Way overpriced. Would never go to this shop. My buddy who does oil changes at Firestone only charges half that : Internet 2020. . (Just kidding Johnny, the price is very good) : Car Wizard 2020
Dave I think the trick is to know exactly what's wrong with the vehicle and then have a nationally accredited shop like Meineke or Tuffy perform the work at 1/4 of the price and then call corporate on the franchisee if they screw up (also I love your channel Wizard!)
Hat’s off to Johnny for being a good sport on the camera and especially for working with people hovering. He seems cooler than the flip side of a pillow.
Johnny is a saint. I was working on my 323i in my back yard. Neighbor came over, trying to be helpful. I asked him to leave, telling him there was going to be some yelling, a lot of cursing, perhaps some crying. He ran.
Im a mechanic by trade, but i loved tearing down my old 325i, the e36 was a fantastic car. Original M52 lived on for just over 500k kms before finally giving in!
This brings back so many memories of working on my 7 series with very little knowledge or experience. Makes me feel much better to know the experts still have the same problems I did working on this thing.
I worked in a Chrysler/Jeep/Dodge service center for a while, and all but 1 of the techs were there for this same reason. They'll never be out of work!
There's an old expression: "never watch sausage being made", or in this case: "never watch a mechanic working on your car." That was BRUTAL! Necessary, but brutal. Props for Johnny keeping his cool...for most of the time.
having grown up on a farm and helping to work on farm machinery that kind of maneuver looked pretty normal to me. Things rarely went easy and often required some brute forcing
I did this same timing chain job on my 01 540i in my garage. My impact didn't have enough clearance to get the main crank bolt off. Used a floor jack shaft as a 5 ft cheater bar and cranked on that bad boy for hours before I got it to lose. But I was lucky the pulley just came off. Watching you do this job gives me flashbacks. I wish they just used 4 timing chains like the previous v8 instead of a really long chain with crucial plastic that would be jealous of a legos durability. In a different life if I wasn't in the career I'm in I would love to be an apprentice to Car Ninja, madd Respect.
I agree, but this one really got him pissed off on camera...yes he needs his own channel...or Hoovie just bounces back & forth from Johnnies to the Car Wizard...and keeps his sanity, while the both of them loose theirs...its getting those failed parts off, or just finding the problem...what a major pain in the ass,... some times.
The Car Ninja doesn't get paid enough. The last thing I need when I have a stuck bolt is some mechanically incompetent observer sticking a camera in my face and making snarky comments. He should charge a surcharge (2x) when youtubers film while he is working.
Nothing screems PREMIUM and LUXURY like plastic parts inside an engine. Man guys from BMW are smart,building cheap cars and selling them for a lot of money.
Lol wizard says hell nah to broken bmw plastic junk. I actually enjoy how poorly these engines (along w the inline 6s from early 2000s) were designed. If it wasn’t for those garbage engineers, I would know literally nothing about cars.
@@EM-cc6gi Thank EU for that. If it wasn't for the EU mandating all cars must be recyclable, BMW and others wouldn't be putting in so much plastic garbage in their cars!
@@donkgated8074 Are you sure about that? Metal is also quite recyclable. I suspect it has a lot more to do with cheaping out on materials than it does with EU regulations.
BMW saved $3 in factory on that plastic, you lost much more on repair, and also they sold you new part LOL BMW profit from their cars 20 years after car left factory
I'm sure they have an arrangement. Maybe a revenue share on the video. Also, it's free advertisement for his shop. Hoovie doesn't seem like a guy who screws his friends.
I saw a sign in a workshop once. Labor: 1 hour $50. If you want to watch $60. If you want to watch and talk $70. If you want to watch talk and help : $80.
I've owned 4 BMWs over the years. Love driving the damn things, but the design concepts they use in their engines is beyond baffling! I mean, really, plastic guides for a metal chain. Nothing can go wrong there, right? And all the plastic parts in the cooling systems? By 50 or 60,000 miles, I was so scared to death of catching a $5,000 repair bill that I was selling or trading them. I drive a Lexus GS 350 now, a fine vehicle that can't really match a BMW for driving dynamics, but I sleep much better at night!
id say with any german car, you.d need patience of a saint. My Mercedes AMG is THE most difficult car in my fleet to work on and my patience can get tested with it.
Just picked up one of my two 2001 E38s today for a light control module replacement, again. When I got home I discovered that the right front and left rear floorboard were soaking wet, the left front and right rear floorboard were dry. Back to the mechanic tomorrow for a sunroof repair. This right after I had the other one repaired for running on 7 cylinders (bad coil) and had the rear brake pads replaced. Brake light was on, but I already had a set of pads waiting in the trunk. But I did have the cup holders in both cars replaced with permanently mounted E39 cup holders that function exactly as two holes molded in plastic should, as opposed to the ridiculous contraption that is the stock E38 cup holder. Victory! I see my old comment below. In 7 months I have added about $3000 miles to each car, at a repair cost of about $1 per mile. E38 life!
German engineers: veee shall make zii alternator vatercooled for extreme reliability and performance! Ya! Also german engineers: yaaa just use zi tupperware for zii timing chain guards.
@@StephanPluemer so a group that has no place making mechanical decisions has stepped in to do just that...I worked in an industry where the opposite happened, the engineers were made management, HR and all other positions up to CEO. The end result was similarly not good. People need to know their strengths and weaknesses and go with those.
I bought an 02 540i because Tyler said this was the golden age…I haven’t driven it but I’m falling in love with it! I got a great deal but I have a few things to figure out…hopefully it pays off!
@@daszieher that's what Scotty Kilmer says. One of my friends bought a used BMW with a V8, active suspension, all wheel drive, etc. It's been in the shop more than it's been on the road, and he still has payments on it! 🤣 He isn't aware of all of the problems they have, so he's going to realize in time it's an endless money pit. I don't know why anyone buys these things anymore.
So true... E90 325xi had to rebuild complete engine 6 months after warranty due to cam bearings fail and remains destroying the alusil bores. Never again!
I love how The Wizard and The Car Ninja are cool with their prices and estimates being discussed on youtube. Makes them seem like very honest people to me.
The auto repair industry uses standard "book times" for consistency shop to shop. The variables are parts prices and labor rate. A good tech will get a job done under book hours and make a better wage.
Was so great to see this job being done. I’m a BMW guy and have owned many straight 6 Beamers but have always been wary of these older 4.4L v8 motors due to the damn chain guides!
Even if I had all of Johnny's experience, I would of flipped out, broke the camera's and told Hoovie to leave and never come back. Johnny is 10x the man I am
As a mechanic from Germany I can tell you that dropping the engine with subframe and suspension as a whole and wheeling the whole thing over to a work bench is completely normal overhaul at most BMW dealers. Especially 7series.
Mr. German Mechanic- I was wondering, as far as dealership technicians are concerned, how are the pay rates/ classifications? Aren’t al of you salaried techs?
My wife's 85 Corolla GTS; 16 valve motor, manual trans, fun to drive. No matter what you had to get at under the hood, you had to remove something else in the way first.
Well: I had that notion many times! Specially while working on my own cars. I started hating my Mercedes 123: Even my father, who was a quiet guy and helped me working on the car told me that I should blow this piece of crap up. Once I was so mad with a beautiful Fiat sports car that I loved but that was broken non stop. The hood fell and nearly cut my finger in half. I was about to grab a hammer and beat the car to pieces. That very moment a friend showed up and asked me if I was willing to sell the car to a coworker of his. I told him to take the car right away! Hardly two years later I saw it on in a junkyard! But believe me: Of the masses of cars I owned this is one of of those I miss the most! And today it would be a rare and hard to find classic.
Jonny's odyssey with the crank bolt reminds me of when I was a young amateur mechanic trying to do my own timing belt on my 1989 Honda Accord. I didn't have an impact gun and had to resort to a 1/2 inch breaker bar plugged into an extension and the socket, with a 4 foot pipe over the breaker bar, using a spare jackstand as a fulcrum. I put the left front wheel back on, put the car on the ground, shifted the transmission into 5th gear, pulled the e brake hard, and laid into that pipe with all my might. I ended up dragging the rear wheels a few inches before that stupid bolt finally gave in.
“BMW engines are JUNK!” Correction: “BMW V8’s are junk” I want to see Hoovie buy a Bimmer with a straight 6 in the same condition physically as this 7 series.
I have a 330,000km 07 530, I've owned and worked on nearly every brand out there, BMW is way better then internet speak makes them out to be, beautiful design, really nice materials, amazing corrosion resistance (plastic and aluminum don't rust) the V8 timing guides were not great, should have been better but how many cars can't handle long oil change intervals? many. Nice to see the mechanic doing the exact same stuff I do, breaking tools, torch, impossible bolts, nice!
I purchased used on Craigslist a 3/4 drive breaker bar and head (actually snap on brand for both pieces of the tool) to break loose the crank bolt on any bmw engines or engines requiring the main crank bolt to be removed. The bar bends under torque but doesn't break. It is a meter long or so and quite thick. They're on very tight, I think in the 325 foot pounds range. I would guess break away torque exceeds 500 foot pounds. They make often a popping sound as they release little by little. Pro tip, torque new bolt (bmw says to replace) 60 degrees, 60 again, and then 30, total of 150 degrees after the initial jointing torque of 100nm. You can mark a corner of the 6 sided bolt to the crank hub flange and turn it until the mark lines up with the next corner of the bolt, voila 60 degrees. Then do it again. Then do it halfway between the bolt corners and you got your 150 degrees. I am surprised a mechanic with such a beautiful professional shop who works on BMWs doesn't have a 3/4 bar and instead wants to warranty 500 bucks in wrenches to his snap on dealer. Source: I just did 3 of these V8 chain jobs back to back on various bmw engined vehicles and my experience is 23 total times doing the chain job on these V8s. I have never failed to remove the "Jesus bolt", even back in the earlier days of busting the nut loose using a jack handle over harbor freights trusty half inch breaker bar. Harbor freight also sells a 3/4 bar that I would guess should do the trick. Will listen to the video on the way to work.
Like many things, the germans are being taken over by millennial engineers who think they know more than they do and are so clever. This is what happens when mediocrity becomes the norm. Even Toyota and Honda are suffering from it. The new kids, Hyundai and Kia are kicking ass. 5 and 7 year bumper to bumper warranties.....where ford can't build an engine that lasts the warranty period.
@@mechanoid5739 Yup, and the application of 5¢ worth of some high-temp grease during OEM assembly would have prevented it. But No. Hopefully this was done when it was reassembled. And I would've used that last puller right from the get-go instead of torquing on the entire shaft & engine like that with pry bars and applying such intense, uneven lateral force . :/ And I'm sure that that much heat didn't do the front seal any favors.
@@muskokamike127 that was a 2000 year BMW 740i. Millennials are people born between 1980 to 1996. By that logic BMW employed at best 14 to 24 year old engineers at the time of making the M62 range of engines (made from 1995 to 2005). Don't blame the failures of your generation on the one that came after yours.
When I was younger I had such a hard on for German technology, I thought they were the best and so cool. Now that I am an old curmudgeon, just give me a simple Toyota.
You are not wrong - there are some German cars that are bulletproof - off the top of my head - older mercs (W123, W124), VW group cars with the robust 1.9 TDI engine
@@Captain_Brown_Beard Thats right. The M60 has a better construction than M62 on V8s after 1995. Hoovie should have bought a E38 750 with a V12 they are bullet proof.
Japan, Korea (South Korea, obviously), Sweden. For the most part, those are the 3 countries you want to get a car from if you want it to actually work.
Smart move to do a preventative maintenance on the M62TU, it's a great engine and after 20 years needs some love. It's pricey, but worth it if you want to keep the engine for another 20 years it's worth the money. Excellent video!
Johnny is a treasure and as such he must be cherished. I especially like how much he's gotten used to you and filming, he's more animated and vocal. I aspire to be as patient and cool as him
Honestly, now many times have you heard someone go, its got a timing chain so I'm good. I'm sure not every manufacture made their timing guides out of chocolate, but still.
BMWs may be harder to work on, but timing chain guide issues are incredibly common even in "reliable" cars. The famous Ford modular V8s eat them, for instance. I took the guides out of my Mustang and they were 400% worse than Hoovie's, not to mention the shards had filled up the oil pickup. Had a Caravan with a Mitsibishi engine that did the same thing.
Tyler, this is by far one of your best videos ever posted. I enjoyed watching Johnny work very much. This video was not only fun to watch, it was educational. Thank you and keep up the good work.
I'm not judging this repair, but my E39 540i with same engine had the same job done and labor cost were 1200€ in Finland, labor was like 70€/h. Parts were like 1000€ with crank timing sprocket and that alone was 300€. And i also did altenator replacement mysefl and new furbished Bosch was 330€, so 1000$ at altenator in US seems quite overpriced. One thing hurt my soul, was seeing the car ninja prying with two long bars againts aluminium block, that's seems to me a big no-no. Why not use pulley extractor tools rightaway?
cuz bmws during his car's period were absolute garbage. terrible cars as they chose to make mass production a higher priority than quality. plus bmw, mb, and Audi all price gouged in America.
you're right a bosch re-manufactured alternator can be bought on amazon for like $350 for that car. Mechanics in europe seem to make much less than EURO mechanics in the US. It's not so much the labor rate which is similar it is the parts mark up! i don't know if its because of the suppliers the mechanics use who inflate the prices and then the mechanic is making a margin on top of that. I get that they have someone carrying that inventory but it does always seem like it's a bit much.
Of course it is expensive job and crap engine if mechanic just wastes time on it. He breaks 3 tools and then uses impact gun what works right away. Same story with pully - 1h wasted with flame and prybar and then he uses puller...
@Chuck Hibbett I think he hates these two, but he makes a sacrifice for free advertising, with this channel alone he is exposing his workshop to more than 1 million people.
he tortures everyone who watches his videos, like" i bought a cheap rolls royce only 70 years old and already needing a set of tyres why do they don´t make noise?", he´s the new doug demuro or something like that," i bought a cheap bmw V8 from a junkyard why doesn´t he works? "more or less the same
Lol your one of the guys that has reliability on the top of your list.. some of us want a little more in our A to B traveling... take your boring ass appliance and have a nice life
He’s too polite to tell hoovie to get out of his damn bubble. He’s got soooo much patience. I work on my own bmw and he never threw a wrench or called it a nazi wagon not even once.
I will always be a fan of the rubber timing belt on an overhead cam engine. I've seen belts outlast timing chain components on many occasions. The problem is not limited to BMW by a long shot.
I own an E30 BMW with 350k miles and she runs like a top. Everything works. Inline 6 model BMWs from the early 2000s and older, are extremely dependable.
This is unquestionably my new favorite Hoovies Garage video. "Hanging like a horse." "Because they're stupid." "I'm not supposed to pull on this, am I?" "That's a man who's dedicated his life to fixing BMWs." "You're really mad, aren't you?" "Disappointed" SO MANY GEMS!!
Guy definitely knows BMW for sure I had a 99 323i a 2001 a 530 with the m sport pack too I have a 2005 325 xDrive and I just had to part with a 2008 535i twin turbo that just had way too many issues even at 95,000 miles so I'm going to the BMW dealership tomorrow for my valve cover gasket for a 2005 325 extra just did everything underneath the sun in it oil pan gasket oil filter housing gasket new radiator thermostat water pump $3,000 oil pan gaskets PCV valve system that's all in the 2005 325 xDrive so I definitely know BMWs this guy is amazing if I had a BMW like that I would take it to him too love you guys you guys are amazing thanks for the channel you're so cool man appreciate you guys
Kia's are surprising easy to work on, The issue comes that their owners are far less apt (stupid) to drop thousands on old ones that should of been junked years ago.
Had two of them my last 740il I had for over 10 years and never had a problem till I Totaled it in a monsoon rain storm and by the way I didn’t have a crash on me the safest car I ever had. I loved that car👍🏻
My Grandfather was a mechanic and had a client who always brought his own parts and wanted to help...the guy was a restaurant owner...One day to make a point my Gramps went to the guys restaurant with a bag of groceries and asked "how much to cook this food plus I want to help" The guy never brought his parts or asked to help again...
I was guilty of bringing my own parts to my mechanic for him to install but it was only once and it was because I failed in fixing the problem myself. It was coming winter and it snowed 2 feet and temperature dropped to 17 degrees. I apologized when I got there but the guy said it was alright as long as they were quality parts. They were.
when the shop puts in something else than you'd agreed on, then you start binging your own stuff to them. went to a shop with a 1 series bmwfor oil change, said to them i want them to put in 0w-30 oil , they said ok, when i come to drop off the car i see they wrote 0w-40 on the work order, told them again, hey i want 0w-30, can you change it? they said sure, wrote 0w.30 on the paper, when i come to et the car back, i see the amount i have to pay is 5% less than quoted, and i say, interesting, that's a bit less than i was told, and the guy tells, oh yeah, it's because we put in 5w-40 oil and it is a bit cheaper. when i had visited the dealer another time and asked for 2L of oil for that car they gave me 0w-30 and i told this to the guy at this shop and i got replied, don't worry, the oil we put in is approved for this engine. so they know better than the manufaturer. next time i had to do an oil change i brought my own oil, to another shop. not going to those jokers again.
@@Paul-fb1em I took a 2nd hand alternator to a bmw specialist which he fitted for a fair price after I decided I couldn't work out how to fit. He said I should have let him put a reman on but the part cost would have near doubled what I spent on ebay + labour. Risk if it fails is down to me. Car had 275k miles at that point by the way. He fitted it from below with car on a lift so I would never have succeeded.
"BMW used cheap plastic" - No, they didn't. The plastic will last beyond the lease period and the warranty period, that's all that matters with these cars.
My good old 1986 535i also has plastic chain guides. I recently opened it up and it was destroyed! Engine still ran good and made good power and wasn't noisy. This V8 would let ya know its time to open it up by the big sounds it makes when the U shaped guide breaks its plastic off. All engines use plastic guides that I've seen.
I agree, BMW ( and others) deliberately built their cars to last thru the warrantee period...period! They all forgot to inform the consumer of this critical fact!
Car wizard just doesn't have the passion to work on BMW, While this guy owns two of the same car as this one. For me I know which one straight away who I'd go for.
Nice to see a video of a pro struggling too... sometimes I wonder if it’s just me that has those ‘that should now come out, why won’t it’ and the ‘this is unfathomably tight’ or the ‘forum and online tutorials said just unbolt and remove... 3 hours later, hammer, heat, swearing’!! 😂👍
I usually have that one issue that turns a 45 min job into 4-5 hours. I got lucky last time, all the tutorials said the hub was going to need a puller/sledge hammer/torch to get off and mine fell in my lap after I unbolted it haha.
Im in the middle of extracting a broken bolt out of my dirt bike. broke several bits, then the extractor broke in the hole... took a break and watching someone else struggle lol
There is ABSOLUTELY. NO. EXCUSE. for any of that. PERIOD! Where in the hell do they think it's gonna go??? It's bad enough that they use bargain basement quality parts but then make it damn near impossible to take apart short of using C4 or thermite! I think it's secret Nazi revenge on the rest of the world. I used to like these cars until I saw this. My 1988 560 SEL was 10 times the car this is. And just as understatedly elegant looking.
I gonna tell You: This V-Guide plastics broke apart at our 735 (1999) and the funny thing is: if these parts break, the engine won't die or blow up on the spot. the front covers for the timing chain are made in a way, that the chain can't jump from the cogs. the will however rub against the aluminium of those covers and produce a nervewrecking sound, so You will quickly stop and get the car to a garage xD. We repaired the whole damn thing in our garage and it wasn't fun. But I still accept those parts to be worn out after 20+ years and who-knows-if-ever maintenance.
@vit i’m not sure what you mean by eastern European methods of pulling car parts out but I missed in European and there’s more than one way to skin a cat and I do find your comment pretty offensive.
I love the natural progression of tactics to remove that part that was stuck. I love how Johnny keeps his cool because he knows he's on camera. You can clearly see his frustration on his face. The man is talented.
The perfect variant is the 750i. Had one years ago. But keep in mind, when your are planning to buy an E38, you will need the same amount of money for fixing its "typical issues". After a while you will get used to the Gong sound and that its always costing a hundred bucks ;-) But a 750i E38 in collectors condition - like mine was - is and will ever be on of the best luxory sedans.
I drove from LA to Laughlin one Christmas day in my '95 Subaru. The back wheel locked up on the Fwy in Barstow. I dragged the wheel and got off the Fwy. Luckily found an open mechanic shop about a 1/2 mile away. He got the wheel off, but the race was frozen to the spindle. I watched him beat on it with a 5 lb hammer and a chisel for literally 4 hours. He kept saying, "it will come". Finally on the 4 thousandth blow, the race cracked and fell off. He charged me $20.
A good person would have paid the man for 4 hrs of work at his rate. We're you a good man that day or did you drive away feeling great about how it only cost you 20 dollars? Just curious.
"The Car Ninja has dedicated his life to BMW's". No, he's dedicated his life to FIXING BMW's because job security. Also, has his own shop so he doesn't have to get flat rate pay for frozen parts and broken bolts.
Is it me, or does it seem "Johnny" wants nothing to do with the cameras and wants to be left alone, but he won't complain since Tyler drops so much $$ on him...
I don't think that's true even if it seems like it. Sometimes people aren't used to the cameras and don't really know how to act. The same thing happened with the Car Wizard. Super awkward with the camera at first, but after some time he's gotten so natural with it.
I'm impressed with Johnny's patience and good nature in the face of BMW"s amazingly bad/weird choices. I just unloaded an '04 X3 before the transfer case, known to be a weak point, grenaded. Or the bean counters call (I hope - no sane engineer would ever do this): BMW's plastic(!!) fuel line couplings in the K-series bikes... I've been to Munich. The water isn't bad, the beer's good... what's left to blame?
The Good Idea Fairy. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should. Holding multiple degrees in mechanical fuckery doesn't guarantee that you'll make something good. Then again they want you to get a new car every couple years so who knows, maybe they give out prizes for who can design a contraption that takes a complete shit 1 mile past warranty and that counts as success.
@@devincook2736 Also, just because something "works" in AutoCAD, doesnt mean its a good idea to build in real life! So many complex designs look good on the monitor, but are a complete disaster to work on after the fast.
This is exactly why I proudly drive a 2013 Honda Civic with only 73 K miles. I change all fluids regularly and am expecting to get at least 300 K miles of trouble free driving. I hate expensive repairs. My big ticket items are wiper blades.
John Ross. Fills his garage and driveway up with "projects". Then moves to his neighbours and fill it up with more "projects". Now taking his projects to fill up the ninjas garage. Tyler, you see where this is going? Don't let him near your garage.
I love this sort of more in depth content. Rather than some 10 minute review with some guy just yelling about reliability issues and other vague crap. I like this much more when a dive-in gets done to find the exact problem.
It actually takes less than you'd think, especially if you're using a cheater. I've twisted one off before, an old craftsman... twisted the nose off an extension and an adapter, split a deepwell socket up the side, etc. No cheaters, just a really good angle like deadlifting and *ping*.
Omg, this reminded me of my M62B44 swap in my E34. The ‘god’ bolt on the dampener made me break 2 tools. Luckily you don’t have a manual gearbox, because taking the flywheel off is another odyssey. Why they made the timing chain guide like this is a mystery. An earlier M60 engine had a normal sprocket instead. And my M60 did 350 000 km, had no issues with it. Seems to me BMW started practicing planned obsolescence at some point
Crank bolt threads are usually smeared with thread locker before the bolt is tightened to something like > 250 pound-feet of torque. The heat definitely helps.
Hack mechanic....the BMW factory tools makes this job way easier. Done this job and had a unopened tool kit from the dealer on loan.By the way he handles his problems and tools, this is a HACK Ham handed gas station guy in an expensive shop.
Did this job on my old Jaguar XJ8. I am not a mechanic and it took me a couple of days and I had to buy some special tools. Glad I managed to get the crank pulley off without breaking anything, and no oxy acetylene needed. First start is a bit nerve wracking, but it's very satisfying when it starts and runs. Another problem the Jag shares with older BMWs is the nickasil cylinder liners. Fortunately mine seem OK at 80k miles. I wish I didn't have a sealed for life transmission, another way of reducing service costs. I hope it lasts over 100k miles.
I really enjoy how much passion Johnny has for his work. It shows that you really have some skin in the game when you storm off out of frustration over a car that isn't your own.
I have multiple co workers with BMWs, from e46 3 Series, e64 6 Series to F10 5 Series and none of them run without minor to major failures. Oil burning engines, water leaking doors - and none was happy with regular BMW shop' s Repair success. I think you're really lucky to have someone like the ninja going proper ways instead of factory warranty backed solutions that keep failing repeatedly.
My first car was a e46 320ci that brought me through my studies. It was the cheapest bmw coupe online and the most loyal and fun friend i ever had. Did my coolant expansion tank crack and my waterpump fail? Yes. Did the engine overheat a little when i still drove it home? Yes. Did it matter? No, worked great for anlther 30.000km after which i sold it to another broke man. I guess it will live another 20 years in africa after him :D Now a drive a F10 with the last naturally aspirated straight six in the world. One year so far and everythings great except the rocker gasket leaked once but is only 25€. 150.000km and still makes my neighbours and colleagues envious and drives way better than any other car, be it japanese or american. Even if some of them are crazy unreliable, so are ferraris and Lamborghinis and british oldtimers. Do we love em still? Yes cause they look great and drive perfectly.
Way overpriced. Would never go to this shop. My buddy who does oil changes at Firestone only charges half that : Internet 2020. . (Just kidding Johnny, the price is very good) : Car Wizard 2020
Dave I think the trick is to know exactly what's wrong with the vehicle and then have a nationally accredited shop like Meineke or Tuffy perform the work at 1/4 of the price and then call corporate on the franchisee if they screw up (also I love your channel Wizard!)
Car Wizard 2020! You have my vote!
Weeeeezard
What you said about timing chains and guides is dead on with this job.
His prices are honestly very good for the work he does.
But you're right, my cousin's half brother Jimbo can do it for half as much in 1/3 the time!
Hat’s off to Johnny for being a good sport on the camera and especially for working with people hovering. He seems cooler than the flip side of a pillow.
Nice comparison 👌
Yeah, he's got a litter of TH-cam clients underfoot.
Don’t you mean “Hoovering” ;)
Brady - I see what you did there... 👀
There is nothing cooler than the flip side of a pillow...EVER! But yeah, Ninja is a cool Kat.
Johnny is a saint. I was working on my 323i in my back yard. Neighbor came over, trying to be helpful. I asked him to leave, telling him there was going to be some yelling, a lot of cursing, perhaps some crying. He ran.
@Richi RIch a week is pretty generous
Richi RIch They made me shit my pants instead
🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣
I feel you, had worked on my 318i and the yelling is inevitable :D
Im a mechanic by trade, but i loved tearing down my old 325i, the e36 was a fantastic car. Original M52 lived on for just over 500k kms before finally giving in!
This brings back so many memories of working on my 7 series with very little knowledge or experience. Makes me feel much better to know the experts still have the same problems I did working on this thing.
That is a man who has devoted his whole life to BMW's.
That is a man who realises he will never be out of work.
Called job security. So true.....
I worked in a Chrysler/Jeep/Dodge service center for a while, and all but 1 of the techs were there for this same reason. They'll never be out of work!
I know, I am semi retired now and still they come in...
Honda would be bankrupt if they allowed that crap to happen. BMW thrives..... somehow
Well said Gvor, Well said!
There's an old expression: "never watch sausage being made", or in this case: "never watch a mechanic working on your car." That was BRUTAL! Necessary, but brutal. Props for Johnny keeping his cool...for most of the time.
Watching him rocking that engine was painful.
LOL I remember when I took my 2004 Golf for a belt change to my dad's friend, I left when he started to rock the engine, couldn't watch it
Exactly. And I DON’T want to know what happens during my colonoscopy.
Cursing at cars while working on them is required by State Law!
having grown up on a farm and helping to work on farm machinery that kind of maneuver looked pretty normal to me. Things rarely went easy and often required some brute forcing
WHEN WILL YOU LEARN THAT YOUR ACTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES
He will never learn. It’s Hoovies Garage.
That's a classic meme. God bless Sammy.
Don't you have a basket case to sort out there Tavarish? lmao
Tavarish... Your car buying history is not much better. Lol
I enjoy your videos too.
It's an addiction he can't break out of. It's entertaining yet I still feel bad for him. 😅
I did this same timing chain job on my 01 540i in my garage. My impact didn't have enough clearance to get the main crank bolt off. Used a floor jack shaft as a 5 ft cheater bar and cranked on that bad boy for hours before I got it to lose. But I was lucky the pulley just came off. Watching you do this job gives me flashbacks. I wish they just used 4 timing chains like the previous v8 instead of a really long chain with crucial plastic that would be jealous of a legos durability. In a different life if I wasn't in the career I'm in I would love to be an apprentice to Car Ninja, madd Respect.
How Johnny managed to keep smiling and not tell Tyler where to shove his camera I don't know. He must truly be a ninja.
I strongly suspect Johnny's restraint came through the magic of editing footage.
Johnnys revenge will come with the final bill.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Johnny is so cool. He's always calm. Always professional. And great in front the the camera. A great video
I agree, but this one really got him pissed off on camera...yes he needs his own channel...or Hoovie just bounces back & forth from Johnnies to the Car Wizard...and keeps his sanity, while the both of them loose theirs...its getting those failed parts off, or just finding the problem...what a major pain in the ass,... some times.
The Car Ninja doesn't get paid enough. The last thing I need when I have a stuck bolt is some mechanically incompetent observer sticking a camera in my face and making snarky comments. He should charge a surcharge (2x) when youtubers film while he is working.
Nothing screems PREMIUM and LUXURY like plastic parts inside an engine. Man guys from BMW are smart,building cheap cars and selling them for a lot of money.
And he is very quick witted 🤣
Johnny must be serbian. 😁
I love how Hoovie had to find another mechanic because the wizard kept turning away all of the crap BMW jobs he kept giving him
Lol wizard says hell nah to broken bmw plastic junk. I actually enjoy how poorly these engines (along w the inline 6s from early 2000s) were designed. If it wasn’t for those garbage engineers, I would know literally nothing about cars.
@@EM-cc6gi
Thank EU for that. If it wasn't for the EU mandating all cars must be recyclable, BMW and others wouldn't be putting in so much plastic garbage in their cars!
He may have to find another new one after this car is done...
@@donkgated8074 Are you sure about that? Metal is also quite recyclable. I suspect it has a lot more to do with cheaping out on materials than it does with EU regulations.
@@donkgated8074 Lol, metal is more recyclable than plastic. Are you just a BMW apologist?
BMW saved $3 in factory on that plastic, you lost much more on repair, and also they sold you new part LOL
BMW profit from their cars 20 years after car left factory
Johnny is a real professional, relaxed and smooth guy. I really like him!
I’m surprised “Johnny” doesn’t charge more, because Hoovie is helping, and constantly commenting.....
Yeah I'd charge Hoovie an "appearance fee" for being in his videos lol
He probably does. I would be writing up an agreement for a small percentage of video revenue
I'm sure they have an arrangement. Maybe a revenue share on the video. Also, it's free advertisement for his shop. Hoovie doesn't seem like a guy who screws his friends.
I saw a sign in a workshop once. Labor: 1 hour $50. If you want to watch $60. If you want to watch and talk $70. If you want to watch talk and help : $80.
If he was annoying him he would tell him
Johnny has patience of a saint. Respect to him! His job is very difficult!!!
Yes sir, and notice not one cuss word or hammer to the BMW. He's got to be or will be a good father...
I've owned 4 BMWs over the years. Love driving the damn things, but the design concepts they use in their engines is beyond baffling! I mean, really, plastic guides for a metal chain. Nothing can go wrong there, right? And all the plastic parts in the cooling systems? By 50 or 60,000 miles, I was so scared to death of catching a $5,000 repair bill that I was selling or trading them. I drive a Lexus GS 350 now, a fine vehicle that can't really match a BMW for driving dynamics, but I sleep much better at night!
Remember he’s getting payed hella good. And he doesn’t want his shop to look bad.
id say with any german car, you.d need patience of a saint. My Mercedes AMG is THE most difficult car in my fleet to work on and my patience can get tested with it.
And to top it off he is being filmed struggling with stuff- which at the time must be very stressful
Just picked up one of my two 2001 E38s today for a light control module replacement, again. When I got home I discovered that the right front and left rear floorboard were soaking wet, the left front and right rear floorboard were dry. Back to the mechanic tomorrow for a sunroof repair.
This right after I had the other one repaired for running on 7 cylinders (bad coil) and had the rear brake pads replaced. Brake light was on, but I already had a set of pads waiting in the trunk.
But I did have the cup holders in both cars replaced with permanently mounted E39 cup holders that function exactly as two holes molded in plastic should, as opposed to the ridiculous contraption that is the stock E38 cup holder. Victory!
I see my old comment below. In 7 months I have added about $3000 miles to each car, at a repair cost of about $1 per mile.
E38 life!
Tyler comes to the Ninja’s shop
Johnny: “Oh boy, more money!”
JR comes to the Ninja’s shop
Johnny: “Oh boy, some help!”
Actually he thinks, "Damn, now I'm going to have to discount another job just to get the publicity."
Somethimes the situation requires some ultraviolence.
There was definitely a point in this video where ole Johnny was contemplating this career choice 🤣. Outstanding mechanic though.
After the second breaker bar I would have lost my shit.
Bushy556 3 ratchet drives blow up, before he gets the massive impact driver?
He’s questioning the wisdom of getting involved with youtubers
Uses two prybars shaking everything to death instead of going right to 3 jaw puller? Breaks multiple breaker bars instead of using an impact? Cmon.
No way, he makes wayyyyy more money servicing BMWs than he would reliable cars.
German engineers: veee shall make zii alternator vatercooled for extreme reliability and performance! Ya!
Also german engineers: yaaa just use zi tupperware for zii timing chain guards.
😆
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂
LMAO
in Germany no engineer builds an engine anymore, that's what the controllers do (an that is stupid) .... Regards from Germany
@@StephanPluemer so a group that has no place making mechanical decisions has stepped in to do just that...I worked in an industry where the opposite happened, the engineers were made management, HR and all other positions up to CEO. The end result was similarly not good. People need to know their strengths and weaknesses and go with those.
I bought an 02 540i because Tyler said this was the golden age…I haven’t driven it but I’m falling in love with it! I got a great deal but I have a few things to figure out…hopefully it pays off!
Johnnie went all the way to "I'm not mad, just disappointed..."
That feels ☹️
The Car Wizard is probably watching this and eating popcorn right now and laughing his ass off... :-P
He's a smart man refusing to take any more crappy BMWs from Hoovie...
car wizard also has a special tool to remove those crank bolts. car ninja should have learned from the car wizard.
Should bury any BMW in the car wizards back yard.
I think BMW’s warranty period is more like an expiration date
It's even worse on the newer ones. Just lease them and ditch them after. Do NOT hold on to them.
@@daszieher that's what Scotty Kilmer says. One of my friends bought a used BMW with a V8, active suspension, all wheel drive, etc. It's been in the shop more than it's been on the road, and he still has payments on it! 🤣
He isn't aware of all of the problems they have, so he's going to realize in time it's an endless money pit. I don't know why anyone buys these things anymore.
That, my friend, is so funny and so true!!
So true... E90 325xi had to rebuild complete engine 6 months after warranty due to cam bearings fail and remains destroying the alusil bores. Never again!
I’m laughing in MINI warning chimes! Owning a mini is like having a dog with permanent diarrhea!
Johnny seems like an amazing mechanic and nice person.
I love how The Wizard and The Car Ninja are cool with their prices and estimates being discussed on youtube. Makes them seem like very honest people to me.
The auto repair industry uses standard "book times" for consistency shop to shop. The variables are parts prices and labor rate. A good tech will get a job done under book hours and make a better wage.
Between you and JR, Johnnie's going to need a lot of therapy.
At least he'll be able to afford it!
think Johnny may consider being the "LS Swap your BMW" NINJA
Ha, he can now afford the island right next to the Car Wizard's.
@Historical Archive Sounds like he is a bigger man than you.
I fear that one day Tyler will be in the way of a roundhouse to the chin....Do not make Johnny angry....you won't like him when he's ANGRY !! 🤬🤬🤬
Put bicycle rack on so when car breaks down, you have transportation!! LOL
the previous owner of this car was living in 3020
Bicycle, Metro, Walk.
hahahahahah
Reminds me of the old Yugo joke about how they had rear window defrosters as standard equipment, so you'll keep your hands warm while pushing it.
Was so great to see this job being done. I’m a BMW guy and have owned many straight 6 Beamers but have always been wary of these older 4.4L v8 motors due to the damn chain guides!
they only failed because the oil was not changed often enough.
Even if I had all of Johnny's experience, I would of flipped out, broke the camera's and told Hoovie to leave and never come back. Johnny is 10x the man I am
The fact he devoted his life to working on BMW's he is a VERY patient man.
ninja training
I would have used the right tools from the start. Don't get why he went brutal instead of selecting the proper tools.
You heard those screams in the video? Maybe those were Johnnys screams of frustration.
As a mechanic from Germany I can tell you that dropping the engine with subframe and suspension as a whole and wheeling the whole thing over to a work bench is completely normal overhaul at most BMW dealers. Especially 7series.
The automotive version of the film, "The Exorcist".
Not in an e38 though.
@@Transportador33 why not
Mr. German Mechanic- I was wondering, as far as dealership technicians are concerned, how are the pay rates/ classifications? Aren’t al of you salaried techs?
@@Bmizzzle1 in the us most are flat rate
I feel Johnny's pain. Anyone working on, most any car, has contemplated sticking explosives on the vehicle and blowing it to kingdom come.
For real, I replaced a water pump an a lb7 duramax and they put the damn harmonic dampener over one 10mm bolt on it, stupidest design ever
Dang I know I have. Axles in Mitsubishi. Explosives seemed logical.
My wife's 85 Corolla GTS; 16 valve motor, manual trans, fun to drive. No matter what you had to get at under the hood, you had to remove something else in the way first.
Well: I had that notion many times! Specially while working on my own cars. I started hating my Mercedes 123: Even my father, who was a quiet guy and helped me working on the car told me that I should blow this piece of crap up.
Once I was so mad with a beautiful Fiat sports car that I loved but that was broken non stop. The hood fell and nearly cut my finger in half. I was about to grab a hammer and beat the car to pieces. That very moment a friend showed up and asked me if I was willing to sell the car to a coworker of his. I told him to take the car right away! Hardly two years later I saw it on in a junkyard! But believe me: Of the masses of cars I owned this is one of of those I miss the most! And today it would be a rare and hard to find classic.
Worked at Hyundai for 3 1/2 year, Mitsubishi for 2 1/2 years. had this idea a lot of time
Jonny's odyssey with the crank bolt reminds me of when I was a young amateur mechanic trying to do my own timing belt on my 1989 Honda Accord. I didn't have an impact gun and had to resort to a 1/2 inch breaker bar plugged into an extension and the socket, with a 4 foot pipe over the breaker bar, using a spare jackstand as a fulcrum. I put the left front wheel back on, put the car on the ground, shifted the transmission into 5th gear, pulled the e brake hard, and laid into that pipe with all my might. I ended up dragging the rear wheels a few inches before that stupid bolt finally gave in.
“BMW engines are JUNK!”
Correction: “BMW V8’s are junk” I want to see Hoovie buy a Bimmer with a straight 6 in the same condition physically as this 7 series.
I just picked up a perfect condition 2002 z3 2.5 manual and it just hit 21k miles. This is the car Hoovie should have.
What in the world makes you think any BMW 6 cyl has less problems than the V8's? They have the exact same issues actually.
All bmw engines are junk. Because bmw is junk. Expensive junk
@@_Bonez12 ikr??! As if the entire rest of the cars don't constantly break in every way imaginable 🤣
I own a 2000 M Roadster - S52 engine is a beast that you can beat on and it just keeps going. It's like an aircraft engine. Love that car.
I have to give him some credit. Juggling two toddlers while doing guides on a 740.
It's a miracle Johnny gets any work done at all with all these dudes hanging around comparing their crappy beemers.
Poor Johnny has to put up with these guys auction finds
I'm sure it pays quite well lol
@@TheLootownpunx yea, his shop looks beautiful and I'm sure its expensive
I was thinking about it, and can only assume he bills by the hour whether or not a TH-camr is causing delays. The clock just keeps on ticking.
I have a 330,000km 07 530, I've owned and worked on nearly every brand out there, BMW is way better then internet speak makes them out to be, beautiful design, really nice materials, amazing corrosion resistance (plastic and aluminum don't rust) the V8 timing guides were not great, should have been better but how many cars can't handle long oil change intervals? many. Nice to see the mechanic doing the exact same stuff I do, breaking tools, torch, impossible bolts, nice!
"You're really angry aren't you"
"disappointed"
Okay dad, I'm sorry 😭
Now I understand why the Car Wizard refuses to work on those BMW's. They're a total pain in the ass 🤣🤣🤣
10:33 The Car Ninja has gone for the “can’t be tight if it’s a liquid” method of removal!
I purchased used on Craigslist a 3/4 drive breaker bar and head (actually snap on brand for both pieces of the tool) to break loose the crank bolt on any bmw engines or engines requiring the main crank bolt to be removed. The bar bends under torque but doesn't break. It is a meter long or so and quite thick.
They're on very tight, I think in the 325 foot pounds range. I would guess break away torque exceeds 500 foot pounds. They make often a popping sound as they release little by little.
Pro tip, torque new bolt (bmw says to replace) 60 degrees, 60 again, and then 30, total of 150 degrees after the initial jointing torque of 100nm.
You can mark a corner of the 6 sided bolt to the crank hub flange and turn it until the mark lines up with the next corner of the bolt, voila 60 degrees.
Then do it again.
Then do it halfway between the bolt corners and you got your 150 degrees.
I am surprised a mechanic with such a beautiful professional shop who works on BMWs doesn't have a 3/4 bar and instead wants to warranty 500 bucks in wrenches to his snap on dealer.
Source: I just did 3 of these V8 chain jobs back to back on various bmw engined vehicles and my experience is 23 total times doing the chain job on these V8s.
I have never failed to remove the "Jesus bolt", even back in the earlier days of busting the nut loose using a jack handle over harbor freights trusty half inch breaker bar.
Harbor freight also sells a 3/4 bar that I would guess should do the trick.
Will listen to the video on the way to work.
"It's supposed to slide by hand."
GERMAN ENGINEERING BABY
Like many things, the germans are being taken over by millennial engineers who think they know more than they do and are so clever. This is what happens when mediocrity becomes the norm. Even Toyota and Honda are suffering from it. The new kids, Hyundai and Kia are kicking ass. 5 and 7 year bumper to bumper warranties.....where ford can't build an engine that lasts the warranty period.
To be fair. The bloody thing was rusted on!
@@mechanoid5739
Yup, and the application of 5¢ worth of some high-temp grease during OEM assembly would have prevented it. But No. Hopefully this was done when it was reassembled.
And I would've used that last puller right from the get-go instead of torquing on the entire shaft & engine like that with pry bars and applying such intense, uneven lateral force . :/
And I'm sure that that much heat didn't do the front seal any favors.
@@muskokamike127 that was a 2000 year BMW 740i. Millennials are people born between 1980 to 1996. By that logic BMW employed at best 14 to 24 year old engineers at the time of making the M62 range of engines (made from 1995 to 2005). Don't blame the failures of your generation on the one that came after yours.
That's showbiz
Ninja’s face when he said hanging like a horse is absolutely brilliant
What about his face at 10:10 and 10:23, when he was trying to take off that “slide on” flange.
When I was younger I had such a hard on for German technology, I thought they were the best and so cool. Now that I am an old curmudgeon, just give me a simple Toyota.
You are not wrong - there are some German cars that are bulletproof - off the top of my head - older mercs (W123, W124), VW group cars with the robust 1.9 TDI engine
After 1995 BMW went down hill. Their pre 1995 V8s dont have the timing chain guide issue, I know I have one.
@@Captain_Brown_Beard Thats right. The M60 has a better construction than M62 on V8s after 1995. Hoovie should have bought a E38 750 with a V12 they are bullet proof.
heck with toyotas, gimmie an ole dodge anyday, fix it in the dark with a piece of wire.. and some black tape.. ask me how I know lol....
Japan, Korea (South Korea, obviously), Sweden. For the most part, those are the 3 countries you want to get a car from if you want it to actually work.
Smart move to do a preventative maintenance on the M62TU, it's a great engine and after 20 years needs some love. It's pricey, but worth it if you want to keep the engine for another 20 years it's worth the money. Excellent video!
Johnny is a treasure and as such he must be cherished. I especially like how much he's gotten used to you and filming, he's more animated and vocal. I aspire to be as patient and cool as him
$75 an hour patience is a pleasure!
BMW Salesman: "It's got a timing chain. No need for replacement.
Timing chain guide: "Hold my beer".
BMW accountant: If only the clients knew...hahahaha...too late; we made billions!
Seriously, that makes a timing belt in a Honda or Toyota look dead simple.
Honestly, now many times have you heard someone go, its got a timing chain so I'm good. I'm sure not every manufacture made their timing guides out of chocolate, but still.
BMWs may be harder to work on, but timing chain guide issues are incredibly common even in "reliable" cars. The famous Ford modular V8s eat them, for instance. I took the guides out of my Mustang and they were 400% worse than Hoovie's, not to mention the shards had filled up the oil pickup. Had a Caravan with a Mitsibishi engine that did the same thing.
@@theodordanieldinca4460 BMW Accountant so evil hahahaha
Tyler, this is by far one of your best videos ever posted. I enjoyed watching Johnny work very much.
This video was not only fun to watch, it was educational.
Thank you and keep up the good work.
I'm not judging this repair, but my E39 540i with same engine had the same job done and labor cost were 1200€ in Finland, labor was like 70€/h. Parts were like 1000€ with crank timing sprocket and that alone was 300€. And i also did altenator replacement mysefl and new furbished Bosch was 330€, so 1000$ at altenator in US seems quite overpriced.
One thing hurt my soul, was seeing the car ninja prying with two long bars againts aluminium block, that's seems to me a big no-no. Why not use pulley extractor tools rightaway?
The real junk here is the channel. 1M subs, how is that possible...?
cuz bmws during his car's period were absolute garbage. terrible cars as they chose to make mass production a higher priority than quality. plus bmw, mb, and Audi all price gouged in America.
European parts are expensive in the USA because of overseas shipping. I guess American parts are more expensive in Europe.
you're right a bosch re-manufactured alternator can be bought on amazon for like $350 for that car. Mechanics in europe seem to make much less than EURO mechanics in the US. It's not so much the labor rate which is similar it is the parts mark up! i don't know if its because of the suppliers the mechanics use who inflate the prices and then the mechanic is making a margin on top of that. I get that they have someone carrying that inventory but it does always seem like it's a bit much.
Of course it is expensive job and crap engine if mechanic just wastes time on it. He breaks 3 tools and then uses impact gun what works right away. Same story with pully - 1h wasted with flame and prybar and then he uses puller...
I think the car ninja needs a channel. He's so knowledgeable but I feel like he doesn't get enough air time to explain things lol.
@Chuck Hibbett I think he hates these two, but he makes a sacrifice for free advertising, with this channel alone he is exposing his workshop to more than 1 million people.
Hoovie and JRGo are his only customers, so there would be nothing new
Today I learned that Hoovie really does like to torture his mechanics
And pay all their bills. But that's not new.
he tortures everyone who watches his videos, like" i bought a cheap rolls royce only 70 years old and already needing a set of tyres why do they don´t make noise?", he´s the new doug demuro or something like that," i bought a cheap bmw V8 from a junkyard why doesn´t he works? "more or less the same
he should drive a hugo they are incredible cars from a country destroyd by a war financed by u.s of a. and england
@@RUfromthe40s
Yugo....good cars. No they are not
I love it when JR and Hoovie cross into each others channels
trying to outdo each other with BMW disasters
Hey, leave my e30 shennanigans out of this, okay, guys?
I want to see Hoovie buy a used Accord and make a 10 second episode on what's wrong with it
I felt it when that crankshaft pulley bolt came loose. And he
Kissed the impact lmao 😅
Because where hand tools failed, Milwaukee delivered the desired results!
Makes me want to go out and sell all my power tools and replace them all with Milwaukee. I do have several of them now and I do really like them.
Milwaukee Fuel M18 to the rescue... Fun fact, the new Milwaukee batteries use Tesla 2170 cells!
@@digitalrailroader so true!
This channel constantly proves the best thing about the old Toyota I own - it starts and I go
But then you have to live with the fact you own and drive a clapped out olf toyota worth $100
@@whatsittoya3770 Yea, but consider the money that built-up in someone's bank account.
@@whatsittoya3770 Toyota pickups say otherwise.
Lol your one of the guys that has reliability on the top of your list.. some of us want a little more in our A to B traveling... take your boring ass appliance and have a nice life
Scotty, is that you? :D
He’s too polite to tell hoovie to get out of his damn bubble. He’s got soooo much patience. I work on my own bmw and he never threw a wrench or called it a nazi wagon not even once.
I will always be a fan of the rubber timing belt on an overhead cam engine. I've seen belts outlast timing chain components on many occasions. The problem is not limited to BMW by a long shot.
"From the land of running BMWs."
Truly a mythical place if one ever was!
I own an E30 BMW with 350k miles and she runs like a top. Everything works. Inline 6 model BMWs from the early 2000s and older, are extremely dependable.
@@OMthree28 i think we are speaking of the mythical 335i lmao the normal 328i inline 6s are reliable
I feel bad for jonny. Hoovie and John Ross hovering around the whole time he’s trying to work!
I think it's all in good fun, they probably pay for the privilege as well
These two are practically free ads for his shop
I found it cringe. Just let the guy work. I HATE the customer watching me.
@@Jay-Kay-Em That's why you're not successful as either of them
@@9inchpp jr is actually doing stuff tho
This is unquestionably my new favorite Hoovies Garage video.
"Hanging like a horse."
"Because they're stupid."
"I'm not supposed to pull on this, am I?"
"That's a man who's dedicated his life to fixing BMWs."
"You're really mad, aren't you?" "Disappointed"
SO MANY GEMS!!
Yeah
/Johnny/
Pure gold! 🤣🤣🤣
“Not enough beer when they designed it”
@@BobTheHatKing I could argue that the engineers at BMW had too many beers and went full German.
Guy definitely knows BMW for sure I had a 99 323i a 2001 a 530 with the m sport pack too I have a 2005 325 xDrive and I just had to part with a 2008 535i twin turbo that just had way too many issues even at 95,000 miles so I'm going to the BMW dealership tomorrow for my valve cover gasket for a 2005 325 extra just did everything underneath the sun in it oil pan gasket oil filter housing gasket new radiator thermostat water pump $3,000 oil pan gaskets PCV valve system that's all in the 2005 325 xDrive so I definitely know BMWs this guy is amazing if I had a BMW like that I would take it to him too love you guys you guys are amazing thanks for the channel you're so cool man appreciate you guys
Car ninja doesn’t need a utube channel, he has Hoovie and JR for content.
Hoovie has so many broken cars he supports 2 shops.
Johnny is a saint, that was fighting him all the way, plus having hoovie filming it all
“Kia.”
LOL 😂
Johnny rules
Kia's are surprising easy to work on, The issue comes that their owners are far less apt (stupid) to drop thousands on old ones that should of been junked years ago.
KIA had to testify before congress due to them catching fire and killing infants. They should be called baby killers and sent back to Korea.
juztyn00 you compare the regular Kia or the one which has a v8? Because they are kinda different.
@@diavalus That's the point.
@@SyphADL87 lol, because they're the only car maker to be liable for deaths - laughs in Ford
Had two of them my last 740il I had for over 10 years and never had a problem till I Totaled it in a monsoon rain storm and by the way I didn’t have a crash on me the safest car I ever had. I loved that car👍🏻
"So they were just stupid?"
"Yeah"
I was dying when he said they must of been knocking down beers
14:00 “Ready to start working on Mercedes, Ford?” “Kia” 😭😂😭😂
K Hinttxv kias are pretty good now
He wants an easier life after all that German crap
Hyundai is getting pretty good and reliable too.
Bigbaldybear he made $3k in labor in 2 days of work. The man has his priorities straight he’s just hard on himself.
Johnny deserves a medal. So nice to customers and a really good mechanic.
My advice for crankshaft pulley bolts: put a weighted socket on your impact, if you haven't already.
Agreed.. but it won't matter here because the pulley and not the bolt was stuck
My Grandfather was a mechanic and had a client who always brought his own parts and wanted to help...the guy was a restaurant owner...One day to make a point my Gramps went to the guys restaurant with a bag of groceries and asked "how much to cook this food plus I want to help"
The guy never brought his parts or asked to help again...
BEST Story too True!
I was guilty of bringing my own parts to my mechanic for him to install but it was only once and it was because I failed in fixing the problem myself. It was coming winter and it snowed 2 feet and temperature dropped to 17 degrees. I apologized when I got there but the guy said it was alright as long as they were quality parts. They were.
when the shop puts in something else than you'd agreed on, then you start binging your own stuff to them. went to a shop with a 1 series bmwfor oil change, said to them i want them to put in 0w-30 oil , they said ok, when i come to drop off the car i see they wrote 0w-40 on the work order, told them again, hey i want 0w-30, can you change it? they said sure, wrote 0w.30 on the paper, when i come to et the car back, i see the amount i have to pay is 5% less than quoted, and i say, interesting, that's a bit less than i was told, and the guy tells, oh yeah, it's because we put in 5w-40 oil and it is a bit cheaper.
when i had visited the dealer another time and asked for 2L of oil for that car they gave me 0w-30 and i told this to the guy at this shop and i got replied, don't worry, the oil we put in is approved for this engine.
so they know better than the manufaturer.
next time i had to do an oil change i brought my own oil, to another shop. not going to those jokers again.
@@Paul-fb1em I took a 2nd hand alternator to a bmw specialist which he fitted for a fair price after I decided I couldn't work out how to fit. He said I should have let him put a reman on but the part cost would have near doubled what I spent on ebay + labour. Risk if it fails is down to me. Car had 275k miles at that point by the way. He fitted it from below with car on a lift so I would never have succeeded.
HAHAHA. Bravo. That's funny, appropriate and (to some degree) I'm busted. I'll go kick rocks and mumble to myself. Good post.
Hoovie making TH-cam stars..first the Wizard now the Ninja...Johny is Class A mechanic..
After watching this, I'm thinking he bought the flathead Ford wagon to remind himself that some V8s can actually be simple and last a while.
@chris younts half of it did.
I love that Johnny got down with the 'Can't be tight if its a liquid' method with the torch. We've all been there sir! Way To Go!
"BMW used cheap plastic" - No, they didn't. The plastic will last beyond the lease period and the warranty period, that's all that matters with these cars.
My good old 1986 535i also has plastic chain guides. I recently opened it up and it was destroyed! Engine still ran good and made good power and wasn't noisy. This V8 would let ya know its time to open it up by the big sounds it makes when the U shaped guide breaks its plastic off. All engines use plastic guides that I've seen.
Spot on
I agree, BMW ( and others) deliberately built their cars to last thru the warrantee period...period! They all forgot to inform the consumer of this critical fact!
Its not the plastic guides which is the problem, ive had cars run over 600000 km’s on stock chain/guides with no issue
I always said if I had a company I'd do things the right way but it seems like if your company's name is big enough you can do whatever you want
I can only imagine that the reason its here instead of The Car Wizard's shop is because the Car Wizard told him to get that garbage out.
Pretty much actually. Car wizard flat out refuses to work on BMWs
Adel not to mention Johnny being an expert on German cars it’s an incentive to go to the expert on them versus your normal mechanic
Car wizard just doesn't have the passion to work on BMW,
While this guy owns two of the same car as this one. For me I know which one straight away who I'd go for.
Didnt Car Wizard hire an ex BMW factory mechanic?
IFFY_TOO nope he was a Mercedes mechanic
Nice to see a video of a pro struggling too... sometimes I wonder if it’s just me that has those ‘that should now come out, why won’t it’ and the ‘this is unfathomably tight’ or the ‘forum and online tutorials said just unbolt and remove... 3 hours later, hammer, heat, swearing’!! 😂👍
I usually have that one issue that turns a 45 min job into 4-5 hours. I got lucky last time, all the tutorials said the hub was going to need a puller/sledge hammer/torch to get off and mine fell in my lap after I unbolted it haha.
Im in the middle of extracting a broken bolt out of my dirt bike. broke several bits, then the extractor broke in the hole... took a break and watching someone else struggle lol
There is ABSOLUTELY. NO. EXCUSE. for any of that. PERIOD!
Where in the hell do they think it's gonna go??? It's bad enough that they use bargain basement quality parts but then make it damn near impossible to take apart short of using C4 or thermite! I think it's secret Nazi revenge on the rest of the world.
I used to like these cars until I saw this. My 1988 560 SEL was 10 times the car this is. And just as understatedly elegant looking.
I gonna tell You: This V-Guide plastics broke apart at our 735 (1999) and the funny thing is: if these parts break, the engine won't die or blow up on the spot. the front covers for the timing chain are made in a way, that the chain can't jump from the cogs. the will however rub against the aluminium of those covers and produce a nervewrecking sound, so You will quickly stop and get the car to a garage xD.
We repaired the whole damn thing in our garage and it wasn't fun. But I still accept those parts to be worn out after 20+ years and who-knows-if-ever maintenance.
Hoovie: Ninja, how much is this gonna cost?
Ninja: $3,000 ($5,000 if you help me...)
He’s teaching Hoovie how to repair BMWs! 😜
Johnny is truly using Eastern European methods of pulling car parts out. Loving it !!!
These are methods seen at BMW dealerships worldwide
@vit i’m not sure what you mean by eastern European methods of pulling car parts out but I missed in European and there’s more than one way to skin a cat and I do find your comment pretty offensive.
Vit Canadian back yard ones also lolol
I love the natural progression of tactics to remove that part that was stuck. I love how Johnny keeps his cool because he knows he's on camera. You can clearly see his frustration on his face. The man is talented.
Impact after one broken breaker bar, Sorry Johnny. Flat rate you do things a Little differently. LOL!!
The perfect variant is the 750i. Had one years ago.
But keep in mind, when your are planning to buy an E38, you will need the same amount of money for fixing its "typical issues".
After a while you will get used to the Gong sound and that its always costing a hundred bucks ;-)
But a 750i E38 in collectors condition - like mine was - is and will ever be on of the best luxory sedans.
I drove from LA to Laughlin one Christmas day in my '95 Subaru. The back wheel locked up on the Fwy in Barstow. I dragged the wheel and got off the Fwy. Luckily found an open mechanic shop about a 1/2 mile away. He got the wheel off, but the race was frozen to the spindle. I watched him beat on it with a 5 lb hammer and a chisel for literally 4 hours. He kept saying, "it will come". Finally on the 4 thousandth blow, the race cracked and fell off. He charged me $20.
You ignored the obvious sings of wheel bearing failure until it welded itself to the hub...wow. I'm notifying your insurance company.
@@TheGuruStud And you know what company he uses? Piss off.
Too funny people in SW they hate corrosion...rust they freak out
That is WILDER than your last name..Hope you tipped him at least a single buck,LOL.
A good person would have paid the man for 4 hrs of work at his rate. We're you a good man that day or did you drive away feeling great about how it only cost you 20 dollars? Just curious.
Johnny is so sick of hoovie just following him around with a camera annoying him all day 😂😂😂😂
100 dollars per hour he gets he is not sick and people see him, he gets more custommers
"The Car Ninja has dedicated his life to BMW's". No, he's dedicated his life to FIXING BMW's because job security. Also, has his own shop so he doesn't have to get flat rate pay for frozen parts and broken bolts.
... and I believe learned his craft in the EU (where we have more experience with these cars) before coming to the US.
Is it me, or does it seem "Johnny" wants nothing to do with the cameras and wants to be left alone, but he won't complain since Tyler drops so much $$ on him...
I don't think that's true even if it seems like it. Sometimes people aren't used to the cameras and don't really know how to act. The same thing happened with the Car Wizard. Super awkward with the camera at first, but after some time he's gotten so natural with it.
It’s just you lol. I see a cool friendship
Nah Jonny is cool
Johnny having fun bruh shut up
Wizard's whole attitude is straight-up "you're paying for my new house and no there are no discounts."
I'm impressed with Johnny's patience and good nature in the face of BMW"s amazingly bad/weird choices. I just unloaded an '04 X3 before the transfer case, known to be a weak point, grenaded. Or the bean counters call (I hope - no sane engineer would ever do this): BMW's plastic(!!) fuel line couplings in the K-series bikes... I've been to Munich. The water isn't bad, the beer's good... what's left to blame?
The Good Idea Fairy. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should. Holding multiple degrees in mechanical fuckery doesn't guarantee that you'll make something good. Then again they want you to get a new car every couple years so who knows, maybe they give out prizes for who can design a contraption that takes a complete shit 1 mile past warranty and that counts as success.
@@devincook2736 Also, just because something "works" in AutoCAD, doesnt mean its a good idea to build in real life! So many complex designs look good on the monitor, but are a complete disaster to work on after the fast.
“Hanging like a horse”
Hahaha.
The way he slaps it lmao
The man knows his horses
Johnny cursing in another language was probably saying something like "I wish Tyler would STFU and let me work!!!!!!"
I wonder which language that is... I don't pick up any accent I'm familiar with.
@@bellezayverdad he's albanian
@@bellezayverdad Albanian
If it was me it would be "hijo de puta"
@@bellezayverdad Albanian!!
This is exactly why I proudly drive a 2013 Honda Civic with only 73 K miles. I change all fluids regularly and am expecting to get at least 300 K miles of trouble free driving. I hate expensive repairs. My big ticket items are wiper blades.
"I wish Tyler wasn't standing next to me filming right now."
Car Ninja, probably.
John Ross. Fills his garage and driveway up with "projects".
Then moves to his neighbours and fill it up with more "projects".
Now taking his projects to fill up the ninjas garage.
Tyler, you see where this is going? Don't let him near your garage.
You can see why the wizzard refueses to work on Hoovies BMWs...
He's probably laughing so hard watching this video.
Wiz is making enough working on the fleet of very expensive cars.
Chris Larson the BMW is very expensive too. At least to repair
Righteous So does my bank account. Hows yours by the way?
@@CarWizard that was one of the best TH-cam comment comebacks I've seen In a while! Keep up the great work
I love this sort of more in depth content. Rather than some 10 minute review with some guy just yelling about reliability issues and other vague crap. I like this much more when a dive-in gets done to find the exact problem.
Jonny is a strong man.
Snaps breaker bars with ease and holds back the tears of frustration until off camera.
That would be a funny behind the scenes, crying over a broken tool lol
@@lucashearne I mean the one brand I saw was Snap On, and those... The prices make me want to cry.
It actually takes less than you'd think, especially if you're using a cheater. I've twisted one off before, an old craftsman... twisted the nose off an extension and an adapter, split a deepwell socket up the side, etc. No cheaters, just a really good angle like deadlifting and *ping*.
I have snapped those also, but after the first out comes the Oxy-Acetelene torch to get things hot
Omg, this reminded me of my M62B44 swap in my E34. The ‘god’ bolt on the dampener made me break 2 tools. Luckily you don’t have a manual gearbox, because taking the flywheel off is another odyssey. Why they made the timing chain guide like this is a mystery. An earlier M60 engine had a normal sprocket instead. And my M60 did 350 000 km, had no issues with it. Seems to me BMW started practicing planned obsolescence at some point
so why not stick with the M60 i got E34 with M60B40 450.xxxKM
You are correct went into action with the finish of the old E46 era, then 5 year life cycle only, I left soon after that
When someone with Johnny's ability is pulling out the oxy torch you know there's an issue
Crank bolt threads are usually smeared with thread locker before the bolt is tightened to something like > 250 pound-feet of torque. The heat definitely helps.
This tool was maby made in China? :)
Hack mechanic....the BMW factory tools makes this job way easier. Done this job and had a unopened tool kit from the dealer on loan.By the way he handles his problems and tools, this is a
HACK Ham handed gas station guy in an expensive shop.
Levers only work to a point, any more and you are just going to sear the metal as demonstrated above, hence the leaver and percussion aka a hammer.
Did this job on my old Jaguar XJ8. I am not a mechanic and it took me a couple of days and I had to buy some special tools. Glad I managed to get the crank pulley off without breaking anything, and no oxy acetylene needed. First start is a bit nerve wracking, but it's very satisfying when it starts and runs. Another problem the Jag shares with older BMWs is the nickasil cylinder liners. Fortunately mine seem OK at 80k miles. I wish I didn't have a sealed for life transmission, another way of reducing service costs. I hope it lasts over 100k miles.
"Is it supposed to be doing that?"
"It's pretty typical."
That's not what Hoovie asked. :D
I really enjoy how much passion Johnny has for his work. It shows that you really have some skin in the game when you storm off out of frustration over a car that isn't your own.
It's reassuring to see the pros suffering from the issues an amateur also deals with (e.g. breaking tools on stuck bolts)
I have multiple co workers with BMWs, from e46 3 Series, e64 6 Series to F10 5 Series and none of them run without minor to major failures. Oil burning engines, water leaking doors - and none was happy with regular BMW shop' s Repair success. I think you're really lucky to have someone like the ninja going proper ways instead of factory warranty backed solutions that keep failing repeatedly.
My first car was a e46 320ci that brought me through my studies. It was the cheapest bmw coupe online and the most loyal and fun friend i ever had. Did my coolant expansion tank crack and my waterpump fail? Yes. Did the engine overheat a little when i still drove it home? Yes. Did it matter? No, worked great for anlther 30.000km after which i sold it to another broke man. I guess it will live another 20 years in africa after him :D
Now a drive a F10 with the last naturally aspirated straight six in the world. One year so far and everythings great except the rocker gasket leaked once but is only 25€. 150.000km and still makes my neighbours and colleagues envious and drives way better than any other car, be it japanese or american.
Even if some of them are crazy unreliable, so are ferraris and Lamborghinis and british oldtimers. Do we love em still? Yes cause they look great and drive perfectly.