My question is if the afganistan that the United states trained for 20 yrs, why were they joining the Taliban?? Not all but alot did?? United states allies are mad at us, but if it wasn't working there why keep trying?? I realize it was alot of money and people died, why did we stay there?? Plus in Vietnam we left in 1975, how can you help other countries if they don't want help??
@@jenniferpoland8886 maybe they’re were intrigued by the Talibans ideology? Idk. Back in the Vietnam war, the NVA and the Vietcongs uses a lot of techniques to rally more men to join them, going as far as starving the families who refused to join infusing communist ideology into peoples lives and deliberately spread misinformation about the US and the South Vietnamese government. Maybe the Taliban did something similar? It’ll be unfolded.
JOe Biden promised that this will never happen and Vietnam and Afghanistan departure is not comparable. He did the impossible - he made Trump look like a colossal politician....
Actually the core value of communism in east Asia wasn’t about communism but nationalism-reunite the country at all costs, erase foreign influence at all costs.
@Burning Bird Vietnam just donated 200,000 masks for US medical staffs. In return, US grants Vietnam 9.5 million to fight Covid-19, way more than WHO has ever provided for Vietnam.
US killed Osama bin laden but just because the Afghan government failed after 20 years of support and 2 trillions people wanna say US failed. Just look at Afghan army training on youtube
They didn’t lose they leave because there no point to stay there forever, it’s too expensive to stay there. Everything was peace until America leave that’s proof America didn’t loose the war, use your brain, and stop criticizing American.
@@ripley2229 so. The Americans left Afghanistan beacause they couldn’t fight some people with bad training and even worse trigger finger. Even tho they have the most advanced army in the world with over 15 trillion dollars of tax payer money?
2:00 Here you see the contrast between the South Vietnamese, and the Afghan Army. The ARVN were outnumbered, undersupplied against an enemy with tanks and an air force. Even when the Americans abandoned them, they still fought till the bitter end. The Afghan Army was ten times the size of the Taliban, and possessed tanks, and an Air Force. Yet they put up zero resistance. The Taliban simply walked into every major city uncontested.
acturely no, if they are undersupplied, north vietnamese force wouldnt be so strong after the war , with a buch of US equipment, they are not poor, but low fighting will
@@erwin9065 actually the Afghan army did for some time…since 2014 the Afghan army has been fighting the Taliban pretty much entirely (losing over 50,000 soldiers in that timeframe) with the US providing Intelligence and Air Support.
@@erwin9065 btw. My parents left Saigon that morning with the US withdrawal. My cousins and Uncles didn’t get out and ended up going to Prison for the next 10-16yrs. My Uncle did 16 yrs in the re-education camp as he was Colonel (Đại tá) during the war.
Better than Venezuela and Cuba economy-wise🤷🏻♀️. Poorly performed democracy is still totalitarianism. Same reason why North Korea has a “democratic” election. Vietnam is doing well because the Communist government basically exploit the Southern provinces. More than 2/3 the National GDP comes from 4 Southern provinces, yet the money is distributed largely to the North.
Transition of democratic society cannot be forced. When will they learn this. When democratic value is forced, they're no longer a democratic value, just an authoritarian secularism value
My parents fled Vietnam many years ago. I don't know how my mom ended up in Luxembourg, but I know how my dad escaped from the Vietnam War to get into America while his brothers and sister went to Germany. Wartime was scary for both of my parents.
@Teh Chuan so you are saying that 50k people who fled worked for the US? no, the people who worked for the US is just some of the people who fled the country.
0:44 Those tanks were actually North Vietnamese T-54s damaged during the battle (you can see the gold star insignia of Vietnamese People's Army), not of the Saigon military
You have to be at least born in 1960s to witness such thing. I am just glad that i was born in the peaceful time. Hope peace will finally exist in Afghanistan.
That's not the US Embassy in the beginning of the video. That's a building a few blocks away. It's still standing in Saigon but kinda hard to find. And that wasn't the last flight out. The last flight was airlifting the remaining embassy security platoon.
With the exception of the contractors and wealthy elite who made millions and maybe even billions off the Afghan war. There's always a winner and it's typically not who you'd think. People made a lot of money the past 20 years.
Idk why people think taliban and vietcong are similar they arent Vietcong fought while all taliban did was to hide in caves and wait for americans go Vietnamese knew what to do after winning and they established todays vietnam which is progressing country Taliban doesnt even know how to run a country they couldnt even make a constitution by their own implementing 7 ad laws in in modern day pathetic idiots Taliban are just bunch of rbels all they know was rebelion they dont know how to rule or run a country
Japan during WW2 gave these Asian countries the idea that European and American colonizers are not invincible and can be kicked out of their territories. The colonizer's attempts to reestablish control after WW2 was a complete disaster.
For Vietnam it was the battle of Dien Bien Phu which did it. Japanese during WW2 are no different than European colonizers, if not worse, in term of countless heinous war crimes committed.
Not really. Man is the one repeating history. History wouldn't have done it the first time much less the second time. Both instances were a direct result of mans actions. Makes you wonder about mankind and in these two cases Americans.
If South Vietnam survived it would have been a highly developed highly advanced nation essentially the little brother of South Korea. The only reason Vietnam adopted capitalism is because of the fall of the USSR and the rise of China.
My family is the South Vietnamese who supports the North Vietnam in the past, I remember the stories my grandmother told much about her times, the Americans just really showing to us as another invader, but after the war, we shows forgiveness if they willing to let go the past of hateness, learn our mistakes and never made another one again in the future but after Afghanistan War, they really haven't learned their's lessons it seems and still showing hated to the countries that they never stepped a foot in before
My mom and my aunt were wandering around the neighborhood, and they were grabbed to the helicopter by some soldiers. Those soldiers thought that my mom and my aunt were lost. They tried to evacuate everyone in the area. My aunt and my mom were inside and confused, and then she told a staff that she wanted to go home with parents. They let my mom and my aunt go. It was an unforgettable memory about that day. She was a little kid back then.
After seeing what is happening in Afghan, I feel happy for Vietnam people today. They are on the right track of development, with GDP per capita 3500 USD, though it is still developing and not rich, it is much better than the 1980s when they had the poorest earnings due to the war. Wishes from China.
@takachi China had historical relation with Vietnam.The Chinese people also helped Vietnam in 13th century when Mongols invaded Vietnam & both took part in the war.
But there is a big difference in the Middle East. Afghanistan will be dragged into Iran and Saudi Arabia feud, the support to setup a stable government is unstable and historically Middle East thrives on religious regime, in which some laws goes 100% against humanitarian system hence they don’t garner stable backing. Vietnam success in growth is also mainly due to china being its neighbour, whether Vietnamese accept it or not, it’s a given fact. There are border disputes, some feuds but the Vietnam policy of privatisation which saved its economy is mainly due to private Chinese investment. And sadly I can’t see it happening in Afghanistan, although the world is more global and support is so much easier to provide, the clashing beliefs and local laws hinder the growth. Ultimately the citizens will suffer while the top dogs who sets up for power and riches will enjoy their luxury until death.
I cried everytime when i've been in saigon (vietnam war museum) to witness the cruelty and inhuman act of US soldiers. They using all biological weapons towards Vietnam people
open your eyes USA. American politicians and generals should read the following books: Mao Zedong's On Guerrilla War Mao Zedong's On Protracted War Sun Tzu's Art of War No amount of military hardware or special force training will ever defeat a highly organized and politically-zealous enemy. While the US armed forces is apolitical; the armed forces of the Chinese, Russian, Cubans, Vietnam, are politically indoctrinated and their loyalty are tested even before they learn how to fire a gun or rifle. America didn't learn her lesson in Vietnam; America didn't understood itself and forgotten that the US Armed Forces was born out of a revolutionary group. America focused too much on technology and special forces rather than on national strategy. America's military is metric-driven and not driven by strategy on the top.
Actually much worse because there were no plans for the Afghans like there was for the south Vietnamese. There was a lot of covert operations in Vietnam planning for the swift exodus of south Vietnamese unlike the zero planned exodus for Afghans.
@@semperfi6801 That's true, but I do see some similarities between Kabul and Saigon and how they were captured by the enemy the US was helping them fight. The two most important to me are: the corruption of the goverment(for what I have read) and the ineptitude of the army.
@@nestorechevers7263 as well as the army not getting paid. They abandoned their posts. When afghan officials were asked about it they simply said "the people who ran away were put back to their position".
@@semperfi6801 Yes, it was planed to let the South Vietnamese seize an American ship, it was planned to have no room for rescue helicopters, we planned to leave many of those that worked for us behind to be captured, very well planned chaos, we bungled the whole thing on purpose.
My uncles from my mom’s side fled by cramming onto a fishing boat. They were one of the lucky boats that didn’t run into any pirates and were able to get to a refugee camp in the Philippines before coming to the US. My dad’s grandpa, who fought for the ARVN was imprisoned after the war and spend 9 years in a labor camp. Afterwards he and my dad would work on getting their visas to come to the US. after 13 years, they were finally granted their visas and were able to come to the US by plane.
I believe you guys need to re-check that. The helicopter was apparently a CIA helicopter leaving from one of their sites - not the military helicopters leaving from the embassy.
@Daood Zafar yes the mainstream media is full of fake news. only people who have no clue would believe that building is the embassy. Looks nothing like it.
Knew a Canada born Vietnamese back in students date, his dad was among the South Vietnamese soldiers fought till the last day, then headed straight to the refugees boat
USA not lost... they withdraw the troop back because there were political in America back in 1970s. People protest in USA to stop Viet Nam war... USA could easily bomb north Viet Nam like JApan, but they choose not to...no one can beat USA that time beside Soviet. USA abandoned south vietnam for some reasons. HOw can you fight against aircraft and machine gun on the sky.
@Cardinal RG I dont record they have navy and air force. you probably mistake in the moview or something. second, they ak 47 was support by the soviet union... if american want, they could massacre the north just like hiroshima and nagasaki, and they are capable doing so. Viet nam war is not a war because the US congress never declare war with Viet Nam. This fight took place in viet nam for the cold war of Soviet and US.
@@noblegendforever2052 Of course the USSR gave equipment and supported Vietnam with some help from China too but what is important is the Vietnamese people who bled for their liberation
By the time Saigon fell most Americans had already been evacuated out of the rest of Vietnam. With Kabul Biden just left them scattered throughout Afghanistan.
It actually started with the French. If the US had gone ahead and given Vietnam it's independence after WW II instead of handing them back to the French, the Vietnam War would've never happened.
They went to re-education camp if they worked for the U.S. My family’s assets were taken and was forced out of our home. My grandpa went to re-education camp for years. That’s what happened to most families in the South. Many even tried to escape by boats years later or they got sponsored to move to the U.S.
@@mdokpoplover21 taking assets happens in all communist countries because private property doesn't exist. The extra is the re-education camps and potential prosecution I guess... Until you get lucky and escape... What about the officials of the south? I bet not all of them managed to escape on time?
@@nguyenuctrung3814 Nope (do your research before any "Nope"). Those tanks were destroyed by Red Beret Angels. They didn't expect to be ambushed by the last of the force.
the south said they don't have enough guns and ammunation but after vietnam war the north use that same weapons the south use to defeat hkmer rouge and push china out of vietnam borders
Not matter where u ran or planning to live there will always be corruption. Just some place is less than other while some place hide it better than other.
lol the Covid-19 proved it all. Only unity in all peoples can do an impressive job fighting back the pandemic. If Vietnam is 'fractured', ask some of actual Vietnamese and see how high or low their morale is to their motherland.
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
“History doesn’t repeat itself but it does rhyme”
Indeed it does.
Now we can feel the similarity in Afghanistan = saigon 2.0
My question is if the afganistan that the United states trained for 20 yrs, why were they joining the Taliban?? Not all but alot did?? United states allies are mad at us, but if it wasn't working there why keep trying?? I realize it was alot of money and people died, why did we stay there?? Plus in Vietnam we left in 1975, how can you help other countries if they don't want help??
Yes it does th-cam.com/users/shortszCIUqUw_pA0?feature=share
@@jenniferpoland8886 maybe they’re were intrigued by the Talibans ideology? Idk. Back in the Vietnam war, the NVA and the Vietcongs uses a lot of techniques to rally more men to join them, going as far as starving the families who refused to join infusing communist ideology into peoples lives and deliberately spread misinformation about the US and the South Vietnamese government. Maybe the Taliban did something similar? It’ll be unfolded.
History does rhyme. Afghan is falling and US' evacuation is in full swing
This is sad”
JOe Biden promised that this will never happen and Vietnam and Afghanistan departure is not comparable. He did the impossible - he made Trump look like a colossal politician....
Little Saigon now have friend
Its Little Kabul
@@ikipemiko but this also bidens either mistake or regret probably regret
@Save meamericans have not friend, they have only own interes
Actually the core value of communism in east Asia wasn’t about communism but nationalism-reunite the country at all costs, erase foreign influence at all costs.
everyone Vietnamese from bothsides want to reunite their country BUT "Under what regime?"is the thing that made this meaningless war happened
So true, Communist revolution in East Asia were more about overthrowing the colonial powers and their local puppet governments than anything else.
@Burning Bird Vietnam just donated 200,000 masks for US medical staffs. In return, US grants Vietnam 9.5 million to fight Covid-19, way more than WHO has ever provided for Vietnam.
@@lucassmith4847 mĩ cc 🖕
@@go2marakesh agreed. and the current Vietnam government is extremely corrupted
US saying Afghanistan is a victory but everything looks like the fall of Saigon.
Yeah true
Wait who tf says it was a Victory?
@@sooryan_1018 Biden and Blinken.
@@theabsolutelygoldenboyofas9812 who is blinken.
US killed Osama bin laden but just because the Afghan government failed after 20 years of support and 2 trillions people wanna say US failed. Just look at Afghan army training on youtube
Fall of kabul . History repeating
@@MaleAnkha exactly
Both involves the Americans
Liberation of Kabul, as viewed from the Taliban perspective
@@magicwiz8416 yes liberation of afghan people
@@magicwiz8416 Both a liberation and an enslavement of afghan people
America is funny. Before the lose, they leave. Then say “We didn’t lose.”
faxxxxxx
They didn’t lose they leave because there no point to stay there forever, it’s too expensive to stay there. Everything was peace until America leave that’s proof America didn’t loose the war, use your brain, and stop criticizing American.
@@ripley2229 'twas a joke
@@ripley2229 in the year 1971
@@ripley2229 so. The Americans left Afghanistan beacause they couldn’t fight some people with bad training and even worse trigger finger. Even tho they have the most advanced army in the world with over 15 trillion dollars of tax payer money?
2066: The 'Fall of Kabul' in 2021, how the news reported it.
2066: Watching the fall of Kabul 2021 as the fall of Washington takes place.
@@basedblackbeard4456 do you know something we dont?
Biden: "The Taliban will never take Kabul.... Now where's my ice cream?"
@@basedblackbeard4456 th-cam.com/video/Sp9gzO1wZt0/w-d-xo.html
I would say I watched it live on the internet. What a moment in history to witness.
2:00 Here you see the contrast between the South Vietnamese, and the Afghan Army. The ARVN were outnumbered, undersupplied against an enemy with tanks and an air force. Even when the Americans abandoned them, they still fought till the bitter end.
The Afghan Army was ten times the size of the Taliban, and possessed tanks, and an Air Force. Yet they put up zero resistance. The Taliban simply walked into every major city uncontested.
acturely no, if they are undersupplied, north vietnamese force wouldnt be so strong after the war , with a buch of US equipment, they are not poor, but low fighting will
@@souvik43209 i dont think i am, my point is that their logistic is bad, not the thing he say
@@vivelarevolution2835 The ARVN fought intensely for quite a while before surrendering to the NVA. The Afghans army didn't resist that much.
@@erwin9065 actually the Afghan army did for some time…since 2014 the Afghan army has been fighting the Taliban pretty much entirely (losing over 50,000 soldiers in that timeframe) with the US providing Intelligence and Air Support.
@@erwin9065 btw. My parents left Saigon that morning with the US withdrawal. My cousins and Uncles didn’t get out and ended up going to Prison for the next 10-16yrs. My Uncle did 16 yrs in the re-education camp as he was Colonel (Đại tá) during the war.
imagine you are standing at the highest end of the ladder than others & the helicopter just left...
maybe its worst, but have you seen afghan cling to an American plane just to escape?
th-cam.com/video/Sp9gzO1wZt0/w-d-xo.html
@@Kaybossboi Reported for spam.
@@Jezzaaa what is the video? I don't want to click the link
@@Fred_the_1996 I don’t recall, but just some spam
The US still denied that fact that they cannot simply overthrow a regime and install new to hope it can lasts long by itself.
They tried working and training the Afghanistan army. They ran from the Taliban.
Or they joined them too
Anime profile pic
Afghan army worse than south vietnamese
shut up weeb
But compared to many "democratic" African and South American countries, Vietnam is doing pretty well today isn't it?
Well they reformed themselves in 90s.
Better than Venezuela and Cuba economy-wise🤷🏻♀️. Poorly performed democracy is still totalitarianism. Same reason why North Korea has a “democratic” election. Vietnam is doing well because the Communist government basically exploit the Southern provinces. More than 2/3
the National GDP comes from 4 Southern provinces, yet the money is distributed largely to the North.
Transition of democratic society cannot be forced. When will they learn this. When democratic value is forced, they're no longer a democratic value, just an authoritarian secularism value
@@tompham1631 same in India
All the money comes from the South and the West but is all donated to the north and the East
@@tompham1631 what do you think of the health care and education in Cuba?
This isn’t even the algorithm at this point. It’s TH-cam saying “wake up”.
The algorithm is so complex it went sentient
My parents fled Vietnam many years ago. I don't know how my mom ended up in Luxembourg, but I know how my dad escaped from the Vietnam War to get into America while his brothers and sister went to Germany. Wartime was scary for both of my parents.
How in the world Luxembourg? That Crazy
So are your parents still together? Were they later re-united?
☭ ☭ ☭ ☭
@S C Refugees more like
@Teh Chuan so you are saying that 50k people who fled worked for the US? no, the people who worked for the US is just some of the people who fled the country.
I like how TH-cam algorithm is recommending Saigon related videos now. It's like adding salt to wound for US. 🤣
0:44 Those tanks were actually North Vietnamese T-54s damaged during the battle (you can see the gold star insignia of Vietnamese People's Army), not of the Saigon military
Even if you fail, what can you do?
I was born in '97 so I did not have a chance to watch it on live telecast...
Now, I have.. And I am watching it..
History does repeat itself
Same I was born in 2005
2003 reporting in
Of course you didn't watch the fall of Saigon, you were born in 97. I'm much older and I didn't even watch the fall of Saigon.
You have to be at least born in 1960s to witness such thing.
I am just glad that i was born in the peaceful time.
Hope peace will finally exist in Afghanistan.
"Those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it."
Biden just ignored everything and let his senile mental health let the situation get to this severity
@@ohdahngboi_2237 mental health?
Thos who knows history will try to repeat it for their benefit
That's not the US Embassy in the beginning of the video. That's a building a few blocks away. It's still standing in Saigon but kinda hard to find. And that wasn't the last flight out. The last flight was airlifting the remaining embassy security platoon.
correct... that was a CIA operation in that video - not the embassy. poor reporting.
My grandfather disappeared during the Vietnam war. Don’t know if he was killed or tortured, he was a pilot. Seeing this brings tears to my eyes.
😔
Bless your grandfather, love from Saigon, Vietnam itself 🇻🇳
He could just stay at home and drink tea you know.
@@lucassmith4847 Hahaha
@@lucassmith4847 that not funny bro
Sadness, for both sides, at the end what we really care is only about our families. Looking at the eyes of the kids makes my heart so empty.
If only their government wasn't corrupt and took steps to being responsible.
@@joshuawaldorf9559 🍼
@@joshuawaldorf9559 The South Vietnamese government highly discriminated against Buddhists.
@@joshuawaldorf9559 "If only the government was corrupt" Ignores the american and ussr interventions.
@@joshuawaldorf9559 Corruption stemming from US money and meddling
The Vietnam war was a disgrace,in the end everybody lost
Actually only the South Vietnamese lost, cuz human life means nothing to the North Vietnamese.
@@erwin9065 same to US
... lol that's a cope. North Vietnam won
Same with the War on Afghanistan. In the end everybody lost.
With the exception of the contractors and wealthy elite who made millions and maybe even billions off the Afghan war. There's always a winner and it's typically not who you'd think. People made a lot of money the past 20 years.
The fall of kabul is the perfect memorial to the the fall of Saigon.
No, it's worse.
That helicopter wasn't taking off from the American Embassy. That was a different government building.
The CIA building
and now it a coffee building
@@hungle-is6cc Coffee much better than CIA
Taliban has proved that you can defeat any mighty military force with will , courage... history repeated again
*Cough! cough!*
Idk why people think taliban and vietcong are similar they arent
Vietcong fought while all taliban did was to hide in caves and wait for americans go
Vietnamese knew what to do after winning and they established todays vietnam which is progressing country
Taliban doesnt even know how to run a country they couldnt even make a constitution by their own implementing 7 ad laws in in modern day pathetic idiots
Taliban are just bunch of rbels all they know was rebelion they dont know how to rule or run a country
Japan during WW2 gave these Asian countries the idea that European and American colonizers are not invincible and can be kicked out of their territories. The colonizer's attempts to reestablish control after WW2 was a complete disaster.
For Vietnam it was the battle of Dien Bien Phu which did it. Japanese during WW2 are no different than European colonizers, if not worse, in term of countless heinous war crimes committed.
Who's here in 2050? After something similar like Vietnam and Afghanistan?
Afghanistan’s just fallen to the Taliban. I guess, in the end, history really does repeat itself.
Not really. Man is the one repeating history. History wouldn't have done it the first time much less the second time. Both instances were a direct result of mans actions. Makes you wonder about mankind and in these two cases Americans.
to be fair south korea, japanese, germany, taiwan ... etc still stand
History doesn't repeat, it rhyme
They call it 'the fall' because they lost
When in fact it shouldn't be called 'the fall' so much as 'the liberation'
You're right
I Agree
I like how this was recommended to me following the fall of Kabul. History does repeat itself.
After this incident, it makes Vietnam to grow stronger and now become the most fastest growing economy in SEA.
The most totalitarian regime in SEA?
@@stupidben999 No, is the fastest economy in the area, its a fact, and there is nothing you can do.
If South Vietnam survived it would have been a highly developed highly advanced nation essentially the little brother of South Korea. The only reason Vietnam adopted capitalism is because of the fall of the USSR and the rise of China.
@@YellowstoneKevin it will become American military dictatorship puppet regime
@@nguyenuctrung3814 False! South Korea is not a puppet and they are doing just fine.
0:45 the fck are you talking about? Those were North Vietnamese tanks and they were knocked out.
bad narration.
Judging by the brit's accent, he probably thought all asians were the same.
The footage from 1975 has more clarity than my iphone 11
Who's here after the fall of Kabul?
Me
Me
The only difference the Vietnamese will offer to drink tea to their former enemies and forgiven them
We don't have to learn history, we're actually witness it
My family is the South Vietnamese who supports the North Vietnam in the past, I remember the stories my grandmother told much about her times, the Americans just really showing to us as another invader, but after the war, we shows forgiveness if they willing to let go the past of hateness, learn our mistakes and never made another one again in the future but after Afghanistan War, they really haven't learned their's lessons it seems and still showing hated to the countries that they never stepped a foot in before
My mom and my aunt were wandering around the neighborhood, and they were grabbed to the helicopter by some soldiers. Those soldiers thought that my mom and my aunt were lost. They tried to evacuate everyone in the area. My aunt and my mom were inside and confused, and then she told a staff that she wanted to go home with parents. They let my mom and my aunt go. It was an unforgettable memory about that day. She was a little kid back then.
What passed is past. This era is for economic and social development, not for these painful memories from the past.
Well this didn't age well
@@Isajinglebells lol
@@Isajinglebells Nah it's still aged well. Vietnam conquered Covid 19 again lol.
After seeing what is happening in Afghan, I feel happy for Vietnam people today. They are on the right track of development, with GDP per capita 3500 USD, though it is still developing and not rich, it is much better than the 1980s when they had the poorest earnings due to the war. Wishes from China.
@@gamingwithlanzbackupaltacc5586 go play your games kiddie
"USD"
@takachi China had historical relation with Vietnam.The Chinese people also helped Vietnam in 13th century when Mongols invaded Vietnam & both took part in the war.
im impressed with how far vietnam has came. Same with Germany and Korea. I wouldnt expect the same for Afghanistan.
But there is a big difference in the Middle East.
Afghanistan will be dragged into Iran and Saudi Arabia feud, the support to setup a stable government is unstable and historically Middle East thrives on religious regime, in which some laws goes 100% against humanitarian system hence they don’t garner stable backing.
Vietnam success in growth is also mainly due to china being its neighbour, whether Vietnamese accept it or not, it’s a given fact.
There are border disputes, some feuds but the Vietnam policy of privatisation which saved its economy is mainly due to private Chinese investment.
And sadly I can’t see it happening in Afghanistan, although the world is more global and support is so much easier to provide, the clashing beliefs and local laws hinder the growth.
Ultimately the citizens will suffer while the top dogs who sets up for power and riches will enjoy their luxury until death.
Imagine the utter fear and having to flee for your life I know the US can’t stay in countries forever but it’s very sad.
Past : fall of Saigon
Now : fall of Kabul
Future : fall of Taiwan
Fall of Seoul 😂
Fall of Israel
Fall of Washington...
2069: Fall of the world
Fall of seoul, fall of tokyo, fall of saigon part 2
15000: Fall of everything
I cried everytime when i've been in saigon (vietnam war museum) to witness the cruelty and inhuman act of US soldiers. They using all biological weapons towards Vietnam people
It's communist propaganda, because no matter which side won, they would have reported a biased history saying the other side is inhumane.
The Vietnamese are very brave people, respect! 👍
Droiz the bio weapon that US used is the truth, there are evidences about that
@@DZ477 Apocalypse now!
I only heard of agent Orange, which was a chemical used to clear out trees, not a biological weapon. Which biological weapons are you talking about?
Fall of Saigon: Part II
At least the South Vietnamese Army actually put up a fight instead of giving up immediately.
*coughs in Afghan National Army*
That's actually an Air America Huey evacuating Vietnamese civilians off of the CIA regional offices on April 29th.
@@TheCoolCucumber in Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Thailand.
open your eyes USA. American politicians and generals should read the following books:
Mao Zedong's On Guerrilla War
Mao Zedong's On Protracted War
Sun Tzu's Art of War
No amount of military hardware or special force training will ever defeat a highly organized and politically-zealous enemy.
While the US armed forces is apolitical; the armed forces of the Chinese, Russian, Cubans, Vietnam, are politically indoctrinated and their loyalty are tested even before they learn how to fire a gun or rifle.
America didn't learn her lesson in Vietnam; America didn't understood itself and forgotten that the US Armed Forces was born out of a revolutionary group.
America focused too much on technology and special forces rather than on national strategy.
America's military is metric-driven and not driven by strategy on the top.
This didn't age well with Fall of Kabul too. Today is August 15th 2021. #USFlashback
My grandfather was offered the opportunity to get on a helicopter to flee the country that day but he refused it to stay with his family (us).
glory and honour to those who fought for freedom against colonialism and imperialism. Thousands vietnamese and americans died in vain
Political war
@@tuanz8009 war for independence
Is so sad that Kabul is the Saigon of our generation😔
Actually much worse because there were no plans for the Afghans like there was for the south Vietnamese. There was a lot of covert operations in Vietnam planning for the swift exodus of south Vietnamese unlike the zero planned exodus for Afghans.
@@semperfi6801 That's true, but I do see some similarities between Kabul and Saigon and how they were captured by the enemy the US was helping them fight. The two most important to me are: the corruption of the goverment(for what I have read) and the ineptitude of the army.
@@nestorechevers7263 as well as the army not getting paid. They abandoned their posts. When afghan officials were asked about it they simply said "the people who ran away were put back to their position".
@@semperfi6801 Yes, it was planed to let the South Vietnamese seize an American ship, it was planned to have no room for rescue helicopters, we planned to leave many of those that worked for us behind to be captured, very well planned chaos, we bungled the whole thing on purpose.
Smart people don't wait until the last day to leave a country in war and smarter people always have ready a route for escape.
They didn’t know they were slowly losing
The US was putting out a lot of propaganda in the South saying that help was coming and the tide was turning in their favor.
Thanks for this video-clip.
In 45 years TH-cam will run the same footage, but with the last transport plane from Kabul
My uncles from my mom’s side fled by cramming onto a fishing boat. They were one of the lucky boats that didn’t run into any pirates and were able to get to a refugee camp in the Philippines before coming to the US. My dad’s grandpa, who fought for the ARVN was imprisoned after the war and spend 9 years in a labor camp. Afterwards he and my dad would work on getting their visas to come to the US. after 13 years, they were finally granted their visas and were able to come to the US by plane.
Biden: America is back!
Taliban: We are back too!
Isis: Ey Wassup!!?!
AL Qaeda: what's cookin dude
America literally lost to North Vietnam cause of the population demanding to end the war.
America also lost to the Taliban, bruh.
I believe you guys need to re-check that. The helicopter was apparently a CIA helicopter leaving from one of their sites - not the military helicopters leaving from the embassy.
@Daood Zafar yes the mainstream media is full of fake news. only people who have no clue would believe that building is the embassy. Looks nothing like it.
Air America, the CIA Airline.
@@deanladue3151 yeah they want to pretend it didn't exist
This is a comment to stop people from saying first.
..
😂🐻
... First...
@@RackHasAttacked bruh
@@RackHasAttacked we force you to work in gulag.
At least those South Vietnam sodiels tried to defend the cilivizations not just run like afganishtans. Respect them
America really knows well on how to turn a country upside down
I'm here to cheer our liberation day
American always do this, run and always run and they're doing same in Afghanistan now
Blame Biden for that one.
@@YellowstoneKevin agreed
But Vietnam now has become modern country
This wasn't actually the last helicopter to leave. People just say that because of how bad it looks.
That's also not the roof of the embassy, but a hotel in Saigon.
Anyone still remember the cool song '19' by Paul Hardcastle?
Love that song. Also tells a story.
@@cheez7240 Yeah...
This was recommended to me in perfect time.
Comments under this video should be absolutely delightful, I bet
“Know your history, or be forced to repeat it.”
Great Day. Respect and glory to the friendly people of Vietnam from Russia! 🇻🇳🇷🇺
Knew a Canada born Vietnamese back in students date, his dad was among the South Vietnamese soldiers fought till the last day, then headed straight to the refugees boat
How the US lost against some untrained rice farmers
It's like Russia in Afghanistan
USA not lost... they withdraw the troop back because there were political in America back in 1970s. People protest in USA to stop Viet Nam war... USA could easily bomb north Viet Nam like JApan, but they choose not to...no one can beat USA that time beside Soviet. USA abandoned south vietnam for some reasons. HOw can you fight against aircraft and machine gun on the sky.
@Cardinal RG I dont record they have navy and air force. you probably mistake in the moview or something. second, they ak 47 was support by the soviet union... if american want, they could massacre the north just like hiroshima and nagasaki, and they are capable doing so. Viet nam war is not a war because the US congress never declare war with Viet Nam. This fight took place in viet nam for the cold war of Soviet and US.
@@noblegendforever2052 Of course the USSR gave equipment and supported Vietnam with some help from China too but what is important is the Vietnamese people who bled for their liberation
Considering how fast the Taliban is gaining territory in Afghanistan, absolutely no lessons have been learnt.
ironic how this got into my recommendation
Today in Viet Nam is 28th April so only 2 days to get to 30th April.
And now today when last US soldiers leave Afghanistan, TH-cam recommended this video.
somehow the fall of saigon looked more calm could kabul actually be worse?
By the time Saigon fell most Americans had already been evacuated out of the rest of Vietnam. With Kabul Biden just left them scattered throughout Afghanistan.
Dude, I am pretty it was a lot worse than showed in the video.
@@aster4405 vietnam actually got destroyed by the usa, scary moments
2021 brought me here…
It was never a war until Americans came in.
It actually started with the French. If the US had gone ahead and given Vietnam it's independence after WW II instead of handing them back to the French, the Vietnam War would've never happened.
"Fall or Saigon"??? It was the liberation of Vietnam.
We called it here "forgotten war", a war that we'll never mention about... A war that our vets hv to call home, and bragging for immediate departure
I think forgotten war is meant to refer to Korean War.
@@dawuid1491 Yeah, the forgotten war is Korea, we never even bothered to end it.
Who cames here as me because of the fall of Kabul?
I wonder if there's any documentary covering what happened after the fall, especially those who failed to flee...
They went to re-education camp if they worked for the U.S. My family’s assets were taken and was forced out of our home. My grandpa went to re-education camp for years. That’s what happened to most families in the South. Many even tried to escape by boats years later or they got sponsored to move to the U.S.
@@mdokpoplover21 taking assets happens in all communist countries because private property doesn't exist. The extra is the re-education camps and potential prosecution I guess... Until you get lucky and escape...
What about the officials of the south? I bet not all of them managed to escape on time?
Re education camp and if they lucky enough they can have a government seat like the dương văn minh guy
The Afghans are not willing to fight for their own freedom.
0.48 so were abandoned Soviet's tank and destroyed previously by South Vietnam Republic Army
nope the south surrenders before they come to saigon
@@nguyenuctrung3814 Nope (do your research before any "Nope"). Those tanks were destroyed by Red Beret Angels. They didn't expect to be ambushed by the last of the force.
Who's here after fall of Kabul
The defeat involving guns and ammunitions. Now, we are witnessing a defeat from nature’s wrath. May we all reflect on our sins and repent.
the south said they don't have enough guns and ammunation but after vietnam war the north use that same weapons the south use to defeat hkmer rouge and push china out of vietnam borders
The scare me the most is kid suffering
It means world knew about fate of Afghanistan since last year
Looking at this today ...
1975 - Fall of Saigon
2021 - Fall of Kandahar
Facts
*Kabul
All of these Vietnamese that ran to other countries probably find Vietnam now a very much better place to stay now.
Not matter where u ran or planning to live there will always be corruption. Just some place is less than other while some place hide it better than other.
if Vietnam got their freedom, Afhganistan will probably too.
Yes, The Islamic state of Taliban, now that’s freedom
Except in Kabul, women are now forced to become Ninjas
@Win Everything if its hijab that's fine
But forced to wear Burqa's
Then no
I need a similar video remembering Tiananmen square massacre.
More like CIA-funded coup
@@justanormalguyonyoutube1098 what?
@@justanormalguyonyoutube1098 +100 social credit points
"bUt WhAt AbOuT tIaNaNmEn sQuArE ?! "
These CIA trolls are working full time it seems 😏
Same Incident with different country..... But same Old America
America has a history of being most truthful ally 😂
Just American thing..
Thanks
Now there's a 2.0 but in Kabul.
even to this day, vietnam has only been territorially reunited, its people is still fractured as the day the civil war started
In someone's delusion about Vietnam. Lol
@@pirotess2 if it truly was reunited then the 3 stripes flag wouldnt be flying in usa
Deny them all you want, they are still vietnamese by blood
@@thecommentguy9380 they stopped being vietnamese when they choose another country.
lol the Covid-19 proved it all. Only unity in all peoples can do an impressive job fighting back the pandemic. If Vietnam is 'fractured', ask some of actual Vietnamese and see how high or low their morale is to their motherland.
2067: how the fall of kabul in 2021 is similar to fall of washington dc
2168:how the fall of Washington DC in 2067 is similar to fall of new delhi.
@@RTXti-ez6ye maybe possible
@@RTXti-ez6ye 2165 fall of islamabad
@@joydevsarkar4474 fall of human society...
@@issacschneider2499 the fall of milky way
Once my grandfather said that
History will repeat itself again and again
And
No one in permanent enemy or friend.