeli here, standing behind every word.
I hope that one day we can live in peace, none of us deserve this war.
I see your pain.
We are still traumatised as a nation. As you are too.
We want peace.
We cherish life.
We believe we can have a better future, with you- peace seekers- among us.
We have nothing against Palestinians.
Only against those who want to harm us.
I'm Jewish, but not religious.
Yet I pray with all my heart to find our way for peace.
❤
Very touching words ❤️ I am a Christian in Germany. I have been to Israel two weeks ago, because I wanted to be with my jewish sisters and brothers in these dark and sad times. I will always pray with all my heart for Israel and for all the people loving this wonderful land 🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️
@doraross5810 Israel vored in a far right government. So all Israeli Jews will be responsible for what happened and is happening. 67% of all Israeli Jews voted in this government. So what is Israel now? A horrible nation.
@@stefaniehegmann6250 End Zionism and land theft. Spread the word.
You know the problem is Zionism. There will never be peace following ancient bible verses. Land thieves and liars.
Does the majority want to hurt jews? Or the minority? I just want to know if you're talking to a few or most palestinians
Please, answer these questions about Gaza Arabs:
1/ Jordan once gave citizenship to all Palestinians.
Why they later kicked them out of the country?
2/ Why Egypt built a strong double wall on Gaza border and insist not to take 1 child or woman or wounded Gazan to Egypt?
3/ Why Lebanon, once beautiful half Christians country, was TOTALLY DESTROYED when Jordan kicked out Palestinians and they moved to Lebanon?
4/ Why Kuwait kicked out 400 000 Palestinians in only one week?
5/ Why none of many Arabic Muslim countries would not accept Gazans?
Gazans are troublemakers thats why they got kicked out every where they go.😂
1. All the Palestinians that Jordan accepted after the 6 day war try to overthrow the Jordanian monarch. They even assassinated the prime minster.
2. Egypt has had peace with Israel for a very long time. They refuse to jeopardize it to help Palestinian refugees.
3. The Palestinian refugees that enter Lebanon sided with the radical Islam groups to over throw the government.
4. All the Palestinian refugees supported the invasion of Kuwait by Iraq.
5. History has shown time and time again that any country who has accepted Palestinian refugees has lead to chaos within their country.
1) because the palestinians tried to overthrow the jordanian goverment with a violent uprise. 2) Same in egypt.
3 and 4) they saw what happended to countries who trust palestinians.....
1. Their violence both directed at and launched from Jordan.
2. Arab rejection of Palestinians whom they regard as inferior and whose brains they filled with fantasies of reversing 48, coupled with mutual violence.
3. Palestinian narcissism and meddling in Lebanon.
4. The Palestinians backed Saddam , hoping that his conquest would lead to a joint uprising against israel.
5. Arabs don’t like Palestinians, they just exploit them. The Abraham accords put a fine point on this betrayal - Palestinians know that nobody in the neighborhood cares about them. This leads to the nihilism you see today.
Excellent comment
Born in Gaza and my family lived in Gaza for generations. I approve of this video ! !
Stay safe 🙏🏻
❤️ From 🇮🇱
@@Thenoobestgirlthankfully we no longer live there , yet the horrors we endured live in our memories. I’d like to remember all the wonderful people we lived alongside and there is many. Unfortunately radical Islam is what destroyed the people and Gaza
@@Qeewee8500 but muslim out of palestine is blaming of israel for this tragedy
Could you please say something about what children in Gaza are being taught about the conflict?
@@ThenoobestgirlStop being a white savior.
As an Israeli, although the last year was rough (to say the least) I hope one day we live side by side in peace, no terror proxies, no terrorist attacks, just two countries side by side. That is my true dream.
Not possible with one community who seeks only expansion.
Not going to happen,
Islamism is a group of ideologies that say that the Muslim world should be run by sharia (Islamic laws). Generally, it is the idea that Islam should guide both society and politics, as well as people's personal lives.
@@peachNplum and one that claims genocide but is the one that wants to genocide a whole nation state.
That's what I was hoping would happen, until Hamas was elected in Gaza.
I wish this video reaches all those people protesting Free Palestine in college campuses. They need to hear it from Gazans
They aren't even pro Palest*nians, they are anti-Jewish and don't actually care about Pales*inians.
@@savxired How can you say this is a propaganda? What proof do you have?
@savxired you are a liar and you are kidding yourself. Go back under the rock you crawled out from and stop b3ing part of the problem.
@savxired you are a liar and you are kidding yourself. Go back under the rock you crawled out from and stop b3ing part of the problem.
@@savxiredThose videos are from a documentary series called Whispered in Gaza. The speakers’ identities and proper translations were confirmed. News outlets like Al Arabia and Al Monitor authenticated the series. There are 25 vignettes to watch. Pull up a chair and get started.
I don't understand why it is Israel's and sometimes Egypt's responsibility to give Gaza food, water, fuel and electricity. They have their own government and practically state since 2005... Why can't they do anything themselves?
They spent all the aid money on tunnels and weapons. So sad. As you said they have had a country since 2005 and they chose to fight one more time. By the way, Palestine is receiving the biggest amount of international aid. There is no other example of a 75-year refugee statute in the world. The world's most privileged refugees they are... They are indoctrinated and this is the reason why they still choose to fight against "Jews". The key word is Jew. It is not about free Palestine.
they are like the 13% in the USA?
@@stephendotson9255 What's 13%?
Especially with all the BILLIONS of dollars in aid they got. Where is all of it??
@@Zane70K In Ismail's and Yahyar's Qatari bank accounts!
Sending a heartfelt embrace from Israel to all the innocent people in Gaza. Thank you so much for this honest video, Unpacked.
Educate yourself with the world expert on Israel/Palestine, Norman Finkelstein.(On youtube) I Dare you!
Arab Israelis are sitting in Goverment and have the right to vote. They also have the option of joining the Israeli army, which is not compulsory for them. So life in general for Israeli Arabs (muslims) is good.
You forgot to mention academic institution priorities for them etc etc
@@alexchertin3 what academic priorities?
Your right that 'technically' they're equal, but there's still lots of racism that even reaches the political scene.
Still, much better than what goes on in gaza.
@@uataweye6264 It's easier for an Arab to go to medical school here than Jews. I personally have friends whose children had to go to Italy to study medicine, while the admission requirements for Arabs and Druze are lower. Many Arabs, both men and women, are pharmacists. In Ariel University, (I know because I'm on the staff) Arabs can get dispensations because Eng is their third language, even if they have good grades, etc.
@@naattxxnaattxx7055No more racism exists in Israel than in the US, Australia and Eastern Europe. Why is it that Israel must be beyond reproach just because they’re Jews.
I had a school teacher that remembered the open borders as well. he always said how nice it was to go shopping in the gazan market with his son
many more facts and information is available people don't want to see it , they are either to biased to Israel or Hate H a m as to much to understand the other side
My grandma still talks about how much she loved going to the Gazan market, both as a little kid, and as a young adult, and says that often you couldnt find better goods (spices, fish and etc.) for cheaper, with a better experience.
why she did could move thier permanently if it was so nice?
@@gevor1726 why she did could move thier permanently if it was so nice?
@@smartlady3892 what's your point?
Thank you ❤I am a German Jew , came to Israel 30 years ago and just wanted peace for everyone.
After Oktober 7. I am afraid that too many extremists are in powerful positions on both sides 😢
@rutharusi394 the only extremists come from Gaza you know better than that, Israel is protecting its homeland and people so stop your BS
Better u stay at Gaza
Thank you for this honest commentary.
@@pavila195417I personally know people from Gaza who are suffering and afraid because of Hamas.
So no bs here.
And in Israel are extreme people too who make others suffer.
Hamas is cruel even to its own people
Hamas is one of a dozen or more.
No Terrorist organisation is fair to its own people. It's a common trait.
You right , but don't forget , most palestinians are for Hamas sick us it is , like the ones that was part of the 7th palestinians from young to old ,raided the kubuts the men raping jewish women it was not just Hamas
You misspelt IDF
@@RenderingUser The IDF has lowest ratio of civilian to combatant deaths in the history of modern urban warfare and that’s a fact
IS Any nation will take gazans/hamas in? !
NOT even ONE of 54 Muslims countries? WHY not?
I wonder?
Ya'll should be the last one talking about countries not letting people in. How many countries were the chosen people expelled from and continue to be expelled from? Even from Guatemala.
@@blueizumi Jews were expelled and hunted down by basically every nation and empire ever since the religion was formed. Pretty much every European country has hunted and expelled us, and now the Middle East won't even let us create a nation after the Ottomans sold land to Jewish people after the Ottomans lost WW1.
Any person with a functioning brain understands knows that the people who were invented in the last hundred years were created for a clear purpose. Islamic unity.Look at the discussions about the design of their flag; it proves it.
@@lofemix Why were y’all expelled from the humble indigenous region of Guatemala then?
walt, thats cause islamist nations working hard to enable more their kind to succeed and jewish to fail,they keep fighting israel when they home is arabia
Without lies Islam dies
אתה לא יודע כמה אתה צודק . אני מדבר עם ערבים והם מגיעים מהר מאוד בשיחה קצרה לנקודה בלי המשך לא יודעים היסטוריה אמיתית הכל גנב אצלהם . בקיצור זה נכון
no way out for their leader sinwar
Same exact thing can be said for all religions. Including yours.
I am an exmuslim but unlike you I know how respect others beliefs
@@HermanDinkins Religion is the root of all evil.
The fact that I never even knew about the 'we want to live' movement until now after learning about the region since the war started in surprising
If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
Hey man, just wanted to say thank you for posting this, it's refreshing to see someone being humane and compassionate to others first and foremost. I've been referring to the Whispered in Gaza series as well as talking about the protests in Gaza since the war started, but those who choose to be blind will remain so. Much love from an Israeli Arab.
I am not surprised that many Gazan's want to be done with Hamas. Their rule has been oppressive and devastating... and perhaps SOME of the Gazans elected this new government on right pretenses but as we see, were really duped by their lies. BUT, one thing that SIMPLY CAN'T BE IGNORED -- because it would be ignoring reality, and therefore could end up being very dangerous -- is that there were literally thousands of Gazans celebrating in the streets after October 7th. Thousands. Please address this in another video. What about those celebrating Gazans?
I am Arab and I approve of this message. I have lived in Cairo, Khartoum, Tangier, Amman, Baghdad and Beirut. I have also spent time in Israel and the Palestinian Territories. I know from first hand observations that Palestinian leadership has rejected peace time after time to keep the money rolling in to support their lavish lifestyle OUTSIDE OF PALESTINE. Anyone who sides with Hamas is a fool. You can blindly believe their propaganda or do what I did and go to Palestine and see for yourself how they (Palestinian leadership) exploit the Palestinian people for their own vanity. Life is better for Israeli Arabs of any religion or sexual orientation than in anywhere else in the Middle East. You might know that if you at least read and even better, go to the Middle East to see for yourself.
wish more people like you existed! and really put the words out because the ones that do and when I share those videos always get me a message Israeli propaganda and so on. People can be so blind in life. Shalom Aleichem Salaam Alaikum my brother.
@ Thank you for the words of encouragement!
It was very obvious with Yasser the terror. PLO was evil. people have short memories.
thanks for raising awareness of who hamas is
"Freedomfighters".
I'm not sure why ppl are surprised I mean they are literally classified as a terrorist organization
@@robertgorlee2552 terrorist
@@robertgorlee2552If you look into it, its supposed to be an acronym, but its even scarier if you translate it to english. It means violence. Even if you don't beleive in the supernatural, its prophesised that violence will be destroyed completly by God himself. Not just the terror organization that coincidentaly named themselves basically violence. Just look into the history. Who invaded first? Thats right. The Islamic Forces. Islam beleives to kill all non beleivers. Look in the Quran. It says that.
@@robertgorlee2552 Freedom fighters that kills and abuse their own people, while using them as human shields.
Hope you had when the Hamas leader said that 75% some those living in Gaza are refugees, and they don't care about them.
Your problem is the virus called Islam, you don't even care about the Gaza people, if you do you should have moved there.
This report needs to go to Every university in the United States and all over Europe because it tells the truth of the plight of the Gazans and how they have been shorted, tortured, killed, and restricted by Hamas. Israel did nothing but help them until they attacked Israel. Israel would never attack them unprovoked.
🤣 israel stole the land in 1948, Hamas wasn't founded till 1987. Israel had 39 years to make peace before Hamas and they refused.
@@micahjohnsonboxing6409 obviously brains aren't your strongest quality.
Agree. As for this actual war, Israel never wanted it, never asked for it, never started it. They have been really good to Arabs.
@@micahjohnsonboxing6409in 1947 four Arab countries tried to erase Jews from Israel, and somehow they lost the war…. The Arabs who wanted to stay and live in Israel still live there and still own their homes from 100 years ago… so p,ease stop the bs
So just so I'm clear here. Israel are the goodies and hamas are the baddies?
I am israelí, I wish Gazan`s to have a good life and I wish more people in the world see this video and begin to understand what is really happening in Gaza. May peace come as soon as possible and forever! Thank you for this video
with the money and help they got they should have a good life
@@smartlady3892But no, they dug tunnels and fatten the pockets of their oppressors.
The Arabs have rejected a state at least 6 times. Consider the following:
One: At the recommendation of the Peel Commission, the British, who controlled Palestine at the time, agreed to create a two-state solution, offering the Palestinian Arabs 80 per cent of the disputed territory.
The Palestinian Jews said yes, the Arabs said no.
Two: On Nov. 7, 1947, the United Nations voted to create two states. The Palestinian Jews (who changed their name to Israelis) said yes, the Palestinian Arabs said no.
Three: After the Six Day War In 1967, Israel wanted to return the captured lands to Egypt and Jordan or to the Palestinian Arabs. The Arab league met in Sudan and said: “No peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel.” In other words, the Arabs said no.
Four: In 2000, then-Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak offered all of Gaza and 94 per cent of the West Bank with East Jerusalem as its capital to Yasser Arafat. Arafat said no.
Five: In 2008, the prime minister of Israel, Ehud Olmert, added additional land to the previous offer of 2000. Mahmoud Abbas said no. History shows that each time Israel has agreed to offering land for peace, the Palestinian Arabs have rejected the offers.
Six: The one time, in 2005, when Israel unilaterally left Gaza to the Palestinian Arabs. The terrorists took control and turned it into a base from which thousands of rockets have been fired into Israel up to, and including, the present day.
Trading land for peace didn’t work.
The Arabs want the eradication of Jews more than they want a state
If the Palestinians truly care about their children and, here are some tips for them:
1. Do not elect a terrorist organization to rule over you.
2. Do not educate your children from the age of zero to hate Jews and to aspire to murder them as the sole purpose of their lives. Invest in your children's education instead, maybe in a few decades their lives could improve as a result.
3. Cherish life instead of death and martyrdom.
4. Hold your leaders accountable and protest when they operate against your wellbeing, use you or manipulate you. Revolt against them if they treat you badly.
5. Admit the historical fact that the Arabs lost the war they started in 1948. Deal with it. Own your loss, there is no shame in it. Hold yourself accountable and leverage it as a growth opportunity instead of calling it “Nakhba” and blaming others for the consequences of your leaders' actions.
6. Recognize Israel’s right to exist and accept the fact that Israel is a sovereign state and legitimate under international law. Understand that the Jews are here to stay and will never again leave this region, no matter how hard you try.
7. Focus on rebuilding yourself as a nation instead of spending your time and energy trying to annihilate your neighbors. Focus on the land that you do have and on how to self develop and thrive.
8. Stop trying to constantly frame Israel and blame it for false crimes using Qatar funded media outlets and other means of propaganda.
9. Stop institutionalizing and legislating salary payments of hundreds of millions of dollars annually to imprisoned terrorists and the families of terrorists who died while carrying out terror attacks against Israel.
10. Stop accepting military aid, training, weapons and financial aid from Iran, the world's worst state sponsor of terrorism. They do not truly care about you and only use you as pawns.
11. Release the hostages kidnapped by Hamas on October 7, including a one-year old infant and his mother who have been held hostages to this very day.
12. Lay down your arms and stop choosing violence as the only solution for your problems. Look where it got you to in the last 75 years.
13. Understand that actions speak a whole lot louder than meaningless and empty words. The entire world is watching you.
14. Take a hard look at yourself and your actions before blaming Israel for yet another injustice.
15. Now take a hard look at Israel and see how, just by following these tips, it became the most thriving and successful democracy in the region.
16. Embrace peace.
Well said
the moment i saw 80 percent, I already know that your cooked😂
@@MuhammadIdris-jb6jvyou got no point, shut up
The Israelis have won three wars!!! They own the entire territory.
@@MuhammadIdris-jb6jvofficially, it was more than 50% which translate that the UN gave the arabs more land than the Jews. Now, losing wars resulted to losing land.
Congratulations on the best, most honest video I've seen in 9 months. I hope everyone and every country sees this and all the nonsense disappears. Thank you💗☮️💗☮️💗☮️
👌👍👍
Thank you for your Channel UNPACKED. This is honest journalism many like to read and hear. Thank you so much.
Students in American universities should watch this and learn the truth!
They’re brainwashed already. Sad
🤣If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
they dont care about the truth. they already know it and prefer to hate jews.
They will adamantly deny the truth. That's the extent of their indoctrination.
This is Juden propaganda...... US students are smart, they know what the baby killers are doing in Gaza...
I am totaly convinced that where islam goes trouble follows look at the world and what they do
We must not say or even think such things if we want peace. Research how many moderate vs how many extremist muslims there are worldwide, the majority is non-violent, only in war-torn, conflict-ridden, poverty-stricken areas do radical extremists thrive. We cannot be either racists or islamophobes, we cannot spread such rhetoric. They use vile anti-Jewish 1930s slander Tropes, antisemitic conspiracy theories which WW2 Germany used to fuel the Holocaust, we must rise taller, be morally upright and not mirror the vile slander.
The OVERWHELMING majority of terrorist organizations come from islam.
100% right
Yes, all religion is horrible and more middle ages and is not fit for a modern world.
From where I came from , it is the truth
THAT was Beautiful! ❤ I will save your video to share. I am praying for the Gazan people and I know that God wants them to have life and have it abundantly ❤
Given that this is a plainly pro-Israel channel, I was impressed with how fair and frank this video was. As well as comprehensive and well researched. Good job!
Because truth is with Israel
@@davidcooks2379 Alright, I have a question for you. How many palestinians did israel displace between 1947-mid 1948? (Before the arab-israeli war)
he didn't mentioned that majority of people in Gaza are refuges ethnically cleans in 1948 they want to retrun but not allowed
@@Lukxvsp That doesn't matter for the current ongoing conflict getting obsessed over past aggressions isn't fixing helping Palestinians, who have also, committed acts of genocide against the Jews. You sound like a Hamas and oct 7 apologist bro
@@starcapture3040 Your also leaving out a bunch of context, but also what about the Jews and Christians that were ethnically cleansed from every arab country?? There is factually no diversity among the Muslim majority countries.
Europeans/americans who says they're on the "right side of history" when supporting "the resistance"/Hamas should be ashamed of them selves.
I hope this video will reach every person that owns a computer/cellphone on earth! This needs to be seen and heard.
You are too late the world knows the truth!
@@Azie-ev6rk do they ...
@@Azie-ev6rk and that is?
they already saw the bombing and double standards, they wont believe these channels lies since billions are speaking out about these people!
Wowww what an amazing video. Thank you. Praying for all the innocent Palestinians and Israel ❤❤❤
Wow, this is the most honest reporting i have seen on this war! Thank you!
Wow well done! Hope everyone sees this video! Thank you for bringing light on a very sad time!
I hope everyone knows that when Israel uprooted the lives of all Gazan Jews in 2005’s disengagement, they left the infrastructure to support the population- Hamas destroyed it all as it was “Jewish and dirty”
Educate yourself with the world expert on Israel/Palestine, Norman Finkelstein.(On youtube) I Dare you!
wow this brought tears in my eyes fr. we need more of this content and mentality instead of the warmongering biased crap that permeates on both sides..
תודה לך על זה אחי
< 3
This historical documentary answers so many questions. Thank you
you tube this video should be viewed by millions ..
As an Israeli I want to believe them but I can't, they are talking like Hamas is something that came from the sky.
Hamas is within them, every year they get new recruits, from where?
Agreed, we've watched this happen time and time again. I saw the news in the 2nd intifada and the targeting of civilians, this time I'm not staying silent. It's the same playbook as before. Somehow we're supposed to forget they do the same thing over and over and over. We can't be lulled into complacency again. Israel is always expected to be the good guy and leave their sworn enemy to attack another day. It's sickening.
Don't give up. Good people can be badly influenced.
not all palestinians are bad. some are sadly.
They get them from people o serving how israel treat them. You created tour own anemy
idk maybe the rockets from israel has something to do with it
UN is as much to blame as Hamas. With All the money given to Gaza there’s absolutely nothing to show. Gaza should have had several water plants, electrical plants,and water treatment plants to show that money was being used for the people. Investigation should be done to see which UN leaders received kick backs. Gazans are to blame as they kept quite. 16:15
Right.
This kind of content is gold. please share, repost and comment. The world must see this
I love these videos. As someone from the US who really doesn't understand any of this.. or why?? But these videos give me a better understanding of what's going on over there and why? Thanks for the education. 😊👍
Happy to hear that!
@@UNPACKED well it seems hella biased to me, which is why i went to the comments. but really all these are here are a shitshow. not an ounce of help. i'll go back to watching the Grayzone and Norman Finklestein. hey, i gave it a shot.
What’s biased about it?
Oh this video make me cry ❤❤❤❤ the people are suffering in Gaza. Thank you for this work ❤❤❤❤
Absolutely amazing video with a beautiful message. Thank you for creating this masterpiece.
Thank you!
Brilliant and informative feature. Such a shame mainstream Western Media appears to be incapable of reporting these dimensions of this tragic narrative.
Mainstream media promotes antisemitic tropes, for some reason their reporting would make a person even less informed about events if all they did was listen to the news. Frustrating to say the least.
This is really moving, very touching. I hope to be alive to witness when you children of the same Father get two sit together again.
What a wonderful, powerful video. So informative and broad in its testimonies that it really gave me a wider perspective on the situation and people’s experiences.
Just want to say that your video is the most unbiased, factually correct depiction of the Israel/Hamas war going on at the moment. It is refreshing not to have to sift through slanted narratives to understand the situation. Your dedication to presenting the facts without taking sides is highly appreciated. Thank you for your commitment to truthful reporting. RG from South Africa
🤣🤣🤣
@@agahanaga1868do FACTS frighten you?
I love this channel, because it is highly informative❤
I really really look forward to your podcasts bro. Excellent .
You can find our podcasts here! www.youtube.com/@UnpackedPodcasts/podcasts
Why is it so rare and impressive to see people spreading truth in this world?? Thank you for doing this.
the problem i have with this is that i have seen personally the vedios of Gazan people celebrate in the streets all across gaza. thousands of social media post from gaza about the joy the felt on october 7th. so to see them crying about how bad hamas is now is hipocritical becouse we all know now very clearly what their view on freedom is, what their view on peace is, and what their view on israel is.
There’s probably some innocent individuals there in Gaza, but I suspect that they have no love for Jews and Israel, they just want Hamas gone more.
This is exactly the best a complex document ever made.This should be presented around the world 24/7 in every primetime news.
The greco-roman Palestine has never been a state in all of history and was just a colonialist province!!!Tis so-called palestinians have just never existed!!!By the way the letter "P" does not exist in arabic alphabet!!!They are in majority jordanians and more than 50% of the gazouites are egyptians!!!
Dude most of palestine are actually jews who intermarriage with arabs this have been confirmed by dna they are arab jews u are basically at war with your people
Very true Thomas. L'chaim. My Hebrew name Jacova is the female form of Jacob. I was born March 11th in Bethlehem 51 years ago. In Aramaic Khubba means love. Khubba to you and yours.
Twice now I written you a response that was erased by youtube. L'chaim. In Aramaic Khubba means love. Khubba to you and yours. I was born March 11th in Bethlehem 51 years ago.
They're in fact islamised jews, check at tsvi misinai
If people who do not know about the disgusting terrorists watch this video full of lies and no mention of facts, and do not confirm the picture presented, they will think that the cruel devils in Gaza are human. Could there be a person whose culture consists only of hatred for destroying Jews, and who started sending their children to terrorist camps to commit massacres in the future when they were only 6-7 years old? Can someone who raises his children to murder people from the age of 12-13 be human? Do you know of any other society that uses places such as hospitals, mosques and schools as terrorist bases, and uses people, including babies, children, women, the sick and the elderly, as human shields? These despicable creatures, which are disgusted even by Arabs, who use the money sent for the welfare of their society for their evil purposes, build tunnels, use places such as hospitals, schools and mosques as weapons and terrorist depots, cannot even be called devils, let alone humans. A special definition should be used for this species.
This is so important, more people here in Europe should see this ..
250,000 work permits were issued from January 2023 till October 6th 2023. How many Gazan's spied while working in Israel? Also how many civilians attacked Israel on October 7th?
Hundreds, for sure. 😢
And a catastrophic economic situation by now for the West bank since all job with Israel stoped. According to The times of Israel, 150 000 palestiniens from West bank enter every day to work in Israel and some 18 000 were crossing Gaza border every day (it was part of a sort of "pacification" policy toward Gaza, better busyness meaning more peace from the population). Of course hamas could not care less about that, the population is just there to be human shield and victimisation propaganda against Israel. At the present 10 000 of palestinien are authorized again.
They attacked on Oct 7 while both sides were still in a ceasefire.
Did not expect so much reality. Thanks.
Waow! Such a clear and comprehensive document! I loved it! It reveals facts, testimonies, and most important - emotions!
Wow - very informative; thank you!! May Peace be achievable soon for all Peace Loving peoples.
a beatuiful and honest presentation / Shalom to all!!
Thanks for this amazing documentary ❤️
I remember the 2019 protest, social media and international news made it look like it was Israel 🇮🇱 not HAMAS!! Now, I know the truth....
AM YISRAEL CHAI 🇮🇱 My people live
If Gazans are fed up with Hamas, why did the survey show that 70 or 80 % support Hamas? I may be mistaken, but I think the survey covered BOTH the West Bank and Gaza.
Because most of them are pro-Hamas.
You have 2 things here. First Hamas has little to none existent state in the West bank since it's a PLO rule (And btw the Palestinians there live way better - Note that there are terror cells starting to pop up which may will cause their lives to be a lot harder for no reason...) additionally you have the fact that people can not say anything bad on Hamas even if they thinks it's anonymous survey they know they may be killed.
trusting polls that come out of gaza is like trusting polls north koreans give. they're not free to say what they truly believe so the polls just aren't very trustworthy. unfortunately they're all we have aside from what we've all seen.
I start to think they supported them at start due to false promises as often in Dictatorships and when they realised that it's gotten worse they can't really officially speak out against it anymore due to being prosecuted for it. I can imagine that lots still fall for the blame game towards Israel though and children are heavily indoctrinated for the jihad but I am sure many want out of Hamas Regime. I wished western societies would support the ones who try to get out rather than the fairy tale narrative of the terrorists.
Educate yourself with the world expert on Israel/Palestine, Norman Finkelstein.(On youtube) I Dare you!
Thanks! I hope with all my heart that I will see a much better future for Israel and Gaza during my lifetime. We are all exhausted . The blood shed has to stop! We want peace and quite!
Thank you! Amen!
Under Hamas Rejime, horror
Thanks for reaveling the truth and for making us to fully understand what's really happening in Gaza.Please kindly share this video to the ICJ,ICC,UN and the US Universities.This is really a great video.
They are all hamas.
I like to see "Democracy Now" talk about this!
Islamer J.had is anathema to God and life. L'chaim.
They wont, they're completely lost in their anti-Israel narrative. Algorithm showed me a video once, I didn't know them. It was right after Oct 7th, like days later only. This was one of the most disgusting things I've watched in all these months. I think it was Amy Adams who 'contextualized' things there.
you mean "Communism Now"
@@Parpl22 Inform Amy Goodman, I danced ballet across the Iron Curtain thru Romania. Whilst she was. Wishing she danced ballet with The Philadelphia Orchestra, Eugene Ormondy, Conductor.
🤣🤣🤣
Thank you for great material! More people need to see it.
Thanks for sharing. I hope for peace for all!
So very informative. I hope your video reaches everyone on the planet.
Slava Yisrael , I am Israel chai
slava ukraine, slava israilu!
Just show we all knew so little about all the conflicts and problems, thanks for info appreciated
Amazing, amazing report! Thanks! I will be sharing this!
Brought me tears
RESPECT TO YOUR SHOW FOR FINALLY SHOWING SOME COURAGE AND BRINGING SOME TRUTH TO THIS CONFLICT
Great video. Thanks
I believed that there are many Palestinians in Gaza that hate Hamas but then there was also some polls that showed most of them support Hamas and support the 7th of October attack. Do they support Hamas just because their life would be threatened if they don't?
Good question, exactly what I was thinking.
This is the same situation for Germany under Nazi. They claimed they did not support Nazi, they were not with the Nazi. But no one said a thing when they are swimming in the wealth and benefits that Nazi gave them.
A lot of it has to do with Hamas’s education system turning innocent children into warriors before they’re even 10. I imagine if there wasn’t such indoctrination taking place they would think differently.
Honestly a whole lot of brainwashing.
what did you expect from a totalitarian organisation
Update: 14:11 he no longer lives in Qatar, or anywhere else.
I roughly knew about Gaza's story since 2005.
Initially, Hamas was democratically elected. But so was Hitler, and the rest is history!
Mossab, and many others have no idea ( or not officially) how Gaza will be administered "after".
Am Yisrael Chai, Druze, Jews and Bedouins are together defending the only country they have!
Hamas lied to win those votes.
So you get what you vote for , 😢.
So here's the BIG QUESTION.....Are there enough Palestininans prepared to live side by side in peace with Israel? If yes, are they prepared to get behind a leader who supports that same vision and push back against the rejectionists who want a one state solution?
No
I feel bad for them , for the children especially, however it is terrifying tot hink about the future of these children that they might get revenge without learning the history of their war.. they have to know between good muslim and extremists muslim. GOD GIVE THEM PEACE
My favorite unpacked video
What is life like for the 130 hostages who have been denied food medicine and freedom for 9 months?
stfu! have you seen the released hostages who look like they have been staying in a hotel vs the ones released from israeli prisons who can barely walk and have lost 80 lbs and been tortured? gimmie a f'n break
Well done for this well balanced and factual video. You did an awesome job.
I grew up hearing stories of playing SheshBesh and smoking shisha with locals on the beaches of Gaza, and Sinai... every israeli I grew up with has a rich and diverse background that somehow makes them even more intriguing... even the "boring" white kids all had a old polish song or Russian tradition that makes them special. I hope one day people can see Israel for its true beauty - the ability to accept all beliefs and cultures and blend history with innovation and aspiration. We will free Gaza from Hamas then it's up to us to make that beach town great again ;) Together.
לפי התגובות אני יכולה להבין שהרבה אנשים בעולם נוקטים עמדה כבר שנים , מבלי לדעת מה קורה פה , ומבלי לבוא לישראל ולהבין את השורש של הסכסוך.
אני מציעה לא לנקוט עמדה מבלי לדעת את כל הפרטים. וגם בסירטון הזה חסרים המון פרטים.
בתור ישראלית אני יכולה לספר לכם שאין ישראלי אחד שגדל פה מבלי לחוות מלחמות , טילים , פיגועים. לכל אחד בישראל יש חברים או משפחה שנהרגו או נרצחו .
אני שירתתי בצבא הייתי בעזה . חברים אם אתם לא יודעים- עדיף לא לנקוט עמדה . מי שנוקט עמדה שילמד טוב טוב את ההיסטוריה.
בעזה כמו בכל המקומות מסביב לישראל מלמדים ילדים מגיל אפס לרצוח ולשנוא יהודים. זה מה שהם לומדים בבתי הספר שלהם! אז איך אפשר לצפות לשלום?
😂😂😂 lo mismo pasa con los judíos, ustedes comenzaron esto.
@@SillyCatGoofyI don’t understand what’s so funny but, lack of knowledge will do that to a person.
💯
Am Israel Chai ❤️🎗️🇮🇱
Amen
Number of questions-1. Why did Gazan citizens participate in the massacre on 7.10? They murdered, raped and stole... 2. Why were tunnel shafts, antisemitic books found in houses in Gaza? 3. Why until now have Gazan citizens not cooperated with the Israeli army and not found out where the abductees are? 4. Why did families from Gaza keep hostages in their home? The innocent citizens of Gaza are not believed!! All of Hamas!!!
because the war didnt start on 2023, it started 76 years ago
Not all citizens participated. Books can easily be planted so that is not a solid reason. When you are ordered and controlled by an authority that can easily eliminate you or your family what choice do you have not to hold hostages handed to you to secure while they do other things
@@HaAbi-u7i there were NO RAPES.
And Israel? Innocent pigs?
Same questions from me.
Why not help Israel end Hamas. And the war
Unfortunately, these people are not the majority in Gaza. Hamas has a very high approval rating there. In fact, most Gazan civilians approve of October 7th.
How do we know if they can't speak out and Hamas opressed them and only leaks the propaganda they want to further their cause. No child "wants" to be in this awful situation, they are indoctrinated and forced into it.
Again if you are asked by a pollster if you support Hamas, most sensible people will say yes. If Hamas was so wonderful they would allow elections but of course they won't. Election 2006, nothing since then.
Great video Achi
When Hamas is finally defeated Israel has a real chance at turning Gaza into a success story. I hope Israel doesnt squander it.
By success story you mean land grab and the expansion of Israel colonial settlements?
May Gods will and love for his children prevail.
Porq no midieron las consecuencias antes de la masacre y despues sus festejos....ahora lloran busquen a sus lideres escondidos como ratas y platiquenlo.....
Bring the hostages back now!!!
one of the most unbiased videos
What I don’t get is, the tunnels cost up to 1.5 billion money. How can a country with its own administration, have so much money without contributing to the world anything the world would like?
Gaza should look like and act Dubai. Our tax dollars fund UNRw4, PLO, Martyrs Fund 🤮 and more. Watched a video of two Ham4s t’s sipping tea under a tree each holding stacks of US Currency 💵 in their hands. The following countries temporarily suspended and then resumed funding to UNRW4, in addition to providing annual contributions:
- USA: $343.9 Million
- Canada: $23.7 Million
- Germany: $202.1 Million
- European Union: $114.1 Million
- Sweden: $61 Million
- Japan: $30.2 Million
- France: $28.9 Million
- Switzerland: $25.5 Million
- The Netherlands: $21.2 Million
- Australia: $13.8 Million
- Italy: $18 Million
- Austria: $8.1 Million
- Finland: $7.8 Million
- New Zealand: $560.8 K
- Iceland: $558.7 K
- Romania: $210.7 K
- Estonia: $90 K
The UN and EU feel bad for Gazans and donate money. Hamas then steals this money for their own uses like tunnels.
The United States and other foreign countries through the UN.
It’s way more than 1.5 billion 200 miles of concrete fortified underground tunnels built over 17 years is at least billions in the double digits and it’s not in the hundreds because they use free child labor , the Hamas leaders themselves stole over ten billion dollars for their own personal pocket money this is a global money laundering scam
Through donations.
Very touching
Best video on this topic by far!
Wow.l.what a great episode
If you live on a piece of land, only your own people live there, schools only teach in your language, 32 hospitals are there for the 2 million people, you have your own flag, rules and your own government. Isn't this then an independent country? Not a refugee nation. Praying for the people who suffer under the rule of Hamas.
The people of Gaza prepared for 17 years to pick a fight with the Israelis. Serious misjudgment and now they pay the price
Beautiful video.
Thank you for exposing the truth.