@@dogkungfu8510 You know there's some dude in there whispering "Should we tell him nobody drinks ale anymore?" And his friend is like "Shut up! Free booze." And then the third friend is like: "Somebody wanna tell this guy?"
@@stevengalloway8052 instead of serving Worf's brother caviar with his replicated burned birdflesh I would have served it with beans beans beans... beans beans beans!
Why do I get the feeling Patrick Stewart just wasn't given the script for this episode, And this is just him being himself while the cameras are rolling?
Of all the Sr staff, Riker is the only one who's been through an actual mutiny, so he was being very cautious in this scene to not replicate that scenario, knowing that it could get everyone killed.
Also, although I can see why Worf, as a Security Office, would immediately see gathering confederates as a move towards mutiny, Riker, who wrestling with removing his captain from command (not mutiny), understandably wants to make sure he's not overreacting or overreaching, and confers with fellow officers to get their perspectives on the situation... which looks and has to feel a lot like mutiny, regardless.
Also, the eventual hearing could get awkward: _Why did you commit mutiny?_ - _Well, you see, the captain was giving ale for everyone and singing songs with us. ..._
Data being so insightful here as usual. He mentions their only piece of hard evidence, the energy reading the sensors recorded in the Captain's quarters.
You know, since alien possession/mind control/replacement is the most common scenario in Star Trek, Starfleet probably should create a procederem to deal with it.
@@We_Are_Borg_478 The man brought a book to Risa! Would be my counter argument for Picard having fun. I forgot about this episode, I'm going to rewatch it. 😁
@@bingeMAFIA If memory serves, it's the one with the two aliens that capture picard with the beast creature and the starfleet girl and the wimpy alien and they have to co exist while the imposter picard continues to put the crew in danger to see how far they will go in following orders. Then picard captures them with the force field to demonstrate how much captivity sucks.
It's crazy how the command crew find Picard's sudden change in demeanor almost mutiny-worthy while the rest of the crew in the lower decks don't notice or don't care. It would have been kind of scary to be there singing along with the captain, then turn to look at the redshirt table to see subdued looks of horror being shared with each other.
The story seems to be adapted from one of the Hornblower stories. Rather than being an alien, the captain has some kind of personality disorder like paranoid schizophrenia, and the gist is that the captain gets the crew on his side by lavishing them with booze and leisure time, because he's convinced his officers are plotting to kill him. Ironically the brutality he shows against the officers encourages them to mutiny.
The lower deck crew doesn't interact with the captain directly on a day to day basis, unlike the senior officers and bridge crew. They don't have the context about the captain to know that something is really out of the ordinary. From their perspective, Captain is just being jovial for some reason.
At some point you would think the TNG crew would start to expect that people have been possessed by aliens or whatever when they are acting differently.
@@afaultytoaster Lt. Hornblower, to be specific. The situation is resolved when the Captain just happens to fall down some stairs and become invalided. We never find out if he was pushed.
@@smartalec2001 Not according to the episode where Worf has the replicator replicate Blood Wine for the alcoholic Irishman from the low-tech colony whose sun was going crazy and had to be evac'd to the colony of clones experiencing replication failure. The man was quite pleased with the drink as I recall.
@@imonlyamanandiwilldiesomed4406 isn't there one where Scotty from the original series is complaining how weak the drink is, and they find him some proper booze behind the counter?
@@smartalec2001 Pretty sure he and the Irishman had the same complaint. I wonder if the typical drinks are synthesized with relatively less alcohol content? I bet a crafty engineer could create new or alter old recipes ;)
As much as I respect the tactically brilliant and stuffy britches & reserved Picard.... Quite frankly, the poker playing, ale buying (ahem) lounge singing Picard would be a hell of a lot more fun to explore deep space with. If the replicant's mission commands weren't so dangerously absurd, the crew might have chosen to keep him instead. 😉
You don't understand Picard's psychology at all. Picard acts cold and aloof to hide his passionate and emotional nature. We see that all the time, outbursts of passionate emotion when he loses his iron self-control: "The line must be drawn HERE! This far! No farther!" It's in fact the entire reason he chose Riker as his XO. They are polar opposites. Where Picard hides his romantic heart under a layer of cool officiousness, Riker is everyone's best friend and a party animal -- to hide his _true_ nature of cold ruthlessness. We see the real Riker in Thomas, the man he would have become without Picard's influence. Both men learn from each other over the course of the series, with Picard learning how to let a little of his feelings show and Riker learning how to feel a little compassion for people.
@@yourstruly4817 I never felt that Movie Picard behaved out of character with respect to TNG Picard. Maybe he was more emotional, but he was also dealing with much more emotional situations than he usually did in TNG.
This is how I imagine the Picard who commanded the Stargazer to be. Smaller ship, smaller more intimate crew, younger brasher captain. I think Picard recruited Riker because Riker reminded him of himself as he once was.
'Ales for everyone' - I'm assuming that's telling the bar to break out their small supply of real alcohol rather than the non-alcoholic replicated stuff. The stuff reserved for special occasions.
It would have to be for the scene to make sense. But it was weird how quickly they got them ready. It being real alcohol would explain his behavior, though, haha. ... If he got a really fast metabolism and hasn't had real alcohol for ages.
Despite being from France, singing an official Royal Navy song is one of the more British things Picard did until he led Worf and Data to sing A British Tar.
Memory is a funny phenomenon; This song; O'Brien's _The Minstrel Boy;_ and Lore's _Abdul Abulbul Amir_ will suddenly pop into my head at random, and _Star Trek: The Next Generation_ is my only source, thirty years ago.
@@jimmesser4412 wrong. TOS has several references that they were paid, that it took money to build the enterprise. how could Mudd be charged with counterfeiting currency if it didn't exist.
@@mhelvens Replicator credits!? XD Literally anyone anywhere can replicate as much food or drink as they want. Yes, there are some limitation in place; like everything from a replicator is nutritionally balanced and it wont let you replicate real alcohol (though, anyone with technical expertise would be able to modify a replicator...). The time replicators actually had rations was when Voyager was flung out into the Delta quadrant and energy used for replication came at a premium.
4:10 "Nobody has suggested removing the captain from command." Correct, but you're meeting in secret trying to determine whether there is a certain condition that would justify mutiny. I get it's not an easy argument but you were all thinking that, one way or another.
Watching Star Ttek Picard was like watching a whole season-full of watching whoever this guy/Picard is. Riker’s right “This is different, _he’s different_ I can’t put my finger on it, but I’m worried… That’s not the captain _I_ know…” Yeahhhhh
Thanks ! i love these short and well written Discussion scene. i am used to watch Star Trek with japanese dub and subtitles, and rarely heard the original voice much. These your clips helps me to re-visit Star Trek with original Voice, looks refleshing for me.
How do you perceive the original vs. the dubbed? Is the dubbing industry in Japan kinda 'underdeveloped', too?` I can say that in Germany the range is wide and usually you need a really decent budget to get proper dubbing. Animated dubs tend to be worst, because voice acting often isn't so much acting as making-funny-voices. There are a few instances, though, where the German dubbing is actually arguably better than the original. The first Star Wars movies, for example. - And although I might be biased because I grew up watching Saber Rider in German, I would say that, too, sounds a lot better in German than in English. Adds so much distinct character.
@@Dowlphin First, i am the guy who watch anything with JP dubbed with JP subtitles with my eyes and ears. (cause it will tell me more information). i think JP dubbed is par with or better than original . especialy male voice acting. (But female voice acting, original voice is good and strong than dubbed voice). in my opinion, Most Moveis, Shows and Animes will be dubbed well in japanese. Because the voice acting industry in japan is really big and has many good actors. (Especially, low tone heavy male voice). Star Trek (TNG to ENT) has got with Top Tier voice actores. P.S. You can check How japanese voice actors are. Check comparison video like "Adventure Time" OP in any language. and Lemongrab screaming (lemon guy) in any language. you see japanese actors doing well.
I do like how Picard floats around and there's a table of dudes who have joined in singing. Nobody else, just 3/4 of the ship's barbershop quartet chilling and discussing their next lineup
A man enjoying himself with drink and song, and the crew goes "there is something seriously legitimately wrong with this man", it's pretty funny really.
It's the one where Picard is trapped in a room with 3 aliens and they're being tested like lab rats with puzzles. That's probably the more memorable story line from the episode. The "Picard" seen in this clip is a replacement they left to experiment on the crew and see how far they will listen to authority.
I wished the writers allowed greater "fraternazation" between the Captain and members of the senior staff.. for example, a Tuesday breakfast with Dr. Crusher. Or, an occasional chess game with Data.
@erikseidler793 I can understand why he acted that way. Sometimes knowing or interacting less with somebody, makes it easier to make the toughest decisions-- such as having Riker go on a suicide mission
There is something interesting about a Scotsman, playing a Frenchman, singing an English song commemorating the victory over the French at Trafalgar (and is the march past for the RN, RCN, RAN and RNZN.) 🙂
Picard is acting MAD sus. I think he might be an imposter. To be fair though, randomly asking the officers to start singing sea shanties seems to have sold his disguise to a lot of them.
Data be like "Wile i understand Picard knows these songs. To randomly sing with the crew, is something iv never imagined hed do. But deny his Earl Gray? Oh no" XD
Efficiency drills for the first time in his tour of duty? They've never run an effciency drill before? And the captain ordering one is cause for concern about his mental wellbeing... I suppose Starfleet is not meant be a miltary, and "drills" are something that militaries do. I wonder if they do fire drills. Or is that too "military".
It's possible that he never felt the need to do so because the Enterprise keeps running into real emergencies. He might just read the reports and come to the conclusion that they were at peak efficiency in these emergencies, so doesn't see a reason to add drills on top of that. The drill itself wouldn't be concerning, nor would the toast or the poker game. Not really, anyways. It's all of them happening at once that raises eyebrows.
Picard already had his Youth XD The man we respect is so dignified he might drop dead at the thought of bursting into random song XD Hes like a Vulcan XD
Captain Picard: for once in my life, I’m gonna get out there, sing some jolly songs and hit on that sexy doctor. Riker and company: that’s not our Captain.
Aliens: we made a replica of you that is so perfect he can pass as you with no problems more or less Picard replica: doesn’t know that the ales come out of the hole in the wall for free
I may have forgotten some details, since the last time i saw this episode was more than 20 years ago, but I wonder how those aliens, who were interested in the culture and behaviour of other species, allready knew so much about the federation and mankind to be able to act in a way which would disturb the crew so much. One would think that they would believe that acting strange for the captain would be to drink coffee instead of earl gray, and start to scratch his nose frequently.
"Here's to the finest crew in Starfleet!" (music starts playing) o/" Captain Jean Luc Picard of the U S S Enterprise (Make-ma-ma-ma-make it so. Make it so.)... o/"
The Original Series was always a western with the veneer of being a sci-fi. The Enterprise was always exploring the “untamed lands”, which could be clearly linked thematically to the Wild West. Moments like this make me think that TNG was supposed to be something along the line of a civilized Royal British Navy show, but in space. There are a surprisingly large number of times that someone on this show breaks out into the sort of drinking song that would be sang by stuffy British naval officers on a wooden sailing ship in the 18th century. Even all the way up to Star Trek: Insurrection.
Worf does a good job reminding everyone that this discussion, while justified, still doesn't green light removal of the Captain. This show is a great example of military matters, interactions and relationships.
So many mind control episodes . . . You would think the bridge crew would establish a "Hey, If I am getting weird, ask me into the conference room and ask me for my level 2 security code". Diana should have told Picard about this conference. The alien is like "Dude they really trust this guy I am 30 minutes away from killing everyone . . . and they are still "OK boss" . . .weird"
0:06 I would suspect it is the remaster that made this warp exit starfield effect look so crappy. It is lacking any filtering, looking too crisp. _"Ales for everyone!"_ - Wow, the captain is so generous. How much energy it must cost to replicate that. 😜 (Surely it is not real alcohol in those, so also not some exception while on duty.) 1:30 *Engage!* 😁 1:41 Wow, so that *is' real ale, and it went to his head reeeal quick. 😄 But great that someone reminded of the unusual energy activity in his quarters. That should have been a tremendously relevant clue all-along. They could even have asked him about it.
Picard has dinner with an old flame. Picard visits the ship's bar: "Ale's for everyone! What shall we sing?" His officers: We need to overthrow this guy but do we put him in the brig? Or just put him in his quarters with an armed guard out of courtesy?"
The engines were running at 96% efficiency for the first time. Ale was apparently now free in a moneyless society, and the Captain sang to the crew. Riker: fuck this, that’s not Captain Picard.
"Ales for everyone!"
That one guy: "WHOA!"
His friend: "You know you can get them for free anytime, right?"
"But I don't like ale... 😔"
Half the people in ten forward pretending to enjoy ale because the captain 'bought' the house a round. 😁
@@dogkungfu8510 You know there's some dude in there whispering "Should we tell him nobody drinks ale anymore?" And his friend is like "Shut up! Free booze." And then the third friend is like: "Somebody wanna tell this guy?"
@@dogkungfu8510 - But you DO like beans, right? 😆
@@stevengalloway8052 instead of serving Worf's brother caviar with his replicated burned birdflesh I would have served it with beans beans beans...
beans beans beans!
@@dogkungfu8510 - YES!! IT'S THE BEANS!!! 😆
Here is a tip. If you are mascaradeing as a French Captain singing the marching song of the British Royal Navy is a bit of a giveaway!
_Tea, Earl Grey, hot._
etc.
Assuming anyone in the lounge would be able to tell the difference between a French song and an English song lol
@@barnabusdoyle4930if star fleet education is to be believed that's preschool learning
@@DRKLCNS1"An obscure language known as French."
@@Riley_Mundt "*Mr. Data*, the French Language for centuries, on Earth, represented civilization"
So... it’s not such a generous gesture to order ales for everybody... when it’s all free lol.
😂😂😂
Exactly and let's be honest, beer is usually on special so he "bought" them cheap drinks.
they still have replicator rationioning I'm sure haha - I seriously doubt a fresh cadet would be allowed to order unlimited beers
What's even better is that there's an appreciative murmur from the room after he does it. (and one random guy saying "thank you captain!")
@@stonem0013 It's not actual beer anyway, so why not?
Why do I get the feeling Patrick Stewart just wasn't given the script for this episode, And this is just him being himself while the cameras are rolling?
There is one example of that that I know off. In The Most Toys the script just had a note to insert a Shakespeare quote.
@@danielyeshe " he was a man, taken for all in all; i shall not lookup his likeness again"
@@ghostrider-be9ek his like
Of all the Sr staff, Riker is the only one who's been through an actual mutiny, so he was being very cautious in this scene to not replicate that scenario, knowing that it could get everyone killed.
Never thought about that but very spot on. His experiences as helmsman on the Pegasus taught him just how ugly that could go.
Also, although I can see why Worf, as a Security Office, would immediately see gathering confederates as a move towards mutiny, Riker, who wrestling with removing his captain from command (not mutiny), understandably wants to make sure he's not overreacting or overreaching, and confers with fellow officers to get their perspectives on the situation... which looks and has to feel a lot like mutiny, regardless.
Also, the eventual hearing could get awkward:
_Why did you commit mutiny?_
- _Well, you see, the captain was giving ale for everyone and singing songs with us. ..._
Given the Pegasus episode was still years away, I doubt they'd written that particular bit of Riker's backstory yet.
@@AdmiralKarelia Definitely not, but it still fits very well in terms of the lore.
Picard: *Starts to sing merrily with his men*
Me: Blast that fricken thing out the airlock
Alien Picard is kind of a wildman. Boozing, singing, socialising and trying to bed hot redheads. Legend!
Maybe he's drunk on being human?
Nothing wrong with try to bed Mrs crusher....👍
"trying" ?
It's what the creators originally wanted the "next Kirk" in TNG to be like
@@CS-zn6pp Hey, I'd give her *my* Captain's Log!
Data being so insightful here as usual. He mentions their only piece of hard evidence, the energy reading the sensors recorded in the Captain's quarters.
That clue should have been on their minds all the time.
And everyone ignores his comment.
Yup. As usual, Data is the only one thinking logically.
You know, since alien possession/mind control/replacement is the most common scenario in Star Trek, Starfleet probably should create a procederem to deal with it.
Picard: Has fun for five minutes.
Crew: Mutiny!!!
Underrated comment. 😂
@@bingeMAFIA
Haha I know he was cloned and replaced in that episode, but it's funny that the crew is so concerned by him having fun.
@@We_Are_Borg_478 The man brought a book to Risa! Would be my counter argument for Picard having fun. I forgot about this episode, I'm going to rewatch it. 😁
@@bingeMAFIA
If memory serves, it's the one with the two aliens that capture picard with the beast creature and the starfleet girl and the wimpy alien and they have to co exist while the imposter picard continues to put the crew in danger to see how far they will go in following orders.
Then picard captures them with the force field to demonstrate how much captivity sucks.
It's crazy how the command crew find Picard's sudden change in demeanor almost mutiny-worthy while the rest of the crew in the lower decks don't notice or don't care.
It would have been kind of scary to be there singing along with the captain, then turn to look at the redshirt table to see subdued looks of horror being shared with each other.
The story seems to be adapted from one of the Hornblower stories. Rather than being an alien, the captain has some kind of personality disorder like paranoid schizophrenia, and the gist is that the captain gets the crew on his side by lavishing them with booze and leisure time, because he's convinced his officers are plotting to kill him. Ironically the brutality he shows against the officers encourages them to mutiny.
The lower deck crew doesn't interact with the captain directly on a day to day basis, unlike the senior officers and bridge crew. They don't have the context about the captain to know that something is really out of the ordinary. From their perspective, Captain is just being jovial for some reason.
At some point you would think the TNG crew would start to expect that people have been possessed by aliens or whatever when they are acting differently.
@@afaultytoaster Lt. Hornblower, to be specific. The situation is resolved when the Captain just happens to fall down some stairs and become invalided.
We never find out if he was pushed.
The look of concern on Worf’s face when Picard suggests they sing 😂
beans for everyone
I’m in!
And beans to you
Such calming advice for such a tense scene...
Ordering free stuff for the whole room is gonna be my signature move.
Imagine being a guest and exclaiming "Drinks are on the house!". 😄
*walks into a McDonald's*
"KETCHUP PACKETS FOR EVERYONE!!!"
*grabs big box of ketchup packets and begins tossing them at people*
I'm from Yorkshire. It's standard procedure.
"Ales for everyone!"
everyone: uh, we have replicators, our drinks are free anyway. Wtf? Do I have to drink this shit?
I guess he's basically saying 'break out the real alcoholic stuff you keep behind the bar'. The replicated stuff isn't very alcoholic.
@@smartalec2001 Not according to the episode where Worf has the replicator replicate Blood Wine for the alcoholic Irishman from the low-tech colony whose sun was going crazy and had to be evac'd to the colony of clones experiencing replication failure. The man was quite pleased with the drink as I recall.
@@imonlyamanandiwilldiesomed4406 isn't there one where Scotty from the original series is complaining how weak the drink is, and they find him some proper booze behind the counter?
@@smartalec2001 Pretty sure he and the Irishman had the same complaint. I wonder if the typical drinks are synthesized with relatively less alcohol content? I bet a crafty engineer could create new or alter old recipes ;)
@@imonlyamanandiwilldiesomed4406 that was not blood wine. Chech'tluth is a smoking beverage that has no syntheol equivalent
Worf: "IT IS NOT ENOUGH EVIDENCE TO JUSTIFY MUTINY"
Damn Worf, talk about a denial conclusion right there.
I’m shocked at just how much of this series I don’t recall at all.
Your brain is trying to encourage you to watch it again.
Get to relive it again.
When Picard is sus
He is wearing red… 🤔
Aborgus
@@SageRap Yes the command uniform. So?
@@LordTalax It's a meme from Among Us, that the red player is sus
As much as I respect the tactically brilliant and stuffy britches & reserved Picard....
Quite frankly, the poker playing, ale buying (ahem) lounge singing Picard would be a hell of a lot more fun to explore deep space with. If the replicant's mission commands weren't so dangerously absurd, the crew might have chosen to keep him instead. 😉
You don't understand Picard's psychology at all. Picard acts cold and aloof to hide his passionate and emotional nature. We see that all the time, outbursts of passionate emotion when he loses his iron self-control: "The line must be drawn HERE! This far! No farther!"
It's in fact the entire reason he chose Riker as his XO. They are polar opposites. Where Picard hides his romantic heart under a layer of cool officiousness, Riker is everyone's best friend and a party animal -- to hide his _true_ nature of cold ruthlessness. We see the real Riker in Thomas, the man he would have become without Picard's influence. Both men learn from each other over the course of the series, with Picard learning how to let a little of his feelings show and Riker learning how to feel a little compassion for people.
@@NoJusticeNoPeace Movie Picard is different from TNG Picard
@@yourstruly4817 I never felt that Movie Picard behaved out of character with respect to TNG Picard. Maybe he was more emotional, but he was also dealing with much more emotional situations than he usually did in TNG.
Or, how about *"THERE ARE FOUR LIGHTS!"*
This is how I imagine the Picard who commanded the Stargazer to be. Smaller ship, smaller more intimate crew, younger brasher captain. I think Picard recruited Riker because Riker reminded him of himself as he once was.
'Ales for everyone' - I'm assuming that's telling the bar to break out their small supply of real alcohol rather than the non-alcoholic replicated stuff. The stuff reserved for special occasions.
Ah. Romulan Ale, then. 🍻
It would have to be for the scene to make sense.
But it was weird how quickly they got them ready.
It being real alcohol would explain his behavior, though, haha. ... If he got a really fast metabolism and hasn't had real alcohol for ages.
@@Dowlphinhe had Guinan stash a bunch
Like the green stuff?
there is only ONE reason for mutiny... not enough beans
I take my rations seriously.
Or TOO MANY beans.
@@artman2oo3 never too many beans
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
bean gang woop woop
Troi: “and he was very odd with me afterwards…” 😂😂😂
"Show me your thingies"
-Captain Beavis Picard
Despite being from France, singing an official Royal Navy song is one of the more British things Picard did until he led Worf and Data to sing A British Tar.
He's having fun! That's not the captain I know!
Picard had his Youth XD
The man we respect is more dignified then thrill seeking
Memory is a funny phenomenon;
This song; O'Brien's _The Minstrel Boy;_ and Lore's _Abdul Abulbul Amir_ will suddenly pop into my head at random, and _Star Trek: The Next Generation_ is my only source, thirty years ago.
Better relieve that wackadoodle of command, because he's lost his mind. Perhaps he's going to the pulsar to find it?
Only the second time thats happened XD
Giving a round of drinks to everyone in the bar kind of loses its meaning when everything's free lmao
And alcohol free too.
“Ale’s for everyone!” Sir, they are free….
no they are not. they are rationed or are paid with credits
@@toomanyaccounts they did away with financial compensation, by the time Kirk came around
@@jimmesser4412 wrong. TOS has several references that they were paid, that it took money to build the enterprise. how could Mudd be charged with counterfeiting currency if it didn't exist.
@@toomanyaccounts there’s no money or rationing in TNG youve got it all wrong
@@tonoornottono yet episodes, movies, novels, games outright state otherwise.
Why was there gratitude when Picard said 'Ales for Everyone!'. It is just from the replicator, it is not as though he has to buy it with money.
Don't the crew have a limited amount of replicator credits?
@@mhelvens Not on the Enterprise.
i have plenty of money to buy my own drinks, to have my commander make such a guesture to my co-workers+i, has value above all scarcity.
@@YD-uq5fi that's what I thought; the absence of want or need.
@@mhelvens
Replicator credits!? XD
Literally anyone anywhere can replicate as much food or drink as they want. Yes, there are some limitation in place; like everything from a replicator is nutritionally balanced and it wont let you replicate real alcohol (though, anyone with technical expertise would be able to modify a replicator...).
The time replicators actually had rations was when Voyager was flung out into the Delta quadrant and energy used for replication came at a premium.
Picard: What ales you
4:10 "Nobody has suggested removing the captain from command."
Correct, but you're meeting in secret trying to determine whether there is a certain condition that would justify mutiny.
I get it's not an easy argument but you were all thinking that, one way or another.
Bahahahahaha that one belated “Thank you, Captain!”
Picard wanted to get some space buns from Dr. Crusher...
Watching Star Ttek Picard was like watching a whole season-full of watching whoever this guy/Picard is. Riker’s right “This is different, _he’s different_ I can’t put my finger on it, but I’m worried… That’s not the captain _I_ know…” Yeahhhhh
Thanks ! i love these short and well written Discussion scene.
i am used to watch Star Trek with japanese dub and subtitles,
and rarely heard the original voice much.
These your clips helps me to re-visit Star Trek with original Voice, looks refleshing for me.
How do you perceive the original vs. the dubbed?
Is the dubbing industry in Japan kinda 'underdeveloped', too?`
I can say that in Germany the range is wide and usually you need a really decent budget to get proper dubbing. Animated dubs tend to be worst, because voice acting often isn't so much acting as making-funny-voices.
There are a few instances, though, where the German dubbing is actually arguably better than the original. The first Star Wars movies, for example. - And although I might be biased because I grew up watching Saber Rider in German, I would say that, too, sounds a lot better in German than in English. Adds so much distinct character.
@@Dowlphin First, i am the guy who watch anything with JP dubbed with JP subtitles with my eyes and ears. (cause it will tell me more information).
i think JP dubbed is par with or better than original . especialy male voice acting.
(But female voice acting, original voice is good and strong than dubbed voice).
in my opinion, Most Moveis, Shows and Animes will be dubbed well in japanese.
Because the voice acting industry in japan is really big and has many good actors.
(Especially, low tone heavy male voice).
Star Trek (TNG to ENT) has got with Top Tier voice actores.
P.S.
You can check How japanese voice actors are.
Check comparison video like
"Adventure Time" OP in any language.
and Lemongrab screaming (lemon guy)
in any language. you see japanese actors doing well.
I would 100% watch TNG dubbed in Japanese!
0:18 - THATS NOT RIKER. He sat down normally!
1/2 impulse to the beans pulsar
Grandma's secret recipe baked beans is in there
shouldve bought everyone a round of beanz :D
That is the best Patrick Stewart acting ever!
I love these videos! I enjoy them so much, I went to my kitchen and warmed up a can of beans! Peace!
1:28
CAPTAIN
JEAN-LUC PICARD
OF THE USS
ENTERPRISE
I suspect that Patrick Stewart enjoyed shooting that Ten Forward scene.
Picard: Ales for everyone!
Riker: You never drink ale. You only drink Earl Grey.
I do like how Picard floats around and there's a table of dudes who have joined in singing. Nobody else, just 3/4 of the ship's barbershop quartet chilling and discussing their next lineup
The next time we hear Picard singing is in Insurrection to jolt Data from whatever was going on with him
Data befriended a little boy and the crew was all “oh shit, we’d better pay the family and have them sign an NDA”
He does a little dance in his quarters as they are all de-aged
He said “ale” not “synthale”. Hence, he ordered real beer for everyone.
i'm hanging on the edge of my seat for the next episode
A man enjoying himself with drink and song, and the crew goes "there is something seriously legitimately wrong with this man", it's pretty funny really.
You do know what _normal_ Picard is like, right?
I watched this show religiously in college. I own in some format every episode. I cannot for the life of me remember this episode. What is the title?
Allegiance (details in the descriptions)
Allegiance. The real Picard has been kidnapped.
It's the one where Picard is trapped in a room with 3 aliens and they're being tested like lab rats with puzzles. That's probably the more memorable story line from the episode. The "Picard" seen in this clip is a replacement they left to experiment on the crew and see how far they will listen to authority.
I wished the writers allowed greater "fraternazation" between the Captain and members of the senior staff.. for example, a Tuesday breakfast with Dr. Crusher. Or, an occasional chess game with Data.
It makes it all the sweeter, though, when he finally joins the poker game in the series finale.
He just wasn't that kind of Captain, every other Captain bonded with their staff on some level.
@erikseidler793 I can understand why he acted that way. Sometimes knowing or interacting less with somebody, makes it easier to make the toughest decisions-- such as having Riker go on a suicide mission
That’s not enough reason for mutiny!
He’s forbidden the preparation, consumption, or discussion of beans…
MUTINY!!!!
"Nobody has suggested removing the Captain from command!"
....
"Well, he did make a pass at me once."
"We need to remove the Captain from command!"
This comment gave me a grin....a *major* grin.
"Except Wesley, he gets water."
Shut up Wesley
He should have said it and fooled everyone but Data XD
There is something interesting about a Scotsman, playing a Frenchman, singing an English song commemorating the victory over the French at Trafalgar (and is the march past for the RN, RCN, RAN and RNZN.) 🙂
what gave him away was that he didn't sing Wellermann
I have no idea how any of them kept a straight face while filming this 😂🤣
Picard happy? Damn, that's not him.
Hes france there only happy when drunk
"Ales for everyone!" "Sir everything is free, if i wanted one i would have ordered it"
Oh God, this is one of the greatest pieces of TV history ever
Picard is acting MAD sus. I think he might be an imposter. To be fair though, randomly asking the officers to start singing sea shanties seems to have sold his disguise to a lot of them.
Data be like
"Wile i understand Picard knows these songs. To randomly sing with the crew, is something iv never imagined hed do. But deny his Earl Gray? Oh no" XD
A post-scarcity intergalactic federation, powered by anti-matter engines capable of actual miracles, and he thinks "I'm buying" makes him a hero?
"Ale's for everyone!" Wow what a big spender since nobody has to ever pay.
"Ales for everyone"
That's a Captain I would like to have :=D
Efficiency drills for the first time in his tour of duty? They've never run an effciency drill before? And the captain ordering one is cause for concern about his mental wellbeing... I suppose Starfleet is not meant be a miltary, and "drills" are something that militaries do. I wonder if they do fire drills. Or is that too "military".
It's possible that he never felt the need to do so because the Enterprise keeps running into real emergencies. He might just read the reports and come to the conclusion that they were at peak efficiency in these emergencies, so doesn't see a reason to add drills on top of that.
The drill itself wouldn't be concerning, nor would the toast or the poker game. Not really, anyways. It's all of them happening at once that raises eyebrows.
The best way to keep a classic car nice is keep the miles off it
For a space ship, id imagine slow and steady is the answer to prolonged life
Riker you toad, that is ~absolutely~ something Picard would've done, back in his Academy days. Picard is the most British Frenchman who ever lived!
Picard already had his Youth XD
The man we respect is so dignified he might drop dead at the thought of bursting into random song XD Hes like a Vulcan XD
Funny how everyone ELSE besides the senior staff knew the words.
It's funny, buying a round for everyone means a whole lot less when the drinks are created from thin air.
And it's not like you'd have to pay anyway. No currency and all that.
I imagine there's a limit per day and such
I bet Stewart had fun doing that scene 🤣
Riker: Nobody has suggested removing the Captain from command..
Worf: (dangit)
Picard: Finally fraternizes with the crew
Senior Staff: "So there's obviously something wrong with the captain"
I'm stunned that more than one guy in there knew that little sea-shanty
Captain Picard: for once in my life, I’m gonna get out there, sing some jolly songs and hit on that sexy doctor.
Riker and company: that’s not our Captain.
Aliens: we made a replica of you that is so perfect he can pass as you with no problems more or less
Picard replica: doesn’t know that the ales come out of the hole in the wall for free
mutiny no happy yes
he bought drinks for everyone
and hang out with the Crew
I may have forgotten some details, since the last time i saw this episode was more than 20 years ago, but I wonder how those aliens, who were interested in the culture and behaviour of other species, allready knew so much about the federation and mankind to be able to act in a way which would disturb the crew so much. One would think that they would believe that acting strange for the captain would be to drink coffee instead of earl gray, and start to scratch his nose frequently.
they were testing the crews loyalty.
"Here's to the finest crew in Starfleet!" (music starts playing) o/" Captain Jean Luc Picard of the U S S Enterprise (Make-ma-ma-ma-make it so. Make it so.)... o/"
Poor Captain Picard, can't even relax a little without the crew committing mutiny.
The Original Series was always a western with the veneer of being a sci-fi. The Enterprise was always exploring the “untamed lands”, which could be clearly linked thematically to the Wild West.
Moments like this make me think that TNG was supposed to be something along the line of a civilized Royal British Navy show, but in space. There are a surprisingly large number of times that someone on this show breaks out into the sort of drinking song that would be sang by stuffy British naval officers on a wooden sailing ship in the 18th century. Even all the way up to Star Trek: Insurrection.
Worf does a good job reminding everyone that this discussion, while justified, still doesn't green light removal of the Captain. This show is a great example of military matters, interactions and relationships.
“Ales for everybody!”
“Wow…more free synthahol…thanks.”
Picard being complimentary around 1:10 is definitely a sign that something was off.
At 2:25, the rare Riker facepalm.
They were so good of actors when I first watched this episode I picked up at this scene and I was skeptical it wasn’t him with them lol
So many mind control episodes . . .
You would think the bridge crew would establish a "Hey, If I am getting weird, ask me into the conference room and ask me for my level 2 security code".
Diana should have told Picard about this conference.
The alien is like "Dude they really trust this guy I am 30 minutes away from killing everyone . . . and they are still "OK boss" . . .weird"
Picard joined the poker game. Blows "All Good Things" out of the water.
As usual, the writers simple forget about Deanna’s powers and skills.
Giving the crew free drinks loses quite a bit when there's no money.
They get the WASP men to start singing the drinking songs (maybe minus the dark haired one)... nobody else had a clue about the words.
0:06 I would suspect it is the remaster that made this warp exit starfield effect look so crappy. It is lacking any filtering, looking too crisp.
_"Ales for everyone!"_ - Wow, the captain is so generous. How much energy it must cost to replicate that. 😜 (Surely it is not real alcohol in those, so also not some exception while on duty.)
1:30 *Engage!* 😁
1:41 Wow, so that *is' real ale, and it went to his head reeeal quick. 😄
But great that someone reminded of the unusual energy activity in his quarters. That should have been a tremendously relevant clue all-along. They could even have asked him about it.
I love this channel
So in a future where replicators exist, how does "ales FOR EVERYONE" excite anyone?
Damn id fear having a crew think mutiny so fast😮
I can't unhear Pogo's song when I watch this scene.
Stewart really loved the script in this episode.
"ALES FOR EVERYONE!"
"But it's- *gets elbowed*
"*whispers*Shut up, man..the boss man is letting us drink on the clock *loud voice* HERE HERE!"
Drinks are free and the Captain buys a round.
Picard has dinner with an old flame. Picard visits the ship's bar: "Ale's for everyone! What shall we sing?"
His officers: We need to overthrow this guy but do we put him in the brig? Or just put him in his quarters with an armed guard out of courtesy?"
I like the idea that this is just Picard having a good time and the crew doesn't know how read the situation
"Ales for everyone!" ummmm sir, you know they're free?
The engines were running at 96% efficiency for the first time. Ale was apparently now free in a moneyless society, and the Captain sang to the crew.
Riker: fuck this, that’s not Captain Picard.