Hello from Singapore 😊 I'm super interested in the history of the American Civil War! So much to learn and understand. This is absolutely my favourite go-to channel for maps and the battles which took place. Wonderful videos, guys! Thank you! 😊❤️❤️❤️🇸🇬
Good presentation- informative and enthusiastic. As a Kansan, I want to note that the 8th Kansas was there as part of Gibson's 1st Brigade in Wood's Third Division. Proud of 'em.
My 3rd great grandfather fought with the 26th Alabama (O'Neal under Walthall) at Peachtree Creek. He lost his life here in a poorly executed attack. If you ever get to explore the west part (Springlake Park) of the battle line you will see how bad the terrain is in this area. Roller coaster terrain and very thick brush (Norfleet Rd just off Northside Dr.). The south side of this road is still pretty much like it was in 1864. The Confederates were moving thru this brush and couldn't see the Union troops until they were almost on top of them. But they were still attacking uphill and the Union troops firing down hill into their ranks.
do you know the regiment? this seems very unlikely given where the Ohio units fought and generally low level of union dead for the forces engaged. such a loss at one place in brothers would surely also be a known story that is recorded with sources referencing it. if you have documented sources to back this up, it would be important historical note. if they all died during the war, it is very possible, but all at this engagement? highly unlikely for these reasons.
Wow to talk about the New Jersey 33rd ,my Great grand father and his brother,were both captured. And then taken to Andersonville. Where my great grandfather survived and his brother died in the prison.
I'm hearing a lot of Hood apologists. He had been writing letters to Davis during most of the Atlanta Campaign asking to replace Johnson. He had pulled out of one of Johnsons few planned attacks against Sherman before he was near Atlanta. The army that he was given had not been decimated by futile frontal attacks against well defended positions. It did not have low moral because of serious defeats. A Cavalry raid by Nathan Bedford Forrest had turned Grants first attack against Vicksburg away and Sherman's line of communications was longer than Grant's. Why is it that modern historians are seem to be trying to say Hood wasn't that bad when every previous historians all blamed Hood? They are even saying the Battle of Franklin wasn't his fault. They are saying he had no choice but to attack even when all his Generals advised him not to attack.
My gg grandfather, Francis Kirkus fought and was wounded at Peachtree Creek. He was only 15 years old. He was in the Georgia militia which was comprised of old men and boys
Thank you for mentioning the Battle of Utoy Creek. It badly needs professional researching and documenting, but mentioning it helps put it on the map. Maybe some day ...
Can confirm your comments on Coburn’s Brigade. Gg grandfather served in the 33rd IN (Coburns original command) In a short set of memoirs he left to us he relates their annoyance at seeing the pickets come tumbling back as they’d just gotten their dinners prepared. He did stop to pour his coffee into his canteen before going into line. He does reference a point where regiments on either side bent backward subjecting them to severe enfilade fire until they “shot down many of them, not two rods in our front”. I think this was the 33rd Mississippi as he mentions killing their color bearer and “starting them back”. It was a short, sharp and nasty engagement.
So let’s get this straight, John Bell Hood, a one arm one leg morphine using confederate Lt. General, on July 20, 1864 in his first engagement as the AoT commanding general looses to George Thomas at the battle of Peach Tree Creek. Then not quite five months later between December 15-16, 1864, Hood looses again to George Thomas at the battle of Nashville. And THEN Hood, after having his ENTIRE army eliminated as an effective force, asks to be relieved of command on January 23. 1965. Makes you think that Hood, second only to maybe Leonidas Polk was one of the best Union assets in the confederate high command.
Yes. but, his Tennessee strategy had merit, even though it did not pan out. as for Atlanta he lost, but he was aggressively trying to defend the city which he had little time to prepare for and was having to act based on pressure from politicians, particularly Davis, who put him in command for this reason and he had few other options. I find the criticism of Hood to be a bit over blown. He was backed into a corner... the same one Longstreet wanted to put Meade into by getting around his right at gettysburg. He is generally blamed for losing results, but he was put in a situation where winning was very unlikely. The only real criticism is his decision to attack at Franklin, which he did not need to do and then pursuing to Nashville when he probably should have fallen back and try to go after Sherman again defensively in the Carolinas while he still had a decent force to use. But, again he pushed on in no small part due to political pressures.
@@MickeyJWind Mr. Wind: An officer, being considered for the command of an army, doesn’t get there without political considerations being factored into the selection. Jefferson Davis had initially asked Robert E. Lee take command of the Army of Tennessee. But Lee refused not wanting to surrender command of the Army of Northern Virginia. Jefferson Davis's asked Lee for his opinion on promoting Hood to the command of the AoT. Robert E. Lee gave an ambiguous reply calling Hood "a bold fighter, very industrious on the battlefield, careless off"…Lee had a high opinion of Hood's "gallantry, earnestness, and zeal"…however, he remained "doubtful" as to whether Hood possessed all of the qualities necessary to command an army in the field. John Bell Hood’s AoT “selection board” essentially consisted of Jefferson Davis and Gen. Braxton Bragg. After Hood’s leg amputation and recovery in Richmond, Davis and Hood were close friends. Bragg’s interview and recommendation of Hood for command has to be assessed in light of Bragg’s bitter disagreements and resentments against General Hardee. Hood wasn’t “backed into a corner” Hood was exactly where he ambitiously wanted to be. He was going to be the Confederacy’s “glorious battle champion”. He was going to route union forces, drive them back North and save Atlanta and the Confederacy. At 33 years old, Hood was too young, too ambitious, too infirm, too quarrelsome and too reckless to be given command of the AoT. This was the core political mistake made by the politician Jefferson Davis. Even Hood himself, is one of his letters criticizing Johnston wrote: "I have, General, so often urged that we should force the enemy to give us battle as to almost be regarded reckless by the officers high in rank in this army” And Hood was perceived as reckless not only by himsel and within the CSA but also by the Union commander General Sherman who planned on and used Hood’s recklessness to the advantage of Union forces. Respectfully, W.S.
Hood is a perfect example of the Peter Principle A brilliant Brigade Commander, an adequate Divisional Commander with strong supervision but promoted above his ability in the West...and yet..in the great realm of What if..had his plan succeeded at Peach Tree Creek he would have been hailed as one of the greatest generals of the Confederacy
Can someone help me in the direction to help donate towards American Battlefield preservation? Also interested in collecting civil war stamps and coins.
I disagree. I think Joe Johnston was in good mood and had a firm plan set up to fight Sherman at Atlanta, but was removed, Hood a great leader of combat troops was given command at a time he did not want the command, and despite hard fighting following some of Johnston"s advice he could not save Atlanta, Hood army did not work together well on the offensive, Johnston plan was a good one and he should have been kept in command, Hood as army commander was only planning not leading combat troops like he was great at.
OVER THE COURSE OF THE LAST WEEK, I HAVE HAD TO ENDURE THE INSULTING DESCRIPTION OF MY TWO ANCESTORS LEONIDAS POLK AND JOSEPH EGGLESTON JOHNSTON. COULD SOMEONE TEACH MACKOWSKI HOW TO PRONOUNCE JOHNSTON'S NAME?
@@johnkean2466 HE WAS ONE OF SHERMAN'S PALLBEARERS. A COMRADE OF THE HIGHEST ORDER. TRAITORS WERE EXECUTED AT THAT TIME. HE WAS CELEBRATED WITH THE HONOR OF CARRYING SHERMAN'S COFFIN. AND HE DID IT IN THE BITTER COLD WITH DIGNITY YOU SIR ARE A FILTHY WOKE PROPAGANDIST WITH LITTLE KNOWLEDGE OF THE MEN OF THE WAR OF NORTHERN AGGRESSION.
This is where Jefferson Davis lost the Civil War. Johnston probably would have held on and made Sherman keep attacking and losing far more men that Johnston would have behind the earthworks around Atlanta. If Sherman had not taken Atlanta by November, it was very possible that a disenchanted northern populace would have voted for McClellan for president instead of Lincoln, and Little Mac was ready to make peace with the Confederacy.
Shoupidade???? Shoupade, if you people are going to come west, at least learn the proper pronunciation of the terms. The fortifications along Johnston's River Line were designed by Francis Shoup, thus the name.
![ไลฟ์สุ่ม iPhone 295 บาท... โกงมั้ย?[ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.97 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gdstHEE4UUE/mqdefault.jpg)
Loving these not well known battles. You guys are so brilliant at bringing all this stuff to us. Thanks
Hello from Singapore 😊 I'm super interested in the history of the American Civil War! So much to learn and understand. This is absolutely my favourite go-to channel for maps and the battles which took place. Wonderful videos, guys! Thank you! 😊❤️❤️❤️🇸🇬
Good presentation- informative and enthusiastic. As a Kansan, I want to note that the 8th Kansas was there as part of Gibson's 1st Brigade in Wood's Third Division. Proud of 'em.
My 3rd great grandfather fought with the 26th Alabama (O'Neal under Walthall) at Peachtree Creek. He lost his life here in a poorly executed attack. If you ever get to explore the west part (Springlake Park) of the battle line you will see how bad the terrain is in this area. Roller coaster terrain and very thick brush (Norfleet Rd just off Northside Dr.). The south side of this road is still pretty much like it was in 1864. The Confederates were moving thru this brush and couldn't see the Union troops until they were almost on top of them. But they were still attacking uphill and the Union troops firing down hill into their ranks.
I miss you guys.
huh?
My Civil War era ancestor and 5 of his 6 brothers were killed at Peach Tree Creek...in an Ohio Volunteer Regiment.
do you know the regiment? this seems very unlikely given where the Ohio units fought and generally low level of union dead for the forces engaged. such a loss at one place in brothers would surely also be a known story that is recorded with sources referencing it. if you have documented sources to back this up, it would be important historical note. if they all died during the war, it is very possible, but all at this engagement? highly unlikely for these reasons.
Wow to talk about the New Jersey 33rd ,my Great grand father and his brother,were both captured. And then taken to Andersonville. Where my great grandfather survived and his brother died in the prison.
SAVE OUR BATTLEFIELDS AMERICA 🇺🇸
Harrison for the win! Future president!
I'm hearing a lot of Hood apologists. He had been writing letters to Davis during most of the Atlanta Campaign asking to replace Johnson. He had pulled out of one of Johnsons few planned attacks against Sherman before he was near Atlanta. The army that he was given had not been decimated by futile frontal attacks against well defended positions. It did not have low moral because of serious defeats. A Cavalry raid by Nathan Bedford Forrest had turned Grants first attack against Vicksburg away and Sherman's line of communications was longer than Grant's. Why is it that modern historians are seem to be trying to say Hood wasn't that bad when every previous historians all blamed Hood? They are even saying the Battle of Franklin wasn't his fault. They are saying he had no choice but to attack even when all his Generals advised him not to attack.
I know this place. I live here. Hallowed ground always.
Cool this battle is the one that took the life of colonal Cobham from the 111th pa he was a local from warren pa
Do I see the animations for an upcoming Atlanta Campaign map? Very excited if so!
My gg grandfather, Francis Kirkus fought and was wounded at Peachtree Creek. He was only 15 years old. He was in the Georgia militia which was comprised of old men and boys
The Georgia Militia eating goober peas
Will youo visit where the battle of utoy creek too place? Great site and some actual remains left in Atlanta
My ggg grandfather was wounded there with Scott's brigade.
Thank you for mentioning the Battle of Utoy Creek. It badly needs professional researching and documenting, but mentioning it helps put it on the map. Maybe some day ...
Can confirm your comments on Coburn’s Brigade. Gg grandfather served in the 33rd IN (Coburns original command) In a short set of memoirs he left to us he relates their annoyance at seeing the pickets come tumbling back as they’d just gotten their dinners prepared. He did stop to pour his coffee into his canteen before going into line. He does reference a point where regiments on either side bent backward subjecting them to severe enfilade fire until they “shot down many of them, not two rods in our front”. I think this was the 33rd Mississippi as he mentions killing their color bearer and “starting them back”. It was a short, sharp and nasty engagement.
Thomas is the best field commander for the union army. He is the thrust for Sherman in the Atlanta campaign.
So let’s get this straight, John Bell Hood, a one arm one leg morphine using confederate Lt. General, on July 20, 1864 in his first engagement as the AoT commanding general looses to George Thomas at the battle of Peach Tree Creek. Then not quite five months later between December 15-16, 1864, Hood looses again to George Thomas at the battle of Nashville. And THEN Hood, after having his ENTIRE army eliminated as an effective force, asks to be relieved of command on January 23. 1965. Makes you think that Hood, second only to maybe Leonidas Polk was one of the best Union assets in the confederate high command.
Yes. but, his Tennessee strategy had merit, even though it did not pan out. as for Atlanta he lost, but he was aggressively trying to defend the city which he had little time to prepare for and was having to act based on pressure from politicians, particularly Davis, who put him in command for this reason and he had few other options. I find the criticism of Hood to be a bit over blown. He was backed into a corner... the same one Longstreet wanted to put Meade into by getting around his right at gettysburg. He is generally blamed for losing results, but he was put in a situation where winning was very unlikely. The only real criticism is his decision to attack at Franklin, which he did not need to do and then pursuing to Nashville when he probably should have fallen back and try to go after Sherman again defensively in the Carolinas while he still had a decent force to use. But, again he pushed on in no small part due to political pressures.
@@MickeyJWind At Peachtree Creek, Hood failed to reconnoitor the rugged terrain in front of him which helped to doom him & his army.!
@@MickeyJWind Mr. Wind: An officer, being considered for the command of an army, doesn’t get there without political considerations being factored into the selection. Jefferson Davis had initially asked Robert E. Lee take command of the Army of Tennessee. But Lee refused not wanting to surrender command of the Army of Northern Virginia.
Jefferson Davis's asked Lee for his opinion on promoting Hood to the command of the AoT. Robert E. Lee gave an ambiguous reply calling Hood "a bold fighter, very industrious on the battlefield, careless off"…Lee had a high opinion of Hood's "gallantry, earnestness, and zeal"…however, he remained "doubtful" as to whether Hood possessed all of the qualities necessary to command an army in the field.
John Bell Hood’s AoT “selection board” essentially consisted of Jefferson Davis and Gen. Braxton Bragg. After Hood’s leg amputation and recovery in Richmond, Davis and Hood were close friends. Bragg’s interview and recommendation of Hood for command has to be assessed in light of Bragg’s bitter disagreements and resentments against General Hardee. Hood wasn’t “backed into a corner” Hood was exactly where he ambitiously wanted to be. He was going to be the Confederacy’s “glorious battle champion”. He was going to route union forces, drive them back North and save Atlanta and the Confederacy.
At 33 years old, Hood was too young, too ambitious, too infirm, too quarrelsome and too reckless to be given command of the AoT. This was the core political mistake made by the politician Jefferson Davis. Even Hood himself, is one of his letters criticizing Johnston wrote:
"I have, General, so often urged that we should force the enemy to give us battle as to almost be regarded reckless by the officers high in rank in this army”
And Hood was perceived as reckless not only by himsel and within the CSA but also by the Union commander General Sherman who planned on and used Hood’s recklessness to the advantage of Union forces.
Respectfully, W.S.
Lee's 5 word assessment of Hood is priceless ! " All lion and no fox ! "
Hood is a perfect example of the Peter Principle A brilliant Brigade Commander, an adequate Divisional Commander with strong supervision but promoted above his ability in the West...and yet..in the great realm of What if..had his plan succeeded at Peach Tree Creek he would have been hailed as one of the greatest generals of the Confederacy
👍
Love all your incredible videos. Having trouble understanding Cris. He just has a voice better for classroom and not outdoor narration.
But you have no trouble with Gary?
How could the town fathers allow these important battlefields be lost?
A plan gone wrong when I have conceived it
Can someone help me in the direction to help donate towards American Battlefield preservation? Also interested in collecting civil war stamps and coins.
Boom: www.battlefields.org/give
Smyrna,Smeerna? Locals pronounce it Smerna.
ANOTHER YANKEE.
I think Johnson did the best he could. Considering he was so badly outnumbered. Jefferson should have sent Forrest down to help.
I think that Grierson had Forrest tied up
I disagree. I think Joe Johnston was in good mood and had a firm plan set up to fight Sherman at Atlanta, but was removed, Hood a great leader of combat troops was given command at a time he did not want the command, and despite hard fighting following some of Johnston"s advice he could not save Atlanta, Hood army did not work together well on the offensive, Johnston plan was a good one and he should have been kept in command, Hood as army commander was only planning not leading combat troops like he was great at.
9/29/24 Correct pronunciation of “Smyrna” is not “Smeer-na.” It’s “Smur-na,” Chris Mackowski.😁
OVER THE COURSE OF THE LAST WEEK, I HAVE HAD TO ENDURE THE INSULTING DESCRIPTION OF MY TWO ANCESTORS LEONIDAS POLK AND JOSEPH EGGLESTON JOHNSTON. COULD SOMEONE TEACH MACKOWSKI HOW TO PRONOUNCE JOHNSTON'S NAME?
Why don’t you tell us too.
@@roynoccorina5022 UH...WITH A
'T".
@@bassmaster1953 with a T as in traitor, I never forget it!
@@johnkean2466 HE WAS ONE OF SHERMAN'S PALLBEARERS. A COMRADE OF THE HIGHEST ORDER. TRAITORS WERE EXECUTED AT THAT TIME. HE WAS CELEBRATED WITH THE HONOR OF CARRYING SHERMAN'S COFFIN. AND HE DID IT IN THE BITTER COLD WITH DIGNITY YOU SIR ARE A FILTHY WOKE PROPAGANDIST WITH LITTLE KNOWLEDGE OF THE MEN OF THE WAR OF NORTHERN AGGRESSION.
Secesh trash deserves nothing.
This is where Jefferson Davis lost the Civil War. Johnston probably would have held on and made Sherman keep attacking and losing far more men that Johnston would have behind the earthworks around Atlanta. If Sherman had not taken Atlanta by November, it was very possible that a disenchanted northern populace would have voted for McClellan for president instead of Lincoln, and Little Mac was ready to make peace with the Confederacy.
Shoupidade???? Shoupade, if you people are going to come west, at least learn the proper pronunciation of the terms. The fortifications along Johnston's River Line were designed by Francis Shoup, thus the name.
"Smyrna' also mispronounced in this well- done video. Also, 'Etowah' was mispronounced in an earlier video. But in all, great work guys!