Sir half of your conclusions to report are based on your presumtions and assumptions. Justice for abhaya doesn't end with just opposing rape, there's a huge game behind it which led to what happened with Abhaya- The Party's Political Influence, false medicines, threat culture etc. All these summed up under the banner of "JUSTICE FOR ABHAYA". And we all knew about it. This was not a usual rape, it happened due to corruptions and abhaya speaking against corruption, which actually led to her death. Yes we all, who were protesting from the ground, knew about it. We supported WBJDF to even fight against these corruptions, that actually led to the death of this young doctor. Even if they were voicing against corruption, keeping lawyers to fight the case on behalf of them, we all supported it. People who funded, even supported this cause. This is the reason why Avik, Birupakkho, Sandip are now under trial. These are all part of JUSTICE, we are DEMANDING, and we support it.
@ Tamal Saha - when you started it was so impressive. I meant your independent, from the ground, fearless & unbiased journalism was like fresh air. And it continued for some time. However from mid of August 2024, that is after the Abhaya/ Tilottama case things have changed completely. Question is not that whether you are right or wrong in your assessment of the "Justice for Abhaya" protest. Question is as a Journalist are you doing justice to your audience by ignoring pertinent questions about the case. While you should always question the motive of protesting junior doctors, their sources of funds, the dubious role of the left parties in this movement etc, should not you raise questions about the following as well??? 1) Didn't the RG Kar authority initially try to push the case under the carpet? Else why such a delay? 2) Wasn't the police reluctant about filing the FIR? Even when they filed it, the FIR was not comprehensive. Even the police investigation looked like it was just about identifying & arresting the one culprit without looking at the big picture 3) Why the post mortem conducted so late? Why a second one was not done despite insistence from her parents? 4) Did the CBI do justice through a thorough investigation or did they just organized, structured & presented the evidences given by the Police to prepare a strong chargesheet against this one criminal? 4) Had the CBI felt that all evidence was not there or some evidence have been destroyed/ tampered with, they should have clearly mentioned the same in the court and tried pulling up those who were behind such things! 5) Did the CBI interrogate all concerned - staffs present in the RG Kar hospital during that night, security guards, nurses, doctors, classmates, department heads? What were the findings? 6) Why couldn't the CBI file chargesheet against Sandeep Ghosh and the local OC in 90 days? Where did they get stuck? 7) Don't you think the Hon'bl Judge in this case did the right thing by giving life imprisonment to the culprit Sanjay Ray - that way at least there's a possibility that in future the truth (if there's any more than what is presented now) may actually come out??
@@hannanhub1717 we don't want to compare tamal with godi or whatever media it is... that's why he is asking this question as an audience of his journalism videos
@@rajrupachatterjee256 media shows so many statements of parents, it's a question what they actually said, recently they said 50 peoples involved, initially this is all about Sandeep Ghosh & his few accomplices, they meet Suvendu Adhikari from bjp for justice but now they are saying it's a setup of modi & didi, btw video is about money & yes junior doctors collected money in the name of protest & justice. There are another rape case in Jaynagar around same time where death penalty was given to accused, no one collected money for justice in that case
Yes, this Sherlock Holmes will only expose them 🤣🤣, which is the right thing to do. But this Sherlock Holmes can never expose the government 🤣🤣. He only exposes small people. If he were a real Sherlock, he would expose the big ones along with the small ones too!
So, this means he is a biased journalist, just like other journalists who support a particular party. In in my country , there are no real journalists, bro. Some support the right wing, and some support the left wing 😂.
The central government has been perceived as neglecting Bengal and Punjab since India's independence. Despite Bengalis playing a crucial role in the country's independence, no Bengali has become the Prime Minister to date. Even Netaji's birthday is not a national holiday. The most rich 22 persons of India have the same money as that of 70 cr people have!
Finally Netaji is gradually getting his recognition. Check the recent developments. It was earlier such because the new Congress govt post independence was a continuation of the Raaj - as we had power transfer not direct revolutionary independence
খুব খারাপ লাগছে..যেটা নিয়ে গোয়েন্দা হওয়ার থেকে মানবিক হওয়ার দরকার ছিল। কুসঙ্গ একেই বলে। শিক্ষা স্বাস্থ্য কাটমানি এটা নিয়ে মনে হয় বেশি বলা দরকার ছিল। খুঁজে বের করুন দেখি কে করল কেনো করলো...সেটা মনে হয় বেশি দরকারি ছিলো।😔
Facts are facts. Kon kon jaygay mislead kora hoyeche seta dekhale somossa kothay. Prosasoner fault gulo to sobai jane kintu opposite side er blunder guloy loke januk!
I cannot commented any channel. But today this news channel are constrained me to commen. But i have one suggestion that you sir promote this channel in bengali version
@@koushikbiswas5517 thanks a lot. Please engage more with us. Plz subscribe to the channel and kindly ask your friends and family to support us by subscribing. We are coming up with NTT Bengali very soon. Dhonnobad
Everyone got money for the protest needs to give a proper justification of in which ways they have used the money.. It is their job to give all the details because it's the money of the common people... If they would have done that before then no one would have tried to frame them... They need to give a proper data of the expenses.. Why hasn't they done that? It is their duty to do so without even asking.. And if there are a lot of funds still left, then they should have either given the money back who sent that money or may be they should have given that to any NGO's or atleast they should have gaven that to the family of the Abhaya... It's not their fucking money that they will keep it to themselves... And if they do so, then from the next time if anything happens like this then no one would support the protesters.. This will make a very bad example to the people...
I still can't find anything fishy. Just one thing in the Supreme Court Indira Jaysingh was paid 11lac was worthless. Other than that everything is fine and the choice of the doctors. In the first part there was nothing also. I can't understand your point.
@@shahbaaz2958 Define Open Mind!!! I have scrutinised every part of the video. I didn't find anything other than speculations. As per "Merriam Webstar" Open Mind means a willingness to listen to or accept different ideas or opinions. So please investigate the meaning of "Open Mind", "Scrutiny" and "Speculation". I had become a fan of Mr. Tamal Saha during the Manipur Series. But now!! He didn't used to do speculative videos
Can u answer why event management company were hired nd why fund from two individual accounts where not transferred to main account. Futher why they r asking for more donations when the funds r lying ideal. They shud have transferred the amount to abhaya parents bank account. Doctors these days r not god they will recommend medicines in which they get hired cut money from pharmaceutical companies.
@@akashagarwal869 first of all I am not here to advocate anyone. But still as your are asking.. don't you have multiple bank accounts do you transfer all the amounts to the same account? Let's say you and your friend have organised a crowd funding for a great social cause. You have distributed pamphlets with two bank accounts details on it. Now it has become so big that you didn't expect lakhs of money are coming everyday. Now you both decided to operate with a single account. And you did distribute the account details with the crowd. Crowd are being crowd the still sending money to the old bank account. Now what you will decide! Let's get hell with it we will operate all the three accounts isn't it! Does Aavayas parents need that money! Or the movement needs money! Even a Saraswati Puja of kids nowadays are organised by event management organisations. Then what is the problem! They are probably organising food transport etc. and trust me on one thing two crore is really small amount for such a large movement. yes the doctor's nowadays the perfect কসাই . But this has nothing to do with these movement because these movement was not of the doctors only these movement was for the justice and the doctors made it look like about their elections they are fools. This movement needed to be political and it was actually not that was the main problem.
All you have shown is that people funneled money anonymously. Unless the identity is found, no political intent can be proved. The alleged digital transfer against cash too seem a matter of convenience - not laundrring.
JETA ABP 24 GHONTAR KORAR KOTHA CHILO APNARA KORE DEKHIACHEN . HATS OFF . KOLKATA POLICE R GOVT K BOLBO PRESS CONF KORTE AND IMMIDIATLY START AN INVESIGATION
I respect you guys but upi settlement is not a settlement you are defining in the video. Actually when you don't want to deposit a small amount received through upi in your account you instruct banks to deposit the whole amount in your account every fortnight or whatever time interval in which you are comfortable. So the amount credited to your bank account after accumulating all amounts received during that period of time and it will be credited as upi settlement.
Tamal Da, Big fan. But your Kolkata Operation analysis might be wrong. I am a Hdfc account holder. If you deposit any cheque, the "Kolkata Operation" term is automatically added by HDFC. So basically the total amount tagged as "Kolkata Operation" can be simply considered as cheque deposits.
@@baniksden7481 thanks for writing to us. I have verified with the bank before doing the story. On the same day there has been several other transactions, several other cheque deposits but not all were termed as “Kolkata operation”. 24 selective were drawn as Kolkata Operation.
The indiscretion of HDFC Bank in revealing details of their clients' account is appalling. Their gross failure to maintain secrecy and confidentiality of their customer's account is shocking - they have violated the most sacrosanct duty of a banker.
@@somnathchoudhury2633 I don't think youtuber like him will get this type of info that easily... either it is made up or he has state police support...or maybe someone known to him works in the HDFC...
Investigative journalism এটাকেই বলে, টিভি নিউজ এ তো এসব হয়না, হোয়াটস্যাপ এর fake নিউজ থিওরি চালায় তাই বোধহয় বিষয় টা আপনাদের মনে নেই @@soumitrachakraborty9413
Comment section ta porun..akjon bolechhe oi hdfc branch er cheque use korechhilo.. tar transaction eu kolkata operation eta lekha aschhetransaction history te...sudhu suspenseful sound ar speculations diye youtube chole professional journalism noi..akta investigation amder state er eto durniti related kore dekhak...lifetime support korbo@@BeautyMoreByManisha
When NTT begin it's journey, I was happy to see true journalism.. impressed with your Manipur episodes.. but over the period NTT has turned out to be ' just one of them'.. particularly your stories on Bengal is blindfolded.. Not telling truth
এই বিচার এর জন্য, মোমবাতি মিছিল করার জন্য, নবান্ন অভিযান করার জন্য যারা Fund দিল এবং যাদের pocket এ ঢুকলো সেই কাজ টা আস্মিকার চিকিৎসার donation এর বেলা কোন গর্তে লুকিয়ে আছে খুব জানতে ইচ্ছা হচ্ছে,
So now the question is if this incident repeats what will be the procedures or reprucursions that should be taken by the general public and the governmert and if all facets of the involvement to those in the case whoa re directly or indirectly related to the accused or the victim has been detailed for and presented to the public, if corruption and politics creeps into such matters then we need to question what type of society we are living in and if the government that we elected has been successful enough to maintain order and ethics in the society. Please make a documentary on the other accused as well.
Excuse this two guys why are they trying to use this case of crowdfunding and using their youtube channel for creating an expose. What is the type of this channel is this a news channel, roast channel an edu informative channel. Well this views are going to add to their account also. Please guys if you have not been sheepish during the rg kar mass protest, don't try to negate a forum stating the same as a post mortem of a doctor's forum. You donot belong to that league also
Wrong explanation of "UPI SETTLEMENT" - Settlement can be either Gross(Gross settlement means transactions are handled and settled individually, so multiple transactions) or Net(Net settlement is a bank's routine resolution of the day's transactions at the end of the business day). Since the settlement type here is not known so we can only speculate. Otherwise as always fantastic work by NTT👍
Moreover it's very bard to trace the physical movement of cash and thus easier for the money raised via Chanda/Donation to pay in cash/hawala. If it's via UPI or any other channels law enforcement agencies can easily trace the origin.
😂 I don't know why ,, West Bengal protest is very much faster spread rather than other states, but indias others unsecured states peoples are crying for west Bengals security , its fully a fake imotion till now 😂 Whyyyyy,,,, because bjp have no gvrmt there? Whyyy ,, we were not able to change realy our india , because we were again missed change by only focusing a single case rather than entire INDIA's social system..
Excellent data collection.lf anybody is raise his finger and question about this account and its expenditure pattern and go to hon'ble High Court,Kolkata for justice,with due respect to the hon'ble Court it may be said that public has no accountibility to question in this tegard.
Bjp's tried every thing to bring down the mamta govt and politicise the issue but it failed to reach its conclusion this giving a blow to the bjp. Such grave issues should never be made. Political tool but rather justice should be delivered to the victims family .
What a shame in the name of journalism. Firstly, if a group has ill intensions, they will never deposit money in bank accounts, because it's digital and it has money trail. So, I'm good to know that money we sent were actually moved to a legit bank account. Secondly, they needed legal voice, if they paid to advocate legal fees through digital means, it's no issue. It's white money transferred. Third, when you are fighting against a government who spends crores of rupees in media management through IPAC, you need counter social media campaigns to gain any traction. This is the harsh truth in today's digital age. If they don't do it, IPAC bot channels will flood the internet with counter false propaganda and kill the cause. Now the questions, as a "journalist", can you expose how much government has spent on legal fees till now to fight all the corruption charges ? That is public money collected through tax not voluntary donations. Next, disclose your funding, show us NTT financials. Given your youtube subscription and views, you are not earning a lot through youtube to run the show. I will believe all your stories and even start paying for your journalism, if you publish NTT audited financial statements. Cut the crap Tamal, you are propaganda machine funded by TMC and history will remember you.
Ebar apni prothom din theke sanjay rai er verdict obdi akta aai rokom ashadharon report tairi korun tar por amta bhabte boshbo ke beshi doshi junior doctors naki sandip ghosh n company.
Rules are main not only one person related matters it is Rules helps to control over what is used for unnecessary circumstances of social life's related services facilities taken by people
Why r u in Qatar??? Simply leaving waste bengal & saying this is honest journalism.this is called leura journalism.journalist can't track any politicians bank account .
@@Anirudh-er9fgWhat a Language! Shows BJP IT Cell culture very well. Please also ask the people of Gujarat why are they leaving India to enter into USA through borders illegally.
@@Inmyopinion-s9 I am an Indian citizen.i don't belong from any third class poltical party.when u said BJP it's clearly showing that u belong from a political party who is an uneducated .
The video is really beautiful because every piece of information is analyzed through observation and methodology. Best wishes for the future. I would like to see many more such reports. But I have one regret. If this reporting was in Bengali, I think it would have reached more people in Bengali. But I will say that this effort is really commendable. Where other media have forgotten this issue in the media, you are the only one reporting on the issue.
So along with good points being raised, the whole thing went down a few notches just because of inclusion of a few non-sensical points. The whole Kolkata Operation thing was just clickbait. As if "operation" isn't a thing which is associated with a doctor day in/day out. Why High Court branch, the question serves no logical purpose. You don't have to go down to the branch everyday to deposit money. You open the account once and then operate it online. So branch is of no consequence. Also isn't an event management company the perfect choice for ensuring continuous supply of water bottles, fans, food materials, tarpauline sheds? Is it even a logical question? The other points are fair enough. But these three are just worthless and illogical.
It would be brave if do this type of investigation against sandip ghosh, vinit goyal, or similar types of people...RG kar was actually oppressed by sandip ghosh or not...
@@Opinion_01 What if anyone is questioning the money movement? Are Jr.Doctors above all law? No one cannot question them? Is this you are saying. They should give clarification on their money collection and sources.
@@rajatkantidutta who said dr are above law...I said it not bravery since there is no threat...but investing vandalism etc there are threats..and those things will never came out...if this protest is connected to larger conspiracy against the st. then our brave police will promptly find it...Tamal Saha is as brave as our police.
Abhaya was a victim of a system led by individuals like Sandip Ghosh and his goons. Such incidents should never recur, which is why the youth are fighting for this cause. Posting video clips to polarize the situation is the lowest form of journalism. Shame on you all. Tamal the dress looks very nice, hope you glow more with the new earn dirty money.
Bapre, english speaking Tolamul channel. Bro, find some money trail of Sandip Ghosh. How much money reached to Kali****t and the concerned Money channel after dividing 75-25 commission cut.
Data dekhle ato ga jole keno satotar natok gulo loke jene jache bole ato chulkani? Sandip ghosh akjon kalprit take niye cbi tadanto akhon ses hoini... ota under investigation ache dosi promanito hole dristantomulok sasti hok tai bole era char pabe keno jara meyetar laser opor darie koti koti taka pocket a vorlo? Expose sabai hok
I have never seen him interested in exposing any scam , any corruption , how construction industry is thruving with such poor quality? Nothing encourages him there are so many issues but why money has been collected in the name of a cause is a major threat for him 😅..ridiculous and highly motivated ...call it anything but independent JOURNALISM 😢😡
Excellent exposure of Crowd Funding in the name of "justice". Keep exposing on ...great
বাঙলায় এই অসাধারণ ভিডিও দুটো বের করুন। হুজুগে বাঙ্গালী জাতির চোখ কান যদি খোলে বিশেষতঃ শিল্পী দের । 😢
একদম 😢😢
Exactly বাংলায় দরকার আছে, তমাল দার data আর বিশ্লষণী ক্ষমতা যা million view derserve করে সাথে বাংলার মানুষ সঠিক তথ্য deserve করে
Sir half of your conclusions to report are based on your presumtions and assumptions. Justice for abhaya doesn't end with just opposing rape, there's a huge game behind it which led to what happened with Abhaya- The Party's Political Influence, false medicines, threat culture etc. All these summed up under the banner of "JUSTICE FOR ABHAYA". And we all knew about it. This was not a usual rape, it happened due to corruptions and abhaya speaking against corruption, which actually led to her death.
Yes we all, who were protesting from the ground, knew about it. We supported WBJDF to even fight against these corruptions, that actually led to the death of this young doctor. Even if they were voicing against corruption, keeping lawyers to fight the case on behalf of them, we all supported it. People who funded, even supported this cause. This is the reason why Avik, Birupakkho, Sandip are now under trial. These are all part of JUSTICE, we are DEMANDING, and we support it.
This is call Real JOURNALISM
HAT'S OFF
choti chata.
@wonji5385 khuni budho r dhuti chata
Brilliant work! Keep going!
@ Tamal Saha - when you started it was so impressive. I meant your independent, from the ground, fearless & unbiased journalism was like fresh air. And it continued for some time. However from mid of August 2024, that is after the Abhaya/ Tilottama case things have changed completely. Question is not that whether you are right or wrong in your assessment of the "Justice for Abhaya" protest. Question is as a Journalist are you doing justice to your audience by ignoring pertinent questions about the case. While you should always question the motive of protesting junior doctors, their sources of funds, the dubious role of the left parties in this movement etc, should not you raise questions about the following as well???
1) Didn't the RG Kar authority initially try to push the case under the carpet? Else why such a delay?
2) Wasn't the police reluctant about filing the FIR? Even when they filed it, the FIR was not comprehensive. Even the police investigation looked like it was just about identifying & arresting the one culprit without looking at the big picture
3) Why the post mortem conducted so late? Why a second one was not done despite insistence from her parents?
4) Did the CBI do justice through a thorough investigation or did they just organized, structured & presented the evidences given by the Police to prepare a strong chargesheet against this one criminal?
4) Had the CBI felt that all evidence was not there or some evidence have been destroyed/ tampered with, they should have clearly mentioned the same in the court and tried pulling up those who were behind such things!
5) Did the CBI interrogate all concerned - staffs present in the RG Kar hospital during that night, security guards, nurses, doctors, classmates, department heads? What were the findings?
6) Why couldn't the CBI file chargesheet against Sandeep Ghosh and the local OC in 90 days? Where did they get stuck?
7) Don't you think the Hon'bl Judge in this case did the right thing by giving life imprisonment to the culprit Sanjay Ray - that way at least there's a possibility that in future the truth (if there's any more than what is presented now) may actually come out??
why 6th questions to godi media and bjp, as cbi thier caged parrot
@@hannanhub1717 we don't want to compare tamal with godi or whatever media it is... that's why he is asking this question as an audience of his journalism videos
The parents are habitually lying that is what is creating trouble else this is an open and shut case
@@thedocgamermy goodness 😢 now you are saying parents are lying..are you a normal human being ?
@@rajrupachatterjee256 media shows so many statements of parents, it's a question what they actually said, recently they said 50 peoples involved, initially this is all about Sandeep Ghosh & his few accomplices, they meet Suvendu Adhikari from bjp for justice but now they are saying it's a setup of modi & didi, btw video is about money & yes junior doctors collected money in the name of protest & justice.
There are another rape case in Jaynagar around same time where death penalty was given to accused, no one collected money for justice in that case
Sir u r not a Journalist...You are Sherlock Holmes 👏
ha bhai ..tor nam dekhei bojhacche tui keno support korchis
@@subhadipmallick3899 ei videor onnyano comment gulor nam dekhe bolto tara keno support korchhe ?
Still couldn't find money trail that goes to kalighat
Yes, this Sherlock Holmes will only expose them 🤣🤣, which is the right thing to do. But this Sherlock Holmes can never expose the government 🤣🤣. He only exposes small people. If he were a real Sherlock, he would expose the big ones along with the small ones too!
So, this means he is a biased journalist, just like other journalists who support a particular party. In in my country , there are no real journalists, bro. Some support the right wing, and some support the left wing 😂.
Still justice not served...kolkata police cbi all are ghus khor..and tmc is biggest chor of state
Bjp has some links with rgkar case
It was last ditch attempt by communists to stay relevant.
Excellent reporting throughout ❤ take love
Tamal Bhai ,
Need to publish in Bengali language to reach out to common people specially urban .
Make it in bengali also, so that many can realise the real story
make this two part in Bengali or hindi for maximum reach otherwise no one knows nothing....
@@night-c3l thanks for the feedback. The work has started. Will be there very soon. But till then, kindly do share the story if you like it. Thanks
@@NTT-BY-TAMALSAHA thank you davai etai sunte chichilam
opekhai roilam
The central government has been perceived as neglecting Bengal and Punjab since India's independence. Despite Bengalis playing a crucial role in the country's independence, no Bengali has become the Prime Minister to date. Even Netaji's birthday is not a national holiday.
The most rich 22 persons of India have the same money as that of 70 cr people have!
Finally Netaji is gradually getting his recognition. Check the recent developments.
It was earlier such because the new Congress govt post independence was a continuation of the Raaj - as we had power transfer not direct revolutionary independence
খুব খারাপ লাগছে..যেটা নিয়ে গোয়েন্দা হওয়ার থেকে মানবিক হওয়ার দরকার ছিল। কুসঙ্গ একেই বলে। শিক্ষা স্বাস্থ্য কাটমানি এটা নিয়ে মনে হয় বেশি বলা দরকার ছিল। খুঁজে বের করুন দেখি কে করল কেনো করলো...সেটা মনে হয় বেশি দরকারি ছিলো।😔
Facts are facts. Kon kon jaygay mislead kora hoyeche seta dekhale somossa kothay. Prosasoner fault gulo to sobai jane kintu opposite side er blunder guloy loke januk!
We want more exposures on these fund transactions
One of the best journalism❤ we are just seeing one side of story in the media ...❤
I cannot commented any channel. But today this news channel are constrained me to commen. But i have one suggestion that you sir promote this channel in bengali version
@@koushikbiswas5517 thanks a lot. Please engage more with us. Plz subscribe to the channel and kindly ask your friends and family to support us by subscribing. We are coming up with NTT Bengali very soon. Dhonnobad
@@NTT-BY-TAMALSAHAplz Ata bangla te korun r Atai first video korun.
Love you Tamal. Keep up the good work. ❤❤❤
"kolkata operation" definitely has to do something witn "chaddi gang"
Everyone got money for the protest needs to give a proper justification of in which ways they have used the money.. It is their job to give all the details because it's the money of the common people... If they would have done that before then no one would have tried to frame them... They need to give a proper data of the expenses.. Why hasn't they done that? It is their duty to do so without even asking.. And if there are a lot of funds still left, then they should have either given the money back who sent that money or may be they should have given that to any NGO's or atleast they should have gaven that to the family of the Abhaya... It's not their fucking money that they will keep it to themselves... And if they do so, then from the next time if anything happens like this then no one would support the protesters.. This will make a very bad example to the people...
Brilliant journalism
Keep it up Tamal and team!!
Please release Bengali version of this video and the previous video of this series
@@probalbanerjee8746 we are working on that. We thank you for your support
Need bengali
কিছু লোকের(ডাক্তারের)গাঁড় জ্বলবে.... 🤭🤭
Dev er bank account check korben.kichu loker ( apnar moto bokachoda public er )jolbe..
sorir kharap hole choti chatbi...rog sere jabe ..daktar er kache bhuleo jas na
Superb journalists analysis.
Nobody bothers about murder and rape.People are bothering about their political gains.
Expose these doctors. They have played with our emotion it seems like. Dil mange more - Part 3 pls
I still can't find anything fishy. Just one thing in the Supreme Court Indira Jaysingh was paid 11lac was worthless. Other than that everything is fine and the choice of the doctors. In the first part there was nothing also. I can't understand your point.
Watch this video with an open mind you will understand
@@shahbaaz2958 Define Open Mind!!! I have scrutinised every part of the video. I didn't find anything other than speculations. As per "Merriam Webstar" Open Mind means a willingness to listen to or accept different ideas or opinions. So please investigate the meaning of "Open Mind", "Scrutiny" and "Speculation". I had become a fan of Mr. Tamal Saha during the Manipur Series. But now!! He didn't used to do speculative videos
Can u answer why event management company were hired nd why fund from two individual accounts where not transferred to main account. Futher why they r asking for more donations when the funds r lying ideal. They shud have transferred the amount to abhaya parents bank account. Doctors these days r not god they will recommend medicines in which they get hired cut money from pharmaceutical companies.
@@akashagarwal869 first of all I am not here to advocate anyone. But still as your are asking.. don't you have multiple bank accounts do you transfer all the amounts to the same account? Let's say you and your friend have organised a crowd funding for a great social cause. You have distributed pamphlets with two bank accounts details on it. Now it has become so big that you didn't expect lakhs of money are coming everyday. Now you both decided to operate with a single account. And you did distribute the account details with the crowd. Crowd are being crowd the still sending money to the old bank account. Now what you will decide! Let's get hell with it we will operate all the three accounts isn't it! Does Aavayas parents need that money! Or the movement needs money! Even a Saraswati Puja of kids nowadays are organised by event management organisations. Then what is the problem! They are probably organising food transport etc. and trust me on one thing two crore is really small amount for such a large movement. yes the doctor's nowadays the perfect কসাই . But this has nothing to do with these movement because these movement was not of the doctors only these movement was for the justice and the doctors made it look like about their elections they are fools. This movement needed to be political and it was actually not that was the main problem.
@abjee93 organic movement being managed by event management company with drone videos omg. Btw did u donated anything or just giving Gyaan
All you have shown is that people funneled money anonymously. Unless the identity is found, no political intent can be proved. The alleged digital transfer against cash too seem a matter of convenience - not laundrring.
Really well done my brother. Lots of love, support and wishes to you and your team.
Awesome investigative journalism! Keep up the great work
Amr 450/- taka beekar gelo😑
Ferot chan ota parle asmika r parents er account a din
Level of journalism is beyond words!
youtubers o journalist 😀
tahole sofikul o journalist 😅
Fantastic! Journalism. Keep up the good work👏
JETA ABP 24 GHONTAR KORAR KOTHA CHILO APNARA KORE DEKHIACHEN . HATS OFF .
KOLKATA POLICE R GOVT K BOLBO PRESS CONF KORTE AND IMMIDIATLY START AN INVESIGATION
Excellent job done!! Bravo 👏👏
Great work dada
I respect you guys but upi settlement is not a settlement you are defining in the video. Actually when you don't want to deposit a small amount received through upi in your account you instruct banks to deposit the whole amount in your account every fortnight or whatever time interval in which you are comfortable. So the amount credited to your bank account after accumulating all amounts received during that period of time and it will be credited as upi settlement.
Very many thanks for the laboursome works to nail the ill intentions behind the picaresque act wich destroys goodwills and trust of general public.
very very good journalism.
Brilliant work dada
The investigation must be released in Bangla and Hindi also.
All the doctors involved shall be trailed for PMLA
Great work Tamal 👌🏻👌🏻
Tamal Da,
Big fan. But your Kolkata Operation analysis might be wrong. I am a Hdfc account holder. If you deposit any cheque, the "Kolkata Operation" term is automatically added by HDFC.
So basically the total amount tagged as "Kolkata Operation" can be simply considered as cheque deposits.
@@baniksden7481 thanks for writing to us. I have verified with the bank before doing the story. On the same day there has been several other transactions, several other cheque deposits but not all were termed as “Kolkata operation”. 24 selective were drawn as Kolkata Operation.
@NTT-BY-TAMALSAHA Ok Dada,
But in my account whenever any cheque is getting deposited, it's getting the Kolkata Operation tag as well.
The indiscretion of HDFC Bank in revealing details of their clients' account is appalling. Their gross failure to maintain secrecy and confidentiality of their customer's account is shocking - they have violated the most sacrosanct duty of a banker.
@@somnathchoudhury2633 I don't think youtuber like him will get this type of info that easily... either it is made up or he has state police support...or maybe someone known to him works in the HDFC...
Investigative journalism এটাকেই বলে, টিভি নিউজ এ তো এসব হয়না, হোয়াটস্যাপ এর fake নিউজ থিওরি চালায় তাই বোধহয় বিষয় টা আপনাদের মনে নেই @@soumitrachakraborty9413
State support @@soumitrachakraborty9413
Comment section ta porun..akjon bolechhe oi hdfc branch er cheque use korechhilo.. tar transaction eu kolkata operation eta lekha aschhetransaction history te...sudhu suspenseful sound ar speculations diye youtube chole professional journalism noi..akta investigation amder state er eto durniti related kore dekhak...lifetime support korbo@@BeautyMoreByManisha
@@soumitrachakraborty9413 abar ki?????
Excellent Job...of Crowd Funding & Political Agenda also Private Hospital Scams
why your views are always so low
Because no one cares about actual investigative journalism
Excellent presentation. Investigation should be ordered.
hisab ta kemon guliye gelo
When NTT begin it's journey, I was happy to see true journalism.. impressed with your Manipur episodes.. but over the period NTT has turned out to be ' just one of them'.. particularly your stories on Bengal is blindfolded.. Not telling truth
Well exposed bro ❤ keep posting.....
India is not Bangladesh. Here one has to win an election and one just cannot overthrow an elected Government.
Brilliant explanations,thanks a lot.
Need a solid Investigation...😇😇
এই বিচার এর জন্য, মোমবাতি মিছিল করার জন্য, নবান্ন অভিযান করার জন্য যারা Fund দিল এবং যাদের pocket এ ঢুকলো
সেই কাজ টা আস্মিকার চিকিৎসার donation এর বেলা কোন গর্তে লুকিয়ে আছে
খুব জানতে ইচ্ছা হচ্ছে,
Ja korechen besh korechen!! More power to you ❤!!
দ্রোহ মারানি দের র কি বলার আছে
So now the question is if this incident repeats what will be the procedures or reprucursions that should be taken by the general public and the governmert and if all facets of the involvement to those in the case whoa re directly or indirectly related to the accused or the victim has been detailed for and presented to the public, if corruption and politics creeps into such matters then we need to question what type of society we are living in and if the government that we elected has been successful enough to maintain order and ethics in the society. Please make a documentary on the other accused as well.
If govt is corrupted on the other junior doctors are also corrupted.They have looted the fund in the name of Avaya.
I feel sorry for the people who donated this money. These doners may wel not be well off.
Excuse this two guys why are they trying to use this case of crowdfunding and using their youtube channel for creating an expose. What is the type of this channel is this a news channel, roast channel an edu informative channel. Well this views are going to add to their account also. Please guys if you have not been sheepish during the rg kar mass protest, don't try to negate a forum stating the same as a post mortem of a doctor's forum. You donot belong to that league also
Sir please do some news on exam scam and share some details how much money tmc earn from it..
Wrong explanation of "UPI SETTLEMENT" - Settlement can be either Gross(Gross settlement means transactions are handled and settled individually, so multiple transactions) or Net(Net settlement is a bank's routine resolution of the day's transactions at the end of the business day). Since the settlement type here is not known so we can only speculate. Otherwise as always fantastic work by NTT👍
Moreover it's very bard to trace the physical movement of cash and thus easier for the money raised via Chanda/Donation to pay in cash/hawala. If it's via UPI or any other channels law enforcement agencies can easily trace the origin.
uff Tamal excellent job...now plz try to find out the money trail left behind Sandeep Ghosh & Co.
That he conveniently won't
😂 I don't know why ,, West Bengal protest is very much faster spread rather than other states, but indias others unsecured states peoples are crying for west Bengals security , its fully a fake imotion till now 😂
Whyyyyy,,,, because bjp have no gvrmt there?
Whyyy ,, we were not able to change realy our india , because we were again missed change by only focusing a single case rather than entire INDIA's social system..
ফাটাফাটি ❤
Excellent data collection.lf anybody is raise his finger and question about this account and its expenditure pattern and go to hon'ble High Court,Kolkata for justice,with due respect to the hon'ble Court it may be said that public has no accountibility to question in this tegard.
Bjp's tried every thing to bring down the mamta govt and politicise the issue but it failed to reach its conclusion this giving a blow to the bjp.
Such grave issues should never be made. Political tool but rather justice should be delivered to the victims family .
What a shame in the name of journalism.
Firstly, if a group has ill intensions, they will never deposit money in bank accounts, because it's digital and it has money trail. So, I'm good to know that money we sent were actually moved to a legit bank account.
Secondly, they needed legal voice, if they paid to advocate legal fees through digital means, it's no issue. It's white money transferred.
Third, when you are fighting against a government who spends crores of rupees in media management through IPAC, you need counter social media campaigns to gain any traction. This is the harsh truth in today's digital age. If they don't do it, IPAC bot channels will flood the internet with counter false propaganda and kill the cause.
Now the questions, as a "journalist", can you expose how much government has spent on legal fees till now to fight all the corruption charges ? That is public money collected through tax not voluntary donations.
Next, disclose your funding, show us NTT financials. Given your youtube subscription and views, you are not earning a lot through youtube to run the show. I will believe all your stories and even start paying for your journalism, if you publish NTT audited financial statements.
Cut the crap Tamal, you are propaganda machine funded by TMC and history will remember you.
I hope you are aware that you are being trailed as well.
Ebar apni prothom din theke sanjay rai er verdict obdi akta aai rokom ashadharon report tairi korun tar por amta bhabte boshbo ke beshi doshi junior doctors naki sandip ghosh n company.
Rules are main not only one person related matters it is
Rules helps to control over what is used for unnecessary circumstances of social life's related services facilities taken by people
Excellent, this is honest journalism, keep it up guys , good luck, from Doha, Qatar
Why r u in Qatar??? Simply leaving waste bengal & saying this is honest journalism.this is called leura journalism.journalist can't track any politicians bank account .
@@Anirudh-er9fgWhat a Language! Shows BJP IT Cell culture very well. Please also ask the people of Gujarat why are they leaving India to enter into USA through borders illegally.
@@Inmyopinion-s9 I am an Indian citizen.i don't belong from any third class poltical party.when u said BJP it's clearly showing that u belong from a political party who is an uneducated .
@@Anirudh-er9fg If you are an Indian citizen then don't disrespect any state. There is no India without Bengal.
@@Inmyopinion-s9 perhaps u don't know the meaning of democracy in india.
Brilliant job
Even God May Not Save, WAITING.
Appreciate
This is a TMC dalal channel.
How much money u get from Kalighat Taalir Chala?
Totally untrue and has some vested interest
Have these doctors paid the celebs also then , to be a part of their protest .. 🤔🤨
This could be part of a larger BJP modus operandi in opposition ruled states ably supported by national media & governor to create unrest.
The video is really beautiful because every piece of information is analyzed through observation and methodology. Best wishes for the future. I would like to see many more such reports. But I have one regret. If this reporting was in Bengali, I think it would have reached more people in Bengali. But I will say that this effort is really commendable. Where other media have forgotten this issue in the media, you are the only one reporting on the issue.
চাঁদা তুলে তাবুর নিচে রান্ডী নাচ, এরা হলো ডাক্তার
Brilliant exposing
So along with good points being raised, the whole thing went down a few notches just because of inclusion of a few non-sensical points.
The whole Kolkata Operation thing was just clickbait. As if "operation" isn't a thing which is associated with a doctor day in/day out.
Why High Court branch, the question serves no logical purpose. You don't have to go down to the branch everyday to deposit money. You open the account once and then operate it online. So branch is of no consequence.
Also isn't an event management company the perfect choice for ensuring continuous supply of water bottles, fans, food materials, tarpauline sheds? Is it even a logical question?
The other points are fair enough. But these three are just worthless and illogical.
Very Brave Reporting. Thank you
It would be brave if do this type of investigation against sandip ghosh, vinit goyal, or similar types of people...RG kar was actually oppressed by sandip ghosh or not...
@@Opinion_01 What if anyone is questioning the money movement? Are Jr.Doctors above all law? No one cannot question them? Is this you are saying. They should give clarification on their money collection and sources.
@@rajatkantidutta who said dr are above law...I said it not bravery since there is no threat...but investing vandalism etc there are threats..and those things will never came out...if this protest is connected to larger conspiracy against the st. then our brave police will promptly find it...Tamal Saha is as brave as our police.
@@Opinion_01It takes courage to question the BJP and BJP backed activities.
@@Opinion_01 You are bypassing the issue of mone laundering.
Abhaya was a victim of a system led by individuals like Sandip Ghosh and his goons. Such incidents should never recur, which is why the youth are fighting for this cause. Posting video clips to polarize the situation is the lowest form of journalism. Shame on you all. Tamal the dress looks very nice, hope you glow more with the new earn dirty money.
হাসালেন!
none of your business bhai balkata ar ektiyar er baire esob faltu video baniye justice ke chup korie deua jaabe naa
heart broken
Tamal honest journalist theke apni paid tmc stooge hoye gelen? Wah
আপনার মনের মত কথা না হলেই stooge নাকি?
Tamal dont poke your nose and try to play with fire you dont know what you are playing with
Bapre, english speaking Tolamul channel.
Bro, find some money trail of Sandip Ghosh. How much money reached to Kali****t and the concerned Money channel after dividing 75-25 commission cut.
Come to comment droho marani 😅
@@birdandfishfarmlover8519 asli account se aao kalight er dalal???
Data dekhle ato ga jole keno satotar natok gulo loke jene jache bole ato chulkani?
Sandip ghosh akjon kalprit take niye cbi tadanto akhon ses hoini... ota under investigation ache dosi promanito hole dristantomulok sasti hok
tai bole era char pabe keno jara meyetar laser opor darie koti koti taka pocket a vorlo? Expose sabai hok
Excellent job
Keep it up
I have never seen him interested in exposing any scam , any corruption , how construction industry is thruving with such poor quality? Nothing encourages him there are so many issues but why money has been collected in the name of a cause is a major threat for him 😅..ridiculous and highly motivated ...call it anything but independent JOURNALISM 😢😡
But we all want to know what doctors did with the money
Absolutely @@borrisagassinoida
Baseless single sided video to support an agenda
This is part 2 dumbass
Prove the facts he states wrong instead of throwing comments to suit your leftists agenda which is being exposed here.
RS ticket aspirant in waiting tamal da
apni youtubers নাকি journalist
ᴛᴀᴍᴀʟ ɢᴏ ᴀʜᴇᴀᴅ ᴀʙᴏᴜᴛ ᴛʜɪꜱ ᴍᴀᴛᴛᴇʀ. ᴡᴇ ᴇʀᴇ ᴇᴀɢᴇʀ ᴛᴏ ᴋɴᴏᴡ ꜰᴜʀᴛʜᴇʀ.
salute to whistle blower