The problem in the comments section is people like to give their opinion on matters in which they have no knowledge of, i see pure ignorance from these comments, no ilm no hikmak no adab, go back and actually study the Deen before commenting seriously fear Allah. SubhanAllah I saw an ignorant one say their is no sciences of hadeeth. People slandered our dear sheikh Rahimahullah with unjust accusations. O ignorant ones, do you not know that even if the sheikh was wrong in his opinion then he is still rewarded by Allah azawajal for his efforts as is mentioned in sahih Ahadeeth?
Is the below hadith weak? 😂 Grade : Sahih (Al-Albani) صـحـيـح (الألباني) حكم : Reference : Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 600 In-book reference : Book 30, Hadith 63 English translation : Book 30, Hadith 600 Sa'id ibn al-'As reported that 'Uthman and 'A'isha told him that Abu Bakr asked for permission to come in to the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, while he was lying of 'A'isha's bed, wearing *'A'isha's woollen shirt.*
ASA, the real problem is you don't understand the power of the internet or the power of writing a simple commenting programming script... this technology is old, you should understand many of the 'profiles' of 'people' on here are just botnets built with a 'mission' - keep this in mind, its not localized to youtube, its anywhere there are profiles, including marriage sites...hope this eases your query... #quran #haqq
What an intellect Shyakh al albani ( rahmatulla) has.. What an explanation beautiful. No scholars in recent times have worked so hard as shyakh did. May Allah forgive our beloved shyakh and give him highest place in jannah. Exceptional Hadith scholar!
Dear brother, you did a great Job by providing English Subtitles.. May Allah bless you with the best of the best in this world and the Aakhira..! From past 1 hours I am glued to your channel.. listening to Imam Albani.. May Allah grant him Paradise, and highest ranks in jannah
No book is flawless and absolutely sound other than the Qur'an. Sahih al-Bukhari is the "second" most authentic book to us. People need to understand it.
Dear brothers and sisters, a few years ago I remember using a site online where I could see the classifications by Albani for every single Hadith in Sahih Al Bukhari and Sahih Muslim while also reading the narrations. I can't find it and I would be really glad if someone could help me.
he didn't weaken his work but it's important to know if a narration is upon a Sahaba or the messenger. many hadith the companion added their opinions to like the hour on Friday in sahih muslim
Imam Al Bukhari was a Beautiful Flower. Mircale of ALLAH SWT in the feild of Hadeeth and and Science of Hadeeth. The likes of whom the world never witnessed after his death. people who didn't knew this flower in reality got carried away by dry grasses in passing times. Many such dry grasses disappeared. but the flower always kept blooming. Never ever faded.
JazaakAllah kyrun. Perhaps us women folks strive within the Path of Allah subhana wata ila singling out His Messenger (s) wives; women of Madina; & all the other pious predecessors of the Book by Way of His Messenger (s). Subhan'Allah by Allah subhana wata ila it would be a mercy and a grand guide to emulate his (s) wives; tabieena; or tabiuna; etc. Men don't imitate women👳🏽♂️ or visa versa🧕🏼. Please overlook my weak transliterations
Assalamualaikum uploader, I recently came upon your channel and have noticed your replies to comments. I have a question: Where are you learning the Deen? What qualifications do you have in other words?
he doesn't weaken hadith he clarifies some hadith. and he says he don't know any other book as good as bukhari. it's just your poor title that causes doubt and rebellion to the people of hadith. we follow those who preceeded us in good only not in their fault
All humanbeings are falliable because Allah Almighty wished it so by creating unique Creature-Bashre-Adam and Eve-whose falliability was testified in the very beginning. Prophets being chosen ones for the guidance of humanity are under direct surveillance of Allah and hence perfect models made for us. Rest can never be infallible. The Last Book of Allah is perfect and no other man-made book can claim perfection.
As Salaam Alaikum what does the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after qu'ran in this context even as the shaykh mentioned some hadiths are weak in sahih bukhari?
Wa alaykum salaam wa rahmatullah wa baraktaho Yes, Sahih Al-Bukhari is the most authentic book after the Qur'an, but just because it is the most authentic of all other hadith books, there are still a few weak hadiths in there; while the Qur'an is the book of Allah wherein there is no mistake or contradiction; and there is no book that is of the level of Qur'an,
Amir Abdullah Al-Bey As salaam Alaikum beloved brother my question is what does the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after the qu'ran mean in this context while the shaykh mentioned contain weak hadiths ? In other words how do we understand sahih bukhari being the most authentic after the qu'ran while it has weak hadith ? Are the weaknesses regarding to chain or text ? Are the authenticity regarding to chain only or both ? I'm sorry my confusion arise when someone said something is most authentic book after qu'ran but it contain weak hadith..I hope my question is clear
أهل العلم People Of Knowledgeso if I understand what you are saying ...the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after Qu'ran is regarded in only relation to other hadith books such as sahih muslim, sunna abi dawud so on.....in other words it has more authenticity than the rest of hadith books
Who was a blind mifti of saudi arabia? Was he Slbani or bin baaz who said Ofont believe earth is toumf shaped or egg shapef as i walk on earth it is flat mostly.?
Like others scholars, sheikh albani also has possibility of doing mistakes, by his own arguments, i reject his opinion in hadiths due to trust issues, and take imam muslim and bukhari's compilation. Whom i held in much higher rank than albani.
The Quranists will use this to justify their belief that we should follow Quran and reject the Sunnah 🤦🏻♂️ How should we deal with these guys who come to us and preach that our beliefs about Hadith are wrong and theirs is correct?
Assalam Alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu ya ikhwaani. What happened to the weak Ahadeeth that are found in Sahih Al Bukhari? They're still in the volumes of books of Sahih Al Bukhari that we have today? Why the scholars of this ummah still calls it Sahih while it have those weak Ahadeeth?
Wa alaikom alsslam Wa rahmatuAllah wa brakatoh. You have heared the answer of shaykh Alalbani and you still confused. So my advice to you if you truly seeking knowledge about the matter then you need to Do effort in study and learn under reliable shaykh/or islamic university. Dont seek answer in youtube comment section without proper basic knowledge. Learning needs effort.
When AlBani (May Allah have mercy on him) points out weakness in a hadith from Sahih Al Bukhari, what is highlighted to me is the fallibity and weakness in AlBani's knowledge. Imam Al Bukhari (May Allah have mercy on him) has many books and Sahih is just one among them. We don't say that Sahih is 100 percent authentic just because Imam Bukhari has compiled it, but rather its authenticity is established by the testimony of so many hadith scholars throughout centuries that have passed by. The collective testimony of the scholars of this ummah is a hujja for us.
As Al Albani mentioned others have preceded him in criticising hadiths in Sahih Bukhari and among those was Al Asqalani (a giant in the field of Hadith)
okay he keeps on saying he studied the sciences of hadith and it's different branches but the AL Hus Sunnah wal jammat want to know from whom?????? you can not teach yourself the sciences from reading a book. there is something called sanad, sissila, ijaza to teach a certain study in deen. that's why many different ulama from all four madhabs wrote and warned against him ummmmm ib wonder why?? No chain of knowledge that goes back to Rasool'Allah Sallallahu alayhi wa alihi wa sahbihi wa sallam
First off salam alaykum Clearly you have been told about Albani from others who are biased towards him and gave you a narrative about him without you yourself verifying. As for the Teacher of Albani in this Ilm of hadith it was the muhaddith of Aleppo Shaykh Ragibh At-Tabak, you and your deobandi scholars need to come and take knowledge from this mountain, stop believing Allah is everywhere and then start worryin about seeking knowledge.
I follow the madhab of رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم firstly. And blindly And I take from madhab of الشافعي رحمه الله But I do not blindly follow any imams opinion if it is weak For example in the hanafi madhab it says a divorced women does not need a wali for nikah; following that is going against the sunnah..so I hope you understand where I am coming from....we respect the madhabs but are not fanatics
wahabies salafies are claiming for over many centuries the ummah was on bidah and shirk and all of a sudden you guys came and abondoned and ridicule the madhabs , start slandering the four major imams and you guys force and shove your wahabie salafie methodology down the ummahs throat
FITNA. .. I hope you relaying this is correct and that you stand by what he declares is weak and sahih as its a major sin to lie upon the messenger. this channel always mixes truth with falsehood or doubtful matters. I stand by imam bukhari may Allah have mercy on him and I'm not here to seek or expose his flaws. I guess imam albani knows it all Rahim allah. those men have already passed and we will not be asked about what they did
Brother, are you confused? No one is 'exposing' Imam Bukhari; it's called hadith studies and any hadith narrator is up for critique and yes there are weak hadiths in bukhari and muslim, read the video carefully; the whole point of haditb critique is to NOT LIE on Rasool Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم, Also a hadith that is weak is not a lie on the Prophet rather a fabricated hadith is. You have alot to learn; think before you accuse and write about others
to mix truth and falsehood is deviance and to go into doubtful matters is worse. so bukhari said Ubay ibn Kab wrote the speech of Allah to uthman. maybe we should cut the speech of Allah to albani standards. la may Allah forgive our salaf and may we follow them in good
their is no hadith science. we follow the messenger in good he never left a hadith science and Umar al faruq stopped the collection of hadith in his khalifa. so your science is something that come after so it's best you follow the salaf in good and stop saying science. hadith is fine but don't make it seem like you know and someone else doesn't based on something that was not done in the time of the messenger. bukhari work was painstaking and I take nothing from it and may he b e rewarded double for the mistakes of the companion of added to the wudu hadith
Hass Caram there is no hadith science? Clearly you are young or just plain do not know what you are talking about, I expect more from you akhi...look into things, barakAllahu feek
Hass Caram - The first ḥadīth of Bukhārī from the book of Revelations is Khabar al-Wahid, the second ḥadīth is Mursal Ṣaḥābī, the third ḥadīth is Mudraj, the fourth ḥadīth is al-Munqati.. this was the geniusness of Imām al-Bukhārī to know the authenticity and still be able to use them which was in accordances to his criteria of what is maqbūl and mardūd.
Scholars and people, who knowledge of Islamic history is shockingly poor. Also the lack of understanding of the evolution of language and the importance of culture. How that played a siginificant part in the transmission of hadith. Shaykh Al-Albani, was sincere but misguided in his works. As he only caused fitnah and disunity in the Ummah. Most people who praise Shaykh Al-Albani, do not realize Albanian was his mother tongue! His father Hanafi scholar, disagreed with him on many matters. He was self taught in the hadith books. He self interpreted. Isnad, Isnad for teaching? Who gave Shaykh Al-Albani, the authority to teach hadith books??
My dear brother or sister in Islam. This is a very very bad idea. Let's not backbite other Muslims. I really want you to think about this, you said who gave him permission to teach hadith books, but who gave you the right to tarnish someone's reputation based off of your opinion? You didn't provide any sources so I can't accept anything you said but the allegation that his father disagreed with him doesn't mean he was wrong, albanian being his mother tounge doesn't mean anything, he cleary spoke arabic. Where is your proof he didn't have teachers or that he self interpreted? Please take down your comment.
May Allah forgive and have mercy on his soul for commenting on Saheeh Albukhari. Saheeh Al Bukhari is 100% Saheeh and no body can disprove it. Why this sheikh has opened the doors of ftnah I will never know.
I don't think its fair to say that sh.Albaani opened the door. There were plenty of scholars like Ibn Hajjar and Ibn Qayyium who were mountains in the study of Hadith that have critiqued both Bukhari & Muslim. So the door was always open, you just didn't know
More than 1400 years all scholars, high scholars, sheik al islams . No one Said this and then comes Mr albani with his theory that Some sahih Hadith in bukhari are weak. Who paid him money. Did he sold his soul to the devil. We are the ahle sunna wal jamaa"a and who follows albani, Ibn baz, ibn tayimma, utaymeen etc etc are ahle bidda. I am not saying kafir. Wa allahu alam .
Abdullah BandeHaqq Subhan Allah...clearly you have not read the video...the Shaykh mentioned Ibn Hajr and many weakened some hadiths in Bukhari, before jumping to conclusions; think before you type, your smart I hope you can look into the matter deeper
Abdullah BandeHaqq ,,akhee, sohih bukhari wasn't compiled 1400 years ago and if u watch the video, you should see some scholars that have done the same thing as the sheik. You sound too harsh as if he is refuting the Qur'an. If you really listen well, you should understand a little from his explanations. May Allah grant us useful knowledge.
You have a name brother? And its called IGNORANT! YOU WILL BE QUESTIONED FOR WHAT YOU HAVE ACCUSED OUR GREAT IMAM OF HADITH. MAY ALLAH MAKE US AMONG THOSE WHO RESPECT THE SCHOLARS AND AMONG THOSE WHO SPEAK OUT OF KNOWLEDGE AND NOT EMOTIONS.
You are all wrong. You all misunderstood The Word of Allaah❤❤❤, The Alknown. Stop spreading lies about Allaah❤❤❤, The Almighty. Stop spreading lies about Rassoulloullaah. This is SHIRK. Allaah ❤❤❤ has strictly forbidden us in The Qo'raan to follow self written hadith by mankind. The Qo'raan,The Word of Allaah ❤❤❤The Most Loved is Perfect. What do you not understaand????? You misguide people. Woe you.
![Is Allah Confined to a Place? [Sheikh Muhammad Naasir-ud-Deen al-Albaani]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1IjNSLbA19w/mqdefault.jpg)
At first it looks extreme but when start listening you come down. Sheikh Albani , a great scholar , May Allah grant him the Gardens of Firdaus! !!
The problem in the comments section is people like to give their opinion on matters in which they have no knowledge of, i see pure ignorance from these comments, no ilm no hikmak no adab, go back and actually study the Deen before commenting seriously fear Allah. SubhanAllah I saw an ignorant one say their is no sciences of hadeeth. People slandered our dear sheikh Rahimahullah with unjust accusations. O ignorant ones, do you not know that even if the sheikh was wrong in his opinion then he is still rewarded by Allah azawajal for his efforts as is mentioned in sahih Ahadeeth?
Is the below hadith weak? 😂
Grade : Sahih (Al-Albani) صـحـيـح (الألباني) حكم :
Reference : Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 600
In-book reference : Book 30, Hadith 63
English translation : Book 30, Hadith 600
Sa'id ibn al-'As reported that 'Uthman and 'A'isha told him that Abu Bakr asked for permission to come in to the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, while he was lying of 'A'isha's bed, wearing *'A'isha's woollen shirt.*
jxcess3891 What’s funny about the Hadith?
Mohammad Rizwaan I don’t get what’s funny either, it may be funny to one who’s heart is dead. May Allah protect us from it.
Agreed brother
ASA, the real problem is you don't understand the power of the internet or the power of writing a simple commenting programming script... this technology is old, you should understand many of the 'profiles' of 'people' on here are just botnets built with a 'mission' - keep this in mind, its not localized to youtube, its anywhere there are profiles, including marriage sites...hope this eases your query... #quran #haqq
What an intellect Shyakh al albani ( rahmatulla) has.. What an explanation beautiful. No scholars in recent times have worked so hard as shyakh did. May Allah forgive our beloved shyakh and give him highest place in jannah. Exceptional Hadith scholar!
Dear brother, you did a great Job by providing English Subtitles.. May Allah bless you with the best of the best in this world and the Aakhira..! From past 1 hours I am glued to your channel.. listening to Imam Albani.. May Allah grant him Paradise, and highest ranks in jannah
When I entered Islaam Shaykh al Albaanee.. He clarified a lot for me. He, raheemah Allaah was gone already. Then we lost Shaykh Bin Baaz.
Subhan Allah. Where are you from brother?
JazakAllah Khair ya akhi. And just before I run out of statements of thanking you. Just keep on doing this Khair.
Wa iyakum akhi karim..in sha Allah
@@peopleofknowledge1 . Same here. JazakAllahu khayr.
No book is flawless and absolutely sound other than the Qur'an. Sahih al-Bukhari is the "second" most authentic book to us. People need to understand it.
بارك الله فيك اخي
People attack sheikh Al Albani, رحمه الله, a lot for his works in Hadith. This was a great clarification on the matter.
I personally didn't know this. I thought all the scholars considered the Saheehayn to be 100% perfect.
Dear brothers and sisters,
a few years ago I remember using a site online where I could see the classifications by Albani for every single Hadith in Sahih Al Bukhari and Sahih Muslim while also reading the narrations. I can't find it and I would be really glad if someone could help me.
jazakAllah khayr for uploading this.
Eye opening alhamdurillah
he didn't weaken his work but it's important to know if a narration is upon a Sahaba or the messenger. many hadith the companion added their opinions to like the hour on Friday in sahih muslim
Ayewallah MashaAllah 👍💯💐🌹
Imam Al Bukhari was a Beautiful Flower. Mircale of ALLAH SWT in the feild of Hadeeth and and Science of Hadeeth. The likes of whom the world never witnessed after his death.
people who didn't knew this flower in reality got carried away by dry grasses in passing times. Many such dry grasses disappeared. but the flower always kept blooming. Never ever faded.
SubahanAllah
Jazakallahoe khairan.
Thank you for the english but many parts are still not understandable. If you can get someone who can translate better please do.
Sahih with Weak Hadeeth this is a serious confusion
We need clarifications. Logical explanations on this
Why are there advertisements of card games in the midst of these video clips? Inna lillahi wa inna ilaihi raajioon.
We don't put ads on this channel, so it is TH-cam. Barak Allahu feek
Guys you choose imam bukhari or albani?
imaam bukhari
isn't translating yatimma as 'perfect' better than 'complete'? jazakallah Khair for the video brother
from what i just heard, these are still considered SAHIH. just have some technicality issues with the source itself. Again, still SAHIH.
JazaakAllah kyrun. Perhaps us women folks strive within the Path of Allah subhana wata ila singling out His Messenger (s) wives; women of Madina; & all the other pious predecessors of the Book by Way of His Messenger (s). Subhan'Allah by Allah subhana wata ila it would be a mercy and a grand guide to emulate his (s) wives; tabieena; or tabiuna; etc. Men don't imitate women👳🏽♂️ or visa versa🧕🏼. Please overlook my weak transliterations
Assalamualaikum uploader, I recently came upon your channel and have noticed your replies to comments. I have a question: Where are you learning the Deen? What qualifications do you have in other words?
H G quran and sunnah
he doesn't weaken hadith he clarifies some hadith. and he says he don't know any other book as good as bukhari. it's just your poor title that causes doubt and rebellion to the people of hadith. we follow those who preceeded us in good only not in their fault
He does both and Allah knows best
All humanbeings are falliable because Allah Almighty wished it so by creating unique Creature-Bashre-Adam and Eve-whose falliability was testified in the very beginning. Prophets being chosen ones for the guidance of humanity are under direct surveillance of Allah and hence perfect models made for us. Rest can never be infallible. The Last Book of Allah is perfect and no other man-made book can claim perfection.
As Salaam Alaikum what does the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after qu'ran in this context even as the shaykh mentioned some hadiths are weak in sahih bukhari?
Abu Muhamed Alee Al Ansari What is your question?! What is it that you are asking ya habib?!
Wa alaykum salaam wa rahmatullah wa baraktaho
Yes, Sahih Al-Bukhari is the most authentic book after the Qur'an, but just because it is the most authentic of all other hadith books, there are still a few weak hadiths in there; while the Qur'an is the book of Allah wherein there is no mistake or contradiction; and there is no book that is of the level of Qur'an,
Amir Abdullah Al-Bey As salaam Alaikum beloved brother my question is what does the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after the qu'ran mean in this context while the shaykh mentioned contain weak hadiths ? In other words how do we understand sahih bukhari being the most authentic after the qu'ran while it has weak hadith ? Are the weaknesses regarding to chain or text ? Are the authenticity regarding to chain only or both ? I'm sorry my confusion arise when someone said something is most authentic book after qu'ran but it contain weak hadith..I hope my question is clear
أهل العلم People Of Knowledgeso if I understand what you are saying ...the statement sahih bukhari is the most authentic book after Qu'ran is regarded in only relation to other hadith books such as sahih muslim, sunna abi dawud so on.....in other words it has more authenticity than the rest of hadith books
Abu Muhamed Alee Al Ansari exactly akhi
Who was a blind mifti of saudi arabia? Was he Slbani or bin baaz who said Ofont believe earth is toumf shaped or egg shapef as i walk on earth it is flat mostly.?
Same people transmitted quran as those who transmitted Ahadiths
Like others scholars, sheikh albani also has possibility of doing mistakes, by his own arguments, i reject his opinion in hadiths due to trust issues, and take imam muslim and bukhari's compilation. Whom i held in much higher rank than albani.
Watch it again he not criticizing but talked about what he found out through the science of hadith
The Quranists will use this to justify their belief that we should follow Quran and reject the Sunnah 🤦🏻♂️
How should we deal with these guys who come to us and preach that our beliefs about Hadith are wrong and theirs is correct?
Assalam Alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu ya ikhwaani.
What happened to the weak Ahadeeth that are found in Sahih Al Bukhari?
They're still in the volumes of books of Sahih Al Bukhari that we have today?
Why the scholars of this ummah still calls it Sahih while it have those weak Ahadeeth?
Wa alaikom alsslam Wa rahmatuAllah wa brakatoh.
You have heared the answer of shaykh Alalbani and you still confused. So my advice to you if you truly seeking knowledge about the matter then you need to Do effort in study and learn under reliable shaykh/or islamic university.
Dont seek answer in youtube comment section without proper basic knowledge.
Learning needs effort.
When AlBani (May Allah have mercy on him) points out weakness in a hadith from Sahih Al Bukhari, what is highlighted to me is the fallibity and weakness in AlBani's knowledge.
Imam Al Bukhari (May Allah have mercy on him) has many books and Sahih is just one among them. We don't say that Sahih is 100 percent authentic just because Imam Bukhari has compiled it, but rather its authenticity is established by the testimony of so many hadith scholars throughout centuries that have passed by. The collective testimony of the scholars of this ummah is a hujja for us.
As Al Albani mentioned others have preceded him in criticising hadiths in Sahih Bukhari and among those was Al Asqalani (a giant in the field of Hadith)
okay he keeps on saying he studied the sciences of hadith and it's different branches but the AL Hus Sunnah wal jammat want to know from whom?????? you can not teach yourself the sciences from reading a book. there is something called sanad, sissila, ijaza to teach a certain study in deen. that's why many different ulama from all four madhabs wrote and warned against him ummmmm ib wonder why?? No chain of knowledge that goes back to Rasool'Allah Sallallahu alayhi wa alihi wa sahbihi wa sallam
First off salam alaykum
Clearly you have been told about Albani from others who are biased towards him and gave you a narrative about him without you yourself verifying. As for the Teacher of Albani in this Ilm of hadith it was the muhaddith of Aleppo Shaykh Ragibh At-Tabak, you and your deobandi scholars need to come and take knowledge from this mountain, stop believing Allah is everywhere and then start worryin about seeking knowledge.
okay your going way off topic their bud lol relax let me buy you dinner one day InshaAllah first of all which madhab you follow brother
I follow the madhab of رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم firstly. And blindly
And I take from madhab of الشافعي رحمه الله
But I do not blindly follow any imams opinion if it is weak
For example in the hanafi madhab it says a divorced women does not need a wali for nikah; following that is going against the sunnah..so I hope you understand where I am coming from....we respect the madhabs but are not fanatics
أهل العلم People Of Knowledge how is following that going against the sunnah
wahabies salafies are claiming for over many centuries the ummah was on bidah and shirk and all of a sudden you guys came and abondoned and ridicule the madhabs , start slandering the four major imams and you guys force and shove your wahabie salafie methodology down the ummahs throat
Albani has great knowledge in sciences of hadiths but he has made mistake too
Are you seaching a masoom scholar. U can't find one. Masoom is only our beloved Prophet( alaihesalaam)
Really - we all make mistakes 🤔 😀 😀
FITNA. .. I hope you relaying this is correct and that you stand by what he declares is weak and sahih as its a major sin to lie upon the messenger. this channel always mixes truth with falsehood or doubtful matters. I stand by imam bukhari may Allah have mercy on him and I'm not here to seek or expose his flaws. I guess imam albani knows it all Rahim allah. those men have already passed and we will not be asked about what they did
Brother, are you confused?
No one is 'exposing' Imam Bukhari; it's called hadith studies and any hadith narrator is up for critique and yes there are weak hadiths in bukhari and muslim, read the video carefully; the whole point of haditb critique is to NOT LIE on Rasool Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم, Also a hadith that is weak is not a lie on the Prophet rather a fabricated hadith is. You have alot to learn; think before you accuse and write about others
to mix truth and falsehood is deviance and to go into doubtful matters is worse. so bukhari said Ubay ibn Kab wrote the speech of Allah to uthman. maybe we should cut the speech of Allah to albani standards. la may Allah forgive our salaf and may we follow them in good
their is no hadith science. we follow the messenger in good he never left a hadith science and Umar al faruq stopped the collection of hadith in his khalifa. so your science is something that come after so it's best you follow the salaf in good and stop saying science. hadith is fine but don't make it seem like you know and someone else doesn't based on something that was not done in the time of the messenger. bukhari work was painstaking and I take nothing from it and may he b e rewarded double for the mistakes of the companion of added to the wudu hadith
Hass Caram there is no hadith science? Clearly you are young or just plain do not know what you are talking about, I expect more from you akhi...look into things, barakAllahu feek
Hass Caram - The first ḥadīth of Bukhārī from the book of Revelations is Khabar al-Wahid, the second ḥadīth is Mursal Ṣaḥābī, the third ḥadīth is Mudraj, the fourth ḥadīth is al-Munqati.. this was the geniusness of Imām al-Bukhārī to know the authenticity and still be able to use them which was in accordances to his criteria of what is maqbūl and mardūd.
Albani is kholaf scholar, not salaf
Scholars and people, who knowledge of Islamic history is shockingly poor. Also the lack of understanding of the evolution of language and the importance of culture. How that played a siginificant part in the transmission of hadith.
Shaykh Al-Albani, was sincere but misguided in his works. As he only caused fitnah and disunity in the Ummah.
Most people who praise Shaykh Al-Albani, do not realize Albanian was his mother tongue! His father Hanafi scholar, disagreed with him on many matters. He was self taught in the hadith books. He self interpreted.
Isnad, Isnad for teaching? Who gave Shaykh Al-Albani, the authority to teach hadith books??
You deserved to be ignored! May Allah rectify our affairs
My dear brother or sister in Islam. This is a very very bad idea. Let's not backbite other Muslims. I really want you to think about this, you said who gave him permission to teach hadith books, but who gave you the right to tarnish someone's reputation based off of your opinion? You didn't provide any sources so I can't accept anything you said but the allegation that his father disagreed with him doesn't mean he was wrong, albanian being his mother tounge doesn't mean anything, he cleary spoke arabic. Where is your proof he didn't have teachers or that he self interpreted? Please take down your comment.
Albani don't have a teacher, don't have a sanad from ahlul hadis
May Allah forgive and have mercy on his soul for commenting on Saheeh Albukhari. Saheeh Al Bukhari is 100% Saheeh and no body can disprove it. Why this sheikh has opened the doors of ftnah I will never know.
I don't think its fair to say that sh.Albaani opened the door. There were plenty of scholars like Ibn Hajjar and Ibn Qayyium who were mountains in the study of Hadith that have critiqued both Bukhari & Muslim. So the door was always open, you just didn't know
More than 1400 years all scholars, high scholars, sheik al islams . No one Said this and then comes Mr albani with his theory that Some sahih Hadith in bukhari are weak. Who paid him money. Did he sold his soul to the devil.
We are the ahle sunna wal jamaa"a and who follows albani, Ibn baz, ibn tayimma, utaymeen etc etc are ahle bidda. I am not saying kafir. Wa allahu alam .
Abdullah BandeHaqq Subhan Allah...clearly you have not read the video...the Shaykh mentioned Ibn Hajr and many weakened some hadiths in Bukhari, before jumping to conclusions; think before you type, your smart I hope you can look into the matter deeper
Abdullah BandeHaqq ,,akhee, sohih bukhari wasn't compiled 1400 years ago and if u watch the video, you should see some scholars that have done the same thing as the sheik. You sound too harsh as if he is refuting the Qur'an. If you really listen well, you should understand a little from his explanations. May Allah grant us useful knowledge.
Abdullah BandeHaqq but you should understand that many scholars have proceeded him like Ibn hajar
You have a name brother? And its called IGNORANT! YOU WILL BE QUESTIONED FOR WHAT YOU HAVE ACCUSED OUR GREAT IMAM OF HADITH. MAY ALLAH MAKE US AMONG THOSE WHO RESPECT THE SCHOLARS AND AMONG THOSE WHO SPEAK OUT OF KNOWLEDGE AND NOT EMOTIONS.
Shame on you !!
You are all wrong. You all misunderstood The Word of Allaah❤❤❤, The Alknown. Stop spreading lies about Allaah❤❤❤, The Almighty. Stop spreading lies about Rassoulloullaah. This is SHIRK. Allaah ❤❤❤ has strictly forbidden us in The Qo'raan to follow self written hadith by mankind. The Qo'raan,The Word of Allaah ❤❤❤The Most Loved is Perfect. What do you not understaand????? You misguide people. Woe you.
th-cam.com/video/bB4cARWalY4/w-d-xo.html