MY FINAL STATEMET FOR COMMENTS 😊. I apologised for one specific segment which shouldn’t have been there and sheikh asim al hakem is correct to say this wasn’t right and I accept it. But let me be crystal clear, I do not care about anyone’s “opinion” in the comment section, if the entire globe came and said this is “free mixing” etc etc, as long as I know Alhamdulillah we have the fatwa of much senior scholars, I will never stop the show Wallahi. Just as some have said, “oh do you think sheikh asim just made up his opinion from thin air?, it’s from Quran & sunnah”, oh really? Lol. Do you think the scholars we went to gave us a fatwa from thin air 🤦. They’re evidence is from Quran and sunnah. So until then if you don’t like the show and think it’s haram, don’t watch it. But not for a moment think your comments or videos will stop me from doing something which senior scholars have said is HALAL and I know this show will save many marriages in sha Allah.
Bro which scholar are you even talking about?? Which scholar say the name . It's about understanding of Qur'an and sunnah even deviant sects gave references from Qur'an and sunnah so from which scholar are you taking knowledge from Sheikh bin baaz ? Sheikh ibn uthaymeen? Who exactly Also thumbnail girl is actually wearing an adornment probably makeup too so are you going to justify that too ??
Brother, you should provide the Name of the senior scholars in connection with the evidence its not enough to just mention it. Fa jazkumu Allahu kheiran
find something alternative if you wanna do something beneficial in those matters, looks like you are deep inside losing your cool cause you know there is some problem in it, otherwise you would keep your calm, don't worry about views, you are very good at choosing hot topic and make a short video of review which you call dawah, so you will eventually get views no worries, pretend to be a content creator instead of Islamic scholar, and when you said "NOT FOR A MOMENT' we think you are gonna stop the show, it shows you are taking negative opinion as a super challenge and we are actually "not for a moment" thinking about you stopping the show, we know you have an arrogant attitude, we are just giving our opinions, keep your calm AKHI
Alhamdulillah the comment section is full of sensible people. Haram is haram and shaytan beautifies sins with whispers justifying haram. It's Ramadan bro. May we all repent for all of our sins.
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
No matter what explanation or reasoning you give . It is NOT OKAY to have Muslim men and women mixed in a room talking about these intimate things such as “ not being able to perform in bed “ and “ not satisfied in the bedroom “ what is wrong with you folks ?! Where is the shame and shyness ? SubhanAllah
Exactly Muslims are just like non Muslims they copy everything they do and say, Muslims don’t keep anything private anymore they don’t have hayya no shame at all it’s beyond sad and embarrassing the Ummah is lost and qiyamah is near!
@Fortifier1021 I am a woman brother . And YES I HAVE SHYNESS I have shyness and I didn’t feel comfortable with watching this videos it’s so wrong ! So now I’m calling it out ! If I see something wrong and it’s going to misguide our youth I will call it out .
@Fortifier1021 please I don’t like to talk too much and talk nonsense about something that is clearly wrong . I will not argue in the comments with something I know is wrong in allahs eyes . Salam alaikum
@Fortifier1021 Bro you must kidding right? Women attracted to women? Do you know that gays are very tiny percentage of any society. What are you crusading and raising the banner for? Mixing between genders is haraaaaam Haraaaam. Some men practice same sex people of Lot action doesnt means Men being with men will f each other unless you are gay. I all my life rarely mingled with women other than family members and I live in Islamic country have no issues, no didnt become gay or guys I know did same sex whatsoever, we all waited for marriage. We did not become gays, you might not be a muslim u troll!!
Have you found anybody who doesn’t watch tv daily in the vast majority who criticize him? You are very coherent? It sounds like hypocrisy and you don’t even realise?
@@unclegardener Okay very good for you !! Still do you feel sick in your stomach to read all the commentaries of hypocrites who criticize Ali Dawha’s program while watching dumb down programs daily on Tv? Now use your brain if you are not one of those hypocrites : what is your problem to hold your opinion while qualified scholars have a different opinion?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 I also do not own a TV since 2020. The problem is that he is using his platform to promote Islam which is also promoting fitnah. ( plus he is also justifying it without providing any evidences for his claim)
@@thinkislamically But how can you say that? Not owning a tv doesn’t mean you don’t watch audiovisual material stop messing about when you talk religion !!! Give up on try to be smart about it you obviously don’t know nothing, not our sources and not the respect due to the variety of opinions coming from our scholars !! Females scholars were numerous and like any scholars they would talk about any matters like a doctor talk about any maters… but you are faking being shocked because being shocked for you equates with being pious? What about keep your tongue when you don’t master a subject?
@@yunusalih Come on man. Scholars don't watch these stuff. They don't even know whats happening behind the screen. Orgasm and cumming! There is nothing to discuss here.
Brother ..if you afraid of divorces ...bring a scholar of islam and let people Call in and ask questions...BUT bringing girls and men and bickering is not the way bro.
"If women in the times of the Prophet left after prayers before men in order for there to be no fitnah, ask yourself Ali would the Prophet authorise for you to bring men and women together like this? Accept you are wrong, brother, and just go according to Quran and Sunnah"
So men and women should never talk to each other about anything ever? 😂 Even if the purpose is to literally save marriages? This is what I call extremism. They are not sitting there to chit chat, their topics are important and no else is addressing them.
One of the signs of the day of judgement is people will talk about things they have no knowledge of. Ali, you're not a scholar and shouldn't be giving Islamic advice.
@@Chimaeri0n I watched the full podcast , no one was flirting it was a respective discussion only that they touched some sensitive topic which he has apologized btw. So if you are looking for faults then you won't see any good in it!
@@ImenBen12 Because no scholar will validate such actions. For a person to be scholar there are some milestones that need to be qualified. You can't regard a random spokesperson as scholar. You wrongly said I am committing sin. I said what truth and it's right infront of us . Islam has clearly laws against it. Allah Azzawajal orders Ummul Momineen to speak appropriately before opposite gender or else he might react to sickness in his heart . Aisha Radi'Allahu Anha addressed some private issues which were related to body or intimacy like kiss in wudhu and during fast etc. But she never disclosed the actions that were performed in full fledged intimacy. So there is these rules for Ummul Momineen. We are nothing to even ignore that.
Akhi respectfully if your Mrs or sister went on a Show like yours free mixing with bloggers and TH-camrs talking about private bedroom issues would u allow it?? Didn’t think so..
How comes his wife is not on his show I don't watch his shows but have come across them... is that not a little hypocritical if I'm wrong and she is on his show please correct me jazakallahukhayr
I have alsoconfronted him and majid about the question why they put their wives in the podcast. With other discussing about divorce there no different than Saida Psychology all using the mantle of Islam
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
@@EIibra not every Muslim watch Movies or series like that . Also there is a difference between the podcasts and the series the setup and motivations are different although I don't support the way Ertugrul series proceeded. In Movie or Series too interaction can be made to a limit just like normally in real life women men are supposed maintain according to Sharia. During the time of Sahaba people used to ask Ummul Momineen issues or hadith. She used to narrate that . The current system of job is dajjal system. However brothers can avoid that by limiting to general communication which is totally different from what happens in podcasts.
What I don't understand is, you have made debate videos where males and females are discussing topics at length, when Islam has already provided all the answers to these questions. You could have easily created videos where you sit down with a scholar and ask him these same questions and he answers it succinctly and efficiently, completely avoiding any unnecessary mixing. Was this way the only way? Why not pick the route that you know is safer for your deen?
The thing is, he could have been easily done this show over voice call, which would protect the women’s sanctity and also not show themselves online. I don’t think men and women being in a room together for some reasons is free-mixing, but the topics they are discussing are intimate, and they are not really talking from an Islamic standpoint but they are debating it with a little Islam mixed in.
We don’t care of your opinion… as much as you OBVIOUSLY do not care about the opinion of qualified scholars? The vast majority of people in the comment section do watch tv daily… as a Muslim do you consider (Allah being ou witness) as hypocrisy?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 To be honest, i love brother Ali, but you just can't tell us there are "senior scholars" whom gave fatwa on it and get away with it. I wholeheartedly believe that is just wrong. He should state who said it, what he said, what evidence he used. People "attacking him" or whatever should not matter.
Marriage is encouraged in Islam however discussing sensitive topics like “performance in the bedroom” is not encouraged to be spoken about among random Muslim brothers and sisters who are all Non-Mehram for each other. If you have marital problems or intimate issues, you can go to Islamic marriage counselling sessions or other professionals in this area.
I haven’t made a comment on TH-cam in over 15+ plus years. And I have to state that I’m shockingly surprised and pleased with that fact that most of the comments are in agreement that this is NOT a appropriate show to have. Masha’Allah Tabarak’Allah you folks give hope to the ummah. Dear Brother @Ali Dawah please give this further thought Insha’Allah. This is not the way. May Allah Azza Wajjal forgive us all for our shortcomings. Ameen 🤲🏼
@@randomhuman2595 He doesn’t show his wife due to protective jealousy, men and women have protective jealousy for a reason which is why that would be so uncomfortable to let his wife on such a show or even show her in vids.
Sorry, akhi, but I can't back this one. The natural feeling of watching it just feels wrong. Your viewers are both Male and female. How can you be lowering your gaze yet providing us with the perspective of both genders. Doesn't make sense.
Also to add to your important advice, would or did the prophet or any of his companions address matters in such manner, addressing Islamic values is important and the way in which we do this is also ibadah. We are imitating the liberal world to address Islamic values is wrong.
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
@@EIibra if you are watching a TV series with the mere purpose or entertaining yourself... Okay. That's your decision. However if you chose to solve real life problems and take examples from this TH-camr, then it's up to you too but the risks of a bad results are higher. Don't kid around with life changing decisions.
Your bitter truth show is nothing but a tone down version of fresh and fit bro. Muslim couples who are having issues should consult with counselors, scholars and people of knowledge instead of watching laymen discuss their problems and opinions.
@AfrikanischUnterwegs-hu8br if he says its Halal then he comes into the section of those who will make haram thing's halal our prophet peace be upon him warned us about. We should warn each other and community against such people
@@spaceinvader2977 women and especially Mutbarrijat that put on make up and don't dress properly are being shown to thousands of men, these topics should be discussed by respectable knowledge people, and the podcast format leads to unnecessary talks between the two genders which is haram
Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem's response. "It is kind of him to identify me as a student of knowledge which I am proud to be known for. However, when we start to make haram things halal based on fatwas of ‘big scholars” and we fail to name them, this shows how “weak” their argument is!! I have Bin Bazz and Ibn Othaimeen backing my opinion about such gatherings and indecent topics to be totally prohibited and shameful in Islam. Ibn Abbas may Allah be pleased with him said to the people when they objected to a fatwa he gave by saying that Abu Bakr and Omer say something else, he said: hails of rocks and stones are about to fall upon you! I say Allah says and the prophet salla allahu alaihi wa sallam says and you counter that by saying Abu Bakr and Omer say??? Real Islam is corrupted and tarnished by such people who brush Quran and Sunnah off for the quotes of unknown “big scholars”! No one is above the sharia no matter how big they may think they are. Real men are known to stand down when they are wrong and admit it for the sake of truth and not to win an argument in this dunya and ending up finding that they have lost in their graves or the hereafter, may Allah make all our deeds sincere for His sake and give us a good ending on tawheed and the sunnah of our prophet salla Allahu alaihi wa sallam. "
As a lowly and unworthy person, I must say, I can see a slight of arrogance and ignorance in brother Ali. May Allah keep you away from harm, Ya akhi. You gave us hope against taghut, Alhamdulillah. May Allah SWT protect us from harms of the Nafs, shayateen and people. Ameen
The Muslim youth needs to start listening to the Ulema/Scholars. Having millions of likes and subscribers on TH-cam doesnt make you an Islamic scholar. And we all need to be humble enough to realize our mistakes, accept them and try to rectify them, instead of arrogantly denying and justifying it. May Allah guide us all and protect us, Ameen 🤲
@Fortifier1021 Focus on the issue that's been addressed here.. it's about the Haram mix gatherings that he and others are indulged into. I dunno why r u do keen on the lesbian thing.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته I love brother Ali as a Muslim brother and the effort he is putting into the Deen. May Allah accept from him. Personally, I didn’t watch a single episode of his show where the men and women were sitting and discussing issues… never sat right with me. Imagine if it was your husband or wife sitting there discussing such issues with strangers. If Ali wants to address these problems or issues in marriage … a simple scholarly informative discussion with a knowledgeable scholar is million times better and more than enough.
Brother Ali you lower your gaze from those sisters , yet you display them on your channel to be viewed by millions ?? Don’t you find that ironic!!? Would you show your wife on your channel talking to strange men about all kinds of issues!?
At the time of the prophet sws do you lower your gaze when you buy goods at your supermarket? Who do you think you are to beleive that qualified scholars are not qualified to give an opinion different than yours? Cheer up and go and and watch TV like the VAST MAJORITY of people who criticize BUT STILL watch tv daily… I hope you are not of those otherwise you would qualified yourself probably as being an hypocrite for better words to describe this double standard?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 Again, your arguments fail hard. - Who are the ghost scholars? They are as good as not there if he doesn't present their fatwa. - Don't generalize, i don't watch TV for example. If the majority are doing it doesn't mean its Halal, childish opinion right there. - Non mehram women, full face of make-up, INCORRECT hijab, bright colors, is not covered. Period. Ali brings them to a "public space" with other non mehram men, ok. They still talk about very sensitive topics, distasteful, but ok. However, ALL UNECESSARY. Their knowledge is relative from one another, are you telling me a guy who does Qaza' and a woman who wears full makeup and a scarf with tight clothing know more than an actual senior scholar? Get over yourself, this is all very unecessary which is why it most probably enters the threshold of haram. but I challenge you to bring me a scholar with actual knowledge that says this stuff is halal.
It's clear now even you provided so much clarity. Still there are some people who think you are arrogant. But soon they will know that their rejection and argument or Ali Dawah will be of no use on the day of Judgement. Hypocrisy in Ummah has contaminated it very hard.
🖤Your show is same as going to nightclub with hijab on, no drinking but only chatting. Akhi, man up and take our feedbacks as a constructive criticism for self improvement. You’re causing a big fitna and it’s hurting us all. Thank you.
LOL… now your « comments » are more important than the scholars that gave him a green light? That’s funny… as if you ignore that the vast majority who criticize watch tv entertainment, movies and the like? Would you qualify this as hypocrisy (Allah is our witness) ?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 we don’t care if all the scholars give him the green light. Chatting with non mehram is haram except in the case of emergency. My and your job is to share even if it’s an ayat. It’s not my > It’s the command of Allah mentioned in the Quran.
@@watchyourjet You are from a sect.. not your comment but Allah? You are a modernist… never Muslims in the past denied differences of positions and opinions ! In my sight you are a joke (and anybody intelligent would agree) not because you might have a different opinion but because you are blind to see that the vast majority of people watch tv daily still they criticize… Allah be ou witness if you watch tv you are a disease a cancer… if you don’t watch tv then you have your opinion and congratulation to behave according to your belief. Still I let you know that I know our sources and I see no issues as long as these interactions are made with good intentions.
@@watchyourjet You have never lived in a Muslim country where we speak daily with strangers with no ill intent. And you are an arrogant who despise senior scholars. And you fell miserably to reconized that the vast majority of people here who criticize DO WATCH TV DAILY… That is the sign of hypocrisy… so as I say not as I do… Do you watch tv by the way?
@@watchyourjetthis is untrue. it is entirely permissible in a professional or educational setting. in a respectful dignified manner. it is not akin to a nightclub which would be a leisure setting just because.
Haram is haram, we shouldn't find loop holes in the deen, our scholars say what they say from Qur'an and sunnah. With evidence, these weman must have a mehram present, period
@@yousufnoori4439 if someone doesn’t want their wife going somewhere that doesn’t make it haraam. Some men wouldn’t want it some do. So you let your wife or sister work in a free mixing environment when providing is not one of their musts. ? Shiek Assim says that’s haraam
As I said, bring your own wife to the show. Why not? Since you said it's not Haram and let her speak about her intimacy with you as these sisters did. You say it's not Haram but deep down you know it is. Fear Allah brother, don't argue just for the sake of arguing. If our prophet Muhammad SAW was here, would be approve of this show? That should be your standard.@@dubai_fitness
@@yousufnoori4439 THE VIDEO IS LITERALLY ABOUT THE INTIMACY CLIP AND HIM APOLOGISING ABOUT THAT AND SAYING HE AGREES IT SHOULDNT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED, So is everyone at speakers corner sinning? Also main part.... im assuming your wife does not work in a free mixed environment.. as its not her obligation to provide so no need for her to be there... shiek aasim also said thats haraam for a woman to work somewhere unless its female only...
Even our mother 'Aisha RA, when she's giving lessons to her students or when the sahabah having qna sessions with her, she sit behind a curtain. No one can see her. Yet, here we are, justifying free mixing? Nahhh, this is wrong.
Seikh Asim al hakeem has studied under seikh Uthaymeen and seikh bin Baz and many other seikhs and is a student of knowledge who is certified and studied the deen over decades. Pls show us some of your level of islamic education to question this seikh and who are the seikhs saying its permissible otherwise anyone can say trust me bro this top seikh said it.
But the latest video he did where Al Islam productions replied to him when he mocked the Asians for wiping their hands on their face and body after dua, sheikh bib baaz actually refuted everything this wannabe Hakim said.
@@maliknotice7149 what is your point here exactly? Sheikh Assim is a qualified scholar and he is the one commented that Ali is doing haram. Instead of weighting on the right, are you going to try to sound neutral? those do not speak against what's wrong , actually support the wrong by silence. If you don't want to do that, at least don't discourage people who speaks the right thing.
@@maliknotice7149that’s the scary thing I listen to dr zakir, sheikh assim, nouman Ali,Mohammed hoblos as well as my dad who’s correct was always told follow the prophet Mohammed pbuh and his companions
@ItsameAlex that's why ali should name them. I can't think of a single senior scholar who would see this show and allow it, no way. Therefore I rly wanna know who those "senior scholars" are.
Show the fatwa in detail then Ali, let us all see exactly what was asked to these so called "senior ulemas" as it's very easy to fatwa shop nowadays, if one is legit you should show the full fatwa & the full wording, question & answer, not just a claim, stop playing...💯
One thing I am really happy alhamdullilah is that people recognize this fitnah..Majority of comments I see are calling him out about this free mixing. Alhamdullilah,...People know deen well. May Allah keep everyone on straight path..Ameen
@@reomai9576 not really..What he is doing is wrong..As he is declaring his show as "Islamic" so people have right to confront him for that and correct him. People wont be so "judgemental" if he accepts his show for what it is, a free mixing "Jerry Springer" inspired Show, then people wont be so judgemental. Problem is he is trying very hard to convince everyone wrongly that his show adheres to Islamic values and no one is buying that..
It was narrated from ‘Abd-Allah ibn Mas’ood that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “No one who has an atom’s-weight of arrogance in his heart will enter Paradise.” A man said, “O Messenger of Allah, what if a man likes his clothes and his shoes to look good?” He said, “Allah is Beautiful and loves beauty. Arrogance means rejecting the truth and looking down on people.”
@@daisypashe8296 Wrong. The word used is Kibir in the Arabic language so it’s not limited to just a 1-1 translation of the word. Arabic is far richer than English so it encompasses more.
When a mufti or scholar give fatwa on something that it’s haram then it’s not merely his opinion. Scholar give fatwa on the basis of Quran and Sunnah. Dose Islam allow a women talk about explicit family issue/sexual issue with non-mahram and also talk to non-mahram without proper veil? And please mention the name of those scholars who give legitimacy this show.
Lol.....no they dont.....there are many scholars who don't give fatwas based on Quran n sunnah....some are not that well educated some lack common sense some do not understand Quran or sunnah properly n misinterpret n pass fatwas......there are only a handful who are responsible n give fatwa based on QURAN n sunnah.....
@@wsky6315 A fatwa is a religious ruling or opinion issued by an Islamic scholar or mufti. It is usually in response to a question posed by a Muslim concerning Islamic law or doctrine and is not legally binding. The word "fatwa" comes from the Arabic root f-t-y, which means "to decide" or "to give an opinion." A mufti is an Islamic scholar who is qualified to respond to questions about Islamic law or doctrine. A mufti may issue fatwas but does not necessarily have to. The legal process of issuing a fatwa in response to a question posed by a Muslim is known as ifta.
Ya Akhi, you can't just say " We asked a scholar and he said it's ok " without saying who he was and what he exactly said. I can say " I asked one of the top scholars if music is haram and he said no "
Your intentions might be pure. But a woman or man should never ever talk about anything that happens in the bedroom. Islamically the man is a veil to the woman and vice versa. Secondly we cant talk about why women cheat. You shouldnt be doing zina period regardless of what reason you have. That is why divorce is an option.
This case might apply to Non-Mahrams. But I don’t see anything wrong with a woman and man like husband and wife discussing these kind of things privately.
Why is everyone commenting you shouldn’t be talkin about private bedroom stuff WHEN IN THE VIDEO HE SAID THIS WAS BIT RIGHT AND HES GOING TO REMOVE THIS PART
I’m glad I have seen no one support this act of yours. Wallahi you’re entering dangerous territories. I normally make excuses for you and your constituents, but I can’t continue to with the territory you’re entering. Humble yourself, Repent to Allah ya akhi, and retract the ignorance you’re spueing before Shaitan continues to make you justify things that are clearly wrong by making you fatwa shop for fatwas that please you’re desires, because there’s no way any scholar that clings to the Qur’an and sunnah would ever support women being on camera with their faces uncovered discussing these issues, better yet with Non-Mahram men looking at each-other and debating each other. At this point, come out and say these scholars names you consulted with because I literally don’t know any scholar of Islam nor serious student of knowledge that would support what you’re doing. Drop their names so we can drop them for supporting this evil doing. Your comment section is a sign for you and a reminder you received the message on the day of Judgement. There will be no excuses for you. Repent, and ask forgiveness from brother Saajid and other brothers who advised you on this and other things, before they can possibly take your good deeds on the day of Judgement for being in the right for advising their brother in Islam for promoting fahisha. Barakallahu Feekum.
@@BeatingUinFifaMalachi generally speaking,uncovering the face is an issue of dispute but most scholars agree it is better or sunnah to do.However,in camera or in social media where men can look into the details it is haram and allah knows best
And to that can I add to his list to repemt for openly, publicly shaming and humiliating good and chaste women, and degrading them, subhanAllah, but may Allah protect us and him, still because because being the I the public eye is not easy, perhaps we could have had sisters off camera, or on a sisters only platform or some such, but the shaming the women was just too much. We expect better from our Muslim brothers, and apart to have to right this publicly. May Allah help us have private communities for discussions and feedback -
Fame is one of the most powerful addictions known to man. Only the Prophets of Allah were protected from it. As a person builds tolerance to the attention, their reality gets distorted, and the bar for more attention continues to rise. May Allah protect us all. 🤲🏾
You can't tell me all these tons of comments aren't coming from somewhere extremely strong and based upon the knowledge Allah gave us which results in us fearing him as we see, in the comments that is.
That is on the contrary what is really worrying and you must be stupid if you do not see it… We agree that scholars can have a different opinion based on knowledge… BUT YOU disagree with scholars not understanding how the came to the conclusion they draw. Now think of it… the vast majority of people posting comments DO WATCH tv entertainment and movies or even documentaries… That is sheer hypocrisy and you base the soundness of your opinion on this masse of hypocrite? To make it clear WE DO ACCEPT différences of opinons (contrary to YOU) but we expect the person not watching any kind of Tv…
In my opinion, it’s amazing how before the sheikh said that everyone supported this show but now the sheikh said that everyone talks crap about it. Like they literally changed their opinion about this show in a couple of hours. Amazing-
Who said FAR superior scholars… you are a LIAR it is YOU who believe YOUR scholars are superior ? Don’t lie, don’t be an hypocrite.. as soon as you get the qualified scholars you will reject them because you have a disease in your heart? How can you reject scholars because of a difference of opinion?
All the comments are united that this is wrong. This makes me happy that our Muslim ummah is strong and united. Why not make the women cover their face at minimum? I know it doesn’t make it right, but at the very least you can make them cover their face !!
covering their faces is not enough, no skin should be shown. And if they could get one those machines that make a woman's voice sound like a man's, like in police investigations, that would be ideal.
SHE IS NOT A LOWLY OBJECT Allah, the Glorified and High, has protected the woman and covered her and made Her a covered and Preserved Pearl which is not permissible for any to remove her Covering expect her husband who Allah has made her permissible for and made him permissible for her. And he has prohibited the Woman displaying her adornments for foreign men as a protection for her and preservation of her. She is not a lowly object to be handled by the hands and gazed upon by the eyes (of the people) . Rather, she is a preserved pearl ; safeguarded for her husband who Allah has made permissible for her and made her permissible for him. This is the woman within Al Islam. Book: The Status of the Woman in Islam By Shaykh Saalih Al-Fawzaan Translated by Rähä bin Donald Batts. Alhamdulillah for the true Muslim woman.
AsSalaamu Alaykom. I just wanted to ask you how do you justify to yourself some fatwas that seem a little tough about woman in marriage. I’m a brother from USA who was watching the bitter truth show for a little bit of time and I can’t get past the fact that secret wives are halal to lie about. If you can share any wisdom to help me accept it I will be grateful. Jazak Allah Khair
@@jvg6877 hmm from what I learned and iam not scholar , Muslim men can take on a second wife for good reason and with good intentions, (he will be financially responsible for both) , if his first wife is unable to have children, she don’t satisfy his personal needs, she doesn’t cook/clean take care of him etc. he can take a second wife without telling her. But if she finds out and she wants divorce because she can not contain her. Jealousy , anger etc.. he must think of all the outcomes as well and handle them as a man.. good and bad. This from what I learn.. everything must be done with good intentions.
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Two wolves free among sheep are no more destructive to them than a man's desire for wealth and fame is to his religion." Give a thousand justifications for your actions akhi you cant beat this hadith of the prophet ﷺ. You have unfortunately proven the hadith to be true.
This brother has lost his mind to say this behaviour is not free mixing, let alone the context of conversation sisters are having bait faced on social media. I would love to hear what “sheikhs” have given him a pass to do this. You can’t quote sources in an essay and say nah I’m not telling you where I got the information from 😂
Nonsense that senior scholars would say this podcast free mixing with sisters and talking about things related to intimacy is permitted this is ridiculous how does these podcast help anyone, theses issues are all well known in society this is all clout chasing and for money
@@sulisueeeeee0553they are Not needed, this is NOT Islam!! read the Quran and Hadiths peoples opinions and advice will never Help you or be better than what the Quran and Hadith says, Muslims need to stop exposing themselves online!!
@Fortifier1021Oh liar, show me the Hadith where the Prophet of Allah (Sallalahu alayhim Wasalam) would sit with a woman in front of all male sahaba and have one hour long discussion regarding sex and other intimate topics. You’re a lying hypocrite who tries to justify the haram and fitna from Ali “Dawah.”
@Fortifier1021 like that ? It's Ramadan so rectify yourselves ask forgiveness. In hadith says Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wasallam said if anyone make lies about me he or she should see destination in hellfire.
The prophet ﷺ spoke to a “beautiful woman” … Read this Hadith: Al-Fadl bin `Abbas rode behind the Prophet (ﷺ) as his companion rider on the back portion of his she camel on the Day of Nahr (slaughtering of sacrifice, 10th Dhul-Hijja) and Al-Fadl was a handsome man. The Prophet (ﷺ) stopped to give the people verdicts. In the meantime, a beautiful woman From the tribe of Khath'am came, asking the verdict of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). Al-Fadl started looking at her as her beauty attracted him. The Prophet (ﷺ) looked behind while Al-Fadl was looking at her; so the Prophet (ﷺ) held out his hand backwards and caught the chin of Al-Fadl and turned his face (to the owner sides in order that he should not gaze at her. She said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! The obligation of Performing Hajj enjoined by Allah on His worshipers, has become due (compulsory) on my father who is an old man and who cannot sit firmly on the riding animal. Will it be sufficient that I perform Hajj on his behalf?" He said, "Yes."
I’ve lost respect for this brother used to look up to him, but now he’s not able to understand how this is just wrong and free mixing. May الله guide him
I always knew this was wrong and I expected better from u Ali but I didn’t say anything Bcuz I just waited till allah shined some light on this fitna I’d always see the shorts and feel so disgusted with the free mixing going on on those podcasts I’m not gonna shame u for ur sin or the rest of the ppl who were on there but pls fear Allah and take down the videos aswell they will be used against u on judgement day and just don’t repeat it again .
@Fortifier1021I see you copy pasting the same dumb argument everywhere, it's a nice strawman but it doesn't give you the right to make one haram thing into halal to apparently fighting against other haram.
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
Take your L and apologize. Asim al Hakeem is always straight forward, no bs, and always on the way of sunah and quran. Don’t you dare to discredit him.
I lost all respect for this guy. Just to make himself look right he is trying to prove Sheikh Assim al Hakeem wrong. I always thought there is something fishy about this guy, I didnt know why but I had uneasy feeling about him even before this. But now I know why I had this feeling..
“The scholars” without naming… this is not Islam, Ali needs Dawah and it’s a shame that someone who has such little knowledge is held up so high by so many while huge scholars of Islam are forgotten
Atleast blur the faces of sisters, and please don't say scholars allowed you to show faces of na mahram sisters in front of hundreds of thousands,(even millions) of people. Even if they don't hide their faces; it's your responsibility to blur the faces of sisters because you are the one bringing them to huge amount of audience. Many people involved in dawah online brother Muhammad Ali, Sheikh Uthman are really strict about this(I have never seen them show faces of any lady ever). When you say you have discussed with scholars and they say it is permissible then at least make sure you don't pick and choose between scholars(I am not saying you did, this is just an advice from a brother because some people do this) because remember there are both ulama'e sue and ulama'e Haq (Just like in the time of bani israel). JazakAllah Khairan
Agree with the blurring of faces just for the purpose of the video. that way noone can judge them if sensitive topics are spoken about. Im Not referring to face covering as we all know that's optional.
I watched one or two episodes and I was left with more questions and uncertainty. These debates or discussions don't give a conclusion, anyone could end up with any opinion.
When you disobey Allahﷻ but with a "GOOD INTENTION", it will cause more harm than good. Bitter truth. This is not permissible even your intention is good, to combat divorce. But this is not the right way and Allah knows best.
While Allah blesses nonmuslims with the ability to see His other creations such as Moon, Mars and other planets, there are Muslims who focus on nitty gritty and its perhaps the reason why Allah has not freed the ummah from its persecution and oppression from its oppressors.
I feel like it would be better to have these one hour shows and talk about Tawheed and different topics of Islam in general together with Muslim brothers. Personally, I would never want my future wife to indulge in any public shows regardless of the topic.
Maybe that’s the problem akhi. Our religion is more than just Tawheed otherwise we’d be no different to the Christians who believe in faith-only and not works. We believe in Faith+Works and remember the Hadith that marriage is half of Deen. You neglecting this shows your perception of Islam is off. Allah knows best.
@@alphauno6614 I didn’t limit it to Tawheed. Speaking about marriages is important as well, but you can get the same message across without having Non-Mahram women in the room.
Imagine your sister posted on his youtube thumbnail!! For millions to view. Madness man. Im getting angry thinking about it wallahi. Tell him to out his sister on the thumnail
Dude there are soooo many others that do that. No one is actually talking about problems the Ummah is facing. People like YOU are helping to cause that problem. I hate what you people have done to the younger generations! You’re destroying us with this mentality!!!!!
Ali Dawah lost the respect of many people with this shameless show, if he really believes this to be ok then prove it by bringing his wife on the show.
As salamu alaykum I have a few questions and I do not intend to offend you Ali. I dont watch the show so forgive me if this has already been adressesed. 1 If the purpose of the show is to address marital issues why not have a qualified marriage counselor as the cohost? 2 Why not take the criticism and improve the show in a way that will make more Muslims comfortable by redesigning the set to allow more distance and possibly a barrier between the men and women guest? Would that really negatively effect the quality of the content (no)? 3 If the topic goes into more intimate areas why not have the marital counselor or a Muslim physician speak on it or answers directly instead of none mahram men and women going back and forth about it? I advise to look at this as a way to improve the show and not feel the need to justify or defend it. May Allah bless you and your family.
What's the point in a barrier if there's no barrier to the conversation and they can just go online and see who they were talking to and laughing and joking with about sex, and other topics?
Allah said (Ahzab: 53): "And when you (THE SAHABAH) ask (his wives) for anything you want (Benefical Knowledge), ask them from BEHIND A SCREEN, that is purer for your hearts and for their hearts." Allah said this to the Sahaba, what do think about us? These "scholars" are nothing compared to Allah! If a scholar says something, and Allah says different, you take from Allah and not do Taqleed (blind following) of that scholar.
Ya Allah.... How is this not free mixing? It's so unnecessary. In Quran it's says talk with the wives of the prophet behind a curtain. This shows how you should behave with non mahram women. How do u sit and chat with sisters. You copy the kufar astaghfirullah. Why? It's not necessary. Allah guide us all.
Ali, Akhi I hope you see this message. First of all when Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem gives his fatawas, they are not just based on his sentiments. He uses others Scholars as references. Second of all, let us know who the Scholars who advocate for your Bitter truth show are. It is a must that we know who they are and what their Manhajiyyah and Aqeedah is. Fakhr al-Din al-Razi was a very knowledgeable "Scholar" but he was also someone who did not consider the Qur'an and the Sunnah to be unequivocal Hujjah. Also, what about Sheikh Bin Baz, Ibn Uthaymeen, Al-Albani, Saleh Al-Fawzan, Ar-Ruhayli, Al-Usaymi, Abdul Muhsin Al-Abbad, Abdulrazzaq Al-Badr? Would they not see it as being free mixing? Also, these guests that you are bringing are lay people. They clearly don't have Ilm so why should we consider their Naseeha with regards to marriage and divorce if we have Duat who have actually studied the fiqh of it according to the Qur'an and the Sunnah. It's not just a matter of halal and haram (not saying it's not haram by the way) but it also lacks practicality and effectiveness.
Because he is doing it for views not effectiveness. The debate platform generates more views. It’s entertainment. It is NOT dawah the way dawah was intended to be delivered.
I'm very curious to know which high senior scholars you're talking about!? And what is according to you free mixing? Let your wife sit with the brothers as well then. You invite sisters who wear full face makeup and you guys giggle and laugh on diff kinds of subjects. Maybe let your wife do that as well.
How Is It Not Free Mixing when there is literally men and women Namahram sitting few feets across each other facing each other and having open conversations with each other about matters of life that Allah has made very private for people? His confidence in his knowledge has made him arrogant and ignorant
If it isnt free mixxing though then what is it? It isnt a public space within the Studio hence the 'public ruling' doesnt apply. Also the men on the show arent Mahram to the Sisters. Unfortunately some sisters come to the show without proper Hijab which Unfortunately will cause Fitnah for some Men. May Allah guide us and Forgive us
No i don't think so.....some of his answers concerning many topics are pathetic specially when it comes to marriage or divorce.....listen to wat reason he gave for DIVORCE in one of his shows.....
I wouldn't heed advice from a pawn to the Saudi royal family, given that most Saudi clerics are in that position. Although he can criticize Ali, he refrains from criticizing MBS, whom he serves.
Women wearing hijab came to Prophet Muhammad S.A.W p.b.u.h to ask him things pertaining to religion , & they didn't put a curtain in between , so that's ur opinion.
@@mobashirmallick0786also must you have curtains between men and women in the work place ? I don’t understand it. They weren’t sitting next to each other
@@zaza_268 the office you see now all Dajjal system something which is difficult to avoid like riba. This is what that needs to be changed that's why so much of struggle. People gonna listen to UN still .
@@servantofthemerciful3511haha yes, when going that deep I feel like I'm completely out of my mind, yett It is true and the reality. like I could go crazy thinking that deep 🤣😬😂😢😷🤢
Alhamdulillah all the comments i have read so far are against what you do... isnt it obvious you've taken the wrong path even if you are sincere, again if they must participate it should be through voice call. May Allah guide you and us
@@MakachevIsTsarukyanUFCdaddyI’d advice you to read the books of that great scholar who they created that name after. His books are very simple but have a lot of important things related to tawheed and shirk
@@MakachevIsTsarukyanUFCdaddyread Usool Al thalatha (three fundemental principles), Qawaid Al arbaa (four principles of shirk), Usool Al sitta (the six fundemental principles), and ofc his most famous book Kitab Al tawheed
MY FINAL STATEMET FOR COMMENTS 😊.
I apologised for one specific segment which shouldn’t have been there and sheikh asim al hakem is correct to say this wasn’t right and I accept it.
But let me be crystal clear, I do not care about anyone’s “opinion” in the comment section, if the entire globe came and said this is “free mixing” etc etc, as long as I know Alhamdulillah we have the fatwa of much senior scholars, I will never stop the show Wallahi.
Just as some have said, “oh do you think sheikh asim just made up his opinion from thin air?, it’s from Quran & sunnah”, oh really? Lol. Do you think the scholars we went to gave us a fatwa from thin air 🤦.
They’re evidence is from Quran and sunnah. So until then if you don’t like the show and think it’s haram, don’t watch it. But not for a moment think your comments or videos will stop me from doing something which senior scholars have said is HALAL and I know this show will save many marriages in sha Allah.
Bro which scholar are you even talking about?? Which scholar say the name .
It's about understanding of Qur'an and sunnah even deviant sects gave references from Qur'an and sunnah so from which scholar are you taking knowledge from Sheikh bin baaz ? Sheikh ibn uthaymeen? Who exactly
Also thumbnail girl is actually wearing an adornment probably makeup too so are you going to justify that too ??
@@mdazharali4160 he is being so arrogant . May Allah guide him
Brother, you should provide the Name of the senior scholars in connection with the evidence its not enough to just mention it. Fa jazkumu Allahu kheiran
find something alternative if you wanna do something beneficial in those matters, looks like you are deep inside losing your cool cause you know there is some problem in it, otherwise you would keep your calm, don't worry about views, you are very good at choosing hot topic and make a short video of review which you call dawah, so you will eventually get views no worries, pretend to be a content creator instead of Islamic scholar, and when you said "NOT FOR A MOMENT' we think you are gonna stop the show, it shows you are taking negative opinion as a super challenge and we are actually "not for a moment" thinking about you stopping the show, we know you have an arrogant attitude, we are just giving our opinions, keep your calm AKHI
Your hair cut brother قزع
Alhamdulillah the comment section is full of sensible people. Haram is haram and shaytan beautifies sins with whispers justifying haram. It's Ramadan bro. May we all repent for all of our sins.
@Fortifier1021 I'm talking about the sensible people in the comment section that are against Ali's show.
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
@Fortifier1021You need help
I could not have said it better!!! I wish more people saw this comment 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼@@EIibra
@Fortifier1021what? stop deflecting my guy 💀
No matter what explanation or reasoning you give . It is NOT OKAY to have Muslim men and women mixed in a room talking about these intimate things such as “ not being able to perform in bed “ and “ not satisfied in the bedroom “ what is wrong with you folks ?! Where is the shame and shyness ? SubhanAllah
Exactly Muslims are just like non Muslims they copy everything they do and say, Muslims don’t keep anything private anymore they don’t have hayya no shame at all it’s beyond sad and embarrassing the Ummah is lost and qiyamah is near!
@Fortifier1021 I am a woman brother . And YES I HAVE SHYNESS I have shyness and I didn’t feel comfortable with watching this videos it’s so wrong ! So now I’m calling it out ! If I see something wrong and it’s going to misguide our youth I will call it out .
@Fortifier1021 please I don’t like to talk too much and talk nonsense about something that is clearly wrong . I will not argue in the comments with something I know is wrong in allahs eyes . Salam alaikum
@Fortifier1021 Gender segregation does encourage homosexuality. Free mixing is a lot better in the long run.
@Fortifier1021 Bro you must kidding right? Women attracted to women? Do you know that gays are very tiny percentage of any society. What are you crusading and raising the banner for? Mixing between genders is haraaaaam Haraaaam. Some men practice same sex people of Lot action doesnt means Men being with men will f each other unless you are gay. I all my life rarely mingled with women other than family members and I live in Islamic country have no issues, no didnt become gay or guys I know did same sex whatsoever, we all waited for marriage. We did not become gays, you might not be a muslim u troll!!
I haven't found a single person on this comment section who supports this fitnah. Alhamdulillah
Except Ali ofcourse.
Have you found anybody who doesn’t watch tv daily in the vast majority who criticize him? You are very coherent? It sounds like hypocrisy and you don’t even realise?
@@lerecklessbadger2411Me, I never watch TV, last time I did was 2020, I haven’t watched the news in 4 years
@@unclegardener Okay very good for you !! Still do you feel sick in your stomach to read all the commentaries of hypocrites who criticize Ali Dawha’s program while watching dumb down programs daily on Tv?
Now use your brain if you are not one of those hypocrites : what is your problem to hold your opinion while qualified scholars have a different opinion?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 I also do not own a TV since 2020.
The problem is that he is using his platform to promote Islam which is also promoting fitnah. ( plus he is also justifying it without providing any evidences for his claim)
@@thinkislamically But how can you say that? Not owning a tv doesn’t mean you don’t watch audiovisual material stop messing about when you talk religion !!!
Give up on try to be smart about it you obviously don’t know nothing, not our sources and not the respect due to the variety of opinions coming from our scholars !! Females scholars were numerous and like any scholars they would talk about any matters like a doctor talk about any maters… but you are faking being shocked because being shocked for you equates with being pious? What about keep your tongue when you don’t master a subject?
Brother, whatever justification you give, it is still not appropriate for strange men and women to discuss about intimate things.
Exactly
لا يوجد حياء واستحياء
Maybe you should talk with the alims that he guided
@@yunusalih
Come on man. Scholars don't watch these stuff. They don't even know whats happening behind the screen. Orgasm and cumming! There is nothing to discuss here.
???
Brother ..if you afraid of divorces ...bring a scholar of islam and let people Call in and ask questions...BUT bringing girls and men and bickering is not the way bro.
free mixing is just uncomfortable
I agree with you bro
exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You've said it all
Absolutely correct
Stop defending your wrong. Accept the flaw in show and ask for forgiveness.
If you have big followers, you will bcome arou-gants?
I agree with u
11:21 he asks for forgiveness
sorry 11:17
He literally did, atleast watch the full video.
Unsubscribe, do not comment and do not engage with these channels. The more we engage, the more we strengthen them. I have marked "Do not recommend ".
Yes
Thank you exactly
Done!
Done
For some reason my heart doesn’t believe this brother anymore
"If women in the times of the Prophet left after prayers before men in order for there to be no fitnah, ask yourself Ali would the Prophet authorise for you to bring men and women together like this? Accept you are wrong, brother, and just go according to Quran and Sunnah"
So men and women should never talk to each other about anything ever? 😂 Even if the purpose is to literally save marriages? This is what I call extremism. They are not sitting there to chit chat, their topics are important and no else is addressing them.
He did sometimes discuss marital issues with women
why r u lying
Smashed it alhamdolillah
@@sakuranagifrno lies here - why are you ignorant go learn your deen
No need to debate topics that were settled over 1400 years ago. The simple solution is to invite a scholar and let him do a Q&A
One of the signs of the day of judgement is people will talk about things they have no knowledge of. Ali, you're not a scholar and shouldn't be giving Islamic advice.
He said he consulted some senior Ulamas before starting the podcast!!
He's not even a student of knowledge
@@tankodestranger
He never claimed to be one!
@@Sofyh-l4u Wow those must some real scholars that gave him permission to these riduculous things Ali is doing! Some real ulamaa!
@@Chimaeri0n
I watched the full podcast , no one was flirting it was a respective discussion only that they touched some sensitive topic which he has apologized btw. So if you are looking for faults then you won't see any good in it!
Akhi you have to come out and tell the viewers which scholars have said your show isn’t considered as free mixing
Yes so that I can stop watching that shiekh
@@ayeikareviews6127 Based
No scholar has said it is okay. He is doing it on his own . Commiting sin and yet being stubborn.
@@servantofthemerciful3511you're also committing a bigger sin judging him and assuming. How do you know he's not saying the truth?
@@ImenBen12 Because no scholar will validate such actions. For a person to be scholar there are some milestones that need to be qualified. You can't regard a random spokesperson as scholar. You wrongly said I am committing sin. I said what truth and it's right infront of us . Islam has clearly laws against it. Allah Azzawajal orders Ummul Momineen to speak appropriately before opposite gender or else he might react to sickness in his heart . Aisha Radi'Allahu Anha addressed some private issues which were related to body or intimacy like kiss in wudhu and during fast etc. But she never disclosed the actions that were performed in full fledged intimacy. So there is these rules for Ummul Momineen. We are nothing to even ignore that.
Akhi respectfully if your Mrs or sister went on a Show like yours free mixing with bloggers and TH-camrs talking about private bedroom issues would u allow it?? Didn’t think so..
How comes his wife is not on his show I don't watch his shows but have come across them... is that not a little hypocritical
if I'm wrong and she is on his show please correct me jazakallahukhayr
Bring your wife on to discuss these things with these men if it’s okay.
This right there!!! He’s keeping his wife well hidden but exposes other sisters, not right.
@Fortifier1021 what's your obsessions with lesbians? Are you one?
@@SAM-h3k8n big time he’s going to everyone comments who disagree with gender mixing.
@Fortifier1021 it’s because you yourself is flirting with your own gender and thinks that’s we women do the same. You’re just a 😈 😈 😈
I have alsoconfronted him and majid about the question why they put their wives in the podcast. With other discussing about divorce there no different than Saida Psychology all using the mantle of Islam
Don’t westernize Islam!
What about neegrify it? Because african men and women associate pretty freely.
@@ItsameAlexwhat?
@@ItsameAlexThats culture
Its wrong islamically
Arabs also used to mixed and islam destroyed that.
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
@@EIibra not every Muslim watch Movies or series like that . Also there is a difference between the podcasts and the series the setup and motivations are different although I don't support the way Ertugrul series proceeded. In Movie or Series too interaction can be made to a limit just like normally in real life women men are supposed maintain according to Sharia. During the time of Sahaba people used to ask Ummul Momineen issues or hadith. She used to narrate that . The current system of job is dajjal system. However brothers can avoid that by limiting to general communication which is totally different from what happens in podcasts.
AL-QURAN 2:42
And do not mix the truth with falsehood or conceal the truth while you know [it]
❤️
What I don't understand is, you have made debate videos where males and females are discussing topics at length, when Islam has already provided all the answers to these questions.
You could have easily created videos where you sit down with a scholar and ask him these same questions and he answers it succinctly and efficiently, completely avoiding any unnecessary mixing.
Was this way the only way? Why not pick the route that you know is safer for your deen?
The thing is, he could have been easily done this show over voice call, which would protect the women’s sanctity and also not show themselves online. I don’t think men and women being in a room together for some reasons is free-mixing, but the topics they are discussing are intimate, and they are not really talking from an Islamic standpoint but they are debating it with a little Islam mixed in.
Well said 👏🏻
We don’t care of your opinion… as much as you OBVIOUSLY do not care about the opinion of qualified scholars? The vast majority of people in the comment section do watch tv daily… as a Muslim do you consider (Allah being ou witness) as hypocrisy?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 To be honest, i love brother Ali, but you just can't tell us there are "senior scholars" whom gave fatwa on it and get away with it.
I wholeheartedly believe that is just wrong. He should state who said it, what he said, what evidence he used. People "attacking him" or whatever should not matter.
Because of less views = less 💸
Marriage is encouraged in Islam however discussing sensitive topics like “performance in the bedroom” is not encouraged to be spoken about among random Muslim brothers and sisters who are all Non-Mehram for each other. If you have marital problems or intimate issues, you can go to Islamic marriage counselling sessions or other professionals in this area.
Totally agree. This is just airing dirty laundry.
I haven’t made a comment on TH-cam in over 15+ plus years. And I have to state that I’m shockingly surprised and pleased with that fact that most of the comments are in agreement that this is NOT a appropriate show to have. Masha’Allah Tabarak’Allah you folks give hope to the ummah. Dear Brother @Ali Dawah please give this further thought Insha’Allah. This is not the way. May Allah Azza Wajjal forgive us all for our shortcomings. Ameen 🤲🏼
Then why don't you bring your wife in the show and let her discuss this matter with guys?
Come on brother, we don't expect such things from your side?
It wouldn't be haram for him to bring his wife in the show to discuss things like chores or money
@@randomhuman2595 No. To discuss not being satisfied with intimacy like they were discussing in the clip
@@Tea962 That was inappropriate. But just discussing money or child custody is fine right?
@@randomhuman2595but they‘re non maram
@@randomhuman2595 He doesn’t show his wife due to protective jealousy, men and women have protective jealousy for a reason which is why that would be so uncomfortable to let his wife on such a show or even show her in vids.
Sorry, akhi, but I can't back this one. The natural feeling of watching it just feels wrong. Your viewers are both Male and female. How can you be lowering your gaze yet providing us with the perspective of both genders. Doesn't make sense.
Also to add to your important advice, would or did the prophet or any of his companions address matters in such manner, addressing Islamic values is important and the way in which we do this is also ibadah. We are imitating the liberal world to address Islamic values is wrong.
@@Nusaybah459exactly.
He will realize when he lose subscribers
Frankly there are many Hadeeth whcih are very Specific - that even some sahavu were not comfortable with some woman's/ sahabi lady questions
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
@@EIibra if you are watching a TV series with the mere purpose or entertaining yourself... Okay. That's your decision. However if you chose to solve real life problems and take examples from this TH-camr, then it's up to you too but the risks of a bad results are higher.
Don't kid around with life changing decisions.
A real man isn’t the one who is always correct but the one who apologises after doing wrong.
Your bitter truth show is nothing but a tone down version of fresh and fit bro. Muslim couples who are having issues should consult with counselors, scholars and people of knowledge instead of watching laymen discuss their problems and opinions.
@abumaryama6340 It's even worse than Fresh and Fit, because he really want us to make believe it's Halal what he is doing. And people will copy him.
@AfrikanischUnterwegs-hu8br if he says its Halal then he comes into the section of those who will make haram thing's halal our prophet peace be upon him warned us about. We should warn each other and community against such people
Wallahi it's embarrassing, exposing your dirt laundry to the world🤦♂️
what exactly is he doing that is haram?
@@spaceinvader2977 women and especially Mutbarrijat that put on make up and don't dress properly are being shown to thousands of men, these topics should be discussed by respectable knowledge people, and the podcast format leads to unnecessary talks between the two genders which is haram
Shut down the show Ali. Go back to giving Dawah the regular old ways.
Yeah, i mean it's basically a lounge with free mixing and discussing intimacy publically. Just like the show fit and fresh.
😏 you have to diversify and this is giving the people what they were asking for…
💯
Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem's response.
"It is kind of him to identify me as a student of knowledge which I am proud to be known for.
However, when we start to make haram things halal based on fatwas of ‘big scholars” and we fail to name them, this shows how “weak” their argument is!!
I have Bin Bazz and Ibn Othaimeen backing my opinion about such gatherings and indecent topics to be totally prohibited and shameful in Islam.
Ibn Abbas may Allah be pleased with him said to the people when they objected to a fatwa he gave by saying that Abu Bakr and Omer say something else, he said: hails of rocks and stones are about to fall upon you! I say Allah says and the prophet salla allahu alaihi wa sallam says and you counter that by saying Abu Bakr and Omer say???
Real Islam is corrupted and tarnished by such people who brush Quran and Sunnah off for the quotes of unknown “big scholars”!
No one is above the sharia no matter how big they may think they are.
Real men are known to stand down when they are wrong and admit it for the sake of truth and not to win an argument in this dunya and ending up finding that they have lost in their graves or the hereafter, may Allah make all our deeds sincere for His sake and give us a good ending on tawheed and the sunnah of our prophet salla Allahu alaihi wa sallam. "
Where did he say this?
Lmao... bin bazz make many weird fatwa. Red flag
@@charlottesphie7037😂😅 OK then
Your entire existence sounds frustrating and sad. Fake religion, btw.
True. He literally didn't mention these "people of knowledge "
As a lowly and unworthy person, I must say, I can see a slight of arrogance and ignorance in brother Ali. May Allah keep you away from harm, Ya akhi. You gave us hope against taghut, Alhamdulillah. May Allah SWT protect us from harms of the Nafs, shayateen and people. Ameen
Slight ?
He's been arrogant for a very long time.
The Muslim youth needs to start listening to the Ulema/Scholars. Having millions of likes and subscribers on TH-cam doesnt make you an Islamic scholar. And we all need to be humble enough to realize our mistakes, accept them and try to rectify them, instead of arrogantly denying and justifying it. May Allah guide us all and protect us, Ameen 🤲
Always been like this, and the maddest thing is as a revert as well
@ItsTonyMontanaMayn being a revert doesn't help you from faults. Or misguidance after being guided.
What do I see ? Backbiting here ? Aren't u ashamed to talk about ur brother like this
THIS WAS ALWAYS HARAM AND DISGUSTING !
This is what happens when you think you are always right.
May ALLAH Save Us from Such Fitna And Such People
@Fortifier1021 Focus on the issue that's been addressed here.. it's about the Haram mix gatherings that he and others are indulged into.
I dunno why r u do keen on the lesbian thing.
@Fortifier1021 It surely is terrible and it always start with a small sin. like when people don't consider mix gathering a sin etc
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
I love brother Ali as a Muslim brother and the effort he is putting into the Deen. May Allah accept from him.
Personally, I didn’t watch a single episode of his show where the men and women were sitting and discussing issues… never sat right with me. Imagine if it was your husband or wife sitting there discussing such issues with strangers.
If Ali wants to address these problems or issues in marriage … a simple scholarly informative discussion with a knowledgeable scholar is million times better and more than enough.
Brother Ali you lower your gaze from those sisters , yet you display them on your channel to be viewed by millions ?? Don’t you find that ironic!!? Would you show your wife on your channel talking to strange men about all kinds of issues!?
Yes correct BUT he stated its APPROVED/Permissible by a Scholar🙇
At the time of the prophet sws do you lower your gaze when you buy goods at your supermarket? Who do you think you are to beleive that qualified scholars are not qualified to give an opinion different than yours? Cheer up and go and and watch TV like the VAST MAJORITY of people who criticize BUT STILL watch tv daily… I hope you are not of those otherwise you would qualified yourself probably as being an hypocrite for better words to describe this double standard?
@@OloRishaCreole504 What scholar? sheikh haitham? the Scholar that permitted getting student loans??
@@lerecklessbadger2411 Again, your arguments fail hard.
- Who are the ghost scholars? They are as good as not there if he doesn't present their fatwa.
- Don't generalize, i don't watch TV for example. If the majority are doing it doesn't mean its Halal, childish opinion right there.
- Non mehram women, full face of make-up, INCORRECT hijab, bright colors, is not covered. Period. Ali brings them to a "public space" with other non mehram men, ok. They still talk about very sensitive topics, distasteful, but ok. However, ALL UNECESSARY.
Their knowledge is relative from one another, are you telling me a guy who does Qaza' and a woman who wears full makeup and a scarf with tight clothing know more than an actual senior scholar? Get over yourself, this is all very unecessary which is why it most probably enters the threshold of haram.
but I challenge you to bring me a scholar with actual knowledge that says this stuff is halal.
It's clear now even you provided so much clarity. Still there are some people who think you are arrogant. But soon they will know that their rejection and argument or Ali Dawah will be of no use on the day of Judgement. Hypocrisy in Ummah has contaminated it very hard.
When money kicks in , people forget halal haram things
Sad
Right
Just unsusbcribe and he will surely pay attention
I remember Brother Ali telling us that he does not earn anything from TH-cam.
@@Sho-M3-Hear yes I remember aswell but after awhile I think he is monetized
Why don't you name the scholars who have approved this show? If there's nothing to hide, you can name them
🖤Your show is same as going to nightclub with hijab on, no drinking but only chatting.
Akhi, man up and take our feedbacks as a constructive criticism for self improvement.
You’re causing a big fitna and it’s hurting us all.
Thank you.
LOL… now your « comments » are more important than the scholars that gave him a green light? That’s funny… as if you ignore that the vast majority who criticize watch tv entertainment, movies and the like? Would you qualify this as hypocrisy (Allah is our witness) ?
@@lerecklessbadger2411 we don’t care if all the scholars give him the green light.
Chatting with non mehram is haram except in the case of emergency.
My and your job is to share even if it’s an ayat.
It’s not my >
It’s the command of Allah mentioned in the Quran.
@@watchyourjet You are from a sect.. not your comment but Allah? You are a modernist… never Muslims in the past denied differences of positions and opinions ! In my sight you are a joke (and anybody intelligent would agree) not because you might have a different opinion but because you are blind to see that the vast majority of people watch tv daily still they criticize… Allah be ou witness if you watch tv you are a disease a cancer… if you don’t watch tv then you have your opinion and congratulation to behave according to your belief. Still I let you know that I know our sources and I see no issues as long as these interactions are made with good intentions.
@@watchyourjet You have never lived in a Muslim country where we speak daily with strangers with no ill intent. And you are an arrogant who despise senior scholars. And you fell miserably to reconized that the vast majority of people here who criticize DO WATCH TV DAILY… That is the sign of hypocrisy… so as I say not as I do… Do you watch tv by the way?
@@watchyourjetthis is untrue. it is entirely permissible in a professional or educational setting. in a respectful dignified manner.
it is not akin to a nightclub which would be a leisure setting just because.
Haram is haram, we shouldn't find loop holes in the deen, our scholars say what they say from Qur'an and sunnah.
With evidence, these weman must have a mehram present, period
There’s people behind the set. Mahrams mayb be there. I’ve seen the show were Ali mentions the sisters husbands behind set
It's still wrong, bring your own sister and wife to the set then if it's correct.
@@yousufnoori4439 if someone doesn’t want their wife going somewhere that doesn’t make it haraam.
Some men wouldn’t want it some do.
So you let your wife or sister work in a free mixing environment when providing is not one of their musts. ? Shiek Assim says that’s haraam
As I said, bring your own wife to the show. Why not? Since you said it's not Haram and let her speak about her intimacy with you as these sisters did. You say it's not Haram but deep down you know it is. Fear Allah brother, don't argue just for the sake of arguing. If our prophet Muhammad SAW was here, would be approve of this show? That should be your standard.@@dubai_fitness
@@yousufnoori4439 THE VIDEO IS LITERALLY ABOUT THE INTIMACY CLIP AND HIM APOLOGISING ABOUT THAT AND SAYING HE AGREES IT SHOULDNT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED,
So is everyone at speakers corner sinning?
Also main part.... im assuming your wife does not work in a free mixed environment.. as its not her obligation to provide so no need for her to be there... shiek aasim also said thats haraam for a woman to work somewhere unless its female only...
Even our mother 'Aisha RA, when she's giving lessons to her students or when the sahabah having qna sessions with her, she sit behind a curtain. No one can see her. Yet, here we are, justifying free mixing? Nahhh, this is wrong.
Ok but she was the wife of the prophet. Different rules apply
Seikh Asim al hakeem has studied under seikh Uthaymeen and seikh bin Baz and many other seikhs and is a student of knowledge who is certified and studied the deen over decades. Pls show us some of your level of islamic education to question this seikh and who are the seikhs saying its permissible otherwise anyone can say trust me bro this top seikh said it.
But the latest video he did where Al Islam productions replied to him when he mocked the Asians for wiping their hands on their face and body after dua, sheikh bib baaz actually refuted everything this wannabe Hakim said.
@Fortifier1021 shush that tongue of you, it will nullify your good deed.
Brother, with all respect, you do know scholars disagree on many things right? Let us leave haram and halal to the people of knowledge.
@@maliknotice7149 what is your point here exactly? Sheikh Assim is a qualified scholar and he is the one commented that Ali is doing haram. Instead of weighting on the right, are you going to try to sound neutral? those do not speak against what's wrong , actually support the wrong by silence. If you don't want to do that, at least don't discourage people who speaks the right thing.
@@maliknotice7149that’s the scary thing I listen to dr zakir, sheikh assim, nouman Ali,Mohammed hoblos as well as my dad who’s correct was always told follow the prophet Mohammed pbuh and his companions
Glad I didn’t watch that show, and after reading this comment section I found out I wasn’t the only one who didn’t.
Ali dawah is wrong, no matter what he says in his defense. Haram is haram. periodt.
Name the names of the scholars. Its not enough to claim senior ulamaa allowed this.
senior ulamaa aint nothing to sneeze at. His words definitely carry weight
@ItsameAlex that's why ali should name them. I can't think of a single senior scholar who would see this show and allow it, no way. Therefore I rly wanna know who those "senior scholars" are.
Show the fatwa in detail then Ali, let us all see exactly what was asked to these so called "senior ulemas" as it's very easy to fatwa shop nowadays, if one is legit you should show the full fatwa & the full wording, question & answer, not just a claim, stop playing...💯
You got an ego issue Ali, fix youself
Or lets say Tazkiyah - purification of the self
he is a good chap but has alpha syndrome.
Sooooo true! May Allah protect us all
One thing I am really happy alhamdullilah is that people recognize this fitnah..Majority of comments I see are calling him out about this free mixing. Alhamdullilah,...People know deen well. May Allah keep everyone on straight path..Ameen
@@reomai9576 not really..What he is doing is wrong..As he is declaring his show as "Islamic" so people have right to confront him for that and correct him. People wont be so "judgemental" if he accepts his show for what it is, a free mixing "Jerry Springer" inspired Show, then people wont be so judgemental. Problem is he is trying very hard to convince everyone wrongly that his show adheres to Islamic values and no one is buying that..
It was narrated from ‘Abd-Allah ibn Mas’ood that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “No one who has an atom’s-weight of arrogance in his heart will enter Paradise.” A man said, “O Messenger of Allah, what if a man likes his clothes and his shoes to look good?” He said, “Allah is Beautiful and loves beauty. Arrogance means rejecting the truth and looking down on people.”
It was PRIDE i think not arrogance......
@@daisypashe8296 Wrong. The word used is Kibir in the Arabic language so it’s not limited to just a 1-1 translation of the word. Arabic is far richer than English so it encompasses more.
When a mufti or scholar give fatwa on something that it’s haram then it’s not merely his opinion. Scholar give fatwa on the basis of Quran and Sunnah. Dose Islam allow a women talk about explicit family issue/sexual issue with non-mahram and also talk to non-mahram without proper veil? And please mention the name of those scholars who give legitimacy this show.
Fatwa means Opinion
@@mathew1812And a valid reference means, name the source, in this case the scholars. Otherwise it's just a claim.
Lol.....no they dont.....there are many scholars who don't give fatwas based on Quran n sunnah....some are not that well educated some lack common sense some do not understand Quran or sunnah properly n misinterpret n pass fatwas......there are only a handful who are responsible n give fatwa based on QURAN n sunnah.....
@@mathew1812Fatwa doesnt mean opinion. Learn Arabic
@@wsky6315 A fatwa is a religious ruling or opinion issued by an Islamic scholar or mufti. It is usually in response to a question posed by a Muslim concerning Islamic law or doctrine and is not legally binding. The word "fatwa" comes from the Arabic root f-t-y, which means "to decide" or "to give an opinion."
A mufti is an Islamic scholar who is qualified to respond to questions about Islamic law or doctrine. A mufti may issue fatwas but does not necessarily have to. The legal process of issuing a fatwa in response to a question posed by a Muslim is known as ifta.
Ya Akhi, you can't just say " We asked a scholar and he said it's ok " without saying who he was and what he exactly said.
I can say " I asked one of the top scholars if music is haram and he said no "
Your intentions might be pure. But a woman or man should never ever talk about anything that happens in the bedroom. Islamically the man is a veil to the woman and vice versa.
Secondly we cant talk about why women cheat. You shouldnt be doing zina period regardless of what reason you have. That is why divorce is an option.
i likw hoq eveything is about women ya all come down
@@t0xiic_mxchiWhy so toxic?
This case might apply to Non-Mahrams. But I don’t see anything wrong with a woman and man like husband and wife discussing these kind of things privately.
Why is everyone commenting you shouldn’t be talkin about private bedroom stuff WHEN IN THE VIDEO HE SAID THIS WAS BIT RIGHT AND HES GOING TO REMOVE THIS PART
@@t0xiic_mxchihow? Go through every single one of his videos on his channel and then tell me everything is about women. Smh
I’m glad I have seen no one support this act of yours. Wallahi you’re entering dangerous territories. I normally make excuses for you and your constituents, but I can’t continue to with the territory you’re entering. Humble yourself, Repent to Allah ya akhi, and retract the ignorance you’re spueing before Shaitan continues to make you justify things that are clearly wrong by making you fatwa shop for fatwas that please you’re desires, because there’s no way any scholar that clings to the Qur’an and sunnah would ever support women being on camera with their faces uncovered discussing these issues, better yet with Non-Mahram men looking at each-other and debating each other. At this point, come out and say these scholars names you consulted with because I literally don’t know any scholar of Islam nor serious student of knowledge that would support what you’re doing. Drop their names so we can drop them for supporting this evil doing. Your comment section is a sign for you and a reminder you received the message on the day of Judgement. There will be no excuses for you. Repent, and ask forgiveness from brother Saajid and other brothers who advised you on this and other things, before they can possibly take your good deeds on the day of Judgement for being in the right for advising their brother in Islam for promoting fahisha. Barakallahu Feekum.
Well written brother 👊🏻
@@BeatingUinFifaMalachi generally speaking,uncovering the face is an issue of dispute but most scholars agree it is better or sunnah to do.However,in camera or in social media where men can look into the details it is haram and allah knows best
@@taiemgamerxrbg2080Is face awrah?
And to that can I add to his list to repemt for openly, publicly shaming and humiliating good and chaste women, and degrading them, subhanAllah, but may Allah protect us and him, still because because being the I the public eye is not easy, perhaps we could have had sisters off camera, or on a sisters only platform or some such, but the shaming the women was just too much.
We expect better from our Muslim brothers, and apart to have to right this publicly. May Allah help us have private communities for discussions and feedback -
Fame is one of the most powerful addictions known to man. Only the Prophets of Allah were protected from it. As a person builds tolerance to the attention, their reality gets distorted, and the bar for more attention continues to rise. May Allah protect us all. 🤲🏾
Ali needs DAWAH
Shamsi saw what see now
Definitely
Loosing some subs will teach him lesson for sure
You can't tell me all these tons of comments aren't coming from somewhere extremely strong and based upon the knowledge Allah gave us which results in us fearing him as we see, in the comments that is.
That is on the contrary what is really worrying and you must be stupid if you do not see it…
We agree that scholars can have a different opinion based on knowledge… BUT YOU disagree with scholars not understanding how the came to the conclusion they draw.
Now think of it… the vast majority of people posting comments DO WATCH tv entertainment and movies or even documentaries… That is sheer hypocrisy and you base the soundness of your opinion on this masse of hypocrite?
To make it clear WE DO ACCEPT différences of opinons (contrary to YOU) but we expect the person not watching any kind of Tv…
How surprising you have my comment removed… So I repeat : you invoke the vast majority who watch tv daily…. You are an imposter…
In my opinion, it’s amazing how before the sheikh said that everyone supported this show but now the sheikh said that everyone talks crap about it. Like they literally changed their opinion about this show in a couple of hours. Amazing-
@@Hahahaha-7 was quite similar already, it's just double confirmed now
The arrogance and ignorance made me unsubscribe. That's it. I also wonder who that senior scholar/counselor is.
far superior scholars that can't be named😂
Secret identity like batman, but just trust me bro
@@YungRamomy thought was the same. It must be the batman.
@@YungRamoLol 🤣
😂
Who said FAR superior scholars… you are a LIAR it is YOU who believe YOUR scholars are superior ? Don’t lie, don’t be an hypocrite.. as soon as you get the qualified scholars you will reject them because you have a disease in your heart? How can you reject scholars because of a difference of opinion?
All the comments are united that this is wrong. This makes me happy that our Muslim ummah is strong and united.
Why not make the women cover their face at minimum? I know it doesn’t make it right, but at the very least you can make them cover their face !!
covering their faces is not enough, no skin should be shown. And if they could get one those machines that make a woman's voice sound like a man's, like in police investigations, that would be ideal.
@@ItsameAlex😂😂😂😉
@Fortifier1021 what is your obsession with lesbians? That's all you're commenting. Troll.
SHE IS NOT A LOWLY OBJECT
Allah, the Glorified and High, has protected the woman and covered her and made Her a covered and Preserved Pearl which is not permissible for any to remove her Covering expect her husband who Allah has made her permissible for and made him permissible for her.
And he has prohibited the Woman displaying her adornments for foreign men as a protection for her and preservation of her.
She is not a lowly object to be handled by the hands and gazed upon by the eyes (of the people) . Rather, she is a preserved pearl ; safeguarded for her husband who Allah has made permissible for her and made her permissible for him. This is the woman within Al Islam.
Book: The Status of the Woman in Islam
By Shaykh Saalih Al-Fawzaan Translated by Rähä bin Donald Batts.
Alhamdulillah for the true Muslim woman.
It's up to women which opinion they want to follow. May Allah make it easy for them.
Its amazing how many people intensely watch his show yet comment negatively.
Sheikh Assim is my FAVORITE Mashallah, as a revert :)
same here
AsSalaamu Alaykom. I just wanted to ask you how do you justify to yourself some fatwas that seem a little tough about woman in marriage. I’m a brother from USA who was watching the bitter truth show for a little bit of time and I can’t get past the fact that secret wives are halal to lie about. If you can share any wisdom to help me accept it I will be grateful. Jazak Allah Khair
@@jvg6877 hmm from what I learned and iam not scholar , Muslim men can take on a second wife for good reason and with good intentions, (he will be financially responsible for both) , if his first wife is unable to have children, she don’t satisfy his personal needs, she doesn’t cook/clean take care of him etc. he can take a second wife without telling her. But if she finds out and she wants divorce because she can not contain her. Jealousy , anger etc.. he must think of all the outcomes as well and handle them as a man.. good and bad. This from what I learn.. everything must be done with good intentions.
@@theeniqabiofficial1845 Ma Sha Allah. You think from fitra. May Allah bless you and keep you steadfast and allow you to become a teacher one day
same here, he's amazing!
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
"Two wolves free among sheep are no more destructive to them than a man's desire for wealth and fame is to his religion."
Give a thousand justifications for your actions akhi you cant beat this hadith of the prophet ﷺ.
You have unfortunately proven the hadith to be true.
I wasted 13.20 minutes watching this and 1 minute typing this comment.
Thank you Sheikh Assim for highlighting this problem 👏🏼
When something is doubtful, it's better to leave it
Apparently Ali dawah needs real dawah😂
@Fortifier10212 wrongs don't make a right.
Don't run from this topic
This brother has lost his mind to say this behaviour is not free mixing, let alone the context of conversation sisters are having bait faced on social media. I would love to hear what “sheikhs” have given him a pass to do this. You can’t quote sources in an essay and say nah I’m not telling you where I got the information from 😂
Nonsense that senior scholars would say this podcast free mixing with sisters and talking about things related to intimacy is permitted this is ridiculous how does these podcast help anyone, theses issues are all well known in society this is all clout chasing and for money
This one topic should hv been more private. But discussions about other topics are needed, just in a respectful modest manner
@@sulisueeeeee0553they are Not needed, this is NOT Islam!! read the Quran and Hadiths peoples opinions and advice will never Help you or be better than what the Quran and Hadith says, Muslims need to stop exposing themselves online!!
@Fortifier1021Oh liar, show me the Hadith where the Prophet of Allah (Sallalahu alayhim Wasalam) would sit with a woman in front of all male sahaba and have one hour long discussion regarding sex and other intimate topics. You’re a lying hypocrite who tries to justify the haram and fitna from Ali “Dawah.”
@Fortifier1021 like that ? It's Ramadan so rectify yourselves ask forgiveness. In hadith says Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wasallam said if anyone make lies about me he or she should see destination in hellfire.
I said this long back, that is Totally Haram.
Perfect delusion of the devil to make the believer believe what he does is halal when infact it is haram!!!
naming seik with name and photo, but keeping the seik who gave you approval for this nonsense a secret
The prophet ﷺ spoke to a “beautiful woman” … Read this Hadith: Al-Fadl bin `Abbas rode behind the Prophet (ﷺ) as his companion rider on the back portion of his she camel on the Day of Nahr (slaughtering of sacrifice, 10th Dhul-Hijja) and Al-Fadl was a handsome man. The Prophet (ﷺ) stopped to give the people verdicts. In the meantime, a beautiful woman From the tribe of Khath'am came, asking the verdict of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). Al-Fadl started looking at her as her beauty attracted him. The Prophet (ﷺ) looked behind while Al-Fadl was looking at her; so the Prophet (ﷺ) held out his hand backwards and caught the chin of Al-Fadl and turned his face (to the owner sides in order that he should not gaze at her. She said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! The obligation of Performing Hajj enjoined by Allah on His worshipers, has become due (compulsory) on my father who is an old man and who cannot sit firmly on the riding animal. Will it be sufficient that I perform Hajj on his behalf?" He said, "Yes."
What exactly is this supposed to prove?
Masha’Allah, amazing reminder 👍🏼
What r u trying to indicate?
Pls don’t spread diyatha amongst the muslims
Which senior senior scholar did you get your fatwah from?
I’ve lost respect for this brother used to look up to him, but now he’s not able to understand how this is just wrong and free mixing. May الله guide him
That's one point. The other is it's a point system and getting one over each other.
Me too
I Just unsub him
I use to also watch him. When I saw this mixing I stopped
said the hypocrite with her face in display..🤦♂️
The comment section certaintly didnt dissapoint. Glad to see the Muslim ummah united on the haq
I always knew this was wrong and I expected better from u Ali but I didn’t say anything Bcuz I just waited till allah shined some light on this fitna I’d always see the shorts and feel so disgusted with the free mixing going on on those podcasts I’m not gonna shame u for ur sin or the rest of the ppl who were on there but pls fear Allah and take down the videos aswell they will be used against u on judgement day and just don’t repeat it again .
@Fortifier1021I see you copy pasting the same dumb argument everywhere, it's a nice strawman but it doesn't give you the right to make one haram thing into halal to apparently fighting against other haram.
Exactly 👍
Agree, this show itself passes western vibes to me. Never watched any episode and never will. Alhamdulillah.
@@s.afra_f same alhamdulillah It’s embarassing but oh well
HYPOCRISY!! The sad thing about the comment section is that we all know our community is having marriage and divorce problems, and the way we react is just criticizing the efforts to make any advance towards a solution. This, in and of itself, shows how we tend to look at the problem but never solve it because no one wants to take any responsibility. Anyways, there's a lot of hypocrisy in the comments because the Muslims living in the West have daily interaction with the opposite gender (in class, at work...)and dont consider it free mixing .When we attend weddings or family encounters we also have such interactions, but it seems that the cultures of our countries of origin have a special pass. When we watch TV shows like Ertugrul, in which the making of it implied also interactions, no one mentions that. But when it comes to solving real things, everything that was justified according to religious teachings previosly, now is suddenly haram. Im not saying that we dont follow the teachings, and thats why he mentioned he spoke to people of knowledge about the topic.
Take your L and apologize. Asim al Hakeem is always straight forward, no bs, and always on the way of sunah and quran. Don’t you dare to discredit him.
I lost all respect for this guy. Just to make himself look right he is trying to prove Sheikh Assim al Hakeem wrong. I always thought there is something fishy about this guy, I didnt know why but I had uneasy feeling about him even before this. But now I know why I had this feeling..
True
@@rizwana.5420 yup same feeling i had
“The scholars” without naming… this is not Islam, Ali needs Dawah and it’s a shame that someone who has such little knowledge is held up so high by so many while huge scholars of Islam are forgotten
Atleast blur the faces of sisters, and please don't say scholars allowed you to show faces of na mahram sisters in front of hundreds of thousands,(even millions) of people. Even if they don't hide their faces; it's your responsibility to blur the faces of sisters because you are the one bringing them to huge amount of audience. Many people involved in dawah online brother Muhammad Ali, Sheikh Uthman are really strict about this(I have never seen them show faces of any lady ever).
When you say you have discussed with scholars and they say it is permissible then at least make sure you don't pick and choose between scholars(I am not saying you did, this is just an advice from a brother because some people do this) because remember there are both ulama'e sue and ulama'e Haq (Just like in the time of bani israel).
JazakAllah Khairan
Some scholars say covering of face is optional not a fard....some say it is.....there are difference of opinion about face covering....
Agree with the blurring of faces just for the purpose of the video. that way noone can judge them if sensitive topics are spoken about. Im Not referring to face covering as we all know that's optional.
Either way even if face is shown, it shouldn’t be with make up. The sisters on his show have plenty of make up and dressing is not right either
Stop judging everyone is on different level of emaan you're not God stop nitpicking let women breathe
Should women be locked up and never seen in the world?
Muslim married women cheating on their husbands ? What?? Is that even athing? Subhanallah i thought we passed that level. My Allah protect us
I watched one or two episodes and I was left with more questions and uncertainty. These debates or discussions don't give a conclusion, anyone could end up with any opinion.
I said from day one these shows are wrong. Completely wrong.
but you can learn "what not to do" from them
@@ItsameAlextrue to a point. But subconsciously it deters you from marriage also.
It's a very negative show.
When you disobey Allahﷻ but with a "GOOD INTENTION", it will cause more harm than good. Bitter truth.
This is not permissible even your intention is good, to combat divorce. But this is not the right way and Allah knows best.
While Allah blesses nonmuslims with the ability to see His other creations such as Moon, Mars and other planets, there are Muslims who focus on nitty gritty and its perhaps the reason why Allah has not freed the ummah from its persecution and oppression from its oppressors.
I feel like it would be better to have these one hour shows and talk about Tawheed and different topics of Islam in general together with Muslim brothers.
Personally, I would never want my future wife to indulge in any public shows regardless of the topic.
Maybe that’s the problem akhi. Our religion is more than just Tawheed otherwise we’d be no different to the Christians who believe in faith-only and not works. We believe in Faith+Works and remember the Hadith that marriage is half of Deen. You neglecting this shows your perception of Islam is off. Allah knows best.
@@alphauno6614 I didn’t limit it to Tawheed. Speaking about marriages is important as well, but you can get the same message across without having Non-Mahram women in the room.
@@leun6768 perhaps you’re right but this comment of yours nullifies almost entirely your initial comment.
Imagine your sister posted on his youtube thumbnail!! For millions to view. Madness man. Im getting angry thinking about it wallahi. Tell him to out his sister on the thumnail
Dude there are soooo many others that do that. No one is actually talking about problems the Ummah is facing. People like YOU are helping to cause that problem. I hate what you people have done to the younger generations! You’re destroying us with this mentality!!!!!
Ali Dawah fear Allah. That's a vey honest advice. May almighty Allah grant us all guidance. And forgive all our wrongs
Ali Dawah lost the respect of many people with this shameless show, if he really believes this to be ok then prove it by bringing his wife on the show.
As salamu alaykum I have a few questions and I do not intend to offend you Ali. I dont watch the show so forgive me if this has already been adressesed. 1 If the purpose of the show is to address marital issues why not have a qualified marriage counselor as the cohost? 2 Why not take the criticism and improve the show in a way that will make more Muslims comfortable by redesigning the set to allow more distance and possibly a barrier between the men and women guest? Would that really negatively effect the quality of the content (no)? 3 If the topic goes into more intimate areas why not have the marital counselor or a Muslim physician speak on it or answers directly instead of none mahram men and women going back and forth about it? I advise to look at this as a way to improve the show and not feel the need to justify or defend it. May Allah bless you and your family.
I didn't even know he had this show... Oooof
He will lose subscribers with this one
Great
I really think it’s pure entertainment there’s no benefit to it at the end you go away with more questions and doubts
What's the point in a barrier if there's no barrier to the conversation and they can just go online and see who they were talking to and laughing and joking with about sex, and other topics?
Did the senior sholars see the show live and the way and style of interaction or did they give the fatwa in abstraction?
What does "lower your gaze" mean!?
Post your wife as well speaking to ghair mehram about these issues dayooth qada haircut tabbaruj intermixing all these apply to you Ali drama
His show is like Fresh and Fit but only with an Islamic mantle
Allah said (Ahzab: 53):
"And when you (THE SAHABAH) ask (his wives) for anything you want (Benefical Knowledge), ask them from
BEHIND A SCREEN, that is purer for your hearts and for their hearts."
Allah said this to the Sahaba, what do think about us? These "scholars" are nothing compared to Allah! If a scholar
says something, and Allah says different, you take from Allah and not do Taqleed (blind following) of that scholar.
Ya Allah.... How is this not free mixing?
It's so unnecessary.
In Quran it's says talk with the wives of the prophet behind a curtain. This shows how you should behave with non mahram women.
How do u sit and chat with sisters. You copy the kufar astaghfirullah.
Why? It's not necessary. Allah guide us all.
Ali, Akhi I hope you see this message. First of all when Sheikh Assim Al-Hakeem gives his fatawas, they are not just based on his sentiments. He uses others Scholars as references. Second of all, let us know who the Scholars who advocate for your Bitter truth show are. It is a must that we know who they are and what their Manhajiyyah and Aqeedah is. Fakhr al-Din al-Razi was a very knowledgeable "Scholar" but he was also someone who did not consider the Qur'an and the Sunnah to be unequivocal Hujjah. Also, what about Sheikh Bin Baz, Ibn Uthaymeen, Al-Albani, Saleh Al-Fawzan, Ar-Ruhayli, Al-Usaymi, Abdul Muhsin Al-Abbad, Abdulrazzaq Al-Badr? Would they not see it as being free mixing? Also, these guests that you are bringing are lay people. They clearly don't have Ilm so why should we consider their Naseeha with regards to marriage and divorce if we have Duat who have actually studied the fiqh of it according to the Qur'an and the Sunnah. It's not just a matter of halal and haram (not saying it's not haram by the way) but it also lacks practicality and effectiveness.
Because he is doing it for views not effectiveness. The debate platform generates more views. It’s entertainment. It is NOT dawah the way dawah was intended to be delivered.
@@humnaahmed5187 Allahu A3lam about his intentions but I agree that it is not dawah and it's mostly entertainment.
I'm very curious to know which high senior scholars you're talking about!? And what is according to you free mixing? Let your wife sit with the brothers as well then. You invite sisters who wear full face makeup and you guys giggle and laugh on diff kinds of subjects. Maybe let your wife do that as well.
How Is It Not Free Mixing when there is literally men and women Namahram sitting few feets across each other facing each other and having open conversations with each other about matters of life that Allah has made very private for people? His confidence in his knowledge has made him arrogant and ignorant
If it isnt free mixxing though then what is it? It isnt a public space within the Studio hence the 'public ruling' doesnt apply. Also the men on the show arent Mahram to the Sisters. Unfortunately some sisters come to the show without proper Hijab which Unfortunately will cause Fitnah for some Men. May Allah guide us and Forgive us
I recommend for new muslim to learn Islam from sheikh Assim.
No i don't think so.....some of his answers concerning many topics are pathetic specially when it comes to marriage or divorce.....listen to wat reason he gave for DIVORCE in one of his shows.....
@@daisypashe8296I agree with you!
I wouldn't heed advice from a pawn to the Saudi royal family, given that most Saudi clerics are in that position. Although he can criticize Ali, he refrains from criticizing MBS, whom he serves.
@@mr7swag999a guy who is influenced by the khawarij? It’s not permissible to critize a ruler publicly there is a Hadith about it
Please do share the names of these senior scholars. Jazaakallah khiran
Put up a curtain between the men and the women. Everything will feel the same.
Women wearing hijab came to Prophet Muhammad S.A.W p.b.u.h to ask him things pertaining to religion , & they didn't put a curtain in between , so that's ur opinion.
@@mobashirmallick0786also must you have curtains between men and women in the work place ? I don’t understand it. They weren’t sitting next to each other
@@zaza_268 the office you see now all Dajjal system something which is difficult to avoid like riba. This is what that needs to be changed that's why so much of struggle. People gonna listen to UN still .
@@servantofthemerciful3511haha yes, when going that deep I feel like I'm completely out of my mind, yett It is true and the reality. like I could go crazy thinking that deep 🤣😬😂😢😷🤢
This one topic should hv been more private. But discussions about other topics are needed, just in a respectful modest manner
Asalamulaykum
Can you be transparent and name the scholars who endorse the show and give abit more detail?
Jazakallah khair
Alhamdulilah glad Shiekhs are refusing uour fitnah
Thanks for letting me know. Im beyond disappointed. Time to unsubscribe. May Allah swt fotgive us our sins. Ameen
Alhamdulillah all the comments i have read so far are against what you do... isnt it obvious you've taken the wrong path even if you are sincere, again if they must participate it should be through voice call. May Allah guide you and us
Once again Ali Needs Dawah makes excuses for this blatant haram
Like this Comment if you demand the Fatwa of those scholars who said it's not free mixing and it's allowed. 👇
Which senior scholars name them and show the evidence that they approved of it and is it from the Quran and Sunnah ??
Nowadays, sticking to what is true, to the Quran and the Sunnah, is considered being strict!
And some jabronis will label you as "wahhabi" for that. What a sad situation this ummah is in.
@@MakachevIsTsarukyanUFCdaddyI’d advice you to read the books of that great scholar who they created that name after. His books are very simple but have a lot of important things related to tawheed and shirk
@@MakachevIsTsarukyanUFCdaddyread Usool Al thalatha (three fundemental principles), Qawaid Al arbaa (four principles of shirk), Usool Al sitta (the six fundemental principles), and ofc his most famous book Kitab Al tawheed